Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Mate Boban


Mate Boban (12 February 1940 – 7 July 1997) was a Bosnian Croat political leader instrumental in founding and governing the Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia, a self-proclaimed entity established in November 1991 amid the violent dissolution of Yugoslavia. Serving as its first president until February 1994, Boban directed efforts to secure Croat-majority areas in western Herzegovina against Serb aggression, organizing the Croatian Defence Council (HVO) as an armed force that initially allied with Bosniak units before engaging in territorial disputes with them. Born in Sovići near in what was then the Kingdom of , Boban rose through the ranks of the Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia and Herzegovina (HDZ BiH), becoming its president in March 1992 after serving as . Under his , Herzeg-Bosnia's in coordinated military and political initiatives to establish control over regions with significant Croat populations, reflecting a strategy of partition aligned with Croatia's President to counter both Serb offensives and perceived threats from Bosniak authorities. Boban's tenure ended with the Washington Agreement in 1994, which dissolved Herzeg-Bosnia and integrated Croat forces into the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, though he remained influential among hardline nationalists. Subsequent investigations by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia identified him as a central figure in an alleged joint criminal enterprise involving the persecution and displacement of non-Croats, particularly Bosniaks, in areas under HVO control; however, he evaded formal indictment by dying of a cerebral hemorrhage in Mostar at age 57. For his contributions to Croatian defense efforts, he was posthumously awarded medals including the Homeland War Memorial Medal and the Commemorative Medal of the Homeland's Gratitude by Croatia.

Early life

Childhood and family background

Mate Boban was born on 12 February 1940 in the village of Sovići, situated in the Municipality of Grude in Herzegovina, then part of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia (now Bosnia and Herzegovina). Sovići, a rural settlement in the predominantly Croat-populated Herzegovina region, provided the backdrop for his early years amid an agricultural economy and ethnic homogeneity among local Catholics of Croat descent. He was the son of Stjepan Boban and Iva Boban, and grew up in a large family typical of rural Herzegovinian households during the interwar and postwar periods, which often featured extended kinship networks supporting subsistence farming. Little documented detail exists on specific childhood experiences or siblings, but the region's history—marked by World War II upheavals including Ustaše control and subsequent Yugoslav communist consolidation—shaped the environment of his formative years, fostering resilience in a community navigating ideological shifts under Tito's regime. By adolescence, Boban engaged with Yugoslav institutions, joining the League of Communists of Yugoslavia in 1958 at age 18, indicating early alignment with the socialist system prevalent in his upbringing.

Education and early professional career

Boban earned a degree in economics, with some accounts specifying it as postgraduate. In his early professional years, he worked in diverse roles within the Yugoslav economy, including as a traveling salesman for a clothing firm and as manager of a tobacco factory. He also served as general manager of a Yugoslav enterprise spanning multiple sectors. After a four-year stretch of unemployment, Boban took up a position as a professor of economics at the University of Split. These roles reflected the economic constraints and opportunities in socialist Yugoslavia, where professionals often shifted between state-managed industries and academia.

Entry into politics

Involvement in Croatian national movement

Boban's engagement with the Croatian national movement in Bosnia and Herzegovina began in the context of the Yugoslav federation's unraveling after Josip Broz Tito's death in 1980, which intensified ethnic assertions among Croats seeking greater autonomy from Serb-dominated central structures. As a Herzegovinan Croat, he aligned with emerging efforts to assert Croatian identity and interests separate from multi-ethnic Yugoslavism, particularly in regions like western Herzegovina where local Croat majorities resisted perceived marginalization. By 1990, amid the formation of nationalist parties across Yugoslavia, Boban joined the Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia and Herzegovina (HDZ BiH), a branch of Franjo Tuđman's HDZ in Croatia dedicated to safeguarding Bosnian Croat rights and opposing Serb expansionism. Within HDZ BiH, Boban quickly emerged as a figure in the party's more assertive faction, advocating for Croatian self-determination in Bosnia rather than integration into a unitary state. This stance contrasted with the initial moderate leadership under Stjepan Kljuić, who prioritized alliance with Bosniak parties for a sovereign Bosnia. Boban's group, emphasizing ties to Zagreb and territorial claims in Croat-inhabited areas, gained traction by late 1991 through internal party maneuvers, culminating in Kljuić's forced resignation and the consolidation of control by hard-line elements led by Boban and associates like Dario Kordić. This shift reflected broader Croatian nationalist goals of partitioning Bosnia along ethnic lines to enable potential union with Croatia, amid escalating violence from Bosnian Serb forces.

Leadership in HDZ BiH

Mate Boban rose to prominence within the Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia and Herzegovina (HDZ BiH), which was established in 1990 as the local branch of Croatia's Croatian Democratic Union amid the multi-party elections following the end of communist monopoly in Yugoslavia. Joining the party in its founding year, Boban was elected to the Bosnian parliament in the November 1990 general elections, representing Croat interests in the multi-ethnic legislature. By September 1991, as ethnic tensions escalated, Boban was appointed to the HDZ BiH Crisis Staff alongside party president Stjepan Kljuić and Dario Kordić, tasked with addressing the deteriorating security situation for Croats. Kljuić, favoring a civic Bosnian state with equal rights, clashed with hardliners influenced by Zagreb, leading to his resignation as HDZ BiH president in February 1992; Boban, representing the Herzegovinian faction more aligned with Croatian President Franjo Tuđman, assumed the presidency the following month. As president from early 1992 to 1994, Boban steered HDZ BiH toward policies prioritizing Croatian self-determination and autonomy, including coordination with Croatian authorities and rejection of a unitary Bosnian state perceived as dominated by Bosniak leadership. This shift consolidated power among Herzegovinian nationalists, enabling the party to mobilize Croat communities against Serb aggression while preparing parallel institutions, though it deepened divisions with Bosniak parties. Boban's tenure emphasized ethnic realism over multi-ethnic integration, reflecting causal pressures from Yugoslavia's dissolution and local power dynamics.

