Frederick Horsman Varley (January 2, 1881 – September 8, 1969) was a British-born Canadian painter best known as a founding member of the Group of Seven, a collective that revolutionized Canadian art by emphasizing bold landscapes inspired by the nation's wilderness.[1][2][3] Immigrating to Toronto in 1912 after training at the Sheffield School of Art and the Académie Royale des Beaux-Arts in Antwerp, Varley distinguished himself through his expressive use of color and form, often infusing spiritual and emotional resonance into depictions of nature and the human figure.[1][2][3]Varley's early career in Canada involved commercial illustration at Grip Limited, where he connected with Group of Seven members like J.E.H.H. MacDonald and with the influential artist Tom Thomson, leading to sketching trips in Algonquin Park that shaped his landscape style.[1][4][3] During the First World War, he served as an official war artist for the Canadian War Memorials Fund from 1918 to 1920, producing poignant works such as For What? that captured the devastation of battlefields in France and Belgium, marking a shift toward themes of human suffering and resilience.[1][2][4]In 1920, Varley co-founded the Group of Seven, contributing iconic pieces like Stormy Weather, Georgian Bay (1921), which exemplifies his dramatic portrayal of Canada's rugged terrain with swirling skies and vibrant hues.[1][4] Unlike many peers focused solely on landscape, Varley's oeuvre uniquely integrated portraiture and figurative elements, influenced by Asian philosophies and his view of art as a spiritual pursuit.[1][2]Relocating to Vancouver in 1926, Varley headed the School of Decorative and Applied Arts and co-founded the British Columbia College of Arts, mentoring a generation of Western Canadian artists until financial and personal challenges prompted his return east in 1936.[1][4][3] Later travels to the Arctic in 1938 and the Soviet Union in 1954 enriched his palette with abstract and symbolic motifs, culminating in retrospectives like the 1954 exhibition at the Art Gallery of Toronto.[1][3] His legacy endures through over 600 works held in public collections, including the Varley Art Gallery in Markham, Ontario, established from a major donation by his longtime companion Kathleen McKay.[2][3]
Early Life
Childhood in England
Frederick Horsman Varley was born on January 2, 1881, in Sheffield, England, into a family rooted in the skilled trades of the industrial city. His father, Samuel Varley, worked as a lithographer, a profession that involved precise artistic reproduction techniques, while his mother was Lucy Barstow.[5][6] As the youngest of four children, Varley grew up in a household where creative pursuits were accessible, though the family's circumstances reflected the modest economic realities of Sheffield's working-class communities during the late Victorian era.[7][8]From a young age, Varley displayed a keen interest in drawing, nurtured by his father's encouragement and direct involvement in his early artistic endeavors. Samuel Varley introduced his son to sketching and frequently drove him to the outskirts of Sheffield, away from the urban clamor of steel mills and factories, to capture the surrounding landscapes.[5] These outings fostered Varley's initial exposure to art as a means of observing and interpreting the world, blending the stark industrial backdrop of his hometown with the more rugged terrains beyond.[2]The natural environments near Sheffield profoundly shaped Varley's formative creativity, as he was drawn to the wild hills, moors, and variable weather that contrasted with the city's grit. He often rose before dawn to explore these areas, sketching scenes of the countryside and developing a deep appreciation for nature's dramatic forms, which later echoed in his mature work.[2] This period of self-directed observation, supported by familial support amid everyday economic constraints, built the resilience and observational skills that defined his artistic roots.[9]
Artistic Training
Varley's interest in art emerged during his childhood in Sheffield, England, where he frequently engaged in sketching as a precursor to formal study.[2]In 1892, at the age of 11, he enrolled at the Sheffield School of Art, studying there until 1900 and focusing on foundational skills in life drawing and design.[10][1]Seeking advanced training, Varley moved to Antwerp, Belgium, in 1900 to attend the Académie Royale des Beaux-Arts from 1900 to 1902, where the curriculum emphasized academic realism and engagement with European masters such as Peter Paul Rubens.[10][1]During his studies in England and Belgium, Varley experimented with watercolor and oil media, building a strong foundation in portraiture and landscape techniques that would define his later professional output.[2][11]
Career
Early Professional Work in Canada
