Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Archaeopteris

Archaeopteris is an extinct genus of progymnosperm trees that dominated late Devonian landscapes, emerging around 393 million years ago and persisting until approximately 359 million years ago. These plants, among the earliest known trees, could attain heights of up to 40 meters with thick trunks featuring secondary wood similar to modern conifers, while bearing fern-like foliage and exhibiting a heterosporous reproductive cycle that bridged non-seed vascular plants and seed plants.^[1]^[2] As key components of the first widespread forests, Archaeopteris species influenced global biogeochemical cycles by accelerating rock weathering, modifying fluvial systems, and altering atmospheric CO₂ levels, potentially contributing to climatic shifts and the Late Devonian mass extinction. Fossils reveal a cosmopolitan distribution, from equatorial to high-latitude sites such as the approximately 70°S paleolatitude Waterloo Farm lagerstätte in South Africa, where trees exceeded 20 meters in height and formed dense stands in coastal environments warmed by ocean currents.^[3]^[2] Structurally, Archaeopteris trunks displayed advanced vascular architecture, including helical patterns of short-lived apical branches for foliage support and delayed adventitious branches akin to those in seed plants, enabling rapid canopy development and ecological dominance. This progymnosperm's advanced root systems, with seed plant-like features, further revolutionized terrestrial ecosystems by stabilizing soils and enhancing nutrient uptake in early forest settings. Despite its success, Archaeopteris vanished at the Devonian-Carboniferous boundary, supplanted by emerging seed plant lineages.^[4]^[1]

Taxonomy and Classification

Historical Discovery and Naming

The genus Archaeopteris was established by Canadian geologist John William Dawson in 1871, based on fossil fronds collected from Upper Devonian strata in eastern North America, including the Gaspé Peninsula in Quebec, Canada, as well as sites in New York, Maine, and New Brunswick.^[5] Dawson described these specimens in his monograph The Fossil Plants of the Devonian and Upper Silurian Formations of Canada, initially interpreting them as fern-like plants and placing them within the genus Cyclopteris as a new subgenus Archaeopteris due to their large, bipinnate fronds with alternate pinnules.^[5] The etymology of Archaeopteris combines the Greek archaios ("ancient") and pteris ("fern"), underscoring Dawson's view of it as an archaic representative of fern vegetation, distinct from more modern forms. Among the species Dawson named, A. jacksoni was based on material from the Gaspé Peninsula and Perry, Maine, while A. halliana—honoring American paleontologist James Hall—derived from specimens in the Chemung Group of western New York.^[5] A. rogersi, resembling A. jacksoni but with more elongated pinnules, came from Perry, Maine, and Montrose, Pennsylvania. These type specimens, illustrated in Dawson's plates, highlighted the plant's robust rachises and fern-like dissection, leading to its early assignment among pteridophytes.^[5] Throughout the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Archaeopteris was subject to taxonomic confusion, with some researchers affirming its fern affinity based on foliar morphology, while others noted gymnosperm-like features in associated woody tissues, prompting debates over its systematic position.^[6] A pivotal re-evaluation occurred in the 1960s through the work of paleobotanist Charles B. Beck, who demonstrated anatomical continuity between Archaeopteris fronds and permineralized wood previously classified as Callixylon, unifying them as parts of the same extinct tree and resolving much of the earlier ambiguity.^[6] This linkage, first reported in 1960, marked a shift toward recognizing Archaeopteris as a progymnosperm rather than a true fern or seed plant.

