Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Momin Ansari

The Momin Ansari (Urdu: مومن أنصاري) are a Sunni Muslim community traditionally occupied in handloom weaving, historically identified with the Julaha caste and distributed primarily across northern India, with smaller populations in Pakistan's Sindh province and Nepal.^[1]^[2] Emerging from economic marginalization under colonial policies that devastated artisanal textile production, the community sought to elevate its social standing in the early 20th century by adopting the "Ansari" surname to invoke descent from the Ansar companions of the Prophet Muhammad, while reorganizing around themes of Islamic piety and occupational pride as "Momin" (believer).^[3] The All India Momin Conference, established in the 1910s–1920s in Calcutta under leaders such as Maulvi Ali Hussain Asim Bihari and Abdul Qayyum Ansari, served as their primary institutional vehicle for promoting khadi (hand-spun cloth) production, establishing weaver cooperatives, and building welfare schools to counter caste-based inequalities within Muslim society.^[3] Politically, the Momin Ansari distinguished themselves by rejecting the All-India Muslim League's separatist agenda, instead aligning with the Indian National Congress to advocate for a composite nationalism and unified India, a stance that led to conflicts with League elites and positioned the community as precursors to the broader Pasmanda movement against ashraf dominance among Muslims.^[3]^[4] Despite these efforts, post-partition assimilation diluted their distinct identity in regions like Pakistan, where many integrated into the Urdu-speaking Muhajir population, while in India they continue to navigate occupational shifts amid modernization and persistent socioeconomic challenges.^[3]

Origins and Etymology

Historical Background

The Momin Ansari community traces its historical origins to the Julaha caste, a Muslim artisan group specializing in handloom weaving that emerged in the Indian subcontinent during the medieval period. Julahas primarily produced cotton and silk textiles, contributing to regional economies in areas like northern India and the Deccan, where they settled in urban clusters around weaving centers. Their presence is documented in colonial ethnographies from the 19th century, which describe them as a distinct occupational community integrated into Muslim society but often facing social stigma due to their artisanal status.^[5]^[6] The name "Julaha" derives from the Persian term julah, meaning a ball of thread, reflecting the core tools and techniques of their trade, such as spinning and loom work. Historical accounts indicate that many Julahas originated from conversions of local Hindu weaving castes, including the Kori and similar groups, who adopted Islam between the 13th and 16th centuries amid Sufi influences and Mughal expansion, while preserving their vocational expertise. This transition maintained continuity in textile production but positioned them within the broader hierarchy of Muslim occupational castes.^[7]^[8] By the early 20th century, amid colonial census categorizations and internal reform movements, Julahas began reorganizing their identity as Momin Ansari to assert religious piety and elevated lineage. "Momin" denotes a faithful believer in Arabic Islamic terminology, while "Ansari" references the Medinan supporters of the Prophet Muhammad, a claim advanced by community leaders to counter perceptions of lowly origin despite limited pre-colonial evidence for direct Arab descent. This shift gained momentum through associations like the All India Momin Conference, founded around 1911, which advocated for socioeconomic upliftment and challenged caste-like discriminations within Indian Muslim communities.^[9]^[10]

Claimed Ancestral Links

The Momin Ansari community asserts descent from the Ansar, the inhabitants of Medina who aided the Prophet Muhammad following his hijra (migration) from Mecca in 622 CE, earning the Arabic term al-Ansār meaning "helpers" or "supporters."^[11] This claimed linkage is embodied in the surname "Ansari," a nisba (attributive) form denoting affiliation with the Ansar tribe, which the community adopted to signify an elevated Islamic pedigree tied to the Prophet's earliest followers.^[12] The Ansar were primarily from the Aws and Khazraj tribes and played a pivotal role in the establishment of the early Muslim community, including hosting the Prophet and participating in key battles like Badr in 624 CE.^[13] A specific ancestral figure frequently invoked is Abu Ayyub al-Ansari (d. 674 CE), a companion of the Prophet who reportedly sheltered him in Medina upon arrival and served as the first Muslim standard-bearer at the Battle of the Ditch in 627 CE; the Momin Ansari maintain that their forebears trace directly to him or his kin.^[14] Community narratives hold that descendants of these Ansar migrated eastward during the early Islamic expansions, eventually settling in the Indian subcontinent, with some traditions citing establishments in sites like Farangi Mahal in Lucknow as early hubs.^[13] This purported Arab-Islamic origin serves to underscore a narrative of fidelity (momin, meaning "believer" or "faithful one" in Arabic) to the Prophet's cause, contrasting with occupational associations like weaving.^[15] In regional variations, such as among Momin Ansari in Rajasthan, additional claims emerge of pre-Islamic warrior status, positing that ancestors were fighters who transitioned to weaving following military defeats, though these are subordinated to the overarching Ansar descent in communal self-identification.^[16] The emphasis on Ansar ancestry gained prominence in the early 20th century through organizations like the All India Momin Conference, which promoted "Momin Ansari" nomenclature to foster unity and assert sharif (noble) status amid colonial censuses and social reforms, often invoking Quranic references to the Ansar as exemplars of piety (e.g., Quran 9:100).^[9] These claims, while central to group identity, reflect strategic self-representation rather than independently verified genealogy, as historical records of subcontinental Muslim artisan castes more commonly indicate conversions from local Hindu weaving groups like the Kori during medieval Islamic rule.^[14]

