William Roth
William Victor Roth Jr. (July 22, 1921 – December 13, 2003) was an American Republican politician and attorney who represented Delaware in the United States Congress for thirty-four years, first as a member of the House of Representatives from 1967 to 1970 and then as a Senator from 1971 to 2001.[1][2] A fiscal conservative and World War II veteran, Roth focused his legislative efforts on reducing taxes and improving government efficiency.[3] Roth's most enduring legacy stems from his advocacy for tax reforms that promoted individual savings and economic growth. He sponsored the legislation creating the Roth IRA in 1997, a retirement account allowing after-tax contributions with tax-free qualified withdrawals, which has since become a cornerstone of personal finance planning.[3][4] Earlier, as co-author of the Kemp-Roth bill, he helped enact the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, which substantially lowered marginal income tax rates and was credited with stimulating job creation and expansion during the 1980s.[3][5] During his tenure as chairman of the Senate Committee on Finance from 1995 to 2001, Roth oversaw the passage of the IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998, which addressed taxpayer complaints by curbing abusive practices and enhancing agency accountability.[3] His career concluded with an unsuccessful reelection campaign in 2000 against Democrat Thomas Carper, amid investigations into his acceptance of improper gifts from a constituent, marking the end of his long service in the Senate.[1][6]
Early Life and Education
Upbringing and Family Background
William V. Roth Jr. was born on July 22, 1921, in Great Falls, Cascade County, Montana, to William Victor Roth and Clara Nelson Roth.[1][5] He was the younger of two children, with an older sister, Lucille, born in 1916.[3] Roth's father initially managed a grocery store in Great Falls before the family moved to Helena, Montana, where he oversaw operations at a brewery.[7][5] The family resided in Helena during Roth's formative years, where he was raised in a modest environment shaped by his father's business endeavors in the state's capital.[8]Academic Pursuits and Military Service
Roth attended public schools in Helena, Montana, graduating from Helena High School in 1939.[3] He spent one year at Montana State University in Missoula before transferring, eventually enrolling at the University of Oregon, from which he graduated in June 1943 with a Bachelor of Arts in business administration.[3] [1] During this period, he took graduate classes at Harvard Business School from 1942 to 1943 and entered Army ROTC there.[3] Following his undergraduate graduation, Roth enlisted in the U.S. Army as a private on June 12, 1943.[3] He completed Officer Candidate School and served as a platoon leader and instructor before being assigned to the Psychological Warfare Branch at General Douglas MacArthur's headquarters in August 1944, where he became chief of the Collation Department until September 1945.[3] Subsequently, he worked as a planner in the Collation Department and information chief of the Radio Division through 1946.[3] Roth was promoted to second lieutenant on November 11, 1943, first lieutenant on January 22, 1945, and captain on August 29, 1945; he received the Bronze Star Medal on September 17, 1945.[3] He was honorably discharged in 1946.[3] [1] After his military service, Roth returned to Harvard, completing an MBA at Harvard Business School in February 1947 and graduating from Harvard Law School in June 1949.[3] [1]Pre-Political Professional Career
Legal Practice and Civic Involvement
Following his graduation from Harvard Law School in June 1949, William V. Roth Jr. joined Hercules Powder Company as an attorney, initially managing defense contracts for the firm's Virginia plant.[3] He was admitted to the California State Bar in January 1950, reflecting his early professional mobility before settling in the East.[3] During the Korean War era, Roth served as a civilian plant attorney at the U.S. Army's Radford Arsenal, handling legal matters tied to munitions production under Hercules' contracts.[3] By 1955, Roth had relocated to Wilmington, Delaware, where he was appointed senior legal counsel at Hercules Powder Company's headquarters, overseeing corporate legal affairs for the chemical manufacturer over a 15-year tenure ending in 1964.[3] He gained admission to the Delaware State Bar in 1958, enabling full practice in his adopted state.[8] His role at Hercules focused on contract negotiation, regulatory compliance, and defense-related litigation, building expertise in industrial law amid post-World War II economic expansion.[5] Roth's civic engagement predated his elective office and centered on Republican Party organization and policy advocacy. While in Virginia post-law school, he chaired and presided over the Sixth District Young Republican Federation from 1952 to 1954, fostering grassroots mobilization among young conservatives.[8] Upon moving to Delaware, he was elected chairman of the Delaware Young Republicans in 1956 and served on the state's Republican Platform Committee, shaping party positions on economic and governmental issues.[8] In 1957, Roth co-chaired the Delaware Citizens Committee for the Hoover Report, a nonpartisan effort to promote government efficiency recommendations from the Commission on Organization of the Executive Branch, emphasizing fiscal restraint and administrative reform.[3] These activities positioned him as an emerging leader in Delaware Republican circles without holding public office.[3]Political Career
