Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Goodbye Charlie

Goodbye Charlie is a 1964 directed by and produced by 20th Century Fox, adapted from the 1959 Broadway play of the same name by . The story follows Sorel, a philandering who is shot and killed by the jealous husband of one of his lovers, only to mysteriously reincarnate as a beautiful blonde woman named Virginia Mason, leading to comedic situations as his best friend George attempts to navigate the bizarre circumstances. Starring as George Tracy, in the dual role of /Virginia, and featuring as Bruce Minton alongside supporting actors like and , the film explores themes of gender roles and identity through and elements. The original play, a full-length comedy by Axelrod known for works like , premiered on at the Lyceum Theatre on December 16, 1959, directed by the playwright himself, and starred in the lead female role opposite Sydney Chaplin, running for 140 performances before closing on March 19, 1960. Despite its short run, the play's premise of a deceased playboy returning as a garnered attention for its satirical take on and attracted interest, leading to the film adaptation with a by Axelrod and Harry Kurnitz. Minnelli's direction emphasized visual humor and the performances of Reynolds, who was praised for her versatile portrayal capturing the character's lingering male traits, though the film received mixed reviews for its uneven tone and reliance on dated gender stereotypes. Overall, Goodbye Charlie represents a mid-1960s effort to blend with fantasy, reflecting Axelrod's signature witty dialogue and , and it remains notable for its star power and Minnelli's elegant despite a modest and performance.

Background and Development

Original Play

George Axelrod, a prolific and renowned for his sexually frank farces and witty satires, crafted Goodbye Charlie as a dark comedy exploring and gender reversal, where a lecherous womanizer is reborn as a woman to atone for his sins against . Following successes like (1955), which ran for over 700 performances, Axelrod drew on his experience in radio, television, and stage writing to infuse the play with sharp dialogue and provocative themes. The premise, likened by Axelrod to a "" suddenly becoming a "lamb chop," highlighted the irony of reversed sexual dynamics in a manner bold for the late . The play premiered on Broadway on December 16, 1959, at the Lyceum Theatre in , directed by Axelrod himself and produced by . It closed on March 19, 1960, after 109 performances, marking a modest run that fell short of commercial blockbuster status despite the era's appetite for sophisticated comedies. The original cast featured in the lead role of the reincarnated Charlie Sorel, as her best friend George Tracy, and Sarah Marshall as Rusty Mayerling, with supporting performers including Frank Roberts as Sir Leopold Sargente, as Greg, as Paul Blair, and Michelle Reiner as Jacqueline. Bacall's portrayal, marking her return to the stage after 17 years, was praised for sustaining a masculine essence within a feminine allure, while Chaplin brought comedic energy to the confused dynamics. Marshall's performance earned her a nomination for the 1960 Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Play, recognizing her sharp comedic timing amid the ensemble. Critics offered mixed responses, with describing it as an "expanded vaudeville sketch" that delivered "a few droll moments" through Axelrod's direction but lacked deeper substance. The play's frank handling of sexual themes—such as , gender confusion, and predatory behavior—drew attention for pushing boundaries in post-Hays Code theater, though some reviewers found the humor contrived and the gimmick underdeveloped, contributing to its lukewarm and limited run. Despite this, Bacall's star power provided a boost, sustaining interest through its three-month engagement.

Film Adaptation Development

In July 1959, prior to the premiere of George Axelrod's play Goodbye Charlie, 20th Century Fox acquired the film rights in a deal with the , who also directed the stage production. The agreement included an initial payment of $150,000, along with a percentage of the play's profits that could bring the total compensation to as much as $400,000. Screenwriter Harry Kurnitz was subsequently hired to adapt Axelrod's play for the screen, transforming its stage-bound structure into a more visually dynamic narrative suited to while amplifying the comedic elements of the premise. Kurnitz's version shifted the tone toward broader Hollywood , emphasizing visual gags and romantic entanglements to enhance appeal for a wider audience. Vincente Minnelli was attached to direct in early 1964, marking his first project outside since joining the studio in 1943. This attachment followed the project's consideration by other directors, including and , who ultimately passed. advanced with secured in a starring role, leveraging his established comedic talents, and the budget set at $3.5 million to support elaborate production values. The film was developed as a between Curtis's independent outfit, Venice Productions, and 20th Century Fox.

