Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Negative energy

In physics, negative energy refers to a phenomenon in quantum field theory where the expectation value of the energy density in certain quantum states falls below that of the vacuum state, resulting from the suppression of quantum vacuum fluctuations.^[1] This sub-vacuum energy arises in coherent quantum states, such as squeezed vacua, and is distinct from classical notions of energy, as it represents a temporary "debt" to the vacuum rather than a literal negative total energy.^[1] While classical physics enforces positive energy densities through conditions like the weak energy condition, quantum mechanics permits localized negative values, though they are constrained by quantum inequalities that limit their magnitude and duration to prevent macroscopic violations of causality.^[2] A prominent example of negative energy density is the Casimir effect, observed between two uncharged, parallel conducting plates in a vacuum, where the exclusion of certain virtual photon modes leads to an attractive force and a negative energy density of approximately -\frac{\pi^2 \hbar c}{720 a^4} (with a as the plate separation), confirming quantum predictions experimentally.^[1] Other instances include the Hawking radiation near black hole event horizons, where the Hartle-Hawking vacuum state yields negative energy fluxes, and squeezed light states in quantum optics that can produce arbitrarily negative but short-lived energy densities.^[2] These effects highlight how negative energy emerges from boundary conditions or quantum coherence, underscoring the non-intuitive nature of the quantum vacuum as a fluctuating sea of virtual particles.^[1] The implications of negative energy extend to speculative applications in general relativity, where it equates to negative mass-energy and violates classical energy conditions, potentially enabling exotic structures like traversable wormholes or warp drives for faster-than-light travel.^[2] For instance, stabilizing a wormhole throat requires negative energy to counteract gravitational collapse, as proposed in the Morris-Thorne metric, though quantum inequalities impose severe restrictions, making large-scale realizations improbable without advanced engineering of quantum fields.^[2] Despite these possibilities, ongoing research emphasizes the fundamental role of negative energy in unifying quantum mechanics and gravity, while cautioning against interpretations that could imply perpetual motion or causality paradoxes.^[1]

Fundamentals

Definition and Conceptual Overview

Negative energy in physics denotes physical systems, states, or regions where the energy or energy density is lower than a defined reference zero point, such as the energy configuration at infinite separation in interacting potentials or the ground state of the quantum vacuum in field theories. This concept arises because energy is not absolute but relative to a chosen normalization, allowing values below zero without implying absolute negativity. In mathematical terms, negative energy is represented generally as E < 0, where the sign depends on the reference frame or baseline; for instance, in potential energy formulations, E = -|E| relative to the zero at dissociation or equilibrium.^[3]^[4] This framework manifests in diverse contexts, including gravitational binding energy, where the potential energy of orbiting bodies is negative to signify stability against separation; quantum vacuum fluctuations, which can produce localized sub-vacuum energy densities through suppressed zero-point oscillations; and relativistic scenarios, such as energy extraction processes involving particles with negative energy relative to distant observers. These examples highlight how negative energy facilitates bound configurations or transient extractions without global violations of conservation principles.^[3]^[4]^[5] The presence of negative energy has key implications for system stability: it underpins bound states, like atomic electrons or planetary systems, where negative potential energy is balanced by positive kinetic energy, ensuring overall conservation and preventing spontaneous disassembly. In quantum field theory, however, unrestricted negative energy densities could theoretically induce instabilities, such as runaway processes or violations of thermodynamic laws, though quantum inequalities impose bounds on their magnitude and duration to maintain physical consistency.^[3]^[6] Importantly, negative energy is distinct from negative mass or negative pressure: it is a scalar measure of energy below a reference, applicable to standard positive-mass matter, whereas negative mass implies exotic gravitational repulsion and is not required for negative energy states, and negative pressure pertains to specific components of the stress-energy tensor rather than the energy itself.^[7]^[6]

Historical Development

The concept of negative energy emerged in the late 1920s through Paul Dirac's efforts to reconcile quantum mechanics with special relativity. In his seminal 1928 paper, Dirac formulated a relativistic wave equation for the electron that incorporated both positive and negative energy solutions to ensure the equation was first-order in both space and time, avoiding non-physical faster-than-light propagation. These negative energy states initially posed interpretational challenges, as they suggested electrons could occupy unbound negative energy levels, potentially leading to catastrophic cascades of transitions.^[8] By the early 1930s, Dirac reinterpreted these negative energy solutions as "holes" representing positrons, the antiparticles of electrons, providing a theoretical prediction of antimatter. This hole theory gained empirical support in 1932 when Carl Anderson experimentally discovered the positron in cosmic ray tracks using a cloud chamber, confirming Dirac's prediction and marking the first observation of antimatter. Anderson's finding, initially puzzling, aligned with Dirac's framework by identifying the positron as an absence in the sea of negative energy electrons, though this "Dirac sea" model later proved outdated in favor of field-theoretic descriptions.^[9] The mid-20th century saw a pivotal shift to quantum field theory (QFT) in the 1940s and 1950s, where negative energy issues were resolved by treating particles and antiparticles as excitations of underlying fields, eliminating single-particle negative states. This era addressed infinities in QFT calculations through renormalization techniques developed by Sin-Itiro Tomonaga, Julian Schwinger, Richard Feynman, and Freeman Dyson, enabling consistent predictions for processes involving virtual particles with transient negative energy contributions. A key milestone was the 1945 Wheeler-Feynman absorber theory, which incorporated advanced waves—associated with negative frequencies and energies—to explain radiation reaction without self-interaction divergences in classical electrodynamics. In the 1960s and 1970s, negative energy concepts extended into general relativity (GR), bridging QFT and gravity. Roger Penrose's 1969 process demonstrated how particles in a black hole's ergosphere could split, with one fragment carrying negative energy into the horizon, allowing extraction of rotational energy from the black hole. Stephen Hawking's 1974 work on black hole evaporation further integrated these ideas, showing that virtual particle pairs near the event horizon could result in real emission if the negative energy partner fell inward, leading to black hole mass loss via quantum effects. The Casimir effect was theoretically predicted in 1948, with experimental confirmation in the 1990s—such as the 1997 experiment by S. K. Lamoreaux and the 1998 measurement by U. Mohideen and A. Roy—demonstrating that negative energy densities between conducting plates produce a measurable attractive force, thus confirming QFT's allowance for localized negative energies.^[10]^[11] Since the late 20th century, no major paradigm shifts have occurred in the core understanding of negative energy, though ongoing refinements continue in efforts to unify QFT and GR, such as in quantum gravity approaches that constrain negative energy fluxes to avoid instabilities.

