Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Gender

Gender refers to the binary classification of humans as male or female based on biological sex, defined by the type of gametes produced—small motile sperm in males or large immobile ova in females—and associated reproductive anatomy, a dimorphism fundamental to sexual reproduction in mammals including humans.^[1] The term originates from the Latin genus, meaning "kind" or "sort," and was historically synonymous with sex, denoting these reproductive categories.^[2]^[3] Empirical evidence establishes gender roles, behaviors, expressions, and identities as bimodally distributed – with two primary modes typically aligning with male and female sexual dimorphism – and strongly tied to biological sex (heritability exceeding 50%, over 99% natal alignment, 80-90% desistance in childhood dysphoria). Variation arises from a combination of biological overlap in dimorphic traits and social flexibility, producing an apparent continuum without undermining the underlying binary framework of sex or bimodal patterns in gender manifestations.^[4] In mid-20th-century medical and social scientific contexts, gender became distinguished from sex to describe psychosocial roles, behaviors, and identities potentially independent of biology, a conceptual shift originating in clinical observations of atypical cases.^[5]^[6] Empirical evidence, however, supports biological sex as a strict binary in humans, with disorders of sex development (intersex conditions) affecting roughly 0.018% of births and representing developmental anomalies rather than viable third sexes or a spectrum undermining dimorphism.^[7]^[1]^[8] Gender roles—social expectations and behavioral tendencies linked to each sex—exhibit cross-cultural consistencies rooted in evolutionary pressures, such as higher male investment in mating effort versus female parental care, yielding differences in aggression, spatial abilities, and mate preferences.^[9]^[10] These patterns, while modulated by culture, demonstrate a biological foundation, with gender primacy as a perceptual category appearing universal across societies.^[11] Contemporary expansions of gender to include fluid identities and expressions, decoupled from sex, have generated significant controversies, particularly around gender dysphoria—a condition of distress over perceived mismatch between identity and sex—whose reported prevalence has risen sharply among youth, from near rarity to notable increases amid social contagions and institutional affirmation.^[12]^[13] Critiques from biological perspectives argue the sex-gender distinction obscures causal realities of dimorphism, fostering policies that prioritize subjective identity over objective sex differences in domains like athletics, where male physiological advantages persist post-puberty regardless of identity.^[14]^[15] Such debates highlight tensions between empirical data on sex-based traits and ideologically driven narratives, often amplified by biases in academic and media sources favoring non-biological interpretations.^[16]

Etymology and Historical Development

Etymology and Early Usage

The English word gender derives from the Latin genus (stem gener-), meaning "kind," "sort," "race," or "birth," which entered Middle English around 1300 via Old French gendre or Anglo-Norman gendre, primarily to describe grammatical classifications of nouns into categories such as masculine, feminine, or neuter.^[2]^[17] This linguistic application mirrored the Latin use of genus as a translation of ancient Greek γένος (genos), denoting type or class, without inherent ties to biological reproduction or social roles.^[3] In early modern English dictionaries, gender retained its strictly grammatical connotation. Samuel Johnson's A Dictionary of the English Language (1755) defined it in terms of noun classification and syntactic agreement, reflecting prevailing usage in discussions of inflected languages like Latin, French, and German, where pronouns and adjectives concord with noun genders irrespective of natural sex.^[18] The term's application to human or animal sex appeared sporadically from the late 14th century but remained uncommon and secondary to its grammatical sense until the 20th century, with no established link to societal roles or identities.^[2] By the 18th century, scientific disciplines occasionally extended analogous grammatical terminology to biological categorization, as in botany, where Carl Linnaeus's 1735 Systema Naturae classified plants using a sexual system based on stamen (male) and pistil (female) structures, drawing parallels to gendered noun classes while grounding distinctions in observable reproductive morphology.^[19] This usage preserved gender's roots in categorical sorting tied to empirical traits, predating any abstract social interpretations.^[20]

Grammatical Gender in Languages

Grammatical gender constitutes a system of noun classification in linguistics, wherein nouns are grouped into categories—typically masculine, feminine, and/or neuter—that govern agreement patterns with modifiers such as articles, adjectives, and pronouns. This feature, distinct from biological sex, primarily facilitates syntactic structure rather than semantic content related to referents' attributes. In the Indo-European language family, grammatical gender originated in Proto-Indo-European, which exhibited three genders: masculine for active or male-associated animates, feminine for female-associated or certain collectives, and neuter for inanimates or abstracts.^[21] The categories often assign genders arbitrarily to inanimate nouns, decoupling them from biological sex. In French, "table" receives feminine gender as "la table," dictating feminine forms for agreeing elements like adjectives (e.g., "une grande table"). In German, "Mädchen" (girl) is neuter ("das Mädchen") owing to its diminutive ending "-chen," which neutralizes nouns regardless of the referent's sex, requiring neuter agreement. These conventions underscore the system's syntactic utility over any mimetic representation of natural properties.^[22]^[23]^[24] Languages with natural gender, by comparison, tie pronoun and agreement distinctions more closely to biological sex for animates while eschewing broad noun classification. English employs "he" for males, "she" for females, and "it" for inanimates or unspecified sex, without requiring gender agreement on inanimate nouns. Danish maintains a grammatical common-neuter distinction for nouns (e.g., "en bil" common for car, "et hus" neuter for house) but defaults pronouns to natural gender patterns for humans, reflecting a partial shift from fuller Proto-Indo-European systems.^[25]^[26] Evolutionary linguistics views grammatical gender as an emergent cognitive adaptation for partitioning lexical items into manageable classes, aiding memory, reference tracking, and phrase-level predictability via agreement, rather than deriving from or causally influencing social gender constructs. Proto-Indo-European gender likely expanded from an animate-inanimate binary to three classes for finer nominal organization, with subsequent languages retaining or simplifying it for processing efficiency.^[27]^[21] The concept of gender as a social phenomenon distinct from biological sex gained traction in the mid-20th century, initially through philosophical and psychological lenses rather than empirical validation. In her 1949 book The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir articulated an existentialist view that women's social position arises not from innate biology but from cultural conditioning, famously stating, "One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman," thereby laying groundwork for later constructionist theories that emphasized socialization over biological determinism.^[28] This perspective, rooted in phenomenological analysis rather than controlled studies, influenced subsequent feminist thought by prioritizing lived experience and societal roles, though it faced criticism for overlooking cross-cultural biological universals in sex differences.^[29] Psychologist John Money operationalized the distinction in clinical contexts, coining the term "gender role" in 1955 to describe the behavioral and psychological attributes adopted by individuals with intersex conditions, separate from their chromosomal or anatomical sex.^[30] Money extended this to "gender identity" by the 1960s, arguing that identity could be shaped environmentally if interventions occurred early, as in cases of ambiguous genitalia where he advocated surgical reassignment and upbringing aligned with the chosen role.^[31] However, his theories rested on limited case studies with methodological flaws, including non-representative samples from intersex populations that comprised less than 0.02% of births, and lacked longitudinal controls to isolate nurture from nature.^[32] The 1970s saw feminist anthropologists like Gayle Rubin formalize the separation through the "sex/gender system," defined in her 1975 essay "The Traffic in Women" as societal mechanisms converting biological sexuality into gendered products of human activity, such as kinship roles and labor divisions.^[33] This framework, drawing on Marxist and structuralist ideas, promoted gender as a cultural overlay amenable to deconstruction, influencing academic disciplines amid second-wave feminism's push against perceived patriarchal biology. Yet, early empirical support was scant, with Rubin's model relying on ethnographic analogies rather than falsifiable data, and it contrasted with emerging evolutionary psychology critiques that highlighted innate, heritable sex differences in behavior observable in infants and primates, predating socialization.^[34] Money's claims were dramatically undermined by the David Reimer case, where a biologically male twin (born 1965) underwent reassignment after a botched circumcision in 1966, raised as "Brenda" under Money's protocol from 1967 onward; despite intensive therapy, Reimer rejected the female identity by adolescence, reverting to male at age 14 in the 1980s, and later died by suicide in 2004, exposing the limits of environmental determinism.^[35] This outcome, publicized in the 1990s, revealed ethical lapses like coerced compliance in Money's reports and underscored that gender concepts often outpaced rigorous testing, with constructionist views persisting in activist circles despite biological counterevidence from twin studies showing 50-80% heritability in gender-typical behaviors.^[36] These constructivist views, foundational to gender ideology, emphasize cultural flexibility over biological dimorphism but face critiques for evidentiary gaps (e.g., Money's Reimer case failure).

Biological Basis of Sex and Gender

Genetic and Chromosomal Foundations

In humans, biological sex is primarily determined by the chromosomal complement at fertilization, with typical females possessing a 46,XX karyotype and males a 46,XY karyotype.^[37] The presence of the Y chromosome distinguishes males, as it contains the SRY (sex-determining region Y) gene, which encodes a transcription factor that initiates the differentiation of the bipotential gonad into testes around the 6th to 7th week of embryonic development.^[38] ^[39] In the absence of SRY, as in XX individuals, the default developmental pathway leads to ovarian formation.^[37] The SRY protein achieves this by binding to DNA and activating downstream genes such as SOX9, which promote Sertoli cell differentiation and subsequent testicular morphogenesis, establishing the binary trajectory of sexual dimorphism.^[39] This mechanism underscores the chromosomal foundation as the primary causal driver, with over 99% of individuals conforming to these XX/XY patterns and producing anisogamous gametes—small, mobile sperm in males or large, sessile ova in females—as the evolutionary hallmark of sex.^[40] No viable chromosomal configuration in humans or other sexually reproducing species generates a third gamete type capable of fusing with either sperm or ova to propagate reproduction.^[41] Disorders of sex development (DSDs), including chromosomal aneuploidies, occur in approximately 1 in 4,500 to 5,500 births and represent deviations that do not negate the binary framework, as affected individuals align with one sex based on gamete production potential or default to sterility without intermediate functionality.^[42] For instance, Klinefelter syndrome (47,XXY) results in a male phenotype with testicular dysgenesis, elevated gonadotropins, and near-universal infertility due to azoospermia, though rare mosaic cases may produce limited sperm; these individuals do not develop ovaries or ova.^[43] ^[44] Similarly, Turner syndrome (45,X or mosaics) yields a female phenotype with streak gonads, ovarian dysgenesis, and infertility, lacking functional spermatogenesis.^[45] ^[46] Such conditions, comprising less than 0.02% of the population for those severely disrupting gonadal development, reinforce gametic dimorphism as the definitive criterion, as no DSD enables production of both sperm and ova or a novel gamete class.^[40]^[42]

Hormonal and Physiological Dimorphism

In male fetuses, testosterone production surges between approximately weeks 8 and 24 of gestation, peaking around weeks 10 to 20, driven initially by human chorionic gonadotropin from the placenta.^[47]^[48] This prenatal androgen exposure organizes the differentiation of male external genitalia, including the formation of the penis and scrotum from genital tubercle and folds, as well as internal structures like the prostate and seminal vesicles.^[47] It also influences skeletal development, promoting greater male-typical bone growth patterns evident in later dimorphisms such as broader shoulders and denser long bones.^[47] Causal evidence for these effects comes from congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), a disorder causing excess adrenal androgen production in XX fetuses; affected females exhibit virilization of external genitalia, including clitoral enlargement and labial fusion resembling male structures, directly attributable to elevated prenatal androgens rather than genetic sex.^[49]^[50] Studies of opposite-sex twins further isolate hormonal influences, showing that female co-twins of males experience prenatal testosterone transfer via shared placental circulation, resulting in subtle physical shifts like reduced female-typical ovarian follicle counts, independent of genetic confounding.^[51] During puberty, circulating testosterone in males rises 20- to 30-fold, far exceeding estrogen-driven changes in females, amplifying dimorphisms in muscle, bone, and cardiovascular capacity.^[52]^[53] Males develop approximately 40% greater total skeletal muscle mass than females by adulthood, with lean body mass increasing disproportionately in boys due to androgen receptor activation in muscle fibers.^[54] This contributes to males averaging 15% to 30% higher maximal oxygen uptake (VO2 max), reflecting enhanced aerobic capacity tied to larger hearts, higher hemoglobin levels, and greater mitochondrial density in muscle, as isolated in twin studies controlling for shared genetics.^[55]^[56] Females, conversely, accrue more adipose tissue and develop wider pelvic structures optimized for gestation, with estrogens promoting fat deposition in hips and thighs while inhibiting excessive muscle hypertrophy.^[54] These hormonal divergences underpin lifespan health disparities. Estrogens in females enhance immune responsiveness but predispose to autoimmunity, with women comprising 75% to 80% of cases across diseases like rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus, as evidenced by disease flares during high-estrogen phases like pregnancy.^[57]^[58] In males, sustained testosterone supports higher bone mineral density and muscle power but correlates with elevated injury rates, including 2- to 3-fold higher trauma incidence in young adults, linked to androgen effects on tissue resilience and biomechanics rather than purely behavioral factors.^[59] Twin data reinforce hormonal causality by showing that prenatal androgen exposure predicts later physical vigor in males beyond genetic baselines.^[60]

Neurological and Brain Sex Differences

Males possess larger total brain volumes than females, with meta-analyses reporting an average difference of approximately 11% in adults after adjusting for body size.^[61] This dimorphism emerges early, as newborn males exhibit greater subcortical volumes and overall brain size compared to females, even after controlling for total intracranial volume.^[62] Females, in turn, demonstrate relatively greater cortical gray matter volumes and enhanced interhemispheric connectivity, including stronger co-activation patterns between brain hemispheres during functional tasks.^[63]^[64] Prenatal androgen exposure influences early behavioral indicators of brain dimorphism, correlating with sex-typical toy preferences in toddlers; higher androgen levels predict preferences for wheeled toys and mechanical objects, observed across genetic sexes in conditions like congenital adrenal hyperplasia.^[65]^[66] Transcriptomic analyses of early fetal brains, conducted in April 2025, reveal sex-specific gene expression differences detectable from the first trimester, involving over 3,000 genes with divergent activity patterns driven by both chromosomal and hormonal factors, though the magnitude remains limited.^[67]^[68] Functional neuroimaging, including fMRI, demonstrates sex-differentiated activation patterns in cognitive domains: females exhibit stronger responses in regions associated with empathy, such as the mirror neuron system, while males show heightened activity in areas linked to systemizing, like visuospatial processing networks, patterns that align with the empathizing-systemizing framework and persist independent of cultural context.^[69]^[70] A May 2025 investigation uncovered marked sex differences in mitochondrial gene activity within brain cells, with males displaying elevated expression across all protein-coding mitochondrial genes compared to females, potentially contributing to divergent energy metabolism and cellular resilience.^[71] Longitudinal studies further indicate that brain aging proceeds faster in males, with greater volume loss across multiple regions—including frontal and temporal lobes—relative to females, despite females' higher incidence of certain neurodegenerative conditions.^[72]^[73]

