Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Cosmic string

Cosmic strings are hypothetical, one-dimensional topological defects in spacetime, predicted to arise during symmetry-breaking phase transitions in the early universe, such as those associated with grand unified theories beyond the Standard Model of particle physics.^[1] These filamentary structures form when a scalar field, cooling from a high-energy symmetric phase to a lower-energy broken phase, develops regions of frustration where the field cannot uniformly align, resulting in linear defects where the field vanishes.^[2] Analogous to vortices in superfluids or dislocations in crystals, cosmic strings are characterized by their extreme thinness, with a core width on the order of the inverse symmetry-breaking scale, approximately $10^{-32} meters for grand unification scales.^[2] The fundamental property of cosmic strings is their tension, which equals their mass per unit length \mu, typically scaling as \mu \approx \eta^2, where \eta is the energy scale of the phase transition, often around $10^{16} GeV for grand unified theories.^[2] This leads to a dimensionless parameter G\mu, where G is Newton's constant, with values around $10^{-6} to $10^{-7} for such scales, though lower tensions are possible in other models.^[3] Modeled effectively as Nambu-Goto strings in general relativity, they are stable due to topological conservation, such as a nonzero winding number in the field configuration, preventing decay except through dynamical processes.^[4] Distinctions exist between local (Abelian Higgs model) and global strings, with local ones coupling primarily to gravity and global ones producing scalar radiation in addition to gravitational waves.^[1] In cosmology, cosmic strings would form a scaling network of long, infinite strings and closed loops shortly after the phase transition, evolving through intercommutations and loop formation to maintain a constant energy density relative to the expanding universe.^[5] Loops oscillate and decay predominantly by emitting gravitational waves, potentially contributing to the stochastic gravitational wave background detectable by pulsar timing arrays like NANOGrav or future space-based detectors such as LISA.^[4] Observationally, they could induce gravitational lensing of background sources, producing double images or temperature discontinuities in the cosmic microwave background (CMB), and high-energy cosmic rays via particle production.^[5] Current constraints from CMB anisotropies and pulsar timing data limit G\mu \lesssim 10^{-10} to $10^{-7}, ruling out dominant roles in structure formation but leaving room for subdominant contributions or detection in high-frequency gravitational waves.^[6] Recent analyses, including those from the 2023 NANOGrav dataset, continue to tighten these bounds, highlighting cosmic strings as testable probes of high-energy physics.^[7]

Formation in the Early Universe

Topological Defects and Phase Transitions

Topological defects in cosmology are stable configurations of scalar and gauge fields that emerge during spontaneous symmetry-breaking phase transitions in the early universe, persisting as relics due to the topology of the vacuum manifold.^[8] These defects are categorized by their codimension, corresponding to the dimensionality of the symmetry-breaking pattern: zero-dimensional magnetic monopoles arise from point-like mismatches, one-dimensional cosmic strings from line-like defects, and two-dimensional domain walls from sheet-like separations between distinct vacuum states.^[3] Cosmic strings, as one-dimensional (1D) defects, represent linear concentrations of energy where the field configuration cannot be continuously deformed to the uniform vacuum state.^[3] The Kibble mechanism, first proposed by Tom Kibble in 1976, explains the origin of these defects during rapid cosmological phase transitions.^[8] As the universe expands and cools through the critical temperature, causal horizons limit correlations between distant regions, causing the vacuum expectation value (VEV) of the Higgs-like field to select random orientations independently in each causally connected domain.^[3] In regions where adjacent domains meet with incompatible vacuum choices—such as phase differences that are topologically non-trivial—these mismatches stabilize into persistent defects, with cosmic strings forming along the intersections of mismatched two-dimensional domains.^[8] In grand unified theories (GUTs), cosmic strings typically form during symmetry breaking at energy scales of $10^{15} to $10^{16} GeV, corresponding to the unification of the strong, weak, and electromagnetic forces.^[3] The characteristic tension \mu of these strings, defined as their energy per unit length, scales as \mu \approx \eta^2, where \eta is the VEV associated with the phase transition.^[3] This tension sets the physical scale of the defects, with GUT-scale strings yielding a dimensionless measure G\mu \sim 10^{-6} to $10^{-7}, where G is Newton's gravitational constant, influencing their gravitational interactions without dominating the universe's energy density.^[3] Mathematically, the stability and existence of cosmic strings are determined by the homotopy properties of the vacuum manifold \mathcal{M} = G/H, where G is the original gauge group and H the residual unbroken subgroup.^[8] Specifically, strings form when the first homotopy group is non-trivial, \pi_1(G/H) \neq \{0\}, classifying closed field configurations (loops) that cannot be contracted to a point within \mathcal{M}.^[3] For example, in Abelian U(1) gauge theories breaking to the trivial group, \pi_1(U(1)) = \mathbb{Z}, producing stable Nielsen-Olesen vortex strings wound around the symmetry direction.^[3] In non-Abelian GUT models like SO(10), certain breaking patterns—such as SO(10) to SU(5) × U(1)—yield \pi_1(G/H) = \mathbb{Z}_2 or similar discrete groups, allowing for strings with embedded symmetries and potential for monopole-string complexes.^[3]