Classical and Relativistic Contexts

Gravitational Potential Energy

In Newtonian gravity, the gravitational potential energy V for two point masses M and m separated by distance r is given by

V = -\frac{GMm}{r},

where G is the gravitational constant; this expression is negative due to the attractive nature of the force. For a bound orbit, the total mechanical energy E = K + V < 0, with K > 0 denoting kinetic energy, ensuring the system cannot dissociate without external energy input and thus remains stable./Book%3A_University_Physics_I_-Mechanics_Sound_Oscillations_and_Waves(OpenStax)/13%3A_Gravitation/13.05%3A_Satellite_Orbits_and_Energy) Representative examples include planetary systems, where satellites like Earth orbit the Sun in elliptical paths sustained by negative total energy, and interstellar gas clouds that collapse under self-gravity during star formation when their negative potential energy exceeds positive thermal kinetic energy, forming bound protostellar cores./Book%3A_University_Physics_I_-Mechanics_Sound_Oscillations_and_Waves(OpenStax)/13%3A_Gravitation/13.05%3A_Satellite_Orbits_and_Energy) For self-gravitating systems in virial equilibrium, such as star clusters or galaxies, the virial theorem establishes $2K + W = 0, where W < 0 is the total gravitational potential energy; consequently, the overall energy E = K + W = -K < 0, confirming the bound nature and dynamical balance.^[12] Observational evidence from galaxy dynamics reinforces this, as rotation curves—measuring stellar and gas velocities—combined with the virial theorem yield dynamical masses implying negative binding energies necessary to maintain galactic cohesion against dispersion.^[13] The zero-energy universe hypothesis, introduced by Edward Tryon in 1973, argues that the universe's positive matter and radiation energy is precisely offset by negative gravitational potential energy, yielding a net total energy of zero and allowing spontaneous emergence consistent with quantum principles.^[14] In general relativity, these ideas generalize, with the stress-energy tensor's components permitting negative contributions in pseudo-tensor formulations of gravitational energy, such that bound systems exhibit negative gravitational energy relative to separated constituents.^[15] For example, the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner (ADM) total energy for an isolated bound system is less than the sum of individual rest masses, attributable to negative binding contributions from the gravitational field.^[16] Relativistic cosmological models further illustrate this: a closed universe (positive spatial curvature) dominated by matter behaves like a bound system with effectively negative total energy, driving expansion to a maximum followed by recollapse in a Big Crunch scenario if the density parameter \Omega > 1 without counteracting dark energy.^[17]

Black Hole Ergosphere and Penrose Process

In the context of rotating black holes described by the Kerr metric, the ergosphere is an oblate spheroidal region exterior to the event horizon where the spacetime is dragged by the black hole's rotation, a phenomenon known as frame-dragging. This region arises due to the off-diagonal terms in the metric that couple time and azimuthal coordinates, preventing stationary observers from remaining at rest relative to distant stars. In Boyer-Lindquist coordinates, the ergosphere is precisely defined as the volume where the metric component g_{tt} > 0, which implies that the timelike Killing vector field becomes spacelike, forcing any object in this region to acquire angular velocity in the direction of the black hole's spin.^[18] The boundary of the ergosphere, called the static limit, touches the event horizon at the poles and extends farthest in the equatorial plane, with its shape determined by the black hole's spin parameter a = J / M, where J is the angular momentum and M is the mass. The Penrose process, proposed by Roger Penrose in 1969, exploits the ergosphere to extract rotational energy from a Kerr black hole by allowing particles to achieve negative energy states as measured by observers at infinity.^[19] In this classical mechanism, a particle enters the ergosphere and decays into two fragments: one escapes to infinity with energy greater than the incoming particle, while the other falls into the black hole carrying negative energy relative to infinity. This negative energy particle reduces the black hole's total energy and angular momentum without violating conservation laws, as the overall energy balance is preserved locally but allows net extraction from the hole's rotation. The process requires the infalling fragment to have angular momentum opposite to the black hole's spin to achieve negative energy. Mathematically, the conserved energy E of a particle in the Kerr geometry, as measured at infinity, is given by E = -u_t, where u_t is the time component of the particle's four-velocity in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates.^[18] For timelike geodesics in the ergosphere, negative energy orbits are possible when E < 0, which occurs if the particle's angular momentum L satisfies L < 2Mar \sin^2\theta / \Sigma (with \Sigma = r^2 + a^2 \cos^2\theta), enabling the energy extraction. The maximum efficiency of the Penrose process, defined as the fractional energy gain of the escaping particle relative to the initial energy, reaches approximately 20.7% for an extremal Kerr black hole (a = M).^[20] Astrophysically, the Penrose process and its wave analog, superradiance, have been proposed to explain the collimation and high-energy output of relativistic jets in quasars and active galactic nuclei, where rotational energy from supermassive black holes powers outflows.^[21] While the process has not been directly observed due to its microscopic scale and the challenges of particle splitting in strong gravity, indirect evidence arises from spin measurements of stellar-mass black holes in X-ray binaries, which confirm rapid rotation consistent with energy extraction mechanisms.^[22] Thermodynamically, each extraction event decreases the black hole's irreducible mass and angular momentum, aligning with the second law of black hole mechanics by increasing the total entropy outside the horizon, and it parallels the irreversible spin-down observed in accreting systems.^[23]