Founding of Herzeg-Bosnia

Establishment of the Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia

The Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia was established on 18 November 1991 in Mostar by representatives of the Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia and Herzegovina (HDZ BiH), amid the escalating dissolution of Yugoslavia and threats from Serb separatist forces. Mate Boban, a prominent HDZ BiH leader, was elected as its first president at the founding assembly, which included local Croat political figures responding to the failure of federal Yugoslav institutions to protect ethnic minorities. The entity's founding document described it as a "political, cultural, economic, and territorial whole of the Croatian people" in Bosnia and Herzegovina, encompassing approximately 26 municipalities with Croat majorities, primarily in Herzegovina and parts of central Bosnia, while nominally affirming loyalty to a sovereign Bosnia but prioritizing Croatian self-administration. This establishment followed a 12 November 1991 meeting in Ljubuški, chaired by Boban and Dario Kordić, where HDZ BiH leaders agreed to pursue autonomous Croatian structures to counter Serb advances and secure territorial continuity with Croatia proper, influenced by Zagreb's support under President Franjo Tuđman. The community created parallel institutions, including the Croatian Defence Council (HVO) as its armed force, formed earlier on 15 April 1991 but integrated into Herzeg-Bosnia's framework to organize defense against JNA and Bosnian Serb attacks. Initial governance focused on administrative autonomy, with Boban directing efforts to arm and finance the entity through Croatian channels, establishing a de facto proto-state amid Bosnia's 18 February 1991 sovereignty declaration and impending independence referendum. The move reflected causal pressures from ethnic partitioning trends in Yugoslavia, where Serb entities like the Republika Srpska were forming, prompting Croats to preempt marginalization in a Muslim-majority Bosnian state; however, it lacked international recognition and drew criticism for undermining Bosnia's unitary framework. By early 1992, the community controlled key areas like Mostar and Čitluk, with Boban issuing decrees to consolidate power, including the HVO's expansion to over 50,000 personnel by mid-1992 through Croatian military aid. This foundation laid groundwork for later escalation into the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, but prioritized immediate survival against Serb offensives that had already seized 70% of Bosnian territory by April 1992.

Declaration of the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia

On 28 August 1993, the Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia, established two years earlier, was proclaimed as the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia (Hrvatska Republika Herceg-Bosna) by its political leadership in response to escalating ethnic tensions and the perceived collapse of joint Croat-Bosniak defenses against Serb forces. Mate Boban, who had served as president of the community since its inception, retained the presidency of the newly declared republic, directing its administrative and military structures, including the Croatian Defence Council (HVO). The proclamation asserted sovereignty over approximately one-third of Bosnia and Herzegovina's territory, encompassing Croat-majority areas in western Herzegovina, central Bosnia, and parts of Posavina, with Grude designated as the temporary capital due to its strategic inland location. This upgrade from community to republic occurred amid the intensifying Croat-Bosniak War, which had erupted earlier in 1993 following breakdowns in the 1992-1993 alliance against Bosnian Serbs; Croat leaders cited Bosniak attacks on HVO positions and irredentist claims by Sarajevo authorities as justifications for formalizing separate governance to safeguard ethnic Croat populations from displacement and assimilation. The declaration aligned partially with the contemporary Owen-Stoltenberg peace proposals, which envisaged Bosnia and Herzegovina as a loose union of three constituent ethnic units—Serb, Croat, and Muslim—to end the war through territorial partition, though Herzeg-Bosnia's claims exceeded the plan's suggested boundaries and lacked endorsement from major powers. Boban emphasized in contemporaneous statements that the republic represented a defensive measure for self-preservation, not aggression, amid reports of over 100,000 Croat refugees fleeing Serb offensives and internal frictions. Internationally, the entity received no formal recognition, with the United Nations and European Community viewing it as a unilateral secession violating Bosnia's sovereignty, echoing the 1992 Constitutional Court ruling against the original community as unconstitutional. Domestically, it enabled consolidated Croat control over municipalities like Mostar, Čitluk, and Livno, implementing parallel institutions such as courts, currency (initially Croatian kuna), and taxation, funded partly through ties to Zagreb. The move drew condemnation from Bosniak leadership, who accused it of partitioning Bosnia, while Serb forces exploited the rift by advancing in contested areas; Boban coordinated with Croatian President Franjo Tuđman for military support, including arms and volunteers, to maintain viability. Despite its short-lived status—effectively dissolved by the 1994 Washington Agreement creating the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina—the declaration solidified Herzeg-Bosnia's de facto autonomy until 1994, prioritizing ethnic homogeneity and defense over multi-ethnic integration.

Role in the Bosnian War

Initial defense against Bosnian Serb forces

In the wake of Bosnia and Herzegovina's independence declaration on April 6, 1992, following its March 1 recognition of sovereignty, Bosnian Serb forces under the Yugoslav People's Army (JNA) and nascent Army of Republika Srpska (VRS) initiated widespread offensives to seize territory, targeting Croat-inhabited regions in Herzegovina and Posavina. Mate Boban, as president of the Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia (HZHB), responded by accelerating the organization of Croat defenses, viewing centralized Bosnian government structures as inadequate for protecting Croatian interests amid the Serb assault. On April 8, 1992, Boban and other HZHB leaders formally established the Croatian Defence Council (HVO) as the community's armed forces, initially comprising local Croat Territorial Defence units reorganized for combat readiness against Serb advances. Two days later, on April 10, Boban issued a decree declaring the Bosnian Territorial Defence (TO)—newly formed by the Bosnian government on April 9—illegal on HZHB territory, thereby subordinating Croat units to HVO command to ensure unified resistance without interference from Sarajevo's authority. This move enabled rapid mobilization, with HVO forces, supported by Croatian Army (HV) elements, halting Serb incursions in key areas such as the defense of Capljina and Stolac in mid-April, where they repelled JNA-VRS attacks aimed at linking Serb-held territories. By mid-May 1992, HVO structures were further consolidated under Boban's direct oversight as its president, with the issuance of organizational orders on May 15 formalizing its role as HZHB's executive, administrative, and defensive body. HVO units, numbering around 30,000 by summer and armed via Croatia, cooperated with Bosniak forces in joint operations, notably stopping a VRS offensive at Bosanski Brod on April 16 and contributing to the stabilization of fronts in central Bosnia, including Kiseljak and Vitez, where Serb pushes were contained through defensive engagements. These efforts prevented the overrunning of Croat enclaves, establishing a de facto frontline stalemate against Serb forces by late spring, though at the cost of significant casualties and displacement.

