Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Apple Daily

Apple Daily was a Chinese-language tabloid newspaper founded in Hong Kong in 1995 by Jimmy Lai, initially known for its sensationalist coverage of crime, gossip, and entertainment before becoming a leading pro-democracy outlet critical of the Chinese Communist Party and Beijing's influence over Hong Kong.^[1]^[2]^[3] The newspaper achieved rapid success through aggressive marketing and price wars, reaching daily circulations of around 300,000 copies in Hong Kong at its peak, and played a pivotal role in mobilizing public support for democratic movements, including the 2003 protests against national security legislation, the 2014 Umbrella Movement, and the 2019 anti-extradition bill demonstrations by highlighting issues such as police conduct and demands for universal suffrage.^[1]^[3] It also conducted investigative reporting that exposed local corruption, contributing to accountability among officials, though its tabloid style drew criticism for vulgarity and prioritizing infotainment over depth.^[3]^[1] Apple Daily's defining controversies stemmed from its unyielding opposition to authoritarian policies, which included publishing articles deemed to incite foreign sanctions against Hong Kong and China, leading to repeated police raids, arrests of executives including founder Jimmy Lai under the 2020 National Security Law, and ultimately the freezing of assets worth millions, forcing its closure on June 24, 2021, after printing a final edition of one million copies that sold out amid public queues.^[2]^[3]^[1] The shutdown symbolized the erosion of press freedoms in Hong Kong post-NSL, with Lai facing ongoing trials for alleged collusion with foreign forces and sedition, potentially carrying life imprisonment, while the paper's assets were liquidated and staff detained.^[3]^[2]

Founding and Early Operations

Launch and Initial Business Strategy

Apple Daily was launched on 20 June 1995 by Jimmy Lai, a Hong Kong entrepreneur who had amassed wealth through the apparel chain Giordano and the weekly magazine Next Magazine, the latter established in 1990 as a response to the 1989 Tiananmen Square crackdown.^[4]^[5] Lai personally earmarked approximately US$100 million for the newspaper's startup, funding its operations amid a sluggish economy and a saturated Chinese-language print market dominated by established dailies.^[6] The initial business strategy centered on disrupting incumbents through price competition and mass-market appeal. Apple Daily debuted at a promotional cover price of HK$2—roughly half the HK$5 standard for rivals like Oriental Daily and Ming Pao—accompanied by giveaways such as complimentary apples and shopping bags to drive impulse buys and trial readership.^[7]^[4] This low-price tactic ignited an industry-wide price war, leading to the eventual closure of five competing newspapers as resources strained under discounted sales and rising newsprint costs.^[8] Complementing the pricing model, the paper pioneered full-color printing throughout Hong Kong's press, adopting a compact tabloid format with oversized headlines, vivid layouts, and content skewed toward entertainment, celebrity gossip, and human-interest stories to attract a broad, working-class audience rather than elite subscribers.^[9] This populist orientation prioritized high-volume circulation over immediate profitability, yielding claimed daily sales of 310,000 copies by December 1995 despite lacking independent audits at the time.^[10] The strategy reflected Lai's calculated risk to capture market share in a pre-handover environment, leveraging print innovation and aggressive promotion to challenge complacent incumbents.^[11]

Price Competition and Circulation Expansion

Apple Daily launched on June 20, 1995, with an aggressive pricing strategy and an initial print run of 200,000 copies, significantly exceeding typical launches in Hong Kong's saturated newspaper market.^[7] This approach, backed by heavy promotional campaigns, enabled the newspaper to achieve rapid circulation growth, reaching claimed daily sales of 290,000 copies by October 1995, with print runs consistently selling out.^[6] The low introductory pricing disrupted the longstanding circulation price cartel among established Chinese-language dailies, sparking an intense price war that forced several competitors, including Sing Pao Daily News, to slash rates or cease operations.^[12]^[13] In December 1995, Apple Daily reduced its cover price from HK$0.65 to HK$0.52, prompting rivals like Oriental Daily to follow suit and drop to as low as HK$0.26, intensifying competition amid rising newsprint costs.^[14] This "brutal" tactic, as described by observers, eroded profit margins across the industry but propelled Apple Daily's circulation to a claimed 310,000 copies per day by late 1995.^[10]^[15] By the late 1990s, sustained price competition and market consolidation had expanded Apple Daily's reach to approximately 400,000 daily copies, establishing it as one of Hong Kong's top-selling tabloids despite ongoing financial pressures from the war.^[15]^[4] The strategy's success stemmed from founder Jimmy Lai's willingness to subsidize losses initially, prioritizing volume over immediate profitability to build a loyal readership base.^[16]

