Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Subhash Kak

Subhash Kak (born March 26, 1947) is an Indian-American computer scientist and Indologist renowned for his foundational contributions to quantum neural computing, cryptography, and information theory, as well as for elucidating scientific concepts embedded in ancient Indian texts. Regents Professor Emeritus of Electrical and Computer Engineering at Oklahoma State University, Kak earned his Ph.D. from the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi in 1970 and has published extensively on neural networks, quantum information processing, and secure coding schemes. His interdisciplinary scholarship extends to archaeoastronomy and cognitive models in Vedic literature, arguing for advanced computational and astronomical insights predating modern paradigms, as detailed in works like Computing Science in Ancient India. In recognition of these achievements, he received India's Padma Shri award in 2019. Kak's critiques of scalable quantum computing, emphasizing inherent error correction barriers, highlight his commitment to rigorous empirical assessment over hype.

Early Life and Education

Birth and Family Background

Subhash Kak was born on March 26, 1947, in Srinagar, then part of Jammu and Kashmir, India. He was the son of Ram Nath Kak (1917–1993), a Kashmiri veterinarian employed by the government who pursued yogic practices in his youth and later authored the autobiography Autumn Leaves, and Sarojini Chuni Kak (née Kaul). Kak grew up in a family environment influenced by his father's early spiritual explorations, which exposed him to stories of yogic discipline and inner life during his childhood in Kashmir. He has an older brother, Avinash Kak, a computer scientist specializing in software engineering and imaging, as well as a sister, Jaishree Odin, a literary theorist.

Formal Education and Early Influences

Subhash Kak received his early schooling in institutions across Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh, amid frequent relocations tied to his father's profession as a veterinarian. He subsequently earned a Bachelor of Engineering degree from the Regional Engineering College, Srinagar (now the National Institute of Technology, Srinagar). Kak completed his formal higher education with a Ph.D. in electrical engineering from the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, in 1970; his dissertation, titled "Studies in Pattern Recognition," laid foundational groundwork for his later research in neural networks. Kak's early intellectual development was shaped by a spiritually enriched household environment in Jammu and Kashmir, where his father, a former yogic apprentice, fostered discussions on texts such as the Bhagavad Gita and Upanishads, alongside encounters with swamis devoted to traditions honoring Vishnu, Shiva, or Shakti. These familial influences introduced him to themes of consciousness and mysticism from a young age. A pivotal encounter with the mystic Gopi Krishna further stimulated his curiosity about extraordinary human experiences and the boundaries of empirical knowledge. At IIT Delhi, Kak began critiquing the constraints of conventional Western science, particularly its materialist assumptions, which prompted an initial turn toward examining ancient Indian knowledge systems for complementary insights into reality and cognition. This phase marked the convergence of his engineering training with nascent interests in Vedic interpretations of nature, setting the trajectory for his interdisciplinary scholarship.

Academic and Professional Career

Key Positions and Institutions

Subhash Kak joined the faculty of Louisiana State University in Baton Rouge in 1979, where he served as the Donald C. and Elaine T. Delaune Distinguished Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering until 2007. During this period, his research focused on areas including wireless communications, data security, neural networks, information technology, and quantum computing. Following his tenure at LSU, Kak moved to Oklahoma State University in Stillwater, assuming the role of Regents Professor in the School of Electrical and Computer Engineering. He also held the position of Head of the Department of Computer Science at OSU. In recognition of his contributions, he was designated Regents Professor Emeritus. Earlier in his career, Kak was a visiting faculty member at Imperial College London during 1975–1976 and a guest researcher at Bell Laboratories in Murray Hill. He has additionally held short-term visiting appointments, including as Visiting Professor at the Indian Institute of Advanced Study in Shimla in 2004 and as a visitor at the Santa Fe Institute starting in 1998.

Administrative and Leadership Roles

Subhash Kak joined Oklahoma State University in 2007 as head of the Department of Computer Science, a position he held prior to transferring to the School of Electrical and Computer Engineering in 2014. During his tenure at OSU, he also served as the OSURF Endowed Chair of Engineering in the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering. In addition to his university roles, Kak has held leadership positions in specialized research centers and advisory bodies. He is the Distinguished Scientist and Chair of the Taksha Artificial Intelligence and Cyber Security (TAICS) Center at Taksha Institute, focusing on advancing research and education in AI and cybersecurity. From 2008 to 2009, he served as one of the principal editors for the International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) project under UNESCO, tasked with identifying potential world heritage sites. Kak was appointed in 2018 to the Indian Prime Minister's Science, Technology and Innovation Advisory Council (PM-STIAC), where he continues to contribute to national policy on scientific and technological advancements, including participation in council meetings as recently as August 2025.

Scientific Contributions

Innovations in Neural Networks and AI

Subhash Kak contributed to the development of efficient training algorithms for feedforward neural networks in the early 1990s, proposing methods that enable three-layered architectures to map n-dimensional binary input vectors to m-dimensional binary output vectors with reduced computational complexity compared to backpropagation-heavy approaches. These algorithms, including corner classification techniques, facilitate faster convergence for pattern recognition tasks by leveraging structured weight initialization and localized adjustments. In 2002, Kak introduced a class of fully connected (FC) neural networks designed for instantaneous training, bypassing traditional iterative optimization to achieve rapid learning on non-binary data patterns. These networks operate by directly computing weights based on input-output correspondences in a single pass, making them suitable for real-time applications where training data is limited or dynamic. Kak secured a patent for this innovation, highlighting its utility in scenarios requiring immediate adaptability without retraining overhead. Kak applied instantaneously trained neural networks (INNs) to practical AI challenges, such as accelerating web search and predictive modeling, as detailed in his 1999 IEEE Intelligent Systems publication, where INNs demonstrated superior speed in indexing and querying large datasets over conventional methods. This work underscored the causal advantages of one-shot learning paradigms in reducing latency for information retrieval systems, influencing early AI-driven search technologies.

