Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Proband

A proband, also known as a propositus (male), proposita (female), or index case, is the first individual in a family ascertained to have a genetic condition or trait, typically the person who initially seeks medical attention or genetic counseling, thereby initiating the study of familial inheritance patterns.^[1]^[2]^[3] In genetic research and clinical practice, the proband plays a central role in pedigree construction and family-based studies, where their phenotype or genotype serves as the starting point for tracing hereditary risks across relatives.^[4] This ascertainment process is crucial for identifying patterns of inheritance, such as autosomal dominant or recessive traits, and for estimating disease penetrance, though challenges like incomplete family data or variable expressivity can complicate analysis. Proband-initiated genetic testing often leads to cascade screening of at-risk family members, improving early detection and management of conditions like hereditary cancers or cardiomyopathies.^[1]^[5] The term originates from the Latin probandus, the gerundive of probare meaning "to test" or "to prove," reflecting its historical use in early 20th-century genetics to denote the subject through whom a family's genetic profile is validated.^[6] First documented around 1929, it has become standardized nomenclature in fields like human genetics, with guidelines emphasizing its distinction from terms like "consultand" (the person seeking advice) to ensure precise communication in research and counseling.^[4]^[2]

Definition and Terminology

Core Definition

In genetics and medicine, a proband is defined as the individual who first brings a genetic condition or concern to the attention of healthcare professionals or researchers, thereby initiating a family-based investigation into potential hereditary risks.^[1] This person serves as the focal point for constructing a family pedigree, enabling the tracing of genetic patterns across generations.^[7] While often affected by the condition, the term proband is neutral and applies to any family member—whether affected, unaffected, symptomatic, or an asymptomatic carrier—who prompts the study, such as a relative worried about inheriting a familial disorder.^[8] Key characteristics of a proband include their role as the entry point for genetic assessment in both clinical diagnostics, where they may seek counseling for personal symptoms or family history, and research protocols, where they facilitate broader genomic analysis.^[9] In pedigree charts, the proband is typically denoted by a diagonal arrow pointing to their symbol, standardizing their identification for inheritance pattern evaluation.^[10] Examples of proband types illustrate this versatility: a symptomatic proband might be an individual presenting with overt traits, such as a child with muscle weakness due to a suspected neuromuscular disorder, while an asymptomatic carrier proband could be an unaffected adult initiating testing based on a family history of the same condition.^[9] These distinctions highlight the proband's importance in revealing hidden genetic risks without assuming personal affliction.^[8]

Etymology and Linguistic Origins

The term "proband" derives from the Latin probandus, the gerundive form of probare, meaning "to test," "to prove," or "to examine," which aptly reflects the individual's role as the primary subject under scrutiny in familial studies.^[6] This linguistic root underscores the concept's emphasis on verification through the affected person as the starting point for investigation.^[11] The term first appeared in scientific literature in 1912 within German genetics, introduced by Wilhelm Weinberg in his article "Weitere Beiträge zur Theorie der Vererbung. 4. Über Methode und Fehlerquellen der Untersuchung auf Mendelsche Zahlen beim Menschen" on segregation analysis and ascertainment methods for human heredity.^[12] Weinberg's application of the "proband method" (Probandmethode) in studies of traits like tuberculosis and psychiatric conditions marked its initial adoption, particularly in collaborations with researchers such as Ernst Rüdin on schizophrenia inheritance.^[12] It gained traction in the 1920s through eugenics-influenced anthropological and psychiatric genetics.^[13] By the mid-20th century, "proband" had been translated and integrated into English-language medical and genetic texts, with its first recorded use around 1929, evolving into a standardized term by the 1950s amid growing formalization of pedigree analysis in clinical genetics.^[6] This shift solidified its place beyond early psychiatric and anthropological contexts, becoming essential for unbiased family-based research.^[14] The term's influence extended to non-English scientific vocabularies, retaining "Proband" in German usage while inspiring adaptations like "probando" in Spanish and Portuguese genetic literature, maintaining the core idea of the tested individual across Romance languages.^[15]

