Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Three Flags

Three Flags is a 1958 painting by American artist Jasper Johns, consisting of three overlapping images of the American flag rendered in encaustic on canvas, with each successive flag reduced in scale by approximately 25% and projecting forward to challenge traditional perspective.^[1] The work measures 30 5/8 × 45 1/2 × 4 5/8 inches (77.8 × 115.6 × 11.7 cm) and is held in the permanent collection of the Whitney Museum of American Art in New York, acquired in 1980 through funds from multiple donors including the Gilman Foundation.^[1] Johns began incorporating the American flag as a motif in his paintings in 1954, inspired by a dream in which he envisioned creating such an image, marking a departure from abstract expressionism toward the use of everyday symbols to explore the boundaries between representation and abstraction.^[1] In Three Flags, the encaustic medium—pigment mixed with heated wax—creates a richly textured, sculptural surface that draws attention to the flag's formal qualities, such as its patterns and brushstrokes, rather than its patriotic symbolism.^[1] Johns himself described the composition as allowing him to “go beyond the limits of the flag, and to have different canvas space,” emphasizing its innovative spatial dynamics.^[1] The painting is one of Johns' signature flag series, which established him as a key figure in mid-20th-century American art, influencing pop art and conceptual movements by prompting viewers to reevaluate familiar icons through a lens of perceptual ambiguity.^[1]

Overview

Description

Three Flags is a painting by American artist Jasper Johns, consisting of three overlapping canvases depicting the American flag in a triptych format. The work measures 30 5/8 × 45 1/2 inches (77.8 × 115.6 cm) overall, with a thickness of 4 5/8 inches (11.7 cm) due to the layered construction.^[1] The three flags are rendered in progressively diminishing sizes, with each subsequent flag approximately 75% the scale of the one beneath it, creating an illusion of receding depth while simultaneously projecting forward through physical buildup.^[1] The medium is encaustic and newspaper collage on canvas, where pigmented wax is applied hot and layered to form a textured, sculptural surface that emphasizes the flags' materiality.^[1] Each flag precisely replicates the U.S. ensign of 1958, featuring 48 white stars arranged in alternating rows of six on a blue field, alongside thirteen red and white stripes, all in traditional red, white, and blue tones.^[1] Newspaper fragments are collaged into the encaustic, adding subtle texture and visible imprints that enhance the work's tactile quality without altering the flag's iconic form.^[1] This layered composition challenges the flatness inherent to painting, as the forward-protruding elements—achieved through the wax's dimensional accumulation—blur the boundaries between two- and three-dimensional space.^[1] The result is a visually dense arrangement where the largest flag forms the base, partially obscured by the middle and smallest flags atop it, inviting close inspection to discern the intricate details of stars, stripes, and collaged underlayers.^[1]

Creation

In 1954, Jasper Johns experienced a dream in which he envisioned himself painting the American flag, serving as the catalyst for his initial exploration of the motif in works like Flag (1954–55).^[2] This inspiration came one year after his discharge from the U.S. Army in 1953, where he had served from 1951 to 1953, including a posting in Sendai, Japan, during which his exposure to military symbols likely heightened his awareness of the flag as a ubiquitous emblem.^[3] Seeking to move away from the gestural abstraction dominant in Abstract Expressionism, Johns deliberately chose subjects like the flag—describing them as "things the mind already knows"—to challenge viewers' preconceptions and emphasize perception over invention.^[1] By 1958, Johns had developed this theme further, completing Three Flags in his studio at 128 Front Street in Lower Manhattan, a space he shared in proximity with Robert Rauschenberg during this period.^[4] The painting emerged as one of his large-scale flag works from that year, produced alongside smaller studies and drawings that tested variations on the composition.^[5] In creating the triptych, Johns innovated by layering three progressively smaller flags—each reduced by approximately 25% in scale—directly atop one another on separate canvases, allowing the format to physically embody themes of repetition and spatial ambiguity specific to this piece.^[1] This structure, built up to a depth of nearly five inches, transformed the flat icon into a sculptural object, reflecting Johns' intent to expand beyond traditional pictorial limits.^[6]

