Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Major archbishop

A major archbishop is the metropolitan of a see determined or recognized by the Supreme Authority of the Church, on whom the governance has been conferred of an entire Eastern Church sui iuris equivalent to that of a patriarchal Church, this governance having been expressly conferred by the same Authority.^[1]^[2] This rank, intermediate between that of a metropolitan and a patriarch, was established by Pope Paul VI in 1964 for the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church to accord it quasi-patriarchal privileges while reserving certain decisions—such as the confirmation of elections and the erection of new eparchies outside the traditional patriarchal territory—to papal approval, distinguishing it from full patriarchal autonomy.^[3] Currently, four Eastern Catholic Churches hold major archiepiscopal status: the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, headed by Sviatoslav Shevchuk; the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church; the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church; and the Romanian Greek Catholic Church.^[3] These churches enjoy synodal governance akin to patriarchal ones, with the major archbishop exercising legislative, executive, and judicial powers assisted by a permanent synod, though papal sanction is required for headship succession and some jurisdictional expansions, reflecting a balance between Eastern autonomy and Roman primacy.^[1]^[3] The title underscores the historical and liturgical antiquity of these churches while navigating ecumenical sensitivities and canonical precedents in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO, canons 151–154).^[2]

Definition and Canonical Basis

Canonical Definition

A major archbishop is defined in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO) as the metropolitan of a determined see who presides over an entire Eastern Catholic Church sui iuris that lacks patriarchal status but enjoys special rights and obligations recognized by the Supreme Authority of the Church due to factors such as antiquity, tradition, or the size of the faithful community.^[2] This rank, equivalent to a patriarch in many respects but with delineated limitations, underscores the Church's full communion with the Roman See while preserving Eastern autonomy.^[2] The CCEO, promulgated by Pope John Paul II on October 18, 1990, and effective from October 1, 1991, establishes this hierarchy in Canon 151, specifying that the major archbishop governs with rights akin to those of a patriarch unless common law, particular law, or papal concession provides otherwise.^[2] Unlike full patriarchs, whose sees trace to ancient apostolic origins with broader jurisdictional independence, major archbishops operate under closer oversight by the Roman Pontiff, particularly in episcopal appointments and synodal confirmations, reflecting a balanced ecclesiology that integrates Eastern patrimony with universal Catholic unity.^[2] This canonical framework applies the norms of patriarchal governance to major archiepiscopal churches mutatis mutandis (Canon 152), ensuring the major archbishop's role in convening and presiding over the synod of bishops, fostering liturgical and disciplinary cohesion, and representing the Church externally, all while subordinating key decisions—such as the erection of eparchies or major legislative acts—to papal approbation.^[2] The title thus serves as an intermediate rank, ranking immediately after patriarchs by date of Church erection (Canon 154), and embodies the CCEO's intent to codify Eastern canon law distinct from the Latin Code of Canon Law while affirming primacy.^[2]

Terminology and Titles

The term major archbishop (Latin: archiepiscopus maior) designates the metropolitan who presides over a major archiepiscopal church, a sui iuris Eastern Catholic Church with patriarchal antiquity but lacking full patriarchal status, as codified in canon 151 of the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO).^[2] This title, introduced in the CCEO promulgated by Pope John Paul II on October 18, 1990, reflects a hierarchical rank immediately below patriarchs in precedence of honor, per canon 154.^[2] In Eastern liturgical traditions, the equivalent term major archeparch may be used, emphasizing the archeparchial (diocesan-like) governance structure over a province of eparchies.^[4] The official title incorporates the see's name, such as "Major Archbishop of Kyiv-Halych and Galicia" for the head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church or "Major Archbishop-Catholicos of Trivandrum" in the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church, where the additional "Catholicos" denotes a traditional Syriac title retained with papal approval.^[5] Unlike patriarchs, who use "Patriarch of [See]", major archbishops do not employ patriarchal nomenclature to preserve canonical distinctions in authority and election processes.^[2] Major archbishops are formally addressed as "Your Beatitude" (Beatitudo Vestra in Latin correspondence), a style shared with Eastern patriarchs, reflecting their elevated dignity while subordinated to the Roman Pontiff.^[6] This protocol applies universally except in cases like the Syro-Malankara Church, where informal Syriac honorifics such as "Bava" (father) may supplement official usage among the faithful.^[5]

Historical Origins and Evolution

Establishment for the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church

The title of major archbishop was first established for the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (UGCC) on December 23, 1963, when Pope Paul VI conferred it upon Josyf Slipyj, who had served as metropolitan archbishop of Lviv since succeeding Andrey Sheptytsky in 1944.^[7]^[8] This innovation in canon law created a new hierarchical rank intermediate between metropolitan and patriarch, specifically tailored to recognize the UGCC's historical significance and Slipyj's endurance after 18 years of Soviet imprisonment, including hard labor in Siberia following the church's forcible suppression by Ukrainian Soviet authorities in 1946.^[9]^[10] Slipyj's release in February 1963, secured through Vatican diplomatic efforts amid Nikita Khrushchev's partial thaw, enabled his arrival in Rome and participation in the Second Vatican Council, where on October 11 he advocated elevating the see of Kyiv-Halych to patriarchal dignity as a testament to the UGCC's "witness of blood" under persecution.^[11]^[9] The major archbishopric, however, represented a measured elevation short of full patriarchal autonomy, granting the UGCC head enhanced liturgical and administrative privileges—such as convening synods and ordaining bishops with papal confirmation—while maintaining direct accountability to the Holy See to navigate geopolitical sensitivities, including relations with Orthodox churches opposed to Catholic patriarchates in historically contested territories like Ukraine.^[10]^[8] This establishment affirmed the UGCC's continuity in exile and diaspora, where it had preserved Byzantine liturgical traditions and hierarchical structure despite the loss of its homeland base, numbering over 4 million faithful pre-suppression.^[12] The title's see was initially Lviv of the Ukrainians, later transferred to Kyiv-Halych in 2005 upon the church's legal restoration in independent Ukraine, underscoring the major archbishopric's role in adapting Eastern Catholic governance to suppressed yet resilient communities.^[13]^[12]

