Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

DNA supercoil

DNA supercoiling refers to the topological state in which a closed-loop DNA molecule is twisted beyond its relaxed helical configuration, resulting in either over-winding (positive supercoiling) or under-winding (negative supercoiling) that forms superhelical structures.^[1] This phenomenon is quantified by the linking number (Lk), an integer representing the total number of times one DNA strand winds around the other, which remains constant in closed circular DNA and decomposes into the twist (Tw) (helical turns) and writhe (Wr) (superhelical coiling).^[1] Negative supercoiling, the more prevalent form in cellular DNA, underwinds the helix and generates right-handed superhelices, placing torsional stress on the molecule to facilitate processes requiring strand separation.^[2] In biological systems, DNA supercoiling plays a crucial role in compacting the genome, regulating gene expression, and driving essential transactions such as transcription, replication, and repair.^[2] Negative supercoiling lowers the energy barrier for unwinding DNA strands, thereby promoting the initiation and progression of RNA polymerase during transcription and helicase activity in replication forks.^[3] It also aids in DNA decatenation and unknotting by type II topoisomerases, preventing tangles in replicated chromosomes and maintaining genomic stability, particularly in bacteria where supercoiling levels are tightly controlled.^[3] Positive supercoiling, conversely, arises ahead of transcribing polymerases and must be actively relaxed to avoid stalling cellular processes.^[2] Supercoiling is dynamically managed by enzymes called topoisomerases, which alter DNA topology by creating transient breaks in the strands.^[2] In bacteria, DNA gyrase introduces negative supercoils using ATP hydrolysis, while topoisomerase I relaxes excess negative supercoiling to prevent hyper-activation of promoters.^[2] These mechanisms ensure that superhelical density—typically around -0.06 in Escherichia coli—remains optimal for cellular function, with disruptions targeted by antibiotics like quinolones that inhibit gyrase.^[1] First observed in polyoma virus DNA in the 1960s, supercoiling has since been recognized as a universal feature of DNA organization across prokaryotes and eukaryotes.^[2]

Fundamentals of DNA Supercoiling

Definition and Types

DNA supercoiling refers to the over- or under-winding of the DNA double helix beyond its relaxed B-form state, which introduces torsional stress and alters the molecule's topology. This structural feature is particularly prominent in closed circular DNA molecules, such as bacterial plasmids and viral genomes, where the ends are covalently sealed, preventing rotation and thus trapping the superhelical tension. The concept of DNA supercoiling was first elucidated in the 1960s by Jerome Vinograd and colleagues through sedimentation velocity experiments on polyoma viral DNA, which revealed distinct fast-sedimenting twisted circular forms compared to relaxed open circles. These studies demonstrated that supercoiling arises from deviations in the helical winding, leading to compensatory changes in the DNA's three-dimensional configuration to relieve strain. Supercoiling manifests in two primary types: negative and positive, distinguished by the direction of winding relative to the relaxed state. Negative supercoiling, characterized by underwinding (a deficit in helical turns), predominates in vivo across bacteria and eukaryotes, promoting DNA unwinding to facilitate essential processes like transcription initiation. For instance, in Escherichia coli, genomic DNA maintains a negative superhelical density of approximately −0.06, corresponding to about one negative superhelical turn every 175 base pairs.^[4] In contrast, positive supercoiling involves overwinding (an excess of helical turns) and typically arises transiently, such as in the region ahead of RNA polymerase during active transcription or at replication forks, where it must be rapidly relieved to prevent structural impediments. These types are topological properties, with negative supercoiling generally stabilizing open promoter complexes and positive supercoiling favoring compact chromatin-like states in certain contexts.

Topological Properties

The topological properties of DNA supercoils are characterized by three key invariants that describe the configuration of closed circular DNA molecules: the linking number (Lk), twist (Tw), and writhe (Wr). The linking number Lk quantifies the total number of times one strand of the DNA double helix winds around the other in a closed, circular topology, remaining constant unless altered by specific enzymatic action. Twist (Tw) measures the number of helical turns within the DNA double helix itself, reflecting the local helical winding of the base pairs, while writhe (Wr) captures the coiling of the DNA's central axis in space, independent of the internal helix. These quantities are related by the equation Lk = Tw + Wr, which partitions the overall topology into local helical deformation and global axis geometry. In the relaxed state, where no supercoiling is present, the DNA adopts the standard B-form conformation with approximately 10.5 base pairs per helical turn, yielding a reference linking number Lk_0 that corresponds to the natural helical winding without torsional stress. The degree of supercoiling is then quantified by the superhelical density \sigma = \frac{Lk - Lk_0}{Lk_0}, a dimensionless parameter that indicates the relative under- or overwinding of the molecule; negative values of \sigma denote underwinding (negative supercoiling), which is prevalent in cellular DNA. In vivo, superhelical densities typically range from -0.03 to -0.06 in bacterial cells, reflecting a constrained yet dynamic topological state that influences DNA structure.^[4]^[5] Supercoiled DNA manifests these topological invariants through distinct structural forms, primarily plectonemic and toroidal supercoils. Plectonemic supercoils involve the interwinding of the DNA duplex around itself in a side-by-side, branched configuration, where negative supercoiling produces right-handed plectonemes and positive supercoiling yields left-handed ones, allowing the writhe to absorb much of the topological stress. In contrast, toroidal supercoils feature the DNA axis wrapping around a virtual toroidal core in a solenoid-like manner without intersegmental crossing, distributing the writhe more uniformly along the molecule. These geometries represent alternative partitions of writhe, with plectonemes favored under low ionic strength conditions and toroids under higher crowding or wrapping scenarios.^[5]00896-2)

