Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Etaoin shrdlu

Etaoin shrdlu is a phrase originating from the keyboard layout of the , where the letters e-t-a-o-i-n and s-h-r-d-l-u represent the two leftmost vertical columns arranged in descending order of in English text to optimize efficiency. This arrangement was derived from linguistic analyses of letter in English corpora. It was commonly typed by operators to fill incomplete lines of text or to signal errors for deletion during the hot-metal printing era, though it occasionally appeared in published newspapers due to oversights. The , invented by German-American engineer Ottmar Mergenthaler in the mid-1880s, with the first issued in and commercial use beginning in 1886, transformed the industry by automating the casting of entire lines of (known as slugs) from molten metal, vastly increasing the speed and volume of newspaper production compared to manual . By 1886, the machine was in commercial use, with major newspapers like the adopting it, enabling the rise of mass-circulation dailies in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The keyboard's etaoin-shrdlu layout reflected linguistic analysis of letter frequencies, a design choice that influenced workflows until the machine's decline with the advent of photocomposition and digital in the 1960s and 1970s. The phrase first appeared in print as an error in the Davenport Daily Republican on November 14, 1895, and subsequent instances, such as in the Dickenson County Herald in 1948, highlighted the errors inherent in high-pressure environments. In by 1931, "etaoin shrdlu" denoted bungled lines to be discarded, but its whimsical nature led to cultural adoption in literature, including James Thurber's 1931 story "The Night the Bed Fell," by in 1942, and a 1972 program named SHRDLU developed by . Today, it serves as a mnemonic for English letter frequencies and a nostalgic emblem of pre-digital printing technology.

Origins in Typography

Letter Frequency Arrangement

The phrase "etaoin shrdlu" originates from the statistical of letter frequencies in English, representing the twelve most common letters in descending order of occurrence: e, t, a, o, i, n, s, h, r, d, l, u. This arrangement reflects empirical counts derived from extensive examinations of English texts, where 'e' appears approximately 12.7% of the time, 't' 9.1%, 'a' 8.2%, 'o' 7.5%, 'i' 7.0%, 'n' 6.7%, 's' 6.3%, 'h' 6.1%, 'r' 6.0%, 'd' 4.3%, 'l' 4.0%, and 'u' 2.8%. These percentages are based on analyses of large corpora of written English. An of the Concise (11th edition revised, 2004) provides slightly varying figures, such as e: 11.16%, t: 6.95%, a: 8.50%, confirming overall consistency. Historical studies of letter frequencies in English date back to the , influenced by practices and early . Samuel , in developing his during the 1830s and 1840s, consulted the distribution of type in printers' cases to assign shorter codes to more frequent letters, establishing an early quantitative basis for such rankings. Pre-digital analyses from this era, often tied to compositor workflows, confirmed similar hierarchies through manual tallies of letters in newspapers and books, laying groundwork for later cryptologic applications where became a cornerstone for decoding substitution ciphers. These 19th-century efforts, though less formalized than modern corpora like the —which draws from over two billion words of contemporary English—demonstrate the consistency of letter distributions over time. This frequency order optimizes efficiency by positioning the most common letters on the most accessible keys of mechanical keyboards, reducing operator fatigue and increasing speed in high-volume . In the context of early 20th-century innovations, such as the Linotype machine's keyboard layout, this ergonomic principle allowed skilled operators to compose lines of type more rapidly, as frequent letters required fewer finger movements. The resulting mnemonic "etaoin shrdlu" not only encapsulated linguistic patterns but also became a practical tool in workflows.