Demographic Distribution

Presence in India

The Momin Ansari, also known as Ansari or Julaha among Muslim weavers, maintain their strongest demographic footprint in northern India, particularly Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, where they constitute a sizable portion of the Muslim weaving communities. Uttar Pradesh hosts the largest concentration, with estimates placing the Ansari population at approximately 4.73 million residents.^[17] Varanasi district in Uttar Pradesh is widely recognized as the historical and cultural hub, home to dense clusters in neighborhoods such as Madanpura, Adampura, and Jaitpura, where traditional silk weaving remains a core occupation. Local assessments indicate that the weaving population in Varanasi, predominantly Momin Ansari, numbers around 300,000, though economic shifts have reduced active artisan participation.^[18] In Bihar, the community is similarly prominent, with the 2022 state caste-based survey enumerating 4,634,245 individuals in the Momin (Muslim)/Julaha/Ansari category, underscoring their role as one of the state's major backward Muslim groups.^[19] Smaller but notable presences extend to Maharashtra (around 800,000 Ansari), Telangana (approximately 796,000), West Bengal, Karnataka, Gujarat, and Jharkhand, often tied to handloom clusters and urban migration patterns.^[17] These distributions reflect historical migrations from weaving centers during the medieval period, compounded by post-independence urbanization, though precise national figures remain elusive due to the absence of comprehensive caste data in federal censuses for Muslim subgroups. Overall, the Indian Momin Ansari population is estimated in the range of 10-12 million, forming part of the broader pasmanda Muslim demographics focused on artisanal trades.^[17]

Presence in Pakistan and Other Regions

The Momin Ansari, a Muslim artisan community traditionally associated with weaving, have a significant presence in Pakistan as part of the broader Ansari group, with an estimated population of 5,063,000, predominantly Sunni Muslims engaged in textile-related occupations.^[5] This demographic largely resides in urban centers, reflecting post-1947 migrations from northern India during the partition, when many weaver families relocated to seek economic opportunities in the new state.^[20] In Pakistan, they often integrate into the Muhajir ethnic category, continuing artisanal trades amid urbanization, though socioeconomic challenges like poverty and illiteracy persist among segments of the group.^[5] Smaller Momin Ansari populations exist in other regions, including Nepal with approximately 46,000 individuals primarily in the Terai region, where they maintain weaving traditions.^[21] In Bangladesh and Afghanistan, communities number in the tens to hundreds of thousands collectively, forming part of South Asian Muslim artisan networks but facing similar economic marginalization; these groups trace origins to historical migrations and share occupational profiles with their Indian and Pakistani counterparts.^[22] Overall, outside India, the community's distribution remains urban-oriented and tied to declining handloom industries, with limited distinct organizational structures compared to their pre-partition networks.^[5]

Socioeconomic Profile

Traditional Occupations

The Momin Ansari community, historically identified as Julahas or Muslim weavers, has long been primarily engaged in handloom weaving and textile production as their core traditional occupation. This vocation involved crafting cotton, silk, and embroidered fabrics, with a specialization in intricate techniques such as zari work for sari embellishment.^[14]^[17] In regions like Varanasi, community members have sustained generational expertise in producing Banarasi sarees on handlooms, incorporating traditional motifs and metallic threads derived from gold or silver.^[23] Ancestral ties to the Ansar tribe of Medina, as claimed in community narratives, reinforced their occupational identity around artisanal trades, though empirical evidence points to a medieval consolidation among Indian Muslim artisan castes focused on loom-based crafts.^[14] By the early 20th century, economic pressures from colonial-era mechanized mills prompted some diversification into textile selling, yet weaving remained dominant, often within family-run units employing basic pit looms.^[24]^[17] Subsidiary roles included dyeing, spinning preparatory yarns, and minor mercantile activities tied to fabric distribution in local bazaars, but these were extensions of weaving rather than independent pursuits.^[25] Historical records from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh indicate that up to 80-90% of Momin Ansari households in pre-independence India derived livelihoods from such crafts, underscoring their socioeconomic anchoring in manual textile labor amid agrarian dominance elsewhere.^[24]^[7]

Contemporary Economic Roles

In India, members of the Momin Ansari community remain predominantly engaged in the textile industry, with a focus on handloom silk weaving, particularly in regions like Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, where they dominate the production of Banarasi sarees featuring intricate techniques such as kadhwa and tanchoi.^[26] Master weavers from the community typically employ 10-15 individual weavers, who earn wages of Rs. 100-250 per saree depending on design complexity, with production cycles lasting 7-10 days per piece and peaking during festive seasons.^[26] The handloom sector, contributing about 15% to India's overall textile production and with 95% of output exported, faces significant challenges including competition from powerlooms, low remuneration, and dependency on middlemen who inflate raw material costs by up to 50%.^[26] Government interventions, such as the National Handloom Development Programme allocating Rs. 3,884 crore for subsidies on yarn (10% of costs) and marketing support through e-commerce platforms and exhibitions, aim to sustain these roles, alongside the establishment of nine Common Facility Centers in Varanasi to aid production.^[26] In Bihar, while hereditary weaving persists as the core occupation, improved educational attainment has enabled diversification into government employment and religious positions, such as community members serving as imams, elevating their relative economic standing compared to other artisanal groups.^[15] In Pakistan, particularly in Sindh province, the community maintains roots in artisanal trades, including weaving and fabric selling, with many functioning as merchants (saudagar) in textile-related commerce.^[5] Economic marginalization persists, however, as the community is often characterized by low literacy and poverty, limiting broader occupational shifts.^[17] Overall, mechanization and market pressures have prompted some migration toward urban informal sectors, though textiles remain the primary economic anchor across both nations.^[27]

