Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Harad

Harad is a vast southern region of Middle-earth in J.R.R. Tolkien's legendarium, extending from the borders of Gondor and Mordor southward into unknown expanses, divided into Near Harad adjacent to the Free Peoples and the more distant Far Harad.^[1] The land's inhabitants, the Haradrim—tribes of Men described as tall, dark-skinned warriors with coal-black hair and eyes—were ancient foes of Gondor, having clashed with its kings since the Second Age over territories like Umbar, their principal corsair haven.^[1] The Haradrim's defining traits in Tolkien's narratives include their employment of massive war-beasts known as mûmakil (oliphaunts), which terrorized Gondor's forces during the War of the Ring, and their allegiance to Sauron, symbolized by banners bearing a black serpent on a scarlet field.^[2] This alliance stemmed from Sauron's conquest and oaths of fealty extracted in the Third Age, rendering the Haradrim key participants in assaults such as the Battle of the Pelennor Fields, where they deployed oliphaunts laden with archers and fell in great numbers to the Rohirrim and Aragorn's host.^[3] Post-war, Aragorn's campaigns reconquered much of Harad, imposing renewed Gondorian suzerainty, though the region's remoteness and cultural independence persisted.^[1] Tolkien drew Harad's conceptual foundations from historical perceptions of ancient Near Eastern and African civilizations, evoking parallels to Carthage or Ethiopia through elements like elephantine warfare and serpentine iconography, while emphasizing the Haradrim's humanity amid Sauron's manipulation rather than inherent villainy.^[4] Scholarly analyses note the portrayal's basis in Edainic migrations and Númenórean imperialism, with Harad representing unassimilated southern peoples resistant to northern dominion, free from allegorical impositions as Tolkien explicitly rejected direct political mappings.^[5]

In-universe description

Geography and natural features

Harad occupies a broad expanse of southern Middle-earth, positioned south of Gondor and the inland sea of Nurnen, with its northern limits marked by the rivers Poros and Harnen. The Harnen originates in the southern extensions of the Ephel Dúath mountains and flows westward into the Bay of Belfalas, historically delineating the boundary between Gondorian territories and Haradwaith.^[5] This river, crossed by ancient roads, facilitated both trade and military movements across the region. The western coastline features prominent formations such as Umbar, a large cape enclosing a sheltered firth that forms a natural deep-water harbor conducive to naval operations.^[6] The geography of Harad exhibits significant variation, with Near Harad—adjacent to Gondor—dominated by semi-arid plains and expansive deserts under a relentlessly hot sun. Far Harad, extending deeper into the south, transitions to more humid environments, including dense tropical jungles and possibly vast coastal stretches, though detailed mappings remain sparse in surviving records. These climatic gradients contribute to Harad's strategic value, providing routes for overland invasions from the south and access to maritime paths along the western seaboard.^[7] Among Harad's natural features are its unique megafauna, notably the mûmakil, enormous proboscidean creatures adapted to the region's sweltering heat and varied terrains, particularly the lush interiors of Far Harad. These beasts, standing taller than houses with thick hides and serpentine trunks, underscore the environmental extremes of the land, from parched expanses to verdant wilds capable of sustaining such colossal life forms.^[8]

Inhabitants and societal structures

The inhabitants of Harad, known collectively as the Haradrim or Southrons, comprised diverse tribes of Men characterized by dark skin tones, with variations ranging from swarthy complexions among the Near Haradrim to black-skinned warriors in the Far Harad.^[9] These peoples formed complex, decentralized societies rather than a unified polity, organized into tribal groups led by chieftains or kings, often maintaining autonomy despite external alliances.^[10] In Near Harad, particularly around the coastal haven of Umbar, societal structures showed greater urbanization and hierarchy, influenced by the corsair lords who governed as semi-independent rulers, blending local Haradrim customs with legacies of Númenórean seafaring traditions.^[11] Far Haradrim societies, by contrast, remained more tribal and nomadic, with descriptions in Tolkien's texts portraying certain warriors as "black men like half-trolls with white eyes and red tongues," suggesting robust, formidable physiques adapted to their southern environments.^[12] Daily life among the Haradrim incorporated vibrant cultural elements, such as scarlet and gold livery in attire and regalia, alongside the use of swords, round shields, and domesticated beasts for transport and labor, reflecting both martial readiness and practical adaptations to arid or coastal terrains.^[9] Umbar's corsairs exemplified advanced societal specialization in naval crafts, operating structured fleets for trade and raiding, governed by captains claiming titles like "Heirs of Castamir," which underscored a blend of hereditary leadership and opportunistic piracy.^[11] Religious practices among the Haradrim included veneration of Sauron as both king and god, often framed in their lore as a deliverer from northern dominion, alongside worship of darker deities predating his influence, which reinforced tribal loyalties and social cohesion through shared rituals.^[13] These structures allowed for internal divisions and rivalries among tribes, enabling independent city-states like Umbar to thrive as corsair republics while broader Haradrim groups pursued agrarian, pastoral, or mercantile pursuits shaped by regional geography.^[14]

Military capabilities and warfare

The Haradrim utilized mûmakil, or oliphaunts, as primary shock troops, mounting these enormous elephantine beasts with war towers carrying archers and spearmen to overwhelm enemy lines. In the Battle of the Pelennor Fields on March 15, T.A. 3019, dozens of these creatures advanced amid the Haradrim host, their charge bellowing terror and trampling foes until disrupted by targeted Rohirrim assaults on vulnerable undersides and drivers.^[15] This deployment leveraged the region's access to such fauna for psychological and physical impact, independent of broader Sauronian coordination. Haradrim infantry favored curved scimitars for close combat, drawing them in coordinated advances that glittered like stars under sunlight during charges, paired with spears for formation fighting.^[16] These warriors, often clad in scarlet garb, complemented their melee prowess with archery from mûmakil towers and foot ranks, emphasizing volume over precision to exploit numerical superiority in open engagements. Complementing land forces, Haradrim naval assets centered on the corsairs of Umbar, whose fleets raided Gondor's southern coasts, disrupting supply lines and preventing reinforcements from reaching key battles like the Siege of Minas Tirith. These operations, drawing on Umbar's strategic harbor, imposed persistent defensive burdens on Gondor by threatening Ethir Anduin and beyond, distinct from Easterling riverine or steppe maneuvers.^[17] Southern tactics adapted to arid terrains through beast-mounted cavalry and multi-front pressure, sustaining pressure on Gondor's extended borders via overland incursions and coastal harassment.