Linotype Machine Mechanics

The , invented by German-American engineer Ottmar Mergenthaler, represented a pivotal advancement in , enabling the rapid production of solid lines of type known as slugs, which were essential for high-volume newspaper printing. Development began in the late 1870s under a commission to create a mechanical system, culminating in Mergenthaler's breakthrough prototype patented on May 12, 1885 (U.S. Patent No. 317,828), with the first operational model demonstrated in 1886 at the . This innovation automated the assembly and casting process, allowing operators to set and cast 5,000 to 7,000 characters per hour, a vast improvement over manual compositing and transforming the efficiency of daily . By integrating a keyboard-driven selection with on-demand metal casting, the machine cast entire lines from molten lead alloy directly into reusable brass molds, producing durable slugs ready for press assembly without individual type handling. Central to the machine's operation was its specialized 90-key , divided into sections for lowercase, uppercase, and , with the optimized for English letter frequencies to reduce operator fatigue and increase speed. The leftmost vertical rows positioned the most common letters downward: the first row as e-t-a-o-i-n and the adjacent second row as s-h-r-d-l-u, allowing fingers to access high-frequency characters with minimal lateral movement in a QWERTY-like but frequency-based . When an operator typed, each key press released a corresponding brass —a thin embossed with the character—from one of the machine's magazines, which stored up to 90 sets of matrices sorted by notches for automatic redistribution after use. These matrices aligned in a to form a line up to about 30 ems wide, after which the assembly transferred to a casting mechanism where molten metal (typically a lead-antimony-tin heated to around 550°F) was injected under pressure to form the , which cooled and ejected while the matrices returned to their magazine via a elevator. Error correction during operation relied on the machine's line-by-line assembly, as partial lines could not be edited mid-process. To discard a faulty line without wasting time, operators commonly ran their fingers down the first two vertical rows, producing the nonsense sequence "etaoin shrdlu" to fill the matrix line, which was then cast into a discard and removed from . This technique, leveraging the 's ergonomic , ensured quick continuation while marking the error for , though occasional oversights allowed such to slip into final print. The overall mechanics, powered initially by in early "Blower" models and later by , underscored the Linotype's reliability, with machines weighing over 1,800 pounds and featuring thousands of interdependent parts for precise matrix handling and metal flow.

Historical Incidents

Accidental Print Appearances

The earliest documented accidental appearance of "etaoin shrdlu" in print occurred on December 2, 1895, in the Davenport Daily Republican. One of the early instances followed on October 30, 1903, in , where the phrase intruded into a sports article on contests, reading "Many close bowling contests were decided / last etaoin shrdlu." This error stemmed from a Linotype operator's quick fill to discard a faulty line, which was overlooked during . During the hot type era, from the late through the , such mishaps were relatively common in production, as operators frequently typed the sequence to flag errors for removal. Databases of historical U.S. newspapers record over 1,800 instances of "etaoin shrdlu" slipping into print across major dailies, equating to dozens of occurrences annually in prominent publications like those in and during peak years. These intrusions often appeared in less scrutinized sections, such as filler lines or short notices, where lapses were more likely. Notable anecdotes highlight the phrase's persistence into the mid-20th century. The magazine played with the term intentionally in pieces like Wolcott Gibbs's 1932 "Shrdlu Etaion." Internationally, similar errors surfaced in British papers during the , typically in obituaries or column fillers where rushed composition amplified risks. By the pre-1980s decline of , these slips had become emblematic of the era's mechanical vulnerabilities.

Impact on Publishing Practices

The phrase "etaoin shrdlu" served as a typographer's in the industry, instantly recognizable to compositors and as a marker of . Linotype operators, unable to delete mid-line due to the machine's mechanics, would complete a flawed line by running a finger down the first two columns—producing "etaoin" or the full "etaoin shrdlu"—to signal that the entire should be discarded. This practice became for sloppy workmanship and proofreading oversights, training new compositors to spot and excise such insertions during proofing stages to maintain quality. In workflows, "shrdlu" functioned as an informal deletion , equivalent to a modern block-and-delete command, streamlining error correction in hot-metal . Proofreaders routinely scanned galleys for these nonsense sequences, which, if missed, could lead to embarrassing print errors but underscored the importance of rigorous . This reliance on visual cues for error flagging influenced union-negotiated practices around compositor accountability, emphasizing speed alongside precision in high-volume production. The advent of and in the 1970s accelerated the decline of hot type, rendering "etaoin shrdlu" obsolete as Linotype machines were phased out across the industry. Major publishers, seeking reduced labor costs and faster production, transitioned to digital methods that eliminated the need for such manual error markers. ' shift on July 2, 1978—replacing 129 Linotype machines with just five computer terminals—symbolized of this era, minimizing typographical errors and transforming workflows by empowering reporters to directly layouts. Documented in the film Farewell, Etaoin Shrdlu, this change marked the phrase's fading relevance in daily , though it lingered as a nod to the tactile precision of traditional .