Internal Hierarchy and Customs

The Momin Ansari community, synonymous with the Momin Julaha weavers, organizes socially around endogamous biradaris, which function as kinship-based units subdivided by regional or ethnic origins to maintain occupational and cultural cohesion. Marriage is confined to within the caste and its sub-groups, with preferences for unions reinforcing claims to Shaikh descent, such as through the "Ansari" title, though intermarriages with higher-status Ashraf groups like Shaikhs occur sporadically to elevate social position.^[28]^[28] Internal hierarchy remains relatively egalitarian and non-rigid, lacking the stratified varna-like divisions of Hindu castes, with authority vested in informal panchayats or councils of elders who resolve disputes, oversee marriages, and uphold norms derived from pre-conversion customs adapted to Islamic frameworks. Economic standing in weaving or allied trades confers informal leadership, as evidenced by the community's formation of bodies like the All-India Jami’at ul-Ansar (later Momin Conference) in the early 20th century to advocate collective upliftment.^[28]^[28]^[15] Customs emphasize occupational continuity, with joint families predominant in rural areas as socio-economic units supporting weaving enterprises, while lifecycle rituals blend Quranic observances with local traditions, such as community feasts tied to textile production milestones. Social control via biradari enforces exogamy at the gotra or clan level to prevent consanguinity, reflecting persistent cultural contact with indigenous practices despite egalitarian Islamic ideals.^[28]^[29]

Status Within Broader Muslim Communities

In the stratified social structure of Indian Muslim communities, Momin Ansaris are positioned as Ajlaf, an intermediate category of occupational castes distinct from the elite Ashraf groups (such as Syeds, Sheikhs, and Mughals) who claim noble foreign ancestries and monopolize leadership in religious, educational, and political spheres.^[30]^[29] This hierarchy, rooted in pre-Islamic Indian social norms adopted post-conversion, manifests in practices like endogamous marriages, where Ashraf families rarely intermarry with Momin Ansaris, and preferential treatment for Ashraf in mosque committees, madrasas, and community resource allocation.^[31] Despite theological assertions of equality in Islam, empirical patterns of discrimination persist, with Momin Ansaris often relegated to subordinate roles in joint community endeavors.^[10] The community's self-identification as descendants of the Ansar—the Medinan helpers of Prophet Muhammad—affords a measure of symbolic religious legitimacy, elevating their perceived piety in folk narratives and allowing participation in broader Sunni rituals without doctrinal exclusion.^[32] However, this claim does not translate to practical parity; socioeconomic realities as traditional weavers reinforce their marginalization, prompting assertions from Pasmanda activists that Ashraf dominance perpetuates a "caste ceiling" in Muslim institutions.^[33] Momin Ansaris maintain orthodox Sunni adherence, split between Barelvi and Deobandi affiliations, but their influence in pan-Islamic bodies remains limited compared to clerical Ashraf networks.^[29] Efforts to assert higher status, such as through the All India Momin Conference's campaigns for dignity and economic upliftment since the 1920s, highlight tensions with elite Muslim orthodoxy, which often downplays caste to preserve unity against external threats.^[10] In Pakistan and Nepal, similar dynamics prevail, with Momin Ansaris integrated into local Muslim fabrics but facing analogous biradari-based exclusions from power structures.^[31] Overall, their status reflects a pragmatic adaptation of Islamic universalism to regional hierarchies, where occupational identity overrides egalitarian ideals in daily social interactions.^[30]

