Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Fitzwilly

Fitzwilly is a film directed by and written by , based on the 1960 A Garden of Cucumbers by Poyntz Tyler. The story centers on Claude R. Fitzwilliam, nicknamed Fitzwilly, a loyal butler played by , who leads the household staff in elaborate thefts and cons to preserve the illusion of wealth for his eccentric, philanthropic employer, Victoria Woodworth (), after her fortune dwindles to just $180. Complications arise when a new secretary, Juliet Nowell (), joins the household and begins to uncover the scheme, leading to romantic and chaotic developments. Produced by for the Mirisch Corporation and released on December 20, 1967, the film runs 102 minutes and blends elements with holiday-themed antics, including a climactic disruption at on . Supporting roles feature as the family lawyer and as a timid accomplice, contributing to the ensemble's comedic dynamics. The score was composed by Johnny Williams (later ), with the theme song "Make Me Rainbows" featuring lyrics by . Critically received as a lighthearted family comedy, Fitzwilly earned praise for Van Dyke's charismatic performance and its witty take on Robin Hood-inspired larceny, though it was not a major box-office success. The film highlights themes of loyalty, deception, and generosity, set against a backdrop of 1960s New York City affluence.

Synopsis and cast

Plot

Claude Fitzwilliam, the resourceful butler known as Fitzwilly, serves the elderly philanthropist Miss Victoria Woodworth in her opulent New York City brownstone, maintaining the illusion of her vast wealth despite her actual inheritance of just $180 after her family fortune has been depleted by estate taxes. To sustain Miss Woodworth's generous charitable donations and lavish lifestyle, Fitzwilly leads the household staff—including the cook Poopdeck, the valet Buck, and the footman Albert—in a series of meticulously planned petty thefts from high-end stores, adhering to a strict code of honor that limits their targets to wealthy corporations rather than individuals. These operations rely on clever alibis, such as staging thefts during Miss Woodworth's dictation sessions for her unusual project: a dictionary compiling common phonetic misspellings of words. The scheme faces disruption when Fitzwilly hires Juliet Nowell, a bright graduate student, as Miss Woodworth's part-time secretary to assist with the dictionary. Juliet quickly notices inconsistencies, such as deliberate errors in the dictation that provide cover for the staff's outings, and begins inadvertently thwarting minor thefts, heightening tensions within the household. Fitzwilly attempts to Juliet romantically to encourage her and protect the operation, but their feigned relationship blossoms into genuine affection, complicating his loyalties as Juliet grows suspicious of the criminal activities funding Miss Woodworth's unwitting —donations to causes like the St. Dismas Home for the Aged that ironically benefit the needy through ill-gotten gains. As Christmas approaches, a looming $190,000 shortfall from an oversized charitable pledge forces Fitzwilly to escalate the operation into "Get Out While You're Ahead," a daring heist at Gimbel's on . The staff infiltrates the bustling store disguised as holiday figures—including Santas, elves, and even involving Cub Scouts and shoppers—creating diversions like malfunctions and chaotic crowds to swap price tags, pilfer merchandise, and load trucks with valuables worth the required sum. The plan nearly succeeds amid the frenzy, but is caught by store detectives and confesses the entire scheme to , leading to the arrest of the household staff. In a tense courtroom-like confrontation at the police station, Miss Woodworth arrives unaware of the full truth and, leveraging her perceived wealth, offers a $190,000 check to cover the stolen goods—unwittingly revealing the operation's coverage that makes the a . The crisis resolves dramatically when a producer, impressed by samples of Miss Woodworth's quirky dictionary, purchases it as the basis for a screenplay for $500,000, providing a legitimate fortune that secures the household's future, clears the staff's names with suspended sentences, and allows Fitzwilly and to announce their .