Mechanisms Generating Supercoiling

Enzymatic Processes

Enzymatic processes play a central role in the active management of DNA supercoiling, primarily through the action of topoisomerases, which regulate the linking number (Lk) of DNA to prevent topological stress during replication, transcription, and other cellular activities.^[6] Type I topoisomerases, such as TopoI in Escherichia coli, relax supercoils by creating a transient single-strand break in the DNA backbone, allowing the intact strand to pass through and thereby reducing torsional strain without requiring ATP hydrolysis.00178-2) In contrast, type II topoisomerases, including DNA gyrase and topoisomerase IV, introduce double-strand breaks and pass another double-stranded DNA segment through the break, altering Lk by steps of ±2; this mechanism is ATP-dependent and enables both relaxation and the introduction of supercoils.00055-1) DNA gyrase, a type II topoisomerase unique to bacteria, actively introduces negative supercoils into DNA, counteracting the positive supercoils generated ahead of replication and transcription forks. The enzyme wraps DNA in a right-handed manner around its core, forming a positive node that is then resolved through strand passage, with ATP binding and hydrolysis providing the energy to drive this thermodynamically unfavorable process against the natural tendency toward relaxation.01179-1) This ATP-driven mechanism allows gyrase to maintain a steady level of negative supercoiling, which is the predominant form in most cellular contexts, facilitating DNA unwinding for essential processes.00896-2) In hyperthermophilic organisms, reverse gyrase, a specialized type IA topoisomerase, introduces positive supercoils into DNA, enhancing thermal stability under extreme temperatures.00896-2) Found predominantly in archaea and some bacteria, reverse gyrase uses ATP hydrolysis to promote positive supercoiling, which compacts DNA and protects it from denaturation in high-heat environments.^[7] In vivo, supercoiling levels are dynamically balanced by the opposing activities of gyrase, which promotes negative supercoiling, and relaxing topoisomerases like TopoI and TopoIV, ensuring topological homeostasis amid fluctuating cellular demands.90140-X) This regulation is crucial in E. coli, where gyrase activity is modulated by supercoiling-sensitive promoters, and imbalances lead to compensatory adjustments in enzyme expression to restore equilibrium.^[8]

Non-Enzymatic Induction

Non-enzymatic induction of DNA supercoiling occurs through passive physical and chemical perturbations that alter the topological state of DNA without the involvement of enzymes such as topoisomerases. Intercalating agents, like ethidium bromide (EtBr), are prototypical molecules that insert between adjacent base pairs of the DNA double helix, causing local unwinding of the helical structure. This intercalation reduces the twist (Tw) by approximately 26 degrees per bound EtBr molecule, as the planar aromatic rings of the intercalator stack parallel to the bases, elongating and unwinding the DNA locally.90304-3) In covalently closed circular DNA, where the linking number (Lk) is fixed, this decrease in Tw is compensated by an increase in writhe (Wr), leading to positive supercoiling that relaxes preexisting negative supercoils or induces positive writhe.^[9] The binding affinity of EtBr is higher for negatively supercoiled DNA than for relaxed forms, facilitating titration experiments to quantify superhelical density.90304-3) This mechanism of intercalation-induced topological change has been instrumental in experimental analyses of DNA supercoiling. In agarose gel electrophoresis, EtBr is commonly added to visualize and separate topoisomers, as the dye's binding alters migration patterns based on superhelical states: negatively supercoiled DNA binds less EtBr initially and migrates faster, while progressive relaxation occurs with increasing dye concentration until a point of minimal supercoiling, after which positive supercoils form.^[10] Such in vitro probing allows precise determination of superhelical turns without enzymatic intervention, providing insights into DNA topology under controlled conditions. Other intercalators, such as daunomycin or actinomycin D, operate similarly by unwinding the helix and modulating Wr, though with varying unwinding angles and binding specificities.80004-1) A major non-enzymatic mechanism for generating supercoils arises during transcription and replication, where the progress of RNA or DNA polymerase along the helix creates torsional stress. According to the twin-domain model, the advancing polymerase induces positive supercoiling ahead of the transcription bubble and negative supercoiling behind it, as the enzyme rotation relative to the fixed Lk overwinds the DNA in front and underwinds it behind. This process, independent of topoisomerases, diffuses superhelical tension over domains and influences gene expression and process efficiency until relieved by relaxing enzymes.^[11] Beyond chemical agents, environmental factors like temperature fluctuations can non-enzymatically influence DNA supercoiling by affecting the intrinsic helical twist. The helical pitch of B-DNA increases with rising temperature, increasing the number of base pairs per turn and thus decreasing Tw; conversely, cooling enhances twist, making the helix more tightly wound.^[12] In closed circular DNA with invariant Lk, a temperature decrease (e.g., cold shock from 37°C to 15°C) therefore increases negative supercoiling, as the augmented Tw necessitates more negative Wr for compensation.^[13] This physical response has been observed in plasmid DNA, where cold exposure transiently heightens negative superhelical density before potential enzymatic adjustments.^[13]

