Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Third Side

Third Side is a centrist political party in Hong Kong founded in 2015 by former Democratic Party lawmakers Tik Chi-yuen and Nelson Wong Sing-chi, who sought to promote moderate reforms after their expulsion from the Democratic Party over support for Beijing's 2014 political reform proposal.^[1]^[2] The party advocates a "third road" approach, rejecting alignment with either the pro-establishment camp or radical democrats, and emphasizes dialogue with all parties, including Beijing officials, to advance pragmatic governance and social welfare policies.^[1]^[3] Tik Chi-yuen, a registered social worker with over 30 years of community service, chairs Third Side and secured the party's sole Legislative Council seat in the 2021 election, becoming Hong Kong's only non-establishment lawmaker under the overhauled "patriots-only" system.^[3]^[4] This victory highlighted the party's niche as a moderate voice amid Beijing's tightened control over elections following the 2019 protests and national security law.^[5]^[6] However, Third Side has struggled with electoral participation, failing to field candidates in the 2023 district council elections due to inability to secure required nominations under vetting processes.^[7] In 2024, the party announced plans for a U.S. visit to clarify Hong Kong's political situation and address security concerns, meeting with the U.S. consul general prior.^[8]
Third Side's defining characteristic lies in its centrist positioning within Hong Kong's polarized politics, prioritizing social services, housing, and incremental democratic progress over confrontation.^[3]^[9] While praised by some for providing a non-radical opposition outlet, critics from both sides have questioned its viability in an electoral landscape favoring pro-Beijing loyalty.^[7]^[9]

History

Founding and Establishment

Third Side was founded in January 2016 by Tik Chi-yuen and Nelson Wong Sing-chi, both former lawmakers from the Democratic Party.^[1]^[10] Tik Chi-yuen, a registered social worker and ex-vice-chairman of the Democratic Party, left the group amid growing divisions within the pan-democratic camp following the 2014 Umbrella Movement.^[3] Nelson Wong, a founding member of the Democratic Party expelled in July 2015 for supporting constitutional reform proposals, co-led the initiative to create a moderate alternative.^[10] The party's establishment responded to Hong Kong's polarized political landscape, positioning itself as a centrist force willing to engage in dialogue with Beijing officials, pro-establishment groups, and fellow pan-democrats.^[1]^[2] Founders emphasized pragmatism, including openness to members accepting government roles to advance policy influence from within, contrasting with the Democratic Party's more adversarial approach.^[1] A preparatory committee comprised other ex-Democrats like Chan Ka-wai and Chow Yick-hay, alongside businessman Shih Wing-ching, to build organizational foundations.^[1] Initial efforts centered on fundraising and electoral preparation, with the party raising HK$800,000 toward a first-year goal of HK$3 million to support candidacy in the 2016 Legislative Council elections and a by-election.^[1] Third Side aimed to field 3-4 candidates, primarily young professionals new to politics, targeting 10% voter support to secure legislative seats and facilitate negotiations on political reforms.^[2] By early 2016, membership reached 68, establishing a base for its "third road" advocacy of incremental democratic progress through compromise.^[2]

Early Activities and Growth

Third Side was formally established in January 2016 by former Democratic Party lawmakers Tik Chi-yuen and Nelson Wong Sing-chi, following their departure from the larger pro-democracy group amid disagreements over political reform strategies.^[11] The party positioned itself as a moderate alternative, emphasizing dialogue with Beijing authorities and openness to members serving in government roles, distinguishing it from more confrontational pro-democracy factions.^[1] In its initial months, Third Side organized a fundraising banquet on January 7, 2016, which attracted then-Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying and other senior officials, signaling early efforts to build cross-spectrum support despite its pro-democracy roots.^[10] These activities focused on grassroots engagement and policy advocacy for incremental reforms, with Tik Chi-yuen leveraging his background as a social worker to promote community-oriented initiatives. However, the party encountered early setbacks, including the resignation of 10 members in July 2016, who cited internal disagreements over its centrist approach and willingness to engage establishment figures.^[11] Membership remained modest, totaling around 68 individuals by mid-2016, reflecting limited initial growth amid Hong Kong's polarized political landscape post-2014 Umbrella Movement.^[12] The party's strategy of fostering ties across divides yielded some visibility but struggled against the dominance of larger camps, with early efforts centered on public forums and reform proposals rather than mass mobilization. By 2018, Third Side was described as a small entity navigating the shrinking space for non-establishment voices, prioritizing pragmatic outreach over ideological rigidity.^[13]

