Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Meteor Rain

Meteor Rain (Chinese: 流星雨; : Liúxīng Yǔ) is a four-episode Taiwanese drama that aired on CTS from September 27 to October 18, 2001, serving as a supplementary production to the hit series . The series focuses on three standalone side stories exploring the backstories and personal lives of members Dao Ming Si (played by ), Xi Men (), and Mei Zuo (), set before, during, and after the events of , while omitting a dedicated episode for Hua Ze Lei () due to the actor's scheduling conflicts. Directed by Yueh-Hsun Tsai and partially adapted from Yoko Kamio's (also known as ), it incorporates original content alongside -inspired plots, with reprising her role as Xiao You in Xi Men's storyline. The delves into themes of romance, family trauma, and personal growth: Mei Zuo's episode involves aiding a girl named Ai Sha in locating her grandmother while preparing for a contest; Xi Men's arc examines his rekindled relationship with Xiao You upon her return from , revealing his past attachment to a girl named Xiao Geng; and Dao Ming Si's narrative follows his encounter with a girl, Xin Xin, and her father during a evasion, uncovering his own emotional scars. Produced in Mandarin and broadcast weekly on Thursdays, Meteor Rain capitalized on the massive popularity of Meteor Garden and F4, the formed by the lead actors, contributing to the franchise's cultural impact in during the early . It holds a user rating of 6.9 out of 10 on MyDramaList based on over 900 reviews, reflecting its niche appeal as an extension of the original series.

Background and production

Development and premise

Meteor Rain originated as a supplementary to the 2001 Taiwanese drama , which follows the interactions between a working-class girl and the elite group at a prestigious , produced by Comic Ritz International Production to delve deeper into the backstories of the F4 members. The project capitalized on Meteor Garden's widespread popularity in and across , where it achieved average viewership ratings of around 12%, drawing approximately three million viewers per episode and prompting the creation of additional content to extend the franchise./International_broadcast_and_release) The premise centers on four episodes— with Dao Ming Si's narrative divided into two parts—each providing standalone side stories that explore untold aspects of the F4 members' lives at various points: before, during, and after the events of the main series. These tales loosely draw from side elements in the original Japanese manga by Yoko Kamio, adapting them to expand on the characters' personal histories and relationships without directly advancing the primary plot. Planning and announcement for Meteor Rain occurred in mid-2001, shortly after Meteor Garden's initial broadcast success, with production handled by Angie Chai and direction by Cai Yuexun under a supported by the parent series' commercial achievements. The creative choice emphasized in-depth focus on three F4 members—Mei Zuo, Xi Men, and Dao Ming Si—while limiting Vic Chou's portrayal of Hua Ze Lei to supporting roles, allowing for character-specific explorations without involving the full ensemble in every segment.

Filming and crew

Principal photography for Meteor Rain took place from late summer 2001 through early 2002, with production commencing on September 13, 2001, and concluding on January 17, 2002, partially overlapping with the post-production and promotional efforts for the later episodes of Meteor Garden.) The was directed by Tsai Yueh Hsun, known for his focus on intimate, character-driven narratives in supplementary content tied to the franchise, and produced by Angie Chai of Comic Ritz International Production, who emphasized seamless integration of F4's music elements, such as their title track "Liu Xing Yu," into the episodes' emotional arcs. Filming occurred primarily in Taipei, Taiwan, utilizing urban streets to capture the contemporary, bustling atmosphere of Ken Chu's Mei Zuo episode, while rural coastal areas like Baisha Bay in Kenting National Park served as key settings for Jerry Yan's Dao Ming Si storyline, featuring beach cabins and natural landscapes. Indoor studio sets in Taipei were employed for Vanness Wu's Xi Men segment, allowing for controlled environments that highlighted interpersonal dynamics. Cinematography prioritized emotional close-ups and soft lighting to underscore the standalone, reflective tone of each 60-minute episode. The production faced significant challenges, including a tight driven by F4's surging and concurrent commitments following their debut album release, which limited to minimal and emphasized practical on-location shooting. Filming was notably delayed by Nari in mid-September 2001, which destroyed crew-built cabins at Baisha Bay intended for Jerry Yan's episode, requiring hasty reconstructions and adjustments to maintain the timeline.

