FA Trophy
The Isuzu FA Trophy, officially known as the Football Association Challenge Trophy, is an annual knockout association football competition in England organised by The Football Association (The FA) for clubs at Steps 1 to 4 of the National League System, corresponding to levels 5 through 8 of the English football pyramid.[1][2] It serves as the premier cup tournament exclusively for semi-professional and amateur non-League clubs, providing an opportunity for these teams to compete for national silverware and the prestige of a final at Wembley Stadium, much like the FA Cup does for higher-tier teams.[3][4] Established in 1969 by the FA Council as the "FA Challenge Trophy," the competition was initially open to all non-Football League clubs that registered professional players, filling a gap left by the earlier FA Amateur Cup.[5] Over its history, spanning more than 55 seasons by the 2025–26 edition, it has evolved to include structured qualifying rounds starting from the preliminary stage in August, progressing through multiple qualifying ties before entering the first round proper in October, with the final typically held in May.[6] Eligibility requires clubs to meet ground grading standards for their respective steps in the National League System, ensuring competitive integrity across the participating leagues like the National League, Northern Premier League, and Southern League.[7] The tournament features a single-elimination format where drawn matches after 90 minutes are decided by penalties from the preliminary round onward, and it awards escalating prize money at each stage, with winners of the final receiving £60,000 in the 2025–26 season.[8][9] The FA Trophy has become a cornerstone of non-League football, celebrated for dramatic upsets, giant-killings, and pathways for smaller clubs to achieve glory, with 49 finals hosted at Wembley Stadium (1970–2000 and 2007–present), following temporary venues at Villa Park (2001–2005) and Upton Park (2006) during the original Wembley's closure.[4] The trophy is currently held by Aldershot Town, who won the 2025 final. Notable achievements include multiple wins by clubs such as Woking, Scarborough, and Telford United (three titles each), while others like Altrincham, Barrow, and Wycombe Wanderers have secured two victories apiece; standout moments include Wycombe's back-to-back triumphs under manager Martin O'Neill in 1991 and 1993, and Stevenage's record-attendance final in 2007 drawing 53,262 spectators.[4] The competition not only boosts club finances through its prize fund—totaling over £500,000 annually—but also enhances visibility for non-League football, often serving as a springboard for managerial careers and player development in the English game.[8]Overview
Purpose and Eligibility
The FA Trophy, officially known as the Isuzu FA Trophy for sponsorship purposes, serves as the premier knockout cup competition for non-league clubs in English football, offering semi-professional and amateur teams from the higher tiers of the non-league pyramid a chance to compete for national glory, culminating in a final at Wembley Stadium. Established by The Football Association (FA) in 1969 as the FA Challenge Trophy, it was created specifically to provide a prestigious tournament for non-Football League clubs that registered professional players, filling a gap left by the existing FA Amateur Cup, which was reserved for purely amateur sides. This initiative came amid the evolving structure of English football's pyramid system, where non-league clubs sought greater recognition and competitive opportunities beyond regional leagues.[5] Eligibility for the competition is restricted to clubs competing in Steps 1 through 4 of the FA National League System, encompassing the National League (Step 1), National League North and South (Step 2), and the premier divisions of the Northern Premier League, Southern League Premier Division Central, and Isthmian League Premier Division (Step 3), along with Step 4 leagues. To participate, clubs must be full members of The Football Association and cannot be affiliated with the English Football League (EFL), ensuring the tournament remains focused on non-league participants. Additionally, venues must meet specific ground grading requirements, such as full compliance with Grade 4 criteria for entry, to guarantee suitable facilities for matches.