Future Present Past
Future Present Past is the second extended play by the American rock band the Strokes, released on June 3, 2016, through Cult Records, the independent label founded by frontman Julian Casablancas.[1][2] Comprising three original songs—"Drag Queen," "Oblivius," and "Threat of Joy"—along with a remix of "Oblivius" by drummer Fab Moretti, the EP marked the band's first new studio material in three years following their 2013 album Comedown Machine.[1][2] The title alludes to the stylistic influences of each track, with "Drag Queen" evoking a futuristic sound, "Oblivius" representing the band's present electronic-leaning phase, and "Threat of Joy" drawing from their raw garage rock past.[3] Issued amid the Strokes' intermittent activity and internal tensions, the EP received mixed critical reception, praised for its concise energy and nods to the band's evolution but critiqued for lacking innovation, with outlets like AllMusic awarding it 3.5 out of 5 stars and Pitchfork highlighting its role in sustaining the group's legacy for newer audiences rather than breaking new ground.[2][3]Background and Context
The Strokes' Post-2011 Hiatus
Following the release of their fifth studio album, Comedown Machine, on March 26, 2013, The Strokes entered an extended period of inactivity as a collective unit, with no subsequent full-length album until 2020.[4] The band opted against touring the record, a decision rooted in internal conflicts, including lead singer Julian Casablancas's expressed aversion to extensive road commitments, which he described as draining and uninspiring in later reflections on the group's dynamics.[5] These tensions, compounded by creative divergences—such as Casablancas's preference for solo production and collaborations over band obligations—resulted in a de facto hiatus without a formal dissolution, as members maintained amicable relations but prioritized individual paths.[6] During this interval, Casablancas channeled efforts into his side project, forming the experimental rock band The Voidz and releasing their debut album Tyranny on September 23, 2014, which featured politically charged lyrics and avant-garde arrangements diverging from The Strokes' garage rock roots.[7] Guitarist Nick Valensi developed his own group, CRX, debuting material in 2016 that emphasized his frontman role and riff-driven style, while Albert Hammond Jr. issued his second solo album, Moment of Weakness, in 2015, exploring introspective themes amid his ongoing recovery from substance issues.[8] Drummer Fabrizio Moretti engaged in visual arts and occasional collaborations, including early work toward his later project Machinegum, and bassist Nikolai Fraiture maintained a lower profile with limited public musical output. These pursuits underscored causal factors in the band's stasis: divergent artistic evolutions and personal priorities that reduced incentives for unified Strokes activity under RCA Records' expectations. By early 2016, informal jamming sessions among members signaled a tentative reconnection, motivated by a desire for low-stakes collaboration free from major-label timelines.[9] This shift facilitated a self-financed return through Casablancas's independent Cult Records imprint, bypassing external pressures that had strained prior efforts and allowing focus on unhurried output amid ongoing solo commitments.[10]Conceptual Origins and Band Dynamics
The Future Present Past EP originated in early 2016 as a compact, three-song project—later expanded with a remix—serving as The Strokes' tentative return following a three-year hiatus since their 2013 album Comedown Machine.[11] [12] This minimalist approach contrasted with prevailing industry tendencies toward extended, overproduced releases, emphasizing brevity to prioritize artistic immediacy over commercial elaboration.[13] The EP's title deliberately evokes temporal progression across its tracks: "Drag Queen" aligns with futuristic synth-driven drag imagery, "Oblivius" captures present-tense themes of forgetfulness and detachment, and "Threat of Joy" reflects retrospective confrontations with past anxieties.[14] Julian Casablancas, via his independent Cult Records label established in 2013, drove the self-managed release on June 3, 2016, eschewing major-label involvement to maintain uncompromised control and enable a swift rollout without typical promotional bloat.[11] This decision stemmed from a causal preference for raw, garage-rock roots over polished contemporary production norms, as evidenced by the EP's stripped-back aesthetic and Casablancas' parallel solo ventures favoring unadorned expression.[3] Band dynamics during ideation highlighted internal recoveries and contributions: Albert Hammond Jr. participated actively after addressing longstanding substance abuse challenges, which had intensified post-2006 but stabilized by his 2015 solo album Momentary Masters, allowing focused guitar and keyboard work.[15] [16] Nikolai Fraiture supplied foundational bass lines, including the driving patterns in "Threat of Joy" that evoke early post-punk influences without excess elaboration.[17]Production and Composition
