The Mali caste, also known as Phul Mali, is an occupational jati among Hindus in India traditionally associated with gardening, floriculture, and the cultivation of fruits and vegetables. Deriving its name from the Sanskrit term mālā meaning "garland," the community has historically specialized in growing flowers for religious offerings, garlands, and ornamental purposes, as well as maintaining gardens for elites and temples. Primarily distributed in western and northern India, including states like Maharashtra, Rajasthan, and Uttar Pradesh, Malis form endogamous groups with subgroups such as Saini in the north, reflecting regional variations in occupation and self-identification.[1]In traditional Hindu society, the Mali caste aligned with Shudra varna duties, emphasizing practical agrarian skills over ritual purity, though some subgroups assert Kshatriya origins tied to ancient warrior or royal gardener roles, a claim debated among historians due to the primarily occupational basis of jati formation. Empirical records from colonial gazetteers highlight their role in village economies, where they supplied produce and performed horticultural services, often intermarrying within the caste to preserve vocational expertise. Socially, Malis have experienced upward mobility through education and reservation policies, classified as Other Backward Classes in many states, enabling access to government jobs and quotas, while facing persistent endogamy and regional disparities in status.[2]Notable figures from the Mali caste include Jyotirao Phule (1827–1890), a pioneering social reformer who challenged Brahminical dominance and advocated for education among lower castes, founding institutions like the Satyashodhak Samaj to promote non-Brahmin leadership. This legacy underscores the community's contributions to anti-caste movements, though internal divisions persist over varna claims and political alignments, with some factions aligning with broader OBC coalitions. Contemporary Malis engage in diverse professions beyond traditional gardening, including agriculture, business, and public service, amid ongoing debates on caste identity influenced by affirmative action and urbanization.[3]
Origins and Etymology
Traditional Occupation and Derivation
The term Mali derives from the Sanskrit word mālā (माला), signifying a garland, which underscores the caste's historical association with the cultivation and arrangement of flowers into garlands for ceremonial and decorative purposes.[4][1] This etymological root aligns with self-designations such as Phul Mali (flower Mali), adopted by subgroups focused on floriculture to highlight their expertise in growing and supplying blooms.[4][1]The traditional occupation of the Mali centered on gardening, floristry, and the intensive cultivation of ornamental plants, vegetables, and flowers in small, often irrigated plots suitable for market production rather than large-scale field farming with ploughs. They specialized in producing garlands, wreaths, and fresh flowers for Hindu rituals, temple offerings, and elite households, leveraging knowledge of horticultural techniques to ensure year-round yields of items like roses, jasmine, and marigolds.[4]Colonial ethnographies, such as R. V. Russell's 1916 survey of castes in the Central Provinces, document the Mali's role in baghbani (garden cultivation), where they maintained vegetable and flower gardens near settlements, selling produce in local bazaars and avoiding the extensive agrarian labor associated with higher landholding castes. This focus on specialized, labor-intensive market gardening—evident in 1901 Census of India data enumerating them as vegetable-growers—distinguished them from broader cultivator groups, emphasizing artisanal skills in propagation and floral artistry over grain-based agriculture.[5]
Historical Roots and Claims
The Mali caste's emergence traces to the medieval expansion of agrarian specialization in India, particularly between the 10th and 15th centuries, when increased irrigation and urbanization created demand for intensive horticulture in fertile riverine zones. Groups likely of indigenous agricultural origin adopted roles as gardeners to supply flowers, garlands, and vegetables to temples, courts, and growing towns, integrating into the Hindu occupational framework without evidence of prior distinct ethnic identity. This development aligned with broader patterns of land grants and wet-rice cultivation in peninsular and northern river valleys, where ecological conditions favored small-scale, labor-intensive farming over large-scale grain production.[6]Colonial ethnographies, including the 1901 Census compilation by A. H. Baines, describe the Mali as a diffuse occupational group widely engaged in garland-making (mālā-derived) and market gardening, concentrated near urban peripheries rather than as independent landowners.