Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Nef reaction

The Nef reaction is an organic transformation that converts primary and secondary nitroalkanes into the corresponding aldehydes and ketones, respectively, by first deprotonating the nitro compound to form a nitronate salt and then hydrolyzing it under strongly acidic conditions (pH < 1).^[1] This reaction exemplifies umpolung reactivity, where the nitro group serves as a synthetic equivalent to an acyl anion, enabling the preparation of carbonyl compounds from readily available nitro precursors often generated via the Henry (nitroaldol) reaction or Michael additions.^[2] The process is particularly valuable in total synthesis for introducing carbonyl functionality in complex molecules, such as natural products like norzoanthamine and microminutinin.^[3] The reaction was first reported in 1893 by Russian chemist Mikhail Konovalov but was independently developed as a general method in 1894 by Swiss-American chemist John Ulric Nef, who initially demonstrated it by treating the sodium salt of nitroethane with sulfuric acid to yield acetaldehyde and nitrous oxide, as detailed in Nef's seminal publication in Justus Liebigs Annalen der Chemie.^[4]^[5] Nef's work built on earlier observations of nitro compound behavior but established the general method for nitro-to-carbonyl conversion, which has since become a cornerstone of aliphatic nitro chemistry despite challenges with substrate scope in the classical procedure.^[6] Over the decades, the reaction has been refined to accommodate a broader range of functional groups, including ethers, silyl ethers, acetals, and esters, through modified conditions.^[7] The mechanism proceeds via protonation of the nitronate to form a nitronic acid intermediate, followed by dehydration to an a-nitroso alkene, tautomerization to an oxime, and final hydrolysis to the carbonyl product under strongly acidic conditions that ensure the intermediate oxime is converted to the carbonyl, thereby avoiding its isolation as a side product.^[1] Variations include oxidative methods using reagents like Oxone® or KMnO₄, which tolerate acid-sensitive groups, and reductive approaches with TiCl₃, offering alternatives to the traditional strong acid hydrolysis.^[3] While tertiary nitroalkanes cannot undergo the reaction due to lack of α-hydrogens for deprotonation, the Nef process remains the most direct and commonly employed strategy for deoxygenating nitro groups to carbonyls in synthetic organic chemistry.^[6]

History

Discovery

The Nef reaction was first observed in 1893 by Russian chemist Mikhail Konovalov, who converted the potassium salt of 1-phenylnitroethane with dilute sulfuric acid to acetophenone. It was reported and generalized in 1894 by the Swiss-American chemist John Ulric Nef, who investigated the constitution of nitroparaffin salts during his studies on the structure and reactivity of these compounds at Clark University.^[8] In his seminal paper published in Justus Liebigs Annalen der Chemie, Nef described the conversion of primary and secondary nitroalkanes to the corresponding carbonyl compounds through base-mediated deprotonation followed by acid hydrolysis.^[8] This transformation was observed while examining the tautomerism and stability of nitroparaffin derivatives, building on contemporary interest in nitro compounds' chemical behavior.^[9] Nef's procedure involved treating nitroalkanes, such as nitromethane, with bases like alcoholic potassium hydroxide (KOH) or sodium hydroxide (NaOH) to generate the corresponding potassium or sodium nitronates.^[10] These salts were then acidified with dilute sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄, typically in a 1:5 or 1:10 ratio with water) at low temperatures to effect the hydrolysis, yielding aldehydes or ketones along with nitrous oxide (N₂O).^[10] For instance, Nef demonstrated the reaction using sodium ethoxide as the base for nitromethane, followed by sulfuric acid treatment, to produce formaldehyde.^[8] In his initial experiments with simple nitroalkanes, Nef reported moderate to good yields for the carbonyl products. For the conversion of nitroethane to acetaldehyde, yields were 85–89%, while nitromethane to formaldehyde proceeded with yields up to 70% for the aldehyde and associated nitrous oxide byproduct.^[10] These results established the reaction's utility for primary nitro compounds, though Nef noted challenges with more complex substrates due to side reactions at higher temperatures.^[10]