Recording Sessions and Key Contributors
The Future Present Past EP was recorded across multiple studios in New York City—including The Music Building, Red Bull Studios, Electric Lady Studios, and East Village Recording Center—and in Austin, Texas, primarily during 2015, with production wrapping up ahead of the EP's June 3, 2016 release.[18][19] The sessions emphasized the band's core lineup working collaboratively with producer Gus Oberg, reflecting a streamlined approach suited to the EP's three original tracks plus one remix, rather than extended album-length commitments.[11][20] Key contributors included the full Strokes ensemble: Julian Casablancas on lead vocals and guitar, Nick Valensi on guitar, Albert Hammond Jr. on guitar and keyboards, Nikolai Fraiture on bass, and Fabrizio Moretti on drums, with no additional guest musicians credited on the primary recordings.[18] Engineering was handled by Chris Tabron and Phil Joly, who supported Oberg's production oversight to capture the band's live-oriented garage rock energy through minimal layering and direct takes.[18] Moretti additionally provided a remix of "Oblivius," incorporated as the fourth track to enhance digital playback options and offer a rhythmic variation on the original.[18] This personnel focus underscored the EP's in-house efficiency, prioritizing band cohesion over external studio elaboration.[11]Musical Style and Track Breakdown
The Future Present Past EP marks a reversion to The Strokes' foundational garage rock revival aesthetic, emphasizing terse, hook-laden compositions under four minutes each—"Drag Queen" at 3:33, "Oblivius" at 3:00, and "Threat of Joy" at 3:23—over the synth-pop and experimental detours of their 2010s albums Angles (2011) and Comedown Machine (2013).[3] [21] This stylistic pivot prioritizes angular post-punk guitar riffs, fuzzy distortion, and rhythmic propulsion, evoking the raw urgency of their debut Is This It (2001) while eschewing prolonged builds or ambient textures common in contemporary indie rock.[22] Critics noted this revival recaptures the band's early kinetic energy, absent amid the genre's mid-2010s bloat toward polished production, though some argued it recycles debut-era tropes without advancing beyond nostalgic familiarity.[23] [24] "Drag Queen," positioned as a forward-looking track, drives with an upbeat, riff-centric groove reminiscent of 1980s New York undercurrents, featuring Julian Casablancas' warbling delivery over clashing instrumentation that nods to drag culture's performative tensions.[25] [26] Its dynamic layers and spirited rhythm underscore the EP's textural density, blending post-punk edges with anti-establishment undertones, yet reviewers highlighted its energetic hooks as potentially derivative of the band's initial formula.[27] "Oblivius," capturing present-day detachment, deploys synth-mimicking guitars and filtered vocals in a radio-ready indie rock framework, fostering an energizing yet aloof vibe through strong riffing and immediate choruses.[3] [28] This structure echoes the catchy, verse-chorus economy of early Strokes output, with its effected lines and distorted timbre providing a textured urgency; a remix by drummer Fabrizio Moretti appends electronic flourishes, diverging slightly into hybrid territory.[29] [21] Detractors, however, faulted its adherence to classic signposts—fuzzy electrics and mumbled phrasing—as lacking fresh innovation, rendering it a competent but unadventurous revisit.[30] [24] "Threat of Joy," evoking past indulgences' hazards, unfolds at a brooding mid-tempo with lethargic vocals offsetting peppy, low-key instrumentals, yielding a dynamic contrast that amplifies its introspective menace through subtle builds and rhythmic whimsy.[31] [32] This approach sustains the EP's gritty elation, rewarding replay with its understated propulsion, but faced accusations of formulaic restraint, prioritizing safe revival over bold evolution amid the band's extended absence.[33] [34]Release and Formats
Announcement and Timeline
