Northern cardinal
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) is a medium-sized songbird native to eastern and central North America, measuring 8–9 inches (21–23 cm) in length with a wingspan of 9–12 inches (25–31 cm), renowned for the male's brilliant red plumage, black face mask, and prominent crest, while females are duller brownish with red tinges and a similar crest.[1][2] This species is a year-round resident, non-migratory, and common in backyards, forest edges, and shrubby thickets across its range from southern Canada to central Mexico, with an estimated population of about 130 million individuals whose range has been expanding westward.[3][2] Northern cardinals inhabit a variety of semi-open to brushy environments, including woodland edges, overgrown fields, swamps, urban parks, and desert washes, where they prefer dense undergrowth for cover and foraging.[3][2] They are omnivorous, feeding primarily on seeds (especially sunflower), insects, and berries, often foraging on or near the ground in pairs or small family groups, and are frequent visitors to bird feeders.[1][2] Behaviorally, males are highly territorial, aggressively defending their area year-round with loud, whistled songs that both sexes produce—a rare trait among female songbirds—and may attack their reflections in windows or mirrors.[1][2] Breeding occurs from March to August, with pairs forming strong bonds and sharing similar song phrases; females typically lay 3–4 eggs in a cup-shaped nest of twigs and bark, incubating them for 12–13 days while the male provides food, followed by both parents feeding the fledglings, often raising 2–3 broods per year.[2][3] The species holds cultural significance as the state bird of seven U.S. states (Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, North Carolina, Ohio, Virginia, and West Virginia) and is classified as Least Concern by conservation assessments due to its stable and increasing population.[2][1]Taxonomy
Etymology and classification
The Northern cardinal bears the binomial name Cardinalis cardinalis, serving as the type species for the genus Cardinalis within the family Cardinalidae, a group of New World passerine birds known as cardinals, grosbeaks, and allies.[4][5] This classification reflects its placement among 19 recognized subspecies distributed across North and Central America, emphasizing the family's diversity in seed-eating songbirds.[6] The species was first formally described by Swedish naturalist Carl Linnaeus in his 1758 work Systema Naturae under the name Loxia cardinalis, grouping it initially with crossbills in the genus Loxia due to superficial similarities in beak structure.[7] Subsequent taxonomic revisions recognized its distinct morphology; in 1838, Charles Lucien Bonaparte reclassified it as Cardinalis virginianus, establishing the genus Cardinalis to better accommodate its robust, finch-like bill and crest.[4] Further adjustments occurred in the mid-19th century when Thomas Mayo Brewer proposed the genus Richmondena in 1858, leading to Richmondena cardinalis, a name used in ornithological literature until approximately 1966. In 1963, the American Ornithologists' Union restored the species to Cardinalis cardinalis in its official check-list, a designation upheld in modern taxonomy to honor its historical precedence and phylogenetic coherence.[6][4] The etymology of Cardinalis cardinalis draws from the Latin cardinalis, meaning "principal" or "chief," but more directly alluding to the Roman Catholic cardinals whose scarlet robes inspired the naming due to the male Northern cardinal's striking red plumage.[8] This evocative reference, first noted in Linnaeus's description, underscores the bird's vivid coloration as a key diagnostic trait. The specific epithet cardinalis redundantly emphasizes this connection, a common practice in binomial nomenclature to highlight defining characteristics.[9] Phylogenetically, Cardinalis cardinalis belongs to the monophyletic family Cardinalidae, which comprises about 14 genera and is characterized by molecular evidence from ultraconserved elements supporting its evolutionary divergence from other passerines around 12 million years ago. Within Cardinalidae, the genus Cardinalis forms a tight clade with the pyrrhuloxia (C. sinuatus) and the vermilion cardinal (C. phoeniceus), with C. cardinalis and C. sinuatus sharing a particularly close sister relationship evidenced by shared genetic markers and morphological convergences in arid habitats.[9][10] This positioning highlights the genus's adaptation to diverse North American environments, distinct from more distant relatives like the grosbeaks (Pheucticus) or buntings (Passerina).[11]Subspecies
