Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Rawhide Kid

The Rawhide Kid is a fictional gunslinger and outlaw hero in American comic books published by Marvel Comics, renowned for his exceptional marksmanship and commitment to justice amid the lawlessness of the Old West.^[1] Created by writer Stan Lee and artist Joe Maneely, the character debuted in Rawhide Kid #1 in March 1955 under Atlas Comics, Marvel's predecessor.^[2] Initially depicted as a nameless blonde cowboy, the series was relaunched in 1960 with a new origin for Johnny Bart, a red-haired orphan raised by his uncle, Texas Ranger Ben Bart, who becomes unjustly branded an outlaw after defending his honor in a gunfight.^[1]^[3] Throughout its run, the Rawhide Kid series exemplified Marvel's Western genre output during the 1950s and 1960s, blending fast-paced action with moral dilemmas as the protagonist roams the frontier righting wrongs while evading capture.^[4] The character's defining traits include his quick draw, youthful appearance, and reluctance to kill unnecessarily, positioning him as a heroic figure in a gritty setting.^[5] A significant relaunch occurred in the 1960s under Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, emphasizing themes of wrongful accusation and vigilante justice that paralleled emerging superhero narratives.^[6] In 2003, Marvel's mature-audience MAX imprint released Rawhide Kid: Slap Leather, a five-issue miniseries written by Ron Zimmerman that humorously portrayed the character as homosexual, drawing both acclaim for its campy style and criticism for retroactively altering the traditionally straight-laced hero to fit contemporary sensibilities.^[7]^[8] This depiction, featuring the Kid as effeminate and flirtatious, ignited debates over canon reinterpretation and cultural imposition in legacy characters, with some outlets highlighting backlash against what was seen as anachronistic identity politics in historical fiction.^[9]^[7] Despite the controversy, the Rawhide Kid remains a staple of Marvel's Western legacy, occasionally crossing over with modern superhero titles.^[3]

Publication History

Creation and Atlas Comics Era (1955–1957)

The Rawhide Kid series debuted with issue #1 (cover-dated March 1955), published by Atlas Comics, Marvel's predecessor imprint. The lead character, Johnny Clay—a tall, blonde deputy sheriff distinguished by his rawhide chaps—fought bandits, rustlers, and corrupt figures in standalone Old West tales, aided by sidekick Cornwall "Corn" Kid and horse Steamboat.^[1]^[2] These early stories prioritized themes of lawful justice, personal honor, and moral resolve against frontier chaos, portraying the protagonist as an upholder of order rather than a rogue vigilante.^[10] Creative credits for the premiere issue are disputed among researchers; writing has been attributed to Don Rico or possibly editor Stan Lee, while art credits vary between Bob Brown and Joe Maneely.^[11] Dick Ayers succeeded as primary artist from issue #6 (January 1956), contributing to the consistent visual style of dynamic gunfights and rugged landscapes through the run's conclusion.^[12] The narrative drew on archetypal Western motifs—fictionalized echoes of historical gunslingers and lawmen like Wyatt Earp—but centered heroic individualism within a framework of civic duty, avoiding anachronistic complexity.^[1] This 16-issue run (March 1955–September 1957) aligned with Atlas' proliferation of Western titles, including Kid Colt Outlaw, Two-Gun Kid, and Wyatt Earp, amid a mid-1950s genre surge driven by television hits like Gunsmoke (debuting September 1955) that romanticized self-reliant heroism in an era of Cold War anxieties.^[10]^[12] Sales reflected broader market demand for escapist tales of unambiguous right versus wrong, though the line's emphasis stayed on formulaic action over deep historical fidelity.^[1] The series ended as Western comic output waned by late 1957, influenced by shifting reader tastes and Comics Code restrictions.^[3]

Silver Age Revival and Marvel Continuity (1960–1979)

The Rawhide Kid series was revived with issue #17, cover-dated August 1960, under the scripting of Stan Lee and pencils by Jack Kirby, marking one of the earliest new characters in Marvel's Silver Age output.^[13]^[14] This relaunch introduced a revised origin for Johnny Clay, portraying him as a young orphan raised by rancher Uncle Ben to master gunfighting skills with twin Colt revolvers, only to become a wanted outlaw after Ben's murder by bandits, vowing revenge while adopting a heroic stance against injustice.^[3] The narrative emphasized the protagonist's youth—depicted as a teenager skilled beyond his years—and framed him as a reluctant gunslinger fighting for the innocent, aligning with Marvel's shift toward more relatable, flawed heroes amid the publisher's broader expansion from Atlas Comics branding.^[1] Though Marvel's superhero titles began forging a shared universe around this period, the Rawhide Kid's stories remained rooted in standalone Old West adventures, occasionally incorporating serialized elements like recurring foes or multi-issue pursuits starting in the mid-1960s.^[3] Crossovers with fellow Marvel Western protagonists, such as the Two-Gun Kid, appeared in titles like Two-Gun Kid #85 (July 1967), integrating the character into a loose network of cowboy heroes without direct ties to contemporary superhero continuity.^[15] Larry Lieber, Stan Lee's brother, assumed primary writing and penciling duties by the mid-1960s, sustaining the series' focus on high-stakes gunfights, moral dilemmas, and the Kid's expert marksmanship and quick draw as a lone defender of frontier justice.^[16]^[3] The title persisted monthly through issue #48 in 1967 before continuing irregularly to its conclusion with #151 (May 1979), as the Western genre faced declining sales amid the dominance of superhero comics.^[17]^[18] Throughout, creators preserved the Rawhide Kid's archetype as a rugged, macho gunslinger—swift, honorable, and unyielding in duels—eschewing modernization to uphold traditional pulp Western tropes despite evolving industry trends.^[3]

Sporadic Appearances and Decline (1980s–1990s)