Work in Cryptography and Information Theory

Subhash Kak has contributed to cryptography through the development of quantum protocols and sequence-based methods for secure communication. In 2005, he proposed a three-stage quantum cryptography protocol that integrates public key elements, where each participant employs their own secret key to enhance security against eavesdropping. This approach builds on quantum key distribution principles by dividing the process into preparation, transmission, and verification stages to minimize information leakage. Kak further advanced quantum cryptography with the intensity-aware protocol (iAQC) in 2012, which accounts for photon intensity variations to improve detection of interception attempts in practical implementations. His cryptographic work extends to threshold schemes and visual cryptography. In 2008, Kak introduced a recursive threshold visual cryptography scheme for 2-out-of-n participants, allowing layered hiding of images that reveal content only when sufficient shares are combined, suitable for applications in secure image sharing. He also explored polarization states for cryptography and system state estimation, demonstrating how polarization measurements can encode and decode information resilient to certain noise models. Additionally, Kak investigated sequences like binary primes and Pythagorean triples for cryptographic coding, proposing their use to generate pseudorandom patterns that strengthen physical-layer security in communications. In information theory, Kak pioneered analyses linking information measures to physical and computational limits. He developed a novel entropy measure for quantum systems to quantify limitations on quantum computing capabilities, arguing that inherent informational constraints prevent universal speedups beyond classical bounds in specific tasks. This work underscores trade-offs in quantum information processing, influencing debates on practical quantum advantages. Kak also applied information theory to spatial dimensionality, proposing in 2020 that optimal data representation implies a non-integer intrinsic dimension approximating e (≈2.718), derived from compression principles and scale-invariance in natural systems. This e-dimensionality principle, elaborated in his 2024 book, posits that information efficiency in representations naturally yields fractal-like structures observed in biology and physics. These contributions emphasize first-principles derivations over empirical fitting, prioritizing verifiable algorithmic bounds.

Advances in Quantum Information and Computing

Subhash Kak has contributed to quantum information theory by developing measures of quantum entropy that account for the inherent uncertainties in quantum states, distinguishing them from classical Shannon entropy. In a 2007 paper, he introduced a quantum entropy function that incorporates phase information and superposition effects, arguing it better captures the informational content of quantum systems compared to von Neumann entropy, which overlooks certain non-local correlations. This approach highlights limitations in standard quantum information metrics for practical computation, as it reveals how decoherence amplifies information loss in noisy environments. Kak's work on quantum computing emphasizes fundamental barriers to scalability, including the initialization problem, where preparing a precise initial quantum state amid environmental noise violates uncertainty principles. In his 1998 analysis, he demonstrated that statistical constraints on state preparation impose exponential resource demands, rendering large-scale coherent operations infeasible without classical preprocessing that negates quantum advantages. Extending this, his 2002 examination of uncertainty in quantum computation showed that measurement-induced collapses introduce irreducible errors proportional to the Hilbert space dimension, challenging claims of exponential speedup for algorithms like Shor's. These critiques, grounded in the no-cloning theorem and decoherence dynamics, predict that error correction overheads will dominate for systems beyond a few dozen qubits, as evidenced by persistent hardware error rates exceeding 10^{-3} in experimental setups as of 2019. In exploring hybrid paradigms, Kak pioneered quantum neural computing in the early 1990s, proposing networks where quantum superposition enables parallel associative processing akin to classical neural models but with enhanced pattern recognition via entanglement. His 2009 revisit formalized quantum neurons as operators on density matrices, suggesting applications in optimization problems resistant to classical solvers, though practical realization awaits fault-tolerant hardware. Kak has also proposed a novel information measure for quantum systems that quantifies "active" informational capacity, linking it to observer-dependent collapses and critiquing overly optimistic scalability projections in national quantum initiatives. Overall, his contributions underscore causal constraints from quantum mechanics—such as phase randomization and error propagation—that temper enthusiasm for universal quantum computers, advocating instead for specialized quantum simulators over general-purpose devices.

Indological Scholarship

Vedic Astronomy and Archaeoastronomy

Subhash Kak's research in Vedic astronomy posits that the Rigveda encodes sophisticated astronomical observations through structural regularities in its hymns, such as the arrangement of 1080 ṛks (verses) across 10 maṇḍalas (books), which aligns with the approximate number of days in three years (accounting for intercalary months), and the association of deities with celestial bodies like the sun, moon, and nakṣatras. In his 1994 book The Astronomical Code of the Ṛgveda, Kak argues these patterns reflect knowledge of the 27 or 28 lunar mansions, solsticial markers, and precessional cycles, suggesting composition around 4000–3000 BCE based on references to the vernal equinox in Orion (Mṛgaśiras). He further claims the text's metrical structure, including the use of gāyatrī and triṣṭubh meters, mirrors lunar phases and planetary retrogressions observed in Vedic rituals. Kak's analysis of Vedic altars, detailed in works like "Astronomy of the Vedic Altars" (1993), demonstrates geometric encodings of astronomical data in the Śulbasūtras, where altar shapes (e.g., falcon for Agnicayana) incorporate ratios such as √2 for diagonal approximations and circle-square equivalences reflecting the year length of 366 days via layered brick counts. These constructions, he contends, served not only ritual but observational purposes, embedding knowledge of equinoxes and the Ṛgvedic calendar's 360-day civil year plus adjustments for actual solar motion. Such encodings imply an empirical tradition predating later Siddhāntic astronomy, with altars functioning as analog computers for timekeeping. In archaeoastronomy, Kak examines alignments in ancient Indian monuments, as in his 2010 paper "Archaeoastronomy in India," highlighting temple orientations toward cardinal directions or specific stars, such as the 14th-century Vijayanagara structures aligned with the rising sun on key festival days and earlier Harappan sites potentially tracking solstices via grid planning. He interprets megalithic dolmens and Iron Age observatories as evidence of continuity from Vedic practices, with rock art depicting constellations like the Pleiades (Kṛttikā). Kak's broader framework links these to a cosmological model dividing the universe into 33 layers (earth, atmosphere, heavens), influencing architectural symbolism in sites like the Kailasanatha temple at Ellora, where proportions evoke celestial geometries. His findings challenge diffusionist models by emphasizing indigenous development of observational techniques traceable to 3000 BCE or earlier.

