Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Six Paths

In Buddhist cosmology, the Six Paths, also known as the six realms of samsara, represent the cyclical process of rebirth and transmigration experienced by unenlightened sentient beings, determined by the accumulation of karma from their actions in previous lives.^[1] These realms encompass six distinct domains of existence: the realm of gods (deva), demigods or titans (asura), humans, animals, hungry ghosts (preta), and hell beings (naraka), each characterized by varying degrees of suffering and pleasure influenced by karmic consequences.^[2] The concept originates from early Buddhist teachings and is prominently depicted in the Wheel of Life (Bhavachakra), a symbolic mandala illustrating the perpetual cycle of birth, death, and rebirth under the influence of ignorance, desire, and aversion.^[3] The Six Paths underscore the Buddhist doctrine of impermanence and the inevitability of dukkha (suffering) within samsara, emphasizing that all beings, regardless of their realm, remain trapped in this wheel until achieving enlightenment (nirvana) through practices such as the Eightfold Path.^[4] Among the realms, the human domain is considered particularly auspicious for spiritual progress, as it balances suffering and opportunity for ethical conduct and insight, unlike the more extreme pleasures of the god realm—which can foster complacency—or the intense torments of hell.^[5] Asuras, often depicted as jealous warriors, and pretas, tormented by insatiable hunger, highlight karmic retributions for aggression and greed, respectively, while the animal realm symbolizes ignorance and instinctual bondage.^[2] This framework not only serves as a moral guide in Mahayana and Theravada traditions but also influences Tibetan and East Asian Buddhist art and meditation practices, reinforcing the path to liberation from the cycle.^[3]

Historical Development

Origins in Early Buddhist Texts

The concept of the six paths (cha-gati in Pali, ṣaḍ-gati in Sanskrit) as realms of rebirth originated in the foundational texts of early Buddhism, particularly the Pali Canon, compiled between the 5th and 4th centuries BCE in ancient India. These scriptures outline a cosmology where sentient beings are reborn into one of six realms—hell (niraya), hungry ghosts (peta), animals (tiracchāna-yoni), humans (manussa), demigods or titans (asura), and gods (deva)—determined by the quality of their karmic actions (kamma). Early texts often enumerate five primary destinations of rebirth (apāya: hell, animals, ghosts; plus humans and gods), with asuras sometimes grouped under the deva realm or treated separately in rare instances, such as in the Itivuttara Nikaya (Iti 93).^[6] Influenced by pre-existing Indian notions of lokas or cosmic worlds, the Buddha reframed this system through the doctrine of dependent origination (paṭiccasamuppāda), emphasizing that rebirth arises interdependently from ignorance, craving, and volitional actions, rather than eternal souls or divine decree, and underscoring the impermanence (anicca) of all realms.^[7] Key enumerations of the realms and their karmic bases appear throughout the Pali Canon, particularly in the Anguttara Nikaya and Digha Nikaya. For instance, the Saṅgīti Sutta (DN 33) lists the primary destinations of rebirth, often grouping asuras with devas in Theravada interpretations, while highlighting how unwholesome karma propels beings into lower realms and wholesome karma elevates them to higher ones.^[8] The Devadūta Sutta (MN 130) illustrates karmic consequences through the vivid depiction of hellish torments inflicted by "messengers" (devadūta) on those guilty of misdeeds, serving as a moral warning against actions rooted in hatred and delusion.^[9] Similarly, the Mahānidāna Sutta (DN 15) integrates the realms into the broader chain of dependent origination, tracing how consciousness and name-and-form condition rebirth across these planes, driven by past volitions.^[10] The Anguttara Nikaya provides detailed correlations between specific karmic causes and rebirth destinations, establishing the doctrinal foundation for the six paths. For example, the Apāyasaṁvattanika Sutta (AN 8.40) explains that repeated killing of living beings leads to rebirth in hell, the animal realm, or among hungry ghosts, due to the unwholesome root of hatred (dosa).^[11] Ignorance or delusion (moha) is identified as a primary cause for rebirth in the animal realm, where beings are characterized by instinctive behaviors and limited understanding, as elaborated in suttas linking the three unwholesome roots (greed, hatred, delusion) to lower existences (e.g., AN 3.99).^[12] In contrast, ethical conduct, generosity, and wisdom foster rebirth in the human or divine realms, with the human realm prized for its balance conducive to enlightenment. In early Theravada traditions, the asura realm was often subsumed under the deva category, reflecting a focus on the transient pleasures and sufferings across all paths rather than rigid separations.^[7] This early framework laid the groundwork for later elaborations in Mahayana traditions, where the six paths were further visualized in the Wheel of Life (bhava-cakra).^[13]