Adaptation to Post-National Security Law Environment

Following the enactment of the Hong Kong National Security Law on June 30, 2020, which introduced stringent requirements for political participation including vetting for "patriots" loyal to the Basic Law and national security, Third Side recalibrated its approach to remain operational amid the disqualification of many pro-democracy figures and parties. The party, originally formed in 2016 as a moderate alternative, emphasized compliance with the new electoral framework to avoid dissolution or arrest, while upholding its self-described centrist positioning that critiques both establishment conformity and radical opposition. This involved candidates publicly affirming support for the law during nomination processes, as seen in the 2021 Legislative Council election where Third Side's chairman Tik Chi-yuen secured the sole non-pro-establishment seat in the social welfare functional constituency after passing vetting by the Election Committee.^[14]^[1] In subsequent elections, Third Side attempted to expand participation but encountered barriers inherent to the post-NSL system, such as restricted candidate nominations controlled by pro-establishment-dominated bodies. For the 2023 District Council elections, reformed to limit direct public voting and prioritize appointed or vetted seats, the party nominated Timothy Chui and Marie Pang but withdrew after failing to obtain required endorsements from rural committees and other gatekeepers, highlighting the challenges of independent mobilization under tightened oversight.^[7] Despite these setbacks, Third Side maintained low-profile advocacy on issues like social welfare and moderate reforms, avoiding confrontational protests that had characterized pre-NSL opposition activities. The party's adaptation also extended to international engagement, seeking to project Hong Kong's evolving political landscape without endorsing foreign interference narratives prohibited under the law. In May 2024, Third Side leaders, including vice-chairman Casper Wong, met U.S. Consul General Gregory May and announced plans for a U.S. visit to "explain the situation in the city," framing this as dialogue rather than dissent, though such outreach risked scrutiny given the law's provisions on external collusion.^[8] Internally, Third Side focused on grassroots social work and policy proposals aligned with national security priorities, such as community stability, enabling survival where more adversarial groups like the Democratic Party faced existential pressures by 2025. This pragmatic pivot preserved a nominal "third road" voice in a legislature increasingly dominated by pro-Beijing forces, though critics argued it diluted ideological independence.^[9]

Ideology and Political Positioning

Core Principles and "Third Road" Concept

Third Side positions itself as a centrist political force in Hong Kong, advocating principles of pragmatism, dialogue, and incremental reform to navigate the territory's polarized landscape. The party's ideology emphasizes balancing respect for the "one country, two systems" framework with aspirations for accountable governance, rejecting both uncritical alignment with Beijing authorities and disruptive opposition tactics that hinder functionality.^[1] This approach prioritizes evidence-based policymaking, social cohesion, and economic vitality, with leaders underscoring the need to address residents' daily concerns through constructive engagement rather than ideological rigidity.^[15] Central to its outlook is the "third road" concept, which seeks to carve a moderate pathway between the pro-establishment camp's emphasis on stability and loyalty to central government directives and the traditional pro-democracy camp's focus on immediate universal suffrage and confrontation. Third Side describes this road as broadening Hong Kong's political spectrum by drawing on establishment-aligned rule of law for institutional integrity while incorporating pan-democratic elements of representation and accountability in a non-adversarial manner.^[1] The strategy entails active participation in legislative processes to influence outcomes pragmatically, such as supporting national security measures while critiquing inefficiencies in public administration.^[16] In practice, these principles manifest in stances favoring national security legislation as essential for order, opposition to governance paralysis through filibustering or boycotts, and promotion of policies that enhance livelihoods without undermining sovereignty.^[16]^[17] Collaborations, such as with Path of Democracy, reinforce this by pooling resources for joint candidacies aimed at sustaining a viable centrist presence post-2019 unrest and electoral reforms. Adherents argue this road enables genuine influence in a constrained environment, though its longevity depends on securing electoral viability amid dominance by patriotic vetting criteria.^[18]

Policy Stances on Key Issues

Third Side positions itself as a centrist political force advocating a "third route" that seeks pragmatic solutions through dialogue with Beijing, distinct from confrontational pro-democracy tactics and uncritical pro-establishment alignment. The party's platform emphasizes incremental governance improvements, social welfare enhancements, and economic stability over radical constitutional changes, reflecting Chairman Tik Chi-yuen's background as a social worker with over 30 years in community service.^[19]^[9] On political reform, Third Side supports eventual universal suffrage but views it as secondary to immediate socioeconomic priorities. In July 2024, during consultations for the Chief Executive's policy address, Tik Chi-yuen urged the formulation of a "dual universal suffrage roadmap" for the Legislative Council and Chief Executive elections, while acknowledging that constitutional changes are not Hong Kong's most pressing need amid economic recovery challenges. The party's 2021 Legislative Council election platform notably omitted explicit calls for political reform, focusing instead on administrative efficiency and public consultation mechanisms.^[20]^[21] The group endorses Hong Kong's national security framework as essential for stability post-2019 unrest. Third Side backs the 2020 National Security Law and the 2024 Article 23 legislation, with Tik expressing non-opposition to the latter while stressing the need to heed public feedback to mitigate concerns over its scope. This stance aligns with the party's participation in "patriots-only" elections since 2021, positioning it as a moderate voice willing to engage within Beijing's red lines rather than challenge them outright.^[22]^[4] In socioeconomic policy, Third Side prioritizes welfare, housing affordability, and healthcare access, critiquing the government for lacking clear direction and humility in execution. Tik has advocated expanding services for vulnerable populations, including elderly care and community development initiatives, drawing from his representation of the social welfare functional constituency. The party calls for targeted economic measures to address youth unemployment and housing shortages, favoring evidence-based interventions over ideological debates.^[19]^[23]

