Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Quirinius

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius (c. 51 BC – AD 21) was a Roman senator, military commander, and imperial administrator renowned for his conquest of the Homonadensian tribes in Cilicia and his governance of Syria, where he implemented a provincial census in AD 6 that incorporated Judea as a Roman client territory following the deposition of Herod Archelaus.^[1]^[2] Born into a wealthy equestrian family near Lanuvium, Quirinius advanced through the senatorial cursus honorum, serving as consul in 12 BC alongside Marcus Vipsanius Agrippa and later as proconsul of Crete and Cyrenaica around 15–11 BC, where he campaigned against the Garamantes.^[1]^[2] His most celebrated military achievement came during his legateship in Galatia (c. 5–3 BC), when he subdued the rebellious Homonadenses—a fortified Pisidian people—in a grueling campaign that involved constructing roads through rugged terrain and earned him triumphal honors from Augustus.^[1]^[2] Appointed legate of Syria in AD 6 amid regional instability, Quirinius supervised the taxation census across the province, including the newly annexed Judea, an administrative measure confirmed by inscriptions such as the tombstone of his subordinate Quintus Aemilius Secundus.^[2]^[3] This assessment, aimed at standardizing Roman revenue collection, ignited widespread Jewish opposition and contributed to the revolt led by Judas of Galilee, fostering the emergence of the Zealot movement.^[3] Quirinius's tenure is also referenced in the Gospel of Luke (2:1–2), which associates a census under his authority with the birth of Jesus during Herod the Great's reign; however, extrabiblical evidence, including Josephus and Roman records, dates his Syrian governorship and the census to AD 6–9, postdating Herod's death in 4 BC by a decade, presenting a noted chronological tension in historical reconstruction.^[1]^[3] He died in AD 21, receiving a public funeral in Rome as a figure of "great dignity," though childless and amid personal scandals, including a contentious divorce.^[1]^[2]

Early Life and Career

Origins and Entry into Roman Service

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius was born circa 51 BC in Lanuvium, a Latin municipality located approximately 30 kilometers southeast of Rome in the Alban Hills region of Italy.^[2] His family belonged to the equestrian order, possessing considerable wealth from landholdings but lacking any prior senatorial or consular ancestors, distinguishing him as a novus homo without ties to the patrician branch of the Sulpicii gens.^[1]^[2] Quirinius entered Roman public service through the conventional cursus honorum for equestrians of ambition, beginning military duties around age 18 as per standard practice for his class.^[1] He progressed via junior offices such as military tribune and quaestor, which facilitated his elevation to the senate in his late twenties, enabling access to higher magistracies.^[1] His initial prominence came in 15 BC, when Augustus appointed the approximately 36-year-old Quirinius as proconsul of Crete and Cyrenaica, a consular province in North Africa. There, he led effective military operations against the nomadic Garamantes tribe, securing Roman frontiers and demonstrating administrative competence that aligned with imperial priorities for provincial stability.^[1] This role marked his transition from preparatory offices to imperial favor and governance, setting the stage for further advancement under the principate.^[1]

Initial Administrative and Military Roles

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius, originating from a wealthy equestrian family without prior senatorial distinction, entered the senatorial order as a novus homo and pursued the traditional cursus honorum. The initial stages of his career, prior to documented provincial commands, included the requisite offices of quaestor and praetor, though specific dates, locations, or assignments for these positions remain unattested in primary sources such as Tacitus or Cassius Dio.^[1] His first recorded administrative appointment came circa 15 BCE as proconsul of Crete and Cyrenaica, a consular province requiring prior praetorian experience. In this role, Quirinius oversaw civil governance while directing military operations against the nomadic Garamantes tribe in the Libyan desert region of Cyrenaica, demonstrating early competence in both spheres.^[1] These achievements facilitated his rapid elevation to suffect consul in 12 BCE, shared with Gaius Valgius Rufus, marking a key milestone in his ascent under Augustus. Tacitus notes Quirinius's consular tenure as a foundation for subsequent legateships, underscoring the interconnected nature of administrative and military duties in imperial Rome.^[1]^[4]

