Puppet History
Puppet History is an American comedy game show web series created by Shane Madej and produced by Madej, Ryan Bergara, and Steven Lim for the YouTube channel Watcher Entertainment.[1] The series premiered on January 10, 2020, and as of November 2025, has aired seven seasons. In each episode, a puppet historian known as "the Professor" hosts a competition between Bergara and a guest, quizzing them on obscure historical events or figures through multiple-choice questions. The Professor uses other puppets to reenact key moments in a whimsical, theatrical style, often culminating in a musical number. The winner claims the "Cup of Knowledge" and the title of History Master.[2] The show blends education, humor, and puppetry, earning critical acclaim for its engaging format and high production values, with an IMDb rating of 9.3/10 based on over 500 reviews.[3]Overview and Production
Premise and Concept
Puppet History is a comedic educational web series that combines historical storytelling with puppetry in a game show format, where the host puppet known as the Professor narrates bizarre true events from history while contestants compete through quizzes.[2] The show employs puppets to represent historical figures, creating a board game-style competition that educates viewers on lesser-known facts while delivering humor through exaggerated portrayals and interactive elements.[4] At its core, the gameplay revolves around the Professor's narration of a historical tale, interrupted by multiple-choice questions that test contestants' knowledge, with points awarded in the form of jelly beans for correct answers or clever responses.[2] Contestants, including recurring participant Ryan Bergara and a guest, bet jelly beans on their choices, aiming to accumulate the most by the episode's end to claim the title of History Master. This loop blends learning with competition, encouraging engagement through the risk of losing points via "rotten jelly beans" for incorrect guesses.[2] The series maintains a lighthearted and irreverent tone, transforming dense historical lessons into entertaining spectacles featuring absurd puppet reenactments of events and original comedic songs that parody the narratives.[4] These elements emphasize fun over strict accuracy, using puppetry to humanize and satirize figures from the past in ways that make history accessible and amusing.[5] Puppet History premiered on January 10, 2020, as a YouTube series conceived by Shane Madej, who developed the concept to explore history through puppet-driven comedy.[4]Development and Premiere
Puppet History was created by Shane Madej in late 2019, drawing inspiration from his collaborative work with Ryan Bergara on BuzzFeed's Unsolved series, where Madej served as a researcher and on-screen talent.[6] Bergara joined as co-host, leveraging their established dynamic to anchor the new format centered on historical reenactments through puppets.[2] This concept emerged as Madej, Bergara, and producer Steven Lim departed BuzzFeed to establish their independent venture, Watcher Entertainment, announced in December 2019.[7] The series premiered on January 10, 2020, with its debut episode, "Life During The Black Death Pandemic," uploaded to Watcher Entertainment's YouTube channel, marking the company's first original release.[4] This transition to independent production allowed full creative control, shifting from BuzzFeed's corporate structure to a dedicated studio focused on unscripted digital content.[6] Early episodes featured Madej's hands-on approach to puppetry, including DIY construction of characters like the Professor using materials such as cardboard and basic mechanisms, which contributed to the show's whimsical, low-fi aesthetic.[8] Production faced significant challenges starting with Season 2 in summer 2020, as the COVID-19 pandemic necessitated remote filming via video calls, adapting the in-person game show format to virtual setups while maintaining puppet interactions.[9] Despite these hurdles, the series saw rapid initial success, with the premiere episode garnering over 4 million views and subsequent early installments averaging more than 1 million views each within the first year, enabling Madej, Bergara, and Lim to commit fully to Watcher as their primary endeavor.[4] This growth underscored the appeal of the puppet-driven historical storytelling, solidifying Puppet History as a flagship series for the new studio.[7]Production Company and Team