Varley immigrated to Toronto, Canada, in 1912, seeking new opportunities after limited success as an illustrator and teacher in England. Advised by his fellow Sheffield native Arthur Lismer, who had arrived the previous year, Varley quickly secured a position at Grip Limited, a leading commercial art and advertising firm in the city. There, he worked alongside other designers, including future Group of Seven members Lismer, J.E.H. MacDonald, Franklin Carmichael, and Tom Thomson, with A.Y. Jackson joining the firm in 1913.[12][3]At Grip, Varley engaged in commercial illustration, producing designs for book covers, posters, and advertising materials that reflected his training in technical drawing and color application from his studies in Sheffield and Antwerp. This work provided essential financial stability, allowing him to support his growing family while pursuing personal artistic endeavors. His contributions to the firm's projects honed his ability to adapt European stylistic influences to commercial demands, bridging his background to the North American market.[13][12]During these initial years, Varley created his first body of Canadian artwork, consisting of landscapes and portraits that explored the local environment. He sketched urban Toronto scenes, capturing the city's evolving streetscapes and architecture, and ventured into rural Ontario for plein-air studies of the countryside, often using watercolour to convey atmospheric effects. These pieces demonstrated his emerging engagement with Canadian subjects, distinct from his earlier English works.[2][12]The Grip studio served as a key hub for Varley's early artistic networks, where informal discussions and sketching sessions with colleagues laid the groundwork for future collaborations. He also began integrating into Toronto's broader art community, participating in exhibitions such as the 1912 Canadian National Exhibition and those of the Ontario Society of Artists in the mid-1910s, which helped establish his reputation among local artists and patrons.[14][12]
World War I Service
In early 1918, Frederick Varley was commissioned as an official war artist by the Canadian War Memorials Fund, joining the Canadian Expeditionary Force as an honorary captain specifically to document the war through painting.[2] He arrived in England in February and soon proceeded to the Western Front, where he attached to the Canadian Corps during the Hundred Days Offensive, advancing from Amiens, France, to Mons, Belgium, in the final months of the conflict.[15] His prior experience as a commercial illustrator in Toronto had honed his skills in rapid sketching under pressure, which proved invaluable amid the chaos of frontline conditions.[16]Varley's assignment focused on capturing the realities of combat, including ruined landscapes, artillery positions, and the human cost of battle, often working in oil on canvas despite the hazards of mud, shellfire, and gas.[1] Among his notable works from this period is For What? (1918), depicting a lone gravedigger beside a cart piled with Canadian soldiers' bodies near Arras, France, which starkly confronts the futility and scale of death without glorification.[17] Another powerful piece, The Sunken Road (1919), portrays mutilated German corpses in a devastated trench, drawing from photographs and direct observation to evoke the grotesque aftermath of bombardment.[18] He also produced portraits of soldiers, such as those of weary infantrymen and officers, highlighting individual resilience amid exhaustion and injury.[6]The horrors Varley witnessed profoundly traumatized him, including mass casualties from artillery and the sight of unburied dead strewn across no-man's-land, which he described in letters home as scenes beyond comprehension.[19] In one correspondence to his wife, he wrote, “You’ll never know…anything of what it means. I’m going to paint a picture of it, but heavens, it can’t say a thousandth part of a story…It is foul and smelly—and heartbreaking.”[19] These experiences shifted his artistic approach toward a more emotionally charged palette of muted earth tones and distorted forms, emphasizing psychological desolation over mere documentation, a somber evolution that marked his later landscapes and figures.[18]
Group of Seven Involvement
Frederick Horsman Varley was a founding member of the Group of Seven, a collective of Canadian artists established in 1920 to promote a distinctly national artistic vision through landscape painting.[1][20] The group, comprising Varley, Lawren Harris, J.E.H. MacDonald, A.Y. Jackson, Arthur Lismer, Franklin Carmichael, and Frank Johnston, emerged from earlier informal associations among Toronto-based designers and painters who sought to capture Canada's rugged wilderness in a modern, expressive style.[20] Varley's prior experiences, including his World War I service as an official war artist, briefly informed his bold approach to color and form within the group's endeavors.[1]The Group's inaugural exhibition opened on May 7, 1920, at the Art Gallery of Toronto (now the Art Gallery of Ontario), featuring 121 works that introduced their innovative interpretations of the Canadian landscape to the public.