Military Achievements

Campaigns in Cilicia and Galatia

Quirinius, following his consulship in 12 BC, commanded Roman forces in a prolonged campaign against the Homonades (also known as Homonadenses), a warlike tribe inhabiting fortified strongholds in the Taurus Mountains along the borders of Cilicia Tracheia and Pisidia. These tribesmen had assassinated King Amyntas of Galatia in 25 BC while he attempted to subdue them, thereafter maintaining independence through guerrilla tactics and raids on lowland settlements in Roman-administered territories. Operating primarily from the province of Galatia, where he served as legate around 5–3 BC, Quirinius coordinated operations that extended into Cilicia, leveraging the interconnected provincial administrations to encircle Homonades positions.^[1]^[2] The campaign emphasized attrition over direct assault, with Quirinius besieging the tribe's approximately 44 hilltop fortresses while severing access to food supplies and water sources, forcing surrender through starvation. This approach addressed the Homonades' defensive advantages in rugged terrain, where earlier efforts by Amyntas and subsequent Roman commanders had faltered. The war spanned roughly from 12 BC to 1 BC, reflecting the difficulty of pacifying dispersed mountain redoubts without overwhelming manpower commitments. Tacitus records that Quirinius ultimately stormed and captured these strongholds, compelling the Homonades to submit.^[5]^[6] Victory resulted in the tribe's subjugation, with thousands reportedly killed or enslaved and survivors resettled in lowland areas under Roman oversight, thereby securing trade routes and agricultural lands in Cilicia and Galatia. This success demonstrated Quirinius' strategic acumen in imperial frontier warfare, earning imperial commendation from Augustus and bolstering his career trajectory toward higher commands. No major engagements in Galatia proper are attested beyond logistical support for the Homonades operations, though the province's governance under Quirinius facilitated the broader pacification efforts.^[5]^[7]

Suppression of the Homonades

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius, as imperial legate of Galatia-Cilicia following his consulship in 12 BC, conducted a prolonged military campaign against the Homonadenses, a warlike tribe of Cisrhenian mountaineers dwelling in fortified villages across the Taurus Mountains in Pisidia.^[2] The Homonadenses, estimated to number around 30,000 individuals capable of bearing arms, had previously assassinated Amyntas, the Galatian king whose realm Augustus annexed in 25 BC, and persisted in raiding lowland settlements while resisting Roman control from over sixty strongholds.^[8] Quirinius' operations, spanning roughly 12 BC to 1 BC, emphasized strategic encirclement over direct assaults, involving the construction of at least twenty-three fortresses and fortified roads to seal mountain passes and isolate rebel positions.^[9] The campaign demanded meticulous logistics and engineering, as the tribe's terrain—steep gorges and defensible caves—favored guerrilla tactics, prolonging the conflict for nearly a decade. Roman forces under Quirinius systematically reduced Homonadensian resistance through blockades, which induced surrenders by starvation and demoralization, culminating in the capture or slaughter of thousands; Strabo notes that the survivors were resettled in the lowlands to prevent resurgence.^[8] This pacification integrated the region more firmly into Roman administration, facilitating trade routes and taxation. For his success, Augustus granted Quirinius the rare honor of an ovation in Rome, later eulogized by Tiberius in the Senate as a triumph over the Homonenses, underscoring Quirinius' reputation as an indefatigable commander.^[10]

Governorship and Administrative Roles

Tenure as Governor of Syria

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius was appointed as legate of Syria by Emperor Augustus in AD 6, immediately following the deposition and exile of Herod Archelaus, which resulted in Judaea's annexation as a Roman province subordinated to Syrian administration.^[1] His tenure, lasting until approximately AD 9, focused on consolidating Roman control through fiscal and administrative measures amid regional tensions.^[6] Quirinius restructured taxation in Judaea, shifting from in-kind payments under Herodian rule to direct monetary assessments, necessitating property valuations and enrollment of inhabitants.^[1] This reform, implemented with the assistance of the high priest Joazar, aimed to standardize revenue collection but encountered opposition due to cultural sensitivities over Roman coinage depicting imperial or divine imagery.^[1] Although initial disturbances arose, including a rebellion led by Judas the Galilean against the census process, Quirinius maintained order without escalating to widespread revolt, as evidenced by Tacitus' account of his effective governance.^[1] He collaborated with local Jewish authorities to quell resistance and oversaw the installation of a Roman prefect in Judaea, ensuring provincial stability until his replacement around AD 9.^[6]

