Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Simon Robertson

Sir Simon Manwaring Robertson (born 1941) is a investment banker and corporate director renowned for his extensive career in merchant banking and leadership positions at major multinational corporations. He joined Group in 1963, advancing through various roles in , , and international advisory before serving as its chairman for over three decades. In 1997, Robertson became president of Europe and managing director of International, overseeing significant expansion in European operations. Following his tenure at , he established his own financial advisory firm and held non-executive directorships, including as chairman of plc from 2005 to 2013, where he guided the engineering giant through technological and market challenges. At Holdings plc, he served as senior independent from 2006 to 2016 and deputy chairman from 2010 to 2016, contributing to and oversight amid global financial scrutiny.

Early Life and Education

Family Background and Childhood

Sir Simon Manwaring Robertson was born on 4 March 1941 in . He was the eldest of three children of David Lars Manwaring Robertson CVO (1917–1999), who received the Commander of the Royal Victorian Order for services likely tied to the royal household, and Pamela Lauderdale Mahon (1918–2009). Details of Robertson's early childhood remain sparse in public records, reflecting the private nature of upper-class British families of the era. Born amid , he grew up in a milieu shaped by his father's court-related honors and the family's established social standing in , which positioned him for elite educational opportunities.

Formal Education

Robertson attended , a prestigious independent boarding school in , , where he completed his secondary education. No records indicate that Robertson pursued at a ; instead, upon leaving Eton, he entered professional training in international banking, beginning with stints at Banque de Neuflize, , in and Kredietbank in in 1961 and 1962, followed by Frères in . This early immersion in banking apprenticeships marked the start of his career in , reflecting a path common among some mid-20th-century British elites who prioritized practical experience over formal higher degrees.

Professional Career

Tenure at Kleinwort Benson

Simon Robertson joined in 1963, embarking on a 34-year career at the firm that spanned various roles across its major businesses, including merchant banking, , and international corporate advisory. His tenure coincided with significant challenges for the bank, particularly in the post-Big Bang era following the deregulation of London's financial markets, during which Kleinwort Benson faced difficulties adapting to increased competition. Despite these hurdles, Robertson rose through the ranks, leveraging his expertise in cross-border transactions and advisory services in markets including the , , , and the . A key aspect of his contributions involved advising the on major privatisations, such as the sector sell-offs in the early , which helped privatize state-owned utilities and marked a pivotal shift in Britain's toward market . By 1996, he had ascended to chairman of Group plc, overseeing the investment bank's operations during a period of strategic realignment amid merger discussions and market pressures. Robertson resigned from the group in 1997 to pursue opportunities at , departing at a time when was navigating ownership changes that would eventually lead to its acquisition by . His leadership emphasized resilience and deal-making prowess, though the bank's performance during his chairmanship reflected broader industry turbulence rather than isolated mismanagement.

Leadership at Goldman Sachs International

Simon Robertson joined in 1997 as a managing director and was appointed of Europe Ltd on September 1 of that year. In this capacity, he also served as a managing director of International, the firm's primary London-based entity for European operations. His role encompassed overseeing activities, including advisory, across the region, drawing on his prior experience as chairman of Limited. During his tenure, Robertson helped steer the expansion and development of ' European business, focusing on building client relationships and enhancing the firm's competitive position in cross-border deals. This period coincided with ' broader global growth, during which the firm solidified its presence in markets amid increasing and M&A activity. Robertson's leadership emphasized strategic advisory services, leveraging his reputation as one of London's influential bankers to attract high-profile mandates. Robertson retired from the partnership in 2003 but continued in his presidential role until August 2005, when he resigned to establish Simon Robertson Associates, an independent advisory boutique. His departure marked the end of a nearly eight-year leadership stint that positioned as a dominant player in European .

Founding and Operations of Simon Robertson Associates

Simon Robertson Associates LLP was established in August 2005 by Sir Simon Robertson following his departure from International, where he had served as president of the European operations. The firm operated as a incorporated earlier that year on 30 March 2005, with its registered office in . Headquartered in , it was structured as a advisory practice to provide personalized services without the scale of larger investment banks. The firm's core operations centered on delivering independent advice, specializing in , transaction structuring, and strategic financial counsel to a select group of major international clients. Unlike full-service banks, Simon Robertson Associates emphasized trusted, conflict-free guidance, leveraging Robertson's extensive network from prior roles in merchant banking and global finance to advise on high-value deals without broad market solicitation. This lean model allowed for focused engagement, typically limiting advisory mandates to a handful of corporations annually to maintain discretion and depth. In January 2013, the firm rebranded as Robertson Robey Associates LLP upon the addition of , former head of global M&A at , expanding its capacity for complex cross-border transactions while retaining its boutique ethos. This partnership briefly enhanced operations before a 2014 restructuring, after which Robertson resumed independent advisory under his original framework, underscoring the firm's adaptability to maintain specialized, high-level service amid evolving industry dynamics.