Technological Applications

Computing and AI Systems

One of the earliest computational applications of the phrase "etaoin shrdlu" appeared in SHRDLU, a pioneering program developed by at between 1968 and 1970. SHRDLU operated within a constrained "" simulation, where users could issue English commands to manipulate virtual blocks via a , and the system would parse, interpret, and respond to queries while maintaining a model of the environment. This demonstrated foundational techniques in procedural semantics and knowledge representation, allowing the program to handle ambiguities through and . The name SHRDLU, a of "etaoin shrdlu," was deliberately chosen to signify the system's experimental status, akin to nonsensical in that tested mechanical limits without implying meaningful content. In the mid-1970s, the full phrase inspired the naming of the ETAOIN SHRDLU chess program, authored by Garth Courtois Jr. at Michigan State University and implemented on a Nova 1200 minicomputer. This software participated in the ACM North American Computer Chess Championships, achieving third place in 1975 with a score of 3 out of 4 points and ninth place in 1976 with 1 point from three games. ETAOIN SHRDLU employed selective search algorithms and evaluation functions optimized for the era's limited hardware, contributing to the evolution of game-playing AI by balancing depth and breadth in move generation. The name evoked the efficiency of letter frequency layouts on keyboards, paralleling the program's focus on streamlined computation for strategic decision-making.

Software and Educational Tools

In educational software, the phrase "etaoin shrdlu" inspired the name of the virtual instructor Etienne Shrdlu in , a popular touch-typing program first released in 1987 by and later developed by Broderbund Software. This character guided users through keyboarding lessons, emphasizing finger placement and speed on layouts, drawing from the phrase's typographic roots to engage learners with a nod to printing history. The rogue-like video game NetHack, developed starting in 1987 by DevTeam and maintained as open-source software to the present, incorporates "etaoin shrdlu" as one of the randomized labels for unidentified magic scrolls. These Easter eggs reference the phrase's origins in Linotype keyboard mechanics, appearing sporadically in engravings, messages, or item descriptions to delight players familiar with typography. Beyond gaming and typing tutors, "etaoin shrdlu" serves as placeholder text in font design and digital publishing software, particularly for testing layouts and letter spacing. In tools like and , designers use the phrase—alongside pangrams—as dummy content to evaluate typeface readability and without semantic distraction, a practice that persists in 2025 standards for responsive web and print workflows. For instance, it approximates English letter frequencies (e.g., e-t-a-o-i-n as the top six), aiding quick prototypes in text generators and composition apps.

Cultural Depictions

Literature and Media

In literature, "etaoin shrdlu" has served as an evocative motif symbolizing the chaos and mechanization of early printing and typing technologies. The phrase underscores critiques of modernity in various works, where human lives mirror the inexorable clatter of adding machines and typewriters. Fredric Brown's 1942 science fiction short story "Etaoin Shrdlu," published in Unknown Worlds, anthropomorphizes a Linotype machine that achieves sentience after an operator repeatedly types the phrase during a late-night shift. The narrative blends horror and whimsy, portraying the machine's awakening as a magical event triggered by the nonsense string, which reflects real-world typesetting folklore. This tale, nominated for a Retro Hugo Award in 2018, exemplifies how "etaoin shrdlu" transitioned from technical jargon to a literary device exploring the blurred line between technology and the occult. Comics have occasionally invoked "etaoin shrdlu" for humorous or mystical effect. Film depictions emphasize "etaoin shrdlu" as a relic of printing heritage. The 2011 documentary Linotype: The Film, directed by Doug Wilson, chronicles the Linotype machine's invention and decline, spotlighting the phrase as a "magical" test string that typified hot-metal production and its role in democratizing text. Similarly, the 1978 short film Farewell, Etaoin Shrdlu, directed by David Loeb Weiss, captures the New York Times' final Linotype shift in 1978, using the title to mourn the era's end and its accidental print legends.

