Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Craniate

Craniates, formally known as the clade Craniata, are a monophyletic group of chordates defined by the presence of a cranium—a bony, cartilaginous, or fibrous structure that encloses and protects the brain, sensory organs, and associated facial elements.^[1] This defining feature distinguishes them from other chordates, such as tunicates and lancelets, while all craniates retain the core chordate traits including a notochord, dorsal hollow nerve cord, pharyngeal slits, and a post-anal tail during at least one life stage.^[1] Craniata encompasses more than 66,000 extant species (as of 2024), representing the vast majority of chordate diversity.^[2] The clade Craniata originated during the Cambrian explosion around 540 million years ago, evolving from ancestral chordates through innovations such as enhanced sensory capabilities and protective cranial structures, as evidenced by early fossils like Haikouichthys.^[1] This evolutionary milestone facilitated the development of more complex nervous systems and active predation lifestyles, setting the stage for subsequent radiations into diverse habitats from deep oceans to terrestrial environments.^[1] Key genetic events, including two rounds of whole-genome duplication in early vertebrate lineages, further drove morphological innovations like neural crest cells, which contribute to the formation of the cranium, peripheral nerves, and other structures.^[3] Taxonomically, Craniata is positioned within the phylum Chordata and is often treated as synonymous with the subphylum Vertebrata, though precise classifications distinguish it to explicitly include hagfishes (class Myxini), which possess a cranium but lack a true vertebral column.^[3] The remaining members form the sub-clade Vertebrata, which includes lampreys, jawless fishes, and jawed vertebrates (Gnathostomata) such as cartilaginous fishes, bony fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals.^[1] This division highlights ongoing debates in phylogeny, with molecular evidence supporting the inclusion of hagfishes as the sister group to vertebrates based on shared cranial features and genomic similarities.^[3]

Overview

Definition and Scope

Craniata, also known as Craniates, constitutes a monophyletic clade within the phylum Chordata, distinguished by the possession of a cranium—a protective structure composed of bone, cartilage, or fibrous tissue that encloses the brain, along with associated jaw and facial elements.^[4] This defining feature marks Craniata as the chordate lineage that evolved a centralized neural enclosure, enabling advanced neurological and sensory integration.^[3] As chordates, all members develop a notochord during embryogenesis, though it persists as a prominent structure only in basal forms like hagfishes and lampreys, while being largely replaced by the vertebral column in more derived groups.^[3] The scope of Craniata encompasses the class Myxini (hagfishes), which serves as the sister group to Vertebrata—the subclade including all vertebrates with a backbone.^[3] Craniates occupy diverse habitats worldwide, including marine, freshwater, and terrestrial environments, with over 65,000 described species dominated overwhelmingly by vertebrates such as fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Hagfishes, numbering around 80 species, represent the only non-vertebrate craniates and highlight the clade's basal diversity.^[4] In contrast to the broader Chordata, which includes non-craniate groups like Cephalochordata (lancelets) and Urochordata (tunicates), Craniata is defined by the evolution of a true head featuring specialized sense organs, such as eyes, olfactory structures, and paired sensory appendages, integrated with the cranium.^[4] This head morphology facilitates active predation and environmental interaction, absent in the more primitive, headless body plans of lancelets and tunicates. As the most derived chordates, Craniata bridges transitional invertebrate-like forms to the highly complex vertebrates, underscoring their pivotal role in chordate evolution.^[3]

