Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

The Final Problem

"The Final Problem" is a short story by British author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, first published in the December 1893 issue of The Strand Magazine, and later collected in the 1894 volume The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes.^[1]^[2] Narrated by Dr. John Watson, the story portrays the detective Sherlock Holmes in his ultimate confrontation with Professor James Moriarty, a mathematical genius and the shadowy leader of London's criminal underworld, whom Holmes describes as his intellectual equal and greatest adversary.^[3] The narrative unfolds in 1891, with Holmes revealing to Watson the extent of Moriarty's vast criminal network and the detective's efforts to dismantle it through arrests and evidence gathering.^[3] The plot centers on a tense pursuit after Moriarty evades capture and vows revenge on Holmes, leading to multiple assassination attempts in London that force the pair to flee across Europe.^[3] Using disguises and strategic misdirection, Holmes and Watson travel through France and into Switzerland, where Holmes sends Watson back to Meiringen on the pretext of a medical emergency for an Englishwoman staying at the inn, leaving himself alone at the Reichenbach Falls near Meiringen, where Moriarty confronts him.^[3] There, resulting in a violent struggle at the cliff's edge; both men plummet into the abyss and are presumed dead, with Watson discovering Holmes's farewell note and signs of the fatal fight.^[3] This apparent demise allows Holmes's accumulated evidence to convict Moriarty's lieutenants, effectively breaking the organization, though the story leaves Holmes's survival ambiguous at the time.^[3] Doyle wrote "The Final Problem" as the twelfth and concluding tale in the Memoirs collection, intending it to end the Sherlock Holmes series permanently, as he sought to focus on other literary pursuits and was weary of the character's popularity.^[4] The publication provoked a strong backlash from readers; over 20,000 subscribers canceled their Strand Magazine subscriptions, and fans in London mourned publicly by wearing black armbands, while the publisher described the event as "dreadful."^[5]^[4]^[6] Despite this, the story established Moriarty as an iconic villain in literature and marked a pivotal moment in detective fiction, influencing the genre's emphasis on intellectual duels between protagonists and master criminals.^[4]

Plot and Characters

Plot Summary

In "The Final Problem," the narrative is presented as Dr. John Watson's final account of his friend Sherlock Holmes's adventures, written with a heavy heart following Holmes's presumed death. On 24 April 1891, Holmes arrives unannounced at Watson's medical practice in Kensington, appearing unusually pale and haggard after evading an assassination attempt earlier that day by a thug wielding a life-preserver, whom Holmes subdued with his cane.^[3] He explains that the attack was orchestrated by Professor James Moriarty, whom he describes as the organizing genius behind a vast criminal network operating undetected across Europe, often centered in London, where Moriarty employs subordinates to execute crimes while remaining invisible to the law.^[3] Holmes reveals that his investigations since January have systematically dismantled this syndicate, prompting Moriarty to declare war and vow Holmes's destruction unless he desists.^[3] To evade Moriarty's agents, Holmes urges Watson to assist in his flight to the Continent, providing meticulous instructions for their departure that evening: Watson is to send his luggage ahead to Victoria Station, proceed by hansom cab to Lowther Arcade in the Strand, where a brougham arranged by Holmes's brother Mycroft will collect him, and board the train to Canterbury.^[3] Holmes himself slips out through Watson's back garden to avoid detection, having already disguised himself. The pair travels incognito, using disguises and strategic misdirection, crossing from Newhaven to Dieppe, then onward via Luxembourg and Basle, arriving in Switzerland by early May.^[3] Throughout the journey, they sense Moriarty's relentless pursuit, with Holmes noting telegrams and shadows indicating the professor's proximity, though evasion tactics like changing trains and routes keep them ahead temporarily.^[3] As they reach Meiringen in the Bernese Oberland, while walking from the Englischer Hof toward Rosenlaui, Holmes receives a forged note from the innkeeper about an ill Englishwoman at the hotel needing his assistance; this proves a ruse by Moriarty.^[3] Holmes instructs Watson to continue to Rosenlaui, arm himself with his revolver, and await further instructions, while he returns to the inn. En route, Watson receives a second forged note from the innkeeper requesting his immediate medical aid for the worsening patient.^[3] Returning to the Englischer Hof, Watson learns from the confused innkeeper that no such woman exists, realizes the deception, and rushes back along the path to the Reichenbach Falls. There, he discovers Holmes's walking stick, his half-smoked cigarette, and a farewell letter pinned to a rock, in which Holmes describes Moriarty's arrival, a brief exchange confirming the professor's abilities, and their violent struggle at the cliff's edge.^[3] The letter details how Moriarty attacked, leading to a fatal combat where both men plummeted into the roaring Reichenbach Falls, their bodies never recovered, leading authorities and experts to conclude they perished locked in mortal combat.^[3]