Political Engagement

Formation of the All India Momin Conference

The All India Momin Conference originated from earlier local efforts to organize the Momin Ansari community, particularly through the Jamiat-al-Momineen, which was established in Kolkata in 1912 by Momin Mohammad Yahya to address welfare needs among Pasmanda Muslims, including weavers facing economic decline due to competition from mill-produced cloth.^[10]^[34] This precursor organization focused on socio-economic upliftment, laying groundwork for broader mobilization amid colonial policies favoring imported textiles and internal Muslim community hierarchies that marginalized artisan groups like the Momins.^[35] The conference's first all-India session convened on 22 and 23 March 1925 at Kolkata's Town Hall, presided over by Professor Hafiz Shamsuddin Ahmad Shams of Maner, Bihar, whose father, Engineer Maulvi Zameeruddin, had been involved in early Momin welfare initiatives.^[35]^[10] This gathering marked a shift toward national coordination, emphasizing revival of handloom weaving, promotion of khadi to counter British imports, and political representation for Momins as a distinct occupational group within Indian Muslims. Key early figures included Maulana Ali Hussain Asim Bihari, who contributed to the initial Pasmanda mobilizations linking economic grievances to anti-colonial nationalism.^[36] Formal establishment occurred on 25-26 December 1926 in Sasaram, Bihar, under the leadership of Haji Mohammad Farkhund Ali, with objectives centered on protecting weavers' livelihoods, advocating for reservations in education and jobs for backward Muslims, and fostering unity against ashraf-dominated Muslim politics.^[24] The conference aligned with the Indian National Congress's swadeshi campaigns, viewing handloom revival as both economic self-reliance and resistance to partition demands from the Muslim League, which it opposed as detrimental to artisan communities concentrated in Hindu-majority areas.^[37] By prioritizing empirical economic data—such as the Momins' overrepresentation in weaving (e.g., comprising a significant portion of Bihar's handloom workforce)—the organization challenged narratives of monolithic Muslim unity, instead grounding its formation in caste-specific causal factors like occupational decline and colonial trade disruptions.^[38]

Stance on Indian Partition and Nationalism

The All India Momin Conference, the primary political body representing the Momin Ansari community, explicitly opposed the partition of India in 1947, advocating instead for a united secular nation where Muslims could thrive alongside Hindus. Founded in the 1910s and gaining political momentum under leaders like Abdul Qayyum Ansari, the conference positioned itself against the All-India Muslim League's separatist demands, arguing that partition would harm the socioeconomic interests of artisan Muslims like the Momins, who were concentrated in Hindu-majority regions such as Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. In resolutions passed during the 1930s and 1940s, the organization emphasized composite nationalism, rejecting Muhammad Ali Jinnah's two-nation theory as an elite-driven agenda disconnected from the realities of lower-caste Muslims.^[3] This opposition stemmed from a pragmatic assessment of the community's vulnerabilities: Momins, as weavers and traders, feared economic marginalization in a Pakistan dominated by Punjabi and Urdu-speaking elites, whom they viewed as ashraf (upper-caste) Muslims indifferent to Pasmanda concerns. Ansari, a key figure from Bihar, mobilized mass rallies and propaganda campaigns in 1946 to counter League influence, urging Momins to prioritize Indian unity over religious separatism and warning that Pakistan would exacerbate caste-like hierarchies within Islam. The conference allied with the Indian National Congress in elections, contesting League candidates to prevent fragmentation of anti-partition votes, though their efforts were undermined by British policies and League dominance in Muslim-majority provinces.^[39]^[40] Post-partition, the Momin Conference curtailed its overt political activism by August 15, 1947, shifting focus to rehabilitation and community welfare amid the violence that displaced many Momins who had opposed migration to Pakistan. Despite the partition's enactment, the organization's pre-1947 stance reflected a broader Pasmanda Muslim nationalism, prioritizing empirical economic survival and regional ties over pan-Islamic ideology, a position echoed in their criticism of the League's "Islam in danger" rhetoric as manipulative. This legacy underscores the conference's role in articulating dissent from non-elite Muslim perspectives, though it received limited mainstream acknowledgment due to prevailing narratives favoring partition proponents.^[3]^[39]

Connections to Pasmanda Movements

The All India Momin Conference, founded in 1926 under the leadership of figures like Haji Mohammad Farkhund Ali, represented an early organized challenge to caste-based inequalities within Indian Muslim society, mobilizing primarily Momin Ansari weavers against the dominance of Ashraf elites.^[10] This effort is widely regarded as a precursor to the modern Pasmanda movement, which advocates for the socioeconomic and political upliftment of backward (Ajlaf) and Dalit (Arzal) Muslims, including the Ansari community classified as Other Backward Classes in states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh.^[37] The conference's platform emphasized the distinct interests of artisan castes like Momins, who comprised a significant portion of Muslim voters in provinces such as Bihar, where they opposed the All-India Muslim League's elite-driven agenda.^[3] Under Abdul Qayyum Ansari, a prominent Julaha (Momin) leader who served as conference president from the 1930s, the organization demanded separate electorates for lower-caste Muslims to counter Ashraf control over communal representation, a stance that aligned with Pasmanda critiques of internal Muslim hierarchy.^[41] In 1946, the conference formally entered electoral politics, fielding candidates to prevent fragmentation of nationalist votes among Pasmanda groups and explicitly rejecting partition as a scheme benefiting upper-caste Muslims while marginalizing weaver communities economically tied to Hindu-majority regions.^[3] This positioning highlighted causal links between caste status and political exclusion, with Momins arguing that elite-led separatism ignored their reliance on integrated Indian markets for handloom production.^[40] In contemporary Pasmanda activism, Momin Ansari figures continue to feature prominently, as seen in organizations like the All India Pasmanda Muslim Mahaz, which draws on the Momin Conference's legacy to push for sub-categorization of Muslim quotas and recognition of caste realities despite theological assertions of Islamic egalitarianism.^[42] Post-Mandal Commission developments in the 1990s revived these demands, with Ansari leaders advocating for OBC status to access reservations, though implementation varies by state and faces resistance from Ashraf-dominated bodies.^[43] Scholarly analyses note that while the Momin Conference achieved localized successes, such as influencing Bihar's 1937 elections, broader Pasmanda gains remain limited by elite capture of Muslim political institutions.^[44]

