Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Penrose process

The Penrose process is a theoretical mechanism proposed by British mathematical physicist Roger Penrose in 1969 for extracting rotational energy and angular momentum from a rotating black hole, specifically a Kerr black hole. It exploits the properties of the black hole's ergosphere, a region outside the event horizon where the spacetime is dragged along by the black hole's rotation, enabling the existence of particle trajectories with negative energy as measured by a distant observer.^[1] In this process, an incident particle enters the ergosphere and decays into two fragments: one fragment, carrying negative energy and angular momentum relative to infinity, falls into the black hole, thereby reducing the black hole's mass and spin, while the other fragment escapes to infinity with greater total energy than the incoming particle possessed.^[1] This energy extraction arises from the conservation of energy and angular momentum in the curved spacetime around the black hole, where the absorption of the negative-energy fragment effectively transfers a portion of the black hole's rotational energy outward.^[2] The maximum efficiency of the original particle-decay version is approximately 20.7% more than the total energy of the incoming particle for an extremal Kerr black hole (with spin parameter a = M), though practical implementation requires the fragments to achieve relativistic velocities exceeding half the speed of light, posing challenges for astrophysical scenarios. Penrose's proposal, initially sketched in a review on gravitational collapse and later detailed in collaboration with R. M. Floyd, demonstrated that up to 29% of a black hole's total mass-energy could theoretically be extractable as usable energy, far exceeding the efficiency limits of nuclear processes (around 0.7%).^[1] The Penrose process has profound implications for black hole thermodynamics and astrophysics, highlighting how rotating black holes are not eternal energy sinks but potential power sources that slow their spin over time.^[2] It inspired subsequent developments, including the Blandford-Znajek mechanism (1977), which extracts energy via magnetic field lines threading the ergosphere to power relativistic jets in active galactic nuclei and quasars. Variants such as the magnetic Penrose process, proposed in the 1980s, incorporate electromagnetic fields to accelerate charged particles, achieving efficiencies exceeding 100% under certain conditions (e.g., with milliGauss fields and relativistic electrons), and offering explanations for ultra-high-energy cosmic rays and gamma-ray bursts. While no direct observational confirmation exists as of 2025, the process remains a cornerstone of theoretical general relativity, influencing models of black hole accretion and evolution.

Theoretical Background

Kerr Black Holes

Black holes in general relativity are initially described by the Schwarzschild metric, which models non-rotating, uncharged, spherically symmetric objects with an event horizon at r = 2M, where M is the mass in geometric units (G = c = 1). This solution assumes zero angular momentum, leading to time-independent and static spacetime geometry outside the horizon. In contrast, the Kerr metric describes rotating black holes, incorporating the effects of angular momentum through the parameter a = J/M, where J is the angular momentum; for $0 < a < M, the black hole remains stable with a ring-like singularity, while a = 0 recovers the Schwarzschild case and a > M results in a naked singularity. The rotation introduces axial symmetry and frame-dragging, fundamentally altering the spacetime structure to allow phenomena not possible in non-rotating cases. The Kerr metric is most commonly expressed in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates (t, r, \theta, \phi), which generalize spherical coordinates to account for rotation. The line element is given by

ds^2 = -\left(1 - \frac{2Mr}{\rho^2}\right) dt^2 - \frac{4Mar \sin^2\theta}{\rho^2} dt d\phi + \frac{\rho^2}{\Delta} dr^2 + \rho^2 d\theta^2 + \frac{\sin^2\theta}{\rho^2} \left[ (r^2 + a^2)^2 - a^2 \Delta \sin^2\theta \right] d\phi^2,

