Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Plot device

A plot device is a narrative technique or element—such as an object, character, event, or situation—employed by writers to propel the story forward, resolve conflicts, or introduce new developments, often prioritizing functionality over deeper integration into the world-building.^[1] The term was coined in 1986 by British classicist and science fiction critic Nick Lowe in his essay "The Well-Tempered Plot Device," where he described it as "something in the story that's just a little bit too obviously functional to be taken seriously," particularly critiquing its overuse in speculative fiction genres like science fiction and fantasy.^[2] Plot devices serve as essential tools in storytelling across literature, film, and other media, helping to maintain momentum, heighten tension, or facilitate character growth by bridging gaps in the narrative logic.^[3] They can be material, like a key artifact, or immaterial, such as a coincidental encounter, but their effectiveness depends on seamless integration to avoid appearing contrived or clichéd.^[1] When well-crafted, plot devices enhance drama and engagement; however, overuse or poor execution can undermine credibility, leading to reader dissatisfaction, as seen in critiques of sudden resolutions that feel unearned.^[3] Common types of plot devices include the MacGuffin, a goal or object that motivates characters but holds little intrinsic value (e.g., the briefcase in the film Pulp Fiction, the term having been coined by screenwriter Angus MacPhail and popularized by Alfred Hitchcock).^[3] Another is the deus ex machina, an unexpected intervention that abruptly resolves a crisis, originating from ancient Greek theater where gods were lowered onto the stage via machinery to untangle plots.^[4] Additional varieties encompass red herrings (false clues to mislead, as in Arthur Conan Doyle's A Study in Scarlet), plot vouchers (items foreshadowed early for later utility, echoing Anton Chekhov's "gun" principle), and plot twists (surprising revelations that reframe the narrative).^[3] In practice, plot devices must balance utility with subtlety to support thematic depth rather than dominate the story, as Lowe argued that their predictability in commercial fiction often stifles originality.^[2] Successful examples, like the memory tattoos in Memento, demonstrate how innovative devices can enrich character-driven tales, while failures, such as overly convenient artifacts in sequels, highlight the risks of formulaic application.^[1] Ultimately, these elements underscore the craft of narrative construction, enabling creators to navigate complex plots while inviting audiences into immersive worlds.^[3]

Definition and Characteristics

Definition

A plot device is a narrative element within a story, such as an object, character, event, or situation, used to propel the story forward by resolving conflicts, introducing new motivations, or generating complications.^[5] This technique may prioritize plot progression over considerations of character depth, thematic consistency, or realistic integration, potentially straining the story's internal logic if poorly executed.^[1] The term "plot device" emerged in literary and dramatic criticism to describe these narrative conveniences, distinguishing them from organic story components like recurring motifs or character-driven developments that serve broader artistic purposes. In essence, while all narrative elements contribute to the plot, a plot device is identifiable by its primary utilitarian role, functioning as a tool for advancement rather than an essential pillar of the story's world-building or emotional core. Key criteria for recognizing a contrived plot device include its abrupt or improbable appearance without prior foreshadowing, its limited influence beyond immediate plot advancement, and its tendency to simplify complex dilemmas in ways that may undermine suspension of disbelief—for instance, a coincidental discovery that unlocks a mystery or an unforeseen ally that averts disaster.^[1] These features highlight the device's role as an expedient mechanism in storytelling across literature, film, and theater.

Key Characteristics

Plot devices exhibit varying levels of contrivance, ranging from subtle integrations that align seamlessly with narrative logic to overt mechanisms that introduce abrupt resolutions or coincidences. Subtle contrivances maintain narrative probability and necessity, ensuring events follow from prior actions in a manner that feels inevitable, as emphasized in classical theory where plots should arise organically from character decisions rather than external impositions.^[6] Overt contrivances, by contrast, can disrupt the story's internal consistency, potentially straining the audience's engagement by introducing improbable elements that do not stem from established motivations.^[7] A key risk of plot devices lies in their capacity to undermine suspension of disbelief, the temporary acceptance of fictional premises that enables immersion in the narrative. When a device feels forced or arbitrary, it prompts critical scrutiny, breaking the "poetic faith" that allows readers to overlook real-world implausibilities for the sake of the story's emotional or intellectual impact.^[8] Effective integration with broader themes mitigates this, as devices that reinforce ideological, moral, or symbolic patterns—such as reversals highlighting ethical dilemmas—enhance thematic depth without alienating the audience.^[7] Plot devices vary in their organic versus inorganic nature, with organic variants emerging naturally from character arcs and world-building to propel the story without apparent authorial intervention, fostering a sense of authenticity. Inorganic devices, however, rely on external or coincidental forces that bypass logical progression, often serving as shortcuts to resolution but risking narrative incoherence. Additionally, devices differ as reusable tropes—recurring patterns like quests or revelations that span genres and stories—or one-off elements tailored uniquely to a single narrative, providing bespoke propulsion without broader applicability.^[9] In narratological frameworks, plot devices function as non-essential components of the syuzhet (discourse arrangement), facilitating the causal and temporal linking of events while remaining subordinate to character development and thematic concerns. Structuralist approaches, such as Vladimir Propp's morphology of folktales, identify devices as functional motifs that standardize plot progression across narratives, yet they do not dictate character evolution, which often takes precedence in rhetorical and cognitive theories. This positioning underscores their role as supportive mechanisms rather than core drivers of psychological or moral arcs.^[7]