Historical context within Middle-earth

Origins and early migrations

The ancestors of the Haradrim, the Men of Harad, originated among the Atani who awoke in the distant eastern region of Hildórien at the first rising of the Sun, marking the commencement of the First Age.^[4] Unlike the three houses of the Edain, who undertook arduous migrations westward into Beleriand in pursuit of the Eldar and the rumored Light of the Valar, the forebears of the Haradrim either remained in the eastern lands or dispersed southward, evading the direct upheavals of Morgoth's wars that dominated the northwestern continents.^[18] This separation ensured their minimal entanglement in the cataclysmic conflicts of the First Age, including the Nirnaeth Arnoediad and the War of Wrath, allowing for organic cultural evolution insulated from Valinorean influences.^[1] These southward migrations unfolded gradually during the First Age, as groups of Men traversed the untamed expanses east of the Inland Sea and south of later Gondorian territories, populating the arid and tropical climes of Haradwaith.^[4] By this era, distinctions in physical traits emerged, with the southern migrants developing swarthy complexions adapted to their environments, a characteristic later reflected in northern nomenclature such as the Hobbitish term "Swertings," denoting dark-skinned Southrons independent of later political alignments.^[19] Such internal variations among these peoples—encompassing tribal divisions predating widespread external contacts—fostered autonomous societal structures, with sporadic interactions possibly limited to eastern Dwarven enclaves rather than the Edain's western kin.^[1] Into the early Second Age, after the tumultuous drowning of Beleriand and the reshaping of Middle-earth's northwest, the Men of Harad consolidated into distinct cultural enclaves, their pre-Sauronic independence marked by self-reliant developments unmarred by the refugee influxes from the North.^[18] This period solidified their divergence, with societies oriented toward the vast southern landscapes, emphasizing adaptation to local geographies over alliances with northern powers.^[4]

Conflicts with Númenóreans and Gondor

The Númenóreans, during their voyages of exploration and colonization in the Second Age, established fortified havens along the coasts of Harad, such as Umbar, which served as bases for trade but evolved into centers of exploitation.^[14] As Númenórean power grew under the influence of the King's Men, they conducted raids into the interior, capturing and enslaving Haradrim for labor and sacrifice, actions that engendered lasting animosity among the southern peoples toward these "sea-kings."^[4]^[20] Following the Downfall of Númenor in S.A. 3319, Black Númenóreans—descendants of the rebel faction—fled southward to Umbar and other enclaves, where they intermarried with and ruled over Haradrim lords, channeling the locals' resentment into organized opposition against the remnant Faithful who established Gondor.^[21] This alliance transformed Harad's coastal regions into a persistent threat to Gondor's southern frontiers, with Black Númenórean sorcery and naval prowess amplifying Haradrim raids. Gondor's expansionist policies intensified conflicts, as kings sought to subdue Haradwaith and secure trade routes; in T.A. 933, Eärnil I assembled a great fleet and army to besiege and capture Umbar, expelling most Black Númenórean lords and incorporating the haven as a key Gondorian fortress.^[21] Yet Haradrim resistance endured through revolts and alliances with Umbar's Corsairs—descendants of Castamir's rebels after Umbar's loss in T.A. 1448—including devastating coastal assaults that culminated in the slaying of King Minardil at Pelargir in T.A. 1634.^[22] These actions, framed by Gondor as defensive necessities, were perceived by Haradrim as further encroachments on their sovereignty, fueling cycles of piracy and border warfare. Sauron adroitly manipulated these grievances upon his resurgence in the late Second Age, forging pacts with Haradrim chieftains by pledging to liberate them from Númenórean overlordship and restore their autonomy, oaths that masked his intent to bind them as vassals in his broader conquests.^[23] This deception recast Harad's defensive resentments into ideological fealty, enabling coordinated assaults on Gondor while subordinating southern independence to Mordor's strategic aims.

Role in the War of the Ring

In early March T.A. 3019, Haradrim forces advanced northward into Ithilien as part of Sauron's coordinated offensives, transporting supplies and troops along the Harad Road toward Mordor; a convoy of these warriors, including captains and archers clad in scarlet, was ambushed by Faramir's Rangers of Ithilien near the Emyn Muil, resulting in significant casualties and the capture of prisoners, which delayed reinforcements for the siege of Minas Tirith.^[24]^[25] The Haradrim played a prominent role in the Battle of the Pelennor Fields on March 15, T.A. 3019, contributing infantry and mûmakil (oliphaunts) to the southern assault on Minas Tirith after the gates were breached; these massive beasts, armored and bearing howdahs of archers, trampled through the Rammas Echor and advanced nearly unhindered toward the city's walls, their thick hides resisting arrows from Gondor's defenders and threatening to shatter the beleaguered lines before the arrival of the Rohirrim.^[26] The Haradrim host, marked by their standard of a black serpent on a scarlet field, was led by a chieftain or king in scarlet livery with gold adornments, who charged prominently but was slain during Théoden's counterassault, contributing to the disruption of their formation.^[27] Following the fall of the Witch-king, the Haradrim, like other Easterling and Southron contingents, suffered heavy losses from the Rohirrim's charge and faltered, with many fleeing southward amid the collapse of Sauron's morale-dependent host; this retreat underscored the contingent nature of their allegiance, tied more to Sauron's dominion and immediate command structures than unwavering loyalty, as tribal divisions prevented sustained cohesion without overarching control.^[28] Without Sauron's victory, Harad's forces lacked the unity for independent resurgence against the West, reverting to fragmented loyalties post-defeat.^[29]