where \rho^2 = r^2 + a^2 \cos^2\theta and \Delta = r^2 - 2Mr + a^2. These coordinates feature singularities at \rho = 0 (the ring singularity at r = 0, \theta = \pi/2) and where \Delta = 0, but the latter represents coordinate artifacts removable by transformation. The metric highlights off-diagonal terms like g_{t\phi}, reflecting the coupling between time and azimuthal directions due to rotation.^[3] The event horizons in the Kerr geometry are located at the roots of \Delta = 0, yielding an outer horizon at r_+ = M + \sqrt{M^2 - a^2} and an inner (Cauchy) horizon at r_- = M - \sqrt{M^2 - a^2} for a < M; the outer horizon is smaller than the Schwarzschild radius for a > 0, shrinking to r_+ = M at the extremal limit a = M. Unlike the Schwarzschild case, the horizons are oblate due to rotation. The physical implications of this rotation include the absence of static observers (those with fixed spatial coordinates) in certain regions outside the outer horizon, as the timelike Killing vector \partial_t becomes spacelike there, forcing all observers to co-rotate with the black hole and enabling energy extraction mechanisms. This region, known as the ergosphere, bounds the static limit where g_{tt} = 0.^[3]

Ergosphere and Frame-Dragging

The ergosphere is a distinctive region surrounding a rotating black hole described by the Kerr metric, forming an oblate spheroid where the metric coefficient g_{tt} > 0. This condition arises because the time-translation Killing vector becomes spacelike, preventing any observer from remaining at rest relative to asymptotic infinity. The outer boundary of the ergosphere is defined by the static limit, the surface where g_{tt} = 0, given in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates by r = M + \sqrt{M^2 - a^2 \cos^2 \theta}, where M is the black hole mass and a = J/M is the specific angular momentum (|a| \leq M). The inner boundary coincides with the event horizon at r = M + \sqrt{M^2 - a^2}, with the ergosphere vanishing on the rotation axis (\theta = 0, \pi) and reaching maximum extent in the equatorial plane (\theta = \pi/2), where the static limit is at r = 2M.^[4] The frame-dragging effect, known as the Lense-Thirring precession, manifests in the Kerr geometry as a compelled co-rotation of spacetime with the black hole's angular momentum, twisting inertial frames in the direction of the spin. This effect is quantified by the angular velocity of zero angular momentum observers (ZAMOs), who locally measure no vorticity and follow the local geometry without additional rotation: \Omega = \frac{2 M a r}{(r^2 + a^2)^2 - a^2 \Delta \sin^2 \theta}, where \Delta = r^2 - 2 M r + a^2. At the event horizon, this reduces to the black hole's angular velocity \Omega_H = \frac{a}{r_+^2 + a^2} = \frac{a}{2 M r_+}, with r_+ = M + \sqrt{M^2 - a^2}, decreasing monotonically outward. In the ergosphere, \Omega lies between 0 and \Omega_H, ensuring all objects are dragged prograde relative to the black hole's rotation.^[5]^[4] Within the ergosphere, no stationary observers can exist, as the positive g_{tt} implies that the norm of any timelike 4-velocity with zero spatial components would be spacelike, violating the timelike condition; consequently, all timelike geodesics are inevitably dragged in the direction of the black hole's rotation. This enforced motion arises directly from the frame-dragging, with the tilt of local light cones preventing counter-rotation. The ergoregion thus permits negative-energy states relative to infinity for observers or particles with angular momentum opposing the black hole's spin, as their conserved energy E = -u_t (with u_t > 0) can become negative while remaining positive locally. This feature underpins energy extraction mechanisms and enables superradiance, where incident waves with frequency \omega < m \Omega_H ( m the azimuthal mode number) are amplified by extracting rotational energy from the black hole.^[4]

The Process

Particle Trajectory in the Ergosphere

In the Penrose process, an incoming particle originating from spatial infinity with positive total energy E > 0 follows a geodesic path governed by the Kerr metric, allowing it to penetrate the ergosphere without violating the principles of general relativity. This trajectory is determined by the particle's initial four-momentum, which remains timelike outside the ergosphere but can exhibit unique behaviors inside due to the region's geometry. Upon entering the ergosphere—the oblate, spindle-shaped region bounded by the event horizon and the static limit—the particle can undergo a physical process such as radioactive decay or a collision with another particle, resulting in its division into two fragments. These fragments inherit portions of the original particle's energy and momentum, but their subsequent paths diverge based on the local spacetime curvature and frame-dragging effects. One fragment acquires sufficient energy to escape the gravitational pull, following an outgoing geodesic back to infinity with total energy E_{\text{out}} > E, thereby carrying away excess energy from the system. The other fragment, conversely, is directed inward, crossing the event horizon and accreting into the black hole. The overall process upholds conservation laws, as the total energy-momentum tensor remains conserved in the asymptotically flat spacetime of the Kerr geometry, balancing the extracted energy against the black hole's rotational reservoir. Qualitatively, diagrams of this trajectory illustrate the incoming particle's path curving into the ergosphere, where it splits at a critical point; the escaping fragment's trajectory bends outward, asymptotically approaching infinity, while the infalling one spirals toward the singularity, highlighting the directional asymmetry imposed by rotation.