Comparative Evidence from Non-Human Animals

In non-human animals, sex-linked behaviors exhibit strong dimorphism tied to reproductive roles and hormonal profiles, providing evidence for evolutionarily conserved traits that parallel human gender-typical patterns independent of cultural influences. Observations across species demonstrate that males often engage in competitive displays or territorial defense to attract mates, while females select partners based on these signals, a pattern driven by gamete asymmetry and parental investment differences.^[74]^[75] Mate selection behaviors highlight this dimorphism, as seen in avian species where males perform elaborate courtship displays, such as the acrobatic leaps and snaps of golden-collared manakins (Manacus vitellinus), which females evaluate for motor precision and vigor. These displays, absent in females, correlate with mating success and are modulated by sex-specific neural and hormonal circuits. In mammals, testosterone facilitates territorial aggression; for instance, in seasonally breeding birds and rodents, elevated testosterone levels during breeding seasons enhance defense of resources critical for reproduction, with experimental implants increasing territorial responses in males.^[75]^[74]^[76] Castration experiments further causally link hormones to these behaviors: in male rats, orchiectomy reduces mounting, aggression toward intruders, and shock-induced fighting, effects reversed by testosterone administration, indicating that gonadal androgens organize and activate male-typical patterns post-puberty. Similar reversals occur in other mammals, where androgen deprivation diminishes competitive and exploratory tendencies otherwise prominent in intact males.^[77]^[78]^[79] Parental roles also show sex-specificity, with females in primates like common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) exclusively providing nursing due to lactation, while males contribute carrying and grooming, behaviors essential for twin offspring survival in cooperative breeding systems. Same-sex pairings in captivity rarely replicate these dimorphic roles without biological surrogacy, as males cannot lactate and females lack the same provisioning capacity, underscoring the necessity of physiological dimorphism for functional caregiving division.^[80]^[81]^[82] Wild populations exhibit no systematic evidence of innate gender fluidity, where individuals persistently adopt opposite-sex behavioral repertoires decoupled from morphology; transient same-sex mounting occurs for dominance or alliance but does not entail role reversal or identity shifts akin to human claims. Anomalies like intersex traits in fish, such as oocyte development in male roach (Rutilus rutilus), correlate with exposure to anthropogenic endocrine disruptors like alkylphenols and estrogens from wastewater, rather than adaptive variation, and prevalence declines in uncontaminated habitats.^[83]^[84]^[85]^[86]

Psychological Aspects of Gender

Development of Gender Identity

Gender identity in typically developing children emerges early in life, with basic awareness of one's own sex appearing by around age 2 years, as children begin to label themselves and others using sex-based categories such as "boy" or "girl."^[87] This initial gender self-concept aligns with biological sex in the vast majority of cases and precedes explicit parental instruction or broader socialization, as evidenced by longitudinal observations showing spontaneous categorization without cognitive prerequisites like gender constancy.^[87] By ages 2-3, over 90% of children demonstrate sex-typical behavioral preferences, including strong inclinations toward gender-congruent toys—girls favoring dolls and boys preferring vehicles or construction items—with meta-analyses of free-play studies reporting large effect sizes (Cohen's d ≈ 1.0-1.6) indicative of near-universal patterns in unselected populations.^[88]^[89] These preferences stabilize and intensify through middle childhood, correlating with biological markers like prenatal androgen exposure rather than cultural reinforcement alone, as cross-cultural consistencies and animal analogs suggest innate drivers.^[89] In cases of early gender nonconformity, longitudinal clinic data from pre-2010s cohorts indicate high rates of resolution, with 80-95% of children diagnosed with gender dysphoria desisting by adolescence or adulthood without intervention, often aligning with their natal sex following puberty.^[90]^[91] Persistence is rarer and linked to intensity of early symptoms and comorbidities like autism spectrum traits, rather than isolated nonconformity.^[4] Twin studies further illuminate etiology, estimating moderate heritability for childhood gender nonconformity (30-70% of variance), as seen in Dutch and U.S. cohorts where monozygotic concordance exceeds dizygotic but shared environment plays a minimal role.^[92]^[93] However, genetic influences do not predict long-term persistence absent additional factors, with desistance predominant in uncomplicated cases, underscoring developmental plasticity aligned with biological sex.^[91] These patterns hold in data from specialized clinics prior to widespread social transitioning, which newer evidence suggests may reduce desistance rates.^[94]

Gender Dysphoria: Etiology and Persistence

Gender dysphoria, which evolved from "gender identity disorder" added in DSM-III (1980) for clinical treatment of persistent cross-gender identification and renamed in DSM-5 (2013) to emphasize distress and incongruence while reducing pathologization of identity itself, as defined in the DSM-5 published in 2013, involves a marked incongruence between one's experienced or expressed gender and primary or secondary sex characteristics or biological sex, lasting at least six months and accompanied by clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.^[95]^[96] This diagnosis requires evidence of at least two indicators, such as a strong desire to be rid of one's sex characteristics, a conviction that one's feelings and reactions align with the opposite gender, or a desire to live as that gender, distinguishing it from mere gender nonconformity without distress.^[97] Empirical studies indicate substantial comorbidities with gender dysphoria, including elevated rates of autism spectrum disorder (ASD), with meta-analyses estimating a pooled prevalence of 11% among individuals with gender dysphoria, far exceeding general population rates of around 1-2%.^[98] Clinical overlap reaches 20-26% in some youth cohorts referred to gender clinics, potentially linked to shared neurodevelopmental factors or difficulties in social cue interpretation that may amplify body-related distress.^[99] Additional associations include histories of trauma, with gender-dysphoric individuals reporting higher rates of adverse childhood experiences compared to non-dysphoric peers, and overlaps with body dysmorphic disorder, where preoccupation with perceived bodily flaws exacerbates incongruence-related anxiety.^[100]^[101] Referrals for gender dysphoria, particularly adolescent-onset cases, surged post-2010, exemplified by the UK's Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) at Tavistock, where total referrals rose from 77 in 2009 to 2,590 in 2018-19, with female referrals increasing over 4,000% from 40 in 2009-10 to 1,806 in 2017-18.^[102]^[103] This shift toward predominantly adolescent females contrasts with historical patterns dominated by pre-pubertal boys and aligns with evidence of social contagion, including cluster outbreaks within friend groups and sudden onsets reported by parents in surveys of over 1,600 cases.^[104]^[105] The rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) phenomenon, described in parental reports, features abrupt declarations during or after puberty, often following increased online exposure or peer identification, challenging traditional etiological models rooted in innate cross-sex identification. Persistence of gender dysphoria from childhood into adulthood remains low, with longitudinal studies reporting desistance rates of 73-98% among pre-pubertal cases, meaning fewer than 15-27% maintain dysphoria post-puberty without intervention.^[106] Early-onset cases without social transition show even higher resolution, often resolving alongside puberty's hormonal changes, whereas adolescent or rapid-onset subtypes exhibit variable trajectories, with parental reports indicating higher reversal rates in non-medicalized contexts, potentially due to external influences dissipating over time.^[107]^[94] These patterns suggest etiological heterogeneity, where pre-pubertal dysphoria may stem more from transient developmental factors and adolescent surges from psychosocial amplifiers, underscoring the need for causal discernment beyond affirmation assumptions prevalent in biased clinical reporting.^[108]

Associated Mental Health Factors

Individuals with gender dysphoria exhibit markedly elevated rates of suicidal ideation and attempts compared to the general population, with lifetime suicide attempt rates often exceeding 40% among transgender adults and youth cohorts prior to medical interventions.^[109] In adolescent samples, female-to-male identifying individuals have reported attempt rates as high as 51%.^[110] These figures persist even after accounting for demographic factors, underscoring a baseline psychiatric vulnerability in this group.^[111] Comorbid mental health conditions are prevalent, with 60-70% of individuals diagnosed with gender dysphoria also experiencing depression or anxiety disorders.^[112] Over 70% of youth with gender dysphoria present with additional psychiatric comorbidities, including mood disorders and trauma-related conditions.^[113] Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) co-occurs at rates 3-6 times higher than in the general population, potentially indicating that gender-related distress in some cases reflects broader neurodevelopmental challenges rather than isolated incongruence with biological sex.^[114] This overlap suggests misattribution risks, where underlying ASD traits may amplify perceptions of body incongruence or social discomfort.^[115] Long-term cohort data reveal that psychiatric risks do not substantially abate following gender-affirming surgeries or hormones. A Swedish nationwide study tracking 324 individuals post-sex reassignment from 1973 to 2003 found suicide mortality rates 19.1 times higher than matched controls, alongside elevated overall mortality and psychiatric inpatient admissions; the authors noted that results should not be interpreted as sex reassignment per se increasing morbidity and mortality, but rather that the patient group is at high risk, and outcomes might have been worse without intervention.^[116] Recent analyses, including a 2024 review of surgical outcomes, confirm persistently higher self-harm and suicide risks post-intervention, challenging assumptions that transition causally resolves underlying distress.^[117] These patterns imply that gender dysphoria often signals deeper, untreated psychopathologies, with affirmative treatments showing limited efficacy in mitigating long-term harms.^[118]

Evolutionary Origins of Gender Roles

Evolutionary theories posit that sex differences in human behavior originated from asymmetries in reproductive costs and parental investment between males and females, shaping adaptive strategies over deep time.^[119] In Robert Trivers' 1972 parental investment theory, the sex facing greater obligatory investment—typically females due to internal gestation, lactation, and initial offspring care—evolves greater selectivity in mate choice and risk aversion to protect reproductive efforts, while the lower-investing sex, males, pursues multiple matings through intrasexual competition and risk-taking.^[120] ^[121] This framework predicts and explains patterns observed across species, where male-male competition for mates manifests in traits like aggression and territoriality, contrasted with female choosiness and neophobia to safeguard higher-stakes investments.^[119] Cross-species evidence supports these origins, as in the vast majority of vertebrates and invertebrates, males exhibit greater variance in reproductive success through competitive strategies, while females prioritize quality over quantity in partners.^[119] For instance, in polygynous mammals such as elephants and gorillas, males engage in lethal combats for harems, reflecting evolved risk tolerance absent in females focused on sustaining pregnancies and nursing.^[119] These patterns extend to behavioral dimorphisms, with males often displaying exploratory and aggressive tendencies tied to mate access, while females emphasize caution and provisioning—dynamics that parallel human universals without invoking cultural invention alone.^[122] In ancestral human environments, such as hunter-gatherer societies representing over 95% of hominid history, these pressures manifested in a near-universal sexual division of labor: men predominantly hunted large game requiring strength, endurance, and group coordination for high-risk, high-reward returns, while women focused on gathering reliable plant resources and childcare compatible with mobility constraints of infancy.^[123] Ethnographic surveys, including Ember's 1978 analysis of 179 foraging groups, found men as sole or primary big-game hunters in 93% of cases (166 societies), linked to average male physical advantages in upper-body strength and aerobic capacity suiting variable-distance pursuits.^[123] ^[124] This division maximized caloric efficiency and offspring survival, with women's contributions stable yet proximate to camps to minimize predation risks during vulnerable reproductive phases.^[125] Contemporary deviations from these roles correlate with evolutionary mismatches, including fertility declines and well-being disparities. In developed nations, women's mass workforce entry since the 1970s has coincided with fertility rates dropping below replacement levels (e.g., 1.6 births per woman in the U.S. by 2023), as egalitarian shifts delay partnering and childbearing, conflicting with peak reproductive windows.^[126] ^[127] Studies link traditional gender attitudes to higher fertility intentions, with acceptance of role specialization predicting more children via complementary investments.^[126] Similarly, General Social Survey data from 1972–2006 reveal women's self-reported happiness declining relative to men's, with the gender gap reversing amid expanded options that amplify trade-offs between career and family demands.^[128] ^[129] These trends suggest costs to overriding evolved predispositions, though adaptive flexibility allows variation within sex-typical ranges.^[128]

Cross-Cultural Patterns and Variations

Cross-cultural ethnographic databases, such as George P. Murdock's Ethnographic Atlas covering 1,291 societies, reveal consistent sex-based divisions of labor, with men performing warfare, big-game hunting, and tool-making in over 90% of cases, while women undertake childcare, cooking, and gathering of vegetable foods or small game in nearly all societies.^[130] ^[131] In the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample of 186 societies derived from Murdock's work, these assignments show probabilistic entailments rather than strict universals, yet exceptions are rare and never involve wholesale reversals, such as women dominating warfare or men assuming primary infant caregiving roles.^[132] ^[133] The Human Relations Area Files (HRAF), aggregating data from hundreds of societies, confirm that factors like task distance from home or physical demands predict sex-typical allocations, with women contributing more to nearby, low-risk subsistence in horticultural groups, but retaining primary responsibility for kin care across subsistence types.^[134] ^[135] No documented society features reversed dimorphisms, such as female-led raiding parties or male-dominated childcare, underscoring the robustness of these patterns against cultural variation.^[131] ^[136] In matrilineal societies like the Mosuo of southwestern China, where women inherit property and manage households through "walking marriages" without formal cohabitation, flexibility in roles does not erase sex differences; women remain focused on maternal kin and exhibit choosier mate selection based on traits like physical attractiveness, while men display competitive behaviors in social networks.^[137] ^[138] These modulations highlight cultural influences on role expression but preserve underlying behavioral dimorphisms, as Mosuo women show muted but persistent preferences aligning with broader cross-cultural female patterns in partner evaluation.^[139] Immigration data further illustrate persistence: among migrants to Western countries, origin-country sex gaps in religiosity endure, with women maintaining higher attendance and traditional attitudes linked to individual piety, even after generations, as seen in Muslim and Latin American groups where female religiosity exceeds male by 10-20 percentage points in surveys.^[140] ^[141] Occupational segregation similarly holds, with religious immigrant women from conservative origins participating less in the labor market (e.g., 15-25% lower employment rates than nonreligious peers) and clustering in care-oriented fields, resisting full assimilation to host norms.^[141] Such evidence from over 100 societies and migrant cohorts refutes pure social constructionism, revealing invariant cores modulated by ecology and tradition rather than arbitrarily invented.^[131]^[134]