Expansion to Other Eastern Churches

The rank of major archbishop, initially conferred on the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church in 1963, was extended to other Eastern Catholic Churches as a means to recognize their ecclesiastical maturity and numerical significance while maintaining canonical oversight by the Holy See. This expansion aligned with the provisions of the 1990 Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, which formalized the title for sui iuris churches not attaining full patriarchal status but possessing substantial internal governance through synods.^[14] The Syro-Malabar Catholic Church, the second-largest Eastern Catholic Church with roots tracing to the apostolic era in India, was elevated to major archiepiscopal status on December 16, 1992, by Pope John Paul II. This decree appointed Cardinal Antony Padiyara as the first major archbishop, affirming the church's hierarchical structure established in 1923 and its rapid growth to over four million faithful by the late 20th century. The elevation addressed longstanding requests for greater autonomy amid the church's expansion beyond Kerala, while reserving key decisions like episcopal elections for papal confirmation.^[15]^[16] Subsequently, on February 10, 2005, Pope John Paul II raised the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church to major archiepiscopal rank, appointing Moran Mar Baselios Marthoma Cyril as its inaugural major archbishop. Formed in 1930 through reunion with Rome from Oriental Orthodoxy, this church, centered in Kerala with around half a million members, gained enhanced synodal authority over liturgy and discipline, reflecting its doctrinal fidelity and organizational consolidation despite historical schisms.^[17] Later that year, on December 16, 2005, Pope Benedict XVI extended the dignity to the Romanian Greek Catholic Church, designating Cardinal Lucian Mureșan as major archbishop of Făgăraș and Alba Iulia. Suppressed under communist rule from 1948 to 1989, this Byzantine-rite church, numbering approximately 500,000 adherents primarily in Transylvania, received the status to bolster its post-restoration recovery and synodal functions, including the election of bishops by the holy synod subject to papal assent.^[18]

Key Papal Interventions and Documents

Pope Paul VI established the rank of major archbishop on December 23, 1963, by appointing Cardinal Josyf Slipyj as Major Archbishop of Lviv, thereby granting the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church an intermediate form of hierarchical autonomy short of full patriarchal status, in response to longstanding requests for greater recognition amid Soviet suppression.^[19] This intervention addressed the church's suppressed metropolitan tradition while preserving Roman oversight, as Slipyj's elevation followed his release from Soviet imprisonment and participation in the Second Vatican Council.^[20] Pope John Paul II formalized the canonical structure for major archbishops in the Codex Canonum Ecclesiarum Orientalium, promulgated on October 18, 1990, with canons 151–154 delineating their election, confirmation by the Roman Pontiff, jurisdictional rights over suffragan bishops, and liturgical privileges akin to patriarchs but subordinate to papal authority.^[21] He then extended the rank to the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church via decree on December 16, 1992, appointing Cardinal Antony Padiyara as its first major archbishop, recognizing the church's ancient apostolic origins and growing eparchies in India.^[22]^[23] Further expansions occurred under Pope John Paul II, who elevated the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church to major archiepiscopal status in February 2005, bestowing the title on its head to affirm its distinct East Syriac heritage reconciled with Rome since 1930.^[24] Pope Benedict XVI similarly raised the Romanian Greek Catholic Church to this rank, appointing Lucian Mureșan as major archbishop on June 2, 2005, acknowledging its Byzantine rite continuity despite communist-era persecution and property losses.^[25] These actions balanced Eastern ecclesial aspirations with the principle of unity under the Roman Pontiff, as articulated in post-Vatican II reforms.

Rights, Privileges, and Limitations

Jurisdictional Authority

The major archbishop exercises ordinary jurisdictional authority as the metropolitan of the principal see of a major archiepiscopal church sui iuris, presiding over the synod of bishops and governing the internal affairs of the entire church in a manner analogous to a patriarch, subject to the provisions of the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO).^[2] This includes oversight of all eparchies within the territorial boundaries of the church, with rights to conduct visitations, regulate ecclesiastical discipline, and ensure fidelity to the traditions of the rite.^[2] As a local hierarch, the major archbishop holds full eparchial authority within his own see, equivalent to that of an eparchial bishop, encompassing legislative, executive, and judicial powers over the faithful, clergy, and institutions therein.^[2] In collaboration with the synod, the major archbishop appoints bishops to eparchies within the church sui iuris, requiring synodal consent and subsequent confirmation by the Roman Pontiff before consecration and installation.^[2] The synod, convened and presided over by the major archbishop, serves as the highest legislative and judicial authority for the church, enacting norms on doctrine, discipline, and administration, though decisions with broader implications demand Apostolic See approval to take effect beyond internal governance.^[2] Judicial competence extends to establishing an ordinary tribunal for the church, appointing officials with permanent synodal consent, and handling penal matters through extra-judicial decrees or synodal processes, limited to subjects within the territorial jurisdiction.^[2] Unlike patriarchs, whose jurisdiction may extend extra-territorially with greater autonomy, the major archbishop's authority is more circumscribed, confined primarily to the church's traditional territory and requiring papal consent for actions such as erecting new eparchies abroad, accepting resignations, or dispensing from obligations like clerical celibacy.^[2] This structure reflects the CCEO's intent to balance autonomy with communion under the supreme authority of the Roman Pontiff, as the major archbishop's election itself necessitates papal confirmation before exercising office (CCEO can. 153).^[2] Consequently, while empowered to manage church goods, receive non-Catholic hierarchs into communion (with synodal consent), and remove clerics from the clerical state in urgent cases, these prerogatives remain subordinate to Roman oversight, distinguishing the rank from full patriarchal status.^[2]