The Census of Judaea

In 6 CE, following the removal of Herod Archelaus from rule over Judaea by Emperor Augustus, the region was annexed as a Roman province under direct imperial administration. Publius Sulpicius Quirinius, appointed as legate of Syria, was tasked with conducting a comprehensive census to assess property and population for taxation purposes. This marked a transition from the indirect tribute system under Herodian client kings to direct Roman provincial taxation, enforced through registration of assets and individuals. Quirinius undertook this role alongside Coponius, the first Roman prefect of Judaea, who arrived in the region to oversee local governance. The census involved systematic enrollment, requiring inhabitants to declare their property holdings, which would form the basis for tributum soli (land tax) and tributum capitis (poll tax). Roman practice typically demanded such registrations every 14 years in provinces, but this one was expedited due to the administrative overhaul after Archelaus's deposition. Quirinius, leveraging his prior experience in fiscal matters from campaigns in Galatia, directed the process with military support to ensure compliance, though it extended into 7 CE amid resistance. Josephus records that Quirinius aimed to liquidate Archelaus's estate and redistribute properties, further integrating Judaea into the imperial fiscal system.^[7] The imposition of direct taxation provoked widespread unrest, viewed by many Jews as an infringement on autonomy and a form of enslavement, contravening traditions of tribute exemption under the Temple. This sparked a revolt led by Judas of Galilee (also called Judas the Gaulonite) and the Pharisee Zadok (or Saddok), who rallied followers against Roman oversight, framing the census as the catalyst for zealot resistance. Josephus describes Judas as founding a "fourth philosophy" emphasizing liberty over submission to earthly rulers, distinct from Pharisees, Sadducees, and Essenes. The uprising was quelled by Roman forces under Quirinius and Coponius, but not without casualties and the execution of key insurgents' descendants later. Acts 5:37 corroborates the event, noting Judas's leadership during the enrollment as drawing followers who were later scattered. This census is thus seen as igniting the Zealot faction's ideology, contributing to escalating tensions culminating in the First Jewish-Roman War.

Personal Life and Later Honors

Marriages and Political Alliances

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius's first marriage was to Appia Claudia, a woman from a respectable but otherwise obscure patrician lineage, though little is known of the union beyond its eventual dissolution through divorce.^[2]^[1] This early alliance provided modest social elevation for Quirinius, who originated from a non-senatorial equestrian background, aiding his initial ascent in Roman administrative roles during the late Republic and early Empire.^[1] His second marriage, contracted around 3 CE to Aemilia Lepida, daughter of Quintus Aemilius Lepidus and granddaughter of the triumvir Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, forged a far more significant political connection to Rome's republican nobility.^[1]^[2] Aemilia's lineage traced back to Sulla through her grandmother Cornelia, and to Pompey via her descent, linking Quirinius to influential gentes that retained prestige despite the dominance of the Julio-Claudians.^[11] This union, arranged after Quirinius's military successes had amassed him considerable wealth, bolstered his standing among the senatorial elite and facilitated his appointment as consul suffectus in 12 CE, as well as his legateship in Syria.^[1] The marriage to Aemilia Lepida deteriorated, culminating in divorce and a high-profile trial in 20 CE, where Quirinius accused her of adultery with a slave, consulting sorcerers, and attempting to poison him—charges that the Senate upheld, resulting in her exile and property confiscation.^[11]^[12] Despite the scandal, Quirinius's prior cultivation of ties with Tiberius, including deference during the princeps's exile on Rhodes, preserved his favor with the imperial court, underscoring how his matrimonial strategies intertwined personal alliances with broader Julio-Claudian patronage networks.^[11] No children are recorded from either marriage, limiting direct familial legacies but not impeding his career trajectory.^[2]