The ongoing Rawhide Kid series concluded with issue #151 in December 1979, marking the effective end of Marvel's sustained publication of Western titles amid a genre-wide downturn.^[19] By the late 1970s, reader preferences had shifted decisively toward superhero narratives, which offered escalating stakes and fantastical elements absent in traditional Westerns, resulting in the cancellation of long-running books like Kid Colt, Outlaw (1948–1979) and contributing to Rawhide Kid's archival status rather than new content.^[20] ^[21] A short-lived revival occurred in 1985 with a four-issue limited series (Rawhide Kid vol. 2, #1–4, August–November), written by Bill Mantlo and illustrated by artists including Herb Trimpe, depicting an elderly Rawhide Kid reckoning with lingering threats from his outlaw past.^[22] This miniseries, priced at $0.75 per issue, represented Marvel's exploratory foray into miniseries formats during the decade but failed to spawn further solo material, underscoring the character's marginal viability in a superhero-saturated lineup.^[23] Into the 1990s, Rawhide Kid's visibility dwindled to infrequent cameos in anthology and crossover books, such as Marvel Super-Heroes #3 (Fall 1990 special) and brief roles in Incredible Hulk #370–371 (July–August 1990), often as part of Western-themed ensembles without advancing his solo arc.^[24] These appearances aligned with Marvel's occasional nods to legacy characters in low-stakes backups, but the absence of an ongoing title or significant sales traction—mirroring the Western genre's post-1970s contraction—cemented the Kid's decline into obscurity until later revivals.^[25]

MAX Imprint Miniseries and Retcons (2002–2003)

In 2003, Marvel Comics published the five-issue miniseries Rawhide Kid: Slap Leather under its MAX imprint, which was designated for mature-audience titles featuring more explicit content and themes unsuitable for the mainstream all-ages line.^[26] The series, written by Ron Zimmerman and penciled by John Severin, reimagined the Rawhide Kid as an alternate-universe character openly portrayed as gay, incorporating heavy sexual innuendo and campy humor centered on his exploits in the Old West.^[27] Issue #1, cover-dated April 2003, launched the storyline, with subsequent issues following monthly through August 2003, positioning it as a deliberate departure from the character's prior depictions to appeal to adult readers amid Marvel's early-2000s experimentation with edgier, non-traditional interpretations of legacy properties.^[28] Explicitly set outside the main Marvel Universe continuity of Earth-616, the miniseries did not introduce retcons or alterations to the established Rawhide Kid's canonical history, instead functioning as a standalone, parallel-universe tale marketed for its provocative reinterpretation rather than integration into ongoing narratives.^[29] This approach aligned with the MAX line's mandate for self-contained stories unbound by standard continuity constraints, allowing for thematic risks without impacting the core character's 19th-century gunslinger persona from earlier Atlas and Marvel publications.^[30] The project generated initial industry buzz primarily through its shock value and media publicity, contributing to it being projected as one of the highest-selling Western comics in years at the time, though exact sales data remains limited in public records.^[31]

Fictional Character Profile

Origin Story and Canonical Biography

Johnny Clay, later known as the Rawhide Kid, was born in 1850 in the American Midwest during the frontier era.^[32] Orphaned as an infant following the death of his parents, he was adopted and raised by Ben Bart, a rancher and former Texas Ranger, on a ranch near the town of Rawhide, Texas.^[1] Bart trained the young Clay in marksmanship, horsemanship, and frontier survival skills, fostering his proficiency with twin revolvers and a swift horse.^[5] In 1868, Ben Bart was murdered by the Clayton gang, who sought to seize the family ranch.^[1] Clay pursued the outlaws, gunning down two of them in a confrontation and wounding a third, who escaped.^[1] To evade retribution from the surviving Clayton associates and continue his quest for justice without endangering the town, Clay adopted the alias of the Rawhide Kid, altering his appearance with a distinctive yellow shirt and bandana.^[1] By 1870, after clearing his name from a false murder charge related to the killings, he fully embraced the Rawhide Kid persona as a wandering gunslinger dedicated to combating outlaws and upholding frontier law through personal vigilance.^[32] The Rawhide Kid's canonical adventures, set in the post-Civil War American West, emphasize self-reliant pursuit of criminals without reliance on formal authorities or supernatural aid.^[5] His interactions in early stories consistently portray straightforward heterosexual dynamics, such as romantic interests in female characters, with no textual ambiguity regarding his orientation.^[1] Key exploits involve single-handedly dismantling bandit gangs, resolving range wars, and delivering rough justice to corrupt sheriffs and claim jumpers, all rooted in verifiable depictions from the character's primary 1960s continuity.^[5]

Personality Traits and Skills

The Rawhide Kid, whose real name is Johnny Clay, is depicted as a stoic and quick-tempered gunslinger archetype in his canonical Marvel Comics appearances, driven by a rigid moral code centered on personal honor and opposition to corruption. Despite his small stature and youthful demeanor, Clay exhibits exceptional courage, often intervening to protect the vulnerable from bandits and unjust authority figures, reflecting the traditional Western hero's emphasis on individual justice over institutional law.^[33]^[5]^[34] This characterization prioritizes self-reliance and ethical integrity, with Clay's temper flaring in response to betrayal or cowardice, yet tempered by a commitment to fair play in duels and confrontations. Unlike later reinterpretations in non-canonical miniseries that introduced flamboyant elements, the Earth-616 version maintains a reserved, no-nonsense persona focused on rectifying wrongs through decisive action rather than showmanship.^[5]^[35] Clay possesses no superhuman abilities, relying instead on peak human conditioning honed through rigorous practice and frontier survival. He is renowned as one of the premier gunslingers of the American Southwest, with unparalleled marksmanship using twin Colt revolvers, potentially ambidextrous for rapid dual-wielding, and proficiency in rifles, shotguns, and derringers for varied combat scenarios.^[36] Complementing his firearms expertise, Clay excels in strategic hand-to-hand combat, often outmaneuvering larger opponents through speed, agility, and tactical wit rather than brute strength, while also demonstrating skilled horsemanship and use of a rawhide whip for disarming foes or controlling mounts. These traits underscore his archetype as a nimble fighter who leverages precision and intellect to prevail in gunfights and brawls.^[5]^[36]^[37]