Systematic Position and Species

Archaeopteris is classified within the class Progymnospermopsida, an extinct group of vascular plants characterized by free-sporing reproduction and secondary xylem production akin to that of gymnosperms, distinguishing them from ferns and true seed plants. The genus serves as the type for the family Archaeopteridaceae and the order Archaeopteridales, which encompass large, tree-like forms dominant in Late Devonian forests. This systematic position was established through the recognition of organic connections between fern-like foliage, woody stems (often preserved as the form genus Callixylon), and fertile structures, highlighting their transitional role in plant evolution. The genus Archaeopteris comprises several recognized species, primarily differentiated by variations in frond architecture, leaf segmentation, and overall size. The type species, A. hibernica (Forbes, 1856), is widespread across Late Devonian deposits in North America and Europe, featuring pinnate fronds up to 2 meters long with entire-margined leaflets and evidence of both sterile and fertile branches. A. halliana (Göppert) Dawson, 1871, is widespread across Late Devonian deposits in North America and Europe, featuring pinnate fronds up to 2 meters long with entire-margined leaflets and evidence of both sterile and fertile branches. A. fissilis Dawson 1873, from European localities, exhibits more deeply dissected fronds with narrower pinnae compared to A. halliana. A. gaspiensis Dawson 1882, known from Canadian Escuminac Formation assemblages, displays robust fronds with broader leaflets, often exceeding 1.5 meters in length. A. hibernica Forbes 1856 and A. macilenta Lesquereux 1884, both common in Appalachian and European sites, differ in leaf margin dissection, with A. macilenta showing finely serrated or segmented tips on smaller fronds (typically under 1 meter). A. notosaria Anderson et al. 1995 represents a high-latitude variant from southern Gondwanan (South African) deposits, characterized by compact fronds adapted to polar light conditions, with shorter pinnae than northern counterparts. A. obtusa Lesquereux 1880 features blunt-tipped leaflets and less branched fronds, while A. sphenophyllifolia Lesquereux 1884 has wedge-shaped leaves with reduced dissection, often preserved in compressed assemblages from New York State. These distinctions aid in biostratigraphic correlation but reflect ecophenotypic variation within a cohesive genus.^[7] Certain species, notably A. halliana, demonstrate heterospory, producing dimorphic spores including small microspores (ca. 50-100 μm) assignable to the Geminospora-Aneurospora complex and larger megaspores (up to 500 μm) similar to Contagisporites, borne on separate but morphologically similar sporangia. This condition, observed in fertile fronds from Belgian and North American sites, underscores an evolutionary bridge toward the seed habit in spermatophytes, as heterospory enhances spore specialization for gametophyte development.^[8]^[9] The monophyly of Archaeopteridaceae remains debated, with some analyses questioning whether all assigned fronds and stems represent a single clade or if related progymnosperm genera, such as Tetraxylopteris from the Aneurophytales, warrant inclusion based on shared branching patterns and vascular anatomy. However, current consensus maintains Archaeopteris as the core of the family, with Tetraxylopteris retained in a sister order due to differences in frond dissection and sporangial position.^[10]

Morphology and Anatomy

Vegetative Features

Archaeopteris exhibited a tree-like habit, attaining heights of 10 to 30 meters with trunk diameters ranging from 0.5 to 1.5 meters.^[11]^[3] The trunk featured secondary xylem of the Callixylon type, characterized by pycnoxylic wood with thin-walled tracheids and rays, and concentric growth increments indicative of seasonal growth patterns.^[12]^[13] The main trunk displayed an orthostichous growth form, with dichotomous branching producing lateral branches arranged in a helical or spiral pattern around the axis.^[14] These lateral branches bore fern-like fronds up to 2 meters in length, which were pinnately compound to maximize light capture in forested environments.^[15] Foliage consisted of densely packed, wedge-shaped pinnae measuring 1 to 5 centimeters in length, attached along the frond rachis; evidence from fossil specimens suggests periodic abscission, as indicated by distinct scars at the base of detached pinnae.^[16]^[17] The root system was deep and extensively branching, with primary roots extending up to 10 meters in length and secondary laterals forming a dense network for anchorage and resource acquisition; associations with mycorrhizal fungi likely facilitated nutrient uptake in nutrient-poor Devonian soils.^[18]^[3]

Reproductive Structures

The fertile fronds of Archaeopteris closely resemble vegetative fronds in overall architecture but differ in possessing modified pinnae that terminate in clusters of sporangia, often arranged in synangia-like fused groups on the adaxial surface. These fertile structures typically occur on specialized branches, with sporangia borne in one or two rows along the fertile leaves, which are helically arranged on the axes.^[17] The sporangia themselves are elongated and fusiform, bilateral in symmetry, and measure up to 2 mm in length, dehiscing longitudinally to release free spores. They are attached by short stalks and positioned on the upper (adaxial) side of the fertile pinnae, facilitating spore dispersal. No evidence exists for true seeds or pollen organs in Archaeopteris; reproduction was exclusively spore-based and anemochorous (wind-dispersed).^[17] Most species of Archaeopteris exhibit homospory, producing a single type of trilete spore assignable to the Geminospora-type, with diameters ranging from 44–100 μm and featuring a distal trilete mark and ornamented exine. These spores were numerous within each sporangium, supporting efficient aerial dispersal in late Devonian environments.^[19] In contrast, A. halliana demonstrates heterospory, a derived condition with dimorphic spores: microspores (33–70 μm in diameter, over 100 per microsporangium) belonging to the Geminospora-Aneurospora complex, and fewer megaspores (110–500 μm, 16–32 per megasporangium) likely referable to Contagisporites. This disparity in spore size and number suggests an evolutionary progression toward endospory and pre-seed heteromorphic reproduction, bridging pteridophyte-like and gymnospermous strategies without achieving integumented seeds.^[19]^[20]