Biological Roles

Chromatin Organization

In eukaryotic cells, negative supercoiling plays a crucial role in facilitating the wrapping of DNA around histone octamers to form nucleosomes, the basic unit of chromatin. Each nucleosome typically incorporates approximately 147 base pairs of DNA wrapped in about 1.7 left-handed superhelical turns, which constrains negative supercoils and promotes the initial compaction of the genome.^[14] This wrapping not only stabilizes the nucleosome core particle but also enables the formation of higher-order DNA loops, where unconstrained supercoils can drive the folding of chromatin fibers into more compact structures.^[15] Supercoiling further contributes to the organization of chromatin into distinct domains, such as topologically associating domains (TADs), where supercoils are often constrained within loops anchored by insulator proteins like CTCF. These CTCF-bound loops help delineate chromatin territories, preventing inappropriate interactions between distant genomic regions and facilitating territorial organization that supports cellular functions like replication and repair.^[16] By localizing torsional stress within these bounded loops, supercoiling maintains structural integrity across large-scale chromatin architectures. Enzymatic processes, such as those mediated by DNA gyrase, help sustain the appropriate levels of negative supercoiling necessary for this organization.^[17] In bacteria, supercoiling is essential for the extreme compaction of the nucleoid, reducing the effective length of the chromosome by approximately 1000-fold to fit within the cell. Negative supercoils induce the formation of plectonemic structures, where DNA strands intertwine to create right-handed superhelices that further condense the genome.^[18] Histone-like proteins such as HU and IHF bind to these supercoiled regions, stabilizing plectonemes and bridging DNA segments to enhance overall nucleoid compaction and organization.^[19] A key quantitative role of supercoiling in chromatin organization involves absorbing torsional stress generated during processes like replication fork progression, where unwinding of the double helix ahead of the fork produces positive supercoils that could otherwise stall machinery. In chromatin contexts, nucleosome arrays effectively absorb these supercoils, buffering mechanical stress and allowing smoother progression of the replication fork without widespread denaturation.^[20]

Transcriptional Control

During transcription, the advancement of RNA polymerase along the DNA template generates torsional stress, leading to the formation of positive supercoils ahead of the enzyme and negative supercoils behind it, as described by the twin-supercoiled-domain model. This model posits that the unwinding of DNA at the transcription bubble necessitates a compensatory rotation, which, in the absence of free rotation, results in over-winding (positive supercoiling) in the forward domain and under-winding (negative supercoiling) in the backward domain. Topoisomerases, such as DNA topoisomerase I and II, are essential for relieving this accumulated superhelical tension, preventing stalling of the polymerase and maintaining transcriptional fidelity. Negative supercoiling facilitates the initiation of transcription by promoting the melting of the promoter DNA double helix, thereby enhancing the binding and open complex formation of RNA polymerase.^[21] In bacterial systems, this effect is particularly evident in promoters like the lac operon of Escherichia coli, where increased negative superhelical density lowers the energy barrier for promoter unwinding, resulting in higher transcription initiation rates compared to relaxed DNA templates. In eukaryotes, DNA supercoiling contributes to transcriptional regulation by facilitating long-range interactions between enhancers and promoters through DNA looping. Negative supercoils stabilize these looped configurations, bringing distal regulatory elements into proximity with the transcription start site and thereby augmenting gene activation. In vitro transcription assays using supercoiled plasmid templates have demonstrated that negative supercoiling increases activation rates by up to several fold for bacterial promoters, with the effect diminishing or reversing under excessive superhelical tension. These experiments, conducted in the presence of purified RNA polymerase and topoisomerases, confirm the mechanistic link between supercoiling levels and transcriptional output, highlighting the role of torsional stress in modulating elongation efficiency.^[22]

Stress Response Adaptation

In response to cold shock, such as a sudden decrease in temperature from 37°C to 10–15°C in Escherichia coli, the DNA double helix experiences an increase in twist due to the stabilization of the B-form structure at lower temperatures, prompting compensatory negative supercoiling to maintain topological equilibrium.^[23] This transient increase in negative supercoiling, observed in plasmid DNA via agarose gel electrophoresis with chloroquine, is mediated by enhanced activity of DNA gyrase and involvement of the nucleoid-associated HU protein, as evidenced by its abolition with nalidixic acid (a gyrase inhibitor) and reduced effect in HU-deficient mutants.^[23] The altered balance between gyrase and topoisomerase I facilitates the upregulation of cold-induced genes, such as those encoding cold shock proteins (e.g., CspA), by promoting accessible promoter conformations for RNA polymerase binding and transcription initiation. During heat shock, elevated temperatures cause thermal unwinding of the DNA helix, leading to a rapid relaxation of negative supercoils and a relative buildup of positive supercoiling in E. coli.^[24] This topological shift, transient and reverting within minutes, is driven by reduced gyrase activity and increased topoisomerase I function, with contributions from heat shock-induced proteins like GroEL and DnaK that stabilize supercoiling dynamics.^[25] The resulting positive supercoiling activates the expression of heat shock proteins (e.g., via the σ^{32} regulon), enhancing cellular protection against protein denaturation and misfolding by facilitating stress-specific promoter recognition and transcription.^[24] Osmotic and oxidative stresses also induce dynamic changes in DNA supercoiling that influence sigma factor recruitment for stress gene activation in E. coli. Under hyperosmotic conditions, increased negative supercoiling promotes the induction of osmoprotectant genes like osmE through enhanced promoter activity, independent of but synergistic with the stationary-phase sigma factor RpoS (σ^S), as shown in mutants where supercoiling alterations via topA or gyrase inhibition disrupt osmotic responsiveness. Similarly, oxidative stress from hydrogen peroxide causes a transient decrease in negative supercoiling (relaxation), which signals through nucleoid proteins like Fis to activate topoisomerase I expression and broader stress responses, while DNA relaxation from such stresses is processed by the C-terminal domain of σ^S to recruit RNA polymerase to general stress genes.^[26] These supercoiling-mediated adjustments amplify the recruitment of alternative sigma factors, such as RpoS for osmotic and oxidative adaptation, ensuring coordinated gene expression under adverse conditions. In thermophilic organisms, adaptations to chronic high-temperature stress involve reverse gyrase, a unique ATP-dependent type I topoisomerase that maintains positive supercoiling to enhance DNA stability. Found exclusively in hyperthermophiles like Archaeoglobus fulgidus (optimal growth >80°C), reverse gyrase introduces positive supercoils by unwinding and re-passaging DNA strands via its helicase-like N-terminal domain and topoisomerase C-terminal domain, counteracting thermal denaturation and stabilizing the double helix against melting.^[27] This positive supercoiling prevents aberrant secondary structures, supports replication and transcription fidelity, and is essential for viability at extreme temperatures, as deletion mutants exhibit growth defects above 70°C.^[27]^[28]