Role in Marvel Universe Crossovers

The Rawhide Kid's earliest verified crossovers within the Marvel Universe occurred in the shared continuity of Marvel's Western titles during the early 1960s, integrating him with other period heroes like Kid Colt and the Two-Gun Kid. These team-ups, such as those depicted in Rawhide Kid #25 (August 1962), involved collaborative efforts against outlaws and threats in the Old West, reinforcing a proto-team dynamic among Marvel's cowboy protagonists without introducing supernatural elements beyond standard gunplay.^[38] Similar interactions extended to anthology formats, including frequent appearances alongside Kid Colt and Two-Gun Kid in issues of Kid Colt, Outlaw and Two-Gun Kid, establishing a loose "Weird Western" alliance that emphasized frontier justice over broader Marvel lore.^[20] By the 1970s, crossovers expanded into larger ensemble stories, notably the Sensational Seven arc in Rawhide Kid #41–48 (1974–1975), where the Rawhide Kid joined forces with Two-Gun Kid and Kid Colt (replaced intermittently by other Western figures) to combat escalating menaces like the Circus of Crime. These narratives, later echoed in Giant-Size reprints and specials such as Giant-Size Kid Colt #1 (1975), highlighted tactical gunfighting synergies but remained confined to historical settings, serving as nostalgic fillers amid Marvel's superhero dominance.^[39] One rare incursion into modern-era continuity appeared in Avengers #142 (December 1975), where the Rawhide Kid, portrayed as Johnny Bart in 1873, briefly allied with Thor against time-displaced foes including the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, without altering his core gunslinger persona or achieving lasting ties to contemporary heroes. Such limited integrations underscored the character's role as a temporal curiosity, providing Western flavor to superhero tales but exerting negligible causal influence on overarching Marvel events like Avengers arcs or multiversal crises.^[40]^[41]

Alternative Versions

Marvel Zombies Universe

In the Marvel Zombies 5 miniseries (2010), the Rawhide Kid is portrayed as a reanimated corpse in the alternate Earth-483, a zombie-infested variant of the American Old West. A meteorite infected with the zombie plague crashes near the town of Rango, emitting radiation that revives all buried dead, including the long-deceased Rawhide Kid from his grave in the local cemetery.^[42] This undead iteration preserves the character's exceptional gunslinging accuracy and quick-draw reflexes but subordinates them entirely to insatiable hunger for living flesh, stripping away any prior moral compass or sense of justice.^[43] The zombified Rawhide Kid allies with other resurrected Western figures, such as Two-Gun Kid, Kid Colt, and the Phantom Rider, forming a horde that assaults Rango in a rampage of cannibalism and violence, exemplifying the erosion of chivalric frontiersman ideals into primal savagery.^[42] The group overwhelms initial defenses, feasting on townsfolk, until confronted and ultimately destroyed by Hurricane Kane's daughter, Jackie Kane, who inherits wind-manipulating powers and dispatches the zombies, including her own turned parents.^[44] This cameo highlights the horror genre's inversion of heroic archetypes, with no carryover effects to the primary Marvel Universe timeline.^[45]

Battleworld in Secret Wars

In the Secret Wars (2015) crossover event orchestrated by writer Jonathan Hickman, a variant of the Rawhide Kid manifests as a member of the Thor Corps, Battleworld's multiversal police force tasked with upholding the rule of God Emperor Doom. This iteration, drawn from a frontier-styled domain evoking the American Old West, embodies the character's gunslinger prowess reimagined with Mjolnir-wielding authority, patrolling the fractured planet assembled from colliding realities following the Beyonders' multiversal incursion. The Thor Corps, comprising domain-specific Thors, responds to threats like interdimensional smuggling and domain incursions, with the Rawhide Kid variant exemplifying adapted survival tactics against escalated perils. Depicted in Jason Aaron's Thors miniseries (October–December 2015), the Rawhide Kid Thor engages in enforcement actions, including the arrest of Hank Pym—a variant Ant-Man—for trafficking adamantium across Battleworld's shielded territories, an infraction that underscores the Corps' role in maintaining fragile order amid patchwork societies. His brief appearances emphasize rapid marksmanship and frontier grit, confronting adversaries with a blend of Western dueling precision and Asgardian might, such as during probes into serial killings by the warped All-Mother. This action-focused portrayal prioritizes tactical confrontations over deep character exploration, highlighting the variant's utility in Doom's synthetic hierarchy rather than personal backstory.^[46] As Battleworld unravels in Secret Wars #9 (cover date December 2015, on sale December 9), the Rawhide Kid variant, like other domain constructs, disintegrates with the restoration of the prime Marvel multiverse, reinforcing the event's theme of impermanent realities forged from catastrophe. This dissolution precludes lasting integration into Earth-616 continuity, positioning the appearance as a self-contained element of Hickman's narrative on multiversal collapse and rebirth.

Other Non-Canonical Depictions

In the 2010 five-issue miniseries The Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven, written by Ron Zimmerman and drawn by Howard Chaykin, the Rawhide Kid forms a posse comprising fellow Marvel Western characters such as Kid Colt, the Two-Gun Kid, and the Outlaw Kid to rescue Wyatt and Morgan Earp from the bandit Cristo Pike and his gang in the late 19th century. The narrative emphasizes high-stakes gunfights, banter among outlaws, and satirical nods to Western tropes, with the Kid depicted as a dapper, quick-witted leader whose flamboyance—stemming from the 2003 MAX retcon—serves comedic purposes without dominating the action-oriented plot. This standalone story integrates brief cameos from figures like Ghost Rider (as a sheriff), diverging from strict continuity by prioritizing ensemble humor over canonical biography.^[47]^[48]^[49] No What If? issues or similar hypothetical scenarios featuring the Rawhide Kid have been published by Marvel, limiting explorations of alternate paths such as an aged version evolving into an elder gunslinger statesman. Reprints of classic Rawhide Kid tales, such as those in Marvel Masterworks volumes collecting issues from the 1950s–1970s series, preserve original depictions without introducing new variants, focusing instead on archival preservation of the character's early heroic outlaw persona.^[50]^[51]