Board Directorships and Advisory Roles

Key Appointments at Major Corporations

Robertson served as Chairman of Rolls-Royce plc from January 2005 until February 2013, succeeding John Rose in leading the board of the aerospace and defense company. He joined the board of HSBC Holdings plc as a non-executive director on 28 July 2005 and held the position until 18 July 2017, during which he became Senior Independent Non-Executive Director in 2007 and Deputy Chairman effective 1 December 2010. At Evercore Inc., Robertson has served as a board member, receiving total compensation of $175,921 in 2021 for his independent director role. Earlier in his career, he acted as a non-executive director for Inchcape plc and Invensys plc, roles he held concurrently with his appointment to the Rolls-Royce board in 2004.

Role in Executive Remuneration at HSBC

Sir Simon Robertson served as chairman of HSBC Holdings plc's Group Remuneration Committee from May 2013 until March 2015. In this capacity, he oversaw the determination of policies, including performance-based incentives and long-term awards for , amid post-financial scrutiny of banker pay in the UK and globally. His appointment followed his long-standing role as a senior independent and deputy chairman at , positions he held since December 2010, providing continuity in governance oversight. During Robertson's tenure, HSBC's framework emphasized alignment with shareholder interests and , incorporating provisions and deferred bonuses tied to . However, in April 2015, at HSBC's , approximately 24% of shareholders voted against the bank's report and specific pay packages, prompting Robertson, as chairman, to defend the structures by highlighting their linkage to metrics and the bank's recovery efforts. This opposition reflected broader investor concerns over high variable pay in banking, though the proposals passed with majority support. Robertson stepped down as remuneration committee chairman effective after the 2015 AGM, succeeded by Sam Laidlaw, while remaining on the board as deputy chairman for an additional year to ensure transition stability. His nine-year board service by that point underscored his influence on 's compensation governance during a period of regulatory reforms, including rules capping bonuses at 100% of base salary for material risk-takers.

Recognition and Influence

Honors and Knighthood

In 2010, Robertson was appointed in the Queen's for services to . The honour recognized his extensive contributions to the financial sector, including leadership roles at institutions such as International and chairmanship of Rolls-Royce Group Plc. Robertson has also received French distinctions, including appointment as an Officier in the Ordre des Arts et des Lettres, acknowledging his engagements. He serves as president of the Légion d'Honneur U.K. Chapter Ltd., reflecting ongoing ties to Franco-British relations in commerce and culture.

Contributions to the Financial Sector

Sir Simon Robertson's contributions to the financial sector span over five decades of leadership in , particularly in (M&A) and corporate advisory, where he advanced European deal-making standards and facilitated cross-Atlantic banking integration. Beginning his career at in 1963, he ascended through various roles to become chairman of Dresdner Kleinwort Benson, earning recognition as one of Europe's premier advisors for his expertise in structuring high-stakes transactions. In 1997, Robertson joined as president of its European operations, a role focused on enhancing client relationships and driving the firm's continental growth amid increasing of capital markets. Under his leadership until 2005, expanded its influence in , adapting U.S.-style to local markets and supporting major cross-border deals that bolstered the sector's efficiency and scale. Following his departure from , Robertson established Simon Robertson Associates LLP in 2005, a advisory firm providing independent counsel on M&A and strategic to select multinational corporations. This venture emphasized high-integrity, client-centric advice, contrasting with larger banks' scale-driven models and contributing to a niche for specialized expertise amid post-financial crisis scrutiny of banking practices. The firm's selective approach has influenced by prioritizing long-term value over volume transactions.