Ecology and Paleobiology

Habitat and Growth Environment

Archaeopteris primarily inhabited moist riparian zones along rivers and floodplains during the Late Devonian, where fossil soils (paleosols) reveal evidence of high water tables and organic-rich sediments indicative of wetland conditions. These environments were characterized by periodic flooding and sediment deposition, allowing Archaeopteris to thrive as a dominant tree in coastal plain settings across Euramerica.^[21]^[22] The growth of Archaeopteris occurred during the Upper Devonian Frasnian and Famennian stages, approximately 372 to 359 million years ago, under temperate to subtropical climates with seasonal rainfall patterns. Growth rings preserved in fossil wood suggest responses to monsoonal influences and wet-dry cycles, enabling the tree to reach heights exceeding 20 meters in these dynamic settings.^[23]^[3] As a pioneer species in wetlands, Archaeopteris played a key role in stabilizing sediments through its extensive root systems, which helped bind floodplain soils and prevent erosion during floods. It commonly associated with lycopsids, such as cormose forms, and early fern-like plants like Rhacophyton, forming mixed communities with niche partitioning where Archaeopteris occupied better-drained microsites. Additionally, its abundant leaf litter contributed to nutrient cycling by enriching soils with organic matter, fostering microbial activity and supporting understory vegetation in these ecosystems.^[21]^[24] Physiologically, Archaeopteris exhibited efficient water transport through its xylem, featuring a eustelic vascular system and secondary growth that supported hydraulic conductivity in tall trunks. Root anatomy, including adventitious roots and adaptations for anchorage in soft sediments, conferred tolerance to periodic flooding, as evidenced by stable carbon isotope values indicating variable water-use efficiency in fluctuating moisture regimes.^[25]^[14]

Distribution and Fossil Occurrences

Archaeopteris exhibits a broad temporal range spanning the Late Middle Devonian (Givetian stage, approximately 383 million years ago) to the Late Devonian (Famennian stage, approximately 359 million years ago), reaching its peak abundance and diversity during the Late Devonian; the genus declined and became extinct at the Devonian-Carboniferous boundary.^[3]^[26]^[27] This distribution makes Archaeopteris a valuable index fossil for correlating Devonian strata across continents.^[26] The fossil record of Archaeopteris is cosmopolitan, reflecting its presence on major Paleozoic landmasses including Laurussia, Gondwana, and peri-Gondwanan terranes in eastern Asia.^[27] In North America, notable occurrences include the Gilboa Fossil Forest in Schoharie County, New York, which preserves in situ tree stumps from approximately 385 million-year-old deposits representing the oldest known forest ecosystem, and the Miguasha locality in Quebec, Canada, a UNESCO World Heritage site serving as a key reference for Late Devonian plant assemblages. European sites feature fossils from the Hunsrück Slate in Germany and the Anti-Atlas region of Morocco, while Asian records are prominent in South China and Inner Mongolia.^[28] Fossils also occur in Australia and at high southern latitudes of Gondwana, such as South Africa.^[27] A 2024 study highlights recent discoveries of Archaeopteris at high-paleolatitude sites in southern Gondwana, including the Waterloo Farm locality in South Africa, where specimens of A. notosaria indicate tree growth near 70°S, expanding understanding of the genus's latitudinal tolerance during the Famennian.^[3] These finds, preserved in lagoonal deposits, underscore the genus's role in late Devonian forests beyond tropical zones. Preservation of Archaeopteris fossils varies, with common compression-impression specimens of fern-like fronds in fine-grained shales, permineralized wood axes assigned to the genus Callixylon in siliceous nodules, and casts of root systems in paleosols.^[13]^[26] The disarticulated nature of these remains—foliage often detached from axes and roots—presents challenges in reconstructing whole-plant morphology and confirming taxonomic assignments.^[26] Site sediments, such as those from floodplain environments at Gilboa and Red Hill in Pennsylvania, offer glimpses into depositional settings favoring such preservations.^[16]