Adaptations in Other Media

Comic Crossovers and Team-Ups

The Rawhide Kid has featured in multiple comic book crossovers and team-ups within Marvel's Western publications, often alongside other period heroes. A notable early example occurred in Rawhide Kid #40 (June 1964), where the character collaborated with the Two-Gun Kid to confront mutual threats in the Old West.^[52] Similarly, Rawhide Kid #50 (1966) depicted a partnership with Kid Colt the Outlaw, emphasizing shared gunfighting prowess against outlaws.^[53] These team-ups extended to anthology formats, such as appearances in Mighty Marvel Western #2 (1968), which reprinted or featured Western hero interactions.^[39] In a more contemporary crossover, the 2023 miniseries Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven united the Kid with historical gunslingers like Wyatt Earp and Billy the Kid, plus Marvel counterparts including Two-Gun Kid and Kid Colt, in a narrative blending fact and fiction.^[54] Such stories, along with reprints of classic team-ups like the first Rawhide Kid–Kid Colt–Two-Gun Kid encounter from Two-Gun Kid #89, have been digitized for platforms like Marvel Unlimited since the 2010s, enhancing accessibility without venturing into non-print media.^[39] No verified animated series or live-action films have adapted these crossovers, confining the character's collaborative exploits to comic formats amid the Western genre's limited mainstream expansion.

Potential Live-Action and Animation References

Despite periodic fan advocacy and speculative discussions within comic communities, the Rawhide Kid has not been adapted into any live-action film or television project as of 2025.^[55]^[56] Online forums and industry speculation have occasionally proposed the character for inclusion in Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) productions, such as casting suggestions for actors like Colton Haynes in a Western-themed entry, but these remain unconfirmed and undeveloped by Marvel Studios.^[56]^[57] Similarly, no animated series or direct-to-video features featuring the Rawhide Kid have materialized, even amid broader interest in Marvel's Western properties for potential Disney+ content.^[58] Early 2000s Western revival trends in Hollywood, exemplified by films like the 2007 remake of 3:10 to Yuma, did not extend to Marvel's cowboy characters, with studio priorities shifting toward high-grossing superhero franchises following the MCU's launch in 2008.^[59] This contrasts with the Ghost Rider, another Marvel Western-inspired antihero, who received live-action films in 2007 and 2011 due to his supernatural elements aligning better with blockbuster demands for spectacle over historical grit.^[60] The character's limited cultural resonance post-1970s—when Western comics sales plummeted amid genre fatigue—has contributed to its exclusion from adaptation pipelines, as Marvel has favored IPs with established fanbases and merchandising potential over niche historical tales.^[59]^[61] Without official announcements or leaked development documents, these potentials remain hypothetical, underscoring a broader industry preference for scalable superhero narratives over pure Western revivals.^[62]

Reception and Controversies

Initial Critical and Commercial Response

The debut of The Rawhide Kid #1 in March 1955 occurred amid a surge in Western genre popularity driven by television successes like Gunsmoke, which premiered that year and ran for two decades as one of the era's top-rated programs, spurring demand for cowboy escapism in comics.^[63]^[64] The series' initial 16-issue run through September 1957 reflected modest commercial viability, as Atlas Comics (Marvel's predecessor) produced multiple Western titles to capitalize on this trend, though exact sales figures from the period remain scarce due to limited reporting.^[3] Revived in August 1960 with issue #17, featuring a retold origin and pencils by Jack Kirby inked by Dick Ayers, the title garnered praise for its straightforward heroism suited to young readers, with Ayers' artwork highlighted for professional dynamism and action-oriented panels that evoked classic Western vigor.^[65]^[66] Critics and retrospectives noted the stories' formulaic outlaw-redemption plots as typical of the genre's escapist fare, appealing amid ongoing TV Western dominance but lacking innovation compared to emerging superhero narratives.^[4] By the late 1960s, average per-issue sales hovered around 204,896 copies in 1969, placing it mid-tier among Marvel's output and signaling niche rather than blockbuster appeal as Westerns faced competition from superheroes.^[67] The prolonged but inconsistent run into the 1970s underscored declining genre interest, with short initial bursts and reliance on reliable art like Ayers' contributing to sustained but unremarkable performance.^[68]

Legacy in Western Genre Comics

The revival of the Rawhide Kid in Rawhide Kid #17 (August 1960), written by Stan Lee and penciled by Jack Kirby, represented a pivotal shift in Marvel's approach to Western comics, introducing serialized continuity, deeper character motivations, and high-stakes action that tested narrative techniques later refined in the superhero era with [Fantastic Four](/page/Fantastic Four) #1 (November 1961).^[3] This reinvention transformed the titular hero from a generic gunslinger into a reluctant outlaw with a code of honor, serving as an archetype for Marvel's Western protagonists and influencing the revival of titles like Two-Gun Kid through shared stylistic elements such as moral ambiguity and explosive confrontations.^[6] According to comic historian accounts, these innovations in pre-superhero Westerns provided a low-risk proving ground for Marvel's evolving creative formula, emphasizing personality-driven plots over formulaic adventures.^[1] Rawhide Kid's longevity, with the series spanning 151 issues from 1960 to 1979, underscored its role in sustaining Marvel's Western output amid declining genre sales in the 1960s, while crossovers in anthologies like Marvel Super-Action integrated it into ensemble stories with figures such as the Phantom Rider, foreshadowing hybrid Western-superhero narratives in later decades.^[69] These appearances helped prototype multi-character dynamics, blending lone-wolf heroism with team-oriented conflicts, though the character's influence remained confined to Marvel's niche Western revival rather than broadly reshaping the genre.^[70] Reprints in collections such as Marvel Masterworks: Rawhide Kid (2006) and Essential Rawhide Kid (2006) affirm its archival significance, preserving early Lee-Kirby collaborations for historical study and highlighting contributions to comic book serialization before the dominant superhero shift.^[71] However, empirical measures of enduring impact—such as modern appearances and adaptations—reveal Rawhide Kid overshadowed by DC's Jonah Hex, which sustained popularity through consistent revivals and multimedia extensions into the 21st century, while Marvel's Westerns largely faded post-1970s.^[72]

