Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Colab

Collaborative Projects Inc., known as Colab, was a New York City-based artist collective founded in 1977 that functioned as a mutual aid society for artists, producing collaborative exhibitions, publications, and activist projects until the mid-1980s. Emerging from open meetings among artists disillusioned with the commercial art world, Colab established a nonprofit structure to secure public grants and operated from alternative spaces like ABC No Rio, emphasizing grassroots organization over traditional hierarchies. Colab's defining projects included the Real Estate Show in 1980, an unauthorized exhibition in a city-owned vacant building on that critiqued urban real estate policies and led to the creation of alternative art spaces, and the Times Square Show later that year, a sprawling, self-curated event in an abandoned facility featuring over 100 artists, , and performances that bypassed gallery gatekeepers and highlighted the scene's raw energy. These initiatives challenged institutional art norms, fostering collaborations among diverse figures like and , while producing publications such as X Magazine for satirical and experimental content. The collective's approach yielded both successes in democratizing art access and internal tensions over and , with members later reflecting on its role in shifting cultural amid New York's economic shifts, though its loose structure contributed to its eventual .

History

Formation and Early Meetings (1977–1978)

Collaborative Projects Inc., commonly known as Colab, emerged in 1977 from a series of open meetings among approximately 30 young artists in who sought alternatives to the commercial gallery system. These gatherings, involving artists from diverse disciplines such as , , and , fostered collaborative ideas for exhibitions, publications, and interventions outside traditional institutions. The group initially adopted the name Green Corporation around summer 1977, a reference to the "color of money" amid their lack of funding, as suggested by artist Michael McClard. Early meetings and ad hoc sessions, often held in private lofts, were characterized by rapid idea-sharing and excitement, leading to preliminary activities like film screenings and gatherings. In 1978, after discovering the Green Corporation name was already in use by another entity, the collective incorporated as Collaborative Projects Inc., a not-for-profit organization to facilitate grant applications, including an initial National Endowment for the Arts Workshop Grant via the Center for New Art Affairs. This period also saw the launch of X Magazine, a newsprint publication featuring art and social satire, which ran from 1977 to 1978 and exemplified their early multimedia efforts. Key participants included Alan Moore, Charlie Ahearn, John Ahearn, Jenny Holzer, Tom Otterness, and Kiki Smith, among a core group of about 50 members operating on democratic principles without formal hierarchy.

Emergence of Key Initiatives (1979–1980)

In 1979, Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab) escalated its activities through a series of themed exhibitions held in inexpensive, artist-run spaces, reflecting the group's emphasis on accessible, issue-driven art outside traditional galleries. The Batman Show, organized by in January at 591 Broadway, featured contributions from members including Andrea Callard. Subsequent events included the Income and Wealth Show at the 5 storefront, exploring economic disparities, and the Doctors and Dentists Show, also mounted that year to critique institutional power in healthcare. The Manifesto Show followed in April at 5 , curated by and Coleen Fitzgibbon, incorporating Holzer's Inflammatory Essays as provocative text pieces. These exhibitions, often low-budget and participatory, fostered among roughly 30-50 members and drew on Colab's recent nonprofit incorporation to pursue small grants, though funding remained precarious. Complementing the shows, Colab initiated the Potato Wolf cable access program in 1979—a weekly half-hour series on Cable Television running through 1986—providing a platform for experimental video and works by members like Julie Harrison. Regular meetings, such as those on February 19, April 8, September 9, and October 7 at locations including 45 Crosby Street, coordinated these efforts and built consensus on anti-institutional principles. By late 1979, these activities culminated in planning for bolder interventions, notably the Real Estate Show. On December 30-31, 1979, approximately 100 artists, coordinated by Colab members including Christy Rupp, Coleen Fitzgibbon, and Steven F. Hager, illegally occupied a city-owned vacant building at 123 Delancey Street to install site-specific works addressing housing crises, gentrification, and urban decay in the Lower East Side. The exhibition opened to the public on New Year's Eve 1979 but was raided and closed by police on January 2, 1980, prompting negotiations with city officials that secured ABC No Rio as a sanctioned alternative space at 156 Rivington Street. This action exemplified Colab's shift toward direct confrontation with socioeconomic realities, bridging 1979's exploratory shows to 1980's larger-scale projects like the Times Square Show.

Expansion and Core Activities (1981–1985)

In the early , Collaborative Projects Inc. () solidified its role as a funding mechanism for artist-driven initiatives, distributing grants obtained through nonprofit status to support exhibitions, publications, and spaces via democratic member votes at regular meetings. This expansion built on prior shows like the Times Square Show, with allocating resources to approximately 50 core members and open participants, emphasizing non-hierarchical over commercial galleries. Annual reports from 1981–1982 document internal budgeting for such projects, prioritizing socially engaged art amid New York's downtown scene. A key focus was sustaining ABC No Rio, a Lower East Side squat-turned-venue originating from Colab's 1980 Real Estate Show eviction, which hosted ongoing exhibitions from 1980–1981 and evolved into a hub for , , and with Colab's financial and organizational backing. Similarly, Colab provided seed funding for Fashion Moda, an interdisciplinary space in the South Bronx founded by member Stefan Eins around 1980, enabling outreach to marginalized urban areas through grants and logistical aid. These efforts exemplified Colab's commitment to decentralizing production beyond Manhattan's elite institutions. Publications received targeted support, including financing for the inaugural issue of Bomb magazine in 1981, which featured artist interviews and criticism, and Tellus Audio Cassette Magazine, distributing experimental sound works to broaden access to no-wave media. From 1981 to 1984, Colab operated A. More Store at 529 Broome Street as a cooperative retail space for member-produced objects, critiquing consumerism while generating modest revenue. Internationally, in 1982, members installed a Gift Store at Documenta 7 in Kassel, Germany, offering free or low-cost art to challenge fair-like commodification. These activities peaked Colab's influence, with meetings like the March 1981 gathering at Christof Kohlhöfer and Ulli Rimkus's apartment coordinating logistics, though tensions over funding priorities and member turnover began surfacing by mid-decade.