[7] District gazetteers from regions like Maharashtra further record sub-groups such as Phul Mali (flower cultivators) and Jire Mali (specializing in greens), serving as attached laborers or suppliers to local elites and rituals, with no indications of martial or proprietary functions. These accounts emphasize causal ties to environmental suitability—irrigated alluvial soils enabling year-round vegetable cycles—over migratory or conquest narratives.Assertions of pre-medieval origins, such as links to ancient Yadava clans or Malava tribes, stem from community traditions but lack corroboration in epigraphic or archaeological records predating the Sultanate era, appearing instead as retrospective claims in 19th-20th century caste ethnographies like those of W. Crooke.[8] Such romanticized pedigrees often served to elevate status amid colonial enumerations, diverging from the verifiable pattern of occupational crystallization amid medieval economic shifts rather than heroic or divine foundations.[9]
Varna Status and Social Hierarchy
Position Within Hindu Caste System
The Mali caste's position in the traditional Hindu varna system is empirically aligned with the Shudra category, stemming from their primary occupation in gardening, floriculture, and related manual services that support higher varnas without involving governance, priestly rites, or independent trade.[10] While some classifications liken such cultivator-service roles to Vaishya functions due to agricultural involvement, the service-oriented nature—providing garlands, vegetables, and temple adornments to Brahmins and landowners—precludes Vaishya status, as it lacks the autonomy of mercantile or proprietary production.[11] Ritual purity norms further confine Malis to Shudra-like roles, with contact involving soil, plants, and labor deemed polluting for Vedic recitation or sacrificial duties reserved for Brahmins.[10]Within the jati hierarchy, Malis maintain endogamous practices and gotra affiliations, such as subgroups invoking Suryavanshi lineages, yet these do not elevate their status, as inter-jati marriage alliances remain subordinate to Brahmin, Kshatriya, and dominant landowning groups. Empirical markers of hierarchy include restricted hypergamy, where Mali women might marry into slightly higher service jatis but not elite varnas, reinforcing a mid-to-lower positioning amid thousands of jatis. This structure derives causally from occupational interdependence, where Malis depend on patronage from superiors for land access and ritual commissions, without reciprocal deference.[12]Historical interactions underscore subordination, as evidenced by commensality taboos prohibiting shared meals with Brahmins to avoid pollution transfer, and ritual precedence yielding to priestly authority in village ceremonies and temple services.[10] Landowners and Brahmins historically directed Mali labor for garland-making and garden maintenance, with no records of Malis officiating higher rites or claiming equivalent purity, countering later reinterpretations that obscure these functional inequalities through egalitarian lenses.[11] Such patterns, observable in pre-colonial accounts of jati duties, affirm a non-egalitarian hierarchy grounded in reciprocal obligations rather than fluid mobility.
Assertions of Kshatriya Lineage
Certain subgroups of the Mali community, particularly in northern and western India, have asserted Kshatriya lineage through narratives linking their origins to Suryavanshi (solar dynasty) or Chandravanshi (lunar dynasty) descent, framing themselves as descendants of ancient warrior clans.[13] These claims often invoke mythological ties to Rajput or Yaduvanshi lineages, positioning Malis as historically martial rather than merely occupational.[14]Such assertions gained traction through Sanskritization, a process of cultural emulation where lower-status groups adopt upper-caste rituals, vegetarianism, and purity norms to elevate their varna position, particularly intensifying in the 19th and early 20th centuries amid colonial administrative scrutiny.[15] A notable example occurred in Rajasthan and Haryana, where Malis began adopting the "Saini" surname in the 1930s, reinterpreting it as "Sainik" (soldier) to claim Kshatriya status and access British military recruitment quotas reserved for "martial races."[14] By the 1941 Census, many registered as "Saini (Sainik Kshatriya) Malis," following official permissions like Jodhpur State's 1937 order (No. 2240) allowing such reclassification.[14]However, these claims lack corroboration from pre-colonial historical evidence, such as inscriptions, royal genealogies, or Vedic texts associating gardening or floral occupations—core to Mali identity—with Kshatriya roles.[16] Traditional Mali vocations in horticulture and market gardening align more closely with Vaishya or Shudra functions, suggesting upward mobility efforts rather than primordial warrior heritage.[17] Colonial censuses incentivized such reassertions by tying caste labels to resource allocation, including army enlistment and land rights, fostering intra-community splits where some subgroups prioritized Kshatriya emulation over occupational cohesion.[18] Post-colonial reservation policies further amplified fragmentation, as competing claims vied for OBC or higher quotas without resolving evidential gaps.[19]
