Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Muse Software

Muse Software was an American video game developer and publisher founded by Ed Zaron on August 1, 1978, in Damascus, Maryland, initially operating as Micro Users Software Exchange and focusing on titles for early home computers including the Apple II, Commodore 64, and Atari 800. The company gained prominence for innovative assembly-language games such as Robot War (1981), Castle Wolfenstein (1981), and Beyond Castle Wolfenstein (1984–1985), with the latter two—programmed by early employee Silas Warner—pioneering stealth and top-down tactical gameplay elements that influenced subsequent action-adventure titles. Muse experimented with non-gaming software but prioritized entertainment, achieving peak annual revenues of $6 million amid the home computing boom; however, internal disruptions, including key personnel departures, contributed to financial decline, culminating in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy filing in 1985, asset sales, and full cessation by 1987. Its legacy endures through the "" intellectual property, acquired post-bankruptcy by for the 1992 , which revived and expanded the franchise into a cornerstone of gaming history.

History

Founding and Early Development (1978–1980)

Muse Software was incorporated on August 1, 1978, by Ed Zaron as Micro Users Software Exchange, Inc., operating under the trade name MUSE Software Company, with initial operations based in . Zaron, along with Silas S. Warner and Jim Black, had previously met while employed at Commercial Credit, a finance firm, where Zaron developed credit scoring software and Warner worked in programming roles. Warner, who acquired his first computer in early 1978 after visiting Zaron, joined as the company's inaugural employee, focusing on game development for the emerging platform. The company initially operated from Zaron's living room, publishing third-party submissions while developing in-house titles, with an emphasis on action-oriented leveraging the Apple II's capabilities. Its inaugural 1978 catalog featured early releases such as Tank War (a shape-table-based authored by Zaron), a , and Warner's debut titles Maze Game and , which introduced and navigation mechanics in a grid-based . These efforts marked Muse's entry into the nascent gaming market, prioritizing empirical playtesting and assembler tools like the custom BMA (vertical memory assembler) to optimize code for limited . By early 1979, Muse relocated to a small office above a in a suburban mall, enabling full-time commitment from Zaron and Black, who handled accounting and operations. The period saw continued Apple II focus with releases like Global War (1979, a territorial strategy game akin to ) and simulations such as Three Mile Island (1979), which modeled operations. In 1980, titles including and ABM: expanded the portfolio, emphasizing real-time action and defensive gameplay, while the company refined its publishing model through direct mail-order distribution. This foundational phase established Muse's reputation for innovative, hardware-constrained programming amid the early personal computing boom.

Rise with Flagship Titles (1981–1983)

In 1981, Muse Software achieved a breakthrough with , an developed by Silas Warner and released for the in September. The title introduced innovative mechanics, including top-down infiltration of a Nazi castle, guard evasion using disguises and environmental distractions, and procedurally generated layouts, setting it apart from contemporaneous arcade-style shooters. Its commercial performance contributed significantly to Muse's visibility in the burgeoning home computer market, where dominated early gaming, helping the company transition from niche utilities to recognized game developer. Complementing this success, Muse released RobotWar the same year for the , a programmable simulator originally conceived by Steve Nelson and further developed for commercial viability. Players coded robot behaviors in a simple assembly-like language to battle in an arena, emphasizing strategy and debugging over direct control, which appealed to the era's hobbyist programmers and foreshadowed later AI-driven titles. These flagship releases solidified Muse's reputation for substantive, intellectually engaging software amid the Apple II ecosystem's growth, with Castle Wolfenstein in particular driving sustained interest through its genre-blending tension and replayability. Building momentum into 1982, Muse diversified with titles like (Apple II), a puzzle-action game involving arson evasion; The Caverns of Freitag (Apple II), an early grid-based dungeon crawler; The Cube Solution (Apple II), a spatial puzzle emphasizing logical deduction; and Frazzle! (Apple II), a dexterity challenge. In 1983, the portfolio expanded to include Advanced Blackjack and Antonym Antics (both Apple II, focusing on strategy and wordplay), The Function Game (Apple II, ), Titan Empire (Apple II, ), and (Commodore 64), marking initial platform diversification beyond Apple dominance. This period of prolific output, anchored by the 1981 hits, reflected Muse's rising operational scale, with Warner's solo efforts evolving into a producing varied genres that capitalized on home computing's educational and entertainment convergence, though exact revenue figures remain undocumented in contemporary records.