Decline and (1986 onward)

By the mid-1980s, Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab) saw a marked reduction in activities, with major exhibitions and interventions tapering off after 1985. The group's anti-hierarchical model, reliant on voluntary attendance at open meetings and consensus-based funding allocation, proved unsustainable for long-term cohesion as attendance dwindled and decision-making grew inefficient. External pressures exacerbated the internal fragmentation, including accelerating in Manhattan's , which raised rents and displaced informal artist squats central to Colab's operations. Spaces like , initially supported by Colab, shifted away from the group's artistic programming toward independent punk and zine activities by 1985, reflecting broader dispersal of members to projects like Fashion Moda in the . Although a small core of participants maintained an evolving affiliation into the late 1980s—evidenced by internal documents proposing projects through 1986 and extensions like the MWF co-op store (directed by former members and Michael Carter until 2000)—no significant group-wide initiatives materialized post-1985. Accounts consistently frame Colab's operational lifespan as 1977–1986, after which the nonprofit effectively dissolved without formal closure, its ethos influencing subsequent activist art but yielding to individual pursuits amid a commercializing .

Organizational Principles and Structure

Founding Ethos and Anti-Hierarchical Model

Collaborative Projects Inc., commonly known as Colab, originated from a series of open meetings among approximately 30 artists in New York City in 1977, initially under the name Green Corporation, before formalizing as a non-profit organization in 1978. The group's founding ethos centered on mutual aid, aiming to enable artists to collectively access government grants for equipment and projects, thereby circumventing the institutional bureaucracy and commercial gallery system that dominated the late 1970s art world. This pragmatic approach blended left-wing politics, punk irreverence, and art-world realism, prioritizing resource pooling for collaborative, publicly oriented initiatives over traditional individual artistic production or movement-building. Colab's structure embodied an anti-hierarchical model, deliberately eschewing formal administrators or leaders to distribute responsibilities and decision-making among members. Membership was open to any artist attending two to three monthly meetings, fostering an inclusive, fluid that grew from dozens to over 60 participants, with roughly 50% female representation in key projects. Decisions on funding and project approval occurred through democratic votes and debates, allowing working groups to form for specific tasks while maintaining and equal artistic input. This non-hierarchical framework supported early endeavors like the production of X Magazine (1977–1978) and the "Income and Wealth" exhibition (1978), where funds were allocated via group consensus to promote accessible, that challenged and systemic exclusions in the art ecosystem. By design, the model resisted top-down control, enabling diverse artists—including figures like and —to collaborate on equal footing and adapt to evolving priorities without centralized authority. Such principles underscored Colab's commitment to artistic independence, though they occasionally led to internal debates over restructuring, as proposed by member around 1981–1982, which were resolved through member votes.

Membership Dynamics and Funding Mechanisms

Collaborative Projects Inc., known as Colab, operated with an open and fluid membership model designed to foster inclusivity and anti-hierarchical collaboration among artists. Membership was accessible to any artist who attended two or three meetings, reflecting the group's emphasis on participation over formal vetting. Initially forming with around two dozen members in 1977–1978 following open organizational meetings, the group expanded rapidly, reaching over sixty members by the early as awareness spread through the downtown art scene. By 1982, a core group of approximately fifty artists handled ongoing activities, though participation could swell to over one hundred for specific large-scale projects, with membership fluctuating constantly due to the lack of fixed rosters or long-term commitments. This dynamic structure avoided bureaucratic roles, such as administrators, and relied on democratic consensus for decisions, enabling diverse contributors—including filmmakers, sculptors, and performers like , , and —to engage without rigid hierarchies. Funding for Colab's initiatives stemmed primarily from its incorporation as a nonprofit organization in 1977, which facilitated access to public grants unavailable to informal collectives. The group secured an initial National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) Workshop Grant through the Center for New Art Activities, Inc., distributing funds equally among members to support early activities. Subsequent funding came from state and federal sources, including the New York State Council on the Arts (NYSCA) and additional NEA allocations, which were generous during the period and directed toward equipment purchases, exhibitions, publications, and affiliated spaces like ABC No Rio and Fashion Moda. Allocation occurred through democratic voting at meetings, prioritizing collective projects over individual pursuits—a principle codified in "Rule C," which prohibited grants solely for personal work and instead funneled resources into group endeavors to maintain artistic autonomy and shared benefit. This mechanism ensured broad member input while leveraging nonprofit status to circumvent commercial art market constraints, though it required ongoing consensus to approve disbursements for ventures like the 1980 Times Square Show.

