Truthdare Doubledare
Truthdare Doubledare is the second studio album by the British synth-pop and dance band Bronski Beat, released in May 1986.[1][2] Following the departure of original lead vocalist Jimmy Somerville in 1985, the album introduced John Foster (also known as John Jøn) as the new frontman.[1][3] The record, produced by Adam Williams and featuring contributions from collaborators like Marc Almond on one track, comprises 11 songs characterized by hi-NRG beats and electronic production typical of mid-1980s dance music.[4][5] Lead single "Hit That Perfect Beat" achieved commercial success, peaking at number 3 on the UK Singles Chart, while follow-up "C'mon! C'mon!" reached the Top 20.[6] The album itself entered the UK Albums Chart at number 18 and spent six weeks in the Top 100.[6][1] Though it continued Bronski Beat's exploration of dance-oriented synth-pop, Truthdare Doubledare received mixed critical reception, with some reviewers noting Foster's competent but less distinctive vocals compared to Somerville's, contributing to diminished impact relative to the band's debut The Age of Consent.[7][4] No major controversies surrounded the release, though the vocalist transition marked a pivotal shift in the band's trajectory amid the evolving 1980s electronic music scene.[5]Background
Formation and initial success of Bronski Beat
Bronski Beat formed in 1983 in London when Jimmy Somerville (vocals), Steve Bronski (keyboards), and Larry Steinbachek (keyboards and percussion) began collaborating after meeting through youth media initiatives, including the documentary Framed Youth: Revenge of the Teenage Rappers. All three members were openly gay and shared a flat in Brixton, which facilitated their creative output in synth-pop infused with direct commentary on gay life, including experiences of rejection and societal marginalization.[8][9][10] The band's debut single, "Smalltown Boy," released on 25 May 1984, narrates the departure of a young gay man from a hostile small town to an urban environment, capturing themes of homophobia and outsider status that gained traction during the early stages of the AIDS epidemic in the UK, where the first cases had been identified three years prior. The track peaked at number 3 on the UK Singles Chart, marking a breakthrough by blending hi-NRG electronic elements with unflinching social critique.[11][12][13] Released on 15 October 1984, their debut album The Age of Consent reached number 4 on the UK Albums Chart, propelled by "Smalltown Boy" and follow-up singles like "Why?" The album's liner notes listed disparate ages of consent for homosexual acts worldwide, emphasizing legal disparities and cultural stigma without compromising artistic integrity for broader commercial viability. This positioned Bronski Beat as early innovators in queer-themed synth-pop, achieving chart success through authentic representation rather than evasion of controversial subjects.[14][6][14]Departure of Jimmy Somerville and lineup transition
Jimmy Somerville departed Bronski Beat in the summer of 1985 following internal tensions within the group.[15] He quickly formed The Communards alongside keyboardist Richard Coles, shifting focus to a new musical project that debuted later that year.[16] The band's instrumental core, consisting of Steve Bronski and Larry Steinbachek, sought to sustain operations by recruiting John Foster—also credited as Jon Jon—as the replacement lead vocalist.[17] This lineup change preserved the synth-driven foundation of Bronski Beat's sound while adapting to Foster's vocal style, which lacked Somerville's signature falsetto range and emotional intensity.[18] The transition underscored the challenges of substituting a frontman whose persona had defined the band's early identity and commercial appeal, with Bronski expressing confidence in Foster's fit despite the inherent risks to continuity.[19]Recording and production
Studio sessions and key collaborators
The album Truthdare Doubledare was recorded at Berry Street Studio and The Scout Hut in London, with mixing handled at Mayfair Studios.[20] Production duties were led by Adam Williams, who also performed on bass guitar and had previously worked with acts such as Eurythmics.[4] [21] Gareth Jones served as mixer, contributing to the album's polished electronic sound.[3] Sessions took place in 1985 and early 1986 under the oversight of London Records, prior to the album's release on MCA Records in some markets.[22] Core band members Steve Bronski and Larry Steinbachek handled keyboards and programming, while new vocalist John Foster's integration shaped the recording process, emphasizing layered synthesizers to define the hi-NRG and synth-pop arrangements.[4] No external guest musicians are credited on the album.[21]Production techniques and challenges