Role in Genetic Studies

Identification in Family Pedigrees

In family pedigrees, the proband is identified as the affected family member who initially seeks medical attention or is referred for evaluation due to symptoms, serving as the entry point for constructing the diagram regardless of their generational position within the family.^[16]^[17] This criterion ensures the pedigree centers on the individual bringing the genetic concern to clinical or research notice, often independently of other relatives' involvement.^[18] Standard notation in pedigrees designates the proband through a shaded symbol—typically a solid square for males or circle for females—to indicate affected status, accompanied by an arrow pointing to the lower left corner of the symbol or a label such as "Pro" or "P" for clarity.^[17]^[19] The proband is positioned as the central reference, with lines extending to map parental, sibling, and ancestral connections in birth order, facilitating systematic tracing of familial relationships.^[16] The identification process begins with an initial interview of the proband to gather basic details on personal health history, followed by confirmation of their phenotype through medical records or diagnostic testing, and genotype if applicable via genetic analysis.^[20] Subsequent steps involve expanding the pedigree by querying the proband about relatives, verifying reported phenotypes through accessible medical histories, and diagramming siblings, parents, and ancestors to build a three-generation or broader framework.^[21]^[17] Challenges arise in cases with multiple affected family members, where distinguishing the true proband requires confirming who first presented independently, often necessitating cross-verification of timelines from medical documentation to avoid ambiguity.^[22] Incomplete family records pose additional hurdles, such as unknown relationships or unverified diagnoses, which demand supplementary evidence like birth certificates or historical interviews to ensure accuracy while adhering to confidentiality standards.^[16] These methodological steps underscore the proband's role in enabling broader genetic research by providing a reliable starting point for familial mapping.^[18]

Contribution to Inheritance Pattern Analysis

The proband's genotype and phenotype serve as the foundational data point in pedigree analysis, enabling geneticists to hypothesize the mode of inheritance for a observed trait or disorder. By tracing the occurrence of the trait through family members relative to the proband, patterns such as autosomal dominant (characterized by vertical transmission across generations), autosomal recessive (skipping generations with unaffected carrier parents), X-linked (disproportionate male affection in recessive forms), or mitochondrial inheritance (maternal transmission only) can be deduced.^[23]^[24] For instance, if the proband is affected and both parents are unaffected, this supports a recessive or de novo dominant hypothesis, while male-to-male transmission rules out X-linked inheritance.^[25] Analytical methods often begin with the proband to calculate key parameters like penetrance—the proportion of variant carriers who express the phenotype—and expressivity—the range of phenotypic severity among those who do. Penetrance estimates are derived by identifying probands with the trait, genotyping relatives via cascade testing, and assessing phenotype frequency in variant-positive family members, yielding "familial penetrance" values that may exceed population-based estimates due to ascertainment bias.^[26] Expressivity is similarly evaluated starting from the proband, incorporating family data to quantify variability, as seen in disorders where proband-centered studies reveal allele-specific effects ranging from mild to severe manifestations.^[26] Proband-focused risk assessment for relatives employs these metrics to inform counseling, adjusting probabilities based on shared familial variants. Probands integrate into probabilistic models for refined familial risk evaluation, such as Punnett squares for simple Mendelian predictions or Bayesian analysis for complex pedigrees incorporating prior probabilities and conditional likelihoods from proband data.^[27] In Bayesian frameworks, the proband's test results update carrier or recurrence risks; for example, a proband with cystic fibrosis (an autosomal recessive disorder) and an affected sibling elevates the posterior probability of parental carrier status to near 100%, guiding testing for unaffected relatives.^[28] Next-generation sequencing of the proband and parents further distinguishes inherited from de novo variants, enhancing model accuracy by detecting low-level mosaicism that alters risk estimates.^[25] In case-specific applications, proband data illuminates nuances like de novo mutations or variable expressivity; in cystic fibrosis, rare de novo CFTR variants in the proband can explain isolated cases without parental carriers, while family-wide analysis from the proband reveals modifier genes contributing to expressivity differences, such as milder pulmonary symptoms in some siblings despite shared genotypes.^[29] These insights underscore the proband's centrality in transitioning from descriptive pedigrees to predictive genetic modeling.^[23]