Energy Extraction Mechanism

The rotational energy of a Kerr black hole is stored in its angular momentum, parameterized as J = a M, where M is the black hole's mass and a is the dimensionless spin parameter with |a| \leq M.^[6] This angular momentum represents a significant fraction of the black hole's total energy, up to approximately 29% of M c^2 for maximal spin, which can be extracted under specific conditions.^[7] In the ergosphere surrounding the event horizon, frame-dragging due to the black hole's rotation forces any particle to co-rotate with the spacetime, imparting angular momentum to the particle.^[6] This transfer reduces the black hole's total angular momentum J, thereby decreasing its rotational energy. In the standard Penrose process involving particle splitting, one fragment acquires additional angular momentum from this frame-dragging effect while entering a trajectory that allows the other fragment to escape.^[8] The escaping particle carries away more energy than the initial incoming particle possessed, as the infalling fragment possesses negative energy relative to an observer at infinity—though this energy remains positive relative to local stationary observers, such as those in locally non-rotating frames.^[6] This negative energy state, unique to the ergoregion, effectively subtracts from the black hole's energy when the fragment is absorbed.^[8] The net effect is a conversion of the black hole's rotational energy into the kinetic energy of the escaping particle, with the black hole's spin parameter a decreasing as a result. This mechanism is analogous to the gravitational slingshot effect used in spacecraft maneuvers around rotating bodies, but it uniquely relies on the availability of negative energy states in the ergosphere.^[9]

Mathematical Formulation

Negative Energy Orbits

In the Kerr spacetime, the conserved energy at infinity for a geodesic test particle of rest mass m is given by E = -u_t, where u^\mu denotes the particle's four-velocity. This quantity represents the energy measured by a distant observer and is constant along the geodesic due to the timelike Killing vector \partial_t. In Boyer-Lindquist coordinates, the Kerr metric yields the explicit form E = -g_{tt} \dot{t} - g_{t\phi} \dot{\phi}, where dots indicate derivatives with respect to proper time \tau, g_{tt} = -\left(1 - \frac{2Mr}{\Sigma}\right) with \Sigma = r^2 + a^2 \cos^2\theta, and g_{t\phi} = -\frac{2Mra \sin^2\theta}{\Sigma}. Within the ergosphere, where g_{tt} > 0 due to frame-dragging, negative E becomes feasible for particles satisfying \dot{\phi} < -\frac{g_{tt}}{g_{t\phi}} \dot{t}, as the negative g_{t\phi} term allows the angular contribution to overpower the temporal one when the particle counter-rotates relative to the black hole. The viability of negative-energy states requires specific conditions on the particle's conserved angular momentum L = u_\phi. Bounds arise from the effective potential governing radial motion, ensuring the existence of turning points within the ergosphere. These conditions ensure that geodesics with negative E can originate from particle decay and plunge toward the horizon without violating timelike normalization u^\mu u_\mu = -1. The permissible range for such negative energies is -\Omega_H m < E < 0, where \Omega_H = \frac{a}{2Mr_+}, r_+ = M + \sqrt{M^2 - a^2} is the outer horizon radius, M is the black hole mass, and a is its spin parameter. An infalling particle with E < 0 effectively reduces the black hole's irreducible mass by carrying negative energy across the horizon, thereby enabling rotational energy extraction.

