Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Anthony Parnes

Anthony Keith Parnes (born June 1945) is a British former primarily known for his role in the 1986 Guinness share-trading during the takeover battle for . As one of the "Guinness Four," alongside , , and Jack Lyons, Parnes facilitated the acquisition and distribution of shares to supportive investors, contributing to an illegal scheme that artificially inflated the stock price to secure the £2.5 billion acquisition. In August 1990, he was convicted at of and false , receiving a 30-month sentence that was reduced to 21 months on appeal. Prior to the scandal, Parnes had built a career rising from an office boy to a millionaire broker, but the convictions led to his imprisonment and professional downfall, with ongoing associations limited to family business ties via records.

Early Life and Career

Background and Entry into Finance

Anthony Parnes, the son of a London gown manufacturer, entered the financial sector without formal or family connections in . Parnes began his career at the bottom rung as an office boy, performing clerical tasks on the trading floor of the Stock Exchange, where such roles were colloquially known as 'blue buttons'. He joined the firm A. J. Bekhor, a stockbroking house, marking his initial exposure to market operations through hands-on errands and support duties typical of entry-level positions in the exchange during the mid-20th century. This apprenticeship-style entry allowed Parnes to gain practical knowledge of share trading amid the bustling, less regulated environment of the pre-Big Bang era markets.

Rise as a Stockbroker

Anthony Keith Parnes, born to a London gown manufacturer, entered the financial sector at the entry level as an office boy—commonly known as a "blue button" or messenger—in the . He began this role with the firm A.J. Bekhor, performing rudimentary tasks such as delivering messages and orders on the trading floor, a typical starting point for aspiring brokers in the mid-20th century City of . Parnes advanced through several stockbroking firms, gaining experience at Rowe Rudd and McNally after his initial stint at Bekhor. By the , he had established himself as a dealer, eventually joining Alexander Laing & Cruickshank as a "half-commission" man, or introducing broker, where he brought in clients and shared commissions on trades. This position allowed him greater autonomy, handling transactions for high-profile clients and accumulating over two decades of market expertise by the late 1980s. His ascent was marked by an aggressive, high-volume trading style that earned him the nickname "The Animal," reportedly due to his distinctive hairstyle and relentless deal-making approach. Parnes became a prominent figure in takeover battles, including the earlier Debenhams bid, positioning him as a go-to broker for substantial share dealings among the City's elite. By the mid-1980s, he had risen to millionaire status, acting for some of the largest names in share trading and solidifying his reputation as a self-made force in London's financial markets.

The Guinness Share-Trading Affair

Context of the Guinness-Distillers Bid

In late 1985, plc, a leading Scottish producer of and gin with key brands including , , and Gordon's, became the target of acquisition interest amid the era's aggressive corporate activity in the UK beverages sector. On 2 December 1985, Argyll Group plc, a diversified with operations, launched a hostile bid for valued at approximately £2.3 billion, prompting concerns from Distillers' management over strategic fit and independence. Distillers' board rejected the offer and sought a friendly alternative to preserve its whisky-focused heritage. Guinness plc, an established brewer known for its and having recently expanded into Scotch via the June 1985 acquisition of Arthur Bell & Sons, positioned itself as a complementary "" suitor to counter Argyll's advances. On 20 January 1986, announced an initial offer of £2.5 billion, which ' board recommended to shareholders as superior in value and synergy for building a broader international spirits portfolio. The bid structure combined cash and shares—specifically, eight ordinary shares plus £6.50 in cash for every five shares—making the effective valuation sensitive to fluctuations in 's share price. The contest escalated through multiple revisions, with countering aggressively while leveraged its beverage expertise to appeal to stakeholders. By April , secured 50.74% of ' shares, clinching the deal at a final value of £2.7 billion (equivalent to about $4.1 billion), marking one of Britain's largest takeovers to date and forming the basis for future industry consolidation leading to entities like United Distillers. This outcome reflected broader trends in mergers, where share-backed bids incentivized tactics to stabilize bidder valuations amid market volatility.