Early developments

Following the initial discovery by John U. Nef in 1894, subsequent investigations rapidly expanded the understanding of the reaction's scope. In particular, Nef's own work demonstrated that secondary nitro compounds, such as 2-nitropropane, could be converted to the corresponding ketones like acetone upon treatment of their sodium salts with dilute sulfuric acid, achieving yields of approximately 85% based on evolved nitrous oxide.^[10] During the 1920s and 1930s, researchers focused on procedural refinements to enhance reliability and minimize side reactions. Key optimizations included the introduction of controlled, gradual acidification using dilute hydrochloric or sulfuric acid at low temperatures (around 0°C), which reduced the formation of polymerization byproducts—particularly problematic with primary nitroalkanes prone to aldol-type condensations under harsh acidic conditions—and improved overall efficiency.^[10] The 1921 review by Hass and Riley in Chemical Reviews synthesized prior findings and helped standardize the protocol, reporting typical yields of 70–80% for aldehydes derived from primary nitroalkanes like nitroethane.^[10] By the 1940s, the transformation had gained formal recognition as the "Nef reaction" in organic chemistry textbooks and synthetic literature, distinguishing it from related nitro compound reductions (e.g., to amines) and emphasizing its unique deprotonation-acidolysis pathway to carbonyls.

Reaction overview

General scheme

The Nef reaction converts primary and secondary nitroalkanes into the corresponding aldehydes and ketones, respectively, through a two-step process involving deprotonation followed by acidification.^[11]^[12] For primary nitroalkanes of the form R-CH₂-NO₂, where R is hydrogen or an alkyl group, the overall transformation is represented as:

\ce{R-CH2-NO2 ->[base] R-CH=NO2^- ->[H+] R-CHO + N2O + H2O}

This scheme applies explicitly to nitromethane (R = H), yielding formaldehyde (though practical yields are low due to formaldehyde's reactivity), and to 1-nitropropane (R = CH₃CH₂), yielding propanal.^[11]^[13] For secondary nitroalkanes of the form R₂CH-NO₂, the reaction proceeds analogously:

\ce{R2CH-NO2 ->[base] R2C=NO2^- ->[H+] R2C=O + N2O + H2O}

A representative example is 2-nitropropane (R = CH₃), which affords acetone.^[11]^[12]^[13] This transformation exemplifies umpolung reactivity, wherein the nitro group serves as a masked carbonyl synthon, allowing the nitroalkane anion to function as an acyl anion equivalent for carbon chain extension in organic synthesis.^[12] The primary byproduct is nitrous oxide (N₂O), which may evolve as a gas.^[13]

Typical conditions

The classical Nef reaction begins with the treatment of a primary or secondary nitroalkane with 1-2 equivalents of sodium hydroxide (NaOH) or potassium hydroxide (KOH) in aqueous ethanol or methanol, typically at temperatures between 0°C and 25°C for 1-2 hours, to generate the corresponding nitronate salt.^[13] This step ensures complete deprotonation of the nitro compound, forming a stable aci-form intermediate that sets the stage for the subsequent conversion to the carbonyl product.^[2] Following salt formation, the nitronate solution is subjected to acidification by slow addition of 10-20% sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄) or hydrochloric acid (HCl) at -10°C to 0°C to achieve strongly acidic conditions (pH < 1), after which the mixture is warmed to room temperature to complete the hydrolysis.^[13]^[1] The low temperature during acidification minimizes side reactions and controls the exothermic nature of the process, promoting clean transformation of the nitronate to the aldehyde or ketone.^[2] The reaction mixture is then worked up by extraction with diethyl ether or dichloromethane (DCM), followed by drying over an anhydrous salt such as magnesium sulfate and distillation to isolate the carbonyl compound, with typical yields ranging from 60% to 85% for unhindered substrates.^[13] These yields reflect the efficiency under optimized conditions for simple aliphatic nitroalkanes, though they can vary based on substrate sterics.^[2] The procedure is best suited for laboratory scales of 1-100 mmol, as larger scales increase the risk of uncontrolled exotherm during acidification, potentially leading to decomposition or reduced selectivity.^[13] Careful monitoring of temperature and addition rate is essential to maintain safety and reproducibility on these scales.^[2]