The production of Truthdare Doubledare relied heavily on synthesizers such as the Yamaha DX7 and TX816, MemoryMoog, PPG, Sequential Circuits Pro-One, OSCar, and MiniMoog, integrated with drum machines including the LinnDrum, Roland TR-707, TR-727, and Yamaha RX11 for crafting dance-oriented hi-NRG beats.[23] Sampling was facilitated by Akai units and an Emulator II, while the Yamaha QX1 sequencer structured tracks by layering bass lines, melodies, and chord progressions that blended acoustic instruments like guitars with electronic elements.[23] Vocals were typically recorded last in the control room for a more organic performance feel, using headphones to overlay them onto pre-built instrumental beds.[23] Adam Williams oversaw production, with Tom Frederikse handling engineering and Gareth Jones mixing at Hansa Studios in Berlin.[24] For the single "Hit That Perfect Beat," Mike Thorne contributed production using his New England Digital Synclavier for FM synthesis and digital sampling, alongside a large Serge modular synthesizer and the band's existing gear to generate the track's distinctive electronic textures.[25] Key challenges arose from equipment limitations, including the MemoryMoog's frequent instability caused by heat buildup in its 18 oscillators and the Yamaha RX11's constrained sample memory, which hindered complex drum programming.[23] The band also faced difficulties during the New York sessions for "Hit That Perfect Beat," ultimately deeming the results inferior to their Denmark Street demo and opting for revisions to preserve the raw energy.[23] These hurdles, compounded by the need to adapt production layers to John Foster's more straightforward vocal delivery after Jimmy Somerville's falsetto-driven style, led to denser sonic arrangements aimed at sustaining commercial momentum.[26]Musical content
Style and influences
Truthdare Doubledare employs a synth-pop framework infused with hi-NRG dynamics, featuring synthesizer-heavy arrangements and upbeat electronic propulsion suited for dance environments.[1] Tracks such as "Hit That Perfect Beat" exemplify this through rapid tempos around 140 beats per minute and emphatic basslines, marking a refinement from the debut album's comparatively rawer synth textures toward sleeker, club-oriented production.[7][27] Spanning 11 tracks and roughly 50 minutes in duration, the album emphasizes relentless rhythm sections and layered percussion over melodic foregrounding, which facilitates the integration of the replacement vocalist's less idiosyncratic delivery.[2] This structural focus aligns with hi-NRG conventions, prioritizing dancefloor momentum derived from disco's evolution into faster electronic forms.[7] The sound draws from the British electronic tradition while incorporating Eurodisco production methods, including those associated with Giorgio Moroder's synthesizer-driven techniques from the late 1970s, as seen in the pulsating sequences and octave bass patterns throughout.[28]Lyrics and thematic elements
The lyrics of Truthdare Doubledare, primarily credited to Steve Bronski, Larry Steinbachek, and new lead vocalist John Jon, shift toward explorations of interpersonal vulnerability, romantic risk, and emotional caution compared to the debut album's more explicit treatments of gay identity and societal rejection, such as in "Smalltown Boy."[1][29] This change aligns with Jon's songwriting involvement post-Jimmy Somerville's departure, emphasizing universal relational dynamics over targeted activism.[1] Tracks like the title song "Truthdare Doubledare" depict love as fraught with defensive posturing and fear, with lines such as "Gotta be careful who I meet tonight / Put up the struggle, I'll put up the fight / Loving is different, so full of fear" illustrating a hedonistic pursuit tempered by anticipatory barriers in an era of cultural restraint.[30] Similarly, "Punishment For Love" examines the causal fallout of unchecked romantic idealism, portraying infatuation as self-inflicted hardship where "love's a crime" invites personal reckoning without recourse to external victimhood.[29] These elements prioritize raw emotional realism, reflecting desires constrained by internal and social hesitations rather than declarative protest. Other songs, including "Hit That Perfect Beat," evoke escapist rhythms amid relational disconnection—"Searching for some company / Feel the rhythm dance with me"—highlighting desire's tension with isolation, while "We Know How It Feels" acknowledges cruelty through name-calling as an "exception to the rule," downplaying systemic narratives in favor of resigned endurance.[31] Overall, the album's content foregrounds hedonic impulses against 1980s conservatism's undercurrents, crediting Bronski and Steinbachek's core contributions for a less politicized, more introspective lens on human connection.[1]Singles and promotion