Parnes's Role in Share Support Operations

Anthony Parnes, a stockbroker, coordinated key aspects of the illicit share support scheme during Guinness plc's January 1986 takeover bid for plc, valued at approximately £2.5 billion. As part of this operation, Parnes recruited investors and facilitated the purchase of substantial volumes of shares to artificially elevate the stock price, thereby making Guinness's paper offer more competitive against Group's rival cash bid. His efforts included enlisting participants such as Ephraim Margulies of S&W Beresford plc to acquire shares, with Guinness providing indemnities against potential losses to incentivize these buys. Parnes submitted multiple false invoices to , disguising payments for share purchases and related support activities as legitimate fees for "intelligence gathering" and advisory services. disbursed £3.35 million to Parnes under these pretexts, which prosecutors later established funded the scheme's mechanics, including reimbursements to buyers and success fees upon the bid's success. These transactions formed the basis of his convictions for four counts of false and two counts of theft, as the scheme violated laws against and fraudulent inducement of share trades. The support operations, in which Parnes actively participated alongside figures like and Jack Lyons, involved secret cross-border funding and purchases totaling hundreds of millions of pounds in stock, propping up the share price from around 150p to over 220p during the bid contest. Parnes's brokerage network enabled rapid execution of these trades, often through entities to obscure origins, though investigations revealed the payments traced back to 's corporate funds without shareholder approval. This role underscored the scheme's reliance on insider coordination to circumvent regulations, with Parnes's compensation reflecting the high-risk, high-volume trading he orchestrated.

Charges and Trial

Anthony Parnes was formally charged on March 24, 1988, with and related to his role in the Guinness share support scheme during the 1986 Distillers takeover bid. The prosecution alleged that Parnes, through his company, dishonestly obtained approximately £3.35 million from by submitting invoices falsely claiming the funds were for "intelligence gathering" and advisory services, when they were actually compensation for orchestrating purchases of shares to artificially prop up the stock price amid the competitive bid. These charges specified two counts of and either four or five counts of , focusing on the of payments in 's financial records to conceal the illicit nature of the transactions. The trial against Parnes and his co-defendants—Ernest Saunders, Gerald Ronson, and Jack Lyons—began on February 13, 1990, at in , selected due to the case's scale requiring larger facilities than the could provide. Described by financial observers as the "City trial of the century," the proceedings spanned over six months and featured testimony from dozens of witnesses, including bankers, investors, and executives, alongside examination of thousands of documents detailing share transactions and offshore payments. Prosecutors contended that Parnes, a flamboyant nicknamed "," actively recruited overseas investors—such as institutions in and —to acquire more than 40 million shares, enabling the company to issue additional stock in its £2.7 billion offer for without diluting value excessively. Parnes's defense maintained that the payments were legitimate success fees for legitimate deal facilitation and market intelligence, denying any intent to deceive shareholders or regulators. Central to the trial evidence were records showing funds routed through Parnes's entities, including Triumph Investment Management, with payments approved by Saunders but not disclosed to Guinness's board or the Takeover Panel, violating stock market rules against share manipulation. The case highlighted tensions between aggressive tactics and duties, with prosecutors emphasizing how the scheme distorted market pricing and potentially misled rival bidders like Argyll Group. No prior convictions marred Parnes's record at the time, and the challenged the admissibility of certain overseas banking obtained via cooperation.

Verdict and Sentencing

On August 27, 1990, Anthony Parnes was convicted at the in on four counts of false and two counts of related to his involvement in illicit share support schemes during plc's 1986 bid for . The jury delivered guilty verdicts following a lengthy trial that examined Parnes's role in coordinating undisclosed payments and trades to artificially inflate shares, including transfers exceeding £6 million to his accounts. The next day, August 28, 1990, Mr Justice Denis Henry sentenced Parnes to 30 months' , emphasizing the deliberate involved in the operations that distorted market integrity. Unlike co-defendants , who received a £5 million fine alongside his term, Parnes faced no additional financial penalty at sentencing, though he had been expelled from the earlier. Parnes collapsed in court shortly after the verdict due to the strain of overnight detention, resuming proceedings upon recovery.