Mechanism

Deprotonation step

The deprotonation step initiates the Nef reaction through base-mediated removal of the alpha proton from a primary or secondary nitroalkane, establishing an acid-base equilibrium that favors the nitronate anion under typical conditions. Nitroalkanes exhibit pKa values of approximately 9–10 due to the stabilizing effect of the nitro group on the conjugate base, enabling efficient deprotonation by bases such as sodium ethoxide, potassium tert-butoxide, or aqueous sodium hydroxide. For instance, nitroethane has a pKa of 8.6 in water, while 1-nitropropane has a pKa of 9.^[14] The nitronate anion thus formed is resonance-stabilized, delocalizing the negative charge between a carbanion structure and an aci-nitronate form:

\ce{R-CH2-NO2 + B- ⇌ R-CH^- -NO2 ↔ R-CH=N(O)O^- + BH}

This resonance contributes to the anion's stability and reactivity, with the aci form predominating in characterization studies.^[15] The alpha carbon in the nitronate anion adopts sp² hybridization, resulting in a planar geometry that renders the species achiral; consequently, optically active nitroalkanes yield racemic products upon deprotonation and subsequent reaction.^[16] Protic solvents, such as ethanol or water, enhance nitronate formation by stabilizing the anion via hydrogen bonding, which lowers the effective pKa and shifts the equilibrium toward deprotonation. Reaction rates are influenced by steric factors at the alpha position, with primary nitroalkanes deprotonating more rapidly than secondary ones due to reduced hindrance impeding base approach. Nitronate salts, often prepared as alkali metal derivatives, are generally stable solids that can be isolated and stored for weeks in the absence of moisture and CO₂, serving as versatile intermediates in nucleophilic additions like the Henry reaction.

Acidification and hydrolysis

Upon acidification of the nitronate anion, protonation occurs at the oxygen atom of the nitro group, yielding the highly unstable aci-nitro compound (nitronic acid), represented as R-CH=N(OH)OH for primary nitroalkanes.^[17] This tautomer is transient and prone to rapid decomposition, necessitating careful control of reaction conditions to prevent side pathways.^[17] The aci-nitro compound undergoes tautomerization under acidic conditions to form the oxime (nitrosolic acid, R-CH=NOH), which is then hydrolyzed in the strongly acidic aqueous medium (pH < 1) to afford the corresponding aldehyde (R-CHO) and hydroxylamine (NH₂OH). In the case of primary nitroalkanes, the hydroxylamine produced can react with traces of nitrous acid (a side product) to generate nitrous oxide (N₂O) and ammonium salts.^[1] For secondary nitroalkanes, the sequence is analogous, with the dialkyl-substituted nitronate R₂C=NO₂⁻ protonating to R₂C=N(OH)OH, tautomerizing to the oxime R₂C=NOH, and hydrolyzing to the ketone R₂C=O and hydroxylamine (NH₂OH).^[1] The reaction is under kinetic control, where low temperatures (typically 0°C or below) are employed to suppress polymerization or other side reactions of the reactive intermediates, ensuring selective formation of the carbonyl product.^[17] Evidence for these transient species, including the aci-nitro and oxime tautomers, has been obtained through UV spectroscopy, which reveals characteristic absorption spectra during the hydrolysis process.^[17]