Quantum Field Theory

Vacuum Fluctuations and Virtual Particles

In quantum field theory, the vacuum is not a static void but a dynamic state characterized by fluctuations arising from the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. This principle, in its energy-time form, states that \Delta E \Delta t \geq \hbar / 2, permitting temporary violations of energy conservation where the energy uncertainty \Delta E allows for short-lived excitations with energies differing from the ground state.^[24] These vacuum fluctuations manifest as transient disturbances in quantum fields, enabling the brief existence of states with non-zero energy borrowed from the vacuum itself.^[25] Virtual particles emerge within this framework as off-shell excitations of quantum fields, representing intermediate states in perturbative calculations that do not satisfy the on-shell condition E^2 - p^2 c^2 = m^2 c^4. Typically conceptualized as particle-antiparticle pairs, these virtual entities "borrow" energy from the vacuum for durations constrained by the uncertainty principle, after which they annihilate to restore energy balance.^[26] In certain processes, such as interactions near strong gravitational fields, one member of the pair can be absorbed while carrying a negative energy relative to the observer's frame, effectively transferring negative energy to the absorbing system.^[27] The energy-time uncertainty extends to the stress-energy tensor T_{\mu\nu} in quantum field theory, where the vacuum expectation value \langle 0 | T_{00} | 0 \rangle—representing local energy density—can fluctuate to negative values over small spacetime regions due to quantum indeterminacy. Although the globally renormalized vacuum energy density averages to zero or a positive cosmological constant in flat spacetime, these local negative contributions arise from the operator nature of T_{00}, allowing probabilistic dips below zero in finite volumes.^[28] Direct measurement of these negative energy densities remains elusive, but their effects are inferred from phenomena like the dynamical Casimir effect, where rapid changes in boundary conditions amplify vacuum fluctuations into detectable real photons.^[29] Similarly, virtual pair separation near event horizons contributes to particle creation, as seen in Hawking radiation, where the negative-energy partner falls inward, reducing the black hole's mass.^[27] To prevent unphysical divergences, such as infinite negative energies enabling arbitrary spacetime manipulations, quantum inequalities impose bounds on the integrated magnitude and duration of negative energy densities. Developed by Ford and Roman in the 1990s, these inequalities, derived from uncertainty principles applied to field propagators, ensure that the time-averaged energy density \int \langle T_{00} \rangle dt remains bounded below, limiting macroscopic effects from vacuum fluctuations.^[30] For instance, in flat spacetime, the inequalities scale as \langle T_{00} \rangle \gtrsim -\frac{\hbar}{c^4 t^4} for observation times t, constraining the feasibility of exotic structures reliant on sustained negative energy.^[31]

Casimir Effect

The Casimir effect manifests as an attractive force between two parallel, uncharged conducting plates separated by a small distance in a vacuum, arising from the suppression of certain electromagnetic vacuum fluctuation modes—specifically, virtual photons—permitted between the plates compared to the exterior space.^[32] This mode suppression reduces the zero-point energy density inside the cavity relative to the surrounding vacuum, resulting in a net negative pressure that draws the plates together.^[32] In Hendrik Casimir's original theoretical derivation, the vacuum energy density \rho between the plates at separation a is calculated using zeta-function regularization of the divergent mode sum, yielding

\rho = -\frac{\pi^2 \hbar c}{720 a^4}.

The corresponding attractive force F per unit area A follows from the derivative of the total energy with respect to separation,

\frac{F}{A} = -\frac{\pi^2 \hbar c}{240 a^4}.

These expressions highlight the inverse-fourth-power dependence on separation, characteristic of the quantum vacuum origin.^[32] The first experimental confirmation came in 1958 from Marcus Sparnaay, who measured forces between parallel plates using a spring-balance setup and obtained qualitative agreement with theory, though with uncertainties around 15% due to challenges in controlling surface roughness and electrostatic effects.^[33] A landmark precise verification occurred in 1997 by Steve Lamoreaux, employing a torsion pendulum with a spherical plate and flat surface to measure the force over separations from 0.6 to 6 \mum, achieving agreement with the predicted magnitude to within 5% after corrections for edge effects and thermal contributions. The Casimir energy \Delta E for plates of area A represents a negative shift in vacuum energy,

\Delta E = -\frac{\pi^2 \hbar c A}{720 a^3},

which implies a localized negative energy density that violates classical energy conditions, such as the weak and strong energy conditions in general relativity, though quantum inequalities impose bounds preventing unbounded violations.^[32] An extension to the static case is the dynamical Casimir effect, where accelerating boundaries—simulating moving plates—convert virtual photons into real ones; this was experimentally observed in 2011 by Christopher Wilson and colleagues using a superconducting circuit with a rapidly modulated boundary condition at microwave frequencies, producing photon pairs in agreement with theory.

Squeezed States of Light

In quantum optics, squeezed states of light represent quantum states of the electromagnetic field where the uncertainty in one quadrature (such as amplitude or phase) is reduced below the vacuum level, while the uncertainty in the conjugate quadrature increases to satisfy the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.^[34] Specifically, for a quadrature operator X, the variance satisfies \Delta X < 1/2, implying \Delta P > 1/2 for the conjugate P, where the vacuum state has \Delta X = \Delta P = 1/2. This squeezing enables local regions of negative energy density in the field, as the expectation value of the photon number operator \langle a^\dagger a \rangle can effectively lead to sub-vacuum fluctuations in certain components, resulting in negative local values for the energy density operator.^[35] The squeezed vacuum state is formally defined as |\xi\rangle = S(\xi)|0\rangle, where |0\rangle is the vacuum state and the squeeze operator is S(\xi) = \exp\left[\frac{1}{2}(\xi^* a^2 - \xi (a^\dagger)^2)\right], with \xi = r e^{i\theta} parameterizing the squeezing strength r and phase \theta. In this state, the electromagnetic field exhibits an oscillating energy flux, with alternating regions of positive and negative energy density \langle T_{00} \rangle < 0, where T_{00} is the time-time component of the stress-energy tensor.^[35] This negative energy arises from the correlated creation and annihilation of photon pairs, suppressing vacuum fluctuations in one quadrature at the expense of the other.^[36] Squeezed states are generated through nonlinear optical processes, such as parametric down-conversion in a nonlinear crystal, where a pump photon splits into signal and idler photons, or via cavity squeezing using four-wave mixing in atomic vapors.^[37] The first experimental observation of squeezing was achieved in 1985 using four-wave mixing in an optical cavity with sodium atoms, demonstrating noise reduction below the quantum limit.^[38] Subsequent experiments employed degenerate parametric down-conversion in optical parametric oscillators, achieving greater than 50% noise reduction in the squeezed quadrature.^[37] The negative energy density in these states has been inferred through homodyne detection, which measures the quadrature variances and confirms the sub-vacuum fluctuations consistent with \langle T_{00} \rangle < 0. These states have practical applications in precision measurement, notably enhancing the sensitivity of gravitational wave detectors like Advanced LIGO, where frequency-dependent squeezing reduces quantum noise in the detection band. Since the O3 observing run in 2019, the Advanced LIGO detectors have implemented squeezed vacuum injection, improving strain sensitivity by up to 3 dB. Further enhancements came with frequency-dependent squeezing during the O4 run (2023–ongoing) as part of the A+ upgrade, using a 300-meter filter cavity to reduce quantum noise below the standard quantum limit by up to 3 dB in the 35–75 Hz band, enabling detection of fainter gravitational wave signals.^[39]^[40] However, the magnitude and duration of negative energy densities are constrained by quantum inequalities, which prevent unbounded violations of energy conditions; for squeezed light, these bounds limit the integrated negative energy along null geodesics to finite values, ensuring consistency with semiclassical general relativity.^[41]