Artistic Context

Johns' Flag Series

Jasper Johns began his Flag series in 1954, producing his inaugural painting of the American flag and establishing it as a central motif in his practice. Throughout the 1950s and 1960s, the series expanded to encompass over 40 works, including paintings, prints, drawings, and sculptures that explored the flag in diverse scales—from small studies to monumental canvases—media, and orientations, reflecting Johns's sustained interrogation of familiar imagery.^[1]^[7] Prominent examples from the series include the foundational Flag (1954–55), an encaustic, oil, and collage work on fabric mounted to plywood at the Museum of Modern Art, which captures the flag's stripes and stars in a textured, near-life-size format. White Flag (1955), housed at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, presents a bleached, monochromatic iteration that subverts the emblem's traditional vibrancy. The motif extended sculpturally in 1960 with bronze editions of the flag, such as the cast version at the Art Institute of Chicago, marking a three-dimensional departure. Three Flags (1958), a triptych at the Whitney Museum of American Art, comprises three stacked panels in diminishing scales, amplifying the flag's repetitive structure across 30 5/8 × 45 1/2 inches (77.8 × 115.6 cm).^[8]^[9]^[10]^[1] The series evolved from initial treatments that replicated the flag's design with direct fidelity, using techniques like encaustic to highlight material tactility, toward more experimental variations in the late 1950s and early 1960s. These included color inversions, as in grayscale or complementary schemes that estranged the familiar palette; fragmentation, breaking the form into disjointed elements; and thickened encaustic layering, which embedded collaged newsprint and built up surfaces to disrupt optical unity and emphasize process.^[8]^[11]^[12] Central to the Flag series was Johns's conceptualization of the motif as a painted "readymade," echoing Marcel Duchamp's elevation of ordinary objects to art while adapting it to post-war American cultural symbols, thereby questioning the flag's representational role without overt symbolism.^[13]^[14]

Techniques and Materials

Jasper Johns primarily employed encaustic as the medium for Three Flags (1958), a technique involving pigments suspended in heated beeswax, which he applied using brushes and knives to achieve varied impasto effects and a sculptural texture. This ancient method, revived by Johns, allowed the wax to congeal rapidly upon cooling, preserving the fluidity of his strokes while creating a luminous, layered surface that emphasizes the physicality of paint. In Three Flags, encaustic is combined with oil paint for certain areas and integrated with newspaper collage elements, where fragments of newsprint are embedded beneath the wax layers to add subtle texture and a sense of ephemerality, evoking the passage of time through translucent overlays.^[1]^[8]^[15] The process began with Johns layering hot wax mixed with pigments over collaged newspaper on canvas supports, building up the composition through multiple applications that hardened into a dense, tactile buildup. Rather than using stencils for precision, Johns painted the flag motifs from memory and photographic references, introducing deliberate imperfections in the stars and stripes that highlight the hand of the artist and disrupt mechanical reproduction. This approach contrasts with more uniform Pop Art techniques, underscoring Johns' focus on the act of painting itself. For Three Flags specifically, he constructed the work from three separate canvases, each depicting a progressively smaller version of the American flag—reduced proportionally by approximately 25%—which were then joined and stacked to form a multi-panel structure projecting outward in space.^[16]^[17]^[1] These methods marked an evolution in Johns' flag series, transitioning from the relatively flat encaustic surfaces of earlier works like Flag (1954–55) to more three-dimensional constructions in pieces such as Three Flags, where the joined panels and wax buildup blur the boundaries between painting and object. This innovative material exploration influenced subsequent Pop Art practices by prioritizing everyday motifs through experimental media, encouraging artists to treat commercial imagery with sculptural depth and process-oriented mark-making.^[15]^[18]