Governance and administration in Croat territories

The Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia (Hrvatska zajednica Herceg-Bosne), proclaimed on November 18, 1991, under Mate Boban's presidency, instituted administrative mechanisms to manage Croat-majority territories in southwestern Bosnia and Herzegovina, encompassing areas such as Mostar, Čitluk, and Grude, amid escalating conflict with Bosnian Serb forces. Boban, as president, exercised broad executive authority, including the appointment of officials to oversee finance and defense; on May 15, 1992, he designated Jadranko Prlić to lead the Croatian Defense Council (HVO) Department of Finance, reflecting the integration of military and civilian administration in war conditions. By August 14, 1992, Prlić assumed further roles in governmental coordination, underscoring Boban's central role in structuring parallel institutions independent of Sarajevo's authority. Administrative operations emphasized self-sufficiency, adopting the Croatian dinar as currency, designating Croatian as the official language, and implementing a school curriculum aligned with Zagreb's standards to preserve cultural identity in controlled municipalities. Local governance occurred through municipal assemblies and executive committees loyal to the HDZ BiH, with HVO units enforcing order and providing civil services like resource distribution in territories facing Serb blockades; government members were appointed directly by Boban, ensuring unified command over an estimated 20-30 municipalities by mid-1992. The HVO functioned as the primary executive and security apparatus, with Boban chairing presidency sessions to direct policy, including objections to external organizational interference. On August 28, 1993, the entity was elevated to the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, formalizing a tripartite structure of presidency, government, and HVO-led defense, with a parliament convening in Grude to legislate on internal affairs; this included a council of ministers under Prlić as prime minister from February 1994, though Boban's influence persisted until his resignation. Administration prioritized defense against Bosnian Serb advances, managing a force of approximately 50,000 HVO personnel while handling civilian logistics, such as food rations and infrastructure repair in war-damaged areas; however, ICTY records note instances of centralized control enabling resource extraction and population policies favoring ethnic Croats. These structures, financed and armed largely from Croatia, sustained governance until the 1994 Washington Agreement curtailed autonomy.

Escalation of Croat-Bosniak conflict

The alliance between Bosnian Croat forces of the Croatian Defence Council (HVO) and Bosniak units of the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina (ARBiH) against Bosnian Serb aggression deteriorated in late 1992 due to irreconcilable disputes over command structures, resource allocation, and control of territories liberated from Serb occupation. HVO leadership, headed by Mate Boban as president of the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, prioritized securing contiguous Croat-held areas linking to Croatia proper, refusing full integration into the Bosnian state's unitary military framework favored by Bosniak authorities. These frictions, compounded by Croatian President Franjo Tuđman's strategic aim of partitioning Bosnia to incorporate Croat regions into Croatia, set the stage for open conflict. Initial armed clashes erupted on 23 October 1992 in Gornji Vakuf (Uskoplje), where HVO forces attacked ARBiH positions, dividing the town into ethnic sectors and displacing civilians amid shelling and street fighting that killed dozens. This marked the first major inter-ethnic combat in central Bosnia, triggered by HVO efforts to dominate mixed areas previously defended jointly against Serbs. Escalation followed in Prozor, where HVO units launched an offensive on 23 October, capturing the town center by 2 November after intense urban combat; Bosniak forces and civilians numbering around 15,000 were expelled eastward, with reports of arson and summary executions fueling retaliatory ARBiH actions elsewhere. Boban, as HVO supreme commander, endorsed these operations to consolidate Croat administrative control. By January 1993, sporadic fighting had hardened into systematic HVO offensives across central Bosnia, including assaults on ARBiH garrisons in Novi Travnik and Zenica, where HVO units seized municipal buildings and imposed dual power structures. On 30 January, local HVO and ARBiH commanders met in Vitez under international mediation but failed to resolve integration demands, leading Boban to authorize heightened HVO mobilization. ARBiH counteroffensives, such as the 16 April killings of 22 Croats in Trusina by the El Mudžahid detachment, prompted HVO reprisals, including the Ahmići massacre on 16 April where over 100 Bosniak civilians died. These tit-for-tat atrocities, amid mutual ethnic cleansing, displaced tens of thousands and collapsed coordination against Serb advances. The conflict intensified in April 1993 when Boban declared a "state of imminent war" and the HVO issued ultimatums demanding ARBiH subordination or withdrawal from designated Croat provinces under the Vance-Owen peace plan, sparking coordinated attacks in Vitez, Busovača, and Kiseljak that expelled or killed thousands of Bosniaks. In Herzegovina, HVO forces initiated the siege of Mostar on 9 May, shelling the Bosniak-held west bank for nine months, destroying the 16th-century Stari Most bridge on 9 November, and confining 50,000 civilians to dire conditions with limited aid. Boban directed these campaigns from Grude, coordinating logistics and reinforcements from Croatia, as part of a policy to create ethnically homogeneous zones. On 6 May, he met Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadžić in Graz to reaffirm partition lines excluding Bosniak sovereignty, revealing strategic alignment against a unified Bosnia despite tactical Serb-Croat fighting. Under Boban's tenure, HVO actions resulted in the displacement of over 200,000 Bosniaks from Croat-controlled areas by mid-1993, though ARBiH offensives similarly targeted Croat villages, contributing to a death toll exceeding 10,000 in the Croat-Bosniak theater.