Linguistic and conceptual development

The term Harad derives from Sindarin harad, meaning "south", as documented in Tolkien's linguistic notes on the Grey-elven tongue spoken by the Sindar of Beleriand and later adopted in Gondor. This exonym reflects the perspective of northern peoples, particularly the Elves and Dúnedain, who mapped regions relative to their own heartlands in northwestern Middle-earth. Variants include Haradwaith, combining harad with gwaith ("people" or "region"), denoting the "South-folk" or southern lands collectively.^[30] In the Common Speech (Westron), inhabitants of Harad were termed "Southrons", a direct calque translating the Westron endonym for southern peoples, while Hobbits used "Swertings" in their dialect, evoking archaic connotations of southern or swarthy folk.^[9] The Haradrim's own self-designations remain unknown in Tolkien's writings, suggesting linguistic diversity among their tribes, potentially incorporating substrates uninfluenced by Elvish or Adûnaic, though coastal enclaves like Umbar show Adûnaic lexical traces from Númenórean colonization, such as in toponyms denoting fortresses or havens.^[14] Elvish nomenclature for the south connects to Quenya Hyarmen, literally "left-hand direction", arising from the Vanyar's eastward orientation upon arriving in Aman, where south lay to their left; this contrasts with formen ("right-hand", north) and underscores an Elvish cardinal bias prioritizing their migratory frame over objective geography.^[31] Sindarin harad aligns etymologically with this system, deriving from Primitive Quendian khyar- ("left"), adapted in the Grey-elven dialect.^[32] Such terms highlight how Elvish languages imposed a northwestern-centric nomenclature on distant realms, with limited insight into indigenous southern idioms.

Influences from Tolkien's philological studies

Tolkien's philological investigation into the Old English term Sigelwara land profoundly shaped his conception of Harad as a distant, sun-baked southern realm. In his essay "Sigelwara Land," published in two parts in the journal Medium Ævum in 1932 and 1934, Tolkien dissected the compound Sigelwara, deriving it from sigel ("sun") combined with elements evoking scorching heat and dark coloration, ultimately associating the term with ancient Ethiopian lands and their swarthy inhabitants. This etymological framework, rooted in Anglo-Saxon textual evidence rather than contemporary racial constructs, informed the portrayal of Haradwaith—literally "South-folk" in Sindarin—as a hot, arid expanse whose people, the Haradrim, were depicted with "swarthy" features and "black" steeds amid "sun-scorched" plains in The Lord of the Rings. The linguistic depth Tolkien applied to Sigelwara extended to Harad's depiction as a loose confederation of tribes, echoing the fragmented polities of ancient Near Eastern or African cultures inferred from philological sources. Rather than monolithic, Harad encompassed diverse groups like the "swertings" (black men) of Near Harad and more remote variants, reflecting Tolkien's commitment to realistic onomastics drawn from historical linguistics, where names evolve from primordial roots denoting geography and phenotype. This approach prioritized empirical reconstruction of ancient tongues over invented uniformity, mirroring how Old English terms like Sigelwara preserved traces of pre-Christian cosmographies. Tolkien's primary philological focus on northwestern European traditions—evident in his preference for Old English, Norse, and Celtic materials—resulted in sparse canonical details for Harad, treating it as peripheral to the core legendarium centered on Free Peoples' histories. Incidental references in his correspondence underscore that Haradrim foes embodied generic antagonism from the South, devoid of direct allegory to modern entities, aligning with his aversion to symbolic mapping onto contemporary conflicts. For instance, Tolkien clarified in letters that such southern adversaries represented perennial threats akin to historical migrations, not encoded critiques of specific races or nations.

Real-world inspirations and Tolkien's intent

Historical and mythological parallels

The lands of Harad parallel ancient mythological conceptions of southern realms, particularly the classical Greek Aethiopia, depicted in Homer's Iliad (c. 8th century BCE) as a distant, sun-scorched territory inhabited by dark-skinned peoples ruled by figures like Memnon, who led Ethiopian warriors against the Greeks at Troy. These echoes appear in Tolkien's philological work on Old English "Sigelwara Land," an essay published in Medium Ævum (1932–1934), where he traces the term to descriptions of Ethiopian antiquity, evoking hot deserts and "soot-black" inhabitants akin to biblical Cush, the region south of Egypt referenced in Genesis 2:13 as a source of gold and bdellium. Such pre-modern sources emphasize causal geography—vast distances fostering "exotic" but human adversaries—rather than modern projections.^[33] Umbar, Harad's chief port and naval base, bears resemblances to ancient Carthaginian maritime power, which deployed fleets and war elephants against Rome during the Punic Wars (264–146 BCE), including Hannibal's use of approximately 37 North African elephants in his 218 BCE Alpine crossing to invade Italy. Tolkien's Corsairs of Umbar, with their black ships raiding Gondor's coasts, mirror Carthage's role as a Phoenician colony dominating Mediterranean trade and warfare, supported by alliances with eastern powers. Similarly, Harad's broader imperial structure evokes Persian Achaemenid satrapies, with tributary kings like those of Near Harad submitting to a high king, paralleling the Persian Empire's (c. 550–330 BCE) layered hierarchy of subject peoples furnishing troops for campaigns against western foes. Mythological motifs in Harad include the oliphaunts, massive beasts employed in battle, akin to the Indian elephants integrated into Hellenistic armies post-Alexander (e.g., Pyrrhus of Epirus's use against Romans in 280–275 BCE) or Seleucid forces, though Tolkien specified oliphaunts as a surviving prehistoric species distinct from modern elephants, denying direct historical allegory while nodding to ancient marvels of the East. These parallels stem from verifiable antique accounts, underscoring Tolkien's reliance on first-millennium sources for depicting Harad as a confederation of ancient, sun-baked kingdoms locked in perennial border strife with northern empires, without imputing contemporary racial or colonial dynamics.^[34]