Music and Visual Arts

The phrase "etaoin shrdlu" has been incorporated into musical works as a symbol of mechanical precision and typographic heritage. The band Cul de Sac featured an opening track titled "Etaoin Shrdlu" on their album Crashes to Light, Minutes to Its Fall, an piece that layers dissonant guitars and percussion to evoke the clattering rhythm of Linotype machines. In performance and , Farewell, Etaoin Shrdlu (1978), directed by David Loeb Weiss and narrated by Carl Schlesinger, chronicles the final day of hot-metal at . The 28-minute work combines live footage of operators at their machines, ambient sounds of molten lead, and reflective narration to stage a poignant farewell to an era, blending archival elements with on-site performances of the process. referencing "etaoin shrdlu" often highlight its nostalgic ties to , appearing in graphic narratives during the and .

References

  1. [1]
    Etaoin shrdlu - WorldWideWords.org
    Sep 2, 2000 · Etaoin shrdlu is a sequence from old Linotype keyboards, used to fill out lines with nonsense, and now a mnemonic for most used letters in ...
  2. [2]
    Etaoin shrdlu - Origin & Meaning of the Phrase
    ### Summary of "etaoin shrdlu" from https://www.etymonline.com/word/etaoin%20shrdlu
  3. [3]
    The Linotype: The Machine that Revolutionized Movable Type
    Jun 8, 2022 · The phrase “etaoin shrdlu” is not a name but a signal phrase that a composer would type out to signify that there was a typo in the slug. The ...
  4. [4]
    [PDF] The frequency of the letters of the alphabet in English
    The frequency of the letters of the alphabet in English ... An analysis of the letters occurring in the words listed in the main entries of the Concise Oxford.
  5. [5]
    The Electrical Telegraph | Getting the Message - Oxford Academic
    According to another story, Morse deduced the relative frequency of the letters from the lead types of the compositors at the local newspaper. 5. A very ...Britannia Rules The Cables · Morse Code Versus Binary... · Diplomacy<|control11|><|separator|>
  6. [6]
    http://www.math.utah.edu/~fguevara/ACCESS2013/freq.html
  7. [7]
    Frequency - Oxford English Dictionary
    Historical frequency values are derived from Google Books Ngrams (version 2), a data set based on a corpus of several million books printed in English between ...
  8. [8]
    FAQs, Myths, & Misconceptions (Linotype/Intertype) - Circuitous Root®
    In 1890 Ottmar Mergenthaler also demonstrated in public a prototype of a revised machine which was very similar to the model introduced commercially in 1892.
  9. [9]
    Ottmar Mergenthaler Invents the Linotype - History of Information
    A skilled operator of a Linotype could produce up to 6000 ems per hour as compared to handsetting which could produce 250 ems per hour. Mergenthaler developed ...Missing: frequency analysis source
  10. [10]
    Ottmar Mergenthaler | Immigrant Entrepreneurship
    The invention was the result of a decade of intense engagement with mechanized typesetting machines and the surrounding literature. The Linotype represented a ...
  11. [11]
    ETAOIN and SHRDLU - The Engines of Our Ingenuity
    Linotype operators call down individual letters from a magazine. They form a row of letters that then becomes a die. It's used to cast a one-line slug in a ...
  12. [12]
    The Press: Etaoin Shrdlu - Time Magazine
    The easiest thing for him to do is to run his fingers down the first two vertical rows of his keyboard. The result is the emergence of a line containing “etaoin ...Missing: layout | Show results with:layout
  13. [13]
