Walter Matthau
Walter Matthau (October 1, 1920 – July 1, 2000) was an American actor and comedian celebrated for his rumpled appearance, gravelly voice, and portrayals of grumpy, everyman characters in film and theater.[1] Best known for originating the role of slovenly sportswriter Oscar Madison in Neil Simon's The Odd Couple on Broadway (1965) and reprising it in the 1968 film adaptation opposite Jack Lemmon, Matthau won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for his scheming lawyer in Billy Wilder's The Fortune Cookie (1966).[2] He earned two Tony Awards for his stage work, including Best Featured Actor for A Shot in the Dark (1962), and became a staple of Hollywood comedy through frequent pairings with Lemmon in films like The Front Page (1974), The Sunshine Boys (1975), and Grumpy Old Men (1993).[3] Born Walter John Matthow to impoverished Jewish immigrants Milton Matthow—a Russian-Jewish peddler—and Rose Berolsky—a Lithuanian seamstress—in New York City's Lower East Side, Matthau endured a challenging childhood marked by his father's abandonment when he was three years old.[4] His mother supported the family through sweatshop labor, and young Walter navigated the tenements while attending public schools and discovering an early passion for acting in Yiddish theater productions starting at age 11.[4] After graduating from Seward Park High School, he enlisted in the U.S. Army Air Forces during World War II, serving as a radioman-gunner on B-24 Liberator bombers with the Eighth Air Force's 453rd Bombardment Group in England, flying 25 combat missions over Europe and earning the Air Medal along with six battle stars.[5] Postwar, Matthau utilized the GI Bill to study acting at The New School's Dramatic Workshop in Manhattan, shortening his surname to Matthau and making his Broadway debut in 1948's Anne of the Thousand Days.[3] His theater career flourished in the 1950s and early 1960s with supporting roles in plays like Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter? (1955) and Once More, with Feeling (1958), before his Tony-winning turns propelled him to leading-man status.[6] Transitioning to film in the late 1950s, Matthau appeared in dramatic roles such as the villain Max in Charade (1963) opposite Cary Grant and Audrey Hepburn, but his comic genius shone in Billy Wilder collaborations, including The Apartment (1960) and The Fortune Cookie.[1] Over a six-decade career spanning more than 70 films, he also starred in family comedies like Dennis the Menace (1993) as Mr. Wilson and The Bad News Bears (1976) as Coach Buttermaker, often drawing on his world-weary persona while occasionally tackling dramatic parts, such as in Fail Safe (1964).[4] Matthau married actress Grace Geraldine Johnson in 1948 (divorced 1958, with whom he had two children, David and Jenny), then wed author Carol Grace in 1959, with whom he had a son, Charlie (also an actor and director); he remained with Grace until his death from a heart attack at age 79 in Santa Monica, California.[7][8]Early Years
Childhood and Education
Walter Matthau was born Walter John Matthow on October 1, 1920, in New York City's Lower East Side to poor Jewish immigrant parents. His father, Milton (or Melas) Matthow, was a Russian Jewish peddler and electrician from Kiev who abandoned the family when Matthau was three years old and died on August 30, 1935, when Matthau was 14. His mother, Rose Berolsky Matthow, a Lithuanian seamstress who worked long hours in sweatshops, raised Matthau and his older brother Henry amid constant financial hardship during the Great Depression; the family frequently moved between tenement apartments due to unpaid rent and evictions. A younger brother, Marvin, completed the family structure, though details on him are sparse.[8][9] Matthau's impoverished upbringing instilled a strong work ethic from an early age. Starting at 11, he took on jobs selling soft drinks and ice cream in the lobbies of Lower East Side Yiddish theaters to help support his mother, occasionally landing bit parts in productions that exposed him to the vibrant world of Jewish performance arts. These experiences, combined with attendance at Jewish nonprofit sleepaway camps like Tranquillity Camp and Surprise Lake Camp—where he participated in staged shows—fostered his initial interest in acting and comedy. He drew inspiration from comic figures like Milton Berle, whose vaudeville routines and radio broadcasts captivated him during his youth. Frequent moves and family struggles limited leisure, but Matthau found escape in self-directed pursuits, including reading and observing street life in the neighborhood.