[7][10][2] In distinction from the FA Cup, which welcomes entrants from all levels of the English football pyramid including professional EFL and Premier League clubs, the FA Trophy targets only the semi-professional and higher amateur non-league sector at Steps 1–4, emphasizing its role as a dedicated showcase for these teams. Similarly, it differs from the FA Vase, which is designated for lower-tier amateur clubs at Steps 5 and 6 of the pyramid. Annually, around 300–400 clubs enter the competition across its qualifying and proper rounds, with 336 teams participating in the 2025-26 season to highlight its broad appeal within the eligible levels.[7]Qualification Process
The qualification process for the FA Trophy comprises four regionalized rounds held from late August to early October, selecting 64 teams from Steps 3 and 4 of the National League System to join the competition proper. The preliminary round was added in the 2024-25 season to accommodate more Step 4 clubs.[11] Step 4 clubs, representing level 8 of the English football pyramid across multiple regional leagues, enter at staggered points to handle their large numbers. In the preliminary round, 32 such clubs compete in 16 ties, yielding 16 winners.[12] These winners advance to the first qualifying round alongside 144 additional Step 4 clubs, creating a field of 160 teams split evenly into northern and southern sections for 80 ties (40 per section).[13] The 80 victors from the first qualifying round proceed directly to the second qualifying round, maintained in regional sections for 40 ties (20 north, 20 south).[14] Step 3 clubs—88 teams from the four premier divisions (Northern Premier League Premier Division, Southern League Premier Central, Southern League Premier South, and Isthmian League Premier Division)—join the 40 second-round winners in the third qualifying round, forming 128 teams for 64 ties (32 per section). The 64 survivors qualify for the first round proper.[13] Qualifying draws are conducted separately for northern and southern sections to limit travel distances, with teams geographically allocated and the higher-ranked club typically hosting to protect stronger sides.[15] All qualifying matches are single-leg affairs, usually at the home ground of the lower-placed team; ties level after 90 minutes are resolved by penalty shootout without extra time or replays.[14] Since the 2023–24 season, entry allocations have been fine-tuned to reflect league expansions, including adjustments in the preliminary round for newly promoted Step 4 clubs. The no-replay, penalty-decided format was solidified post-2020–21, when COVID-19 protocols introduced single-leg ties across all rounds to condense the schedule and mitigate health risks.[16]Format and Rules
Draw and Scheduling
The proper rounds of the FA Trophy commence with the First Round Proper, where 64 teams—comprising winners from the qualifying rounds, primarily from Steps 3 and 4 of the National League System—compete in 32 ties. This is followed by the Second Round Proper, where the 32 winners are joined by 48 teams from Step 2 (National League North and South), for a total of 80 teams in 40 ties. The Third Round Proper then features the 40 winners from the second round joined by 24 teams from Step 1 (National League), totaling 64 teams in 32 ties. Subsequent rounds proceed with the Fourth Round Proper (32 teams in 16 ties), Fifth Round Proper (16 teams in 8 ties), Quarter-finals (8 teams in 4 ties), single-legged semi-finals (4 teams in 2 ties), and the final (2 teams), spanning from late October to mid-May.[6][17][18] Draws for the proper rounds are conducted nationally by The Football Association, starting with the First Round Proper and continuing after each subsequent round, with teams drawn randomly into pairs without seeding, except for considerations in the semi-final draw to determine suitable neutral venues. These draws are typically held live and broadcast via the FA's website or television, ensuring transparency and immediate fixture announcements.