Regional Distributions
Mali in Northern India
In northern India, the Mali caste maintains a notable presence in Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh, with population estimates of approximately 1.987 million in Rajasthan and 770,000 in Uttar Pradesh derived from ethnographic surveys.[1] These communities are classified as Other Backward Classes (OBC) under state reservation frameworks, reflecting their socio-economic positioning within the regional hierarchy.[20] Subgroups such as Phul Mali, focused on flower cultivation, and associations with Saini identifiers in Uttar Pradesh, highlight internal variations adapted to local agrarian contexts.[21][22]The Malis in these regions are predominantly concentrated in arid and semi-arid zones, where their traditional expertise in floriculture and vegetable farming aligns with environmental constraints. In Rajasthan's desert areas, they cultivate resilient crops like hardy vegetables suited to low-water conditions, sustaining livelihoods through specialized horticultural practices.[1] This adaptation differentiates them from wetter regions, emphasizing drought-tolerant varieties over extensive field crops. Economic activities extend to urban areas, with remittances from migrant workers bolstering rural persistence in gardening roles.[23]Social customs in northern Mali communities include the operation of panchayats for enforcing endogamy and mediating disputes, ensuring adherence to caste norms amid modernization. These bodies, drawn from community elders, resolve intra-caste conflicts over marriage and resources, fostering cohesion in dispersed settlements.[19] Such practices, rooted in occupational solidarity, persist alongside shifts toward diversified farming and town-based employment.[1]
Mali in Western India (Maharashtra)
In Maharashtra, the Mali caste is historically linked to market gardening and floriculture, with communities concentrating in districts such as Pune, Nashik, and Buldhana, where they cultivate vegetables, flowers, and spices like cumin under irrigated conditions.[24][25] This specialization in wet farming distinguishes them from dry-crop cultivators like Marathas and Kunbis, positioning Malis as key suppliers to urban markets and elites in regions around Pune.[25] Subgroups such as Phulmali focus on ornamental flowers, reflecting occupational divisions that enhance their role in local economies.[25]Within Maratha-dominated society, Malis integrate as a cultivating group resembling Kunbis in social practices, including Maratha-style marriages and allowance for widow remarriage, while maintaining good standing slightly below pastoral castes but above certain artisan ones.[25] Economic ties bind them to broader agrarian networks, supplying produce amid competition for fertile lands and market access in peri-urban Pune.[19]Jyotirao Phule, born in 1827 to a Pune-based Mali family of vegetable vendors, exemplified subgroup overlaps by aligning Mali interests with Kunbi agrarian identities, framing shared economic grievances against Brahmin dominance in trade and ritual services rather than doctrinal disputes.[26][27] This perspective, rooted in Phule's firsthand experience of gardening commerce, underscored Mali contributions to Maharashtra's reformist undercurrents through practical alliances over ideological abstraction.[26]
Mali in Nepal
The Mali in Nepal form a small Hindu occupational caste, numbering 19,605 according to the 2021 National Population and Housing Census, representing approximately 0.07% of the country's total population. Predominantly residing in the Tarai (Madhesh) region along the southern border with India—from Jhapa in the east to Bardia in the west—they are largely descendants of immigrants from northern and western Indian states, integrating into Nepal's Madhesi Hindu social framework.[28] Unlike their larger counterparts in India, Nepali Mali exhibit a more localized concentration, with limited presence in hilly areas, and maintain endogamous practices tied to clans such as Mahlauri, Saini, and Bhagat.[29][28]Traditionally, Nepali Mali specialize in floriculture, cultivating flowers for garlands, ritual accessories like maur (crowns) and fulgeduwa (floral decorations), and sales to higher-caste Hindus, alongside vegetable gardening under the Baghban subgroup.[29][28] In the fertile Tarai plains, their practices emphasize commercial horticulture suited to subtropical climates, producing items for weddings and festivals, though some engage in military service, reflecting noted industriousness and bravery.