    File:Etaoin shrdlu.png - Wikimedia Commons
    English: An October 30, 1903 article from The New York Times containing the linotype string w:etaoin shrdlu. "Many close bowling contests were decided / last ...
  14. [14]
    Etaoin and Other Shrdlu in the News - Readex
    Mar 28, 2012 · Etaoin Shrdlu is a nonsense phrase from Linotype errors, created by running down the keys to finish a line, and sometimes printed by mistake.
  15. [15]
    Shrdlu Etaion | The New Yorker
    Shrdlu Etaion” by Wolcott Gibbs was published in the print edition of the December 10, 1932, issue of The New Yorker.Missing: etaoin | Show results with:etaoin
  16. [16]
    Sunday Times clue writing contest 1854: Linotype - The Times
    Occasionally, the “etaoin shrdlu” sequence from the first two columns, which was supposed to be easy for proof readers to spot, accidentally reached the printed ...
  17. [17]
    Etaoin shrdlu: learning to proofread on Baltimore Street
    May 17, 2021 · It became the universal practice of Linotype operators to address their errors by running down the first two columns of the keyboard, etaoin ...
  18. [18]
    Do You Know Etaoin Shrdlu? - CreativePro Network
    Nov 11, 2019 · Etaoin Shrdlu was born of the Linotype machine. Before Macs, before PCs, before Adobe Suite and Aldus PageMaker, there was the Linotype.
  19. [19]
    How It Was, How It Is - The New York Times
    Jul 3, 1978 · Five whirring machines, each no bigger than an executive desk, now do the work once done by 129 Linotype machines. When a labor contract was ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  20. [20]
    Procedures as a Representation for Data in a Computer Program for ...
    This paper describes a system for the computer understanding of English. The system answers questions, executes commands, and accepts information in normal ...Missing: original | Show results with:original
  21. [21]
    1975 U.S. Computer Chess Championship - David N. L. Levy ...
    ... Slate depth DUCHESS endgame ETAOIN SHRDLU evaluation factor FQMOBL heuristics IRON FISH K-B4 predicting K-side KAISSA King safety Larry Atkin look-ahead ...
  22. [22]
    ACM 1975 - Chessprogramming wiki
    Participants ; David Slate, Larry Atkin · Northwestern University · CDC Cyber 175 ; Michael Valenti, Zvonko Vranesic · University of Toronto · Amdahl.Missing: Lawrence | Show results with:Lawrence
  23. [23]
    ACM 1976 - Chessprogramming wiki
    David Slate, Larry Atkin · Northwestern University · CDC Cyber 175 · Chesstar ... Duke University · IBM 370 · ETAOIN SHRDLU, US, Garth Courtois Jr. Michigan State ...
  24. [24]
    Early Artificial Intelligence Projects - MIT CSAIL
    The name SHRDLU was derived from ETAOIN SHRDLU, the arrangement of the alpha keys on a Linotype machine, arranged in descending order of usage frequency in ...
  25. [25]
    What is ETAOIN SHRDLU? - Computer Hope
    Nov 13, 2018 · ETAOIN SHRDLU is a made-up phrase of the 12 most used letters in English, used as an in-joke by Linotype machine operators.
  26. [26]
    Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing 21 : Broderbund - Internet Archive
    Jan 31, 2022 · Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing 21. by: Broderbund. Publication date: 2008. Topics: Typing software, Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing. Item Size: 374.4M.
  27. [27]
    Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing - Classroom Edition - Windows
    In stock $5.82 deliveryThe most comprehensive typing instruction system now includes learning tools and an updated user interface to guarantee typing improvements in just 2 weeks!