Characters

Sherlock Holmes is depicted as a consulting detective of unparalleled deductive genius, characterized by his methodical analytical approach, keen observation, and intellectual drive to unravel complex mysteries. In "The Final Problem," he exhibits signs of exhaustion from the prolonged threat posed by his adversary, leading him to contemplate retiring from his career to achieve a sense of fulfillment through the dismantling of a vast criminal network.^[3] His heroic sacrifice underscores his commitment to justice, as he prioritizes societal benefit over personal survival, viewing the confrontation as the pinnacle of his professional life.^[3] Holmes's traits include emotional composure under pressure, strategic resourcefulness, and a willingness to engage in physical exertion only when necessary, all of which highlight his role as the story's resolute protagonist.^[7] Dr. John Watson serves as the loyal narrator and chronicler of Holmes's adventures, providing a grounded, practical perspective through his medical background and conventional demeanor. He initially expresses skepticism toward the gravity of the danger Holmes faces but demonstrates unwavering loyalty by accompanying his friend despite the risks.^[3] Watson's compassion shines through in his profound grief following Holmes's presumed death, emphasizing his role as both assistant and emotional anchor to the detective.^[3] His observations often contrast Holmes's detachment, adding depth to their partnership and underscoring themes of friendship and reliability.^[7] Professor James Moriarty emerges as the archetypal criminal mastermind, portrayed as the "Napoleon of crime" due to his organizational genius and subtle orchestration of London's underworld activities. A former mathematician with a treatise on the Binomial Theorem, Moriarty applies his intellectual prowess to crime, maintaining anonymity while exerting influence through a network of subordinates.^[3] His vengeful nature drives him to pursue direct confrontation with Holmes, reflecting a calculating and dangerous temperament that mirrors yet inverts the detective's own brilliance.^[3] Scholars note Moriarty's role as Holmes's intellectual equal and dark counterpart, embodying stagnation and isolation in contrast to Holmes's potential for growth.^[7] Mycroft Holmes, Sherlock's older brother and a senior government consultant, provides crucial support by arranging discreet transportation for their escape and is later entrusted with Holmes's property and the evidence needed to convict Moriarty's gang.^[3]

Background and Creation

Doyle's Motivations

Arthur Conan Doyle grew increasingly frustrated with the overwhelming popularity of Sherlock Holmes, which he felt overshadowed his more ambitious historical novels and other literary endeavors. In his autobiography, he described Holmes as an "incubus" that dominated his reputation and limited his creative freedom, tying him to what he considered a "lower stratum of literary achievement."^[8] This sentiment stemmed from the detective's success in short stories for The Strand Magazine, which brought financial security but diverted attention from works like Micah Clarke (1889) and The White Company (1891), which Doyle viewed as his true artistic contributions.^[8] To escape this constraint, Doyle resolved to kill off the character, seeing it as a necessary step to pursue more significant projects. The decision crystallized between 1891 and 1893, amid growing fatigue from the demands of producing Holmes short stories. By late 1893, after completing two novels and eighteen short stories, Doyle expressed weariness over the "monotony of the work" and the strain of continually inventing intricate plots.^[8] This exhaustion peaked during a family holiday in Switzerland in 1893, where the Reichenbach Falls setting was inspired by his earlier visit to the site in May 1891, and he penned "The Final Problem" while seeking respite for his wife's health at a sanatorium, ultimately noting in his diary simply, "Killed Holmes."^[9]^[10] The act represented a deliberate break from the formulaic detective genre, allowing him to redirect his efforts toward historical fiction such as The Refugees (1893), which he prioritized immediately after Holmes's demise.^[8] Real-life events further shaped Doyle's motivations during this period, including his wife Louisa's diagnosis with tuberculosis in August 1893 and the recent decline of his father, Charles Altamont Doyle, who suffered from alcoholism and epilepsy before his death on October 10, 1893.^[11]^[12] These personal hardships, combined with Doyle's emerging involvement in spiritualism—he joined the Society for Psychical Research in 1893 and had been exploring psychic phenomena since the 1880s—fueled his ambition to shift toward nonfiction and historical writing that aligned with his broadening intellectual pursuits.^[13] Despite the intense public backlash that followed, Doyle initially stood firm in his choice.^[9]

Development of the Antagonist

Professor James Moriarty was conceived by Arthur Conan Doyle as the arch-nemesis of Sherlock Holmes, introduced specifically in "The Final Problem" (1893) to provide a formidable adversary capable of justifying the detective's dramatic demise.^[7] Moriarty's character draws partial inspiration from real-life figures, notably the notorious criminal Adam Worth, a suave master thief dubbed the "Napoleon of crime" for orchestrating elaborate heists across Europe and America in the late 19th century, whose shadowy operations and intellectual cunning mirrored the fictional villain's organizational genius. Additionally, Moriarty's portrayal as a brilliant mathematician—author of a treatise on the Binomial Theorem and dynamics of asteroids—echoes influences from prominent mathematical theorists of the era, such as the astronomer Simon Newcomb, whose analytical prowess and reputed temperament informed the antagonist's intellectual depth.^[14] However, Doyle primarily invented Moriarty as a singular embodiment of criminal supremacy, a "Napoleon of crime" who directed London's underworld from the shadows without direct involvement, thereby elevating the stakes for Holmes's final confrontation.^[7] Doyle's writing choices emphasized Moriarty's late entry into the Holmes canon, marking his debut in "The Final Problem" as a revelation to both Watson and the reader, underscoring his elusive, almost mythical presence as the unseen orchestrator of prior crimes alluded to in earlier stories.^[15] This shadowy depiction—limited to Holmes's descriptions and a single climactic encounter—symbolized Moriarty as Holmes's dark intellectual mirror, a degenerate genius whose mathematical mind rivaled the detective's deductive brilliance but twisted toward malevolence, serving Doyle's narrative purpose of crafting an equal worthy of ending the series.^[7] The antagonist's minimal direct action reinforced his role as a structural device, embodying the pinnacle of Holmes's career while allowing Doyle to conclude the saga amid his growing fatigue with the character's popularity.^[15] Doyle's later ambivalence toward Moriarty's abrupt introduction became evident in the 1915 novel The Valley of Fear, where he retroactively expanded the character's backstory to integrate him into the earlier timeline, portraying Moriarty as already active in 1888 as the "high priest" of a vast criminal network influencing events like the American Scowrers' activities.^[15] This adjustment addressed chronological inconsistencies, such as Watson's feigned ignorance of Moriarty in "The Final Problem" despite the professor's prior operations, effectively retconning him as a longstanding force in the canon to enhance narrative cohesion after public demand revived Holmes.^[7]