Cultural and Religious Practices

Religious Observances

The Momin Ansari community, predominantly Sunni Muslims, adhere to core Islamic observances including the five daily prayers (salah), fasting during the month of Ramadan, payment of zakat (obligatory almsgiving), and, for those financially and physically able, performance of the Hajj pilgrimage to Mecca.^[17] These practices form the foundation of their religious life, aligned with the teachings of the Quran and the example of Prophet Muhammad as transmitted through Sunni traditions.^[17] The two principal annual festivals observed are Eid al-Fitr, marking the end of Ramadan with communal prayers, feasting, and charity, and Eid al-Adha, commemorating Abraham's readiness to sacrifice his son through ritual animal sacrifice and distribution of meat to the needy.^[17] Collective participation in these events, including special congregational prayers at mosques, reinforces social cohesion and religious identity among the Momin Ansari, as noted in studies of Muslim communities in southern India where similar groups maintain these customs.^[45] While no distinctive rituals unique to the community beyond mainstream Sunni practices in the Indian subcontinent are widely documented, the All India Momin Conference historically emphasized pious conduct to uphold orthodox Islamic devotion amid social reforms.^[9]

Community Institutions and Traditions

The Momin Ansari community traditionally lacks formalized social councils akin to those in other Indian caste groups, relying instead on informal biradari networks for dispute resolution and social oversight. Modern institutions have emerged to address welfare and economic needs, notably the All India Momin Ansar Welfare Society (AIMAWS), established to support destitute families through arranged marriages, free medical aid for the elderly, and promotion of the weaving export sector among community members.^[46] ^[47] These organizations emphasize upliftment for weavers and lower-income households, reflecting the community's historical focus on artisanal labor amid economic marginalization. In the handloom industry, particularly in northern Indian centers like Varanasi and Barabanki, Momin Ansari weavers have sustained guild-like structures based on biradari affiliations, which organize production, apprenticeship, and trade in zari-embroidered textiles.^[48] ^[49] These guilds, evolving from pre-colonial occupational clusters, enable collective bargaining and skill transmission, with members often asserting descent from early Islamic converts to bolster social legitimacy within Muslim hierarchies.^[50] Apprenticeship traditions transition youth from home-based looms to workshop (karkhana) settings, preserving techniques amid industrialization pressures.^[51] Social traditions prioritize endogamy within the biradari to maintain occupational and kinship ties, with marriages arranged to reinforce economic interdependence among weaving families. Community cohesion is further upheld through shared rituals tied to the weaving cycle, such as invocations for prosperous yields during loom setup, though these blend Islamic piety with artisanal folklore rather than distinct sectarian deviations.^[52] No unique festivals diverge from mainstream Sunni observances, but biradari gatherings often coincide with Eid celebrations to network and distribute aid.^[17]