Development of Tabloid Format and Features

Apple Daily launched on 20 June 1995 under the ownership of Jimmy Lai's Next Media company, explicitly adopting a tabloid format to challenge the dominance of established, more conservative Chinese-language newspapers in Hong Kong.^[2] This approach emphasized sensationalist content, including bold, oversized headlines, extensive use of paparazzi-style photographs, and stories focused on celebrity gossip, crime, and personal scandals, which were designed to appeal to a mass audience seeking entertaining, accessible journalism.^[2] ^[17] The format drew inspiration from Western tabloids but adapted to local tastes, incorporating elements like lurid exposés and light soft pornography in its early issues to drive initial readership growth amid fierce price competition.^[1] Key features of the tabloid style included vibrant full-color printing, graphic-heavy layouts, and a mix of spot news with visual storytelling, which set it apart from the text-dominant broadsheets prevalent at the time.^[18] These innovations, such as prominent photo spreads and animated-style illustrations in print, prioritized immediacy and emotional impact over detached analysis, enabling rapid circulation expansion to over 300,000 daily copies within months of launch.^[19] The paper's early emphasis on entertainment-driven content, including humorous narratives and scandal-mongering, established a provocative tone that blurred lines between infotainment and reporting, influencing competitors to adopt similar visual and stylistic elements.^[20] Over the subsequent years, particularly following the 1997 handover of Hong Kong to China, the tabloid format evolved by integrating harder-edged political commentary and investigative pieces while retaining its core sensationalist features.^[21] Opinionated columns, satirical cartoons, and front-page political scandals became fixtures, allowing the paper to sustain reader engagement through a hybrid model that combined gossip with critiques of authority, though this shift drew accusations of prioritizing provocation over objectivity from detractors.^[19] By the 2000s, digital adaptations like short video clips and online animations extended these print innovations, but the foundational tabloid aesthetics—large visuals, emotive language, and boundary-pushing narratives—remained central to its identity across 26 years of operation.^[19]

Editorial Stance and Journalistic Practices

Core Political Positions

Apple Daily's editorial stance was characterized by strong opposition to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and its political system, viewing it as incompatible with Hong Kong's freedoms and autonomy. The newspaper consistently criticized Beijing's interference in Hong Kong affairs, including the imposition of the 2020 national security law, which it portrayed as eroding the city's semi-autonomous status under the "one country, two systems" framework.^[2] This position aligned with founder Jimmy Lai's advocacy for democratic reforms, rooted in his post-1989 Tiananmen Square experience, emphasizing free expression and resistance to authoritarian control.^[22] The publication championed Hong Kong's pro-democracy movement, supporting calls for universal suffrage and genuine elections free from Beijing's vetting. It framed the 2014 Umbrella Movement and 2019 anti-extradition protests as legitimate public demands for accountability rather than mere unrest, often urging international attention to pressure China.^[21] Apple Daily's coverage extended to localist sentiments, with editorials and reporting that occasionally endorsed self-determination narratives, including independence advocacy as articulated by Lai, though the paper positioned itself as defending Hong Kong's Basic Law rights against encroachment.^[23] Critics, including Hong Kong authorities, alleged the newspaper's content amounted to seditious incitement by lobbying foreign governments for sanctions against China, but Apple Daily maintained its role was to amplify democratic discourse and hold power accountable.^[24] This stance led to advertising boycotts from pro-Beijing entities and positioned the outlet as a counterweight to state-aligned media, prioritizing empirical reporting on corruption and rights abuses over deference to official narratives.^[19]

Sensationalist Style and Content Characteristics

Apple Daily employed a tabloid format that emphasized sensational headlines, large color graphics, and paparazzi-style photography to attract readers, distinguishing it from conventional Hong Kong newspapers.^[2] This approach drew from popular Western tabloids, focusing initially on entertainment, crime, celebrity gossip, and mildly erotic content to build circulation, which peaked at over 600,000 daily copies by the early 2000s.^[1] The newspaper's content often blended scandal-driven stories with political commentary, using hyperbolic language and dramatic visuals to highlight government corruption or policy failures, such as portraying officials in unflattering, exaggerated scenarios.^[17] For instance, front pages frequently featured oversized images of public figures in compromising situations alongside accusatory banners, amplifying emotional appeals over nuanced analysis.^[25] This style resonated with younger, urban audiences seeking irreverent alternatives to staid media but drew rebukes for prioritizing provocation over restraint.^[26] Critics, including pro-Beijing commentators, labeled the outlet's tactics as akin to yellow journalism, citing instances of unsubstantiated claims in pursuit of reader engagement, though supporters argued the vibrancy fueled necessary scrutiny of power.^[27] Despite such characterizations, the format's commercial success—evident in sustained high sales through 2019—underscored its alignment with market demands for accessible, attention-grabbing journalism in a competitive landscape.^[25]