Platform Expansion and Internal Challenges (1984–1986)

In 1984, Muse Software broadened its portfolio beyond the Apple II by porting titles to emerging platforms including the Commodore 64, Atari 8-bit family, and MS-DOS, exemplified by Beyond Castle Wolfenstein, a stealth-action sequel that incorporated digitized voice samples and top-down gameplay mechanics. The company also debuted Space Taxi, a physics-based puzzle-platformer, on the Commodore 64, targeting the console's growing user base amid intensifying competition in the home computer market. These efforts capitalized on prior successes like Castle Wolfenstein, with annual revenues peaking at approximately $6 million that year, supported by an expanded marketing team and retail distribution channels. By 1985, further releases such as Leaps and Bounds! sustained platform diversification, but internal disruptions eroded operational stability. Key departures included marketing director Pete Bavarus, whose exit left a leadership vacuum; his replacement, hired from , was soon incapacitated by AIDS-related illness, effectively halting promotional activities and sales pipelines. Development persisted on Commodore 64 titles and an enhanced Apple II word processor, yet unchecked product returns from mass-market retailers like Toys "R" Us compounded revenue shortfalls, dropping sales to near zero despite ongoing coding efforts by Warner and team. These cascading issues—stemming from personnel turnover, inadequate sales infrastructure, and overreliance on hit-driven revenue without robust contingency planning—precipitated a by 1986. The development staff, excluding Warner, was dismissed amid cash flow collapse, prompting Warner's own departure; Muse filed for Chapter 7 , with assets ultimately acquired by Variety Discounters under Jerry Herskowitz, marking the prelude to full dissolution in 1987. This downturn reflected broader industry volatility, where small publishers struggled against scaling distributors and shifting consumer preferences toward arcade-style graphics over strategy depth.

Bankruptcy and Dissolution (1987)

By the mid-1980s, Muse Software had dwindled from a peak of approximately 40 employees in to just six, grappling with persistent fallout from the video game market crash, including retailer returns of unsold inventory such as from Toys "R" Us and a collapsed department that halted . The departure of the marketing manager, followed by his replacement's incapacitation due to AIDS within nine months, exacerbated operational paralysis, prompting the firing of the development team. These issues culminated in Chapter 7 bankruptcy proceedings, initiating asset and permanent closure rather than reorganization. The company officially filed for bankruptcy on October 7, 1987, marking its dissolution. Marketing deficiencies were identified as a primary factor in the failure to sustain revenue amid industry contraction. In the aftermath, remaining inventory was liquidated through discounted sales, exhausting stockpiles without revival efforts. Key intellectual properties, including the "" trademark from , were acquired at minimal cost by to facilitate development of . No significant revival or acquisition of the core entity occurred, ending Muse's independent operations.

Games and Innovations

Stealth and Action Pioneers

, released in September 1981 for the by Muse Software, marked an early milestone in stealth gameplay mechanics. Developed by Silas Warner, the top-down placed players in the role of an Allied prisoner escaping a Nazi-occupied castle to retrieve secret war plans. Core innovations included avoiding guard detection through hiding behind doors or crates, using silenced pistols for quiet kills, and donning enemy uniforms as disguises to bypass patrols, emphasizing tension over direct confrontation. These elements differentiated it from contemporaneous shoot-'em-ups, introducing risk-reward decisions like the chance of guards discovering bodies or raising alarms, which could summon reinforcements and lead to mission failure. The game's of castle layouts added replayability, while —such as limited and keys—reinforced cautious playstyles. Ports followed to 8-bit systems in 1982, Commodore 64 in 1983, and in 1984, broadening its influence on . The 1984 sequel, , expanded these foundations by shifting objectives to assassinating via a bomb plot inspired by the real . Players navigated bunkers with enhanced tools, including passkeys and a larger inventory for varied disguises, alongside improved enemy AI that reacted to noise and suspicious behavior. This title further refined action- hybrid elements, such as timed escapes and multi-room infiltration, solidifying Muse's role in genre evolution. Muse also contributed to action genres through titles like Pharaoh's Curse (1983), an Apple II platformer where players explored Egyptian tombs battling mummies and traps with a whip and pistol, blending combat, jumping, and puzzle-solving in a side-scrolling format atypical for early PC games. These releases demonstrated Muse's experimentation with player agency in hostile environments, predating broader adoption of such dynamics in later arcade and console action titles.