Criticisms and Debates

Assertions of Caste Denial in Islam

Assertions that caste hierarchies contradict core Islamic tenets of equality form a central pillar of theological discourse among Muslims, drawing from Quranic verses such as Surah Al-Hujurat 49:13, which declares that human superiority derives from piety rather than nobility of birth or tribe.^[30]^[31] Proponents of this view, including many Ashraf (elite Muslim) scholars and leaders, maintain that any observed social stratification among South Asian Muslims—such as the biradari (fraternity-based) endogamy practiced by groups like the Momin Ansari—stems from pre-Islamic cultural accretions or occupational divisions rather than sanctioned caste systems, insisting Islam mandates taqwa (God-consciousness) as the sole criterion for status.^[30] This denial is reinforced by historical fatwas, such as those from Deobandi muftis like Azizur Rahman in the early 20th century, prohibiting inter-marriage across perceived low-status groups including weavers, yet framing such rulings as preserving communal harmony rather than endorsing hierarchy.^[30] Despite these assertions, empirical evidence from anthropological studies reveals persistent caste-like practices among Indian Muslim communities, including the Momin Ansari, who are classified as Ajlaf (converted artisan castes) and exhibit strong endogamy, occupational inheritance in weaving, and exclusion from Ashraf-dominated institutions.^[31] For instance, Momin Ansari biradaris maintain social boundaries that limit inter-group marriages and ritual interactions, mirroring Hindu jati dynamics, as documented in 19th- and 20th-century colonial ethnographies and post-independence surveys.^[53] Critics, including Pasmanda activists from communities like the Ansari, argue that elite-driven denial obscures structural inequalities, noting that Ashraf Muslims—comprising roughly 15-20% of the population—hold disproportionate political power, with approximately 85% of elected Muslim parliamentarians from 1952 to 2019 being Ashraf despite their minority share.^[30]^[31] The Momin Ansari community's historical rebranding from the stigmatized Julaha to "Momin Ansari" in the early 20th century, invoking descent from the egalitarian Ansar of Medina, exemplifies efforts to reconcile observed hierarchies with Islamic denial narratives, yet this has not eradicated discrimination, as evidenced by incidents like the 1995 Allahpur mosque violence in Bihar where lower-status Muslims, including weavers, were barred from prayer spaces by Ashraf groups.^[30] Scholarly analyses, such as those by Imtiaz Ahmad in the 1970s, contend that while Islam's doctrinal egalitarianism rejects rigid caste, syncretic South Asian practices have embedded hereditary occupations and purity-pollution concepts, with denial often serving to delegitimize demands for affirmative action by Ajlaf and Arzal groups.^[54] This tension underscores a causal disconnect between theological ideals and social reality, where assertions of caste denial persist amid verifiable patterns of exclusion, as seen in the limited electoral success of Pasmanda candidates—only three in Bihar's 2020 assembly elections despite comprising over 80% of Muslims.^[31] The All India Momin Conference, dominated by Momin Ansari leaders, mounted significant opposition to the partition of India, viewing the Muslim League's demand for Pakistan as a scheme benefiting only elite Ashraf Muslims while disadvantaging artisan communities like the Momins. In 1940, the Conference aligned with the All India Azad Muslim Conference, which convened to reject the Lahore Resolution and affirm loyalty to a united India, with Momin representatives emphasizing economic self-interest over religious separatism.^[3] This position stemmed from the belief that Pakistan's governance would perpetuate Pasmanda exclusion, as articulated by figures like Abdul Qayyum Ansari, who campaigned against migration and warned of elite capture.^[55] This opposition provoked violent reprisals from Muslim League activists, who perceived the Momin stance as a threat to their two-nation agenda. Conference gatherings became frequent targets of assault, with cadres killed in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh during the 1940s, including direct attacks on leaders like Ansari, whom the League branded an enemy for mobilizing weavers against separatism. ^[56] The League's Muslim National Guard units were implicated in suppressing dissent through intimidation and riots, forcing the Momin Conference to issue warnings of countermeasures and highlighting intra-Muslim class fractures.^[57] Post-1947, remnants of this rift persisted in narratives accusing Momin nationalists of disloyalty, though the community largely remained in India, contributing to Congress-aligned politics in regions like Bihar.^[3] Socially, the Momin Ansari emphasis on occupational caste solidarity has fueled tensions with upper-strata Muslims over marriage practices and community leadership, reinforcing endogamy and biradari networks despite Islamic egalitarianism claims. In northern India, this manifested in disputes over madrasa control and waqf resources, where Ashraf dominance sidelined Pasmanda voices, as evidenced by early 20th-century mobilizations for separate representation.^[24] Contemporary extensions through Pasmanda activism have intensified scrutiny, with critics alleging fragmentation of Muslim unity, though Momin leaders counter that such hierarchies predate colonial rule and demand affirmative action like OBC quotas.^[58]^[30]