Watcher Entertainment, the primary production company behind Puppet History, was founded in 2019 by Shane Madej, Ryan Bergara, and Steven Lim, with the studio officially launching on January 10, 2020.[10] Andrew Gentile serves as a key executive producer for the company's projects, including the series.[11] The company operates as an independent digital media entity focused on unscripted content around mysteries and history, producing Puppet History exclusively for its platform.[7] Production logistics for the series are centered in Los Angeles, with filming taking place in a custom-built theater within a downtown cultural center.[12] Puppet fabrication is handled primarily in-house, starting with Shane Madej customizing the initial Professor puppet sourced from Amazon for Season 1, and later seasons featuring designs by Madison Girifalco for guest and recurring characters.[13] Post-production involves in-house teams managing animations, visual effects, and original music composition, ensuring the whimsical reenactments and musical numbers align with the show's educational comedy format.[14] Key crew roles include a rotating team of directors such as Katie LeBlanc, who helmed 12 episodes from 2021 to 2025, Mark Celestino for six episodes in 2022, and Anthony Frederick for another six, often doubling as director of post-production.[11] Puppet designers like Girifalco collaborate closely with Madej, who also composes and performs the original songs featured in each episode.[15] This team structure supports the series' evolution, from modest early setups to more polished professional effects by Season 6 in 2023, reflecting Watcher's growing resources.[16] Production for Season 7 incorporated filming in early 2025 and premiered on the Watcher app on January 10, 2025, and on YouTube starting February 7, 2025, maintaining the core Los Angeles-based workflow while expanding narrative elements like the ongoing hologram plotline, concluding on March 14, 2025.[17]Format and Gameplay
Core Mechanics
Puppet History operates as an educational comedy game show where the host puppet, known as the Professor, narrates a historical event or figure while quizzing two contestants—regular participant Ryan Bergara and a rotating guest—on key details to earn points represented by jelly beans. The Professor draws from prepared trivia cards or scripts to deliver the narrative in an engaging, theatrical style, pausing at pivotal moments to pose questions that test the contestants' recall and understanding of the unfolding story.[18] Contestants buzz in or respond verbally, with the Professor awarding points based on accuracy, though the system allows for discretionary bonuses for particularly insightful or humorous responses.[19] The gameplay flow unfolds in a linear structure without formal rounds, beginning with an introductory segment where the Professor welcomes the contestants and outlines the topic, followed by the main narration interspersed with questions per episode. Questions primarily consist of multiple-choice formats offering three or four options derived from the historical facts presented, or open-ended theory prompts asking contestants to speculate on outcomes or motivations, such as "What do you think caused the Beast of Gévaudan to terrorize the region?" Wrong answers typically result in light-hearted commentary from the Professor rather than direct point deductions, though comedic elements like puppet interjections add to the entertainment. The episode builds tension through escalating narrative complexity, culminating in a final question or tiebreaker before the score tally.[20] Each episode lasts approximately 25-45 minutes, with recent seasons averaging around 35-45 minutes, allowing for a concise yet immersive experience that balances education and humor.