Etymology and History

The term "Craniata" derives from the Latin cranium, meaning "skull," combined with the suffix "-ata," denoting a group characterized by possession of that feature. It was introduced for chordates in the 19th century, with "Craniota" coined by Ernst Haeckel in 1866 and the form "Craniata" used by E. Ray Lankester in 1877 to encompass animals with a skull, often including lampreys, jawed fishes, and tetrapods as a broader group than "Vertebrata."^[5] In the 19th century, the term gained prominence in comparative anatomy to specifically denote skull-bearing animals, as evidenced by its frequent use in Carl Gegenbaur's 1878 Elements of Comparative Anatomy, where "Craniata" (and variant "Craniota") described a major subgroup of Vertebrata distinguished by the presence of a cranium formed through concrescence and differentiation of skeletal elements, contrasting with "Acrania" such as Amphioxus.^[6] The historical development of the Craniata concept began with early classifications emphasizing anatomical traits like the skull, with Ernst Haeckel contributing significantly in the late 19th century by integrating Darwinian evolution into phylogenetics; through his recapitulation theory and genealogical trees, Haeckel highlighted the evolutionary emergence of the vertebrate head as a key innovation, linking it to progressive ontogenetic stages in chordates.^[7] Edwin S. Goodrich advanced this framework in the early 20th century, particularly in his 1930 Studies on the Structure and Development of Vertebrates, where he analyzed vertebral column distinctions, arguing that craniate vertebrae arose from segmental mesodermal contributions, setting craniates apart from non-craniate chordates and influencing debates on head-trunk homology.^[8] During this period, prevailing views often excluded hagfishes from Craniata, classifying them as non-craniates due to the absence of a true vertebral column and other derived skeletal features. Post-1950s advancements in embryology and molecular biology solidified Craniata as a monophyletic clade, with embryological studies revealing shared developmental patterns in neural crest and placode formation across hagfishes and other chordates, while molecular phylogenies from the early 1990s demonstrated close affinities between hagfishes and lampreys, supporting their inclusion within Craniata.^[9] The shift from Linnaean groupings to cladistic approaches accelerated in the 1980s, as exemplified by Philippe Janvier's 1981 cladistic analysis in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, which redefined Craniata based on shared derived characters like the cranium and associated sensory structures, prioritizing monophyly over traditional vertebral criteria and supplanting the outdated "Acraniata" dichotomy.^[10]

Anatomy and Physiology

Cranial Structures

The cranium in craniates forms a protective enclosure around the brain, composed primarily of cartilage in primitive forms and evolving into more complex bony structures in advanced lineages. In hagfish, the only living non-vertebrate craniates, the cranium is rudimentary and fibrous, consisting of a thin cartilaginous neurocranium with a delicate roof that lacks extensive ossification, serving as a basic scaffold rather than a robust enclosure.^[11] In vertebrates, the cranium develops into a more elaborate structure, including an ossified neurocranium derived from cartilage that encases the brain and sensory capsules, alongside a dermatocranium of dermal bones that reinforces the skull roof and sides.^[12] This cartilaginous base in vertebrates often ossifies through endochondral processes, providing greater durability.^[11] Associated skeletal elements include the branchial arches, which originate as cartilaginous bars supporting the pharynx in all craniates, and remnants of the notochord at the skull base. In hagfish, these arches remain simple and non-jawed, functioning in respiration and feeding with keratinous tooth plates.^[11] In gnathostomes (jawed vertebrates), the anterior branchial arches evolve into the jaw apparatus, with the mandibular arch forming the upper and lower jaws, enabling complex predation.^[13] Notochord remnants persist in the skull base across craniates, influencing the formation of parachordal cartilages in hagfish and contributing to the basioccipital region in vertebrates, where they provide axial support.^[12] Developmentally, cranial structures arise from contributions of neural crest cells, which migrate to form the cranial mesenchyme that differentiates into cartilages and bones of the neurocranium and viscerocranium. In hagfish, neural crest-derived ectomesenchyme populates rostral elements, while paraxial mesoderm forms basal components under notochordal influence.^[12] In vertebrates, cranial neural crest cells specifically generate the skeletal elements of the head, including pharyngeal arches that integrate with ectodermal placodes to facilitate sensory organ attachment and patterning.^[14] This mesenchyme supports the integration of cranial nerves and sensory systems, though detailed neural functionalities extend beyond structural roles.^[14] Functionally, these cranial structures provide essential support for brain expansion and the positioning of sensory organs, enhancing navigational abilities and predatory efficiency in craniates. The cranium's enclosure protects the enlarging brain, while associated arches and jaws in gnathostomes allow for bite force and food processing, marking a key adaptation for active lifestyles.^[4] In hagfish, the simpler design accommodates a scavenging ecology, underscoring the cranium's role in head formation across diverse habitats.^[11]