Dirac Sea Model

The Dirac equation, formulated by Paul Dirac in 1928, is a relativistic wave equation that successfully incorporates both quantum mechanics and special relativity for electrons. The equation is given by

(i \gamma^\mu \partial_\mu - m) \psi = 0,

where \gamma^\mu are the Dirac matrices, \partial_\mu is the four-gradient, m is the electron mass, and \psi is a four-component spinor wave function.^[42] For free-particle plane-wave solutions, the energy eigenvalues are E = \pm \sqrt{\mathbf{p}^2 + m^2}, yielding both positive-energy solutions corresponding to electrons and negative-energy solutions that posed interpretational challenges, as they implied particles with negative kinetic energy and potential instabilities.^[42] To resolve these issues and avoid negative probabilities in the quantum mechanical interpretation, Dirac proposed the "sea" model in 1930, envisioning the vacuum as an infinite sea of electrons occupying all negative-energy states, fully filled due to the Pauli exclusion principle for fermions.^[43] In this picture, excitations above the sea represent ordinary electrons, while absences or "holes" in the sea—created by promoting a negative-energy electron to positive energy—manifest as particles with positive charge, opposite spin, and the same mass as electrons, which Dirac initially associated with protons but later reinterpreted as a new type of particle.^[43] This hole theory provided a physical mechanism for the negative-energy states without violating causality or probability conservation. Despite its ingenuity, the Dirac sea model suffered from fundamental problems, including an infinite negative charge and energy density in the vacuum due to the uncountable negative-energy electrons, which complicated coupling to electromagnetic fields and led to unphysical divergences. These issues were resolved in the 1930s and 1940s through the development of quantum field theory (QFT) via second quantization, where the Dirac field is treated as an operator that creates and annihilates electrons and positrons relative to a neutral vacuum state, eliminating the need for a filled sea and incorporating renormalization to handle infinities. The model's legacy endures in its prediction of antimatter, directly influencing Carl Anderson's 1932 experimental discovery of the positron as the electron's antiparticle, confirming Dirac's vision and paving the way for quantum electrodynamics. The plane-wave solutions and structure of the Dirac equation remain foundational for describing relativistic fermions. In modern physics, the Dirac sea is considered superseded by QFT's particle-antiparticle formalism, though it retains conceptual analogy to the Fermi sea in condensed matter physics, where filled states below the Fermi level mimic the saturated negative-energy vacuum.^[44]

Quantum Gravity Effects

Hawking Radiation

Hawking radiation is a theoretical prediction that black holes emit thermal radiation due to quantum effects near their event horizons, leading to a gradual loss of mass and energy. In this semiclassical process, quantum vacuum fluctuations produce particle-antiparticle pairs close to the horizon; the particle with negative energy relative to an observer at infinity can fall into the black hole, while its positive-energy counterpart escapes as radiation, effectively reducing the black hole's mass. This mechanism arises from the mismatch between the quantum vacuum states far from and near the black hole, allowing the black hole to absorb negative-energy particles without violating energy conservation.^[45] The rigorous derivation of Hawking radiation employs Bogoliubov transformations to relate the quantum field modes in the "in" vacuum (before the black hole forms) to the "out" vacuum (observed at infinity after formation), revealing particle creation as a consequence of the curved spacetime geometry. These transformations mix positive and negative frequency modes, resulting in a thermal spectrum for the emitted radiation. The black hole's effective temperature is given by

T = \frac{\hbar c^3}{8\pi G M k_B},

where M is the black hole mass, \hbar is the reduced Planck constant, c is the speed of light, G is the gravitational constant, and k_B is Boltzmann's constant; this temperature decreases inversely with mass, making smaller black holes "hotter" and more luminous. The luminosity scales as L \propto 1/M^2, reflecting the rapid emission from low-mass black holes compared to their stellar counterparts.^[45]^[46] The radiation spectrum approximates a blackbody distribution at temperature T, but includes greybody corrections due to scattering by the spacetime geometry outside the horizon, which suppress low-frequency modes while allowing higher ones to escape more freely. The total power radiated, accounting for these effects in the scalar field approximation, is

P = \frac{\hbar c^6}{15360 \pi G^2 M^2}.

This emission implies that black holes evaporate over a timescale \tau \propto M^3, with solar-mass black holes persisting for times far exceeding the universe's age, while primordial black holes of asteroid mass could evaporate detectably today. A key implication is the black hole information paradox, first highlighted in the 1970s, where the thermal nature of the radiation appears to destroy quantum information about infalling matter, conflicting with unitarity in quantum mechanics; this puzzle remains unresolved despite ongoing theoretical efforts.^[45] Direct observation of Hawking radiation from astrophysical black holes is infeasible, as the flux is exponentially suppressed for stellar-mass objects and overwhelmed by cosmic microwave background radiation. However, laboratory analogs using sonic black holes in Bose-Einstein condensates or fluids have simulated the effect since the 2000s, observing correlated Hawking-like pairs and stimulated emission consistent with the predicted thermal spectrum in controlled, low-temperature environments.^[47]