Proband versus Index Case

In medical genetics, a proband refers to the first individual in a family who is affected by or at risk for a genetic condition and seeks medical attention, thereby prompting evaluation of relatives for hereditary patterns.^[1] In contrast, an index case in epidemiology denotes the initial documented instance of a disease within a population or outbreak, serving as the starting point for tracing transmission or spread, particularly in infectious disease contexts.^[30] The primary distinction lies in scope and focus: the proband is inherently family-centered and oriented toward identifying inherited disorders through pedigree analysis, whereas the index case is population- or event-based, often applied to broader epidemiological investigations like disease clusters without emphasizing familial inheritance.^[1]^[30] For instance, in hereditary conditions, the proband's diagnosis raises suspicion for relatives, facilitating genetic counseling and testing.^[31] In outbreaks, the index case alerts public health authorities to initiate contact tracing and containment measures, regardless of family ties.^[30] In genetic epidemiology, the terms occasionally overlap or are used interchangeably, especially when studying household contacts for both infectious and heritable traits, though "proband" retains emphasis on familial lineage tracing.^[32] Representative examples illustrate these contexts: in a family study of Huntington's disease, the proband is the affected member whose symptoms, such as chorea and cognitive decline, lead to genetic testing of relatives to confirm autosomal dominant inheritance.^[33] Conversely, in a tuberculosis outbreak at an educational institution, the index case is the first student identified with active pulmonary disease, prompting screening of contacts to halt transmission.^[34]

Proband versus Consultand

In genetic counseling, the terms proband and consultand refer to distinct roles within family-based assessments for hereditary conditions, though they may overlap in certain scenarios. The proband is defined as the first family member identified as affected by or at risk for a genetic condition who first comes to medical attention, often initiating the evaluation of familial risks independent of other relatives.^[2] In contrast, the consultand is the individual—typically unaffected—who seeks genetic counseling to assess personal or familial risks, such as a relative inquiring about inherited predispositions.^[35] A key difference lies in their interpersonal dynamics during patient-provider interactions: the consultand initiates the counseling session by presenting concerns, but recommendations are primarily driven by data from the proband's condition or testing results. For instance, in hereditary breast and ovarian cancer syndromes involving BRCA1 mutations, an unaffected parent (the consultand) may seek counseling regarding their child's early-onset breast cancer (where the child is the proband), prompting cascade testing to evaluate the parent's carrier status and inform risk management for other relatives.^[5] Over time, a consultand may transition to proband status if they later develop symptoms of the genetic condition, shifting their role from advisor-seeker to the focal affected individual in pedigree analysis. Ethical considerations in distinguishing these roles emphasize privacy protections when family data is shared between probands and consultands. Genetic counselors must balance confidentiality under laws like the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) of 2008, which safeguards against discrimination based on genetic information, with the potential duty to warn at-risk relatives if imminent harm is identified—though providers typically do not verify inter-family disclosures due to legal and access constraints.^[5] This tension arises particularly in shared family histories, where consultands may request access to proband results, requiring informed consent to prevent unauthorized breaches while promoting beneficence through risk communication.^[36]

Historical and Modern Applications

Historical Introduction and Early Usage

The term "proband," introduced by Wilhelm Weinberg in 1912, was employed by German psychiatrist Ernst Rüdin in his seminal 1916 monograph Zur Vererbung und Entstehung der Dementia Praecox, where it denoted the primary affected individual through whom a family pedigree was ascertained in studies of schizophrenia inheritance.^[37] Rüdin, working at the German Research Institute for Psychiatry in Munich, employed the term alongside statistical methods developed by Wilhelm Weinberg, such as the proband method for correcting ascertainment bias in familial risk calculations.^[38] This usage marked an early application in psychiatric genetics, emphasizing systematic family investigations to trace hereditary patterns of mental disorders. In 1922, Rüdin extended the term's application in an unpublished study on the inheritance of manic-depressive insanity (now bipolar disorder), analyzing over 200 proband families to estimate morbid risks among relatives while subordinating findings to prevailing eugenic ideologies.^[39] The concept was soon adapted by geneticist Fritz Lenz, who incorporated "proband" into hereditary research frameworks in the textbook Menschliche Erblichkeitslehre und Rassenhygiene (co-authored with Erwin Baur and Eugen Fischer), first published in 1921 and revised through the 1930s; Lenz used it to describe the starting point for pedigree analysis in human traits, broadening its scope beyond psychiatry to general eugenics-influenced anthropology.^[40] By the early 1930s, Franz Josef Kallmann, a student of Rüdin's group who later emigrated to the United States, routinely applied "proband" in twin studies of schizophrenia, identifying the initiating affected twin as the proband to quantify concordance rates and genetic penetrance.^[41] Pre-World War II, the term proliferated in eugenics-driven research across Europe, particularly in German and Scandinavian contexts, where it facilitated mapping of "degenerate" traits for sterilization policies and racial hygiene programs.^[42] After 1945, amid the discrediting of eugenics due to Nazi abuses, "proband" transitioned to apolitical medical genetics, focusing on unbiased clinical pedigrees. The term's first documented appearance in English occurred circa 1929. It gained prominence in post-war human genetics research, appearing in the inaugural volume of the American Journal of Human Genetics in 1949.^[6]