Sensory and Nervous Systems

The nervous system of craniates features a centralized dorsal nerve cord, known as the spinal cord, which extends caudally from the brain. In vertebrates, it is protected within the vertebral column; whereas in hagfish, rudimentary cartilaginous arcualia provide partial protection.^[15] It consists of white matter tracts for signal conduction and gray matter containing neuronal cell bodies, with segmental dorsal root ganglia housing sensory neuron cell bodies at each spinal level.^[16] These ganglia enable the integration of peripheral sensory inputs into the central nervous system, facilitating reflexes and coordinated motor responses. The brain itself is enlarged relative to non-craniates, organized into three primary regions: the forebrain (prosencephalon), which includes structures for sensory processing and higher cognition; the midbrain (mesencephalon), involved in visual and auditory reflexes; and the hindbrain (rhombencephalon), comprising the medulla oblongata and cerebellum for vital functions like respiration and balance.^[17] Craniates possess advanced sensory organs that interface with this neural architecture, allowing sophisticated environmental perception. Paired eyes with image-forming retinas predominate, featuring photoreceptor cells (rods and cones) that transduce light into electrical signals processed via the optic nerve to the brain's visual centers, though hagfish exhibit rudimentary, non-image-forming eyes lacking lenses and corneas.^[18] Olfactory organs, consisting of sensory epithelia with bipolar neurons detecting chemical cues, connect directly to the forebrain's olfactory bulbs for chemosensation critical to feeding and navigation. In aquatic craniates, the lateral line system provides mechanoreception through sensory structures such as neuromasts (clusters of hair cells) in many species or simple grooves in hagfish, in superficial canals or free on the skin—that detect water movements and pressure gradients, relaying signals via cranial nerves to the hindbrain for spatial awareness.^[19]^[20] The inner ear, derived from ectodermal thickenings associated with gill arches, includes semicircular canals filled with endolymph fluid; these detect angular head accelerations through cupula deflection in hair cells, projecting to vestibular nuclei in the hindbrain for balance and equilibrium maintenance—hagfish possess a single canal, lampreys two, and most jawed forms three.^[21] Neural crest-derived cells play a pivotal role in physiological integration, contributing sensory and autonomic neurons to cranial and spinal ganglia, Schwann cells that provide myelination in vertebrates, and peripheral glia, thereby enabling complex, coordinated reflexes such as escape responses and sensory-motor loops absent in non-craniates.^[22]^[23] This neural crest contribution enhances signal fidelity and behavioral adaptability, with cranial ganglia (e.g., trigeminal for touch) integrating inputs from multiple modalities. The cranium provides bony or cartilaginous enclosure for the brain and sensory capsules, safeguarding these systems during locomotion.^[22]

Evolutionary Origins

Phylogenetic Position

Craniata occupies a pivotal position within the phylum Chordata, forming the sister clade to Tunicata (urochordates) in the larger grouping known as Olfactores, with Cephalochordata (lancelets) serving as the successive outgroup to this clade based on extensive molecular phylogenetic analyses.^[24] This arrangement reflects a derived evolutionary lineage where Craniata diverged from the common ancestor shared with Tunicata, highlighting the monophyly of chordates through shared developmental genetic toolkits. The monophyly of Craniata is robustly supported by molecular evidence, including analyses of 18S and 28S rRNA genes, which demonstrate close affinities between hagfishes (Myxini) and vertebrates (lampreys plus jawed vertebrates), resolving earlier morphological uncertainties about hagfish placement. Mitochondrial genome sequences further corroborate this unity, showing conserved synteny and gene arrangements that distinguish Craniata from non-craniate chordates.^[25] Shared Hox gene clusters, particularly the presence of multiple paralogous groups resulting from ancient whole-genome duplications, provide additional genetic evidence linking Craniata internally while differentiating it from the single or partial Hox clusters in Tunicata and Cephalochordata.^[26] Key synapomorphies defining Craniata include the development of a cartilaginous cranium enclosing neural structures and a tripartite brain organization, traits absent in non-craniate chordates and marking the transition to advanced cephalization.^[25] The divergence between hagfishes and vertebrates is estimated at approximately 500 million years ago during the early Paleozoic, based on molecular clock calibrations integrating ribosomal and protein-coding genes.^[27] These innovations contrast sharply with the more decentralized nervous systems of non-craniate chordates, where neural elements lack centralized encapsulation and exhibit diffuse patterning along the body axis.^[24] Ongoing phylogenomic studies since the 2010s, leveraging whole-genome and transcriptome data, have solidified this positioning by overcoming limitations of earlier single-gene approaches and confirming Craniata's derived status within Chordata through high-resolution trees.^[28]