Evolution in Mahayana Traditions

In Mahayana Buddhism, the concept of the six paths underwent significant expansion beginning in the 1st to 5th centuries CE, as elaborated in key sutras that reinterpreted the realms as part of a broader cosmological framework emphasizing bodhisattva practice and universal salvation.^[13] Mahayana traditions, including texts like the Avatamsaka Sutra (c. 3rd-4th century CE) and the Lotus Sutra (c. 1st century CE), formalized the asura realm as a distinct category, separating it from the deva realm due to its association with jealousy, conflict, and martial tendencies, thereby completing the sixfold structure of rebirth destinations.^[14] This development marked a shift from the early Buddhist inclusion of asuras within the heavenly spheres, positioning the asuras as semi-divine beings prone to strife against the devas, which underscored karmic consequences of anger and envy in samsaric cycling.^[7] A key evolution in Mahayana traditions transformed the six paths from literal rebirth destinations into metaphors for entrapment within samsara, where all realms illustrate the illusory nature of existence under the doctrine of emptiness (shunyata).^[15] This perspective, drawn from foundational Mahayana texts, posits that the realms lack inherent existence and arise interdependently through karma, allowing bodhisattvas to navigate them compassionately for the liberation of all beings.^[13] By the 8th century CE, Vajrayana influences further integrated the realms into meditative visualizations within mandalas, as seen in the Guhyasamaja Tantra, where practitioners contemplate the paths as symbolic domains to purify obscurations and realize non-dual awareness. (Note: While the tantra emphasizes deity mandalas, it exemplifies Vajrayana's use of cosmological structures for tantric practice.) Regional variations highlight diverse emphases across Mahayana lineages. In Tibetan Buddhism, the six paths are intricately woven into the bardo (intermediate state) teachings, particularly in texts like the Tibetan Book of the Dead, where the realms manifest as visionary experiences during death and rebirth, offering opportunities for recognition and liberation through guided contemplation.^[16] This detailed integration contrasts with East Asian traditions, such as Chinese and Japanese Pure Land schools, which often simplify the cosmology by prioritizing devotion to Amitabha Buddha's realm over elaborate realm descriptions, viewing the six paths as transient states to be transcended via faith and recitation rather than exhaustive visualization.^[13]

The Six Realms

Deva Realm

The Deva realm, known as the heavenly or god realm in Buddhist cosmology, is inhabited by devas, luminous and long-lived beings who reside in celestial abodes characterized by exquisite sensory pleasures and material splendor. These beings, often depicted with radiant bodies and divine attributes surpassing those of humans, dwell in realms like the Trayastriṃśa heaven (Tāvatiṃsa), where they enjoy luxurious palaces, gardens such as Nandanavana, and ambrosial sustenance, free from the grosser afflictions of lower realms.^[7]^[17] Despite their bliss, devas remain bound to saṃsāra, subject to eventual rebirth due to attachment to these pleasures, as their existence is impermanent and ends when accumulated merit depletes.^[18]^[17] Rebirth into the Deva realm arises from virtuous (kuśala) karma, particularly actions rooted in generosity (dāna), moral conduct (sīla), and meditative development, which generate the wholesome volitions necessary for such favorable conditions. For instance, practices like almsgiving, upholding the five precepts, or fulfilling ethical duties can lead to rebirth here, with the specific sub-realm determined by the potency of the merit; even non-human beings, such as animals hearing the Dhamma, may attain it through resultant good karma.^[17] Lifespans in these realms extend for eons—ranging from 9 million human years in the lowest Cāturmahārājika heaven to over 9 billion in Paranimmitavaśavartin—yet they conclude with a decline, often plummeting to lower realms when the effects of past virtue wane.^[7]^[17] In early Buddhist texts, the Deva realm within the desire sphere (kāmadhātu) is subdivided into six principal worlds, ascending in refinement and sensory delight: Cāturmahārājika (realm of the four great kings), Tāvatiṃsa (thirty-three gods), Yāma (free from strife), Tuṣita (contented), Nimmānarati (delight in creating), and Paranimmitavaśavartin (masters of others' creations).^[7]^[17] These abodes offer escalating pleasures, from the guardianship duties and crystalline palaces of Cāturmahārājika to the self-manifested luxuries and subtle companionship in higher realms, but none provide ultimate liberation, as devas lack the direct path to awakening without further practice.^[17] Symbolically, the Deva realm embodies the subtle duḥkha of pride and sensual indulgence, where even profound enjoyments foster attachment (taṇhā) and conceit, masking the inherent unsatisfactoriness of conditioned existence and underscoring the need for detachment to escape cyclic rebirth.^[17]

Asura Realm

The Asura realm, one of the six paths of rebirth in Buddhist cosmology, is home to semi-divine beings known as asuras, who possess formidable power and god-like appearances but are plagued by intense jealousy and belligerence toward the devas. These entities are typically portrayed as residing in expansive domains at the base of Mount Meru, such as the underwater city of Asurabhavana, which measures 10,000 yojanas across and features opulent pavilions along oceanic shores where they revel in the eight qualities of the sea. Asuras exhibit traits blending divinity and demonism, including long lifespans comparable to devas, yet they are spiritually inferior, marked by aggression and reduced intelligence; notable figures like Vepacitti rule over them, while Rahu among them is said to cause solar and lunar eclipses by devouring celestial bodies. Their great tree, the Cittapatali, blooms in tandem with the devas' Paricchattaka tree, underscoring their envious proximity to higher realms.^[17] Rebirth into the Asura realm stems from karmic actions involving a mixture of partial virtues overshadowed by dominant envy, pride, and rivalry, particularly against superior beings, which propels individuals into this domain of strife within the kama-dhatu (desire realm). Such karma classifies the Asura realm among the apayabhumi (unfortunate destinies), alongside hells, hungry ghosts, and animals, where unskillful volitions fueled by jealousy ensure ongoing torment despite the beings' might. Unlike the devas' realm of relative bliss, the asuras' existence is defined by ceaseless warfare aimed at reclaiming their primordial kingdom on Meru, reflecting how envy disrupts even semi-divine prosperity.^[19]^[17] Historically, the Asura realm was not distinctly separated in early Buddhist texts, where asuras were often subsumed under the deva category or viewed as ocean-dwelling adversaries; it solidified as an independent gati (realm of existence) in later Abhidharma traditions, notably Vasubandhu's Abhidharmakosha, which formalized the sixfold division in Mahayana cosmology. This evolution drew from Vedic precedents, adapting asuras as expelled descendants of Danu who were ousted from Meru's heights by Sakka through divine stratagems, as recounted in Jataka tales like the Vessantara Jataka.^[19]^[17] Symbolically, the Asura realm illustrates the samsaric trap of unresolved aggression, where external battles with devas mirror internal conflicts that bind beings to cyclic suffering, preventing progress toward enlightenment despite their potent capabilities.^[17]