Contemporary Uses in Clinical and Research Contexts

In clinical diagnostics, the proband remains the primary entry point for genomic sequencing efforts aimed at identifying causative variants in rare genetic disorders. Whole exome sequencing (WES) applied to probands has become a standard approach, particularly for conditions like Rett syndrome, where analysis of affected individuals has uncovered de novo or inherited mutations in genes such as MECP2 and others, elucidating the phenotypic heterogeneity beyond classical presentations. For instance, WES in probands with Rett-like symptoms has revealed variants in a diverse array of genes, facilitating targeted therapies and family counseling. This proband-focused strategy enhances diagnostic yield, with studies reporting molecular confirmation rates of up to 30-40% in undiagnosed cases of neurodevelopmental disorders. Recent studies as of 2024 report whole genome sequencing (WGS) diagnostic yields approaching 50% in neurodevelopmental disorders when including structural variants.^[43] Predictive testing protocols often initiate from the proband's results, enabling cascade screening for at-risk relatives to assess carrier status or presymptomatic risks in hereditary conditions like cardiomyopathies or cancers. In genetic research, probands drive the recruitment of representative family cohorts for large-scale studies, including genome-wide association studies (GWAS) and biobank initiatives, which amplify power to detect both common and rare variants. Family-based GWAS leveraging proband-ascertained pedigrees have been instrumental in quantifying genetic nurture effects, where parental genotypes influence offspring traits independently of direct inheritance, as demonstrated in analyses of refractive error and longevity. In biobanks, proband data from high-density disease families supports whole genome sequencing to map inherited risks, ensuring cohorts reflect real-world familial clustering and improving variant interpretation across populations. This approach has been pivotal in consortia like the Collaborative Study on the Genetics of Alcoholism, where proband recruitment yielded insights into psychiatric disorder polygenicity. Ethical and legal frameworks governing proband-involved family studies prioritize informed consent to balance individual autonomy with familial benefits, while navigating privacy regulations like HIPAA and GDPR. Under HIPAA, clinicians may directly notify at-risk relatives of genetic risks identified through proband testing, provided it promotes public health without unauthorized disclosure, as affirmed in guidance allowing cascade testing recommendations. GDPR mandates explicit consent for processing sensitive genetic data in research, including safeguards against re-identification in family contexts, with dynamic consent models enabling ongoing family notifications while addressing incidental findings. Challenges persist in diverse populations, where cultural stigmas, language barriers, and historical mistrust reduce proband participation and family uptake, exacerbating inequities in genetic services and necessitating tailored outreach. AI models integrating proband pedigrees with polygenic scores have further enhanced accuracy in diverse ancestries. Advancements since the 2010s have integrated artificial intelligence with proband-derived family data to refine risk prediction models, enhancing precision in hereditary disease forecasting. Machine learning pipelines analyzing proband pedigrees have automated risk stratification for thousands of conditions, outperforming traditional models by incorporating familial health histories for more accurate polygenic liability estimates. For example, neuro-symbolic AI tools process pedigree charts to predict cancer susceptibilities, aiding oncogenetic counseling by simulating inheritance patterns from proband variants. These AI-driven methods, validated in large cohorts, have improved predictive accuracy by 10-20% over non-familial approaches, supporting personalized interventions in clinical genetics.