Cast and characters

Main cast

Jerry Yan stars as Dao Ming Si, the arrogant heir to a powerful and the central leader of the group, reprising the character from his breakout role in the preceding series . Vanness Wu portrays Mei Zuo, the playful and lighthearted member of whose storyline centers on a romance with a Japanese girl. Ken Chu plays Xi Men, the charismatic womanizer of the F4 with a complex and vulnerable inner life. Rainie Yang depicts Xiao You, the devoted love interest to Xi Men who serves as a bridge connecting the miniseries to the broader narrative of Meteor Garden, reprising her supporting role as Xiao You from the original series Meteor Garden, which marked her acting debut. The principal actors—Yan, Wu, Chu, and Chou—gained international prominence as the boy band F4, formed in 2001 following the success of Meteor Garden.

Supporting cast

Vic Chou appears as Hua Ze Lei, contributing brief but essential moments that reinforce the F4's group dynamics, with his role featuring limited screen time compared to the other members. In Mei Zuo's chapter, Aisa Senda portrays Ai Sha, a immigrant girl struggling to survive in after leaving her home to search for her grandmother. Her character introduces a cultural clash subplot when she pickpockets Mei Zuo, leading to a series of encounters that highlight themes of trust and budding romance, ultimately supporting Mei Zuo's emotional growth without overshadowing the main dynamics. Senda, a actress making her drama debut, brings authenticity to Ai Sha's resilient yet vulnerable personality. For Xiao Geng in Xi Men's chapter, Pally Chien (Chien Pei En) plays the deceased childhood friend and first love of Xi Men, revealed through poignant flashbacks that explore his regrets over standing her up on a crucial day. This role underscores Xi Men's softer, introspective side, as her unfulfilled wish to share a "special thing" motivates Xiao You's quest, adding depth to his of loss and emotional barriers. Chien's brief but impactful performance captures the innocence and tragedy of their high school bond. In Dao Ming Si's chapter, Peng Xin (also known as He Xinyun) depicts Xin Xin, a traumatized young girl who discovers the unconscious Dao Ming Si on the beach and shelters him with her adoptive father, Ah Yuan. Rescued from an abusive past, Xin Xin's mute and withdrawn demeanor evolves through her attachment to Si, emphasizing his protective instincts and aiding her path to emotional recovery, which humanizes his otherwise brash character. As a child actress at age six, Peng Xin's portrayal earned early recognition for conveying subtle vulnerability. The ensemble includes supporting roles such as family members like Dao Ming Si's butler (Liu Er Jin), who provides and logistical aid in the F4's world, and minor rivals or locals encountered in each chapter's settings. CTS guest stars, including background dancers in social scenes and incidental characters like Mai Sato as in Mei Zuo's arc, enhance the cultural and atmospheric texture without driving the primary plots. These peripheral figures collectively bolster the side stories, illustrating the F4's interactions in everyday and high-society contexts.

Synopsis

Mei Zuo's chapter

Mei Zuo's chapter, the first episode of the 2001 Taiwanese miniseries Meteor Rain, centers on the character Mei Zuo, portrayed by , as he encounters a girl named Ai Sha (also spelled Aisa), played by Aisa Senda. The story begins when Ai Sha, struggling to survive in after leaving to search for her grandmother, pickpockets Mei Zuo's wallet in a moment of desperation. Mei Zuo catches her and initially threatens to involve , but upon learning of her financial hardships and her quest to locate her long-lost grandmother, he sympathizes and decides to assist her instead. This encounter sets the stage for a partnership driven by mutual reliance, highlighting Mei Zuo's carefree and compassionate personality outside his usual role in the group from the main series . As their interaction deepens, Mei Zuo teaches Ai Sha about Taiwanese customs to help her navigate life in the unfamiliar environment, fostering moments of cultural exchange and understanding. Ai Sha repeatedly deceives Mei Zuo with fabricated stories about needing money—for instance, claiming funds for a sick relative or her dog's care—before revealing the truth about her grandmother search, which underscores themes of and . Confronting her ongoing financial struggles, which compel her to resort to theft, Mei Zuo remains supportive, promising to aid in reuniting her with her family. After learning her grandmother has passed away, Ai Sha reunites with her mother, who arrives from . To generate the necessary funds, Ai Sha enters a televised contest suggested by her friend ; although she initially asks Mei Zuo to partner her, she ultimately dances with her mother while Mei Zuo and cheer from the audience. The episode culminates in the dance contest, where Ai Sha wins and prepares to return to with her mother, bidding farewell to Mei Zuo with a kiss and expressing in that she will think of him. Throughout, themes of cultural misunderstanding emerge through Ai Sha's adjustment to Taiwanese society, contrasted with budding romance as the pair develops an affection. Unique to this arc is the incorporation of Japanese-Taiwanese bilingual dialogue, emphasizing , and the dance sequences, which serve as both a and a showcase of Mei Zuo's playful side. Set independently before the primary events of , the chapter portrays Mei Zuo's independent charm and generosity without relying on .