[20] Varley contributed several pieces to this show, emphasizing dramatic natural scenes that highlighted the untamed beauty of northern Ontario.[20] This debut marked a pivotal moment, positioning the Group as advocates for an art form rooted in Canada's own terrain rather than European academic traditions, with their paintings evoking the raw power of the wilderness to foster a sense of national identity.[20][21]During the early 1920s, Varley actively participated in the Group's sketching expeditions to the Algoma region along Lake Superior's north shore, where members traveled by boxcar on the Algoma Central Railway to access remote sites for on-location studies.[20] These trips, often organized and funded by Lawren Harris, allowed Varley to produce vibrant oil sketches and canvases capturing the area's autumnal forests and rocky cliffs, contributing to the collective's emphasis on direct engagement with nature.[20] A representative work from this period's influence is his 1921 painting Stormy Weather, Georgian Bay, which, though from a related 1921 sketching venture at Georgian Bay, exemplifies the stormy, emotive landscapes that aligned with the Group's wilderness themes.[22]Within the Group, Varley collaborated closely with Harris and MacDonald, whose leadership shaped the collective's aesthetic and promotional efforts. Harris's financial support enabled the Algoma outings, while MacDonald's poetic sensitivity to color influenced shared explorations of light and atmosphere in their plein air work.[20] These dynamics fostered a unified yet diverse output during the 1920s, with Varley's contributions peaking in his landscape paintings that blended post-war emotional intensity with the Group's nationalistic fervor, solidifying his role in defining Canadian modernism through nature.[1][20]
Later Career and Teaching
In 1926, Frederick Varley relocated to Vancouver, British Columbia, where he accepted a teaching position at the Vancouver School of Decorative and Applied Arts, serving as head of drawing, painting, and composition until 1933. In 1933, he co-founded the British Columbia College of Arts, where he taught until its closure in 1935.[2][9] During this decade on the West Coast, Varley immersed himself in the dramatic British Columbia landscapes, producing a significant body of work that included both expressive portraits and increasingly abstract interpretations of the natural environment.[1] His portraits captured local figures with psychological depth, while his landscapes evolved toward abstraction, as seen in watercolours like Snow People (c. 1929), which blend fluid forms and vibrant colour to evoke the region's misty mountains and forests.[2]By 1936, amid financial strains from the Great Depression, Varley returned east to Ontario, initially settling in Ottawa before moving to Montreal and eventually Toronto in 1944. In 1938, he joined fellow Group of Seven member A.Y. Jackson on a sketching trip to the Arctic aboard the RMS Nascopie, creating works inspired by the region's stark landscapes.[1][9] In Toronto, he became affiliated with the Canadian Society of Painters in Water Colour, contributing to its exhibitions and furthering his mastery of the medium, which he had honed extensively in Vancouver.[2] This period marked a continuation of his landscape focus but with growing experimentation in modernism, influenced by his interest in Eastern philosophies and colour symbolism.[1]In the post-war years, Varley delved deeper into spiritual themes, viewing art as a means to explore metaphysical states, as expressed in his 1936 letter describing painting as a "spiritual vocation."[1] Works like Liberation (1943) exemplify this shift, featuring bold, semi-abstract compositions that convey emotional and transcendent narratives through dynamic lines and luminous palettes.[2] He also resumed teaching, instructing summer sessions at the Doon School of Fine Arts near Kitchener, Ontario, in 1948 and 1949, where he mentored emerging artists in techniques emphasizing expression and colour theory.[2] Later, in the 1950s, Varley revisited British Columbia for inspiration and traveled abroad, including a 1954 trip to the Soviet Union, enriching his evolving modernist approach until his death in 1969.[1]
Personal Life
Marriages and Family