[8][10][11] Matthau received his formal education in the public schools of the Lower East Side, attending Public School 25, Junior High School 64, and Seward Park High School, from which he graduated around 1938. At Seward Park, a hub for many future performers, he excelled athletically, lettering in six sports, and engaged in student activities like dramatic productions and campaigns, honing skills that later informed his career. Though his schooling provided structure amid chaos, Matthau left formal education behind after graduation to focus on odd jobs, including work with the Civilian Conservation Corps in Montana and coaching boxing and basketball through the Works Progress Administration in New York City. His self-taught immersion in vaudeville shows, radio comedy, and Yiddish theater classics—often accessed through settlement houses and neighborhood venues—shaped his comedic timing and affinity for character-driven humor, setting the stage for his entry into military service as an escape from poverty.[8][12][10]World War II Service
Matthau enlisted in the U.S. Army Air Forces on April 11, 1942, at the age of 21.[5] His decision was influenced by his impoverished upbringing during the Great Depression, which left him seeking steady employment and structure amid economic hardship.[10] He underwent training and was assigned to the Eighth Air Force's 453rd Bombardment Group, where he served as a radioman, tail gunner, and cryptographer aboard Consolidated B-24 Liberator bombers stationed at RAF Old Buckenham in England.[8][13] Over the course of his service from 1942 to 1945, Matthau flew 25 combat missions targeting Nazi Germany and occupied Europe, including operations during the Battle of the Bulge.[8] These raids exposed him to intense peril, as B-24 crews faced heavy antiaircraft fire, fighter attacks, and mechanical failures at high altitudes over enemy territory.[14] Matthau later described the constant dread of these flights, noting close calls that heightened his sense of mortality, with one incident involving a near-miss that nearly led to a crash landing.[15] He flew alongside notable figures like James Stewart, who commanded the group, and credited the shared dangers with forging unbreakable bonds among the crew.[14] For his valor, Matthau rose to the rank of staff sergeant and received the Air Medal with three oak leaf clusters, along with six battle stars recognizing his participation in major campaigns.[8] Discharged in 1945, he returned to New York City and utilized the GI Bill to enroll in acting classes at The New School for Social Research's Dramatic Workshop, studying under the influential director Erwin Piscator.[16] The discipline gained from military routine provided a foundation for his structured approach to performance, while the cynicism born from wartime traumas deepened the world-weary, sardonic humor that defined his iconic comedic characters in films like The Odd Couple.[17]Acting Career
Early Work (1940s–1950s)
Following his discharge from the U.S. Army Air Forces in 1945, Walter Matthau used benefits from the GI Bill to enroll in acting classes at the New School for Social Research's Dramatic Workshop in New York City, where he studied under director Erwin Piscator. He later described the experience as challenging but formative, though he found the rigorous training demanding.[16] To supplement his income during this period, he took on odd jobs such as working as an usher at the Yiddish Theatre on Second Avenue.[18] Matthau began his stage career in earnest with off-Broadway productions and summer stock theater in 1947 and 1948, performing in regional repertory companies where he gained practical experience through rapid role changes and ensemble work. His Broadway debut arrived in December 1948 with Anne of the Thousand Days by Maxwell Anderson, where he served as an understudy for multiple roles, including an 83-year-old English bishop, while also appearing onstage as a servant; the production ran for nearly a year and earned him $100 per week.[19] He followed this in 1950 with a supporting role as a guard in the short-lived musical comedy The Liar, directed by George Abbott and based on Carlo Goldoni's work, which closed after just nine performances despite a cast including Alfred Drake.[20] These early stage efforts helped Matthau build a reputation for dramatic roles, often portraying authoritative or intense characters that contrasted with his emerging natural comic timing, though opportunities remained limited.