Controversies and Criticisms

Debates on Banker Compensation

Simon Robertson served as chairman of HSBC's committee from approximately 2011 to 2015, during a period of heightened scrutiny over executive and banker pay at the bank. opposition peaked in multiple annual general meetings, with critics arguing that compensation packages failed to adequately align with performance amid post-financial crisis reforms and regulatory caps on bonuses. In May 2011, nearly one-fifth of voted against HSBC's , prompting calls to strengthen oversight under Robertson's . By 2014, investor discontent intensified, as evidenced by vocal protests at the AGM where Robertson defended the bank's pay structure, emphasizing its linkage to long-term and the need to retain talent in a competitive global market. He highlighted challenges from the European Union's bonus cap, implemented in , which limited variable pay to 100% of fixed salary (or 200% with approval), warning that such restrictions could hinder competitiveness without improving or . HSBC responded to pressure by capping the chairman's potential bonus at £1 million and adjusting awards, with Robertson noting these changes reflected input while preserving incentives for top performers. The 2015 AGM saw further revolt, with 24% of votes against the policy for chairman and CEO , forcing Robertson, then deputy chairman, to publicly defend the packages as necessary for global talent retention despite stagnant returns on equity (around 8-10% in prior years). Critics, including institutional investors, contended that multimillion-pound awards—such as Gulliver's £5.5 million total pay in 2014—exacerbated in banking, echoing broader post-2008 debates on whether high fixed pay circumvented deferral rules intended to curb excessive risk-taking. Robertson's tenure ended amid these tensions, with his replacement by Sam Laidlaw in 2015, amid ongoing calls for reforms tied to metrics like and capital efficiency rather than revenue growth alone. These episodes reflected systemic debates on banker compensation, where proponents like Robertson argued for market-driven pay to attract expertise, supported by evidence from peer banks like JPMorgan and maintaining similar structures to avoid talent flight to less-regulated hubs. Opponents, drawing on empirical data from the UK's , pointed to correlations between high incentives and misconduct fines ( paid over $1.9 billion in U.S. penalties in 2012), advocating clawbacks and provisions—features Robertson's committee incorporated but which shareholders deemed insufficiently punitive. No evidence emerged of personal impropriety by Robertson, but his defenses underscored a divide between and industry norms favoring substantial pay to sustain profitability in volatile sectors.

Industry-Wide Banking Critiques Applied to Career

Robertson's extensive career in , spanning over four decades at firms like and , exemplifies industry critiques regarding the prioritization of short-term deal-making over long-term economic stability. During his chairmanship of from 1996, the firm grappled with profitability challenges in the post-Big Bang regulatory environment, where intensified competition and exposed vulnerabilities in the traditional merchant banking model reliant on advisory fees from . Critics of the sector argue that such models incentivize volume over value, fostering leveraged buyouts and restructurings that burden companies with debt, as evidenced by broader empirical data on post-1980s M&A outcomes showing frequent underperformance relative to standalone growth. At , where Robertson served as president of the European division from 1997 to 2005, the firm's expansion into complex structured products and drew retrospective scrutiny for amplifying systemic risks through interconnected leverage across global markets. Although Robertson departed before the , industry analyses highlight how European operations under such leadership contributed to the diffusion of high-risk practices, with Goldman's overall model implicated in packaging and distributing subprime exposures that exacerbated the downturn, leading to taxpayer-backed interventions estimated at trillions globally. This aligns with causal critiques positing that fee-driven advisory cultures, prevalent in Robertson's era, systematically undervalue downside risks in pursuit of immediate revenue, as quantified in post-crisis studies of investment bank balance sheets showing correlations between compensation incentives and crisis-era losses. In his board and advisory roles, including as chairman of HSBC's committee from 2013, Robertson's oversight of executive pay amid regulatory fines—such as HSBC's $1.9 billion for anti-money laundering failures in 2012—has fueled arguments that banking elites perpetuate misaligned incentives. Approvals like CEO Stuart Gulliver's £1.8 million in 2013, part of a £7 million package, occurred against a backdrop of public and analytical contention that post-crisis pay structures failed to internalize costs of lapses and moral hazards, with data from disclosures indicating persistent multimillion-pound awards despite shareholder dilution from fines and provisions. Such practices, critics maintain, reflect a sector-wide insulation from accountability, where senior figures like Robertson bridge advisory boutiques and corporate boards, potentially prioritizing network-driven transactions over rigorous .