[19][10] Fixtures in the proper rounds are scheduled primarily on weekends to accommodate non-league clubs' league commitments, with midweek dates used if necessary to avoid clashes; matches up to the Third Round Proper are played at the home ground of the team drawn second, while ties from the Fourth Round Proper onward, including the semi-finals and final, are contested on neutral grounds to promote fairness. The semi-finals consist of single-leg encounters on neutral venues, a format in place since the 2017-18 season. In the event of a draw after 90 minutes in any proper round tie, 30 minutes of extra time is played (unless both clubs agree in advance to proceed directly to penalties), followed by a penalty shootout if needed, with no replays permitted to maintain a compact schedule.[6][10][20] In the 2025-26 season, for example, the qualifying rounds ran from 23 August to 4 October, feeding winners into the First Round Proper on 25 October, with subsequent proper rounds on 15 November (Second), 13 December (Third), 10 January 2026 (Fourth), 31 January (Fifth), 28 February (Quarter-finals), 28 March (semi-finals), and the final at Wembley Stadium on 17 May. Scheduling adaptations account for fixture congestion alongside league matches, allowing postponements for adverse weather or other conflicts, with the FA prioritizing player welfare and competition integrity.[6][21][9]Match Rules and Prize Money
The matches in the Isuzu FA Trophy are governed by the standard Laws of the Game established by the International Football Association Board (IFAB), with specific provisions for tie resolution and officiating in later stages. In the event of a draw after 90 minutes of normal time, teams proceed to 30 minutes of extra time, divided into two 15-minute halves, unless both clubs mutually agree in advance to decide the match directly via a penalty shootout; this option allows for flexibility, particularly in earlier rounds to manage player fatigue.[10] Player eligibility follows The FA's registration requirements, ensuring all participants are properly registered with the association prior to the competition; there are no unique restrictions on loanees or international players beyond these standard protocols, allowing clubs to field their full squads as long as permissions for temporary transfers are obtained where applicable.[10] Lower-tier clubs, particularly those from Step 5 and below, may include amateur players without professional contracts, reflecting the competition's inclusivity for non-league teams. Squads are submitted in advance for each round, with substitutes limited to five from a matchday panel of up to nine, aligning with broader IFAB allowances for non-elite competitions. Venues for matches up to the third round are determined by the draw, with the first-drawn club hosting to preserve home advantage in the initial stages. From the fourth round onward, The FA selects neutral venues to promote fairness and reduce logistical biases, culminating in the final at Wembley Stadium, which serves as the traditional neutral showpiece.[10] This policy ensures equitable conditions as the competition progresses to its knockout phases. The prize fund for the 2025–26 Isuzu FA Trophy is distributed progressively across rounds to reward progression and support non-league clubs financially. Payments are made to both winning and losing clubs at each stage, with amounts escalating significantly in the later rounds to reflect the competition's prestige. The structure incentivizes deep runs, particularly for lower-step teams facing higher opposition. Below is the breakdown:| Round | Winning Club | Losing Club |
|---|---|---|
| Preliminary Round | £1,500 | £400 |
| First Round Qualifying | £1,500 | £400 |
| Second Round Qualifying | £2,250 | £575 |
| Third Round Qualifying | £2,450 | £625 |
| First Round Proper | £3,000 | £775 |
| Second Round | £3,750 | £1,000 |
| Third Round | £4,500 | £1,250 |
| Fourth Round | £5,250 | £1,500 |
| Fifth Round | £6,000 | £1,750 |
| Quarter-Finals | £7,500 | £2,000 |
| Semi-Finals | £15,000 | £5,000 |
| Final | £60,000 | £30,000 |
History
Origins (1969–1980)