Major Projects and Exhibitions

Real Estate Show (January 1980)

The Real Estate Show was an unauthorized and organized by Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab) that opened on , 1980, in a vacant, city-owned storefront at 123 on the of . The event involved approximately 35 artists who broke into the building on December 30, 1979, using bolt cutters, to install works addressing urban housing crises, including absentee landlordism, for profit, municipal neglect of vacant properties, and the displacement of low-income residents and artists. The exhibition's theme critiqued how financial interests dominated housing allocation in , particularly in the , where city policies exacerbated poverty and abandonment while favoring speculative development. Organizers, including Becky Howland as a principal figure, framed the show as an act of solidarity with affected communities, highlighting issues like alternative energy sources for tenements and the conversion of public spaces for artistic use. Notable installations included Peter Fend's instructional diagrams for producing gas from to power urban buildings, Bobby G's sculpture of cigarette packs proposing a collective fund for housing, Robin Winters's drawing of a landlord demanding "Pay or Get Out," and Becky Howland's mural depicting an octopus entwining tenements with symbols of money, knives, and jewels. The show was dedicated to Elizabeth Mangum, a resident killed by police during an eviction resistance. Authorities from the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) evicted the artists on January 2, 1980, by padlocking the entrance, prompting a public press conference on January 8, 1980, outside the building where demonstrators confronted officials. German artist Joseph Beuys attended the press event in support. Installed artworks were removed and stored in an uptown warehouse on January 11, 1980, before being returned to participants. Negotiations following the resulted in a temporary compromise granting artists access to a nearby space at 172 until February 1980, which evolved into the establishment of , a permanent artist-run cultural center at 156 Street. Colab member described the motivation as stemming from frustration with opaque financial forces dictating outcomes: "A lot of people are tired of getting the short end of the stick in the real estate world because of forces they don’t understand but that always amount to money." The marked an early instance of Colab's strategy blending , , and against institutional barriers to exhibition spaces.

Times Square Show (June 1980)

The Times Square Show was a self-curated art exhibition organized by Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab) that occupied an abandoned building at 201 West 41st Street, between Seventh and Eighth Avenues in New York City's Times Square, throughout the month of June 1980. The venue, a former massage parlor and porn theater emblematic of the area's 1980s decay, was identified by Colab members Tom Otterness and John Ahearn, who proposed its use for the event. Open 24 hours a day without admission fees, the show drew crowds to its multi-floor sprawl of improvised installations, reflecting Colab's ethos of accessible, site-responsive art amid Times Square's peep shows and adult venues. More than 100 artists contributed works across disciplines, including paintings, sculptures, performances, videos, and , with participants such as , , , , and . The exhibition's chaotic layout defied conventional curation, featuring a six-page and artist list by Otterness and Ahearn as its primary documentation rather than a polished catalog. Many pieces engaged the site's history through themes of sexuality, commerce, and urban marginality, such as sex-themed installations and that blurred lines between and vernacular expression. Colab solicited proposals openly, fostering inclusivity across emerging downtown scenes while prioritizing raw, unpolished output over institutional polish. Funding came from grants awarded to Colab by the National Endowment for the Arts and the New York State Council on the Arts, supporting the group's shift toward larger-scale interventions after smaller projects. Promotional efforts included posters by Jane Dickson and Charlie Ahearn, television advertisements, and word-of-mouth, amplifying its visibility in a pre-gentrified Times Square. The event's decentralized structure led to logistical challenges, including unvetted contributions and site degradation, yet it exemplified Colab's anti-hierarchical model by integrating graffiti writers, filmmakers, and performers without gatekeeping. Contemporary reviews praised its disruption of SoHo's gallery dominance, with dubbing it "the first radical art show of the '80s" for merging high art with street culture and challenging art-world elitism. The show propelled visibility for underrepresented artists and presaged the East Village art boom, though its ephemerality—marked by the building's return to vacancy post-event—highlighted tensions between impermanence and documentation in alternative exhibitions. Subsequent accounts note its role in democratizing access but critique the romanticization of grit, as participant numbers and exact contributions remain imprecise due to the lack of formal records.

Subsequent Exhibitions and Interventions (1981–1984)

Following the high-profile exhibitions of 1980, Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab) shifted toward sustained interventions in commercial and alternative spaces, emphasizing artist-driven sales, documentation, and cross-regional collaborations. The A. More Store, initiated in 1981 at 529 in , functioned as a outlet where over 50 Colab members sold affordable artworks, multiples, and directly to the public, challenging gallery gatekeeping by enabling artists to retain control over pricing and distribution; this initiative recurred annually through 1984, with participating artists including Joe Lewis and Christy Rupp. At , Colab supported ongoing exhibitions and performances into 1981–1982, including group shows like The Absurdities Show featuring members such as , William Scott, and Robin Winters, which highlighted experimental and amid the venue's punk-infused programming. Photographer Tom Warren established a "Portrait Studio" at in 1981, producing signed portraits of approximately 12–15 Colab affiliates, including Jane Dickson, Joseph Nechvatal, and Walter Robinson, as a documentary intervention capturing the collective's membership dynamics. These activities at , legalized after the 1980 Real Estate Show, drew on Colab's non-hierarchical model to host over a dozen exhibitions in 1981 alone, focusing on , , and revivals. In 1982, Colab extended its reach internationally via a Gift Store at 7 in , , selling low-cost items produced by members to democratize access to and critique institutional commodification, aligning with the event's theme of artistic autonomy under curator Rudi Fuchs. Domestically, Colab funded and collaborated with affiliates like Fashion Moda in the , supporting interventions such as John Ahearn and Rigoberto Torres's community-based casting projects, though these were primarily Fashion Moda-led rather than direct Colab exhibitions. A pivotal intervention occurred in 1983 with the Ritz Hotel Project, co-organized with the in an abandoned hotel in , spanning one month and involving over 300 artists in site-specific installations across 119 rooms, transforming the derelict space into a temporary venue that echoed Colab's earlier tactics while expanding to interdisciplinary works like video and performance. Posters by Becky Howland promoted the event, emphasizing its anti-establishment ethos, and it secured grants exceeding $1,500 per artist in some cases, though logistical challenges highlighted tensions in scaling Colab's loose structure. By 1984, activities tapered with smaller shows like those at Hallwalls in , signaling a transition toward decline amid funding constraints and internal divergences.