References

  1. [1]
    Sir Simon Robertson | Artist | Royal Academy of Arts
    Sir Simon Robertson (b. 1941). RA Collection: People and Organisations. Profile. Born: 1941. Honorary officer ...
  2. [2]
    Sir Simon Robertson - Board Member - Evercore Inc.
    He has served on the boards of numerous public and private entities in the past, including as chairman of Rolls-Royce Holdings plc (2005-2013), on the board ...
  3. [3]
    Meet the Rich List banker overseeing pay at HSBC
    From 2004, he sat on the board of British car maker and engineering firm Rolls-Royce, where he was appointed chairman in January 2005. Robertson advised the ...
  4. [4]
    Simon Robertson - Powerbase.info
    Oct 19, 2017 · Sir Simon Robertson is the deputy chairman of HSBC. He is also a former Goldman Sachs Europe president and managing director of Goldman Sachs International.
  5. [5]
    Sir Simon Robertson | Futures For All - Speakers for Schools
    His previous roles include: Chairman of Rolls-Royce Holdings plc, Deputy Chairman & Senior Independent non-executive Director of HSBC Holdings plc, non ...
  6. [6]
    Rolls-Royce chairman Sir Simon Robertson to step down
    Feb 14, 2013 · Rolls-Royce is expected to say on Thursday that Sir Simon Robertson will step down as chairman of the aircraft engine maker after eight years on ...<|separator|>
  7. [7]
    Sir Simon Manwaring Robertson - London Remembers
    Simon Manwaring Robertson was born on 4 March 1941, the eldest of the three children of David Lars Manwaring Robertson CVO (1917-1999) and Pamela Lauderdale ...Missing: background childhood life
  8. [8]
    DEF 14A - SEC.gov
    Before joining Goldman Sachs, Sir Simon served various roles at the Kleinwort Benson Group. He joined the Kleinwort Benson Group in 1963, working in most of ...<|separator|>
  9. [9]
    Simon Robertson, Former chairman, Dresdner Kleinwort Benson
    Apr 1, 1997 · According to inside sources, Robertson's glittering 34-year career ended in less than an hour. Whither Robertson now? Will he accept a ...
  10. [10]
    The deal-maker: what it takes to lead the way - News & insight
    Apr 21, 2016 · ... Sir Simon Robertson. I am proud to belong to a ... I am a keen member of the 30% Club and got Rolls Royce to join it when I was Chairman.
  11. [11]
    Rollercoaster days for bank set to continue - The Times
    Simon Robertson, now a managing director of Goldman Sachs, also rose to prominence at Kleinwort Benson, where he aided the electricity privatisation drive.
  12. [12]
    Knighthood: Simon Robertson - Financial Times
    Jun 11, 2010 · Regarded as one of the country's best-connected bankers, he was chairman at the UK investment bank Kleinwort Benson before leaving in 1997 to ...
  13. [13]
    https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB867960073424611000
  14. [14]
    HSBC promotes banker Robertson in board reshuffle - Reuters
    Aug 9, 2007 · Robertson was president of Goldman Sachs Europe until August 2005, a post in which he helped steer the development of the U.S. firm's ...Missing: CEO | Show results with:CEO
  15. [15]
    Ex-Goldman Robertson launches boutique - Financial News London
    Simon Robertson, who resigned as president of Goldman Sachs Europe yesterday, today started his own business: Simon Robertson Associates, a mergers and ...
  16. [16]
    https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB112302081613603056
  17. [17]
    Job Wrap: Goldman's Robertson goes it alone - eFinancialCareers
    Aug 8, 2005 · Simon Robertson, president of European operations at Goldman Sachs, became the latest senior investment banker to strike out alone last week. ...
  18. [18]
    Top Morgan Stanley dealmaker joins City veteran's boutique | Reuters
    Jan 16, 2013 · Robertson, himself a former banker at Goldman Sachs, set up his own advisory firm in 2005 to offer companies financial advice on transactions ...
  19. [19]
    simon robertson associates llp - Companies House - GOV.UK
    Previous company names. Name, Period. ROBERTSON ROBEY ASSOCIATES LLP, 16 Jan 2013 - 07 Apr 2014. SIMON ROBERTSON ASSOCIATES LLP, 01 Aug 2005 - 16 Jan 2013.Missing: operations | Show results with:operations
  20. [20]
    Simon Robertson Associates Company Profile - PitchBook
    Simon Robertson Associates was founded in 2005. Where is Simon Robertson Associates headquartered? Simon Robertson Associates is headquartered in London, United ...
  21. [21]
    Robey joins forces with Robertson - Financial News London
    Robey, who announced last year he would be stepping down from Morgan Stanley, is to join Robertson's firm Simon Robertson Associates LLP, with the firm filing ...
  22. [22]
    Three Star Deal Makers Going Separate Ways in London - DealBook