Significance and Reception

Critical Analysis

Three Flags (1958) presents the American flag as an ambiguous icon, simultaneously evoking patriotism and a sense of detachment that invites viewers to question its symbolic potency. Art historian Fred Orton describes Johns' flag paintings as operating "in the space of difference... neither positive nor negative, but both," underscoring their undecidability as either national emblem or abstract composition. This ambiguity extends to themes of perception and memory, where the work's encaustic medium—pigment mixed with warm wax—creates a textured surface that embeds layers of newsprint, suggesting historical and personal recollections beneath the flag's familiar form. The painting blurs the boundary between image and object, as curator Alan R. Solomon queried of Johns' flags: "Is it a flag or a painting?" prompting an examination of how symbols function both representationally and materially.^[19]^[19]^[15]^[19] In art historical context, Three Flags serves as a pivotal bridge between the emotional abstraction of Abstract Expressionism and the incorporation of quotidian imagery in Pop Art. Johns' treatment of the flag as a readymade motif challenges the gestural spontaneity of predecessors like Jackson Pollock while prefiguring Andy Warhol's serial reproductions of consumer icons, emphasizing the flag's status as an everyday yet loaded symbol. This transitional role aligns with Leo Steinberg's theory of the "flatbed picture plane," where the canvas functions less as a window into illusionistic depth and more as a horizontal surface akin to a printing press bed, allowing the incorporation of real-world information and textures—evident in the overlapping flags' tactile, layered construction that rejects vertical orientation toward the viewer. Post-World War II nationalism further contextualizes the work, as the flag's depiction amid Cold War tensions reframes patriotic fervor as a site of cultural reevaluation rather than unexamined allegiance.^[15]^[20]^[17] Key critiques highlight the painting's formal innovations and socio-political implications. Michael Fried, in his advocacy for modernist opticality, praised Johns' flags for their emphasis on pure visual experience, where the work's surface demands focused, absorptive viewing detached from theatrical or literal associations. Debates on nationalism, particularly in the postwar era, frame the flags as enacting American hegemony through a balance of coercion and consent, as Anne M. Wagner argues, revealing the "fatal power and persuasiveness of Americanism" in shaping identity amid global dominance.^[21]^[22] The triptych form of Three Flags offers unique interpretations, metaphorically layering historical narratives while creating an illusion of depth within a fundamentally flat medium. The three canvases, each diminishing by approximately 25% in scale and stacked to project forward, defy traditional perspective, transforming the flags into a receding yet protruding structure that symbolizes temporal accumulation—past, present, and future iterations of national identity overlaid on the picture plane. This configuration, as noted by the Whitney Museum, shifts emphasis from the flag's emblematic nationalism to its geometric and textural properties, fostering a perceptual tension between surface flatness and implied volume. Within Johns' broader flag series, this triptych amplifies the motif's exploratory potential through multiplication.^[1]^[1]

Cultural Impact

Three Flags played a pivotal role in the development of Pop Art, serving as a bridge between Abstract Expressionism and the movement's embrace of everyday imagery. By recontextualizing the American flag as a layered, encaustic composition, Johns inspired contemporaries like Andy Warhol and Robert Rauschenberg to incorporate banal symbols into fine art, challenging traditional notions of originality and abstraction.^[23] This work became an emblem of 1960s American identity, its repetitive flags evoking both national pride and ambivalence during the Vietnam War era, when the symbol's meaning shifted amid anti-war protests and cultural upheaval.^[19] The painting has permeated popular media through reproductions, including posters, lithographs, and merchandise such as T-shirts, making its image widely accessible beyond museum walls.^[24] Its market significance was underscored in 1980 when the Whitney Museum acquired it for $1 million—a record for a living artist at the time—highlighting its status as a cornerstone of postwar American art.^[25] As a flagship piece in the Whitney's collection, Three Flags fosters public engagement with themes of patriotism, prompting discussions on national symbols in contemporary contexts, including post-9/11 reflections on flag-waving rituals.^[1] It has been parodied in media, notably in a 1999 Simpsons episode where Johns guest-voiced as himself, satirizing his flag motifs amid Homer's "outsider art" escapades.^[26] The work also influenced U.S. flag desecration debates, as its artistic manipulation of the flag echoed protests against laws restricting symbolic expression, from Vietnam-era dissent to later constitutional challenges.^[27] The painting's enduring impact was reaffirmed in the 2021-2022 retrospective Jasper Johns: Mind/Mirror at the Whitney Museum of American Art and the Philadelphia Museum of Art, which featured Three Flags and explored its role in ongoing dialogues about perception, symbolism, and American identity.^[28]