Tolkien's statements on race and geography

In 1938, J.R.R. Tolkien rejected Nazi inquiries into his racial ancestry for publishing The Hobbit in Germany, protesting in Letter 30 that such criteria were impertinent and regretting the lack of Jewish heritage among his forebears while criticizing the underlying assumptions.^[35] He characterized race-doctrines as "wholly pernicious and unscientific," affirming in related correspondence a view of humanity undivided by biological supremacist hierarchies but susceptible to cultural and willful moral failings.^[36] This stance informed his portrayal of Middle-earth's peoples, where Men form one species differentiated by kindreds through history, migration, and linguistic evolution rather than inherent moral essences tied to biology. Tolkien's geographical framework in Middle-earth symbolizes the diffusion of evil influences from ancient power centers in the East and South—Morgoth's northern fortresses and Sauron's eastern domains—yet emphasizes free will over environmental or locational determinism. Haradrim allegiance to Sauron reflects deception, conquest by Black Númenóreans at Umbar, and chosen subjugation, not predestined wickedness linked to their swarthy complexion or southern habitat.^[37] Moral gradients thus represent mythic patterns of temptation's persistence in peripheral regions, counterbalanced by individual agency, as Númenórean colonists and even Gondorian figures like Denethor demonstrate corruption's universality irrespective of origin. Central to Tolkien's intent is the ethic of pity extended to adversaries, humanizing foes against reductive categorizations. In The Two Towers, Sam's contemplation of a slain Haradrim soldier evokes empathy: "He wondered what the man's name was and where he came from; and if he was really evil of heart, or what lies or threats had led him on the long march from his home; and if he would not really rather have stayed there in peace."^[38] This narrative device, rooted in Tolkien's Catholic worldview prioritizing personal responsibility and mercy, rebuts interpretations imputing racial or geographic inevitability to Harad's belligerence, framing enemies as fallen individuals redeemable in principle through choice.^[39]

Adaptations and modern portrayals

Film depictions

In Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003), Harad is represented through the Haradrim's participation in the Battle of the Pelennor Fields, where they deploy mûmakil-mounted charges against the forces of Gondor and Rohan. The film portrays the Haradrim as dark-skinned warriors dressed in red and gold attire, manning war towers on the colossal, CGI-rendered beasts that trample infantry and clash with cavalry.^[40] This visualization emphasizes the spectacle of the oliphaunts' rampage, with computer-generated effects highlighting their size, tusks adorned with spikes, and the warriors' archery volleys.^[41] The depiction maintains fidelity to J.R.R. Tolkien's source material by showing the Haradrim's tribal ferocity in combat, as their forces contribute to Sauron's assault without altering core battle dynamics like the mûmakil's breakthrough against Rohirrim lines.^[42] Screen time is limited to integrate within the extended siege sequence, prioritizing visual impact over extended cultural depth, which simplifies the Haradrim as formidable but archetypal foes.^[43] This portrayal popularized the Haradrim's image in popular culture, rendering them as exotic, elephant-borne threats that amplify the epic scale of the conflict.^[44]

Television and recent series

In The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, which premiered on September 2, 2022, on Amazon Prime Video, the Second Age setting encompasses the Southlands—a cluster of territories including Tirharad and Ostirith that are later reshaped into Mordor following a volcanic eruption in season 1, episode 7. These lands lie north of Harad in Tolkien's broader geography, with canon texts indicating Númenórean colonies and early Sauronic influence extending into Near Harad during this era, yet the series omits any direct references to Harad or its inhabitants across 16 episodes through season 2, which concluded on October 21, 2024.^[10]^[45] The absence of Haradrim characters persists despite the Southlands' diverse human populations, portrayed with actors of varied ethnic backgrounds loyal to or resisting Sauron's forces, such as the villagers led by Bronwyn (played by Nazanin Boniadi). This approach has sparked fan debates over representational choices, with critics contending that the series bypassed opportunities to depict Haradrim—canonically bold, dark-skinned warriors from Near Harad, influenced initially by Númenórean trade and later by Sauron—for authentic southern cultures, opting instead for non-canon diversification in northern groups like Elves and Dwarves.^[46]^[47] Season 2 expands Sauron's manipulations in eastern Rhûn and among orcs, hinting at broader alliances but without southern Haradrim involvement, diverging from sparse Second Age texts where Sauron recruits men from Haradwaith amid Númenórean incursions southward. Future seasons, renewed through at least season 5 as of November 2024, could introduce such elements to align with Sauron's pre-Last Alliance coalitions, though showrunners J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay have emphasized fidelity to Tolkien's appendices over explicit southern expansions to date.^[9]

Video games and other media

In the real-time strategy games The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth (2004) and its sequel The Battle for Middle-earth II (2006), Haradrim units form part of the evil faction's arsenal, including spearmen, archers, and oliphaunts (mûmakil), with gameplay emphasizing massed infantry charges supported by siege-breaking war beasts for overwhelming enemy lines.^[48] Mods such as Rise of the Witch-king and Age of the Ring for Battle for Middle-earth II elevate Harad to a standalone playable faction, incorporating expanded rosters and tactics centered on swarm assaults and serpent-themed auxiliaries.^[49]^[50] The tabletop role-playing game Middle-earth Role Playing (MERP), published by Iron Crown Enterprises, features dedicated supplements like Greater Harad (1990) and Far Harad: The Scorched Land (1988), which detail non-canonical expansions on Haradrim tribal structures, regional variants such as Near and Far Harad, and adventure hooks involving desert nomads and coastal corsairs.^[51] In miniature wargaming, Games Workshop's The Lord of the Rings: Strategy Battle Game (released 2001, ongoing) includes plastic and metal models of Haradrim warriors (24 figures per box with spear or bow options), raiders on foot or mount, and colossal oliphaunt kits, enabling assembly of full Haradrim armies focused on mobility and volume of fire in skirmish scenarios.^[52]^[53] The massively multiplayer online game The Lord of the Rings Online announced its Kingdoms of Harad expansion on September 24, 2025, scheduled for release on December 3, 2025, which will add Haradrim-inhabited zones, quests, and faction interactions as an endgame region south of Gondor.^[54]