Appeals and Controversies

UK Appeals and Sentence Reductions

Following his on August 22, 1990, for false accounting and theft in connection with the Guinness share-support operations, Anthony Parnes was sentenced to 30 months' imprisonment and ordered to pay £440,000 in costs. Parnes immediately appealed both the conviction and sentence to the . In a ruling that reduced the penalties without overturning the conviction, the court shortened the prison term to 21 months and the costs order to £250,000, citing mitigating factors in the sentencing while upholding the jury's verdict on the substantive charges. Parnes and his co-defendants, known as the "Guinness Four," pursued further domestic appeals in the late 1990s and early 2000s to challenge the convictions themselves, arguing procedural irregularities including the admissibility of Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) interview transcripts and claims of an unfair trial. On December 21, 2001, the Court of Appeal dismissed these contentions, rejecting arguments that the defendants had been denied a fair hearing and affirming the original trial's integrity. The appellants then sought leave to appeal to the , contending that the use of compelled statements violated principles of . On November 14, 2002, the dismissed the final UK appeal, maintaining the convictions and declining to grant relief despite acknowledging related concerns that were later addressed in proceedings. These outcomes exhausted domestic remedies, with no further sentence reductions granted beyond the initial appellate adjustment.

European Human Rights Challenges and Scapegoating Claims

In 1996, Anthony Parnes, alongside and Jack Lyons, lodged an application with the (ECHR), contending that their 1990 trial for offenses related to the Guinness share-support scheme violated Article 6 of the , which mandates a fair hearing by an independent tribunal. The applicants argued that the prosecution's reliance on transcripts from compulsory interviews conducted by the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI)—interviews in which they were legally required to answer questions under threat of penalties—compromised their right against and led to unfair adverse inferences. On August 4, 1999, the ECHR's Chamber ruled unanimously that the use of such compelled evidence had indeed rendered the trial unfair, as it breached the privilege against protected under Article 6, though the Court awarded no damages beyond costs. The ECHR's finding prompted Parnes and his co-applicants to seek to reopen their cases in the UK Court of Appeal, invoking the then-forthcoming , which incorporated the into domestic law effective October 2, 2000. They contended that the Act should apply retrospectively to quash convictions predating it, given the identified procedural flaws. However, in December 2001, the Court of Appeal dismissed their renewed appeals, holding that the did not permit retrospective invalidation of final convictions absent exceptional circumstances, and that the trial's overall fairness had not been impugned beyond the specific evidential issue already addressed by the ECHR. The upheld this in November 2002, rejecting further arguments for retroactivity and affirming that the ECHR ruling did not automatically entitle the applicants to acquittals, as domestic courts retained discretion over evidential admissibility at the time of trial. Parnes has consistently portrayed his conviction as unjust, aligning with broader claims by the so-called Four that they were to exemplify regulatory crackdowns on financial excesses amid public outrage over corporate greed. In 2015, , then a peer, publicly advocated for a into the affair, asserting that Jewish businessmen including Parnes—described as targeted due to their heritage—were disproportionately prosecuted in what he called an anti-Semitic effort to find villains for the bid's irregularities, citing warnings from a minister about authorities "going after the ." These allegations, echoed in parliamentary debates, point to purported inconsistencies in enforcement, such as lighter treatment of non-Jewish participants and the subsequent dementia-related pardon of in 1996, but lack independent corroboration and have been dismissed by prosecutors as revisionist defenses unsubstantiated by evidence of . Parnes's legal team reiterated scapegoating themes in post-ECHR submissions, arguing amid the era's political pressure for high-profile convictions, though courts found no merit in claims of or evidential suppression. The , reviewing Parnes's case as recently as September 2024, declined referral to the Court of Appeal, citing insufficient new evidence or arguments to undermine the original verdict despite the dimension.

Personal Life and Later Years

Family and Relationships

Anthony Parnes was married to Denise Ratner, the sister of British jewelry businessman . The marriage, which occurred prior to the Guinness share-trading scandal, ended in divorce following Parnes's 1990 conviction and subsequent imprisonment. Parnes and Ratner had two children together: a son, Michael Parnes, who later entered the industry as a broker, and a daughter. No further marriages or long-term relationships for Parnes are documented in available records.