Publication History

Initial Appearance

"The Final Problem" was first published in various US newspapers on 26 November 1893 under the title "The Adventure of the Final Problem", and appeared in the December 1893 issue of The Strand Magazine, serving as the twelfth and final short story in the Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes series serialized in the publication.^[16] The story spanned pages 558 to 570 and was accompanied by nine illustrations from artist Sidney Paget, who depicted iconic scenes such as Holmes disguising himself as an elderly Italian priest and the climactic struggle between Holmes and Moriarty at the Reichenbach Falls.^[16]^[17] Priced at sixpence per copy—half the rate of many comparable magazines at the time—the December issue reached a wide audience through The Strand's robust monthly circulation of approximately 500,000 copies during the peak of the Sherlock Holmes serializations in the early 1890s.^[18]^[19]

Subsequent Publications

Following its initial magazine appearance, "The Final Problem" was collected as the final story in The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes, a volume of eleven short stories published in December 1893 in the United Kingdom by George Newnes and in February 1894 in the United States by Harper & Brothers. This book edition retained the original Strand Magazine illustrations by Sidney Paget, with adjustments primarily to formatting for the bound format, such as consolidated text without serial divisions. The story has since appeared in numerous complete collections of the Sherlock Holmes canon, including the first comprehensive edition, The Complete Sherlock Holmes Long Stories (1929) and The Complete Short Stories of Sherlock Holmes (1927), both compiled by John Murray in London, which gathered all 56 short stories and four novels for the first time. These compilations standardized the text across Doyle's oeuvre and facilitated its widespread availability in single-volume formats throughout the 20th century. In the United States, all Sherlock Holmes stories, including "The Final Problem," entered the public domain on January 1, 2023, following a series of copyright rulings that confirmed the expiration of protections for works published before 1923.^[20] This status has enabled unrestricted digital reproductions and new editions, such as those available through Project Gutenberg and Standard Ebooks, promoting free access to the original text.^[21] Among modern scholarly editions, Leslie S. Klinger's The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes (W. W. Norton, 2004–2005) provides extensive annotations for "The Final Problem," including historical context on Victorian criminality, Reichenbach Falls geography, and Doyle's inspirations, across its three volumes encompassing the full canon.^[22]

Reception

Public Reaction

The publication of "The Final Problem" in the December 1893 issue of The Strand Magazine elicited an unprecedented outpouring of grief and anger from readers, marking one of the earliest instances of mass public reaction to a fictional character's death. Fans inundated Arthur Conan Doyle with thousands of letters expressing outrage, including abusive missives and threats; one began, "You Brute," while others begged for Holmes's revival.^[1] Even Doyle's mother, Mary Doyle, protested the decision in a letter, writing, "You won't! You can't! You mustn't!"^[23] Conan Doyle later recalled receiving correspondence "from all over the world reproaching me on the subject," underscoring the global scale of the dismay.^[24] This emotional response manifested in visible acts of mourning, with some devotees in London wearing black armbands in public as a tribute to the fallen detective, treating his demise as akin to a real celebrity's passing.^[25] The fervor even inspired organized efforts, such as the formation of "Let's Keep Holmes Alive" clubs in the United States, where members circulated petitions urging Doyle to restore the character—though exact signature counts remain unverified, the initiative reflected the depth of fan attachment.^[23] Commercially, the backlash severely impacted The Strand Magazine, as more than 20,000 subscribers canceled their subscriptions in protest, nearly dooming the publication; staff thereafter referred to the event as "the dreadful event."^[23] The story's serialization in American outlets like Harper's Weekly amplified the fallout across the Atlantic, where Holmes's death made front-page headlines and prompted similar dismay among U.S. readers.^[1] In Europe and the U.S., the tragedy inspired immediate tributes and parodies, including J.M. Barrie's satirical piece "The Late Sherlock Holmes," published in St. James's Gazette on December 29, 1893, which humorously reported on a fictional arrest related to the detective's demise.^[26] Such responses highlighted Holmes's status as an international icon, with echoes in continental press coverage and fan writings through 1894.^[24]