Impacts of Language, Religion, and Tradition

Empirical investigations into the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which posits that language structure influences thought, have tested whether grammatical gender systems—present in languages like Spanish, German, and French—shape perceptions of gender norms or identity. Studies demonstrate weak effects on object categorization: for instance, German speakers, who assign feminine gender to "bridge" (Brücke), describe it with attributes like "elegant" more often than Spanish speakers, who use masculine "puente" and favor terms like "strong."^[142] However, these biases are subtle, context-dependent, and confined to inanimate objects, with no robust evidence extending to human gender identity or overriding biological sex differences in self-perception.^[143] A systematic review of 43 studies involving nearly 6,000 participants found inconsistent and small-scale influences, suggesting language reinforces rather than causally determines gender-related cognition.^[143] Abrahamic religions, drawing from creation accounts in Genesis 1:27—"So God created man in his own image... male and female he created them"—emphasize a binary sexual dimorphism as divinely ordained, which correlates with reduced gender nonconformity in adherent populations. Surveys indicate that individuals in conservative Christian, Jewish, and Muslim communities exhibit lower rates of transgender identification compared to secular groups; for example, U.S. data show religiously affiliated adults are more likely to affirm that gender aligns with biological sex at birth (62% among Catholics in 2022, up from 52% in 2021), reflecting normative pressures that align with observed lower self-reported dysphoria.^[144] This pattern holds in global comparisons, where high-religiosity societies report transgender prevalence below 0.5% versus 1-2% in secular Western contexts, though causation remains correlative and intertwined with cultural enforcement of biological norms rather than suppression of innate variance.^[145] Traditional practices exaggerating gender roles, such as Chinese foot-binding (prevalent from the 10th to early 20th century) and female genital mutilation (FGM) in parts of Africa and the Middle East, impose physical modifications to enforce female subservience but fail to alter underlying biological preferences. Foot-binding, which deformed feet to symbolize beauty and immobility, affected up to 50% of Chinese women by the 19th century yet ended rapidly after 1912 bans without shifting persistent sex differences in occupational interests or mate selection criteria observed cross-culturally.^[146] Similarly, FGM—performed on over 200 million girls as of 2023—increases risks like postpartum hemorrhage by 55% and neonatal death by 15%, per systematic reviews, yet longitudinal data from migrant communities show no diminishment of innate female preferences for nurturing roles post-avoidance, indicating these customs amplify but do not reprogram evolved dimorphisms. Such interventions highlight cultural limits in overriding physiology, often yielding net harms without evidence of sustained psychological reconfiguration.^[147]

Gender in Contemporary Society

Educational and Cognitive Sex Differences

Sex differences in cognitive abilities manifest in average group performance across academic domains, with males exhibiting advantages in spatial reasoning and mathematical aptitude at the extremes, while females show superior verbal abilities. The greater male variability hypothesis posits that males display larger standard deviations in cognitive traits, leading to overrepresentation at both high and low tails of distributions.^[148] This pattern is evident in fields requiring exceptional quantitative skills, where males comprise approximately 92% of International Mathematical Olympiad winners since 1988, reflecting a 12:1 male-to-female ratio among top performers. Similarly, in scientific Nobel Prizes (physics, chemistry, and physiology or medicine), fewer than 6% of laureates have been female as of 2024, yielding ratios exceeding 15:1 in favor of males.^[149] In contrast, females outperform males in reading comprehension, with gaps ranging from 0.13 to 0.34 standard deviations in assessments like PISA and NAEP, where girls score 22-24 points higher on average in OECD countries.^[150]^[151]^[152] These disparities in STEM-related domains correlate strongly with biological factors, particularly sex differences in mental rotation and spatial visualization, which meta-analyses attribute to males' consistent outperformance by 0.5-1.0 standard deviations.^[153]^[154] Such abilities explain over 50% of variance in mathematical and engineering performance, as spatial tasks predict success in these fields beyond general intelligence.^[153] Twin studies reinforce a genetic etiology, revealing higher heritability for spatial and quantitative traits in males (up to 66% in adolescence) compared to shared environmental influences, with sex-specific genetic effects persisting into adulthood.^[155]^[156] For verbal abilities, heritability estimates similarly favor genetic over environmental factors, though female advantages emerge earlier and show less variability.^[157] Intervention efforts, including affirmative action quotas in STEM admissions and scholarships, have increased female enrollment but failed to eliminate performance gaps or boost representation at elite levels.^[158] Despite such policies, women constitute only 29% of the global STEM workforce as of 2024, with persistent underrepresentation in high-variance domains like mathematics competitions and patenting.^[158]^[159] Studies of quota implementations show short-term enrollment gains but no proportional rise in degree completions or innovation outputs, suggesting intrinsic cognitive variances limit equalization.^[160] Emerging neuroimaging and experimental data from 2025 highlight sex-specific neural mechanisms underlying learning optima. Males rely more on NMDA receptors for synaptic strengthening in spatial tasks, while females utilize estrogen modulation, leading to superior episodic memory for contextual details but differential handling of quantitative loads.^[161] These findings, derived from controlled brain imaging, indicate tailored educational approaches—such as optimized nutrition influencing fatty acid sensitivity via estrogen—could address variances without overriding biological baselines.^[162]

Occupational Segregation and Economic Outcomes

Occupational segregation by sex remains pronounced globally, with women comprising over 90% of workers in nursing and childcare roles, while men hold over 80% of positions in engineering fields.^[163]^[164] This horizontal segregation aligns with persistent differences in vocational interests: women disproportionately select people-oriented occupations, and men things-oriented ones, patterns observed across cultures and economic systems.^[164] Longitudinal research indicates these preferences emerge early and drive career trajectories independently of socialization or exposure. For instance, gender-typed interests measured in adolescence bidirectionally predict skills and occupational outcomes in adulthood, with male-typed interests (e.g., mechanical) preceding entry into technical fields.^[165] Prenatal androgen exposure further correlates with object-oriented interests that forecast STEM career choices, suggesting biological influences on revealed preferences over discriminatory barriers.^[166] The gender pay gap, often cited as 16-20% unadjusted in the U.S. (women earning 83.6% of men's median weekly earnings in 2023), shrinks to near zero when accounting for occupational choices, hours worked, and experience.^[167] Decompositions attribute 70-80% of the gap to voluntary factors, including women's preferences for flexible, lower-hour roles and the motherhood trade-off, where reduced labor supply reflects prioritized family commitments rather than coercion.^[168]^[169] This dynamic intensifies in egalitarian settings, as evidenced by the Nordic paradox: despite policies promoting equality, occupational segregation and pay gaps are larger in Sweden and Norway than in less interventionist nations, implying that reduced external pressures allow innate preferences to diverge more freely.^[170]^[171] Men's higher propensity for risk manifests in entrepreneurship, where they found approximately 87% of startups, driven by adaptive strategies favoring high-variance pursuits despite elevated failure rates.^[172] Women's underrepresentation (around 13%) in founding teams persists even in funded ventures, underscoring sex differences in tolerance for uncertainty over access barriers.^[172]^[173]

Family Dynamics and Reproductive Roles

Sex differences in reproductive biology impose distinct constraints on family formation and stability. Women experience peak fertility between ages 20 and 30, after which fecundity declines sharply due to diminishing oocyte quality and quantity, whereas men maintain higher fertility into later decades with a more gradual decline beginning around age 30.^[174]^[175] This asymmetry influences partnering patterns, as women's narrower reproductive window incentivizes earlier family establishment, while men's extended potential allows deferred paternity but raises risks of age-related genetic mutations in offspring. Delayed childbearing among women, increasingly common in developed nations, elevates aneuploidy risks, such as trisomy 21 (Down syndrome), with incidence rising from approximately 1 in 1,500 births for mothers under 25 to 1 in 100 for those aged 40 and older.^[176]^[177] In family dynamics, these biological imperatives manifest in patterns of marital dissolution and parenting roles. In the United States, women initiate approximately 69% of divorces in heterosexual marriages, a figure derived from longitudinal analyses of marital histories.^[178] This propensity contributes to the prevalence of single-mother households, which comprise about 80% of single-parent families and are associated with elevated child adversity. Children in such households face heightened risks of delinquency and incarceration; for instance, father-absent homes correlate with juvenile violent crime rates up to 17% higher than intact families, and youth from single-mother families represent a disproportionate share—around 70%—of juvenile delinquents in some datasets.^[179]^[180] Paternal investment plays a critical role in mitigating these risks, aligning with evolutionary models positing that male provisioning enhances offspring survival and competitiveness. Empirical studies confirm that father presence and involvement improve child developmental outcomes, including reduced behavioral problems and better socioeconomic attainment, independent of maternal effects.^[181]^[182] In species-typical human pair-bonding, biparental care buffers against instability, as single-mother arrangements often strain resources and supervision, amplifying delinquency odds through mechanisms like reduced monitoring and economic hardship.^[183] These patterns underscore causal linkages between intact dual-parent structures—facilitated by complementary sex roles—and favorable child trajectories, with disruptions disproportionately affecting outcomes via absent male investment.^[184]

Legal and Policy Frameworks

2025 U.S. Executive Order 14168 (Jan 20) mandates federal recognition of sex as immutable binary (male/female).^[185]

Definitions of Sex in Law and Policy

Prior to the 2000s, legal frameworks in many jurisdictions defined sex as a binary, immutable biological classification distinguishing males from females based on reproductive anatomy and chromosomes.^[186]^[187] This understanding underpinned anti-discrimination laws, such as the U.S. Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which applies intermediate scrutiny to classifications based on biological sex as an objective trait.^[188] In the United States, Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 prohibited discrimination "on the basis of sex" in federally funded education programs, with "sex" originally grounded in biology at the time of enactment, enabling sex-segregated facilities and sports to address historical disparities faced by females.^[189]^[190] Emerging policies in the early 2000s introduced mechanisms to alter legal sex markers, diverging from strict biological anchoring. The United Kingdom's Gender Recognition Act 2004 established a process for obtaining a Gender Recognition Certificate, which retroactively changes a person's legal sex for most purposes, converting their birth-registered sex to the acquired gender.^[191] This shift facilitated civil recognition of gender identity over biology in documents like birth certificates, though it required medical evidence and did not fully override all contexts, such as certain sporting regulations. Recent judicial and executive actions have reaffirmed biological sex as the operative definition in key policies, countering expansions incorporating gender identity. In April 2025, the UK Supreme Court ruled unanimously that "sex," "man," and "woman" in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex recorded at birth, unaffected by a Gender Recognition Certificate for anti-discrimination purposes.^[192]^[193] In the U.S., a February 2025 executive order defined sex as "an individual's immutable biological classification as either male or female," directing enforcement of Title IX based on biology to protect women's opportunities in education and sports.^[194] Federal courts in 2024 and 2025 invalidated Biden administration rules redefining "sex" under Title IX to include gender identity, holding that such interpretations exceeded statutory authority and undermined biological protections.^[195]^[196] Policies permitting self-identification without biological verification have correlated with safety compromises in single-sex spaces, prompting empirical scrutiny and legal reversals. UK Ministry of Justice data and analogous international reports document increased sexual offenses in female facilities following self-ID access, including a sharp rise in rapes attributed to "female" offenders after self-declaration reforms in jurisdictions like Ireland.^[197] U.S. sports cases before the Supreme Court in 2025 highlight how gender identity overrides erode fairness, with courts recognizing biological differences in strength and performance as necessitating sex-based segregation under Title IX.^[198]^[199] These developments underscore causal links between policy detachment from biology and tangible harms, informing ongoing efforts to restore immutable sex as the legal baseline for protections.^[200] Policy debates often pit ideological affirmation against empirical caution, as in the Cass Review's (2024) findings of weak youth intervention evidence; see Opposition to Gender Ideology for global pushback dynamics.^[201]

Transgender Recognition and Rights

In the United States, the Supreme Court's 6-3 decision in Bostock v. Clayton County on June 15, 2020, ruled that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employment discrimination against individuals based on transgender status, interpreting it as discrimination on the basis of sex.^[202] This landmark ruling extended federal protections to transgender employees in hiring, firing, promotions, and workplace conditions, influencing subsequent interpretations under fair housing laws to bar discrimination in housing based on gender identity.^[203] However, these accommodations have raised concerns over privacy in sex-segregated facilities, with some employers and jurisdictions facing challenges in balancing transgender access rights against the privacy expectations of others, particularly in restrooms and changing areas.^[204] Transgender recognition often includes provisions for changing legal gender markers on identification documents, with varying requirements across jurisdictions; for instance, some U.S. states permit self-attestation without medical intervention, while others mandate surgery or hormone therapy.^[205] Proponents cite low reported detransition rates—ranging from 1% to 8% in recent studies—as evidence supporting expansive rights, with many cases attributed to external pressures like discrimination rather than internal regret.^[206] ^[207] Yet, methodological limitations, including loss to follow-up and stigma discouraging disclosure, suggest potential underreporting, as highlighted in critiques of long-term outcome tracking.^[208] ^[209] Rising litigation by detransitioners underscores tensions in recognition policies, with multiple malpractice suits filed since 2022 alleging inadequate evaluation and informed consent in gender transitions, including cases like those of Chloe Cole and Prisha Mosley against medical providers.^[210] ^[211] These actions, often citing failures in mental health assessments, have prompted extended statutes of limitations in states like North Carolina to allow claims for harms from transition procedures.^[212] Internationally, approaches to transgender rights vary, with some nations adopting self-identification for legal gender changes while imposing evidence-based limits on associated medical interventions. In Sweden, following a 2022 review by the National Board of Health and Welfare deeming youth hormone treatments experimental due to insufficient evidence of benefits outweighing risks, policies restricted such interventions for minors, prioritizing psychotherapy.^[213] ^[214] Finland's 2020 systematic review similarly classified hormonal transitions for adolescents as experimental, leading to guidelines favoring non-medical approaches amid high comorbidity rates in gender-dysphoric youth.^[215] These shifts reflect causal assessments of low-quality evidence supporting rapid affirmation, balancing anti-discrimination frameworks with protections against irreversible harms, though adult recognition remains accessible under regulated conditions.^[216]

Intersex Conditions and Medical Interventions

Intersex conditions, medically classified as disorders of sex development (DSDs), encompass congenital anomalies in chromosomal, gonadal, or anatomical sex differentiation, resulting from genetic or hormonal disruptions rather than evidence of innate sexual ambiguity or spectra beyond the binary. These disorders affect a narrow subset of births; the true prevalence of neonates with ambiguous genitalia requiring expert multidisciplinary evaluation is 0.018%, far lower than inflated estimates of 1.7% that incorporate non-ambiguous conditions like mild late-onset congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) or chromosomal variations without phenotypic incongruence.^[7]^[217] Such broad figures, often promoted in advocacy contexts, conflate treatable medical variances with normative sex development, but empirical data confirm that genuine genital ambiguity—where sex cannot be readily identified at birth—occurs in roughly 1 in 5,500 cases, underscoring DSDs as rare pathologies, not validations of gender fluidity.^[7] The most prevalent DSD, CAH due to 21-hydroxylase deficiency, primarily impacts XX individuals with prenatal androgen excess leading to virilized genitalia, yet genetic sex remains female; treatments prioritize glucocorticoid replacement to manage cortisol deficiency and surgical correction of clitoromegaly or labial fusion to align anatomy with chromosomes, thereby enabling fertility, sexual function, and reduced long-term health risks like adrenal crisis.^[49]^[218] Hormone therapy alone often suffices for milder cases, but early genitoplasty in severe virilization improves urinary continence and psychosexual outcomes without compromising ovarian function, with fertility rates approaching 90% in optimized classic CAH cases.^[219] Interventions focus on biological normalization for physical health and functionality, distinct from identity-based approaches, as DSDs involve deterministic developmental errors amenable to causal correction rather than psychosocial affirmation. Medical protocols for DSDs originated in the 1950s at Johns Hopkins Hospital, where multidisciplinary teams, influenced by figures like John Money, standardized early surgical normalization to mitigate stigma and facilitate rearing congruent with underlying gonadal/chromosomal sex, emphasizing anatomical and functional repair over deferred decision-making.^[220] These approaches faced criticism amid isolated failures, such as mismanaged gender assignments, yet longitudinal data reveal low regret rates below 1% among treated cohorts, with high satisfaction tied to restored typical morphology, psychosexual adaptation, and avoidance of complications like infertility or gonad cancer risk in discordant gonads.^[221] Recent scrutiny from activist sources highlights potential over-intervention, but evidence from followed cases supports efficacy in reducing morbidity when guided by genetic etiology, not emergent self-identification, which lacks causal linkage to DSD pathophysiology. Advancements in diagnostics mitigate invasive procedures; in 2024, researchers at the Hudson Institute developed a technique reprogramming patient skin fibroblasts into Sertoli cells—key testicular support cells—to model and diagnose DSDs like 46,XY gonadal dysgenesis without gonadal biopsies, enabling precise genetic assessment and tailored interventions while preserving tissue integrity.^[222] This innovation underscores a shift toward molecular precision, affirming DSD management as restorative medicine aligned with binary sex determination, where deviations are aberrations correctable for health optima rather than celebrated diversities.