References

[1]
Proband - National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI)
A proband is an individual who is affected by a genetic condition or who is concerned they are at risk. Usually, the proband is the first person in a family ...Missing: authoritative source - -
[2]
Dictionary of Genetics Terms - PDQ Cancer Information Summaries
Dictionary of Genetics Terms. acrochordon. A small, benign skin growth ... proband. The first individual in a family to be identified as possibly having ...
[3]
Definition of proband - NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms
The first person in a family to be identified as possibly having a genetic disorder and who may receive genetic counseling or testing.
[4]
Defining "proband" - PMC
Defining "proband". M L Marazita. M L ... Articles from American Journal of Human Genetics are provided here courtesy of American Society of Human Genetics.
[5]
Cancer Genetics Risk Assessment and Counseling (PDQ®) - NCI
Jan 3, 2025 · Cancer genetics risk assessment and genetic counseling includes family history, psychosocial assessments, and education on hereditary cancer ...
[6]
PROBAND Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
Etymology. Latin probandus, gerundive of probare ; First Known Use. circa 1929, in the meaning defined above ; Time Traveler. The first known use of proband was ...
[7]
Glossary - Genetics for Surgeons - NCBI Bookshelf - NIH
Particularly relevant in the analysis of diseases associated with dynamic mutations. Proband (propositus) – index case. The first individual to present with a ...
[8]
Basic Principles of Genetics | Plastic Surgery Key
Sep 15, 2019 · ... affected or unaffected. The family is usually ascertained through one family member, the proband , around whom the pedigree is built with ...
[9]
Proband - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The term proband is one of several terms used to indicate the first member of a family who has contact with the doctor or researchers in a study. Sometimes the ...
[10]
Standardized pedigree nomenclature update centered on sex and ...
Sep 15, 2022 · Pedigree number (e.g., I-1, I-2, I-3), typically used in research or ... Exploring genetic counselors' use of pedigree symbols to represent ...
[11]
proband - Wiktionary, the free dictionary
Etymology. From international scientific vocabulary, from New Latin, from ... (genetics, genealogy) proband (subject of a genealogical study). Synonym ...
[12]
Wilhelm Weinberg's Early Contribution to Segregation Analysis - PMC
The affected child is referred to as a proband or propositus. This term, introduced by Weinberg, became ubiquitous in subsequent ascertainment studies. The most ...
[13]
Race biology | Hereditas | Full Text - BioMed Central
Nov 25, 2020 · Lundborg had consulted the eminent human geneticist Wilhelm Weinberg in selecting a proper proband method [53]. Lundborg had another paper in ...
[14]
STATISTICAL STUDIES OF PROBANDS AND THEIR RELATIVES
The term proband refers to an affected person who at any time was ... rooted in the history of genetics: (1) Theoretical or practical. Steinberg ...
[15]
Glosario parlante de términos genómicos y genéticos
Probando. Un probando es una persona que está afectada por una afección genética o que se considera que está en riesgo de tenerla. Habitualmente, el probando ...
[16]
[PDF] Standardized Human Pedigree Nomenclature - Amazon S3
Consultand. Individual(s) seeking genetic counseling/ testing. 7. Proband. An affected family member coming to medical attention independent of other family ...<|separator|>
[17]
How to Draw a Pedigree - Iowa Institute of Human Genetics
First name or initials of relatives (To maintain confidentiality do NOT use full names; alternatively, use generation-individual numbers (I-1, I-2, II-1).
[18]
Pedigree and Family History Taking - Understanding Genetics - NCBI
In addition, a family history can even help to exclude genetic diseases, particularly for common diseases in which lifestyle and environment play strong roles.Missing: proband criteria
[19]
4.2 Symbols used in Pedigree Charts - Introduction to Genetics
The affected individual that brings the family to the attention of a geneticist is called the proband (or propositus). If the individual is unaffected, they ...
[20]
Taking and Drawing a Family History - OSCE Guide - Geeky Medics
Nov 1, 2024 · Step 1. Start with the patient (the proband). · Step 2. Move through the family, generation by generation (e.g. the patient's partner and their ...
[21]
Family History: The Three-Generation Pedigree | AAFP
Aug 1, 2005 · The three-generation pedigree provides a pictorial representation of diseases within a family and is the most efficient way to assess hereditary influences on ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