Debates Over Sexual Orientation Retcon

In the 2002 Marvel MAX miniseries The Rawhide Kid, writer Ron Zimmerman reimagined the character, originally introduced in 1955 as a rugged gunslinger in Atlas Comics' Rawhide Kid #1, as openly homosexual, marking Marvel's first title starring an explicitly gay protagonist in a mainstream line aimed at mature readers.^[73] This non-canonical portrayal emphasized innuendo-laden dialogue and flamboyant mannerisms, such as fussing over attire, which proponents hailed as groundbreaking queer representation in Western comics, bucking traditional heteronormative tropes amid early 2000s pushes for diversity in superhero media.^[9] Supporters, including Zimmerman, argued it celebrated queer masculinity by blending heroism with camp elements, defending "sissy" traits against antagonists while maintaining the character's gunslinging prowess.^[74] Critics, however, contended the retcon disrespected the character's macho origins, transforming a symbol of frontier masculinity into a caricature reliant on gay stereotypes like lisping speech and double entendres, as evidenced in reader letters and contemporary reviews decrying lines such as those playing on phallic imagery in gunplay.^[75]^[76] Longtime fans labeled the change "abominable," viewing it as a commercial gimmick to capitalize on cultural shifts toward inclusion without altering the main continuity, where the Kid remained heterosexual.^[77] Some gay readers and commentators echoed this, calling it an insult to the community for perpetuating offensive tropes akin to outdated ethnic caricatures, with one review noting it reinforced rather than shattered effeminate gay clichés, potentially alienating audiences on both sides of the political spectrum.^[78]^[79] The debates pitted conservative objections—emphasizing fidelity to 1950s source material and concerns over "pandering" to progressive agendas—against claims of narrative progress, though sales figures for the five-issue series, which did not spawn ongoing success or canon integration, suggested limited acclaim beyond niche interest.^[7]^[80] This polarization highlighted broader tensions in comics over retrofitting legacy characters for modern sensibilities, with no subsequent mainline adoption of the orientation shift.^[75]

Fan and Creator Criticisms

Fans expressed significant backlash against the 2003 Rawhide Kid: Slap Leather miniseries for altering the character's established heterosexual persona into an openly gay gunslinger, viewing the retcon as unnecessary pandering that undermined decades of canon.^[77] Long-time readers denounced the change as "abominable," arguing it disrespected the character's origins as a rugged Western hero created in 1955, with complaints centering on the series' reliance on campy stereotypes like lisping dialogue and fashion obsessions that caricatured gay men rather than portraying authentic representation.^[77] ^[75] Some gay fans and critics echoed these concerns, labeling the depiction an "insult to the homosexual community" akin to outdated ethnic caricatures, with the humor seen as tone-deaf and reliant on offensive tropes for shock value rather than substantive storytelling.^[78] ^[81] Creator Ron Zimmerman, who wrote the series, defended it as satirical comedy modeled after Blazing Saddles, intending the Rawhide Kid as a "bad-ass" figure using innuendo for laughs without explicit content, though he acknowledged the concept originated from editorial direction.^[8] In contrast, writer Chuck Dixon criticized the portrayal as a publicity stunt that insulted both gay audiences and traditional fans by forcing a sexual orientation retrofit onto a legacy character, suggesting Marvel should have created a new gay hero instead to avoid diluting established lore.^[78] ^[82] Dixon further claimed his public objections contributed to professional repercussions, including reduced opportunities at Marvel, highlighting perceived industry intolerance for dissenting views on such retcons.^[83] Overall reception remained polarized, with some reviews praising the art by John Severin while faulting the script for prioritizing gimmickry over narrative depth, reflecting broader tensions in early 2000s comics where identity-focused revivals often prioritized controversy over consensus acclaim.^[84] ^[76] This division underscored criticisms that the series exemplified a shift toward identity-driven content at the expense of genre fidelity, evidenced by sharply split fan forums and media coverage rather than widespread endorsement.^[75]^[77]