Relations with the Holy See

Major archbishops maintain a relationship of full communion and subordination with the Holy See, as defined in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO), wherein they exercise ordinary legislative, judicial, and administrative powers over their respective sui iuris churches while remaining subject to the supreme authority of the Roman Pontiff.^[2] This framework ensures ecclesial unity, requiring major archbishops to align their governance with universal Church law and the Pontiff's directives, distinguishing their role from that of autonomous patriarchs by imposing additional layers of papal oversight.^[2] For instance, Canon 152 of the CCEO mandates that major archbishops govern in communion with the Roman Pontiff, who holds the right to intervene in matters affecting the Church's welfare.^[2] A pivotal aspect of this relation is the election process: the synod of bishops elects the major archbishop according to Canons 63–74, but the candidate must formally request confirmation from the Roman Pontiff, who notifies acceptance via a synodal letter before enthronement and exercise of office can proceed.^[2] If confirmation is denied, a new election occurs within a timeframe set by the Pontiff (CCEO Canon 153).^[2] This contrasts with patriarchal elections, which require only notification to the Holy See without prior confirmation. Recent examples include Pope Francis's confirmation of Bishop Raphael Thattil as Major Archbishop of the Syro-Malabar Church on January 9, 2024, following synodal election.^[26] Major archbishops are obligated to seek papal consent for significant structural actions, such as erecting ecclesiastical provinces or eparchies (CCEO Canon 154) and appointing bishops, which requires both synodal consent and Pontifical approval (CCEO Canon 155).^[2] They must also submit quinquennial reports on the state of their church (CCEO Canon 157), visit the tombs of Apostles Peter and Paul with a subsequent report (CCEO Canon 156), and obtain acceptance for resignations (CCEO Canon 158).^[2] Judicial decisions by major archbishops may be appealed directly to the Roman Pontiff (CCEO Canon 162), and broader norms on liturgy or discipline affecting other churches require papal approval (CCEO Canon 166).^[2] These provisions reflect a deliberate canonical balance: major archbishops enjoy near-patriarchal autonomy internally but with heightened accountability to the Holy See to preserve doctrinal and jurisdictional unity, as evidenced by the CCEO's emphasis on the Pontiff's role in confirming elections, reviewing acts, and directing transitions upon vacancy (CCEO Canons 159–160).^[2] Financial administration and seminary establishments further fall under potential papal audit or standards (CCEO Canons 167–168), underscoring the Holy See's supervisory prerogative without daily interference in routine governance.^[2]

Differences from Patriarchal and Metropolitan Ranks

A major archbishop possesses the same rights, privileges, and obligations as a patriarch, except in cases expressly denied by common law or the supreme authority of the Church, as stipulated in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO) canons 151–154.^[1] This includes authority to preside over a synod of bishops for the entire Eastern Church sui iuris, to legislate for that Church within the limits of the law, and to govern with ordinary power, but with notable restrictions on autonomy compared to patriarchal rank. The primary distinction lies in the election process: the synod of bishops elects a major archbishop, but papal confirmation is required for the election's validity and the candidate's installation, whereas a newly elected patriarch merely notifies the Roman Pontiff, who grants ecclesiastical communion without confirmatory approval.^[3] ^[27] Additionally, major archbishops exercise lesser jurisdiction outside their Church's traditional territory and receive fewer ceremonial honors in precedence, with patriarchs ranking higher in liturgical and diplomatic protocols.^[28] In contrast to metropolitan rank, which governs a metropolitan Church sui iuris comprising a province of eparchies under CCEO canons 155–171, a major archbishop holds broader authority over an entire Eastern Church equivalent to a patriarchal structure, including the power to erect, suppress, or modify eparchies within the Church's territory subject to fewer papal interventions than a metropolitan requires.^[29] Metropolitans, while also elected by their synod and requiring papal confirmation, lack the full synodal governance model of major archbishops and must seek Roman approval for actions such as appointing coadjutors or auxiliaries beyond their province, reflecting a more limited scope confined to regional oversight rather than church-wide presidency.^[29] This positions major archbishops as an intermediate rank, bridging metropolitan provincial authority and patriarchal near-autonomy, often established by the Holy See to recognize historical sees without granting full patriarchal dignity.^[3]

Current Major Archiepiscopal Churches

Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church

The Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (UGCC) is the largest Eastern Catholic Church sui iuris, governed as a major archiepiscopal church with its see in Kyiv-Halych, Ukraine.^[30] Its head holds the title of Major Archbishop of Kyiv-Halych and Father and Head of the UGCC, presiding over a synod of bishops that exercises legislative, executive, and judicial authority within the church's internal affairs.^[31] The UGCC traces its origins to the Union of Brest in 1596, when bishops of the Kyivan Metropolia entered full communion with the Holy See while retaining the Byzantine liturgical tradition. In 1963, following the release of Cardinal Josyf Slipyj from Soviet imprisonment, Pope Paul VI elevated the head of the Ukrainian Catholic Church in exile to the rank of Major Archbishop of Lviv, granting enhanced autonomy short of full patriarchal status to accommodate the church's suppressed situation in Ukraine and its diaspora communities.^[32] This elevation recognized the UGCC's historical metropolitanate structure, centered in Halych (Galicia), while reserving certain prerogatives, such as the creation of new eparchies or the acceptance of resignations of bishops, to papal approval. After the fall of the Soviet Union and the legalization of the UGCC in Ukraine on December 1, 1989, the church reestablished its hierarchy domestically, with the first post-suppression synod convening in Lviv in 1992.^[12] Pope John Paul II relocated the major archepiscopal see from Lviv to Kyiv in 2004, renaming it Major Archbishop of Kyiv-Halych to reflect the church's broader Ukrainian patrimony and apostolic origins in Kyivan Rus'.^[33] The current Major Archbishop, Sviatoslav Shevchuk, was elected by the Synod of Bishops on March 23, 2011, at age 40, and confirmed by Pope Benedict XVI. Born in 1970 in Stryi, Ukraine, Shevchuk had previously served as apostolic visitor for Ukrainian faithful in Kazakhstan and Siberia.^[34] Under his leadership, the UGCC comprises 34 eparchies worldwide, serving approximately 5.5 million baptized members, predominantly in western Ukraine, with significant diaspora communities in Canada, the United States, Europe, and Australia.^[30] The UGCC's major archiepiscopal status enables it to function with substantial self-governance, including the election of its primate from among three candidates selected by the synod, subject to papal assent. Liturgically Byzantine and canonically distinct, the church maintains its distinct identity amid Ukraine's Orthodox majority, emphasizing evangelization, social outreach, and ecumenical dialogue while navigating geopolitical challenges, including the ongoing Russian invasion since 2022.^[35]