Human Realm

The human realm, known as the manussa loka in Pali texts, encompasses earthly existence characterized by a diverse array of experiences, including birth, aging, death, and complex social structures that foster both cooperation and conflict. This realm stands out for its balanced interplay of pleasure and suffering, allowing beings to encounter the full spectrum of sensory joys and pains without the extremes found in other realms. Unlike the instinctual limitations of lower rebirths or the overwhelming bliss of higher ones, human life provides the mental clarity to reflect on impermanence and causality.^[7] Rebirth in the human realm arises from balanced karma rooted in ethical conduct, such as developing virtue through refraining from the ten destructive actions—like killing, stealing, and lying—and cultivating constructive behaviors including generosity and meditation. This karmic foundation reflects a harmonious accumulation of positive and negative intentions, distinguishing it from the predominantly virtuous karma leading to godly realms or the overwhelmingly unwholesome karma of hells. Notably, the human realm uniquely encapsulates the potentials of all six realms in microcosm, as humans can experience pride like devas, jealousy like asuras, desire, ignorance, greed, and hatred within their lifetimes.^[18]^[20] The primary advantage of the human realm lies in its proximity to Buddhas and the Dharma, enabling practitioners to engage in renunciation, ethical discipline, and the path to enlightenment, which is unattainable in realms dominated by distraction or torment. This optimal balance motivates spiritual aspiration, as the awareness of suffering prompts mindfulness and wisdom, while sufficient pleasure sustains effort in practice. However, disadvantages include pervasive distractions from sensory desires and attachments, which can lead to squandered opportunities for liberation if not addressed.^[4]^[21]^[20] Symbolically, the human realm embodies the "middle path" in Buddhist teachings, representing a state of equilibrium where enlightenment is most attainable, free from the excesses of indulgence or asceticism that hinder progress in other realms. This positioning underscores its role as the ideal arena for traversing karmic rebirth cycles toward nirvana.^[22]^[4]

Animal Realm

The Animal Realm, known in Pali as tiracchāna-yoni, represents one of the three unfortunate realms of rebirth in Buddhist cosmology, where sentient beings are reborn as nonhuman animals due to predominant ignorance and delusion in previous lives. These beings, encompassing a vast array from insects and fish to mammals, exist primarily on Earth alongside humans but are driven entirely by instinctual impulses rather than rational thought or moral discernment. Their existence is marked by a profound lack of agency, as they navigate environments where survival depends on predation, foraging, or submission, often in wild habitats or under human domestication.^[23]^[24] The primal sufferings in this realm stem from mutual consumption and exploitation, forming a relentless cycle of eater and eaten that exemplifies samsaric confusion. Animals endure constant threats of being hunted, devoured by predators, or subjected to human-inflicted harms such as slaughter, labor, or experimentation, often experiencing short, brutal lifespans punctuated by heat, cold, and separation from offspring. For instance, fish schools are decimated by larger marine life, while domestic animals like cattle face ritualistic killing or industrial farming torments. These hardships arise directly from karmic residues of stupidity—manifesting as aversion to ethical teachings or indulgence in base behaviors in prior human existences—ensuring that beings here cannot accumulate merit or cultivate wisdom to escape the cycle.^[23]^[25]^[26] This realm's challenges highlight a critical limitation: the absence of moral agency perpetuates lower rebirths, as animals lack the cognitive capacity for reflection, speech, or ethical action, rendering spiritual progress impossible during such existences. Symbolically, it embodies the delusions that obscure clear perception, trapping beings in instinctual reactivity and reinforcing karmic bonds through unexamined suffering. In contrast to the human realm's potential for balanced awareness and enlightenment practice, the Animal Realm underscores the perils of unchecked ignorance.^[24]^[23]^[25]