Historical Context

Ancient and Classical Origins

The earliest conceptual foundations of plot devices in Western literature emerged in ancient Greek theater during the 5th century BCE, where mechanisms like divine intervention served to resolve complex narratives and underscore themes of fate and human limitation. In the works of Euripides, the deus ex machina—a literal "god from the machine," referring to a crane that lowered actors portraying deities onto the stage—became a prominent tool for concluding plays, often appearing in more than half of his surviving tragedies to provide resolution, commentary, or epiphany.^[10] For instance, in Medea, the sun god Helios intervenes by sending a divine chariot to spirit the protagonist away, while in Hippolytus, Artemis descends to offer insight and prophecy at the tragedy's close. This device, possibly innovated or popularized by Euripides, allowed for supernatural elements to tie up loose ends that human characters could not, reflecting the Greek worldview where gods actively shaped mortal affairs.^[10] Aristotle, in his Poetics (c. 335 BCE), offered a foundational critique of such contrived resolutions, arguing that they undermined the integrity of tragic plots by introducing improbable or unnecessary external forces. He specifically condemned the use of gods ex machina for denouements, stating that "the solution should come out of the plot itself, and not through a contrivance like the one in the Medea, or in the Iliad with the machine of the gods," emphasizing that resolutions must arise from probability and necessity inherent to the narrative structure rather than arbitrary divine fiat. Aristotle viewed these interventions as suitable only for divine commentary outside the main action, not for resolving conflicts, as they disrupted the unity and logical progression essential to effective tragedy. His analysis in Poetics Chapter 15 thus established a critical standard prioritizing internal coherence over spectacle, influencing subsequent dramatic theory.^[11] Roman adaptations of Greek dramatic traditions further evolved these plot devices, often prioritizing spectacle and rhetorical intensity over strict logical consistency, as seen in the comedies of Plautus (c. 254–184 BCE) and the tragedies of Seneca (c. 4 BCE–65 CE). Plautus, drawing from Greek New Comedy, employed farcical elements like mistaken identities, eavesdropping, and metatheatrical asides to heighten visual and performative excitement, allowing actors to break the fourth wall for humorous effect and emphasizing crowd-pleasing antics over Aristotelian probability.^[12] In tragedies, Seneca reworked Greek myths—such as in Thyestes or Oedipus—incorporating supernatural invocations like ghosts or furies to drive plots toward moral and psychological climaxes, with divine forces manifesting more as omens or internal torments than resolving interventions, adapting the Greek model to Roman interests in Stoic fate and imperial excess.^[13] These Roman uses amplified theatrical spectacle, using plot devices to evoke awe and horror in audiences attuned to public games and oratory. Key examples of divine interventions in ancient tragedies highlight their role as plot-resolving mechanisms, appearing in works like Euripides' Bacchae, where Dionysus reveals his identity to affirm divine justice, or Aeschylus' Eumenides, with Athena's intervention to establish a jury trial, resolving the cycle of vengeance through judicial decree. These instances, common across Greek and Roman tragedy, served not only to conclude narratives but also to explore theological tensions between human agency and cosmic order, without relying on later interpretive lenses.

Development in Modern Storytelling

In the 19th century, Gothic and Victorian fiction frequently employed plot devices such as hidden inheritances and sudden revelations to drive narratives amid social anxieties over property, identity, and morality. In Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights (1847), inheritance serves as a central mechanism tying characters' fates to contested estates, symbolizing unresolved familial and class tensions.^[14] Similarly, sensation novels like Wilkie Collins's Armadale (1866) used inheritance disputes to explore legal and ethical liabilities, propelling plots through unexpected bequests and contested wills.^[14] Sudden revelations, often through bigamy plots, added shock value; the abrupt reappearance of a presumed-dead spouse disrupted domestic stability, as seen in Mary Elizabeth Braddon's Lady Audley's Secret (1862), where concealed pasts erupt to unravel social facades.^[15] The 20th century saw plot devices evolve in film and genre fiction, with Alfred Hitchcock refining suspense through innovative mechanisms like the MacGuffin—an object of apparent importance that motivates action but holds little intrinsic value, as in The 39 Steps (1935), where a stolen espionage formula propels the chase without detailing its contents.^[16] Hitchcock's techniques, including withheld information and subjective camera angles, elevated plot devices from mere contrivances to psychological tools, influencing thriller genres broadly.^[17] In sci-fi and fantasy, magical artifacts emerged as pivotal drivers; J.R.R. Tolkien's One Ring in The Lord of the Rings (1954–1955) functions as a corrupting force central to the quest, embodying power's allure while advancing the epic's moral conflicts.^[18] Contemporary trends in digital media and serialized television have amplified episodic devices like cliffhangers, which suspend resolution to sustain viewer investment across platforms. Shows such as Lost (2004–2010) and Game of Thrones (2011–2019) routinely ended episodes or seasons with revelations—like the Oceanic Flight 815 survivors' island mysteries or Jon Snow's apparent death—exploiting streaming's binge model to heighten anticipation.^[19] This marks a shift from print-era linearity to interactive, multi-threaded storytelling.^[20] Cultural shifts toward postmodern narratives have integrated plot devices more subtly, subverting overt mechanics in favor of fragmented, self-reflexive structures that question narrative reliability. Authors like Thomas Pynchon in Gravity's Rainbow (1973) embed devices such as conspiracies and chance encounters within nonlinear plots, blending contrivance with ambiguity to critique causality and authority.^[21] This evolution contrasts earlier explicitness, prioritizing thematic depth over mechanical resolution in works that deconstruct storytelling conventions.^[21]

Functions in Narrative

Advancing the Plot

Plot devices serve as essential mechanisms within narrative structures, integrating seamlessly to propel the story forward by functioning as inciting incidents that initiate conflict, complications during rising action that heighten tension, or climactic triggers that force pivotal resolutions.^[22] In Freytag's dramatic pyramid, these elements correspond to the exciting force that sparks the initial impulse, the progressive stages of rising action built through motives and episodes, and the climax as the peak of irreversible action, ensuring a unified progression from exposition to catastrophe.^[22] Similarly, in the three-act structure, plot devices manifest as plot points—major reversals at the end of Act I and Act II—that thrust the narrative into new directions, such as the inciting incident in Act I or confrontations in Act II leading to the resolution in Act III.^[23] These devices advance the plot through distinct types: motivational, by driving character actions via causal links like the exciting force or character-specific motives that propel the hero toward goals; complicating, by introducing obstacles and tensions in the rising action or confrontation phases to build suspense and depth; and resolving, by tying loose ends in the falling action or Act III through denouement elements that provide closure to conflicts.^[22]^[23] In narrative theory, plot devices relate closely to Freytag's pyramid by filling logical gaps in the dramatic arc, connecting exposition to climax and counter-play, while in the three-act model, they align with paradigm beats to maintain causality and progression without disrupting unity.^[22]^[23] Their contrived nature allows authors to bridge structural necessities, ensuring motives and episodes enhance rather than interrupt the flow.^[22] The primary benefit of plot devices lies in their efficiency for pacing long-form stories, enabling balanced distribution across acts—such as concise introductions and escalating intensities in five-act dramas—to sustain audience attention over extended performances without unnecessary prolongation.^[22] In Syd Field's paradigm, this efficiency manifests through timed plot points that divide the screenplay into proportional segments (e.g., Act I at 25 pages, Act II at 55 pages), optimizing dramatic context shifts for sustained momentum in feature-length narratives.^[23]