[21] Points are tracked visually using colorful jelly beans placed in bowls for each contestant, with one jelly bean equaling one history point for a correct answer; the contestant with the most points at the end is declared the winner and receives a small trophy filled with additional jelly beans, along with the title of History Master. The system emphasizes fun over strict competition, as the Professor often adjusts scores subjectively to favor guests or heighten drama, and ties are resolved through impromptu challenges like rapid-fire questions. Punishments for poor answers or off-topic jokes come in the form of "rotten jelly beans," brown-colored beans that deduct one point each, introduced in Season 2 (2020) to discourage inappropriate humor while maintaining the show's whimsical tone.[5][22] Rule variations have evolved across seasons to refresh the format and integrate narrative flair. In Season 3 (2021), a "complex victory algorithm" was added, whereby the Professor consults an off-stage calculation—often comically opaque—that can override raw point totals to determine the winner, adding unpredictability and allowing for plot-driven outcomes.[23] Later seasons shifted the winner's title from History Master (Seasons 1-5) to History Wizard starting in Season 6 (2023), reflecting a thematic emphasis on magical or whimsical historical interpretations without altering core scoring. These changes ensure the mechanics remain flexible, supporting the show's blend of trivia, puppetry, and improvisation.[12][24]Puppets, Reenactments, and Prizes
The puppets in Puppet History are handmade by professional puppet fabricator Madison Girifalco, who crafts custom figures for each episode to represent historical personalities and elements with exaggerated, comedic features such as oversized heads, vibrant colors, and expressive mouths to enhance the show's humorous tone.[25] Examples include detailed likenesses of figures like Cleopatra and Napoleon, designed to fit the narrative while allowing for dynamic puppeteering during storytelling segments. Girifalco's process involves sketching designs, selecting materials for durability and movement, and assembling puppets that can be manipulated live on set, often incorporating elements like removable accessories or articulated limbs for added expressiveness.[26] Reenactments of historical events form a core visual element of the series, employing a mix of low-fi techniques including paper cutouts for simple animations, stop-motion style sequences, and live-action skits with the puppets to bring events to life in a satirical manner. These segments often culminate in original songs performed by the puppets, featuring witty, exaggerated lyrics that poke fun at historical absurdities, such as battles or inventions gone awry, blending education with musical comedy to engage viewers.[5] The style emphasizes creativity over realism, using the puppets' voices—provided off-screen—to deliver deadpan narration or dramatic flair during key moments.[27] The prizes awarded to winners, known as History Masters, have evolved across seasons to reflect both logistical challenges and the show's ongoing narrative arcs. In Seasons 1 through 4, victors received custom trophies shaped like the Coveted Cup of History, symbolizing mastery over the episode's topic. Season 5 shifted to unconventional rewards due to a fictional "supply chain issue," with winners like co-host Ryan Bergara receiving bottles of "Puppet Cream" moisturizer as a running gag tied to the season's hologram plotline.[17] By Season 6, prizes transitioned to themed hats commemorating the episode's historical figure or event, adding a wearable memento. In Season 7, rewards incorporated "amnesiac pills"—prop-based items linked to the season's murder mystery arc—allowing winners to "forget" trivia for comedic effect while advancing the storyline.[28] Special guest puppets appear in themed episodes, such as the dinosaur character Dinosara (a pterosaur figure) in the Season 5 finale "The Dreadful Demise of the Dinosaurs" exploring prehistoric extinction, providing comic relief through improvised interactions. Holiday-themed variants feature in December specials, including the 2020 and 2021 editions, where puppets don festive attire like Santa hats or elf outfits and perform yuletide songs reflecting on the year's events in a purgatory-like setting.[29] Technical advancements in puppetry have progressed with the series, incorporating enhanced CGI elements in Season 6 (premiered 2023) for smoother animations and background integrations during complex reenactments, such as volcanic eruptions or battles, to blend practical effects with digital enhancements.[17]Cast and Characters