Quantitative Descriptions

Linking Number Formalism

The linking number (Lk) serves as a fundamental topological invariant that quantifies the intertwining of the two strands in a closed circular DNA molecule. For two oriented, closed curves representing the DNA strands, Lk is defined by the Gauss linking integral:

Lk = \frac{1}{4\pi} \oint \oint \frac{ (\mathbf{r}_1 - \mathbf{r}_2) \cdot (d\mathbf{r}_1 \times d\mathbf{r}_2) }{ |\mathbf{r}_1 - \mathbf{r}_2|^3 },

where \mathbf{r}_1 and \mathbf{r}_2 are position vectors along the two curves. This integral yields an integer value for closed curves, reflecting the fixed number of times one strand links through the other, independent of deformations that do not break the strands. In the relaxed state of closed circular DNA, where the double helix adopts its natural B-form conformation without supercoiling, the linking number Lk_0 equals the twist number Tw_0, given by Lk_0 = N / h, with N the number of base pairs and h the helical repeat of approximately 10.5 base pairs per turn. This value arises from the intrinsic helical structure of B-DNA in solution. Supercoiling is characterized by the deviation from this relaxed state, defined as the change in linking number \Delta Lk = Lk - Lk_0. The superhelical density \sigma, a normalized measure of supercoiling extent, is then derived as \sigma = \Delta Lk / Lk_0, providing a dimensionless parameter that indicates the degree of underwinding (negative \sigma) or overwinding (positive \sigma) relative to the relaxed topology. DNA topoisomerases modulate supercoiling by altering Lk through transient strand breaks. Type I topoisomerases change Lk by units of \pm 1 by nicking one strand and allowing rotation before resealing, while Type II topoisomerases change Lk by units of \pm 2 by passing one double-stranded segment through another.

Energetics and Dynamics

The free energy associated with DNA supercoiling arises primarily from torsional stress and is approximated by the quadratic form G = \frac{K}{2} (\Delta Lk)^2, where \Delta Lk is the linking difference relative to the relaxed state, and K is an effective elastic constant with a value of approximately 1100 RT for DNA molecules longer than 2000 base pairs.^[29] This formulation captures the harmonic approximation of the energy stored in deviations from the equilibrium linking number, treating supercoiling as an elastic deformation analogous to a twisted rod. For negatively supercoiled DNA, this energy drives conformational changes, with the total free energy scaling with the square of the superhelical density \sigma = \Delta Lk / Lk_0, where Lk_0 is the linking number of relaxed B-DNA.^[29] In supercoiled DNA, the linking difference \Delta Lk partitions between changes in twist (\Delta Tw) and writhe (Wr), such that \Delta Lk = \Delta Tw + Wr. For long DNA molecules, there is an energetic preference for writhe over twist because writhe accommodates superhelical stress through geometric coiling with lower torsional penalty compared to uniform twisting along the helix, which incurs higher bending and electrostatic costs.^[30] This partitioning is more pronounced in negatively supercoiled states, where plectonemic writhe forms branched supercoils that minimize overall strain energy, as supported by theoretical models and simulations showing writhe fractions increasing with DNA length and superhelical density. The dynamics of supercoiling involve rapid interconversions between twist and writhe, governed by rotational diffusion and thermal fluctuations, with characteristic timescales on the order of milliseconds for twist propagation and seconds for writhe reconfiguration in micron-scale DNA. Ionic conditions significantly influence these rates; for instance, divalent cations like Mg²⁺ reduce electrostatic repulsion between phosphate backbones, facilitating faster writhe formation and interconversion by lowering the energy barrier for bending.^[31] In low-salt environments, interconversion slows due to heightened repulsion, whereas physiological Mg²⁺ concentrations (around 1-10 mM) accelerate dynamics, enabling responsive adaptation to cellular processes.^[31] Supercoiled DNA exhibits stability thresholds where accumulated torsional energy triggers phase transitions, such as the B-to-Z conformation change in susceptible sequences like poly(dG-dC). The critical superhelical density for this transition is approximately \sigma \approx -0.01 under low mechanical tension, though it rises to \sigma \approx -0.06 to -0.09 in standard physiological conditions, reflecting the energy relief provided by left-handed Z-DNA in absorbing negative superhelicity.^[32] This transition is cooperative and sequence-dependent, with the free energy of supercoiling providing the driving force once the critical density is exceeded, stabilizing alternative helical forms.^[32]