Efficiency and Limits

The efficiency of the Penrose process is quantified by the fractional increase in energy carried away by the escaping particle relative to the rest mass energy of the incoming particle, which enters the ergosphere from infinity. For an extremal Kerr black hole with spin parameter a = M, detailed analysis of geodesic motion shows that the maximum efficiency reaches 20.7%, such that the outgoing particle's energy E_\text{out} satisfies E_\text{out}/m \approx 1.207, where m is the rest mass. This limit arises from optimizing the trajectory and decay point near the horizon, where the frame-dragging effect is strongest, allowing the trapped particle to carry away negative energy relative to infinity. A general approximation for near-extremal cases is E_\text{out}/m \approx 1 + \sqrt{1 - (2/3)(1 - a/M)^2}, highlighting how efficiency scales with the black hole's spin. The energy gain in a single Penrose process event is \Delta E = E_\text{out} - E_\text{in}, with E_\text{in} = m for an incoming particle at rest at infinity. The relative gain is bounded by \Delta E / E_\text{in} < (\Omega_r - \Omega_H)/(1 - \Omega_r), where \Omega_r is the angular velocity at the splitting radius in the ergosphere and \Omega_H = a/(2Mr_+) is the horizon angular velocity; this bound stems from the condition for the trapped particle to follow a negative-energy orbit, maximizing the energy transfer while conserving total energy and angular momentum. Over multiple extractions, the Penrose process can reduce the black hole's mass to its irreducible component, beyond which no further rotational energy can be extracted by classical means. The irreducible mass is M_\text{ir} = M \sqrt{(1 + \sqrt{1 - (a/M)^2})/2}, such that up to 29% of the initial mass M is extractable as rotational energy in the extremal limit. This overall limit underscores the process's potential to tap into the black hole's spin energy, though each individual extraction remains capped at the per-particle efficiency. The process becomes inefficient for low-spin black holes (a \ll M), as the ergosphere shrinks and frame-dragging weakens, minimizing the region where negative-energy orbits are possible and demanding highly precise incoming trajectories for viable splitting.

Historical Development

Original Proposal

The Penrose process was proposed by Roger Penrose in his 1969 review article on gravitational collapse.^[10] In this work, Penrose outlined a mechanism for extracting rotational energy from a rotating black hole, building on the earlier discovery of the Kerr metric describing such objects.^[11] The proposal emerged within a broader discussion of how general relativity governs the final stages of stellar collapse into black holes. Penrose's motivation stemmed from a desire to elucidate the physical implications of black holes under general relativity, particularly in relation to the emerging no-hair theorem, which posits that black holes are characterized solely by mass, charge, and angular momentum.^[12] He provided an initial qualitative description of the process: an incoming particle enters the ergosphere—a region outside the event horizon where frame-dragging forces objects to co-rotate with the black hole—and decays into two fragments.^[10] One fragment, possessing negative energy relative to an observer at infinity, falls into the black hole, thereby reducing the black hole's rotational energy, while the other escapes with greater energy than the original particle.^[11] This initial idea was quantitatively detailed in a 1971 paper co-authored with R. M. Floyd, calculating the maximum efficiency.^[1] This mechanism highlighted how rotation allows black holes to store and potentially release extractable energy, contrasting with non-rotating cases.^[13] The proposal was immediately recognized as a theoretical breakthrough, demonstrating a purely geometric pathway to access a black hole's rotational energy and linking it to fundamental properties of spacetime.^[14] It spurred subsequent developments in black hole physics, including connections to thermodynamics.^[12] Penrose's contributions to black hole theory, encompassing this process, were honored in the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics, awarded for his foundational work on black hole formation and stability in general relativity.