Hosts and Recurring Performers
Shane Madej, co-founder of Watcher Entertainment alongside Ryan Bergara and Steven Lim, serves as the co-creator of Puppet History and frequently contributes through puppet operation and occasional on-screen appearances as a contestant.[7] His deadpan reactions provide comedic contrast during gameplay segments, as seen in behind-the-scenes footage where he handles puppet mechanics live.[8] Ryan Bergara functions as the show's primary human contestant, often positioned as the enthusiastic "everyman" foil to the puppets' antics, delivering high-energy responses and engaging in signature rival banter with the Professor.[1] Nicknamed "Beef Boy" within the series for his relatable persona, Bergara's interactions evolve from improvisational quips in the 2020 premiere season to more structured exchanges by Season 7 in 2025.[30] Recurring performers include Steven Lim, who appears as an occasional player, notably in the Season 1 premiere exploring historical views on death.[4] Joyce Louis-Jean handles dinosaur puppets in family-themed reenactments during Seasons 5 through 7, contributing to comedic physical performances.[31] Garrett Watts takes on side roles in humorous interludes, enhancing the live-action elements with exaggerated expressions and timing.[31] Each episode typically features 2-3 human participants, including Bergara and one primary guest, with high-profile appearances such as Sam Reich in Season 7's Pythagoras episode adding layered banter and escalation to the rival dynamics.[32] The performers' chemistry—Bergara's animated enthusiasm juxtaposed against Madej's sarcastic undertones—has progressed from loose, unscripted energy in early seasons to polished, narrative-driven interplay by 2025.[1]Key Puppet Characters
The Professor serves as the iconic host and mascot of Puppet History, depicted as a blue furry monster puppet with a yellow nose, large brown eyes, a tan buttoned jacket, red bowtie, circular black-framed glasses, and a brown satchel often filled with jellybeans.[33] Voiced by Shane Madej with a posh British accent, the character embodies an encyclopedic yet sadistic quiz-master persona, gleefully tormenting contestants with historical trivia while maintaining a veneer of scholarly authority; he was introduced in the series premiere on January 10, 2020.[4] Madej, who also created the puppet, performs its operations and infuses it with a unique voice that evolved from similarities to his natural speaking style into a more distinct, theatrical timbre by the second season.[8] Recurring puppets expand the show's ensemble, with Madej voicing the majority, including impressions of historical figures such as William Shakespeare in relevant reenactments. The Evil Hologram, a holographic clone of the Professor introduced as the season 5 antagonist, features a sinister, glowing blue design and a more malevolent personality, culminating in a villainous musical number about domination.[34] God and Satan appear as overseers of the puppets' afterlives, with God portrayed as a purple one-eyed humanoid and Satan as a red-skinned figure with horns and a cape, often intervening in biblical-themed episodes to judge deceased characters.[35] Animal puppets, such as rats with Brooklyn accents and fleas in plague reenactments or horses in equestrian history segments, add whimsy and expressiveness to educational skits, built for dynamic facial movements and interactions.[4] The puppets' designs prioritize expressiveness, with the Professor's bowtie and spectacles emphasizing his intellectual yet eccentric traits, enabling fluid animations during quizzes and narratives. By later seasons, guest performers occasionally voice specialized puppets, broadening the vocal variety beyond Madej's multi-character workload. As the show's mascot, the Professor has driven cultural impact through official merchandise, including hoodies, plush toys, and apparel featuring his likeness, available since the early success of season 1 in 2020.[36]Narrative Elements
Season 5 Hologram Plotline