References

[1]
The Rawhide Kid - Don Markstein's Toonopedia
Rawhide's real name was Johnny Bart. He was an orphan of the Indian wars, raised by his dad's brother, Texas Ranger Ben Bart, near the town of Rawhide, Texas ( ...<|separator|>
[2]
Rawhide Kid #1 Published March 1955 - Key Collector Comics
Rawhide Kid. Published. March 1955. Creators. Artist. Joe Maneely. Writer. Stan Lee. Synopsis. Note: This issue features the first appearance of the Rawhide Kid ...
[3]
THE RAWHIDE KID and — Perhaps — the True Birth of the ...
May 8, 2025 · Prior to that issue, the title character was a nameless blonde gunman who was like many other comic book Western heroes at the time: fast on the ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[4]
50 Years Ago -- The Rawhide Kid! - Bob Batchelor
Dec 17, 2021 · The Rawhide Kid sprung to life in the mid-1950s when Marvel was called Atlas and a young editor named Stan Lee needed to find exciting (yet wholesome) heroes.
[5]
Rawhide Kid (Character) - Comic Vine
Mar 20, 2024 · The Rawhide Kid is Johnny Bart, one of Marvel's best-known Western heroes. Though branded an outlaw, he continues to fight for right and justice.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[6]
Lee & Kirby: The Two Origins of the Rawhide Kid
Jun 27, 2021 · ... Rawhide Kid, in 1960, a response in part to the popularity of the RAWJIDE television series. Editor Stan Lee scripted this one himself, and ...
[7]
Tall in the saddle | Books | The Guardian
Aug 9, 2003 · Much of the current controversy surrounds Marvel's The Rawhide Kid, a 'gay western' title launched earlier this year and soon to be published as ...Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
[8]
Gay gunslinger is target for comics controversy | The Seattle Times
Feb 18, 2003 · This month, Marvel Comics begins what could be its most controversial title to date, and also its funniest, "Rawhide Kid: Slap Leather." The ...Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
[9]
Marvel's gay Rawhide Kid is bucking the backlash
May 12, 2003 · The comic-book giant has just revived an old Western gunslinger the Rawhide Kid. In the '50s the well-groomed Kid was said to be shy around women.Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
[10]
Atlas's Western Comics: An Old Idea with Some New Twists %
Apr 10, 2018 · Rawhide Kid #1–16 tells the story of a blonde cowboy, only ever referred to as “Rawhide Kid,” who rides from town to town righting wrongs. And, ...
[11]
Rawhide Kid (Marvel, 1955 series) #1 - GCD :: Issue
Don Rico identified as early Rawhide Kid scripter by Jerry Bails. Previous indexer credited Stan Lee. Splash panel appears to be drawn by an unknown artist.
[12]
13 COVERS: It's the 70th Anniversary of THE RAWHIDE KID
Dec 14, 2024 · Dick Ayers took over the interior art with the sixth issue (Jan. 1956) and remained on the title through the final issue, #16 (Sept. 1957).
[13]
Rawhide Kid (1955) #17 | Comic Issues - Marvel.com
Published. August 01, 1960. From the incomparable Stan Lee comes Rawhide Kid! This hidden gem brings the word "Western" to a whole new level.
[14]
The Rawhide Kid (Marvel, 1960 series) #17 - GCD :: Issue
Information about the comic The Rawhide Kid #17, which has a publication date of August 1960 and was published by Marvel.Missing: relaunch | Show results with:relaunch
[15]
Two-Gun Kid #85 1967-Marvel-Rawhide Kid crossover-FN
This item can be returned in its original condition for a full refund or replacement within 30 days of receipt. You may receive a partial or no refund on ...
[16]
Larry Lieber - Lambiek Comiclopedia
Nov 29, 2022 · Larry Lieber is an American comic book artist, known for drawing Marvel's 'Rawhide Kid' and the newspaper strips of the 'Incredible Hulk' and 'The Amazing ...<|separator|>
[17]
Series :: The Rawhide Kid - GCD - Grand Comics Database
Publisher: Marvel ; Publication Dates: August 1960 - May 1979 ; Number of Issues Published: 135 (#17 - #151) ; Color: color cover; color interior ; Dimensions: ...
[18]
The Rawhide Kid (Marvel, 1960 series) #151 - GCD :: Issue
Information about the comic The Rawhide Kid #151, which has a publication date of May 1979 and was published by Marvel.
[19]
A Rambling Chronicle of Marvel's Western Comics
Nov 27, 2018 · In 1979 the western genre at Marvel was basically declared dead, with Rawhide Kid and Kid Colt finally canceled. The latter after over 30 years ...Missing: era boom
[20]
More Marvel Cowboys: Kid Colt - Outlaw
Jan 20, 2024 · , becoming the sixth Marvel Western comic and the third cowboy to appear in his own title. ... cancelled with issue 229 (Apr 1979), an incredible ...
[21]
Comics of the American West - The PorPor Books Blog
Sep 29, 2019 · Horn chronicles the slow but inexorable decline of the Western genre in U.S. comics and comic strips as the 70s unfolded, when Marvel began ...
[22]
Series :: Rawhide Kid - GCD - Grand Comics Database
Rawhide Kid (1985 series). Published in English (United States) United States. Random Cover from Series #2. September 1985. Cover Gallery. Publisher: Marvel.
[23]
Rawhide Kid Issue # 1 (Marvel Comics) - Comic Book Realm
Issue: # 1, Rawhide Kid Issue # 1's cover image. Cover Date: Aug '85. Cover Price: $0.75. Current Value: $5.00 Historical Pricing Values. Searched: 719.
[24]
Rawhide Kid (modern appearances only) - Earth's Mightiest Blog
MARVEL COMICS PRESENTS #116 (1992): Two-Gun Kid · NAMOR VS HULK by ERNIE CHAN · SOVIET SUPER SOLDIERS (1992) · AVENGERS #203 (1981) · MARC SPECTOR: MOON KNIGHT ...
[25]
The Resurgence of Western Comic Books in the Late 1960s and ...
May 21, 2022 · The Seventies saw the cancellation of the long running Westerns Bonanza and Gunsmoke. Even readership for Western fiction began declining in ...
[26]
RAWHIDE KID VOL. 1: SLAP LEATHER (2003) | Comic Series | Marvel
Free delivery 30-day returnsBrowse the Marvel comic series RAWHIDE KID VOL. 1: SLAP LEATHER (2003). Check out individual issues, and find out how to read them!Missing: figures | Show results with:figures
[27]
RAWHIDE KID VOL. 1: SLAP LEATHER (Trade Paperback)
Jan 1, 2003 · Published. January 01, 2003. Writer Ron Zimmerman and legendary Western comics artist John Severin take aim at the lovable redheaded Western ...
[28]
Rawhide Kid Issue # 1 (MAX Comics)
Issue: # 1, Rawhide Kid Issue # 1's cover image. Cover Date: Apr '03. Cover Price: $2.99. Current Value: $3.00 Historical Pricing Values. Searched: 594.Missing: canonical 616
[29]