Differentiation from Pro-Democracy and Pro-Establishment Camps

Third Side differentiates itself from the pro-democracy camp by endorsing the Hong Kong National Security Law enacted on June 30, 2020, and committing to operate within the "patriots administering Hong Kong" framework established thereafter, rather than rejecting these measures as infringements on civil liberties.)^[8] Pro-democracy groups, historically aligned with demands for universal suffrage without preconditions and often critical of Beijing's influence, have largely boycotted or condemned post-2020 electoral reforms, viewing them as erosions of autonomy; in contrast, Third Side participated in the 2021 Legislative Council election under these rules, with chairman Tik Chi-yuen securing the sole non-pro-establishment seat in the social welfare functional constituency on December 19, 2021.^[3]^[14] This pragmatic engagement aims at incremental policy influence, such as advancing social welfare and education reforms, over confrontational tactics like street protests or legislative filibusters prevalent in the pro-democracy approach prior to the 2019 unrest. Relative to the pro-establishment camp, which comprises parties like the Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong (DAB) closely tied to Beijing's priorities and emphasizing unconditional loyalty to central government directives, Third Side asserts independence as a non-establishment entity focused on local Hong Kong interests without subservience to mainland-aligned agendas.^[7]^[9] Founded in 2015 by Tik Chi-yuen after his departure from the Democratic Party, the group targets moderate voters disillusioned with polarization, critiquing government shortcomings—such as in housing policy or inequality metrics like the Gini coefficient hovering near 0.6—while avoiding the pro-establishment's deference to state-led economic integration with the Greater Bay Area at the potential expense of local autonomy.^[24]^[15] Tik's 2021 victory, garnering support from centrist sectors rather than establishment mobilization, underscores this distinction, positioning Third Side as a bridge for voices sidelined by the binary divide but vetted under patriotism criteria.^[25]^[2] This centrist positioning, however, has drawn scrutiny for diluting opposition to Beijing's oversight, with pro-democracy advocates labeling it accommodationist and pro-establishment critics questioning its loyalty amid nomination failures in the 2023 District Council elections, where candidates like Timothy Chui and Marie Pang withdrew on October 27, 2023, after vetting hurdles.^[7] Despite such challenges, Third Side's strategy prioritizes sustained legislative presence over ideological purity, evidenced by Tik's continued tenure and engagements like the May 3, 2024, announcement of a U.S. visit to clarify Hong Kong's post-NSL stability to international audiences.^[8]

Organizational Structure

Leadership and Key Figures

Tik Chi-yuen serves as chairman of Third Side, a position he has held since co-founding the party on January 3, 2016, following his departure from the Democratic Party in 2015.^[19] A registered social worker with more than 30 years of community service, Tik previously represented the Social Welfare functional constituency in the Legislative Council from 2012 to 2016 and was re-elected in the 2021 election, becoming the sole lawmaker outside the pro-establishment bloc amid the "patriots-only" vetting process.^[3] ^[8] Casper Wong acts as vice-chairman, focusing on external engagement; in May 2024, he announced plans for a party delegation to visit the United States to address misconceptions about Hong Kong's political situation after meeting U.S. Consul General Gregory May.^[8] Wong Sing-chi, a former Democratic Party member and media professional, co-founded Third Side alongside Tik and has contributed to its early organizational development as vice-convenor.^[26] The leadership emphasizes a centrist approach, with Tik publicly describing the party as pursuing a "middle-of-the-road" path distinct from both radical democrats and pro-establishment forces.^[3]

Membership and Internal Operations

Third Side was founded in late 2015 by former members of the Democratic Party, including Tik Chi-yuen as convenor and Nelson Wong Sing-chi as vice-convenor, drawing initial support from a 20-member preparatory committee that included ex-Democrats such as Chan Ka-wai and Chow Yick-hay, as well as businessman Shih Wing-ching.^[1] The party's recruitment targeted moderates open to cross-camp engagement, with an explicit policy allowing members to accept government appointments as a pathway to influence policymaking.^[1] Internal decision-making has centered on pragmatic electoral and dialogue strategies, though early challenges arose from factional tensions. In July 2016, ten members resigned in protest after the leadership decided against fielding candidates in the New Territories East constituency for the Legislative Council elections, highlighting strains over candidate selection and competitive positioning.^[11] Operations remain informal, lacking formal registration under Hong Kong's absence of a political party ordinance, and rely on fundraising from private donations—excluding those from tobacco or gambling sectors—to sustain activities, with an initial target of HK$3 million raised in the first year (HK$800,000 secured by late 2015).^[1]^[27] The party's small scale has shaped its internal dynamics, emphasizing leadership-driven coordination under figures like chairman Tik Chi-yuen and vice-chairman Casper Wong, who handle outreach and policy alignment.^[8] Membership continues to prioritize ideological flexibility, fostering operations geared toward bilateral talks with Beijing officials, pro-establishment groups, and international stakeholders rather than rigid hierarchies.^[1]

Electoral Participation and Performance

Legislative Council Elections

Third Side first participated in the Legislative Council elections during the 2021 poll, held on December 19 under the electoral reforms enacted in response to the 2020 National Security Law, which expanded the body's size to 90 seats and introduced vetting for candidates' "patriotism."^[28] ^[14] Party chairman Tik Chi-yuen, a registered social worker and former Democratic Party affiliate who positioned himself as a centrist, won the single-member Social Welfare functional constituency with sufficient votes from eligible sector voters, securing Third Side's sole seat and marking the group as the only non-pro-establishment presence in the chamber.^[3] ^[29] This outcome reflected the election's overall pro-establishment dominance, with 89 seats captured by Beijing-aligned candidates amid a record-low turnout of 30.2 percent, attributed by observers to voter disillusionment and restrictions on opposition participation.^[14] Tik's election highlighted Third Side's strategy of navigating the "patriots-only" framework by emphasizing moderate policies on welfare and social issues while affirming support for national security measures, distinguishing the party from boycotting pro-democracy groups.^[3] During his term from 2021 to 2025, he advocated for enhancements in social services and youth engagement without challenging core establishment priorities, though his isolated position limited legislative influence.^[29] As of October 2025, Third Side faces uncertainty in the upcoming December 7 Legislative Council election for the eighth term, with Tik Chi-yuen announcing he will not seek re-election, citing personal reasons amid a wave of incumbents opting out—over 20 lawmakers total, or about a quarter of the chamber.^[30] ^[31] The party's prior experience with nomination hurdles, as seen in its withdrawal from the 2023 District Council race after failing to secure sufficient endorsements from district leaders and rural committees, underscores ongoing challenges in meeting the system's pro-Beijing vetting and support requirements.^[7] No candidates from Third Side had been publicly confirmed for the 2025 LegCo race by late October, potentially signaling a strategic pause or difficulties in assembling compliant slates for the 20 geographical, 30 functional, and 40 Election Committee seats.^[32]