Fossil Evidence

The fossil record of craniates commences in the Early Cambrian with soft-bodied forms from the Chengjiang Lagerstätte in China, such as Myllokunmingia, dated to approximately 520–530 million years ago (Ma). This eel-like organism is interpreted as a proto-craniate, featuring a possible cranium, segmental myomeres, and a notochord, though its exact affinities remain debated due to the absence of definitive vertebral or cranial structures.^[29] Similarly, Haikouichthys from the same deposit exhibits a distinct head region with paired eyes, a possible otic capsule, and sensory structures suggestive of early vertebrate organization, representing a transitional form between chordates and more derived craniates.^[30] These Cambrian explosion taxa provide the earliest evidence of craniate-like anatomy, emerging rapidly alongside other bilaterian phyla.^[31] By the Ordovician period, around 450 Ma, more robust fossils appear, including Astraspis from North American deposits like the Harding Sandstone. This jawless form displays a star-shaped head shield of dermal plates, a series of branchial openings indicating gill arches, and hints of internal skeletal elements such as rudimentary vertebral arcs, marking an early diversification of armored agnathans within the craniate lineage.^[32] These specimens highlight the transition to better-preserved exoskeletons, though soft tissues remain elusive.^[33] The major diversification of craniates unfolded during the Silurian and Devonian periods (443–359 Ma), with the radiation of jawed gnathostomes including placoderms—armored predators like Dunkleosteus—and primitive chondrichthyans such as Cladoselache, which together dominated aquatic ecosystems and exhibited innovations in jaw mechanics and locomotion.^[34] In contrast, hagfish-like forms, characterized by soft, unarmored bodies, left a sparse fossil trail, with only rare impressions known from the Carboniferous and later, underscoring taphonomic challenges for non-mineralized taxa. Significant gaps persist in the pre-Cambrian record, where soft crania and other delicate features of early craniates are unlikely to preserve due to oxidative decay and lack of exceptional Lagerstätten, resulting in no confirmed fossils before ~520 Ma.^[35] Molecular clock analyses, integrating genetic divergence rates with fossil calibrations, suggest craniate origins in the Ediacaran-Cambrian transition around 550 Ma, implying a pre-Cambrian evolutionary phase obscured by these preservation biases.^[36]

Taxonomy and Classification

Historical Debates

The classification of hagfish within Craniata has been a central point of contention in vertebrate taxonomy since the 19th century, primarily due to their lack of vertebrae, a defining feature of Vertebrata. Early classifications, such as the 1806 proposal of Cyclostomi grouping hagfish and lampreys based on shared morphological traits like circular mouths, included them among jawless forms but often excluded them from true vertebrates owing to the absence of a vertebral column.^[37] This exclusion persisted into the early 20th century, with hagfish sometimes placed in a separate category from lampreys and gnathostomes, reflecting debates over whether their rudimentary skeletal elements warranted inclusion in Craniata solely on the basis of a cartilaginous cranium.^[38] Embryological investigations began to challenge this exclusion, highlighting developmental parallels with other craniates. In 1931, J.L. Conel's study of hagfish anatomy, drawing on Bashford Dean's earlier embryological collections, provided evidence of shared organogenic patterns, such as in the genital system, arguing for hagfish affinity to vertebrates despite morphological divergences.^[38] These findings contributed to a gradual shift, though hagfish remained controversial, with some 20th-century systematists maintaining their separation based on the "Acrania-Craniata" dichotomy that positioned non-craniate chordates apart from skull-bearing forms.^[39] The monophyly of Craniata faced further scrutiny in the 1970s with the rise of cladistic methods, which questioned the cranium as a reliable synapomorphy amid perceived paraphyly in cyclostome relationships. A 1977 analysis proposed lampreys grouping more closely with gnathostomes than with hagfish, based on neontological traits like branchial and neural structures, challenging the unity of jawless craniates.^[37] Philippe Janvier's 1981 review synthesized fossil and extant data on agnathan origins, emphasizing the phylogenetic significance of early jawless forms and supporting Craniata as a clade while noting unresolved ambiguities in hagfish positioning.^[40] Resolution emerged in the 1990s through molecular evidence affirming cyclostome monophyly and thus Craniata integrity. Stock and Whitt's 1992 analysis of 18S ribosomal RNA sequences demonstrated that lampreys and hagfish form a natural sister group to gnathostomes, countering paraphyly claims with genetic congruence.^[41] Complementary embryological work in the late 1990s and early 2000s identified shared neural crest-derived structures in hagfish, such as migratory cells contributing to craniofacial elements, reinforcing the cranium's synapomorphic status across the clade.^[9] By the post-2000 period, the "Acrania-Craniata" framework was deemed outdated, with consensus affirming Craniata as a monophyletic group encompassing hagfish, lampreys, and gnathostomes, despite hagfish-specific anomalies like slime glands that highlight their basal position.^[42] This resolution integrated molecular phylogenies, developmental genetics, and fossil calibrations, solidifying hagfish inclusion while acknowledging their derived traits.^[43]