Cast

The cast of Fitzwilly features an ensemble of character actors portraying the quirky household staff and key associates of the central figures, contributing to the film's comedic caper tone through their collective ingenuity and camaraderie.
ActorRoleDescription
Dick Van DykeClaude R. FitzwilliamThe loyal and resourceful butler who serves as the mastermind leading the household staff in their efforts to maintain their employer's lifestyle.
Barbara FeldonJuliet NowellThe intelligent new secretary hired for the household, who develops a romantic connection with Fitzwilliam; this marked Feldon's first credited feature film role following her breakout as Agent 99 on the television series Get Smart.
John McGiverAlbertThe guilt-prone footman and household member who assists in the thefts but is eventually caught.
Edith EvansMiss Victoria WoodworthThe eccentric elderly employer around whom the devoted staff revolves, unaware of their behind-the-scenes maneuvers.
Harry TownesMr. NowellJuliet's father, involved in the periphery of the household's affairs.
Sam WaterstonOliverA young member of the household staff assisting in daily operations; this was one of Waterston's early feature film appearances.
Cecil KellawayBuckmasterAn experienced household servant contributing to the team's coordinated efforts.
Norman FellOberblatzA security agent at a major department store who interacts with the household's activities.
Supporting players like John Fiedler as Mr. Morton Dunne and Anne Seymour as Grimsby further enhance the ensemble's dynamic of eccentric loyalty and clever collaboration.

Production

Development

The film Fitzwilly originated as an adaptation of Poyntz Tyler's 1960 novel A Garden of Cucumbers, a comedic tale involving larceny and domestic intrigue. The Mirisch Corporation acquired the rights to the novel in May 1961 for over $50,000, but the project stalled until production was revived in June 1965. Dick Van Dyke was cast in the lead role in June 1965 as part of a four-picture deal. Screenwriter Isobel Lennart, who had previously collaborated with the Mirisch Company on projects like Two for the Seesaw (1962), expanded the novel's humorous elements into a screenplay emphasizing heist comedy and petty crime. Lennart brought the source material to producer Walter Mirisch, initiating development under the Mirisch Company banner in the mid-1960s. Mirisch, known for producing acclaimed comedies and dramas such as Some Like It Hot (1959), selected director Delbert Mann to helm the project; Mann, an Academy Award winner for Marty (1955) and acclaimed for Separate Tables (1958), joined in the summer of 1966. This assembly of key creative talent paved the way for principal photography later that year, culminating in the film's 1967 release as a lighthearted exploration of loyalty and mischief among the upper class.

Filming

Principal photography for Fitzwilly commenced on October 10, 1966, and wrapped several months later, allowing for a 1967 release. The production was primarily staged at Samuel Goldwyn Studios in , where interiors, including elaborate recreations of settings like the bustling for the climactic sequence, were constructed on soundstages to simulate the film's backdrop. Limited location shooting occurred in , capturing authentic exteriors such as Steinway Hall on West 57th Street and the Isaac L. Rice House, while second-unit work handled additional urban establishing shots to evoke the holiday bustle without extensive on-location disruptions. Cinematographer employed anamorphic lenses to capture the film in a 2.35:1 , utilizing processing to highlight the vibrant decorations and comedic chaos within the confined mansion and store sets. Editor Ralph E. Winters assembled the footage with precise timing to underscore the , ensuring the ensemble dynamics—featuring Dick Van Dyke's alongside supporting players like and —flowed seamlessly in group scenes of orchestrated . directed the film with a focus on stylish comedy and precise timing.

Release

Distribution

Fitzwilly premiered in the United States on December 20, 1967, with its opening distributed by , strategically timed for the holiday season to capitalize on the film's family-oriented comedy appeal. The theatrical rollout continued with a opening on December 25, 1967, aligning with festivities to attract audiences seeking lighthearted entertainment. Marketing efforts positioned the film as a showcase for , leveraging his popularity from television, with promotional posters featuring him prominently alongside and emphasizing the caper comedy's humorous theft schemes through taglines such as "He's a crook, an embezzler, a conman, a forger...You'll love him!" These materials highlighted the ensemble's antics in a whimsical setting to draw in viewers interested in screwball-style humor. International distribution remained limited during the late , with handling releases in , , , and in 1968. The film runs 102 minutes and received no MPAA rating, though its content—mild in language, violence, and themes—made it suitable for viewing. Early television broadcast rights were secured by , allowing the movie to reach broader audiences through network airings in the years after its theatrical run, enhancing its accessibility beyond cinemas. The film has been released on , including a DVD on April 15, 2010, by , and a Blu-ray edition on August 17, 2021, by Studio Classics.

Box office

Fitzwilly achieved domestic rentals of approximately $2.1 million in the United States and . Worldwide earnings were modest for a production given the studio's track record with higher-grossing films like The Great Escape (1963). The film's performance paled in comparison to contemporary 1967 comedies, notably underperforming against , which amassed over $43 million in domestic rentals amid a crowded holiday release slate that included major titles like . This timing, tied to ' distribution strategy for audiences, contributed to limited traction despite positive word-of-mouth potential. Break-even analysis, factoring in rental figures of about $2.1 million against and expenses, positioned Fitzwilly as a minor hit that recouped most investments but fell short of full profitability by roughly $300,000.