[29] This contrasts with broader Indian Mali diversification into agriculture or urban trades, as Nepali variants remain occupationally focused amid Nepal's agrarian economy. They also perform traditional healing for ailments like measles, attributing them to divine curses and using shamanistic rituals.[28]Within Nepal's caste hierarchy, Mali are categorized as a Madhesi-origin Hindu group equivalent to Shudra status—touchable and water-acceptable but below Brahmin, Chhetri, and Vaishya equivalents—under the historical Muluki Ain legal code promulgated in 1854, which codified inter-caste relations and occupations.[30] The 1963 revision of the Muluki Ain abolished formal caste-based slavery, untouchability, and discriminatory penalties, legally elevating all groups including Mali to equal status while preserving customary social distinctions.[30] This positioned Nepali Mali as non-enslavable intermediates, distinct from Matwali (indigenous hill tribes) or Dalit categories, fostering integration into broader Hindu practices without the Kshatriya assertions common among some Indian Mali subgroups.[29]Culturally, Nepali Mali adhere to Hinduism, primarily venerating Devi (such as Maha Kali), with practices like permitting widow remarriage and optional corpse burial (feet oriented north), diverging from orthodox Indian Hindu norms that often prohibit the former and mandate cremation.[29] While Nepal's Hindu-Buddhist syncretism influences valley and hill communities, Tarai-based Mali retain purer Hindu orthodoxy tied to their Indian migrant roots, with minimal documented Buddhist admixture.[29] Their social embedding in Madhesi networks underscores cross-border continuities in occupation but highlights Nepal-specific legal equalization post-1963, reducing ritual barriers compared to India's persistent varna debates.[28]
Socio-Economic Evolution
Traditional Roles Versus Modern Occupations
The Mali caste has historically specialized in gardening and floriculture, cultivating flowers, vegetables, and garlands for religious and ornamental purposes, with the caste name derived from the Sanskrit term mala meaning garland.[1] This vocation persists in rural regions, where Mali communities apply inherited expertise in horticultural practices, including irrigation techniques that support cash crop production like sugarcane.[23] In Maharashtra, for instance, Mali groups initiated cooperative movements for water management and established farmer-owned sugar mills, expanding traditional skills into organized agro-processing.[31]Contemporary economic dynamics, particularly the mechanization of agriculture, have diminished opportunities in labor-intensive traditional farming, compelling many Mali households to diversify livelihoods.[32] This shift manifests in rural-to-urban migration and entry into non-farm sectors, as surplus agricultural labor seeks alternative employment amid declining farm viability.[33] While specific NSSO data on Mali occupational patterns highlight broader trends of diversification among rural agricultural households into informal labor and small enterprises, the caste's core horticultural base contributes to India's floriculture sector, which achieved exports valued at USD 86.63 million in 2023-24.[34]Despite successes in niche areas like floriculture and sugarcane processing, Mali communities generally exhibit lower average incomes and literacy levels than upper castes, constrained by historical socio-economic factors and limited access to higher education.[35] These disparities underscore the causal role of structural changes in agriculture, where mechanization exacerbates employability challenges for castes reliant on manual cultivation, fostering adaptive but uneven occupational transitions.[36]
Economic Status and Urban Migration
The Mali caste's classification as an Other Backward Class (OBC) in states such as Maharashtra, Rajasthan, and others provides access to affirmative action measures, including reservations in educational institutions and government jobs, aimed at addressing historical disadvantages.[37][38] These benefits have enabled some upward mobility, yet empirical indicators reveal ongoing economic challenges; rural Hindu OBC households, encompassing groups like the Mali, face poverty rates around 36%, reflecting limited asset ownership and income diversification compared to forward castes.[39]Urban migration patterns among the Mali reflect broader rural-to-urban shifts driven by agricultural stagnation and urban job prospects, with caste-based networks aiding initial entry into informal service sectors such as retail, transportation, and petty trade in cities like Mumbai and Nagpur.[40] However, this transition often yields marginal gains, as migrants encounter barriers to white-collar employment due to educational deficits and residual discrimination, resulting in overrepresentation in low-skill urban labor markets.[41]Critiques of reservation policies highlight potential drawbacks for communities like the Mali, where organized sub-groups in states such as Maharashtra are accused of monopolizing OBC quotas, crowding out less dominant OBCs and fostering dependency on state handouts rather than incentivizing skill development or entrepreneurial investment.[42] This dynamic, per policy analysts, sustains claims of backwardness to preserve access to benefits, while failing to bridge structural gaps in human capital formation essential for sustained economic advancement.[43][44]
