Norfolk Spaniel

The Norfolk Spaniel, also known as the Shropshire Spaniel, was a breed of land spaniel that originated in 19th-century England and became extinct by the early 20th century.^[1] This medium-sized gundog, standing approximately 17 to 18 inches tall at the shoulder, featured a distinctive liver-and-white coat with heavy flecking and a white blaze on the forehead, resembling a thickly built English Setter in structure.^[1] It was prized for flushing game birds from cover, often giving tongue while working, though it was noted for being challenging to train. Historically, the Norfolk Spaniel emerged as one of several early land spaniel types developed for sporting purposes, with records dating back to at least the 1860s and associations with royalty, including use at King Edward VII's Sandringham estate.^[1] Reputedly linked to the Duke of Norfolk, though this theory was later disproved by investigations such as that of 19th-century breeder James Farrow,^[2] the breed shared ancestry with other spaniels and was shown in the United States as early as 1886, where a specimen named Dash II competed at Madison Square Garden.^[1] By the late 19th century, selective breeding efforts aimed to standardize its traits, but it was often confused or interbred with similar varieties like the Sussex Spaniel.^[1] The breed's decline stemmed from the 1902 classification of spaniels by the Sporting Spaniel Society, which reorganized land spaniels into distinct types and led to the Norfolk Spaniel being absorbed into the emerging English Springer Spaniel lineage without preservation as a separate variety.^[1] Today, its legacy persists in the English Springer Spaniel, which inherited many of its flushing abilities and coat patterns, marking the Norfolk as an important precursor in the development of modern gundog breeds.^[3]

History

Origins and Early Development

Land spaniels emerged as a distinct type in England during the 16th century, when spaniels were broadly categorized into water and land varieties based on their working roles in hunting. The Norfolk Spaniel, also known as the Shropshire Spaniel, developed in the 19th century as one such land spaniel, bred primarily for flushing or "springing" game birds from cover, a function that distinguished them from setters or pointers, and the term "springing spaniel" began appearing in records by the 18th century to describe this action of driving game toward nets or, later, guns. The breed's name likely derived from regional associations in East Anglia, particularly Norfolk and Shropshire counties, rather than a specific creator, reflecting the localized breeding practices common among English gamekeepers and landowners at the time.^[4]^[1] Early theories linking the Norfolk Spaniel's development to a Duke of Norfolk—suggesting a cross between spaniels and black-and-tan terriers—originated in 1845 with William Youatt's writings in The Dog, which popularized the idea of aristocratic patronage. However, this connection was thoroughly disproven; the 15th Duke of Norfolk himself clarified in a 1899 letter to breeder James Farrow, published in The Kennel Gazette, that no such breeding program existed in his family's history, attributing the myth to unsubstantiated folklore. More credible accounts, such as those from Rawdon B. Lee in his 1893 book Modern Dogs of Great Britain and Ireland, proposed that the Norfolk Spaniel resulted from crosses between the curly-coated water spaniel and land spaniels like the Sussex Spaniel, yielding a sturdy, versatile hunter with a characteristic liver-and-white or black-and-white coat, standing 17-18 inches (43-46 cm) at the shoulder, and featuring heavily feathered ears and a high-legged build suited to rough terrain. By the mid-19th century, the breed was described as the "commonest" working spaniel in England and widely employed by gamekeepers for its reliable flushing abilities.^[5]^[4]^[1] The Norfolk Spaniel's early development was shaped by practical selection for hunting prowess rather than formal standardization, with notable use documented in the 1860s by the future King Edward VII at Sandringham Estate, where the dogs were prized for giving tongue while working close to handlers. Historical accounts from J.R. Walsh in The Dog (1867) and Thomas Pearce (1872) emphasize its prevalence and physical resemblance to a thick-set English setter, while Vero Shaw's 1880 descriptions highlighted variations in coat and build across regions. This era marked the breed's peak as a foundational type, serving as a direct ancestor to the modern English Springer Spaniel, with early show entries in 1857 listing specimens as "Norfolk Spaniel or Springer" under Sir Hugo Fitzherbert's Tissington Flush, signaling the onset of organized recognition.^[1]^[4]