Interpretations and debates

Geopolitical and cultural realism

The establishment of Númenórean colonies along the coasts of Harad, particularly the fortified haven of Umbar founded in the Second Age, represented an extension of imperial ambition that disrupted local autonomy and resource access. These settlements, initially trade outposts under the Faithful and later dominated by the King's Men, imposed tribute and military garrisons, fostering resentment among Haradrim tribes displaced or subjugated by superior Númenórean naval and architectural prowess. Following the Downfall of Númenor in SA 3319, Umbar devolved into a rebel stronghold under Black Númenóreans, who allied with Sauron and conducted piratical raids on Gondor's shipping lanes, perpetuating cycles of retaliation that Sauron exploited as a proxy for anti-colonial resistance rather than ideological alignment.^[21] Harad's geopolitical position as a peripheral power was sustained by its fragmented tribal structure, comprising mutually hostile clans across Near and Far Harad—brown-skinned warriors of the north with black hair and eyes, and darker peoples further south—mirroring the internal divisions of ancient confederacies like the Achaemenid satrapies or nomadic alliances. This diversity precluded unified empire-building but enabled economic resilience through overland trade routes carrying spices, ivory from mûmakil herds, gold, and gems northward via the Harad Road, funding military autonomy without reliance on northern powers. Such resource-driven independence, rooted in arid and equatorial environments rich in exotic goods yet lacking centralized metallurgy, positioned Haradrim polities to negotiate alliances opportunistically, allying with Sauron during Gondor's weakening phases (e.g., the Kin-strife of TA 1432–1447) to reclaim contested territories like Umbar, seized by Haradrim forces around TA 1800.^[55] Environmentally adapted warfare conferred persistent military advantages, with Haradrim leveraging vast deserts and riverine deltas for asymmetric tactics that neutralized Gondor's equine-heavy hosts. Domesticated mûmakil—towering proboscideans tamed for battle, bearing howdahs armed with archers and javelins—provided shock value and elevated command platforms, trampling infantry and outmaneuvering horses unaccustomed to southern heat and terrain, as evidenced in sustained offensives like the Battle of the Pelennor Fields on March 15, TA 3019. This ecological edge, combined with corsair fleets from Umbar harassing Gondor's Anduin trade, ensured Harad's role as a chronic threat despite lacking the industrial base for total conquest, reflecting realist dynamics where peripheral actors exploit core overextension through attrition and proxy leverage.^[41]

Thematic roles in good-evil dynamics

In J.R.R. Tolkien's legendarium, the Haradrim represent Men capable of redemption, drawn into Sauron's service through deception rather than intrinsic depravity, embodying a Catholic-influenced view of moral agency where souls ensnared by lies retain the potential for pity and conversion.^[56] This is vividly illustrated in The Two Towers, where Samwise Gamgee contemplates a fallen Haradrim warrior, envisioning his life as one of simple agrarian roots and lured ambitions for glory and wealth under Sauron's false banner, evoking universal human pathos and critiquing the totalitarian manipulation that binds free peoples to evil causes.^[57] Tolkien's cosmology posits that while Harad's proximity to Mordor intensifies exposure to Sauron's corrupting influence—correlating with higher rates of allegiance to tyranny—ultimate responsibility lies in individual and collective choice, rejecting deterministic interpretations of a "moral geography" in favor of free will as the arbiter of good and evil outcomes among Men.^[58] The Haradrim's ensnarement underscores Sauron's strategy of posing as a liberator to subjugated tribes, aligning with themes of anti-totalitarianism where deception exploits human vulnerabilities without excusing complicity.^[59] To avert a binary North-South moral divide, Tolkien depicts flaws in northern realms, such as Gondor's stratified society where Dúnedain nobility asserted superiority over "lesser" Men through blood purity doctrines, fostering pride and exclusion that mirror the very hierarchical sins they opposed in the South.^[60] This portrayal emphasizes that ethical imperfection pervades all human societies, reinforcing free will's primacy over locational predestination in the struggle against evil.^[61]