Theories Incorporating Cosmic Strings

Cosmic strings emerge in grand unified theories (GUTs) through spontaneous symmetry breaking at energy scales around $10^{16} GeV, where the breaking of groups like SU(5) or SO(10) can produce stable U(1) defects if the vacuum manifold's topology permits nontrivial \pi_1 homotopy groups. In SU(5) models, for instance, the breaking pattern can lead to Z_2 strings or electromagnetically neutral strings that carry fermionic zero modes, potentially influencing baryogenesis.^[9] Seminal 1980s models by Vilenkin explored these formations, showing that GUT-scale strings could dominate the early universe's energy density before decaying into radiation. Shellard's contributions further detailed the stability and dynamics of such strings in SO(10) embeddings, emphasizing their role in producing gravitational radiation. Beyond GUTs, cosmic strings appear in electroweak and extensions of the Standard Model via the breaking of SU(2) × U(1) at approximately 100 GeV, though the minimal model yields unstable electroweak strings due to confinement by monopoles. However, the Standard Model electroweak transition is a crossover, precluding stable string formation; stable electroweak-scale strings require extensions like supersymmetry or two-Higgs-doublet models that preserve a discrete symmetry, leading to currents along the strings from electroweak gauge bosons.^[10] These lower-scale strings would have tensions approximately $10^{-28} times the GUT scale (or Gμ ≈ 10^{-34}), making them relevant for early nucleosynthesis constraints but less impactful on large-scale structure. Integration with inflationary cosmology allows cosmic strings to form post-inflation during reheating, where the rapid particle production avoids dilution from the preceding exponential expansion. In preheating scenarios, parametric resonances in scalar fields trigger nonthermal phase transitions, efficiently generating string networks without requiring ultra-high reheating temperatures. This compatibility resolves tensions between defect formation and inflation's horizon problem solution, as strings produced after the inflaton decay era evolve independently of the inflationary dilution. The Abelian-Higgs model provides a foundational toy framework for studying cosmic string formation, modeling a U(1) gauge theory coupled to a complex scalar field whose spontaneous breaking creates vortex-like defects. The model's Lagrangian is given by

\mathcal{L} = -\frac{1}{4} F_{\mu\nu} F^{\mu\nu} + (D_\mu \phi)^* (D^\mu \phi) - V(|\phi|),

where D_\mu = \partial_\mu - i e A_\mu is the covariant derivative, F_{\mu\nu} = \partial_\mu A_\nu - \partial_\nu A_\mu, and the potential V(|\phi|) = \frac{\lambda}{4} (|\phi|^2 - \eta^2)^2 drives the symmetry breaking at scale \eta. Numerical solutions reveal stable string solutions with energy per unit length \mu \approx \pi \eta^2, classifying them as type-I or type-II depending on the coupling ratio \lambda / e^2. This model underpins simulations of GUT and electroweak strings, capturing essential features like intercommutation and loop formation.

Physical Characteristics

Geometry and Dimensions

Cosmic strings are one-dimensional topological defects characterized by their linear geometry, extending infinitely or forming closed loops without endpoints due to topological stability.^[2] In flat spacetime, idealized cosmic strings appear as straight lines, but in the expanding universe, their trajectories become curved, adapting to the large-scale cosmic geometry while maintaining their filamentary structure. The transverse thickness of a cosmic string is extremely small, on the order of the inverse of the symmetry-breaking scale η, typically δ ∼ 1/η ≈ 10^{-30} cm for grand unified theory (GUT) scales where η ≈ 10^{16} GeV.^[2] This thin core region encompasses concentrated scalar and gauge fields where the symmetry is broken, while outside the core, the string's behavior is well-approximated by a relativistic thin-string model. The mass per unit length μ, which equals the string tension in the simplest models, scales as μ ≈ η^2, yielding a dimensionless gravitational coupling parameter Gμ ∼ 10^{-6} for typical GUT-inspired scenarios.^[2] The effective dynamics of these strings beyond the core are governed by the Nambu-Goto action, which treats the string as a timelike worldsheet embedded in spacetime:

S = -\mu \int d\tau \, d\sigma \, \sqrt{-\gamma},

where γ_{ab} is the induced metric on the worldsheet parametrized by coordinates (τ, σ), and μ is the constant mass per unit length. This action captures the relativistic motion of the string, with energy and momentum conserved along its length in the absence of external influences.^[2]

Gravitational Properties

Cosmic strings act as sources of gravity through their tension, which is comparable to their energy density per unit length, denoted as \mu. For a static, straight, infinite cosmic string aligned along the z-axis, the spacetime metric in cylindrical coordinates (t, r, \phi, z) takes the form

ds^2 = -dt^2 + dz^2 + dr^2 + (1 - 4G\mu)^2 r^2 d\phi^2,

where G is Newton's gravitational constant.^[2] This metric describes a locally flat spacetime that is globally conical, equivalent to Minkowski space with a wedge of angular width \Delta\phi = 8\pi G\mu removed and the edges identified.^[2] The deficit angle arises directly from the string's mass-energy, leading to no standard Newtonian gravitational potential (which would vary as $1/r) but instead an angular deficit that affects geodesics passing near the string.^[2] When a cosmic string moves relativistically through matter, its conical geometry induces a velocity perturbation in surrounding particles, causing them to converge toward a plane trailing the string, known as a wake. This results in sheet-like density enhancements with contrasts \delta\rho / \rho \sim 1, forming caustics where matter accumulates nonlinearly. The wake's transverse extent is set by the deficit angle, with particles acquiring a relative velocity kick of order $4\pi G\mu v, where v is the string's speed, leading to planar overdensities.^[11] Time-dependent configurations, such as oscillating string loops, radiate gravitational waves due to their non-axisymmetric motion. The average power radiated by such a loop is P \approx \Gamma G \mu^2, where \Gamma is a numerical factor approximately 50, determined by averaging over the loop's periodic oscillations. This energy loss causes loops to shrink.^[2]

