Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Neti neti

Neti neti (: neti neti, नेति नेति) is a foundational phrase meaning "not this, not that" or "neither this, nor that," serving as a key method of negation in to describe the ineffable, non-dual reality of beyond all attributes and limitations. This apophatic approach, prominent in the and systematized in , guides spiritual inquiry by systematically rejecting identifications with the body, senses, mind, and empirical world, thereby revealing the transcendent Self () as identical with the absolute . Originating in ancient Vedic texts, it emphasizes that cannot be positively defined through or concepts, avoiding objectification while pointing to its unconditioned essence. The phrase first appears explicitly in the , one of the principal , where it articulates the nature of the in dialogues between sage and King . In Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.2.4, it states: "This one is the Self which is understood as 'not this, not this.' He is not perceptible because he cannot be perceived with the senses. He is indestructible for he cannot be destroyed. He is without attachments for he does not hold on to anything. He is unfettered, free from suffering, and free from injury." This passage illustrates the doctrine's role in transcending sensory and intellectual grasp, negating impermanent qualities to affirm the eternal, unchanging reality. Similar negations recur in Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.4.22 and 2.3.6, reinforcing that is incomprehensible (agrahya), indestructible (), and unattached (). These teachings, predating Advaita systematization by over a millennium, form the scriptural basis for later philosophical developments. In , as expounded by (c. 8th century CE), neti neti integrates into a broader epistemological framework involving shruti (scriptural revelation), yukti (reasoning), and experiential realization to dismantle avidya (ignorance) and false superimpositions (adhyasa). Shankara employs it to counter potential misinterpretations of as a finite entity, using negation after affirmative indications () to preserve non-duality without lapsing into . For instance, in his commentary on the (3.2.22), he describes neti neti as stripping away all discontinuities and qualifications, enabling the intuitive apprehension of as the substratum of all . This method remains a cornerstone of (path of knowledge), practiced through self-inquiry to attain (liberation) by discerning the real from the unreal.

Etymology and Meaning

Linguistic Breakdown

The phrase "neti neti" in Sanskrit is formed by the repetition of "neti," a sandhi contraction of the words "na" and "iti." Here, "na" functions as the standard negation particle, equivalent to "not," while "iti" serves as an adverbial particle denoting "thus" or "so," often used to quote or delimit a preceding statement or thought. This combination yields "neti" as "not thus" or "not so," with the duplication in "neti neti" providing rhythmic emphasis typical of emphatic expressions in classical Sanskrit. Originating in , the archaic form of the language used in the earliest Indo-Aryan religious and philosophical compositions, "neti neti" reflects the oral traditions of ancient that preserved linguistic structures through mnemonic recitation long before their transcription. These traditions, active from approximately 1500 BCE onward, evolved into written forms around 800–500 BCE, during which featured complex phonological rules like vowel that fuses "na" and "iti" into "neti" by combining the final 'a' of "na" with the initial 'i' of "iti" to form 'e'. Grammatically, the construction relies on the particle "na," which precedes and modifies the quotative "iti" to create a of the quoted or implied , resulting in a repetitive structure that underscores progressive exclusion. This pattern, employing simple particles without inflected verbs, exemplifies a concise form distinctive to Sanskrit's philosophical , where repetition enhances doctrinal precision. As a linguistic for , it facilitates conceptual delimitation in .

Philosophical Translation

"Neti neti" translates literally as "not this, not that," encapsulating a core method in for approaching the ultimate reality, , through negation rather than affirmation. This phrase underscores the of , indicating that the cannot be adequately captured by any positive , thereby pointing to its transcendent beyond empirical or conceptual grasp. Conceptually, "neti neti" represents the via negativa, a philosophical strategy of systematic denial that dismantles dualistic frameworks inherent in language and thought. By rejecting attributes such as form, name, or quality, it transcends the subject-object dichotomy, avoiding the limitation of the infinite absolute to finite categories that positive affirmations might impose. This negation process reveals Brahman's unobjectifiable essence as nondual consciousness, free from all predicates that could reify it as a discrete entity. Unlike cataphatic approaches, which build understanding through affirmative descriptors—for instance, portraying as "," "," or "bliss"— "neti neti" deliberately eschews such qualifications to prevent misconstruing the absolute as possessing limited characteristics. Instead, it negates false superimpositions on the , complementing positive scriptural statements while ultimately surpassing them to avert nihilistic interpretations or objectification. This distinction highlights "neti neti" as a tool for , fostering direct realization of the unqualified reality over indirect, attributive approximations.