Publications, Media, and Documentation

Key Publications and Books

Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab) initiated its publishing activities with X Motion Picture Magazine, a newsprint periodical launched in 1977 that encompassed art, social satire, film criticism, photography, and commentary from downtown New York artists. Coordinated by figures such as Jimmy DeSana, Colen Fitzgibbon, and Lindzee Smith, the magazine's inaugural issue appeared in February 1978, reflecting the collective's emphasis on interdisciplinary and anti-institutional content. Multiple volumes followed, serving as a platform for Colab members to document and critique cultural phenomena, including punk and no-wave scenes. Exhibition catalogs and ephemera formed another core output, such as those for the Times Square Show in June 1980, which captured the event's chaotic, site-specific installations across abandoned buildings. These publications often functioned as fundraising tools and archival records, distributed at benefit events like the 1978 concert supporting X Magazine. Post-dissolution documentation includes A Book About Colab (and Related Activities), edited by Max Schumann and published by Printed Matter in 2015, with a foreword by Walter Robinson. This 368-page volume compiles , posters, and texts tracing Colab's projects from 1977 to the mid-1980s, establishing it as the primary scholarly reference on the group's activities. A second printing appeared in 2024, underscoring ongoing interest in Colab's archival legacy.

Films, Videos, and Archival Works

Colab operated a dedicated and video division within its structure as an art and , enabling members to produce low-cost experimental works using formats like , Sony Portapak, and 3/4-inch tape. These efforts complemented exhibitions by documenting events and extending the collective's reach through cable access television. A key production was the cable TV series Potato Wolf, broadcast from 1978 to 1985, which included segments like Raptures of the Deep (21 minutes, ), News News (10 minutes, ), and Nightmare Theater (7 minutes, ), often featuring satirical news, performances, and artist collaborations. Following the group's decline, the M/W/F Club initiative launched in 1986 to distribute Colab and affiliated filmmakers' works via , preserving output from the no-wave era. Digitization efforts in the 2000s and 2010s addressed deteriorating tapes; Coleen Fitzgibbon and Andrea Callard processed select footage from 2006 to 2013, culminating in the two-disc Colab TV DVD released around 2013, with excerpts from Potato Wolf, M/W/F Club, and the 2013 XFR STN preservation event at the . Specific documentation includes 1979 edited video footage of the Real Estate Show, recording the January 1980 occupation of 123 and installed artworks. A 2009 film-video completion by Fitzgibbon and further chronicled early projects, while shorter pieces like Vertual Realty – Real Estate Show (2014, 1 minute, digital, color, sound) revisited themes of urban space. Archival holdings feature 600 to 800 videotapes from the MWF Video Club, including Potato Wolf props and performance recordings, deposited at the Center for Film and Theater Research at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Associated spaces like augmented these with tapes of 1980s performances by groups such as the Bill T. Jones/Arnie Zane Dance Company. For the Times Square Show, documentation comprises hybrid home video-art films capturing the June 1980 event's chaotic installations across a derelict building. Retrospective screenings underscore the works' legacy; in 2014, Spectacle Theater's "In and Around Collaborative Projects Inc." series presented over 20 pieces by members and affiliates, such as Liza Béar's Earthglow (1983, 8 minutes, poetic text overlay) and the All Color News Sampler (1977, 22 minutes, alternative news parody), emphasizing Colab's role in fostering accessible, anti-institutional media. These efforts prioritized raw, collective experimentation over polished production, reflecting the group's ethos amid New York's 1970s-1980s economic constraints.

Notable Members and Associates

Core Contributors and Their Roles

Collaborative Projects Inc. () maintained an anti-hierarchical structure, where roles emerged organically through member initiative rather than fixed positions, enabling a fluid collective of approximately 50 artists to pursue grants, exhibitions, and interventions democratically. Founding and core contributors often overlapped in organizational duties, such as curating shows or handling publicity, with decisions made via group votes on proposals. Becky Howland served as a primary initiator of Colab in 1977, co-founding it as a mutual aid network for securing funding, and played a central role in organizing the Real Estate Show (1980), including designing its iconic octopus flyer symbolizing urban decay and activism. She also contributed to ABC No Rio's establishment as a follow-up space. Jane Dickson emerged as a key organizer and officer, participating in early meetings and contributing artworks like paintings on garbage bags for the and videos for the (1980), while helping coordinate logistics for multiple exhibitions. Alan W. Moore acted as a documentarian and curator, chronicling Colab's activities through writings, co-authoring the book (1985), and aiding in the and Shows' conceptual framing. Charlie and John Ahearn, co-founders, bridged visual art and performance; Charlie directed the film (1983) with Colab support and contributed to the Times Square Show, while John produced realistic portrait busts for the Real Estate Show. Stefan Eins, though primarily associated with Fashion Moda, collaborated closely as a co-organizer of the Times Square Show, facilitating connections between downtown and art scenes. Coleen Fitzgibbon focused on media and video, creating installations like Gun, Money, Plate for the and producing films within Colab's broader output. Other notable core figures included Christy Rupp, who managed press for the ; , who designed catalogues like Art Direct (1982); and Walter Robinson, an active participant in meetings and publications.