Hungry Ghost Realm

The Hungry Ghost Realm, known as the preta-loka in Sanskrit, is one of the six realms of samsaric existence in Buddhist cosmology, characterized by profound deprivation and unquenchable desires.^[27] In this realm, beings endure relentless torment from insatiable hunger and thirst, a direct karmic retribution for unwholesome actions in previous lives.^[28] These entities, termed pretas or "departed ones," inhabit a barren landscape of scorched earth and desolation, perceiving the human world through distorted illusions where sustenance appears tantalizingly close yet eternally inaccessible.^[27] Pretas are typically depicted as emaciated figures with grotesquely distended bellies and needle-thin throats, rendering them incapable of ingesting even the smallest amounts of food or water without excruciating pain.^[29] Their bodies are frail and shadowy, often invisible to human eyes, though they roam amidst humans, drawn to offerings during specific rituals. For instance, in the Ullambana Sutra, pretas are described as manifesting during ancestral rites to receive merit transfers, highlighting their proximity to the human realm yet isolation in suffering.^[30] The primary agonies include fiery mouths that incinerate any attempted nourishment—such as in fire-mouth pretas—or throats that constrict like pins, causing vomit or pus upon consumption, as detailed in narratives from the Petavatthu.^[29] This eternal frustration perpetuates a cycle of futile striving, where visions of feasts mock their deprivation, amplifying psychological torment alongside physical starvation.^[27] Rebirth into the preta realm stems primarily from karma rooted in greed, stinginess, and the misuse of resources, such as withholding offerings from monks or the needy.^[28] The Abhidharmakosa attributes this destination to akusala-karma, encompassing acts of avarice and arrogance that fixate the mind on unfulfilled cravings.^[27] In the Sutra of Differences in Karmic Retributions, ten specific karmic offenses are outlined leading to preta existence, including slandering the Three Jewels, disrespecting parents, and fraudulent almsgiving, each culminating in tailored forms of deprivation.^[31] Pretas are subdivided into various types based on the precise nature of past misdeeds; for example, needle-throat pretas arise from habitual stinginess, while fire-mouth variants result from scorning sacred offerings, as elaborated in Mahayana texts like the Saddharmasmṛtyupasthāna Sūtra.^[32] Their lifespan spans 15,000 human years, during which they may birth through wombs or spontaneous apparitions, coexisting in the human world but perceiving it as a wasteland of pus and filth.^[27] Symbolically, the Hungry Ghost Realm embodies the futility of attachment and the consequences of ungenerous desires, serving as a cautionary depiction of how greed transmutes abundance into illusionary scarcity.^[33] In the Wheel of Life mandala, pretas illustrate the second noble truth of the origin of suffering, where obsessive craving leads to perpetual dissatisfaction, underscoring the need for generosity (dāna) to mitigate such rebirths.^[29] Rituals like the Obon festival, rooted in the Ullambana tradition, enable humans to alleviate preta sufferings through shared merit, reinforcing the interconnectedness of karmic realms.^[30]

Hell Realm

The Hell Realm, known as naraka in Sanskrit, represents the lowest of the six paths of rebirth in Buddhist cosmology, characterized by intense physical and mental suffering as a direct result of severe unwholesome karma. According to the Abhidharmakośa, a foundational Abhidharma text, this realm encompasses multiple levels of torment, primarily divided into eight hot hells and eight cold hells, each escalating in severity and located beneath the continent of Jambudvīpa in the sensuous realm. These hells are temporary abodes of retribution, where beings endure unimaginable agonies inflicted by infernal guardians such as yakṣas, who employ weapons, fire, frost, and other means of dismemberment, boiling, or crushing.^[27] The hot hells involve fiery tortures, such as in the Reviving Hell (Sañjīva), where beings are repeatedly slain by slashing swords or crushing mountains only to revive and suffer anew, or in the Heating Hell (Tapana), where victims are scorched on iron surfaces heated to incandescence. More extreme examples include immersion in molten copper cauldrons, as described in the Devadūta Sutta, where hell-beings are boiled alive in swirling vats of searing metal until their karma is partially exhausted. The cold hells, conversely, feature freezing torments, beginning with the Blister Hell (Arbuda), where extreme frost causes the skin to blister and crack, progressing to the Great Lotus Hell (Mahāpadma), with skin splitting open like massive lotus petals amid unrelenting shivers and lamentations. These sufferings are not inflicted by an external judge but arise mechanistically from one's accumulated negative actions, underscoring the impersonal nature of karmic causation.^[34]^[9]^[35]^[27] Rebirth in the Hell Realm stems from grave unwholesome deeds, particularly the five heinous crimes—such as matricide, patricide, killing an arhat, wounding a Buddha, or causing schism in the Saṅgha—or intense actions rooted in hatred, like premeditated murder and torture of sentient beings. In the Devadūta Sutta, such negligence toward ethical conduct, including disrespect toward parents, elders, or ascetics, leads to these retributions, with tortures mirroring the harm caused in life. Durations of suffering are finite yet extraordinarily prolonged, calculated in the Abhidharmakośa as spanning from lesser kalpas (eons) in the outer hells—equivalent to billions of human years—to an intermediate kalpa in the innermost Avīci Hell, the Unrelenting Torment, where agony persists without respite until the full measure of karma dissipates.^[9]^[27] Symbolically, the Hell Realm illustrates the ultimate consequences of unbridled defilements, serving as a stark warning of saṃsāra's perils while emphasizing even this extremity's impermanence—no suffering endures eternally, as all conditioned phenomena are transient, allowing eventual rebirth elsewhere once karma ripens. This contrasts with the milder, craving-driven torments of the Hungry Ghost Realm, highlighting hell's focus on acute physical retribution over perpetual dissatisfaction.^[7]^[27]