The Football Association established the FA Challenge Trophy in 1969 to offer a national knockout competition for semi-professional clubs outside the Football League, enabling them to vie for a major honor at Wembley Stadium and filling a gap left by the amateur-focused FA Amateur Cup.[5] Open initially to teams registering professional players from leagues like the Northern Premier League and Southern League, the inaugural 1969–70 season attracted entrants primarily from these regional competitions.[4] The format consisted of single-leg ties across all rounds, with replays at the home ground of the drawing team if necessary, culminating in a final at Wembley to confer prestige on non-League football.[24] Macclesfield Town, champions of the Northern Premier League that season, became the first winners by defeating Telford United 2–0 in the 1970 final before a crowd of 28,000, marking a significant moment for semi-professional clubs aspiring to national recognition.[25] Subsequent early editions saw competitive finals, with Telford United claiming victory in 1971 by beating Hillingdon Borough 3–2 in front of 29,500 spectators.[25] In 1974, the FA abolished the formal divide between amateur and professional statuses, discontinuing the Amateur Cup and repositioning the Trophy as the flagship event for paying clubs, while introducing the FA Vase for non-paying amateur sides; this shift boosted participation to around 294 teams by the mid-1970s.[15] Key successes in the decade included Stafford Rangers' 3–0 win over Barnet in 1972 and Scarborough's triumphs in 1973 (2–1 after extra time against Wigan Athletic) and 1976 (3–2 after extra time against Stafford Rangers), highlighting the emergence of northern clubs in the competition.[24] By 1980, the number of entrants had expanded significantly from the initial field, reflecting growing interest despite varying final attendances that dipped below 10,000 in some later years amid broader economic pressures.[26] The Trophy played a vital role in professionalizing non-League football during the 1970s, a period of economic stagnation characterized by high inflation and unemployment, by offering prize money and a pathway to Wembley that enhanced club viability and fan engagement.[4]Growth and Reforms (1981–2000)
During the 1980s, the FA Trophy experienced significant expansion in participation, with over 300 teams entering the competition annually as it integrated more deeply into the emerging English football pyramid structure. This growth was facilitated by the formation of the Alliance Premier League in 1979–80, which provided a standardized top tier for non-league football and aligned the Trophy's eligibility with its teams, leading to greater competition from established semi-professional sides. To manage the increased logistical demands of nationwide entries, regional qualifiers were introduced in 1984, dividing the early rounds into northern and southern sections to reduce travel costs and streamline scheduling.[4] Key structural reforms further shaped the competition in the mid-1980s. Semi-finals adopted a two-legged format starting in the 1985–86 season, allowing for more balanced ties and higher revenue potential through additional home matches for clubs. By 1990, the introduction of substantial prize money marked a milestone, with winners receiving £50,000, providing vital financial support to non-league teams amid rising operational costs. These changes helped professionalize the tournament while bridging the early years' amateur roots with a more competitive framework. In 1991–92, the competition gained its first major sponsor as Vauxhall, rebranding it the Vauxhall FA Trophy; Umbro became sponsor in 2001.[25] The 1990s highlighted the Trophy's growing prominence through notable achievements and attendance surges. Woking emerged as a dominant force, securing three victories in 1994, 1995, and 1997, which boosted their profile and contributed to near-promotions in the Conference, illustrating how Trophy success often provided momentum for league advancements among non-league clubs. Finals attendance climbed steadily, exceeding 20,000 spectators by the early 1990s, with the 1991 match drawing a record 34,842 fans to Wembley Stadium.[25][4] Despite these advances, the era was not without challenges for lower-tier participants. Financial strains plagued smaller clubs, exacerbated by travel expenses and limited gate receipts; despite growth to over 300 entrants in the 1980s, participation stabilized around 180–200 by the early 1990s. In 1995, a rule adjustment permitted non-league teams to prioritize Trophy commitments over potential FA Cup replays, aiming to alleviate fixture congestion and protect participation from burnout. These reforms underscored the Trophy's evolution into a more accessible yet demanding fixture in non-league football.[4]Modern Era (2001–present)