Consulships and Final Years

Publius Sulpicius Quirinius held the consulship in 12 BC, a pinnacle of his early senatorial career as a novus homo risen from equestrian origins.^[1] In his final years, following the conclusion of his governorship in Syria around AD 9, Quirinius returned to private life in Rome but remained entangled in personal and legal disputes. In AD 20, he divorced his second wife, Aemilia Lepida—daughter of Manius Aemilius Lepidus and related to Emperor Augustus—after she gave birth to a child during a period of separation; Quirinius accused her of adultery and unchastity, leading to a highly publicized trial where she was convicted and exiled, though the infant's paternity claim was a point of contention.^[1]^[5] Quirinius died in AD 21 at approximately 72 years of age, without issue from either of his marriages.^[1] Emperor Tiberius addressed the Senate to request a public funeral, eulogizing Quirinius's consular tenure under Augustus, his capture of Homonadensian strongholds earning triumphal ornaments, his advisory role to Gaius Caesar during the Armenian campaigns, and his loyalty to Tiberius while the latter was in voluntary exile on Rhodes.^[5] The Senate approved the honors, but Tacitus records that the Roman public evinced little regard for Quirinius's memory, attributing this to resentment over his ruthless prosecution in the Lepida affair and the perception of petty cruelty combined with overweening authority in his declining years.^[5]

Archaeological and Epigraphic Evidence

Key Inscriptions Attesting to Quirinius

The Lapis Tiburtinus, a fragmentary Latin inscription discovered in 1764 near Tivoli (ancient Tibur) and preserved in the Vatican Museums, provides the most detailed epigraphic record of a Roman official's career plausibly identified with Quirinius. The text, partially reconstructed, describes a sequence of offices including legatus Augusti iterum in Syria ("legate of Augustus a second time in Syria"), followed by a consulship and further provincial commands, suggesting dual tenures in Syria that align with Quirinius' documented roles circa 6–9 CE and a possible earlier posting.^[13] Although the inscription lacks a name and head, its chronological fit with Quirinius' consulship in 12 CE and Syrian legateship has led most scholars to attribute it to him, despite debates over the exact order of offices due to lacunae.^[14] Another key attestation appears in a Roman inscription honoring Quintus Aemilius Secundus, a military surveyor who records receiving decorations in castris divi Augusti sub Publio Sulpicio Quirinio legato Syriae ("in the camp of the divine Augustus under Publius Sulpicius Quirinius, legate of Syria"). Found on the Palatine Hill and dated to the Augustan period, this explicitly confirms Quirinius' command in Syria, likely during the 6–9 CE governorship associated with provincial censuses and administrative reforms.^[2] Epigraphic evidence from Asia Minor further corroborates Quirinius' military exploits, including dedications linked to his suppression of the Homonadensians in Cilicia and Galatia circa 12–1 BCE; for instance, inscriptions from Pisidian sites reference a legate's victories that match Tacitus' account of Quirinius' triumph over these tribes, awarded in 20 CE.^[15] These artifacts, while not naming Quirinius directly in all cases, align with his reconstructed itinerary from literary sources and underscore his role in extending Roman hegemony, though survival of personal inscriptions remains sparse compared to more prominent contemporaries.