Resignation and immediate aftermath

Washington Agreement and political transition

The Washington Agreement, formally agreed upon on 1 March 1994 and signed on 18 March 1994 in Washington, D.C., established a ceasefire between the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, while creating a framework for the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina comprising Bosniak- and Croat-held territories. The accord divided the federation's territory into ten cantons with significant local autonomy, effectively ending active hostilities between Croat and Bosniak forces that had escalated since 1993 and integrating Croat-administered areas into a joint structure rather than maintaining Herzeg-Bosnia's de facto independence. In the lead-up to the agreement, Mate Boban, president of Herzeg-Bosnia since its declaration in 1993, faced mounting pressure from Croatian President Franjo Tuđman and international mediators to cede control to more compliant leadership; he resigned on 6 February 1994 in Livno, citing health reasons, and was immediately replaced by Krešimir Zubak, a moderate figure amenable to federation talks. Zubak represented the Croat side in negotiations alongside Croatian Foreign Minister Mate Granić, signing the agreement and overseeing Herzeg-Bosnia's dissolution as a distinct entity by August 1994. This transition subordinated Croat political ambitions in Bosnia to Zagreb's influence and Western diplomacy, guaranteeing Croats one seat in the federation's tripartite presidency and parity in the upper house of parliament, though it curtailed aspirations for full territorial autonomy. Boban's ouster marked the end of his direct governance role, transitioning him into political retirement amid criticism from hardline nationalists who viewed the federation as a concession diluting Croat self-determination; Tuđman publicly endorsed the shift to align with U.S.-brokered peace efforts, including subsequent Dayton talks. The agreement's implementation faced resistance in Croat areas, with informal networks loyal to Boban persisting, but it formalized the political realignment by embedding Croat institutions within the federation's cantonal system, reducing the viability of separatist structures.

Post-resignation activities

Following his resignation as president of the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia on February 8, 1994, Mate Boban relocated to Croatia. There, he was appointed to a director's position in the state-run INA oil company, reflecting continued influence within Croatian political and economic circles despite his diminished public role. He held this managerial post until shortly before his death, when he was replaced amid reports of declining health. During this period from 1994 to 1997, Boban maintained a low public profile, avoiding formal political engagement while residing in Croatia.

Later years

ICTY indictment and evasion of capture

Mate Boban was named in ICTY indictments, including the Prlić et al. case, as a co-perpetrator and leader in a joint criminal enterprise (JCE) involving crimes against humanity—such as persecution on political, racial, or religious grounds—and violations of the laws or customs of war, including unlawful attacks on civilians, destruction of protected cultural sites, plunder, and unlawful labor, primarily targeting Bosniaks in territories claimed by Herzeg-Bosnia from 1992 to 1994. The alleged JCE sought to ethnically cleanse and partition Bosnia and Herzegovina to incorporate Croat-claimed areas into Croatia, with Boban portrayed as directing HVO forces and political structures to implement these aims, including the establishment of detention camps and forced expulsions. No formal public indictment was confirmed against Boban personally before his death, likely due to the timing of ICTY investigations and his relocation. Following his resignation as president of Herzeg-Bosnia on 12 February 1994, Boban moved to Croatia, residing openly near Imotski without facing arrest or extradition. Croatian government under President Franjo Tuđman systematically resisted ICTY demands for surrendering ethnic Croat suspects, prioritizing national solidarity over tribunal cooperation until after Tuđman's death in 1999. This political protection enabled Boban's evasion of any investigative detention or transfer to The Hague. Boban died on 6 October 1997, precluding any prosecution; ICTY records note his passing without reference to prior custody efforts. His role in the JCE was adjudicated posthumously in trials like Prlić et al., where convictions of surviving co-accused reinforced the tribunal's findings on the enterprise's scope, though defenses contested the JCE's intent as defensive wartime measures rather than systematic ethnic removal.

Death and circumstances

Mate Boban died on July 7, 1997, at the age of 57 in a hospital in Mostar, Bosnia and Herzegovina, following a stroke. He had been living in seclusion in the Mostar area after resigning from political leadership roles in 1994 and amid growing international scrutiny over his wartime actions. At the time of his death, Boban faced an indictment from the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) for alleged crimes against humanity, though he had evaded arrest and remained at large. Official reports attributed his death solely to natural causes, with no evidence of foul play confirmed in contemporaneous accounts from Croatian or international observers. However, subsequent rumors circulated among some Bosnian Muslim communities and in media reports suggesting the death might have been staged to avoid prosecution, though these claims lacked substantiation and were dismissed by Croatian authorities. Boban's passing occurred shortly after the Dayton Agreement's implementation, during a period of fragile stabilization in the region, and it precluded any potential testimony or trial that might have clarified his role in Herzeg-Bosnia's governance. Flags were flown at half-mast in Croatian-controlled areas of Bosnia, reflecting his enduring status among Bosnian Croat nationalists despite international condemnation.

Legacy

Honors and public commemorations

Boban was posthumously awarded several decorations by the Republic of Croatia and entities associated with Croatian wartime efforts in Bosnia and Herzegovina, including the Order of Ante Starčević for contributions to Croatian statehood and the Homeland War Memorial Medal (Spomenica Domovinskog rata) on May 28, 1995. He also received the Order of Nikola Šubić Zrinski, the highest Croatian military honor, and the Commemorative Medal of the Homeland's Gratitude, though these are primarily acknowledged within Croatian nationalist and veteran circles rather than by broader Bosnian or international authorities. ![Mate-Boban-street01276.JPG][float-right] Public commemorations of Boban occur annually on July 7, the date of his death in 1997, organized by Croatian political and veteran groups in Bosnia and Herzegovina, particularly in Hercegovina. These events, held at locations such as Gorica near Grude—close to his birthplace in Sovići—typically include a memorial Mass (misa zadušnica) followed by speeches honoring his role in establishing Herzeg-Bosnia. For instance, the 28th anniversary in 2025 featured a Mass at the Church of St. Stephen the Protomartyr in Gorica at 7:00 p.m., succeeded by a commemorative program at 7:45 p.m. Similar observances marked the 26th anniversary in 2023 and 27th in 2024, emphasizing his leadership during the Croatian Defence Council (HVO) era. Streets and public spaces in Croat-majority municipalities of Bosnia and Herzegovina bear his name as tributes from local authorities, reflecting his status among Bosnian Croat communities. Examples include Ulica Mate Bobana in Grude and Čapljina, as well as Trg Hrvatskih Velikana—Trg Mate Bobana, a central roundabout in West Mostar renamed during or after the 1990s conflicts to symbolize Croatian wartime figures. These namings, part of broader ethno-national street renaming efforts in divided cities like Mostar, have persisted despite his ICTY indictment, underscoring localized veneration amid ongoing ethnic tensions.