Allegations of bias and textual rebuttals

Critics, particularly in academic analyses influenced by postcolonial theory, have alleged that Tolkien's depiction of the Haradrim embodies orientalism and racism, portraying dark-skinned southern peoples as inherently antagonistic to the "civilized" West through descriptors like "swart-faced" warriors and those from Far Harad likened to "half-trolls with white eyes and red tongues," interpreted as dehumanizing tropes equating otherness with savagery.^[62]^[63] Such interpretations often frame Harad's alignment with Sauron as a racial allegory for real-world imperialism's "barbaric East," overlooking textual nuances in favor of anachronistic ideological projections.^[64] These allegations are countered by Tolkien's philological foundations; his unpublished essay "Sigelwara Land" (c. 1930s, drawing on Old English attestations) derives names for southern "Ethiopians" from sigel ("sun") and hearwa (evoking scorching heat producing dark hues), envisioning Harad as a literal "sun-charred" realm shaped by environment, not innate moral or racial defect.^[65] The "half-troll" simile in The Return of the King (1955) describes the imposing stature and ferocity of Far Harad contingents—reinforced by their use of massive oliphaunts—mirroring epic traditions of formidable foes, without implying hybrid degeneracy, as trolls themselves hail from southern origins but represent corrupted primordial beings distinct from Men.^[9] Textually, the Haradrim exhibit agency and historical depth absent in propagandistic stereotypes: a slain Southron in The Two Towers (1954) wears a red garment embroidered by his grandfather after slaying Gondor's King Eärnil's heir, suggesting vendettas rooted in Gondor's southward expansions rather than unmotivated enmity, while their serpentine heraldry and tactical oliphaunt warfare denote sophisticated culture under Sauron's sway.^[9] Tolkien's correspondence repudiates racial essentialism; in a 1938 letter to his German publisher, he rejected inquiries tying his works to Aryan doctrines as "wholly pernicious and unscientific," affirming moral geography over biological determinism, with Harad's peoples—descended from the same Hildórien-wakened Men as the Edain—capable of redemption post-Sauron, as implied in The Silmarillion (1977).^[66] Modern adaptation efforts to "diversify" northwestern protagonists, while sidelining Harad's canonical exoticism, undermine textual fidelity by conflating fidelity to Tolkien's "otherness"—a deliberate narrative device for exploring alliance, temptation, and cultural clash—with bias, prioritizing contemporary equity over the legendarium's mythic structure where Sauron's dominion corrupts willing allies irrespective of hue.^[37] Such revisions, often from production teams assuming subtextual prejudice, ignore Tolkien's stated applicability over allegory and his aversion to reducing conflicts to skin color, as evidenced by free peoples' internal divisions (e.g., Dunlendings' Rohan grudge).