Syro-Malabar Catholic Church

The Syro-Malabar Catholic Church, an Eastern Catholic Church of the East Syriac liturgical tradition with origins tracing to the evangelization of India by St. Thomas the Apostle in the first century, was elevated to major archiepiscopal rank on December 16, 1992, by Pope John Paul II through the apostolic constitution Spirituali militum curae.^[36] This status positioned the church's metropolitan see of Ernakulam-Angamaly as a major archeparchy, granting its head quasi-patriarchal authority over internal governance while reserving certain acts, such as the erection of new eparchies or the approval of synodal laws, for papal sanction.^[37] The elevation addressed longstanding aspirations for greater autonomy within the Catholic communion, building on the church's restoration to full hierarchical structure in 1923 and its recognition as a distinct rite in 1930.^[38] The major archbishop, elected by the permanent synod of bishops and confirmed by the Roman Pontiff, presides over the synod, which holds legislative, executive, and judicial powers akin to those of a patriarchal synod under the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO, canons 140-242). This includes the right to canonical visitation of eparchies, convocation of synodal sessions, and oversight of liturgical, doctrinal, and disciplinary matters specific to the Syro-Malabar Rite.^[39] Unlike a patriarch, the major archbishop's primacy is not historically rooted in ancient sees of the first millennium, limiting claims to ecumenical significance, but it enables effective administration of the church's 35 eparchies worldwide, serving nearly five million faithful, predominantly in Kerala, India.^[40] Mar Raphael Thattil, born April 21, 1956, in Thrissur, Kerala, serves as the current major archbishop, having been elected by the synod on January 8, 2024, and enthroned on January 11, 2024, following the resignation of Cardinal George Alencherry due to health and age-related issues in December 2023.^[41] Ordained a priest on December 21, 1980, and consecrated bishop on April 10, 2010, for the Eparchy of Shamshabad, Thattil previously held roles in ecumenical dialogue and pastoral formation. His tenure has involved addressing internal liturgical tensions over the uniform celebration of the Qurbana (Eucharist), where some factions resisted synodal directives favoring a compromise between ad orientem and versus populum orientations; these disputes prompted papal delegates and culminated in a 2025 reorganization under Pope Leo XIV, including new eparchial boundaries and the lifting of the delegate's mandate on July 8, 2025, signaling restored synodal authority.^[42]^[43] Predecessors include Mar Varkey Vithayathil, appointed major archbishop on December 23, 1999, by Pope John Paul II and serving until his death in 2011, and Mar George Alencherry, elected May 24, 2011, and elevated to cardinal the same year, who navigated financial accountability inquiries alongside liturgical governance.^[44] The major archbishop's role underscores the church's commitment to preserving its Chaldean heritage amid modernization pressures, with the synod retaining veto power over episcopal appointments outside the major archbishop's nomination.^[45]

Syro-Malankara Catholic Church

The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church, an Eastern Catholic Church sui iuris of the West Syriac liturgical tradition, was elevated to major archiepiscopal rank on February 10, 2005, by Pope John Paul II through the apostolic bull Ab ipso Sancto Thoma.^[46]^[47] This status recognizes the church's ancient heritage tracing to the missionary work of Saint Thomas the Apostle while granting it a synodal governance structure headed by a major archbishop, who holds the title Major Archbishop-Catholicos of Trivandrum and presides over an episcopal synod for electing successors and managing internal affairs, subject to papal confirmation.^[48] The elevation affirmed the church's approximately 500,000 faithful primarily in Kerala, India, and its diaspora, allowing greater autonomy in liturgical, theological, and disciplinary matters akin to patriarchal churches, though without full patriarchal privileges such as creating new dioceses abroad without Roman approval.^[17] Cyril Baselios Malancharuvil (born James Malancharuvil, 1935–2007), previously Metropolitan Archbishop of Trivandrum since 1995, was appointed the first Major Archbishop-Catholicos upon the elevation and assumed the title "Catholicos of the Malankara Catholic Church" in line with Syriac tradition.^[46]^[49] His tenure, from February 10, 2005, to his death on January 18, 2007, oversaw the convocation of the church's first episcopal synod in August 2005, which formalized particular laws and statutes under the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches.^[48]^[50] Following Cyril Baselios's death, the Holy Episcopal Synod convened on February 8, 2007, and elected Isaac Cleemis Thottunkal (born June 15, 1959), then Archbishop of Tiruvalla, as the second Major Archbishop-Catholicos; he adopted the name Baselios Cleemis and was enthroned on March 5, 2007, at St. Mary's Cathedral in Trivandrum.^[5]^[51] Pope Benedict XVI elevated him to the College of Cardinals on November 24, 2012, as one of three Eastern Catholic cardinals created that consistory, enhancing the church's visibility in universal Church governance.^[5] As of October 2025, Baselios Cleemis continues in office, leading a synod of over 20 bishops across 14 eparchies in India and abroad, including missions in the United States, Europe, and Australia, while advocating for ecumenical dialogue with Oriental Orthodox churches amid Kerala’s diverse Christian landscape.^[52]^[5]