Non-Binary and Third Gender Categories

Non-binary identities encompass self-perceptions that reject strict male or female classification, while third gender categories often denote culturally or legally recognized positions outside the binary, typically without a basis in reproductive biology. Biologically, human sex remains dimorphic, defined by the production of either small, mobile gametes (sperm) or large, immobile gametes (ova), with no third gamete type observed in any sexually reproducing species, rendering third sex claims incompatible with anisogamy as the foundation of sexual dimorphism.^[223] ^[41] Evolutionary psychology frames gender roles as extensions via parental investment theory (Trivers 1972): females' ova costs promote selectivity/nurturing, males' sperm variance competition/risk-taking (>50% heritable per twin studies). Studies link cultural patterns like polygyny to these strategies, underscoring binary reproductive ties with environmental flexibility.^[119] ^[224] In South Asia, third gender recognition has historical roots in roles like India's hijras, a traditional category involving eunuch-like figures who undergo castration and adopt feminine presentations but do not produce gametes aligning with male or female reproductive functions. India's Supreme Court formalized this in a 2014 ruling on April 15, declaring transgender persons, including hijras, a "third gender" entitled to self-identification and affirmative actions, such as reservations in education and employment, to address longstanding social marginalization.^[225] ^[226] This recognition applies to official documents like passports, using codes such as "O" for other, but remains tied to specific cultural practices rather than a universal biological category.^[227] Western legal adoptions of non-binary or third options contrast with such cultural specificity, often emphasizing self-identification over traditional roles. Germany's 2018 Civil Status Act introduced a "diverse" (div) marker on birth certificates for individuals with intersex variations or those opting out of binary classification, requiring a medical certificate initially but shifting toward self-declaration in later implementations; uptake has remained minimal, with fewer than 0.1% of births recorded as diverse by 2023, reflecting limited demand amid administrative hurdles like court approvals for changes.^[228] ^[229] Similar provisions in countries like Australia (X passport marker since 2011) and Canada show low utilization rates under 0.5% of the population seeking formal changes, often linked to transient identifications rather than fixed traits.^[230] Empirical data on non-binary identifications indicate high fluidity, particularly among youth, challenging their stability as enduring categories. Longitudinal studies of transgender and non-binary youth report gender identity changes in up to 30% over short periods (e.g., 3 months to 1.5 years), with equal likelihood of shifting toward binary or non-binary labels, and overall fluidity rates exceeding 50% when including sexual orientation intersections by 2025 analyses.^[231] ^[232] Such patterns suggest many non-binary self-reports represent exploratory phases rather than immutable states, with desistance common post-adolescence, though policy frameworks rarely account for this variability.^[233] Critiques of third gender policies highlight increased administrative burdens, including document revisions, database overhauls, and verification processes, which strain public systems without commensurate gains in rights or equity. For instance, Germany's diverse option has prompted debates over categorization ambiguity in censuses and welfare allocation, imposing compliance costs on individuals and bureaucracies while yielding negligible population-level impacts given low adoption.^[229] ^[234] Policy evaluations note that these categories often fail to resolve underlying discrimination, as evidenced by persistent socioeconomic disparities among hijras in India despite 2014 reforms, underscoring their role as symbolic rather than causally effective measures.^[235]

Controversies and Scientific Debates

Affirming policies like Belgium's 2017 self-ID law prioritize subjective declaration over gamete dimorphism, despite Cass Review (2024) evidentiary gaps in youth interventions and desistance rates (80-90%). This enables non-binary markers without biological alignment checks (>99% natal via chromosomes).^[236]^[237]^[238] Biological essentialism asserts that observed differences between males and females in behavior, interests, and cognition are primarily driven by innate biological factors, including genetics and prenatal hormones, rather than socialization alone.^[239] In contrast, social constructionism posits that gender roles and differences are largely products of cultural norms and environmental influences, malleable through societal change.^[36] Empirical evidence from twin studies supports essentialism by estimating heritability of personality traits, including those showing sex differences like masculinity-femininity, at around 50% or higher, indicating substantial genetic contributions beyond shared environments.^[239]^[240] The case of David Reimer, born male but raised as female after a botched circumcision in 1966, exemplifies the limits of constructionist interventions. Psychologist John Money's attempt to socially construct female gender identity failed; Reimer exhibited male-typical behaviors, rejected the imposed identity, and ultimately transitioned back to male before dying by suicide in 2004, underscoring biology's resistance to override via upbringing.^[36]^[241] Cross-cultural studies reveal universals in sex differences, such as men's greater emphasis on physical attractiveness in mates and women's on resources, observed consistently across 45 countries, alongside male mate competition patterns linked to evolutionary pressures.^[242]^[243] Constructionist predictions falter under scrutiny; for instance, the gender-equality paradox shows larger sex differences in vocational interests—men favoring realistic and investigative fields, women social ones—in more egalitarian nations, contradicting expectations of convergence through reduced stereotypes or barriers.^[244] Causal tests for constructionism remain scarce, with no robust evidence of reversing innate differences via policy or education, while essentialist accounts align with persistent gaps post-feminist reforms.^[245] In academia as of 2025, essentialist research faces challenges from institutional biases favoring constructionist views, including reports of universities failing to shield gender-critical scholars from bullying and research restrictions for questioning gender fluidity.^[246] Cases like pressure on UK faculty to affirm ideological positions highlight self-censorship risks, potentially skewing discourse away from data-driven inquiry.^[247]^[248]

Efficacy and Risks of Gender-Affirming Interventions

The evidence supporting the efficacy of gender-affirming interventions, including puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries, has been characterized as low quality in multiple systematic reviews. The 2024 Cass Review, commissioned by the UK's National Health Service, analyzed over 100 studies and concluded that the evidence base for puberty suppression in youth is "remarkably weak," with most research rated as low or very low quality due to methodological flaws such as small sample sizes, lack of controls, and short follow-up periods. Similarly, a 2025 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) review of pediatric gender dysphoria treatments found the evidence for benefits "very low across all intervention types," emphasizing insufficient demonstration of long-term improvements in mental health or dysphoria while highlighting risks like reduced bone density from puberty blockers and potential infertility from hormones. These reviews underscore that interventions often proceed despite uncertain causal links between treatments and reduced distress or suicide risk.^[249]^[250] For youth, puberty blockers and hormones carry documented physical risks without robust proof of net benefits. The Cass Review noted potential harms including impacts on growth, bone health, and fertility, with no high-quality randomized trials available to confirm safety or efficacy; it recommended restricting blockers outside research settings. The HHS review echoed this, citing evidence of bone mineral density loss (up to 1-2 standard deviations below norms after 2-3 years of blockers) and irreversible fertility impairment from subsequent hormones, while cautioning against routine use due to elevated risks of adverse outcomes like cardiovascular issues and cancer in limited adult extrapolations. Mental health improvements, such as reduced suicidality, remain unproven in controlled studies, with pre-existing comorbidities often confounding results.^[249]^[251] In adults, long-term follow-up studies indicate persistent elevated morbidity post-transition without suicide rate reductions. A 2011 Swedish cohort study of 324 individuals post-sex reassignment surgery found 19.1 times higher suicide rates and substantially increased psychiatric hospitalization risks compared to matched controls, persisting 10-30 years later, attributing this to unresolved underlying factors rather than treatment failure per se. Dutch protocol evaluations, foundational to many guidelines, reported in 2023 analyses no sustained mental health gains decades post-hormones and surgery, with ongoing gender dysphoria in subsets and unaddressed physical complications like osteoporosis. These findings challenge assumptions of interventions as curative, as elevated morbidity (e.g., 6-10 times higher for mood disorders) suggests treatments may not address root causes like trauma or autism comorbidities.^[252]^[253] Detransition rates, though variably reported, appear undercounted due to loss to follow-up, with recent estimates ranging from 5-10% driven by resolution of dysphoria or external pressures. A 2024 analysis of high-quality studies pegged true detransition at 5-10%, higher than clinic-reported 1%, as many do not return for documentation; visibility has risen, prompting a 2025 NIH directive under executive order to fund research on regret and detransition effects, including physical reversibility limits like voice deepening or skeletal changes. This follows patterns where 82.5% of detransitioners cite external factors like discrimination but also internal realizations of misaligned identity.^[254]^[255] Underlying ideological premises, such as an innate cross-sex identity amenable to affirmation, lack empirical substantiation and may reflect social influences. Parent surveys in a 2018 study documented "rapid-onset gender dysphoria" clusters, where 60-80% of cases emerged in adolescence amid friend-group contagions, with multiple members transitioning simultaneously, often alongside social media exposure and prior mental health issues. This aligns with peer contagion models observed in other youth behaviors, suggesting environmental amplification over fixed biology, though contested by pro-affirming sources favoring individual autonomy narratives.^[104]^[108]

Impacts on Fairness in Sports, Prisons, and Women's Spaces

In sports competitions segregated by sex, policies permitting males who identify as women to compete in the female category have led to documented performance disparities. Studies indicate that even after hormone therapy, transgender women retain significant physical advantages over biological women, including 9-17% greater grip strength and muscle mass that exceeds female norms by up to 50% in some metrics, persisting beyond 12-36 months of treatment.^[256]^[257] A 2023 analysis found that transgender women maintained 20% greater strength and cardiorespiratory capacity compared to biological women, even 14 years post-transition.^[258] The case of swimmer Lia Thomas, who competed as a male for three years before transitioning and winning the 2022 NCAA women's 500-yard freestyle title, exemplifies this: Thomas' post-transition times ranked him 1st among women but would have placed him 462nd against men, thereby displacing female competitors and prompting backlash from athletes citing retained male physiological edges in height, reach, and power.^[259] By mid-2025, 27 U.S. states had enacted laws restricting transgender women from female sports categories to preserve competitive fairness, reflecting empirical concerns over unmitigated male advantages in strength-based events.^[260] In prison systems, housing biologically male inmates who identify as women in female facilities has resulted in safety risks for female prisoners, driven by sex-based differences in violence patterns where males commit 80-90% of sexual assaults.^[261] The 2018 Karen White case in the UK highlighted this: a male rapist transferred to a women's prison assaulted four female inmates, including two rapes, despite prior convictions, underscoring failures in risk assessment that prioritize identity over offense history and physicality.^[262] Similar incidents include Isla Bryson, convicted in 2023 of raping two women pre-transition and initially housed in a Scottish female prison, sparking policy reversals; and reports of female inmates facing elevated sexual assault risks from transgender prisoners, with one 2021 UK lawsuit alleging assault by a male-bodied inmate in a women's facility.^[263]^[264] These cases reveal a mismatch: female prisoners, often vulnerable due to trauma histories, experience heightened predation without evidence that identity-based transfers reduce overall male violence rates, prompting 2023 UK guidance to segregate high-risk transgender inmates.^[265] Access to sex-segregated women's spaces like shelters and changing rooms has faced disruptions from policies allowing male entry based on gender identity, leading to privacy invasions and assaults that erode female-only protections. In shelters, a 2023 Canadian incident involved a transgender woman crawling into a female resident's bed and sexually assaulting her, resulting in the perpetrator's arrest and highlighting vulnerabilities in trauma-recovery environments designed for female safety.^[266] U.S. cases include evictions of female residents objecting to shared quarters with males, as in a 2017 shelter where women were removed for raising assault concerns amid a pattern of male predators exploiting inclusive policies.^[267] In changing rooms, multiple school incidents—such as a 2023 Wisconsin case where a biologically male student exposed genitalia to four underage girls in a female locker room—have prompted lawsuits and parental complaints over non-consensual exposure, with no reciprocal safeguards for females.^[268] These events, logged in incident reports and tribunals (e.g., a 2025 UK nurse distressed by a transgender colleague's intrusive queries in a changing area), demonstrate how overriding sex-based boundaries compromises female autonomy without verifiable safety gains for transgender individuals, as male-pattern intrusions persist regardless of identity claims.^[269]