Frederick Varley married Maud Pinder in 1910 in England, shortly before the couple emigrated to Canada with their young family.[3] Together, they had four children: Dorothy (born 1910), John (born 1912), James (born 1915), and Peter (born 1921).[3] The family initially settled in Toronto, where Varley pursued his artistic career amid the demands of raising a growing household.[2]Varley's bohemian lifestyle, characterized by his nomadic tendencies and dedication to art over financial security, contributed to strained family relationships, compounded by chronic instability and inconsistent income.[12] The family faced hardships, including evictions from rented homes in Toronto during the 1920s, as Varley's earnings from commercial illustration and painting often proved insufficient.[2] By the early 1930s, the marriage had deteriorated, leading to separation around 1937, after which Varley lived apart from Maud and the children, first in Vancouver with companion Vera Weatherbie and later in eastern Canada.[3][2]In his later years, from 1950 onward, Varley formed a close companionship with Kathleen Gormley McKay, with whom he lived until his death in 1969; she provided emotional and practical support, including studio space for his work.[3] Despite the challenges, Varley's children served as muses for several of his portraits and domestic scenes, notably Dorothy (1925), a tender depiction of his eldest daughter, and The Artist's Son (1928), which captured the introspective quality of family life amid his evolving artistic focus on human subjects.[23][24] These works reflect how familial bonds informed his expressive portraiture, blending emotional depth with his signature bold use of color and form.[2]
Relocations and Challenges
After departing Vancouver in 1936 amid financial strain that forced the closure of his British Columbia College of Arts, Varley relocated to Ottawa to seek portrait commissions, but soon drifted between there and Montreal in a period marked by poverty and personal isolation.[12][2] During these years, he produced few artworks and battled alcoholism, which compounded his hardships.[25]Varley returned to Toronto in 1944, gradually reestablishing himself through teaching roles, including at the Doon School of Fine Arts near Kitchener in 1948 and 1949.[12][6] By 1957, he made a more permanent settlement in Unionville (now part of Markham, Ontario), residing there for the final twelve years of his life with companions Kathleen and Donald McKay, who offered crucial family-like support by providing a dedicated studio space.[2]In his later decades, Varley persisted with financial difficulties and bouts of isolation, though the McKays' encouragement helped sustain his productivity despite ongoing personal adversities.[2][12]Varley died on September 8, 1969, in Toronto at age 88 from age-related complications.[12] He was buried on the grounds of the McMichael Canadian Art Collection in Kleinburg, Ontario, joining other Group of Seven members in a site dedicated to their legacy.[12] In the immediate aftermath, Kathleen McKay honored his memory by donating numerous paintings and personal effects to Markham, forming the foundation for the Varley Art Gallery established in 1997.[2]
Artistic Style
Influences and Themes
Frederick Varley's artistic influences drew heavily from British academic traditions, where he trained at the Sheffield School of Art and the Académie Royale des Beaux-Arts in Antwerp, blending rigorous draftsmanship with the emotive lyricism of Romantic painters like J.M.W. Turner and John Constable.[26] His experiences as an official war artist during World War I profoundly shaped his worldview, instilling a preoccupation with human suffering and mortality that permeated his oeuvre.[17] Additionally, exposure to Eastern philosophies and Chinese painting during his time in Vancouver introduced mystical and symbolic elements, enriching his spiritual approach to art.[1] These influences merged with Canadian nationalism through his association with the Group of Seven, where he contributed to a distinctly national vision of the landscape while maintaining a personal focus on the human figure.[4]Central to Varley's themes were recurrent motifs of the Canadian wilderness, portrayed not merely as scenery but as a sublime force evoking awe and isolation, as seen in his Georgian Bay works that capture the raw power of nature.[1]Spirituality underpinned much of his practice, viewing art as a vocation to unlock the imagination and divine essence, influenced by Romantic ideals and later Asian mysticism, which infused his landscapes with transcendent qualities.[4] Human suffering emerged as a poignant theme, particularly from his war sketches depicting devastation and loss, reflecting a deep empathy for the fragility of life amid conflict.[17] His portraiture emphasized psychological depth, probing the inner lives of subjects including friends and Indigenous peoples encountered during travels, such as Inuit communities in the Arctic, where he sought to convey emotional authenticity and cultural presence.[27][26]In his later career, Varley's themes evolved from realistic depictions of the Canadian landscape toward more abstract and mystical representations, particularly in Vancouver, where generalized forms and ambiguous spaces suggested spiritual introspection and emotional abstraction.[26] This shift blended his British roots with Canadian identity, prioritizing evocative mood over literal detail to explore universal human experiences.[1]
Techniques and Evolution
