Thoros II

Thoros II, also known as Thoros the Great (Armenian: Թորոս Բ; born before 1120 – 6 February 1169), was the sixth lord of Armenian Cilicia from the Rubenid dynasty, ruling as "Lord of the Mountains" from 1144 until his death.^[1] The son of Lewon I, he spent years in Byzantine captivity following the empire's conquest of Cilicia but escaped Constantinople in 1143, returning to rally Armenian forces and systematically reclaim territories from Byzantine control.^[1]^[2] Thoros's reign marked a period of restoration and expansion for Armenian Cilicia, as he liberated major strongholds such as Vahka in 1144, Anazarba, Adana, Sis, and others, often with support from Crusader allies in Antioch.^[1]^[2] He navigated complex relations with neighboring powers, briefly accepting Seljuk suzerainty in 1158 to counter Byzantine pressure before revolting against imperial forces, including a decisive victory over a Byzantine army near Mamistra in 1152.^[1]^[2] Thoros also repelled Turkish incursions, notably defeating Seljuk forces under Sultan Mas'ud I in 1156, which secured Cilicia's borders and extended influence into Isauria.^[2] These military successes, coupled with strategic diplomacy, placed Armenian Cilicia on a stable footing amid the era's turmoil of Crusader-Byzantine-Seljuk conflicts, strengthening the Rubenid principality's autonomy and laying foundations for its later transformation into a kingdom.^[1]^[2] Thoros married twice—first to Isabelle, daughter of Joscelin II of Edessa, and later to a daughter of Prince Thomas of Antioch—and was succeeded by his son Rupen III, though he retired to monastic life before his death at Trazarg.^[1]

Early Life and Captivity

Family Background and Upbringing

Thoros II was the second son of Leo I, lord of Armenian Cilicia (also known as "Lord of the Mountains"), who ruled from 1129 until his capture by Byzantine forces in 1137 or 1138, and Leo's wife Beatrice of Rethel, a noblewoman from the County of Rethel in the Latin East.^[1]^[3] Leo I, born around the 1060s, was himself the son of Constantine I (died 1100 or 1103), who had consolidated Rubenid control over key fortresses like Vahka and Partzerpert following his father Ruben I's establishment of the dynasty.^[1] The Rubenids traced their origins to Armenian nobility displaced by Seljuk Turk incursions into the Armenian highlands in the late 11th century; Ruben I (born circa 1025–1035, died 1095), an Armenian émigré who initially served Byzantine interests in Cilicia, rebelled around 1080 to found an independent principality amid the power vacuum created by the Byzantine-Seljuk wars and the First Crusade.^[1] Thoros II's siblings included Stepanos (Stephen), Mleh (who later ruled Cilicia from 1170 to 1175), and Rupen, as well as possibly other brothers and sisters, reflecting the extensive progeny typical of Rubenid rulers who sought to secure alliances through kinship in a volatile region bordered by Byzantine, Seljuk, and Crusader territories.^[1] Constantine I's earlier sons, including Thoros I (who ruled 1102–1129), positioned the family as de facto sovereigns over Armenian-populated enclaves in Cilicia, leveraging mountainous terrain for defense against external threats.^[1] The dynasty claimed descent from ancient Armenian royalty, such as the Bagratuni, though primary chronicles like those of Matthew of Edessa emphasize their pragmatic adaptation to frontier lordship rather than unbroken royal lineage.^[1] Details of Thoros II's upbringing prior to the family's 1137 submission to Byzantine Emperor John II Komnenos—which led to their relocation as hostages to Constantinople—are sparse in contemporary accounts, but as a prince in a militarized court, he grew up in fortresses like Vahka during Leo I's brief reign, a period marked by alliances with the Crusader County of Edessa against Seljuk incursions and tensions with Byzantine overlords seeking to reassert control over Cilicia.^[1] This environment, documented in sources like the Chronicle of King Het'um II, fostered martial skills and political acumen essential for Rubenid survival, with the family's Orthodox Christian Armenian identity reinforced amid interactions with Latin Crusaders and Greek imperial administrators.^[1] No specific birth date for Thoros II survives, but his active role in later events suggests he reached maturity before the captivity, likely in the 1110s or early 1120s.^[1]