Scope and limitations

Substrate compatibility

The Nef reaction demonstrates excellent substrate compatibility with primary nitroalkanes, which are converted to the corresponding aldehydes in high yields under classical conditions. For example, treatment of 1-nitropropane with base followed by acidification affords propanal in yields typically around 70%, with optimal results achieved at low temperatures and controlled acid strength. This efficiency extends to longer aliphatic chains, including primary nitroalkanes up to C10, where the reaction proceeds reliably, though solubility in aqueous base may pose challenges for highly hindered or longer-chain substrates.^[6] Secondary nitroalkanes, particularly acyclic variants, are also well-suited substrates, producing ketones in good yields. The conversion of 2-nitrobutane to butan-2-one exemplifies this, achieving good yields in standard protocols, comparable to the 85% yield obtained from 2-nitropropane to acetone.^[18] While some sterically hindered secondary nitroalkanes may experience reduced efficiency due to solubility issues in the deprotonation step, simple branched systems like 2-nitropropane proceed smoothly without significant yield drops.^[6] The reaction tolerates a range of functional groups, including alcohols, ethers, and esters, which remain intact during deprotonation and acidification steps. For instance, primary nitroalkanes bearing free hydroxyl groups, like 1-desoxy-1-nitromannitol, undergo smooth conversion to the aldehydic product. In contrast, alkenes are incompatible, as the acidic conditions promote isomerization of the double bond, leading to side reactions and diminished selectivity. Groups sensitive to strong bases, such as certain esters or protecting groups, may also degrade during the initial deprotonation, limiting applicability in multifunctional syntheses. Aromatic nitro compounds, such as nitrobenzene, are unsuitable substrates due to the stability of the anion and lack of acidic alpha protons, restricting the Nef reaction to aliphatic nitroalkanes exclusively.^[1]

Common side reactions

In the Nef reaction, several competing pathways can reduce the yield of the desired carbonyl compound by diverting the nitroalkane substrate or intermediates toward undesired products. One frequent side reaction involves the formation of oximes or hydroxynitroso compounds during the acidification step, which occurs if the pH is not maintained below 1, as the nitronic acid intermediate fails to tautomerize properly to the nitroso-alkene. ^[1] This is particularly problematic in classical procedures using sulfuric acid, where insufficient acidity leads to stable nitronate-derived species instead of hydrolysis to the carbonyl. Denitration can occur under the acidic conditions of the hydrolysis step, resulting in the corresponding alkane product. This pathway may be more prevalent for substrates prone to carbocation formation. For example, beta-branched primary nitroalkanes sometimes show reduced efficiency due to competing denitration. Elimination reactions also compete effectively, particularly when excessively strong bases are employed for nitronate formation, promoting E2 elimination in nitroalkanes bearing beta-hydrogens to yield conjugated nitroalkenes. This side pathway is triggered during the deprotonation phase and can be exacerbated by elevated temperatures or prolonged basic exposure, diverting substrate away from the nitronate prior to acidification. For the specific case of nitromethane-derived formaldehyde, a Cannizzaro-type self-oxidation can occur if the product is not promptly isolated, leading to disproportionation into methanol and formic acid, with the formaldehyde tending to oligomerize above 0°C, forming polymeric byproducts that complicate isolation. The acidification step often serves as the trigger for these post-formation sides, emphasizing the need for controlled workup to minimize losses. ^[1]

Variants

Classical procedure

The classical procedure for the Nef reaction follows a two-step protocol, first forming the nitronate salt and then hydrolyzing it under acidic conditions to yield the corresponding carbonyl compound. In the initial step, the nitroalkane is combined with a 10% excess of aqueous NaOH in ethanol and stirred for 30 minutes at room temperature to generate the nitronate anion.^[1] This deprotonation is typically carried out in standard glassware, such as a round-bottom flask equipped with a magnetic stirrer, without the need for an inert atmosphere unless the substrate contains particularly sensitive functional groups.^[1] The second step involves cooling the reaction mixture to 0°C in an ice bath, followed by the dropwise addition of 3 M sulfuric acid to achieve pH <1. The mixture is then stirred at this temperature until completion of hydrolysis, after which the organic product is extracted into an immiscible solvent like diethyl ether or dichloromethane, washed, dried, and isolated by evaporation or distillation.^[1] This acidification must be controlled to ensure strong acidity, which promotes the reaction, and the low temperature helps maintain selectivity.^[2] A representative example is the conversion of nitrocyclohexane to cyclohexanone, achieved in very good yield using this method as refined in mid-20th century literature.^[19] The procedure requires only basic laboratory equipment, emphasizing its accessibility for synthetic applications prior to later modifications.^[19]