Critical Analysis

Scholars have long interpreted the duality between Sherlock Holmes and Professor James Moriarty as a central theme in "The Final Problem," portraying them as intellectual and moral mirrors that reflect Victorian anxieties about degeneracy and the blurred line between law and crime.^[27] Holmes describes Moriarty as possessing "a brain of the first order," equal to his own, underscoring their shared genius, while their physical similarities—both tall and thin—reinforce the doppelgänger motif, symbolizing the detective's potential descent into criminality.^[28] This mirroring extends to their roles as "consulting" figures, with Holmes combating crime and Moriarty orchestrating it, highlighting an aesthetic appreciation of criminal artistry that Holmes admires despite its immorality.^[27] Such duality serves as a narrative device to explore internal conflict, positioning Moriarty as Holmes's "evil twin" who embodies the societal threats Holmes suppresses.^[7] The story also engages with the myth of the detective's mortality, challenging the archetype of the invincible sleuth through Holmes's apparent demise at Reichenbach Falls, which underscores themes of sacrifice and the limits of rationalism.^[15] Holmes's "fall" represents a heroic culmination, freeing society from Moriarty's influence at the cost of his own life, thereby mythologizing the detective as a mortal figure whose death elevates his legacy beyond mere solvency of cases.^[28] This narrative constructs Holmes as a tragic hero, whose confrontation with an equal adversary exposes the fragility of order in a degenerating empire, blending admiration for Moriarty's skill with the inevitability of mutual destruction.^[27] Narrative unreliability in Watson's account further complicates these themes, as his first-person narration in "The Final Problem" invites skepticism about the veracity of events, particularly Holmes's death, given later revelations in the canon. Watson's emotional investment and limited perspective—relying on Holmes's reports without witnessing the climax—position him as an unreliable mediator, potentially embellishing details to honor his friend's heroism while concealing inconsistencies, such as the absence of a body from the falls.^[29] Structurally, critics note pacing issues arising from Moriarty's abrupt introduction, which creates chronological tensions within the Holmes canon; Watson claims prior ignorance of Moriarty in this story, yet later tales imply earlier awareness, disrupting narrative flow and forcing retroactive coherence.^[15] This hurried escalation from London to the European chase culminates in Holmes's "fall," evoking comparisons to Greek tragedy, where the protagonist's hubris leads to a cathartic downfall against a formidable antagonist, mirroring the inexorable fate in classical drama.^[27] The near-total absence of female characters highlights gender critiques, as the male-centric duel sidelines women, reflecting Victorian patriarchal norms that marginalize feminine agency in favor of homosocial bonds between detective and criminal. Recent 2020s scholarship further posits Moriarty as a queer-coded figure, with his obsessive admiration for Holmes suggesting same-sex desire and subverting binary oppositions of heteronormativity, power, and morality through their intertwined fates.^[30]

Influence and Legacy

Literary Influence

The introduction of Professor Moriarty in "The Final Problem" established the archetype of the arch-nemesis in detective fiction, depicting a shadowy criminal mastermind whose intellect rivals that of the hero, thereby elevating the stakes of the narrative beyond isolated crimes to a profound personal and philosophical confrontation. Moriarty, described as the "Napoleon of crime" who orchestrates a vast underworld empire from the shadows, served as a template for subsequent villains in literature and beyond, embodying the trope of the brilliant antagonist who mirrors the protagonist's genius while embodying moral inversion. This influence is evident in characters like Lex Luthor, Superman's calculating foe in DC Comics, whose strategic brilliance and vendetta against a superior force echo Moriarty's dynamic with Holmes, and Hannibal Lecter, the erudite psychiatrist and killer in Thomas Harris's novels, often characterized as a "Professor Moriarty of serial killers" for his manipulative orchestration of chaos.^[7]^[31]^[32] Within the Sherlock Holmes canon, the story's dramatic plunge into the Reichenbach Falls created the "Great Hiatus," a narrative void spanning three years (1891–1894 in the timeline) during which Holmes was presumed dead, profoundly shaping subsequent tales by introducing themes of absence, resurrection, and hidden exploits. This gap fueled fan speculation and pseudo-scholarly debate, transforming the hiatus into a fertile ground for later stories that retroactively filled the period with adventures across Europe, Asia, and Tibet, thereby expanding the series' scope and longevity. Doyle resolved the cliffhanger in the 1903 story "The Adventure of the Empty House," where Holmes reveals his survival through martial arts mastery and disguise, allowing the canon to continue with renewed vigor while cementing the hiatus as a pivotal structural device that influenced the pacing and mythological depth of the remaining 32 stories.^[15] The narrative's structure also advanced the detective genre's evolution by pioneering the "finale" story in serialized fiction, where a climactic showdown with an ultimate foe provides apparent closure, only to be subverted by revival—a pattern that inspired concluding installments in other iconic series. Agatha Christie's "Curtain: Poirot's Last Case" (1975), which ends with Hercule Poirot's suicide after confronting a manipulative serial killer, mirrors this in its deliberate termination of the detective's career amid moral ambiguity, reflecting Christie's broader engagement with and homage to Doyle's Holmes as a foundational influence on her own methodical sleuth. Recent 2020s scholarship further positions "The Final Problem" within postmodern detective deconstructions, analyzing its unresolved tensions and reader-driven coherence-building—exemplified by the "Great Game" tradition of treating the canon as historical fact—as a precursor to fragmented, participatory narratives that challenge linear resolution and authorial authority in contemporary crime fiction.^[15]