The 1964 Film

Plot

Charles Sorel, a notorious womanizer and , is shot and killed by Leopold Sartori, a jealous , after being caught in a compromising position with Sartori's wife, Rusty, during a yacht party; Sorel's body falls overboard and is lost at sea. Days later, at Sorel's seaside Malibu home, his best friend and fellow writer, George Tracy—who has returned from to settle Sorel's debt-ridden estate and deliver the —encounters an attractive blonde woman named "" who arrives with but gradually reveals herself to be Sorel reincarnated in a woman's body, retaining his memories, lecherous personality, and mannerisms. As reluctantly helps the reincarnated adjust to her new and , comedic chaos ensues from role reversals, such as struggling with feminine attire and while attempting to seduce women from her past conquests, including blackmailing them for money to cover old debts; also flirts outrageously with Rusty, a young entangled in Sorel's former affairs, and develops a romantic entanglement with the wealthy, mother-obsessed Bruce Minton, who proposes . Sir Leopold, initially horrified upon recognizing echoes of Sorel in , becomes inexplicably attracted to her, leading to further entanglements that highlight the 's fantastical of karmic for Sorel's philandering ways. The underscores themes of confusion through 's dual male-female , karma via her and arc amid Hollywood's decadent excess of parties, affairs, and financial impropriety, all while grapples with to his old friend and his own growing exasperation. The story culminates in further turmoil when Rusty, discovering Charlie's liaison with Sir Leopold, shoots her in a fit of rage, causing Charlie to fall into the ocean once more; shortly after, George meets a at the beach, and her accompanying dog reveals itself as Charlie's third incarnation through familiar behaviors, allowing George to finally move on to a genuine romance free from his past companion's antics. This resolution reinforces the film's blend of and fantasy, adapted from George Axelrod's 1959 play of similar premise involving a reincarnated philanderer.

Cast

The principal cast of the 1964 film Goodbye Charlie features in the lead role of George Tracy, Charlie's loyal best friend and roommate who grapples with the extraordinary events following his friend's death. portrays the reincarnated Charlie Sorel, initially appearing as the woman Virginia Mason, bringing a dynamic energy to the central gender-reversal premise. plays Bruce Minton, a young suitor entangled in the comedic complications. appears as Janie Highland, one of Charlie's acquaintances. In supporting roles, embodies Sir Leopold Sartori, a flamboyant adding layers of eccentricity to the narrative. , billed as Ellen McRae in her early film appearance, plays Franny Salzman, George Tracy's devoted secretary. makes her debut as Rusty Sartori, contributing to the ensemble's interpersonal dynamics. Additional supporting players include as Morton Craft, a business associate. Casting for the film drew on established stars to anchor its comedic fantasy elements, with Marilyn Monroe initially considered for the role of the reincarnated Charlie but declining due to doubts about convincingly portraying a man's persona in a female body. Shirley MacLaine was also among those considered for the part before Debbie Reynolds was selected.

Filming

Principal photography for Goodbye Charlie commenced on March 16 or 18, 1964, under the production of David Weisbart at 20th Century Fox, and wrapped in late June 1964 after approximately two and a half months of shooting. The 117-minute film marked Vincente Minnelli's first directorial effort outside Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer since 1942, allowing him to explore a broader palette free from studio constraints. Filming took place primarily on the Fox studio lot in , , with additional location work around , including Malibu for the beach house sets and yacht sequences that opened the story. Minnelli's directorial style focused on visual comedy, leveraging vibrant colors and dynamic framing to heighten the farce's playful tone and accommodate the widescreen format's expansive compositions. Cinematographer Milton R. Krasner employed processing to capture these elements, emphasizing Minnelli's signature aesthetic of pop-art-inspired decadence in scenes like the yacht party. For the reincarnation theme, special effects supervision by L.B. Abbott and Emil Kosa Jr. handled subtle visual transitions, though the film's comedic emphasis relied more on performance than elaborate technical feats. On set, Minnelli navigated challenges with comedic timing to balance the screwball elements, a departure from his musicals, while production anecdotes highlighted logistical creativity: loaned his 1932 Rolls-Royce for key scenes, and studio head supplied five genuine Academy Award statuettes as props. ' brief absence on April 10 due to exhaustion briefly halted filming, underscoring the demands of her dual-gendered role. A seamstress also coached in authentic for her scenes, adding realism to the ensemble dynamics.

Release and Reception

Theatrical Release and Box Office

Goodbye Charlie premiered in on , 1964, before its wider theatrical release by 20th Century Fox later that month. The studio distributed the film across the in format, positioning it as a broad-appeal for general audiences. Promotional materials focused on the star appeal of and , with posters featuring taglines that played up the film's gender-swap premise, such as "They don't make girls like Charlie." In terms of financial performance, the film had a budget of $3.5 million and earned $3.7 million in U.S. and rentals, per industry reports, with an estimated worldwide gross of around $10 million; it underperformed relative to expectations for a major release.