Xi Men's chapter

In the second special episode of Meteor Rain, titled "Xi Men's Chapter," the narrative centers on Xi Men Yan, a member of the elite F4 group, as he grapples with unresolved grief from his past. Returning from , Xiao You seeks to reconnect with Xi Men, whom she has long admired, only to find him distant and emotionally guarded. Their encounter unfolds against the backdrop of his lingering sorrow over Xiao Geng, his childhood friend and unrequited love, who disappeared after he failed to meet her. This episode explores themes of and the challenge of moving forward, highlighting how the incident has transformed Xi Men from a carefree into a man haunted by what-ifs. Key events are revealed through poignant flashbacks that delve into Xi Men's relationship with Xiao Geng. As childhood friends, they shared innocent moments, but Xiao Geng developed deeper feelings for the charismatic yet noncommittal Men. In a pivotal moment, she asked him to meet, but fearing commitment, Xi Men did not appear; she later sent a confessing her and explaining her goodbye, after which she never returned. These sequences underscore his profound regret over not knowing what she wanted to share with him. Xiao You's persistent efforts to understand him lead to an emotional confrontation at a , where Xi Men opens up about his pain, marking a rare moment of vulnerability. Inspired by her empathy, Xiao You searches for clues to Xiao Geng's "special thing," ultimately finding a sign reading “Xi Men, my ” (a Siemens advertisement) at dawn, providing him with symbolic closure on her feelings. The episode emphasizes Xi Men's character development, portraying his shift from a facade of superficial charm and fleeting romances to raw about love's permanence. Without deeply involving his F4 comrades, the story focuses on his internal struggle, using quiet, reflective scenes to convey his isolation. Xiao You's role as a catalyst—drawing briefly from her own experiences of displacement and unrequited in the broader series—helps bring him to emotional . Unique to this chapter is its heavy reliance on introspective monologues and atmospheric cues from F4's debut , such as melancholic tracks that amplify the emotional weight of loss and renewal, enhancing the episode's intimate tone.

Dao Ming Si's chapter

Dao Ming Si's two-part chapter in Meteor Rain spans episodes 3 and 4, aired on January 10 and 17, 2002, respectively, and explores the F4 leader's backstory during his high school years. After injuring his leg in a police chase following a bar brawl and jumping from a moving train to evade capture on charges of assault, Dao Ming Si (portrayed by Jerry Yan) collapses unconscious on a beach at Baisha Bay. He is discovered by Xin Xin, a traumatized mute girl, and rescued by her adoptive father Ah Yuan, a kind-hearted fisherman who had saved Xin Xin from an abusive biological father about a year earlier. This chance encounter initiates a profound bond, highlighting Dao Ming Si's rarely seen vulnerable and compassionate side as he assumes a protective role within this makeshift family unit. In Part 1, the narrative builds initial connections amid rising tension: Dao Ming Si recovers in hiding at Ah Yuan's modest seaside home, learning of Xin Xin's silence stemming from her past and Ah Yuan's ongoing struggle against false accusations from Xin Xin's real father. Xin Xin communicates via chalkboard. Dao Ming Si, grappling with his own guilt over the brawl that forced his isolation, begins to atone by helping with daily chores and offering quiet support, fostering themes of and . Action sequences emphasize the peril of his status, including a tense chase through rural terrain that underscores his physical resilience and emotional turmoil. The culminates in Dao Ming Si's deepening attachment, as Xin Xin's tentative trust in him hints at her gradual healing. Part 2 escalates the conflict as antagonists—primarily Xin Xin's abusive father and pursuing —converge, forcing confrontations that test Dao Ming Si's growth. He aids Ah in defending their bond, but Ah is arrested on the kidnapping charges. Xin Xin, inspired by Dao Ming Si's encouragement, breaks her silence to tell the police she was rescued from , not kidnapped, in an attempt to vindicate Ah and expose the truth of her trauma. Despite this, Ah remains imprisoned. The arc ends ambiguously with Dao Ming Si receiving a phone call and identifying himself as "Dao Ming Si," followed by a scene of other characters watching a , symbolizing his emotional growth and potential return to his life without showing explicit reconnection with the F4. The split structure allows for layered resolution, blending high-stakes action like a climactic pursuit with introspective moments on found .