Cultural Impact

The Reichenbach Falls, the dramatic setting of Sherlock Holmes's supposed demise in "The Final Problem," has become an iconic pilgrimage site for fans since the story's publication in 1893.^[33] A memorial plaque commemorating the event was erected at the site in 1991 by the Bimetallic Question of Montreal and the Reichenbach Irregulars of Switzerland, drawing admirers to the Swiss location year after year.^[34] Today, the falls attract thousands of tourists annually, supported by a funicular railway and guided tours that highlight their literary significance, transforming the natural landmark into a cornerstone of Holmesian heritage tourism in the Bernese Oberland region.^[35] The Holmes-Moriarty rivalry introduced in the story has permeated popular culture as a symbol of intellectual duels between good and evil, establishing Moriarty as the archetypal master criminal and Holmes as the quintessential detective.^[36] This dynamic has influenced idioms and phrases evoking clever confrontation, such as references to "Napoleon of crime" for cunning adversaries, while Holmes's persona embodies the cultural archetype of the brilliant, eccentric solver of mysteries.^[37] The story's cliffhanger resolution reinforced Holmes's enduring status as a symbol of deductive triumph over chaos in Western literature and media.^[38] In the 2020s, the narrative's themes of apparent loss and return have resonated in global fan communities, with events like the Sherlock Holmes Society of London's "Reichenbach Revisited" tours in Switzerland and memorial picnics in the United States continuing to draw participants amid post-pandemic recovery.^[39]^[40] These gatherings underscore the story's ongoing relevance, as fans reinterpret the "hiatus" motif—Holmes's faked death and absence—in discussions of resilience and reunion, including online memes likening the plot to societal disruptions like the COVID-19 lockdowns.^[40]

Adaptations

Film Adaptations

The silent era saw some of the earliest cinematic interpretations of elements from "The Final Problem," though direct adaptations were rare until the 1920s. The 1916 American silent film Sherlock Holmes, directed by Bertram Bracken and starring William Gillette as Holmes, incorporated key aspects of the story through its basis in Gillette's 1899 stage play, which drew directly from "The Final Problem" for its depiction of Moriarty as a shadowy criminal overlord orchestrating Holmes's peril. This feature-length production emphasized the intellectual duel between detective and adversary, foreshadowing the Reichenbach Falls confrontation without explicitly staging it. A more explicit early adaptation came in 1923 with the British short film The Final Problem, part of the Stoll Pictures series starring Eille Norwood as Holmes. This 20-minute production faithfully recreated the story's core events, including Holmes's flight across Europe and the climactic struggle at Reichenbach Falls with Moriarty, portrayed by Lyn Harding. Produced under Arthur Conan Doyle's authorization, it highlighted the narrative's tension through intertitles and sparse action, capturing the story's atmosphere of impending doom. The 1922 German expressionist epic Dr. Mabuse, the Gambler, directed by Fritz Lang, drew significant influence from Moriarty's archetype in "The Final Problem," reimagining the "Napoleon of crime" as Dr. Mabuse, a hypnotic mastermind manipulating society through disguise, fraud, and psychological control. Though not a direct adaptation, the film's portrayal of an invisible criminal empire echoed Doyle's concept of a singular genius behind London's underworld, influencing subsequent cinematic villains. Among notable modern film adaptations, Guy Ritchie's 2011 action-comedy Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows prominently featured "The Final Problem" as its structural backbone, with Robert Downey Jr. as Holmes and Jared Harris as Moriarty. The film culminates in a elaborate showdown at Reichenbach Falls, blending the story's elements of pursuit and intellectual rivalry with steampunk visuals and explosive set pieces, grossing over $545 million worldwide. This interpretation amplified Moriarty's role as a chaotic force plotting global war, diverging from Doyle's subtler psychological thriller while retaining the iconic plunge into the falls. As of late 2025, a third installment in Ritchie's franchise, tentatively titled Sherlock Holmes 3 and starring Downey Jr. alongside Jude Law as Watson, remains in development with a script centered on a renewed confrontation with Moriarty. Producer Susan Downey confirmed ongoing story refinements in October 2025, emphasizing a return to the adversarial dynamics inspired by "The Final Problem," though no release date has been set amid scheduling challenges.^[41]

Television Adaptations

Television adaptations of "The Final Problem" have appeared in various formats, ranging from faithful period dramas to modern reinterpretations that incorporate elements of the story into broader narratives. One of the most acclaimed is the 1985 episode from ITV's Granada Television series The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, starring Jeremy Brett as Sherlock Holmes and David Burke as Dr. John Watson. Directed by Alan Grint, this adaptation closely follows Arthur Conan Doyle's original text, depicting Holmes's confrontation with Professor Moriarty (Eric Porter) and their fatal struggle at the Reichenbach Falls in Switzerland. The episode emphasizes the serialized nature of the series, building tension through Holmes's narration and Watson's retrospective account, and is noted for Brett's intense portrayal of Holmes's intellectual and emotional strain.^[42] In contrast, the BBC's modern series Sherlock (2010–2017) reimagines the story in a contemporary London setting with significant twists. The 2017 episode "The Final Problem," written by Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat and directed by Jeremy Webb, serves as the series finale, transforming Moriarty's role into a posthumous influence while introducing Eurus Holmes (Sian Brooke), Sherlock's secret sister, as the true antagonist orchestrating psychological games from a high-security island prison. Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock navigates hallucinatory trials and family revelations, diverging from the original's focus on Moriarty to explore themes of trauma and sibling rivalry, with Martin Freeman delivering a grounded performance as Watson amid the episode's high-stakes, puzzle-driven format.^[43] More recent adaptations integrate "The Final Problem" elements into non-Western contexts and hybrid genres. The 2024 Indian JioCinema series Shekhar Home, created by Aniruddha Guha and directed by Rohan Sippy, draws on the story's climax in its season 1 finale, where eccentric detective Shekhar (Kay Kay Menon) confronts the enigmatic "M" (Rasika Dugal in disguise) on Kolkata's Howrah Bridge, mirroring the Reichenbach Falls showdown as both characters plummet into the Hooghly River. This anthology-style series blends rural Bengal mysteries with Holmesian tropes, using the adaptation to reveal Shekhar's backstory and emphasize visual, atmospheric tension over strict fidelity.^[44] The 2024 CBS medical drama Watson, starring Morris Chestnut as Dr. John Watson, is structured as a sequel to "The Final Problem," opening its pilot episode with a dramatization of Holmes's (unseen) fatal fall at Reichenbach Falls alongside Moriarty. Created by Craig Sweeny, the series shifts to a procedural format focused on Watson running a clinic for rare diseases in Pittsburgh, one year after the presumed deaths, highlighting Chestnut's portrayal of a grieving yet resilient Watson while occasionally referencing Holmes's legacy through flashbacks and investigations. This makes it the fifth major television take on the story's aftermath, prioritizing emotional recovery and medical puzzles over detective work.^[45]