Post-Conviction Activities and Family Legacy

Following his release from Ford Open Prison in July 1992 after serving 11 months of a reduced 21-month , Anthony Parnes adopted a low public profile, having been expelled from the Stock Exchange due to his conviction. He resided quietly in with his son, avoiding involvement in financial markets or public commentary on the scandal. Parnes's marriage to Denise Ratner, sister of jeweler and a wealthy heiress, ended in shortly after the Guinness affair and his imprisonment, which strained family relations. The couple had one son, Michael Parnes, born during their marriage. Michael Parnes pursued a career in stockbroking, entering the finance sector despite his father's notoriety. In May 2006, at age 25, he facilitated a significant deal linking Far East investors to property opportunities through his role at a brokerage firm, marking an early professional milestone. By 2010, Michael had established himself further, leveraging family connections in business networks. This continuation in finance represents a partial family legacy, though Anthony Parnes himself refrained from professional resurgence or mentorship in the field post-release.

References

  1. [1]
    Anthony Keith PARNES personal appointments - Companies House
    Free company information from Companies House including registered office address, filing history, accounts, annual return, officers, charges, ...
  2. [2]
    Guinness Four Are Found Guilty of Share-Trading Fraud - EBSCO
    Anthony Parnes (fl. 1980's), British millionaire stock broker; Ivan Boesky (b. 1937), American stock trader. Summary of Event. The Guinness Four trading-fraud ...
  3. [3]
    27 | 1990: 'Guinness Four' guilty - BBC ON THIS DAY
    Saunders, Ronson and Lyons were convicted of conspiracy, theft and false accounting. Parnes, 45, was found guilty on the theft and false accounting charges.
  4. [4]
    Parnes, Anthony - Criminal Cases Review Commission
    Sep 9, 2024 · Anthony Parnes was convicted in August 1990 of theft and false accounting. Mr Parnes received a sentence of 30 months' imprisonment (reduced on appeal to 21 ...
  5. [5]
    Life and high-flying times of four partners in crime - The Scotsman
    Dec 22, 2001 · The son of a London gown manufacturer, Parnes, started his working life as an office boy with a stockbroker. Advertisement. Hide Ad.Missing: Anthony | Show results with:Anthony
  6. [6]
    CREED OF GREED - AFR
    Sep 14, 1990 · Parnes was described as "a man of the floor not a man of the rule book" despite more than 20 years in the Stock Exchange. Parnes was paid ...
  7. [7]
    GUINNESS CASE WILL TEST CORPORATE MORALITY - AFR
    Feb 12, 1990 · ... Anthony Parnes, a former leading City stockbroker at Laing and Cruickshank nicknamed"The Animal" because of his hairstyle; and Sir Jack ...
  8. [8]
    The City And Industry - Hansard - UK Parliament
    Jan 28, 1987 · The eminent stockbroker referred to at the start of that quotation is said, in the Financial Times of today, to have been Mr. Tony Parnes who is ...Missing: career | Show results with:career
  9. [9]
    Guinness crooks who framed me - Daily Express
    May 22, 2009 · ... Tony Parnes. He had a reputation for being pretty flamboyant, having started as an office boy and worked his way up to become a big deal at ...Missing: Anthony stockbroker
  10. [10]
    Strong foundations: The history of Diageo precursor Distillers ...
    Jan 6, 2025 · In 1997, Guinness merged with Grand Metropolitan to form Diageo, a behemoth in the alcoholic-beverages industry. Today, Diageo is the world's ...
  11. [11]
    [PDF] 1989/13 - THE TAKEOVER PANEL
    The initial Argyll offer was made on. 2 December 1985. On 20 January 1986 Guinness also announced an offer for. Distillers, which was recommended by the board ...
  12. [12]
  13. [13]
    The way Guinness rigged the takeover | The Independent
    Feb 21, 1993 · IN JANUARY 1986, Guinness launched a record-breaking pounds 2.5bn takeover bid for the Distillers Scotch whisky group.