Imprisonment by the Byzantine Empire

In 1137, Byzantine Emperor John II Komnenos launched a campaign to reassert imperial authority over Cilicia, targeting the semi-independent Armenian principalities that had proliferated amid the region's instability following Seljuk incursions. Prince Leo I of Armenian Cilicia, Thoros II's father, had recently attacked the Byzantine-held city of Seleucia, prompting the emperor's response; Leo submitted to John II near Vahka (modern Anavarza), but the emperor demanded the surrender of key fortresses and the deportation of Leo and his family as guarantees of loyalty. Thoros II, then in his early twenties, was captured alongside his father and younger brother Roupen, and the group was conveyed to Constantinople under guard.^[4] Upon arrival in the Byzantine capital, the captives were confined, with Leo I and his sons held as political hostages to ensure Cilician compliance with imperial directives; Byzantine sources portray this as a measure to neutralize Armenian resistance rather than outright conquest, though it effectively placed Cilicia under temporary direct Byzantine administration for several years. Leo I died in captivity in 1140, likely from natural causes exacerbated by confinement, while Roupen was murdered by imperial guards in an apparent act of palace intrigue or punishment for unrest. Thoros II endured harsher scrutiny as the surviving heir, reportedly navigating his detention by cultivating favor among court circles through personal acumen, though primary accounts of daily conditions remain sparse and filtered through later chroniclers.^[5]^[6] The imprisonment reflected broader Byzantine policy toward frontier vassals: integration via coercion and relocation of elites to Constantinople, where cultural assimilation and surveillance aimed to erode autonomy. For Thoros, this period spanned approximately six years, during which Cilicia's Armenian lords nominally submitted but maintained latent resistance, setting the stage for later revolts; Byzantine control faltered after John II's death in 1143, amid distractions from Turkish threats and the Second Crusade.^[7]

Rise to Power and Reconquest

Escape from Constantinople

In 1137, during Emperor John II Komnenos's campaign against Armenian Cilicia, Thoros—son of Prince Leo I—was captured alongside his father and elder brother Roupen, and transported to Constantinople as political hostages to secure Byzantine control over the region.^[8] While Leo I and Roupen perished in captivity, reportedly from illness or execution, the younger Thoros, then in his early twenties, survived his six-year imprisonment, possibly due to his youth and utility as a bargaining chip amid shifting Byzantine priorities following John II's death in 1143.^[1]^[9] Thoros effected his escape from Constantinople in 1143, exploiting the transitional instability after John II's passing and the ascension of Manuel I Komnenos, though the precise mechanism—whether through bribery, disguised flight, or internal Byzantine disarray—remains undocumented in surviving chronicles.^[1] He initially fled to the Byzantine-held island of Cyprus for temporary refuge, evading immediate pursuit, before proceeding to the County of Edessa, where he garnered support from Count Joscelin II de Courtenay, a Frankish ally of the Armenians against common Seljuk threats.^[8] This audacious breakout, undertaken without recorded external orchestration, underscored Thoros's resolve to reclaim his patrimony, setting the stage for his return to Cilicia proper.^[1]

Liberation and Consolidation of Armenian Cilicia

Following his escape from Constantinople in 1143, Thoros II returned to Cilicia in early 1144 and promptly seized the fortress of Vahka, thereby restoring initial Armenian authority in the region amid ongoing Byzantine occupation.^[1] Leveraging local Armenian support and guerrilla tactics, he expanded his reconquest by targeting isolated Byzantine garrisons, recapturing key strongholds such as Anazarbus, Mamistra, Adana, and Sis through surprise assaults that often resulted in the elimination of Greek defenders.^[1]^[5] In 1151, Thoros intensified his campaign by attacking Mamistra, where he personally killed the Byzantine governor Thomas and routed an imperial army led by Andronikos Komnenos, preventing a coordinated Byzantine counteroffensive.^[1] This success enabled further gains, including the recovery of additional sites like Partzerpert and Aryudzapert, effectively expelling most remaining Greek forces from eastern Cilicia and reestablishing Rubenid control over a fragmented but expanding territory.^[5] Thoros drew on alliances with Crusader principals, such as Raymond of Antioch, to bolster his efforts, providing military aid and refuge that facilitated these operations against superior Byzantine numbers.^[5] Consolidation followed through defensive measures and strategic diplomacy; Thoros fortified recaptured positions, encouraged Armenian settlement to reinforce demographic loyalty, and repelled subsequent threats, including a major Byzantine incursion in 1152 where his forces defeated an army of approximately 12,000 under Andronikos near the Taurus Mountains.^[5] Although nominal Byzantine suzerainty was acknowledged in 1158 amid Emperor Manuel I's invasion, Thoros retained de facto autonomy by maintaining garrisons and exploiting imperial distractions elsewhere, ensuring Armenian Cilicia's viability as a Rubenid stronghold until his death.^[1] These actions transformed Cilicia from a Byzantine-administered province into a resilient semi-independent polity, reliant on terrain advantages and opportunistic warfare.^[1]