Released singles
"Hit That Perfect Beat" served as the lead single from Truthdare Doubledare, released in November 1985 on London Records in formats including 7-inch and 12-inch vinyl.[32] The 12-inch edition featured extended mixes tailored for club DJs, with a runtime exceeding seven minutes, and was backed by the B-side "I Gave You Everything".[33] It peaked at number 3 on the UK Singles Chart, marking Bronski Beat's highest-charting release post-Somerville.[6] The follow-up single, "C'mon! C'mon!", arrived in March 1986, also via London Records, primarily in 12-inch format with extended versions and the B-side "Something Special".[32] This track emphasized the band's dance-oriented sound, including percussive elements and instrumental breaks to suit club play.[1] It reached number 20 on the UK Singles Chart.[6] Both singles were strategically released to build anticipation for the album's May 1986 launch, prioritizing the group's electronic dance credentials through remixes and vinyl formats optimized for nightlife venues rather than lyrical narratives.[1] No further singles were issued from the album in major markets.[34]Marketing and tour support
MCA Records and London Records supported the release of Truthdare Doubledare through targeted promotion of lead singles "Hit That Perfect Beat" and "C'mon! C'mon!", distributing 12-inch extended mixes to clubs and securing radio airplay to capitalize on the hi-NRG dance scene.[1] These remixes emphasized dancefloor appeal, aligning with the album's synth-pop production to drive club visibility and playlist inclusion. The band conducted a limited promotional tour across the UK and Europe in 1986, featuring live sets that integrated tracks from Truthdare Doubledare with staples from The Age of Consent to underscore musical continuity amid the vocalist transition from Jimmy Somerville to John Jøn.[35] Key appearances included a BBC Radio 1 session for the Janice Long show, performing "Hit That Perfect Beat" and "In My Dreams" to leverage national broadcast reach.[36] Additional outings, such as the Azzurro Festival in Bari, Italy on April 26, 1986, extended European exposure.[37] Marketing addressed lineup skepticism via interviews highlighting the core rhythm section's persistence and thematic consistency on social issues, yet these efforts struggled against perceptions of diminished vocal charisma, limiting broader fan buy-in despite TV slots like Top of the Pops on January 2, 1986.[38] Promotional focus on visibility through media and remixes prioritized short-term single momentum but failed to fully mitigate the "post-Somerville" narrative.[7]Commercial performance
Chart positions
"Truthdare Doubledare" peaked at number 18 on the UK Albums Chart, entering the top 75 on 11 May 1986 and spending six weeks on the chart overall.[39] The album also reached number 147 on the US Billboard 200.[4]| Chart (1986) | Peak position |
|---|---|
| UK Albums (OCC) | 18[39] |
| US Billboard 200 | 147[4] |
| Single | Chart (1986) | Peak position |
|---|---|---|
| "Hit That Perfect Beat" | UK Singles (OCC) | 3[6] |
| "C'mon! C'mon!" | UK Singles (OCC) | 20+ (Top 20)[40] |
Sales figures and certifications
Truthdare Doubledare achieved no certifications from major recording industry associations, such as the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) or the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), reflecting its limited commercial penetration.[4] Specific global sales figures remain undocumented in public records, though contemporaneous accounts describe the album as a significant underperformer relative to Bronski Beat's debut The Age of Consent, which had leveraged the breakout success of singles like "Smalltown Boy" to drive stronger unit sales.[41][4] This disparity underscores the challenges posed by the transition from Jimmy Somerville to John Foster as lead vocalist, which disrupted the band's established momentum without compensatory gains in broader markets. In the US, sales were particularly modest, confined largely to niche dance audiences without achieving mainstream thresholds for recognition. Later digital streaming equivalents, while registering some post-2010s upticks via platforms like Spotify, do not retroactively elevate the original era's empirically subdued physical and initial sales performance.[4][42]Reception and analysis
Contemporary critical reviews