[22]
Ethical and Methodological Issues in Pedigree Stroke Research - PMC
Proband-derived pedigree Identification of families with clustering of any disease depends on the ability of probands to recognize and report the occurrence of ...
[23]
Chapter 10: Pedigrees – Introductory Biology I
Symbols used in drawing a pedigree. (Credit). The affected individual that brings the family to the attention of a geneticist is called the proband. If an ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
[24]
Mode of Inheritance | Oncology Nursing Society
Each mode of inheritance results in a characteristic pattern of affected and unaffected family members. ... Proband. A proband is an individual being ...
[25]
The Value of Parental Testing by Next-Generation Sequencing ...
When a potential disease-causing variant is detected in a proband, parental testing is used to determine the mode of inheritance.
[26]
https://www.cell.com/ajhg/fulltext/S0002-9297(25)00010-2
[27]
Bayesian Analysis and Risk Assessment in Genetic Counseling and ...
In genetic testing, Bayesian analysis is commonly used to calculate genetic risks in complex pedigrees, and to calculate the probability of having or lacking a ...
[28]
Bayesian analysis for cystic fibrosis risks in prenatal and carrier ...
We provide methods for genetic risk calculations for scenarios in which the proband or another family member has been tested using a different mutation panel ...
[29]
Identification and in silico structural analysis for the first de novo ...
Jun 21, 2024 · A child can develop Cystic Fibrosis (CF) if both parents pass on mutated genes. In some rare cases, new genetic mutations occur spontaneously, ...
[30]
[PDF] Contact Investigations for Tuberculosis - CDC
index case— the initial TB case that prompts a contact investigation ... The goals of a contact investigation are to successfully stop TB transmission and prevent ...
[31]
Definition of proband - NCI Dictionary of Genetics Terms
(PROH-band) The first individual in a family to be identified as possibly having a genetic disorder or condition.Missing: reliable | Show results with:reliable
[32]
The household contact study design for genetic epidemiological ...
In sum, the essence of an HHC design is the recruitment of an entire household through an index case/proband, and collection of extensive clinical and ...
[33]
Examination of Huntington's disease in a Chinese family
The proband in our study suffered from confusion, unresponsiveness, and memory loss. The worsening symptoms suggested progressive cerebral cortex atrophy ...
[34]
An outbreak of pulmonary tuberculosis and a follow-up investigation ...
Feb 24, 2021 · Between October 2016 and July 2019, we identified 52 cases, including nine probable, six confirmed, and 37 LTBI cases. The index case-student ...
[35]
Definition of consultand - NCI Dictionary of Genetics Terms
An individual who presents for genetic counseling. Search NCI's Dictionary of Genetics Terms. Starts with. Contains. Browse:.
[36]
Issues in Genetic Counseling - Assessing Genetic Risks - NCBI - NIH
The genetic counselor does not typically confirm that the proband has informed relevant family members due to limits on time, access, and legal requirements ...
[37]
On the Inheritance and Primary Origin of Dementia Praecox - PMC
Oct 19, 2022 · Weinberg's proband method states that to obtain the correct risk figures, if more than one affected sibling per family is ascertained, the ...
[38]
Rüdin's 1916 Monograph: On the Inheritance and Primary Origin of ...
Oct 19, 2022 · ... proband method,” by means of which especially the lack of dementia praecox-free sibling series from which the psychiatrist suffers is corrected2 ...
[39]
Ernst Rüdin's Unpublished 1922-1925 Study “Inheritance of Manic ...
Nov 6, 2015 · Rüdin applied this methodology for the first time at The German Research Institute of Psychiatry (Deutsche Forschungsanstalt für Psychiatrie, ...
[40]
Human Heredity - Erwin Baur, Eugen Fischer, Fritz Lenz
Bibliographic information ; Authors, Erwin Baur, Eugen Fischer, Fritz Lenz ; Translated by, Eden Paul, Cedar Paul ; Edition, 3 ; Publisher, Macmillan, 1931.
[41]
The place of Franz Kallmann's 1938 “the genetics of schizophrenia ...
Jan 13, 2022 · This essay provides the historical context and key findings of one of the largest fieldwork-based family studies ever done in the history of psychiatric ...Missing: 1930s | Show results with:1930s
[42]
4 - Annihilating Defective Genes: Mendelian Consciousness and the ...
Feb 3, 2020 · ... proband”; but since the symptoms gave the clear impression of ... Fritz Lenz estimated in 1931 that of the entire 65 million German ...