Military Campaigns and Conflicts

Wars Against the Byzantine Empire

Following his escape from Byzantine captivity and the reconquest of Armenian Cilicia around 1148–1151, Thoros II faced immediate military resistance from Byzantine forces seeking to restore imperial control over the region. Byzantine garrisons in key cities such as Anazarbus, Adana, Tarsus, and Mamistra were systematically expelled by Thoros's forces, who leveraged the distraction of Byzantine troops engaged in campaigns against Muslim forces at Turbessel.^[5] This phase of conflict culminated in the Battle of Mamistra in 1152, where Thoros decisively defeated a Byzantine army of approximately 12,000 men commanded by Andronikos Komnenos, a relative of Emperor Manuel I; the victory allowed Thoros to consolidate Armenian dominance in the Cilician plain and deter further immediate incursions.^[5] Emperor Manuel I, aiming to reassert Byzantine suzerainty amid broader Anatolian campaigns, launched a major invasion of Cilicia in the summer of 1158 with an army estimated at 50,000 troops. Thoros, unable to match this force directly, withdrew his family, retainers, and treasury to mountain strongholds like Dadjig, prompting Manuel to capture cities including Anazarbus, Tarsus, and Lamos without prolonged sieges.^[2] ^[5] Thoros subsequently negotiated vassalage, providing hostages and tribute, which permitted him to retain de facto rule over much of Cilicia under nominal Byzantine overlordship; however, simmering tensions persisted, exacerbated by events such as the murder of Thoros's brother Stephen by Byzantine agents, leading to retaliatory massacres of Greek populations in Armenian-held territories.^[5] These engagements highlighted the Byzantines' strategic use of overwhelming numbers and alliances—such as coordinating with Seljuk Sultan Mesud I of Rûm to pressure Thoros from multiple fronts between 1153 and 1155—but Thoros's guerrilla tactics and local knowledge prevented total subjugation.^[10] While no large-scale open warfare resumed after 1158, Byzantine demands for obedience continued to strain relations, with Thoros balancing submission against opportunistic resistance until his capture by Zengid forces in 1168 shifted regional dynamics.^[5]

Conflicts with Seljuk Turks and Zengid Forces

During the early 1150s, Thoros II faced incursions from the Seljuk Sultanate of Rum, often instigated by Byzantine Emperor Manuel I Komnenos to curb Armenian expansion in Cilicia. In 1153, Manuel persuaded Sultan Mesud I to invade and demand Thoros's submission to Seljuk suzerainty, aiming to weaken the independent Armenian lordship; although Mesud's forces temporarily subdued parts of the region, Thoros retained effective control and repelled the deeper integration of Seljuk authority.^[11] This campaign followed Armenian raids into Seljuk-held Cappadocia in late 1154, which provoked a counteroffensive that Thoros successfully defended against, preserving his territorial gains such as fortresses in the Taurus Mountains. By 1155, with Mesud's death and the accession of Kilij Arslan II, Thoros shifted to opportunistic alliances, joining Byzantine general John Kontostephanos in 1160 against Kilij Arslan, thereby balancing threats from both imperial and Turkish powers while consolidating Cilician defenses.^[12] Conflicts with Zengid forces under Nur ad-Din, atabeg of Aleppo, intensified amid broader jihad against Crusader states, drawing Thoros into coalition warfare. In April 1164, Nur ad-Din besieged the fortress of Harim (Harenc), prompting Thoros—alongside his brother Mleh, Bohemond III of Antioch, Raymond III of Tripoli, and Byzantine troops—to join a relief army; initial successes forced Nur ad-Din to lift the siege temporarily, but on August 10–12, the undisciplined Christian forces suffered a catastrophic defeat near Artah, with most leaders captured. Thoros escaped the rout, averting personal capture and enabling him to regroup.^[11]^[12] In the aftermath, Thoros raided Zengid-aligned territories, capturing around 400 Turkish prisoners at Marash (Germanicia) to bolster his position and deter further incursions, though these actions heightened tensions leading to later captures in his reign.^[12] These engagements underscored Thoros's pragmatic alliances with Crusaders and Byzantines against Zengid expansion, prioritizing Cilician survival over ideological commitments.