Evolutionary Significance

Phylogenetic Relationships

Archaeopteris is classified as a progymnosperm, representing an intermediate evolutionary stage between the earlier trimerophytes—considered ancestral to ferns—and the later spermatophytes, or seed plants. This positioning is supported by shared morphological traits, including a bifacial vascular cambium that produced both secondary xylem and phloem, enabling robust woody growth akin to that in gymnosperms, as well as evidence of heterospory in some species like Archaeopteris halliana, which produced two spore types and foreshadowed the reproductive advancements in seed plants.^[29]^[18] These features distinguish progymnosperms from homosporous ferns while linking them to the lignophyte clade that encompasses seed plants. Cladistic analyses have consistently placed Archaeopteris as the sister group to lignophytes, including gymnosperms and seed ferns, within a broader phylogenetic framework of vascular plants. Numerical cladistic studies using morphological characters from 27 lignophyte taxa confirm this relationship, with Archaeopteris branching basally to the seed plant lineage based on shared synapomorphies such as eustelic stems and laminate leaves. Morphological phylogenies and molecular clock estimates further support a divergence around 400 million years ago in the Early Devonian, marking the origin of the lignophyte lineage from trimerophyte ancestors.^[30]^[31]^[32] Debates persist regarding Archaeopteris's role in seed plant evolution, with consensus viewing it not as a direct ancestor but as a structural and physiological model for early spermatophytes due to its tree-like habit and advanced vascular system. Comparisons to Carboniferous seed ferns like Lyginopteris highlight similarities in frond architecture and wood structure, both exhibiting compound leaves and secondary growth patterns that bridge progymnosperms to more derived lignophytes, though Lyginopteris possessed true seeds absent in Archaeopteris.^[33]^[34] Recent studies have bolstered these phylogenetic ties through detailed anatomical and distributional evidence. A 2019 analysis of Mid-Devonian Archaeopteris roots revealed a highly advanced system with extensive branching and secondary xylem production comparable to modern seed plants, supporting closer evolutionary affinity via enhanced resource acquisition capabilities that prefigured lignophyte dominance. Additionally, 2024 discoveries of Archaeopteris fossils at high southern latitudes (around 70°S) in South Africa demonstrate its global adaptability and forest-forming potential, refining phylogenies by confirming a cosmopolitan distribution for progymnosperms and their role in late Devonian diversification.^[35]^[36]

Innovations and Impact on Ecosystems

Archaeopteris introduced several key biological innovations that enabled its dominance in Late Devonian landscapes. It exhibited the first widespread arborescent habit supported by true wood, characterized by extensive lignified secondary xylem produced via a bifacial vascular cambium, allowing trunks to reach heights exceeding 10 meters and providing structural support for elevated canopies. Its root systems represented another breakthrough, with advanced, perennial structures comparable to those of modern seed plants, featuring primary roots up to 16 cm in diameter, complex branching patterns, and dense mats of fine rootlets extending depths of 1.2–1.6 meters. These roots not only anchored the trees but also optimized nutrient and water uptake in variable substrates. Complementing this, the fronds displayed leaf dimorphism—smaller adaxial leaves reducing water loss and larger abaxial ones maximizing light capture—optimized for efficient photosynthesis in both canopy and understory positions within forested settings.^[35] These innovations profoundly reshaped Devonian ecosystems, culminating in the formation of the earliest widespread forests around 385 million years ago, as documented at sites like Gilboa and Cairo in New York. The proliferation of Archaeopteris forests accelerated organic carbon burial, driving a significant rise in atmospheric oxygen levels; biogeochemical models based on the COPSE framework indicate elevated burial rates during Late Devonian expansions. Deep roots enhanced soil formation by promoting pedogenesis in vertisols and intensified silicate weathering, which increased erosion rates and nutrient runoff—particularly phosphorus—transforming fluvial systems from braided to meandering channels and elevating marine productivity. This nutrient influx contributed to episodic anoxia, fostering the deposition of organic-rich black shales characteristic of events like the Kellwasser crises. On a broader scale, Archaeopteris facilitated a biome shift from lycopsid-dominated wetlands to upright, tree-led forests, stabilizing landscapes and creating stratified habitats that supported diverse understory communities. These wooded environments influenced early animal evolution, offering moist, shaded floodplains and oxbow lakes where proto-tetrapods could exploit new foraging opportunities, selecting for limb and neck adaptations in taxa like those from the Catskill Formation. The genus's abrupt decline at the Devonian-Carboniferous boundary, coinciding with the Hangenberg extinction event around 359 million years ago, disrupted these systems, with Archaeopteris vanishing entirely and allowing the rise of new arborescent lignophytes in the early Carboniferous. Comparisons to modern conifers underscore Archaeopteris's role in carbon sequestration, as its decay-resistant lignified tissues and rooting depth mirrored gymnosperm contributions to long-term organic preservation, influencing global biogeochemical cycles in ways analogous to today's boreal forests. Post-2019 Earth system models, incorporating Devonian plant data, quantify these geoengineering effects, revealing how such early innovations amplified weathering feedbacks and altered atmospheric composition over millions of years.