Impact and Legacy

Influence on Artist Collectives and Alternative Spaces

Colab's emphasis on non-hierarchical, consensus-based organization and open membership influenced subsequent artist collectives by demonstrating viable alternatives to institutionalized art structures, prioritizing collective autonomy over authorship. This approach, which avoided formal administrators and relied on democratic funding models like member dues and grants, enabled groups to maintain independence from commercial galleries and museums, fostering experiments in politicized across creative processes. The collective's use of unconventional venues—such as abandoned buildings for the Real Estate Show in January 1980 and the Times Square Show in June 1980—pioneered site-specific interventions that blurred distinctions between art, architecture, and , inspiring later collectives to repurpose marginal spaces for exhibitions. These events highlighted economic pressures on artists amid City's real estate crisis, prompting groups to adopt similar guerrilla tactics to critique and access underutilized sites. By 1981, Colab's exhibitions had drawn over 75,000 visitors to the Times Square Show alone, validating the model of large-scale, unjuried shows in non-gallery contexts and encouraging replication in lofts and streets. Directly, Colab facilitated the establishment of enduring alternative spaces through financial and logistical support; the Real Estate Show's occupation of city-owned buildings led to the legalization of as a permanent artist-run venue on the in 1980, serving as a hub for punk-inflected art and performance into the . Similarly, Colab provided grants to member-founded initiatives like Fashion Moda, opened by Stefan Eins in the in 1979, which extended the collective's ethos of to underserved neighborhoods, influencing Bronx-based artist networks by integrating , , and forms. These efforts contrasted with mainstream alternative spaces increasingly aligned with market dynamics, positioning Colab as a catalyst for more radical, self-sustaining models. In the broader scene, Colab's legacy extended to East Village galleries and No Wave-affiliated groups, where its advocacy for artist-initiated funding and thematic interventions—such as and media critique—shaped collectives like those at PS122 or Gallery 98, emphasizing and activist-oriented programming over commodified . However, retrospective analyses by former members note that while Colab inspired short-term experimentation, its loose structure contributed to operational challenges, limiting long-term scalability for imitators without similar consensus mechanisms.

Broader Cultural and Economic Effects

Colab's interventions, particularly the Real Estate Show in January 1980 and the Times Square Show in June 1980, extended art beyond institutional confines into public and derelict urban spaces, fostering a cultural shift toward accessible, site-specific practices that critiqued commodification and elitism in the art world. By occupying abandoned buildings amid New York City's fiscal crisis and housing shortages, these exhibitions integrated artistic expression with social commentary on urban decay and gentrification, influencing subsequent generations of artists to prioritize activism and collectivity over market-driven individualism. This approach prefigured broader trends in relational and interventionist art, where everyday environments became canvases for addressing socioeconomic contradictions, thereby embedding art within the lived realities of marginalized communities in the Lower East Side and Times Square. Economically, Colab's establishment as a non-profit entity in 1977 enabled artists to secure public grants from state and federal sources, circumventing reliance on private galleries and the market, which funded exhibitions without traditional sales mechanisms. The Real Estate Show specifically highlighted mismanaged city properties, drawing attention to the economic abandonment of neighborhoods and prompting discussions on artist housing amid rising evictions and , though direct changes were limited to heightened rather than immediate reforms. This model of grant-supported, non-commercial production contributed to a parallel art economy that sustained independent projects during the late recession, influencing later collectives to explore self-funding and occupation as viable alternatives to market dependency.

Criticisms, Challenges, and Assessments

Internal Conflicts and Operational Failures

Colab's consensus-driven process, which required extensive in regular meetings attended by up to 60 members, often resulted in operational inefficiencies and frustration among participants. This structure prioritized collective input but led to protracted discussions that hindered timely project execution, as evidenced by member Tom Otterness's circulated proposal around 1981–1982 advocating for organizational restructuring to streamline operations. Several proposed initiatives failed to materialize, highlighting operational shortcomings in follow-through and resource allocation. For instance, in 1981, artists Mike Glier and Jane Dickson pitched The Journal of Male Behavior, soliciting contributions from artists and writers for a satirical publication, but the project was never realized due to insufficient momentum or funding within the group. Such unrealized efforts underscored the challenges of maintaining commitment in a loosely structured collective reliant on volunteer labor and ad hoc grants. While major interpersonal disputes appear limited in documented accounts—likely owing to the group's non-hierarchical ethos and fluid membership—internal tensions arose from the tension between artistic and obligations, contributing to member . By the mid-1980s, these dynamics, combined with external factors like shifting funding landscapes, led to Colab's gradual dissolution without a formal disbandment, as core members transitioned to individual practices. The absence of a centralized exacerbated these issues, preventing sustained beyond one-off exhibitions.