Advocacy for Indigenous Aryan Origins

Subhash Kak has argued that the Indo-Aryans originated indigenously within the Indian subcontinent, rejecting the Aryan migration or invasion theory as a 19th-century construct lacking empirical support from archaeology, linguistics, or textual evidence. In his co-authored book In Search of the Cradle of Civilization (1995), Kak, along with Georg Feuerstein and David Frawley, posits that Vedic civilization predates supposed external arrivals, with astronomical references in the Rigveda indicating compositions as early as 4000–3000 BCE, aligning with the mature Harappan phase rather than a post-invasion synthesis. This view emphasizes cultural continuity, including shared motifs between Harappan seals and Vedic rituals, such as fire altars and yogic postures, without evidence of disruptive conquest. Kak's advocacy draws on Vedic astronomy to challenge conventional chronologies, interpreting the organization of Rigvedic hymns by lunar asterisms and solstice alignments as encoding precise dates that place the text's core before 2000 BCE, predating any proposed Indo-European steppe migrations. He contends that the Sarasvati River, described as mighty in the Vedas, corresponds to the Ghaggar-Hakra paleochannel, which dried up around 1900 BCE due to tectonic shifts, not invasion-induced abandonment, supporting an indigenous timeline. Linguistically, Kak proposes an "Out of India" model where Indo-European languages radiated from Sanskrit-like roots, explaining similarities in Eurasian vocabularies through ancient maritime and overland dispersals remembered in Puranic accounts, rather than unidirectional western influxes. Critiquing mainstream narratives, Kak highlights how the invasion theory originated from colonial interpretations of texts like the Rigveda to justify British rule, persisting in academia despite contradictory data, such as the absence of horse or chariot remains in early Harappan sites that would indicate invaders. He argues for reevaluating genetic studies, noting that interpretations assuming negligible ancient Indian populations to fit migration models overlook endogenous admixture and inflate external contributions. This framework aligns Vedic and Harappan material culture, positing yoga, decimal systems, and fire worship as unbroken indigenous developments traceable to at least 7000 BCE via archaeoastronomical markers. Kak's position underscores a holistic synthesis of textual, scientific, and artifactual evidence, urging scholars to prioritize primary Indic sources over Eurocentric reconstructions.

Critiques of Mainstream Historical Narratives

Subhash Kak contends that mainstream historical narratives of ancient India originated in colonial-era historiography crafted to rationalize British dominion, portraying the subcontinent as a disjointed aggregation of castes devoid of national cohesion or scientific prowess, thereby necessitating Western tutelage. This framework, which misconstrued indigenous jātis as rigid "castes" and dismissed evidence of advanced technologies such as multi-masted shipbuilding documented in ancient texts, has endured in academic curricula and textbooks, fostering a diminished self-perception among Indians and sidelining native contributions to knowledge systems. Kak specifically impugns the Aryan migration theory as a 19th-century construct unsupported by archaeological continuity or genetic markers of mass influx, positing instead that Indo-European linguistic elements, including Vedic Sanskrit, arose indigenously within the Indian subcontinent by at least 5000 BCE. Mainstream linguistics, he argues, clings to obsolete tree-model phylogenies and circular validations—such as presupposing a Proto-Indo-European homeland in the European steppes—while disregarding language's multifaceted, non-linear evolution and anomalies like the centum-language Bangani in the Himalayan region that confound migration timelines. To counter the conventional dating of the Rigveda to circa 1500–1200 BCE as a post-migration artifact, Kak employs archaeoastronomical analysis of hymns encoding celestial observations, such as nakṣatra positions and solstice alignments, to establish composition in the 4th or 3rd millennium BCE, aligning with uninterrupted cultural strata rather than disruptive external impositions. He critiques institutional Indology for perpetuating these late chronologies despite contradictory empirical data, attributing resistance to entrenched paradigms that prioritize linguistic speculation over interdisciplinary evidence like Vedic internal references to cataclysmic events around 7000 BCE. This selective adherence, Kak maintains, reflects a broader academic inertia rooted in colonial precedents, where narratives favoring discontinuity obscure India's holistic civilizational arc.

Publications

Major Scientific Publications

Kak's pioneering work in neural networks includes the invention of instantaneously trained neural networks (INNs), patented in 1995 (U.S. Patent No. 5,426,721), which enable single-pass training for applications in pattern recognition and robotics. This approach, building on earlier algorithms for feedforward networks, was elaborated in his 1994 paper "New algorithms for training feedforward neural networks," published in Pattern Recognition Letters, demonstrating faster convergence compared to backpropagation methods. In 1999, he applied these networks to inverse kinematics problems in robotics, showing their efficacy in solving nonlinear equations for manipulator control in Information Sciences. In quantum neural computing, Kak's 1995 paper "On quantum neural computing" in Information Sciences introduced models integrating quantum superposition with neural architectures, arguing for potential advantages in parallelism and error correction over classical networks. He revisited this in a 2009 arXiv preprint, "Another Look at Quantum Neural Computing," critiquing limitations in quantum gate implementations and proposing hybrid classical-quantum hybrids for practical computation. Kak's contributions to cryptography feature quantum-enhanced protocols, such as the 2006 paper "A three-stage quantum cryptography protocol" in Foundations of Physics Letters, which uses sequential key distribution and verification to achieve unconditional security against eavesdropping via Bell inequalities. His 2013 work "Threshold Quantum Cryptography" on arXiv extends this to multi-party scenarios, requiring a threshold of participants for key reconstruction while maintaining privacy. Earlier classical efforts include the 1985 paper "Encryption and error-correction using d-sequences" in IEEE Transactions on Computers, proposing sequence-based codes for secure data transmission with built-in error detection. In quantum information theory, Kak's 2007 paper "Quantum information and entropy" in International Journal of Theoretical Physics derives entropy measures for quantum states, linking them to computational complexity and arguing that quantum entropy exceeds classical analogs due to non-commutativity. His 1999 publication "The initialization problem in quantum computing" in Foundations of Physics addresses coherence loss in qubit arrays, proposing initialization schemes based on information-theoretic bounds to mitigate decoherence in early quantum devices. These works, with over 5,500 citations across 469 publications as of recent profiles, underscore Kak's focus on bridging information theory with quantum mechanics.