References

[1]
[PDF] Bihar Bench - National Commission for Backward Classes
The caste/community Momin (Muslim), Ansari and Julaha are one and the same ... The Ansari of Bihar, also called momin or Julaha, are distributed in the ...
[2]
Artisanal Towns (Chapter 2) - Small Town Capitalism in Western India
“Momin” refers to a rather diverse set of people who were spread widely over northern India but who shared their Islamic faith and an association with handloom ...
[3]
Momin Tehreek: How this movement of Pasmanda Muslims tried to ...
Aug 15, 2023 · In 1946, the Momin Conference entered politics as a political party but it took steps to ensure there was no division of the nationalist vote.
[4]
Who founded the Momin Movement in Bihar as a ... - GKToday
Jun 28, 2025 · Notes: Abdul Qaiyum Ansari (1905-1973) founded the Momin Movement in Bihar and opposed the Muslim League's demand for Pakistan. He led the All ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[5]
Ansari in Pakistan people group profile - Joshua Project
Introduction / History. The Ansari community has its roots in working as artisans. Most were weavers and sellers of fabrics. What Are Their Lives Like?
[6]
Existence - Dakhani Momin Jamat
Russell and Hiralal(1916) stated that the " Julaha(Momin) are a low Mohammededan caste group of weavers resided mainly in Saugor and Burhanpur.
[7]
WHY INDIA'S JULAHA WEAVER COMMUNITY MATTERS
Sep 18, 2025 · The word Julaha is likely to be of Persian origin, in Persian, Julah means 'weaver,' which in turn comes from jula or a 'ball of thread' (Pandey ...
[8]
Weaver Communities of India | Sahapedia
Julaha. This community derives its name from the Persian julah, meaning a ball of thread. Many Julahas associate the words jaal (net) and jils (decorated) with ...
[9]
formation of a colonial identity: the momin ansars in early twentieth ...
In this context this paper discuses the restructuring and reorganization of the Muslim julaha community as Momin Ansars during the early twentieth century. The.
[10]
From Momin Conference to Pasmanda Movement: The Challenges ...
May 26, 2023 · This organisation of weavers (Jolaha) led a movement to challenge the Upper Caste hegemony among Muslims which was later joined by other castes ...
[11]
Ansari in Nepal people group profile - Joshua Project
Ansar originated from the Medinan people who assisted the prophet Mohammed as he migrated from Mecca to Medina. These people later became his emissaries and ...
[12]
Ansari Surname Meaning & Ansari Family History at Ancestry.com®
Anṣar is the plural of Nāṣir 'friend supporter' a term traditionally used to denote the people of Medina who helped the prophet Muhammad after the Hegira in 622 ...Missing: Momin | Show results with:Momin
[13]
[PDF] A SOCIO-ECONOMIC STUDY OF ANSARIS OF BIJNOR DISTRICT
After all, the status of Ansaris is first and foremost identified within the Muslim community and then within the Indian society as a whole.
[14]
Momin Ansari - Academic Dictionaries and Encyclopedias
The Momin Ansari (Urdu: مومن أنصاري ) or Ansari, are a Muslim community, found mainly in West and North India, and the province of Sindh in Pakistan.
[15]
[PDF] Working Paper – 5 - TISS
This was in favour of 'Momin', meaning the faithful/men of honour, or 'Ansari', after the name of the Arab ancestor they claimed theselves, or 'Momin Ansar' or ...
[16]
Momin Ansari - Bharatpedia
Aug 26, 2021 · The Momin Ansari (Urdu: مومن أنصاري) or saudagar are a Muslim community found mainly in India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Nepal.
[17]
Ansari in India people group profile - Joshua Project
Learn about the Ansari in India people group. Profiles include statistics, text, photo, map, progress indicator and language resources.
[18]
Varanasi's Muslim Silk-Weavers Battle Mechanisation ... - IWMF
Nov 21, 2023 · Locals estimate the total weaving population, including artisans and master weavers or gaddidaars to be close to 3 lakh. But these numbers are ...
[19]
Muslim Communities in Uttar Pradesh - newpakhistorian
Aug 6, 2022 · Muslim Communities in Uttar Pradesh ; 1. Shaikh, 1,340,057 ; 2. Pathan, 966,502 ; 3. Julaha (Ansari), 898,032 ; 4. Rajput, 404,781 ...
[20]
[PDF] Introduction - Assets - Cambridge University Press
7 The Momin Ansari, or simply Ansari, are a Muslim community located in West and ... 19 Thus, the opponents of the Pakistan movement in both India and Pakistan ...
[21]
Ansari people group in all countries | Joshua Project
India, 10,888,000 ; Nepal, 46,000 ; Pakistan, 5,063,000 ; Sri Lanka, 1,100 ...
[22]
[PDF] Ansari - people-groups.asiaharvest.org
The Ansari are well-known as cotton and silk weavers. Over 12 million Ansaris live in a wide swath across Bangladesh, north and central India, southern Nepal, ...
[23]
Hand-loom weaving community of Varanasi
Varanasi is known for its production of Banarasi sarees traditionally weaved on hand-looms and techniques by Momin Ansari Muslims. For generations they have ...
[24]
(PDF) Muslim Weavers' Politics in Early 20th Century Northern India
From sharing an occupational class identity, the weavers mobilised and asserted themselves as a caste group, seeking special recognition as Momins or Ansaris ...
[25]
Founding Leaders - Bihar State Momin Conference (Q)
The Momin Ansars, traditionally involved in weaving and textile-related occupations, are recognized as part of the Extremely Backward Community (EBC) and form a ...
[26]
[PDF] Handloom Entrepreneurship & Government Intervention- A Case ...
This art of weaving is centuries old which evident from history. Varanasi Handloom silk industry is basically dominated Momin Ansari. Weaving is mainly done by.
[27]
(PDF) Handloom: AN Endangered Industry - Academia.edu
The paper examines the decline of the handloom industry in Banaras, focusing on the Momin Ansari community, whose traditional weaving practices are ...
[28]
Muslim Caste In Uttar Pradesh (1960)
GHAUS ANSARI, Ph D. Lectwer in Anthropolofiy in the University of ... Momin Julfthft exists to this day as a distinct caste of Muslim weavers in ...
[29]
[PDF] Politics of Recognition and Caste among Muslims
Muslim society in India is divided into three distinct caste groups. 1 The first is Ashraf (noble), which comprises foreign-origin Muslims from Arab countries, ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[30]