Varley's early artistic practice, shaped by his training at the Sheffield School of Art and the Académie Royale des Beaux-Arts in Antwerp, emphasized watercolor as a primary medium for capturing loose, atmospheric effects in en plein air sketches.[2] He often combined watercolor with graphite underdrawings to achieve delicate, fluid impressions of landscapes, adapting European landscape traditions—such as those influenced by John Ruskin—to Canadian subjects like Ontario hillsides and harbors.[2] This approach allowed for rapid, on-site rendering of natural light and form, as seen in works like Ebb Tide, Whitby Harbour (c. 1905–6), where translucent washes created ethereal depth.[2] Donald W. Buchanan noted Varley's exceptional skill in watercolors, stating they "excel[ed] and surpass[ed] all other Canadian artists of his generation in his ability to depict the subtle nuances of light and atmosphere."[2]During his involvement with the Group of Seven in the 1920s, Varley transitioned to oil paints, employing bolder impasto techniques to build textured, dynamic surfaces that conveyed the rugged vitality of Canadian wilderness.[2] This shift from the fluidity of watercolor to the solidity of oil enabled thicker applications of pigment and broader strokes, enhancing the three-dimensionality of his compositions, as in war-related pieces like Shelled Buildings, France (1919).[2] His World War I service acted as a catalyst, pushing him toward more emotionally charged applications of paint to express the chaos of conflict.[28]In portraiture, Varley specialized in techniques that harnessed light and shadow to evoke emotional intensity, using dramatic contrasts to model faces and reveal inner psychological states.[28] He applied experimental approaches to color and illumination, often with bold, meaty brushstrokes for subjects that inspired him, creating restrained yet profound moods of dignity and introspection.[29] This method, rooted in his classical training but infused with modernist expressiveness, distinguished his portraits from mere likenesses, emphasizing subtle tonal gradations for depth.[30]Post-1930s, particularly during his Vancouver period and beyond, Varley's style evolved from representational forms toward semi-abstract compositions, incorporating vibrant color palettes—such as rose-pink, turquoise, and lilac—and vigorous, expressive brushwork to heighten emotional resonance.[2] In British Columbia landscapes like Snow People (c. 1929) and later impressionistic works such as Outside My Studio Window (c. 1963), he loosened forms into fluid, abstracted elements while retaining a core of observed reality, blending modernist experimentation with his foundational skills.[2] This progression reflected a deepening synthesis of European influences with the raw energy of Canadian environments, resulting in paintings marked by energetic impasto and intuitive renderings of light and volume.[2]
Recognition
Awards and Honors
Varley's service as an official war artist during the First World War represented one of his earliest formal recognitions from the Canadian government. Appointed in 1918 by the Canadian War Memorials Fund—a government-backed program led by Lord Beaverbrook—he accompanied Canadian troops on the Western Front, producing poignant depictions of the conflict's devastation. In 1919, following the Armistice, his works were acquired by the fund and exhibited publicly, earning commendations for their unflinching portrayal of war's human cost and contributing to the establishment of Canada's national war art collection.[14]His involvement with the Group of Seven, formalized in 1920, served as a collective honor that amplified his standing among Canadian artists.[31]Later in his career, Varley was conferred an honorary Doctor of Laws degree by the University of Manitoba in 1961, recognizing his lifelong dedication to art education and creative expression. In 1963, the City of Toronto awarded him the Civic Award of Merit for his enduring contributions to the cultural life of the city. The pinnacle of his individual accolades came in 1967 with his appointment as a Companion of the Order of Canada, the country's highest civilian honor, celebrating his profound impact on Canadian visual arts.[3]
Exhibitions and Collections