Release and distribution

Original broadcast

Meteor Rain was originally broadcast on the free-to-air Chinese Television System (CTS) in Taiwan, airing its four episodes from September 13, 2001, to January 17, 2002. The series served as a supplementary miniseries to the highly successful Meteor Garden, capitalizing on the peak popularity of the F4 group during that period. The episodes followed a weekly Thursday schedule in prime time at 9:30 PM, with each installment lasting approximately 60 minutes. Episode 1, titled "Mei Zuo's Chapter," premiered on September 13, 2001, and was replayed the following week on September 20 due to Typhoon Nari, which disrupted the schedule. Episode 2, "Xi Men's Chapter," aired on September 27, 2001, while the final two episodes—"Dao Ming Si's Chapter, Part 1" on January 10, 2002, and "Part 2" on January 17, 2002—concluded the run after a production hiatus caused by the typhoon damaging filming locations. Promoted as an extension of Meteor Garden, the broadcast featured tie-in elements that leveraged the existing fandom to draw viewers, contributing to solid engagement despite the staggered airing. The series' placement in CTS's lineup allowed it to maintain momentum from the parent show's cultural phenomenon, though specific viewership metrics were not as extensively documented as those of the main series.

International releases and availability

Following its premiere in , Meteor Rain saw limited international television distribution, primarily in Asia. In the , the mini-series aired on from July 28 to August 8, 2003, dubbed in and serving as a follow-up to the broadcast of Meteor Garden. It was rebroadcast on [GMA Network](/page/GMA Network) from October 8 to 19, 2007, also with a Tagalog dub. In other parts of , it was available through networks, though without widespread broadcasts. There was no major television airing . As of 2025, Meteor Rain is streamable in full on internationally. English-subtitled clips and episodes can be found on , often uploaded by fans. The series is not offered on . Home media releases began with DVDs produced by (CTS) in 2002 for the Taiwanese market. These were reissued in the with bonus features, including interviews and behind-the-scenes content; international versions, such as those by YA Entertainment in the , followed similar timelines.

Reception and legacy

Viewership and critical response

Meteor Rain, released as a four-episode mini-series in late 2001, achieved strong appeal among teenagers in during its original broadcast on CTS, drawn to the F4 members' charisma. This success was bolstered by the lingering popularity of the preceding , which had established F4 as a cultural sensation. Internationally, the series resonated in markets like the , further solidifying Taiwanese dramas' foothold in . Critics and audiences praised Meteor Rain for expanding on the F4 characters' emotional depths, with Taiwan media reviews highlighting how the standalone episodes provided nuanced backstories that enriched the . The series holds an average rating of 8.2/10 on based on 31 user votes, and 6.9/10 on MyDramaList based on 924 user reviews. Contemporary feedback often described it as enjoyable filler content designed for , though some critiques pointed to uneven pacing, especially in Dao Ming Si's episode. While Meteor Rain itself earned no major awards, the broader received recognition.

Cultural impact

Meteor Rain significantly amplified the F4 phenomenon by providing deeper insights into the group's dynamics, which propelled their debut album sales to nearly 4 million copies across by the end of 2001. The miniseries' focus on individual member backstories fostered widespread fan engagement, including extensive merchandise lines featuring characters and apparel that remain available through official and licensed channels. As part of the franchise, Meteor Rain influenced later adaptations, such as the 2009 Korean series , which built upon the popularity and stylistic elements established by the Taiwanese versions. The 2018 Chinese reboot of drew from the original F4 narrative, incorporating references to the broader universe that included supplementary stories like Meteor Rain to appeal to longtime fans. In July 2025, the original F4 members—, , , and —reunited for a surprise performance of the theme song "Meteor Rain" at Taiwanese rock band Mayday's 25th anniversary concert at , sparking a wave of nostalgia and trending discussions across . This event underscored the continued fame of lead actor , who remains active in acting and music projects as of 2025, including recent tributes and public appearances tied to the franchise. The contributed to the early wave of Taiwanese idol dramas by exemplifying the expansion of main narratives through side stories, a technique that enriched character development and encouraged franchise extensions in subsequent productions. This approach helped solidify the genre's emphasis on youthful romance and ensemble casts, influencing regional television trends.