Scriptural Origins

Upanishadic References

The phrase "neti neti" ("not this, not this") first appears prominently in the , one of the oldest , where it serves as a key method to describe the ineffable nature of during philosophical dialogues on the self (). In this text, the sage employs it repeatedly to negate attributes and empirical realities, emphasizing that transcends all forms, qualities, and dualities. For instance, in verse 2.3.6, states to King Janaka: "Now, therefore, the description of : 'Not this, not this' (Neti, neti); for there is no other and more appropriate description than this 'Not this.'" This negation arises in the context of a teacher-disciple exchange, where instructs that cannot be adequately captured by positive definitions, as any such attempt limits the infinite. Similar usage recurs in later sections of the , reinforcing its role in transcending sensory and conceptual limitations. In verse 3.9.26, describes the as: "This Self is that which has been described as 'Not this, not this.' It is imperceptible, for it cannot be perceived; indestructible, for it cannot be destroyed; unattached, for it does not attach itself; unfettered, it does not suffer, nor does it perish," to underscore its ungraspable essence beyond fear or injury. Verses 4.2.4, 4.4.22, and 4.5.15 extend this in conversations with his wife , where negates the self's identification with the body, mind, or world, stating in 4.5.15: "Where one sees nothing else and hears nothing else, that is the world of ... neti neti," to guide realization of non-duality. These instances, part of late Vedic literature composed around 700 BCE, illustrate "neti neti" as a tool in socratic-like interrogations to dismantle illusions of the self. The , a later minor Upanishad attached to the , employs a series of negations akin to "neti neti" in verses 16-24 to negate the , , , , body, senses, and physical elements in the realization of (). For example, it states: "I am not the , the , the , or the organs of knowledge; I am not the five elements or the five actions... Thus realizing the nature of the ," affirming the self's detachment from all composite realities to merge with the formless . This builds on the Brihadaranyaka's foundation, applying negation to personal sheaths (koshas) in a meditative context. In the , the shortest principal Upanishad, "neti neti" is implied through the analysis of states (avasthas), culminating in the description of the fourth state, . Verses 7 and 12 negate the waking, dream, and states as incomplete, stating "is not that which is conscious of the inner subjective world... not that which is conscious of the outer objective world... not a mass of ," effectively embodying "neti neti" to point to the undifferentiated reality beyond phenomena. This analytical negation, without the exact phrase, aligns with the Upanishadic tradition of discarding empirical layers to access the absolute.

References in Later Texts

In post-Upanishadic Hindu scriptures, the concept of "neti neti" continues from its foundational dialogic form in the , appearing in key Advaita texts to emphasize negation as a path to realizing non-dual reality. The , attributed to and dated to the 9th to , employs "neti neti" to affirm the liberated soul's transcendence beyond dualities such as form and formlessness. In verse 1.25, it states that the illusory world composed of the five elements is declared "not this, not this" by scripture, rejecting material compositions as untrue. Similarly, verse 1.62 reinforces this by applying "not this, not this" to both the formed and the formless, highlighting the soul's eternal freedom from all attributes and bonds. Gaudapada's Mandukya Karika (circa 6th century CE) echoes this negation in its exposition of non-dual reality, using the "neti neti" method to discard impermanent states like waking, dreaming, and deep sleep, revealing the unchanging fourth state () as the sole reality. This approach negates apparent dualities to affirm the self-luminous as beyond causation and modification. Adi Shankara's Vivekachudamani (8th century CE) integrates "neti neti" into self-inquiry, instructing the negation of the five sheaths (koshas) and objective phenomena to uncover the witness consciousness. For instance, verse 246 declares "neither this (gross), nor this (subtle) is the Self," dismissing body and mind as illusory projections akin to a rope mistaken for a snake. Verses 210 and 179 further apply this to eliminate superimpositions, leaving only the knowledge-absolute as the substratum. Over time, "neti neti" evolves from the Upanishads' interrogative dialogues to more poetic expressions in the Avadhuta Gita and systematic instructional tools in Gaudapada and Shankara's works, adapting negation for meditative discernment in medieval Advaita literature.