Political Engagement and Identity Politics
Activism and Reservation Demands
In the wake of the Mandal Commission implementation during the 1990s, Mali community associations intensified advocacy for dedicated reservations, seeking a 12% quota in northern states including Rajasthan to address underrepresentation within aggregated Other Backward Classes (OBC) allocations.[45] These efforts, coordinated through regional bodies like the Mahatma Jyotiba Phule Mali Seva Sanghatana, emphasized the community's distinct socio-economic challenges stemming from traditional horticultural occupations.[46]A prominent mobilization occurred in Rajasthan in April 2023, where Mali members, alongside allied groups such as Saini, Kushwaha, and Maurya, blocked the Jaipur-Agra national highway and staged protests demanding separation from the state's 21% OBC quota for targeted benefits in jobs and education.[47][48] The 11-day stir, marked by a maha panchayat in Jaipur drawing thousands, concluded after delegations met the Rajasthan OBC Commission, which committed to a fresh survey on community backwardness rather than immediate concessions.[49][50]Proponents of the demands invoke historical exclusion as a gardener caste, arguing that shared OBC pools favor numerically dominant subgroups like Jats and Yadavs, perpetuating uneven access despite Mali numerical strength in regions like eastern Rajasthan.[51] Critics counter that such claims overlook the community's established political leverage, including representation through figures like former Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot—a Mali himself—indicating a prosperous "creamy layer" that captures disproportionate benefits, thereby eroding merit principles and straining resources for genuinely disadvantaged castes.[37][51]Outcomes have varied by political context, with Rajasthan's Congress government under Gehlot issuing assurances tied to pre-election affidavits but resisting quota hikes to avoid exceeding the 50% reservation cap, reflecting vote-bank calculations amid BJP competition for Mali support.[51] In Maharashtra, parallel activism focused on defending existing OBC entitlements, as evidenced by 2023 strikes against Maratha inclusions and a 2025 suicide by a Mali activist protesting perceived dilutions, underscoring defensive strategies over expansions.[52][46] These campaigns highlight tensions between equity claims and empirical patterns of elite capture within reservation frameworks.[51]
Inter-Caste Dynamics and Criticisms
In Maharashtra, members of the Mali caste, classified as Other Backward Classes (OBCs), have expressed opposition to efforts by the politically influential Maratha community to obtain Kunbi certificates, which would grant access to the OBC reservation quota. This conflict, highlighted in 2023 protests and statements from Mali leaders, stems from fears that expanded eligibility would dilute the share of educational and employment opportunities available to established OBC groups like Malis, illustrating resource competition among agrarian castes in a zero-sum reservation framework.[40][53]Such dynamics reveal underlying power imbalances, where Malis, as intermediate-status cultivators, navigate alliances and rivalries with dominant forward castes like Marathas while maintaining social distance from Scheduled Castes (Dalits). Rural inter-caste tensions in Maharashtra often involve OBC groups asserting control over land and local governance against Dalit claims, though Mali-specific disputes are embedded in broader patterns of OBC dominance in village power structures, leading to sporadic clashes over inheritance, irrigation, and employment. These frictions underscore how caste hierarchies persist, with OBCs leveraging numerical strength to counter both upper-caste privileges and lower-caste mobilizations for affirmative action.[54]Critics of Sanskritization, the process through which castes like Malis have historically adopted upper-caste rituals and claimed Kshatriya descent to elevate social standing, argue that it represents opportunistic emulation rather than organic cultural authenticity. Anthropological analyses contend that such assertions prioritize ritual hierarchy over substantive economic or political empowerment, often serving elite interests within the caste while perpetuating the very varna system being mimicked, as evidenced in studies of mobility strategies among intermediate castes.[55]From a policy standpoint, reservation politics involving OBC castes such as Malis has drawn criticism for entrenching caste-based divisions and prioritizing collective entitlements over individual merit and market-driven growth. Analysts note that quota competitions, as seen in OBC intra-group rivalries, hinder economic liberalization by fostering entitlement mindsets and zero-sum conflicts, potentially stifling broader productivity gains that could uplift communities through skill development rather than mandated allocations.[56][57]