Extensions and Variants

One significant extension of the Penrose process is the Blandford-Znajek mechanism, proposed in 1977, which provides an electromagnetic variant for extracting energy from rotating black holes surrounded by magnetospheres. In this process, energy is drawn from the black hole's rotation via twisted magnetic field lines threading the ergosphere, powering relativistic jets without requiring particle splitting. The mechanism relies on the frame-dragging effect inducing an electric field in the magnetosphere, leading to currents that extract rotational energy, with efficiencies that can exceed 100% relative to the accretion rate in certain magnetized accretion models.^[15]^[16] Superradiance represents another related amplification mechanism that builds on the principles underlying the Penrose process, where waves (such as electromagnetic or gravitational) incident on a rotating black hole in the ergosphere can extract rotational energy and emerge amplified. First predicted for classical systems by Zel'dovich in 1971 and extended to black holes by Press and Teukolsky in 1972, superradiance occurs when the wave's frequency satisfies \omega < m \Omega_H, where m is the azimuthal quantum number and \Omega_H is the horizon angular velocity, resulting in exponential growth if confined (as in the "black hole bomb" instability). This wave-based extraction complements the particle-focused original process by enabling continuous energy draw from bosonic fields.^[17] A notable collision variant, introduced by Bañados, Silk, and West in 2009, involves high-energy particle collisions near the horizon of an extremal Kerr black hole, where the center-of-mass energy can become arbitrarily large due to the fine-tuning of one particle's angular momentum to critical values. In this setup, one particle reaches the horizon with near-critical parameters, boosting the collision energy in the center-of-mass frame to unlimited scales, potentially producing ultra-high-energy particles or radiation. This extends the Penrose idea to accelerator-like scenarios, with applications to probing quantum gravity effects, though realizability depends on overcoming fine-tuning challenges.^[18] The magnetic Penrose process further generalizes the framework by incorporating magnetic charges or fields in charged rotating black holes, such as the Kerr-Newman metric, to enhance energy extraction efficiency. Proposed in detailed form by Wagh and Dhurandhar in 1989, it allows charged particles in the ergosphere to achieve negative energy states influenced by the Lorentz force from ambient magnetic fields, enabling extraction efficiencies exceeding the original 20.7% limit, sometimes up to 100% or more in optimized configurations. This variant is particularly relevant for dyonic black holes, where magnetic monopoles amplify the negative energy orbits.^[19] Generalizations of the Penrose process to other spacetimes, such as the Kerr-Taub-NUT metric, explore energy extraction in metrics with NUT (Newman-Unti-Tamburino) parameters that introduce gravitomagnetic monopoles. In a 2011 analysis, the process remains viable in Kerr-Taub-NUT, with the NUT charge slightly modifying effective potentials to allow negative-energy trajectories, but its astrophysical relevance is limited due to the metric's pathological features like closed timelike curves and lack of a well-defined asymptotic region. Such extensions highlight the robustness of the mechanism but underscore constraints in non-standard geometries.^[20]

Modern Implications

Astrophysical Applications

The Penrose process has been proposed as a potential energy source for relativistic jets in active galactic nuclei (AGN) and quasars, where supermassive black holes power luminous emissions and outflows. In these environments, the process operates through its magnetic variant, known as the magnetic Penrose process (MPP), which facilitates the extraction of rotational energy from the Kerr black hole via interactions with strong magnetic fields threading the ergosphere. This mechanism is analogous to the Blandford-Znajek process, where plasma in the surrounding accretion disk generates a poloidal magnetic field that twists into a toroidal component, enabling efficient energy transfer to outgoing particles and potentially collimating jets observed in radio-loud AGN.^[21]^[22] In the context of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), the Penrose process may contribute to energy release during the merger of binary black holes or neutron star-black hole systems, particularly for short-duration GRBs. The post-merger black hole, inheriting significant spin from the orbital angular momentum, could extract rotational energy through particle scattering or magnetic reconnection in the ergosphere, powering the ultra-relativistic outflows that produce the observed gamma-ray emission. This extraction is thought to supplement accretion-driven mechanisms, providing up to 29% of the black hole's rotational energy as high-energy particles or radiation.^[21] Observational evidence for the Penrose process remains indirect, relying on signatures of rapidly rotating black holes in various systems. The Event Horizon Telescope's 2019 image of the M87* supermassive black hole reveals an asymmetric shadow and photon ring consistent with a Kerr metric, implying sufficient spin (a ≈ 0.9) for ergosphere-mediated energy extraction. Similarly, X-ray spectroscopy of stellar-mass black holes in binaries, such as Cygnus X-1, measures high spin parameters (a > 0.9) through iron line profiles and continuum fitting, supporting the presence of ergoregions where the process could occur, though direct detection of negative-energy particles is elusive.^[23] Practical implementation of the Penrose process in astrophysics faces significant challenges, as the pure particle-based version is inefficient without supporting structures like accretion disks or magnetic fields to supply incoming particles and sustain interactions. Synchrotron radiation losses from accelerated charged particles further limit efficiency, particularly for electrons, explaining why observed cosmic rays favor protons over leptons. Consequently, the isolated particle process is unlikely to dominate energy budgets, with collective variants like the Blandford-Znajek mechanism providing more viable pathways in magnetized environments.^[21]^[24] Unlike Hawking radiation, which arises from quantum vacuum fluctuations near the event horizon and extracts energy thermally regardless of black hole rotation, the Penrose process relies on classical frame-dragging in the ergosphere to enable negative-energy orbits, making it a rotational-specific mechanism with potentially higher efficiency for spinning black holes.^[21]