Interpretations

Psychological and Consciousness-Based Views

In psychological and consciousness-based interpretations of the six paths, the realms are often viewed not as external cosmological destinations but as metaphors for internal mental states and afflictions that shape human experience. Tibetan Buddhist teacher Chögyam Trungpa, in his teachings, described the six realms as psychological patterns arising from the delusions of ego, where the deva realm represents states of pride and complacency, the asura realm embodies jealousy and competitiveness, the human realm reflects balanced but conflicted awareness, the animal realm signifies ignorance and instinctual reactivity, the hungry ghost realm captures insatiable craving, and the hell realm manifests as intense anger and hatred. This approach emphasizes how these "realms" manifest in everyday consciousness, influencing perception and behavior without requiring belief in literal rebirth cycles. Trungpa's framework draws from Vajrayana traditions but adapts them for modern audiences, portraying the bardo (intermediate state) as a continuous process of mental transitions rather than a post-mortem event. Historical precedents for this mind-centered view trace back to the Yogacara school of Mahayana Buddhism, particularly its cittamatra (mind-only) doctrine, which posits that all phenomena arise from the eight consciousnesses (vijnanas). In Yogacara texts like the Yogacarabhumi-sastra, the six realms are viewed as projections arising from defiled mental factors (kleshas) such as attachment, aversion, and delusion, rather than independent realities. For instance, the alaya-vijnana (storehouse consciousness) serves as the substrate from which realm-specific delusions propagate, illustrating how subjective experience constructs one's "world" through cognitive processes. This interpretation, developed by thinkers like Asanga and Vasubandhu in the 4th-5th centuries CE, underscores the illusory nature of external realms, prioritizing introspective analysis for liberation. In contemporary Western Buddhism, these psychological views have been integrated into therapeutic and meditative practices, treating the six paths as archetypes of habitual mind patterns that can be observed and transformed. Teachers like Jack Kornfield and organizations such as the Insight Meditation Society apply this model in mindfulness-based therapies, where the animal realm, for example, is likened to automatic, reactivity-driven behaviors akin to those addressed in cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), helping practitioners recognize and interrupt cycles of suffering. Such applications, influenced by figures like Trungpa and the Dalai Lama's dialogues with psychologists, facilitate secular adaptations of Buddhist psychology, as seen in programs combining meditation with emotional regulation techniques. These interpretations do not negate traditional beliefs in karmic rebirth but complement them by emphasizing the immediacy of subjective experience as the primary arena for practice. As the Dalai Lama has noted in discussions with Western scientists, viewing the realms psychologically allows for empirical validation through personal insight, bridging ancient doctrine with modern neuroscience on consciousness and emotion. This dual emphasis maintains the soteriological goal of transcending all realms through wisdom, while highlighting their relevance to mental health in daily life.

Karmic Mechanisms and Rebirth Processes

In Buddhist doctrine, the karmic framework posits that wholesome (kusala) actions, characterized by non-greed, non-hatred, and non-delusion, propel rebirth into the upper realms of humans, asuras, or devas, while unwholesome (akusala) actions, rooted in the three poisons, lead to the lower realms of animals, hungry ghosts, or hell beings; neutral (avyakata) karma typically results in human rebirth due to its balanced nature.^[36]^[37] This classification stems from the ethical quality of volitional activities, ensuring that positive intentions foster favorable conditions in samsara. The rebirth process unfolds at the moment of death, when accumulated karma ripens through the bhavanga consciousness—a passive, subconscious stream that maintains continuity between lives and carries karmic imprints. This bhavanga, established by the dominant (weighty) kamma from the individual's past, activates as the final thought-moment, generating the rebirth-linking consciousness (patisandhi-citta) that propels the being into one of the six gatis (destinations or realms) based on the potency of that kamma.^[36] For instance, if death is attended by recollection of a strong wholesome deed, the bhavanga aligns with a higher gati; conversely, a dominant unwholesome kamma directs toward a lower one. Central to this mechanism is intention (cetana), deemed the essence of karma, as the Buddha declared: "It is intention (cetana), O monks, that I call karma; having willed, one acts by body, speech, and mind."^[39] Thus, an act of generosity (dana) driven by pure intention may lead to deva rebirth, as exemplified by King Dutthagamani's meritorious deeds resulting in Tusita heaven, whereas intense anger or hatred, as in Devadatta's schism in the Sangha, culminates in hellish realms.^[36] These processes interconnect within samsara's twelve links of dependent origination (paticca-samuppada), where karmic formations (sankhara) arise from ignorance and craving, conditioning consciousness and rebirth across the realms, yet allowing upward mobility through accumulated merit from wholesome deeds that can override lesser kamma.^[36]^[40]