District Council and Other Local Elections

In the 2023 Hong Kong District Council elections, held on December 10 under the "patriots administering Hong Kong" framework introduced by electoral reforms, Third Side attempted to field two candidates: Timothy Chui and Marie Pang.^[7] These elections featured a reduced directly elected component, with 88 of 470 seats open to public vote and the remainder appointed or indirectly elected, alongside mandatory vetting of candidates by committees to ensure adherence to national security requirements. Neither Chui nor Pang obtained the necessary nominations from district-based committees dominated by pro-establishment figures, resulting in Third Side's complete withdrawal from the contest.^[7] The party described this as a barrier for centrist groups seeking to participate outside traditional camps, though it did not challenge the vetting process legally. Voter turnout reached a record low of 27.5%, amid criticisms of the reforms' restrictiveness, but Third Side's absence underscored its limited foothold in local governance. Prior to 2023, Third Side had not contested district council or other local elections, as the party was established in the post-2021 Legislative Council election period and focused initially on higher-level legislative races.^[8] No subsequent local elections have occurred as of October 2025, with district councils remaining the primary sub-provincial bodies for community affairs like housing and welfare.^[33] This lack of participation has confined Third Side's electoral activity to legislative arenas, where it secured one seat in 2021 via Tik Chi-yuen.^[14]

Controversies and Criticisms

Accusations of Moderatism from Pro-Democracy Advocates

Pro-democracy advocates, particularly those aligned with more assertive factions of the pan-democratic camp, have accused Third Side of adopting an excessively moderate approach that undermines confrontational strategies against Beijing's influence. Founded in 2015 by Tik Chi-yuen after his departure from the Democratic Party's moderate wing, Third Side positioned itself as pursuing a "third road" involving dialogue with mainland authorities and openness to government roles, which critics viewed as compromising the pro-democracy movement's demand for immediate universal suffrage and resistance to electoral reforms.^[1] This split was seen by some as fragmenting the opposition vote ahead of the 2016 Legislative Council election, where Third Side fielded candidates without aligning fully with traditional pan-democrats. Such criticisms intensified following the 2019 protests and the 2020 national security law, as Third Side rejected calls for boycotting the reformed "patriots-only" electoral system. Tik Chi-yuen, who opposed a Legislative Council election boycott in early 2021, argued that participation could foster incremental change, but pro-democracy figures like those in the Democratic Party labeled this as legitimizing a Beijing-controlled framework that disqualified opposition candidates and reduced direct elections.^[34]^[35] Tik's subsequent election as the sole non-establishment lawmaker in the 2021 poll drew further accusations of being "middle-of-nowhere" rather than a genuine alternative, with detractors claiming it propped up the system's facade of pluralism while avoiding radical tactics like mass abstention or street mobilization.^[3]^[36] These views reflect broader tensions within Hong Kong's opposition, where moderates like Third Side are faulted for prioritizing stability over uncompromising demands for democratic restoration.^[37]

Scrutiny from Pro-Establishment Perspectives

Pro-establishment figures in Hong Kong have scrutinized Third Side for its self-positioned "third road" approach, arguing that such centrism risks diluting unified support for national security and Beijing's authority in a post-2020 National Security Law environment, where unequivocal patriotism is prioritized over independent moderation.^[35] This perspective holds that groups like Third Side, despite passing initial vetting for "patriots-only" elections, may harbor residual influences from pre-reform democratic leanings, potentially complicating legislative cohesion.^[14] A key manifestation of this scrutiny occurred during the 2023 District Council elections, where Third Side candidates Timothy Chui and Marie Pang failed to secure the required nominations from rural committees and other subsector bodies—predominantly controlled by pro-establishment loyalists—effectively barring their participation despite intentions to contest.^[7]^[38] Pro-establishment gatekeepers interpreted this as a failure to demonstrate sufficient alignment, with nomination processes serving as a de facto loyalty test under the reformed electoral system emphasizing prevention of "anti-China" elements.^[39] Within the Legislative Council, Third Side chairman Tik Chi-yuen's status as the sole non-establishment member elected in 2021 has invited ongoing wariness, with pro-establishment leaders like LegCo President Andrew Leung urging new entrants to prioritize promotion of Hong Kong over partisan independence, implicitly critiquing outliers for potential disruption.^[40] Tik's advocacy for jury trials in the national security case against 47 pro-democracy figures and his calls for government responsiveness on Article 23 legislation have been viewed by establishment observers as overly accommodating to liberal procedural norms, contrasting with the camp's emphasis on swift security enforcement.^[41]^[4] Additionally, Third Side's May 2024 announcement of plans for a U.S. visit—following meetings with U.S. Consul General Gregory May—to "explain the situation" and address security concerns has drawn implicit pro-establishment concern over engaging foreign diplomats, amid heightened sensitivities to perceived collusion risks under the security law.^[8] Such outreach is seen by critics in the camp as unnecessary and potentially signaling internal divisions, undermining the narrative of post-reform stability.^[42] Overall, these episodes reflect pro-establishment insistence that true patriotism demands full integration rather than moderated differentiation, limiting Third Side's operational space.