The Rawhide Kid MAX - YouTube
Dec 23, 2022 · In 2003, Marvel published a new mini-series built around the Rawhide Kid. In a break with continuity, this version of the Kid was gay and ...Missing: appearances 1990s
[30]
RAWHIDE KID MAX #1 by Zimmerman and Severin
From the Marvel Max adults-only imprint. This copy is in good second hand condition, with some minor damage to the cover and spine.<|control11|><|separator|>
[31]
Article 10: 2002 Backwards - Ninth Art
By sheer weight of publicity, RAWHIDE KID looks set to be the highest selling western in years. Mainstream press coverage and controversy never did anyone any ...
[32]
Rawhide Kid - Alchetron, The Free Social Encyclopedia
Sep 23, 2024 · Johnny Clay was born in 1850 and orphaned as an infant, adopted by Ben Bart. In 1868 his "uncle" was murdered and he left the family ranch. In ...<|separator|>
[33]
RAWHIDE KID WEDNESDAY 114 - Tony Isabella's Bloggy Thing
Jun 21, 2017 · Something about his short stature, but large courage, honor and fighting skills speaks to me. After rereading the Kid's earliest adventures when ...Missing: personality traits
[34]
Rawhide Kid (1955) #29 | Comic Issues | Marvel
Rawhide Kid (1955) #29 ... Known for his larger-than-life identity, The Kid is truly what his nickname implies...a kid. In terms of size and stature he is small ...
[35]
RAWHIDE KID WEDNESDAY 71 - Tony Isabella's Bloggy Thing
Jan 20, 2016 · Something about the short of stature (but big on courage and fighting skills) Johnny Clay spoke to the short of stature (but big on comics- ...
[36]
Jonathan Clay (Earth-616) | Marvel Database | Fandom
The man later known as the Rawhide Kid was born in 1850 in the Midwest America during the days of the American Frontier. During his infancy, his parents were ...History · Origins · Interactions with Time Travellers · Uncertain ChronologyMissing: biography | Show results with:biography
[37]
Rawhide Kid - International Superheroes
Powers/Abilities: Expert shot. Skilled rider. History: (Kid Colt #59, 121, 229, Mighty Marvel Western #1-46, Rawhide Kid I #1-151, ga) After his parents were ...
[38]
Rawhide Kid - the Sensational Seven - Marvel Chronology Project
May 30, 2017 · Kid Colt and Two-Gun Kid crossed over frequently with Rawhide Kid in his series and their own series. So based upon these events, it is ...
[39]
Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven Comic Book Review - Facebook
Jan 10, 2025 · The Rawhide Kid was created by Stan Lee and Bob (SUPERBOY/DAREDEVIL) Brown in RAWHIDE KID#1 (March 1955). Larry Lieber, Stan Lieber's brother, ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[40]
The Avengers #142 - Go West, Young Gods! (Issue) - Comic Vine
Jul 31, 2019 · Go West, Young Gods! Thor, Moondragon and Immortus travel back to the year 1873 searching for their missing comrade!
[41]
Avengers #142 (December, 1975)
Sep 13, 2025 · We begin with the Rawhide Kid, the second version of which is the one featured in our present storyline. (As we'll soon see, having at least two ...
[42]
Marvel Zombies 5 #1 - The Dead And The Quick (Issue) - Comic Vine
MACHINE MAN IS BACK! Zombies of the multiverse, watch your rotting backs! To obtain a cure for the zombie virus for Morbius the Living Vampire, Aaron Stack, ...
[43]
Marvel Zombies 5 Characters - Comic Vine
Marvel Zombies 5 · Volume ». Volume 5. Summary. Short summary describing ... Zombie Marvel. 1. A zombified nerd from an alternate reality. Old Skull. 1. Old ...
[44]
Marvel Zombies 5 (2010) comic books - MyComicShop
4.9 113 · $12.95 delivery · 7-day returnsRawhide Kid, Red Sonja, Richie Rich, Robin, ROM, Spaceknight, Romance Comics ... Marvel Zombies 5 (2010) comic books. All Issues; In Stock. Display. Issue list ...
[45]
Marvel Zombies Reading Order, 2005-Present: Earth-2149 & Into ...
Oct 5, 2025 · ... zombie Mister Fantastic of Earth-2149, creating the divergent Earth-21050. EVIL EVOLUTION. ✓, Marvel Zombies 5 #1-5 (2010) Earth-483, Earth ...
[46]
I read some more Secret Wars tie-ins - Every Day Is Like Wednesday
May 9, 2016 · That's 1872 Pym remembering being arrested by a Thor, who is apparently a Rawhide Kid-as-Thor. ... Thors seem to just show up and zap ...
[47]
THE RAWHIDE KID: THE SENSATIONAL SEVEN (2010) - Marvel.com
Free delivery 30-day returnsBrowse the Marvel comic series THE RAWHIDE KID: THE SENSATIONAL SEVEN (2010). Check out individual issues, and find out how to read them!Missing: miniseries | Show results with:miniseries
[48]
The Rawhide Kid #1 Review - IGN
Rating 8/10 · Review by Jesse SchedeenJun 9, 2010 · Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven. The Rawhide Kid #1 Review. Marvels ... There's no particular need for Zimmerman to play up Rawhide's sexual ...
[49]
The Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven | Bookreporter.com
Dec 29, 2010 · There's a lot of blood and Old West violence, as well as themes of familial abuse, mild profanity, and plenty of innuendo as The Kid references ...Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
[50]
Rawhide Kid Masterworks Vol. 2
This page discusses in detail the contents of Rawhide Kid Marvel Masterworks Vol. 2, which reprints Rawhide Kid #26-35. Includes letters pages, house ads, ...Missing: depictions | Show results with:depictions
[51]
MASTERWORKS PREVIEW: RAWHIDE KID VOL. 1
This page discusses in detail the contents of Rawhide Kid Marvel Masterworks Vol. 1, which reprints Rawhide Kid issues #17-26. Includes letters pages, house ...Missing: depictions | Show results with:depictions
[52]
Let's Partner Up! Marvel's Western Team-Ups Reviewed!
Nov 6, 2020 · In October 1972, Outlaw Kid had introduced letters pages in #12, with Rawhide Kid following in #104. Gunhawks, an all-new series that debuted in ...
[53]
Rawhide Kid #50 1966 Marvel Comics Kid Colt Outlaw Crossover
In stock $5.75 deliveryThis is an amazing comic book featuring the Rawhide Kid and Kid Colt Outlaw characters from Marvel Comics. The story takes place in the Wild West and follows ...Missing: ups | Show results with:ups
[54]
Crossover Covers: Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven
Jul 12, 2023 · Then you'll love this miniseries, in which the Rawhide Kid teams up with not only three historical gunslingers, but also fellow Marvel cowboys ...
[55]
Marvel Studios should make a Western featuring one or more of ...
Jul 15, 2024 · For the record, Rawhide Kid was the one who was eventually revealed to be gay. ... Maybe something like adapting Secret Wars 1872 so you could ...