Sack of Cyprus and Alliance with Antioch

In 1156, Thoros II forged a military alliance with Raynald de Châtillon, the consort and effective military leader of the Principality of Antioch through his marriage to Constance of Antioch.^[13] This partnership aimed to counter Byzantine encroachments in the region, as both leaders faced pressure from Emperor Manuel I Komnenos, who sought to reassert control over Cilicia and Antiochene territories.^[13] The alliance culminated in a joint raid on Cyprus, a prosperous Byzantine island under imperial administration. In spring 1156, Thoros and Raynald assembled a combined force of Armenian and Frankish troops, launching a sudden amphibious assault that caught Byzantine defenses off guard.^[13] The invaders systematically looted coastal settlements and inland areas, targeting wealthy monasteries, villages, and administrative centers; chroniclers record the seizure of vast quantities of gold, silver, livestock, and slaves, with the expedition lasting approximately three weeks.^[13] Key captures included the island's governor, Ioannes Komnenos (a relative of the emperor), along with other high-ranking Byzantine officials, whose ransom and humiliation underscored the raid's punitive intent against imperial overreach.^[13] Thoros's forces focused on eastern Cyprus, leveraging his Cilician naval capabilities, while Raynald's contingent ravaged the west, ensuring comprehensive devastation estimated to have crippled local Byzantine fiscal resources.^[13] The sack not only yielded substantial plunder—divided between the allies to bolster their treasuries—but also reinforced the strategic bond between Armenian Cilicia and Antioch, enabling mutual defense against subsequent Byzantine retaliation campaigns in 1158–1159.^[13] This opportunistic strike highlighted Thoros's pragmatic diplomacy, prioritizing short-term gains and regional solidarity over long-term imperial reconciliation.

Diplomacy and Alliances

Relations with Crusader States

Thoros II initially relied on the Principality of Antioch for support following his escape from Byzantine captivity in Constantinople around 1144–1145. Disguised as a merchant, he fled via a Venetian ship to Antioch, where Prince Raymond of Poitiers provided crucial aid, alongside assistance from Armenian Patriarch Athanasius VIII, enabling Thoros to rally forces and reclaim key strongholds in Cilicia such as Anazarba, Adana, and Sis from Byzantine control.^[5] This early collaboration reflected shared opposition to Byzantine expansionism, with Thoros leveraging Antiochene military backing to consolidate Rubenid authority amid the power vacuum left by the fall of the County of Edessa in December 1144, where he had briefly sought refuge with his cousin Joscelin II prior to that county's collapse.^[5] Throughout the 1150s, Thoros maintained alliances with Antioch against mutual threats, including joint efforts to repel Seljuk Turkish incursions, such as the decisive defeat of Sultan Mas'ud I's forces in 1156.^[5] However, relations strained under Raymond's successor, Renaud de Châtillon (prince from 1153 to 1160), who in circa 1156 compelled Thoros to surrender control of several Amanus Mountain castles—Baghras, Darbsak, La Roche de Guillaume, and La Roche de Roissol—that Thoros had captured from the Byzantines; Renaud then granted these fortifications to the Knights Templar to bolster Antioch's defenses.^[14]^[5] This territorial dispute highlighted competing claims over Cilician borderlands, though Thoros retained de facto autonomy under nominal Byzantine suzerainty after Manuel I Komnenos's invasion in 1158. By 1164, Thoros had forged a temporary coalition with Bohemond III of Antioch and Raymond III of Tripoli to counter Zengid forces under Nur ad-Din, assembling at Harim in a campaign that ended in defeat for the Christian alliance on August 12.^[14] These pragmatic partnerships underscored Thoros's strategy of balancing Crusader support against isolation from Latin principalities like Antioch and Tripoli, amid intermarriages and cultural exchanges that fostered intermittent Frankish-Armenian ties, though driven more by realpolitik than ideological alignment.^[15]