Interpretations of Material Findings

The fragmentary Lapis Tiburtinus, discovered near Tivoli in 1764 and housed in the Vatican Museums, records a Roman official's career including service as proconsul of Asia and legatus divi Augusti iterum in provincia Syria ("legate of the divine Augustus a second time in the province of Syria").^[13] Scholars attribute this inscription to Quirinius based on matches with his documented offices, such as his proconsulship in Asia around 11–8 BC and known legateship in Syria from AD 6–9, interpreting iterum as evidence of an earlier Syrian command, possibly 3–1 BC or 10–7 BC, during which he may have held special fiscal or military authority without full provincial governorship. Critics counter that the inscription lacks Quirinius' name due to its damaged state, and iterum could modify a preceding phrase rather than the Syrian legateship, potentially referring to another official like Lucius Calpurnius Piso; this view holds that literary sources, including Josephus and Tacitus, confirm only one Syrian governorship under Quirinius, with predecessors like Saturninus (9–6 BC) and Varus (6–4 BC) attested without overlap.^[14] The Lapis Venetus, a tombstone of the military officer Quintus Aemilius Secundus found in Beirut, details his service under Quirinius as legato Augusti Caesaris Syriae, including conducting a census of 117,000 citizens in Apamea and operations against Iturean fortresses north of Galilee. Epigraphers date this activity to circa 10–7 BC, prior to Quirinius' confirmed AD 6 census in Judaea, suggesting he exercised delegated authority in Syrian territories—possibly a provincial census or military assessment—while Saturninus held formal governorship, as legates could handle ad hoc tasks without supplanting the proconsul.^[2] This interpretation aligns with Roman administrative flexibility, where multiple officials operated in one province; however, some analyses question the precision of the dating, noting that the inscription's reference to Quirinius' Syrian oversight does not explicitly denote full governorship, and Iturean campaigns may reflect border pacification rather than a comprehensive enrollment.^[16] Additional epigraphic material, such as inscriptions from Pisidian Antioch (ILS 9502–9503), identifies Quirinius as duumvir (chief magistrate) around 12 BC, corroborating his early imperial favor under Augustus following the Homonadensian campaigns in Galatia-Cilicia (circa 12 BC–AD 1).^[2] Collectively, these findings imply Quirinius held iterative high commands in eastern provinces, but debates persist on whether they necessitate revising the single Syrian governorship attested in historiographical texts; proponents of multiple terms cite the cumulative weight of iterum and pre-AD 6 activities as indicating co-regency or special legations, while skeptics emphasize the inscriptions' incompleteness and potential for non-exclusive roles, favoring continuity with known consular sequences.^[7] No artifacts directly link Quirinius to Judaean administration before AD 6, underscoring reliance on fragmentary evidence for chronological reconstructions.

Historical Accounts and Scholarly Debates

Primary Sources: Josephus and Tacitus

Flavius Josephus, in Antiquities of the Jews (Book 18, Chapter 1), describes Publius Sulpicius Quirinius as a Roman senator and former consul dispatched by Augustus to Syria circa AD 6, following the deposition and exile of Herod Archelaus, to assess the property of the inhabitants for taxation purposes after Judaea was annexed as a Roman province under the legate of Syria.^[17] Josephus notes that Quirinius arrived with a small entourage and collaborated with the equestrian procurator Coponius, conducting an enrollment that encountered resistance from Jewish zealots, including Judas of Galilee (also called the Gaulonite) and Zadok, who decried the taxation as tantamount to slavery and incited a revolt.^[17] This census, according to Josephus, marked the formal imposition of direct Roman fiscal administration on Judaea, previously under Herodian client rule, and contributed to the founding of the Zealot faction.^[17] In Book 18, Chapter 2, Josephus further records that Quirinius concluded the assessment by AD 9, disposing of Archelaus's estate and replacing High Priest Joazar with Ananus amid ongoing administrative reforms.^[17] Tacitus, in Annals (Book 3, Chapter 48), provides a biographical obituary for Quirinius upon his death in AD 21, portraying him as a prominent senator who held the consulship twice—first in 12 BC with Marcus Valerius Messalla Corvinus and again circa AD 3—and who commanded Roman forces in Cilicia, successfully subduing the Homonadensian tribe in a protracted mountain campaign around 12–1 BC.^[18] Tacitus emphasizes Quirinius's military valor in suppressing this rebellious Cilician group, which had long harassed provincial borders, but notes public ambivalence toward his memory due to personal scandals, including his prosecution of Lepida on charges of adultery and poisoning attempts.^[18] Unlike Josephus, Tacitus does not detail Quirinius's Syrian governorship or the Judaean census, focusing instead on his senatorial career, consular honors, and Tiberius's request for a public funeral, which underscores his status despite waning senatorial esteem.^[18] These accounts from Josephus and Tacitus, written in the late first century AD, represent the principal literary attestations to Quirinius's administrative and military roles, with Josephus offering localized Judean context and Tacitus a broader Roman imperial perspective.^[17]^[18]