Provenance and Exhibitions

Ownership History

"Three Flags," created by Jasper Johns in 1958, was initially acquired by collectors Burton G. Tremaine Sr. and Emily Hall Tremaine in 1959 for $900 from the Leo Castelli Gallery.^[25] The Tremaines, renowned for their extensive collection of 20th-century modern art emphasizing post-1945 works, integrated the painting into their holdings, which included significant pieces by emerging American artists.^[29] During their ownership, "Three Flags" was loaned to various exhibitions, showcasing its prominence in institutional displays prior to its permanent placement.^[30] In 1980, the Tremaines sold "Three Flags" to the Whitney Museum of American Art through the Pace Gallery for $1 million, establishing a record price for a work by a living artist at the time and signaling a pivotal escalation in valuations for contemporary American art.^[25] The acquisition, funded by donors including the Gilman Foundation and A. Alfred Taubman to commemorate the museum's 50th anniversary, marked the painting's entry into the Whitney's permanent collection as accession number 80.32.^[1] Since then, it has remained in the Whitney's custody without further transfers, underscoring its status as a cornerstone of their holdings in postwar American art.^[1]

Notable Displays

Three Flags debuted at Jasper Johns's first solo exhibition, held at the Leo Castelli Gallery in New York from January 31 to February 28, 1958.^[31] The work was soon recognized as a pivotal piece in Johns's early career and was included in subsequent international showcases representing American art, such as the United States Pavilion at the 32nd Venice Biennale from June 20 to October 18, 1964.^[32] It also appeared at the 9th São Paulo Biennial in 1967, further highlighting its role in U.S. cultural diplomacy during the Cold War era.^[32] The painting gained prominence through major retrospectives dedicated to Johns's oeuvre. It was featured in the comprehensive Jasper Johns exhibition at the Whitney Museum of American Art from October 17, 1977, to January 22, 1978, which surveyed over 200 works from 1955 to 1976.^[32] Similarly, Three Flags was loaned from the Whitney for the landmark Jasper Johns: A Retrospective at the Museum of Modern Art in New York from October 20, 1996, to January 21, 1997, before touring to the Museum Ludwig in Cologne and the Museum of Contemporary Art in Tokyo through 1997.^[33]^[32] Three Flags has remained a cornerstone of the Whitney Museum of American Art's permanent collection since its 1980 acquisition for a record $1 million from collectors Burton and Emily Hall Tremaine, and has been frequently displayed there.^[1]^[25] It was temporarily loaned to The Broad in Los Angeles for Jasper Johns: "Something Resembling Truth" from February 10 to May 13, 2018, and prominently displayed in the Whitney's Jasper Johns: Mind/Mirror retrospective from September 29, 2021, to February 13, 2022.^[34] These displays underscore the work's enduring curatorial significance, with occasional conservation assessments conducted in preparation for such presentations.^[1]