Key Works in Indology and History of Science

Subhash Kak's contributions to Indology and the history of science emphasize the scientific sophistication of ancient Indian texts, particularly through archaeoastronomical analysis and reinterpretation of Vedic literature. His works challenge conventional timelines derived from 19th-century colonial scholarship by integrating textual, astronomical, and archaeological evidence to argue for greater antiquity and indigenous development of Indian civilization. In The Astronomical Code of the Rigveda (Aditya Prakashan, 1994), Kak decodes patterns in the Rigveda's 1,017 hymns, proposing they reflect deliberate astronomical alignments, such as the 27-fold division mirroring the lunar mansions (nakshatras) and solar-lunar cycles observed around 4000–3000 BCE. He contends this structure encodes celestial knowledge integral to Vedic ritual, including altar geometries tied to planetary periods, supporting composition dates predating the Indus Valley decline. The book draws on metrics like the anu-vak divisions and hymn counts to demonstrate non-random ordering, attributing it to priestly astronomers rather than later interpolations. Kak co-authored In Search of the Cradle of Civilization: New Light on Ancient India (Quest Books, 1995) with Georg Feuerstein and David Frawley, synthesizing archaeoastronomical data from Vedic references—like the drying of the Sarasvati River around 2000 BCE—with Indus Valley artifacts to posit Vedic culture's roots in the subcontinent as early as 7000–4000 BCE. The text critiques the Aryan invasion/migration model as unsupported by genetics or linguistics, favoring continuity from pre-Harappan phases based on star alignments in texts like the Shatapatha Brahmana. Other notable publications include essays on Indian scientific history, such as "A Brief History of Indian Science" (2003), which traces advancements in mathematics, astronomy, and philosophy from Vedic ritual codes to medieval treatises, emphasizing empirical methods in texts like the Sulba Sutras for geometric approximations of √2 accurate to five decimals by 800 BCE. Kak's paper "Astronomy and its Role in Vedic Culture" (2000) further details how celestial observations underpinned rituals, with references to 27 nakshatras and yuga cycles reflecting pre-2000 BCE knowledge. These works collectively advocate for reevaluating Indian contributions through primary sources over Eurocentric frameworks.

Reception and Controversies

Academic Praise and Influence

Subhash Kak's scholarly output in computer science, particularly in cryptography and quantum information, has demonstrated substantial influence through extensive citations in peer-reviewed literature. His development of self-synchronizing codes and contributions to quantum cryptography protocols, including the three-stage quantum cryptography method, have been referenced in subsequent research on secure communication systems. On platforms aggregating academic metrics, his publications have accumulated over 5,500 citations, reflecting impact across information theory and related fields. In the domain of Indological studies, Kak's analyses of Vedic texts have elicited commendation from prominent scholars for advancing empirical interpretations of ancient cosmology. Klaus Klostermaier, in his assessment of Vedic scholarship, highlighted Kak's decoding of the Rig Veda as opening "an entirely new approach to the study of Vedic cosmology from an empirical point of view," emphasizing its mathematical rigor. This recognition underscores Kak's role in bridging computational methods with historical astronomy, influencing interdisciplinary examinations of ancient Indian scientific traditions. His appointment as Regents Professor at Oklahoma State University further attests to institutional acknowledgment of his foundational contributions in these areas. Kak's influence extends to mentoring and shaping discourse in quantum neural computing and archaeoastronomy, where his early papers on quantum paradigms for neural networks continue to inform explorations of consciousness and computation limits. Overall, these elements of praise and citation metrics position Kak as a pivotal figure in niche yet rigorous academic intersections, though his broader reception varies by disciplinary consensus.

Criticisms and Scholarly Debates

Kak's interpretations of Vedic astronomy, particularly his claim in The Astronomical Code of the Ṛgveda (1994) that the text encodes knowledge of 27 lunar mansions and solar-lunar alignments dating to around 4000 BCE, have faced significant scholarly pushback. Critics contend that these readings impose later astronomical systems anachronistically onto the Rigveda, which linguistic analysis dates to 1500–1200 BCE, lacking explicit references to such structures in the hymns themselves. Michael Witzel, Wales Professor of Sanskrit at Harvard University, has described such chronological revisions as methodologically loose, arguing they rely on selective textual ambiguities rather than corroborated philological evidence, potentially inflating Vedic sophistication to fit preconceived indigenous timelines. Meera Nanda, a historian of science, has sharply critiqued Kak's broader "Vedic science" framework, including astronomical and mathematical encodings purportedly anticipating modern physics, as pseudoscientific and empirically unsupported. In her analysis, these claims—such as deriving the sun-earth distance or light speed from Vedic metrics—represent "utterly incredible" assertions devoid of testable validation, blending introspection and metaphysics in ways that undermine scientific rigor while serving nationalist narratives of civilizational primacy. Nanda attributes this to a postmodern relativism that equates yogic insight with empirical method, linking it to Hindutva efforts to retroject advanced knowledge onto ancient India against the scholarly consensus of gradual development. Debates over Kak's advocacy for indigenous Aryan origins intensify these criticisms, with opponents like Witzel and geneticists citing Steppe pastoralist DNA influx around 2000–1500 BCE, Indo-European linguistic divergences, and chariot burials as evidence against autochthonous theories. Kak's rejection of migration models as colonial holdovers, emphasizing cultural continuity from the Indus Valley, is dismissed by some as ideologically driven, prioritizing symbolic interpretations over interdisciplinary data convergence. Yet, Kak maintains that genetic signals reflect later elite exchanges rather than mass invasion, underscoring ongoing tensions between revisionist chronologies and mainstream syntheses in Indology.