References

  1. [1]
    Meteor Rain - MyDramaList
    May 8, 2018 · Meteor Rain ; Country: Taiwan ; Type: Drama ; Episodes: 4 ; Aired: Sep 27, 2001 - Oct 18, 2001 ; Aired On: Thursday ...
  2. [2]
    Meteor Rain - AsianWiki
    Drama: Meteor Rain · Chinese: 流星雨 (Liu Xing Yu) · Director: Yueh-Hsun Tsai · Writer: Yoko Kamio (manga) · Network: CTS · Episodes: 4 · Release Date: 2001 · Runtime: ...
  3. [3]
    Meteor Rain (TV Mini Series 2001–2002) - IMDb
    Rating 8.2/10 (31) Meteor Rain (pinyin: Liu Xing Yu) is a 2001 Taiwanese drama starring Jerry Yan, Vanness Wu and Ken Chu of F4 and Rainie Yang. It is a supplementary mini-series ...
  4. [4]
    Meteor Rain (TV Mini Series 2001–2002) - Plot - IMDb
    Meteor Rain (pinyin: Liuxing Yu) is a side series to the Taiwanese drama, Meteor Garden (2001). It was partially based on Boys Over Flowers by Yoko Kamio.
  5. [5]
    Meteor Rain | Boys Over Flowers Wiki - Fandom
    Meteor Rain (Chinese: 流星雨; pinyin: Liúxīng Yǔ) is a side series to the Taiwanese drama, Meteor Garden (2001). It was partially based on Boys Over Flowers ...
  6. [6]
    Meteor Rain (TV Mini Series 2001–2002) - Trivia - IMDb
    Filming was delayed by Typhoon Nari in mid-September 2001. Cabins built by the crew at Baisha Bay for Jerry Yan's episode were destroyed by the storm.Missing: timeline challenges
  7. [7]
    Jerry Yan - IMDb
    Jerry Yan(I)​​ Appearing in various MVs, TV shows and print ads, his biggest break came when he was cast for the lead male role of "Dao Ming Si" in the wildly ...
  8. [8]
    Meteor Rain Full Cast & Crew - MyDramaList
    Producer. Angie Chai in Meteor Rain Taiwanese Drama · Angie Chai ; Main Role. Ken Chu. Xi Men. Main Role. Jerry Yan. Dao Ming Si. Main Role. Vanness Wu · Mei Zuo.<|control11|><|separator|>
  9. [9]
    Rainie Yang: Nostalgia of My Drama Journey - MyDramaList News
    Nov 20, 2022 · Meteor Garden (2001) ; In Meteor Garden and the sequel Meteor Rain, Rainie played the character Xiao You, the best friend of the main character ...
  10. [10]
    Meteor Garden stars: Where are they now? - PEP.ph
    Feb 5, 2025 · Find out what the stars of the pan-Asia hit Taiwanese drama "Meteor Garden" like (LR) Barbie Hsu, Ken Chu, Jerry Yan, Vanness Wu, and Vic Zhou are up to now.
  11. [11]
    Are Boy Band F4 Coming Back!? We Look Into the Runion Tour ...
    Jun 16, 2025 · Meteor Garden successfully launched the careers of its four male leads—Jerry Yan, Vic Chou, Ken Chu, and Vanness Wu—who formed the boy band F4 ...
  12. [12]
    Aisa Senda - Wikipedia
    She made her debut on television dramas when she was cast in Meteor Rain, the sequel of the famous drama Meteor Garden among F4.. She joined Da Mouth in ...
  13. [13]
    Meteor Rain (TV Mini Series 2001–2002) - Full cast & crew - IMDb
    No readable text found in the HTML.<|control11|><|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Peng Xin (彭歆) - MyDramaList
    Peng Xin is a former child actress. She retired from acting, after graduating from high school in order to focus on college. Xin now is an active musician.
  15. [15]
    Meteor Rain - Wikipedia
    Meteor Rain is a 2001 Taiwanese drama starring Jerry Yan, Vanness Wu and Ken Chu of F4 and Rainie Yang. It is a supplementary miniseries of Meteor Garden ...