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) exhibits substantial geographic variation, leading to the recognition of 19 subspecies divided into two primary groups: the cardinalis group and the carneus group. These groups are distinguished primarily by bill shape (shorter and thicker in the cardinalis group versus more slender in the carneus group), crest length (shorter in the cardinalis group), overall size, and subtle differences in plumage intensity.[4][8] Subspecies in the cardinalis group occupy much of eastern and southern North America, extending into central Mexico, and generally feature brighter red plumage in males with less pronounced size clines in arid regions. In contrast, the carneus group is centered in western and southern Mexico, often showing adaptations like longer crests and paler tones suited to drier habitats. Morphological differences, such as body size and bill dimensions, follow patterns like Bergmann's rule, with northern populations larger than southern ones; for instance, Florida birds (C. c. floridanus) have shorter crests and smaller mass, tarsus, and wing lengths compared to those in the Midwest and Northeast.[12][4] The following table enumerates representative subspecies from each group, highlighting their geographic ranges and key distinguishing traits:| Subspecies | Group | Geographic Range | Distinguishing Traits |
|---|---|---|---|
| C. c. cardinalis (nominate) | cardinalis | Southeastern Canada to eastern Texas and Florida, USA; northeastern Mexico | Typical brilliant red male plumage; medium size; baseline for species description. |
| C. c. floridanus | cardinalis | Southeastern Georgia to peninsular Florida, USA | Smaller overall (reduced mass, tarsus, wing chord); shorter crest than northern forms. |
| C. c. magnirostris | cardinalis | Southern Texas to southwestern Mississippi and Louisiana, USA | Larger, thicker bill; similar plumage to nominate but adapted to coastal regions. |
| C. c. canicaudus | cardinalis | Western Oklahoma and Texas, USA, to central Mexico | Grayer tail; intermediate size between eastern and western forms. |
| C. c. superbus | carneus | Southwestern USA (Arizona, New Mexico, southern California) to northern Sonora, Mexico | Paler gray dorsal plumage in males; lighter red overall; suited to desert environments. |
| C. c. affinis | carneus | Baja California, Mexico (Cape region) | Similar size to superbus but brighter red in males; paler underparts in females. |
| C. c. carneus | carneus | Western Mexico (Colima to Isthmus of Tehuantepec) | Longer crest; more slender bill; richer red tones in humid coastal areas. |
Description
Plumage and appearance
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) exhibits striking sexual dimorphism in its plumage, with the male displaying vibrant red coloration across the body, including the crest, wings, tail, and underparts, accented by a distinctive black face mask surrounding the eyes and a conical red-orange bill.[14][15] This brilliant red derives from carotenoid pigments acquired through diet and incorporated during molt, serving as a signal of the bird's health and foraging ability.[16] In contrast, the female possesses a more subdued plumage of pale brown or olive-brown overall, with warm red tinges limited to the wings, tail, crest, and occasionally the face or upper breast, while lacking the male's full black mask—though darker facial areas may appear.[14][15] Her red-orange bill matches the male's, and the red accents on her plumage also stem from dietary carotenoids, correlating with her body condition.[17] Juveniles resemble females in their grayish-brown or mottled plumage with subtle red hints on the wings, tail, and crest, but feature a duller gray-black bill that transitions to the adult's red-orange coloration.[15] They undergo a post-fledging molt, acquiring adult-like feathers by their first fall, though some retained juvenile primaries may appear faded or paler.[17] Plumage shows minor seasonal changes without major molts beyond the annual cycle; males' red feathers acquire grayish tips during late-summer molt but brighten progressively through fall and winter as these tips wear away, reaching peak vibrancy by midwinter.[16] Females exhibit similar but less pronounced wear patterns on their red accents.[16] The prominent crest, present in both sexes and juveniles, consists of elongated feathers on the head and functions in visual displays beyond mere ornamentation, such as signaling alertness or intent.[14][18] Certain subspecies, like C. c. magnirostris in southeastern Texas and southern Louisiana, display paler or grayer overall tones compared to the nominate's richer reds.[19]Size and measurements
The Northern cardinal measures 21–23 cm in length, with a wingspan ranging from 25–31 cm and an average mass of 42–48 g.[14][2] These dimensions position it as a mid-sized perching songbird, comparable in scale to other members of the Cardinalidae family, enabling agile movement through dense vegetation.[19] Males exhibit slight sexual size dimorphism, being marginally larger than females in overall body measurements such as mass and linear dimensions like wing chord and tail length.[12] This difference, while subtle, aligns with patterns observed in many passerine species where males invest in traits supporting territorial defense and mate attraction.[20] The bill is stout and conical, a key adaptation for cracking hard seeds, which form a primary component of the diet.[2][21] This robust structure allows efficient processing of sunflower seeds and other tough-shelled foods, with its form reflecting evolutionary pressures from seed-predation habits rather than marked intraspecific variation tied to local diets.[22] The legs are relatively short and sturdy, supporting a perching lifestyle in shrubs and low branches, while the feet feature an anisodactyl arrangement—three toes directed forward and one backward—facilitating secure grips during foraging and nesting activities.[23] This foot morphology also enables effective hopping on the ground to search for insects and fallen seeds, balancing arboreal and terrestrial behaviors essential to the species' habitat use.[24]Distribution and habitat