Historical evaluations and ongoing debates

Historical evaluations of Mate Boban portray him as a pivotal figure in the establishment of the Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, with assessments varying sharply by perspective. Croatian nationalist interpretations often frame Boban as a resolute leader who safeguarded Croat populations amid Serb military offensives and the ensuing power vacuum in Bosnia and Herzegovina following Yugoslavia's dissolution in 1991–1992. His proclamation of Herzeg-Bosnia on November 18, 1991, is depicted in such accounts as a pragmatic response to existential threats, enabling Croat self-organization and resistance against the Yugoslav People's Army (JNA) advances that displaced thousands of Croats by mid-1992. These views emphasize Boban's coordination with Zagreb under President Franjo Tuđman to secure arms and logistics, positioning Herzeg-Bosnia as a provisional entity for survival rather than permanent secession. In contrast, Bosniak and many international analyses, informed by post-war tribunals and contemporaneous reporting, criticize Boban as an instigator of ethnic partitioning and violence, particularly during the Croat-Bosniak conflict from 1993 to 1994. Under his leadership, the Croatian Defence Council (HVO) forces pursued policies that resulted in the expulsion of Bosniak civilians from areas like Mostar and central Bosnia, actions linked to a joint criminal enterprise aimed at territorial consolidation. Western media outlets, such as The New York Times, described him as overseeing a "campaign to drive the Serbs and Muslims from the territory," highlighting the enclave's reliance on Croatian funding and military support for expansionist aims aligned with Tuđman's irredentist visions. Boban's involvement in secret partitions, including the 1991 Graz agreement delineating Croat-Serb spheres in Bosnia, underscores critiques of premeditated division over multi-ethnic coexistence. Ongoing debates revolve around Herzeg-Bosnia's legitimacy and Boban's intent, with regional historiography questioning whether his entity represented defensive autonomy or de facto ethnic dominance. Croatian scholars and politicians argue that Bosniak rejection of power-sharing proposals, such as the 1992 Cutileiro Plan, necessitated Croat separatism, while Bosniak narratives and International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) records portray it as aggressive irredentism, though Boban evaded formal indictment before his death in 1997 amid investigations into HVO atrocities. Critiques of ICTY proceedings, voiced in Croatian discourse, highlight perceived biases favoring Bosniak accounts, potentially inflating Croat culpability relative to documented Bosniak wartime expulsions of Croats. Parliamentary discussions in Bosnia and Herzegovina since the 2000s reflect this polarization, linking Boban's legacy to unresolved demands for Croat self-governance and accusations of wartime revisionism. Empirical analyses prioritize archival evidence of HVO-Bosniak clashes—over 10,000 casualties by 1994—over ideological framings, underscoring mutual escalations driven by territorial fears rather than unilateral aggression.

Controversies

War crimes allegations

Mate Boban, as President of the Croatian Community of Herceg-Bosna (established November 18, 1991) and later the Croatian Republic of Herceg-Bosna until February 1994, faced allegations of participating in a joint criminal enterprise (JCE) aimed at the political and military subjugation of Bosniaks, with the goal of permanently removing them from territories claimed for a Croat-dominated entity linked to a greater Croatia. The ICTY prosecution in the Prlić et al. case described Boban as a core JCE member alongside figures like Franjo Tuđman and Gojko Šušak, alleging he coordinated HVO forces and policies that facilitated systematic persecutions on political, racial, or religious grounds, including unlawful deportations, forced labor, wanton destruction of property, and destruction of cultural or religious sites. These claims centered on his establishment of the HVO as Herceg-Bosna's supreme executive, defense, and administrative body on April 8 and May 15, 1992, and his appointments, such as naming Jadranko Prlić to key financial and presidential roles, which enabled operations in municipalities like Mostar, Stolac, Prozor, Ljubuški, and Čapljina. Specific allegations tied to Boban's leadership included HVO attacks and ethnic cleansing campaigns against Bosniak civilians. In Prozor, from August to October 1992, HVO forces under Herceg-Bosna authority conducted assaults on October 23-24, destroying homes and beating detainees, as part of broader expulsions affecting tens of thousands. In Stolac, July 1993 operations involved forced removals of over 3,000 Bosniaks, destruction of mosques, and killings, such as those in Pjesivac Greda and Bivolje Brdo. Mostar saw a prolonged HVO siege from June 1993 to April 1994, with shelling, sniping, aid blockades, and detention of about 1,800 Bosniaks at Heliodrom camp, where inhumane conditions, beatings, and deaths occurred; around 800 were deported to Croatia in July 1993. Detention facilities like Dretelj and Gabela under HVO control were accused of torture, sexual assaults, and murders, including 37 deaths in Stupni Do. Boban died on July 8, 1997, before any formal ICTY against him could be issued or tried, though the Prlić et al. Chamber convicted six subordinates in May 2013 for crimes within the same JCE framework, referencing Boban's pivotal role in securing personnel and coordinating actions. Allegations also extended to central Bosnia influences, such as purported orders for 1993 Lašva Valley killings leading to Tihomir Blaškić's , though primarily linked to Herceg-Bosna's Herzegovina-focused operations. These claims, primarily from ICTY prosecutions and supported by reports on HVO abuses, emphasize for policies enabling ethnic homogenization, without direct evidence of Boban ordering individual atrocities.