Scriptural Exegeses

The Saddharmasmṛtyupasthānasūtra, a Mahāyāna Buddhist text composed in the first half of the first millennium CE, discusses karmic consequences leading to rebirth in various realms, such as through meditation practices that contemplate suffering and impermanence in the animal realm and other gatis, highlighting the role of ethical conduct and dispassion in mitigating samsaric entrapment.^[41]^[42] Vasubandhu's Abhidharmakośa (Treasury of Abhidharma), a foundational Sarvāstivāda text from the fourth or fifth century CE, offers a systematic classification of the six realms within the broader cosmological framework of the three worlds (traidhātuka). In its third chapter on the world (loka), the text delineates the desire realm (kāmadhātu) as encompassing the hells (naraka), hungry ghosts (preta), animals (tiryañc), humans (manuṣya), demigods (asura), and gods (deva), explaining karmic retributions through the ripening of volitional actions (saṃskāra) that propel beings into these domains based on the quality of their karma—wholesome, unwholesome, or neutral. Vasubandhu further elucidates how ignorance (avidyā) and afflictions (kleśa) sustain rebirth across these paths, while ethical discipline and insight mitigate retributive suffering, providing a doctrinal basis for understanding samsaric continuity.^[43] Tibetan commentaries on the Bardo Thö dol (Liberation Through Hearing During the Intermediate State), attributed to Padmasambhava and revealed by Karma Lingpa in the fourteenth century, elaborate on the six paths as potential outcomes during the bardo of becoming (siṃhavāsin bar do), where the deceased's consciousness confronts karmic visions leading to rebirth. These commentaries, such as those by Chögyam Trungpa, interpret the realms as projections arising from residual karma, guiding practitioners to recognize their illusory nature and invoke compassion to avert lower rebirths, thereby facilitating transfer to higher realms or liberation.^[44] The text stresses reciting aspirational prayers to direct karma toward the human realm, ideal for dharma practice, while warning of the deceptive allure of divine realms that prolong samsara.^[45] Across these exegeses, a recurring interpretive theme emerges in Mahāyāna sutras: the six paths as illusory projections of the deluded mind, akin to dreams or mirages, prompting the cultivation of universal compassion (karuṇā) for all beings ensnared therein, as seen in texts like the Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra, which asserts that all dharmas resemble illusions devoid of inherent existence.^[46] Sutras urge bodhisattvas to extend empathy across realms, viewing suffering as shared and empty of self, to foster awakening for the benefit of all. Early Abhidharma-oriented texts, such as the Abhidharmakośa, prioritize ethical analyses of karmic causation and retributive mechanisms, whereas later Mahāyāna works shift toward the doctrine of emptiness (śūnyatā), revealing the paths as non-substantial appearances to be transcended through wisdom.^[47]

Integration in the Wheel of Life

The Bhavachakra, or Wheel of Life, visually integrates the six paths as a central mandala symbolizing samsara, the cycle of rebirth driven by karma. The wheel is typically depicted as being grasped by Yama, the lord of death, who embodies impermanence and clutches it in his teeth or hands to signify the inescapable grip of cyclic existence on sentient beings. The wheel's interior is divided into six pie-shaped segments, each representing one of the six realms—gods, demigods, humans, animals, hungry ghosts, and hell beings—arranged clockwise to illustrate the diverse outcomes of karmic actions. At the hub, three animals form an interlocked circle: a pig symbolizing ignorance, a cock (or rooster) representing desire or greed, and a snake (sometimes depicted with an arrow) denoting anger or hatred, collectively known as the three poisons that propel the wheel's motion and perpetuate suffering. The outer rim consists of twelve segments portraying the nidanas, or twelve links of dependent origination, which trace the causal chain from ignorance to aging and death, reinforcing how karma binds beings to the realms. This iconographic structure serves as a pedagogical tool in Buddhist art, particularly in Tibetan and Theravada traditions, where it has been used since the 8th century CE to teach core doctrines of impermanence, karma, and the consequences of actions. Painted on temple walls, monastery entrances, or as thangka scrolls, the Bhavachakra acts as an accessible visual aid for monastics and laypeople, allowing monks to explain samsara's mechanics without relying solely on textual study. Its emphasis on the six realms highlights the variability of rebirth based on ethical conduct, encouraging practitioners to cultivate virtue to avoid lower paths and aspire toward higher ones. Interpretations of the Bhavachakra emphasize the six paths' role in demonstrating samsara's profound diversity and futility, with the realms collectively portraying the full spectrum of conditioned existence under the influence of the three poisons. Often, an image of the Buddha appears outside the wheel, pointing to a crescent moon or luminous sphere symbolizing nirvana, the state beyond cyclic suffering, to underscore that liberation is attainable through insight into emptiness and cessation of karma. This external positioning reminds viewers that while the wheel encompasses all possible rebirths, enlightenment transcends it entirely. Originating in Indian Buddhist art as early as the 5th century CE in sites like the Ajanta Caves, the Bhavachakra evolved through cultural adaptations, becoming a staple in Himalayan and Tibetan iconography by the 10th century, where it features intricate details like Yama's skull crown and realm-specific vignettes. In East Asian traditions, such as Chinese and Japanese Buddhism, variations include five or six realms with added motifs like warring gods in the demigod section, and sometimes a water wheel analogy for karmic flow, reflecting integrations with local cosmology while preserving the core symbolic teachings. Theravada depictions, rooted in Abhidharma texts, are rarer and more textual, but appear in Southeast Asian murals emphasizing the five aggregates over elaborate realms.