Modeling Approaches

Modeling approaches for DNA supercoiling primarily rely on computational frameworks that capture the polymer's elastic properties and topological constraints to simulate conformational dynamics in biological contexts. The worm-like chain (WLC) model serves as a foundational framework, treating DNA as a semi-flexible polymer with bending rigidity and torsional stiffness, while incorporating supercoiling through constraints on twist and writhe to predict equilibrium structures under torsional stress. This model has been extended to the twistable worm-like chain (TWLC) to account for both bending and twisting deformations, enabling simulations of supercoiled configurations where excess linking number leads to plectonemic or toroidal forms. Stochastic models, such as Monte Carlo (MC) simulations, are widely used to explore the ensemble of possible conformations for supercoiled DNA, efficiently sampling configurations that minimize elastic energy while satisfying topological invariants. In these simulations, plectoneme formation is modeled as branched, interwound structures that absorb negative supercoils, with MC moves like crankshaft rotations and slithering allowing rapid equilibration of chain segments to reveal how supercoiling density influences writhe partitioning and overall compactness.^[33] Additionally, MC methods simulate the diffusion of supercoils along the DNA chain by tracking twist propagation through rotational fluctuations, highlighting how barriers like protein binding can impede or facilitate this process. Brownian dynamics (BD) simulations build on these elastic models by incorporating hydrodynamic interactions and thermal noise to predict time-dependent behaviors of supercoiled DNA, such as the relaxation of torsional stress. These simulations treat DNA as a chain of rigid segments connected by flexible joints, evolving under Langevin equations to compute diffusion properties, including the propagation of supercoils along the molecule. BD predictions yield supercoil diffusion coefficients on the order of 10^5 bp^2/s in vivo conditions, reflecting the rapid redistribution of twist that influences gene regulation processes.^[34] Advanced models integrate supercoiling dynamics with nucleosome positioning to simulate chromatin fiber organization, where nucleosomes act as topological barriers that constrain writhe and influence higher-order folding. For instance, mesoscale simulations couple TWLC representations of linker DNA with nucleosome beads, demonstrating how supercoiling modulates nucleosome array compaction into solenoid or zigzag structures, with periodic spacing optimizing torsional stress absorption.^[35] These approaches use energetics of twist and bend as input parameters to predict how supercoiling-driven nucleosome repositioning facilitates chromatin accessibility during transcription.^[36]

Experimental Characterization

Sedimentation Analysis

Sedimentation analysis, particularly through analytical ultracentrifugation, provides a key method for detecting DNA supercoiling by measuring differences in sedimentation behavior between supercoiled and relaxed forms. The sedimentation coefficient (s), corrected to standard conditions (s20,w), quantifies the rate at which DNA molecules sediment under centrifugal force, reflecting their hydrodynamic properties. Supercoiled DNA, due to its compact plectonemic structure, exhibits a higher sedimentation coefficient than relaxed or nicked circular DNA, typically sedimenting 20-30% faster; for example, polyoma virus DNA shows s20,w values of approximately 21 S for the supercoiled form compared to 16 S for the nicked form.^[37] In cesium chloride (CsCl) density gradient ultracentrifugation, supercoiled DNA demonstrates buoyant density shifts, particularly when intercalating agents like ethidium bromide are added. These agents bind preferentially to supercoiled DNA, altering its topology and causing it to band at a higher buoyant density than relaxed forms; for instance, supercoiled polyoma DNA bands at about 1.784 g/cm³ versus 1.766 g/cm³ for the slower-sedimenting form in CsCl-ethidium bromide gradients.^[38] This technique was pivotal in the historical discovery and characterization of supercoiled DNA during the 1960s, as demonstrated by Jerome Vinograd and colleagues, who used sedimentation velocity and buoyant density analyses to distinguish the twisted, supercoiled form I from relaxed and nicked forms in polyoma virus DNA, establishing supercoiling as a fundamental topological feature of closed circular DNA.^[37]^[39] Despite its utility, sedimentation analysis has limitations, including high sensitivity to ionic strength, which modulates DNA conformation and thus alters sedimentation coefficients—for supercoiled plasmids, increasing salt concentrations can shift s20,w by up to 20% due to changes in electrostatic repulsion.^[40] Additionally, intercalators used in density gradients can introduce artifacts by relaxing supercoils or perturbing DNA structure, complicating interpretation of results.^[41]

Structural Visualization

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) enables the high-resolution imaging of supercoiled DNA molecules adsorbed on surfaces, such as mica or lipid bilayers, where plectonemic structures appear as interwound helices with visible branch points that manifest the writhe of the supercoil.^[42] Under high salt concentrations or surface charges that screen electrostatic repulsion, negatively supercoiled plasmids form compact, branched plectonemes, with AFM revealing irregular shapes and junctions where superhelical segments intersect.^[42] These observations highlight how ionic conditions modulate the 2D projection of 3D supercoiling, with branch points indicating sites of topological complexity.^[43] Electron microscopy (EM), particularly through metal shadowing or negative staining, provides detailed views of supercoil crossings in viral DNA, such as in bacteriophage phiX174 replicative form I, where plectonemic nodes are resolved as interwinding points along the circular genome.^[43] Cryo-EM and electron spectroscopic imaging further capture supercoiled configurations in protein-DNA complexes, showing compact gyres and compensatory supercoils introduced by factors like condensin, with outer diameters around 12 nm for ~188 bp segments.^[44] In low ionic strength, EM images display reduced nodes (1-2 per molecule) in negatively supercoiled DNA, contrasting with ~15 nodes at higher salt, underscoring the role of cations in stabilizing writhe.^[43] Single-molecule techniques, including magnetic tweezers coupled with fluorescence microscopy, allow real-time observation of dynamic supercoil formation under applied tension, where DNA buckling leads to plectoneme extrusion visible as shortened, fluorescently labeled segments.^[45] At forces below 0.6 pN and superhelical densities up to σ = -2.5, these methods track plectoneme growth and melting, revealing transitions from relaxed B-DNA to interwound structures.^[45] Such visualizations demonstrate the mechanical response of DNA to torsional stress, with plectonemes forming rapidly upon negative supercoiling.^[45] Key findings from these approaches include the observation of branched plectonemes in negatively supercoiled DNA, where EM and AFM confirm multiple superhelical arms emanating from junction points to distribute writhe and minimize energy.^[46] Branching frequency increases with superhelical density and DNA length, as seen in Monte Carlo simulations validated by imaging, providing insight into how topological writhe accommodates unconstrained twists.^[46]