Romanian Greek Catholic Church

The Romanian Greek Catholic Church, formally the Romanian Church United with Rome of the Byzantine Rite, traces its origins to the Union of Alba Iulia in 1697–1701, when Romanian Orthodox bishops and faithful in Transylvania entered into full communion with the Holy See while retaining their Eastern liturgical traditions and ecclesiastical discipline.^[53] Established as a metropolitanate in 1853 with its see at Făgăraș and later transferred to Alba Iulia and Blaj, the church endured severe persecution under the communist regime from 1948 to 1989, during which its hierarchy was imprisoned or suppressed and properties confiscated, forcing it underground.^[54] Post-restoration in 1989, it reorganized with seven eparchies in Romania and oversight of diaspora communities, including the Eparchy of Saint George in Canton, Ohio, for the United States and Canada, serving approximately 500,000 faithful across 1,240 parishes.^[55] On December 16, 2005, Pope Benedict XVI elevated the church to major archiepiscopal status, granting it a higher degree of autonomy while preserving the major archbishop's dependency on papal confirmation for episcopal appointments and synodal decisions beyond local governance.^[18] This rank, centered on the Major Archeparchy of Făgăraș and Alba Iulia, positioned the church alongside other Eastern Catholic sees like the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, enabling the head to convene a permanent synod and exercise quasi-patriarchal authority over internal affairs, subject to Roman oversight for doctrinal and inter-ecclesial matters.^[56] The elevation recognized the church's historical resilience and numerical significance among Eastern Catholics, though it fell short of full patriarchal status, which requires explicit papal concession. Cardinal Lucian Mureșan, ordained a priest in 1957 after clandestine seminary training amid communist restrictions, was appointed bishop of Maramureș in 1990, metropolitan archbishop in 1994, and the first major archbishop in 2005, receiving the cardinal's red biretta in 2010.^[57] His tenure emphasized recovery of confiscated assets, ecumenical dialogue with the Romanian Orthodox Church, and preservation of Byzantine patrimony, including the restoration of historic sites like the Blaj Cathedral. Mureșan died on September 25, 2025, at age 94 in Blaj, leaving the see vacant pending synodal election of a successor, whose candidacy must receive papal assent.^[58]^[59] Under major archiepiscopal governance, the church maintains six suffragan eparchies in Romania—Oradea Mare, Cluj-Gherla, Lugoj, Maramureș, Orșova, and Baia Mare—coordinating pastoral care, seminary formation at Blaj, and charitable works amid ongoing property restitution disputes with state authorities.^[55] This structure underscores the major archbishop's role in fostering liturgical fidelity to Eastern traditions while navigating Romania's post-communist secular landscape and minority status relative to the dominant Orthodox population.

Debates and Aspirations

Calls for Elevation to Patriarchal Status

The Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church (UGCC) has advocated for decades for the elevation of its major archbishop to patriarchal status, viewing it as essential for organizing its internal governance and affirming its historical significance as the largest Eastern Catholic Church.^[27]^[60] In May 2024, Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk expressed hope that the UGCC would soon achieve patriarchal rank, reiterating long-standing requests from its synod and faithful.^[27] This aspiration dates back centuries, with the major archbishopric title granted in 1963 as a compromise to avoid provoking the Russian Orthodox Church, which regards the UGCC's structure as tied to the historic Kyivan metropolitanate rather than a full patriarchate.^[61] Proponents argue that patriarchal status would enhance ecclesial autonomy without undermining communion with Rome, allowing the UGCC to better manage its global diaspora amid geopolitical pressures, including the Russian invasion of Ukraine.^[62] In February 2022, the Vatican's Dicastery for the Eastern Churches was reported to be reviewing such a request, though no elevation has occurred, reflecting caution over ecumenical relations with Eastern Orthodox Churches that view patriarchal claims in Ukraine as provocative.^[62] Shevchuk has emphasized that the status transcends honorary titles, enabling structured self-governance akin to other patriarchal sees.^[60] In contrast, calls from other major archiepiscopal churches are less prominent or documented. The Syro-Malabar Catholic Church has occasionally discussed expanded jurisdiction in seminars, such as one in November 2008 on its ecclesial mission, but formal demands for patriarchal elevation remain sporadic and tied more to liturgical and administrative autonomy debates rather than a unified push.^[63] Similarly, neither the Syro-Malankara nor Romanian Greek Catholic Churches have issued sustained public campaigns for such promotion since their respective elevations to major archiepiscopal rank in 2005, focusing instead on internal consolidation and relations with local Orthodox counterparts.^[64] These aspirations, where present, underscore tensions between Eastern Catholic desires for canonical parity with ancient patriarchates and the Holy See's prioritization of unity and historical precedents in granting full patriarchal privileges.