Critical Response

Upon its release, Goodbye Charlie received mixed reviews from critics, who often highlighted its uneven blend of fantasy and comedy. of panned the film harshly, describing it as a "bleak conglomeration of outrageous whimsies and stupidities" that was "much more vulgar than stylish" and "much more sluggish and dull than fast," while lamenting the miscasting of stars and in "distasteful roles." offered a more tempered assessment, describing it as "the mildest type of entertainment" due to its "wildly implausible premise." The overall critical consensus reflects this , with holding a 50% approval rating on based on eight reviews, praising the cast's chemistry while critiquing its dated humor and pacing. Reviewers commended Reynolds for excelling in blending lechery with and for delivering as the bewildered best friend, creating engaging interplay between the leads. However, the humor was frequently dismissed as sophomoric and reliant on crude innuendo, with the narrative's sluggish pace failing to sustain momentum. In retrospective analyses, Goodbye Charlie has been viewed as a campy artifact of 1960s sex comedies, appreciated for its outrageous premise and acerbic take on Hollywood excess. Director Vincente Minnelli's handling of the material, often underappreciated amid his more acclaimed musicals, brings a daring originality through uproarious humor that masks industry critiques, though some note its jagged style clashes with the story's tone. Compared to George Axelrod's original play, the film adaptation adopted a lighter, more fantastical comedic tone suited to the screen.

Adaptations and Legacy

Television Pilot

In 1985, aired a adaptation of Goodbye Charlie as a potential , updating the original story's premise of the deceased reincarnated as a for a contemporary audience. The pilot, titled Goodbye Charlie, starred in the dual role of Charlene, the reincarnated form of the late Sorel, bringing a glamorous, comedic edge suited to television humor. Directed by Charlotte Brown, the episode modernized the narrative with faster-paced dialogue, broader physical comedy, and a condensed 30-minute format to fit network sitcom standards, while retaining core elements like Charlie's resurrection and interactions with his skeptical friend George. John Davidson portrayed George Erskine, Charlie's loyal companion navigating the absurdity of the situation, alongside supporting cast members Kathleen Wilhoite as Victoria Burns and Ray Buktenica as Ray Lemmon. Guest appearances included Steve Guttenberg and George Gaynes, adding star power to the ensemble. An earlier Austrian television adaptation, titled Letzte Grüße, lieber Charlie, was produced in 1971. The pilot premiered on June 4, 1985, at 8:30 p.m. ET on , produced by Twentieth Century Television, but despite Somers' rising popularity post-, the network opted not to order a full series, citing insufficient viewer interest and scheduling conflicts. This marked an unsuccessful attempt to revive the property on , with no further episodes produced.

Cultural Influence

The 1964 film Goodbye Charlie served as a direct inspiration for the 1991 comedy Switch, directed by and starring , which adapts the same gender-reversal premise from George Axelrod's original play, where a womanizing man returns as a woman to confront his past indiscretions. Home media availability for Goodbye Charlie includes a manufactured-on-demand DVD release by Cinema Archives on April 16, 2013, presented in a 4:3 pan-and-scan format rather than its original . The film is also accessible for rent or purchase on major streaming platforms such as Amazon Video, , and at Home, and it occasionally airs on (TCM) as part of their classic film programming. In terms of broader cultural legacy, Goodbye Charlie is regarded as an early precursor to gender-bending comedies, pioneering the trope of a male character's reincarnation as a woman to explore themes of identity and sexuality within a screwball framework, though its treatment often leaned toward titillation over deeper commentary. The film's handling of gender transformation has placed it within discussions of LGBTQ+ film history, particularly as one of Hollywood's initial forays into transgender-adjacent narratives during the 1960s, highlighting sexual liberation amid the era's conservative norms. Despite receiving no major awards or nominations, Goodbye Charlie has been featured in retrospectives of director Vincente Minnelli's oeuvre, such as those organized by film festivals examining his post-MGM works.