Philosophical and Public Views

Integration of Science and Spirituality

Subhash Kak posits that science and spirituality are complementary domains, with ancient Indian traditions offering a holistic epistemology that anticipates modern scientific insights into consciousness and reality. He contends that Vedic thought integrates empirical observation with introspective knowledge, viewing consciousness as a foundational principle rather than an epiphenomenon of physical processes. This perspective challenges materialist paradigms dominant in Western science, which Kak argues overlook the subjective dimension of cognition central to quantum interpretation and information theory. In his 1997 paper "From Vedic Science to Vedanta," Kak delineates a progression from Vedic ritual sciences—such as the geometric and astronomical precision in fire altars like Agnicayana—to Vedanta's non-dualistic metaphysics, rejecting dismissals of these traditions as pre-scientific. He highlights how Vedic epistemology emphasizes recursive structures and observer-dependent phenomena, paralleling wave mechanics' unity and continuity, where particle and wave aspects coexist akin to Vedanta's atman and brahman. Kak maintains this framework resolves dualisms in contemporary physics, such as measurement problems in quantum theory, by prioritizing consciousness as the unifying ground. Kak's 2016 translation and commentary on the Vaiśeṣika Sūtra of Kaṇāda, titled Matter and Mind, elucidates an ancient atomic theory that incorporates mind (manas) as a substantive entity interacting with matter, prefiguring debates in cognitive science and neuroscience. He interprets Kaṇāda's categories—substance, quality, action—not as reductive materialism but as a dynamic system where consciousness enables perception and volition, aligning with empirical findings on neural correlates without reducing mind to brain states. This work underscores Kak's broader thesis that Indian philosophy provides causal mechanisms for qualia and intentionality, absent in purely computational models of mind. Through books like The Gods Within: Mind, Consciousness, and the Vedic Tradition (2005), Kak extends these ideas to argue that spiritual practices such as yoga enhance cognitive faculties, fostering insights verifiable by scientific metrics like altered brain states during meditation. He critiques institutional biases in academia that marginalize such integrations as non-empirical, attributing this to Eurocentric histories that undervalue non-Western contributions to scientific thought. Kak's approach thus advocates a revived scientific pluralism, where spirituality refines empirical methods by addressing the limits of objectivist reductionism.

Recent Commentary on AI and Society

In his 2025 book The Age of Artificial Intelligence, Subhash Kak examines the trajectory of AI advancements alongside their geopolitical, philosophical, and ethical ramifications, positing that while AI holds potential to liberate humans from routine labor, it risks entrenching power in the hands of tech oligarchs or authoritarian regimes capable of manipulating information flows and suppressing dissent through algorithmic control. He draws historical parallels to industrialization and colonization, suggesting AI could homogenize cultures and erode collective memory unless safeguarded by ethical frameworks rooted in traditions emphasizing truth and meaning, such as those from Indian philosophy. Kak forecasts profound societal disruption from AI-driven automation, which he anticipates will eliminate over 50% of jobs in sectors like transportation via self-driving technologies and robotics, exacerbating economic uncertainty and deterring family formation amid rising child-rearing costs. This, combined with already observed fertility declines (e.g., total fertility rates of 1.1 to 1.5 in advanced economies), could shrink the global population to 100–500 million by 2300, yielding widespread loneliness, social fragmentation, and intercultural conflicts. He describes this trajectory as "devastating for society," attributing public underestimation to a failure to grasp AI's inexorable dominance over human endeavors. On AI's intrinsic limits, Kak asserts that machines cannot attain consciousness, lacking the self-referential qualia inherent to human cognition, yet they will supplant most procedural and creative human functions, potentially birthing an "AI State" where policy derives from opaque algorithms prone to errors like those evident in certain regulatory frameworks. He warns of existential perils, including weaponization and mind control, echoing concerns from figures like Stephen Hawking, while advocating cultural preservation as a counter to dehumanization.