Challenges with Election Vetting and Patriot Requirements

The electoral reforms implemented in Hong Kong following the passage of the "Improving Electoral System" decision by China's National People's Congress in March 2021 require candidates to undergo vetting by the Candidate Eligibility Review Committee to confirm their patriotism, defined as upholding the Basic Law and pledging allegiance to the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR).^[43] These reforms also mandate nominations from government-appointed committees or subsectors, with District Council candidates needing at least three such nominations under the July 2023 overhaul that reduced directly elected seats from over 450 to 88.^[44]^[45] Third Side, positioning itself as a centrist alternative, has faced significant hurdles in navigating these vetting and nomination processes, often attributed to skepticism from pro-establishment nominators regarding the party's sufficient alignment with national security priorities. In the December 2023 District Council elections—the first under the "patriots-only" framework for that level—Third Side aimed to field candidates Timothy Chui and Marie Pang but withdrew after failing to obtain the required nominations despite outreach efforts including letters and emails to committee members.^[7] Party vice-chairperson Caspar Wong stated that "elections have never been easy," emphasizing persistence amid difficulties, while Chief Executive John Lee indicated that nominators may withhold support if they doubt a candidate's "love for the country and Hong Kong or allegiance to the SAR."^[7] This nomination shortfall highlights a structural barrier for groups like Third Side, which lack the entrenched networks of pro-establishment parties to secure endorsements from the vetting-dominated committees. The U.S. State Department's 2023 human rights report noted that Third Side, alongside other non-establishment entities, sought but failed to obtain sufficient nominations for the District Council race, underscoring how the system favors candidates with demonstrated loyalty to Beijing's framework.^[38] In contrast, Third Side achieved limited success in the 2021 Legislative Council election, where chairman Tik Chi-yuen secured a seat in the social welfare functional constituency through a lottery draw among shortlisted candidates, marking him as the sole non-pro-establishment winner amid a 90-member chamber.^[46] However, this isolated victory has not translated to broader participation, as the party's moderate stance—criticized by pro-democracy advocates for insufficient opposition to reforms—invites scrutiny over its "patriot" credentials in subsequent cycles.^[14] The vetting process's emphasis on excluding perceived threats to stability, post-2019 protests, amplifies these challenges for Third Side, requiring public affirmations of patriotism that risk alienating its intended centrist base while still falling short of establishment expectations. As of October 2025, with the December Legislative Council election approaching, incumbent lawmakers including potential Third Side affiliates have cited the rigorous "patriots-only" criteria among reasons for opting out, though the party has not publicly detailed its strategy.^[31] This dynamic illustrates how the reforms, intended to consolidate governance under loyalists, constrain third-path political actors by tying electoral viability to unequivocal pro-HKSAR demonstrations.^[47]

Impact and Recent Developments

Influence on Hong Kong Politics

Third Side has positioned itself as a centrist force in Hong Kong's polarized political landscape, advocating dialogue with Beijing while critiquing aspects of the establishment's approach, thereby attempting to carve out space for moderate voices amid post-2019 electoral reforms.^[1] Founded in 2015 by former Democratic Party members, the group emphasizes pragmatic engagement, including openness to members serving in government roles, which distinguishes it from more confrontational pro-democracy factions.^[1] This stance has enabled limited participation in the "patriots-only" framework imposed after the 2020 national security law, though with constrained impact. In the 2021 Legislative Council election, Third Side's chairman Tik Chi-yuen secured the sole non-pro-establishment seat in the social welfare functional constituency, marking a rare breakthrough for moderates in an election redesigned to prioritize candidates vetted for loyalty to Beijing.^[14] Tik, a registered social worker with over 30 years of community service, leveraged his incumbency and centrist credentials to win amid record-low turnout and a pro-Beijing sweep, providing a platform for discussing welfare policies without outright opposition to central government directives.^[19] This victory underscored Third Side's strategy of navigating vetting processes, contrasting with boycotts by pan-democrats, but its isolation— as the only such seat—limited broader legislative sway.^[48] Efforts to expand influence faltered in the 2023 District Council elections, Hong Kong's first under restricted "patriots-only" rules slashing directly elected seats to 20% of total. Third Side intended to field candidates Timothy Chui and Marie Pang but withdrew after failing to secure sufficient nominations from pro-establishment rural committees, highlighting barriers for non-aligned groups in the revamped system.^[7] ^[39] This outcome reflected systemic challenges, as similar moderate parties like the Hong Kong Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood also secured no seats, effectively marginalizing centrist alternatives at the local level.^[38] Beyond elections, Third Side has pursued external engagement to amplify its voice, meeting U.S. Consul General Gregory May in early 2024 and planning a U.S. visit to clarify Hong Kong's situation and address security misconceptions.^[8] Such moves signal an intent to influence international perceptions of Hong Kong's reforms, positioning the party as a bridge between local realities and global scrutiny, though without tangible policy shifts domestically. Overall, Third Side's influence remains niche, sustaining a moderate discourse in a legislature dominated by pro-Beijing forces (88 of 90 seats post-2021), but struggling against vetting and nomination hurdles that favor establishment loyalty.^[49]