Negative Energy in Quantum Gravity Theories

In quantum gravity theories, semiclassical approximations, such as those used to describe Hawking radiation as a precursor to full quantum effects, encounter significant challenges at the Planck scale, where quantum fluctuations dominate and classical notions of energy break down.^[48] These limitations arise because negative energy densities, while permissible in quantum field theory, can violate the averaged null energy condition (ANEC), which requires non-negative energy along null geodesics, potentially leading to instabilities or unphysical spacetimes in gravitational contexts.^[49] Such violations highlight the need for a complete quantum gravity framework to reconcile these phenomena without invoking ad hoc restrictions.^[50] In loop quantum gravity (LQG), the discrete nature of spacetime at the Planck scale introduces modifications that may accommodate negative curvature contributions, effectively allowing negative energy densities in cosmological bounce models to resolve singularities.^[51] These bounces replace the Big Bang with a contracting-to-expanding transition, where quantum corrections to the Hamiltonian yield a negative definite quadratic term in the effective energy density when it approaches a critical Planckian value, preventing collapse without classical divergences.^[51] While no explicit formula for negative energy propagation exists in full LQG, these effective descriptions suggest that quantized geometry inherently bounds and stabilizes such contributions.^[52] String theory addresses negative energy through tachyonic states, which exhibit negative mass-squared and signal instabilities in higher-dimensional vacua, but tachyon condensation mechanisms stabilize them by rolling to a true vacuum with vanishing negative energy.^[53] In brane-world scenarios within string theory, negative tension branes (or orientifolds) balance positive tension D-branes, enabling warped geometries that resolve the hierarchy problem while maintaining overall positive energy, as required for consistency.^[54] These negative tension objects, arising from string dualities, do not propagate freely but contribute to localized gravitational effects without global instabilities.^[55] Recent developments, particularly in the 2010s, leverage the AdS/CFT correspondence to probe negative energy fluxes in holographic dualities, where bulk gravitational solutions with negative energy correspond to boundary conformal field theory states violating classical energy conditions but respecting quantum bounds.^[56] For instance, fluctuations in anti-de Sitter space can produce negative energy fluxes that test causality in the dual field theory, providing insights into how quantum gravity evades ANEC violations through nonlocal effects.^[56] Complementing this, Christopher Fewster's work in the 2000s established quantum inequalities in curved spacetimes, deriving state-independent lower bounds on energy density averages for scalar and spinor fields, which constrain negative energy magnitudes and ensure stability in quantum gravity regimes.^[57] These inequalities, extended to four-dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetimes, confirm that negative energies are transient and sampling-time dependent, aligning with holographic expectations up to 2025 analyses.^[57]

Speculative and Applied Concepts

Exotic Matter for Wormholes

In general relativity, traversable wormholes require exotic matter to prevent collapse at the throat, where the geometry connects distant regions of spacetime. The seminal Morris-Thorne metric, proposed in 1988, provides a static, spherically symmetric framework for such structures with the line element

ds^2 = -e^{2\Phi(r)} dt^2 + \frac{dr^2}{1 - b(r)/r} + r^2 d\Omega^2,

where \Phi(r) is the redshift function ensuring finite proper distance, and b(r) is the shape function satisfying b(r_0) = r_0 at the throat radius r_0 to maintain flaring-out. For stability at the throat, the Einstein field equations demand that the energy density \rho and radial pressure p_r satisfy \rho + p_r < 0, indicating a negative stress-energy contribution that threads the wormhole. This condition explicitly violates the null energy condition (NEC), \rho + p \geq 0, which holds for all known classical matter and is essential for the stability of most relativistic structures. Quantum field theory offers potential sources of negative energy, such as the Casimir effect between conducting plates, which generates a localized negative energy density due to vacuum fluctuations. However, quantum inequalities limit the magnitude and duration of such negative energy, rendering the Casimir contribution insufficient to support a macroscopic wormhole throat against gravitational collapse.^[58] To explore stability, thin-shell wormholes construct the geometry by surgically joining two spacetime regions at a hypersurface, concentrating exotic matter on the shell. In a 1995 analysis, linear perturbations around static thin-shell configurations in asymptotically flat spacetimes were examined, revealing that stability requires the surface energy density to decrease appropriately with radius, but the NEC violation persists as a fundamental necessity.^[59] Despite these theoretical constructs, no laboratory realization of wormholes exists, remaining confined to mathematical models; numerical simulations in the 2020s, incorporating backreaction and perturbations, demonstrate that wormhole geometries rapidly destabilize into black holes or singularities without exquisite fine-tuning of the exotic matter distribution. Alternatives invoking positive energy densities in higher-dimensional theories, such as braneworld scenarios, can evade the NEC in effective four-dimensional descriptions by leveraging bulk contributions. Nonetheless, the core requirement for negative stress-energy to prop open traversable wormholes in standard general relativity endures, underscoring the speculative nature of these constructs.

Alcubierre Warp Drive

The Alcubierre warp drive, proposed by physicist Miguel Alcubierre in 1994, describes a spacetime geometry that enables effective superluminal travel by contracting space ahead of a spacecraft and expanding it behind, while the ship remains at rest within a localized "warp bubble." This configuration allows the bubble to move at arbitrary speeds v_s > c relative to distant observers, without the spacecraft locally exceeding the speed of light. The metric is given by

ds^2 = -dt^2 + [dx - v_s f(r_s) \, dt]^2 + dy^2 + dz^2,

where v_s(t) is the bubble's velocity, r_s(t) = \sqrt{(x - x_s(t))^2 + y^2 + z^2} is the distance from the ship's trajectory, and f(r_s) is a shape function that equals 1 inside the bubble (radius R) and 0 outside, typically defined using hyperbolic tangents with wall thickness parameter \sigma.^[60] The metric requires negative energy density to sustain the warp bubble, as the stress-energy tensor component T_{00} must satisfy a volume integral less than zero in the bubble walls. The energy density is approximately \rho \approx - \frac{v_s^2 \sigma^2}{8\pi G} (in units where c=1), concentrated in a thin shell where the shape function transitions. This negative energy violates classical energy conditions like the weak energy condition, necessitating exotic matter not observed in nature. Initial calculations indicated enormous requirements, equivalent to a significant fraction of the observable universe's mass-energy for a macroscopic bubble at modest superluminal speeds.^[61]^[60] Subsequent modifications addressed the energy scale. In a 1999 variant by Chris van den Broeck, introducing a lapse function and nested geometries reduced the total negative energy to about one solar mass, though still immense. Further refinements by Harold White in 2012, reshaping the bubble to a toroidal profile, lowered estimates to the equivalent of a small spacecraft like Voyager 1 (around 700 kg in negative energy). However, these designs introduce event horizons within and around the bubble, creating causality issues: particles or signals ahead of the bubble cannot enter it, and rear horizons trap matter, potentially leading to particle pile-up or closed timelike curves if multiple bubbles interact, though single-bubble travel avoids direct chronology violation.^[62]^[63] As of 2025, NASA’s Eagleworks Laboratories has explored experimental analogs using quantum optical setups and interferometers to detect minute warp-like spacetime distortions, but no macroscopic effects have been achieved, and quantum inequalities—bounds on negative energy duration and magnitude from quantum field theory—severely limit practicality, allowing only fleeting, submicroscopic violations insufficient for propulsion. Unlike wormhole stabilization, which connects distant points, the Alcubierre drive focuses on local bubble propulsion for direct travel. More recent theoretical models, developed in 2024–2025, propose warp drive configurations that do not require negative energy, relying instead on positive energy densities to form the bubble, though they necessitate energy equivalents to several Jupiter masses for practical scales.^[64]^[65]^[66]