Strategy and Puzzle Releases

Muse Software's strategy releases emphasized and tactical decision-making, often requiring players to manage resources or program behaviors in competitive scenarios. ABM, released on June 1, 1980, for the , simulated along the U.S. East Coast, where players launched interceptors to neutralize incoming nuclear threats in , drawing direct inspiration from arcade-style mechanics while adapting them to home computing constraints. The game featured escalating waves of attacks, limited ammunition, and strategic placement of defenses, highlighting early computational limits on Apple hardware with vector-style graphics. Robotwar, developed by Silas Warner and published in 1981 for the , represented a pioneering programming-based title, tasking players with authoring BASIC-like code to direct combatants in an . Players scripted instructions for movement, scanning, targeting, and firing, compiling and programs to outmaneuver opponents in up to five-robot battles, fostering emergent tactics through iterative testing. This approach prefigured modern simulations, emphasizing logical foresight over reflexes, and included utilities for editing and simulating code, which Muse provided to aid development. In the puzzle domain, Space Taxi, released in 1984 for the Commodore 64 and later ported to other platforms, challenged players to pilot a as a taxi service, navigating 25 procedurally influenced levels with platforms, hazards, and passenger pickups/drop-offs. Controls demanded precise thrust management, rotation, and landing gear deployment to avoid collisions with moving obstacles like elevators and crushers, blending arcade action with puzzle-solving through trial-and-error . The game's escalating complexity and hidden features, such as unlocking bonus modes, rewarded experimentation, though its difficulty curve drew mixed reception for frustrating restarts. These titles collectively showcased Muse's versatility in non-action genres amid its primary focus on Apple II development, though limited marketing and platform specificity constrained broader adoption.

Role-Playing and Adventure Titles

The Caverns of Freitag, released in 1982 for the , represented Muse Software's primary foray into elements, functioning as an action-oriented hybrid. In the game, players control a lone navigating procedurally generated underground caverns filled with monsters, collecting weapons and items to ultimately slay a dragon guarding treasure. Its combat and exploration mechanics distinguished it from turn-based contemporaries, emphasizing direct control and immediate decision-making in a fantasy setting. The title's design, originally submitted to Muse by external developer Ed Zaron, incorporated for replayability, though it remained relatively obscure compared to the company's action titles. Beyond Castle Wolfenstein, published in 1984 for platforms including , 8-bit, 64, and , built on adventure gameplay traditions with top-down maze navigation and puzzle-solving. Players assume the role of an Allied agent infiltrating a Nazi chateau to rescue a spy, utilizing , disguises, keys, and weapons while avoiding guards and dogs in a World War II scenario. The game required strategic item management and route planning across multi-level structures, blending adventure tropes like inventory-based progression with timed evasion sequences. Released as a direct sequel to , it expanded the scope with larger environments and narrative depth, though its hybrid action-adventure nature limited pure exploratory freedom. These titles demonstrated Muse's experimentation with genre fusion, prioritizing accessible real-time systems over complex character progression or branching narratives typical of later RPGs, reflecting hardware constraints of early home computers. No further dedicated or text-based releases followed, as the company shifted focus amid financial pressures by mid-decade.

Business Operations

Key Personnel and Management

Muse Software was founded on August 1, 1978, by Ed Zaron, who served as the company's president and primary decision-maker, incorporating it initially as Micro Users Software Exchange in , before adopting the Muse Software trade name and relocating to . Zaron, previously employed at Commercial Credit, a Maryland firm, handled overall operations and product development oversight, including early titles like Tank and Super-Text, while transitioning from part-time to full-time commitment in 1979. Jim Black, an accountant from the same Commercial Credit billing department, co-founded the company alongside Zaron and contributed to and administrative functions, joining full-time in 1979 after the firm secured its first above a suburban . Silas S. Warner, the first dedicated employee and a who also met Zaron and Black at Commercial Credit, became the lead developer, creating flagship titles such as (1981) and RobotWar (1981), though he departed in 1985 amid financial difficulties preceding the company's filing. Under Zaron's leadership, Muse expanded from a three-person operation in his to approximately 40 employees by , incorporating a retail storefront on Baltimore's Charles Street for direct sales and . The management structure emphasized in-house development and alongside games, but lacked robust financial controls, contributing to overextension as the company pursued ports to multiple platforms like 8-bit and 64. Following the 1985 Chapter 7 , assets were acquired by Jerry Herskowitz and Jack Vogt, who briefly continued limited operations before dissolution in 1987.