Recognition, Decline, and Extinction

The Norfolk Spaniel, also known as the Shropshire Spaniel, gained early recognition in the mid-19th century through its exhibition in dog shows and descriptions in contemporary literature. It was first showcased as the "Norfolk Spaniel or Springer" at events such as the 1857 Crystal Palace show, where specimens like "Tissington Flush," owned by Sir Hugo Fitz-Herbert, were entered. It was also shown in the United States as early as 1886, with a specimen named Dash II competing at Madison Square Garden.^[1] In 1867, prominent dog writer J.R. Walsh detailed the breed in the magazine The Dog, portraying it as a compact, heavily built dog resembling a smaller English Setter, typically 17-18 inches tall with a liver-and-white coat, and emphasizing its widespread use among English gamekeepers for flushing game.^[1] By 1872, the Kennel Club formalized the separation of Springer and Cocker Spaniels, classifying the Norfolk Spaniel alongside other medium-legged springers without establishing it as a fully independent breed at that time.^[6] The breed's decline began in the late 19th century amid shifting classifications and breeding practices within the spaniel family. The founding of the Sporting Spaniel Club in 1885 marked a turning point, as it promoted standardized field trials that blurred distinctions between regional spaniel types, leading to interbreeding and a loss of the Norfolk's distinct purity, as noted by Walsh in 1867 and later observers like Thomas Pearce in 1872.^[1] By the 1880s, writers such as Vero Shaw described the Norfolk's characteristic liver-and-white coloration with a white blaze, but its regional naming—possibly tied to Norfolk County or King Edward VII's use at Sandringham in the 1860s—began to wane as broader spaniel categories gained prominence.^[1] Rawdon Briggs Lee, in his 1893 writings, highlighted the interchangeable use of "Norfolk" and "Shropshire" names, reflecting confusion over origins and contributing to the breed's fading identity.^[6] The Norfolk Spaniel's extinction as a distinct breed occurred in the early 20th century due to official reclassification by the Kennel Club. In 1902, the Kennel Club designated all medium-legged spaniels—excluding Clumber and Sussex types—as English Springer Spaniels, effectively absorbing the Norfolk into this new category to standardize working spaniels and avoid regional naming limitations, such as implying only liver-and-white dogs.^[6] By 1903, the breed ceased to exist independently, with all remaining Norfolk Spaniels reclassified as English Springers, marking the end of its separate lineage despite its role as an ancestor to the modern breed.^[1] This merger preserved its genetic contributions but eliminated the Norfolk Spaniel from formal recognition, a fate shared by other regional spaniel variants amid the era's push for unified standards.^[2]

Physical Characteristics

Size and Build

The Norfolk Spaniel was a medium-sized sporting dog, typically standing 17 to 18 inches (43 to 46 cm) at the shoulder, which positioned it between smaller cocker types and larger field spaniels. This height allowed for agility in flushing game from cover while maintaining endurance for extended hunts.^[1] In build, the breed exhibited a sturdy, compact frame resembling a scaled-down English Setter, with a deep chest for lung capacity, a strong, level back for stability, and relatively long legs that contributed to its leggy appearance and springing ability. The overall proportions were thick-set and muscular, emphasizing functionality over showy elegance, with heavily feathered ears adding to its distinctive spaniel silhouette. Historical observers noted it as stouter and more staunch than the common springer spaniel of the era, reflecting selective breeding for reliability in rough terrain.^[1]^[7]^[8] These physical traits underscored the Norfolk Spaniel's role as a versatile hunter, capable of navigating dense underbrush without excessive bulk that might hinder speed or stamina. While exact weights were not uniformly recorded, the breed's robust yet balanced structure suggested a range supportive of active field work, typically estimated around 35 to 45 pounds based on comparative spaniel standards.