Empirical Critiques and Academic Freedom Issues

Empirical critiques of gender ideology emphasize the absence of robust evidence supporting the innateness or immutability of gender identity, with organizations like the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine (SEGM) arguing that claims of biological fixedness lack longitudinal data and rely on low-quality studies prone to bias.^[270]^[271] SEGM's analyses from 2022 to 2025 highlight that persistence rates for youth gender dysphoria diagnoses drop significantly over time, as seen in a 2024 German study where only 36.4% retained the diagnosis after five years, challenging assumptions of inherent stability.^[271] These critiques extend to pediatric interventions, noting that high desistance rates—ranging from 61% to 98% in pre-pubertal children without medical transition—have been systematically downplayed in favor of affirmative models, despite evidence from watchful waiting approaches showing 75-95% resolution without harm.^[272]^[273] The rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) phenomenon, identified in parent reports of sudden adolescent identifications linked to social influences, further underscores potential iatrogenic harms from uncritical affirmation, with SEGM citing social contagion patterns among peer groups and online communities as maladaptive coping mechanisms rather than innate traits.^[272]^[104] The 2024 Cass Review in the UK, while contested by some for methodological exclusions, prompted empirical-driven policy shifts, including NHS England's halt to routine puberty blockers for minors due to insufficient evidence of benefits outweighing risks like bone density loss and fertility impacts, rejecting ideologically driven misrepresentations that overstated affirmation's efficacy.^[274]^[275] Recent studies, such as a 2025 longitudinal analysis of over 7,700 couples, reveal parenthood often realigns views toward traditional roles, with new mothers adopting more conservative gender ideologies post-childbirth, particularly when partnered with higher-income men holding similar beliefs, suggesting experiential causality over abstract innateness claims.^[276] Academic freedom in gender research faces intensifying suppression, exemplified by a July 2025 UK report documenting censorship, professional pressures, and threats against scholars questioning ideological premises on sex and gender, including demands to affirm non-empirical identity constructs in curricula.^[277] In universities like UCL, staff reported coercion to promote gender ideology under threat of disciplinary action, reflecting broader institutional biases where left-leaning dominance in academia stifles causal inquiries into biological sex realities.^[247] Philosophers, despite tools for dissecting identity claims, largely evade debates, as critiqued in an August 2025 City Journal analysis, where elite thinkers proffer unsubstantiated support for gender fluidity while shunning dissenters, prioritizing conformity over rigorous first-principles scrutiny.^[278] Classroom environments amplify these issues, with monitoring of faculty for "gender-critical" views leading to self-censorship, as physical intimidation and ideological vetting erode open discourse on desistance data or ROGD evidence.^[279]^[280]