Implications for Ecclesial Unity and Autonomy

The rank of major archbishop, as defined in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (CCEO), confers extensive internal governance rights upon the head of a sui iuris church, including the convocation of permanent synods for legislative and judicial functions, akin to those of patriarchal churches, while mandating papal confirmation of the major archbishop's election to safeguard doctrinal and jurisdictional unity with the Holy See.^[65] This structure implies a deliberate tension: autonomy in liturgical, disciplinary, and administrative matters fosters local ecclesial vitality, yet the requirement for Roman approval in key areas—such as the erection or suppression of eparchies (CCEO canon 155) and the transfer of the major archbishop's see (CCEO canon 57)—prevents unilateral actions that could erode communion.^[65] For ecclesial unity, the rank reinforces the Eastern Catholic Churches' integration into the universal Church by embedding mechanisms of accountability, such as the major archbishop's obligation to seek papal assent for certain synodal decrees and the right of appeal to the Roman Pontiff, thereby mitigating risks of isolation or alignment with non-Catholic Orthodox jurisdictions amid geopolitical pressures.^[66] In the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, for instance, this framework has sustained fidelity to Rome during historical suppressions and contemporary conflicts, as evidenced by Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk's affirmations of papal support amid Russian aggression, ensuring the church's role in ecumenical witness without compromising autonomy in pastoral adaptations.^[67] Critics within Eastern circles, however, argue that the rank's limitations—contrasted with patriarchal churches' broader latitude in bishop elections and territorial expansions—can engender perceptions of subordination, potentially straining unity if unaddressed aspirations for elevation lead to internal dissent.^[68] Regarding autonomy, major archbishops wield quasi-patriarchal authority over their churches' internal affairs, including the governance of eparchies and the preservation of Eastern traditions, which has enabled churches like the Syro-Malabar to convene general assemblies for self-regulation since 1999.^[69] Yet, this autonomy remains qualified: unlike patriarchs, major archbishops cannot independently alter the church's patriarchal status or relocate its principal see without papal consent, implications that underscore Rome's ultimate oversight to preserve the Church's hierarchical communion.^[65] This calibrated model has empirically supported resilience, as in the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church's synodal operations under persecution, but it also highlights causal vulnerabilities—such as delayed Roman approvals potentially hampering rapid responses to crises—prompting debates on whether fuller patriarchal autonomy would enhance or jeopardize the delicate equilibrium of unity.^[70]