Varley's works gained significant international exposure through group exhibitions, notably the British Empire Exhibition at Wembley, London, in 1924 and 1925, where several pieces by the Group of Seven, including his landscapes, were displayed alongside global artists.[32][33]During his lifetime, Varley held notable solo exhibitions, such as his 1932 show at the Vancouver Art Gallery, which highlighted his evolving West Coast influences.[34] In 1954, the Art Gallery of Toronto (now the Art Gallery of Ontario) organized a major retrospective covering his paintings from 1915 to 1954, underscoring his contributions to Canadian modernism.[3]Posthumously, institutions continued to celebrate his legacy with comprehensive retrospectives. The National Gallery of Canada presented "Salute to Frederick Horsman Varley" in 1969, shortly after his death, featuring a broad selection of his oeuvre.[35] A centennial exhibition in 1981 traveled to venues including the Art Gallery of Greater Victoria and the National Gallery of Canada, emphasizing his foundational role in Canadian art.[36]Varley's paintings and drawings are prominently held in major Canadian public collections. The National Gallery of Canada houses key works such as Stormy Weather, Georgian Bay (1921), acquired following the Group's second exhibition, along with portraits like Self-portrait (1919) and Vera (1930s).[1][14] The Art Gallery of Ontario maintains an extensive holding, including over 30 paintings such as Immigrants (c. 1922), Liberation (1921), and West Coast Sunset, Vancouver (1926), as well as numerous drawings and watercolours.[3][37] The Vancouver Art Gallery features significant representations of his oeuvre, particularly his British Columbia-period landscapes, within its rich Canadian collection.[38] Additionally, the Varley Art Gallery of Markham preserves over 600 of his works (as of 2025), including a 2020 transfer of 474 items from the Art Gallery of Ontario, forming a dedicated institutional archive of his career.[2][39]
Notable Works
Selected Paintings
Frederick Varley's "Stormy Weather, Georgian Bay" (1921) is a quintessential landscape from his time with the Group of Seven, capturing the raw power of Canada's northern wilderness through turbulent skies and rocky shores battered by wind and waves. Created during a summer sketching trip to Georgian Bay, Ontario, the painting employs bold contrasts of green and blue tones to evoke the sublime force of nature, distinguishing Varley's expressive style from more literal depictions by his contemporaries. Oil on canvas, measuring 132.6 × 162.8 cm, it is held in the collection of the National Gallery of Canada in Ottawa.[40]In "For What?" (1918), Varley confronts the devastation of World War I, portraying a lone gravedigger resting beside a horse-drawn cart piled with shrouded corpses amid a desolate, muddy battlefield, symbolizing the senseless loss of life. Commissioned as part of his role as an official Canadian war artist, the work was developed from on-site sketches made near the front lines in France and Belgium, reflecting Varley's horror at the mechanized slaughter he witnessed. Rendered in oil on canvas (147.4 × 180.6 cm), it resides in the Beaverbrook Collection of War Art at the Canadian War Museum in Ottawa.[17]Varley's Arctic expedition in 1938 inspired works like "Iceberg" (1938), an oil on canvas depicting a majestic floating iceberg in icy waters under a pale sky, symbolizing isolation and the sublime beauty of the northern landscape. This piece, measuring 76.2 × 101.6 cm, captures his fascination with light and form in extreme environments and is held in the McMichael Canadian Art Collection in Kleinburg, Ontario.[41]
Auction Records
Frederick Varley's works have achieved significant prices at auction, reflecting growing appreciation for his contributions to Canadian art, particularly landscapes associated with the Group of Seven. The highest recorded sale is for Bridge Over Lynn (1935–1936), an oil on canvas depicting a dramatic West Coast scene, which fetched CAD 1,321,250 (including buyer's premium) at Heffel Fine Art Auction House in Toronto on November 21, 2024.[42] This sale surpassed previous benchmarks, underscoring the robust demand for Varley's mature period pieces from his time in British Columbia.Other notable high-value transactions include Sun and Wind, Georgian Bay (1916 or 1920), a quintessential Group of Seven landscape that sold for CAD 984,000 (including premium) at Cowley Abbott Auction House in Toronto on December 7, 2023, exceeding its pre-sale estimate by over ten times.[43] Earlier examples of strong market performance feature Vera (c. 1930s), a portrait that realized CAD 721,250 at Heffel in 2018, and Stormy Weather, Georgian Bay (1921), which brought CAD 661,250 at the same house in 2015.[44] These sales highlight the premium placed on Varley's early Ontario landscapes and portraits with strong provenance.
Since 2000, the market for Varley's art has shown rising interest, particularly in his Group of Seven-era landscapes and war-related pieces, driven by increased recognition of Canadian modernism and institutional acquisitions.[45] Auction values have trended upward, with average prices for oils climbing from around CAD 50,000 in the early 2000s to over CAD 200,000 in recent years, fueled by domestic collectors and the scarcity of major works.[46] As of November 16, 2025, no major sales have been recorded this year, though upcoming auctions indicate sustained demand. Factors such as impeccable provenance from private or museum collections, excellent condition, and exhibition history significantly influence values, often multiplying estimates for authenticated pieces.[47]