References

[1]
Why are sex and gender important to basic physiology and ... - NIH
Sex refers to biological differences between men and women. Although sex is a fundamental aspect of human physiology that splits the population in two ...Abstract · Sex And Gender: Are We... · Table 1
[2]
Gender - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Originating c.1300 from Old French and Latin genus meaning "kind, species, or sex," gender means a class or category and also "to bring forth" or beget.Gender(n.) · Gender(v.) · Entries Linking To Gender
[3]
gender, n. meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English Dictionary
Gender is the distinction of sex. There are three genders, the masculine, the feminine, and the neuter. L. Murray, English Grammar 24
[4]
Author Interview with Sandra Eder: How the Clinic Made Gender
Jun 13, 2023 · I discovered that the term “gender” was first used in medicine in the 1950s when clinicians introduced a new concept of sex, claiming that ...
[5]
What Do We Mean By Sex and Gender? - Yale School of Medicine
Sep 19, 2021 · In the study of human subjects, the term sex should be used as a classification, generally as male or female, according to the reproductive ...
[6]
How common is intersex? a response to Anne Fausto-Sterling
The true prevalence of intersex is seen to be about 0.018%, almost 100 times lower than Fausto-Sterling s estimate of 1.7%.
[7]
Biological sex is binary, even though there is a rainbow of sex roles
Dec 21, 2022 · Biomedical and social scientists are increasingly calling the biological sex into question, arguing that sex is a graded spectrum rather than a binary trait.SEX AND GENDER IN HUMANS · THE VARIOUS... · CONCLUSION: DENYING...<|separator|>
[8]
In Humans, Sex is Binary and Immutable by Georgi K. Marinov | NAS
However, no such examples have ever been observed in mammals, in which binary sexual reproduction appears to be extremely strongly enforced. Why is that?
[9]
[PDF] The Origins of Sex Differences in Human Behavior
From the perspective of evolutionary psychology, human sex differences reflect adaptations to the pressures of the differing physical and social environments ...
[10]
[PDF] Psychological Sex Differences - Origins Through Sexual Selection
Evolutionary psy- chology jettisons the false dichotomy between biology and environment and provides a powerful metatheory of why sex differences exist, where ...
[11]
Is gender primacy universal? - PNAS
Aug 19, 2024 · This study supports the idea that gender is a fundamental social category across societies by investigating its primacy in social perception.
[12]
Epidemiology of gender dysphoria and gender incongruence in ...
Jan 24, 2025 · Conclusions Recorded prevalence of gender dysphoria/incongruence increased substantially in children and young people between 2011 and 2021, ...
[13]
Gender Dysphoria - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf
The etiology of gender dysphoria (GD) remains unclear, but it is thought to originate from a complex biopsychosocial link.
[14]
Does the Sex/Gender Distinction Do More Harm Than Good?
May 17, 2024 · The sex/gender distinction, meant to guard against biological determinism, has diminished biology's significance, and signs point to it doing ...
[15]
Understanding the Sex Binary | City Journal
Mar 20, 2023 · Mammals, which include humans, have evolved what's called “chromosomal sex determination,” meaning that certain genes residing on chromosomes ...
[16]
Misrepresentations of Evolutionary Psychology in Sex and Gender ...
Despite success in explaining cognitive, behavioral, and morphological sex differences in many species, evolutionary theory remains controversial when applied ...
[17]
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gender
[18]
Random thoughts on Mr Gwynne, sex and gender
Jan 14, 2014 · In his famous dictionary, first published in 1755, Samuel Johnson gave three meanings for ' gender': As did Noah Webster in his 1828 dictionary:.
[19]
Linnaeus and the Love Lives of Plants (Chapter 21) - Reproduction
His sexual system played a key role in the popularization of botany during the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Historians of science have often ...
[20]
(PDF) Linnaeus and the Love Lives of Plants - ResearchGate
... Eighteenth-century botany and the modern gendered ! 4! historians that the ... In the 18th century Linnaeus defined the concept and attempted to make ...
[21]
Evolutionary pathways of complexity in gender systems | Oxford
Mar 6, 2024 · Gender systems are interesting because they hint toward the structure of the human cognitive system and the development of linguistic complexity ...
[22]
French Word Gender - StoryLearning
Many nouns have no natural gender, but they still have a grammatical gender, and this often seems entirely arbitrary. For example, table (table) is feminine, ...
[23]
Why Is Girl Neutral in German? A Comprehensive Guide to German ...
Dec 14, 2020 · Every German noun has a grammatical gender: masculine, feminine, or neuter. This is a purely grammatical category – it doesn't necessarily have ...
[24]
The Evolution Of Grammatical Genders - Babbel
Sep 20, 2016 · The evolution of grammatical genders: Why French has two genders, German has three, and English just doesn't care.
[25]
A Language Index of Grammatical Gender Dimensions to Study the ...
Jul 10, 2019 · Natural gender languages (e.g., English) don't classify inanimate nouns according to different genders. Most personal nouns behave similarly, ...
[26]
Danish - Gender in Language Project
It is a common-neuter gender language. Historically, Danish has had three grammatical genders: neuter, masculine, and feminine.
[27]
[PDF] Evolution of Gender in Indo-European Languages - Harry Foundalis
So, for example, a young learner of an Indo-European language employing. “formal gender” could associate a specific category of nouns discernible only through ...<|separator|>
[28]
Simone de Beauvoir - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Aug 17, 2004 · It was also in Les Temps Modernes that Beauvoir first published extracts of The Second Sex (1949). ... One is not born but becomes a woman” (SS: ...
[29]
One is not born, but becomes a woman | TORCH
Mar 22, 2021 · One is not born, but becomes a woman ... Simone de Beauvoir's statement is one which is constantly referred back to in gender studies to question ...
[30]
10.6: Gender Role - Social Sci LibreTexts
Dec 3, 2020 · The term 'gender role' was first coined by John Money in 1955 during the course of his study of intersex individuals to describe the manners ...
[31]
[PDF] The Origin of “Gender Identity” - PhilPapers
May 16, 2023 · Money did coin “gender role,” in a 1955 paper in the Bul- letin of the Johns Hopkins Hospital: The term gender role is used to signify all ...<|separator|>
[32]
The Birth of Gender: Social Control, Hermaphroditism, and the New ...
This chapter shows that pioneering sexologist John Money coined and developed the terms “gender” and “gender role” in the 1950s and 1960s in the United States.Behaviorism and... · Gender: A New Sexual... · The Nuclear Panopticon
[33]
sex/gender system - UMSL
From Gayle Rubin, “The Traffic in Women: Notes on the 'Political Economy' of Sex” (1975):. [Freud and Levi-Strauss] provide conceptual tools with which one ...
[34]
Evolutionary psychology: gender “construction” - Why Evolution Is True
Jan 31, 2011 · The results show that, to a large extent, the roots of gender-specific behavior are biologically rather than socially based, and are present at birth.Missing: constructionism | Show results with:constructionism
[35]
David Reimer and John Money Gender Reassignment Controversy
Nov 15, 2017 · In the mid-1960s, psychologist John Money encouraged the gender reassignment of David Reimer, who was born a biological male but suffered ...
[36]
John Money Gender Experiment: Reimer Twins - Simply Psychology
Jun 23, 2023 · The John Money Experiment involved David Reimer, a twin boy raised as a girl following a botched circumcision. Money asserted gender was primarily learned, not ...Missing: critique | Show results with:critique
[37]
Sexual Differentiation - Endotext - NCBI Bookshelf - NIH
Jul 24, 2025 · X and Y chromosome genes involved in sex determination and differentiation. SRY: Sex-determining region Y chromosome; DAX1: DSS-AHC critical ...
[38]
SRY gene: MedlinePlus Genetics
Sep 28, 2022 · The SRY gene provides instructions for making a protein called the sex-determining region Y protein. This protein is involved in male-typical sex development.
[39]
Sry: the master switch in mammalian sex determination | Development
Dec 1, 2010 · SRY, the mammalian Y-chromosomal testis-determining gene, induces male sex determination. Recent studies in mice reveal that the major role of SRY is to ...Introduction · Sry expression and its regulation · Mechanism of SRY action
[40]
Understanding the Sex Binary - by Colin Wright - Reality's Last Stand
Aug 4, 2024 · Because there is no third gamete type, there are only two sexes that a person can be. Sex is therefore binary. It is important to note here ...
[41]
Colin Wright gives a history of the gametic definition of biological sex
Apr 3, 2025 · There is no third type of gamete in any species. In fact, the ... evolutionary theorists have used gamete type as the defining criterion for sex.
[42]
Differences/Disorder of Sex Development
DSD occur in approximately 1 in 4,500-5,500 births, although prevalence rates vary widely depending upon the specific condition. Many DSD are first detected at ...
[43]
Klinefelter Syndrome - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf
May 5, 2025 · One fetus affected by the 46,XXY pattern was reduced during early pregnancy, leading to the birth of 1 boy and 1 girl with normal chromosomal ...
[44]
Klinefelter Syndrome - AAFP
Dec 1, 2005 · Almost all men with a 47,XXY karyotype will be infertile; Klinefelter syndrome accounts for 3 percent of male infertility. Klinefelter syndrome ...
[45]
Turner Syndrome - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf
Jun 22, 2025 · Individuals with mosaicism involving 45,X/46,XX typically present with a milder phenotype, characterized by fewer left-sided congenital heart ...Pathophysiology · History and Physical · Evaluation · Treatment / Management
[46]
Turner syndrome - Symptoms & causes - Mayo Clinic
Infertility. Most females with Turner syndrome are infertile. However, a very small number may become pregnant spontaneously, and some can become pregnant with ...
[47]
Early androgen exposure and human gender development - PMC
In humans, testosterone is elevated in males from about weeks 8 to 24 of gestation and then again during early postnatal development.
[48]
Maternal Testosterone Concentrations in Third Trimester and ... - NIH
In the male fetus, a surge in fetal testicular testosterone production is seen from gestation weeks 10 to 20, initially driven by human chorionic gonadotropin ...
[49]
Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf - NIH
Jan 27, 2025 · Significant virilization in 46,XX individuals, including ambiguous genitalia at birth, enlarged clitoris, heterosexual precocious puberty, ...Missing: traits | Show results with:traits
[50]
Congenital adrenal hyperplasia - Symptoms and causes - Mayo Clinic
Mar 22, 2024 · Extra androgen hormones in females may lead to facial hair, more body hair than usual and a deeper voice. Altered growth. Children may grow fast ...Missing: masculinization | Show results with:masculinization
[51]
Evidence that prenatal testosterone transfer from male twins ... - PNAS
Mar 18, 2019 · During sensitive periods in utero, gonadal steroids help organize biological sex differences in humans and other mammals.
[52]
The Biological Basis of Sex Differences in Athletic Performance
Sep 29, 2023 · Testosterone levels rise 20-30-fold in males during puberty and are 15 times higher in males than females by age 18. Direct and indirect effects ...Missing: pubertal | Show results with:pubertal
[53]
[PDF] The Biological Basis of Sex Differences in Athletic Performance:
Testosterone levels rise ~20-30 fold in males during puberty and are 15 times higher in males than females by age 18. ... include increased skeletal muscle mass ...
[54]
Sexual dimorphism of body composition - ScienceDirect.com
Adult males have greater arm muscle mass, larger and stronger bones, and reduced limb fat, but a similar degree of central abdominal fat. Females have a more ...
[55]
A Good VO2max Charts by: Age, Gender, Sport and Athlete Fitness
Literature shows that women typically have a VO2max score 15% to 30% below VO2max values of male counterparts. This is partly due to extra body fat and lower ...Normative VO2max data by... · What is a good VO2max for...
[56]
Gender Difference in Aerobic Capacity and the Contribution by Body ...
The male players, on an average, had 18.16% & 12.18% higher VO2max & VO2max/LBM than the females [Table/Fig-1]. The physiological factors which may cause higher ...
[57]
Mechanisms underlying sex differences in autoimmunity - JCI
Sep 17, 2024 · Most autoimmune diseases occur more often in women than men, with rheumatic autoimmune diseases being among those most highly expressed in women ...The role of sex hormones · The role of environment · Pediatric autoimmune diseases
[58]
Sex hormone influence on female-biased autoimmune diseases ...
The majority of autoimmune diseases affect more women than men, suggesting an important role for sex hormones in regulating immune response.
[59]
influence of sex steroid hormones on the response to trauma and ...
Sep 14, 2017 · The literature contains evidence of gender dimorphism in response to injury, with outcomes better in females than males for most injury types, ...Missing: tied | Show results with:tied
[60]
Opposite-sex and same-sex twin studies of physiological, cognitive ...
The Twin Testosterone Transfer (TTT) hypothesis assumes that human sex hormones are transferred between fetuses in the same pregnancy of twins. Transfer of ...
[61]
Dump the “dimorphism”: Comprehensive synthesis of human brain ...
Males' brains are larger than females' from birth, stabilizing around 11 % in adults. This size difference accounts for other reproducible findings.
[62]
Sex Differences in Human Brain Structure at Birth
Oct 17, 2024 · After controlling for total brain volume, females showed significantly greater total cortical gray matter volumes, whilst males showed greater ...
[63]
Sex differences in brain homotopic co-activations: a meta-analytic ...
Oct 21, 2022 · Our results indicated that females exhibit stronger interhemispheric co-activation than males, suggesting that the female brain is less lateralized and more ...
[64]
[PDF] Sex Differences in Human Brain Structure at Birth - bioRxiv
Jun 20, 2024 · Sex differences that were consistent across the two analyses included female>male differences in the corpus callosum and left parahippocampal ...
[65]
Prenatal androgen exposure and children's gender-typed behavior ...
This report focuses on possible influences of prenatal androgen exposure on children's gender-typed behavior and toy and playmate preferences. Extensive prior ...Missing: toddlers | Show results with:toddlers
[66]
Prenatal androgen exposure and sex-typical play behaviour
These meta-analytic findings suggest that prenatal androgen exposure masculinises and defeminises play behaviour in humans.
[67]
Transcriptomic sex differences in early human fetal brain development
Apr 25, 2025 · Our data suggest that limited but potentially important sex differences occur during early human fetal brain development.
[68]
Fetal brain wiring sets up life-long sex differences in gene activity ...
May 27, 2025 · The analysis uncovered more than 3,000 genes whose activity differed between male and female fetal brains, compared with approximately 1,000 ...
[69]
Testing the Empathizing–Systemizing theory of sex differences and ...
Nov 12, 2018 · We test 10 predictions from the Empathizing–Systemizing (ES) theory of sex differences and the Extreme Male Brain (EMB) theory of autism.
[70]
Testing the Empathizing–Systemizing theory of sex differences and ...
In the largest study to date of autistic traits, we test 10 predictions from the Empathizing–Systemizing (E-S) theory of sex differences and the Extreme ...
[71]
New light shed on health differences between males and females
The study reveals vast differences in gene activity within the mitochondria of males compared to females. This is the first ...
[72]
Men's Brains Shrink Faster than Women's. What That Means for ...
Oct 15, 2025 · During ageing, men experience a greater reduction in volume across more regions of the brain than women do, according to a longitudinal study ...
[73]
https://www.sciencealert.com/male-brains-shrink-faster-than-female-brains-study-finds
[74]
Physiological control of elaborate male courtship: Female choice for ...
Male manakins perform physically elaborate courtship displays that are quick, accurate and powerful. Females seem to choose males based on their motor skills.
[75]
Behavioral Sex Differences and Hormonal Control in a Bird with an ...
Oct 14, 2021 · Here we describe our studies over more than 20 years examining sex difference and hormonal control of courtship in Golden-collared manakins.
[76]
Testosterone and Aggression: Berthold, Birds and Beyond - PMC
This hypothesis was tested experimentally. In the field, territorial males were given either long-term subcutaneous testosterone implants or empty implants in ...
[77]
[PDF] The Role of Testosterone in Aggression - McGill Journal of Medicine
In general, castration leads to a decrease in aggression whilst replacement of testosterone restores the behaviour. However differences in the effects induced ...<|separator|>
[78]
Strain differences in post-castration sexual and aggressive behavior ...
Mar 26, 2022 · We expected a castration-induced elimination of sexual behavior and decrease in aggression among C57BL/6J and DBA/2J males [48], [56].
[79]
Sexual dimorphism in the hormonal control of aggressive behavior ...
Castration of the male residents causes a decrease in aggressive behavior, but ovariectomy of the female residents has little effect on their aggression.Missing: mating | Show results with:mating
[80]
Variations in Male Parenting Behavior and Physiology in the ... - NIH
Common marmosets and the related cotton-top tamarin monkeys provide extensive paternal care of multiple offspring and are essential for infant survival.
[81]
The marmoset as a model for the study of primate parental behavior
This article reviews parental behavior and its endocrinological mechanisms in marmosets and tamarins, both cooperative breeders in the callitrichid family, and ...
[82]
C. Jacchus Social Organization and Behavior
May 18, 2005 · Common marmosets do not always give birth to twins; they also have single births and triplets. The reproductive patterns of common marmosets ...
[83]
Are There Transgender Proclivities in Animals? - JSTOR Daily
Oct 6, 2016 · Snakes, lizards, beetles, fish, and birds, to name a few, all exhibit “transgender” behaviors in which males imitate females to gain advantages.
[84]
The evolution of same-sex sexual behaviour in mammals - Nature
Oct 3, 2023 · Ancestral reconstruction suggests that same-sex sexual behaviour may have evolved multiple times, with its appearance being a recent phenomenon ...
[85]
Endocrine disruption, parasites and pollutants in wild freshwater fish
The evidence to indicate that intersex in roach (and other cyprinid fish living in these rivers) is caused by chemicals that mimic and/or disrupt hormone ...
[86]
Intersex condition and molecular markers of endocrine disruption in ...
Phthalates and pesticides were the most abundant EDCs in bile, followed by alkylphenols, musks, bisphenol-A and estrogenic hormones. Statistically significant ...
[87]
Sex-typed preferences in three domains: Do two-year-olds need ...
Aug 6, 2025 · By age 2-3, children typically have a sense of their own gender. They can sort themselves into a gender category (e.g., grouping themselves ...
[88]
Sex differences in children's toy preferences: A systematic review ...
22 de nov. de 2017 · We found that boys played with male-typed toys more than girls did (Cohen's d = 1.03, p < .0001) and girls played with female-typed toys more than boys did.
[89]
How Large Are Gender Differences in Toy Preferences? A ...
Our systematic review and meta-analysis combined 113 effect sizes from 75 studies to estimate the magnitude of gender-related differences in toy preferences.
[90]
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1743-6109.2008.00870.x
[91]
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15532739.2018.1468293
[92]
Factors associated with desistence and persistence of childhood ...
Objective: To examine the factors associated with the persistence of childhood gender dysphoria (GD), and to assess the feelings of GD, body image, and sexual ...
[93]
(PDF) The Heritability of Gender Identity Disorder in a Child and ...
Aug 8, 2025 · To date, heritability estimates for gender identity have come from eight published twin studies. Seven provided evidence suggesting a ...
[94]
A Study of Dutch Twins at Ages 7 and 10 Years - ResearchGate
Aug 5, 2025 · In population-based twin studies, genetic factors were found to explain approximately 0.15-0.39 of the variance in sexual orientation in men ( ...
[95]
Early Social Gender Transition in Children is Associated with High ...
May 6, 2022 · Of note, the 61%-98% (or the 85%) historic desistance statistic has been critiqued as inflated, by those who noted that some of the children ...Missing: 80-90% 2010s