Critiques of Activist Effectiveness and Sustainability

Critics have argued that COLAB's activist interventions, such as the 1980 Times Square Show, failed to achieve enduring structural change in the art world, instead inadvertently accelerating the commercialization of downtown New York scenes. Organized in an abandoned Times Square building to protest art market elitism and urban neglect, the exhibition drew over 100 artists and blurred high and low culture, yet it served as a launchpad for many participants into mainstream galleries, particularly in SoHo and the East Village, where raw, activist aesthetics were quickly commodified by dealers and investors during the early 1980s boom. The sustainability of COLAB's model has been questioned due to its reliance on short-term grants from bodies like the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA), which faced severe cuts under the Reagan administration starting in 1981, limiting the group's capacity for ongoing operations. Active primarily from 1977 to the mid-1980s, COLAB's loose, open-membership structure fostered innovative but ephemeral projects, with participants like Coleen Fitzgibbon citing difficulties in collaborative dynamics after just three years, leading to individual withdrawals and a gradual dissipation of collective energy. Later assessments highlight how techniques pioneered by COLAB, including guerrilla exhibitions and community interventions, were appropriated in subsequent art practices stripped of their original political bite, reducing activist potential to stylistic tropes without challenging underlying economic power structures. This co-optation underscores a broader limitation: while COLAB exposed institutional biases, it did not establish scalable alternatives resilient to market forces or policy shifts, as evidenced by the rapid institutionalization of alternative spaces it sought to critique.