Variants and Extremes

Negative Tension Cosmic Strings

Negative tension cosmic strings represent a hypothetical variant of topological defects characterized by a negative mass per unit length \mu < 0, corresponding to negative energy density and tension, which induces repulsive gravitational effects, such as an angular excess in the surrounding spacetime metric rather than a deficit angle.^[12]^[13] Such structures violate conventional energy conditions in general relativity, potentially allowing for exotic phenomena like traversable wormholes or repulsive gravitational fields.^[12] These strings have been proposed in certain high-energy models, including brane-world scenarios where negative-tension branes or defects emerge as solutions alongside positive ones, and theories involving ghost condensates or negative energy components during phase transitions.^[12] Early explorations of such configurations appeared in the 1990s, often in the context of flux compactifications and exotic matter setups.^[12] Due to the negative tension, these cosmic strings are inherently unstable, exhibiting behaviors that can lead to rapid expansion or decay into particles or other excitations. This instability arises from the negative energy, causing perturbations to grow and fragment the structure.^[13]^[14] Stability criteria for related configurations are discussed in Edward Witten's model of superconducting cosmic strings, where current-carrying phases can introduce negative pressure components along certain directions, but local stability analyses rigorously exclude outright negative tension states to avoid instabilities. In this framework, the equation of state varies with the current magnitude, allowing transient negative pressure without full tension reversal, provided the effective energy-momentum satisfies causality and stability bounds. These conditions highlight the delicate balance required, where superconducting currents might temporarily mimic negative tension effects but ultimately revert to positive tension for viability.^[12]

Super-critical Cosmic Strings

Super-critical cosmic strings are characterized by a dimensionless tension parameter G\mu > 1/4, where G is the gravitational constant and \mu is the string's energy per unit length, leading to a spacetime deficit angle exceeding $2\pi. In general relativity, such bare strings induce a collapse of the exterior spacetime, effectively reducing the dimensionality of the surrounding geometry to a conical singularity. This instability arises because the strong gravitational backreaction warps the metric beyond the point where a static, cylindrical solution remains viable, as analyzed in solutions to Einstein's equations for static strings.^[2] For finite segments or loops of super-critical strings, the collapse can result in the formation of black holes or naked singularities, depending on the configuration and initial conditions.^[2] Dynamical analyses confirm that static configurations are untenable, with the geometry instead evolving toward horizons or singular regions that encapsulate the string core.^[15] Certain variants of super-critical strings can be stabilized against immediate collapse through internal structure. Chiral cosmic strings, which carry helical fermion currents, exhibit an effective tension \mu_\mathrm{eff} < \mu due to the opposing contributions from the current's momentum and the scalar condensate's energy density. Similarly, superconducting strings with bosonic or fermionic currents reduce the net tension via the equation of state parameter w = -k^2 / \mu, where k is the current magnitude, allowing \mu_\mathrm{eff} to drop below the critical threshold even if the bare \mu exceeds it. These stabilized configurations, such as vortons—current-carrying loops balanced by angular momentum—prevent wholesale collapse by maintaining dynamical equilibrium. In standard grand unified theory models, cosmic strings form with G\mu \sim 10^{-6}, well below the super-critical regime, rendering such strings rare or absent.^[2] However, in high-energy frameworks like fundamental superstring theory or brane-world scenarios with Planck-scale symmetry breaking, G\mu \approx 1 becomes feasible, potentially allowing super-critical strings to emerge during early universe phase transitions. These cases could lead to exotic gravitational phenomena, though observational constraints from cosmic microwave background data (Gμ ≲ 10^{-7} as of 2024) and pulsar timing arrays strongly limit their abundance or rule out dominant contributions.^[6]

Network Dynamics

Formation and Evolution

Cosmic strings form in the early universe during second-order phase transitions associated with spontaneous symmetry breaking in grand unified theories, where the system is driven out of equilibrium. The Kibble-Zurek mechanism describes this non-equilibrium process: as the universe cools through the critical temperature, domains of correlated vacuum states emerge with a characteristic size set by the correlation length ξ, leading to mismatches at domain boundaries that nucleate stable string defects.^[16] Numerical simulations of the phase transition confirm that the initial string configuration is a highly tangled network of long strings, resembling a random walk on scales larger than ξ, with an initial correlation length ξ ≈ t, where t is the cosmic time (approximately the Hubble time) at formation. Following formation, the cosmic string network undergoes rapid dynamical evolution dominated by expansion, tension-driven motion, and intercommutations. Long, wiggly strings straighten through gravitational radiation and Hubble stretching, while intersections between strings lead to reconnections (intercommutations), which chop the network into smoother configurations and redistribute energy. This recombination process efficiently reduces small-scale structure, transitioning the initial chaotic tangle into a more ordered network of infinite strings on Hubble scales. The velocity-dependent one-scale (VOS) model provides an analytic framework for quantifying this post-formation evolution, averaging the network properties over characteristic scales. It tracks the characteristic length L(t) (related to the correlation length ξ by L ≈ ξ) and the root-mean-square velocity v of the strings via coupled differential equations that incorporate expansion, curvature acceleration, and energy loss to loops. The length evolution is given by