Notable Figures
Political and Administrative Leaders
Ashok Gehlot, born into the Mali caste, served three terms as Chief Minister of Rajasthan, from December 1998 to December 2003, December 2008 to December 2013, and December 2018 to December 2023.[58][59] His administrations introduced welfare measures targeting Other Backward Classes (OBCs), including Malis, such as increased OBC reservation from 21% to 26% in government jobs and education in 2023, and the establishment of dedicated boards for occupational communities like gardeners—a traditional Mali role—to provide financial and skill development aid.[60][61] These steps enhanced Mali political visibility, with Congress allocating assembly tickets to the community, yielding wins in multiple elections, though demands for a distinct 12% Mali-specific quota persisted amid perceptions of insufficient targeted upliftment.[62][51]Gehlot's tenure correlated with broader state initiatives like expanded health insurance and rural electrification, which benefited Mali-dominated agricultural areas, but critics highlighted reliance on caste mobilization for electoral gains over transformative economic reforms, with data showing persistent low per capita income in Mali-heavy districts compared to state averages.[63] Accusations of nepotism arose, including promotions of family members like son Vaibhav Gehlot as a Lok Sabha MP, potentially prioritizing kin networks over merit-based administration.[20]In Maharashtra, Chhagan Bhujbal, from the Mali (OBC) community, emerged as a key figure after defecting from Shiv Sena in 1991 to join Congress, later aligning with NCP; he served as Deputy Chief Minister (1999–2004, 2023–present) and multiple ministerial roles, championing OBC quotas and infrastructure in Nashik region.[64][65]Bhujbal's advocacy secured enhanced reservations and development funds for Mali areas, though his tenure faced scrutiny for corruption allegations in public projects, underscoring tensions between caste empowerment and governance accountability.[66]At district levels in Rajasthan, Mali officials have leveraged community ties for roles like sub-divisional magistrates, facilitating local implementation of schemes but occasionally drawing claims of favoritism in postings over administrative efficacy.[67] Overall, these leaders' impacts reflect caste networks enabling access to power, with verifiable contributions in welfare distribution tempered by empirical gaps in equitable development and persistent intra-OBC quota disputes.[68]
Social Reformers and Intellectuals
Jyotirao Phule (1827–1890), born into a Mali family of florists and vegetable vendors in Satara, Maharashtra, drew from his caste's position within the Shudravarna to critique the exploitative aspects of the Hindu social hierarchy.[26] His advocacy targeted Brahminical dominance, positing that lower castes, including Malis, suffered systemic subjugation that hindered their access to education and resources.[26]Phule founded the Satyashodhak Samaj on September 24, 1873, in Pune, establishing a platform for Shudras and ati-Shudras to pursue truth-seeking through secular rites and mutual aid, bypassing priestly intermediaries.[69] This organization facilitated community weddings and education drives, empirically expanding literacy among marginalized groups in western India during the late 19th century.[70] In his 1873 treatise Gulamgiri, Phule argued that the caste system originated as a mechanism of enslavement by invading Aryans over indigenous cultivators like the Mali forebears, framing reform as reclamation of pre-Brahminical equality.[71]While Phule's egalitarianism spurred measurable gains in female and lower-caste schooling—such as the 1848 opening of India's inaugural girls' school in Pune—his wholesale rejection of Vedic authority overlooked functional divisions of labor in agrarian economies, where hierarchies arguably sustained cooperative production, though this perspective contrasts with his view of caste as purely oppressive.[26] Post-independence Mali intellectuals, influenced by Phule, have engaged in literature reinforcing subaltern narratives, yet prominent figures remain fewer compared to his foundational role, with community discourse often blending his anti-caste ethos with assertions of Kshatriya origins to navigate reservation politics.[19]