[19] Matthau's initial forays into film and television were modest, consisting of small supporting parts that highlighted his versatility but did not yet lead to prominence. In 1955, he made his screen debut in Burt Lancaster's directorial effort The Kentuckian, playing the antagonistic Stan Bodine, a riverboat gambler and villain who wields a whip in confrontations.[21] On television during the early 1950s, he appeared in anthology series such as Suspense (1953), where he portrayed Lawrence Stevens in the episode "F.O.B. Vienna," and Studio One (1953), as Olsen in a dramatic segment.[22] Throughout the late 1940s and 1950s, Matthau faced significant challenges, including financial instability that forced him to juggle acting gigs with manual labor, and typecasting in secondary roles as heavies or villains due to his distinctive, craggy features and gruff demeanor.[23] The discipline honed during his World War II military service as a radioman-gunner proved invaluable in enduring the rigors of live theater and early rehearsals.[5] Despite these hurdles, his persistence in dramatic work laid the groundwork for broader recognition in the following decade.1960s Breakthrough
Matthau's Broadway career reached a significant milestone in 1962 with his performance as Benjamin Beaurevers in the farce A Shot in the Dark, directed by Marcel Achard and adapted by Harry Kurnitz, where he starred opposite Julie Harris.[24] His comedic timing and physicality in the role earned him the Tony Award for Best Featured Actor in a Play, marking his first major theatrical accolade and highlighting his emerging talent for blending sarcasm with slapstick.[25] This success built on his earlier stage experiences, positioning him for leading roles. In 1965, Matthau solidified his stage stardom as the slovenly sportswriter Oscar Madison in Neil Simon's The Odd Couple, opposite Art Carney's fastidious Felix Ungar, under Mike Nichols' direction.[26] The production ran for 964 performances and showcased Matthau's rumpled, irascible persona, earning him the Tony Award for Best Actor in a Play and critical praise for capturing the character's gruff charm amid domestic chaos.[27] Transitioning to film, Matthau took on dramatic roles that demonstrated his range beyond comedy, including the hawkish game theorist Dr. Groeteschele in Sidney Lumet's Fail-Safe, a tense Cold War thriller where his cold calculation contrasted sharply with his usual warmth.[28] These performances, released in 1964, garnered attention for Matthau's ability to convey intellectual detachment and moral ambiguity, paving the way for his cinematic breakthrough. Matthau's ascent to leading man status came with Billy Wilder's The Fortune Cookie (1966), where he portrayed the scheming ambulance-chasing lawyer Willie Gingrich, opposite Jack Lemmon, in a satire on insurance fraud.[29] His portrayal of the opportunistic yet endearing con artist won him the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor, transforming him from a reliable character player to a bankable star and establishing his sarcastic, world-weary archetype.[30] The film marked a pivotal shift, as Matthau's heart attack during production forced a production halt but ultimately reinforced his resilience and commitment.[8] This momentum carried into comedy with the 1968 film adaptation of The Odd Couple, directed by Gene Saks, reuniting Matthau as Oscar with Jack Lemmon as Felix and launching their legendary on-screen partnership of mismatched buddies.[31] Critics lauded the duo's chemistry, with Matthau's grouchy authenticity driving the film's humor about cohabiting opposites.[32] The movie grossed over $44 million domestically, ranking among the year's top earners and cementing Matthau's comedic dominance.[33] He extended this success in Cactus Flower (1969), playing the philandering dentist Julian Winston in Gene Saks' adaptation of the Broadway hit, opposite Ingrid Bergman and Goldie Hawn, where his flustered everyman antics contributed to the film's lighthearted appeal and commercial viability.[34] These 1960s achievements not only delivered Matthau's first major box-office hits but also fixed his image as the quintessential rumpled antihero, blending cynicism with underlying humanity.[35]1970s Success