Publishing and Distribution Model

Muse Software operated as a self-publisher, developing, producing, and releasing its own software titles without reliance on third-party publishers. Early distribution emphasized direct sales at regional computer trade shows, such as the Trenton Computer Festival in April 1978, where initial cassette-based games like Tank War and were offered to attendees. The company expanded its model by opening the Muse Computer Center, a retail store in on the ground floor of its headquarters building at 330 North Charles Street. This outlet enabled hands-on product demonstrations for consumers, stocked competing software for , and provided access to dealer-discounted pricing on Muse titles and third-party products, yielding resale profits. Direct-to-consumer sales via formed a core channel, supported by printed catalogs listing games, utilities like Super-Text, and , with advertisements in magazines such as Softalk and promoting phone orders (7-day standard delivery or 1-day express mail). To reach broader markets, Muse cultivated a dealer network by including recruitment coupons in its catalogs, offering wholesale terms of approximately $20 per unit against a $39.95 suggested price. This hybrid approach of direct , , and wholesale drove peak annual sales to $6 million in 1984–1985, though it proved vulnerable to industry downturns by the mid-1980s.

Legacy

Influence on Gaming Genres

Castle Wolfenstein, released in 1981 by Muse Software, introduced core mechanics that laid foundational groundwork for the genre, including navigation through enemy-patrolled environments, the use of disguises obtained by eliminating guards, and resource scarcity such as limited forcing avoidance over confrontation. These elements emphasized tension from detection risks and strategic evasion, predating more codified stealth titles and influencing subsequent designs where players prioritize infiltration over direct combat. The game's top-down perspective and procedural guard behaviors further contributed to stealth's evolution by simulating unpredictable patrols and alert states, mechanics echoed in later works that built upon Muse's emphasis on realism and player ingenuity within confined spaces. (1984), a direct , extended these principles with plot-driven objectives like assassination attempts, reinforcing Muse's role in blending narrative urgency with covert tactics. While Muse's output spanned other areas, such as Robot War's (1981) programmable robot combat simulation—which fostered strategic scripting and tactical arena battles—its broader genre impact remained niche compared to the stealth innovations. These contributions from Muse highlighted early experimentation with player agency in adversarial environments, though the company's dissolution in 1987 limited direct lineage, with influences manifesting indirectly through the enduring IP and genre precedents.

Intellectual Property Aftermath

Following Muse Software's Chapter 7 bankruptcy filing on October 7, 1987, the company's assets, including copyrights and trademarks for its game portfolio, were liquidated by a court-appointed trustee to pay creditors, resulting in the sale of intellectual property to third parties. This process dispersed ownership of titles such as Castle Wolfenstein, One on One, Space Taxi, and Leap of Faith, with no evidence of centralized retention by founders or employees. Creator Silas Warner stated that he did not retain personal rights to his works, directing inquiries for permissions to the post-liquidation copyright holders. The most notable transfer involved the franchise. In the early 1990s, id Software sought rights to develop a to (1981). After initial challenges locating owners, id discovered that a private individual—a woman—had acquired the entirety of Muse's output through the liquidation. She sold the trademark to id for $100,000, enabling the release of in 1992 and subsequent franchise expansions. Ownership later passed to via its 2009 acquisition of . For other Muse titles, no comparable commercial revivals occurred post-1987, indicating fragmented or inactive ownership following liquidation. Games like Sim (1985) and Robot War (1982) have not seen official re-releases or licensing deals, with distribution limited to emulation communities and archival sites treating them as unmaintained legacy software. Copyrights, valid for 95 years from publication under U.S. law for corporate works, persist without active enforcement or exploitation by known entities, contributing to preservation challenges in retro gaming.