References

  1. [1]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - Turner Classic Movies - TCM
    When a cavorting Hollwood writer is killed by the angry husband of a woman he was having an affair with, he comes back as a spirit in the form of a ...
  2. [2]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - IMDb
    Rating 6.2/10 (2,264) Womanizing Charlie is shot by an angry husband and falls into the sea. He arrives home after his memorial as a cute woman suffering from amnesia.
  3. [3]
    Goodbye Charlie | Concord Theatricals
    Goodbye Charlie. Full-Length Play, Comedy / 3w, 4m. George Axelrod. "Axelrod's premise is a very funny one." - New York Daily News. Lauren Bacall on Broadway ...
  4. [4]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - Plot - IMDb
    Shot by a jealous husband, Charlie falls out a porthole and is lost at sea--and finds himself returned to land as an attractive blonde woman.
  5. [5]
    Goodbye Charlie - Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 50% (8) Shot by an angry husband, a playboy writer comes back as a blonde (Debbie Reynolds), as his buddy (Tony Curtis) finds out.
  6. [6]
    Goodbye, Charlie – Broadway Play – Original | IBDB
    Written by George Axelrod. Directed by George Axelrod. Scenic Design by Oliver Smith; Lighting Design by Peggy Clark. General Manager: Herman Bernstein ...
  7. [7]
    Goodbye Charlie - Variety
    Pat Boone is an over-rich boy with a mother complex who falls for Debbie and wants to marry her, while Walter Matthau puts goulash in the producer role. Jump to ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  8. [8]
    Shows for Someday #2: GOODBYE CHARLIE (Part 2) - Morgan Sills
    Sep 11, 2020 · Previously we gave an overview of George Axelrod's third play, Goodbye Charlie, as it headed for its Broadway in 1959.
  9. [9]
    GOODBYE CHARLIE – 1964 DVD Review and Tribute to Debbie ...
    Jun 14, 2017 · It is a great showcase for the versatile talents of Debbie Reynolds, she is hysterical and totally believable as a man stuck in a woman's body.
  10. [10]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - The Magnificent 60s
    Jan 27, 2024 · But, basically, the female Charlie decides to become a female version of the male Charlie, the predator, ripping off friends, chasing the big ...
  11. [11]
    George Axelrod | Movies | The Guardian
    Jun 24, 2003 · Goodbye Charlie was built around the promising premise of a lecherous Hollywood heel, murdered by a vengeful husband and reincarnated as a ...Missing: background | Show results with:background
  12. [12]
    George Axelrod, 81, Quirky Writer for Stage and Film, Dies
    Jun 23, 2003 · '' (1955) and ''Goodbye Charlie'' (1959) to adroit screen adaptations of William Inge's ''Bus Stop'' (1956), Truman Capote's ''Breakfast at ...
  13. [13]
  14. [14]
    Sarah Marshall (Performer) | Playbill
    Awards. Theatre World Awards. 1956, Theatre World Award. The Ponder Heart. Winner. Tony Award. 1960, Best Featured Actress in a Play. Goodbye, Charlie. Nominee ...
  15. [15]
    Expanded Vaudeville Sketch; " Goodbye Charlie" Has Premiere at ...
    The 21-page Pentagon document lays out a number of requirements at odds with First. Tierney L. Cross/The New York Times. Review: ...
  16. [16]
    Of Local Origin - The New York Times
    Twentieth Century-Fox has acquired screen rights to the play "Goodbye, Charlie" in a pre-production deal with author- director, George Axelrod.
  17. [17]
    The world's most comprehensive Film database - AFI|Catalog
    Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp. optioned George Axelrod's 1959 play, Goodbye Charlie, circa 1961, according to a 14 Feb 1962 Var item, which stated that ...
  18. [18]
    Goodbye Charlie | film by Minnelli [1964] - Britannica
    Sep 23, 2025 · Goodbye, Charlie (1964), a 20th Century-Fox production, became Minnelli's first project outside the confines of MGM. Debbie Reynolds starred as ...
  19. [19]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - FAQ - IMDb
    What was the budget for Goodbye Charlie? $3.5 million. What is Goodbye Charlie rated? Approved. What genre is Goodbye Charlie? Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, and ...
  20. [20]
    Vincente Minnelli: Goodbye Charlie | Oeuvre - Spectrum Culture
    Mar 6, 2014 · Goodbye Charlie, adapted from Axelrod's 1959 Broadway comedy, is frequently counted among Minnelli's worst films. The movie opens with a ...
  21. [21]
  22. [22]
    1964 in film - Wikipedia