U.S. House of Representatives (1967–1971)
William V. Roth Jr., a Republican, was elected to Delaware's at-large U.S. House seat in the November 8, 1966, general election, defeating five-term Democratic incumbent Harris B. McDowell Jr. by capturing 56% of the vote to McDowell's 44%.[9] The victory marked a Republican gain in a district that had been held by Democrats since 1941, reflecting voter dissatisfaction with McDowell's long tenure and alignment with President Lyndon B. Johnson's policies amid growing opposition to the Vietnam War and federal spending.[9] Roth, a Wilmington lawyer and World War II veteran, campaigned on themes of fiscal conservatism, reduced government intervention, and support for Delaware's business interests, positioning himself as a fresh alternative to entrenched Washington leadership.[3] Roth was sworn into the 90th Congress on January 3, 1967, representing the state's sole House district, which encompassed all of Delaware's population of approximately 500,000 residents at the time.[1] He was reelected in 1968 against Democrat James S. Loeb Jr., securing another term in the 91st Congress with a comfortable margin amid national Republican gains.[8] Roth declined to seek a third House term in 1970, instead announcing his candidacy for the U.S. Senate seat vacated by retiring Republican John J. Williams, and resigned from the House effective December 31, 1970, upon his Senate election victory.[1] In the House, Roth focused on foreign policy and judicial matters through key committee assignments. He served on the Committee on Foreign Affairs from 1967 to 1968, participating in discussions on international alliances and U.S. commitments abroad, including a role in the House Republican Committee on Western Alliances that honored former President Dwight D. Eisenhower.[10] Later, he joined the Committee on the Judiciary, where he contributed to oversight of federal legal and constitutional issues.[3] Roth's early legislative efforts emphasized fiscal restraint and tax policy foundations that would define his later career, though specific bills from this period were preparatory rather than landmark, aligning with his advocacy for limited government spending amid the era's debates over Great Society programs and defense budgets.[3] His House service established him as a proponent of supply-side economic principles, critiquing excessive taxation as a barrier to growth, even as he navigated a Democratic-majority Congress.[11]U.S. Senate (1971–2001)
William V. Roth Jr. assumed office as a United States Senator from Delaware on January 1, 1971, after winning the 1970 election to succeed Republican incumbent John J. Williams, who retired and resigned early to allow Roth to gain seniority.[1] Roth, a Republican, held the seat for five terms spanning thirty years, until January 3, 2001.[3] He was reelected in 1976, 1982, 1988, and 1994, reflecting sustained voter support in a state with divided partisan loyalties.[1] In the 2000 election, Roth sought a sixth term but lost to Democratic challenger Thomas R. Carper, the former governor, in a contest marked by national Republican challenges and Roth's age of 79.[12] His defeat ended three decades of Republican representation in Delaware's Class 1 Senate seat.[1] Roth's Senate service emphasized oversight of government operations and economic policy, positions aligned with his prior House experience.[3] Described as diligent and conscientious, he prioritized legislative diligence amid evolving partisan dynamics.[3]Committee Assignments and Leadership Roles
Upon his election to the U.S. Senate in 1971, William V. Roth Jr. received assignments to the Committee on Banking and Currency (later renamed Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs), the Committee on Government Operations (predecessor to the Committee on Governmental Affairs), and the Foreign Relations Committee.[10] He continued service on the Banking Committee into subsequent years, including its Subcommittee on Housing and Urban Affairs in 1972, and maintained involvement in foreign relations matters.[10] Roth joined the Senate Finance Committee in 1974, serving continuously until his retirement in 2001, which positioned him as a key figure in tax and fiscal policy deliberations.[13] Additional assignments included the Senate Budget Committee, Select Committee on Intelligence, Select Committee on Small Business in 1974, and committees such as Commerce, Science, and Transportation as well as Judiciary later in his tenure.[13] He also participated in joint committees, including the Joint Economic Committee and the Joint Committee on Taxation starting in 1995.