Audio Adaptations

One of the earliest notable audio adaptations of "The Final Problem" was a BBC radio production broadcast on December 21, 1954, featuring Sir John Gielgud as Sherlock Holmes, Sir Ralph Richardson as Dr. John Watson, and Orson Welles as Professor Moriarty.^[46] This full-cast dramatization emphasized the tense confrontation at Reichenbach Falls through dramatic dialogue and sound design, capturing the story's suspenseful atmosphere in a 30-minute format. In the 1990s, the BBC Radio 4 series "The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes," adapted by Bert Coules, included a 1992 episode of "The Final Problem" starring Clive Merrison as Holmes and Michael Williams as Watson.^[47] This full-cast production, first aired on November 4, 1992, incorporated period-appropriate sound effects to heighten the narrative's peril, particularly during the climactic struggle, and ran for approximately 45 minutes.^[47] Audiobook narrations have also brought the story to life, with Sir Derek Jacobi providing a solo reading as part of his 2005 Naxos Audiobooks edition of "The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes," which includes "The Final Problem." Jacobi's performance, known for its measured pacing and nuanced portrayal of Watson's grief-stricken narration, spans about 45 minutes for the story alone and features subtle sound effects evoking the roar of the Reichenbach Falls. Similarly, Stephen Fry narrated the tale in his 2017 Audible complete collection "Sherlock Holmes: The Definitive Collection," delivering a warm, engaging interpretation that underscores Holmes's intellectual duel with Moriarty over roughly 50 minutes, again with atmospheric audio enhancements for the falls sequence. A more recent audio adaptation is the 2022 Audible original podcast series "Moriarty: The Devil's Game," a ten-episode dramatization that reimagines the events leading to "The Final Problem" with fresh twists on Professor Moriarty's character, portraying him as a framed anti-hero pursued by shadowy forces.^[48] Produced by Treefort Media, this full-cast production, starring Ryan Dalusio as Moriarty, integrates dynamic soundscapes and music to build tension toward the iconic confrontation, offering a 5-hour runtime that expands on Doyle's original while maintaining fidelity to its core conflict.^[49]

Other Adaptations

One of the earliest stage adaptations incorporating elements from "The Final Problem" is William Gillette's 1899 play Sherlock Holmes, which draws primarily from the story alongside "A Scandal in Bohemia" and other Doyle tales to depict Holmes confronting Moriarty in a climactic struggle.^[50] This production, which premiered on Broadway and ran for over 1,000 performances across Gillette's career, established key visual and dramatic tropes for the character, including the famous line "Elementary, my dear Watson," though not from Doyle's original text.^[51] A modern reinterpretation appears in Steven Dietz's Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure (2007), which updates Gillette's script to blend "The Final Problem" with other cases, focusing on Holmes and Moriarty's rivalry culminating at Reichenbach Falls; the play has seen widespread productions, including a 2011 run at Theatre Aquarius in Hamilton, Ontario.^[52]^[53] In comics, the manga series Moriarty the Patriot (2016–2023), written by Ryosuke Takeuchi and illustrated by Hikaru Miyoshi, reimagines the events of "The Final Problem" from Professor Moriarty's perspective as a vigilante challenging social inequality, with its "Final Problem" arc spanning volumes 13–14 and reaching a climax in 2020.^[54] A 2023 graphic novel adaptation, Sherlock Holmes – The Final Problem illustrated by Hannes Binder, faithfully renders Doyle's narrative in a visually striking format, emphasizing the detective's pursuit and the Reichenbach confrontation.^[55] Video games have also adapted Holmes' world with nods to "The Final Problem," such as the 2009 adventure title Sherlock Holmes Versus Jack the Ripper by Frogwares, set in 1888 but referencing the detective's ongoing battle against criminal masterminds like Moriarty through dialogue and lore.^[56]