Strategic Maneuvers Against Regional Powers

To counterbalance the existential threats posed by neighboring Muslim emirates and the Byzantine Empire, Thoros II pursued pragmatic diplomatic initiatives that exploited internecine rivalries among regional adversaries. In the wake of Sultan Mas'ud I's death in 1157, Thoros cultivated amicable ties with his successor, Kilij Arslan II of the Seljuk Sultanate of Rûm, formalized through a peace treaty in 1158. This accord neutralized incursions from Anatolian Turkish forces along Cilicia's northern frontiers, enabling Thoros to concentrate defenses against more immediate raids emanating from Zengid-held territories in northern Syria, such as Aleppo.^[5]^[16] The treaty drew scrutiny from Zengid ruler Nur ad-Din, who publicly rebuked Kilij Arslan for consorting with Christian potentates, underscoring how Thoros's overture sowed discord between the Rûm Seljuks and Syrian Zengids—rival Muslim powers vying for dominance in the Levant. By positioning Cilicia as a neutral buffer amenable to Seljuk interests, Thoros indirectly forestalled coordinated assaults from the east and south, preserving his principality's precarious sovereignty amid fragmented Islamic polities.^[16] Concurrently, Thoros navigated Byzantine imperial ambitions through calculated submission. Following Manuel I Komnenos's victorious campaign into Cilicia in 1158, which routed both Seljuk and Armenian forces en route to Antioch, Thoros proffered fealty to the emperor, securing nominal investiture as Cilicia's governor under Byzantine suzerainty. In practice, this concession granted him substantial administrative latitude and military leeway, forestalling outright annexation while Manuel prioritized other fronts; a Byzantine official retained titular oversight, but Thoros wielded de facto control over local garrisons and revenues.^[11]^[10] This temporizing diplomacy bought time for internal consolidation, as Thoros evaded stricter enforcement by leveraging Manuel's distractions with Norman Sicily and internal Seljuk upheavals.^[11]

Later Reign and Death

Final Byzantine Incursions and Capture by Nur ad-Din

In 1158, Emperor Manuel I Komnenos launched a major expedition into Cilicia, advancing from Antioch with a large army that compelled Thoros II to retreat into the Taurus Mountains and seek refuge in the fortress of Dadjig.^[17] Thoros, recognizing the overwhelming Byzantine forces, submitted to Manuel's authority, accepting nominal suzerainty while retaining limited local governance under a Byzantine-appointed administrator.^[11] This arrangement restored Byzantine control over key Cilician cities such as Tarsus, Adana, and Mamistra, marking the culmination of repeated imperial efforts to reassert dominance over the region since John II's campaigns in the 1130s. Despite the submission, tensions persisted, and by 1163 Thoros rebelled against the Byzantine governor, exploiting Manuel's distractions in Anatolia and the Levant to reclaim autonomy in parts of Cilicia.^[11] Manuel's response was limited, prioritizing alliances with crusader states over full reconquest, which allowed Thoros to consolidate his position temporarily. However, this fragile independence faced escalating threats from Zengid forces under Nur ad-Din, whose expansions in northern Syria aimed to encircle Armenian and crusader territories. In summer 1164, Nur ad-Din exploited the absence of King Amalric I of Jerusalem—engaged in Egypt—to besiege Harim, a key fortress on Cilicia's frontier with Antiochene lands. Thoros joined a relief coalition led by Bohemond III of Antioch and Raymond III of Tripoli, comprising around 500 knights and several thousand infantry, confronting Nur ad-Din's army of approximately 10,000 on August 12 near Harim.^[18] The Zengids routed the Christians, capturing Bohemond, Raymond, and most leaders, while Nur ad-Din seized Harim shortly thereafter, severely weakening regional defenses. Thoros evaded personal capture, withdrawing to Cilicia, but the defeat exposed his principality to further raids and highlighted the precarious balance between Byzantine overlordship and Muslim incursions.^[19]