Philosophical Role

Negation in Advaita Vedanta

In Advaita Vedanta, the practice of neti neti functions as a methodological tool for the systematic negation (vivarana) of superimpositions (adhyasa), whereby attributes of the body, mind, senses, and external world are successively denied as belonging to the true Self (Atman), thereby unveiling its eternal, unchanging essence. This process addresses the fundamental ignorance (avidya) that causes the mutual superimposition of the non-Self upon the Self and vice versa, as outlined in Adi Shankara's introduction to his commentary on the Brahma Sutra, where he describes adhyasa as a beginningless cognitive error akin to mistaking a rope for a snake in dim light. By negating these false identifications, neti neti isolates the Atman as pure, undifferentiated consciousness, free from all limitations. Adi Shankara, the preeminent proponent of Advaita Vedanta, integrates neti neti into his commentaries as a critical preparatory discipline preceding shravana (scriptural hearing) and manana (logical reflection), which together form the foundational steps toward direct knowledge (jnana) and liberation (moksha). In his Brahma Sutra Bhashya (3.2.22), Shankara employs this negation to affirm the continuity of consciousness beyond all predicates, emphasizing that while neti neti rejects empirical qualities to avoid misconstruing the absolute, it implicitly points to the substratum of existence that persists through the denial. This methodical rejection serves to dismantle dualistic misconceptions, preparing the seeker for the non-dual realization of Atman as identical with Brahman. The negation process in neti neti proceeds by discarding specific limiting characteristics attributed to the Self, such as "not gross, not subtle, not short, not long," as exemplified in Shankara's commentary on the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (3.8.8), ultimately arriving at an unqualified affirmation of the Self merely as "is" (sat), devoid of all definable qualities. This via negativa starkly contrasts with dualistic (dvaita) traditions, which posit affirmative attributes like form or action to the ultimate reality, whereas Advaita insists that such predications only reinforce the illusion of separation. Through this disciplined inquiry, the practitioner transcends conceptual frameworks, apprehending the Atman in its intrinsic, attributeless reality.

Relation to Brahman and Atman

In Advaita Vedanta, the doctrine of neti neti serves as an ontological tool to delineate the nature of , the , as nirguna—devoid of all attributes, qualities, and limitations that could confine it to empirical categories. By successively negating descriptors such as form, name, or action, neti neti underscores that transcends any positive predication, rendering it ineffable and beyond the grasp of sensory or conceptual faculties. Descriptions like sat-chit-ananda (existence-consciousness-bliss) are employed not as exhaustive definitions but as provisional pointers to guide the seeker toward this attributeless essence, avoiding the error of reifying into a finite entity. Central to this framework is the identity between and , the true self, encapsulated in the Upanishadic mahavakya tat tvam asi ("that thou art"), which affirms their non-dual unity. In Advaita, neti neti applied to the negates superimpositions of body, mind, and ego, revealing it as the infinite, unchanging witness-consciousness identical to . This negation dismantles ignorance (avidya), the root cause of perceived duality, thereby unveiling the self's inherent boundlessness and freedom from all qualifications. Unlike the saguna (qualified) conceptualized in schools such as , where divine attributes like are affirmed, Advaita's neti neti insists on an attributelessness to preserve non-duality. The conceptual culmination of neti neti is the direct realization of pure consciousness (chit) as the sole reality—eternal, self-luminous, and impervious to modification or itself. What persists after the exhaustive removal of all adjuncts is this nondual substratum, liberating the seeker from the cycle of birth and death (samsara) through epistemic insight into the self's intrinsic wholeness. This outcome aligns with Shankara's interpretation, where does not annihilate reality but illuminates its undifferentiated ground.