Geographic range
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) has a native range spanning eastern and central North America, extending from southern Canada southward through the eastern United States to central Mexico, bounded on the east by the Atlantic coast and on the west by the Great Plains, with isolated populations in the southwestern deserts.[25] In the northern portion of its range, it reaches southeastern Ontario and parts of the Maritime provinces, while in the south, it occurs across much of Mexico to the Yucatán Peninsula.[25] The species has undergone significant northward range expansion since the mid-19th century, facilitated by habitat alterations from agriculture, urbanization, and the provision of bird feeders, which have enabled breeding populations to establish farther north, including regular occurrences in southern Ontario by the late 20th century.[25] This expansion accelerated in the 20th century, with the northern limit advancing from the Ohio River valley to beyond the Great Lakes region.[3] Introduced populations have become established outside the native range, notably in Hawaii, where the species was released multiple times between 1929 and 1931 and is now common across all major islands in lowland areas.[25] Smaller introduced groups persist in Bermuda and parts of southern California, though these are less widespread.[25] The Northern cardinal is primarily non-migratory and maintains year-round residency throughout its range, with only limited local movements in response to food availability or weather conditions.[1]Habitat preferences
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) prefers a variety of semi-open and edge habitats that provide a mix of dense vegetation and accessible foraging areas, including woodlands, shrublands, forest edges, and wetlands such as swamps and streamside thickets.[2][26] These birds are commonly found in areas with shrubs, small trees, and understory cover, such as thickets, overgrown fields, and mesquite groves in desert regions.[26][27] Highly adaptable to human-modified landscapes, the Northern cardinal thrives in suburban gardens, city parks, and backyards, where it benefits from artificial provisioning like bird feeders and the proliferation of edge habitats created by development.[2][19] This flexibility has contributed to its range expansion into urban and rural settings across its distribution.[19] The species occupies elevations from sea level up to 2,500 m, though it is most abundant at lower altitudes.[27] For microhabitat requirements, Northern cardinals select sites with dense shrubs, vines, or low trees for nesting and cover, typically placing nests 1–3 m above ground in concealed locations, while favoring open ground or low vegetation nearby for foraging on seeds and insects.[2][26]Behavior
Vocalizations
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) produces a variety of vocalizations, including songs and calls, with both males and females capable of singing. Songs are clear, whistled phrases consisting of repeated syllables, often described as sounding like "cheer-cheer-cheer," "purty purty purty," or "whoit cheer, whoit cheer."[28][29] Individual males typically possess repertoires of 8 to 11 distinct song types, though some may have up to 28 variants, allowing for personal and contextual variation in delivery.[30][29] These songs are usually delivered from elevated perches and serve functions such as territory defense and mate attraction, with females also singing, particularly during the breeding season.[28][31] Calls in the Northern cardinal are diverse, with at least 16 types documented, the most common being a loud, metallic "chip" note used for alarm or contact between mates and offspring.[28][29] Other calls include sharper "tink" notes and descending whinnies, which may signal aggression or warn of predators.[28][32] These calls are shorter and less structured than songs, often produced in response to immediate threats or social interactions. Acoustically, Northern cardinal songs feature pure-toned, whistle-like series with fundamental frequencies ranging from approximately 1 to 8 kHz, enabling clear transmission through their woodland habitats.[29] Songs typically comprise 2 to 4 notes per phrase, with syllables repeated in bouts that can include up to 18 repetitions before switching types.[28][31] Regional dialects occur in Northern cardinal songs, with variations in structure and syllable types observed across geographic ranges; neighboring males often share similar repertoires, while distant populations show distinct differences.[29][30] These dialects arise from cultural transmission during vocal learning, influencing responses to unfamiliar songs from other areas.[31][30]Territoriality