Chronological Disputes and Multiple Governorships

The primary historical sources, including Flavius Josephus in Antiquities of the Jews (17.13.2–5; 18.1.1) and Tacitus in Annals (2.30), attest to Publius Sulpicius Quirinius serving as legate (governor) of Syria only once, from approximately 6 to 9 CE, during which he conducted a census of Judaea following the deposition of Herod Archelaus by Emperor Augustus.^[1] Josephus explicitly states that Quirinius arrived in Syria in the summer of 6 CE, suppressed unrest in Judaea, and oversaw the taxation enrollment that provoked the rebellion led by Judas of Galilee.^[7] Prior governors of Syria are documented as including Quintilius Varus (circa 6–4 BCE) and possibly Publius Quinctilius Varus or others in the preceding years, with no contemporary records placing Quirinius in that role before 6 CE.^[19] A chronological dispute arises from the Gospel of Luke (2:1–2), which describes a census under Quirinius' governorship occurring while Herod the Great still reigned (died 4 BCE), creating an apparent ten-year discrepancy with the attested 6 CE census.^[20] Scholarly attempts to resolve this include proposals of an earlier, unrecorded governorship for Quirinius around 4–2 BCE, potentially during a power vacuum after Varus' departure, when he may have exercised special fiscal authority over Judaea while formally legate in neighboring Galatia-Cilicia (circa 11–4 BCE).^[21] This view draws partial support from the Lapis Tiburtinus (CIL XIV 3613; AE 1913, 136), a fragmented inscription recording a consular legate's career that included a Syrian governorship followed by oversight of Cilicia and a second Syrian term, with some restorations attributing it to Quirinius based on his known Homonadensian campaign (circa 12–1 BCE) and suffect consulship in 12 CE.^[22] However, the inscription's identification with Quirinius remains speculative and contested, as alternative candidates (e.g., Marcus Lollius or Sabinus) fit the fragments equally or better, and no epigraphic or literary evidence confirms dual Syrian legateships for him.^[23] Mainstream historiography, informed by the absence of corroborating inscriptions or accounts from Josephus and Tacitus—who detail Quirinius' career without mentioning prior Syrian service—rejects the multiple-governorship hypothesis as unsupported by primary evidence.^[14] Proponents of an earlier term often rely on reconciling New Testament timelines, but Roman administrative records, including consular lists and provincial fasti, indicate Quirinius held Galatia-Cilicia (not Syria) during the relevant pre-6 CE period, with Syria under separate legates like Sentius Saturninus (9–6 BCE).^[6] Alternative interpretations of Luke 2:2 include rendering the Greek hegemon as "ruling" rather than formal governor (implying procuratorial oversight), or positing a preparatory census enrollment initiated under Saturninus (9–7 BCE) but finalized under Quirinius, though these lack direct attestation and fail to align with Josephus' description of the 6 CE event as novel and disruptive.^[24] The debate underscores the limits of fragmentary Roman prosopography, where gaps in records invite conjecture but do not override attested sequences.

Controversies with New Testament Narratives

The Gospel of Luke states that a census of the entire Roman world was decreed by Caesar Augustus, occurring while Quirinius was governing Syria, prompting Joseph and Mary to travel to Bethlehem for registration, where Jesus was born (Luke 2:1–5). This places the event during the reign of Herod the Great, who died in 4 BCE according to Josephus and corroborated by astronomical data on lunar eclipses.^[3] ^[2] Josephus records Quirinius as legate of Syria beginning in 6 CE, conducting a census in Judaea shortly after the deposition of Herod Archelaus, which provoked a tax revolt led by Judas of Galilee; this census is referenced by Luke himself in Acts 5:37 as a later event distinct from Jesus' birth.^[3] ^[25] Roman provincial governor lists, derived from inscriptions and literary sources like Tacitus, indicate Quirinius held no prior Syrian governorship; predecessors included Sentius Saturninus (9–6 BCE) and Publius Quinctilius Varus (6–4 BCE), with no gap for Quirinius before 6 CE.^[7] ^[6] The resulting chronological discrepancy—approximately a decade between Herod's death and Quirinius' attested term—has led historians to question Luke's precision, with scholars like E. P. Sanders describing it as a historical error in synchronizing the nativity with known events, as no empire-wide census requiring ancestral returns aligns with Roman practices under client kingdoms like Herod's Judaea.^[26] ^[27] Raymond E. Brown notes the absence of corroborating records for a Quirinius-led census in 6–3 BCE, suggesting Luke may have adapted the 6 CE event to fulfill messianic prophecy regarding Bethlehem.^[28] Proposed reconciliations include dual governorships for Quirinius or interpreting Greek hēgemon as a non-legate fiscal role earlier, but these lack inscriptional or literary support and are rejected by most secular analysts due to complete Syrian governor documentation from 12 BCE onward.^[7] ^[29] Alternative readings of Luke 2:2's prōtē as "before" (implying a prior census to the famous 6 CE one) or symbolic alignment with Jerusalem's later destruction face grammatical and evidential hurdles, as prōtē typically denotes "first" in context, and no prior Quirinius census is attested.^[25] While apologetic scholars argue for Luke's overall reliability based on vindicated details elsewhere, the Quirinius synchronization remains a point of unresolved tension with extra-biblical evidence, often viewed as Luke's conflation for theological emphasis rather than strict historiography.^[30] ^[31]