References

[1]
Issue 12 : The Final Problem - Discovering Sherlock Holmes
The Final Problem appeared in The Strand Magazine in December 1893, although the events narrated therein are supposed to take place in 1891. The Strand's ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
[2]
Adventure 11: “The Final Problem” | The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes
Year Published: 1894; Language: English; Country of Origin: England; Source: Doyle, A. C. (1894). The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes.
[3]
The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes ...
The Final Problem. I. Silver Blaze. I am afraid, Watson, that I shall have to go,” said Holmes, as we sat down together to our breakfast one morning. “Go ...Silver Blaze · II. The Adventure of the... · The “Gloria Scott” · VIII. The Crooked Man
[4]
[PDF] The Death, Burial, and Resurrection Of Sherlock Holmes
In 1893, in The Strand Magazine publication of “The Final Problem”, Doyle created a worthy nemesis for Sherlock Holmes: Professor Moriarty.
[5]
[PDF] Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Lucrative Fandom
The fandom's reaction to Holmes's death was immediate and unequivo- cal. More than twenty thousand people canceled their subscription to The. Strand, the ...
[6]
The Case of the Immortal Sherlock Holmes - The College Today
Jul 10, 2018 · And so, in the December 1893 issue of The Strand, in a story aptly named “The Final Problem,” Conan Doyle killed off his character in dramatic ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
[7]
[PDF] Sherlock Holmes and James Moriarty - eCommons
While Conan Doyle only ever introduces Moriarty into the narrative of “The Final Problem” (1893), the BBC introduces him as early as the first episode. Placing ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[8]
Memories and Adventures, by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle—A Project ...
MEMORIES AND ADVENTURES. BY SIR ARTHUR CONAN DOYLE. WITH ILLUSTRATIONS. BOSTON ... First it was Sherringford Holmes; then it was Sherlock Holmes. He could ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
Discovering Sherlock Holmes - A Community Reading Project From ...
As 1893 came to a close, Conan Doyle's wife Louise began the cure that would allow her to live for 13 more years, while Sherlock Holmes (apparently) died. " ...Missing: fan | Show results with:fan
[10]
Louisa Hawkins - The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia
Arthur and Louise travelled to Lucerne and Zermatt (Switzerland). At their return to England, she was diagnosed as suffering tuberculosis. 1894, winter, Arthur ...Arthur Conan Doyle about... · Photos of Louise · Biography · Interview of Louise
[11]
Professor Moriarty - Conan Doyle Info
Conan Doyle Info. The life and work of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[12]
[PDF] The Final Problem: Constructing Coherence in the Holmesian Canon
Abstract: The death and resurrection of Sherlock Holmes, a contrarian reading in which Holmes helps the murderer, and the century-long tradition of the ...
[13]
The Adventure of the Final Problem - The Arthur Conan Doyle ...
The Adventure of the Final Problem (FINA) is a short story written by Arthur Conan Doyle first published in various US newspapers on 26 november 1893.Editions · Illustrations · Locations · Adaptations
[14]
Sidney Paget Drawing: Death of Sherlock Holmes: Sotheby's 2024
Jun 26, 2024 · Paget provided nine illustrations for "The Final Problem," which appeared in the December 1893 Strand Magazine. He depicted Moriarty in ...Drawing Description · History · Provenance
[15]
The Strand Magazine - Engole
Aug 17, 2022 · Priced at sixpence,2½p in decimal currency. the magazine was about half the price of comparable publications. ... A United States edition was ...Missing: figures | Show results with:figures
[16]
1891-1893 The Strand Magazine - Rooke Books
20-day returnsThe Strand Magazine was immediately successful, with a three hundred thousand sale on the first publication, and a steady circulation of half a million copies a ...Missing: figures | Show results with:figures
[17]
Sherlock Holmes, classic tales and songs enter public domain in 2023
Sherlock Holmes is finally free to the American public in 2023. The long-running contested copyright dispute over Sir ...
[18]
The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes, by Arthur Conan Doyle
The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes, published in 1894, is the second collection of Sherlock Holmes ... The Final Problem” in which Holmes struggles with his nemesis ...
[19]
The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes (Vols. 1 & 2) - Leslie Klinger
In this boxed set, Leslie Klinger, a leading world authority, reassembles Arthur Conan Doyle's 56 classic short stories in the order in which they appeared.
[20]
Birth and Burial of Sherlock Holmes
at a "fine romantic place ... I got letters from all over the world reproaching me on the subject.
[21]
Sherlock Holmes's Fan Friction - The New Yorker
Jan 19, 2014 · In 1893, Arthur Conan Doyle famously killed Sherlock Holmes, chucking him off Reichenbach Falls. Protesters wore black armbands in the streets.
[22]
How Arthur Conan Doyle Plotted Against Sherlock Holmes
Oct 15, 2020 · Here is how Arthur Conan Doyle created Sherlock Holmes, tried to destroy him, and resurrected him to literary immortality.
[23]
How Sherlock Holmes changed the world - BBC
Jan 6, 2016 · Conan Doyle stuck to his guns in the face of the protests, calling the death “justifiable homicide” – referring, presumably, to his own ...
[24]
The Late Sherlock Holmes - Famous (and forgotten) Fiction
On December 29, 1893, readers of The St. James's Gazette were shocked to find that an arrest had been made in the tragic death of Sherlock Holmes.
[25]
[PDF] Sherlock Holmes' Dualistic Nature as a Placebo for Degeneracy
May 1, 2018 · Conan Doyle's “The Final Problem” is one of the best examples that depicts the dualism of detective and criminal. The relationship between ...
[26]
[PDF] The Representation of the Double in Arthur Conan Doyle's Three ...
The present paper examines the duality of human nature in late-nineteenth century Victorian society by exploring Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's famous.