Practical Applications

In Jnana Yoga and Meditation

In , "neti neti" serves as a key contemplative tool within the fourfold path of spiritual discipline known as sadhana chatushtaya, which encompasses (), dispassion (), sixfold virtues (shadka sampatti), and intense longing for (mumukshutva). This negation practice is particularly emphasized during nididhyasana, the stage of profound contemplation following scriptural study () and reflection (manana), where the practitioner systematically disidentifies from the , body, mind, and senses by repeatedly affirming "not this, not this" to peel away layers of false identification. Through this process, the 's attachments to transient phenomena are negated, allowing the underlying to emerge unencumbered by sensory illusions or mental constructs. As a meditative technique, "neti neti" involves practitioners sitting in a quiet and mentally repeating the while observing the arising and passing of thoughts, bodily sensations, and emotions without attachment or judgment. This observation cultivates sakshi bhava, or witness consciousness, wherein one assumes the role of a detached spectator to the mind's activities, gradually transcending identification with the observed phenomena and realizing the unchanging awareness beneath. The practice fosters a state of inner stillness, where leads not to but to the direct apprehension of the as the eternal witness, free from the fluctuations of the and senses. Historically, "neti neti" has been transmitted through the guru-shishya parampara, the traditional teacher-disciple lineage in , where gurus guide students in applying negation during personal instruction and contemplation sessions. A prominent example is found in the teachings of , who incorporated similar negation into his method of self-inquiry (atma vichara), advising disciples to ignore adjuncts like body and mind by attending solely to the sense of "I," effectively using "not I, not I" to dissolve egoic identifications and reveal the source of consciousness. This approach, often practiced in silent satsangs or one-on-one dialogues, underscores the technique's role in experiential realization within the guru-shishya framework.

Interpretations in Contemporary Philosophy

In the 20th century, integrated "neti neti" into his exposition of , portraying it as a method of successive —"not this, not this"—to transcend ego-bound limitations and attain inner freedom, contrasting it with affirmative approaches like "iti" (this is it). Similarly, employed "neti neti" within his framework of , using it to negate incomplete mental and vital identifications, thereby facilitating a psychological ascent toward the indefinable beyond all relational forms. These adaptations emphasized "neti neti" not merely as doctrinal but as a dynamic tool for personal transformation, extending its role from scriptural to practical . The principle of "neti neti" finds notable parallels in Western , where negation serves to approach the divine beyond affirmative predicates, as exemplified by Meister Eckhart's conception of God as the "" transcending all beings and attributes—a via negativa resonant with Advaita's rejection of limited descriptors. In comparative philosophy, drew explicit connections, describing "neti neti" as the Hindu affirmation of ultimate reality's elusiveness to positive conceptualization, likening it to the ineffable ground of being that evades linguistic grasp and unites Eastern and Western mystical insights. In contemporary and non-dual practices, "neti neti" informs techniques for disidentifying from transient thoughts and constructs, promoting a state of pure presence, as reflected in guided meditations that systematically negate non-essential identifications to reveal underlying . This approach parallels the emphasis in Eckhart Tolle's teachings on observing and releasing mental forms to access formless , underscoring negation's role in modern psychological and .