Modern modifications

In the late 1990s, oxidative methods using Oxone as a mild oxidant emerged as a key modification to the Nef reaction, enabling conversion of primary nitroalkanes to carboxylic acids and secondary nitroalkanes to ketones in good yields while addressing limitations of harsh acidic conditions for a broader range of substrates.^[20] To mitigate the harsh acidic conditions of the traditional procedure, which can lead to over-acidification and substrate decomposition, milder acidification methods were developed in the 2000s using solid acid catalysts. Treatment of nitronate salts with silica gel in dichloromethane provides a gentle protonation environment, yielding carbonyl products in 80–95% efficiency while preserving acid-sensitive groups such as esters or alkenes.^[21] Recent mechanistic studies have deepened understanding of the Nef reaction's transient intermediates, informing optimized variants for delicate substrates. A 2025 investigation in Organic Letters employed spectroscopic and computational methods to elucidate the role of singlet oxygen in an oxidative Nef pathway, revealing short-lived nitronate-derived species with lifetimes under 1 second that enable rapid quenching and high-fidelity conversions (85–98% yields) for aldehyde synthesis from primary nitroalkanes. These insights have spurred stopped-flow techniques, allowing real-time monitoring and adaptation for biologically active molecules.^[7] The interrupted Nef reaction represents a significant 21st-century advancement, halting the process at the aci-nitro (nitronic acid) intermediate for orthogonal functionalization rather than full hydrolysis to carbonyls. This variant, highlighted in a 2023 Molecules review, supports diversity-oriented synthesis by enabling nucleophilic trapping of the aci-nitro with reagents like alcohols or amines to form ethers or imines (yields 70–90%), expanding nitroalkane utility in library generation for drug discovery without the limitations of complete Nef conversion.^[22]