Upon its release in May 1986, Truthdare Doubledare elicited mixed critical responses, with reviewers frequently highlighting the album's energetic production and club-oriented beats while lamenting the absence of Jimmy Somerville's distinctive falsetto, which had defined Bronski Beat's debut. The replacement vocalist, John Foster, was deemed competent yet insufficiently charismatic to sustain the band's prior intensity, resulting in perceptions of diluted identity.[7] In the United States, Rolling Stone's Jim Farber, writing on August 14, 1986, contextualized the album against the debut's explicit gay consciousness themes, noting the stylistic evolution but implying a shortfall in maintaining that raw edge amid Foster's more conventional delivery. Similarly, a Trouser Press assessment characterized the record as "a halfbaked progression from the first album," crediting the beats' dancefloor viability but faulting Foster as "a competent but far less distinctive singer" unable to replicate Somerville's impact.[7] UK publications echoed this ambivalence, praising tracks like "Hit That Perfect Beat" for their propulsion while questioning the album's thematic depth and cohesion beyond singles. Sounds' Chris Roberts, in a May 10, 1986 review, explored the band's post-Somerville reinvention through Foster, portraying it as an attempt to recapture youthful defiance but critiquing the resultant shift toward broader pop accessibility over the debut's pointed lyricism.[43] Overall, commentators viewed commercial viability as hinging on individual cuts' club traction rather than holistic innovation, reflecting empirical disappointment in the sophomore effort's failure to match The Age of Consent's cultural punch.[44]Retrospective evaluations and comparisons
Retrospective evaluations have frequently characterized Truthdare Doubledare as a quintessential "difficult second album," hampered by the irreplaceable departure of Jimmy Somerville's distinctive falsetto vocals, which had defined Bronski Beat's breakthrough with The Age of Consent in 1984.[7] In a 2025 ranking by Classic Pop Magazine, the album placed 16th among challenging sophomore efforts, highlighting the inherent risks of replacing a charismatic frontman so early, though acknowledging the hi-NRG drive of lead single "Hit That Perfect Beat" as a partial salvage.[44] Critics note that new vocalist John Foster, while competent, lacked Somerville's piercing, emotive range, resulting in tracks that prioritized energetic synth-dance propulsion over the debut's raw, culturally resonant edge.[45] [7] Comparisons to the debut underscore a diminished artistic and commercial potency, with Truthdare Doubledare failing to replicate The Age of Consent's fusion of hi-NRG beats and pointed social commentary that propelled "Smalltown Boy" to ubiquity.[44] AllMusic's assessment emphasizes this shortfall, rating the album middling for its dance-floor focus but critiquing the absence of emotional depth that Somerville's voice uniquely provided, presaging the band's ensuing lineup flux and reduced relevance.[45] Market data supports this causal view: Somerville's vocal timbre, not merely thematic content, drove crossover appeal, as evidenced by the debut's stronger sales trajectory and the sophomore's inability to sustain momentum without it.[7] [44] On a more affirmative note, select tracks like "Hit That Perfect Beat" have endured within hi-NRG circles for their relentless, octave-spanning basslines and club-ready production, influencing later electronic dance acts by demonstrating the genre's viability post-disco commercialization.[44] [4] However, broader retrospectives avoid overstating nostalgic revival, grounding the album's legacy in empirical metrics of listener engagement and chart persistence, where it trails the debut's lasting replay value.[46]Track listing
The track listing for the original vinyl LP edition, released in 1986, consists of nine tracks.[47] [48]| No. | Title | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Hit That Perfect Beat" | 3:38 |
| 2 | "Truthdare Doubledare" | 4:43 |
| 3 | "C'mon! C'mon!" | 3:50 |
| 4 | "Punishment for Love" | 4:14 |
| 5 | "We Know How It Feels" | 4:13 |
| 6 | "This Heart" | 4:19 |
| 7 | "Sometimes" | 4:06 |
| 8 | "Shedding Tears for You" | 5:14 |
| 9 | "Hard Rain" | 3:30 |
Personnel
John Foster provided lead vocals on Truthdare Doubledare.[3] Steve Bronski handled keyboards and programming, while Larry Steinbachek contributed percussion and synthesizers as the core Bronski Beat lineup following Jimmy Somerville's departure.[1] [50] Additional musicians- Backing vocals: Beverley Skeete, Jay Carly, Mike Myers Major Minors, P.P. Arnold[51]
- Brass arrangements and performance: The Kick Horns[51]
- Percussion: Tony Marone[20]
- Nose flute: Tim Wheater[20]
- Producer: Adam Williams[24]
- Engineer: Tom Frederikse[24]
- Mixing engineer: Gareth Jones[24]
- Anthony Kawalski (management), Pete Riches (personal assistant)[20]