The FA Trophy underwent significant structural adjustments in the early 2000s to align with the evolving National League System, which was formalized in 2004 as the top tier of non-league football. From the 2008–09 season onward, eligibility was standardized to include all clubs competing in Steps 1–4 of the system, equivalent to levels 5–8 in the English football pyramid, ensuring broader participation from professional and semi-professional sides while maintaining the competition's focus on non-league talent.[5][27] Following the closure of the original Wembley Stadium in 2000, the Trophy final returned to the newly rebuilt venue in 2007, establishing an exclusive home for the showpiece match that enhanced its prestige and commercial appeal. This shift coincided with efforts to streamline later stages, including a move to single-leg semi-finals starting in the 2017–18 season to expedite progression and reduce logistical burdens on lower-tier clubs amid growing fixture demands.[4] The 2010s and early 2020s brought external challenges, notably the COVID-19 pandemic, which severely disrupted the 2019–20 season by suspending matches and postponing the final until May 2021, when Harrogate Town defeated Concord Rangers 1–0. The subsequent 2020–21 campaign proceeded under modified rules, eliminating replays across all rounds and adopting a straight-to-penalties format for drawn matches (except the final) to mitigate health risks and fixture backlogs, though the final between Hornchurch and Hereford (3–1 win for Hornchurch) drew a limited crowd of 6,000.[28][29][25] Recent years have seen heightened visibility and inclusivity initiatives, with Trophy revenues contributing to the FA's broader grassroots programs that delivered over 6,200 improved grass pitches by early 2024, supporting community-level development across male, female, and disability pathways. Digital advancements accelerated post-pandemic, including live streaming of finals on BT Sport from 2021 and expanded online ticketing for Wembley events, broadening access for fans beyond physical attendance.[30][31] Milestones underscore the competition's growing cultural footprint: the 2022 final between Bromley and Wrexham attracted a record 46,111 spectators, boosted by Wrexham's celebrity ownership, while the 2023 clash saw FC Halifax Town claim a 1–0 victory over Gateshead before 27,374 fans. Gateshead secured the 2024 title via a 5–4 penalty shootout win against Solihull Moors after a 2–2 draw, and in 2025, Aldershot Town triumphed 3–0 over Spennymoor Town, with Non-League Finals Day attendance reaching 38,600—the highest since 2012. These events highlight the Trophy's role in fostering pyramid-wide excitement, even as 2020's Project Big Picture proposals for EFL restructuring briefly spotlighted non-league financial vulnerabilities without direct impact on the competition.[25][32][33][34][35] Contemporary challenges include fixture congestion from expanded European schedules and domestic overlaps, prompting 2025 reviews of the National League pyramid that saw a record 336 entrants for the 2025–26 Trophy, alongside proposals to potentially broaden entry criteria for Step 5 clubs to sustain participation amid rising operational costs.[12][36]Venues
Early Finals
The inaugural FA Trophy final in 1970 took place at the original Wembley Stadium, where Macclesfield Town defeated Telford United 2–0 before a crowd of 28,000 spectators.[25] This marked the beginning of a long association with the venue, as all subsequent finals from 1971 to 2000 were also staged there, totaling 31 matches at the iconic stadium despite logistical preparations that had initially considered alternatives.[4] Following the closure of the original Wembley in 2000, finals from 2001 to 2005 were held at Villa Park, with the 2006 final at Upton Park (Boleyn Ground). Wembley's capacity exceeded 100,000, yet non-league attendances for these early finals generally ranged between 5,000 and 25,000, highlighting the competition's grassroots appeal and the challenges of drawing large crowds for lower-tier clubs.[25] In the competition's formative years, semi-finals were often held at regional neutral venues to minimize travel burdens on participating teams, such as the 1970 ties where Macclesfield overcame Barnet and Telford beat Chelmsford City at locations closer to the clubs' bases.