References

  1. [1]
    Muse Software - MobyGames
    was an American video game developer founded by Ed Zaron in Damascus, Maryland, on August 1, 1978. The company later adopted the trading name Muse Software and ...
  2. [2]
    Muse Software (defunct) - GameCompanies.com
    The company originally published games and experimented with non-gaming applications but ultimately made an impact developing games for the C64 and Atari 800.
  3. [3]
    Old Timers: Muse Software - KansasFest
    In the beginning of 1979 then, Muse Software actually got an office. We were above a gun shop in suburban shopping mall. Ed decided to leave Control Data. Jim ...
  4. [4]
    MUSE Software, Micro User Software Exchange - Retro365
    Dec 28, 2022 · After filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in 1985, the company was bought by Jerry Herskowitz's Variety Discounters Company and in 1988, retired ...
  5. [5]
    Silas Warner and Muse Software | The Digital Antiquarian
    Will Crowther and Ken Williams also among ...
  6. [6]
    Six Game Devs Speak to Computer Games Mag (1984)
    Jul 10, 2025 · We founded Muse in Ed Zaron's living room." (Zaron is president of Muse Software. Muse subsequently published Old Maze and Tank War.).
  7. [7]
    Maze Game & Escape, Silas Warner's first two commercial games ...
    Nov 11, 2020 · Warner left MUSE Software a few weeks before its demise in 1985. He joined Sid Meyer and Microprose where he stayed until 1989 as a programmer ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  8. [8]
    Global War - Muse Software, 1979 - Apple II - YouTube
    Oct 1, 2021 · Bits From my Personal Collection – Global war, Alan Boyd, a pioneer heralding a digital world ...Missing: early 1980
  9. [9]
    Published games - Muse Software - Giant Bomb
    Muse Software was a game developer and publisher who produced games for the early home computers. They are probobly best known for introducing the ...
  10. [10]
    Muse Software - LaunchBox Games Database
    Muse Software · ABM: Anti-Ballistic Missile Game · Advanced Blackjack · Beyond Castle Wolfenstein · Beyond Castle Wolfenstein · Beyond Castle Wolfenstein · Beyond ...
  11. [11]
  12. [12]
    The story of the man who made Wolfenstein - Polygon
    Dec 24, 2019 · He went on to co-found Muse with Warner. In a 1984 interview with Creative Computing, Zaron talked about how he and Warner became friends. “He ...
  13. [13]
    Castle Wolfenstein, the grandfather of stealth, turning 40 - Retro365
    Aug 12, 2021 · While Muse Software saw quite a lot of success with its software and games, and especially the Wolfenstein titles, the company never managed ...
  14. [14]
    Robot War | The Digital Antiquarian
    Jan 30, 2012 · It was common enough even in 1981 for computer programs to model the real world, in the form of flight simulators, war games, etc.
  15. [15]
    RobotWar: the Battlefield of the Future - Core War
    In 1980 RobotWar was ported to the Apple II and published by MUSE Software. The aim of the game is to write a program to control the movement, radar and gun ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  16. [16]
    Castle Wolfenstein (1981) - MobyGames
    Castle Wolfenstein is a classic action game of stealth, fighting and exploration. ... This is the game that was the inspiration for id Software's Wolfenstein 3D.
  17. [17]
    Castle Wolfenstein - StrategyWiki
    Apr 26, 2022 · The game is a slow-paced stealth game set in World War II. The game's main objective is to traverse the levels of the castle to find the secret war plans and ...<|separator|>
  18. [18]
    The history and meaning behind the 'Stealth genre' - Game Developer
    Jun 10, 2011 · The objective in the game was to retrieve war-plan documents from a castle that was infested with guards. The player faced two types of enemies ...
  19. [19]
    Castle Wolfenstein (1981) (Muse) : Silas Warner - Internet Archive
    Oct 29, 2013 · Castle Wolfenstein is an early stealth-based action-adventure shooter video game developed by Muse Software for the Apple II.
  20. [20]
    ABM (1980) - MobyGames