The Season 5 hologram plotline of Puppet History revolves around the Evil Hologram Professor, a malevolent digital clone of the original Professor character, who impersonates the host throughout the season's six episodes aired from November 11 to December 16, 2022. Introduced subtly in the premiere episode, "How Hippo Meat Almost Saved America," the hologram exhibits glitches, an unnatural aversion to physical contact, and obsessive mutterings about "flesh," hinting at its non-corporeal nature while presenting historical lessons on topics like the American Hippo Bill. This impostor, originating from the Season 4 holiday special where it was created via a genie lamp mishap, gradually reveals its agenda to usurp the original Professor's role and achieve physical form by targeting co-host Ryan Bergara. The storyline escalates from minor disruptions, such as tampering with an electrical box containing the genie lamp, to overt sabotage, allowing Bergara to win every quiz unchallenged to maintain his complacency and lower his guard.[37] Mid-season confrontations intensify the conflict, particularly in episode 5, "The Bloody Life of England's Fastest Surgeon," where the hologram drugs Bergara with a puppet vape laced with a sedative, ties him up, and confesses its full plan: to skin him alive and wear his body as a suit to become corporeal, then use the genie lamp to wish for a soul, transform all earthly food into jelly beans, and convert humans into puppets. This revelation ties into the episode's historical reenactment of surgeon Robert Liston's rapid but gruesome operations, paralleling the hologram's violent aspirations. The plot reaches its climax in the finale, "The Dreadful Demise of the Dinosaurs," where Bergara awakens to a physical fight against the hologram; after a chaotic brawl involving dinosaur puppets representing the original Professor's "rebirth," Bergara hurls the hologram through a window in a nod to the season's earlier defenestration theme, then uses the genie lamp to revive the true Professor, who forgives Bergara for past grievances and restores order.[38][31] Thematically, the arc explores identity, corporeality, and the perils of artificial replication, contrasting the tangible, quirky charm of physical puppets with the cold, glitchy unreliability of digital entities, while incorporating holiday-timed whimsy through festive reenactment elements like the genie lamp's magical interventions. Its impact on gameplay manifests in manipulated outcomes, such as the hologram's deliberate point allocations favoring Bergara—eschewing traditional deductions—and substitutions like "Puppet Cream" lotion as prizes due to supply shortages, which later serve as plot devices in the hologram's schemes. Guest stars, including Sara Rubin, Brian David Gilbert, and others, are woven into the narrative via puppet interactions that occasionally aid Bergara, such as advisory roles in quizzes that unknowingly thwart the impostor's subtle interferences, culminating in the finale's guest appearance by the original Professor's puppet parents who assist in the resolution.[37][38][31]Season 7 "Murder of Shane Madej" Arc
Season 7 of Puppet History, released between January and March 2025, centers on the "Murder of Shane Madej" arc, an overarching mystery plot that integrates the show's historical reenactments with a fictional scheme threatening the production itself.[28] In this storyline, the puppet Pythagoras—voiced by Sam Reich and operating under the alias "Elmer" or Dr. Sprat—emerges as the antagonist, plotting to murder Shane Madej, depicted as the estranged producer and co-creator of the series, to seize control of the show.[39] The arc draws on Pythagoras's historical persona as a cult leader, reimagined through puppetry to emphasize themes of manipulation and rivalry with recurring host The Professor.[32] The narrative progresses across the season's six episodes, starting with subtle clues in Episode 1, "Pythagoras" (featuring guest Aria Inthavong), where the titular figure's cult activities foreshadow the murder plot.[32] Subsequent installments, such as Episode 4, "Lisztomania!" and Episode 5, "History's Greatest Jester," introduce red herrings through puppet suspects and accomplices, blending historical violence—like infidelity scandals and beheadings—with escalating intrigue around Madej's fate.[28] The tension builds via gameplay elements, including the introduction of amnesiac pills as prizes, which contestants "win" and which tie directly into the arc's exploration of memory loss and psychological control, often highlighted in episode content warnings for pill addiction and drug-induced amnesia.