International Engagement and Outreach

In May 2024, Third Side leaders, including chairman Tik Chi-yuen and vice-chairman Casper Wong, met with US Consul General to Hong Kong and Macau Gregory May, along with US Consulate officials Roxie Houge and Andrew Riplinger, to discuss Hong Kong's political landscape following the enactment of Article 23 legislation.^[8] The meeting focused on clarifying the implications of the national security measures and addressing perceived international misunderstandings about their scope and enforcement.^[8] Building on this dialogue, Third Side announced plans for a youth delegation visit to the United States in the second half of 2024, targeting cities including Washington, New York, and Los Angeles.^[8] The delegation aimed to engage with American politicians, think tanks, and business enterprises to provide firsthand explanations of Hong Kong's post-Article 23 environment, dispel misconceptions regarding the security law, and promote the city's stability and opportunities.^[8] US officials expressed support for the initiative, indicating willingness to facilitate connections during the trip.^[8] Third Side has also explored outreach to other nations, with scheduled visits to Japan and Germany postponed without specified reasons as of mid-2024.^[8] These efforts reflect the party's strategy to position itself as a bridge between Hong Kong's local developments and global perceptions, emphasizing pragmatic dialogue amid tightened electoral and security frameworks.^[8] No further international activities by the party have been publicly documented beyond these engagements.^[8]

Current Status and Future Prospects

As of October 2025, Third Side maintains one seat in Hong Kong's 90-member Legislative Council, held by chairman Tik Chi-yuen in the social welfare functional constituency, where he was elected unopposed in 2021 as the sole non-pro-establishment candidate.^[14] ^[50] The party, which positions itself as centrist and advocates a "third road" between pro-democracy and pro-establishment camps, has faced barriers in broader electoral participation; it withdrew from the 2023 District Council elections after failing to secure nominations for its candidates under the patriots-only vetting process.^[7] In May 2024, Third Side announced plans for a delegation to the United States to clarify Hong Kong's political situation and counter security-related misconceptions, following meetings with the U.S. consul general.^[8] Tik Chi-yuen, aged 68, declared in October 2025 that he will not seek re-election in the December 7 Legislative Council vote, citing the need for renewal while expressing regret over limited opportunities for diverse voices in the legislature.^[51] ^[52] Third Side plans to field a single candidate in the social welfare sector, its only targeted contest amid the functional constituencies' structure that favors incumbents and vetted patriots.^[52] Prospects for retaining representation hinge on passing the stringent electoral vetting, which requires affirmations of patriotism and has historically excluded moderate or non-establishment figures beyond isolated cases like Tik's prior win. The party's moderate stance, emphasizing dialogue with Beijing while critiquing aspects of governance, offers limited differentiation in a system where pro-establishment parties hold overwhelming majorities—90 of 90 seats post-2021 reforms—and low voter turnout (e.g., 30.2% in 2021 LegCo polls) signals apathy that disadvantages smaller groups.^[14] Without Tik's established profile, Third Side risks losing its foothold, potentially confining it to advocacy outside formal politics unless electoral adjustments emerge, though no such reforms have been confirmed ahead of 2025.^[53]