Impact on Audience Engagement

Plot devices, when integrated seamlessly into a narrative, can significantly enhance audience engagement by fostering surprise, building tension, and emphasizing thematic elements, thereby deepening immersion in the story world. According to narrative transportation theory, this immersion occurs when audiences experience focused attention, vivid imagery, and emotional involvement, leading to greater enjoyment and persuasion by the narrative. For instance, well-crafted devices that advance the plot create cognitive dissonance through unexpected revelations, which, when resolved coherently, heighten satisfaction, making the story more memorable.^[24] Conversely, contrived plot devices risk disrupting engagement by evoking frustration and undermining suspension of disbelief, where audiences willingly accept fictional premises but reject implausible resolutions. Such devices, akin to deus ex machina interventions, can pull viewers out of the narrative, reducing emotional investment and overall satisfaction.^[25] This negative impact is particularly pronounced in realistic genres, where expectations of logical consistency are higher, leading to a sense of authorial manipulation rather than organic storytelling. Psychologically, contrived elements introduce cognitive dissonance by clashing with the audience's mental model of the story's internal logic, prompting critical evaluation over empathetic absorption. In contrast, genre conventions modulate this effect; for example, fantasy narratives tolerate greater contrivance due to established expectations of magical or supernatural resolutions, allowing sustained immersion without dissonance.^[24]

Common Examples

Deus ex Machina

Deus ex machina is a plot device characterized by the sudden introduction of an external force or improbable event that resolves a seemingly insurmountable conflict, often without prior foreshadowing or logical buildup within the narrative.^[26] This intervention typically arrives at a critical juncture, providing an abrupt resolution to the plot's central tension, and derives its name from ancient Greek theater practices where a mechanical crane (machina) lowered actors portraying gods onto the stage to intervene in the action.^[27] The device's mechanics emphasize surprise and convenience, allowing the story to conclude despite narrative deadlocks, though it frequently draws criticism for undermining dramatic tension and character agency.^[28] In historical contexts, deus ex machina appeared prominently in classical drama to facilitate divine resolutions. A notable example occurs in Euripides' Medea (431 BCE), where the protagonist, after murdering her children, escapes retribution by ascending in a dragon-drawn chariot provided by the sun god Helios, an intervention that swiftly concludes the tragedy without further earthly consequence.^[29] Similarly, in William Shakespeare's As You Like It (c. 1599), the god Hymen descends amid celestial music to orchestrate multiple marriages and restore the exiled duke to his throne, resolving the romantic and political entanglements in a harmonious, unforeseen manner.^[30] These instances highlight the device's roots in theatrical spectacle, where supernatural elements served to tie up loose ends in ways that mirrored ancient audiences' expectations of mythic intervention.^[31] Modern literature and film continue to employ deus ex machina, often adapting it to fantastical or superhero genres for climactic saves. In J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings (1954–1955), the Great Eagles repeatedly intervene, most dramatically by rescuing Frodo and Sam from Mount Doom after the Ring's destruction, providing an aerial extraction that averts their capture by orcs.^[32] In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, particularly Avengers: Endgame (2019), Captain Marvel's timely arrival during the final battle against Thanos turns the tide by destroying the enemy's ship and aiding the heroes, an external power boost that resolves the overwhelming odds against the Avengers.^[33] Such examples illustrate the device's persistence in contemporary storytelling, where it amplifies spectacle but risks alienating viewers seeking organic resolutions. A key variation emerges in J.R.R. Tolkien's concept of eucatastrophe, which reframes deus ex machina as a profound, grace-filled turning point toward joy rather than mere contrivance.^[34] Tolkien, who coined the term in his 1947 essay "On Fairy-Stories," distinguished eucatastrophe as an emotionally resonant "sudden happy turn" inherent to the story's mythic structure, as seen in the eagles' role or the Ring's accidental destruction, evoking a sense of divine consolation without arbitrary intrusion.^[35] In contrast, traditional criticism, dating back to Aristotle's Poetics (c. 335 BCE), condemns deus ex machina as a lazy resolution that violates probability and necessity, preferring outcomes driven by internal logic to maintain narrative integrity.^[26] This tension underscores ongoing debates about the device's artistic merit, balancing surprise against plausibility.

Love Triangle

A love triangle functions as a relational plot device in which three characters become entangled in competing romantic affections, typically with two individuals vying for the love of a central figure, thereby generating jealousy, emotional turmoil, and pivotal choices that propel character development.^[36] This configuration often manifests as a rivalry where the affections may form a closed loop—such as person A desiring person B, who desires person C, who in turn desires A—intensifying the conflict through mutual unrequited elements.^[37] As a complication tool, it advances the plot by introducing relational barriers that force characters to confront their priorities and desires.^[36] In literature, the love triangle exemplifies these mechanics through iconic portrayals of romantic rivalry. F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby (1925) centers on the triangle involving Jay Gatsby, Daisy Buchanan, and her husband Tom Buchanan, where Gatsby's obsessive pursuit of Daisy underscores the destructive interplay of longing and infidelity amid 1920s American excess.^[38] Similarly, Stephenie Meyer's Twilight series (2005–2008) revolves around protagonist Bella Swan caught between vampire Edward Cullen and werewolf Jacob Black, a dynamic that amplifies supernatural tensions while highlighting Bella's internal struggle over loyalty and autonomy in young adult romance.^[36] Contemporary media extends the love triangle's reach into serialized formats, leveraging it for sustained viewer investment. The reality television series The Bachelor (2002–present) routinely constructs triangles among contestants competing for the lead's affection, as seen in seasons where multiple suitors vie simultaneously, fostering on-screen drama through orchestrated confrontations and eliminations.^[39] In Korean dramas, or K-dramas, love triangles proliferate as a staple for emotional depth; for instance, Boys Over Flowers (2009) features Geum Jan-di navigating affections from two heirs in a chaebol family, blending romance with critiques of wealth disparity.^[40] Thematically, love triangles delve into the complexities of human desire by depicting characters' conflicting attractions that reveal deeper psychological motivations and vulnerabilities.^[41] They frequently explore betrayal, as shifting allegiances erode trust and expose the fragility of commitments, often culminating in relational ruptures.^[41] Additionally, these devices interrogate social norms, challenging ideals of monogamy, gender roles, and class boundaries by illustrating how romantic entanglements reflect broader societal pressures and expectations.^[36]