    1964 film releases ... Goldfinger, starring Sean Connery as James Bond), with Honor Blackman, Shirley Eaton and Gert Fröbe – (U.K.); Goodbye Charlie, starring ...
  23. [23]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - Release info - IMDb
    Release date ; United States. November 18, 1964 ; Sweden. December 26, 1964 ; Finland. January 22, 1965 ; Ireland. January 22, 1965 ; France. March 12, 1965.
  24. [24]
  25. [25]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) - Vincente Minnelli | Synopsis, Movie Info ...
    Find trailers, reviews, synopsis, awards and cast information for Goodbye Charlie (1964) - Vincente Minnelli on AllMovie. ... Movie Info. Budget. $3,500,000 ...
  26. [26]
    Tony Curtis, Debbie Reynolds, 1964, TM & Copyright © 20th ... - Alamy
    1–3 day delivery 30-day returnsDownload this stock image: GOODBYE CHARLIE, US poster, from left: Tony Curtis, Debbie Reynolds, 1964, TM & Copyright © 20th Century Fox/courtesy Everett ...
  27. [27]
    Debbie Reynolds Stars in 'Goodbye, Charlie' - The New York Times
    GEORGE AXELROD'S play, "Goodbye, Charlie," was bad enough on the stage. On the screen, it is a bleak conglomeration of outrageous whimsies and stupidities.Missing: background | Show results with:background
  28. [28]
    Goodbye Charlie | Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes
    Fresh score. Minnelli, whose work brings together an extraordinary set of themes, looks at the violence and the lust of Hollywood, the riotous pleasure-seeking ...Missing: 1959 critical
  29. [29]
    Movie of the Week: "Goodbye Charlie" | The New Yorker
    Jan 20, 2016 · “Goodbye Charlie,” from 1964 (which I discuss in this clip), which is, in a way, the most daring and original of them all. It's an outrageous sex comedy.Missing: 1959 critical reception commercial success<|control11|><|separator|>
  30. [30]
    Goodbye Charlie (1964) : r/iwatchedanoldmovie - Reddit
    Jun 6, 2024 · It was not a success, running for only 109 performances. New York Times critic Bosley Crowther led his review of the film by panning the play ...
  31. [31]
    Goodbye Charlie (TV Movie 1985) - IMDb
    Rating 4.8/10 (31) Goodbye Charlie ; Director. Charlotte Brown ; Writers. George Axelrod · Harry Kurnitz · Patricia Nardo ; Stars · Suzanne Somers · John Davidson · Kathleen Wilhoite.
  32. [32]
    Goodbye Charlie (1985) - Turner Classic Movies - TCM
    Cast & Crew ; Charlotte Brown. Director ; Suzanne Somers. Charlene Sorrell; Charlie ; John Davidson. George Erskine ; Kathleen Wilhoite. Victoria Burns ; Ray ...
  33. [33]
    Goodbye Charlie (TV Movie 1985) - Full cast & crew - IMDb
    Goodbye Charlie (TV Movie 1985) - Cast and crew credits, including ... Harry Kurnitz. (1964 screenplay). Patricia Nardo · Patricia Nardo. Cast. Edit. (in ...Missing: adaptation | Show results with:adaptation
  34. [34]
    SOMERS RETURNS IN `GOODBYE` - Chicago Tribune
    Jun 4, 1985 · Suzanne Somers, last seen this spring in ”Hollywood Wives,” returns to TV in a sitcom pilot, ”Goodbye, Charlie” at 8:30 p.m. Tuesday on ABC-Ch.
  35. [35]
    What Were Suzanne Somers' Two Failed CBS Pilots After She Left ...
    Oct 28, 2023 · Oh and speaking of ABC, Somers also did a pilot called “Goodbye, Charlie” an adaptation based on a Broadway play by George Axelrod which in turn ...
  36. [36]
    FAULTY `SWITCH` - Chicago Tribune
    May 10, 1991 · ... Goodbye, Charlie” premise of the deceased womanizer who comes back as a desirable female, has much more in common with […]
  37. [37]
    Goodbye Charlie DVD (Fox Cinema Archives / Pan & Scan)
    Goodbye Charlie DVD Release Date April 16, 2013 (Fox Cinema Archives, Pan & Scan). DVD reviews, news, specs, ratings, screenshots. Cheap DVD movies and ...
  38. [38]
    Goodbye Charlie streaming: where to watch online? - JustWatch
    ... for enacting sweet revenge. About the movie. Director. Vincente Minnelli. Rating. IMDB. 6.2 (2k). ROTTEN TOMATOES 50%. Goodbye Charlie. Like. Dislike. Watchlist.<|separator|>
  39. [39]
    Inside Hollywood's First Trans Screwball Farce - Out Magazine
    Sep 21, 2016 · The 1964 film Goodbye Charlie said hello to sexual liberation. Armond White. September 21 2016 11:10 AM EST.
  40. [40]
    Awards - Goodbye Charlie (1964) - IMDb
    It looks like we don't have any awards for this title yet. Be the first to contribute. For guidance, please visit the Awards submission guide.
  41. [41]
    TWO Vincente Minnelli Film Retrospectives
    Sep 8, 2011 · 6:50, 9:15pm: Goodbye Charlie. Tuesday, Oct 18. 4:30, 7, 9:30pm: The Story of Three Loves. Wednesday, Oct 19. 4:30, 6:50, 9:15pm: Tea and ...