Transition to Nirvana

The transition from the six paths to nirvana involves breaking the cycle of rebirth through profound insight into the three marks of existence—impermanence (anicca), suffering (dukkha), and non-self (anatta)—which undermines the attachments that fuel karmic propulsion. This realization, cultivated via the Noble Eightfold Path, fosters dispassion toward conditioned phenomena, extinguishing the cravings that propel rebirth across the realms and leading to the cessation of suffering. In the Anattalakkhana Sutta, the Buddha teaches that recognizing the five aggregates as impermanent, unsatisfactory, and not-self results in relinquishment of clinging, thereby achieving liberation from samsara.^[48] Among the six paths, the human realm is particularly conducive to this practice due to its balanced experience of pleasure and pain, which motivates ethical conduct and insight without the extremes that hinder progress in other realms. Beings in the human realm encounter "deva messengers"—signs of birth, aging, illness, death, and moral reckoning—that prompt reflection on impermanence and the pursuit of the Dhamma, enabling attainment of nirvana in this life.^[49] Nirvana itself transcends all realms, offering an unconditioned state free from the fleeting pleasures of the deva realms or the torments of lower paths, as the extinguishing of defilements ends all conditioned existence. Scripturally, early Pali suttas portray nirvana as the unconditioned peace, an unborn and unmade reality that contrasts with the fabrications of samsara. The Nibbana Sutta describes it as "the unborn, unbecome, unmade, unfabricated," a refuge from the conditioned world.^[50] In Mahayana traditions, this evolves into the dharmakaya, the eternal truth-body embodying ultimate reality and buddha-nature, as expounded in the Mahaparinirvana Sutra, where nirvana is the permanent, blissful essence beyond dualities. Key practices for this transition include meditation on the inherent faults of the realms to cultivate renunciation, such as contemplating how even devas face rebirth upon exhausting positive karma, inspiring detachment from samsaric allure. These reflections, integrated into the Noble Eightfold Path's right mindfulness and concentration, generate the determination to be free, directly countering karmic propensities that cause realm-specific existences.^[51]