Escape, Final Years, and Succession

In 1164, during a Zengid incursion led by Nur ad-Din's forces, Thoros II was captured at Mamistra while defending Cilician territories.^[20] He escaped the following year, 1165, with assistance from Frankish allies who facilitated his release through ransom or negotiation, allowing him to resume control over Armenian Cilicia.^[20] During his final years, Thoros II faced internal family strife, particularly with his brother Mleh, who quarreled with him over governance and attempted an assassination before fleeing to the court of Nur ad-Din in Aleppo, where Mleh converted to Islam to secure Zengid support.^[20] Thoros maintained alliances with Crusader states to counter ongoing threats from both Byzantine remnants and Muslim powers, though primary chronicles like those of Smbat Sparapet note his increasing reliance on monastic retreat amid these pressures.^[20] Thoros II died on 6 February 1169 and was buried at the Monastery of Drazark (Trazark).^[20] He was succeeded by his young son, Roupen (Ruben) II, born around 1165, under the regency of a Frankish lord named Thomas, as recorded in the Chronique Rimée de la Petite Arménie by Vahram of Edessa.^[20] This succession was immediately contested by Mleh, who, leveraging his ties to Nur ad-Din, invaded Cilicia with Turkish auxiliaries shortly after Thoros's death, deposing and murdering Roupen II in 1170 at Hromgla to claim the lordship.^[20]

Family and Personal Life

Marriages

Thoros II entered into his first marriage in 1149 with Isabelle de Courtenay, the daughter of Joscelin II, Count of Edessa, and his wife Béatrice.^[1] Isabelle, who died sometime between 1150 and 1159, was linked to the Crusader nobility through her father's county, which bordered Armenian Cilicia and facilitated alliances against common threats like the Seljuk Turks.^[1] This union, documented in medieval chronicles such as the Lignages d’Outremer and William of Tyre's history, strengthened Thoros's ties to Frankish lords amid his struggles to reclaim territories from Byzantine control.^[1] His second marriage occurred around 1164 to an unnamed daughter of Thomas, the regent of Cilicia.^[1] Thomas held significant influence in the Armenian principalities during Thoros's minority and early reign, and this match likely aimed to consolidate internal power amid external pressures from the Zengids and Byzantines.^[1] The Chronicle of Sempad references this alliance, underscoring its role in stabilizing Rubenid rule, though the wife's identity remains unspecified in primary accounts.^[1] Alternative traditions, such as those suggesting an earlier union with a daughter of Simon of Raban, lack corroboration from contemporary sources like William of Tyre and appear less reliable.^[1]

Children and Descendants

Thoros II's first marriage to Isabelle de Courtenay, daughter of Joscelin II of Edessa, contracted in 1149, produced two daughters.^[1] The elder, Rita, born around 1150, married Hethum III of Lampron circa 1153; the union ended in divorce between 1168 and 1169.^[1] Rita's descendants through Hethum integrated into the Lampron branch of Armenian nobility, though specific lineages beyond immediate heirs are sparsely documented in contemporary chronicles like Sempad's Chronique du Royaume de la Petite Arménie.^[1] The younger daughter, unnamed in sources, married Isaakios Doukas Komnenos, a Byzantine governor, around 1175–1176 and predeceased her spouse before 1182; her offspring, if any, did not notably influence Cilician Armenian succession.^[1] His second marriage, in 1164, to an unnamed daughter (and great-niece) of the regent Thomas, yielded one son, Rupen II, born circa 1165.^[1] Rupen II succeeded Thoros II as lord in 1168 under Thomas's guardianship but was murdered in 1170 at age five, limiting direct records of his progeny in sources such as the Lignages d'Outremer.^[1] The Rupenian dynasty persisted through Rupen II's line, with his son Ruben III assuming rule from 1175 to 1187, though some genealogical accounts based on later compilations debate the immediacy of this succession due to the brevity of Rupen II's life and regency.^[1] No other children are attested in primary medieval records, such as those of Sempad the Constable.^[1]