References

[1]
Nef Reaction - Organic Chemistry Portal
The conversion of nitro compounds into carbonyls is known as the Nef Reaction. Various methodologies have been developed, but the most important is the ...
[2]
The Nef Reaction - Pinnick - Wiley Online Library
Oct 15, 2004 · The Nef reaction is usually defined as the conversion of a primary or secondary nitroalkane into the corresponding carbonyl compound.
[3]
Nef Reaction - Alfa Chemistry
In Nef reaction, the conjugate base of primary or secondary aliphatic nitro compounds is hydrolyzed under the action of sulfuric acid to form aldehydes or ...
[4]
Nef reaction | SpringerLink
Nef, J. U. Ann. 1894, 280, 263––342. John Ulrich Nef (1862–1915) was born in Switzerland and immigrated to the US at the age of four with his parents.
[5]
Nef Reaction - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The Nef reaction is defined as a method for converting nitroalkanes into saturated aldehydes, and it remains the most common approach for this transformation.
[6]
Development and Mechanistic Insights into Nef Reaction for ...
Apr 17, 2025 · The Nef reaction for conversion of nitro compounds to aldehydes is described. Various functional groups, such as ethers, silyl ethers, acetals or esters, were ...
[7]
Ueber das zweiwerthige Kohlenstoffatom - Chemistry Europe - Wiley
Volume 280, Issue 2-3 p. 291-342 Justus Liebigs Annalen der Chemie. Article. Full Access. Ueber das zweiwerthige Kohlenstoffatom. J. U. Nef,. J. U. Nef.Missing: U. | Show results with:U.
[8]
[PDF] JOHN ULRIC NEF - Biographical Memoirs
The above is the "Nef reaction" of the acetylene specialists and is not to be confused with the previously cited "Nef reaction" of the nitroparaffin chemists.Missing: original | Show results with:original
[9]
The NEF Reaction | Chemical Reviews - ACS Publications
Asymmetric Tandem Michael Addition/Interrupted Nef Reactions of Nitromethane with Oxindole-Derived Alkenes: Enantioselective Synthesis of Spiro-polycyclic ...Missing: U. original
[10]
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/cr50001a003
[11]
The Nef Reaction - Organic Reactions
The Nef reaction is usually defined as the conversion of a primary or secondary nitroalkane into the corresponding carbonyl compound.
[12]
[PDF] ""' C=O + N20 + :'.\1+ - Isomer Design
R is the remainder of the original aldose ,. Page 5. THE NEF REACTION ... The yields of simple aldehydes ... Yields in the Nef reaction of 4-nitro-5- ...
[13]
[PDF] pka-compilation-williams.pdf - Organic Chemistry Data
Apr 7, 2022 · This document lists pKa values for inorganic compounds, phenazine, phosphates, pyridine, carboxylic acids, pyrazine, aliphatic, aromatic, and ...Missing: paper | Show results with:paper
[14]
Nucleophilicities of Nitroalkyl Anions - ACS Publications
Because the nucleophilic reactivities of nitronate anions with wide structural variety differ by a factor of less than 102 in water, they cannot predominantly ...
[15]
Kinetic and equilibrium acidities for nitroalkanes - ACS Publications
Resonance, Inductive, Solvation, Steric, and Transition State Hydrogen ... The Journal of Organic Chemistry. Cite this: J. Org. Chem. 1978, 43, 16, 3107 ...
[16]
aci-Nitroalkanes. II. The Mechanism of the Nef Reaction1
aci-Nitroalkanes. II. The Mechanism of the Nef Reaction1. Click to copy article linkArticle link copied! M. Frederick Hawthorne. ACS Legacy Archive. Open PDF ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[17]
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/ja01567a042
[18]
http://electronicsandbooks.com/edt/manual/Magazine/J/Journal%2520of%2520the%2520American%2520Chemical%2520Society%2520US/1952%2520%2520%28vol%2520074%29/10%2520%2520%282447-2698%29/2615-2618.pdf
[19]
The Last Fortress of Tin's Tyranny – Protodenitration of Nitroalkanes
Jan 6, 2023 · ... Nef reaction. Due to the higher acidity of the ... Generally, secondary and tertiary nitroalkane can be denitrated without rearrangement.
[20]
[PDF] the nef reaction
H. RA=O. Leitch (33) has recently proposed the same mechanism for the Nef reaction. In those cases where the reacting carbon is attached to a negative group ...Missing: 1906 | Show results with:1906
[21]
Journey Describing Applications of Oxone in Synthetic Chemistry
Oxone is a white Crystallin solid, easy to handle, not toxic, soluble in water, and, above all, cheap and stable.
[22]
[PDF] Silica gel in organic synthesis - Russian Chemical Reviews
The use of silica gel in the Nef reaction has been described.80. Nitroalkanes were converted into the corresponding carbonyl compounds in high yields by ...
[23]
Overcoming the Usual Reactivity of β-Nitroenones - ACS Publications
Mar 16, 2023 · E.g., in presence of Ac2O and Amberlyst 15, followed by KF/Al2O3 ... Nef reaction/cyclization of β-nitroenones. Organic & Biomolecular ...
[24]
Interrupted Nef and Meyer Reactions: A Growing Point for ... - MDPI
Jan 10, 2023 · Nitro to carbonyl group conversion is one of the key transformations in organic synthesis known since the second half of the 19th century. The ...Missing: context | Show results with:context