\frac{dL}{dt} = H L (1 + v^2) + \frac{\tilde{c} v}{2},

where H is the Hubble parameter, the terms H L (1 + v^2) account for stretching due to cosmic expansion including relativistic effects, and \frac{\tilde{c} v}{2} reflects velocity-dependent energy loss to loops from intercommutations (with \tilde{c} \approx 0.23 from Nambu–Goto simulations); the velocity equation balances acceleration from string curvature against damping from expansion and friction.^[17] This model, building on earlier analytic approaches, captures the intermediate dynamics from the friction-dominated early phases to later relativistic regimes. The Kibble-Zurek mechanism, proposed in 1985, laid the foundation for understanding the non-equilibrium initial conditions that seed this evolution.^[16]

Scaling and Loops

In the scaling regime of cosmic string network evolution, the characteristic length scale \xi, which measures the average distance between long strings, grows linearly with cosmic time t, such that \xi \sim t. This attractor solution ensures that the network structure becomes statistically self-similar when rescaled by the horizon size, independent of initial conditions after early transients.^[18] The corresponding energy density of the infinite string component \rho_\infty scales as \rho_\infty \sim \mu / t^2, where \mu is the string tension, maintaining a constant fractional contribution to the total energy density of the universe during radiation- or matter-dominated eras.^[18] This scaling behavior has been robustly confirmed through numerical simulations employing the Nambu-Goto action to model string dynamics in an expanding universe, with evidence emerging from early computations in the 1980s that demonstrated the network's approach to self-similarity.^[19] Subsequent high-resolution simulations have refined these results, showing that the scaling persists across different cosmological epochs and string tensions, with the correlation length \xi stabilizing at approximately $0.3 t$ in typical setups. Loop production arises primarily from intersections between long strings, which chop off closed loops of characteristic size l \sim \alpha \xi, where the efficiency parameter \alpha \approx 0.1 reflects the typical fraction of the correlation length involved in such events.^[20] These loops inherit the small-scale structure of the parent network but evolve independently, losing energy predominantly through gravitational wave emission as they oscillate in non-spherical modes.^[20] The decay of these loops is governed by the power radiated in gravitational waves, leading to a lifetime \tau \sim l / (\Gamma G \mu), where l is the initial loop length, G is Newton's constant, and \Gamma \approx 50 is a dimensionless numerical factor accounting for the efficiency of radiation from the dominant quadrupole mode.^[21] As loops shrink, their emission produces a bursty spectrum of gravitational waves, contributing to a stochastic background that scales with the network's loop production rate and persists as a relic from the scaling regime.^[21]

Observational Signatures

Gravitational Lensing Effects

Cosmic strings produce gravitational lensing effects due to their unique spacetime geometry, which features a conical deficit angle arising from the string's mass-energy density. The deficit angle is given by \alpha = 8\pi G\mu, where G is the gravitational constant and \mu is the string tension (mass per unit length). This geometry causes light rays passing on opposite sides of the string to experience a relative deflection, resulting in an angular shift \delta\theta = 4\pi G\mu between the two images of a background source. For a string tension parameter G\mu \approx 10^{-6}, this shift corresponds to \delta\theta \approx 2.6 arcseconds, making it potentially observable in high-resolution astronomical images. The primary lensing signatures of cosmic strings include pairs of nearly identical double images of background galaxies or quasars, separated by \delta\theta perpendicular to the projected orientation of the string. These images appear undistorted and equally bright, unlike the magnified and distorted arcs typical of lensing by galaxies or clusters.^[22] Additionally, strings can create straight wakes in the observed distribution of galaxies, manifesting as linear alignments or discontinuities in surface density across the string's position, due to the cumulative lensing shear along the line of sight.^[23] Kink lensing arises from sharp discontinuities, or kinks, along the cosmic string where the direction changes abruptly due to intercommutation events in the string network. These kinks produce highly distinctive lensing patterns, including sudden jumps or discontinuities in the positions of lensed images, which contrast sharply with the smooth deflection fields from conventional lenses like point masses.^[24] Such features allow kinks to be differentiated observationally, as the lensing map exhibits cusps or edges rather than gradual variations.^[24] Searches for these lensing effects using Hubble Space Telescope (HST) archival data, covering several square degrees of deep fields, have identified no confirmed cosmic string candidates, thereby constraining the abundance of long strings and placing upper limits on G\mu \lesssim 6.5 \times 10^{-7} (95% confidence).^[25] As of 2009, no detections have been reported from these surveys, consistent with the low expected density of strings at observable tensions.^[25] Upcoming wide-field surveys, such as those from the Euclid mission, are projected to image billions of galaxies with sufficient resolution to detect or further tighten constraints on string-induced lensing down to G\mu \sim 10^{-8}, enhancing sensitivity to these topological defects.^[23]