The Northern cardinal maintains year-round territories, with males primarily responsible for defending areas that encompass foraging grounds and potential nesting sites. These territories typically range from 0.5 to 2 hectares in size during the breeding season, though sizes can vary by habitat quality and location, such as larger ranges in northern regions.[5][19] Males employ a combination of vocal and physical defenses to maintain these territories, including singing from elevated perches to advertise boundaries and deter rivals, as well as pursuing and engaging in physical confrontations with intruding males.[1][2] Aggressive displays, such as crest-raising and direct challenges, further reinforce territorial claims during encounters.[33] As socially monogamous birds, Northern cardinals form pair bonds that last multiple seasons, with mated pairs sharing and jointly defending the territory against intruders of the same sex. Females actively participate in defense, particularly during the breeding period, by singing and chasing away competitors, contributing to the pair's overall territorial integrity.[1][34][19] Intraspecific aggression often manifests in attacks on perceived threats, including reflections in windows, mirrors, or vehicle surfaces, which birds mistake for rival cardinals; both sexes exhibit this behavior, sometimes persistently for hours or even months, especially in spring.[1][2]Diet and foraging
The Northern cardinal's diet is omnivorous, consisting primarily of vegetable matter including seeds, fruits, and buds, supplemented by insects and other invertebrates. Annual consumption averages approximately 71% vegetable foods and 29% animal matter, with common plant items encompassing weed and grass seeds, berries from species such as dogwood (Cornus), sumac (Rhus), and blackberry (Rubus), as well as buds and waste grains.[35] Animal components feature beetles, caterpillars, grasshoppers, true bugs, flies, spiders, and occasionally snails or centipedes.[3][2] During the breeding season, insects constitute a greater share of the diet to meet elevated protein demands.[35] In winter, the emphasis shifts toward fruits and seeds, including berries and grains, which provide reliable energy sources when insect availability declines.[2] Cardinals readily exploit supplemental foods at bird feeders, favoring black oil sunflower seeds that their robust bills can efficiently process.[3] Northern cardinals forage primarily on the ground or in low shrubs and understory vegetation, hopping methodically to uncover hidden items amid leaf litter or foliage.[3] They employ their strong, conical bills to crack open seeds and husks, discarding shells while consuming the kernels, a technique well-suited to their granivorous habits.[2] Foraging typically occurs within defended territories, often in pairs during breeding or small flocks in non-breeding periods, and they derive much of their hydration from moisture in foods like fruits.[15][3]Reproduction
Breeding season and mating
The breeding season of the Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) varies geographically, typically spanning March to September in the northern portions of its range, where cooler temperatures limit activity to warmer months. In southern regions, such as Texas, breeding can begin as early as January and extend through late August, allowing for more extended reproductive periods due to milder climates. Pairs generally produce one to three broods per year, with the first often starting in March and subsequent ones in late May to July, enabling multiple nesting attempts within a single season.[36][15] Courtship rituals commence in early spring as males intensify their singing and territorial displays to attract females. Males perform elaborate behaviors, including raising their prominent crest, swaying their bodies from side to side with heads held high, and engaging in beak-to-beak food transfers to the female, which strengthens pair bonds. These displays are often accompanied by soft singing, with pairs frequently producing duets that incorporate elements of their vocal repertoire, such as whistled phrases, to coordinate and affirm mutual interest.[2][3][37] Northern cardinals exhibit social monogamy, forming pairs that typically last for the breeding season, though some bonds persist year-round and across multiple years. Up to 20% of pairs may dissolve between seasons, particularly following unsuccessful breeding attempts, leading to re-pairing the following year. Genetic studies indicate occasional extra-pair copulations, with 9–35% of nestlings sired by males other than the social partner, suggesting some flexibility in mating despite the predominant monogamous structure.[3][15][9] Female mate selection emphasizes territory quality, as males defending areas with denser vegetation and better resources achieve higher reproductive success, indirectly influencing female choice through the promise of superior nesting sites and foraging opportunities. Song characteristics may also play a role in assessment, with females potentially evaluating vocal performance during courtship to gauge male fitness, though direct preferences for specific song traits remain less conclusively documented.[38]Nest construction and site selection