Modern Systematics

In modern cladistic classification, Craniata is defined as a monophyletic clade comprising the subclass Myxini (hagfishes) and the subphylum Vertebrata, with hagfishes positioned as the sister group to all other vertebrates.^[28] This structure reflects the shared possession of a cranium while highlighting the divergence of hagfishes, which lack vertebrae, from the vertebral-bearing Vertebrata.^[44] Within Vertebrata, the clade is further subdivided into the jawless lampreys (order Petromyzontiformes) and the jawed Gnathostomata.^[25] Gnathostomata encompasses two major lineages: Chondrichthyes (cartilaginous fishes such as sharks and rays) and Osteichthyes (bony fishes, including tetrapods: amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals).^[28] The Myxini subgroup consists of two families—Myxinidae and Bdellostomidae—encompassing approximately 70 extant species, primarily deep-sea scavengers distributed worldwide.^[45] Phylogenomic analyses, building on microRNA-based studies like Heimberg et al. (2010) that first robustly supported Craniata monophyly through shared genetic markers, have been reinforced by whole-genome sequencing in the 2020s.^[46] Recent chromosome-scale assemblies of hagfish genomes confirm the branch lengths and monophyly of this topology, resolving ancient divergences with high confidence via synteny and ortholog comparisons.^[28]^[25] As of 2025, the consensus classification remains stable with no major revisions since the 2010s, though fossil evidence increasingly places extinct jawless groups like ostracoderms within stem-Craniata, extending the clade's temporal range into the Ordovician.^[47] This integration underscores the evolutionary continuity from Paleozoic armored forms to modern craniates without altering the core extant hierarchy.^[48]