Defenses and contextual interpretations

Supporters of Mate Boban, particularly among Bosnian Croat and Croatian political figures affiliated with the (HDZ), maintain that the establishment of the Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia (HZ HB) on 18 1991, which Boban helped proclaim, constituted a legitimate defensive response to the existential threats faced by following Yugoslavia's dissolution and the onset of Serb-led aggression in . They argue that with the (JNA) dominated by Serb elements advancing on Croat-populated areas, local Croat structures were essential for organizing self-defense, arming militias, and securing supply lines from proper, as the Sarajevo-based Bosnian government proved unable or unwilling to protect non-Bosniak minorities effectively. This perspective frames HZ HB not as a premeditated secessionist project but as a provisional entity mirroring the self-defense formations of Bosnian (Republika Srpska) and Bosniaks (, ARBiH), amid a multi-sided where all factions claimed territorial security imperatives. Contextual interpretations emphasize the initial Croat-Bosniak tactical alliance against Serb forces from April 1992, formalized in joint commands, which enabled shared resistance but eroded due to diverging strategic goals: Bosniaks sought a unitary state, while Croats prioritized ethnic cantons to safeguard against dominance. By mid-1993, as ARBiH offensives targeted HVO positions in central Bosnia—such as the Gornji Vakuf and Vitez areas—Boban issued ultimatums and mobilized defenses, which proponents describe as proportionate countermeasures to Bosniak encroachments rather than unprovoked ethnic cleansing. Boban publicly asserted in correspondence to international bodies that Croat actions countered a "Muslim offensive" threatening Croat survival, citing specific ARBiH attacks on Croat villages that displaced thousands and killed civilians. Croatian parliamentary declarations on the Homeland War extend this rationale to Bosnian Croats, portraying their 1992-1995 efforts as part of a "just and legitimate defensive liberation war" against aggression, with Herzeg-Bosnia's institutions enabling Croat contributions to Bosnia's overall independence from Serb control. Regarding war crimes allegations, Boban's defenders highlight his death on 7 July 1997—prior to any ICTY trial—as preventing adjudication, and critique the tribunal's joint criminal enterprise doctrine applied posthumously in cases like Prosecutor v. Prlić et al. (where associates were convicted in 2013 for crimes including persecutions in 1993-1994) as overreaching by imputing top-down intent without direct evidence of Boban's orders for systematic atrocities. They contend that localized HVO excesses, while regrettable, stemmed from command breakdowns in fluid frontline conditions rather than a centralized policy of expulsion, paralleling unprosecuted or lesser-scrutinized Bosniak and Serb violations, and note ICTY acquittals (e.g., elements in Kordić and Čerkez appeals) that undermined broader conspiracy claims. This view, echoed in Croatian analyses, attributes disproportionate focus on Croat culpability to evidentiary reliance on Bosniak-sourced testimonies, which empirical reviews suggest may inflate victim figures or omit mutual combatant-civilian intermingling. Empirical data from the war's demographics—Croats comprising 17% of pre-war Bosnia but controlling only fragmented enclaves by 1995—bolsters arguments that HVO operations prioritized territorial consolidation for bargaining leverage in peace talks, not irredentist absorption into Croatia, as evidenced by Boban's endorsement of the 1994 Washington Agreement linking Croat areas to a Bosniak-Croat federation.