Impacts on Cosmic Microwave Background

Cosmic string networks imprint distinct signatures on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) through the Kaiser-Stebbins effect, where the motion of strings relative to the line of sight induces temperature discontinuities in the photon field. As a string moves with velocity v, it creates a conical spacetime deficit angle, leading to a relative Doppler shift between photons passing on either side of the string, resulting in a fractional temperature perturbation \delta T / T \approx 8\pi G\mu v \gamma, where G\mu is the dimensionless string tension, v is the string velocity (typically \sim 0.3c), and \gamma = (1 - v^2)^{-1/2}.^[26] For G\mu \sim 10^{-6}, this yields \delta T / T \sim 10^{-5}, producing step-like features in the CMB temperature map aligned with the string's position.^[27] These perturbations arise continuously from the evolving string network, which scales self-similarly with the cosmic horizon, ensuring a persistent population of long strings that source these anisotropies post-recombination.^[28] The resulting CMB temperature power spectrum from cosmic strings exhibits a characteristic profile dominated by vector modes, unlike the scalar perturbations from inflation.^[29] On large angular scales (\ell \lesssim 100), the spectrum shows roughly equal power across multipoles with a slight suppression at low \ell, and an excess of power at higher \ell due to the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and Doppler contributions from moving strings.^[30] Vector modes, generated by the transverse motion of strings, contribute significantly to the temperature anisotropies, leading to unequal power between even and odd parity multipoles on large scales—a feature absent in inflationary models.^[28] This vector-dominated spectrum produces a smooth, broad peak in the angular power spectrum, distinguishable from the acoustic peaks of primordial scalar fluctuations.^[31] In CMB polarization, cosmic strings generate both E-mode and B-mode signals, with B-modes primarily sourced by vector perturbations rather than tensor modes from primordial gravitational waves.^[32] The B-mode power spectrum from strings features a nearly white spectrum at low \ell (\ell \lesssim 100), rising toward higher \ell with amplitude scaling as (G\mu)^2, and is thus separable from the reionization-dominated low-\ell tail and lensing-induced B-modes of inflationary origin.^[33] These signals arise from the coupling of string-induced velocity fields to Thomson scattering at recombination, producing curl-like polarization patterns orthogonal to the temperature discontinuities.^[28] The distinct spectral shape and non-Gaussian bispectrum allow for targeted searches, differentiating string B-modes from those expected from tensor perturbations in single-field inflation.^[31] Observational constraints from CMB data have tightened limits on G\mu without detecting string signatures. Analysis of Planck 2015 temperature and polarization maps using modal bispectrum methods yields an upper bound G\mu < 1.5 \times 10^{-7} at 95% confidence for Nambu-Goto string models, assuming no contribution to the primordial power spectrum.^[34] No evidence for the Kaiser-Stebbins effect or associated vector-mode excesses is found in the data, consistent with the low tension required for compatibility with large-scale structure observations.^[35] Analyses from the 2020s, including machine learning applications to Planck maps, refine bounds to G\mu \lesssim 8.6 \times 10^{-7} at 3\sigma.^[35] Recent ACT DR6 (2023) analyses further constrain G\mu < 5 \times 10^{-8} (95% CL) from high-resolution temperature data.^[36] These templates account for the active sourcing of perturbations, highlighting the absence of the predicted non-Gaussian features in Planck maps.

Connections to Fundamental Physics

Distinctions from String Theory

Cosmic strings, as topological defects in classical field theories, differ fundamentally from the strings of perturbative string theory in terms of scale. The energy per unit length μ for typical grand unified theory (GUT)-scale cosmic strings is on the order of 10^{22} g/cm, corresponding to a dimensionless tension Gμ ≈ 10^{-6}, where G is Newton's constant.^[10] In contrast, fundamental strings (F-strings) in string theory have a characteristic length scale l_s ≈ 10^{-33} cm, set by the string length parameter √α' near the Planck scale, making them microscopic objects vastly smaller than the macroscopic, potentially universe-spanning cosmic strings.^[37] Their origins also diverge sharply. Cosmic strings emerge as stable solitonic configurations in effective four-dimensional field theories, such as the Abelian-Higgs model, formed during spontaneous symmetry breaking phase transitions in the early universe.^[10] F-strings, however, are quantized one-dimensional excitations of the fundamental string in ten-dimensional superstring theory, arising from the perturbative spectrum of closed or open strings in higher-dimensional spacetime.^[37] There is no direct theoretical relation between the two; classical cosmic strings are not predicted by string theory unless approximated in effective four-dimensional limits, such as through dimensional reduction, but even then, they remain distinct phenomenological objects.^[37] This separation is emphasized in analyses of cosmic F- and D-strings, which, while capable of achieving macroscopic lengths in certain string theory embeddings, do not replicate the topological stability or field-theoretic dynamics of cosmic strings.^[37] Historically, confusion arose in the early 1980s when proposals suggested that superstrings from heterotic or type I theories could manifest as cosmic-scale objects, such as boundaries of axion domain walls, potentially linking the two concepts.^[38] However, subsequent developments clarified that these are separate entities, with string theory's fundamental strings requiring specific higher-dimensional mechanisms to reach cosmological relevance, unlike the intrinsic formation of cosmic strings in field theory.^[37]