Reception

Critical response

Upon its release in December 1967, Fitzwilly received mixed-to-positive reviews from critics, who appreciated its lighthearted comedic tone and ensemble performances while noting some narrative predictability and uneven execution. awarded the film two out of four stars, describing it as a "pleasant family comedy" with chaotic charm, particularly praising the intelligent and witty that sets it apart from typical fare. He highlighted the clever premise of a orchestrating thefts to sustain his employer's , calling one of its delights the way characters speak "as if they were educated and witty." Critics offered praise for key performances, especially Dame Edith Evans as the eccentric Miss Victoria Woodworth, whose portrayal was deemed lovable and charmingly haughty by Howard Thompson in The New York Times, noting how she unwittingly saves the day in the film's resolution. Dick Van Dyke's affable turn as the resourceful butler Fitzwilliam was similarly commended for its droll quality by Ebert, though Thompson found the overall comedy "tepid" and lacking in genuine merriment despite its seasonal theft theme. Some reviewers critiqued the pacing of the sequences as overly whimsical and contrived, which occasionally undermined the film's , contributing to a sense of predictability in the plot. Aggregate scores reflect this divided response, with compiling a 67% approval rating from 24 critics and IMDb users rating it 6.6 out of 10 based on over 2,200 votes, blending period and modern perspectives.

Audience and commercial legacy

Despite its modest initial box office performance, where it fell short of breaking even by approximately $312,000, Fitzwilly developed a dedicated audience in the and through television syndication and reruns, particularly valued for Dick Van Dyke's spirited physical comedy as the resourceful butler. The film's holiday setting around contributed to its emergence as an offbeat seasonal favorite, with frequent airings on networks like (TCM) during the 2000s and beyond, enhancing its cult appeal among viewers who enjoy Van Dyke's whimsical antics and the ensemble's caper hijinks. In modern reevaluations, Fitzwilly has been praised for its exploration of and familial among the household staff, themes that resonate in contemporary discussions of the film's heartfelt core beneath the comedic thefts, while ' lively jazz-inflected score has received renewed attention through expanded soundtrack releases and analyses highlighting its early mastery of comedic orchestration. Streaming availability on platforms such as and since the 2010s has further boosted its visibility, introducing the film to new generations and solidifying its status as an underrated gem in the caper comedy genre. Commercially, official merchandise remains scarce, with items like original posters and lobby cards fetching high prices among collectors due to their rarity, reflecting the film's niche but enduring fanbase. Additionally, Barbara Feldon's role as the inquisitive secretary marked a significant step in her transition from television stardom on to s, helping elevate her profile in comedies of the era.

Soundtrack

Composition

The musical score for Fitzwilly was composed and conducted by , credited at the time as Johnny Williams, marking one of his early major contributions before his iconic work on Star Wars a decade later. Recorded in 1967 with a full under Williams' direction, the score exemplifies his emerging style through a blend of light orchestral cues and more expansive symphonic themes that build tension during sequences. Central to the score are two primary themes: a pompous march that provides comedic underscoring for the butler's scheming antics, and the lyrical love theme "Make Me Rainbows," co-written with lyricists . This integration supported the movie's brisk pacing, with shorter motifs underscoring rapid sight gags and longer themes bridging romantic interludes.