Following his Academy Award-winning performance in The Fortune Cookie (1966), which established him as a leading comedic talent, Walter Matthau entered the 1970s with continued success through his enduring partnership with Jack Lemmon. In Kotch (1971), directed by Lemmon, Matthau portrayed Archie Koch, a cantankerous retiree resisting placement in a nursing home and forming an unlikely bond with a pregnant teenager, earning him an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor.[36] The film explored themes of aging and independence with warmth and humor, showcasing Matthau's ability to blend gruffness with vulnerability.[37] Their collaboration extended to The Front Page (1974), Billy Wilder's adaptation of the classic play, where Matthau played the scheming newspaper editor Walter Burns opposite Lemmon's reluctant reporter Hildy Johnson, delivering rapid-fire banter that highlighted their impeccable comic timing.[38] Matthau's versatility shone in dramatic roles that contrasted his comedic persona. In Charley Varrick (1973), directed by Don Siegel, he starred as the titular small-time crop-duster turned bank robber who uncovers a mob connection after a heist gone wrong, marking a rare action-oriented turn in his career and earning praise for his understated intensity in a neo-noir thriller.[39] Similarly, in The Sunshine Boys (1975), an adaptation of Neil Simon's play, Matthau played Willy Clark, a retired vaudeville comedian reuniting with his longtime partner (George Burns) amid bickering and reconciliation, which brought him another Academy Award nomination for Best Actor. The performance captured the pathos of faded showbiz glory, blending sharp wit with emotional depth. The decade also solidified Matthau's status in crowd-pleasing comedies that amplified his signature grumpy everyman archetype. The Bad News Bears (1976), directed by Michael Ritchie, featured him as Morris Buttermaker, a hard-drinking, ex-minor-league pitcher coaching a ragtag Little League team of misfits, whose cynical outlook softens through the kids' irreverence; the film was a major box-office hit, grossing over $42 million domestically.[40][41] In House Calls (1978), a romantic comedy co-starring Glenda Jackson, Matthau played Dr. Charles Nichols, a widowed surgeon navigating awkward post-loss dating until finding a match with a free-spirited divorcée, emphasizing his rumpled charm in lighthearted relational chaos.[42] He also appeared in California Suite (1978), Neil Simon's anthology of interconnected stories set at a Beverly Hills hotel, contributing to one vignette as a harried father dealing with family tensions during an awards ceremony.[43] Throughout the 1970s, Matthau's films consistently drew audiences, with him commanding fees up to $1.5 million per picture, reflecting his bankable appeal as the quintessential hangdog grouch whose world-weary sarcasm masked a relatable humanity.[16] This era refined his archetype from the scheming sidekicks of his earlier years into a multifaceted leading man capable of anchoring both laugh-out-loud farces and poignant character studies, cementing his place as one of Hollywood's most versatile comic actors.[16]1980s and 1990s Roles
In the 1980s, Walter Matthau embraced roles that leaned into his established persona as a world-weary everyman, often blending comedy with dramatic undertones suited to his advancing age. In I Ought to Be in Pictures (1982), directed by Herbert Ross and adapted from Neil Simon's play, Matthau portrayed Hollywood screenwriter Herbert Tucker, a lapsed father confronted by his aspiring actress daughter, delivering a performance noted for its emotional depth and humor in family reconciliation.[44] His collaboration with frequent co-star Jack Lemmon continued in Billy Wilder's Buddy Buddy (1981), where Matthau played the hitman Trabucco, a role that highlighted his deadpan timing amid the film's farcical plot involving a suicidal neighbor, though the movie received mixed critical response for its uneven pacing. Matthau's physical comedy shone in Roman Polanski's Pirates (1986), in which he starred as the bumbling, peg-legged Captain Red, a hapless swashbuckler on a quest for treasure; the film earned praise for Matthau's committed portrayal despite its overall critical panning as a lackluster adventure.[45] Later that decade, in The Couch Trip (1988), Matthau appeared as Donald Becker, a sly ex-priest and con artist who blackmails a fraudulent psychiatrist, contributing to the comedy's chaotic ensemble dynamic with his trademark wry skepticism.[46] The 1990s marked a resurgence for Matthau through age-appropriate character roles that capitalized on his gravelly voice and hangdog expression, often in buddy comedies and heartfelt dramas. His pairing with Lemmon proved especially lucrative in the Grumpy Old Men franchise, beginning with Grumpy Old Men (1993), where Matthau played Max Goldman, a cantankerous retiree locked in a rivalry with Lemmon's John Gustafson over a new neighbor; the film grossed over $70 million domestically, revitalizing Matthau's box-office draw in later years.