References

  1. [1]
    [PDF] Vita: Subhash Kak
    May 6, 2004 · Date of Birth. March 26, 1947. Education. • Ph.D. Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, 1970; Dissertation title: “Studies in Signal The- ory ...
  2. [2]
    Meet Subhash Kak, AI Visionary & Inventor Of Quantum Neural ...
    Jun 5, 2019 · Subhash Kak, one of the biggest names in cryptography and neural network worldwide, recently accepted the Padma Shri award in the field of ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  3. [3]
    Subhash Kak to receive prestigious award from government of India
    Feb 1, 2019 · Subhash Kak, Regents Professor Emeritus in electrical and computer engineering (ECE) at Oklahoma State University, will receive the Padma Shri award from the ...
  4. [4]
    A Dialogue on Quantum Computing - Subhash Kak - Medium
    Jul 10, 2019 · Simplicio: Quantum cryptography is a breakthrough technology. Two users can exchange keys without anyone able to break the system.Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  5. [5]
    Subhash Chandra Kak - Prabook
    Son of Ram Nath and Sarojini Chuni (Kaul) Kak. Education. Bachelor of Engineering, Kashmir University, 1967. Doctor of Philosophy, Indian Institute of ...<|separator|>
  6. [6]
    Subhash Kak - Genealogy - Geni
    May 23, 2018 · Birthplace: Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir, India ; Immediate Family: Son of Ram Nath Kak and Sarojini Chuni Kak Husband of Private User Father of ...Missing: parents | Show results with:parents
  7. [7]
    Subhash Kak - Dharmapedia Wiki
    Subhash Kak completed his BE from Regional Engineering College, Srinagar (Presently National Institute of Technology, Srinagar) and Ph.D. from Indian Institute ...
  8. [8]
    Ram Nath Kak - Dharmapedia Wiki
    Ram Nath Kak (1917–1993) (Kashmiri: राम नाथ काक (Devanagari)) (born in Srinagar and died in Honolulu) was a Kashmiri veterinarian whose autobiography Autumn ...
  9. [9]
    Kashmir Articles by Subhash Kak - Kashmiri Pandit Network
    Some years ago, before having known much about Subhash Kak, I read some leaves from the autobiographical book Autumn Leaves of his father Ram Nath Kak, who had ...Missing: parents | Show results with:parents
  10. [10]
    How I Discovered Vedic Science by Subhash Kak
    Jun 7, 2017 · My father was a serious yogic apprentice for several years before he married, so as a boy I heard many inspiring stories about the spiritual ...
  11. [11]
    Affirmations Inspired by Avinash Kak
    ... Avinash Kak ... Interestingly, Kak has collaborated with his brother, Subhash Kak, who is also a prominent academic in computer science and cryptography. ... Their ...
  12. [12]
    About: Avinash Kak
    About: Avinash Kak. An Entity of Type: animal ... His brother is the computer scientist Subhash Kak and sister the literary theorist Jaishree Odin. ... Avinash Kak ...
  13. [13]
    Rediff On The NeT: The Rediff Interview/ Dr Subhash Kak
    Nov 18, 1999 · Originally from Kashmir, Dr Kak has worked at IIT Delhi, Imperial College, Bell Laboratories and the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research. He ...
  14. [14]
    Distinguished Alumni Awards - Alumni Relations:: IIT Delhi
    Prof. Subhash Kak was born on March 26, 1947, in Srinagar. After studying in schools in Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh, he attended Jammu & Kashmir University.
  15. [15]
    [PDF] Vita: Subhash Kak - Electrical & Computer Engineering, Division of
    Kak, “A three-stage quantum cryptography protocol.” Foundations of Physics ... Kak, “Quantum computing and artificial intelligence,” Plenary Lecture, Proceedings ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  16. [16]
    Subhash Kak - Closer To Truth
    Born in Srinagar, Kashmir, Kak was educated in various places in Jammu and Kashmir. He completed his PhD in Electrical Engineering from Indian Institute of ...
  17. [17]
    Subhash Kak - LSU
    Subhash Kak joined the LSU faculty in 1979. He has worked in the areas of wireless, data security, neural networks, information technology, and quantum ...Missing: positions | Show results with:positions
  18. [18]
    Subhash Kak: Home Page
    Subhash Kak. Professor and Head. Address: Department of Computer Science · Oklahoma State University: Stillwater, Ok 74078. Phone: Off.: (405) 744-5668 ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] Dr. Subhash Kak - Oklahoma State University
    SUBHASH KAK, EMERITUS. REGENTS PROFESSOR. Subhash Kak is an Adjunct Faculty member and Emeritus Regents. Professor at ECE Dept of OSU. His research is in the ...
  20. [20]
    Subhash Kak - The Conversation
    Oct 18, 2017 · Born in Srinagar, Kashmir, Kak completed his PhD in Electrical Engineering from Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi. During 1975-1976, he was ...<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    Subhash Kak Appointed to Prestigious Commission
    Oct 3, 2018 · He has developed new codes for computing and cryptography, worked on variety of problems on data and network security, and he is the originator ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  22. [22]
    Subhash Kak, PhD - ⋆ Taksha Institute
    His research areas include cybersecurity, social networks, artificial intelligence, and quantum computing. He is currently a member of Indian Prime Minister's ...Missing: field | Show results with:field
  23. [23]
    Subhash Kak in Conversation by Vikram Zutshi - Sutra Journal
    Subhash Kak is an Indian American computer scientist. He is Regents Professor and a previous Head of Computer Science Department at Oklahoma State University – ...
  24. [24]
    28th Prime Minister's Science, Technology & Innovation Advisory ...
    Aug 21, 2025 · ... (PM-STIAC) meeting on August 21, 2025 at National Agricultural ... Subhash Kak, Professor, Oklahoma State University; Shri. Baba Kalyani ...
  25. [25]
    New algorithms for training feedforward neural networks
    A new network that maps n-dimensional binary vectors into m-dimensional binary vectors using 3-layered feedforward neural networks is described.
  26. [26]
    [PDF] A Class of Instantaneously Trained Neural Networks
    May 7, 2002 · This paper presents FC networks that are instantaneously trained neural networks that allow rapid learning of non-binary data. These networks, ...
  27. [27]
    [quant-ph/0503027] A Three-Stage Quantum Cryptography Protocol
    Mar 2, 2005 · Authors:Subhash Kak. View a PDF of the paper titled A Three-Stage Quantum Cryptography Protocol, by Subhash Kak. View PDF. Abstract: We present ...
  28. [28]
    A Three-Stage Quantum Cryptography Protocol