References

[1]
P. Sulpicius Quirinius - Livius.org
Apr 28, 2020 · Publius Sulpicius Quirinius (c.45 BCE? - 21 CE): Roman senator, famous as governor of Syria. Portrait of a Roman, ca. 20 CEMissing: primary | Show results with:primary
[2]
Quirinius: An Archaeological Biography
Dec 19, 2019 · Publius Sulpicius Quirinius (or Cyrenius in the Greek) was a well-known Roman official who lived ca. 51 BC – AD 21. He is mentioned by numerous ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[3]
QUIRINIUS, P. SULPICIUS - JewishEncyclopedia.com
Roman governor of Syria about 6 C.E. , with whose name are associated events and problems of great importance. After the banishment of Archelaus in the year ...Missing: historical biography primary sources
[4]
http://perseus.uchicago.edu/perseus-cgi/citequery3.pl?dbname=LatinAugust2012&getid=1&query=Tac.%20Ann.%203.48
[5]
LacusCurtius • Tacitus, Annals — Book III Chapters 40‑55
### Extracted Text: Annals 3.48
[6]
W.M. Ramsay: Was Christ Born in Bethlehem?
Quirinius was a special Lieutenant of Augustus, who conducted the war against the Homonadenses, while Varus administered the ordinary affairs of Syria. The ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
[7]
[PDF] The Census and Quirinius: Luke 2:2 - Scholars Crossing
Some have claimed that Quirinius actually did not rule Syria in A.D. 6-7 but rather some eight to fourteen years earlier, and that the sources that give that.
[8]
https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0239%3Abook%3D12%3Achapter%3D7%3Asection%3D1
[9]
Quirinius census luke - Creation Ministries International
Dec 29, 2011 · Publius Sulpicius Quirinius (51 BC – AD 21) was known to be a most able commander, defeating the Homonadenses tribe in Galatia and Cilicia, in ...
[10]
The Annals of Tacitus - Early Christian Writings
[3.48] About the same time he requested the Senate to let the death of Sulpicius Quirinus be celebrated with a public funeral. With the old patrician family of ...Missing: Quirinius | Show results with:Quirinius
[11]
The Last of the Aemilii Lepidi - Persée
Sulpicius Quirinius, who paid court to Tiberius while on Rhodes 4. The marriage ended in divorce and finally a celebrated trial in which Aemilia was charged ...
[12]
The Trial of Aemilia Lepida in A.D. 20 - jstor
Probably not long after the marriage, which was never a success, Quirinius divorced. Lepida, whether for incompatibility or for unseemly conduct. Within a ...
[13]
Fragment of the sepulchral inscription of Quirinius - Vatican Museums
The inscription, found near Tivoli in 1764, probably belonged to the tomb of Publius Sulpicius Quirinius, "proconsul" (governor) of Asia and "legate divi ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography<|separator|>
[14]
Richard Carrier Quirinius - Internet Infidels
... Roman history, so it would have been extremely unusual and quite remarkable ... Publius Quinctilius Varus rather than Publius Sulpicius Quirinius. Of ...
[15]
[PDF] JOSEPHUS MISDATED THE CENSUS OF QUIRINIUS john h. rhoads*
Josephus, on the other hand, reports that Quirinius conducted his census long after Herod's death, at the exile of. Herod's son Herod Archelaus. So, either Luke ...Missing: Homonades | Show results with:Homonades
[16]
the census of quirinius - Academia.edu
... Quirinius was the proconsul of Africa at that time, and no one that we have knowledge of held an office twice in Roman history. But even if someone had done ...
[17]