Implications in Brane-world Models

In brane-world models, cosmic strings can manifest as localized defects confined to a 3-brane embedded in a higher-dimensional bulk, particularly within the 5D Randall-Sundrum (RS) framework where gravity is warped along the extra dimension.^[2] These brane-localized strings arise from symmetry-breaking phase transitions on the brane, analogous to standard 4D cosmic strings, but their gravitational influence extends into the bulk, leading to modified metric solutions that satisfy the 5D Einstein equations with a negative bulk cosmological constant.^[2] The effective tension of such strings, denoted as \mu, is warped by the exponential factor e^{-2k|y|}, where k is the curvature scale of the AdS bulk and y is the extra-dimensional coordinate, resulting in a reduced 4D-projected tension compared to the bare brane value.^[2] This warping suppresses the string's gravitational effects at large distances along the brane, while bulk graviton modes introduce corrections to the linearized metric around the string. Distinctions emerge between fundamental strings from string theory and effective field-theoretic cosmic strings in these models. Fundamental F-strings or D-strings, extended objects in the 10D bulk, project onto the 4D brane as effective cosmic strings with tension reduced by the warp factor, yielding a dimensionless parameter G\mu \sim 10^{-11} to $10^{-7}, consistent with observational bounds on standard cosmic strings.^[2] Recent pulsar timing data, including from NANOGrav as of 2023, further constrain G\mu \lesssim 10^{-11}, allowing warped cosmic superstrings as potential sources of the stochastic gravitational wave background.^[7] In contrast, effective strings from brane-localized scalar fields exhibit tensions determined by the symmetry-breaking scale on the brane, potentially amplified or diluted by the warp factor without invoking the full string theory spectrum.^[2] These projected F/D-strings inherit extra-dimensional dynamics, such as wiggles or reconnections influenced by bulk propagation, differentiating them from purely 4D effective descriptions. Observational signatures of brane-world cosmic strings differ from 4D expectations due to bulk leakage of gravitational fields, altering phenomena like gravitational lensing. In the RS model, the conical deficit angle around a straight string remains \delta = 8\pi G\mu, similar to general relativity, but higher-order corrections from bulk gravitons modify the lensing profile, potentially producing asymmetric image distortions or reduced magnification for background sources.^[2] Proposals in the early 2000s, building on large extra-dimensional scenarios, suggested that strings spanning extra dimensions could induce non-standard lensing patterns, such as multiple images displaced by angles sensitive to the extra-dimensional size, offering probes of the bulk geometry. These effects, explored in frameworks like those of Arkani-Hamed, Dimopoulos, and Dvali, predict deviations in quasar microlensing events or galaxy cluster alignments that standard 4D strings cannot replicate. Stability considerations for closed string loops, known as vortons, are enhanced in codimension-2 brane configurations, such as 3-branes in 5D bulks. In these setups, vortons—rotating loops carrying a conserved current—avoid the instabilities plaguing 4D field-theoretic analogs, where scalar radiation erodes the current.^[39] The codimension-2 topology confines Goldstone modes to the brane, preventing dissipative bulk losses and allowing macroscopic vortons to persist as stable, spinning configurations with equation of state w=0, potentially contributing to dark matter if formed post-inflation. This stability arises from the brane-dynamical formalism, where the vorton's equilibrium is supported by tension balancing centrifugal forces without invoking higher-codimension instabilities.^[39]

Cosmological and Astrophysical Implications

Role in Structure Formation

Cosmic strings act as active seeds for density perturbations in the early universe, continuously sourcing gravitational effects through their relativistic motion and network evolution, in contrast to the passive quantum fluctuations generated during inflation that freeze out after horizon exit. The perturbations arise from the integrated stress-energy of the string network, captured via unequal-time correlators that describe the time-dependent sourcing of metric perturbations. This leads to induced matter density contrasts of order \delta \rho / \rho \sim G \mu, where G is Newton's constant and \mu is the string tension, providing a characteristic amplitude independent of the expansion scale factor during the radiation-dominated era.^[40] Unlike inflationary models, where perturbations evolve freely after initial generation, the active nature of string-induced perturbations allows for ongoing amplification and non-linear effects as the network scales with the horizon. The resulting power spectrum of density perturbations from cosmic strings exhibits near scale-invariance on large scales (k \lesssim 0.01 \, h \, \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1}), akin to the Harrison-Zeldovich spectrum, but transitions to white noise behavior (P(k) \propto k^0) on smaller scales due to the causal, uncorrelated contributions from local string segments. This excess small-scale power enhances structure formation at high redshifts (z > 10), promoting the collapse of halos and early galaxy precursors more efficiently than in purely inflationary scenarios. High-resolution N-body simulations, incorporating the string network's wake-like perturbations, demonstrate the formation of prominent filamentary structures aligned with string trajectories, where accreting matter falls into planar overdensities behind moving strings. These simulations, evolved from initial conditions at z \approx 1000, reveal a web of sheets and filaments that match the observed large-scale cosmic morphology for G \mu \approx 10^{-6}.^[41] However, the white-noise component on small scales leads to an overprediction of power in the matter distribution compared to observations, particularly in the flux power spectrum of the Lyman-\alpha forest, which probes intergalactic gas at z \approx 2-3. Analyses combining Lyman-\alpha data with cosmic microwave background and galaxy clustering measurements constrain the string tension to G \mu < 2.3 \times 10^{-7} at 95% confidence, ruling out models where strings dominate seeding and highlighting their potential as a subdominant contributor to structure formation.^[42]

Constraints from Observations

Observations of gravitational waves provide stringent upper limits on the cosmic string tension parameter G\mu, where G is Newton's constant and \mu is the string's energy per unit length. Searches for short gravitational-wave bursts from cosmic string cusps and kinks in the LIGO/Virgo O3 dataset yield limits of G\mu < 10^{-11} for the Nambu-Goto model, improving previous constraints by up to two orders of magnitude depending on the loop distribution assumed.^[43] Pulsar timing arrays, such as NANOGrav's 15-year dataset, probe the stochastic gravitational-wave background potentially produced by a cosmic string network, setting upper limits of G\mu \lesssim 10^{-10} to $10^{-7} depending on model assumptions for loop distributions and emission when marginalizing over supermassive black hole binary contributions; the observed signal is consistent with tensions in the range $10^{-12} to $10^{-11} in standard models.^[44]^[7] Large-scale structure surveys impose constraints through the absence of expected density perturbations, such as wakes trailing behind cosmic strings that could enhance galaxy clustering. Analysis of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) data, combined with cosmic microwave background measurements, limits the contribution of strings to the power spectrum, yielding G\mu < 10^{-7} at 95% confidence.^[45] High-energy observations constrain cosmic strings via the lack of gamma-ray bursts expected from particle emission at string cusps. The Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT) analysis of the diffuse gamma-ray background places upper limits of G\mu < 10^{-8} for models where cusps efficiently produce gamma rays through Higgs condensate decay or other field-theoretic mechanisms.^[46] Future observatories promise to push these limits dramatically lower. The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), scheduled for launch in the 2030s, is projected to detect or constrain the stochastic gravitational-wave background from cosmic strings down to G\mu \sim 10^{-16} to $10^{-17}, depending on the network model.^[47]^[48] Similarly, the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) pulsar timing capabilities could reach sensitivities of G\mu \sim 10^{-15} by enhancing stochastic background searches in the nanohertz band.^[47]