    Apr 25, 2006 · We present a three-stage quantum cryptographic protocol based on public key cryptography in which each party uses its own secret key.
  29. [29]
    iAQC: The Intensity-Aware Quantum Cryptography Protocol - arXiv
    Jun 28, 2012 · Access Paper: View a PDF of the paper titled iAQC: The Intensity-Aware Quantum Cryptography Protocol, by Subhash Kak and 2 other authors.
  30. [30]
    A Recursive Threshold Visual Cryptography Scheme
    Dec 28, 2008 · A Recursive Threshold Visual Cryptography Scheme. Abhishek Parakh and Subhash Kak. Abstract. This paper presents a recursive hiding scheme for 2 ...
  31. [31]
    Cryptography and system state estimation using polarization states
    Sep 28, 2011 · Subhash Kak, Pramode Verma, and Greg MacDonald "Cryptography and system state estimation using polarization states", Proc. SPIE 8121, The ...
  32. [32]
    Binary primes sequence for cryptography and secure communication
    This paper investigates the generalized binary primes sequence and proposes its use to enhance commonly used pseudorandom (PN) sequences in physical-layer ...
  33. [33]
    (PDF) Pythagorean Triples and Cryptographic Coding - ResearchGate
    Random Sequences Based on the Divisor Pairs Function. October 2012. Subhash Kak. This paper investigates the randomness properties ...
  34. [34]
    Information theory and dimensionality of space | Scientific Reports
    Nov 26, 2020 · We present an information-theoretic approach to the optimal representation of the intrinsic dimensionality of data and show it is a noninteger.
  35. [35]
    The e-Dimensionality Information Principle - Routledge
    The work explores how optimal information representation naturally leads to scale-invariance and self-similarity—characteristics observed throughout natural ...
  36. [36]
    [0902.4884] Prospects for Quantum Computing - arXiv
    Feb 27, 2009 · Title:Prospects for Quantum Computing. Authors:Subhash Kak. View a PDF of the paper titled Prospects for Quantum Computing, by Subhash Kak.
  37. [37]
    The Initialization Problem in Quantum Computing
    Subhash Kak. 356 Accesses. 35 Citations. Explore all metrics. Abstract. The ... Kak, “Quantum information in a distributed apparatus,” Found. Phys. 28, 1005 ...
  38. [38]
    [quant-ph/0206006] Uncertainty In Quantum Computation - arXiv
    Jun 2, 2002 · Title:Uncertainty In Quantum Computation. Authors:Subhash Kak. View a PDF of the paper titled Uncertainty In Quantum Computation, by Subhash Kak.
  39. [39]
    A quantum computing future is unlikely, due to random hardware ...
    Dec 3, 2019 · Subhash Kak, Oklahoma State University ... The United States' National Quantum Initiative Act provides $1.2 billion to promote quantum information ...
  40. [40]
    [0908.3148] Another Look at Quantum Neural Computing - arXiv
    Aug 21, 2009 · Authors:Subhash Kak. View a PDF of the paper titled Another Look at Quantum Neural Computing, by Subhash Kak. View PDF. Abstract:The term ...
  41. [41]
    Dr. Subhash Kak - Have You Ever Wondered Podcast
    Kak was the first to look for information metric for a quantum state over thirty years ago. His work on quantum information includes the only all-quantum ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  42. [42]
    [PDF] Astronomy and its Role in Vedic Culture
    That astronomy played a very central role in Vedic culture is apparent from the innumerable references to naks.atras and devas (heavenly bodies).
  43. [43]
    [PDF] The Astronomical Code of the Ṛgveda - The Classical Astrologer
    Subhash Kak is a widely known scientist and Indologist. Currently Regents ... The Astronomical Code of the Rigveda. Pu- ratattva: Bulletin of the ...
  44. [44]
    [PDF] The astronomy of the age of geometric altars
    My own researches have outlined the astronomy of the Indian fire altars of the Vedic times and shown that this knowledge was also coded in the organization of ...Missing: contributions | Show results with:contributions
  45. [45]
    [PDF] Birth and Early Development of Indian Astronomy - arXiv
    Kak, Subhash. “Astronomy in Satapatha Br¯ahman.a.” Indian Journal of. History of Science 28: 15-34, 1993. Kak, Subhash. “Astronomy of the Vedic altars.Missing: contributions | Show results with:contributions
  46. [46]
    (PDF) Astronomy of the Vedic Altars - Academia.edu
    Astronomy of the Vedic Altars. Profile image of Subhash Kak Subhash Kak. 1993 ... astronomy of the fire altars, it also presented the Rigvedic astronomical code.
  47. [47]
    [PDF] Archaeoastronomy in India - arXiv
    According to the Persian Page 14 Archaeoastronomy in India – Subhash Kak 14 ambassador Abdur Razaaq (1442 CE): “The City of Vijayanagara is such that the pupil ...
  48. [48]
    [1002.4513] Archaeoastronomy in India - arXiv
    Feb 24, 2010 · Title:Archaeoastronomy in India. Authors:Subhash Kak. View a PDF of the paper titled Archaeoastronomy in India, by Subhash Kak. View PDF.
  49. [49]
    (PDF) Visions of the Cosmos: Archaeoastronomy in Ancient India
    This paper is an overview of archaeoastronomy in ancient India. It describes the Vedic conception of the cosmos and the representation of the knowledge of ...
  50. [50]
    The Aryans and Ancient Indian History ~ Subhash Kak
    Feb 18, 1995 · The concept of invading hordes of Aryans conquering northern India around 1500 BC arose in the nineteenth century for a variety of reasons.Missing: advocacy | Show results with:advocacy
  51. [51]
    In Search of the Cradle of Civilization: New Light on Ancient India
    But in this ground-breaking book, three renowned scholars show that there was no "Aryan invasion," and that India, not Sumer, was the cradle of civilized ...
  52. [52]
    In Search of the Cradle of Civilization: New Light on Ancient India
    30-day returnsRelying on a reexamination of redated Vedic literature and denying that an "Aryan invasion" from the north ever took place, which allegedly would have ...
  53. [53]
    Playing With Zero and Ancient History | by Subhash Kak - Medium
    May 11, 2018 · If one takes ancient India to be effectively zero in population and uses ancient DNA only from regions outside of it, one can “explain” anything ...
  54. [54]
    [PDF] Myth of Aryan Invasions of India--in Brief - University of West Florida
    Dr. Subhash Kak summarizes this line of research as follows: The new findings turn on its head the previous view of the origin of Indians.Missing: indigenous | Show results with:indigenous
  55. [55]
    Whence premium mediocrity in India? | by Subhash Kak - Medium
    Jun 12, 2020 · The historians strove to justify British Raj on two main points: 1. India is a mosaic of castes and not a nation; 2. Indians have no science, ...