  14. [14]
    Guinness Bids $3.2 Billion for Scotch Distiller - Los Angeles Times
    Jan 21, 1986 · Guinness, whose value is put at half that of Distillers, is offering eight of its ordinary shares and $10 in cash for every five shares of ...
  15. [15]
    GUINNESS OFFERS TO BUY DISTILLERS FOR $3.2 BILLION
    Jan 21, 1986 · Arthur Guinness & Sons P.L.C. today announced a record $3.2 billion bid for the Distillers Company, the world's leading maker of Scotch ...Missing: 1985 | Show results with:1985<|separator|>
  16. [16]
    GUINNESS BESTS ARGYLL TO ACQUIRE DISTILLERS CO.
    Apr 19, 1986 · The final Guinness bid was worth $:2.7 billion, or $4.1 billion, according to a Guinness spokesman, Alan Stewart, making it one of the two ...
  17. [17]
    Guinness Wins Takeover Battle for Distillers : Giant Defeats Argyll ...
    Apr 21, 1986 · London-based Guinness PLC defeated Argyll Foods PLC by securing 50.74% of the shares in Distillers, a Scottish company which wanted the merger ...Missing: context | Show results with:context
  18. [18]
    GUINNESS INVESTIGATION LOOKS AT STOCK ACTION
    Dec 4, 1986 · That price surge helped the brewing company win Distillers because both of the competing bids were partly in cash, partly in stock.
  19. [19]
    The way Guinness rigged the takeover
    ### Summary of Anthony Parnes's Role in the Guinness Takeover Share Support Scheme
  20. [20]
    BUSINESS | Guinness Four fail in fight for acquittal - BBC News
    Dec 21, 2001 · Jack Lyons, Anthony Parnes, Gerald Ronson and Ernest Saunders have failed to clear their names after 15 years of legal battles in the UK and on the Continent.
  21. [21]
    [PDF] PRACTICAL LESSONS FROM UK CASES
    Two further false invoices were submitted to Guinness and paid in respect of support recruited by Parnes from Ephraim Margulies, chairman of S & W Beresford plc ...<|separator|>
  22. [22]
    London stockbroker arrested in Guinness case - UPI Archives
    Mar 24, 1988 · Anthony Parnes, 42, who was held for six months in Los Angeles on an extradition warrant, was charged with stealing the money diverted through ...Missing: career rise
  23. [23]
    'Guinness four' launch third appeal | UK news | The Guardian
    Saunders and co-defendants Gerald Ronson, Jack Lyons and Anthony Parnes were found guilty for their various roles in a scheme to boost Guinness' share price ...
  24. [24]
    Ex-Guinness Chief Guilty of Conspiracy : Courts: A London jury ...
    Aug 27, 1990 · Former stockbroker Anthony Parnes, 44, was found guilty of four charges of false accounting and two of theft. The jury convicted millionaire ...
  25. [25]
    Guinness, &apos;City trial of century&apos;, begins - The Herald
    Feb 12, 1990 · charge of theft. Anthony Keith Parnes, 44, faces five charges of false accounting, and. two charges of theft. Sir Isidore Jack Lyons, 74, faces ...<|separator|>
  26. [26]
    Trial Begins in Guinness Stock Case - The New York Times
    Feb 13, 1990 · So did Anthony K. Parnes, a former stockbrocker. Gerald Ronson, chairman of Heron International, and Sir Jack Lyons, the millionnaire financier ...Missing: career Exchange
  27. [27]
    Guinness Four lose appeal | UK news | The Guardian
    Dec 21, 2001 · The court of appeal today rejected the latest appeal by Ernest Saunders and three co-defendants from the 1990 Guinness trial against their convictions.
  28. [28]
    European court rules Guinness trial unfair | UK news | The Guardian
    Sep 19, 2000 · Gerald Ronson, Jack Lyons and Anthony Parnes were found guilty in 1990 of colluding in an unlawful scheme set up to support the Guinness ...
  29. [29]
    Ex-Guinness chairman imprisoned for 5 years - UPI Archives
    Aug 28, 1990 · Parnes, 45, collapsed in Southwark Crown Court as Justice Denis Henry began to address him on his conviction on charges of false accounting ...
  30. [30]
    Business | Guinness Four lose final appeals - BBC NEWS