Coat and Coloration

The Norfolk Spaniel's coat was characterized by a dense, water-resistant structure suited to its working origins in wet terrains, often displaying a slight curl or waviness inherited from water spaniel ancestors.^[9] This texture provided protection against harsh weather, with heavily feathered ears adding to its distinctive appearance, though the overall coat was not as tightly curled as in some contemporary water breeds.^[10] Historical accounts emphasize its thickness, likening it to that of a robust English Setter, which aided in endurance during field work.^[1] In terms of coloration, the breed was predominantly liver-and-white, featuring white markings heavily flecked or ticked with liver (a rich brownish-red hue) across the body.^[9] A prominent white blaze extending up the forehead was a common and admired feature, enhancing the dog's expressive facial structure.^[1] Black-and-white variants also occurred, though less frequently documented, with the white areas similarly ticked or spotted.^[10] These patterns aligned with the practical needs of Norfolk's wildfowling heritage, where the liver tone blended with marshy environments.^[9] By the late 19th century, breed standards formalized these traits, specifying liver-and-white or black-and-white coats without excessive curl, distinguishing the Norfolk from curlier water spaniels while preserving its functional elegance.^[1]

Temperament and Working Role

Personality Traits

The Norfolk Spaniel was renowned for its lively and docile disposition, making it a spirited companion in the field. Historical accounts describe the breed as extremely affectionate and deeply attached to its masters, often forming strong individual bonds that led to pining or distress when separated from them.^[11] This loyalty was tempered by a tendency toward obstinacy if not properly managed, with some sources noting a more ill-tempered streak compared to common springers, requiring patient correction to channel its energy effectively.^[11] In terms of working temperament, the Norfolk Spaniel exhibited great intelligence and enthusiasm for tasks, particularly in hunting scenarios where its active nature shone through. It was described as staunch—meaning steady and reliable—especially in challenging cover like high turnips, where its height and strength allowed it to perform without tiring easily.^[12] However, the breed could be wild and wide-ranging without thorough training. Despite these challenges, its overall eagerness and docility made it a valuable aid to the gun once properly conditioned.^[11]

Trainability and Hunting Abilities

The Norfolk Spaniel was renowned for its versatility in the field, serving primarily as a springing spaniel that excelled at flushing game from dense cover such as thickets, hedges, and high turnips, where its leggy build and strength allowed it to navigate challenging terrain more effectively than smaller breeds.^[12] Historical accounts describe it as stouter and more staunch than the common springer, making it a capable worker for both land and water pursuits, including retrieving birds and small game like rabbits. Its hunting prowess stemmed from a strong nose and questing instinct, enabling it to locate and spring partridges, quail, and waterfowl, though untrained individuals might flush game indiscriminately rather than methodically. In terms of trainability, the breed responded well to patient and consistent handling, often described as easily broken to work when guided with a balance of kindness and firm correction, though it could exhibit stubbornness or obstinacy if not properly socialized from a young age. Breeders noted its high intelligence and tractable nature, allowing it to learn commands for flushing, retrieving, and steadying to gunshots, typically maturing into reliable performers by 18 to 24 months with dedicated training. Despite these strengths, some lines displayed a fiery or impetuous temperament that required early discipline to curb potential ferocity, ensuring the dog remained docile and affectionate toward handlers while focused in the field.^[11] As a working gun dog, the Norfolk Spaniel thrived in mixed shooting scenarios, such as marshlands and coverts, where it could beat through heavy vegetation, retrieve from water without hesitation, and adapt to both upland game and fowl. Its endurance and activity made it a favorite among rustic sportsmen, who valued its all-around capabilities for hedging, rabbiting, and duck shooting, often performing the labor of multiple smaller spaniels in a single brace.^[12] While mute in some individuals, others vocalized during hunts, adding to its spirited presence.^[13] This combination of innate drive and responsive training solidified its reputation as a foundational breed for modern springers, though its extinction by the early 20th century limited further development.