[47] The sequel, Grumpier Old Men (1995), repeated the formula with Matthau reprising Goldman amid escalating pranks and romance, earning $71 million in North America and solidifying the duo's enduring on-screen chemistry. Matthau also took on more introspective parts, such as the retired Judge Cool in The Grass Harp (1995), a Southern Gothic drama directed by his son Charles Matthau, where his portrayal of a wise, eccentric elder was lauded for bringing warmth and nuance to Truman Capote's autobiographical tale.[48] In I'm Not Rappaport (1996), adapted from Herb Gardner's play, Matthau embodied Nat Moyer, an 81-year-old Jewish radical spinning tall tales on a Central Park bench with his friend Midge Carter (Ossie Davis), a role that earned acclaim for its poignant exploration of aging and resilience through Matthau's feisty delivery.[49] As Matthau entered his later years, his output slowed to about one film annually following health challenges including a 1976 heart bypass, shifting focus to roles that reflected maturity and vulnerability while preserving his comedic legacy.[1] In Out to Sea (1997), he reunited with Lemmon as con artists posing as dance hosts on a cruise ship, a lighthearted vehicle that underscored their rapport in senior-centric hijinks. Matthau's final on-screen role came in Hanging Up (2000), directed by Diane Keaton, where he played the irascible, ailing father Lou Mozell, providing a touching capstone to his career amid the story of estranged sisters. Throughout these decades, Matthau's work garnered nominations for later efforts, affirming his status as a comedy legend whose gravelly charm and improvisational flair continued to captivate audiences into the new millennium.[1]Personal Life
Marriages and Family
Walter Matthau was married twice during his lifetime. His first marriage was to Grace Geraldine Johnson on December 13, 1948; the couple divorced in 1958 after a decade together.[11] They had two children: son David, born November 2, 1953, who later became a radio news reporter, and daughter Jenny, born in 1956.[50][51] In 1959, Matthau married actress and author Carol Grace on August 21, following an affair that began when they met during the 1955 Broadway production of Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter?.[52][53] The marriage lasted 41 years until Matthau's death in 2000, and they had one son together, Charles "Charlie" Matthau, born December 10, 1962, in New York City; Charlie pursued a career in entertainment as a director.[54][55] Carol played a supportive role in family life, including helping manage Matthau's gambling habits, which occasionally strained their relationship.[52] Matthau's children showed varying involvement in the entertainment industry. From his first marriage, Jenny became a cooking instructor in Manhattan,[56] while David focused on journalism outside Hollywood. Charlie, from his second marriage, directed his father in films such as The Grass Harp (1995), a adaptation of Truman Capote's novella. The family emphasized privacy amid Matthau's fame, maintaining a low-profile home life.[57] The Matthaus resided in Pacific Palisades, California, relocating there in the late 1960s from Beverly Hills after initially renting a home from Paul Newman; their permanent residence at 578 Toyopa Drive was a five-bedroom Spanish-style house built in 1934, where they raised Charlie and enjoyed the ocean air and community seclusion.[58][59] The neighborhood's relaxed atmosphere allowed the family to avoid the spotlight typical of other celebrity enclaves.[60]Gambling Habit
Walter Matthau's gambling habit began in his youth on New York City's Lower East Side, where at age 6 he ran a card game called "Banker's Brokers" on the roof of his family's apartment building.[61] This early involvement in betting evolved during his World War II service, where he won significant sums playing poker as a radioman-gunner in the U.S. Army Air Forces, ending the war as a sergeant with six battle stars.[62][5] The habit escalated in the 1950s upon his entry into Hollywood circles, fueled by access to bookies and racetracks; by 1957, mounting debts prompted him to take the lead role in the television series Tallahassee 7000, signing over his earnings to a bookie to settle obligations accrued during production.[61] Matthau engaged heavily in horse racing, often at tracks like Santa Anita and Hollywood Park, as well as sports betting on basketball, baseball, and football, and card games including poker.