References

[1]
Jasper Johns | Three Flags | Whitney Museum of American Art
In 1954, Jasper Johns began painting what would become one of his signature emblems: the American flag. As an iconic image--comparable to the targets, ...
[2]
[PDF] Jasper Johns, a print retrospective - MoMA
[A flag coming to him in a dream] was the only instance where a dream was my ... "Jasper Johns." Art News 72 (March 1973), pp. 20-22. Rose, Barbara ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[3]
Jasper Johns | The Guggenheim Museums and Foundation
Johns was drafted into the U.S. Army in 1951 and served for two years in South Carolina and Japan. On his return to New York in 1953, Johns enrolled in ...Missing: 1948-1951 | Show results with:1948-1951
[4]
Jasper Johns Residence & Studio - NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project
Johns moved into a studio on Pearl Street (demolished) in 1954, with Rauschenberg soon joining him in a studio downstairs. ... In 1958, dealer Leo Castelli was ...
[5]
Jasper Johns Paintings, Bio, Ideas - The Art Story
Important Art by Jasper Johns · Flag · Target with Four Faces · False Start · Painted Bronze (Ale Cans) · Periscope (Hart Crane) · According to What · Corpse and ...
[6]
Jasper Johns with John Yau - The Brooklyn Rail
Jasper Johns with John Yau. Word count: 3371. Paragraphs: 89. img1. Portrait of ... Rail: You had a dream in which you saw yourself painting the American flag.
[7]
Flag (Moratorium) by Jasper Johns on artnet Auctions
Lot Details. About This Lot. "Jasper Johns created over 40 works based on the U.S. flag, the first of which he made in 1954 only two years after being ...
[8]
Jasper Johns. Flag. 1954-55 (dated on reverse 1954) | MoMA
Jasper Johns Flag 1954-55 (dated on reverse 1954) ; Medium: Encaustic, oil, and collage on fabric mounted on plywood, three panels ; Dimensions: 42 1/4 x 60 5/8" ...
[9]
Jasper Johns - White Flag - The Metropolitan Museum of Art
During the 1950s and 1960s Johns frequently appropriated well-known images such as targets, maps, and flags—in his words, "things the mind already knows.
[10]
Flag | The Art Institute of Chicago
Jasper Johns, 1960. ... A work made of bronze, edition number two of four. Art © Jasper Johns/Licensed by VAGA, New York, NY ...
[11]
An Art of Changes: Jasper Johns Prints,… | Grand Rapids Art Museum
When American artist Jasper Johns' paintings of flags and targets were ... fragmenting, doubling, reversing, and varying scale or color. The exhibition ...Missing: inversion | Show results with:inversion
[12]
Jasper Johns's Optics - - Blog - Castelli Gallery
Jul 24, 2023 · Johns's complementary color scheme estranges the American flag as it is normally seen, but at the same time confirms it in reverse. The ...Missing: fragmentation | Show results with:fragmentation
[13]
Jasper Johns - AAEP 1600 - The Ohio State University
JASPER JOHNS. Here is a ... In 1954, Johns destroyed all his work (except the pieces owned by friends) and had a dream about painting the American flag.
[14]
[PDF] Flag(1954–55) In late 1954 Jasper Johns destroyed - MoMA
For Johns this icon of American identity was neutral, without polemic, whether political or aesthetic. Explaining his tactics, he said, “Using the design of the ...Missing: post- war
[15]
Jasper Johns, Flag - Smarthistory
Jasper Johns, Flag, 1954-55 (dated on reverse 1954), encaustic, oil, and collage on fabric mounted on plywood, three panels, 42-1/4 x 60-5/8′′ / 107.3 x 153.8 ...
[16]
Jasper Johns' Techniques | MyArtBroker | Article
Nov 21, 2024 · Painted Bronze (1960). One of Johns' most iconic sculptures, Painted Bronze (1960), exemplifies his approach to casting and his conceptual ...
[17]
Jasper Johns Paints the American Flag | Research Starters - EBSCO
Johns conceived the painting after a vivid dream, and it marked a departure from the emotional intensity of abstract expressionism toward a more analytical and ...
[18]