Northern cardinals select nest sites in dense vegetation to minimize predation risk, typically placing nests in forks of small branches within shrubs, saplings, or vine tangles 1–3 m above the ground.[3] Preferred locations include thorny plants such as hawthorn, rose bushes, and blackberry brambles, as well as dogwood, honeysuckle, grapevines, redcedar, spruce, pines, hemlock, elms, sugar maples, and box elders, which provide concealment and structural support.[3] The female chooses the site, often with the male accompanying her during scouting visits 1–2 weeks before breeding begins, assessing potential spots by carrying nesting material.[3] Nest construction is performed almost entirely by the female, who shapes a cup-like structure over 3–9 days, occasionally receiving materials from the male.[3] The nest consists of multiple layers: an outer foundation of coarse twigs (sometimes incorporating trash like paper or cloth), a mat of leaves or bark strips (often grapevine), and an inner lining of finer materials such as grasses, stems, rootlets, or pine needles for softness and insulation.[3] The female crushes twigs with her beak, weaves them into place, and molds the cup by rotating within it and pressing with her feet and breast.[3] Completed nests measure approximately 10 cm in outer diameter and 5–7 cm in depth, with an inner cup about 7–8 cm across.[3] Northern cardinals rarely reuse old nests from previous seasons, preferring to build new ones for each breeding attempt.[3] If a nest is predated early in the cycle, pairs often construct replacement nests nearby to continue the breeding effort.[3]Eggs and incubation
The Northern cardinal typically lays a clutch of 2–5 eggs, with an average of 3.[2] Eggs are laid one per day until the clutch is complete.[9] Northern cardinal eggs are whitish to pale bluish or greenish white, finely speckled or blotched with brown, purple, or gray.[2] They measure approximately 20–27 mm in length and 18–20 mm in width.[3] Incubation is performed solely by the female and lasts 11–13 days, beginning after the last egg is laid.[9] During this period, the male feeds the incubating female at or near the nest.[9] Hatching is generally synchronous, with eggs typically emerging within a few hours of one another, though larger clutches may exhibit some asynchrony.[9]Nestlings and parental care
Northern cardinal nestlings are altricial, hatching with sparse tufts of grayish down, closed eyes, and limited mobility.[3] The nestling period typically lasts 9–10 days, during which the young grow rapidly and develop initial feathers.[39] By 7–8 days old, wing feathers begin emerging from their sheaths, marking the onset of plumage development that continues post-fledging.[17] Both parents share in provisioning the nestlings, with males often delivering a greater proportion of feeds—approximately 57% of trips in observed pairs—while the female primarily broods the young to maintain warmth during the early days.[39] Nestlings are fed at a rate of about 3–5 trips per hour, roughly every 15–20 minutes from dawn to dusk, to support their high metabolic demands. The diet shifts to predominantly insects and other animal matter, comprising up to 95% of provisions such as beetles, caterpillars, and grasshoppers, which provide essential protein for growth.[3][39] Nestlings communicate hunger through chattering begging calls, which intensify as parents approach with food, prompting rapid delivery.[29] To maintain nest hygiene, both parents remove or consume the young's fecal sacs, preventing the accumulation of waste that could attract predators or promote disease.[39] Fledging occurs around 9–10 days after hatching, when the young leave the nest but remain flight-challenged and heavily reliant on parental care.[39] Post-fledging dependence lasts 25–56 days, during which parents continue feeding and protecting the brood; males often assume primary responsibility for the fledglings while females may initiate a second brood.[15][39]Ecology
Predators and threats