Hypothetical Negative-Energy Particles

In quantum field theory, relativistic wave equations such as the Dirac equation yield solutions with negative energy eigenvalues, which are reinterpreted as positive-energy antiparticles to maintain vacuum stability and bound the energy spectrum from below.^[67] This reinterpretation, central to the second quantization formalism, avoids the instabilities associated with genuine negative-energy states by treating them as backward-propagating positive-energy particles.^[68] Hypothetical particles with intrinsically negative energy, however, would destabilize the theory, permitting runaway processes like infinite energy extraction from the vacuum through repeated pair production, unless prohibited by additional symmetries or constraints.^[69] Theoretical proposals for such particles include tachyons, first posited by Gerald Feinberg in 1967 as quanta of a scalar field with negative mass squared, leading to superluminal propagation and, in interacting theories, the emergence of negative-energy modes required by Lorentz invariance.^[70]^[71] Another class involves ghost fields, which appear in certain quantum field theories—such as those with higher-derivative terms in gravity—and possess a wrong-sign kinetic term, resulting in negative energy and probabilistic norms that undermine unitarity.^[72] These ghosts are often auxiliary constructs to maintain gauge invariance but highlight the challenges of incorporating negative energies without theoretical pathologies. Efforts to formulate Dirac-like equations that permit negative-energy solutions without relying on the historical Dirac sea—a filled vacuum model now superseded by field-theoretic interpretations—have explored modified Hamiltonians or projection operators to isolate such states. However, these approaches risk introducing inconsistencies, such as non-Hermitian operators leading to acausal propagation or vacuum instabilities, necessitating ad hoc prohibitions on low-energy excitations to preserve consistency.^[73] Experimental searches for negative-energy particles, particularly tachyons, have yielded no evidence. Experimental searches for tachyons at high-energy colliders like the Large Hadron Collider, operating up to 13.6 TeV in Run 3 through 2025, have yielded no evidence of their production. Cosmological constraints are equally stringent; for example, tachyonic neutrinos with speeds exceeding light are ruled out by big bang nucleosynthesis, as they would disrupt helium-4 yields by more than 0.1%, inconsistent with observed abundances.^[74] Similarly, cosmological observations, including cosmic microwave background anisotropies, bound tachyon dark matter densities to less than 1% of the total energy budget.^[75] Speculatively, negative-energy particles could facilitate faster-than-light signaling, raising causality violations akin to the tachyonic antitelephone paradox, though such scenarios inevitably conflict with unitarity and the principles of local quantum field theory.^[70] Their potential roles in applications, such as providing the negative energy density for warp drive metrics, remain exploratory and unviable without resolving fundamental inconsistencies. The Dirac sea model, as a historical analog, illustrated early attempts to stabilize negative energies by positing a filled continuum, but it has been supplanted by antiparticle reinterpretations in modern theory.^[67]