References

[1]
Who Were the Drúedain, Haradrim, and Easterlings?
Apr 22, 2019 · The “Haradrim” were all the tribes and nations living south of Gondor in Middle-earth. They included the Corsairs of Umbar (or, I should say, ...
[2]
What Do We Know about the Black Serpent of Harad?
Jan 13, 2020 · Then he was filled with a red wrath and shouted aloud, and displaying his standard, black serpent upon scarlet, he came against the white horse ...
[3]
Crash Course: Part One – Middle Earth Fandom - Sites at Penn State
Jan 24, 2022 · Haradrim is the kingdom south of Gondor, home to a race of men. Sauron corrupted the inhabitants of Haradrim and compelled them to war, making ...
[4]
The Barbarians of Middle-Earth: The Haradrim
Jan 3, 2010 · The Haradrim are very human, and the monster they became in the Third Age was created not just by Sauron, but by the protagonists' own ancestors.Rise Of The Haradrim · Fall Of The Haradrim · The Wrath Of Gondor<|control11|><|separator|>
[5]
Harad | Mythgard Forums
Nov 12, 2020 · Far Harad is described as being roughly the size of a continent, with multiple climates and regions, compared to Sub-Saharan Africa. There are ...Session 5-25: HaradThe Long Winter - a Middle Earth rpg?More results from forums.signumuniversity.org
[6]
A large map of Umbar
Umbar was surrounded by an ancient and immensely strong wall, with towers and gates, first built by the Númenoreans in the Second Age and repaired many times ...
[7]
Tolkien's Map and The Messed Up Mountains of Middle-earth
Aug 1, 2017 · The main creator of mountains are tectonic plate collisions. You either end up with the heavier oceanic plate grinding under the continental crust.Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[8]
What are the Mûmakil in Lord of the Rings: War of the Rohirrim? - CBR
Aug 25, 2024 · Mûmakil are massive, lumbering elephant-like creatures native to the Haradwaith region, the land to the south of Gondor and Mordor.
[9]
Haradrim - Tolkien Gateway
May 31, 2025 · Haradrim or the Southrons were the Men of Harad, descendants of the Men who woke in the far eastern land of Hildórien near the end of the First Age.History · Traits and culture · Other versions of the... · Portrayal in adaptations
[10]
Harad - Tolkien Gateway
Jul 26, 2024 · Harad, also known as the South, refers to the little-known lands in southern Middle-earth. The great region is located south of Harondor and Mordor.Missing: primary sources
[11]
Corsairs of Umbar - Tolkien Gateway
May 7, 2025 · The Corsairs were led by four brothers who falsely call themselves the Heirs of Castamir. These were Azruthor, Dolgimil, Azgarzôr, and the ...
[12]
Half-trolls - Tolkien Gateway
... Far Harad black men like half-trolls with white eyes and red tongues. J.R.R. Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings, The Return of the King, "The Battle of the ...Missing: quote | Show results with:quote
[13]
Haradrim | The One Wiki to Rule Them All | Fandom
For Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings film trilogy, the Haradrim's design (by Wētā Workshop) was inspired by the Saracens and Pacific Kiribati tribes. Their ...Missing: physical | Show results with:physical
[14]
Umbar - Tolkien Gateway
Oct 18, 2025 · Gondor's King Eärnil I repaired the haven of Pelargir, built a great navy and besieged Umbar by land and by sea. In T.A. 933, he took Umbar.Missing: annexes | Show results with:annexes
[15]
Chapter XXI: The Battle Of The Pelennor Fields - The Road
Horns were blown and trumpets were braying, and the mumakil were bellowing as they were goaded to war, the greatest of which crashed through the walls of the ...
[16]
"And the joy of battle was upon me": My favorite moments from the ...
Oct 1, 2008 · ... Haradrim, who rally around a standard of a ... "The drawing of the scimitars of the Southrons was like a glitter of stars," writes Tolkien.
[17]
The Corsairs of Umbar – @askmiddlearth on Tumblr
The corsairs of Umbar aren't really pirates in the traditional sense - they seem to be more like privateers than anything. But, they're the closest we get (at ...
[18]
Haradrim - Races, Peoples, Kelvar and Olvar - Elfenomeno.com
In the First Age, it is believed that the Haradrim descend from Men who awoke in Hildórien and emigrated south, although their exact origin remains uncertain.
[19]
Is Swertings Derogatory? - Ask About Middle Earth
Jul 26, 2013 · Based on Tolkien's own definition of the term, and just some common sense, it's clear that “Swerting” is the hobbit-ized version of “Swarthy men ...
[20]
Did Gondor Ever Practice Slavery?
Oct 31, 2019 · The later kings of Númenor practiced or allowed slavery when they began conquering lands in Middle-earth. But that tradition was associated with ...
[21]
Were the Corsairs of Umbar Numenoreans?
Dec 12, 2011 · Umbar therefore remained in Gondorian hands from TA 933 to 1448, when the sons of Castamir the Usurper stole the fleet of Gondor from ...Missing: annexes | Show results with:annexes
[22]
Harad and the Haradrim - Thain's Book - Minas Tirith
In 2758, three fleets from Umbar and Harad attacked Gondor along the southern coast and on the west coast as far north as the River Isen. The Corsairs also ...
[23]
Of the Numenoreans and Haradrim. "He was glad that ... - Facebook
Sep 15, 2024 · The lies of Sauron wormed their way into the Haradrim whose hatred for Numenoreans grew and they started to worship Sauron. Though the Blue ...
[24]
TA 3019 | The One Wiki to Rule Them All - Fandom
Frodo encounters Faramir and his Rangers in Ithilien and is taken to Henneth Annûn. Rangers attack Haradrim travelling up the Harad Road to the Black Gate.
[25]
Mordor / Quotes from the Books - PBworks
... Far Harad black man like half-trolls with white eyes and red tongues. Some now hastened behind the Rohirrim, others held westward to hold off the forces of ...Missing: Tolkien | Show results with:Tolkien
[26]
The Battle of Pelennor Fields - The Red Book
Mar 15, 2016 · Another long quote, because every word is packed. "Tall and proud he seemed again; and rising in his stirrups he cried in a loud voice, more ...
[27]
Analysis of the Battle of the Pelennor Fields in Lord of the Rings
Mar 4, 2025 · "Do what you will, but I will hinder it, if I may. - Hinder me? Thou fool. No living man may hinder me!" ~~J.R.R. Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings ...Theoden's Charge Against the Mumakil in the Battle of Pelennor FieldsOf the Numenoreans and Haradrim. "He was glad that ... - FacebookMore results from www.facebook.com
[28]
One of the most important passages in the book, regarding "is the ...
Feb 28, 2023 · One of the most important passages in the book, regarding "is the portrayal of the Haradrim racist". There is a certain passage from the book ...Theoden's expression when he sees the army. - Reddit[Text] Lord of the Rings, Book V, Chapter V: Ride of the RohirrimMore results from www.reddit.com
[29]
7th March 3019 of the Third Age: Encounters in Ithilien and The ...
Mar 7, 2025 · "The fight was brief but intense. The Haradrim did not yield easily." When the combat ended, among the undergrowth they discovered two ...
[30]
Haradwaith - Parf Edhellen: an elvish dictionary
Another name for the lands of the South (LotR/1045, UT/383), a combination of harad “south” and gwaith “people, region”. Conceptual Development: In Lord of the ...
[31]
Quenya : hyarmen - Eldamo
Q. hyarmen n. “south, (lit.) left-hand direction” (Category: South). Q. hyarmen, 9ÍC6t$5 n. “south, (lit.) left-hand direction” (Category: South).Missing: Tolkien | Show results with:Tolkien
[32]
South - Parf Edhellen: an elvish dictionary
Q. south. hyarmen, Hyarmen noun "south" (SA, SA:men, KHYAR), literally "lefthand-direction" (VT49:12), since the Elves named the directions as they were to ...
[33]
The Kingdom of Cush - Biblical Archaeology Society
The Kingdom of Cush, Egypt's neighbor to the south, played an important role within biblical history despite being one of the lesser known kingdoms.Missing: Tolkien | Show results with:Tolkien