Legacy and Historiography

Achievements in Defending Armenian Independence

Thoros II's escape from Byzantine captivity in Constantinople around 1143 enabled him to rally Armenian forces in the Taurus Mountains and initiate a campaign to reclaim Cilician territories under imperial control. By 1151, he launched a decisive assault on Mamistra, where he killed the Byzantine governor Thomas and routed the army led by Andronikos Komnenos, securing control over key strongholds like Anazarba and Vahka.^[1] These victories expelled Byzantine garrisons from much of Cilicia, restoring de facto Armenian autonomy in the region after years of imperial dominance following the 1137 kidnapping of Thoros and his family.^[1] To counter ongoing threats from Seljuk and Danishmendid raiders, Thoros forged alliances with Crusader principalities, including providing refuge to Joscelin II of Edessa after the city's fall in 1144 and coordinating joint operations with Renaud of Antioch, such as the 1156 invasion of Cyprus and raids into Syrian territories in 1157.^[1] These pacts not only diverted Muslim attention from Cilicia but also facilitated the recapture of border fortresses, bolstering defenses against incursions from the east. Chroniclers like William of Tyre note Thoros's tactical acumen in leveraging such coalitions to maintain territorial integrity amid encirclement by larger powers.^[1] Despite temporary submission to Emperor Manuel I Komnenos during the 1158 invasion—fleeing to the fortress of Dadjig before accepting nominal suzerainty—Thoros exploited Byzantine distractions to reassert control, suppressing internal rivals and repelling localized Seljuk probes through fortified mountain redoubts.^[1] His regency for nephew Stephané until 1165 further stabilized the realm, with military successes in reclaiming disputed lands post-Stephané's murder, ensuring Cilician Armenia's survival as an independent polity capable of resisting assimilation into Byzantine or Zengid spheres until his death in 1169.^[1]

Assessments in Historical Sources and Modern Scholarship

In medieval Armenian chronicles, such as the continuation of Matthew of Edessa by Gregory the Priest, Thoros II is portrayed as a steadfast defender of Cilician independence, enduring captivity in Constantinople from 1137 to 1144 before escaping to reclaim his territories and resist Byzantine incursions, though criticized for occasionally defying traditional caution against superior foes. ^[21] Latin sources like William of Tyre's Historia rerum in partibus transmarinis gestarum describe him as a "noble and most powerful" figure who allied with Crusader states, contributing forces to battles such as Harim in 1164 against Nur ad-Din, reflecting a view of him as a reliable partner in the Frankish defense of the Levant. ^[8] Syriac chronicler Michael the Syrian similarly notes Thoros's military presence at key events, including assemblies with Latin and Armenian leaders, emphasizing his role in regional coalitions against Muslim advances. ^[22] Byzantine historiography offers a contrasting assessment, with Niketas Choniates labeling Thoros "devious, dissembling and crafty" for his repeated rebellions, such as the 1151 uprising that expelled imperial garrisons from Cilicia and raids into Cyprus in 1156, framing him as a treacherous vassal who undermined Manuel I Komnenos's authority despite nominal oaths of fealty. ^[21] This negative portrayal aligns with imperial records highlighting Thoros's opportunistic shifts between submission and defiance, including his flight to the Taurus Mountains in 1158 to evade Manuel's punitive campaign. ^[11] Modern scholarship appraises Thoros II as a pragmatic opportunist who consolidated Rubenid control over Cilicia amid power vacuums left by Seljuk and Byzantine distractions, leveraging alliances with Antioch and Tripoli to counter threats, though his autonomy often hinged on Crusader support rather than independent military dominance. ^[14] Historians note his diplomatic acumen in balancing Zengid pressures—evident in temporary truces with Nur ad-Din—yet critique his policies for fostering internal divisions, as seen in fraternal rivalries that weakened succession after his death in 1168. ^[23] Analyses of Byzantine-Armenian relations underscore that while Thoros achieved de facto independence until 1158, his eventual accommodations with Manuel reveal limits to his defiance against a centralized empire. ^[11]