References

[1]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0911.3597.pdf
[2]
[PDF] Negative Mass in Contemporary Physics, and its Application to ...
While negative energy has moved from a theoretical curiosity to a concept fundamental to the contemporary understanding of physics, it is still not clear ...
[3]
[0911.3597] Negative Energy Densities in Quantum Field Theory
Nov 18, 2009 · Abstract: Quantum field theory allows for the suppression of vacuum fluctuations, leading to sub-vacuum phenomena.
[4]
Gravitational Potential Energy - HyperPhysics
Gravitational potential energy is energy an object possesses because of its position in a gravitational field.
[5]
Extracting black-hole rotational energy: The generalized Penrose ...
Oct 28, 2013 · The necessary and sufficient condition for the Penrose process to extract energy from a rotating black hole is absorption of particles with negative energies ...
[6]
[hep-th/9811081] The Physics of Negative Energy Densities - arXiv
Nov 9, 1998 · Abstract: I review some recent results showing that the physics of negative energy densities, as predicted by relativistic quantum field ...
[7]
[1608.01531] Negative-Energy Matter and the Direction of Time - arXiv
Jun 17, 2016 · This report offers a modern perspective on the problem of negative energy, based on a reexamination of the concept of time direction as it ...
[8]
[PDF] Kinetic theory of self-gravitating systems
So we argue this term is negligible and conclude that 2K + W = 0, where. K ... 2K ∼ Mσ2, so the virial theorem yields σ2 ∼. GM. 2R . (1.7). Putting in ...
[9]
[PDF] 8. Galactic Dynamics Aim: Understand equilibrium of galaxies
8.5 Binding Energy and Formation of. Galaxies. The total energy E of a galaxy is. E = K + W = −K = 1/2W. • Bound galaxies have negative energy - cannot fall ...
[10]
https://www.nature.com/articles/157851a0
[11]
[PDF] Gravitational energy in stationary spacetimes - arXiv
Oct 11, 2006 · We show that EG is indeed negative for static and some stationary systems. 3A typical example is the binding energy of Einstein's spherical ...
[12]
4. Gravitation - Lecture Notes on General Relativity - S. Carroll
Its mass is actually less than the sum of the masses of the proton and electron considered individually, because there is a negative binding energy - you have ...<|separator|>
[13]
WMAP- Fate of the Universe
Feb 20, 2024 · Unlike gravity which works to slow the expansion down, dark energy works to speed the expansion up. If dark energy in fact plays a significant ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[14]
[PDF] The Kerr spacetime: A brief introduction - arXiv
Jan 15, 2008 · Abstract. This chapter provides a brief introduction to the mathematics and physics of the Kerr spacetime and rotating black holes, touching on.
[15]
[PDF] Gravitational Collapse: the Role of General Relativity - UMD Physics
PENROSE: in Battelle Rencontres (ed. C. M. DE WITT and J. A. WHEELER) ... RIVISTA DEL NUOVO CIMENTO. VOLUME I. [32] I. ROBINSON and A. TRAUTMAN: Proc ...Missing: DOI | Show results with:DOI
[16]
[PDF] 1986ApJ. . .307. . .38P The Astrophysical Journal, 307:38-46,1986 ...
*7max ~ 20.7% for the pure extreme Kerr case, that is, in the absence of electromagnetic fields (Chandrasekhar 1983). ... HIGH EFFICIENCY OF PENROSE PROCESS 45.
[17]
Penrose Process: Its Variants and Astrophysical Applications - MDPI
Jul 11, 1997 · We present a review of the Penrose process and its modifications in relation to the Kerr black holes and naked singularities (superspinars).Penrose Process: Its... · 2. Kerr Black Holes And The... · 2.3. The Penrose Process
[18]
The Penrose process, superradiance and ergoregion instabilities
Mar 21, 2018 · We show that superradiant, ergoregion instabilities have a particle analog of similar growth timescales and which can power the formation of a structure ...
[19]
Extraction of Rotational Energy from a Black Hole - Nature
Feb 8, 1971 · Extraction of Rotational Energy from a Black Hole. R. PENROSE &; R. M. FLOYD. Nature Physical Science volume 229, pages 177–179 (1971)Cite ...
[20]
Quantum Fluctuations and Their Energy - Matt Strassler
Aug 29, 2013 · In this article I am going to tell you something about how quantum mechanics works, specifically the fascinating phenomenon known as “quantum fluctuations”.
[21]
Quantum Field Theory - Universe Review
All the quantum numbers of the initial particles disappear by cancellation. The energy is then free to sample the hidden, negative-energy content of the vacuum ...
[22]
Virtual Particles: What are they? - Matt Strassler
“Virtual particles are part of the imagery of quantum field theory. They are figurative language for abstract mathematics, used by experts and laymen as ...
[23]
Hawking Radiation - Physics LibreTexts
Dec 30, 2020 · The vacuum in quantum field theory is not really empty; it's filled with "virtual pairs" of particles and antiparticles that pop in and out ...
[24]
Fermionic condensate and the vacuum energy-momentum tensor for ...
Jun 28, 2024 · The emergence of negative energy density in a quantum field theory is very legitimate. The renormalized energy density of a quantized field ...
[25]
[1006.4790] Fluctuations, dissipation and the dynamical Casimir effect
Jun 24, 2010 · Vacuum fluctuations provide a fundamental source of dissipation for systems coupled to quantum fields by radiation pressure. In the dynamical ...
[26]
Averaged Energy Conditions and Quantum Inequalities - gr-qc - arXiv
Oct 29, 1994 · Connections are uncovered between the averaged weak (AWEC) and averaged null (ANEC) energy conditions, and quantum inequality restrictions on negative energy.
[27]
Quantum inequalities and singular negative energy densities
There has been much recent work on quantum inequalities to constrain negative energy. These are uncertainty-principle-type restrictions on ...
[28]
[PDF] Casimir1948.pdf - MIT
Hendrik Casimir, On the attraction between two perfectly conducting plates. (reprint from Proceedings 51, (1948), 793-795), in: Gems from a century of ...Missing: effect | Show results with:effect
[29]
Measurements of attractive forces between flat plates - ScienceDirect
We provide a review of both new experimental and theoretical developments in the Casimir effect. The Casimir effect results from the alteration by the ...
[30]
Quantum-mechanical noise in an interferometer | Phys. Rev. D
Apr 15, 1981 · This paper presents an analysis of the two types of quantum-mechanical noise, and it proposes a new technique—the "squeezed-state" technique ...Missing: optics | Show results with:optics
[31]
Lorentzian wormholes from the gravitationally squeezed vacuum
Lorentzian wormholes from the gravitationally squeezed vacuum. Author links ... The matter vacuum is automatically squeezed as a result of the gravitational ...Missing: density | Show results with:density
[32]
Negative energy density in superposition and entangled states
Feb 13, 2008 · Although here the superposition state does have negative energy density, it is somewhat less negative than in the case of a single squeezed ...
[33]
Generation of Squeezed States by Parametric Down Conversion
Nov 17, 1986 · Squeezed states of the electromagnetic field are generated by degenerate parametric down conversion in an optical cavity.
[34]
Observation of Squeezed States Generated by Four-Wave Mixing in ...
Nov 25, 1985 · Squeezed states of the electromagnetic field have been generated by nondegenerate four-wave mixing due to Na atoms in an optical cavity.
[35]
Quantum-Enhanced Advanced LIGO Detectors in the Era of ...
Dec 5, 2019 · Figure 2 shows the optical and electronic setup for generating and controlling squeezed light. The central component is a subthreshold OPO, a ...Abstract · Article Text
[36]
[1806.01269] Testing a Quantum Inequality with a Meta-analysis of ...
Jun 3, 2018 · Quantum Inequalities (QIs) have been proposed that restrict the size and duration of the regions of negative quantum vacuum energy that can be ...
[37]
The quantum theory of the electron - Journals
Wu S (2025) Exact solutions of Dirac equation for hydrogen atom using the linear combination of orthogonal Laguerre basis functions, Scientific Reports ...