Recent Theoretical Advances

Recent theoretical advances in the Penrose process have incorporated quantum corrections to the Kerr metric, modifying energy extraction dynamics. In a 2025 study, quantum corrections parameterized by α in rotating black holes expand the ergoregion while altering particle trajectories, with numerical analysis showing a maximum extraction efficiency of 11.64% that deviates from classical values due to these modifications.^[25] Another investigation into nonlinear electrodynamics corrections suppresses the process efficiency compared to standard Kerr black holes, as increased charge and correction parameters increase the ergoregion size while imposing conditions on negative-energy orbits that enhance stability in the near-horizon regime.^[26] Applications to regular black holes, which avoid singularities, have revealed novel evolution pathways via the Penrose process. For the Bardeen metric modeling a magnetically charged regular black hole, charged particle splitting in the ergosphere enables energy extraction, with magnetic charge evaporation driving the black hole toward a singular state through two mechanisms: pure charge loss or combined charge evaporation and mass accretion.^[27] This evaporation process highlights how regular metrics like Bardeen sustain Penrose extraction while evolving under electromagnetic influences, contrasting classical singularities. Magnetic variants of the Penrose process in mimetic spacetimes, such as Kerr-MOG black holes, probe alternatives to general relativity. A 2024 analysis of charged particle acceleration via the magnetic Penrose process demonstrates that strong magnetic fields extend stable orbit regions and facilitate particle escape to infinity, achieving higher extraction efficiencies than in classical Kerr cases, with energy gains exceeding 10^{10} for particle acceleration to ultra-high energies, thus testing modified gravity theories against observational black hole alternatives.^[28] Observational implications for the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) have linked the Penrose process to split hotspot imaging. Negative-energy plasmoids generated through magnetic reconnection in the ergoregion provide prerequisites for such features, as fast plasmoids carrying negative energy enable net extraction while producing observable asymmetric or split emissions in black hole shadows.^[29] Quintessential dark energy surrounding rotating black holes further modulates Penrose efficiency. In a Kerr-Newman-AdS metric with quintessential fields, extraction efficiencies range from 5% to 35%, peaking at high spin parameters due to enhanced frame-dragging, but diminishing with increasing charge or quintessential energy density, which weakens gravitational effects and shifts chaotic orbit behaviors.^[30]