Three Flags (1958): The Story of Jasper Johns' iconic piece
### Summary of Construction, Materials, and Techniques for *Three Flags* (1958) by Jasper Johns
[19]
ACCORDING TO WHAT: JASPER JOHNS'S FLAG - Artforum
This is the canvas that most directly remembers Johns's decade-old dream of painting the flag, only to transform the initial spectral image of a dream-flag ...
[20]
[PDF] Excerpt from Other Criteria: The Flatbed Picture Plane - MIT
The Flatbed Picture Plane. LEO STEINBERG (1920-). I borrow the term from the flatbed printing press—'a horizontal bed on which a horizontal printing surface ...Missing: Flags | Show results with:Flags
[21]
[PDF] art and objecthood - Monoskop
MICHAEL FRIED is the Herbert Boone Professor of Humanities at the johns :Hopkins. University. Cover photograph: Michael Fried in Anthony Caro's studio, Triangle ...
[22]
[PDF] Krauss_Rosalind_E_Optical_Un...
seriality, repetition, the automaton. Which is to say, it is a function of a ... Krauss, Rosalind. “Corpus Delicti.” In. L'Amour Fou: Photography and ...
[23]
A House Divided: American Art since 1955 - Nonsite.org
Jul 24, 2012 · Anne Wagner's subtle meditation on Johns's flag paintings and what they can reveal about the “fatal power and persuasiveness of Americanism as a ...
[24]
'Three Flags' and other rare Jasper Johns works unveiled at the Broad
Feb 7, 2018 · It's one of Johns' earliest flag paintings and, as an encaustic work painted with a mixture of melted beeswax and pigment, it's also one of his ...
[25]
Three Flags, Art Poster by Jasper Johns - Amazon.com
Amazon.com: Three Flags, Art Poster by Jasper Johns: Unframed Prints: Posters & Prints.
[26]
Painting by Jasper Johns Sold for Million, a Record; The Whitney ...
Sep 27, 1980 · “The price was $1,000, less 10 percent, plus a $15 delivery charge. I must have been poor I wouldn't make such a charge today." Recently, he had ...
[27]
Mom and Pop Art - The Simpsons Archive
Jasper Johns: When he's not busy guest-voicing on cartoons, Jasper Johns is a painter. Many of his paintings depict flat subjects like flags, rulers, and ...
[28]
Censorship, Jenny Holzer, and Three Flags - Haber's Art Reviews
But suppose a constitutional amendment, banning desecration of the flag. Would those images still have a home? Now, no one at the Whitney is complaining or ...
[29]
50 Paintings to Be Sold From Tremaine Estate - The New York Times
Jun 7, 1991 · In 1980 the Tremaines privately sold Johns's "Three Flags," from 1958, which they purchased in 1960 for $900, to the Whitney Museum for $1 ...
[30]
History - Emily Hall Tremaine Foundation
She and her husband Burton G. Tremaine, Sr., were collectors of 20th century art with an emphasis on work done by artists after 1945. Their collection of more ...
[31]
TC: Johns Three Flags - Emily Hall Tremaine Foundation
Jasper Johns | Three Flags | 1958. Encaustic on canvas, Overall: 30 7/8 x 45 1/2 x 5 in. (78.4 x 115.6 x 12.7 cm). Whitney Museum of American Art, New York; ...
[32]
Three Flags, by Jasper Johns at the Whitney - New York Art World
The interplay of one complete and two partially visible flags serves to emphasize both design and dimension. Instead of pictorializing the flag, as he had in ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[33]
Jasper Johns. Three flags, (1958) in publications, exhibitions
Meet the lady behind the painting. Her name is Emily. Plus a list of exhibitions and selected publications regarding Three flags.
[34]
Jasper Johns: A Retrospective - MoMA
A comprehensive survey, in all media, of perhaps the most influential American artist of the last three decades, a crucial forefather of Pop, Minimal, and ...Missing: 2014-2015 | Show results with:2014-2015
[35]
Jasper Johns: Mind/Mirror | Whitney Museum of American Art
Jasper Johns: Mind/Mirror is the most comprehensive retrospective ever devoted to Johns's art. Featuring his most iconic works along with many others shown for ...Missing: Eye | Show results with:Eye