    Jan 23, 2014 · An early Missile Command clone which puts the player in charge of defending the US East Coast from a nuclear attack.
  21. [21]
    Old Timers: Muse Software - KansasFest
    Dec 11, 2010 · Muse is probabIy best known for its strategy games Castle Wolfenstein, RobotWar, and ABM, but the company was also an early publisher of ...
  22. [22]
    RobotWar – program your robot to victory - Retro365
    Aug 10, 2021 · Later versions allowed access to all registers. In 1981 Muse Software moved the operation up the road, from 330 to 347 North Charles Street in ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  23. [23]
    Space Taxi (1984) - MobyGames
    Sep 25, 2005 · Space Taxi features 25 screens with varying obstacles and challenges that must be navigated in order to collect your fare.
  24. [24]
    Space Taxi - Commodore 64 Game - Lemon64
    Rating 8.5/10 (229) Space Taxi is a Commodore 64 lander arcade game released in 1984 by Muse Software. Check out screenshots, downloads, cheats and more info!
  25. [25]
    Space Taxi - C64-Wiki
    In the game Space Taxi you fly a taxi and bring passengers either from platform to platform or into the next level.
  26. [26]
    The Caverns of Freitag - MUSE Software, 1982 - Apple II (4K)
    Jul 22, 2022 · Go to channel · The Caverns of Freitag is the BEST Action RPG of 1982! Chronologically Gaming•374 views · 19:02. Go to channel · Warlords - ...
  27. [27]
    The Caverns of Freitag, influential but forgotten - Retro365
    Jul 22, 2022 · The game was sent to Ed Zaron's MUSE Software on the east coast. While MUSE Software had made a name for itself with Silas Warner's 1981 ...
  28. [28]
    Beyond Castle Wolfenstein (1984) - MobyGames
    Genre: Action ; Perspective: Diagonal-down ; Visual: Fixed / flip-screen ; Gameplay: Shooter ; Interface: Direct control
  29. [29]
    Beyond Castle Wolfenstein : Muse Software : Free Borrow & Streaming
    Dec 27, 2014 · Beyond Castle Wolfenstein ; Released 1985 ; Genre Action ; Gameplay Shooter, Stealth ; Perspective Top-down ; Setting World War II.
  30. [30]
    Beyond Castle Wolfenstein - Commodore 64 Game - Lemon64
    Rating 6.8/10 (49) Released: 1984 (41 years ago) ; Publisher: Muse SoftwareInfo / logo ; Coder: Silas S. WarnerInfo ; Players: 1 Only ; Genre: Adventure, Arcade 2D.
  31. [31]
    Muse Software Games - IGN
    Muse Software Games ; ABM. Jun 1, 1980. +1 ; Beyond Castle Wolfenstein. Dec 31, 1984. PC Commodore 64/128. +2 ; Castle Wolfenstein. Oct 10, 1981. Macintosh ...
  32. [32]
  33. [33]
    [PDF] SOFTALK Mar 1981 - Vintage Apple
    MUSE Software .... . .. . ........ :: . ....16. On-Line Systems ... Direct order will incur a $2.00 shipping : handling charge plus sales tax where ...<|separator|>
  34. [34]
    [PDF] Computer Entertainment - Atari Compendium
    Jun 4, 1985 · Muse Software Makes You Alwart computer. ENTERTAINMENT. Fantasy ... doys for delivery 210 7 days for phone orders 1 day express mail!
  35. [35]
    30 Years of Butt-Kicking: The History of Wolfenstein - Xbox Wire
    May 20, 2014 · It introduced innovations that would go on to become standards in the stealth genre, including swiping enemy uniforms and dramatically limited ...
  36. [36]
    Retrospective: Castle Wolfenstein - GROGNARDIA
    Feb 2, 2022 · This was not an arcade shoot-em-up but an early example of the stealth genre that would develop more fully in years to come. At the time ...
  37. [37]
    From 'Castle Wolfenstein' to 'Dishonored 2': A Brief History of Stealth ...
    Nov 4, 2016 · The most prominent early stealth title, the one that made us all stand up and take notice of the emerging genre, was Castle Wolfenstein.Missing: innovations | Show results with:innovations
  38. [38]
    The Early History of the Stealth Game – Pac to the Start
    Nov 14, 2022 · Around the same time, you see the genre evolve via the top-down Apple II game Castle Wolfenstein. This allowed players to dress as Nazi ...
  39. [39]
    Wolfenstein 3D secrets revealed by John Romero in lengthy post ...
    Mar 24, 2022 · Weeks later, he discovered that a woman owned the entirety of Muse's output, and she was willing to sell the Wolfenstein trademark outright to ...