Supercoiling Measurement Techniques

Gel electrophoresis is a cornerstone biochemical method for quantifying DNA supercoiling by separating topoisomers based on differences in their linking number (Lk). In one-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis, supercoiled DNA migrates faster than relaxed or linear forms due to its compact topology, but resolution of individual topoisomers is limited without intercalators. To enhance separation, chloroquine, a DNA intercalating agent, is incorporated into the gel and running buffer; it unwinds the DNA helix, altering the writhe and allowing better distinction of highly supercoiled species. For even higher resolution, particularly in samples with a broad distribution of topoisomers, two-dimensional (2D) agarose gel electrophoresis is employed: the first dimension runs without or with low chloroquine to separate based on size and basic topology, followed by a second dimension perpendicular to the first with higher chloroquine concentration to resolve topoisomers by their altered electrophoretic mobility. The resulting arc-shaped patterns on the gel enable direct counting of topoisomer bands relative to relaxed standards, providing a precise measure of superhelical density (σ = (Lk - Lk₀)/Lk₀). This technique has been instrumental in assessing supercoiling changes induced by topoisomerases or cellular stresses, with band intensities quantified via densitometry for population-level analysis.^[10]^[47]^[48] Topoisomerase relaxation assays offer a functional measure of residual supercoiling by exploiting the enzymes' ability to remove torsional stress. In these assays, isolated DNA (e.g., plasmid) is incubated with excess type I or type II topoisomerase under conditions that permit complete relaxation, converting supercoiled forms to a ladder of relaxed topoisomers differing by ±1 Lk. The extent of relaxation is then assessed by gel electrophoresis, where incomplete conversion indicates persistent superhelical tension resistant to the enzyme, often due to protein binding or sequence-specific barriers. For instance, bacterial topoisomerase I relaxes negative supercoils at rates up to 5 links per minute but halts at σ ≈ -0.05 in vivo-like conditions, revealing steady-state supercoiling levels. This method is particularly useful for comparing supercoiling in wild-type versus mutant cells, as the shift in the topoisomer distribution post-treatment quantifies the initial superhelical content. Variations include time-course incubations to derive relaxation kinetics, providing insights into enzyme efficiency under different supercoiling states.^[49]^[50] Psoralen photoreactivity assays detect superhelical stress through the enhanced intercalation and covalent crosslinking of psoralen derivatives (e.g., 4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen) to underwound DNA upon UV irradiation. In supercoiled DNA, negative torsional tension increases the helix unwinding, promoting psoralen binding at AT-rich sites and subsequent photoadduct formation at rates proportional to the superhelical density; relaxed DNA shows minimal reactivity. For in vitro measurements, purified DNA is treated with psoralen and exposed to 365 nm light, followed by quantification of crosslinks via Southern blotting or qPCR, where adduct frequency inversely correlates with σ (e.g., up to 2-3 fold higher in highly supercoiled plasmids). In vivo applications involve adding psoralen to intact cells, lysing post-irradiation, and mapping crosslinks genome-wide via sequencing, revealing domain-specific supercoiling patterns with resolutions down to kilobase scales. This probe's sensitivity to unconstrained supercoils has quantified average chromosomal superhelical densities around σ = -0.06 in bacteria, highlighting regional variations driven by transcription.^[51]^[52]^[53] In vivo supercoiling is indirectly quantified using reporter plasmids harboring supercoiling-sensitive promoters fused to quantifiable outputs like luciferase or GFP expression. These constructs, such as the E. coli tetA promoter, exhibit modulated transcription rates with supercoiling: negative supercoils facilitate open complex formation, increasing expression up to 10-fold at σ = -0.06, while relaxation represses it. Plasmids are introduced into cells, and supercoiling perturbations (e.g., via gyrase inhibitors like novobiocin) alter reporter activity, measured by fluorescence or enzymatic assays; expression levels inversely correlate with superhelical density, calibrated against direct gel measurements. This proxy has revealed supercoiling homeostasis in mutants lacking topoisomerases, with promoter sensitivity tied to AT-content and discriminator sequences. Seminal studies using such reporters demonstrated that plasmid supercoiling mirrors chromosomal levels, fluctuating with growth phase or stress.^[54]^[55]^[56]