References

[1]
https://bio.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Introductory_and_General_Biology/General_Biology_(Boundless)/29%3A_Vertebrates/29.01%3A_Chordates/29.1C%3A_The_Evolution_of_Craniata_and_Vertebrata
[2]
Invertebrates – INHS Environmental Education - Publish
Cephalochordata – Lancelets (33 species); Tunicata/Urochordata – Tunicates (2,792 species); Craniata/Vertebrata – Vertebrates (64,832 species). Based on Zhang ...
[3]
The phylum Vertebrata: a case for zoological recognition
Dec 26, 2018 · The following year, Balfour [3] altered the terminology of Vertebrata to Chordata and Craniata to Vertebrata (Fig. 1a), further emphasizing ...
[4]
https://bio.libretexts.org/Courses/Lumen_Learning/Biology_for_Majors_II_(Lumen)/15:_Module_12-_Vertebrates/15.05:_Craniates
[5]
Craniata - Tolweb.org
The Craniata fall into two major clades, the Hyperotreti, or hagfishes, and the Vertebrata. Since the early nineteenth Century, and until recently, the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[6]
[PDF] Elements of comparative anatomy - Darwin Online
COMPARATIVE. ANATOMY. BY. CARL. GEGENBAUR,. PROFESSOR OF ANATOMY AND DIRECTOR OF THE ANATOMICAL INSTITUTE AT Heidelberg. TRANSLATED BY.
[7]
Ernst Heinrich Philipp August Haeckel (1834-1919)
Jun 16, 2010 · Haeckel aggressively argued that the development of an embryo repeats or recapitulates the progressive stages of lower life forms and that by ...
[8]
Building the backbone: the development and evolution of vertebral ...
May 15, 2015 · Vertebral arches might have evolved first in the ancestral craniate. Craniates are chordates with a skull (Janvier, 1996) and comprise ...
[9]
Hagfish - Wikipedia
The term "Craniata" was used to refer to animals that had a developed skull, but were not considered true vertebrates. Molecular evidence in the early 1990s ...Pacific hagfish · Hagfish (band) · Inshore hagfish · Rubicundus
[10]
Hagfish embryology with reference to the evolution of the neural crest
Apr 5, 2007 · Here we report the obtainment of multiple pharyngula-stage embryos of the hagfish species Eptatretus burgeri and our preliminary analyses of their early ...
[11]
The phylogeny of the Craniata, with particular reference to the ...
Aug 24, 2010 · The phylogenetic relationships of the extant Craniata are analyzed, and the position of the best known fossil groups of jawless craniates is discussed.
[12]
The Skull – Comparative Vertebrate and Human Anatomy
Hagfishes (Myxinoidea) lack true jaws and vertebrae; they do have a chondrocranium and a simplified, cartilaginous versions of branchial arches called visceral ...Missing: composition | Show results with:composition
[13]
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1571356/
[14]
Evolution of the vertebrate jaw: comparative embryology and ...
The jaw in gnathostomes (jawed vertebrates) is one of the earliest innovations in the evolution of vertebrates and is derived from the mandibular arch (MA).
[15]
Cranial Neural Crest and Development of the Head Skeleton - NCBI
The cranial neural crest (CNC) forms the skull, jaws, and pharyngeal skeleton. CNC cells are patterned by intrinsic differences and signals from adjacent ...Introduction · Specification and Migration of... · Endoderm Patterns CNC and...
[16]
Neuroanatomy, Dorsal Root Ganglion - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf
Sep 21, 2022 · A dorsal root ganglion (DRG) carries sensory signals from the periphery to the CNS, located within the dural sheath, and houses primary sensory ...Missing: craniate | Show results with:craniate
[17]
Phylostratigraphic Profiles in Zebrafish Uncover Chordate Origins of ...
The vertebrate brain is composed of a forebrain, a midbrain, and a hindbrain, therefore having a tripartite organization (fig. 1).
[18]
Sensory system evolution at the origin of craniates - PubMed Central
The multiple events at the transition from non-craniate invertebrate ancestors to craniates included the gain and/or elaboration of migratory neural crest ...
[19]
Lateral Line System - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The lateral line system detects water flow with sensory organs called neuromasts, which are small cell clusters with sensory hair cells at their center. Many ...
[20]
Inner ear development in cyclostomes and evolution of ... - PubMed
Lampreys, which are modern cyclostomes, are generally thought to possess two semicircular canals whereas the hagfishes-which are also cyclostomes-have only a ...
[21]
Evolution and Development of the Neural Crest: An Overview - NIH
In the trunk region, neural crest cells form sensory and sympathetic ganglia, Schwann cells and adrenomedullary cells. Sacral neural crest cells, like vagal ...
[22]
Chordate evolution and the three-phylum system - PMC
Balfour [32] renamed Lankester's Vertebrata 'Chordata', and called the Craniata 'Vertebrata'. This system has been retained for more than a century due to ...5. Reclassification Of... · (b). Cephalochordata... · (iii). Vertebrata
[23]
The hagfish genome and the evolution of vertebrates - Nature
Jan 23, 2024 · As the only surviving lineages of jawless fishes, hagfishes and lampreys provide a crucial window into early vertebrate evolution.
[24]
Evolution of Hoxgene clusters in deuterostomes
Jul 2, 2013 · The expression patterns of Hox genes reflect their position in the cluster: genes at the 3′ end are expressed in and pattern the most ...