[27]
Chapter 7 INTERPRETING THE UNRELIABLE - Oxford Academic
It is works to which I say the second kind of reliability/unreliability is attributable. Watson's is an unreliable narrative within a reliable work.5. But isn't ...
[28]
Postcolonialism in Victorian Holmes and 21st Century Sherlock
the construct of imperialism inhibits his ability to find the real criminal. And chapter three delves into the identity of Sherlock Holmes, and what remains of.
[29]
https://academic.oup.com/book/1578/chapter/141072368
[30]
The Adventure of the Final Problem - Jess Nevins
“The Final Problem” is the first Holmes story in which all of the elements necessary to make an individual Holmes story great come together. “The Final Problem” ...
[31]
[PDF] The Criminological Theories of Hannibal Lecter, Part Two
Hannibal Lecter is a particularly chilling villain because he is both a psychiatrist – a ... the Professor Moriarty of serial killers to its furthest ...<|separator|>
[32]
https://jcjpc.org/s/1-Oleson-2006.pdf
[33]
Reichenbach Waterfall - Haslital Tourismus
120 metre high waterfall "The Final Problem". A Sherlock Holmes memorial plaque at the cable car reminds us that Conan Doyle was so impressed by the wildness ...
[34]
The Reichenbach Falls - Atlas Obscura
Aug 9, 2016 · The Reichenbach Falls, the alpine falls where Sherlock Holmes apparently met his demise can actually be visited.Missing: pilgrimage memorials
[35]
https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/the-reichenbach-falls-schattenhalb-switzerland
[36]
What The Sherlock Archetype Teaches Us About Ourselves - HuffPost
Mar 20, 2015 · Through the Sherlock Holmes character, we vicariously say all the cruel, malicious, arrogant, and dismissive things we long to say to ...
[37]
Sherlock Holmes Archetype Meaning & Symbolism - MyMythos
To embody the Sherlock archetype is to find the universe's secret logic etched into the mundane, transforming life from a series of events into a grand, ...Archetype Meaning &... · Using Sherlock Holmes In... · Shadow Of Sherlock HolmesMissing: Moriarty rivalry cultural<|control11|><|separator|>
[38]
Reichenbach Revisited - The Sherlock Holmes Society of London
Reichenbach Revisited – The Sherlock Holmes Society of London returns to Switzerland! · Details · Organizer · Related Events · Upcoming Events.
[39]
Upcoming Events
Reichenbach Falls Remembrance and Memorial Picnic. May 7, 2022, time TBD ... We will remember the “Death” of Sherlock Holmes by gathering at Silver Falls ...
[40]
Sherlock Holmes 3: Producer Susan Downey Shares Update & Plot ...
Oct 2, 2025 · Susan Downey offers a major update on Sherlock Holmes 3, confirming that the movie is still in development and that they have a story idea.
[41]
"The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" The Final Problem (TV ... - IMDb
Rating 8.4/10 (1,262) Holmes is hired by the French government. The unthinkable has occurred: the Mona Lisa has been stolen from the Louvre. In his inimitable fashion, ...Photos31 · Top Cast13 · Related Interests
[42]
Sherlock | The Final Problem | Season 4 | Episode 3 - PBS
In this episode, written by Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat, long-buried secrets catch up with the Baker Street duo.
[43]
'Shekhar Home' Ending Explained & Finale Recap: What Is Jayavrat ...
Aug 14, 2024 · In a fit of rage, Maurya tried to attack Shekhar and ended up hanging from the railings of the Howrah Bridge. Shekhar tried to save him, but ...
[44]
Is Sherlock Holmes really dead in Watson? - Hidden Remote
Jan 27, 2025 · In The Final Problem, Sherlock and Moriarty went over the Reichenbach Falls in Switzerland, presumably killing them both. The show opened with ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[45]
BBC Radio 4 Extra - Sherlock Holmes, The Final Problem
4 Extra Debut. John Gielgud, Ralph Richardson and Orson Welles star in the great detective's encounter at the Reichenbach Falls. From December 1954.
[46]
BBC Radio 4 Extra - Series 2, The Final Problem - BBC
With the culmination of his life's work, the detective prepares to meet his greatest adversary. Starring Clive Merrison. 45 minutes ...
[47]
The Shape-Shifting Sherlock Holmes, Now Playing the Villain
Jul 7, 2022 · Because “Moriarty” takes place long before Holmes and Moriarty do damp, climactic battle in Conan Doyle's 1893 story “The Final Problem,” its ...
[48]
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/06/arts/sherlock-holmes-podcast-moriarty.html
[49]
[PDF] MOLDING THE IMAGE - William Gillette as Sherlock Holmes
The play was primarily based on two of Doyle's stories, "A Scandal in Bohemia" and "The Final. Problem," but also included elements from others such as A Study.
[50]
William Gillette: Five ways he transformed how Sherlock Holmes ...
Jan 26, 2015 · Gillette adapted Sherlock Holmes for the stage in 1899 and played Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's detective more than 1,000 times. He made only one ...Missing: Final | Show results with:Final
[51]
About the Playwrights: Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure
Preferring to write more serious work, he killed off Holmes in “The Final Problem” (1893). His other stories and novels were successful though not on the same ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
[52]
Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure - Theatre Aquarius, Hamilton
Oct 3, 2011 · September 23-October 8, 2011. “Sherlock in Love”. The main reason to see Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure is to enjoy two outstanding ...Missing: Broadway | Show results with:Broadway
[53]
Moriarty the Patriot Manga's 'The Final Problem' Arc Reaches ...
Nov 3, 2020 · In the manga, he is an orphan who assumes the name William James Moriarty when he and his younger brother are adopted into the Moriarty family.
[54]
Sherlock Holmes: The Final Problem | School Library Journal
Apr 1, 2023 · A new graphic novel adaptation of Sherlock Holmes's final confrontation with his archnemesis is in Binder's capable hands.
[55]
Achievement Guide + Walkthrough Part 1 - IGN
May 3, 2010 · Sherlock Holmes vs Jack the Ripper* Achievements Guide + Walkthrough Developed by Frogwares Published by The Adventure Company ©2009/2010 ...