[10] In leadership roles, Roth chaired the Committee on Governmental Affairs from 1981 to 1986, overseeing government oversight and efficiency initiatives, and briefly again from January 3, 1995, to October 1, 1995, following the Republican majority shift after the 1994 elections.[10] [8] During this period, he also led the Governmental Affairs Committee's Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations from 1981 to 1985 and in 1995.[10] His most prominent leadership came as chairman of the Senate Finance Committee from 1995 to 2000, succeeding Bob Packwood after the latter's resignation, where he influenced major tax reforms including the creation of the Roth IRA.[8] Additionally, he served as chairman of the Joint Committee on Taxation in 1996.[10]Legislative Achievements and Policy Positions
Tax Reform Initiatives
Roth co-sponsored the Kemp-Roth tax cut bill with Representative Jack Kemp in 1978, proposing a 30 percent reduction in individual income tax rates implemented in three annual 10 percent increments to promote economic growth through lower marginal rates and incentives for work and investment.[14] Although the original bill did not pass Congress, its supply-side principles influenced the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, which enacted a 25 percent across-the-board cut in individual income tax rates phased in over three years, reducing the top marginal rate from 70 percent to 50 percent.[15] As a member of the Senate Finance Committee, Roth advocated for comprehensive tax reform during the 1980s, including alternative Republican proposals emphasizing rate reductions and base broadening to simplify the code while maintaining revenue neutrality.[16] He supported the Tax Reform Act of 1986, which lowered the top individual income tax rate from 50 percent to 28 percent, eliminated several deductions, and increased the standard deduction and personal exemption to broaden the tax base and reduce distortions in economic decision-making.[17] Roth proposed amendments during its consideration, such as retaining the alcohol fuel tax credit to advance energy policy goals alongside reform.[18] Roth's most enduring tax initiative was the creation of the Roth IRA, enacted as part of the [Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997](/page/Taxpayer Relief Act_of_1997), which permitted individuals to contribute after-tax dollars to retirement accounts with tax-free qualified withdrawals, contrasting with traditional IRAs' upfront deductions but taxed distributions.[19] First proposed by Roth and Senator Bob Packwood in 1989 as an "IRA Plus" to expand retirement savings options amid prior restrictions on deductible IRAs under the 1986 Act, the provision aimed to encourage long-term saving by deferring taxation until consumption in retirement.[20] By 1998, Roth IRAs became available, growing to hold trillions in assets and influencing subsequent policies like Roth 401(ks, reflecting Roth's focus on individual financial autonomy over government-managed retirement systems.[21]Government Oversight and Fiscal Responsibility Efforts
Throughout his Senate tenure, William Roth served on the Committee on Governmental Affairs, where he chaired the Subcommittee on Oversight of Government Management and prioritized investigations into federal waste, fraud, and abuse. In a June 9, 1981, hearing, Roth presided over examinations of inefficiencies across government programs, emphasizing the need to identify and eliminate such issues as a core component of fiscal discipline.[22] These efforts highlighted systemic vulnerabilities in federal operations, advocating for stricter accountability to curb unnecessary expenditures. Roth advanced fiscal responsibility through legislative proposals to reform the budgeting process, including introduction of a two-year budget cycle designed to provide greater stability and reduce short-term political manipulations of spending.[3] This initiative aimed to enforce long-term deficit reduction by limiting annual disruptions and promoting sustained oversight of outlays, aligning with his broader push against unchecked federal growth. As Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee from 1995 to 2001, Roth spearheaded high-profile hearings into Internal Revenue Service (IRS) practices, beginning in September 1997 with probes into alleged employee misconduct and taxpayer abuses.[23] The investigations revealed outdated management, abusive collection tactics, and inefficiencies costing billions in lost revenue and compliance burdens, prompting bipartisan reforms. These culminated in the IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998, which the Senate passed 97-0 on May 7, 1998, establishing an independent oversight board, shifting to taxpayer rights protections, and modernizing technology to enhance enforcement without expanding bureaucracy.[24] Roth's role in these reforms directly addressed fiscal leakages by improving tax collection efficacy and reducing administrative waste, reflecting his principle that effective oversight precedes sustainable revenue policies.Controversies and Criticisms