References

[1]
Cosmic Strings’ Imprints in High-Frequency Gravitational Waves
### Definition and Key Facts About Cosmic Strings
[2]
Cosmic strings and superstrings | Proceedings of the Royal Society A
Jan 8, 2010 · Cosmic strings are predicted by many field-theory models, and may have been formed at a symmetry-breaking transition early in the history of the universe.
[3]
[hep-ph/9411342] Cosmic strings - arXiv
Nov 19, 1994 · The topic of cosmic strings provides a bridge between the physics of the very small and the very large. They are predicted by some unified theories of particle ...
[4]
Cosmic strings and gravitational waves | General Relativity and ...
Sep 14, 2024 · Here, I review the emission of gravitational waves by Nambu–Goto cosmic strings—thin cosmic strings that couple strongly to gravity only—and ...
[5]
[0911.1345] Cosmic Strings and Superstrings - arXiv
Nov 6, 2009 · Here we review the reasons for postulating the existence of cosmic strings or superstrings, the various possible ways in which they might be detected ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[6]
Revised bounds on local cosmic strings from NANOGrav observations
Dec 3, 2024 · When both SMBHB and cosmic string models are included in the analysis, an upper bound on a string tension Gμ≲ 10-10 was derived. However ...
[7]
Revised bounds on local cosmic strings from NANOGrav observations
Apr 3, 2024 · When both SMBHB and cosmic string models are included in the analysis, an upper bound on a string tension G\mu \lesssim 10^{-10} was derived.
[8]
Topology of cosmic domains and strings - IOPscience
The study explores domain structures in broken gauge theory, showing that domain walls, strings, or monopoles depend on the homotopy groups of degenerate vacua.
[9]
[PDF] Grand Unified Models and Cosmology - arXiv
In grand unified theories with rank greater than five, such as SO(10) or E(6), B − L cosmic strings may form, depending on the symmetry breaking pattern ...
[10]
[PDF] Cosmic strings - arXiv
Similar symmetry breaking sequences occur in SO(10) models, where there is a discrete charge conjugation symmetry at intermediate energies, analogous to ˜h, ...
[11]
None
### Summary of Negative-Tension Cosmic Strings from arXiv:2505.22066
[12]
[PDF] Negative Mass in Contemporary Physics
Negative mass reacts oppositely to all forces, moving towards when pushed and away when pulled. It still falls down, and pushes positive mass away.
[13]
Tachyon condensation in string field theory - IOPscience
Surprisingly, the condensation of the tachyon mode alone into the stationary point of its cubic potential is found to cancel about 70% of the D-brane tension.
[14]
[PDF] arXiv:hep-ph/0406064v3 19 Oct 2004
The cosmic strings are produced by tachyon condensation, which are the daughter D3 branes on the worldvolume of the inflation brane. The daughter brane ...
[15]
https://arxiv.org/abs/1412.2750
[16]
[PDF] arXiv:2105.03433v1 [gr-qc] 7 May 2021
May 7, 2021 · One might expect the equation of state pζ = −ρe to lead to instabilities—since one might generally expect systems containing negative energy ...
[17]
[1412.2750] Radially stabilized inflating cosmic strings - arXiv
Dec 8, 2014 · In this work, we investigate dynamical solutions for cosmic strings with super-critical tensions. To this end, we model the string as a ...
[18]
Cosmological experiments in superfluid helium? - Nature
Oct 1, 1985 · Here I discuss the analogy between cosmological strings and vortex lines in the superfluid, and suggest a cryogenic experiment which tests key elements of the ...
[19]
https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.54.1868
[20]
Scaling solutions in cosmic-string networks | Phys. Rev. D
Feb 15, 1992 · The evolution of a cosmic-string network is examined in terms of two length scales: $\ensuremath{\xi}$, related to the long-string density, ...Missing: seminal papers
[21]
Evolution of Cosmic Strings | Phys. Rev. Lett.
Apr 22, 1985 · Results of numerical simulations of the evolution of a network of interacting cosmic strings in an expanding universe are presented and ...
[22]
Scaling of cosmic string loops | Phys. Rev. D
We find that loops are produced in a wide range of sizes, with most of the string length going into relatively large loops of size l ∼ 0.1 t , comparable to the ...
[23]
Gravitational radiation from cosmic strings | Phys. Rev. D
Jun 15, 1985 · The total radiated power is found to be P=γG 𝜇 2 , where μ is the mass density of the string and γ is a numerical coefficient ∼100. The ...
[24]
Gravitational lensing by cosmic strings: what we learn from the CSL ...
The physical properties of a cosmic string predicted by Kibble are characterized by just one parameter, namely the mass per unit length μ, from which the ...
[25]
Direct observation of cosmic strings via their strong gravitational ...
Cosmic strings, which are topological defects formed in the very early universe and persisting to the present epoch, are a quite generic prediction of many ...
[26]
[PDF] The gravitational lensing by long, wiggly cosmic strings is shown to ...