References

[1]
[PDF] DNA Supercoiling
DNA supercoiling is a topological state where active DNA is not relaxed, but rather negatively supercoiled, resulting in right-handed superhelices.
[2]
DNA supercoiling is a fundamental regulatory principle in the control ...
DNA supercoiling, arising from underwinding, influences gene expression by impacting transcription and providing energy for DNA transactions.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[3]
DNA supercoiling and its role in DNA decatenation and unknotting
Negative supercoiling has an important biological function of facilitating local- and global-strand separation of DNA molecules such as these occurring during ...
[4]
Topological Behavior of Plasmid DNA | Microbiology Spectrum
Circular DNA extracted from cells turns out to be always (or nearly always) negatively supercoiled and has a σ between –0.03 and –0.09, but typically is near ...Topological Behavior Of... · Topology Of Circular Dna · Enzymes Of Dna Topology<|control11|><|separator|>
[5]
Dimensions of Plectonemically Supercoiled DNA - ScienceDirect.com
Closed circular DNA usually exists in a supercoiled, plectonemic configuration in which the DNA duplex is wound around another part of the same molecule to form ...
[6]
A novel and unified two-metal mechanism for DNA cleavage by type ...
Jun 3, 2010 · Topoisomerases transiently make either single-strand (type I topoisomerases) or double-strand (type II) breaks in DNA to prevent the ...
[7]
Kinetic insights into the temperature dependence of DNA strand ...
Jul 14, 2017 · These enzymes are capable of relaxing negative DNA supercoils, or introducing positive DNA supercoils in the case of reverse gyrase.
[8]
Inhibition of the gyrA promoter by transcription-coupled DNA ...
Oct 3, 2018 · DNA supercoiling in vivo is determined by counteractions of DNA topoisomerase I & IV (relaxation) and DNA gyrase ((−) supercoiling).
[9]
Supercoiling of polyoma virus DNA measured by its interaction with ...
Exposure of polyoma virus DNA to increasing amounts of the intercalating drug ethidium bromide reduces the sedimentation velocity of the fast component of ...
[10]
Two-Dimensional Gel Electrophoresis to Resolve DNA Topoisomers
This chapter describes the technique of two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis and how it can be used to resolve a spectrum of DNA topoisomers.
[11]
temperature dependence of the helical twist of DNA - Oxford Academic
Jul 24, 2018 · A defining feature of DNA is its helicity. DNA unwinds with increasing temperature, even for temperatures well below the melting temperature.Missing: enzymatic | Show results with:enzymatic
[12]
Increase in negative supercoiling of plasmid DNA in
Negative supercoiling of plasmid DNA in Escherichia coli cells can decrease transiently when exposed to heat shock. The effect of cold shock on DNA super-.Missing: non- enzymatic
[13]
A physiological role for DNA supercoiling in the osmotic ... - PubMed
We present evidence that DNA supercoiling plays a key role in the osmotic induction of proU transcription. An increase in extracellular osmolarity increases in ...
[14]
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5659657/
[15]
DNA topology in chromatin is defined by nucleosome spacing - NIH
Oct 27, 2017 · Abstract. In eukaryotic nucleosomes, DNA makes ~1.7 superhelical turns around histone octamer. However, there is a long-standing discrepancy ...
[16]
The regulatory role of DNA supercoiling in nucleoprotein complex ...
Nov 19, 2016 · Under these conditions, the maximal negative constraint was ∼1.7 superhelical turns/nucleosome. This value is comparable to that obtained ...
[17]
Transcription forms and remodels supercoiling domains unfolding ...
We suggest that supercoiling domains create a topological environment that facilitates gene activation providing an evolutionary purpose for clustering genes ...
[18]
Transcription-induced supercoiling as the driving force of chromatin ...
Nov 13, 2017 · We show here that growing plectonemes resulting from transcription-induced supercoiling have the ability to actively push cohesin rings along chromatin fibres.
[19]
Organization and segregation of bacterial chromosomes - PMC
The bacterial chromosome must be compacted over 1000-fold to fit into its cellular compartment. How it is condensed, organized and ultimately segregated has ...
[20]
Bacterial chromosome organization and segregation - PMC
Nov 13, 2016 · Within macrodomains and chromosomal interaction domains, loops of genomic DNA are supercoiled, likely forming plectonemes that coil up around ...Proteins That Anchor... · Nucleoid-Associated Proteins... · Figure 5. Chromosome...
[21]
Synergistic Coordination of Chromatin Torsional Mechanics ... - NIH
Single Chromatin Substrates Effectively Absorb (+) Supercoiling. Despite the importance of chromatin torsional mechanics in replication, the torsional ...
[22]
Negative supercoiling induces spontaneous unwinding of ... - PubMed
We have examined the influence of negative supercoiling on the DNA structure of a bacterial promoter (tyrT from Escherichia coli)Missing: seminal paper
[23]
Inhibition of DNA Supercoiling-dependent Transcriptional Activation ...
Closed-circular supercoiled plasmids were used as DNA templates for in vitrotranscription assays performed in the absence and presence of purified IHF protein.
[24]
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK6243/
[25]
Possible Roles of DNA Supercoiling in Transcription - NCBI - NIH
DNA supercoiling also changes transiently during heat shock. The heat stress induces rapid relaxation of negative supercoils and then DNA topology returns back ...
[26]
Topoisomerase activity during the heat shock response in ...
These results suggest that gyrase and proteins synthesized during heat shock are responsible for the changes seen in plasmid supercoiling. Proteins GroE and ...
[27]
General stress response signaling - PubMed Central - NIH
Here we show that the signaling from multiple stresses that relax DNA is processed by a non-conserved 8 amino acid tail of the sigma 38 C-terminal domain (CTD).
[28]
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28331998/
[29]
Reverse gyrase is essential for microbial growth at 95 °C - PubMed
Reverse gyrase is an enzyme that induces positive supercoiling in closed circular DNA in vitro. It is unique to thermophilic organisms and found without ...
[30]
Competitive behavior of multiple, discrete B-Z transitions in ... - PNAS