References

  1. [1]
    Śaṅkara - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    Oct 4, 2021 · Neti neti (negative language) literally means “not (this), not (this)”. Its negation targets the discontinuity aspect by stripping away all ...
  2. [2]
    Néti néti
    ### Summary of "Néti néti" by Walter Slaje
  3. [3]
    Difficulties in Knowing the Reality of Brahman
    The method, which is popularly known as neti neti (not-this not-this), is mentioned in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (4.2.4) in the conversation between King ...
  4. [4]
    [PDF] The Upanishads for Awakening-2-2021-for PDF
    Brihadaranyaka Upanishad. In this final part of the Katha Upanishad we are given practical understanding of the way in which immortality is gained. When all ...
  5. [5]
    Iti, Īti, Iṭi: 19 definitions
    Aug 9, 2025 · Iti (इति).—1. [adverb] thus, so. It refers to something said or thought, which it follows (rarely precedes), and is often = ...
  6. [6]
    Neti-neti, Netineti: 7 definitions
    Oct 30, 2020 · Neti-neti is roughly defined as “not this, not this,” and appears first in an Upanishad. Shankara advocates it as a method of inquiry, and ...In Hinduism · Vedanta · Vaishnavism · General definition
  7. [7]
    What Does 'Neti Neti' Mean and Why is it Used? - Shining World
    Aug 19, 2021 · 'Neti neti' is a compound term in Sanskrit, meaning 'not this, not this'. The root words for 'neti' are 'na iti'.
  8. [8]
    Upanishads - World History Encyclopedia
    Jun 10, 2020 · 1500 - c. 500 BCE. The Upanishads are considered the “end of the Vedas” (Vedanta) in that they expand upon, explain, and develop the Vedic ...
  9. [9]
    Sanskritdictionary.com: Definition of iti
    In quotations of every kind /iti- means that the preceding words are the very words which some person has or might have spoken, and placed thus at the end of a ...
  10. [10]
    What is Neti Neti? - Hridaya Yoga
    “N” is negation. “Iti” indicates “like this” or simply “this”. Hence Neti Neti means “Not this, Not this”. The answers that normally ...Missing: etymology linguistic breakdown
  11. [11]
    The Non-Dual Path of Negation - MDPI
    Jun 28, 2024 · In order to grasp the meaning of the via negativa as a path of deconstruction and disidentification (Neti-Neti) and of the apparent obscurity of ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Negative Theology of the Yogavasistha and the Lankavatara Sutra
    The praetice of neti neti in the Advaita Vedanta tradition serves. as a means to negate all that is not Brahman. Within' the ¥oga tradition the definition ...
  13. [13]
    Section III - The Two Forms of Brahman
    Feb 16, 2018 · Verse 2.3.6: तस्य हैतस्य पुरुषस्य रूपम् ... neti neti, na hyetasmāditi netyanyatparamasti; atha nāmadheyam ...
  14. [14]
    Upanisads - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    The Upanisads are ancient Indian texts from 700-300 BCE, part of the Vedas, exploring philosophical questions and the nature of being.
  15. [15]
    Brihadaranyaka Upanishad - VivekaVani
    2.3.6 The form of that person is like a cloth dyed with turmeric, or like grey sheep's wool, or like the scarlet insect called Indragopa, or ...
  16. [16]
    Section V - Yajnavalkya and Maitreyi (II)
    Feb 16, 2018 · ३ ॥ sā hovāca maitreyī, yannu ma iyaṃ bhagoḥ sarvā pṛthivī vittena pūrṇā syāt, syāṃ nvahaṃ tenāmṛtāho3 neti; neti ... Verse 4.5.15:.
  17. [17]
    The Kaivalya Upanishad - CWSA - Kena and Other Upanishads
    He is All and yet He is neti, neti, He is One and yet He is many. He is Parabrahman and He is Parameswara. He is Male and He is Female. He is Tat and He is ...
  18. [18]
    Mandukya Upanishad Introduction - Shlokam.org
    Negation of the Unreal: The Upanishad uses neti-neti (not this, not this) logic to discard the impermanent states and arrive at the changeless reality. Adi ...
  19. [19]
    The Hermeneutics of the Upanishadic Negation neti ... - ResearchGate
    Jan 14, 2021 · By negating everything that is 'not-self', one is left with only the self. 19 Hindu's call this self atman (soul). Atman serves the function ...Missing: Mandukya | Show results with:Mandukya
  20. [20]
    Cutting the Knot of the World Problem: Sri Aurobindo's Experiential ...
    On the one hand, one can radicalize the Advaitic method of “neti, neti” (“not this, not this”) by following the Buddhist Śūnyavādins in negating even the ...
  21. [21]
    [PDF] UC Berkeley - eScholarship