MacGuffin

A MacGuffin is a plot device in the form of an object, document, or goal that motivates the characters and drives the narrative forward, yet ultimately proves insignificant to the story's actual resolution or themes. The term was coined by screenwriter Angus MacPhail and popularized by director Alfred Hitchcock, who described it as "the thing that the characters are after, but which the audience doesn't care about" or an apparatus of little inherent value that propels the action. In Hitchcock's usage, the MacGuffin serves primarily as a catalyst for conflict and pursuit, interchangeable with any similar item without altering the core plot dynamics.^[42]^[43] Classic examples illustrate this function effectively. In Hitchcock's Notorious (1946), a sample of uranium ore hidden in a wine bottle motivates espionage and romance but fades in importance as the film's interpersonal tensions resolve the story. Similarly, the glowing briefcase in Quentin Tarantino's Pulp Fiction (1994) links disparate characters through theft and retrieval quests, its undisclosed contents irrelevant to the film's nonlinear exploration of fate and morality. In contrast, the Ark of the Covenant in Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) functions as a MacGuffin by spurring Indiana Jones's global adventure, though its supernatural reveal adds audience investment; this differs from truly essential artifacts like the One Ring in J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, which carries thematic weight as a corrupting force central to the narrative's moral and apocalyptic stakes, rather than mere propulsion.^[44]^[45]^[46] In modern storytelling, MacGuffins adapt to expansive franchises and interactive formats. The Infinity Stones in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) exemplify this, serving as cosmic artifacts pursued across multiple films to assemble the Infinity Gauntlet, yet their primary role is to unify disparate hero narratives and escalate threats, with individual stones' powers secondary to ensemble dynamics. In video games, where player agency demands clear objectives, MacGuffins address structural gaps by providing tangible quests in open-world or linear designs; for instance, the ancient treasures in the Uncharted series motivate exploration and combat, their historical allure incidental to themes of greed and adventure, enabling replayability without deep lore dependency.^[47] Unlike a red herring, which misleads audiences through false clues to build suspense or surprise, a MacGuffin remains central to the plot's momentum without deceptive intent, consistently pursued as the story's engine rather than a diversion. This distinction ensures the MacGuffin sustains engagement through goal-oriented tension, as seen in its motivational role in driving character pursuits across media.^[48]

Red Herring

A red herring is a narrative technique employed to mislead the audience by introducing false clues, suspicious characters, or irrelevant details that divert attention from the actual plot resolution or culprit, most commonly in mystery, thriller, and detective genres. This device creates an illusion of progress toward a solution while concealing the truth, encouraging viewers or readers to pursue erroneous deductions.^[49]^[50] The phrase "red herring" derives from the literal use of smoked or pickled herring—a strong-smelling fish—to train hunting dogs by distracting them from the genuine scent, a practice dating back centuries. Its figurative application to storytelling emerged in the early 19th century, first recorded in 1807 by English journalist and political writer William Cobbett, who used it to critique misleading tactics in parliamentary debates and press coverage. Over time, the term adapted to literature and media, where it denotes deliberate misdirection rather than accidental irrelevance.^[51]^[52]^[53] In practice, red herrings operate through subtle integration into the story, such as planting ambiguous evidence or portraying secondary characters with incriminating traits that suggest guilt without confirming it. This mechanic heightens tension by mirroring real investigative processes, where false leads can prolong uncertainty and force reevaluation of earlier assumptions. Authors and creators must balance these elements to avoid frustrating the audience, ensuring the diversions feel organic and tied to character motivations or environmental details.^[49]^[54] Classic examples abound in mystery literature, including Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None (1939), where multiple guests on a remote island exhibit shady pasts and behaviors that implicate them as the murderer, diverting suspicion from the true orchestrator—Justice Wargrave—whose faked death serves as a pivotal red herring. In film, M. Night Shyamalan's The Sixth Sense (1999) employs the technique masterfully by presenting psychologist Malcolm Crowe as a living participant in events, complete with interactions that imply normalcy, only for the twist to reveal his ghostly state and reframe all prior scenes as misdirection.^[55]^[49]^[56] Contemporary media extends red herrings into interactive and serialized formats. In the multiplayer video game Among Us (2018), social deduction gameplay revolves around crewmates accusing one another based on fabricated alibis or suspicious actions, creating red herrings that mask the impostors' identities until tasks or ejections clarify the deception. True crime podcasts similarly leverage the device, as in Serial (2014), where early episodes highlight witness testimonies and timelines—like those from Jay Wilds or Asia McClain—that initially point toward suspect Adnan Syed but later prove unreliable or contradictory, sustaining listener intrigue through unresolved misleads. These modern applications build suspense by deceiving the audience, fostering deeper engagement with the unfolding mystery.^[57]^[58]^[59]

Quibble

A quibble is a plot device that exploits the literal interpretation of ambiguous terms, contracts, or statements to fulfill their exact conditions while evading the broader intent, often resolving narrative conflicts through semantic or legal wordplay. This technique relies on the precision of language, where characters identify loopholes in wording to achieve an unforeseen outcome, turning potential disaster into clever escape.^[60] In classic literature, William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice provides a seminal example, as Portia, disguised as a lawyer, defends Antonio against Shylock's demand for a pound of flesh by arguing that the bond specifies flesh alone, without any blood, thus preventing the fatal extraction. Similarly, in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, the plot hinges on the subtle distinction between a sleeping potion administered to Juliet and the actual poison Romeo procures, leading to tragic irony through misinterpretation of the friar's plan.^[61] These instances demonstrate the quibble's role in Elizabethan drama, where verbal dexterity underscores themes of justice and deception. Modern narratives adapt the quibble to legal thrillers and comedies, emphasizing its versatility in contemporary storytelling. In John Grisham's The Firm, protagonists exploit ambiguities in employment contracts and Mafia-related agreements to outmaneuver corrupt lawyers and federal investigators, highlighting loopholes in legal bindings.^[62] Comedies like the television series Pushing Daisies employ quibbles through whimsical wordplay, such as Ned's magical rules for reviving the dead—touch once to revive, touch twice to kill permanently—creating humorous resolutions via literal adherence to supernatural conditions.^[63] These examples extend the device's application to explore ethical ambiguities in professional and fantastical contexts. Thematically, the quibble satirizes the fallibility of language, the inflexibility of legal systems, and the capricious nature of fate, revealing how minor interpretive differences can profoundly influence human affairs.^[64] By serving as a complication resolver, it invites audiences to appreciate the power of rhetoric in averting catastrophe.^[65]