The Strokes announced the Future Present Past EP on May 26, 2016, through social media posts and their Cult Records label website, unveiling two tracks—"Drag Queen" and "Threat of Joy"—alongside details of the full release.[11][35] This disclosure came approximately one week prior to the EP's digital and 10-inch vinyl release on June 3, 2016, via Cult Records, the independent label founded by frontman Julian Casablancas.[11][35] The timing aligned precisely with the band's headlining slot at the Governors Ball Music Festival in New York City, which ran from June 3 to 5, 2016, enabling an immediate live debut of the material during their opening-night performance.[35][36] The EP's rollout followed the band's 2013 album Comedown Machine and their separation from RCA Records, representing their first self-released project under Cult without major-label orchestration. The compressed announcement-to-release window—spanning just seven days—deviated from industry norms of prolonged promotional cycles, effectively curtailing leaks, over-speculation, and dependency on media narratives by prioritizing unmediated fan availability on release day.[11][35] This approach reflected the band's established preference for autonomy over hype-driven marketing, as evidenced by prior low-profile returns post-hiatus.[35] Tracks debuted at Governors Ball included "Drag Queen," "Threat of Joy," and "Oblivius," integrating seamlessly into the setlist and underscoring the EP's intent as a discrete offering rather than an album precursor.[37] No further timeline extensions or teasers were issued pre-release, reinforcing a strategy that bypassed traditional buildup in favor of experiential immediacy tied to the festival context.[11]Physical and Digital Packaging
The Future Present Past EP was issued on June 3, 2016, in digital and limited physical formats through Cult Records.[1] Digital versions were distributed as MP3 and WAV files, providing immediate access via the label's platform for $4.00.[1][38] Physical releases centered on 10-inch vinyl pressed at 45 RPM, available in standard black and limited colored variants including blue, yellow, green, orange, and red, with no standard CD edition beyond a promotional CDr.[1][39] Certain retailer exclusives, such as the Newbury Comics pressing, bundled Cult Records and Strokes stickers alongside digital download codes.[40] Packaging adopted a minimalist aesthetic, featuring a cover with five differently colored lines symbolizing temporal progression, paired with sparse liner notes limited to production credits.[41] The back sleeve incorporated a refreshed Strokes logo in bold typeface over a blue background, echoed on the vinyl labels, eschewing elaborate lore or deluxe extras to maintain low production costs.[41] This approach enhanced collector appeal through scarcity, as many vinyl pressings quickly became out-of-print rarities.[42] While the simplicity was lauded for elegance and focus on musical substance, it contrasted with more ornate packaging in contemporary indie releases, occasionally viewed as understated relative to genre expectations.[41]Promotion and Media
Live Debuts and Festival Ties
The Strokes debuted tracks from Future Present Past on May 31, 2016, during a warm-up show at the Capitol Theatre in Port Chester, New York, a 1,800-capacity venue, where they performed "Threat of Joy," "Oblivius," and "Drag Queen" alongside rarities like "Electricityscape" and "Vision of Division."[43][44] This intimate setting contrasted with their prior arena-scale tours, allowing for a focused test of the new material amid a set emphasizing deeper cuts from Is This It (2001) and Room on Fire (2003).[45] The following day, June 3, 2016—the EP's release date—The Strokes headlined the opening night of the Governor's Ball Music Festival at Randall's Island Park in New York City, integrating "Threat of Joy" as the third song in a 90-minute set that blended classics like "The Modern Age" with the fresh tracks, though "Drag Queen" and "Oblivius" were not played.[46][37] The festival slot, before an estimated crowd of tens of thousands on the main stage, served as high-profile validation for the EP's raw, garage-rock urgency, with the unannounced new songs surprising attendees and aligning with the band's pattern of minimal pre-release hype.[47][48] Post-release, The Strokes avoided a traditional promotional tour, limiting further EP performances to select one-off shows in mid-sized or smaller venues through late 2016 and into 2017, such as at the Pitchfork Music Festival on July 15, 2016, where "Oblivius" appeared sporadically. This restraint echoed frontman Julian Casablancas's stated aversion to exhaustive touring, which he linked to preserving band cohesion after the 2011-2013 period of internal tensions and side projects. Observers credited these concise live outings with revitalizing the group's onstage chemistry, evident in the EP tracks' punchy delivery that evoked their early-2000s sets.[48] However, the absence of sustained festival runs or arena dates drew commentary that it underscored a provisional commitment, prioritizing artistic control over commercial momentum amid the band's post-hiatus selectivity.Music Videos and Visual Elements