[61][62] His losses were substantial; during a 1957 stint filming Tallahassee 7000 in Florida, he dropped $183,000 betting on spring-training baseball games, while in middle age he estimated his lifetime losses at $5 million, a figure he later revised upward to $50 million in a 1994 interview.[62][63] Despite his success as an actor, which brought high earnings, the habit strained his finances, with friends noting he bet thousands per race yet seemed "in there to lose," deriving thrill from the risk rather than victory.[61] In humorous interviews, Matthau quipped about his compulsion, once exclaiming, "I wish to hell I knew!" why he gambled, and his wife Carol observed, "You’re asking Fate if Fate loves you. It’s a big question to ask, and you ask it a lot."[10] The gambling intersected with his career, as debts occasionally influenced role choices, such as the 1957 series commitment, though it did not derail his rise to stardom.[61] Following a 1966 heart attack during the filming of The Fortune Cookie, attributed partly to gambling-related stress by his doctor, Matthau scaled back; by 1971, he bet only a couple hundred dollars per race, even on his own horses, and in later years limited stakes to $500 or $1,000 to avoid high-risk "heart attack bets."[62][63] The habit persisted into the 1990s but at a reduced level, with Matthau claiming diminished enjoyment, though a telltale groove in his thumb from nail-biting during races and games remained a visible remnant.[61][63]Health and Death
Matthau's health issues began prominently in 1966 when he suffered a severe heart attack while filming The Fortune Cookie, his first leading role in a Hollywood production. The episode, attributed to his heavy smoking of three packs a day and chronic stress from gambling debts, required immediate medical intervention but did not involve open-heart surgery at that time; instead, it marked the onset of lifelong cardiovascular problems. He quit smoking following the incident, which his doctor credited as a key factor in his survival.[62][8] Over the subsequent decades, Matthau endured multiple heart attacks—at least three in total—and was diagnosed with atherosclerosis, a condition that progressively narrowed his arteries. In 1976, he underwent quadruple coronary bypass surgery to address blockages, a procedure described as elective but necessary to prevent further incidents. Additional complications arose in 1993 after filming Grumpy Old Men in frigid Minnesota weather, leading to hospitalization for double pneumonia and another heart attack; around this period, he also received a pacemaker implant to regulate his heartbeat, with surgery occurring shortly before early 1994. These ongoing cardiac and respiratory challenges, exacerbated briefly by the stress of his gambling habit, limited his physical stamina and contributed to a general decline in vitality.[64][65][66] In his final years, Matthau experienced reduced mobility due to his heart condition and other age-related ailments, prompting him to select film roles that accommodated his energy levels, such as voice work or seated characters, and leading to his effective retirement from demanding stage performances after earlier successes like The Odd Couple. On June 30, 2000, he suffered a fatal heart attack at his home in Pacific Palisades, was rushed to St. John's Health Center in Santa Monica, and died the next day, July 1, at age 79 from myocardial infarction caused by atherosclerotic heart disease. A private funeral service was held for immediate family and close friends, after which he was buried at Pierce Brothers Westwood Village Memorial Park Cemetery in Los Angeles.[8][67][68]Filmography
Feature Films
Walter Matthau appeared in over 30 feature films throughout his career, beginning with small and uncredited roles in the 1950s and progressing to leading parts in comedies and dramas from the 1960s onward. He collaborated with Jack Lemmon in 10 films, starting with The Fortune Cookie in 1966. Matthau directed one feature film, Kotch (1971), in addition to his acting role in it.[69]Early Uncredited and Small Roles (1950s)
Matthau's film debut came in the mid-1950s with minor appearances that showcased his emerging screen presence.| Year | Title | Role | Director | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1955 | The Kentuckian | Uncredited | Burt Lancaster | Debut feature film. |
| 1955 | The Indian Fighter | Wes Toller | André De Toth | Supporting role as a trapper. |
| 1956 | Bigger Than Life | Wally | Nicholas Ray | Bit role as a schoolteacher. |
| 1957 | A Face in the Crowd | Mel Miller | Elia Kazan | Early supporting part in a political satire. |