Elitism among Indian Muslims: Caste, Power, Privilege and Inequality
Jun 10, 2019 · Sultan Shamshuddin Iltutmish, who is said to be the founder of the caste system among Indian Muslims didn't allow 'low caste' Muslims to get the ...
[31]
Does caste play a political role among Muslims in India? - GIS Asie
... (Momin Ansari). Conclusion. Caste among Indian Muslims is not a fading but an evolving phenomenon. The contemporary relevance of caste-based mobilization ...
[32]
Pasmanda Muslim community and their social, economic, and ...
Jun 9, 2025 · The Pasmanda Muslim community's status, struggles, and socio-economic reform efforts are discussed, with the AIPMM addressing their issues.
[33]
Everyone Is Equal In Islam, But Not In The Muslim Community
Aug 17, 2022 · Muslims also have a graded inequality. The Ansaris are among the most educated OBCs, well organised politically. They also don't marry outside ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[34]
All India Momin Conference: Uplifting Weaver Caste and Challenging
May 26, 2023 · Originating in Kolkata in 1912 with the establishment of Jamiat-al-Momineen, the conference extended its reach nationwide, inspiring similar ...
[35]
Indian Muslims: From Momin Conference to Pasmanda movement
May 26, 2023 · On 22 and 23 March 1925, the first session of the All India Momin Conference was held at Town Hall in Kolkata. The historic session was presided ...
[36]
https://x.com/KhalidAAnsari4/status/1779755471097708787
[37]
The Alliance Matrix: Dalit-Muslim Unity or Dalit-Pasmanda Unity?
May 28, 2022 · The All India Momin Conference of 1926 under the leadership of Hajiram Mohammad Farkhund Ali of Sasaram in Bihar started an organisation ...
[38]
[PDF] ABSTRACT
THE ALL INDIA MOMIN CONFERENCE (1914-1947)”. The All India Momin conference was a socio-economic and political movement, which began during the second decade ...Missing: formation date founder
[39]
Muslims were against the Partition of India - Awaz The Voice
Aug 14, 2024 · The Conference took up the work to propagate nationalism and secularism among the Indian Muslims and frustrated the designs of Jinnah. As a ...
[40]
The Partition and the Pasmanda Muslims! - New Age Islam
Aug 13, 2024 · In 1937, the Momin Conference which was a reformist organization took a strong political stand against the Partition of India and countered it.
[41]
Time to honour Pasmanda Patriot, Abdul Qayyum Ansari
Jul 1, 2025 · While many chose silence or sectarianism, Abdul Qayyum Ansari raised the banner of unity. As the President of the All India Momin Conference, he ...
[42]
In Defence of the Pasmanda (Backward & Dalit Muslim) Movement
Apr 11, 2016 · The julahas consequently rechristened themselves as Momin Ansar and started using the surname Momin or Ansari.Missing: ancestral | Show results with:ancestral
[43]
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/00490857211068552
[44]
The political life of Muslim caste: articulations and frictions within a ...
Jul 21, 2023 · The topic of Muslim caste has been getting space in media discourse and national politics recently through the concept of 'Pasmanda' – a term which refers to ...
[45]
Anthropological Perspective Study on the Muslims in Mysore City ...
... Momin Ansari. Muslim identity has been reinforced. by the collective observance of festivals like Id. The Muslim is primarily a rural population (65.99 ...
[46]
AIMAWS - All India Momin Ansar Welfare Society - ithepo.org
The Society has arranged ceremonies marriages of many girls belonging to destitute families. · Provided free medical aid to old destitute people. · The society is ...Missing: observances | Show results with:observances
[47]
AIMAWS - All India Momin Ansar Welfare Society - ithepo.org
The AIMAWS is a national body for momin ansar and other communities that belongs to weavers, and down trodden societies in the country.Missing: institutions | Show results with:institutions
[48]
Comparing Associationalism among Handloom Weavers and ...
handloom weavers in Varanasi are members of the Momin Ansari community, which is regarded as a low-ranked or 'backward' Muslim community or biradari.1 Both ...
[49]
The Fuzzy Boundaries: Julaha Weavers' Identity Formation in Early ...
Most of these guilds were based on caste.106 All of them now invariably claimed Sheikh descent and preferred to call themselves as Momin Ansari.107. Until now ...Missing: guilds | Show results with:guilds
[50]
Work, Ritual, Biography: A Muslim Community in North India
Aug 6, 2025 · Mehta (1997) , for example, describes an Ansari 9 weaving community in Barabanki (Uttar Pradesh) who work within the traditional confines of the ...
[51]
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/02576430251385711
[52]
Colonial Knowledge Economy: Handloom Weavers in Early ...
Mar 8, 2022 · ... India Momin Conference, the national body of the Muslim Julaha weavers, in 1926. In April 1923, police intelligence reports from the ...
[53]
[PDF] Debates on Muslim Caste in North India and Pakistan - HAL
Jun 1, 2020 · From 1844 to 1941, the nearly fifteen “castes and tribes” surveys all included Muslim groups in their listings, while the Census, starting in ...<|separator|>
[54]
[PDF] Imtiaz Ahmad - IS THERE CASTE AMONG MUSLIMS IN INDIA?
Empirical studies suggest caste-like groupings exist among Muslims in India, though some argue Islam is egalitarian and others say it's compatible with Hindu ...
[55]
Azad Muslim Conference led Muslims against the Partition of India
Mar 23, 2022 · On this day Mohammad Ali Jinnah-led Muslim League had passed a resolution demanding partition of India, which eventually led to the creation of Pakistan.Missing: attacked | Show results with:attacked
[56]
The Bullies of Partition: How the Muslim League silenced ... - Dailyo
Mar 7, 2019 · But the Muslim League, consisting of upper caste Muslims, ignored the Momin Conference simply because the organisation, despite its gigantic ...
[57]
Betrayal at Midnight – Review of 'Muslims against Partition' - KAFILA
Mar 7, 2016 · He asserted that Muslims belonged as much as Hindus to the various regions in India where they had made their home. The Pakistan idea was also ...
[58]
Caste is a harsh reality of Indian Muslim society - Awaz The Voice
May 27, 2023 · The Muslim community never existed as a unit, but was divided into different classes and castes along the social and economic grounds.