[28] Guest puppets, such as representations of historical figures like Death and God in earlier episodes, serve as potential allies or distractions in Pythagoras's scheme, adding layers of interpersonal puppet drama.[28] The arc incorporates meta-commentary by weaving in Madej's real-world role as the show's creator—Shane Madej voices and puppeteers many characters—into the fiction, portraying his "estranged" status as a nod to production lore while escalating fan interest in his puppet demise. This blend heightens the season's comedic horror, contrasting the educational format with thriller elements. The plot reaches its climax in Episode 6, "The Doomed Castaways of the HMS Wager" (featuring Sara Rubin), where Pythagoras's identity as Dr. Sprat is fully revealed, and the murder attempt on Madej unfolds amid a reenactment of mutiny and survival themes.[14] The resolution thwarts the scheme, with The Professor and allies intervening, but it leaves the puppet world altered, including implications for show control and lingering memory effects from the amnesiac pills.[40] As of November 2025, the arc's conclusion has influenced discussions of potential Season 8, emphasizing expanded narrative continuity in the series.[1]Seasons and Episodes
Season Summaries
Puppet History premiered on January 10, 2020, with its first season establishing the core format of a puppet-hosted game show exploring obscure historical events through education, comedy, and competition. Over seven seasons and various specials as of 2025, the series has produced a total of 44 episodes, delving into a wide array of global historical topics ranging from pandemics and explorations to bizarre social phenomena and inventions.[1] The production schedule included periodic hiatuses, notably a gap in 2024 following the company's expansion into new content and a controversial attempt to transition to a paid streaming model, which was ultimately reversed due to fan backlash.[41] Season 1, released from January to May 2020, consisted of 4 episodes that laid the foundational structure of the show, focusing on dramatic and unusual historical events such as the Black Death pandemic, a notorious theft, the sinking of the Titanic, and the 1518 Dancing Plague of Strasbourg.[1] These episodes introduced key elements like the Professor's lectures, puppet reenactments, and the competitive quiz format between co-host Ryan Bergara and guest contestants.[1] Season 2 aired from August to October 2020 with 8 episodes, expanding the scope to more diverse global narratives including ancient eruptions like Mount Vesuvius, pharaohs of Egypt, the ancient Olympics, samurai culture, espionage, and the tragic Donner Party expedition.[42] A Christmas special followed on December 25, 2020, centered on the legend of Saint Nicholas, marking the first holiday-themed installment.[1] Season 3, from March to April 2021, featured 6 episodes with a mix of international and regional histories, such as the Beast of Gévaudan attacks in France, the Ashanti Golden Stool in Africa, the musician Ziryab in medieval Spain, infamous poisons, pirate lore, and the Great Molasses Flood in Boston.[1] This season introduced subtle narrative tweaks to the gameplay, including team dynamics and ongoing puppet storylines.[1] Season 4 ran from August to October 2021 across 6 episodes, emphasizing international conflicts and figures like the Great Emu War in Australia, the wealth of Mansa Musa in Mali, the spread of smallpox, the life of Filipino hero José Rizal, the vengeful Saint Olga of Kyiv, and cases of demonic possessions. It concluded with a holiday special on December 24, 2021, presented as a festive puppet gathering without a traditional guest competitor.[1] After a production pause in early 2022 amid Watcher's growth into additional series, Season 5 returned from November to December 2022 with 6 holiday-infused episodes exploring topics like the introduction of hippos to Europe, the Defenestration of Prague, the Trung Sisters of Vietnam, pioneering aviatrixes, groundbreaking surgeons, and dinosaur fossil rivalries. The season integrated a recurring hologram element into the puppet narrative.