[96]
Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis - American Psychiatric Association
A marked incongruence between one's experienced/expressed gender and assigned gender, of at least six months' duration, as manifested by at least two or more of ...Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis · Criteria: Gender Dysphoria... · Disorders Of Sex Development
[97]
What is Gender Dysphoria? - American Psychiatric Association
Gender dysphoria: A diagnosis in the DSM-5-TR defined as clinically significant distress or impairment due to gender incongruence, which may include a desire ...Diagnosis · Treatment · Challenges/Complications
[98]
Table 2. [DSM-5 Criteria for Gender Dysphoria ()]. - Endotext - NCBI
A strong desire to be rid of one's primary and/or secondary sex characteristics because of a marked incongruence with one's experienced/expressed gender (or in ...
[99]
Associations between autism, gender dysphoria and gender ...
A recent meta-analysis showed that the pooled prevalence of ASD among people with gender dysphoria or gender incongruence is 11 % (Kallitsounaki and Williams, ...
[100]
Autism Spectrum Disorder and Gender Dysphoria/Incongruence. A ...
May 20, 2022 · Interestingly, among adolescents diagnosed with GID, 6.5% received a co-occurring diagnosis of ASD, whereas 1.9% of children with GID were ...
[101]
Gender dysphoria: prejudice from childhood to adulthood, but no ...
Conclusion. Our findings indicate that individuals with GD experience traumatic events from childhood to adulthood when compared to non-transsexual individuals.
[102]
Why Gender Dysphoria and Eating Disorders Are Often Connected
Jun 7, 2023 · People who are transgender and non-binary experience gender dysphoria often (but not always) live with body dysmorphia as well.
[103]
NHS to hold review into gender identity services for children and ...
Sep 22, 2020 · Review will examine rise in number of children in UK seeking treatment, from 77 in 2009 to 2,590 in 2018-19.
[104]
Minister orders inquiry into 4,000 per cent rise in children wanting to ...
Sep 16, 2018 · In 2009/10 a total of 40 girls were referred by doctors for gender treatment. By 2017/18 that number had soared to 1,806. Referrals for boys ...
[105]
Parent reports of adolescents and young adults perceived to show ...
Parents have reported that their children seemed to experience a sudden or rapid onset of gender dysphoria, appearing for the first time during puberty or even ...
[106]
Study of 1,655 Cases Supports the "Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria ...
Mar 30, 2023 · A new study examining 1,655 parental reports lends further credibility to the rapid onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) hypothesis, first posited by ...
[107]
Desisting and persisting gender dysphoria after childhood
Jan 7, 2011 · Although the persistence rates differed between the various studies (2% to 27%), the results unequivocally showed that the gender dysphoria ...
[108]
Another Myth of Persistence? - PMC - NIH
Sep 16, 2024 · In clinical studies, childhood-onset gender dysphoria does not usually persist through puberty, at least if the child has not socially transitioned.
[109]
The social contagion of gender dysphoria - Professor Dianna Kenny
Social contagion may apply to gender dysphoria and its rapid, epidemic-like spread across the Western world among adolescents and young people.
[110]
More than 40% of transgender adults in the US have attempted suicide
Jul 20, 2023 · Among transgender adults, 44% reported recent suicidal ideation, 7% reported a recent suicide attempt, and 21% reported recent non-suicidal self ...
[111]
Prevalence of gender dysphoria and suicidality and self-harm in a ...
In one of the largest such studies (over 120,000 adolescents), female-to-male transgender adolescents reported the highest rate of attempted suicide (51%), ...Missing: pre- transition
[112]
Suicide-Related Outcomes Following Gender-Affirming Treatment
Mar 20, 2023 · The suicide-attempt rate before gender-affirming surgery was 29.3%; following gender-affirming surgery, the suicide-attempt rate decreased ...
[113]
Prevalence and Determinants of Depressive and Anxiety Symptoms ...
Feb 27, 2023 · In conclusion, remarkably high prevalence rates for both probable depression and probable anxiety were identified among transgender people. ...
[114]
The Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis in Young People Has a “Low ...
Jul 19, 2024 · Adolescent females aged 15–19 had the lowest persistence rate (27.3%), while young males aged 20–24 had the highest persistence rate (49.7%).
[115]
Largest study to date confirms overlap between autism and gender ...
Nearly 70 percent of autistic gender-diverse adolescents say they need medical gender-related care, according to a small 2018 study, and 32 percent say their ...
[116]
Mental Health of Youth With Autism Spectrum Disorder and Gender ...
Nov 1, 2023 · Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and gender dysphoria (GD) frequently cooccur,1–11 and youth with either ASD or GD alone have been shown to be at ...
[117]
Long-Term Follow-Up of Transsexual Persons Undergoing Sex ...
This study found substantially higher rates of overall mortality, death from cardiovascular disease and suicide, suicide attempts, and psychiatric ...
[118]
Risk of Suicide and Self-Harm Following Gender-Affirmation Surgery
Apr 2, 2024 · Patients who have undergone gender-affirming surgery are associated with a significantly elevated risk of suicide.
[119]
Suicide Mortality Among Gender-Dysphoric Adolescents and Young ...
Feb 23, 2024 · The paper's report of 0.51 per 1000 person-years, based on 13,602 person-years (with a median follow-up of about 6 years) represents one of the ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
[120]
(PDF) Parental Investment and Sexual Selection - ResearchGate
Parental Investment and Sexual Selection January 1972 Authors: Robert Trivers at Chapman University Robert Trivers Download full-text PDF
[121]
[PDF] Parental Investment and Sexual Selection - Joel Velasco
Species can be classified according to the relative parental investment of the sexes in their young. In the vast majority of species, the male's only ...
[122]
Parental Investment Theory (Chapter 7) - The Cambridge Handbook ...
Jun 30, 2022 · As proposed by Trivers in 1972, Parental Investment Theory addresses sex differences that result from the trade-off between parenting and mating ...
[123]
[PDF] The Origins of Sex Differences in Human Behavior - USC Dornsife
However, with respect to the other sex differences emphasized by evolutionary psychologists, their cross-cultural patterning suggests that they arise from a ...
[124]
A Bioeconomic Approach to Marriage and the Sexual Division of Labor
In one of the first systematic cross-cultural surveys of hunter-gatherer societies, Ember (1978) found that only men hunt in 166 of 179 societies, both men ...
[125]
Female hunters of the early Americas | Science Advances
Sexual division of labor with females as gatherers and males as hunters is a major empirical regularity of hunter-gatherer ethnography, suggesting an ancestral ...
[126]
The Myth of Man the Hunter: Women's contribution to the hunt ...
Jun 28, 2023 · The sexual division of labor among human foraging populations has typically been recognized as involving males as hunters and females as ...
[127]
Relationship between gender role attitude and fertility rate in women ...
The study found a direct association between acceptance of gender stereotypes and fertility rate, and an inverse association with egalitarianism.
[128]
The New Economics of Fertility - International Monetary Fund (IMF)
Jul 22, 2022 · The result is a decline in fertility and greater female labor force participation. There is in fact historically a strong negative association ...
[129]
[PDF] The Paradox of Declining Female Happiness*
We examine men's and women's subjective well-being in the United States over the last. 35 years using data from the General Social Survey (GSS). This survey is ...
[130]
[PDF] The Paradox of Declining Female Happiness* - Yale Law School
We examine men's and women's subjective well‐being in the United States over the last. 35 years using data from the General Social Survey (GSS). This survey is ...
[131]
Dataset Murdock et al. 1999 'Ethnographic Atlas' - D-PLACE -
1999 'Ethnographic Atlas'. The Ethnographic Atlas (EA) describes cultural practices for 1291 societies, ranging from societies with complex agricultural ...
[132]
(PDF) A cross-cultural analysis of the behavior of women and men
This article evaluates theories of the origins of sex differences in human behavior. It reviews the cross-cultural evidence on the behavior of women and men ...<|separator|>
[133]
(PDF) Pre-Coded Variables for the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample
Murdock, George P., and Douglas White. 1969. The Standard Cross-Cultural Sample. Ethnology 8:329-369.Missing: childcare | Show results with:childcare
[134]
[PDF] A Cross-Cultural Analysis of the - Sexual Division of Labor
principles of task differentiation, which are not absolute, but which form various kinds of probabilistic constraints on the division of labor by sex.Missing: Files | Show results with:Files
[135]
[PDF] Gender - Human Relations Area Files
Nov 19, 2019 · After exploring variation in gender concepts, we turn to what we know from cross-cultural research about division of labor in subsistence, ...
[136]
Factors in the division of labor by sex: a cross-cultural analysis
Jan 1, 1973 · This article investigates factors influencing the division of labor by gender, including occupation specialization, the type of material labor involves.Missing: studies | Show results with:studies
[137]
[PDF] Biosocial Construction of Sex Differences and Similarities in Behavior
For example, if women care for children, they are thought to be nurturing and caring, and if men fight wars, they are thought to be tough and brave. Such gender ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[138]
Elucidating evolutionary principles with the traditional Mosuo
Jul 11, 2022 · Mosuo women are indifferent to a potential mate's social status or resources, do not expect their romantic partners to commit to the ...
[139]
Does gender structure social networks across domains of ...
Nov 28, 2022 · Theory surrounding gender differences in network structure and behaviour is based on sexual selection ... The Mosuo example continues to ...
[140]
[PDF] Elucidating evolutionary principles with the traditional Mosuo
Jul 11, 2022 · Conversely, because Mosuo women can afford to be less stringent in mate selection compared to women from other cultures who must carefully ...
[141]
Explaining religious differences in immigrants' gender role attitudes
Aug 9, 2025 · It shows that higher levels of religiosity can explain immigrants' more traditional attitudes to some extent, but that origin country ...<|separator|>
[142]
The Importance of Religion and Traditional Gender Roles
Apr 20, 2021 · Our findings show that religious immigrant women participate less in the labor market and work fewer hours than nonreligious immigrant women.
[143]
[PDF] Sex, Syntax, and Semantics - Stanford University
To test whether grammatical gender in a language can indeed exert a causal power over thought (without intermediary cultural factors), Boroditsky, Schmidt, and ...<|separator|>
[144]
Grammatical gender and linguistic relativity: A systematic review
Aug 19, 2019 · Many languages assign nouns to a grammatical gender class, such that “bed” might be assigned masculine gender in one language (e.g., ...
[145]
In U.S., views on transgender issues vary widely by religion
Jul 7, 2022 · Among Catholics, the share who say a person's gender cannot differ from sex at birth has risen from 52% in 2021 to 62% this year. By contrast, a ...
[146]
A systematic review of the relationship between religion and ... - NIH
59.4 % agnostics/atheists, 37.1 % Christians (99% Catholics and 1% orthodox), 2.6 % Buddhists, 0.6 % Hindus, and 0.3 % Jews.
[147]
Full article: How the methods used to eliminate foot binding in China ...
Chinese foot binding existed for nearly a thousand years and was seen as a sign of beauty and marriageability. Female genital mutilation (FGM) has existed for ...
[148]
Harmful Practices on the Global Agenda: Comparing Female Genital ...
Aug 1, 2020 · [2010], Psychological, Social and Sexual Consequences of Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting (FGM/C), A Systematic Review of Quantitative ...
[149]
Testing the greater male variability phenomenon
Jul 15, 2020 · The greater male variability phenomenon predicts that males exhibit larger ranges of variation in cognitive performance compared with females.
[150]
Nobel Prizes by Gender - areppim
Indeed, 29% of all Nobel awards received by women were for peace (10% for males) and 26% for literature (11% for males). As for men, the highest percents were ...
[151]
The gender gap in reading - Brookings Institution
Mar 26, 2015 · Expressed in standard deviation units, they range from 0.13 on the NAEP-LTT at age nine to 0.34 on the PISA at age 15. The gaps are shrinking.
[152]
https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/amp-amp0000356.pdf
[153]
[PDF] Gender Differences in Reading and Writing Achievement
Jan 10, 2018 · Grade level. Table 1 presents comparisons between males and females in reading achievement across the three grade levels assessed by NAEP. ...
[154]
Magnitude of sex differences in spatial abilities: a meta ... - PubMed
A meta-analysis found significant sex differences in spatial abilities, with some intertest differences, and partial support for a decrease in magnitude over ...
[155]
Magnitude of sex differences in spatial abilities: A meta-analysis and ...
The present study examined these issues in the context of spatial abilities. A meta-analysis of 286 effect sizes from a variety of spatial ability measures was ...
[156]
The heritability of general cognitive ability increases linearly from ...
The substantial heritability of g has been documented in dozens of family, twin and adoption studies, with estimates varying from 40 to 80%.– Twin studies ...Missing: gender nonconformity
[157]
Sex differences after all those years? Heritability of cognitive abilities ...
We investigated sex differences in genetic and environmental effects on cognitive abilities among older adult twins.
[158]
Sex Differences After All Those Years? Heritability of Cognitive ...
May 1, 2006 · Abstract. We investigated sex differences in genetic and environmental effects on cognitive abilities among older adult twins.
[159]
Affirmative action for women in STEM: Closing gaps or creating new ...
Nov 8, 2024 · Despite continuous efforts to promote gender equality, women's representation in STEM jobs remains low worldwide at only 29%.
[160]
Is Affirmative Action the Answer to the Gender Gaps in STEM Majors?
Dec 20, 2024 · The analysis revealed stronger positive effects in majors that were initially more male-dominated and consequently experienced larger increases ...
[161]
State affirmative action bans and STEM degree completions
State affirmative action bans reduce minority STEM degree completions, especially at highly selective colleges, with a 19% decrease in completions at these ...
[162]
Groundbreaking UC Irvine Research Reveals Significant Sex ...
Males use NMDA receptors for synapse potency, while females use estrogen. Females excel in episodic memory, handling longer lists and "what" and "when" ...
[163]
https://ilostat.ilo.org/where-women-work-female-dominated-occupations-and-sectors/
[164]
Where women work: female-dominated occupations and sectors
Nov 7, 2023 · For instance, occupations related to nursing and childcare exhibit exceptionally high female shares, with figures reaching over 90 per cent.<|separator|>
[165]
Employed persons by detailed occupation, sex, race, and Hispanic ...
Jan 29, 2025 · Employed persons by detailed occupation, sex, race, and Hispanic or Latino ethnicity [Numbers in thousands]
[166]
Longitudinal Associations Between Gender-typed Skills and ...
Results revealed that the longitudinal linkages between male-typed interests and skills were bidirectional, that both male-typed interests and skills in ...Missing: precede exposure
[167]
Gendered Occupational Interests: Prenatal Androgen Effects on ...
Our findings indicate that career choices are influenced by prenatal androgens through a psychological orientation to objects versus people that manifests in ...Missing: precede | Show results with:precede
[168]
Women's earnings were 83.6 percent of men's in 2023
Mar 12, 2024 · Women had lower median weekly earnings than men in most of the occupations for which we have earnings data for both women and men. Chart Image ...
[169]
Harvard Study: "Gender Wage Gap" Explained Entirely by Work ...
Dec 10, 2018 · The gap can be explained entirely by the fact that, while having the same choice sets in the workplace, women and men make different choices.
[170]
Details in BLS Report Suggest That the 'gender Earnings Gap' Can ...
Oct 22, 2021 · The claim of a “gender wage gap” implies for many (like the NCPE) that women are paid lower hourly or daily wages than men when they are working side-by-side.
[171]
The Gender-Segregated Labour Market – A Nordic Paradox - NIKK
May 20, 2015 · It is called the gender equality paradox – that gender-segregated labour markets persist in gender equality-oriented welfare states.Missing: gap | Show results with:gap
[172]
[PDF] The Nordic Gender Equality Paradox - Creative Matter
Apr 30, 2019 · Occupational segregation accounts for about 80% of the gender wage gap of a country (Petersen & Morgan, 1995) which should make it a primary ...
[173]
A sector-by-sector guide to the gender gap among startup founders
Jan 17, 2024 · Women accounted for just 13.2% of all startup founders in 2023. This founder gender gap was larger in some sectors than others.Missing: differences entrepreneurship
[174]
Gender and Race Gaps on the Path to Startup Success | NBER
Men start new businesses at a rate 64 percent higher than that for women. Blacks start new businesses at a 22 percent lower rate than Whites. Gender and race ...
[175]
Age Affects Male and Female Fertility
Peak male fertility is around 25-29 years old. Sperm quality begins to decline at 30. Around 36-37, damage to sperm DNA begins to increase, and risk for genetic ...
[176]
Age and fecundability in a North American preconception cohort study
Studies also indicate that increasing male age, independent of female age, is associated with reduced fertility. Meta-analyses have shown age-related declines ...
[177]
Down Syndrome | Birth Defects - CDC
Dec 26, 2024 · Maternal age and risk for trisomy 21 assessed by the origin of chromosome nondisjunction: a report from the Atlanta and National Down ...Living with Down Syndrome · Screening for Birth Defects · Diagnosing Birth Defects
[178]
Down Syndrome (Trisomy 21) by Year, New Jersey, 2000 to 2023
Jul 16, 2025 · At maternal age 20 to 24, the probability of conceiving a child with Down Syndrome is 1 in 1,562; at age 35 to 39 the probability increases to 1 ...
[179]
Women More Likely Than Men to Initiate Divorces, But Not Non ...
Sep 28, 2022 · As part of his analysis, Rosenfeld found that women initiated 69 percent of all divorces, compared to 31 percent for men. In contrast, there was ...
[180]
The Real Root Causes of Violent Crime: The Breakdown of Marriage ...
... single-parent homes leads typically to a 17 percent increase in juvenile crime. ... parents with criminal histories were at extremely high risk of delinquency ...
[181]
Single-Parent Families Cause Juvenile Crime (From Juvenile Crime
The Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency reports that the most reliable indicator of violent crime in a community is the proportion of fatherless ...
[182]
[PDF] Evolution of Paternal Investment - ResearchGate
These findings are consistent with the view that paternal investment can improve children's later social competitiveness, given the strong relation between ...<|separator|>
[183]
Patterning of Paternal Investment in Response to Socioecological ...
Paternal investment and status-related child outcomes: timing of father's death affects offspring success. J. Biosoc. Sci. 44, 549–569. doi: 10.1017 ...
[184]
Growing up in single-parent families and the criminal involvement of ...
The results suggest that growing up in single-parent families is associated with an elevated risk of involvement in crime by adolescents.
[185]
Single Mother Parenting and Adolescent Psychopathology - PMC
Family factors as correlates and predictors of juvenile conduct problems and delinquency. In: Torny MH, Morris N, editors. Crime and justice: An annual ...Results · Preliminary Analyses · Hypothesis Testing
[186]
[PDF] TRANSFORMING LEGAL SEX* - North Carolina Law Review
Until around the mid-twentieth century, legal sex was mostly understood as immutable sexual difference between males and females that is biologically.
[187]
[PDF] Transforming Legal Sex - Carolina Law Scholarship Repository
Jan 1, 2024 · Until around the mid-twentieth century, legal sex was mostly understood as immutable sexual difference between males and females that is ...
[188]
[PDF] Brief for petitioners - Supreme Court of the United States
Sep 12, 2025 · Equal Protection Clause jurisprudence protects “sex” as an objective trait rooted in biology—not a subjective concept based on gender identity.
[189]
Education Department Finalizes New Title IX Regulations: Sexual ...