[56]
Casting 10 Marvel Heroes For The MCU That Still Haven't Appeared ...
Feb 3, 2024 · The Rawhide Kid broke ground as one of Marvel's first openly gay characters as well, a milestone that LGTBQ actor Colton Haynes, along with his ...
[57]
Marvel Cinematic Universe rumors
Colton Haynes will play the Rawhide Kid. LaKeith Stanfield will play Brother Voodoo. Doctor Strange, Brother Voodoo, Magik, and the Scarlet ...
[58]
Q: Did I hear correctly that Marvel is doing a Disney+ show based on ...
Sep 21, 2022 · Can't find anything at all about this, so it was probably a fake rumor. I would totally be down for a Rawhide Kid project though.Regarding a Rawhide Kid film : r/lgbt_superheroes - RedditMarvel Studios should make a Western featuring one or more of ...More results from www.reddit.com
[59]
Best Marvel Comics As Great Western MCU Film Adaptations - CBR
Aug 19, 2023 · Characters like Two-Gun Kid, Rawhide Kid, and Kid Colt appeared in the first issue, with the groundwork being laid for a 46-issue run that truly ...
[60]
10 Marvel Comics Every Western Fan Should Read - CBR
Feb 1, 2025 · For readers who want to immerse themselves in a genuine cowboy world, Rawhide Kid is the original. 1 1872 Is A Fantastic Western Adaptation.<|separator|>
[61]
Mighty Marvel Western: the Second Tier Heroes
Feb 26, 2021 · ... Marvel's trinity of Rawhide Kid, Kid Colt Outlaw, and Two-Gun Kid, or the memorability of Marvel's version of Ghost Rider/Night Rider/Phantom ...Missing: adaptations | Show results with:adaptations
[62]
Five Non-Superhero Films Marvel Studios Could Make
Aug 24, 2023 · First appearing in 1955 from Marvel's 1950s forerunner, Atlas Comics, the Rawhide Kid had been unjustly accused of a crime he didn't commit, the ...Missing: unproduced | Show results with:unproduced
[63]
GUNSMOKEr-Comic Book Cowboys, by Boyd Magers
“Gunsmoke” was certainly the most successful TV Western of all time, and the comic's 27 issue, five and a half year run, February '56-July '61 (plus a one year ...
[64]
Gunsmoke: Find out about the famous TV western & see the ...
Feb 23, 2016 · Over the years, Gunsmoke evolved from an “adult western” that featured blazing gun battles into a rather talky but magnificently staged, well- ...
[65]
<br/>Comics: Essential Rawhide Kid Volume 1 - Steve Donoghue
Dec 15, 2011 · These issues mark the high point of Marvel's extended pandering to the Westerns market, although the volume weakens its 'essential' claim by ...Missing: era boom
[66]
Essential Rawhide Kid Vol. 1 - Forum 2.0 - Captain Comics - NING
Sep 27, 2011 · Marvel's original Rawhide Kid series appeared in 1955-57. The Silver Age title continued the original's numbering. It started in 1960, with ...
[67]
Comic Book Sales Figures for 1969 - Comichron
Rawhide Kid, Marvel, 204,896. Average Copies Sold Per Issue 204,896. 37, Phantom, Charlton, 199,045. Average Copies Sold Per Issue 199,045. 38, Beetle Bailey ...Missing: 1950s | Show results with:1950s
[68]
Silver Age Best Sellers: Marvel's Rise to Dominance - GoCollect Blog
Apr 15, 2020 · 1963 - Rawhide Kid (23rd overall). Highlights: In 1963, Marvel makes its first significant move in the sales market, holding down every spot ...
[69]
https://marvelsilverage.blogspot.com/2024/01/more-marvel-cowboys-kid-colt-outlaw.html
[70]
https://marvunapp.com/Appendix6/ghostriderwildwest.htm
[71]
https://tonyisabella.blogspot.com/2017/06/rawhide-kid-wednesday-112.html
[72]
DC vs. Marvel Western Heroes | Dr. Hugh Fox III
Feb 13, 2009 · Jonah Hex first appeared in the seventies, not the fifties and sixties like most comic book Westerns, and has managed to survive to the present.
[73]
Marvel Comics unveils gay gunslinger - Dec. 13, 2002 - CNN
Dec 13, 2002 · Marvel Comics is breaking ground by introducing its first openly gay title character of a mainstream comic book, The Rawhide Kid.Missing: portrayal debates controversy
[74]
The Confluence of Heroism, Sissyhood, and Camp in The Rawhide ...
The Rawhide Kid celebrates a combination of sissy and hero, defends queer masculinity, and punishes those who commit anti–sissy crime.Missing: controversies | Show results with:controversies
[75]
Rawhide Kid #1-2 - PopMatters
Mar 19, 2003 · The debate basically came down to “Comics are for kids, and you shouldn't expose them to such horrible things as homosexuality” versus “Well, ...Missing: 2002 portrayal
[76]
Rawhide Kid #1 Review - Inside Pulse
Feb 12, 2003 · This book doesn't shatter the stereotypes of the macho male main character. It reinforces all the stereotypes of the gay male character.Missing: MAX | Show results with:MAX<|separator|>
[77]
Rawhide Kid: Slap Leather | Slings & Arrows
Well into his eighties, he turned in superb artwork, his skills undiminished, applying his long experience on parody magazines such as Cracked and on Marvel's ...
[78]
Looking To The Stars - Religion, Politics and Chuck Dixon
Jan 14, 2007 · I agree that Rawhide Kid was an insult to the homosexual community and was as stereotypically offensive to gay men as Stepin Fetchit films are to those of ...Missing: 2002 | Show results with:2002
[79]
THE SEVEN MOST MISGUIDED ATTEMPTS AT GAY ...
Sep 1, 2010 · 3) The Rawhide Kid. I hear guns can be metaphors for something. Probably the worst dialog for any gay character in comics belongs to Rawhide Kid ...
[80]
Rawhide Kid: The Sensational Seven #1 - CBR
Jun 12, 2010 · If "Rawhide Kid" was written with another minority in the lead and then having every single line of dialogue playing up on bad stereotypes (I'll ...Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
[81]
Rawhide Kid – The Sensational Seven #1 | GAY LEAGUE
Wednesday afternoon on my trip to G-Mart, my local comic shop, I spied a single copy of Rawhide Kid's newest mini, The Sensational Seven, left on the shelf.
[82]
Interview “Shakespeare's language” with Chuck Dixon
I had expressed an opinion about Marvel's decision to portray Rawhide Kid as gay. I felt that, if they were serious about having a gay character, they ...
[83]
Never meet your (super) heroes - Reveal News
Sep 22, 2018 · Chuck Dixon: The Rawhide Kid. They brought the Rawhide Kid back as gay. I said a few things online, like, “Why don't you create ...
[84]
Rawhide Kid: Slap Leather - Cartoon Art Museum
Johnny Bart made his debut in his own comic book series, Rawhide Kid, in March 1955. The series, published by Marvel Comics forerunner Atlas Comics, ...