Northern cardinals are preyed upon by several avian predators, including Cooper's hawks (Accipiter cooperii), sharp-shinned hawks (Accipiter striatus), and eastern screech-owls (Megascops asio), which target adults during foraging or flight.[15] Nest predators pose a greater threat to eggs and young, with species such as eastern gray squirrels (Sciurus carolinensis), black rat snakes (Pantherophis obsoletus), and domestic cats (Felis catus) frequently depredating nests; corvids like blue jays (Cyanocitta cristata) and American crows (Corvus brachyrhynchos) also raid nests opportunistically.[15] [40] Brood parasitism by brown-headed cowbirds (Molothrus ater) occurs occasionally in northern cardinal nests, where female cowbirds may puncture or remove host eggs before laying their own, often resulting in partial or complete nest abandonment by the cardinals. This parasitism reduces reproductive output, as the larger cowbird chick competes aggressively for food, though cardinals sometimes eject parasitic eggs or raise mixed broods. Human-related threats exacerbate natural predation risks. Habitat fragmentation from urbanization and agriculture isolates cardinal populations, increasing exposure to edge predators and reducing available cover.[41] Pesticide use diminishes insect populations, a key protein source for nestlings, thereby lowering chick survival and overall breeding success.[8] Window collisions claim numerous adults and fledglings annually, especially in suburban and urban settings where reflective glass mimics habitat; northern cardinals are among the species commonly affected due to their bold foraging behavior near human structures.[42] [43] Climate change poses additional risks through intensified spring heat waves that can overheat nests and reduce nestling survival, as well as enabling northward range shifts that increase competition with other species.[2] Nest success rates for northern cardinals, defined as the proportion of nests fledging at least one young, typically range from 15% to 40%, with predation accounting for the majority of failures; dense shrubbery nest sites provide partial concealment but remain accessible to climbing and ground-based predators.[44] [5]Interactions with other species
The Northern cardinal engages in competitive interactions with other avian species, particularly for food and nesting resources. It competes with seed-eating birds such as house finches (Haemorhous mexicanus) and sparrows (Passer spp.) at feeders and in shrubby habitats, where overlapping diets of seeds and berries can lead to aggressive displacements. [45] [40] However, the cardinal's larger bill enables it to crack open bigger seeds like those of sunflowers, mitigating direct competition with smaller-billed species such as chickadees or titmice. [40] [18] For nesting sites, it rivals species like the gray catbird (Dumetella carolinensis) and American robin (Turdus migratorius), occasionally leading to interspecific chases or territorial disputes. [18] Northern cardinals participate in mutualistic relationships with plants through frugivory, aiding seed dispersal of berries such as those from blackberry (Rubus spp.) and elderberry (Sambucus spp.). By consuming fruits and occasionally discarding pulp or passing viable seeds in droppings, they contribute to the regeneration of understory vegetation in woodlands and edges. [35] [46] Although they often masticate small seeds, reducing overall dispersal efficiency, their role supports plant diversity in fragmented habitats. [35] Hybridization occurs rarely between Northern cardinals and the pyrrhuloxia (Cardinalis sinuatus) in overlap zones of the southwestern United States, such as Arizona and Texas, where ranges meet in desert scrub. These hybrids exhibit intermediate traits, including blended plumage patterns and bill shapes, and have been documented in both wild and captive settings, though they represent a minor fraction of encounters. [47] [48] In ecosystems, Northern cardinals play a key role in controlling insect populations by consuming pests like boll weevils (Anthonomus grandis), cutworms, and caterpillars, particularly during breeding seasons when animal matter (primarily insects) forms an increased portion of their diet (around 30-40% for adults), and nearly exclusively for nestlings. [15] [35] Their presence also serves as an indicator of habitat health, as non-migratory residents sensitive to urbanization and contaminants; studies use them to monitor environmental stressors like per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in urban versus rural areas. [49] [50]Relationship with humans
State bird designations
The Northern cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis) holds the distinction of being the official state bird for seven U.S. states, more than any other species. This widespread adoption reflects its popularity as a common, year-round resident with striking red plumage and a distinctive song that evokes beauty and vitality. The designations occurred over a span of decades, beginning with Kentucky in 1926, followed by Illinois in 1929, Indiana and Ohio in 1933, North Carolina in 1943, West Virginia in 1949, and Virginia in 1950. These choices were often driven by public enthusiasm, including votes from schoolchildren or legislative recognition of the bird's prevalence and appeal.| State | Year Designated |
|---|---|
| Kentucky | 1926 |
| Illinois | 1929 |
| Indiana | 1933 |
| Ohio | 1933 |
| North Carolina | 1943 |
| West Virginia | 1949 |
| Virginia | 1950 |