Jun 5, 2024 · The Court's decision assumed, but did not decide, that the term "sex" in Title VII refers to biological distinctions between females and males.
[190]
https://www.vitallaw.com/news/health-care-reform-s-d-miss-hhs-final-rule-prohibiting-gender-identity-discrimination-overstepped-title-ix-statutory-authority/hld0159f00f1093374f019ff93cdea1b94890
[191]
Gender Recognition Act 2004, Section 9 - Legislation.gov.uk
... gender is the male gender, the person's sex becomes that of a man and, if it is the female gender, the person's sex becomes that of a woman). (2)Subsection ...<|separator|>
[192]
UK Supreme Court rules legal definition of a woman is based ... - BBC
Apr 16, 2025 · The Supreme Court has ruled that the legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex, in a decision which could have far-reaching implications.
[193]
Legal definition of woman is based on biological sex, UK supreme ...
Apr 16, 2025 · The UK supreme court has issued a historic and definitive ruling that the terms “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act refer only to a biological woman and to ...Gender · Equality Act 2010 · UK supreme court · JK Rowling
[194]
Title IX Shake-Up: Understanding the New Executive Orders and ...
Feb 5, 2025 · The president issued an executive order declaring that “sex” shall refer to “an individual's immutable biological classification as either male ...
[195]
https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/breaking-federal-court-rejects-biden
[196]
[PDF] Supreme Court of the United States
Sep 19, 2025 · The 2024 rule's redefinition was vacated because “expanding the meaning of. 'on the basis of sex' to include 'gender identity' turns. Title IX ...
[197]
Gender recognition reform in an international context
Jun 20, 2022 · A large increase in rapes recorded as committed by women in the year after the self-declaration was introduced (from 12 to 41) appears to be ...
[198]
U.S. Supreme Court to hear two cases involving transgender athletes
Oct 6, 2025 · The U.S. Supreme Court is taking up two cases dealing with state laws that attempt to bar transgender athletes from participating in girls' ...
[199]
Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports - The White House
Feb 5, 2025 · As some Federal courts have recognized, “ignoring fundamental biological truths between the two sexes deprives women and girls of meaningful ...Missing: court | Show results with:court
[200]
[PDF] Supreme Court of the United States
Sep 15, 2025 · What does sex mean for the purpose of the Equal. Protection Clause and Title IX? Challenges to the advancement of fairness for women in sports ...
[201]
[PDF] 17-1618 Bostock v. Clayton County (06/15/2020) - Supreme Court
Jun 15, 2020 · The Supreme Court ruled that firing someone for being gay or transgender violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
[202]
Bostock v. Clayton County | Oyez
Oct 8, 2019 · An employer who fires an individual employee merely for being gay or transgender violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
[203]
Best Ways to Handle Coworker Concerns about Transgender ...
Sep 18, 2025 · The California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) explicitly protects transgender employees, requiring employers to recognize the employees ...
[204]
Know Your Rights: Employment | A4TE - Advocates for Trans Equality
You have the right to safe and adequate access to restrooms and other facilities consistent with your gender identity. According to several federal courts and ...Missing: concerns | Show results with:concerns
[205]
How Many People Detransition? | A Guide to Transgender Regrets
A US study involving 28,000 trans adults showed that only 8% had ever detransitioned, and 62% of them did so temporarily, largely due to societal pressure. A ...
[206]
How Common Is Detransitioning? - Hazard Ratio: Benjamin Ryan
May 2, 2025 · The rate of cross-sex hormone discontinuation typically ranged from 1.5% to 2.4%. However, a pair of studies, published in 2022 and 2023, ...
[207]
Accurate transition regret and detransition rates are unknown - SEGM
Sep 11, 2023 · A new paper by Cohn, “The Rate of Detransition is Unknown,” reviews common limitations of “regret” studies and demonstrates that hormone discontinuation, ...<|separator|>
[208]
The Detransition Rate Is Unknown - PMC - NIH
Jun 12, 2023 · Detransition can mean no longer presenting as transgender, with or without remaining trans-identified, and may or may not involve surgeries.
[209]
Gender Detransition Lawsuits - Kelly Chang Rickert
There are currently five (5) gender detransition lawsuits: Chloe Cole; Kayla Lovdahl; Luka Hein; Prisha Mosley; and Soren Aldaco.
[210]
Physician Exposure to Litigation in Gender Detransition Medical ...
Sep 26, 2025 · All lawsuits were filed after 2022. 100% of cases cited improper mental health evaluation in their complaints. 56.25% of the cases cited double ...Missing: class | Show results with:class
[211]
Lawsuit revived after statute of limitations for detransitioners extended
Aug 14, 2025 · The North Carolina legislature has now extended the time period for individuals to sue for harm caused by gender transition procedures. We look ...Missing: detransition class action
[212]
Swedish Transgender Treatment Guidelines for Youth - SEGM
Sep 24, 2024 · A recent submission of an English translation of Sweden's official 2022 national practice guideline for children and adolescents with gender dysphoria.
[213]
Summary of Key Recommendations from the Swedish National ...
Feb 27, 2022 · The update to the Swedish treatment guidelines represents an impressive step toward safeguarding the growing numbers of gender dysphoric youth ...
[214]
2022 Year-End-Summary - SEGM
Jan 1, 2023 · These two European countries followed Finland, the first Western country to have conducted a systematic review of the evidence for youth gender ...
[215]
Medical gender reassignment in minors – why are we cautious in ...
In Finland, the number of referrals to Gender Identity Services (GIS) for minors appears to have plateaued since 2021. However, as in previous years, the vast ...
[216]
How common is intersex? | Leonard Sax MD PhD
Aug 1, 2002 · Specifically, Fausto-Sterling computes the incidence of intersexual births to be 1.7 per 100 live births, or 1.7%.
[217]
Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia - Medscape Reference
Dec 24, 2024 · Females with virilizing adrenal hyperplasia may have more masculine interests. Females with adrenal hyperplasia have reduced fertility rates ...
[218]
Fertility considerations with classic congenital adrenal hyperplasia ...
Jul 25, 2024 · Women with classic CAH who desire to become pregnant can have fertility rates of around 90%, which is only a small amount lower than fertility rates that occur ...
[219]
Intersex surgery and 'sex change' in Britain 1930–1955 - PMC - NIH
Jan 17, 2018 · This seems to suggest a John Money-like approach to surgery, as a tool to construct and maintain social and cultural norms for the psychological ...
[220]
A principled ethical approach to intersex paediatric surgeries - PMC
Oct 29, 2020 · These surgeries first began to be done at the Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore in the 1950s, and spread around the world, soon becoming the ...
[221]
Breakthrough in diagnosing disorders of sex development
Jul 18, 2024 · Professor Vincent Harley and his team have developed a model to study this through reprogramming skin cells into testicular cells (Sertoli cells).
[222]
Gamete Size Is Essential for Understanding Sex and Sexual ...
Aug 12, 2025 · The binary nature of gametic sex is a critically important concept in evolutionary biology. The evolution of different gamete sizes is important ...
[223]
In India, Landmark Ruling Recognizes Transgender Citizens - NPR
Apr 15, 2014 · India now has a third gender. The Supreme Court has recognized the country's transgender community as being in a third neutral category ...
[224]
India court recognises transgender people as third gender - BBC
Apr 15, 2014 · India's Supreme Court has recognised transgender people as a third gender, in a landmark ruling. "It is the right of every human being to ...
[225]
Entry #11300: Legal recognition of non-binary gender in India
India's Supreme Court recognized a third gender, 'hijra', starting April 15, 2014. Passports use 'O' (other), and other documents use 'T' (transgender) and 'TG ...
[226]
Beyond the Binary: Towards a Third Sex Category in Germany?
Aug 8, 2025 · We believe that the data reported in this paper speak to the current rise in gender-inclusive interventions (third gender markers in legal ...<|separator|>
[227]
Making intersex and non-binary people count? Ambivalent ...
Oct 9, 2023 · This article discusses the recent introduction of 'diverse' and 'no entry' along 'male' and 'female' as gender categories in the German microcensus.
[228]
Rise of X: Governments Eye New Approaches for Trans and ...
Aug 17, 2022 · This article examines the introduction of the X marker, the impacts of gender markers on transgender and nonbinary travelers and migrants, and the evolving ...
[229]
Fluidity in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation Identity in ...
Aug 16, 2023 · It was equally common to move toward a nonbinary gender identity as toward a binary gender identity. SOI fluidity was more common (30.6% from T1 ...
[230]
Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
Jul 15, 2025 · We offer the first detailed longitudinal description of stability and change in gender identity in a large cohort of youths who socially ...
[231]
Stability and Change in Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation ...
We offer the first detailed longitudinal description of stability and change in gender identity in a large cohort of youths who socially transitioned as ...
[232]
A Third Option: Understanding and Assessing Non-binary Gender ...
Sep 12, 2019 · ... policies that support such labor tend to have high administrative burden that impede access. Third, gendered burdens restrict reproductive ...Missing: critiques | Show results with:critiques
[233]
The Third Gender and Hijras | Religion and Public Life
By 2014, India, Nepal, and Bangladesh had all officially recognized third gender people as citizens deserving of equal rights. The Supreme Court of India ...
[234]
The Heritability of Personality is not Always 50%: Gene-Environment ...
Twin studies of personality are consistent in attributing approximately half of the variance in personality to genetic effects.
[235]
Individual Differences in Personality Masculinity-Femininity ...
Mar 7, 2016 · This study examined genetic, environmental, and prenatal hormonal influences on individual differences in personality masculinity–femininity (MF).
[236]
A Boy Raised as a Girl Killed Himself 19 Years Ago Today
May 5, 2023 · David Reimer's suicide. Raising a child with atypical genitals. David, born Bruce, lost his penis to a botched circumcision as an infant in 1966.
[237]
Sex Differences in Mate Preferences Across 45 Countries - PubMed
Considerable research has examined human mate preferences across cultures, finding universal sex differences in preferences for attractiveness and resources ...
[238]
[PDF] Sex Differences in Mate Preferences Across 45 Countries
This research article is a large-scale replication study on sex differences in mate preferences across 45 countries.
[239]
Gender Differences in Vocational Interests Across 57 Countries
Oct 13, 2024 · In more egalitarian countries, gender differences in Realistic, Investigative, and Social interests are larger, revealing an “Interest–Gender-Equality Paradox.”
[240]
Gender stereotypes can explain the gender-equality paradox - PNAS
Nov 23, 2020 · Results suggest that gender occupational segregation can be reduced but will not decrease by itself as societies become more developed.
[241]
UK universities have failed to protect gender-critical academics ...
Jul 2, 2025 · UK universities have failed to protect gender-critical academics from bullying and career-threatening restrictions on their research, according to a report.
[242]
UCL staff under pressure to promote gender ideology.
Oct 6, 2025 · The dynamic is not unfamiliar. Self-censorship was the single most common theme in the government-commissioned Sullivan Review of 2025, which ...
[243]
Worst practices for academic freedom | Freddie Attenborough
Oct 2, 2025 · Has the high tide of campus cancel culture finally receded for gender-critical academics? On paper, you might think so.<|control11|><|separator|>
[244]
Cass Review Final Report
No information is available for this page. · Learn why
[245]
HHS Releases Comprehensive Review of Medical Interventions for ...
May 1, 2025 · HHS released a comprehensive review of evidence and best practices for promoting the health of youth with gender dysphoria.
[246]
[PDF] Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria
May 1, 2025 · Treatments for pediatric gender dysphoria include social transition, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, surgery, and psychotherapy.
[247]
Long-term follow-up of transsexual persons undergoing sex ...
Persons with transsexualism, after sex reassignment, have considerably higher risks for mortality, suicidal behaviour, and psychiatric morbidity than the ...
[248]
The Dutch Studies and The Myth of Reliable Research in Pediatric ...
Jan 11, 2023 · Presenting long-term follow-up data on male-to-female transitioners, the Dutch team acknowledged that while subjects continued to score low on “ ...
[249]
A Trans Researcher's Pursuit of Better Data on Detransition
Oct 26, 2024 · In terms of the numbers, the highest-quality studies suggest that it could be between 5 and 10 percent of people detransition due to a change in ...
[250]
White House orders NIH to research trans 'regret' and 'detransition'
Apr 11, 2025 · The new research will study the physical and mental health effects of gender transition. It comes on the heels of the administration cutting ...
[251]
How does hormone transition in transgender women change body ...
Mar 1, 2021 · Hormone therapy decreases strength, LBM and muscle area, yet values remain above that observed in cisgender women, even after 36 months.
[252]
Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport
Dec 8, 2020 · Despite this modest reduction in strength, transgender women retained a 17% grip strength advantage over transgender men measured at baseline.
[253]
Transgender Women Retain Physical Benefits After Transitioning
Oct 4, 2023 · The study indicated that even 14 years after transitioning, transgender women were, on average, 20 percent stronger and had 20 percent greater heart and lung ...
[254]
A Look At the Numbers and Times: No Denying Advantages of Lia ...
Apr 5, 2022 · The times and rankings of Penn's Lia Thomas are clear and undeniable. The transgender swimmer has an obvious edge over biological women.
[255]
Supreme Court to decide if states can ban transgender girls in sports
Jul 3, 2025 · Twenty-seven states have enacted these laws, with supporters saying they are needed to ensure fairness in athletic competition and to prevent ...
[256]
[PDF] Evidence and Data on Trans Women's Offending Rates
It compared the likelihood of a person having one or more criminal convictions, and convictions for violent crime (defined as “homicide and attempted homicide, ...
[257]
Sexual assaults in women's prison reignite debate over transgender ...
Sep 9, 2018 · A leading prison reformer has said prisoners who have committed violent offences against women should not be able to transfer to women's prisons.
[258]
Trans woman guilty of raping two women remanded in female prison ...
Jan 26, 2023 · Politicians, campaigners and UN special rapporteur concerned by case of Isla Bryson, who offended before she had transitioned.
[259]
Female prisoners at greater risk of sexual assault by transgender ...
Mar 2, 2021 · MoJ policy challenged by prisoner who claims she was sexually assaulted by a trans woman behind bars.<|separator|>
[260]
Trans women inmates who hurt females to go to male prisons - BBC
Dec 5, 2023 · Under previous guidance drawn up in 2014, the prison service allowed all prisoners to be placed in facilities matching their gender identity ...
[261]
Trans woman crawled into bed with, assaulted female resident at ...
Apr 20, 2023 · A self-identified transgender woman in Ontario, Canada, was arrested Tuesday after allegedly sexually assaulting a woman in a women's shelter.
[262]
Two women kicked out of shelter after voicing ... - What's Current
Mar 10, 2017 · There are actual cases of sexual assault on women in homeless ... women's homeless shelters where he sexually assaulted homeless women. shy ...
[263]
Trans student exposed girls to male genitalia in school locker room ...
Apr 21, 2023 · A transgender-identifying student who is biologically male showered in the girls' locker room alongside four freshman girls, exposing them to male genitalia.<|control11|><|separator|>
[264]
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/03/02/female-prisoners-greater-risk-sexual-assault-transgender-inmates/
[265]
SEGM: Home
SEGM's analysis of a large sample of U.S. college students over time suggests that trans/nonbinary identification is at an all-time high as of spring 2025— ...FAQs about SEGM · The Gender Dysphoria... · The NHS Ends the "Gender...Missing: innateness | Show results with:innateness
[266]
2025 German Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Gender ...
Mar 26, 2025 · The 2024 German study found that after 5 years, only 36.4% of young people retained a gender identity-related diagnosis in their medical records ...Missing: innateness | Show results with:innateness
[267]
False Assumptions Behind Youth Gender Transitions - SEGM
Dec 30, 2022 · Increasingly, an alternative theory that gender dysphoria may be a maladaptive coping mechanism rapidly spreading through social networks of ...
[268]
Gender Dysphoria – The Importance of In‐depth Psychological ...
Jan 2, 2025 · There is a very high level of desistance: between 75% and 95% in children with gender dysphoria, if they are offered 'watchful waiting'; however ...<|separator|>
[269]
The Final Cass Review and the NHS England Response - SEGM
Apr 11, 2024 · The Cass Report provides a scathing assessment of the gender-affirming approach in general, and the gender-clinic model of care, which ...Missing: misrepresentations | Show results with:misrepresentations
[270]
Gender medicine and the Cass Review - PubMed Central - NIH
Oct 14, 2024 · The Cass Review is an opportunity to pause, recalibrate, and place evidence informed care at the heart of gender medicine.
[271]
Parenthood linked to shifts in gender ideology, study finds - PsyPost
Mar 7, 2025 · The findings indicate that new mothers who marry partners with traditional gender beliefs and higher incomes may be more likely to adopt traditional gender ...
[272]
New report highlights threats to academic freedom in the study of ...
Jul 22, 2025 · A new report exposes growing threats to academic freedom in the study of sex and gender, detailing how scholars face pressure, censorship, ...
[273]
Philosophers Shouldn't Duck the Gender Debate - City Journal
Aug 15, 2025 · Elite academic thinkers have made sloppy arguments supporting gender ideology—and failed to engage with those who dissent.
[274]
2025: The Gender Wars and Academic Freedom - University of Bristol
May 14, 2025 · Every discipline in the social and human sciences is affected by the demand not to use sex as a conceptual or empirical category. The threat to ...
[275]
The Gender Wars and Academic Freedom
Physical threats and intimidation are also part of the gender identity activist arsenal. ... The need for academic freedom to research and discuss sex and gender ...
[276]
Parental Investment and Sexual Selection
Robert Trivers' 1972 foundational paper introducing parental investment theory in evolutionary biology.
[277]
Meta-analysis of the heritability of human traits based on fifty years of twin studies
Tinca J.C. Polderman et al. 2015 meta-analysis providing heritability estimates for various human traits from twin studies.
[278]
Executive Order 14168—Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism And Restoring Biological Truth To The Federal Government
Official White House publication of Executive Order 14168, issued January 20, 2025, defining "sex" as an individual's immutable biological classification as either male or female.
[279]
Factors associated with desistance and persistence of childhood gender dysphoria: a quantitative follow-up study
Quantitative follow-up study on factors influencing persistence and desistance of childhood gender dysphoria, reporting desistance rates consistent with 80-90% in pre-pubertal cases.
[280]
Cass Review: Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People
Final report assessing evidence for gender identity services, finding weak evidence base for medical interventions in youth.
[281]
New legislation for transgender persons
Official Belgian government page detailing the 2017 law allowing transgender persons to change registered gender and name via self-declaration without medical conditions, effective January 2018.
[282]
Cass Review
Official site of the Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People, including the 2024 final report highlighting evidentiary weaknesses in youth gender services.
[283]
Rainbow Map 2025
ILGA-Europe's 2025 assessment tracking legal and policy advancements for LGBTI rights, including self-ID frameworks across Europe.