References

[1]
[The first trees. The Archaeopteris model] - PubMed
The progymnosperm genus Archaeopteris was widespread worldwide and evolved the highest trees of the Devonian (maximum height estimated at 40 m).
[2]
Great moments in plant evolution - PNAS
Middle Devonian progymnosperms such as Archaeopteris (Fig. 1) are among the oldest known trees. Along with cladoxyl tree ferns such as Wattieza, increased ...
[3]
Archaeopteris trees at high southern latitudes in the late Devonian
Forest-sized Archaeopteris trees were found at high southern latitudes, with a global distribution, and were capable of forming forests in high latitudes.Missing: paleobotany | Show results with:paleobotany
[4]
The development of Archaeopteris - Botanical Society of America
Apr 1, 2000 · This progymnosperm tree produces a helical pattern of traces that we infer belonged to reduced, short-lived, primary (apical) branches (type A) ...
[5]
[PDF] The fossil plants of the Devonian and Upper Silurian formations of ...
Devonian fossils from its upper part, and the resemblance of the upper beds to those of the newer members of the Devonian elsewhere, render it pro-.
[6]
Connection between Archaeopteris and Callixylon - Science
Characters of two Upper Devonian genera, Archaeopteris, often considered to be a fern, and Callixylon, classified with the gymnosperms, have been recognized ...
[7]
[PDF] Plant paleoecology of the Late Devonian Red Hill locality, north
Archaeopteris remains at Red Hill consist almost entirely of 1-cm-wide penultimate branches, usually with attached biseriate ultimate branches.
[8]
Archaeopteris from the Upper Famennian of Belgium
Remains of large leafy branching systems, the so-called penultimate and ultimate branches of Archaeopteris, are the predominant element in several Upper (but ...Missing: original | Show results with:original<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
Archaeopteris From the Upper Famennian of Belgium - PubMed
Heterospory is demonstrated with miospores belonging to the Geminospora-Aneurospora complex and macrospores most probably to Contagisporites genus. The ...
[10]
Introduction to the Progymnosperms
Beck demonstrated that fossils of Archaeopteris were physically attached to Callixylon wood, it was realised that the plant, now collectively called ...Missing: connection | Show results with:connection
[11]
Devonian Times - Archaeopteris spp. - DCMurphy
It has been found at paleolatitudes ranging from equatorial to sub-polar. From its first appearance in the middle Frasnian Archaeopteris quickly became an ...Missing: type | Show results with:type
[12]
Unique growth strategy in the Earth's first trees revealed in silicified ...
Oct 23, 2017 · Archaeopteris, an early lignophyte, has the most familiar tree growth strategy, exhibiting extensive secondary development by producing ...
[13]
Fossil of the month: Callixylon - University of Kentucky
Jan 5, 2023 · Archaeopteris belonged to an extinct division of plants called the progymnosperms. These were the ancestors of modern gymnosperms, which ...
[14]
The Development of Archaeopteris: New Evolutionary Characters ...
Aug 5, 2025 · This progymnosperm tree produces a helical pattern of traces that we infer belonged to reduced, short-lived, primary (apical) branches (type A) ...
[15]
Archaeopteris macilenta was large, tree-like plant from the Late ...
Jun 26, 2020 · These proto-trees grew to a height of 10 meters, with trunk width up to 1.5 meters. They were a very successful plant, spreading to all ...Missing: diameter | Show results with:diameter
[16]
Plant paleoecology of the Late Devonian Red Hill locality, north ...
Jan 1, 2006 · The leaves of Archaeopteris macilenta are less than 1.5 cm in length and are rounded or broadly obovate with deeply cut margins (Fig. 10).
[17]
Archaeopteris macilenta, Anatomy and Morphology of Its Frond - jstor