  16. [16]
    Episode 1 (Meteor Rain)
    ### Detailed Plot Summary of Mei Zuo's Chapter (Episode 1, Meteor Rain)
  17. [17]
    Meteor Garden: Specials (2001) — The Movie Database (TMDB)
    Dao Ming Si's Chapter​​ A young girl by the name of Xin Xin finds him and Dao Ming Si is temporarily taken in by Ah Yuan, who appears to be Xin Xin's father. Ah ...
  18. [18]
    Special 2 Meteor Rain: Xi Men's Chapter 2001 - Trakt
    Rating 75% (2) Xiao Geng had discovered something very special, but he had been somewhat afraid of his feelings and had greatly disappointed her by not showing up. Inspired by ...Missing: Gen | Show results with:Gen
  19. [19]
    Dao Ming Si (Jerry Yan) Chapter Ending Explained - Spoiler Alert! - Meteor Rain - MyDramaList
    ### Detailed Plot Summary of Dao Ming Si's Chapter in Meteor Rain
  20. [20]
    Meteor Rain (TV Mini Series 2001–2002) - Episode list - IMDb
    Meteor Rain · S1.E1 ∙ Mei Zuo Pian · S1.E2 ∙ Xi Men Pian · S1.E3 ∙ Dao Ming Si Pian Part 1 · S1.E4 ∙ Dao Ming Si Pian Part 2.
  21. [21]
    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7969396/episodes/
  22. [22]
    Meteor Rain Ep1 - Meizuo - YouTube
    Nov 30, 2020 · Nana Drama•370K views · 1:55:07. Go to channel · Marriage 3y,he stays ... F4 Meteor Rain Epi. 3 part 1 (Dao Ming Si's Episode) ~English Subs ...
  23. [23]
    meteor garden - Rakuten Viki
    Stream FREE Asian Dramas & Movies with English subtitles: Korean, Chinese, Japanese Dramas & more. From romance to action, find it on Viki!
  24. [24]
    YESASIA: Meteor Rain DVD - Vic Chou, Ken Chu, Joy Sales (HK)
    Awards. This film has received 1 award nomination(s). Golden Bell Awards 2002. Best Sound Nomination. All Award-Winning Asian Films. Customer Review of "Meteor ...
  25. [25]
    What Came First? Boys Over Flowers Edition
    Aug 20, 2015 · Taiwan kicked off the drama series adaptations with Meteor ... Also in 2001 came Taiwanese mini series Meteor Rain which had all of our original ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  26. [26]
    Meeting Dylan Wang was the peak of my 'Meteor Garden' fangirling
    Seeing Dylan Wang felt like a pullback to my youth. The moment he entered the room, I felt like the five-year-old kid whose fangirling was valid.
  27. [27]
    Meteor Garden's boy band F4 thrills fans with surprise reunion - BBC
    Jul 13, 2025 · Vanness Wu, Vic Chou, Jerry Yan and Ken Chu, in black/gray suits and long pants, singing their hit ballad Meteor Rain at the Taipei Dome.
  28. [28]
    OG F4 from Meteor Garden reunites on stage after 12 years - PEP.ph
    Jul 13, 2025 · Jerry Yan, Ken Chu, Vanness Wu, and Vic Chou sent fans' hearts into a tizzy as they performed their famous song "Meteor Rain" at the 25th ...
  29. [29]
    The Sinophone as an Uneven Experience of Time and Place
    Nov 1, 2024 · Hsiu-Chuang Deppman (2009: 93) argues that Meteor Garden and subsequent Taiwanese idol dramas provided “an alternative vision of East Asian ...
  30. [30]
    The Nostalgic Negotiation of Post-TV Legibility in Mom, Don't Do ...
    Aug 1, 2023 · The Taiwanese idol-drama adaptation of Meteor Garden, though originally inspired by a Japanese shōjo manga series, was so well-received that it ...