References

  1. [1]
    Mate Boban, 57, Chief Builder Of Croatian Enclave in Bosnia
    Jul 8, 1997 · Mate Boban, the hard-line leader of the Bosnian Croats during their war with the Bosnian Muslims and a close ally of President Franjo Tudjman of Croatia, died ...<|separator|>
  2. [2]
    Prlic et al. Initial Indictment
    On 18 November 1991, the more extreme nationalist elements of the HDZ-BiH, led by Mate Boban and Dario Kordic, proclaimed the existence of the Croatian ...
  3. [3]
    CONTROVERSIAL CROAT NATIONALIST MATE BOBAN DIES AT 57
    Jul 7, 1997 · Mate Boban, 57, a leader of Bosnia's Croats throughout their year-long war with the Muslims, died July 7 at a hospital here after a stroke.
  4. [4]
    Kordic and Cerkez - Judgement - Part three: I, II and III
    Kljuic resigned as President of the HDZ-BiH in February 1992 and Mate Boban became President in the following month. (The Prosecution points to this as the ...<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    Mate Boban - Alchetron, The Free Social Encyclopedia
    Sep 28, 2024 · Boban was the 1st President of Herzeg-Bosnia from 1991 until 1994. From 1992 to 1994 he was the President of Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia ...
  6. [6]
    Six Senior Herceg-Bosna Officials Convicted
    May 29, 2013 · ... Mate Boban, President of the Croatian Community (later Republic) of Herceg-Bosna. Members of the JCE secured personnel and coordinated ...
  7. [7]
    Homeland War Memorial Medal - Wikipedia
    Notable recipients · Imra Agotic · Mate Boban · Radimir Čačić · Zvonimir Cervenko · Frane Vinko Golem · Josip Jovic · Ante Kotromanovic · Slobodan Lang ...
  8. [8]
    Mate Boban | Historica Wiki | Fandom
    Mate Boban (12 February 1940-7 July 1997) was President of Herzeg-Bosnia from 18 November 1991 to 8 February 1994, preceding Kresimir Zubak.
  9. [9]
    Mate Boban - IMDb
    Mate Boban was born on 12 February 1940 in Sovici, Kingdom of Yugoslavia [now Sovici, Bosnia and Herzegovina]. He died on 7 July 1997 in Mostar, Bosnia and ...
  10. [10]
    CROATIAN PUTS FAITH IN HIS OWN WAR – Chicago Tribune
    In this hilltop village, where men play bowls at night and debate politics at sidewalk cafes, Mate Boban ... economics professor he was before the fortunes of ...
  11. [11]
    Croats (Bosnia) - The Princeton Encyclopedia of Self-Determination
    Historical Evolution. The Croatian nationalist movement emerged in Bosnia in ... Mate Boban, a hard-line Herzegovin leader, replaced Kljuic as party ...
  12. [12]
    The Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina
    Between December 1991 and the referendum, the Boban faction of the HDZ-BiH assumed control of the organization by forcing Kljuic to resign as president of the ...
  13. [13]
    For the Love of Homeland (Chapter 7) - Ethnic Minorities and ...
    ... Bosnia-Herzegovina, with Mate Boban elected president. In disagreement, Kljuić resigned as HDZ BiH president in February 1992. The referendum on Bosnian ...
  14. [14]
    [PDF] Armed Peacekeepers in Bosnia - Army University Press
    Mate Boban, the head of the Croatian Democratic Alliance (HDZ), supported Izetbegovic on the issue of sovereignty and independence. A vast majority of ...
  15. [15]
    2020 Bosnia and Herzegovina- Croatia: Relations in the shadow of ...
    Dec 16, 2020 · Dragan Čović (HDZBiH) will be in the focus of the new US administration. It is believed that he could share the faith of Mate Boban (HDZBiH) ...
  16. [16]
    Polarization and Poison | Bosnia Remade - Oxford Academic
    Oct 13, 1990 · ... Kljuić and appoint Boban as HDZ leader in Bosnia in February 1992). With SDS schemas for the ethnoterritorialization of Bosnia proceeding ...
  17. [17]
    Bosnian Croat Veterans' March Alarms Bosniak War Victims
    Jun 7, 2019 · The Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia was founded on November 18, 1991, as a political and territorial entity on the territory of Bosnia ...
  18. [18]
    (PDF) ON THE WAR AIMS IN THE 1991-1992 YUGOSLAV CONFLICT
    ”35 The Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia was established in Mo- star on November 18 1991, as a political, economic, and territorial entity. The seat of ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] download - HercegBosna.org
    in those circumstances, the Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia, a community of areas with Croatian majorities, was formed on 8 April. 1992. The HVO was ...
  20. [20]
    Sharing the Spoils: When Milosevic and Tudjman Met to Carve Up ...
    Sep 12, 2022 · ... Croatian Community of Herzeg-Bosnia entity, with Mate Boban as president. During a conversation between Tudjman and his associates and one ...
  21. [21]
    Karađorđevo and the territorial-ethnic division of Bosnia and ...
    Mar 25, 2019 · Tuđman, on the other hand, promoted the radical nationalist wing under Mate Boban, who acted as the President of the Croatian Community of ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] bosnia and herzegovina as a
    Sep 20, 2024 · The Croatian Republic Herzeg-Bosnia (Hrvatska Republika Herceg-Bosna) was also proclaimed (on August 28, 1993) in line with the existing accom-.
  23. [23]
    Bosnia and Herzegovina - Bosna a Hercegovina - Armedconflicts.com
    Apr 17, 2009 · The split occurs on August 28, 1993, when the Croats declare the Croatian Republic of Herceg-Bosna (Hrvatska Republika Herceg-Bosna) On the ...
  24. [24]
    [DOC] MSC5441R0000330636.doc
    31 Letter to Mate BOBAN ... Bosnia and Herzegovina as a state entity of the three equal peoples. We welcomed the proclamation of the Croatian Republic of Herceg ...
  25. [25]
    B. The municipality of Vitez
    Mate Boban issued an ultimatum requiring the troops of the Bosnian army on the territories of provinces 8 and 10 under the Vance-Owen Plan, to surrender their ...
  26. [26]
    Policy Of The Republic Of Croatia Towards Bosnia And Herzegovina ...
    Apr 18, 2024 · The attack on Bosanski Brod was stopped by HVO and HV on April 16. In the fighting in May, Croatian forces took advantage of the chaos in the ...
  27. [27]
    [PDF] narodni list hz herceg-bosna
    CROATIAN COMMUNITY. OF HERCEG-BOSNA. CROATIAN DEFENCE COUNCIL. No.: Mostar, 15 May 1992. PRESIDENT OF THE HVO AND HZ H-B. Mate BOBAN M.A. issuel.doc. 88. 2D71- ...
  28. [28]
    Croats Claim Their Own Slice of Bosnia - The New York Times
    Jul 6, 1992 · Mr. Boban emerged as the leader of a 30,000-man army of Croats and Muslims called the Croatian Defense Council, armed and trained by Croatia.
  29. [29]
    [PDF] Prof. Dr. Srebren Dizdar University of Sarajevo Situation Analysis of ...
    In the areas controlled by HVO (“Herzeg-Bosnia”), the curriculum was taken from Croatia, with the emphasis on Croatian as the only official label for the ...<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    000518ed - International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia
    12 Were members of the government appointed by. 13 the decision of the president of the Croatian Community. 14 of Herceg-Bosna, Mate Boban, including Croats and.Missing: Herzeg- | Show results with:Herzeg-
  31. [31]
    [PDF] BOSNIA, HELD ON 17TH OCTOBER AT - Unified Court Records
    President of HZ H-B Mr. Mate Boban greeted all present and he proposed that presidency should continue with its work. He gave objection on organization and.
  32. [32]
    Herceg-Bosna, bloody separatist bid of Bosnian Croats - Justice Info
    Nov 27, 2017 · In May 1992, Bosnian Serb nationalist leader Radovan Karadzic and his Croat counterpart Mate Boban reached a deal that looked much like a ...Missing: Herzeg- | Show results with:Herzeg-<|control11|><|separator|>