Debates Over Tax Policies
Roth co-sponsored the Kemp-Roth bill in 1977, which proposed a 30% reduction in individual income tax rates over three years, later enacted as the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 reducing rates by 25% and lowering the top marginal rate from 70% to 50%.[25] Proponents, including Roth, contended that lower marginal rates would incentivize work, investment, and economic expansion by improving supply-side incentives, potentially offsetting revenue losses through broader growth.[26] Critics, however, warned that the cuts would exacerbate federal deficits without corresponding spending reductions; a Congressional Budget Office analysis projected that fully implementing the proposal would require a 10% cut in expenditures to avoid widening shortfalls, a condition unmet in practice.[27] Post-enactment outcomes fueled ongoing debate: federal revenues increased nominally from $599 billion in fiscal year 1981 to $991 billion by 1989 amid GDP growth averaging 3.5% annually and unemployment falling from 7.5% to 5.3%, which supply-side advocates attributed to the tax reductions' stimulative effects.[15] Detractors countered that deficits ballooned from $79 billion in 1981 to $221 billion by 1986, driven by the revenue shortfall—estimated at $200 billion over five years—and concurrent rises in defense and entitlement spending, rather than self-financing as some supply-siders implied via Laffer curve dynamics.[28] This disparity highlighted causal disagreements: while correlation with recovery existed, empirical assessments, including those questioning supply-side revenue elasticity claims, attributed much expansion to monetary policy easing and cyclical rebound rather than tax cuts alone, with high initial rates suggesting limited Laffer effects.[29] Roth's signature Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 introduced the Roth IRA, permitting after-tax contributions up to $2,000 annually (later increased) with tax-free qualified withdrawals, aimed at boosting retirement savings by deferring taxation until growth occurred.[30] Defenders praised it for encouraging long-term saving among middle-income households, with assets surpassing $1 trillion by 2023, potentially yielding higher after-tax retirement wealth under certain return assumptions.[19] Critics, including analyses from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities—a organization focused on low- and moderate-income policy impacts—argued it disproportionately benefited higher earners via income phaseouts exploitable through conversions and that the bulk of tax relief accrued to upper brackets, with minimal net wealth gains for participants since foregone government revenue could yield equivalent societal returns if invested.[30][31] Long-term revenue losses were projected at tens of billions annually, accelerating with backdoor strategies allowing high-income circumvention, prompting characterizations as a "budgetary con game" that shifted fiscal burdens intertemporally without enhancing overall taxpayer welfare.[32][33] Empirical studies reinforced that Roth accounts reduce federal receipts permanently post-conversion, forgoing future taxes on trillions in sheltered assets, though uptake remained concentrated among those already saving substantially.[31]Investigations and Personal Scrutiny
During his 30-year tenure in Congress, Senator William V. Roth Jr. faced no formal ethics investigations or reprimands from the Senate Select Committee on Ethics, unlike contemporaries such as Bob Packwood, who resigned amid sexual misconduct allegations that elevated Roth to the Finance Committee chairmanship in 1995.[34] The primary personal scrutiny Roth encountered occurred during his 2000 re-election campaign against Democrat Tom Carper, when his age (79) and health became focal points. Opponents highlighted incidents of Roth appearing to doze off during committee hearings and experiencing dizzy spells, portraying him as out of touch and ineffective after decades in office.[34][35] These criticisms contributed to Roth's narrow defeat on November 7, 2000, with Carper securing 55% of the vote to Roth's 45%, ending Roth's Senate career amid voter concerns over his fitness rather than substantive ethical lapses.[4]Later Life and Death
Retirement from Politics
In 2000, incumbent U.S. Senator William V. Roth Jr., aged 79 and seeking a sixth term, faced Democrat Thomas Carper, the former governor of Delaware, in the general election held on November 7.[3] Roth, who had chaired the Senate Finance Committee from 1995 to 2001, campaigned on his long record of tax reform and fiscal policy achievements, but his bid was undermined by concerns over his age and health.[6] Carper defeated Roth decisively, securing 55 percent of the vote to Roth's 44 percent, marking Roth's first electoral loss in over three decades of public service.[36] [4] Roth's Senate tenure concluded on January 3, 2001, after which he did not pursue further elected office, effectively retiring from active politics.[3] This defeat ended a 34-year congressional career that began in the House of Representatives in 1967.[13] Following his exit from the Senate, Roth focused on archival preservation of his congressional papers, donating over 1,000 boxes to the Historical Society of Delaware in 2001 and co-hosting a fundraising gala with former President George H. W. Bush on September 6, 2001, to support their maintenance.[3] While he briefly engaged in non-elected roles, such as co-chairing the U.S.-E.U.-Slovakia Action Commission to promote NATO expansion, these activities did not involve partisan campaigning or bids for office, solidifying his retirement from the political arena.[6]Final Years and Passing
After leaving the U.S. Senate on January 3, 2001, following his defeat in the 2000 election, Roth remained engaged in public affairs, serving as co-chairman of the U.S.-E.U.-Slovakia Action Commission, a private initiative aimed at assisting Slovakia's preparations for European Union membership.[6] In September 2001, he co-hosted a fundraising gala with former President George H. W. Bush at the Historical Society of Delaware to support preservation efforts for the DuPont Company powder yards, reflecting his continued ties to Delaware's historical and industrial heritage.[8] Roth resided primarily in Wilmington, Delaware, during his retirement but maintained a presence in Washington, D.C.[34] On December 13, 2003, at the age of 82, he collapsed while visiting his daughter in Washington and was admitted to George Washington University Hospital, where he died later that day from heart failure.[6][34][7] Delaware Governor Ruth Ann Minner ordered U.S. and state flags lowered to half-staff in his honor.[3]Legacy and Impact
Influence on Retirement Savings and Economic Policy
Roth's sponsorship of the Roth Individual Retirement Account (IRA) through the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 marked a pivotal advancement in U.S. retirement savings policy, allowing individuals to contribute after-tax income to accounts that grow tax-free and permit qualified withdrawals without taxation. This structure contrasted with traditional IRAs by deferring tax benefits to the back end, appealing to savers expecting higher future tax rates or desiring to avoid required minimum distributions during lifetime. Roth, as ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee, championed the provision to foster greater personal savings and self-reliance, building on his earlier efforts to enhance IRA contribution limits and promote family-oriented financial security.[3][19] The Roth IRA's implementation has facilitated billions in accumulated assets, with Investment Company Institute data showing IRAs collectively holding over $13 trillion by mid-2022, of which Roth accounts comprised a growing share due to their flexibility for younger workers and estate planning. Contribution rates among IRA-owning households reached 36% in 2022, reflecting uptake driven by the account's incentives, though critics argue it primarily reallocates existing savings rather than boosting aggregate national saving rates, as behavioral responses to tax preferences often substitute for other investments without net increases in wealth accumulation.[37][31] Empirical analyses, such as those examining post-1997 contribution surges, attribute some growth to heightened awareness and information dissemination rather than inherent savings stimulation.[38] Beyond retirement vehicles, Roth exerted influence on broader economic policy as a proponent of supply-side tax reforms, co-authoring the Kemp-Roth provisions in the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, which slashed top marginal income tax rates from 70% to 50% and indexed brackets for inflation to curb revenue erosion. These measures, enacted under President Reagan, aligned with Roth's fiscal conservatism and aimed to incentivize investment and labor supply, correlating with GDP growth averaging 3.5% annually in the subsequent decade amid reduced inflation. As Finance Committee chairman from 1995 to 2001, he advanced bipartisan initiatives to raise 401(k and SIMPLE plan limits—proposing $15,000 and $10,000 maxima, respectively—and enable after-tax contributions with Roth-like features, embedding retirement security into pro-growth tax frameworks while prioritizing individual accounts over expanded public entitlements.[39][40]Electoral Record and Political Influence
William V. Roth Jr. was first elected to the U.S. House of Representatives from Delaware's at-large district on November 8, 1966, defeating incumbent Democrat Harris B. McDowell Jr. with 56% of the vote.[9] He secured reelection on November 5, 1968, against Democrat James S. Loeb Jr., maintaining his seat until resigning in December 1970 to pursue a Senate bid.[1] Roth transitioned to the Senate by winning the election on November 3, 1970, to succeed retiring Republican John J. Williams, defeating Democrat Jacob W. Zimmerman with 58.83% of the vote (94,979 votes to 64,740).[41] He was reelected in 1976 against Democrat Thomas C. Maloney (55.81%, 125,502 votes), 1982 against Democrat Joseph Biden (54.99%), 1988 against Democrat Dennis Alaskey (59.35%), and 1994 against Democrat Charles M. Oberly III (55.81%, 111,088 votes).[42][43] Roth lost his bid for a sixth term on November 7, 2000, to Democrat Thomas R. Carper (43.70%, 142,891 votes to Carper's 55.53%).[44] These victories, often by comfortable margins in a politically competitive state, reflected Roth's enduring appeal among Delaware voters, particularly on fiscal conservatism.[1]| Election Year | Office | Party | Votes | Percentage | Opponent | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1966 | U.S. House (DE-AL) | Republican | ~91,000 | 56% | Harris B. McDowell Jr. (D) | [9] |