The Strokes released a music video for "Threat of Joy" on June 28, 2016, directed by Warren Fu.[49] The clip depicts the band rehearsing and filming segments that parody an "Oblivius" video shoot, incorporating surreal elements such as a mysterious agent interrupting production and subtle political motifs, including protest imagery and authority figures.[50] This narrative structure ties into the EP's thematic exploration of temporal disorientation, using meta-filmmaking to blur boundaries between planned and realized content.[51] An initial music video concept for "Oblivius," also involving Warren Fu, was filmed but ultimately shelved after production, with frontman Julian Casablancas attributing the cancellation to its "heavy political content" deemed too controversial by publishers.[52] In its place, an official lyric video for "Oblivius" premiered on July 12, 2016, featuring animated text overlays synchronized to the track without narrative footage.[53] Similarly, "Drag Queen" received a lyric video on June 2, 2016, characterized by grainy, distorted VHS-style visuals of galloping horses and abstract distortions, evoking a nostalgic, degraded aesthetic that aligns with the EP's motifs of past-present fusion.[26] The absence of additional full-length videos for the EP's tracks reflects a deliberate minimalist approach, prioritizing audio-focused promotion via Cult Records over elaborate visuals, consistent with the project's independent ethos and post-hiatus restraint.[54] These elements—surreal interruptions, animated lyrics, and retro filters—serve to reinforce thematic ambiguity without substantial narrative depth, providing accessible entry points to the songs' lyrical concerns while maintaining visual economy.Reception and Analysis
Critical Reviews: Achievements
Pitchfork's review awarded the EP a 6.8 out of 10, highlighting "Drag Queen" for its infectious hooks and nod to the band's early raw energy, describing it as a slowed-down alternative to tracks like "The Modern Age."[3] The outlet praised "Threat of Joy" for building tension through its rhythmic drive and Casablancas's charismatic delivery, positioning these elements as a partial return to the terse, garage-rock form that defined the Strokes' initial breakthrough, contrasting with the more experimental mid-period albums like Angles (2011) and Comedown Machine (2013).[3] Reviewers from Consequence noted the EP's efficient songcraft, with tracks clocking under four minutes each and demonstrating the band's ability to deliver concise, hook-driven material without overproduction.[21] The release via Julian Casablancas's Cult Records underscored the Strokes' independence from major labels, allowing creative control that echoed their debut-era autonomy, as affirmed in contemporaneous interviews where members emphasized self-directed production.[55] This DIY approach was credited with revitalizing the project's momentum amid the 2010s decline in garage-rock popularity, where many contemporaries faded post-peak. Fan analyses on platforms like Reddit, aggregating views from 2022 discussions, frequently cite the EP's underrated status, with "Threat of Joy" singled out for its propulsive bassline and lyrical edge as among the band's strongest post-2010 output, fostering renewed discourse on the Strokes' enduring appeal.[56] Overall, the EP achieved a causal uplift in the band's relevance by rekindling interest through minimal commitment—three originals plus a remix—serving as a bridge to later full-length efforts without diluting their core sound, evidenced by sustained streaming metrics and live set inclusions in subsequent tours.[3]Critical Reviews: Criticisms
Critics have pointed to the EP's heavy reliance on the band's established sonic palette as evidence of stagnation rather than progression. Pitchfork's review characterized "Threat of Joy" as stretching back to the Strokes' pre-fame era, resembling a decelerated rendition of their early demo "The Modern Age" from 2001, which underscores a retread of debut-era garage rock tropes without fresh evolution.[3] Similarly, "OBLIVIUS" deploys signature angular guitar interplay reminiscent of Is This It (2001), but with Casablancas' delivery straining in the chorus, interpreted as coasting on legacy charisma amid broader creative inertia.