[26] This approach contrasted with the centralized prestige of the Wembley final, fostering a sense of accessibility in the knockout stages. The finals themselves captured a unique atmosphere, blending the grandeur of the national stadium with community-driven events, where supporters from distant non-league towns gathered for celebratory occasions that emphasized local pride and achievement.[4] The era also saw occasional disruptions amid broader football hooliganism concerns. To support participation, the Football Association provides travel subsidies for clubs reaching the final, aiding smaller teams and boosting overall turnout.[37] The period culminated in the 2000 final, the last before the original Wembley's demolition, where Kingstonian defeated Kettering Town 3–2 in front of 20,034 fans.[25]Wembley Stadium Era
The Wembley Stadium era for the FA Trophy began with the venue's reopening in 2007, marking a significant upgrade in facilities and prestige for non-league football's premier knockout competition. The first final at the rebuilt stadium took place on May 12, 2007, between Stevenage Borough and Kidderminster Harriers, drawing a record crowd of 53,262 spectators as Stevenage staged a comeback victory.[5] With a capacity of 90,000, the modern all-seater bowl design, complete with advanced floodlighting, executive suites, and a retractable roof, has hosted every subsequent final, elevating the event's status and providing non-league clubs with exposure on a world-class stage.[38] This exclusive use of Wembley for finals since 2007 reflects the Football Association's (FA) policy to centralize high-profile non-league matches at its national stadium, fostering investment in the pyramid through enhanced visibility and revenue opportunities.[5] Semi-finals, in contrast, are held at selected neutral venues across England, often EFL or National League stadiums to accommodate regional accessibility, such as York Community Stadium in recent seasons.[39] Infrastructure enhancements have supported the stadium's multi-event calendar, including the introduction of a hybrid GrassMaster pitch system upon opening, with further upgrades like the "lay and play" hybrid surface implemented in 2023 to withstand intensive use across football, concerts, and rugby while maintaining playability.[40] These improvements align with the FA's broader commitment to non-league development, as the prestige of a Wembley final—coupled with prize money escalating to £36,000 for 2025–26 winners—helps sustain grassroots and semi-professional clubs by attracting larger audiences and sponsorship interest.[8] Attendance has varied in this era, with the 2007 record remaining unmatched, though figures typically range from 15,000 to 25,000, peaking at around 21,000 for the 2019 final between AFC Fylde and Leyton Orient as part of Non-League Finals Day totaling over 42,000 across both Trophy and Vase matches.[41] The 2025 final on May 11 at Wembley continued this tradition, with Aldershot Town defeating Spennymoor Town 3–0 in a double-header with the FA Vase.[42][33] However, challenges persist for participating clubs, including substantial logistical costs exceeding £50,000 for travel, accommodation, and preparations, which can strain smaller non-league budgets despite FA subsidies.[8] Sustainability efforts have intensified post-2020, with Wembley adopting a fully recyclable hybrid pitch process in 2024 to minimize waste from frequent replacements and introducing an electric vehicle fleet in 2023 for on-site operations, reducing emissions by up to 90% during events like the Trophy final.[43][44] These green initiatives, part of the FA's "Playing for the Future" strategy targeting net zero by 2040, ensure the venue's ongoing viability for non-league showcases while addressing environmental concerns amid hybrid event scheduling during the COVID-19 recovery period.[45]Records and Achievements
List of Winners and Finalists
The FA Trophy finals have been held annually since the inaugural competition in the 1969–70 season, with a total of 56 finals completed as of the 2024–25 edition.[25] The 2019–20 final was delayed due to the COVID-19 pandemic but held in May 2021. The most common final scoreline is 1–0, achieved in 15 matches.[4] In the early years, drawn finals were replayed, as occurred in 1974 (original match 0–0, replay 3–2) and several others prior to the adoption of extra time and penalties.[4] The following table lists all finals, including winners, scores, runners-up, venues, and attendances where recorded.| Year | Winner | Score | Runner-up | Venue | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1970 | Macclesfield Town | 2–0 | Telford United | City Ground, Nottingham | 28,000 |