References

[1]
151 - CCEO: text - IntraText CT
A major archbishop is the metropolitan of a see determined or recognized by the Supreme Authority of the Church, who presides over an entire Eastern Church.
[2]
[PDF] CODE OF CANONS OF THE EASTERN CHURCHES | Orthocath
Canon 1 - The canons of this Code affect all and solely the Eastern Catholic Churches, unless, with regard to relations with the Latin Church, it is expressly ...
[3]
Major Archbishops - GCatholic.org
There are now four major archiepiscopal Churches, the Ukrainian, Syro-Malabar, Syro-Malankar, and Romanian.
[4]
CODE OF CANONS OF THE EASTERN CHURCHES-1
TITLE V. MAJOR ARCHIEPISCOPAL CHURCHES. Can. 151. A major archbishop is the metropolitan of a see determined or recognized by the Supreme authority of the ...
[5]
Major Archbishop Catholicos - The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church
Informal style: Cardinal Cleemis/ Cleemis Bava. MAIN OFFICES. Major Archbishop-Catholicos of the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church. Major Archbishop of Trivandrum.
[6]
Hierarchical Structure in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches
Hierarchical Structure in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches 141 communion of the people of God. ... major archbishop presides over the Church as “father” ...
[7]
Cardinal Slipyj
December 23, 1963. Josyf Slipyj received the title of 'Major Archbishop,' approved by Pope Paul VI. In 1949, he had been secretly named a cardinal and in ...
[8]
An Extraordinary Life For Extraordinary Times - Patriarch Josyf Slipyj
Jan 31, 2022 · Later in 1963, he received the title of Major Archbishop from Pope Paul VI. It was rumoured that Metropolitan Slipyj had been secretly named ...
[9]
Ukrainian Catholic leader recalls Cardinal Slipyj's heroism
Feb 21, 2017 · Cardinal Slipyj was imprisoned for 18 years, including eight years of hard labor in the Siberian gulag, after Joseph Stalin's regime suppressed ...
[10]
Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church - KCBC
Major archbishop is a unique title within the Catholic Church that was introduced in 1963 as part of the church title hierarchy. Since March 2011 the head of ...
[11]
In honor of Ukraine and of Cardinal Josyf Slipyj, at the 130th ...
Mar 2, 2022 · On October 11 1963 Slipyj spoke at the Council of Ukrainian Church's witness of blood and proposed that the see of Kiev-Halych be raised to the ...
[12]
The Ukrainian Catholic Church | CNEWA
Jun 27, 2024 · On the same day, the title of the head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church was changed from “Major Archbishop of Lviv” to “Major Archbishop ...
[13]
Return to Kyiv 2005 | Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church
The official date of return was the 21 st of August 2005. As of this day, the Head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church holds the title of Major Archbishop ...
[14]
https://www.intratext.com/IXT/ENG1199/_INDEX.HTM
[15]
history of the syro-malabar church - Indian Christianity
So on 16 December 1992 Pope John Paul II declared the Syro- Malabar Church as a Major Archiepiscopal Church and appointed Cardinal Antony Padiyara, the then ...
[16]
Syro Malabar Church History
Major Archbishop Varkey Cardinal Vithayathil passed away on Arpil 1, 2011. On 24 May 2011 Mar George Alencherry was elected Major Archbishop. Pope Benedict XVI ...
[17]
The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church - CNEWA
Oct 24, 2024 · On February 10, 2005, Pope John Paul II raised the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church to the rank of Major Archepiscopal Church. A sixth Syro- ...
[18]
The Romanian Catholic Church | CNEWA
Oct 26, 2021 · On December 16, 2005, Pope Benedict XVI raised the Romanian Greek Catholic Church to the rank of Major Archepiscopal Church, at the same time ...
[19]
Brief History of Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church
After the death of the Metropolitan Archbishop Andrey Sheptytsky on November 1, 1944, the Greek-Catholic Church was headed by Yosyp Slipyi.
[20]
https://catholicnewsagency.com/news/37878/analysis-why-greek-catholics-of-ukraine-seek-recognition-as-a-patriarchate
[21]
[PDF] ECCLESIAL TERMS - usccb
CCEO – abbreviation for the Latin title, Codex. Canonum Ecclesiarum Orientalium, which is the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches. ... major archbishop ( ...
[22]
[PDF] The Syro-Malabar Major Archiepiscopal Church
Thus on December 16, 1992, Pope John Paul II raised the Syro-Malabar Church to the ... The following laws are adapted and decreed in accordance with the CCEO 150.<|separator|>
[23]
Once Again, Syro-Malabar Yogam | ONE Magazine - CNEWA
In 1992 Pope John Paul II, recognizing this need, appointed Antony Cardinal Padiyara, Archbishop of Ernakulam-Angamaly, as Major Archbishop of the Syro-Malabar ...
[24]
The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church - Pro Oriente
In February 2005, the Vatican bestowed the title of Major Archbishop upon the Chief Hierarch of the Syro-Malankara Church, bringing the Syro-Malankara Church ...
[25]
Romanian Greek-Catholic Church - KCBC
On December 16, 2005, as the Romanian Church United with Rome, the Greek-Catholic church was elevated to the rank of a Major Archiepiscopal Church by Pope ...
[26]
Pope Francis confirms election of head of Syro-Malabar Church
Jan 10, 2024 · Pope Francis confirms the canonical election of Bishop Raphael Thattil as Major Archbishop of Ernakulam-Angamaly of the Syro-Malabars.
[27]
Ukrainian Major Archbishop hopes to become Patriarch soon
May 21, 2024 · ... patriarch informs the Pope after his election and requests ecclesiastical communion without requiring confirmation of the election.
[28]
Patriarchs, Archbishops & Metropolitans, Oh My! - byzcath.org
May 3, 2002 · Major Archbishop-Almost identical to a Patriarch, except for the manner of election and enthronement. They also exercise jurisdiction over ...Organization of the Eastern Catholic Hierarchy - The Byzantine ForumCardinals and Patriarchs - The Byzantine ForumMore results from www.byzcath.org
[29]
CCEO: text - IntraText CT
CCEO IntraText CT - Text. TITLE 5 The Major Archiepiscopal Churches. 152. Previous - Next · Click here to hide the links to concordance · Canon 152. What is ...
[30]
About the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church
The UGCC is headed by the Major Archbishop of Kyiv and Halych, His Beatitude Sviatoslav (Shevchuk). According to the canonical tradition of the Catholic Church ...
[31]
Father and Head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church
His Beatitude Sviatoslav is the Father and Head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. Born May 5, 1970, in Stryi, Lviv Region, Ukraine.
[32]
Patriarch Yosyf Slipy 1892–1984 | Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church
one of the most colorful figures in the modern history of UGCC. Scientist, theologian, leader of academic institutions, primate of the Ukrainian ...Missing: VI | Show results with:VI
[33]
The Church today | Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church
The head of the UGCC is the Major Archbishop of Kyiv-Halych, His Beatitude Sviatoslav Shevchuk, who succeeded Cardinal Lubomyr Husar in March 2011, after His ...<|separator|>
[34]
Biography of His Beatitude Sviatoslav
On March 23, 2011, Bishop Sviatoslav was elected Head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church at the Electoral Synod of UGCC Bishops, which was attended by 40 ...
[35]
His Beatitude Sviatoslav Shevchuk: There is great hope that the war ...
Aug 24, 2025 · So explains the Major Archbishop of Kyiv-Halych, Sviatoslav Shevchuk, in an interview with Vatican News. Below is the full transcript: Your ...
[36]
Syro-Malabar Church - PAUL PALLATH