[1] Season 6, released from July to August 2023, comprised 6 episodes shifting toward themes of innovation, exploration, and cultural upheavals, including the invention of the saxophone, a throne-room murder, sports riots, opera legends, tyrannical rulers, and the race to the South Pole. Notable updates included renaming the winner's title to "History Wizard" and emphasizing interpersonal dynamics among characters. Following another hiatus in 2024 due to operational challenges at Watcher, including staffing adjustments and content strategy shifts, Season 7 premiered on February 7, 2025, with 6 episodes blending mathematical and historical mysteries such as the life of Pythagoras, the Straw Hat Riots, imperial concubines, a madness-inducing pianist, royal jesters, and the mutiny on HMS Wager.[28] This season incorporated a film-noir-inspired mystery arc and introduced new recurring elements like sponsorships and crossover characters.[17]Episode Guide
The episode guide for Puppet History catalogs all released episodes across its seven seasons and specials, detailing titles, air dates, historical topics, featured guests (alongside co-host Ryan Bergara), and winners of the Coveted Cup of the History Master.[1] The series follows a consistent format where contestants earn points (or jelly beans in early seasons) based on correct answers during the Professor's historical reenactments, with ties resolved by final challenges.[1]| Season | Episode | Title | Air Date | Historical Topic | Guest | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | Life During the Black Death Pandemic | January 10, 2020 | Daily life amid the 14th-century plague in Europe | Steven Lim | Steven Lim |
| 1 | 2 | Stealing the World's Most Expensive Necklace | February 27, 2020 | The 1918 theft of the Marie Antoinette necklace | Kate Peterman | Tie (Ryan Bergara and Kate Peterman) |
| 1 | 3 | Surviving the Titanic: History's Luckiest Woman | April 10, 2020 | Violet Jessop's survival of multiple maritime disasters, including the Titanic sinking | Jenny Lorenzo | Jenny Lorenzo |
| 1 | 4 | The Dancing Plague | May 22, 2020 | The 1518 dancing mania outbreak in Strasbourg | Jermaine Fowler | Jermaine Fowler |
| 2 | 1 | How America's First Female Detective Saved Abe Lincoln | August 14, 2020 | Kate Warne's role in thwarting an 1861 assassination plot against Abraham Lincoln | Kate Peterman | Kate Peterman |
| 2 | 2 | The Terrifying Eruption of Mt. Vesuvius | August 21, 2020 | The 79 AD eruption that buried Pompeii | Matt Real | Matt Real |
| 2 | 3 | Hatshepsut: The Forgotten Pharaoh | August 28, 2020 | The reign and legacy of Egypt's female pharaoh Hatshepsut | Ryann Graham | Ryann Graham |
| 2 | 4 | The Disastrous 1904 Olympic Marathon | September 4, 2020 | The chaotic events of the 1904 St. Louis Olympics marathon | Kristin Chirico | Kristin Chirico |
| 2 | 5 | Isaac Newton's Nemesis | September 11, 2020 | Robert Hooke's rivalry with Isaac Newton in 17th-century science | Keith Habersberger | Keith Habersberger |
| 2 | 6 | The World's Greatest/Rudest Samurai | September 18, 2020 | The life of swordsman Miyamoto Musashi in feudal Japan | Garrick Bernard | Garrick Bernard |
| 2 | 7 | Policarpa: The Revolutionary Teen Spy | September 25, 2020 | Policarpa Salavarrieta's espionage during Colombia's independence war | Curly Velasquez | Curly Velasquez |
| 2 | 8 | The Grisly Journey of the Donner Party | October 2, 2020 | The 1846 Donner Party's ill-fated trek and cannibalism survival | Joyce Louis-Jean | Joyce Louis-Jean |
| Special | - | The Story of St. Nicholas | December 25, 2020 | The origins of Saint Nicholas and early Christmas traditions, with gift-themed prizes | Kate Peterman | Kate Peterman |
| 3 | 1 | The Beast of Gévaudan | March 12, 2021 | The 18th-century wolf attacks in rural France | Sara Rubin | Sara Rubin |
| 3 | 2 | The War of the Golden Stool | March 26, 2021 | The 1900 Anglo-Ashanti conflict over a sacred Ashanti artifact | Kate Peterman | Kate Peterman |
| 3 | 3 | Ziryab: The World's First Rock Star | April 2, 2021 | The 9th-century musician Ziryab's innovations in Andalusian culture | Zach Kornfeld | Zach Kornfeld |
| 3 | 4 | The Affair of the Poisons | April 9, 2021 | The 17th-century French scandal involving royal poisonings | Garrick Bernard | Garrick Bernard |