[38]
A theory of electrons and protons | Proceedings of the Royal Society ...
Cite this article. Dirac Paul Adrien Maurice. 1930A theory of electrons and protonsProc. R. Soc. Lond. A126360–365http://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1930.0013 ...
[39]
[PDF] Volovik, G. E. Dirac and Weyl fermions - Aalto Research Portal
Feb 17, 2017 · In this approach the Fermi sea serves as an analog of the relativistic quantum vacuum – the Dirac sea. The Gor'kov theory of superconductivity1 ...
[40]
Particle creation by black holes | Communications in Mathematical ...
It is shown that quantum mechanical effects cause black holes to create and emit particles as if they were hot bodies with temperature.
[41]
Hawking Radiation
The usual computation involves Bogoliubov transformations. The idea is that when you quantize (say) the electromagnetic field you take solutions of the ...
[42]
Hawking Radiation in Sonic Black Holes | Phys. Rev. Lett.
Feb 18, 2005 · A one-dimensional Fermi-degenerate liquid squeezed by a smooth barrier forms a transonic flow, a sonic analog of a black hole. The quantum ...Article Text · Introduction. · Part I. Microscopic description. · Conclusion.
[43]
[PDF] Energy conditions in semiclassical and quantum gravity
Oct 2, 2020 · We explore the state of energy conditions in semiclassical and quantum gravity. Our review introduces energy conditions with a philosophical ...
[44]
[gr-qc/9602052] Does backreaction enforce the averaged null ... - arXiv
Feb 27, 1996 · We find that although the ANEC integral can be negative, if we average the ANEC integral transverse to the geodesic with a suitable Planck scale ...
[45]
Does back reaction enforce the averaged null energy condition in ...
Nov 15, 1996 · Most prominent among these nonlocal conditions is the averaged null energy condition (ANEC), which states that ∫ 〈 T a b 〉 ⁢ k a ⁢ k b d 𝜆 > ~ ...
[46]
[PDF] Nonsingular bouncing universes in loop quantum cosmology
Aug 18, 2006 · The quadratic term is negative definite and can lead to generic bounces when the matter energy density becomes equal to a critical value of the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[47]
Gravitational collapse in effective loop quantum gravity - arXiv
Apr 5, 2024 · We study gravitational collapse in effective loop quantum gravity, focusing on non-marginally bound configurations in Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi ...
[48]
[PDF] Tachyon Condensation in Unstable Type I D-brane Systems - arXiv
Type I string theory provides eight classes of unstable D-brane systems. We determine the gauge group and tachyon spectrum for each one, ...
[49]
Stringy negative-tension branes and the second law ... - IOP Science
The negative energy objects that arise in string theory involve special boundary conditions which remove the perturbative instabilities. We show that they ...
[50]
Gauss-Bonnet gravity renders negative tension braneworlds unstable
Nov 10, 2004 · Interestingly, any realization of such a geometrical hierarchy in string theory seems to also require the presence of negative tension objects
[51]
https://repository.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6167&context=physics_astronomy_pubs
[52]
Absolute quantum energy inequalities in curved spacetime - arXiv
Feb 9, 2007 · In this paper we obtain the first absolute QEI for the minimally-coupled massive quantum Klein--Gordon field on four dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetimes.Missing: 2000s | Show results with:2000s
[53]
Natural Inflation and Quantum Gravity | Phys. Rev. Lett.
There are, broadly, two approaches to addressing such QG uncertainties in high-scale inflation models. One is to derive inflationary models directly within ...
[54]
Quantum Gravity and Inflation as an Open System: A New Paradigm
Sep 23, 2025 · If we could find an inflationary model consistent with observations and derived from a theory of quantum gravity, we would move closer to a ...
[55]
Noncommutative-geometry wormholes based on the Casimir effect
Feb 4, 2023 · The Casimir effect does not, however, guarantee that the small-scale violation is sufficient for supporting a macroscopic wormhole.
[56]
[gr-qc/9506083] Thin-shell wormholes: Linearization stability - arXiv
Jun 30, 1995 · View a PDF of the paper titled Thin-shell wormholes: Linearization stability, by Eric Poisson and Matt Visser (Washington University). View ...
[57]
The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity - IOPscience
The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity. Miguel Alcubierre. Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd Classical and Quantum Gravity, ...
[58]
The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity - gr-qc - arXiv
Sep 5, 2000 · 11:L73-L77,1994 ... Access Paper: View a PDF of the paper titled The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity, by Miguel Alcubierre.
[59]
A `warp drive' with more reasonable total energy requirements - arXiv
May 21, 1999 · A minor modification of the Alcubierre geometry can dramatically improve the total energy requirements for a warp bubble that can be used to transport ...Missing: reduction 2001
[60]
[PDF] Warp Field Mechanics 101 - NASA Technical Reports Server (NTRS)
This paper will begin with a short review of the Alcubierre warp drive metric and describes how the phenomenon might work based on the original paper.
[61]
[gr-qc/9702026] The unphysical nature of "Warp Drive" - arXiv
Mar 15, 2001 · We will apply the quantum inequality type restrictions to Alcubierre's warp drive metric on a scale in which a local region of spacetime can be considered flat.
[62]
[PDF] Eagleworks Laboratories - WARP FIELD PHYSICS
Harold “Sonny” White. NASA JSC. Picture courtesy of NASA, http://www.nasa.gov ... Alcubierre, M., “The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity,”.
[63]
[PDF] Relativistic Quantum Mechanics • Klein-Gordon Equation - UF Physics
The solutions for particles with negative energies are reinterpreted as anti-particles with positive energy… All the “truly” elementary particles and “ ...
[64]
[PDF] ccsd-00001476, version 6 - 31 Mar 2005 - HAL
However, these antiparticles have nothing to do with genuine negative energy states propagating forward in time, whose quanta are by construction of the ...Missing: reinterpreted | Show results with:reinterpreted
[65]
[PDF] Negative Energies and Time Reversal in Quantum Field Theory
Jan 18, 2019 · The theoretical and phenomenological status of negative energies is reviewed in Quantum Field Theory leading to the conclusion that hope- fully ...Missing: hypothetical | Show results with:hypothetical
[66]
Possibility of Faster-Than-Light Particles | Phys. Rev.
A quantum field theory of noninteracting, spinless, faster-than-light particles is described. The field theory is Lorentz-invariant, but must be quantized with ...
[67]
Quantum Field Theory of Interacting Tachyons | Phys. Rev.
A new feature of theory is the occurrence of negative-energy particles; this is a necessary consequence of the relativistic invariance of the theory, since the ...
[68]
High Energy Physics – Theory Making sense of ghosts
We discuss how difficulties associated with ghosts are overcome in the context of 0+1d QFT. Obtaining a probability interpretation is the key issue.
[69]
[PDF] Negative Energies in the Dirac equation - HAL
It is easy to check that both algebraic equation Det(p − m)=0 and Det(p + m) = 0 for u− and v− 4-spinors have solutions with p0 = ±Ep = ±pp2 + m2.
[70]
[2204.12017] A Review of Searches for Evidence of Tachyons - arXiv
Apr 26, 2022 · Here we review empirical evidence for the possible existence of tachyons, superluminal particles having m^2 < 0.
[71]
[1201.3284] Cosmological bounds on tachyonic neutrinos - arXiv
Jan 16, 2012 · 32\times 10^{-5} in units where c=1. We show that cosmological bounds rule out an explanation involving a Lorentz invariant tachyonic neutrino.
[72]
Cosmological bounds on tachyonic neutrinos - NASA ADS
We show that cosmological bounds rule out an explanation involving a Lorentz invariant tachyonic neutrino. At the OPERA energy scale, nucleosynthesis ...