COMPARISON WITH OTHER PLANTS-The primary xylem of the young parts of A rchaeopteris recalls two other genera, Siderella Read (1936) and Actinopo- dium H0eg 1942 ...
[18]
Mid-Devonian Archaeopteris Roots Signal Revolutionary Change in ...
Feb 3, 2020 · Here we show that Archaeopteris had a highly advanced root system essentially comparable to modern seed plants. This suggests a unique ecological role for the ...Missing: Archaeosolanum | Show results with:Archaeosolanum
[19]
Essay on Archaeopteris | Progymnospermopsida | Gymnosperms
In heterosporous species (A. halliana, A macienta, A fissilis), the micro- and megasporangia are more or less alike in terms of their sizes.
[20]
Plant paleoecology of the Late Devonian Red Hill locality, north ...
Aug 6, 2025 · Archaeopteris was the only Devonian lignophyte to achieve arborescence, developing a gymnosperm type of tree habit and forming dense forests ...
[21]
The Archaeopterid Forests of Lower Frasnian (Upper Devonian ...
Jun 2, 2022 · Naumova (1953) reports its size as between 100 and 200 μm in diameter, although its scaling relative to other spores on the plates suggests that ...
[22]
Archaeopteris trees at high southern latitudes in the late Devonian
Archaeopteris trees at high southern latitudes in the late Devonian. October 2024; Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 331(1):105212. DOI:10.1016/j.revpalbo ...
[23]
[PDF] MID DEVONIAN Archaeopteris ROOTS 1 SIGNAL ...
Archaeopteris had a highly advanced root system, with features like a eustelic primary vascular system, bifacial cambium, and heterospory, comparable to modern ...
[24]
[PDF] The evolution of water transport in plants: an integrated approach
This review examines the evolution of the plant vascular system from its beginnings in the green algae to modern arborescent plants, highlighting the recent ...
[25]
Plant dispersal in the Devonian world (c. 419–359 Ma) - Liu - 2024
May 10, 2024 · Archaeopteris and Callixylon originated in the Middle Devonian of Laurussia and expanded to Gondwana, Australia, South China, and the Junggar ...
[26]
A new Late Devonian flora from Sonid Zuoqi, Inner Mongolia ...
Mar 1, 2022 · Upper Devonian, an unnamed lithological unit, 18 km southwest of Dalai Sumu Town, northern Sonid Zuoqi, Inner Mongolia, China (GPS location: 44° ...
[27]
RECONSTRUCTIONS OF ARCHAEOPTERIS, AND FURTHER ...
Archaeopteris is a progymnosperm (Beck, 1960b). RECONSTHUCTIONS-No single ... and admittedly of uncertain systematic position, produced secondary xylem.
[28]
Archaeopteris - Wikipedia
It combines characteristics of woody trees and herbaceous ferns, and belongs to the progymnosperms, a group of extinct plants more closely related to seed ...
[29]
Lignophyte Phylogeny and the Evolution of Spermatophytes - jstor
ABSTRACT. Phylogenetic relationships of 27 taxa of extant and extinct lignophytes were assessed in a numerical cladistic analysis using 65 characters.
[30]
Ancient noeggerathialean reveals the seed plant sister group ...
Mar 8, 2021 · There are 32 to 35 sporangia per row in the pseudostrobili depending on the length of the pseudostrobili, producing five sporangia per ...
[31]
The origin and early evolution of vascular plant shoots and leaves
Dec 18, 2017 · Around 430 million years ago [11,12], the innovation of shoots and leaves underpinned an explosive radiation of vascular plant form analogous to ...
[32]
Classes of Fossil Gymnosperms | Botany - Biology Discussion
The stem Lyginopteris was slender and covered with large scaly leaves. Near the base of the plant adventitious roots developed. The plant seems to have been a ...
[33]
Seed Evolution - The Seed Biology Place
The progymnosperm Archaeopteris spp. was the first modern tree, but it produced spores rather than seeds. However, it exhibited an advanced system of spore ...
[34]
http://www.seedbiology.de/evolution.asp
[35]
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.11.067