    Apr 4, 2014 · Simon Robey and Simon Warshaw have formed their own boutique advisory firm less than a year after joining forces with Simon Robertson.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  23. [23]
    Rolls-Royce appoints new chairman - The Guardian
    Feb 14, 2013 · Rolls-Royce has appointed the former head of McKinsey as chairman, ending the eight-year tenure of Sir Simon Roberston.
  24. [24]
    Simon Manwaring ROBERTSON personal appointments
    ROLLS-ROYCE HOLDINGS PLC (07524813) ; Company status: Active. Correspondence address: 8 Canada Square, London, United Kingdom, E14 5HQ ; Role Resigned: Director.
  25. [25]
    [PDF] HSBC ANNOUNCES NEW LEADERSHIP TEAM
    Sep 24, 2010 · Sir Simon Robertson will become Deputy Chairman with effect from 1 December 2010. He continues as Senior Independent Non-Executive Director. Sir ...
  26. [26]
    Simon Robertson Salary Infomation 2021 - ERI
    Simon Robertson, the Independent Director of Evercore Inc, made $175921 in total compensation during 2021, according to salary benchmarking data.
  27. [27]
    Statement re Chairmanship of Rolls-Royce Group plc - Investegate
    Simon is a non-executive director of Inchcape plc, Invensys plc (formerly BTR plc) and Berry Brothers & Rudd Ltd. He was a non-executive director of the London ...
  28. [28]
    HSBC says Robertson to head remuneration committee | Reuters
    HSBC Holdings named Simon Robertson, a former Goldman Sachs banker and chairman of Rolls-Royce, as the new chairman of its remuneration committee to replace ...
  29. [29]
    HSBC shareholders in pay revolt over board remuneration | Business
    Apr 24, 2015 · Deputy chairman Sir Simon Robertson was forced to defend the chairman and chief executive after one in four votes against pay deals at the ...
  30. [30]
    Former Centrica boss to chair HSBC remuneration committee
    Mar 20, 2015 · Laidlaw will take over chairing the bank's remuneration committee from the former Goldman Sachs banker Sir Simon Robertson.
  31. [31]
    Sir Simon to Step Down as Chairman of the Group Remuneration ...
    Sir Simon has agreed to stay on the board as Deputy Chairman for a further one year period following the AGM. Sir Simon will also step down as ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] HSBC non-executive Director roles
    Sir Simon Robertson will have served on the Board of Directors of HSBC for nine years at the conclusion of the AGM. Sir Simon has agreed to stay on the Board as.
  33. [33]
    Rolls-Royce's Robertson, Jimmy Choo's Mellon Given U.K. Honors
    Jun 11, 2010 · ... family, and Stephen Murray, who is “yeoman of the plate pantry ... Chicago-born Playwright and critic Bonnie Greer becomes an OBE, as ...
  34. [34]
    Goldman, Sachs Fills Europe Post - The New York Times
    Jul 5, 1997 · Mr. Robertson, 56, is charged with bolstering the United States investment bank's European client relationships in his newly created position.
  35. [35]
    Robertson revenues hit £1.2m
    Simon Robertson, the former president of Goldman Sachs in Europe, lifted revenues by more than a quarter to £1.15m (€1.7m) at his eponymous corporate advisory ...Missing: Sir | Show results with:Sir<|separator|>
  36. [36]
    HSBC pay deals spark investor revolt - The Guardian
    May 27, 2011 · ... Simon Robertson, to be strengthened. But Cobb backed a new pay plan that will be implemented for HSBC's top 50 bankers, preventing them from ...
  37. [37]
    HSBC, Like Rivals, Hears Earful on Banker Pay at Annual Meeting ...
    On Friday, Simon Robertson, the chairman of HSBC's remuneration committee, defended the bank's pay structure, saying it more closely tied executives to the ...
  38. [38]
    Investors revolt on HSBC excessive boardroom pay | This is Money
    ... Simon Robertson. He said the bank must remain 'globally competitive' and warned that tough new rules on pay, such as the EU bonus cap, were a 'significant ...
  39. [39]
    HSBC says bonus for chairman capped at 1 million pounds | Reuters
    Simon Robertson, chairman of the remuneration committee, said in a statement if any award was made this year to Flint it would reflect changes to his ...
  40. [40]
    HSBC climbs down over massive bonuses after shareholders ...
    Sir Simon Robertson, the chairman of HSBC's remuneration committee, also said in a statement that the reduced award agreed with shareholders would be ...
  41. [41]
    HSBC comes under investor fire on bankers' pay - Reuters
    May 23, 2014 · ... Simon Robertson, chairman of the bank's remuneration committee. ... HSBC attempted to take the sting out of pay criticism last week by ...
  42. [42]
    HSBC Chief Exec Gulliver Lands £1.8m Bonus - Yahoo Finance
    HSBC is to hand its chief executive a bonus of £1.8m as part of a £7m-plus overall pay deal for 2013, Europe's largest bank will disclose on Monday.<|control11|><|separator|>