... elevation of the Syro-Malabar Church to the rank and dignity of a major archiepiscopal Church as well as the present juridical status of this Church. The ...
[37]
[PDF] THE IMPACT OF CCEO ON THE LEGISLATIVE, EXECUTIVE AND ...
Canon Law…, 338. 38 Mar James Pazhayattil, bishop of Irinjalakkuda was appointed assistant to the Major Archbishop. His office ceased with the acceptance ...
[38]
Syro-Malabar Church | Encyclopedia.com
Following the visit of a special pontifical commission to Kerala in 1992, the Holy See elevated the Syro-Malabar Church to the rank of major archiepiscopal ...
[39]
[PDF] PARTICULAR LAWS OF THE SYRO-MALABAR CHURCH
Major Archiepiscopal Church. § 3. Candidates shall get inscribed to such ... Eastern Catholic Churches (Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, canons ...
[40]
Major Archbishop of the Syro-Malabar Church
Mar Raphael Thattil, born on 21 April 1956 in Thrissur to Ouseph and Thresia, has been a significant figure in the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church.Missing: history | Show results with:history
[41]
Major Archbishop - Syro Malabar Church
Mar Raphael Thattil · Date of Birth. 21 April 1956 · Feast Day. September 29 · Ordained Priest. 21 December 1980 · Episcopal ordination. 10 April 2010 · Enthroned as ...<|separator|>
[42]
Signaling end of Syro-Malabar liturgical dispute, Leo XIV concludes ...
Jul 8, 2025 · Pope Leo XIV has ended the mandate of Archbishop Cyril Vasil', SJ, as pontifical delegate in liturgical matters for the Syro-Malabar Archeparchy of Ernakulam- ...<|separator|>
[43]
Sweeping reorganization of Syro-Malabar Catholic Church
Aug 29, 2025 · CWN Editor's Note: Major Archbishop Raphael Thattil of Ernakulam-Angamaly, India, the head of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church since 2024, ...
[44]
Former Major Archbishops - Syro Malabar Church
On 23rd December 1999 His Holiness Pope John Paul II appointed Mar Varkey Vithayathil as the Major Archbishop of the Syro-Malabar Church and as the Archbishop ...
[45]
The Syro-Malabar Rite
Autonomous Status: The Syro-Malabar Church has its own hierarchy and is headed by a Major Archbishop. It obtained major archiepiscopal status, allowing ...
[46]
Malankara Church Jubilant At Elevation, Appointment Of Major ...
Feb 10, 2005 · On 10 February 2005, the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church was raised to the status of a major archiepiscopal Church by the papal document Ab ipso ...Missing: rank | Show results with:rank
[47]
Major Milestones - The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church
Archbishop Isaac Mar Cleemis, elected as the Major Archbishop-Catholicos of the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church by the Holy Episcopal Synod.
[48]
History of SMCC - The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church
The first Synod of the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church was convened from 16 to 18 August 2005 at the Major Archiepiscopal Curia (Catholicate Centre), Trivandrum.
[49]
Major Archbishop Cyril Baselios Catholicos - Malankara Catholic
He assumed the title “Catholicos of the Malankara Catholic Church.” Moran Mor Cyril Baselios, the First Major Archbishop-Catholicos passed away on Thursday 18 ...
[50]
Major Archbishop Cyril Mar Baselios Passes Away
Jan 18, 2007 · It was during his tenure as Archbishop in February 2005 that the Malankara Catholic Church was elevated to Major Archiepiscopal status. Cyril ...
[51]
HIS BEATITUDE BASELIOS CARDINAL CLEEMIS, Major ...
The Holy Episcopal Synod of Syro-Malankara Catholic Church, convoked on 8 February 2007 elected the Most Rev. Isaac Mar Cleemis as the new Major Archbishop- ...
[52]
Holy Episcopal Synod Fathers - The Syro-Malankara Catholic Church
Major Archbishop-Catholicos of the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church. HIS BEATITUDE BASELIOS CARDINAL CLEEMIS, Major Archbishop-Catholicos of the Syro-Malankara ...
[53]
Romanian Greek Catholic Church - Pro Oriente
In December 2005, Pope Benedict XVI appointed the previous metropolitan to the major archbishop, giving the Romanian Greek Catholic Church a more independent ...
[54]
Card. Lucian Mureșan, survivor of Romanian persecution, dies
Sep 27, 2025 · Bishop Lucian Mureșan was appointed bishop of Maramureș in 1990, then became metropolitan archbishop of Făgăraș and Alba Iulia in 1994. In 2005, ...
[55]
The Romanian Greek Catholic Church - Blessed Martyr Bishops
The Eparchy of St. George in Canton is a suffragan to the Major Archeparchy of Făgărăș and Alba Iulia, led by Major Archbishop and Cardinal Lucian Mureșan, the ...
[56]
MUREŞAN Card. Lucian
H.B. Cardinal Lucian Mureşan, Major Archbishop of Făgăraş şi Alba Iulia of the Romanians, was born on 23 May 1931 in Ferneziu, Romania.
[57]
Cardinal Mureşan, minister in secret before communism's collapse ...
Sep 26, 2025 · Cardinal Lucian Mureşan, major archbishop of the Greek Catholic Church in Romania, died Sept. 25, 2025, at age 94 ...
[58]
Cardinal Lucian Mureşan has died - Vatican News
Sep 25, 2025 · Cardinal Lucian Mureşan, Major Archbishop of the Romanian Greek-Catholic Church, died on 25 September in Blaj at the age of 94. Pope ...
[59]
Pope Leo remembers Cardinal Mureșan's exemplary witness under ...
Sep 27, 2025 · Cardinal Lucian Mureşan has died Cardinal Lucian Mureşan, Major Archbishop of the Romanian Greek-Catholic Church, died on 25 September in Blaj ...
[60]
A “Preacher of Peace” Amid Conflict - Catholic World Report
May 12, 2014 · Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk: The “patriarchal” status is not simply a title of “honor”, it is a way to organize the inner life and ...
[61]
The 'red hat challenge' for Ukrainian synodality - The Pillar
Oct 8, 2024 · While there have been calls for several centuries to recognize the head of the Ukrainian Catholic Church as Kyiv's patriarch, and popes have ...
[62]
With war looming, will Kyiv get a Catholic patriarch? - The Pillar
Feb 22, 2022 · The Vatican office which oversees Eastern Catholic Churches is considering a request that the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church be given “patriarchal” status.
[63]
Jurisdictional Tension between Vatican and Syro-Malabar Bishops
Nov 29, 2008 · The Nov. 14-15 seminar titled "Ecclesial mission of Syro-Malabar Church" addressed various issues including the Church's demand for jurisdiction ...
[64]
Romanian Greek Catholic Church elevated - The Byzantine Forum
Dec 16, 2005 · The Romanian Greek Catholic Church has been elevated from Metropolitan to Major Archepiscopal rank. Many years to Major Archbishop Lucian! One ...
[65]
http://www.intratext.com/IXT/ENG1199/_INDEX.HTM
[66]
Servant of the Gospel of Jesus Christ for the Hope of the World
The Eastern Churches with a patriarch or major archbishop have their own institutions of synodal character, namely, the Patriarchal Synod[100] and ...
[67]
Major Archbishop Sviatoslav: Pope wants Ukrainian Greek-Catholic ...
Jul 8, 2019 · Major Archbishop said that the meeting showed the Pope's “support for the Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church; to confirm his closeness to our ...
[68]
Bulletin Synodus Episcoporum - English edition - The Holy See
Since our Major Archbishop, Cardinal Varkey Vithayathil CSsR is not at ... jurisdiction to our hierarchy. Contrary to the opinion generally circulated ...<|separator|>
[69]
[PDF] S.I.C.O. 2004 - The Holy See
Major Archbishop in 1993; while in 1999 the first General Assembly of the. Syro-Malabar Church convened at Mount St. Thomas, Kakkanad. The 2004 Decree might ...<|separator|>
[70]
Despite Gratitude to Holy See, Major Archbishop Shevchuk Says ...
INTERVIEW: Despite Gratitude to Holy See, Major Archbishop Shevchuk Says Declaration With Russian Patriarchate Does Not Function · Leader of Ukrainian Greek ...