References

  1. [1]
    Collaborative Projects Inc (aka Colab): An Artist Group From The ...
    Apr 17, 2025 · When the artist group Colab was founded in 1977 it was conceived more as a mutual aid society than as an art movement.
  2. [2]
    Colab Again - Stedelijk Studies
    Collaborative Projects Inc., known informally as Colab, was a loosely organized group of artists active from 1977 to the mid-1980s, with headquarters in ABC No ...
  3. [3]
    Colab Inc | Avant Garde Artist Collective 1977-Present (Website ...
    Colab formed as a collective in 1977 after a series of open meetings between artists of various disciplines, first taking the name Green Corporation.
  4. [4]
    Colab — 98 BOWERY: 1969-89
    The earliest collective undertaking of Collaborative Projects was X Magazine, a newsprint journal of art, social satire, comment, film criticism and photography ...
  5. [5]
    Thirty Years On, Colab Members Assess Their Successes and Failures
    May 10, 2016 · Colab (Collaborative Projects) produced some of the most significant exhibitions and projects of the 1980s, including the Times Square Show, the Real Estate ...Missing: 1970s | Show results with:1970s
  6. [6]
    Colab - Artsy
    Founded in New York in 1977, Collaborative Projects Inc., known simply as Colab, was an artist collective that included Kiki Smith, Tom Otterness, ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  7. [7]
    “Times Square Show Revisited: Accounts of the Landmark 1980 ...
    Aug 17, 2011 · Michael McClard wanted to name the group Green Corporation for the color of money since we had none. ... This was the beginning of Colab theme ...<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    artnet.com Magazine Books - Book Report
    After discovering that "The Green Corporation" was already taken, the group settled on the name Collaborative Projects, and so a legend (of a sort) was born.
  9. [9]
    Colab » tags » - SketchPort
    Colab came together as a collective in 1977, first using the name Green Corporation ... In 1978, Collaborative Projects was incorporated as a not-for ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] a collection of “Collaborative Projects Inc.” - Bibliopolis
    Colab was established in 1977 by a diverse group of artists who envisioned what co-founder and experimental film artist Coleen Fitzgibbon described as a ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
  11. [11]
    [PDF] THE ARTIST AS CURATOR AN ANTHOLOGY - Monoskop
    In January 1979, Colab members, including Diego. Cortez, Coleen Fitzgibbon ... The shows sponsored in 1979 included Batman Show;. Income and Wealth Show;.
  12. [12]
    Tom Otterness from Kansas to New York - Art of Estates
    Aug 22, 2019 · Collaborate Projects Inc or Colab for short formed in 1977 after a group of meetings between artists from various backgrounds. The group was ...Missing: early | Show results with:early<|separator|>
  13. [13]
    Where Can We Be? The Occupation of 123 Delancey Street
    Artists install the Real Estate Show in a vacant building owned by the city of New York, December 30-31, 1979. [Ann Messner]. On New Year's Eve, 1979, ...
  14. [14]
    Collection of Colab art collective annual reports and internal ...
    Colab was especially savvy in its efforts at grant funding and publicity, evidenced by the present collection of documents. Included are: [1] 1981-82 ...
  15. [15]
    Collaborative Projects Inc (aka Colab): A 1980s Artist Group and ...
    Oct 24, 2024 · When the artist group Colab was founded in 1978 it was conceived more as a mutual aid society than as an art movement.
  16. [16]
    Colab takes a piece, history takes it back: collectivity and New York ...
    May 27, 2008 · ... 1977 through September of 1978, when it incorporated as Collaborative Projects, Inc. (Another nonprofit had already claimed Green ...
  17. [17]
    Exhibitions | Colab Inc - WordPress.com
    Just Another Asshole Show (June 1979), 5 Bleecker Street NYC. Exhibit A (November 1979), 93 Grand Street NYC financed by CNAA, Colab, CVA. The Real Estate ...
  18. [18]
    History - ABC No Rio
    We trace our genesis to The Real Estate Show, an intervention in which more than thirty artists, many associated with Colab, occupied an abandoned building ...
  19. [19]
    Exhibitions - New Museum Digital Archive
    MWF was a co- op “store” of the artists ́ group Colab (Collaborative Projects, Inc.), directed by Alan Moore and Michael Carter from 1986–2000, which showed ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] REBELS REBEL. AIDS, ARt AnD ActIvISM In nEw YoRK, 1979 ...
    these include the Art. Workers' Coalition (1969–1971), Artists Meeting for Cultural Change (1975–. 1978), Collaborative Projects Inc. (1977–1986) and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  21. [21]
    Collaborative Projects Inc. (Colab), Times Square Show, 1980.pdf
    This paper is about the legendary exhibition Times Square Show (1980), which was organized by Collaborative Projects Inc. It was published in an anthology ...<|separator|>
  22. [22]
    The Real Estate Show Was Then: 1980 | Frieze
    The organizers called a press conference for 8 January in front of the building. Reporters witnessed the confrontation between Colab and HPD. Significantly, so ...
  23. [23]
    The Real Estate Show — 98 BOWERY: 1969-89
    The Real Estate Show was all about the way money controls where and how people live in New York City in general, and the Lower East Side in particular.
  24. [24]
    Colab, The Real Estate Show, and ABC No Rio: A History - - Radio
    ... collective, Collaborative Projects, Inc., (familiarly known as Colab), and the 1980 Real Estate Show, which led to the creation of ABC No Rio cultural center.
  25. [25]
    Why Are We Revisiting the Times Square Show? - Hyperallergic
    Oct 12, 2012 · For many of the artists who participated in numerous Colab exhibitions, the Times Square Show at the time did not seem to them to be a singular, ...
  26. [26]
    Tom Otterness & John Ahearn, Times Square Show Floor Plan ...
    This 6-page floor plan and artists list is the closest thing there is to a catalogue for the landmark Times Square Show in June 1980.
  27. [27]
    THE TIME SQUARE SHOW- "The First Radical Art Show of the "80s ...
    The Times Square Show would investigate how art could communicate across race, class, and gender divides and represent a complex urban identity. Colab organized ...Missing: details | Show results with:details<|separator|>
  28. [28]
    Inherent Vice: Contagion and The Archive in The Times Square Show
    The producing collective, Collaborative Projects, Inc. (Colab), a constantly shifting assortment of young artists from many disciplines, had scored ...<|separator|>
  29. [29]
    Crossroads of the (Art) World by John Reed - The Paris Review
    Oct 10, 2012 · There is an answer: “The Times Square Show.” In June of 1980, more than a hundred artists, under the auspice and directed by the vision of Colab ...
  30. [30]
    “Times Square Show Revisited” - Artforum