Album release

The original soundtrack for Fitzwilly, composed by (credited as Johnny Williams), was released in 1967 by on vinyl in both mono (UAL 4173) and (UAS 5173) editions, comprising 11 tracks that included the "" serving as the main title theme. The album presented a re-recording of key cues from the film score, emphasizing Williams' early orchestral style with romantic and comedic motifs. In the 1980s, reissued the soundtrack on vinyl LP (MCA-25098) as part of their Classics Soundtracks series, maintaining the original 11-track program to reach a new generation of listeners amid Williams' growing reputation following scores for films like (1975). A compact disc version followed in 1995 from the German label Tsunami Records (TSU 0121), marking one of the first digital formats for the album and broadening accessibility in . Varèse Sarabande released a limited-edition in 2004 through their exclusive Club series (VCL 0804 1030), pairing the complete Fitzwilly album with Williams' score for The Long Goodbye (1973) on a single disc limited to 2000 copies, which quickly sold out and introduced the material to collectors. This edition preserved the original tracklist without expansions but highlighted Williams' versatility in early career works. The definitive commercial release arrived in 2013 from Records (MBR-035), an expanded archival edition limited to 1000 copies worldwide, which remastered the original 11 tracks alongside 45 minutes of previously unreleased cues for a total runtime of 78 minutes, catering to dedicated fans seeking comprehensive access to Williams' contributions. These limited-run reissues, particularly the and editions, have garnered significant collector interest among enthusiasts, often commanding premium prices on secondary markets due to Williams' enduring legacy and the scarcity of early soundtrack material. By the , select tracks from the album became available digitally through streaming platforms and compilations, though full official digital editions remained limited.