1, the sharp discontinuities (kinks) on the string are vital to the gravitational lensing signature of strings. Unfortu- nately, no suitable ...
[27]
[0908.0602] Direct Observation of Cosmic Strings via their Strong ...
Aug 5, 2009 · We have searched 4.5 square degrees of archival HST/ACS images for cosmic strings, identifying close pairs of similar, faint galaxies and selecting groups ...Missing: constraints | Show results with:constraints
[28]
The Gott-Kaiser-Stebbins (GKS) Effect in an Accelerated Expanding ...
Dec 21, 2012 · We want to find the cosmological constant influence on cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature due to moving linear cosmic strings.
[29]
[PDF] arXiv:astro-ph/9402024v1 9 Feb 1994
is known as the Kaiser-Stebbins effect (Kaiser & Stebbins 1984; Gott 1985). According to this effect, moving long strings present between the time of.
[30]
Cosmic strings - Scholarpedia
Jan 19, 2020 · Strings exist in many field theories motivated by particle physics, and this suggests that they may exist in the universe -- hence the name cosmic strings.
[31]
CMB power spectrum contribution from cosmic strings using field ...
The power spectrum is hence dominated by vector modes for all but the smallest scales, with the scalar, vector and tensor contributions having the ...
[32]
CMB power spectrum of Nambu-Goto cosmic strings | Phys. Rev. D
Apr 14, 2015 · Nambu–Goto strings can be derived as solutions of the Nambu–Goto action, ... to generate Nambu–Goto string networks with Vachaspati–Vilenkin ...Abstract · Article Text · REVIEW OF COSMIC... · COSMIC STRING SIMULATIONS
[33]
[1410.5046] Constraints on the Nambu-Goto cosmic string ... - arXiv
Oct 19, 2014 · Cosmic strings generate vector and tensor modes in the B-channel of polarization, as well as the usual temperature power spectrum and E-mode ...
[34]
[0711.0747] B-modes from Cosmic Strings - arXiv
Nov 5, 2007 · Strings naturally generate as much vector mode perturbation as they do scalar, producing B-mode polarization with a spectrum distinct from that ...Missing: CMB | Show results with:CMB
[35]
Signature of cosmic string wakes in the CMB polarization
We calculate a signature of cosmic strings in the polarization of the cosmic microwave background. We find that ionization in the wakes behind moving ...
[36]
Constraints on the Nambu-Goto cosmic string contribution to the ...
In standard ΛCDM, the Planck likelihood yields an upper limit Gμ<1.49 × 10−7 (95% confidence). We also analyse the possibility of explaining the BB power ...
[37]
Planck Limits on Cosmic String Tension Using Machine Learning
May 31, 2021 · We develop two parallel machine-learning pipelines to estimate the contribution of cosmic strings (CSs), conveniently encoded in their tension ( ...
[38]
[2503.00758] Cosmic Strings-induced CMB anisotropies in light of ...
Mar 2, 2025 · We propose a comprehensive pipeline designed to analyze the morphological properties of string-induced CMB maps within the flat sky approximation.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[39]
None
### Summary of Distinctions Between Cosmic Strings from Field Theory and F-Strings/D-Strings from String Theory
[40]
Cosmic superstrings - ScienceDirect.com
The superstrings of the new O(32) and E8×E8 string theories are boundaries of axion domain walls. These theories are also likely to generate more “conventional” ...Missing: strings | Show results with:strings
[41]
Brane dynamics for treatment of cosmic strings and vortons - arXiv
May 22, 1997 · This course provides a self contained introduction to the general theory of relativistic brane models, of the category that includes point particle, string, ...Missing: codimension- 2
[42]
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0604335
[43]
The growth of linear perturbations in generic defect models ... - arXiv
Oct 22, 1998 · The growth of linear perturbations in generic defect models for structure formation. Authors:P. P. Avelino, J. P. M. de Carvalho.
[44]
[astro-ph/0604335] Cosmological parameters from combining ... - arXiv
Apr 14, 2006 · Cosmological parameters from combining the Lyman-alpha forest with CMB, galaxy clustering and SN constraints. Authors:Uros Seljak, Anze Slosar, ...
[45]
[2101.12248] Constraints on cosmic strings using data from the third ...
Jan 28, 2021 · We search for gravitational-wave signals produced by cosmic strings in the Advanced LIGO and Virgo full O3 data set.
[46]
Cosmic Superstrings Revisited in Light of NANOGrav 15-Year Data
Jun 29, 2023 · We analyze cosmic superstring models in light of NANOGrav 15-year pulsar timing data. A good fit is found for a string tension G \mu \sim 10^{-12} - 10^{-11}
[47]
[1407.3599] Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis and Gamma-Ray ... - arXiv
Jul 14, 2014 · We consider constraints on cosmic strings from their emission of Higgs particles, in the case that the strings have a Higgs condensate with amplitude of order ...
[48]
[1210.2829] Forecast constraints on cosmic strings from future CMB ...
Oct 10, 2012 · In this paper, we evaluate the power of future experiments to constrain cosmic string parameters, such as the string tension Gmu, the initial ...Missing: LISA Gμ