[34]
[PDF] TOLKIEN: MONSTERS, MIDGARD, AND MEDIEVAL ORIGINS
One needs to remember that Hannibal used elephants with devastating effectiveness in 217. B.C.E. when he crossed the Alps and began laying waste to the Roman ...
[35]
Letter 30 - Tolkien Gateway
Apr 15, 2023 · This letter is often cited as a counterargument when Tolkien is accused of racism. Expand The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien.Missing: text | Show results with:text
[36]
JRR Tolkien and Race - Tolkienland - WordPress.com
Jul 29, 2016 · Scholars have countered charges of bigotry with a 1938 letter in which Tolkien rejected “the wholly pernicious and unscientific race-doctrine.” ...
[37]
Racism - Tolkien Gateway
Jan 17, 2025 · While the Easterlings and the Haradrim are dark-skinned people in the service of the Enemy, the Woses are primitive, small, and alien ...
[38]
It was Sam's first view of a battle of Men agai... - Goodreads
'It was Sam's first view of a battle of Men against Men, and he did not like it much. He was glad that he could not see the dead face. H...
[39]
[PDF] The Quest for Pity and Mercy in Tolkien's Middle Earth
Early on in The Fellowship of the Ring, in the second chapter of the book, Tolkien stresses this theme of pity and mercy in a conversation between Frodo and.
[40]
Visual Effects Demonstration The Mumakil Battle The Lord of the Rings
Aug 30, 2018 · Let's have a look on Visual Effects of Demonstration The Mumakil Battle The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.
[41]
Oliphaunts - Tolkien Gateway
Oliphaunts lived in Near or Far Harad, south of Mordor, where the Haradrim called them Mûmakil. Massive, often ferocious beasts, their legs were ...Missing: habitat | Show results with:habitat
[42]
Are the Oliphants in the The Lord of The Rings books as ... - Quora
Aug 18, 2021 · As for oliphaunts, they are just elephants, even if they are bigger versions of their “modern” relatives; 'oliphaunt' is merely derived from ...Where did the elephants come from in Lord of the Rings? - QuoraDo Oliphaunts belong to Tolkien, or are they free for use in a story?More results from www.quora.comMissing: Hannibal denial
[43]
Lord of the Rings: How Faithful Are Peter Jackson's Movies to the ...
Aug 23, 2022 · As The Rings of Power approaches, we take a look back at how The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit trilogies approached fidelity to Tolkien lore.
[44]
The Oliphaunt's CGI is IMPRESSIVE even to this day : r/lotr - Reddit
Mar 29, 2022 · The oliphaunts, on the other hand, appear in broad daylight, and even in 4K, I think they still look REALLY good. The shadows are well cast, and ...How the **** does Return of the King STILL look so good 25 years ...What are some real shots in the trilogy that people think are CGI?More results from www.reddit.comMissing: Pelennor Fields
[45]
Why didn't The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power just add an ...
Sep 2, 2022 · The problem with including Harad in The Rings of Power is that the Haradrim did not play a role in the main events of the Second Age, which ...In Middle Earth, what are the differences between the Haradrim and ...What happened to the lands of the Haradrim after the fall of Sauron?More results from www.quora.com
[46]
The real diversity in Tolkien, and how Rings of Power is a missed ...
Jul 27, 2023 · "Christopher Tolkien linked the Haradrim with ancient Aethiopians. In an interview from 1966, Tolkien likened Berúthiel to the giantess ...The influences for Tolkien to conceive of Harad and Rhûn - RedditBooks, and Stories about the Far East, and South? : r/tolkienfansMore results from www.reddit.comMissing: Cush | Show results with:Cush
[47]
The Haradrim in The Lord of the Rings Were Once Friends of Numenor
Nov 25, 2023 · The Haradrim were initially vassals and friends of Numenor, sharing culture and technology, and were excited to learn from them.
[48]
Haradrim Archers | The Wiki for Middle-Earth | Fandom
The Haradrim Archers are the elite ranged units for Mordor in The Battle for Middle-earth II. Haradrim, also called in Westron the Southrons, were the race ...Missing: game | Show results with:game
[49]
Battle for Middle-earth 2 I Age of the Ring : Haradrim Faction First Look
Dec 3, 2023 · ... video is your ticket to a thrilling journey through one of the game's most intriguing factions. Are you ready to join the fight? Watch ...
[50]
Haradrim Heroes - Battle for Middle Earth II Heaven Forum
May 21, 2007 · With Leadership also, this Haradrim can buff archers by standing next to them or infantry by fighting along side them.BFME 3: New Faction: Men of the East - Battle for Middle Earth II ...BFME 3/New Expansion - Battle for Middle Earth II Heaven ForumMore results from bfme2.heavengames.comMissing: video | Show results with:video
[51]
Greater Harad - Tolkien Gateway
Jul 27, 2025 · Greater Harad is a supplement (in the Campaign-series) for Middle-earth Role Playing, 1st Edition.
[52]
https://www.warhammer.com/en-US/shop/Haradrim-Warriors-2018
[53]
https://www.warhammer.com/en-US/shop/Haradrim-Raiders-2018
[54]
Kingdoms of Harad | The Lord of the Rings Online - LOTRO.com
The Lord of the Rings Online: Kingdoms of Harad expansion is scheduled to be released on December 3rd, 2025. In the event of delay, you will receive the ...
[55]
[PDF] The Earliest Days of Gondor
There were good reasons for this: going by later descriptions, Harad possessed gold and ivory for certain, and may have had gemstones, spices, exotic woods ...
[56]
Were All Easterlings and Haradrim in Middle-earth Evil People?
Nov 1, 2012 · In truth there are plenty of bad guys who live in the northwestern lands (including Orcs, men who turned ruffian, evil men from Angmar, etc.).
[57]
“It Was Sam's First View of a Battle of Men Against Men and He Did ...
Mar 9, 2024 · It was Sam's first view of a battle of Men against Men, and he did not like it much. He wondered what the man's name was and where he came from.
[58]
Fate and Free Will in Tolkien's Middle-earth
When reading The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, one finds several very explicit statements that Free Will applies to Ainur, Elves, Dwarves and Men, such as e.g. ...<|separator|>
[59]
Who were the Haradrim, Southrons, and Easterlings? - Cafe Society
Dec 11, 2003 · They're nations that have been deceived by Sauron. To them, Gondor and Rohan and their Elven allies are the bad guys, and Sauron is the good guy ...
[60]
[PDF] Racial Issues in Middle-Earth - DiVA portal
Jan 30, 2016 · The Dúnedain look down on the other tribes because of their less pure blood and they desperately try to keep their bloodline free from all other ...
[61]
[PDF] Does Tolkien's Middle-earth Promote a Racial Myth? by Eliza Farrell ...
Apr 17, 2009 · The simple answer is no; Tolkien's peoples are not meant to have any racial overtones nor are they divided by essentialized features. This does ...
[62]
[PDF] Othering and Diversity in J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings Trilogy
Jan 20, 2017 · Next, one can look at the way the general of Gondor (Western culture), Faramir, describes different ethnicities of Men: “And they made a truce ...
[63]
"Monsterized Saracens," Tolkien's Haradrim, and Other Medieval ...
Aug 7, 2025 · Curry writes: "Tolkien's evil creatures are frequently 'swart, slant-eyed' and tend to come from the south ('the cruel Haradrim') and east ('the ...Missing: etymology rebuttal
[64]
Scholarship on Racisms and "Tolkien" - by Robin - Writing from Ithilien
Mar 9, 2023 · Review of "Tolkien, Race, and Racism in Middle-earth (2022) by Robert Stuart," Journal of Tolkien Research, vol. 15, iss. 1, article 3. Firchow, ...
[65]
Sigelwara Land - Tolkien Gateway
Dec 24, 2024 · Sigelwara Land is the title of an essay by J.R.R. Tolkien, in which is examined the etymology of Sigelwaran (and the more usual form ...
[66]
https://thatparkplace.com/british-university-claims-tolkien-orcs-represent-people-of-color-and-lord-of-the-rings-is-racist/