References

  1. [1]
    Fitzwilly | Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 67% (24) In this clever 1960s comedy, tireless and loyal butler Fitzwilly (Dick Van Dyke) hides from his eccentric spinster boss, Victoria Woodhouse (Edith Evans).
  2. [2]
    AFI|Catalog
    Based on the novel A Garden of Cucumbers by Poyntz Tyler (New York, 1960). LITERARY SOURCE AUTHOR. Poyntz Tyler. SONGS.
  3. [3]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - IMDb
    Rating 6.6/10 (2,266) Fitzwilly: Directed by Delbert Mann. With Dick Van Dyke, Barbara Feldon, John McGiver, Edith Evans. An elderly woman's butler leads servants in larceny to ...
  4. [4]
    Fitzwilly movie review & film summary (1967) - Roger Ebert
    Rating 3/4 · Review by Roger EbertFitzwilly is a pleasant family comedy about a butler who brings Gimbel's to a halt on Christmas Eve.
  5. [5]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - Turner Classic Movies - TCM
    Released on December 20, 1967, Fitzwilly is based on the novel, A Garden of Cucumbers by Poyntz Tyler. The lyrics to the theme song "Make Me Rainbows" were ...
  6. [6]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - Plot - IMDb
    An elderly woman's butler leads servants in larceny to support her illusion of wealth. In New York City, Claude Fitzwilliam, Fitzwilly in familiar circumstances ...
  7. [7]
    Fitzwilly | Cast and Crew - Rotten Tomatoes
    Cast & Crew ; Delbert Mann · Director ; Dick Van Dyke · Claude Fitzwilliam · Actor ; Barbara Feldon · Juliet Nowell · Actor ; Edith Evans · Miss Victoria Woodworth · Actor.Missing: roles | Show results with:roles
  8. [8]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - Full cast & crew - IMDb
    Cast · Frank Adamo · Frank Adamo · Gimbel's Mail Clerk. (uncredited) · John Alban · John Alban · Fletcher Allen · Fletcher Allen · Reporter · Hal Baylor in A Boy ...
  9. [9]
    Fitzwilly
    ### Cast Summary for *Fitzwilly* (1967)
  10. [10]
  11. [11]
    Norman Fell - Wikipedia
    Filmography ; 1964 · Quick, Before it Melts, George Snell ; 1964 · The Young Warriors, Sergeant Wadley ; 1967, Fitzwilly, Oberblatz ; 1967 · The Graduate, Mr. McCleery.
  12. [12]
    I Thought We Were Making Movies, Not History | PDF - Scribd
    Our Christmas film, released in December 1967, was Fitzwilly, based on the book The Garden of Cucumbers by Poyntz Tyler, given to me by. Isobel Lennart. She ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
  13. [13]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - Filming & production - IMDb
    Filming locations included Steinway Hall, 1275 Broadway, Isaac L. Rice House, High Street in Moorpark, and 424 5th Avenue. Filming started Oct 11, 1966.Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
  14. [14]
    Fitzwilly (Blu-ray Review) - The Digital Bits
    Jul 19, 2021 · Isobel Lennart's screenplay paints Miss Victoria as the opposite of ... Walter Mirisch. Review Categories. Video Disc (0) · Blu-ray Disc ...
  15. [15]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - Technical specifications - IMDb
    Aspect ratio. 2.35 : 1. Laboratory. DeLuxe(color). Negative Format. 35 mm. Cinematographic Process. Panavision(anamorphic). Printed Film Format. 35 mm ...
  16. [16]
    Company credits - Fitzwilly (1967) - IMDb
    Distributors · United Artists. (United States, 1967)(theatrical) · United Artists. (United Kingdom, 1967)(theatrical) · Kommunenes Filmcentral (KF). (Norway, 1968) ...
  17. [17]
    Fitzwilly (Blu-ray)(1967) - Target
    Out of stockMovie MPAA Rating: Nr ; Run Time (minutes): 102 ; Language: English ; Estimated ship dimensions · 6.6 inches length x 5.07 inches width x 0.49 inches height ; About ...
  18. [18]
    The Screen: Servants Who Steal for Their Beloved:Dick Van Dyke ...
    Dame Edith Evans is lovable and charmingly haughty as the lady of the Riverside Drive mansion, who, naturally and unwittingly, saves the day in the end.Missing: behind | Show results with:behind
  19. [19]
    Behind the Scenes: Top of the Flops, United Artists 1965-1969 ...
    Mar 20, 2023 · Some Kind of Nut (1969) lost $1.36 million while Fitzwilly (1967) was $312,000 short of break-even. British star Michael Caine also fell ...<|separator|>
  20. [20]
    Final List Of Christmas Movies On Cable, Netflix, Hallmark 2018
    Dec 22, 2018 · 1:30pm – Fitzwilly (1967, Dick Van Dyke) (TCM); 2:00pm – A Christmas Story (1983, Peter Billingsley) (TBS); 2:40pm – Christmas With the Kranks ...
  21. [21]
    Fitzwilly (1967) - IT CAME FROM THE BOTTOM SHELF!
    Aug 21, 2021 · We even get to witness a very young Sam Waterston in one of his first featured roles. Supporting talent of that caliber can't help but add ...
  22. [22]
    Fitzwilly | Johnny WILLIAMS | CD - Music Box Records
    Long-awaited re-issue of out-of-print soundtrack with complete score as a bonus. 78 minutes of music, including 45 minutes of music never released before.Missing: modern review reassessment
  23. [23]
    Episode 18 - Fitzwilly - The Baton: A John Williams Musical Journey
    Apr 10, 2019 · Host Jeff Commings analyzes the top moments in the score as we say goodbye to Williams' very impressive comedy film era.
  24. [24]
    Watch Fitzwilly | Prime Video - Amazon.com
    Rating 4.7 (428) It's handmaiden-to-footservant combat when secretary Barbara Feldon attempts to scuttle butler Dick Van Dyke right out of the heist business in this ...Missing: modern | Show results with:modern
  25. [25]
    Fitzwilly (1968): Where to Watch and Stream Online | Reelgood
    Rating 61% (29) Currently you are able to watch Fitzwilly streaming on Roku, Prime Video, Kanopy, MGM+ (Via Philo), fuboTV, PlutoTV, DIRECTV Stream, MGM+, and MGM+ (Via ...Missing: modern | Show results with:modern
  26. [26]
    Fitzwilly 1968 One Sheet Poster Folded - Etsy
    In stock Rating 5.0 (35) fitzwilly original, limited edition one sheet poster folded movie poster,<br>circa. Rare find. Price:$440.00. Loading. Fitzwilly 1968 One Sheet Poster Folded.
  27. [27]
    FITZWILLY STRIKES BACK - Rare Film Posters
    In stock 7-day returnsFITZWILLY STRIKES BACK. £39.50. Original British 11 inch x 8 1/4 inch Trade Advertisement from Kinematograph Weekly for the 1967 ...Missing: merchandise | Show results with:merchandise
  28. [28]
    Johnny Williams - Fitzwilly (Original Motion Picture Score)
    ### Summary of Fitzwilly (Original Motion Picture Score) by Johnny Williams
  29. [29]
  30. [30]
  31. [31]
    Johnny Williams - Fitzwilly (Original Motion Picture Score)
    Here are the releases of the *Fitzwilly* soundtrack, listed chronologically:
  32. [32]
  33. [33]
    Fitzwilly (expanded) from Music Box Records - JOHN WILLIAMS
    Oct 15, 2013 · Very nice surprise indeed. The album recording is very good (I hope the remaster is well done, both the Tsunami boot and the Varèse reissue were ...Fitzwilly (expanded) from Music Box Records - Page 3The John Williams Expanded Score Master SpreadsheetMore results from www.jwfan.comMissing: modern reassessment