    Nov 14, 2002 · Stockbroker Anthony Parnes was sentenced to 30 months for false accounting and theft - that sentence was reduced to 21 months on appeal.<|separator|>
  31. [31]
    LYONS AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM - HUDOC
    The Court concluded that, in the circumstances, there had been an infringement of the right not to incriminate oneself and thus a breach of Article 6 § 1 of the ...
  32. [32]
    Trial of Guinness defendants breached their human rights, says ...
    The trial of three businessmen found guilty of colluding in an illegal share-fixing operation during the Guinness takeover of Distillers was a breach of their ...
  33. [33]
    European court says trial of Guinness three was unfair - The Guardian
    Aug 4, 1999 · Guinness case defendants Gerald Ronson, Jack Lyons and Anthony Parnes did not receive a fair trial on allegations of illegal share-support activities.<|separator|>
  34. [34]
    Guinness four's appeal fails | Business - The Guardian
    Dec 21, 2001 · The appeal court judges rejected the argument by the four - Ernest Saunders, Jack Lyons, Gerald Ronson and Anthony Parnes - that they had been ...
  35. [35]
    Call for inquiry amid claims Guinness Four were scapegoats
    Feb 5, 2015 · Ernest Saunders, Anthony Parnes, Jack Lyons and Gerald Ronson were found guilty of criminal offences in relation to inflating the value of ...
  36. [36]
    Lord Mandelson calls for inquiry into Guinness scandal amid 'Jewish ...
    Feb 4, 2015 · He argued that there was an anti-Semitic plot to scapegoat the Jewish businessmen because a Tory minister warned him the authorities were "going ...
  37. [37]
    'Jews were scapegoats' in Guinness scandal, claims peer
    Feb 3, 2015 · ... Guinness scandal, arguing that the Jewish businessmen jailed over the affair were scapegoats. In 1990, Ernest Saunders, Tony Parnes, Sir ...Editor's Picks · More From News · Trump Pardons Crypto Ceo Who...
  38. [38]
    The key players at the centre of the Guinness case and how they have
    Oct 21, 1995 · Anthony Parnes: At the time of the Guinness trial the former stockbroker was married to the wealthy heiress Denise Ratner. They have since ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  39. [39]
    Gerald Ratner - Wikipedia
    His sister Denise Ratner was married to stockbroker Anthony Parnes, one of the Guinness Four. ... They have a daughter and a son. References. edit.
  40. [40]
    City boy Michael Parnes to tie the knot with Tomb Raider Lucy ...
    Feb 12, 2011 · Parnes is to wed Lucy Clarkson after a long courtship. If Lucy's name isn't immediately recognisable, her alter ego's probably is – Lara Croft. ...Missing: personal | Show results with:personal
  41. [41]
    Twenty years after Guinness, Parnes junior brokers Far East deal
    May 3, 2006 · The son of one of the key figures jailed in the Guinness share rigging scandal of the 1980s has just pulled off his first key City deal.<|control11|><|separator|>
  42. [42]
    Denise Parnes Wife Anthony Tony Daughter Editorial Stock Photo
    Denise Parnes Wife Of Anthony (tony) And Daughter. Tony Parnes Is A Millionaire Stockbroker Who Was Involved With Ernest Saunders Gerald Ronson And Jack Lyons ...Missing: personal life
  43. [43]
    Adjusting to life after residence at the Savoy: Mary Braid reports on ...
    Sep 20, 1994 · Having traded his pounds 3.3m home in Hampstead, north London, for a 'small' flat in central London, Parnes, once worth pounds 10m, says he is ...Missing: career | Show results with:career<|control11|><|separator|>
  44. [44]
    How they live now - This is Money
    Dec 20, 2001 · Anthony Parnes The 56-year-old former stockbroker who recruited willing buyers to help in the Guinness share support operation, has never ...
  45. [45]
    Parnes' family tree shows he has impressive roots - The Telegraph
    Jun 29, 2010 · Michael's father is Anthony Parnes, the millionaire stockbroker who got wrapped up, and then locked up, for his part in the Guinness Four affair.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography