C86 is a cassette compilation released by the British music magazine New Musical Express (NME) in May 1986, featuring 22 tracks from emerging independent bands such as Primal Scream, The Pastels, Shop Assistants, The Wedding Present, and Stump.[1][2][3] The album, available via mail order for £2.95 plus coupons from the magazine, captured the vibrant, lo-fi indie scene of the mid-1980s and sold approximately 40,000 copies, making it NME's best-selling compilation at the time.[1][4] Its release marked a shift in the term "indie" from denoting independent distribution to describing a specific guitar-based pop style characterized by jangly guitars, melodic hooks, and DIY aesthetics.[2][5]The compilation emerged from NME's tradition of promotional cassette series, which began with C81 in 1981—a broader showcase of post-punk, reggae, and new wave acts that sold 25,000 copies and encouraged further efforts.[3][5] Curated by NME journalists Roy Carr, Neil Taylor, and Adrian Thrills, C86 narrowed the focus to unsigned or indie-label acts from outlets like Rough Trade, Postcard Records, and Creation, reflecting the regional diversity of the UK scene beyond London, including bands from Glasgow and Manchester.[3][2] Tracks like The Pastels' "It's My Own Cheering" and Primal Scream's "Velocity Girl" exemplified the tape's emphasis on upbeat, fuzzy pop with influences from 1960s garage rock and 1980s post-punk, though the selection process involved compromises as some bands submitted weaker material.[2][4]Despite contemporary criticism for promoting a perceived "anemic" or overly whimsical sound—often labeled as "twee"—C86 has been reevaluated as a diverse snapshot of politically engaged, experimental indie music, with acts like McCarthy addressing leftist themes and others incorporating surrealism or noise elements.[2] Its legacy endures through 1987 reissues by Rough Trade, 2014 deluxe editions adding 50 bonus tracks, and its role in inspiring later indie waves, including shoegaze and Britpop bands like Belle & Sebastian and Pavement.[1][5] The compilation not only boosted careers—such as launching Primal Scream toward mainstream success—but also solidified the cassette as a medium for underground discovery in an era dominated by major-label rock.[3][2]
Background
Indie Music Scene in Mid-1980s UK
The indie music scene in the mid-1980s United Kingdom emerged as an evolution of the post-punk movement that had taken root in the late 1970s, characterized by experimental sounds, raw production, and a rejection of mainstream commercialism. Bands such as The Smiths, who rose to prominence with their literate, melancholic songwriting, exemplified the shift toward indie rock's introspective style, becoming one of the leading acts in the post-punk indie landscape by the mid-decade. Similarly, The Jesus and Mary Chain debuted in 1985 with their debut album Psychocandy, blending noise-pop distortion with pop melodies, while Primal Scream formed in 1982 and gained traction through their raw, garage-influenced sound, contributing to the burgeoning underground scene that spanned from Manchester to Glasgow. This period saw indie music diversify beyond post-punk's angular edges, incorporating elements of psychedelia and folk, as artists sought to create accessible yet subversive alternatives to the polished synth-pop dominating major labels.[6][7][8]Independent record labels played a central role in nurturing this scene, rising rapidly in response to the limitations of major-label gatekeeping. Rough Trade, founded in 1978 as a cooperative shop and label by Geoff Travis, became a cornerstone by releasing influential acts like The Raincoats and supporting feminist and punk-adjacent artists, while its distribution arm, The Cartel, established in 1978, facilitated nationwide reach to independent shops. Factory Records, launched in Manchester in 1978 by Tony Wilson and Alan Erasmus, focused on innovative post-punk releases such as Joy Division's Unknown Pleasures in 1979, emphasizing artistic autonomy over commercial viability. Creation Records, started in 1983 by Alan McGee, quickly amplified the indie ethos with its promotion of raw, energetic bands, operating from a DIY perspective that prioritized underground gigs and limited runs. By 1980, the number of indie labels in Britain had exploded to over 800 from just a dozen at the start of the decade, enabling limited distribution through mail-order services, fanzines, and regional networks that bypassed major distributors.[9][10][11][12][13]Cultural and economic pressures under Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher's government from 1979 onward profoundly shaped this DIY revival, as her free-market policies led to widespread unemployment, factory closures, and social unrest, particularly in northern England and Scotland. These conditions reignited punk's rebellious spirit, fostering a grassrootsindie movement where musicians responded with defiant, community-driven creativity rather than polished production, as seen in politically charged tracks like The English Beat's "Stand Down Margaret" in 1980. The jangly guitar sound that defined much of mid-1980s indie—characterized by bright, arpeggiated Rickenbacker tones—drew heavily from 1960s influences like The Byrds' folk-rock harmonies and The Velvet Underground's raw, minimalist edge, adapted into a post-punk context to evoke nostalgia amid contemporary alienation. NME's indie charts, which began tracking sales in 1980 and grew significantly by 1984-1985 alongside Melody Maker's parallel listings, underscored this shift, highlighting underground hits and challenging the major labels' dominance by showcasing independent sales data. NME played a key role in amplifying these developments through dedicated coverage of the scene.[14][15][16][17][18]
NME's Promotion of Underground Music
New Musical Express (NME), established in 1952 as a weekly music newspaper by London promoter Maurice Kinn, initially concentrated on pop charts and mainstream coverage but evolved significantly in the 1970s to embrace rock and countercultural movements. By the mid-1970s, it positioned itself at the forefront of punk rock through provocative essays, such as Mick Farren's 1976 piece in NME that heralded the genre's arrival, and extensive reporting on emerging acts.[19][20] As punk transitioned into post-punk in the late 1970s and 1980s, NME continued championing underground sounds, reflecting the DIY ethos of the broader indie scene while prioritizing innovative and experimental music over commercial pop.[21]In the 1980s, NME introduced key initiatives to bolster independent music, including the independent chart launched in January 1980, which tracked sales of DIY and post-punk releases distributed outside major labels and served as a vital beacon for alternative acts like Spizzenergi. This chart, often featuring a top 20 rundown, provided weekly visibility to unsigned bands and small imprints, fostering radio play and international interest while countering the dominance of official charts. Writers like Paul Morley played a crucial role during this era, using bold reviews and interviews from the late 1970s through the early 1980s to mythologize and elevate unsigned post-punk groups such as Joy Division, thereby amplifying their cultural impact and aiding breakthroughs for indie talent.[18]NME further supported underground acts through practical promotions, such as flexi-disc giveaways bundled with magazine issues in the 1970s and early 1980s, and later cassette promotions, offering readers affordable access to tracks by emerging artists. In 1985, the magazine highlighted indie momentum with dedicated "Indie Top 20" features drawn from its chart data, spotlighting rising bands and encouraging reader engagement with the scene. Collaborations with distributors like Rough Trade exemplified NME's commitment, notably the 1981 C81 cassette—a free reader giveaway compiling 24 tracks from post-punk and indie outfits such as The Raincoats and Essential Logic—which not only showcased unsigned talent but also distributed music via the label's network, laying groundwork for future indie compilations.[22][23][24]
Creation and Production
Selection of Bands and Tracks
The curation of the C86 cassette was led by NME journalists Roy Carr, Neil Taylor, and Adrian Thrills, who assembled 22 tracks exclusively from unsigned bands and acts signed to independent labels, aiming to showcase the burgeoning UKindiemusic landscape of mid-1986.[25] This process was part of NME's ongoing series of promotional compilations, building on earlier efforts like C81 to highlight undergroundtalent amid the magazine's promotion of DIY and alternative scenes.[2]The selection criteria centered on a distinctive sound: jangly, lo-fi pop infused with punk-derived energy and amateurish charm, capturing what Taylor described as "an aural snapshot of the moment" in British indie music.[26] Tracks were drawn from the magazine's close ties to the indie circuit, including submissions and recommendations from independent labels like Rough Trade, Postcard, and Creation, prioritizing emerging acts that embodied this raw, guitar-driven aesthetic over more polished or divergent styles.[27] This focus intentionally emphasized the fanzine-fueled, regional DIY ethos, excluding broader indie variations to create a cohesive portrayal of the scene's vitality.Key selections underscored the compilation's role in spotlighting both nascent stars and overlooked talents, such as Primal Scream's debut "Velocity Girl," an energetic opener that introduced the Glaswegian group to a wider audience as contemporaries to acts like The Smiths in the post-punk indie continuum.[26] Other notable inclusions were The Wedding Present's "This Girl," exemplifying noisy jangle-pop, and lesser-known outfits like The Bodines with "Theresa," representing the Manchester scene's melodic undercurrents.[28]Challenges during curation included occasional refusals from bands wary of stylistic pigeonholing, such as the June Brides, who opted out fearing the tape would define their sound too narrowly, leading to exclusions based on artistic fit or clearance hurdles.[26] The process also navigated the logistical constraints of licensing from small labels, ensuring all tracks aligned with the cassette's informal, accessible vibe without venturing into high-production territory.[27]
Recording and Cassette Format
The C86 cassette was compiled in early 1986 by NME journalists Neil Taylor, Adrian Thrills, and Roy Carr as a showcase for emerging independent music, with production funded by the magazine and the tape duplicated by Ablex Audio Visual in Telford.[29][27] Released in May 1986, it featured a total runtime of approximately 60 minutes across 22 tracks sourced primarily from pre-existing recordings on independent labels, reflecting the DIY ethos of the era with simple mastering and minimal production interventions such as overdubs.[27][30] The double-sided cassette format was chosen for its accessibility and low cost in the mid-1980s indie scene, where vinyl pressing was expensive; no CD version existed until a 2014 reissue by Cherry Red Records.[2] Priced at £2.95 for mail-order purchase, the cassette's cover artwork adopted a handwritten-style design by Joe Ewart, emphasizing its underground, unpolished aesthetic.[4][29]Distribution focused on direct-to-fan channels to reach the indie audience, with initial sales handled exclusively through NME's mail-order service, supplemented by availability at independent record shops like Rough Trade.[29][30] The cassette achieved an estimated 40,000 copies sold, far exceeding expectations for a niche compilation and prompting Rough Trade to press a vinyl edition later that year to meet ongoing demand.[1][4] This logistical approach underscored the cassette's role in democratizing access to underground music amid limited major-label support.
Content and Release
Track Listing
The original C86 cassette compilation, released by NME in 1986, contained 22 tracks evenly divided between Side A and Side B, drawn from various independent record labels. These tracks were licensed for the compilation, reflecting the diverse indie scene of the time. The following table presents the complete ordered track listing, including artist, song title, duration, and the original label from which the track was licensed.[29]
Side
Track
Artist
Song Title
Duration
Original Label
A
1
Primal Scream
Velocity Girl
1:22
Creation
A
2
The Mighty Lemon Drops
Happy Head
2:42
Dreamworld
A
3
The Soup Dragons
Pleasantly Surprised
2:06
Subway Organization
A
4
The Wolfhounds
Feeling So Strange Again
1:41
Pink
A
5
The Bodines
Therese
3:09
Creation
A
6
Mighty Mighty
Law
3:40
Ron Johnson
A
7
Stump
Buffalo
4:30
Ron Johnson
A
8
Bogshed
Run To The Temple
3:28
Vinyl Drip
A
9
A Witness
Sharpened Sticks
2:30
Ron Johnson
A
10
The Pastels
Breaking Lines
2:59
Creation
A
11
Age Of Chance
From Now On, This Will Be Your God
3:12
Fon
B
1
Shop Assistants
It's Up To You
2:38
53rd & 3rd
B
2
Close Lobsters
Firestation Towers
1:48
Enigma
B
3
Miaow
Sport Most Royal
2:54
Factory
B
4
Half Man Half Biscuit
I Hate Nerys Hughes (From The Heart)
3:46
Probe Plus
B
5
The Servants
Transparent
2:36
Head
B
6
MacKenzies
Big Jim (There's No Pubs In Heaven)
2:34
Creation
B
7
Big Flame
New Way (Quick Wash And Brush Up With Liberation Theology)
1:37
Ron Johnson
B
8
We've Got A Fuzzbox And We're Gonna Use It
Console Me
1:24
Vindaloo
B
9
McCarthy
Celestial City
2:59
Pink
B
10
The Shrubs
Bullfighter's Bones
3:48
Ron Johnson
B
11
The Wedding Present
This Boy Can Wait (A Bit Longer!)
4:00
Reception
Subsequent reissues, such as the 2014 Cherry Red deluxe 3CD edition, retained this core track order but sometimes featured remastered audio or alternate mixes for select songs.[31] The original cassette's J-card insert integrated the track listing with small-print credits, production details, and black-and-white band photos, emphasizing the DIY aesthetic of the indie labels involved.[25]
Featured Bands and Styles
The C86 cassette compilation featured 22 independent bands from across the UK, showcasing a snapshot of the emerging indie scene in 1986. These acts, drawn from labels like Creation, Subway and Rough Trade, included Primal Scream, The Mighty Lemon Drops, The Soup Dragons, The Wolfhounds, The Bodines, Mighty Mighty, Stump, Bogshed, A Witness, The Pastels, Age of Chance, Shop Assistants, Close Lobsters, Miaow, Half Man Half Biscuit, The Servants, MacKenzies, Big Flame, We've Got a Fuzzbox and We're Gonna Use It, McCarthy, The Shrubs, and The Wedding Present.[29]Key acts exemplified the compilation's vibrant range. Primal Scream, hailing from Glasgow, contributed an early track that blended jangly indie pop with noisy edges, serving as a precursor to shoegaze influences in their later work.[2][32]The Wedding Present, from Leeds, delivered jangly indie pop characterized by driving rhythms and emotional lyricism, drawing from post-punk roots.[27][33]The Mighty Lemon Drops, based in Wolverhampton, infused 1960s garage rock influences like those from The Seeds and Nuggets-era bands into their melodic, psychedelic-tinged contributions.[34]The dominant C86 sound was defined by jangly guitars reminiscent of The Byrds, melodic hooks, short songs averaging 2-3 minutes, and lo-fi production that emphasized raw, DIY aesthetics.[27][35] This style drew influences from twee pop associated with labels like Sarah Records, as well as post-punk's angular energy and Phil Spector-inspired pop structures, often embracing musical "incompetence" as a form of rebellion against polished rock norms.[2][35]The lineup reflected regional diversity, with Scottish acts like The Pastels from Glasgow contributing lo-fi, introspective pop, Northern English bands such as The Bodines from Manchester adding buoyant jangle, and London-based groups like Stump bringing quirky, experimental energy.[2][35] Gender balance was notable, exemplified by The Shop Assistants, a Glasgow band with female vocalists and instrumentalists like Aggi Wright, fostering a more inclusive indie ethos.[35]Several bands achieved post-C86 success, transitioning to major-label deals and broader recognition. The Soup Dragons, for instance, signed with major labels and evolved into indie-dance with hits like their 1990 cover of "I'm Free."[35]Primal Scream later expanded their sound on albums like Screamadelica, while The Wedding Present sustained a prolific indie career.[27]
Reception
Critical Response
Upon its release in May 1986, NME promoted the C86 cassette as a vital "state of the nation" snapshot of the UK's burgeoning independent music scene, compiling 22 tracks from emerging bands to showcase the diversity and vitality of underground guitar music.[36] The magazine's internal coverage was overwhelmingly positive, emphasizing the compilation's role in democratizing access to indie sounds and highlighting its eclectic mix of jangly pop, shambling rhythms, and experimental edges.[26]Rival publications offered more mixed reactions; while Sounds magazine recognized its chart presence and lauded the raw energy of the featured acts, Melody Maker responded with ridicule and disgust, dismissing the collection as emblematic of anorak-clad, derivative jangle-pop that paled against broader musical developments.[37][38] Later commentary from critics like Simon Reynolds reinforced some of these dismissals, portraying C86's aesthetic as overly twee and rooted in a cult of whimsy and innocence that prioritized fey melodies over innovation.[39]Reader responses in NME's letters pages reflected strong enthusiasm from indie fans, who praised the cassette's accessibility and its spotlight on regional talent, including feminist-friendly outfits like the Shop Assistants.[2] Debates emerged around the inclusivity of female-led bands, with some correspondents celebrating the presence of acts like the Bodines and McCarthy while others questioned the overall representation in the male-dominated scene.[2]C86 received no formal awards, but it notably boosted indie chart visibility for standout tracks such as Primal Scream's opening cut "Velocity Girl," which climbed to prominence in specialist listings like Sounds' indie singles chart.[37][40] The compilation's initial sales exceeded 40,000 copies through NME mail order, underscoring its immediate appeal among dedicated listeners.[26]
Commercial Performance and Sales
The original C86 cassette, released by NME in May 1986 as a mail-order item priced at £2.50, sold out within weeks, demonstrating strong demand within the underground indie scene. By 1987, total UK sales were estimated at 40,000 units, making it the NME's best-selling compilation to date and prompting a reissue on LP and cassette by Rough Trade.[41][1]On the charts, C86 reached #13 on the UK Indie Chart, reflecting its niche appeal amid reliance on independent distribution networks like Rough Trade's mail-order system, which constrained mainstream exposure. Individual tracks boosted visibility for featured bands; for instance, The Shop Assistants' "It's Up to You" helped propel their earlier singles, such as "Safety Net," into the NME Indie Top 10. International distribution remained minimal in the initial years, with exports limited until later reissues expanded its reach.[41][1]The compilation's economic model embodied the DIY indie ethos, with low profit margins prioritizing artist support over commercial gain despite the modest sales volume. This structure underscored the era's emphasis on community and accessibility over high-volume profitability.[41]
Legacy and Influence
Impact on Indie and Alternative Music
The release of the C86 cassette in 1986 played a pivotal role in codifying what became known as the "C86 sound," characterized by jangly guitars, breezy vocals, and a DIY ethos that defined jangly indie pop. This aesthetic, often featuring lo-fi production and introspective lyrics, emerged as a distinct subgenre within independent music, distinguishing itself from the more aggressive post-punk and goth scenes of the era. Retrospective analyses, such as Nige Tassell's 2022 book Whatever Happened to the C86 Kids?: An Indie Odyssey, highlight how the compilation's track selection crystallized this sound, drawing on influences like The Byrds and 1960s garage rock while emphasizing amateurish charm over polished professionalism.[28]The C86 sound exerted significant influence on subsequent genres, particularly Britpop and shoegaze. Bands like Blur and Oasis in the Britpop movement of the 1990s drew directly from its jangly, guitar-driven template, incorporating C86's melodic pop sensibilities into their guitar-rock anthems and British cultural references. Shoegaze acts, such as My Bloody Valentine, evolved the style by layering C86's jangle with walls of distortion and reverb, creating ethereal soundscapes that marked a sonic progression from the cassette's raw indie pop. This influence extended across the Atlantic, where the C86 compilation inspired American indie scenes, including bands like Pavement and early Merge Records artists, who adopted its lo-fi, home-recorded approach to challenge mainstream rock dominance.[42][43][2]Despite its innovations, C86 also sparked the "anorak" stereotype, portraying fans as shy, bespectacled outsiders in raincoats, a image that both marginalized and romanticized the scene's participants. However, the cassette empowered a surge in DIY labels and grassroots activity, fostering the 1990s indie revival through imprints like Sarah Records, which amplified the twee and melodic elements of C86 while championing emotional vulnerability in indie pop. This expansion democratized music production, encouraging bedroom recordings and fanzine culture that sustained independent scenes amid the rise of major-label commercialization.[44][45][46]C86's cultural legacy endures through media retrospectives that celebrate its role in shaping alternative music's ethos of inclusivity and experimentation. A 2015 BBC documentary series, Music for Misfits: The Story of Indie, examined the cassette's contributions to the broader indie narrative, underscoring its 30th anniversary reflections on fostering community among misfits.[47] Yet, criticisms have persisted, with some observers arguing that C86 paved the way for a more commercialized, nostalgic indie that prioritized accessibility over rebellion.
Related Compilations and Revivals
Following the original 1986 release, the New Musical Express (NME) produced immediate sequels in the form of the double-cassette compilation Indie City, issued in two volumes in 1988 (NME 036 and NME 037).[48][49] These sets curated emerging indie acts, including tracks from Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, The House of Love, and The Pogues, extending the DIY ethos of C86 into the late 1980s indie scene with a focus on post-punk and alternative sounds.[5] A limited promotional 3xLP vinyl edition of Indie City volumes 1 and 2 was also distributed via radio, limited to 500 copies and featuring unique comic-strip artwork.[50]In parallel, NME's compilation efforts evolved with projects like the 1987 Indie Top 20 Vol. 1 LP and cassette, released through Band of Joy Records in collaboration with the magazine's indie charts.[51] This 20-track collection highlighted chart-topping indie hits from acts such as The Flatmates and The Wedding Present, shifting C86's cassette format to vinyl while emphasizing full-length songs from the national indie listings.[52]Revivals of C86 began in the mid-2000s, with Sanctuary Records issuing CD86: 48 Tracks from the Birth of Indie Pop in 2006 to mark the compilation's 20th anniversary.[53] Compiled by Bob Stanley of Saint Etienne, this double-CD set expanded on the original by including 48 influential tracks from the era's jangle-pop and indie movement, drawing directly from C86's participating labels and bands.[54] A more comprehensive reissue followed in 2014 from Cherry Red Records, presenting a deluxe 3-CD box set with the remastered original 22 tracks plus 50 bonus selections of demos, rarities, and related material from acts like Primal Scream, BMX Bandits, and Happy Mondays.[31] Curated by original NME compiler Neil Taylor, the set included interviews and contextual liner notes, totaling 72 tracks and underscoring C86's role in shaping indie pop.[55][56]Unofficial compilations have echoed C86's spirit in subsequent years, such as Rhino Records' 2005 box set Children of Nuggets: Original Artyfacts from the Second Psychedelic Era, 1976–1996, a four-disc anthology of underground psych-influenced indie rock that parallels C86's emphasis on raw, label-sourced gems.[57] In the digital age, modern streaming platforms like Spotify host curated playlists such as "The Sound of C86" and "Best of C86 and 80s Indie Pop," aggregating original tracks alongside contemporary homages to sustain the compilation's jangly, lo-fi aesthetic for new listeners.[58][59]