References

[1]
New Hong Kong political party Third Side prepares to test its ...
Sep 29, 2015 · Ex-Democrats behind Third Side say they will talk to anyone, including Beijing officials, and are open to members taking jobs in government.
[2]
New party stakes claim to Hong Kong's political middle ground ...
Tik Chi-yuen, a Third Side co-founder and a former member of the Democratic Party -- spoke with the Nikkei Asian Review about the political outlook and the ...
[3]
Who is Tik Chi-yuen? Meet Hong Kong's only non-establishment ...
Dec 26, 2021 · “Putting it roughly, [Third Side] is middle-of-the-road. What we are not is 'pro-establishment'. What we are not is 'radical democrats.'” He ...
[4]
Hong Kong's novice lawmakers: Legco's odd man out pledges to ...
Jan 16, 2022 · Tik Chi-yuen, 64, chairman of the Third Side party and the only non-establishment candidate to win a seat in the Legislative Council election on ...
[5]
Pro-establishment candidates win Hong Kong's 'patriots-only' election
Dec 20, 2021 · The only non-pro-establishment candidate to win a seat was Tik Chi-yuen, founder of the self-declared centrist party Third Side. The ...
[6]
Better one voice than none - moderate winner Tik - The Standard (HK)
Dec 21, 2021 · Tik Chi-yuen, chairman of moderate political party Third Side, is the sole non-establishment candidate to win in the Legislative Council ...<|separator|>
[7]
Hong Kong centrist party Third Side to sit out 'patriots-only' District ...
Oct 27, 2023 · Third Side had intended to field two candidates – Timothy Chui and Marie Pang – to run in the newly restricted District Council elections, ...
[8]
Hong Kong centrist Third Side party plans US visit to 'explain the ...
May 3, 2024 · Third Side vice-chairman Casper Wong reveals plan after the group's leaders meet US consul general in Hong Kong and Macau Gregory May.
[9]
Showcasing HK's political diversity - Boase Cohen & Collins
May 10, 2023 · He co-founded a new political group, Third Side, pledging to be “neither pro-establishment nor radical democrats”. Some 20 months ago, he ...
[10]
CY and high-ranking officials attend fundraising banquet for ex ...
Jan 9, 2016 · It was founded by Nelson Wong Sing-chi, a Democratic Party founding member who was expelled in July 2015, and Tik Chi-yuen, the former ...
[11]
10 members from middle-of-the-road political party Third Side leave ...
Jul 22, 2016 · Founded by former Democratic Party lawmakers Tik Chi-yuen and Nelson Wong Sing-chi in January, the Third Side advocates dialogue with Beijing ...Missing: activities | Show results with:activities<|separator|>
[12]
Third Side - Uncensorable Wikipedia on IPFS
Jan 3, 2016 · Third Side is a moderate political party in Hong Kong.[1] Headed by ... Founded, 3 January 2016 (2016-01-03). Membership (2016), 68.
[13]
As Hong Kong Clamps Down, a Tiny Political Party Finds Itself in the ...
Aug 6, 2018 · Since the 2014 Umbrella Movement protests, when democracy advocates occupied major intersections of Hong Kong for nearly three months, activists ...
[14]
West raises concerns after pro-Beijing candidates sweep Hong ...
Dec 20, 2021 · Tik Chi-yuen, of the self-described centrist Third Side party, became the only candidate who is not pro-establishment to be elected. Tik ...<|separator|>
[15]
新思維Third Side - Facebook
新思維Third Side, Hong Kong. 385 likes · 2 talking about this. 【新思維·由心創變】我們立足中間，用心聆聽就如你我一樣，為香港的每一刻，每一天努力.
[16]
立法會選舉｜「民主思路」與「新思維」將以聯合陣營方式參選 - 文匯報
Oct 22, 2021 · 香港是中國不可分割的一部分，香港不能成為破壞或威脅國家安全的地方。「民主思路」與「新思維」不認同癱瘓香港 ... 第三路線」力量，不會定義路線 ...
[17]
香港多個第三路線政團參選立法會政治版圖碎片化 - 美國之音粵語網
Jul 12, 2016 · ... 第三路線的新思維候選人黃成智的得票超過17,000，大幅落後於得票第三的本土派候選人梁天琦的66,000票。同樣走第三路線的民主思路，如何評估今次參選 ...
[18]
Political reality does not bode well for a 'third road' in HK
... Hong Kong 2014 ... Led by Wong Sing-chi and Tik Chi-yuen, they formed a new party conveniently named Third Side. ... The main opposition parties in Hong Kong are ...
[19]
Tik Chi Yuen | South China Morning Post
Dr Tik Chi Yuen is chairman of Third Side. A registered social worker who has served the community for more than 30 years, he has served as a Legislative ...
[20]
政改不是香港的急切選項，狄志遠搞錯了方向文：文武 - 堅料網
Jul 26, 2024 · 特首展開新一份《施政報告》的社會諮詢，陸續約見立法會各政團及議員。其中，立法會議員狄志遠及新思維表示，將向特首提議，盡快制訂雙普選路線圖， ...
[21]
What's a manifesto? Hong Kong Legco candidates' simple slogans ...
Dec 5, 2021 · ... Third Side party did not mention political reform in their mission statements. The group is led by former Democratic Party member Tik Chi ...
[22]
Hong Kong tables new security bill amid fears of widening crackdown
Jan 12, 2024 · Lawmaker Tik Chi-yuen said that while he doesn't oppose the bill, there are public concerns around it that should be listened to. "There are ...Missing: views | Show results with:views
[23]
新思維 - 思考香港
新思維 ; 【財經專訪】粉嶺高球場爭議政黨倡高球場搬去竹篙灣 · 2022-08-30 ; 狄志遠獲重量級建制助取提名「無建制選委支持不能參選」 · 2021-12-01.
[24]
创党成员狄志远宣布退党香港民主党陷分裂 - BBC
Sep 9, 2015 · 狄志远上月初已宣布，将与早前被革除党籍的黄成智合组名为“新思维”的参政平台，争取温和派人士支持。 ... 狄志远早前接受传媒访问，指有意与汤家骅合作，提倡在 ...
[25]
Better one voice than none - moderate winner Tik - The Standard (HK)
Dec 21, 2021 · Tik Chi-yuen, chairman of moderate political party Third Side, is the sole non-establishment candidate to win in the Legislative Council ...Missing: differentiation | Show results with:differentiation
[26]
The 'third way' to nowhere | Voice of Hong Kong
May 10, 2016 · Ronny Tong Ka-wah, founder of the Path of Democracy and a former Civic Party legislator, believes there is a third way to fight for democracy.<|separator|>
[27]
Hong Kong Government and Politics - CountryReports
... Third Side or TS [TIK Chi-yeun] note 1: there is no political party ordinance, so there are no registered political parties; politically active groups ...
[28]
'no one size fits all' democratic model, Hong Kong leader Lam says ...
Dec 20, 2021 · The former Democrat, who ran as a middle-of-the-road candidate, triumphed in the social welfare functional constituency. Pro-Beijing figures won ...
[29]
Tik Chi-yuen - The Standard (HK)