    View of “Times Square Show,” 1980, West 41st Street, New York. Left wall: Jean-Michel Basquiat, untitled, 1980. Photo: Ted Stamm.
  31. [31]
    [PDF] The Times Square Show - Kenny Scharf
    At the beginning the organizers (the artists' group. Collaborative Projects, Inc., or Colab, and friends and some enemies) asked for "proposals" like any self-.
  32. [32]
    Jane Dickson and Charlie Ahearn, Poster, Times Square Show, 1980
    COLAB's Times Square Show, held in June 1980 in a former massage parlor on 41st Street, included hundreds of artists from around the city. Critics proclaimed ...Missing: exact | Show results with:exact
  33. [33]
    Television ads for The Times Square Show, NYC 1980 - mepaintsme
    Dec 20, 2024 · Held in June of 1980 in an abandoned massage parlor on 41st Street and Seventh Avenue, was organized by Collaborative Projects, Inc., an avant- ...
  34. [34]
    What is an “A More Store?” – Artists Take Control of Their Own ...
    Oct 17, 2024 · "A More Store" was a yearly event where artists, like COLAB, opened stores to directly market art, control outlets, and reach wider audiences.
  35. [35]
    COLAB NO MORE STORE! - James Fuentes Online
    Dec 4, 2020 · Their exhibitions included the Income and Wealth Show; Doctors & Dentists Show; The Manifesto Show; The Real Estate Show; A. More Store; and ...<|separator|>
  36. [36]
    Exhibitions 1981-82 — 98 BOWERY: 1969-89
    The art world in the 1980s witnessed a revival of painting and sculpture of which ABC No Rio proved to be an early indicator. Exhibitions at the gallery ...Missing: Inc | Show results with:Inc
  37. [37]
    The Absurdities Show, Group Exhibition with Bobby G, William Scott ...
    The Absurdities Show, Group Exhibition with Bobby G, William Scott, Robin Winters, ABC No Rio, Flyer, 1981. Request Price. Size: 8.5 x 11 inches.
  38. [38]
    Colab & W.P.A. at the Ritz Hotel 1983 | Colab Inc
    Colab Inc. Avant Garde Artist Collective 1977-Present (Website: ColabArchives.com). Colab & W.P.A. at the Ritz Hotel 1983. Ritz 7. Ritz 6. Ritz 5. Ritz 4. Ritz ...
  39. [39]
    [PDF] WASHINGTON ART MATTERS: ART LIFE IN THE CAPITAL 1940
    The huge,. 300-artist, month-long exhibition known as the “Ritz Project,” organized jointly with. Collaborative Projects Inc. (COLAB) of New York, featured just ...
  40. [40]
    Becky Howland, “Colab Hits the Ritz,” Poster, 1983 - Gallery 98
    Becky Howland, “Colab Hits the Ritz,” Poster, 1983. $350. Add to cart. 18″ x 24″. Colab Hits Ritz Becky ...Missing: Hotel | Show results with:Hotel
  41. [41]
    COLAB, X Motion Picture Magazine, February 1978 - Gallery 98
    $$250.00X Motion Picture Magazine, February 1978, a Colab publication assembled by the X Collective and coordinated by Jimmy de Sana, Colen Fitzgibbon, Lindzee Smith, ...
  42. [42]
    Image Gallery | Colab Inc - WordPress.com
    Colab Inc. Avant Garde Artist Collective 1977-Present (Website: ColabArchives.com) ... Seth Tillet, X Magazine ...
  43. [43]
    A Book About Colab (and Related Activities) [Second Printing]
    $$39.95 Free deliveryA Book About Colab (and Related Activities)–edited by Max Schumann, and with a foreword and afterword by art writer and Colab member Walter Robinson–traces ...
  44. [44]
    A Book About Colab (And Related Activities) - Gallery 98
    May 30, 2024 · First published in 2015, Max Schuman's A Book About Colab (and Related Activities) remains the most authoritative source of information about Colab.Missing: key | Show results with:key
  45. [45]
    IN AND AROUND COLLABORATIVE PROJECTS INC.
    Apr 10, 2014 · Operating only for a brief period from 1978-1979, the project space provided numerous artists a way to showcase their work while announcing a ...
  46. [46]
    Colab TV DVD Now Available for Purchase! - COLEEN FITZGIBBON
    Thanks to all COLAB artists involved, Coleen Fitzgibbon and Andrea Callard digitized these specific aging videotapes 2006-2013 and worked with Michael Grenadier ...<|separator|>
  47. [47]
    Colab - The Real Estate Show - YouTube
    May 14, 2015 · Published 1979 Edited video documentation of The Real Estate Show ... Weird Hollywood Movie Facts•894K views · 18:53. Go to channel · The ...
  48. [48]
    Videography | Colab Inc - WordPress.com
    Vertual Realty – Real Estate Show (2014) Digital, color, sound, 1 minute ... The film/video was completed by Coleen Fitzgibbon and Alan Moore in 2009.
  49. [49]
    Colab ABC No Rio - Alan W. Moore
    Colab is a group of artists, and ABC No Rio is an art space in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, with a formal collection.
  50. [50]
    Colab / Real Estate / Times Square Show - Boot Boyz Biz
    ... Colab was a constantly changing nexus of artists. Members proposed projects, and the group's funds were allocated by democratic vote, generally supporting group ...Missing: key | Show results with:key
  51. [51]
    (PDF) Collaboration is not an Alternative: Artists Working Together in ...
    Colab, therefore, sought to engender politicised collaboration at every level of the creative and exhibition processes, conducting group business through large, ...
  52. [52]
    [PDF] Downloaded by [Central Michigan University] at 06:08 13 October ...
    Before Colab achieved its nonprofit status, the group applied for its first NEA grants through LizaBear's Center for New Art Activities,. Inc.,which, according ...<|separator|>
  53. [53]
    [PDF] Art and Politics in New York at the Dawn of the Reagan Era
    Jun 11, 2018 · appeared on New Year's Eve 1979, when a group of young artists associated with Colab opened ... History Takes It Back: Collectivity and New York.
  54. [54]
    Collaborative Projects and Art Economies Panel - Colab Inc
    Jun 28, 2016 · The members of Collaborative Projects (Colab) created themed group shows, Fashion Moda gallery, the Times Square Show, the Real Estate Show ...Missing: core contributors
  55. [55]
    Tom Otterness, Proposal for the Restructuring of Co-lab, Three ...
    Tom Otterness, Proposal for the Restructuring of Co-lab, Three Xerox Pages of Notes, c. 1981/82. Sold. There is some doodling by the ...
  56. [56]
    “A Show About Colab (and Related Activities)” - Artforum
    Oct 15, 2011 · “A Show About Colab (and Related Activities)” ventures past the group's landmarks and explores the surrounding territory.Missing: end 1986 onward<|separator|>
  57. [57]
    https://gallery98.org/2024/tom-otterness-proposal-for-the-restructuring-of-co-lab-three-pages-of-notes-c-1981-82/
  58. [58]
    Why Do Art Collectives End? | Frieze
    Feb 22, 2023 · Former members of artist duos and groups discuss how and why art collectives form, and eventually come to pass.
  59. [59]
    IN CONVERSATION: DAN GRAHAM AND MICHAEL SMITH - Artforum
    “The Times Square Show” was a reaction to the alternative spaces becoming institutionalized, but then it became a platform to go into SoHo. I did a performance ...<|separator|>
  60. [60]
    NEWS FROM NOWHERE, Activist Art and After, a Report from New ...
    Feb 18, 2006 · ... art scene including Artists Space and Grand Street had generated their own alternatives. One of these was Collaborative Projects inc. or ...