Shoulder Angel

The shoulder angel, often paired with a shoulder devil, serves as a plot device to personify a character's internal moral conflict, typically visualized as diminutive figures perched on the protagonist's shoulders, one advocating virtue and the other temptation. This mechanic externalizes the struggle between conscience and impulse, allowing narrative tension to build through dialogue or debate between the figures. The trope traces its origins to medieval morality plays, where good and bad angels appear as allegorical characters guiding or leading the human soul toward salvation or damnation, as seen in works like The Castle of Perseverance, which features a Good Angel counseling the protagonist against worldly vices.^[66] In visual media, prominent examples include Disney's 1940 animated film Pinocchio, where Jiminy Cricket functions as a variant of the shoulder angel, appointed as the puppet's official conscience by the Blue Fairy and providing moral guidance through songs like "When You Wish Upon a Star" and direct interventions to steer Pinocchio from mischief. Modern cartoons frequently employ the device for comedic effect, such as in The Simpsons episode "The Frying Game" (Season 13, Episode 21), where Homer Simpson debates a life-altering decision with miniature angel and devil versions of himself arguing on his shoulders. Adaptations of the shoulder angel extend beyond animation to other media, addressing the challenge of depicting internal conflict in non-visual formats; in literature, it manifests as an inner monologue, where the character's thoughts split into virtuous and tempting voices, akin to stream-of-consciousness techniques in novels exploring ethical dilemmas. In film, particularly live-action, split-screen techniques visualize this duality, creating a visual gap-filler for psychological tension by showing simultaneous perspectives of moral reasoning, as opposed to purely external plot drivers. This internal focus advances character development by highlighting personal growth through resolved conflicts, contrasting with external plot mechanisms. Psychologically, the shoulder angel and devil represent Freudian concepts, with the angel embodying the superego—the internalized moral standards promoting guilt and ideal behavior—and the devil symbolizing the id, the primal urges seeking immediate gratification without regard for consequences. This duality illustrates the ego's mediation between instinct and ethics, providing a narrative shorthand for human decision-making processes rooted in psychoanalytic theory.

Analysis and Criticism

Effective Implementation

Effective implementation of plot devices requires careful integration to advance the narrative without disrupting immersion, primarily through techniques like foreshadowing that ensure contrivances feel organic and earned. Foreshadowing involves subtle hints early in the story that prepare audiences for later revelations, making plot devices such as twists or resolutions appear inevitable rather than arbitrary; this builds suspense and rewards attentive viewers by aligning expectations with outcomes.^[67]^[68] In genre fiction, aligning devices with established conventions enhances their impact—for instance, thrillers often employ pursuit-based elements like MacGuffins to propel action, while fantasies might use prophetic artifacts that resonate with world-building norms, ensuring the device supports rather than overshadows the genre's core appeal.^[69] A notable case study is Alfred Hitchcock's masterful use of the MacGuffin, an object of apparent importance that motivates characters but holds little intrinsic value, allowing tension to derive from pursuit and conflict rather than the item's details. In films like North by Northwest (1959), the MacGuffin—a microfilm containing government secrets—drives the plot without requiring extensive explanation, as Hitchcock emphasized that audiences care only about the characters' stakes, not the "nonsense" object itself; this approach maintains narrative momentum while freeing focus for psychological depth.^[42]^[70] Similarly, in Psycho (1960), stolen money serves as the MacGuffin, redirecting emphasis to character motivations and moral dilemmas, demonstrating how such devices can heighten suspense when subordinated to human elements.^[71] To integrate plot devices effectively, writers should balance them with character growth, using them as catalysts that reveal or challenge protagonists' arcs rather than standalone mechanisms. For example, a device like a hidden letter might not only uncover plot information but also force a character to confront personal flaws, thereby intertwining external action with internal transformation and creating a cohesive narrative.^[72] In realistic fiction, restraint is key to avoiding overuse; devices should emerge naturally from character choices or environmental pressures, preventing contrived interruptions to plausibility—subtle integration, such as a recurring motif tied to backstory, preserves authenticity while advancing the story.^[73] In modern screenwriting, plot devices facilitate twists by maintaining logical consistency through prior setup, ensuring surprises feel surprising yet fair. Techniques include layering misdirection with foreshadowed clues, as seen in films like The Sixth Sense (1999), where visual and dialogic hints about the protagonist's state build to a revelation without retroactive inconsistencies; this approach keeps audiences engaged by honoring narrative rules while delivering emotional payoff.^[69] Screenwriters are advised to root twists in character agency, using devices to escalate stakes progressively rather than as abrupt shifts, thereby sustaining logic and thematic integrity throughout the script.^[74]^[75]