Chairman of centrist party Third Side, Tik Chi-yuen, has become the only non-establishment candidate elected to the Legislative Council.Missing: early | Show results with:early
[30]
Three veteran lawmakers opt out of LegCo election
Oct 11, 2025 · Joining them is 68-year-old Tik Chi-yuen, leader of the Third Side party, who announced his decision not to run in the upcoming election after ...Missing: growth | Show results with:growth
[31]
7 more lawmakers bow out of upcoming 'patriots-only' LegCo election
Oct 13, 2025 · He said he had intended to run alongside a new candidate from his party, but Third Side could only field one candidate due to limited resources.
[32]
https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3329783/hong-kongs-legco-withdraws-farewell-motion-amid-concerns-over-electoral-fairness
[33]
2023 District Council Ordinary Election - Election Brief
Dec 10, 2023 · To reduce the electors' queuing time and avoid excessive crowd gathering at the polling stations, the estimated queuing time will be provided ...Missing: Third | Show results with:Third
[34]
Liberalism in Hong Kong - Wikipedia
2015: The moderate faction left and formed the ⇒ Third Side. Hong Kong ... ^ "Over 100 police officers raid office of Hong Kong pro-democracy newspaper Apple ...Missing: moderatism | Show results with:moderatism
[35]
2016 Hong Kong legislative election - Wikipedia
... Hong Kong Island and New Territories East. Third Side: The new moderate party led by former Democratic Party vice-chairman Tik Chi-yuen planned to ...Missing: moderatism | Show results with:moderatism
[36]
Calls rising for LegCo election boycott in HK - Asia Times
Mar 31, 2021 · Tik Chi-yuen, chairman and founder of the Third Side and a former Democratic Party member, said democrats should not boycott the LegCo elections ...Missing: moderatism | Show results with:moderatism
[37]
Hong Kong elections: already dominant pro-establishment camp ...
Dec 20, 2021 · They said the electoral changes had eliminated the opposition and reversed the trend of growing political diversity. ... Third Side won the seat ...
[38]
Hong Kong elections: middle of the road, or middle of nowhere? A ...
Dec 9, 2021 · ... Democracy or the Third Side, which he claimed were in fact pro-establishment. Instead, Poon said candidates should be categorised by whether ...Missing: moderatism | Show results with:moderatism
[39]
[PDF] Hong Kong pro-democracy 35 plus movement: How different types of
Jan 16, 2024 · For instance, Tik Chi-yuen, the co-founder of. DPHK, quit the party and formed the Third Side, attempting to capture the middle voters (Zeng, ...Missing: moderatism | Show results with:moderatism<|separator|>
[40]
Hong Kong - United States Department of State
... Hong Kong Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood; and the self-described non-establishment party Third Side all sought nominations but failed to ...
[41]
Explainer: Hong Kong's first 'patriots-only' District Council race
Nov 11, 2023 · Moderate party Third Side also failed to get enough nominations, while Roundtable, a pro-establishment group founded by entrepreneur and ...
[42]
'Patriots' election: Hong Kong's sole non-establishment lawmaker ...
Dec 21, 2021 · Lawmakers-elect Stephen Ho (right) and Tik Chi-yuen (left). Photo: Kelly Ho/HKFP. Commercial (Second) sector elect Martin Liao who is currently ...
[43]
Hong Kong centrist party calls for 47 democrats' national security ...
Aug 19, 2022 · Tik Chi-yuen, the chairperson of centrist party Third Side, also ... The media mogul stands accused of conspiring to commit collusion ...
[44]
Covert 'foreign agents' could undermine Hong Kong Legco poll
Dec 11, 2021 · The security law, enacted in June last year, was set up to combat acts of secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign forces.
[45]
Explainer: How Hong Kong's new election law will reshape legislature
Dec 17, 2021 · Hong Kong holds a legislative assembly election on Sunday in which candidates have been vetted for "patriotism" and pro-democracy candidates ...
[46]
https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3149363/hong-kong-elections-just-one-opposition-friendly-candidate
[47]
https://www.nbr.org/publication/hong-kong-after-the-legislative-council-election/
[48]
Hong Kong elections: just 1 opposition-leaning candidate wins seat ...
Sep 20, 2021 · Tik Chi-yuen, whose winning bid came down to drawing numbers with two other finalists, says worth taking part if he can represent how ...Missing: participation | Show results with:participation
[49]
Hong Kong after the Legislative Council Election
Feb 25, 2022 · In response to the electoral changes, which included only permitting “patriots” to run as candidates, pro-democracy politicians and their ...
[50]
Hong Kong voters shun first post-crackdown election | The Week
Dec 20, 2021 · Pro-Beijing candidates won almost every seat in Hong Kong's new legislature after loyalists swept the board in an election marked by a ...
[51]
Hong Kong - The World Factbook - CIA
Dec 6, 2023 · In this agreement, China promised that, under its "one country, two systems" formula, China's socialist economic and strict political system ...
[52]
Members' contact directory
Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Deputies to the National People's Congress, Hong Kong ... Third Side. Office address. Room 1319, 13/F, Legislative Council ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[53]
At least nine lawmakers step back from upcoming LegCo election
Oct 12, 2025 · A growing number of lawmakers -- at least nine -- have declared not to run in the Legislative Council Election in December ahead of the ...
[54]
HK leader dodges questions on age limit for running in 'patriots-only ...
Oct 14, 2025 · The 68-year-old said his party, Third Side, could only field one ... Tagged: 2025 Legislative Council Election, Andrew Leung, Chan Kin ...
[55]
https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3330027/encourage-employees-vote-hong-kongs-coming-legco-election-john-lee