References

[1]
https://doi.org/10.1038/physci229177a0
[2]
Extraction of Energy from a Black Hole - Stanford University
Dec 8, 2011 · Fig. 1: The Penrose Process works by extracting the energy from a black hole through use of a intermediary particle.Missing: original | Show results with:original
[3]
[gr-qc/0510023] Kerr metric, static observers and Fermi coordinates
Oct 6, 2005 · View PDF. Abstract: The coordinate transformation which maps the Kerr metric written in standard Boyer-Lindquist coordinates to its ...
[4]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0706.0622.pdf
[5]
[PDF] Chapter 21 The Kerr solution - INFN Roma
Kerr metric in the Boyer-Lindquist coordinates is a coordinate singularity, which can be removed by an appropriate coordinate transformation. Furthermore ...
[6]
[PDF] Fifty Years of Energy Extraction from Rotating Black Hole - arXiv
May 26, 2019 · The first attempt to tap energy from black hole was made by Roger Penrose in 1969 [16] who pointed out existence of negative energy states ...
[7]
Extraction of Rotational Energy from a Black Hole - Nature
Feb 8, 1971 · Extraction of Rotational Energy from a Black Hole. R. PENROSE &; R. M. FLOYD. Nature Physical Science volume 229, pages 177 ...
[8]
[PDF] arXiv:1811.08204v2 [gr-qc] 15 Oct 2019
Oct 15, 2019 · Therefore, the Penrose process is similar to the so-called “swing-by” or “gravitational slingshot,” where a satellite flies close to a planet.
[9]
Gravitational collapse: The role of general relativity - Inspire HEP
Gravitational collapse: The role of general relativity. R. Penrose(. Birkbeck Coll. ) 1969. 25 pages. Published in: Riv.Nuovo Cim. 1 (1969) 252-276,; Gen.Rel ...
[10]
https://inspirehep.net/literature/54979
[11]
The thermodynamics of black holes: from Penrose process to ... - NIH
Aug 5, 2021 · This paper provides a novel take on the events that led to the rise of the thermodynamic theory of black holes, taking as a starting point the Penrose process.
[12]
Fifty Years of Energy Extraction from Rotating Black Hole - MDPI
May 5, 1997 · Magnetic Penrose process (MPP) is not only the most exciting and fascinating process mining the rotational energy of black hole but it is ...
[13]
Kerr geodesics, the Penrose process and jet collimation by a black ...
The paper starts with a study of Kerr geodesics in Weyl coordinates in Sect. 2; the next section studies the asymptotic behaviour of geodesics of outgoing ...
[14]
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2010/07/aa13678-09/aa13678-09.html
[15]
Floating Orbits, Superradiant Scattering and the Black-hole Bomb
Jul 28, 1972 · PRESS &; SAUL A. TEUKOLSKY. Nature volume 238, pages 211–212 (1972)Cite this article. 3676 Accesses. 635 Citations. 158 Altmetric. Metrics ...
[16]
Kerr Black Holes as Particle Accelerators to Arbitrarily High Energy
Kerr Black Holes as Particle Accelerators to Arbitrarily High Energy. Authors:Máximo Bañados, Joseph Silk, Stephen M. West.
[17]
The energetics of black holes in electromagnetic fields by the ...
In this article our main thrust will be on the study of the formal aspects of the Penrose-type energy extraction from black hole-magnetic field systems. To ...Missing: original paper
[18]
Penrose process in Kerr-Taub-NUT spacetime
Jun 2, 2011 · It has been shown that for the radial motion of particles NUT parameter slightly shifts the shape of the effective potential down.
[19]
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0370157389901567
[20]
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10509-011-0740-8
[21]
First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the ...
Apr 10, 2019 · Evidence for stellar-mass black holes comes from X-ray (Webster & Murdin 1972; Remillard & McClintock 2006) and gravitational-wave ...Missing: binaries | Show results with:binaries
[22]
[PDF] Observational Evidence for Black Holes
If verified, it would suggest that these jets are powered by a generalized Penrose process mediated by magnetic fields. ... Black hole spin in X-ray binaries:.
[23]
[2508.01683] Revisiting the Penrose Process in Rotating Black ...
Aug 3, 2025 · Revisiting the Penrose Process in Rotating Black Holes with Quantum Corrections: Implications for Energy Extraction and Irreducible Mass.
[24]
Penrose Process Efficiency and Irreducible Mass in Rotating Einstein-Born-Infeld Black Holes with Nonlinear Electrodynamics
**Title:** Penrose Process Efficiency and Irreducible Mass in Rotating Einstein-Born-Infeld Black Holes with Nonlinear Electrodynamics
[25]
Energy Extraction and Evolution of Regular Black Holes: The Case of Bardeen Spacetime
**Summary of arXiv:2508.14489**
[26]
Charged particle motion and acceleration around Kerr-MOG black ...
Nov 28, 2023 · ... magnetic Penrose process (MPP) near magnetized Kerr-MOG BHs. First, we study the horizon structure of the BH. Also, we study the effective ...
[27]
Energy Extraction from Rotating Black Hole with Quintessential ...
Mar 15, 2025 · The Penrose process demonstrates efficiencies ranging from 5% to 35%, with peak efficiency achieved at high spin, but diminishing with increased ...