Common Pitfalls

One of the primary pitfalls in employing plot devices is over-reliance, which often results in lazy writing by substituting contrived elements for genuine character-driven development or logical progression. This approach can make narratives feel artificial, as the device serves merely as a shortcut rather than an integral component of the story's structure. Literary analysis highlights that such overuse diminishes narrative depth, prioritizing convenience over coherence.^[9] A related issue is the breaking of immersion through implausibility, where plot devices introduce illogical or unforeshadowed resolutions that violate the story's internal logic. In his Poetics, Aristotle critiques this in the context of deus ex machina, arguing that "the unraveling of the plot... must not be brought about by the Deus ex Machina" but should arise organically to preserve probability and necessity, ensuring the plot's unity.^[76] This ancient principle remains relevant, as implausible devices disrupt the audience's willing suspension of disbelief, transforming potential engagement into frustration. Notable examples illustrate these failures. In M. Night Shyamalan's Signs (2002), the aliens' vulnerability to water serves as an implausible plot device that appears without adequate setup despite water's ubiquity on Earth, undermining the invasion premise and drawing criticism for contrived plotting.^[77] Similarly, poorly executed MacGuffins—objects that propel the plot but lead to unsatisfying resolutions—exemplify narrative laziness; in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008), the titular skull's mystical role as a central motivator has been criticized for its outlandish and controversial handling, contributing to perceptions of incomplete resolution.^[78] The consequences of these pitfalls include significant audience backlash and diminished critical reception, as flawed devices erode trust in the narrative and prompt widespread debate. For instance, the implausible ending of Signs fueled online discussions and mixed reviews, highlighting how such elements can alienate viewers expecting logical consistency.^[77] From Aristotle's foundational emphasis on plot integrity to contemporary analyses of fan reactions in films like Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017), where unmet story expectations amplified discontent, critics consistently note that poor device handling fosters dissatisfaction and lowers overall impact. These negative outcomes directly hinder audience engagement by severing emotional investment. To mitigate these issues at a high level, authors should prioritize devices that align with established rules and themes, fostering inherent plausibility without external contrivances.