    ... Avadhuta Gita, a 9th to. 10th century CE text associated with the less well-known avatara, Dattatreya. In the Avadhuta. Gita, Dattatreya asks “How can I bow ...
  22. [22]
    Avadhuta Gita/Chapter 1 - Wikisource, the free online library
    Sep 5, 2025 · neti neti śrutirbrūyādanṛtaṁ pāñcabhautikam //25//. By such sentences ... verses. Three states, etc. - the waking state, the dream state ...
  23. [23]
    Mandukya Karika by Gaudapada - Shlokam.org
    Gaudapada reveals what remains when false appearances are stripped away: the one, non-dual consciousness that is both individual Self and absolute reality.
  24. [24]
    [PDF] MANDUKYA UPANISHAD - “It Hops Like a Frog”
    Feb 21, 2024 · For this reason, the method of “Negation”, of Neti-Neti or “not this, not this”, is adopted. ... In this Karika,. Sri Gaudapada gives guidance and ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] Vivekachudamani - Arsha Bodha Center
    The Vivekachudamani, literally "The Crest-Jewel of Discrimination," is perhaps the most famous non-commentarial work of Sankara that expounds Vedanta.
  26. [26]
    Vivekachudamani, Verse 210
    Feb 21, 2016 · पञ्चानामपि कोशानां निषेधे युक्तितः श्रुतेः । तन्निषेधावधि साक्षी बोधरूपोऽवशिष्यते ॥ २१0 ॥ ... 210. When all the five sheaths have been eliminated by the reasoning on Shruti ...
  27. [27]
    The spiritual philosophy of Advaita: Basic concepts and relevance to ...
    Feb 12, 2024 · Advaita's core principles are: Brahman is the only truth, the universe is an illusion, and individual consciousness (Atman) is identical to  ...
  28. [28]
    The Interconnection between Brahman and Atman - ResearchGate
    Aug 7, 2025 · PDF | On Jan 1, 2013, Brandon Lee Gordon published The Interconnection between Brahman and Atman | Find, read and cite all the research you ...
  29. [29]
    'adhyAropa' to 'adhiSThAna' – 4/4 - Advaita Vision
    Feb 20, 2024 · ... ego / mind through detachment, discrimination (of neti neti). This sadhana is not to be confused with action (that is not required for ...
  30. [30]
    Types of Meditation – Part 2 | Vedanta Society of Southern California
    In nididhyasana no symbols are used, nor is the self objectified. It is a negative process of neti, neti (“not this, not this”) by which the self cuts asunder ...
  31. [31]
    Vedantic Meditations: The Practice of Self Inquiry
    Sakshi Bhava – the witness state: Learn how to observe the play of life as though watching a movie, without identifying with it. Abheda Bodha Vakya ...
  32. [32]
    Atma-vichara and the 'practice' of neti neti - Sri Ramana Teachings
    Nov 20, 2008 · The simple practice of atma-vichara (self-investigation or self-enquiry) taught by Sri Ramana, which is the only truly effective means by which we can ...Missing: shishya | Show results with:shishya
  33. [33]
    CHAPTER VII – FREEDOM - Swami Vivekananda
    Aug 28, 2024 · One is called the “Neti, Neti” (not this, not this), the other is called “Iti” (this); the former is the negative, and the latter is the ...
  34. [34]
    Sri Aurobindo, "The Synthesis of Yoga", Part II - surasA.net
    The Absolute it seeks after is featureless, indefinable, relationless, not this, not that, neti neti. And yet we can say of it that it is One, that it is ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  35. [35]
    The Strategy of Ontological Negativity in Meister Eckhart's ... - MDPI
    Nov 26, 2018 · We will try to compare the ideas of the mystic-apophatic theology of Eckhart and philosophical traditions of India—the darśana Advaita ...
  36. [36]
    Relevance of Oriental Philosophy - Alan Watts - organism.earth
    So then, of the Godhead the Hindu says: all that can truly be said is neti neti, “not this, not this.” And when the Buddhist uses such a term for the final ...
  37. [37]
    Neti Neti Practice | Betsy Weiner - Insight Timer
    Rating 5.0 (8) Jan 21, 2025 · Neti neti is one of the practices of negation: we simply let go of what is not serving our highest good. Begin by finding a comfortable seat,
  38. [38]
    Self Enquiry, Neti Neti and the Process of Elimination
    Eckhart Tolle said in The Power ... So all objects conceived or perceived that is mistaken as Self are naturally negated as neti neti - not this, not this.
  39. [39]
    An Introduction to Comparative Philosophy
    Wittgenstein has always based itself on and in the object world. The Greek ... only as neti neti, not this, not that. 58 This intending and attending ...