| 1957 | Slaughter on Tenth Avenue | Al Dahlke | Arnold Laven | Supporting role as a union boss in crime drama.[70] |
| 1958 | King Creole | Maxie Fields | Michael Curtiz | Gangster role opposite Elvis Presley. |
| 1958 | Ride a Crooked Trail | Judge Kyle | Jesse Hibbs | Small role in Western. |
| 1959 | Gangster Story | Jack Martin | Walter Matthau | Lead role; Matthau's first writing and producing credit. |
Supporting Leads (1960s)
In the 1960s, Matthau transitioned to more prominent supporting roles, often playing cynical or authoritative figures, which led to his breakthrough as a leading man.| Year | Title | Role | Director | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1960 | Strangers When We Meet | Felix Anders | Richard Quine | Neighbor role in suburban drama. |
| 1962 | Lonely Are the Brave | Sheriff Morey Johnson | David Miller | Lawman pursuing Kirk Douglas. |
| 1963 | Charade | Hamilton Bartholomew | Stanley Donen | Mysterious agent; comic thriller with Cary Grant and Audrey Hepburn. |
| 1964 | Fail Safe | Groeteschele | Sidney Lumet | Hawkish professor in Cold War thriller. |
| 1964 | Mirage | Charles Calvin | Edward Dmytryk | Supporting in psychological mystery. |
| 1966 | The Fortune Cookie | Willie Gingrich | Billy Wilder | Scheming lawyer; first collaboration with Jack Lemmon; earned Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor. |
| 1968 | The Odd Couple | Oscar Madison | Gene Saks | Sloppy sportswriter; iconic role opposite Jack Lemmon; earned Academy Award nomination for Best Actor.[71] |
| 1969 | Cactus Flower | Julian Winston | Gene Saks | Dentist in romantic comedy with Ingrid Bergman and Goldie Hawn. |
| 1969 | Hello, Dolly! | Horace Vandergelder | Gene Kelly | Lead opposite Barbra Streisand in musical. |
Starring Roles in Comedies and Dramas (1970s–1990s)
Matthau starred in numerous lead roles during this period, excelling in character-driven comedies and occasional dramas, often reuniting with Lemmon and directors like Billy Wilder.| Year | Title | Role | Director | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1971 | Kotch | Joseph P. Kotcher | Walter Matthau | Retired man; Matthau's directorial debut; earned Academy Award nomination for Best Actor. |
| 1971 | A New Leaf | Henry Graham | Elaine May | Heir-turned-murderer in black comedy; also produced. |
| 1971 | Plaza Suite | (Multiple characters) | Arthur Hiller | Three vignettes; stage adaptation. |
| 1973 | Charley Varrick | Charley Varrick | Don Siegel | Bank robber in action thriller. |
| 1974 | The Taking of Pelham One Two Three | Lt. Zach Garber | Joseph Sargent | Transit cop in heist film. |
| 1974 | The Front Page | Walter Burns | Billy Wilder | Editor; with Jack Lemmon. |
| 1975 | The Sunshine Boys | Willy Clark | Herbert Ross | Vaudeville star; earned Academy Award nomination. |
| 1976 | The Bad News Bears | Morris Buttermaker | Michael Ritchie | Little League coach. |
| 1978 | California Suite | (Multiple characters) | Herbert Ross | Anthology film; with Michael Caine and Maggie Smith. |
| 1980 | Hopscotch | Miles Kendig | Ronald Neame | Ex-CIA agent in spy comedy. |
| 1980 | Little Miss Marker | Sorrowful Jones | Walter Bernstein | Bookie in remake with Julie Andrews. |
| 1981 | Buddy Buddy | Trabucco | Billy Wilder | Hitman; final film for Wilder and Lemmon collaboration. |
| 1982 | I Ought to Be in Pictures | Herbert Tucker | Herbert Ross | Father-daughter comedy with Dinah Manoff. |
| 1983 | The Survivors | Sonny Paluso | Michael Ritchie | Unemployed man with Robin Williams. |
| 1986 | Pirates | Capt. Thomas Bartholomew Red | Roman Polanski | Adventure comedy. |
| 1988 | The Couch Trip | Donald J. Becker | Michael Ritchie | Psychiatrist impersonator with John Heard. |
| 1991 | JFK | Senator Russell B. Long | Oliver Stone | Brief role in historical drama. |
| 1993 | Dennis the Menace | George Wilson | Nick Castle | Retiree tormented by neighbor kid. |
| 1993 | Grumpy Old Men | Max Goldman | Donald Petrie | Rival neighbor; with Jack Lemmon.[72] |
| 1995 | Grumpier Old Men | Max Goldman | Howard Deutch | Sequel; with Jack Lemmon and Ann-Margret. |
| 1995 | The Grass Harp | Judge Charlie Cool | Charles Matthau (son) | Supporting in Southern drama. |
| 1996 | I'm Not Rappaport | Nat Moyer | Herb Gardner | Park bench conversations with Ossie Davis. |
| 1997 | Out to Sea | Charlie Gordon | Martha Coolidge | Con artist on cruise; with Jack Lemmon. |
| 1998 | The Odd Couple II | Oscar Madison | Howard Deutch | Road trip sequel; with Jack Lemmon.[73] |
| 2000 | Hanging Up | Lou Mozell | Diane Keaton | Father in family dramedy with Meg Ryan and Diane Keaton. |