References

[1]
What is a Plot Device? Definitions and Examples - StudioBinder
Jun 27, 2021 · A plot device is anything that moves a story forward. This can be something material like a character or an object or something immaterial like a situation or ...
[2]
The Well-Tempered Plot Device: Nick Lowe - Ansible
Ansible 46, July 1986. The Well-Tempered Plot Device Nick Lowe. Perhaps once in a generation, the science of criticism is shaken by a conceptual breakthrough ...
[3]
What is a plot device? | BBC Maestro
Apr 14, 2023 · Plot devices are tools used by writers to move the plot or story along, develop drama or mystery, or introduce new elements to the story.What is a plot device? · Red herrings · Plot voucher · MacGuffin
[4]
Literary Terms - Purdue OWL
Plot: The sequence of events that occur through a work to produce a coherent ... device suddenly introduced to resolve the conflict” (43). Exposition ...
[5]
[PDF] Literary Terms Handout
Plot device An object, character, or event whose only reason for existing is to advance the story. Often breaks suspension of disbelief. Prologue An ...
[6]
Literary Devices and Terms - Definitions and Examples | LitCharts
Aristotle coined the term catharsis—which comes from the Greek kathairein meaning ... Dramatic irony is a plot device often used in theater, literature, film, and ...
[7]
The Internet Classics Archive | Poetics by Aristotle
### Extracted and Summarized Content from Aristotle's Poetics
[8]
Plot | the living handbook of narratology
Jan 25, 2014 · “plot” designates the ways in which the events and characters' actions in a story are arranged and how this arrangement in turn facilitates identification of ...History Of The Concept And... · Plot As Progressive... · Works Cited
[9]
Biographia Literaria | Project Gutenberg
Author: Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Release Date: July, 2004 [EBook #6081] ... willing suspension of disbelief for the moment, which constitutes poetic faith.
[10]
7 Common Plot Devices and How to Use Them in Your Writing
Sep 10, 2021 · Deus ex machina: A deus ex machina is a plot device that connects the loose ends of an entire plot and brings them to resolution. Authors from ...
[11]
UNCLES EX MACHINA: FAMILIAL EPIPHANY IN EURIPIDES ...
Dec 28, 2016 · The closing deus ex machina in Electra is one in which the god is assaulted by a barrage of questions and doubts from his niece and nephew below ...
[12]
https://www.jstor.org/stable/4342382
[13]
The Theater of Plautus: Playing to the Audience
Moore shows that Plautus employed these dramatic devices not only to entertain his audience but also to satirize aspects of Roman society, such as shady ...
[14]
415 Roman Tragedy, Classical Drama and Theatre
Granted, Greek tradition handed Seneca a fairly perverted character—the story calls for a figure whose lust for power leads him to extremes that make it all ...
[15]
Inheritance and Speculation in Victorian Fiction
Jun 30, 2024 · Inheritance and Speculation in Victorian Fiction: Finance, Family, and the Law investigates how Victorian fiction reconfigures the narrative ...
[16]
[PDF] THE BIGAMY PLOT - Sensation and Convention in the Victorian Novel
The sudden reappearance of a "dead, yet not dead" spouse is the surprise at the heart of almost every bigamy plot. So ubiquitous was this crucial plot twist ...
[17]
MacGuffin | Definition, Origin, Hitchcock, Examples, & Facts
Oct 3, 2025 · The MacGuffin is essentially the trigger that sets the story's plot in motion; therefore, it is usually introduced within the first act or first ...
[18]
6 Filmmaking Techniques Alfred Hitchcock Used to Create Suspense
Nov 15, 2022 · 1. Hitchcock Leading Ladies · 2. Making Use of Subjectivity · 3. Information to Create Suspense · 4. Montage · 5. Keeping the Story Simple · 6.
[19]
What was JRR Tolkien's inspiration for the One Ring?
Mar 10, 2015 · The question is: Was Tolkien inspired by the Ring of Gyges, or did he come up with a similar artifact on his own?
[20]
10 Best TV Cliffhangers That Changed Their Shows Forever
Feb 5, 2025 · From mind-bending reveals and shocking plot twists to long-awaited confrontations, some cliffhangers completely changed the game.
[21]
The Role of Cliffhangers in Serial Entertainment: An Experiment on ...
Oct 9, 2025 · The results suggest that cliffhangers lead to higher arousal but do not increase enjoyment or the intention to continue watching.
[22]
Postmodern Novels and Novelists - Literary Theory and Criticism
Mar 21, 2019 · Like the modern novel, the postmodern novel is subversive; that is, it counters traditional notions of plot, narrative, chronology, and ...Missing: evolution overt
[23]
Freytag's Technique of the drama - Internet Archive
... DRAMA. 1. Play and Counter-Play. —Two halves. Rise and fall. Two kinds of structure. Drama in which the chief hero leads. Drama of counter-play. Examples ...
[24]
[PDF] paradigm.pdf - Syd Field
The Story: ACT I. ACT II. ACT III. ACT I. ACT II. ACT III. First Half. Second Half. First Half. Second Half. Dramatic Context. Dramatic Context. Plot Point I.
[25]
The science of the plot twist – how writers exploit our brains
May 11, 2018 · The science of the plot twist – how writers exploit our brains · The curse of knowledge · Plot twists pull everything together · The pluses and ...
[26]
Deus Ex Machina: How to USE and/or AVOID in Screenwriting
Jul 15, 2021 · Suspension of Disbelief. Many critics paint using a Deus ex machina as lazy writing. It's a device that calls into question the writer's ...In Modern Cinema · Cons · 2. Foreshadowing
[27]
Deus Ex Machina - Definition and Examples | LitCharts
Criticisms of the device fall into two main categories: That deus ex machina is evidence of a weak plot: Aristotle espoused this view in his philosophical ...
[28]
What is Deus Ex Machina? || Oregon State Guide to Literary Terms
Aug 23, 2020 · Deus Ex Machina is Latin for “God from the machine,” and the device has been around since the time of Greek theater.
[29]
Understanding Deus Ex Machina: Definition and Examples in ...
Nov 24, 2021 · In literary terms, deus ex machina is a plot device used when a seemingly unsolvable conflict or impossible problem is solved by the sudden ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[30]
Analysis of Euripides' Medea - Literary Theory and Criticism
Jul 13, 2020 · The final scene of her escape in her god-sent flying chariot, perhaps the most famous and controversial use of the deus ex machina in drama, ...
[31]
2.3 Passage 3: Hymen's resolution | OpenLearn - The Open University
In As You Like It, Hymen is what is known, in the Latin phrase, as a deus ex machina: a god who intervenes to resolve an impasse at the end of the plot of a ...Missing: celestial | Show results with:celestial
[32]
Deus Ex Machina - Examples and Definition - Literary Devices
The term is Latin for “god out of the machine,” and has its origins in ancient Greek theatre. It denotes scenes in which a crane (machine) was used to lower ...
[33]
In Defense of Tolkien's Deus Ex Machina - Reactor
Dec 27, 2017 · Twice in The Hobbit the Eagles come to the rescue, even bringing beak and talon to bear in the Battle of the Five Armies to help turn the tide.
[34]
MCU: 8 Times A Deus Ex Machina Created A Bigger Plot Hole Than ...
Sep 19, 2022 · MCU: 8 Times A Deus Ex Machina Created A Bigger Plot Hole Than It Fixed · Disabling Ultron · Hulk's Snap · Thor Bestowing Powers · Stark's Hidden ...
[35]
The Difference Between Eucatastrophe and Deus Ex Machina
Following these descriptions, a eucatastrophe can be a deus ex machina, but a deus ex machina cannot be a eucatastrophe. Definition of Eucatastrophe.
[36]
JRR Tolkien Invented the Term “Eucatastrophe.” What Does It Mean?
Aug 24, 2021 · The whole concept of the deus ex machina implies a secular worldview, in which divine intervention can never be the real subject of a drama, and ...
[37]
Challenging the Love Triangle in Twenty-First-Century Fantastic ...
Nov 2, 2022 · In René Girard's influential model of triangular desire, the triangle consists of the “subject” who enacts the desire, the “object” who receives ...
[38]
[PDF] An Analysis of Masculinity and Homosocial Desire in Achebe's A ...
The love triangle, as Eve Sedgwick notes in the above epigraph, is an excellent literary vehicle to represent the complexity of human desire.
[39]
[PDF] The Great Gatsby and the struggle for wealth, purity, and the pursuit ...
Readers may see a parallel between this situation and the love triangle between Daisy,. Tom, and Gatsby. Gatsby can only offer his love to Daisy while Tom can ...
[40]
"The Bachelor Primetime Construction of Romance, Fairy Tales, and ...
The Bachelor is a meticulously crafted device in which fairy tales, fantasies, and melodrama are used to create narrative stories, stories that distort the ...