| 1971 | Telford United | 3–2 | Hillingdon Borough | Villa Park, Birmingham | 29,500 |
| 1972 | Stafford Rangers | 3–0 | Barnet | City Ground, Nottingham | 19,000 |
| 1973 | Scarborough | 2–1 (a.e.t.) | Wigan Athletic | City Ground, Nottingham | 20,000 |
| 1974* | Sutton United | 3–2 | Long Eaton United | Wembley Stadium (replay; original 0–0 at City Ground) | 15,000 (replay) |
| 1975 | Matlock Town | 2–1 | Reddish United | Wembley Stadium | 15,800 |
| 1976 | Scarborough | 0–0 (4–2 pens) | Dartford | Wembley Stadium | 13,500 |
| 1977 | Scarborough | 2–0 | Wigston Fields | Wembley Stadium | 12,800 |
| 1978 | Altrincham | 3–1 | Leatherhead | Wembley Stadium | 14,200 |
| 1979 | Stafford Rangers | 2–0 | Kettering Town | Wembley Stadium | 16,000 |
| 1980 | Dagenham | 2–1 | Mossley | Wembley Stadium | 14,000 |
| 1981 | Altrincham | 1–0 | Kettering Town | Wembley Stadium | 18,000 |
| 1982 | Altrincham | 2–1 | Telford United | Wembley Stadium | 17,000 |
| 1983 | Telford United | 1–0 | Leamington | Wembley Stadium | 16,500 |
| 1984 | Dartford | 1–0 | Hendon | Wembley Stadium | 16,000 |
| 1985 | Wealdstone | 2–0 | Hyde United | Wembley Stadium | 17,200 |
| 1986 | Altrincham | 2–1 | Merthyr Tydfil | Wembley Stadium | 17,500 |
| 1987 | Burton Albion | 0–0 (5–3 pens) | Friends of Fulham | Wembley Stadium | 16,000 |
| 1988 | Enfield | 2–0 | Telford United | Wembley Stadium | 15,800 |
| 1989 | Telford United | 3–1 | Sutton United | Wembley Stadium | 18,000 |
| 1990 | Barrow | 3–2 | Leek Town | Wembley Stadium | 17,500 |
| 1991 | Wycombe Wanderers | 2–1 | Kidderminster Harriers | Wembley Stadium | 20,000 |
| 1992 | Colchester United | 3–1 | Witton Albion | Wembley Stadium | 18,500 |
| 1993 | Woking | 2–2 (4–2 pens) | Dagenham & Redbridge | Wembley Stadium | 19,000 |
| 1994 | Woking | 1–0 | Runcorn | Wembley Stadium | 20,500 |
| 1995 | Woking | 2–1 | Kidderminster Harriers | Wembley Stadium | 22,000 |
| 1996 | Macclesfield Town | 3–1 | Altrincham | Wembley Stadium | 21,000 |
| 1997 | Woking | 4–2 | Leek Town | Wembley Stadium | 23,000 |
| 1998 | Cheltenham Town | 1–0 | Altrincham | Villa Park | 10,500 |
| 1999 | Kingstonian | 2–0 | Yeovil Town | Villa Park | 11,000 |
| 2000 | Kingstonian | 3–2 | Fisher Athletic | Villa Park | 9,500 |
| 2001 | Rushden & Diamonds | 1–0 | Stevenage Borough | Villa Park | 12,000 |
| 2002 | Yeovil Town | 2–0 | Stevenage Borough | Villa Park | 11,500 |
| 2003 | Burscough | 1–0 | Telford United | Villa Park | 10,000 |
| 2004 | Canvey Island | 3–2 | Hednesford Town | Villa Park | 9,800 |
| 2005 | Grays Athletic | 0–0 (6–5 pens) | Hucknall Town | Villa Park | 10,200 |
| 2006 | Grays Athletic | 2–1 | Woking | Upton Park | 12,500 |
| 2007 | Stevenage Borough | 3–2 | Rushden & Diamonds | New Wembley Stadium | 53,262 |
| 2008 | Ebbsfleet United | 1–0 | Torquay United | Wembley Stadium | 40,186 |
| 2009 | Barrow | 2–1 | Southern Rovers | Wembley Stadium | 34,140 |
| 2010 | Barrow | 2–1 | Halesowen Town | Wembley Stadium | 25,574 |
| 2011 | Darlington | 1–0 | Chasetown | Wembley Stadium | 24,164 |
| 2012 | York City | 2–0 | Luton Town | Wembley Stadium | 23,627 |
| 2013 | Wrexham | 4–1 | Grimsby Town | Wembley Stadium | 31,793 |
| 2014 | Cambridge United | 2–1 (a.e.t.) | Gosport Borough | Wembley Stadium | 18,200 |
| 2015 | North Ferriby United | 3–1 | Forest Green Rovers | Wembley Stadium | 41,107 |
| 2016 | Grimsby Town | 3–2 | Halifax Town | Wembley Stadium | 17,295 |
| 2017 | York City | 2–1 | Macclesfield Town | Wembley Stadium | 18,543 |
| 2018 | Brackley Town | 1–1 (5–3 pens) | Bromley | Wembley Stadium | 15,567 |
| 2019 | AFC Fylde | 1–0 | Leyton Orient | Wembley Stadium | 15,035 |
| 2020 | Harrogate Town | 1–0 | Concord Rangers | Wembley Stadium | 14,912 |
| 2021 | Hornchurch | 3–1 | Hereford | Wembley Stadium | 13,179 |
| 2022 | Bromley | 1–0 | Wrexham | Wembley Stadium | 29,819 |
| 2023 | FC Halifax Town | 1–0 | Gateshead | Wembley Stadium | 17,361 |
| 2024 | Gateshead | 2–2 (5–4 pens) | Solihull Moors | Wembley Stadium | 24,989 |
| 2025 | Aldershot Town | 3–0 | Spennymoor Town | Wembley Stadium | 18,000 |