| 1968 | U.S. House (DE-AL) | Republican | Won | N/A | James S. Loeb Jr. (D) | [1] |
| 1970 | U.S. Senate (DE) | Republican | 94,979 | 58.83% | Jacob W. Zimmerman (D) | [41] |
| 1976 | U.S. Senate (DE) | Republican | 125,502 | 55.81% | Thomas C. Maloney (D) | [42] |
| 1982 | U.S. Senate (DE) | Republican | Won | 54.99% | Joseph Biden (D) | [1] |
| 1988 | U.S. Senate (DE) | Republican | Won | 59.35% | Dennis Alaskey (D) | [1] |
| 1994 | U.S. Senate (DE) | Republican | 111,088 | 55.81% | Charles M. Oberly III (D) | [43] |
| 2000 | U.S. Senate (DE) | Republican | 142,891 | 43.70% | Thomas R. Carper (D) | [44] |
Electoral History
House Elections
William V. Roth Jr. was first elected to the United States House of Representatives in the 1966 election for Delaware's at-large congressional district, defeating the incumbent Democrat Harris B. McDowell Jr., who had held the seat for five terms since 1955.[9] Roth, a Republican challenging McDowell amid national Republican gains following the 1966 midterm backlash against President Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society programs, captured 56% of the vote in a state that had been Democratic-leaning in federal races.[9] This victory marked a shift in Delaware's representation, as Roth emphasized fiscal conservatism and opposition to expansive federal spending.[1] Roth sought reelection in 1968 against the same opponent, McDowell, in a rematch during a year of national turbulence including the Vietnam War and assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy.[9] Benefiting from Richard Nixon's presidential plurality in Delaware and continued voter dissatisfaction with Democratic policies, Roth expanded his margin to 59% of the vote, securing a second term.[9] His reelection reflected growing Republican strength in the state, where he won majorities in all three counties—New Castle, Kent, and Sussex—despite urban Democratic strongholds.[9]| Election Year | Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1966 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | - | 56% |
| 1966 | Harris B. McDowell Jr. | Democrat | - | 44% |
| 1968 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | - | 59% |
| 1968 | Harris B. McDowell Jr. | Democrat | - | 41% |
Senate Elections
William Roth first won election to the U.S. Senate from Delaware on November 2, 1970, securing the Republican nomination after incumbent Republican Senator John J. Williams announced his retirement.[1] Roth defeated Democratic nominee Jacob Zimmerman with 58.83% of the vote in the general election.[41] This victory marked the beginning of Roth's 30-year tenure in the Senate, during which he established himself as a consistent winner in a state with a competitive political landscape.[13] Roth was reelected to the Senate four times—in 1976, 1982, 1988, and 1994—each time defeating Democratic challengers by comfortable margins that typically exceeded 10 percentage points.[1] His opponents included state officials and party nominees such as Thomas C. Maloney in 1976, David N. Levinson in 1982, Lieutenant Governor Shien Biau Woo in 1988, and Attorney General Charles M. Oberly III in 1994.[42][47][48] Roth's strongest performance came in 1988, where he garnered 62.06% against Woo.[48] These victories reflected his popularity on fiscal conservatism and seniority, despite Delaware's history of alternating party control in federal offices.[3] Roth sought a sixth term in 2000 but lost to former Governor Thomas R. Carper, who captured 55.5% of the vote to Roth's 43.7%.[49] The defeat ended Roth's Senate career after 30 years, amid a national Republican wave but local factors favoring Carper's executive experience.[13] The following table summarizes Roth's Senate general election results:| Year | Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage | Opponent(s) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1970 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | 94,979 | 58.83% | Jacob Zimmerman (D) | [41] |
| 1976 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | 125,502 | 55.81% | Thomas C. Maloney (D) | [42] |
| 1982 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | 105,357 | 55.17% | David N. Levinson (D) | [47] |
| 1988 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | 151,115 | 62.06% | S. B. Woo (D) | [48] |
| 1994 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | 111,088 | 55.81% | Charles M. Oberly III (D) | [43] |
| 2000 | William V. Roth Jr. | Republican | 142,891 | 43.7% | Thomas R. Carper (D) | [49] |