[25]
[PDF] Molecular evidence for the early history of living vertebrates
An early Palaeozoic divergence time {499 :t 36.8 Mya) was estimated for hagfish and lamprey. Vertebrates have left one of the best fossil records of any major ...
[26]
Hagfish genome elucidates vertebrate whole-genome duplication ...
Jan 12, 2024 · Our relaxed molecular clock analyses estimate the 1R event to have occurred 535.3–524.8 Ma (early Cambrian), 14.3–29.2 Myr before the divergence ...
[27]
New evidence on the anatomy and phylogeny of the earliest ...
We report the discovery of a new agnathan specimen from the Lower Cambrian Chengjiang Lagerstätte of China and thereby provide new evidence on the myomeres.
[28]
Head and backbone of the Early Cambrian vertebrate Haikouichthys
Jan 30, 2003 · Haikouichthys shows significant differences from other fossil agnathans: key features include a small lobate extension to the head, with eyes and possible ...
[29]
Vertebrate characters and the Cambrian vertebrates - ScienceDirect
Currently, the best documented and most informative, putative Cambrian vertebrates are Haikouichthys and Myllokunmingia, from the Early Cambrian of Chengjiang, ...
[30]
A Reassessment of Astraspis desiderata, the Oldest North ... - Science
A reconstruction of Astraspis shows, on the basis of the series of branchial openings, that it is a primitive craniate and not a heterostracan as previously ...
[31]
A Reassessment of Astraspis desiderata, the Oldest North ... - PubMed
The most recently found specimen of Astraspis was reexamined and found to show the orbit, a series of eight branchial openings and a complete tail, structures ...
[32]
The characters of Palaeozoic jawed vertebrates - PMC - NIH
Newly discovered fossils from the Silurian and Devonian periods are beginning to challenge embedded perceptions about the origin and early diversification ...
[33]
Exceptional Fossil Preservation and the Cambrian Explosion1
Exceptionally preserved, non-biomineralizing fossils contribute importantly to resolving details of the Cambrian explosion, but little to its overall patterns.Missing: craniates | Show results with:craniates
[34]
From Cambrian Chordates to the First Vertebrate Radiation
Nov 15, 2024 · The earliest definitive vertebrate fossils appear in the Lower Cambrian Period (approximately 525-520 million years ago), with Myllokunmingia ...Missing: craniate | Show results with:craniate
[35]
Using information in taxonomists' heads to resolve hagfish and ...
In 1806, a hypothesis in which hagfishes and lampreys were classified as the taxon Cyclostomi was proposed on the basis of shared morphological traits.
[36]
The History of Scientific Endeavors Towards Understanding Hagfish ...
This review summarizes the importance of hagfish embryology from a phylogenetic perspective, and the history of attempts to obtain hagfish eggs and embryos.
[37]
The Origin and Early Evolution of the Craniata | Short Courses in ...
Jul 17, 2017 · The first attempt at trying to understand the bauplan differences between “invertebrates” and craniates was by Geoffroy St. Hilaire in 1822, who ...
[38]
The Phylogeny of the Craniata, with Particular Reference to ... - jstor
The phylogenetic relationships of the extant Craniata are analyzed, and the position of the best known fossil groups of jawless craniates is discussed. Some of ...Missing: recognition | Show results with:recognition
[39]
Evidence from 18S Ribosomal RNA Sequences That Lampreys and ...
Whitt, Gregory S. Abstract. Lampreys and hagfishes (cyclostomes) traditionally were considered to be a natural (monophyletic) group. Recently, the consensus of ...
[40]
The hagfish genome and the evolution of vertebrates - PMC - NIH
Under either the Craniata or Cyclostomata hypothesis, living hagfishes provide a critical perspective on the evolutionary history of the vertebrate lineage, ...
[41]
Hagfish from the Cretaceous Tethys Sea and a reconciliation of the ...
Jan 22, 2019 · We report an unequivocal fossil hagfish from the early Late Cretaceous of Lebanon. The soft tissue anatomy includes key attributes of living hagfish.
[42]
microRNAs reveal the interrelationships of hagfish, lampreys, and ...
Hagfish and lampreys share 4 unique microRNA families, 15 unique paralogues of more primitive microRNA families, and 22 unique substitutions to the mature gene ...
[43]
FAMILY Details for Myxinidae - Hagfishes - FishBase
Nov 29, 2012 · Family Myxinidae - Hagfishes. Order, : Myxiniformes · Myxinidae. Class, : Myxini. No. in FishBase, : Genera : 6 | Species : 91 Eschmeyer's ...
[44]
microRNAs revive old views about jawless vertebrate divergence ...
Nov 1, 2010 · The contribution by Heimberg et al. (11) perhaps marks the end of the dream that, in common with the phylogeny of other groups, living jawless ...
[45]
The oldest three-dimensionally preserved vertebrate neurocranium
Sep 20, 2023 · Here we use computed tomography to describe the cranial anatomy of an Ordovician stem-group gnathostome: Eriptychius americanus from the Harding Sandstone of ...<|separator|>
[46]
Histology and affinity of anaspids, and the early evolution of the ...
... stem, and are known collectively as the 'ostracoderms' because they possess extensively developed dermal armour. ... The phylogeny of the Craniata, with ...