[3] The EP's brevity—clocking in at roughly 12 minutes across three original tracks—drew accusations of minimal effort, especially as a follow-up to the band's more expansive, if polarizing, full-lengths like Comedown Machine (2013). Drowned in Sound framed the three-song concept as a calculated bid to replenish goodwill eroded by prior output, implying the format prioritizes low-stakes experimentation over substantive reinvention.[57] This concision, while avoiding the bloat of recent albums, was critiqued as evading deeper artistic risks, with "Drag Queen" dismissed as a self-conscious mess of pasted-on Strokes-ian elements that fails to convincingly project a "future" direction.[3] Such reviews highlight a pattern where indie outlets, despite occasional overemphasis on the band's nostalgic authenticity, reveal underlying fan fatigue through middling scores like Pitchfork's 6.0, signaling that recycling Is This It-adjacent vibes no longer suffices for meaningful advancement.[3] The inclusion of a remix track further amplified perceptions of filler, with Consequence of Sound labeling it superfluous for all but die-hard collectors.[21]Commercial Performance and Fan Perspectives
Future Present Past, released on June 3, 2016, via Cult Records, achieved limited commercial traction. The EP did not enter the Billboard 200 or major U.S. album charts, reflecting its niche appeal amid the band's hiatus from full-length albums. In the United Kingdom, it peaked at number 30 on the Official Physical Singles Chart, driven by vinyl and CD sales rather than digital dominance. Internationally, it reached number 144 on France's Top Albums chart for one week, underscoring modest physical and streaming uptake without blockbuster streaming metrics or widespread radio play.[58][59] Fan reception, as evidenced in online communities, emphasized the EP's raw, unpolished sound as a refreshing counterpoint to polished production trends. Discussions on Reddit from 2019 to 2022 frequently label it an "underrated gem," with users citing "Threat of Joy" as a standout track rivaling the band's early hits for its energetic riffing and lyrical bite. Enthusiasts appreciate the independent ethos of its Cult Records release, viewing the low chart performance not as failure but as authentic resistance to commercial pressures, contrasting with perceptions of critic detachment from the band's garage rock roots.[60][56] The EP's performance sustained band cohesion without fueling a dedicated tour, preserving viability through steady fan loyalty rather than mass-market breakthroughs. Some grassroots commentary critiques reliance on nostalgia but praises its role in bridging to subsequent material, highlighting causal links between its lo-fi approach and enduring cult following over algorithmic virality.[56]Track Listing and Credits
Standard Edition Tracks
The standard edition of Future Present Past contains three original tracks, self-released by The Strokes on June 3, 2016, via their Cult Records label.[1] These songs—"Drag Queen" (4:33), "Oblivius" (3:59), and "Threat of Joy" (4:24)—were written collectively by vocalist Julian Casablancas, guitarist Nick Valensi, drummer Fabrizio Moretti, and guitarist Albert Hammond Jr., reflecting the band's core four-member lineup at the time.[19] [61] A remix of "Oblivius" by Moretti (5:32) served as a digital-exclusive bonus track, extending the EP's runtime without altering the physical three-song format.[62] This structure underscored the EP's intent as a concise release bridging the band's prior album Comedown Machine (2013) and future material, prioritizing brevity over expansive content.[1]| No. | Title | Writer(s) | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Drag Queen" | Casablancas, Moretti, Valensi | 4:33 [19] [61] |
| 2 | "Oblivius" | Casablancas, Hammond Jr., others | 3:59 [19] [61] |
| 3 | "Threat of Joy" | Casablancas, band members | 4:24 [19] [61] |
Personnel and Production Credits
The Future Present Past EP features the standard lineup of The Strokes: Julian Casablancas on lead vocals, Nick Valensi on guitar and keyboards, Albert Hammond Jr. on guitar and keyboards, Nikolai Fraiture on bass guitar, and Fabrizio Moretti on drums.[19][1] Production was handled primarily by Gus Oberg, who also mixed most tracks, with sessions occurring in New York and Austin during 2015.[19] Ben Baptie provided additional mixing for "Oblivius."[63] Engineering credits include additional work by Chris Tabron and Phil Joly, with Samuel Wahl assisting.[1] Mastering was completed by Dave Kutch.[63] The remix of "Oblivius" was produced by Fabrizio Moretti.[19] Songwriting credits vary by track: "Drag Queen" by Casablancas, Moretti, and Valensi; "Oblivius" by Casablancas and Hammond Jr.; "Threat of Joy" by the full band.[19]| Role | Personnel |
|---|---|
| Layout and Design | Liz Hirsch[1] |
| Management | Jack Rovner, Richard Priest, Ryan Gentles[63] |