References

[1]
six paths | Dictionary of Buddhism
The six paths were viewed traditionally as realms within which unenlightened beings repeatedly transmigrate.
[2]
Six Paths: Significance and symbolism
Aug 28, 2025 · The Six Paths in Buddhism represent six realms of existence—gods, humans, asuras, animals, hungry ghosts, and hell beings—where sentient beings ...
[3]
Six Realms of Existence (Samsara = Skt), Japanese Buddhism ...
The Six States are also known as the Six Paths/Roads of Reincarnation/Transmigration. One must achieve nirvana (enlightenment, satori, emancipation, nibanna) to ...
[4]
What are the six realms? - Tricycle: The Buddhist Review
The six realms of rebirth are a schema in which beings are reborn according to the kind of life they lived.<|control11|><|separator|>
[5]
The Six Realms of Existence - Buddhist Churches Of America
Dec 6, 2021 · The six realms, are as follows. There is the realm of heaven, human, animal, fighting demon, hungry ghost, and hell. Prior to Shakyamuni Buddha, ...Missing: Paths | Show results with:Paths
[6]
[PDF] Mahāyāna Mind-bending: Buddhist Visions of Outer/Inner Worlds
Mar 30, 2023 · East Asian texts frequently further subdivide these six realms into dozens of sub-realms. 11 Perhaps the closest analogue with Dante are the ...
[7]
[PDF] THE BUDDHIST SIX-WORLDS MODEL OF CONSCIOUSNESS AND ...
Mahayana Buddhism developed a world model or image variously called the "Wheel of Samsara (Existence)," or the "Wheel of Birth and Death," or the "Six Realms of.
[8]
The Six Bardos: A Guide to Conscious Living and Dying
Dec 25, 2024 · Tibetan Buddhism breaks down the cycle of existence into six distinct bardo states, each representing a different stage of life, death, and rebirth.
[9]
The Thirty-one Planes of Existence - Access to Insight
Scattered throughout the suttas are references to as many as thirty-one distinct "planes" or "realms" of existence into which beings can be reborn.Missing: six | Show results with:six
[10]
[PDF] Urban Dharma - The Buddhist Cosmos
The purpose of this book is to present a comprehensive description of the universe and its inhabitants as they were understood by the Buddhists of ancient India ...
[11]
https://suttacentral.net/an8.40/en/sujato
[12]
Six Classes of Beings - Samye Pathways
The Six Classes. Hell beings; Pretas (starving spirits or hungry ghosts); Animals; Humans; Asuras (Demi-gods); Desire realm gods.Missing: Anguttara Nikaya references
[13]
The Different Realms of Existence and Karma
### Summary of the Human Realm within the Six Realms
[14]
https://www.wisdomlib.org/concept/asura-realm
[15]
Rebirth in Real Time: Navigating Mental States with Mindfulness
Sep 27, 2025 · Human Realm: A balanced state where beings experience a mixture of pleasure and suffering and thus have the opportunity to practice the path to ...
[16]
The lower realms - Thubten Chodron
Animal realm. The general sufferings of animals are the suffering of heat and cold, getting eaten by each other, getting tortured and getting hunted by human ...Missing: primary sources
[17]
2.4. The Six Buddhist Realms of Existence
Oct 16, 2024 · 1. Deva or Heavenly Realm (God Realm). · 2. Asura or Demi-god Realm (Jealous God Realm) · 3. Human Realm · 4. Animal Realm · 5. Preta Realm or ...
[18]
What the Animals Taught | Lion's Roar
Ohnuma begins by detailing the ways in which an animal rebirth is included among the lower realms of samsara: a miserable, pitiable existence that both results ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
[19]
Unfortunate Destiny: Animals in a Buddhist Cosmos - Oxford Academic
This chapter examines the animal realm of rebirth in early Buddhist doctrine and cosmology and shows that the animal rebirth was characterized very negatively ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
[20]
[PDF] Abhidharmakosa Chapter 3: Loka (World) Overview
Preta 餓鬼. Hungry ghosts. (There is great variety in Pretas, some enjoy a glory [unspecified] 15,000 yrs. They live in our world but see it differently, e.g. ...
[21]
Hungry Ghost: Significance and symbolism
Oct 28, 2025 · In Buddhism, Hungry Ghosts (pretas) are beings experiencing insatiable hunger and thirst, stemming from greed, arrogance, or stinginess in past ...
[22]
Petavatthu: Stories of the Hungry Ghosts - Access to Insight
The Petavatthu contains 51 poems, each explaining how unwholesome deeds led to the rebirth of a being into the miserable realm of the hungry ghosts.Missing: descriptions | Show results with:descriptions
[23]
Beyond the Veil: Unmasking Hungry Ghosts in Buddhism - Alan Peto
Aug 17, 2024 · This story became the basis for the Ullambana Sutra that is used by Buddhists regarding hungry ghosts and family members who have passed away.
[24]
1. There are three types of hungry ghosts without wealth - Facebook
Aug 25, 2024 · According to the Sutra of Differences in Karmic Retributions, there are ten types of karma that cause sentient beings to be reborn as hungry ...
[25]
https://www.lionsroar.com/what-the-animals-taught/
[26]
Who Were the Hungry Ghosts, Really? - Tricycle: The Buddhist Review
Apr 27, 2025 · We might best know pretas (Pali: peta) as hungry ghosts occupying one of the lower realms of rebirth. This is how they are depicted in the wheel ...
[27]
Eight Hot Hells - Rigpa Wiki
Jan 5, 2018 · Eight Hot Hells · Reviving Hell (Skt. saṃjīva; Wyl. · Black Line Hell (Skt. kālasūtra; Wyl. · Rounding Up and Crushing Hell (Skt. saṃghāta; Wyl.Missing: descriptions abhidharma
[28]
Devadūtasutta—Bhikkhu Sujato - MN 130 - SuttaCentral
This “hell complex” includes such beliefs as: hell is long-lasting but impermanent; there are many named hells; punishments are terrible and varied; the ...Missing: eight | Show results with:eight
[29]
Eight Cold Hells - Rigpa Wiki
### Summary of the Eight Cold Hells
[30]
Basic Buddhism: The Theory of Karma - buddhanet.net
Nature of Karma Birth (gati) time or condition (kala) substratum of rebirth or showing attachment to rebirth (upadhi) and effort (payoga) act as such powerful ...Missing: Canon | Show results with:Canon
[31]
Buddhist rebirth in different planes of existence - The British Library
Mar 17, 2016 · Explore how Buddhist teachings on kamma shape rebirth across 31 planes of existence, from heavenly realms to the depths of hell.
[32]
https://books.openedition.org/pressesinalco/2120
[33]
Karma - Encyclopedia of Buddhism
Karmic actions are considered to be the engine which drives the cycle of uncontrolled rebirth (samsara); correspondingly, a complete understanding of karmic ...
[34]
Fundamentals of Buddhism: Four Lectures - Access to Insight
The fundamental import of bhavanga-sota, or the subconscious life-stream, as a working hypothesis for the explanation of the various Buddhist doctrines, such ...
[35]
Meditation on the Body in Chapter 7 of ... - MDPI
Saddharmasmṛtyupasthānasūtra is an Indian Buddhist sutra dating to the first half of the first millennium. Chapter 7 of the sutra consists of a very long ...
[36]
A Less Traveled Path: Meditation and Textual Practice in the ...
As part of this study, the second chapter of the Saddharmasmrtyupasthana(sutra) is critically edited and translated based on a recently discovered codex unicus.Missing: Saddharmasmṛtyupasthānasūtra | Show results with:Saddharmasmṛtyupasthānasūtra<|separator|>
[37]
https://www.bl.uk/stories/blogs/posts/buddhist-rebirth-in-different-planes-of-existence
[38]
Commentaries on the Tibetan Book of the Dead | Buddhism & Healing
Here you can read the commentaries of highly respected Buddhist Lama Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche on the Tibetan Book of the Dead, otherwise known as Bardo Thödol.
[39]
Tibetan Book of the Dead (Bardo Thödol)
### Summary of Six Realms, Rebirth Processes, and Commentaries in Bardo Thödol
[40]
[PDF] The Lankavatara Sutra Summary - WordPress.com
Sep 5, 2016 · Although they appear like so many illusory entities, foolish beings imagine them as different from illusions. The illusions and the objects are ...
[41]
Mahayana: Primary Texts - Buddhism - Research Guides
Oct 23, 2025 · The Mahāyāna sūtras are a broad genre of Buddhist scriptures that various Mahāyāna traditions accept as canonical.
[42]
Devaduta Sutta: The Deva Messengers
### Summary of Majjhima Nikaya 130: Devaduta Sutta (Parts on Human Realm for Practice and Release)
[43]
None
Nothing is retrieved...<|separator|>
[44]
Meditation Three: The Sufferings of Samsara
Even if born in the upper realms, we still suffer in samsara, the suffering of bondage and its cause, caught in the circle of the twelve dependent links.