  56. [56]
    [PDF] Indic Language Families and Indo-European
    Over the protestations of its many critics, mainstream historical linguistics has remained within the parameters of 19th century thinking. In the meanwhile ...
  57. [57]
    Subhash Kak, PhD – Selected Publications - ⋆ Taksha Institute
    Books (Selected). 1. R. Penrose, S. Hameroff, S. Kak (eds.) Consciousness and the Universe: Quantum Physics, Evolution, Brain & Mind.
  58. [58]
    On quantum neural computing - ScienceDirect.com
    This paper examines the notion of quantum neural computing in the context of several new directions in neural network research.
  59. [59]
    [1310.6333] Threshold Quantum Cryptography - arXiv
    Oct 23, 2013 · Threshold Quantum Cryptography. Authors:Subhash Kak. View a PDF of the paper titled Threshold Quantum Cryptography, by Subhash Kak. View PDF.
  60. [60]
    Subhash KAK - Oklahoma State University, Stillwater - ResearchGate
    Subhash KAK | Cited by 5544 | of Oklahoma State University, Stillwater (Oklahoma State) | Read 469 publications | Contact Subhash KAK.Missing: professor | Show results with:professor
  61. [61]
    [PDF] History of Indian Science
    History of Indian Science. Subhash Kak. July 31, 2002. Indian literature provides us with considerable layered evidence related to the ...Missing: key Indology
  62. [62]
    (PDF) A Brief History of Indian Science - Academia.edu
    A Brief History of Indian Science. Subhash Kak. INTRODUCTION. To consider the history of Indian science, one must first know why most educated people know ...Missing: Indology | Show results with:Indology
  63. [63]
    [PDF] GOVERNMENT OF INDIA - IGNCA
    Dec 11, 1996 · The Astronomical Code Of The Rigveda. SUBHASH C. KAR. The term Veda means 'knowledge'. When the Vedic. Samhitas are taken together with the ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  64. [64]
    Science and Spirituality: Subhash Kak - SHEHJAR
    He is also a Vedic scholar and archaeoastronomer. His discovery of a long-forgotten astronomy of ancient India, has been called "revolutionary" and "epoch- ...
  65. [65]
    https://bookstaa.com/products/in-search-of-the-cradle-of-civilization-new-light-on-ancient-india-georg-feuerstein-subhash-kak-david-frawley-9788120816268-8120816269-9788120820371-8120820371
  66. [66]
    [PDF] Birth and Early Development of Indian Astronomy - arXiv
    Kak, Subhash. “Vena, Veda, Venus.” Indian Journal of History of Science. 33: 25-30, 1998c. Kak, Subhash. “S¯ayan.a's astronomy.” Indian Journal of History of ...
  67. [67]
    Subhash KAK | Doctor of Philosophy | Research profile - Page 4
    Subhash KAK | Cited by 5521 | of Oklahoma State University, Stillwater (Oklahoma State) | Read 469 publications | Contact Subhash KAK.
  68. [68]
    The Indo-Aryan Controversy: Evidence and Inference in Indian ... - jstor
    unscholarly is rather well enunciated through the essays of Michael Witzel and Lars Martin Fosse. ... is appropriated by the indigenists, such as Subhash Kak in ...
  69. [69]
    Postmodernism, Hindu nationalism and `Vedic science' - Frontline
    Jan 16, 2004 · ... Subhash Kak, an engineer working in the United States. And a ... India · Postmodernism, Hindu nationalism and `Vedic science' · MEERA NANDA.
  70. [70]
    The Indo-Aryan Controversy | Evidence and Inference in Indian History
    Aug 2, 2004 · Edwin Bryant, Laurie Patton. Edition 1st Edition. First Published 2004 ... BySubhash Kak. Abstract. chapter 10|9 pages. The Textual Evidence.
  71. [71]
    [PDF] On the Science of Consciousness in Ancient India
    This paper presents a summary of the Vedic theory of consciousness, the most broad expression of Indian cognitive science, within a framework of contemporary ...
  72. [72]
    The Strange Fight over Science in India | by Subhash Kak - Medium
    May 29, 2023 · Let's come to India and look at its scientific tradition. The fight in the public sphere is whether any of it should be taught in schools and colleges.
  73. [73]
    "From Vedic Science to Vedanta" by Subhash C. Kak
    But recent scholarship has shown that astronomy was one of the bases of the design of Vedic fire altars and an astronomical code has been discovered in the ...Missing: scholarly criticism
  74. [74]
    [PDF] From Vedic Science To Ved¯anta
    The reason behind this situation is the fashionable but wrong view that Vedic thought is “pre-scientific” and at best it represents “archaic modes of thought”.
  75. [75]
    Indian Foundations of Modern Science | by Subhash Kak - Medium
    Jul 24, 2018 · Indian physics, which goes back to the Vaiśeṣika Sūtras (c. 500 BCE), is not believed to have directly influenced the discovery of physical laws ...
  76. [76]
    Subhash Kak - Independent Researcher - Academia.edu
    Subhash Kak: 5644 Followers, 24 Following, 132 Research papers. Research interests: Sanskrit, Vedic Studies, and History of Astronomy.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  77. [77]
    The Mind's Sky: On computers and consciousness | by Subhash Kak
    Jan 19, 2024 · The Mind's Sky: On computers and consciousness The world is worried about where technology is going ... Get Subhash Kak's stories in your inbox.
  78. [78]
    Matter and Mind: The Vaiśeṣika Sūtra of Kaṇāda - Goodreads
    Rating 4.3 (28) Oct 20, 2022 · Subhash Kak ... Matter and Mind is a new translation of the nearly 2,500-year old Vaiśeṣika Sūtra of Kaṇāda together with an introductory essay ...
  79. [79]
    A Lover of Indian Wisdom by Subhash Kak, PhD - Infinity Foundation
    by Subhash Kak, PhD. Although the recent success of Indians in the ... Just to give an example, consider IIT Delhi, my own old school. It has 14 ...
  80. [80]
    The Age of Artificial Intelligence: Kak, Subhash - Amazon.com
    The Age of Artificial Intelligence summarizes new developments in AI, its challenges and limitations in the background of evolving geopolitical equations.
  81. [81]
    Subhash Kak Explores AI's Role In Mastering the Future ...
    May 17, 2025 · Subhash Kak's book The Age of Artificial Intelligence thoughtfully explores AI's trajectory, blending technical insight with philosophical, historical, and ...
  82. [82]
    AI and World Population by 2300 - Subhash Kak - Medium
    Jun 25, 2025 · I have described many economic and geopolitical implications of AI in my book The Age of Artificial Intelligence (2025). ... Get Subhash Kak's ...
  83. [83]
    AI could 'devastate' Earth's population down to the size of the UK by ...
    Jun 2, 2025 · Computer science professor Subhash Kak predicted that artificial intelligence will become so omnipresent on the planet that Earth will have ...