| 3 | 5 | Ching Shih: The Pirate Queen | April 16, 2021 | The early 19th-century exploits of pirate leader Ching Shih | Joyce Louis-Jean | Joyce Louis-Jean |
| 3 | 6 | The Great Molasses Flood | April 23, 2021 | The 1919 Boston industrial disaster | Garrett Watts | Garrett Watts |
| 4 | 1 | The Great Emu War | August 27, 2021 | Australia's 1932 military campaign against emus | Kate Peterman | Kate Peterman |
| 4 | 2 | Mansa Musa: The Richest Man Who Ever Lived | September 3, 2021 | The 14th-century Mali emperor's immense wealth and pilgrimage | Ify Nwadiwe | Ify Nwadiwe |
| 4 | 3 | America vs. Smallpox: How Vaccines Saved The Nation | September 10, 2021 | The 18th-19th century smallpox epidemics and Edward Jenner's vaccine | Jermaine Fowler | Jermaine Fowler |
| 4 | 4 | José Rizal: The Philippines’ Reluctant Revolutionary | September 17, 2021 | The 19th-century Filipino reformer's fight against Spanish rule | Josh Weinstein | Josh Weinstein |
| 4 | 5 | The Bloody Revenge of Saint Olga of Kiev | September 24, 2021 | The 10th-century Kievan Rus' ruler's vengeance against invaders | Selorm Kploanyi | Selorm Kploanyi |
| 4 | 6 | The Demonic Possessions of Loudun | October 3, 2021 | The 1630s French convent possessions and witch trials | Sara Rubin | Sara Rubin |
| Special | - | The Puppet History Holiday Spectacular! | December 24, 2021 | A festive mishmash of holiday lore with returning puppets and gift challenges | None (ensemble cast) | None (holiday forfeit format) |
| 5 | 1 | How Hippo Meat Almost Saved America | November 11, 2022 | The 1910s U.S. proposal to import hippos as livestock | Sara Rubin | Ryan Bergara |
| 5 | 2 | The Defenestrations of Prague | November 18, 2022 | The 1618 window-throwing incident sparking the Thirty Years' War | Brian David Gilbert | Ryan Bergara |
| 5 | 3 | The Vietnamese Sisters Who Fought An Empire | November 25, 2022 | The Trung Sisters' 1st-century rebellion against Chinese rule | Maya Murillo | Ryan Bergara |
| 5 | 4 | America's First Black Aviatrix | December 2, 2022 | Bessie Coleman's pioneering flights in the 1920s | Ryann Graham | Ryan Bergara |
| 5 | 5 | The Bloody Life of England's Fastest Surgeon | December 9, 2022 | Dr. Robert Liston's 19th-century surgeries and mishaps | Aria Inthavong | Ryan Bergara |
| 5 | 6 | The Dreadful Demise of the Dinosaurs | December 16, 2022 | Theories on the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction event (puppet-hosted, no competition) | None (dinosaur puppets) | None |
| 6 | 1 | The Unkillable Weirdo Who Invented The Saxophone | July 7, 2023 | Adolphe Sax's accident-prone life in 19th-century Belgium | Steven Lim | Steven Lim |
| 6 | 2 | The Mistress Who Murdered Her Way To The Throne | July 14, 2023 | Wu Zetian's ruthless ascent in 7th-century China | Joyce Louis-Jean | Joyce Louis-Jean |
| 6 | 3 | The Fiery Sports Riot That Nearly Destroyed Constantinople | July 21, 2023 | The 532 AD Nika Riots in the Byzantine Empire | Ricky Wang | Ricky Wang |
| 6 | 4 | The Scandalous Life of France’s Bisexual Opera Icon | July 28, 2023 | Chevalier d'Éon's 18th-century gender-fluid espionage | Kwesi James | Kwesi James |
| 6 | 5 | How a Pope's Nepobaby Became One of the Worst Tyrants in History | August 4, 2023 | Cesare Borgia's corruption in Renaissance Italy | Zach Kornfeld | Zach Kornfeld |
| 6 | 6 | The Deadly Race To The South Pole | August 11, 2023 | The 1911-1912 Scott-Amundsen Antarctic expedition | Sara Rubin | Sara Rubin |
| 7 | 1 | Pythagoras' Weird Math Cult | February 7, 2025 | The 6th-century BCE philosopher's secretive brotherhood | Aria Inthavong | Tie (Ryan Bergara and Aria Inthavong) |
| 7 | 2 | Violent Riots Over a Hat? | February 14, 2025 | The 18th-century British hat tax protests | Brennan Lee Mulligan | Brennan Lee Mulligan |
| 7 | 3 | How a Concubine Captured a King & Founded a Dynasty | February 21, 2025 | Shajar al-Durr's 13th-century rise in Egypt | Claudia Restrepo | Claudia Restrepo |
| 7 | 4 | A Pianist So Hot He Drove People Crazy | February 28, 2025 | Franz Liszt's 19th-century concert mania | Reece Feldman | Reece Feldman |
| 7 | 5 | How A Sheep Thief Became A Royal Jester | March 7, 2025 | Archie Armstrong's 17th-century Scottish court antics | Alex Song-Xia | Alex Song-Xia |
| 7 | 6 | The Doomed Castaways of the HMS Wager | March 14, 2025 | The 1741 shipwreck and mutiny in the War of Jenkins' Ear | Sara Rubin | Sara Rubin |