Antiquities of the Jews, Book XVIII - Josephus
Josephus here assures us, that the ambassadors from Alexandria to Caius were on each part no more than three in number, for the Jews, and for the Gentiles, ...<|separator|>
[18]
Tacitus, Annals - ToposText
In the light of this, the accused asked for an adjournment to the following day, and left for home, after instructing his relative, Publius Sulpicius Quirinius, ...
[19]
When was Publius Quirinius governor of Syria? - Census in Luke 2:2
The next important historical fact is that Publius Sulpicius Quirinius had a position of authority over both Cilicia and Syria from 4 B.C. to A.D. 1. What ...
[20]
[PDF] The Date of the Census of Quirinius and the Chronology of the ...
Publius Sulpicius Quirinius2, during which Jesus Christ was born, meant that in Christian tradition both these events were inextricably linked. Despite the ...
[21]
Is this passage about Quirinius a historical contradiction?
This census can be dated to AD 6, which is far too late to line up with Jesus' birth, which dates closer to 4-5 BC, because he was born “in the days of Herod,” ...
[22]
Appendix 1 - Quirinius and the Census of Luke 2:2 - Angelfire
A possible reference to an earlier governorship of Quirinius can be found in an inscription called the "Lapis Tiburtinus." This is a tombstone which records ...<|separator|>
[23]
Of Jesus and Quirinius - jstor
before 6 b.c.e. he led campaigns in Cyrenaica and against the Homonadenses ... Tacitus Annales 3.48; Florus Epitome 2.31; A. N. Sherwin-White, Roman Society and.<|separator|>
[24]
The Census: Did Luke Make a Mistake? - Christ and Culture
May 20, 2024 · Quirinius conducted a census as governor in 6 AD (roughly 12 years after Jesus' birth and about 54 years before Luke wrote his Gospel). This ...
[25]
Luke, Quirinius, and the Census - Apologetics Press
Dec 31, 2002 · Some have charged Luke with committing an error on the basis of the fact that history records that Publius Sulpicius Quirinius ... Quaestor ( ...
[26]
The Census, Jesus' Birth In Bethlehem, And History | Dave Armstrong
Dec 16, 2020 · Jesus was not born in Bethlehem, if Luke is taken literally, according to EP Sanders [The Historical Figure of Jesus (Penguin Press, 1993, pp. 84-91)].
[27]
Luke's Alleged Historical Blunder Revisited (Part 1)
Oct 16, 2019 · E. P. Sanders characterizes the account as “a relatively slight historical error,” while Raymond Brown charges Luke with reporting ...
[28]
Library : Brown's Birth Of The Messiah . . . Revisited - Catholic Culture
Though it is true that we have no outside record of a census under Quirinius in the dates most likely for Christ's birth (6 to 3 B.C.), there is no reason to ...
[29]
Census of Quirinius and critical scholarship : r/AcademicBiblical
Dec 4, 2023 · Then in 6 AD, he was governor of Syria. Now some have suggested that Quirinius was governor of Syria twice, but there's no evidence for that.
[30]
Unbelievable? Is Luke's Description of Quirinius Historically ...
Quirinius may actually have ruled Syria during two separate periods and have taken two separate censuses. This is consistent with Luke's account. In Luke 2:2, ...Missing: discrepancy analysis
[31]
FAQ: Can You Explain the Problem with the Census in the Gospel of ...
Jun 8, 2022 · This means there is no way that Quirinius could have called a census while Herod the Great was king. Herod had been dead for a decade! And this ...Missing: Lapis Tiburtinus interpretation