  28. [28]
    Scroll origins - NetHack Wiki
    Jun 12, 2024 · ETAOIN SHRDLU: The most common letters in English, in order. The first two columns of a Linotype keyboard, used in print media in 1886 until the ...
  29. [29]
    Spacing Issue Dummy Text - the Adobe Blog
    Apr 23, 2018 · ETAOIN SHRDLU The twelve most common letters in the English language are another popular choice when a designer just needs a meaningless phrase ...
  30. [30]
    Technology, Capital, and the Degradation of Everyday Life in Elmer ...
    Nov 16, 2009 · Alienation as Death: Technology, Capital, and the Degradation of Everyday Life in Elmer Rice's The Adding Machine ... ETAOIN SHRDLU were ...
  31. [31]
    [PDF] THE ADDING MACHINE | ScholarWorks
    by Elmer Rice. January 24-February 2, 197 4. Su ba I Theatre. 8:15 p.m.. Page 2. THE ADDING MACHINE* by. Elmer Rice ... Etaoin Shrdlu .. .. . . .... . .... .. ...
  32. [32]
    Brown, Fredric - SFE
    ... Etaoin Shrdlu" (February 1942 Unknown) and "Arena" (June 1944 Astounding) ... The Fabulous Clipjoint (New York: E P Dutton, 1947) [hb/]; What Mad ...
  33. [33]
    Fredric Brown - Fantastic Fiction
    The Fabulous Clipjoint (1947) 2. The Dead Ringer (1948) 3. The Bloody ... 2018 Retro Hugo Award for Best Short Story (nominee) : Etaoin Shrdlu. 2018 ...
  34. [34]
    ETAOIN SRHLDCU. - languagehat.com
    Jan 7, 2013 · ETAOIN SHRDLU was made known widely by Pogo. Google tells me that “Elmer Rice's 1923 play, The Adding Machine, had Etaoin Shrdlu as a character” ...
  35. [35]
    archives.nypl.org -- New York Times Company records. General files
    ... Etaoin Shrdlu," about the transition, and the stereotype mat for the front page of the last issue of The Times set by linotype. In addition to changes in ...Missing: incident | Show results with:incident
  36. [36]
    Selected Papers On Fun and Games | PDF - Scribd
    Rating 5.0 (2) Reprinted by permission. ETAOIN SHRDLU non-crashing sets originally appeared in Word Ways 27 (1994), p. 138. Copyright 1994 by A. Ross Eckler.
  37. [37]
    'Linotype: The Film', by Doug Wilson, 2012 - Aphelis
    Oct 31, 2012 · Linotype: The Film is a very interesting, very well crafted documentary about a machine whose exact role in the history of modern media ...
  38. [38]
    https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4953&context=gc_etds
  39. [39]
    [PDF] Reclaiming the Margins of Film History Through the Orphan Film ...
    Jul 21, 2025 · and Farewell, Etaoin Shrdlu (1980), and a sneak preview of a work in progress by Sasha Waters. This symposium provided a comprehensive ...
  40. [40]
    https://www.discogs.com/release/463474-Cul-de-Sac-Crashes-To-Light-Minutes-To-Its-Fall
  41. [41]
    House of Cards Soundtrack - S2E10 (Chapter 23) - whatsong.org
    House of Cards Soundtrack. S2 E10 - (2 Songs). House of Cards ... Etaoin · Dallas Roberts. Gavin Orsay is hacking at the beginning of the episode. Amazon. Shrdlu.
  42. [42]
    Farewell, Etaoin Shrdlu (Short 1980) - IMDb
    Rating 8.4/10 (48) Farewell, Etaoin Shrdlu: Directed by David Loeb Weiss. With Carl Schlesinger. The last day of hot metal typesetting at the New York Times.
  43. [43]
    Star Wars at Marvel (1977-1987): Reviews by Confessor
    Nov 30, 2015 · Yep, Alan Moore wrote a total of ... being... in the background is saying "etaoin shrudlu", which is one letter off from "etaoin shrdlu"!
  44. [44]
    Brooklyn Street Art | …loves you more every day.
    “It may borrow heavily from advertising, branding, traditional mural making, and pop culture aesthetics or methods of creation and dissemination,”…Missing: printing press Etaoin