[41]
10 sweetest love triangles in K-dramas | Tatler Asia
Love triangles in K-dramas can be painful, thrilling or permanently scarring. Which one is your favourite?
[42]
Love Triangles - The Atlantic
Feb 1, 1988 · Romantic love has been described as a religion of two, but love pairs can be infected by triangles and may even be wholly contaminated by them.
[43]
Alfred Hitchcock Explains the Plot Device He Called the 'MacGuffin'
the mysterious object in a spy thriller that sets the whole chain of events into motion.
[44]
Quote Origin: MacGuffin Is the Term We Use To Cover All that Sort of ...
Feb 28, 2018 · In conclusion, Alfred Hitchcock popularized the term MacGuffin in the film theory domain. The term emerged from an anecdote about a mysterious ...
[45]
What is a MacGuffin — Definition and Examples - StudioBinder
Feb 8, 2025 · A MacGuffin is a type of plot device that drives the narrative forward, but ends up having little importance to the story.<|control11|><|separator|>
[46]
Everything You Need to Know About MacGuffins - ScreenCraft
Aug 4, 2021 · Hitchcock popularized his definition of MacGuffins with his 1935 film The 39 Steps, but then continued to use the device in Notorious, Vertigo, ...
[47]
The Best MacGuffins in Movie History - ScreenCrush
Jun 23, 2020 · The glowing briefcase in Pulp Fiction took elements of previous MacGuffins like the box from Kiss Me Deadly and the Ark from Raiders and refined ...
[48]
Best MacGuffins In Games
Oct 22, 2022 · Similar to the first one, The Last Of Us Part 2 uses the MacGuffin technique to build a hook so players can feel like they have a goal.
[49]
What Separates A MacGuffin From A Red Herring? - Game Rant
Sep 24, 2021 · A Red Herring is usually meant to make a story more fun and mysterious, where a MacGuffin might drive the plot, but it's just a way to progress ...
[50]
Red Herring - Definition and Examples - LitCharts
Red herring is a pungent type of pickled fish, but people began to use the term to describe a false or misleading clue because of the way that this pickled ...Red Herring Definition · Red Herring Examples · Red Herring Function
[51]
What Is a Red Herring in Writing? Definition of Red ... - MasterClass
Aug 25, 2021 · The journalist William Cobbett is credited with originating the term “red herring” in an 1807 story. Cobbett criticized the press for ...
[52]
Where Did the Phrase 'Red Herring' Come From? - Mental Floss
May 31, 2023 · The actual origin of the figurative sense of the phrase can be traced back to the early 1800s. Around this time, English journalist William ...
[53]
The Origin of the Red Herring and its Place in Literature - CrimeReads
May 23, 2023 · In literature, a red herring is something that seems like a clue but isn't. It's used to distract and baffle both the reader and the protagonist ...
[54]
What is a Red Herring — Definition and Examples in Storytelling
Jan 27, 2025 · The red herring origin predates the invention of cinema. The first recorded use of the term was all the way back in 1686. It was used to ...
[55]
15 Cunning Red Herring Examples in TV and Film - Industrial Scripts®
Nov 20, 2019 · #6 – The Sixth Sense ... The Sixth Sense is defined by a great third act plot twist. And a red herring is crucial in getting to said plot twist.
[56]
Red Herrings in And Then There Were None - Intermittent Mechanism
Apr 26, 2024 · Agatha Christie's red herrings are more subtle than the red herrings exchanged between her characters, but just as retrospectively incriminating.
[57]
10 Thrillers With Very Successful Red Herrings - MovieWeb
Mar 20, 2023 · The Sixth Sense, directed by M Night Shyamalan is infamous for its use of the most iconic red herring. The film follows a young boy disturbed by ...
[58]
Among Us & The Psychology of Social Deduction - Medium
Oct 20, 2020 · Sticking to a specific story consistently with conviction · Producing a fake alibi with actual innocents or a fellow impostor · Pretending to be ...
[59]
The Best True-Crime Podcasts to Listen to Now | Vogue
Oct 4, 2025 · Whether you're already an obsessive or just wading into the world of cold cases and red herrings, here are Vogue's picks for the best true-crime podcasts to ...
[60]
Serial (Podcast) - TV Tropes
Red Herring: Tons, since this is a Real Life murder case and thus doesn't have the benefit of The Law of Conservation of Detail. It's hard to know what ...
[61]
https://www.folger.edu/explore/shakespeares-works/romeo-and-juliet/read/4/3/
[62]
Romeo and Juliet - Act 4, scene 3 | Folger Shakespeare Library
After facing her terror at the prospect of awaking in her family's burial vault, Juliet drinks the potion that Friar Lawrence has given her. Enter Juliet and ...
[63]
The Firm by John Grisham
An FBI investigation into the firm's connections to the Mafia plunges the straight and narrow attorney into a nightmare of terror and intrigue.
[64]
Pushing Daisies (TV Series 2007–2009) - IMDb
Rating 8.4/10 (61,535) A pastry chef with the power to bring dead people back to life solves murder mysteries with his resurrected childhood sweetheart.Full cast & crew · Episode list · Pushing Daisies · Trivia
[65]
What is a Quibble | Use and Examples in Narrative - Bibisco
Narrative Techniques Series: Quibble. This Technique consists in surprising the reader by finding a loophole and an unexpected way out.
[66]
Understanding the quibble plot device – Microsoft 365
Feb 1, 2024 · A quibble is a plot device where a character takes a verbal condition very literally instead of its assumed intent.
[67]
Morality Plays | Encyclopedia.com
The essential theme of the morality play is the conflict between the forces of good (the good angel, the virtues) and the forces of evil (the bad angel or devil ...
[68]
What is Foreshadowing — Definition, Examples in Film and Lit.
Dec 15, 2024 · Foreshadowing is a literary device that is utilized to give a hint or indication of future events in the story. It can be a very effective tool ...
[69]
Foreshadowing Definition and 10 Techniques for Effective Plot Twists
Foreshadowing is the weaving of hints and subtle clues into a work of fiction for the purpose of making future plot events feel natural and consistent.
[70]
Literary Devices for Screenwriters: A Comprehensive Guide
Sep 23, 2025 · Foreshadowing builds anticipation and rewards attentive viewers. It makes twists feel earned rather than arbitrary. Examples. The Sixth Sense ( ...Foreshadowing · Metaphor & Symbolism · Dramatic Irony
[71]
Writing 101: What Is a MacGuffin? Learn About MacGuffins in Film ...
Sep 2, 2022 · 1. As a catalyst for the action of the story. The MacGuffin is what springs the characters—either the good guys or the bad guys—into action. · 2.Missing: practices | Show results with:practices
[72]
How to Master Alfred Hitchcock's MacGuffin Technique - PremiumBeat
Dec 3, 2019 · A MacGuffin is that magical “thing” that advances the plot, builds the narrative, and helps push the story forward.Missing: practices | Show results with:practices
[73]
Mastering Plot Devices: A Beginner's Key to Compelling Stories
Oct 22, 2024 · Plot devices are essential elements in screenwriting, offering mechanisms to challenge characters, engage audiences, and drive narratives forward.
[74]
What Are Plot Devices? (Why You Should Be Cautious)
Aug 14, 2023 · Plot devices are the little clockwork gears that make a story run. This means plot devices are also one of a writer's most important tools.
[75]
10 Ways To Use Plot Twists In Your Screenplay
Jun 17, 2020 · Plot twists are screenwriting devices to take your story in a new and unexpected direction. They are an effective tool for screenwriters to get audiences out ...
[76]
The Art of Plot Twists - Arc Studio Blog
Aug 11, 2025 · There's a lesson here for screenwriters: Don't just use twists at the end to reframe what came before. Use them in the middle of the movie to ...
[77]
Poetics by Aristotle - The Internet Classics Archive
The Deus ex Machina should be employed only for events external to the drama- for antecedent or subsequent events, which lie beyond the range of human knowledge ...<|separator|>
[78]
Signs: a hucksterish religious parable.
Aug 2, 2002 · He or she has said, “Let there be light.” Details can be planted early that will pay off later; a deus ex machina can be lowered on cue. Without ...
[79]
The five stupidest MacGuffins in cinema history - Far Out Magazine
Aug 2, 2025 · Either they don't fit with the plot, aren't explained well enough, or simply don't make sense; these MacGuffins give the classic trope a bad ...
[80]
This Signs Theory Solves The Controversial Water Plot Hole (But ...
Jul 27, 2024 · ... weakness was water. Now, a theory solves this huge plot ... Signs 2002 alien claw under pantry door.