in which K has the value 1100RT/N for a DNA greater than. 2000 bp in length. This excess free energy may be partitioned between superhelix formation and the ...
[31]
Exploring writhe in supercoiled minicircle DNA - PMC - NIH
No ethidium bromide was added to the gel. The removal of one helical turn results in a large increase in electrophoretic mobility, suggesting a large ...
[32]
The effect of ionic conditions on DNA helical repeat, effective ...
We determined the free energy of DNA supercoiling as a function of the concentration of magnesium and sodium chloride in solution by measuring the variance ...Missing: interconversion | Show results with:interconversion
[33]
Minute negative superhelicity is sufficient to induce the B-Z transition ...
The helical twist (θ) per base in B-DNA changes linearly with temperature ... Unfortunately, this additional effect of temperature on the helical twist ...Sign Up For Pnas Alerts · Results · Single-Molecule Fret And...<|control11|><|separator|>
[34]
Conformational and thermodynamic properties of supercoiled DNA
We used Monte Carlo simulations to investigate the conformational and thermodynamic properties of DNA molecules with physiological levels of supercoiling.
[35]
Internal motion of supercoiled DNA: brownian dynamics simulations ...
The BD simulations also predict with accuracy published experimental values of the diffusion coefficients of supercoiled DNA. To describe the rate of ...
[36]
DNA topology in chromatin is defined by nucleosome spacing
Oct 27, 2017 · DNA supercoiling in nucleosomes varies with DNA linker length, and altered linker spacing changes DNA topology, defining chromatin structure.
[37]
Effects of DNA supercoiling on chromatin architecture - PMC
This supercoiling changes the properties of the DNA helix in a manner that substantially alters the binding specificity of DNA binding proteins and complexes, ...Introduction · Perspective · Fig. 5
[38]
The twisted circular form of polyoma viral DNA. - PNAS
The major part of the DNA from polyoma virus has been shown to consist of circular base-paired duplex molecules without chain ends.'-' The intertwined cir-.
[39]
730 BIOCHEMISTRY: WEIL AND VINOGRAD PROC. NAS - PNAS
The sedimentation velocity of the 15 S DNA was compared with the sedimenta- tion velocity of 4X-174 DNA (16.0 S) in thesame solvent, and its molecular.
[40]
The twisted circular form of polyoma viral DNA - PubMed
The twisted circular form of polyoma viral DNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1965 May;53(5):1104-11. doi: 10.1073/pnas.53.5.1104. Authors. J Vinograd, J Lebowitz ...Missing: sedimentation | Show results with:sedimentation
[41]
The effect of ionic conditions on the conformations of supercoiled ...
Singly nicked circular DNA was prepared by limited digestion by DNase I in the presence of ethidium bromide (Barzilai, 1973). The nucleotide sequence of pAB4 ...
[42]
The impact of DNA intercalators on DNA and DNA-processing ... - NIH
Jun 18, 2015 · DNA intercalators, a type of fluorescent probes widely used to visualize DNA, can perturb DNA structure and stability.
[43]
Surface charge effects on the 2D conformation of supercoiled DNA
Apr 21, 2014 · Plasmid conformations were imaged by Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). ... supercoiled plectonemes are observed. We experimentally demonstrate ...
[44]
Electron and scanning force microscopy studies of alterations in ...
Oct 19, 2001 · The configuration of supercoiled DNA (scDNA) was investigated by electron microscopy and scanning force microscopy.Missing: plectonemes | Show results with:plectonemes
[45]
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25615283/
[46]
Experimental phase diagram of negatively supercoiled DNA ...
Feb 21, 2015 · Using magnetic tweezers combined with fluorescence imaging, we here study DNA structure as a function of negative supercoiling at the single-molecule level.
[47]
Conformational and thermodynamic properties of supercoiled DNA
The superhelix conformations are often branched, as observed using EM and Monte Carlo simulation. Moreover, branching is required to explain the ...Missing: plectonemes | Show results with:plectonemes
[48]
Two-dimensional agarose-gel electrophoresis of DNA topoisomers
Two-dimensional agarose-gel electrophoresis of DNA topoisomers. Methods Mol Biol. 1999:94:19-27. doi: 10.1385/1-59259-259-7:19. Authors. R Hanai , J Roca ...Missing: seminal paper<|separator|>
[49]
Methods to Quantitatively Measure Topological Changes Induced by ...
Agarose gel electrophoresis in the presence of chloroquine (an intercalating agent) can be used to resolve and characterize the population of topoisomers ...Missing: 2D | Show results with:2D
[50]
Topoisomerase Assays - PMC - NIH
Included are an assay for topoisomerase I activity based on relaxation of supercoiled DNA; an assay for topoisomerase II based on the decatenation of double ...
[51]
Roles of Topoisomerases in Maintaining Steady-state DNA ...
Topoisomerase I relaxed DNA at a faster rate, 5 links min−1, but only to a ς of −0.05. Inhibition of topoisomerase IV in wild-type cells increased supercoiling ...Experimental Procedures · Results · Topoisomerase Iv And...
[52]
Torsional tension in the DNA double helix measured with ...
The rate of covalent photobinding of trimethylpsoralen to DNA is greater when the DNA is wound with negative superhelical tension than when it is relaxed.
[53]
Localized torsional tension in the DNA of human cells - PMC - NIH
To examine torsional tension in specific regions of genomic DNA in vivo, we developed an assay using photoactivated psoralen as a probe for unconstrained DNA ...
[54]
Genome scale patterns of supercoiling in a bacterial chromosome
Mar 30, 2016 · We find that stationary phase E. coli cells display a gradient of negative supercoiling, with the terminus being more negatively supercoiled ...
[55]
In vivo correlation between DNA supercoiling and transcription
The superhelical density of pMT plasmid DNA in Escherichia coli cells was measured as a function of the transcriptional activity, which was reduced by ...
[56]
DNA Supercoiling-Dependent Gene Regulation in Chlamydia
DNA supercoiling has been shown to be a global mechanism of gene regulation in Escherichia coli and other bacteria (9, 20, 36, 47). Changes in negative ...Materials And Methods · Southern Blotting · Discussion
[57]
Role of the Discriminator Sequence in the Supercoiling Sensitivity of ...
It defines the predictive rule by which DNA supercoiling quantitatively modulates the expression rate of bacterial promoters, depending on the G/C content of ...