  33. [33]
    080204IT - International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia
    18 Croatian Community of Herceg-Bosna Mate Boban, Bruno Stojic, and a host of. 19 other senior HVO officials. 20 Making reference to the proposed joint ...
  34. [34]
    (PDF) THE CROAT-BOSNIAK WAR: THE SELECT FINDINGS OF ...
    Oct 13, 2025 · ... Mate Boban fought for the dominance of one ethnic group. in a given territory in what would be a de jure or de facto divided Bosnian state.
  35. [35]
    [PDF] The Croat-Bosniak war - Časopis „Istorija 20. veka“
    ABSTRACT: The Croat-Bosniak war is one of the least researched ep- isodes of the Bosnian war. I reviewed the recent works of two regional authors.
  36. [36]
    War Crimes > GORNJI VAKUF / USKOPLJE - HERCEG BOSNA
    The first fierce conflict between B-H Army and HVO occurred on October 23rd 1992 ... The town of Gornji Vakuf was divided on the Croatian and Moslem sections.
  37. [37]
    [PDF] The Muslim-Croat Civil War in Central Bosnia
    On January 30, 1993, ABiH and HVO leaders met in Vitez under the aegis of ... HVO/HOS buildings in Zenica taken over by ABiH; Boban and Izetbegovic.
  38. [38]
    [PDF] Washington Agreement - United States Institute of Peace
    Mar 1, 1994 · The undersigned have agreed on the attached Framework Agreement establishing a Federation in the areas of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina ...
  39. [39]
    The Washington Agreement - Spirit of Bosnia
    (Granić's delegation from “Herceg Bosna” consists of only Akmadžić and Zubak, who has already taken the place of Mate Boban.) The conversation was cursory.
  40. [40]
    The Bosnian War | World History - Lumen Learning
    The Bosnian War was an international armed conflict that took place in Bosnia and Herzegovina between 1992 and 1995.<|separator|>
  41. [41]
    February '94. The breakthrough - BarBalkans
    Feb 13, 2024 · On February 8 in Livno, President Mate Boban is forced to resign and is replaced by the moderate Krešimir Zubak. What happens in Mostar ...
  42. [42]
    Changing Course?: Implications of the Divide in Bosnian Croat Politics
    Aug 13, 1998 · ... Mate Boban, a Herzegovinian, took control of the HDZBiH. This was facilitated by the fact that Herzegovinian émigrés, notable among them ...
  43. [43]
    Kordic and Cerkez - Part four: I, II, III, IV and V, and Annexes
    He occupied an important position in the leadership of the HZ H-B, but was not in the top echelon, being answerable to Mate Boban. ... President of HDZ-BiH.
  44. [44]
    Milestones Jul. 21, 1997 - TIME
    DIED. MATE BOBAN, 57, chauvinistic Bosnian Croat leader who spearheaded the creation of the short-lived Croatian statelet of Herzeg-Bosna; of a stroke; in ...
  45. [45]
    EUROPE | Bosnia war: Main players - BBC News
    Oct 14, 2000 · Mr Boban died of a stroke in 1997 - although subsequent rumours claimed that his death had been faked to avoid his prosecution for war crimes.
  46. [46]
    Key figures in the Bosnian war 1992-1995 | SBS News
    Apr 4, 2012 · Mate Boban, 1940-1997: Bosnian Croat wartime leader and president of ... He died of a stroke in 1997. Franjo Tudjman, 1922-1999: A ...<|separator|>
  47. [47]
    Flags at half-mast — AIMPRESS
    Mr. Mate Boban died in Mostar. Livno, 07 July, 1997 (AIM) - Regarding the death of Mr. Mate Boban, Ex President HDZ B&H, in the part of B&H Federation, ...Missing: suicide | Show results with:suicide
  48. [48]
    Kako i kome je susjedna država zahvalila: Hrvatska je odlikovala ...
    Jan 17, 2021 · Među poznatijim pojedincima koji su dobili odlikovanje „Red Ante Starčevića“ su i predsjednik tzv. Herceg-Bosne Mate Boban, Tuđmanov ministar ...
  49. [49]
    Marina Vukoja “In memoriam mr. Mate Boban” - HB.hteam.org
    Jul 7, 2025 · Odlikovan je i mnogim priznanjima kao što su: Red Nikole Šubića Zrinskog, Red Ante Starčevića, Spomenica Domovinskog rata, Spomenica ...
  50. [50]
    Komemoracija u povodu 28. obljetnice smrti Mate Bobana
    Jul 7, 2025 · U ponedjeljak, 7. srpnja 2025. godine, u Gorici kod Gruda održat će se komemoracija povodom 28. obljetnice smrti predsjednika Hrvatske ...Missing: commemorations | Show results with:commemorations
  51. [51]
    https://rtv-hb.com/bosna-i-hercegovina/obiljezena-26-godisnjica-smrti-mate-bobana
  52. [52]
    Obilježena 26. godišnjica smrti Mate Bobana - RTV HB
    Jul 7, 2023 · Mate Boban je rođen u Sovićima kod Gruda 12. veljače 1940. godine. Preminuo je u Mostaru 7. srpnja 1997. godine.Missing: commemorations | Show results with:commemorations
  53. [53]
    [PDF] Nationalizing the streetscape. The case of street renaming in Mostar ...
    A similar example is Trg Rondo, a central roundabout and square in West Mostar that was renamed Trg Hrvatskih Velikana-Trg Mate Bobana (Croat Nobles Square- ...
  54. [54]
    The Role of Croatia in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Antemurale ...
    Apr 29, 2019 · With the sole exception of the president of HDZ BiH Mate Boban (who died in 1997), the entire political and military leadership of HDZ was tried ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  55. [55]
    Don't oversimplify the Bosnian war | Ivo Petkovski - The Guardian
    May 10, 2010 · Ivo Petkovski: Radovan Karadzic should pay the price for any crimes he committed. But let's not reduce the conflict to goodies v baddies.
  56. [56]
    The Abyss of Ethnic Division: Two Decades of Discussing War in the ...
    Sep 20, 2022 · The article analyses over two decades of parliamentary debates in Bosnia–Herzegovina in order to understand the role of war past in the political ...
  57. [57]
    [PDF] THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL TRIBUNAL FOR THE FORMER ...
    Jun 11, 2008 · (h) BERISLAV PUSIC approved the use of prisoners for unlawful labour. He failed to intervene to stop or denounce the illegal practice of forced.
  58. [58]
    [PDF] IT-04-74-T - Unified Court Records
    May 29, 2013 · Army of the Republic of Croatia; [and] Mate Boban (deceased, 8 July 1997), President of the Croatian. Community (and Republic) of Herceg-Bosna”.
  59. [59]
    [PDF] War Crimes in BosniaBHercegovina - Human Rights Watch
    Meanwhile, "ethnic cleansing" C which includes abuses such as deportations, confinement of civilians in detention camps, torture, rape, murder and ...
  60. [60]
    [PDF] The War in Bosnia, 1992-1995: Analyzing Military Asymmetries and ...
    In response, in early July 1992, Mate Boban, the leader of the Bosnian ... Bosnia's legitimate right to self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter.
  61. [61]
    Shells shatter prayers in Bosnia - Tampa Bay Times
    Mate Boban, leader of Bosnian Croats, sent letters to the United Nations and European Union urging them to stop what he called a Muslim offensive against Croats ...
  62. [62]
    [PDF] Yugoslavia's Wars: The Problem from Hell - USAWC Press
    Oct 1, 1995 · The suggestion of a referendum as a means to establish legitimacy in Bosnia Herzegovina was based on a widely- accepted principle of ...
  63. [63]
    Croatian Views of the Wars of the Yugoslav Succession - jstor
    Boban, Lj. (1992) 'Still More Balance on Jasenovac and the Manipulation of History', East European. Politics and Societies, 6, 2.
  64. [64]
    [PDF] Unequal democracy: The political position of Croats in Bosnia and ...
    Apr 29, 2015 · Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, never officially declared separation or secession from Bosnia and Herzegovina. ... Federal government, and the ...