Achievements in Investigative Reporting

Apple Daily's investigative reporting targeted corruption and misconduct among Hong Kong officials, including exposés on illegal property modifications. In 2018, its reporters uncovered unauthorized structures at the home of Secretary for Justice Teresa Cheng, prompting public scrutiny and highlighting inconsistencies in official compliance with building regulations.^[28] Similar investigations in 2020 revealed illegal extensions at village houses owned by senior police officers, such as Deputy Commissioner Mario Wong and others, amid broader allegations of enforcement hypocrisy during heightened political tensions.^[29]^[30] The newspaper's team earned recognition for in-depth probes into public infrastructure failures. In 2019, Apple Daily received a Merit award in the Human Rights Press Awards' Investigative Feature Writing category for its series on the Shatin to Central Link scandal, which detailed construction delays, safety lapses, and alleged collusion between contractors and officials on the major rail project.^[31] This work exemplified the outlet's focus on accountability in government-backed developments, drawing on fieldwork and document analysis to substantiate claims of mismanagement. Apple Daily also pursued cross-border human rights investigations, contributing to awards for coverage of detained activists. Its 2019 reporting on Liu Xia, wife of Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo, won in the Human Rights Press Awards' Current Affairs category, involving efforts to verify her conditions under Chinese house arrest despite restricted access.^[32] These efforts underscored the paper's role in amplifying suppressed narratives, though critics noted the blend of advocacy with journalism sometimes blurred lines between reporting and activism.^[21] Overall, such investigations bolstered its reputation for challenging elite impunity, even as they invited accusations of selective targeting from pro-Beijing sources.

Role in Hong Kong's Political Landscape

Coverage of the 2014 Umbrella Movement

Apple Daily offered robust on-the-ground reporting of the Umbrella Movement, which erupted on September 26, 2014, after Hong Kong police used tear gas against demonstrators protesting Beijing's August 31, 2014, restrictions on chief executive elections, limiting candidates to those nominated by a Beijing-influenced committee.^[33] The newspaper's journalists documented protest sites in Admiralty, Mong Kok, and Causeway Bay, capturing scenes of protesters using umbrellas to shield against pepper spray and highlighting demands for genuine universal suffrage under the "one person, one vote" principle without pre-screening.^[34] Its coverage emphasized the movement's non-violent civil disobedience origins in Occupy Central, initiated by academics Benny Tai, Chan Kin-man, and Chu Yiu-ming, while critiquing the Chinese Communist Party's interference in Hong Kong's autonomy as promised in the 1984 Sino-British Joint Declaration.^[35] The outlet's digital efforts amplified the protests significantly; its live YouTube stream of events became Hong Kong's most-viewed non-music video of 2014, garnering 3.4 million views—roughly half the city's population at the time.^[36] Editorials and news sections deviated from mainstream Hong Kong media trends, with approximately half of news content and 90 percent of opinion pieces framed as pro-democracy, advocating for protesters' rejection of Beijing's "fake universal suffrage" framework.^[19] Founder Jimmy Lai, a vocal movement supporter, personally engaged by visiting occupation sites and aligning the paper's stance with calls to sustain pressure until electoral reforms met international democratic standards, though some analyses note Apple Daily occasionally platformed moderate pan-democrats urging de-escalation to avoid prolonged disruption.^[37]^[38] This pro-protester orientation drew backlash from pro-Beijing factions, including attempts by anti-occupy groups to disrupt distribution by blockading Next Media's headquarters and impeding delivery vans.^[35] By the movement's dispersal in December 2014, Apple Daily's persistent scrutiny of police tactics and government responses solidified its role as a counter-narrative to state-aligned outlets, though a September 2015 anniversary editorial advised protesters to "put away our umbrellas" temporarily for rest and strategic regrouping amid stalled reforms.^[39] The coverage underscored the paper's commitment to press freedom amid rising tensions, prefiguring later crackdowns on independent media.^[19]

Involvement in the 2019 Anti-Extradition Bill Protests

Apple Daily provided extensive coverage of the protests against the Fugitive Offenders and Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2019, which began with large-scale demonstrations on June 9, 2019, following the bill's second reading on June 12. The newspaper's reporting emphasized the protesters' demands to withdraw the legislation, perceived as enabling extraditions to mainland China and eroding Hong Kong's judicial independence under the "one country, two systems" framework. Editorials and front-page stories framed the movement as a defense of civil liberties, with the July 1, 2019, edition including a complimentary 40-page special supplement reiterating the protesters' slogan "Not to be gone until the Extradition Bill is withdrawn."^[34] Founder Jimmy Lai directed editorial strategies to amplify protest support, including instructions to print 100,000 posters opposing the bill and commissioning a full-page comic strip criticizing the legislation to encourage public participation. On August 18, 2019, amid an estimated 1.7 million participants in a major march, Apple Daily's front page highlighted the scale of opposition, contributing to a surge in circulation as readers sought its pro-democracy perspective. Lai's meetings with U.S. officials in July 2019, including Vice President Mike Pence and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, were cited in later court proceedings as influencing the paper's intensified stance, though Lai maintained this reflected journalistic advocacy for democratic values rather than foreign collusion.^[40]^[41]^[42]^[43] The paper's involvement extended to on-the-ground reporting that prosecutors later argued was intended to rally support for the movement, particularly after the June 12 clashes outside the Legislative Council, with staff instructed to portray protesters sympathetically and highlight government overreach. This coverage contrasted with state-aligned media, positioning Apple Daily as a key voice in sustaining momentum until the bill's formal withdrawal on September 4, 2019, though protests evolved into broader demands for democratic reforms. Circulation reportedly peaked above 1 million copies daily during the height of unrest, reflecting its role in mobilizing public sentiment against perceived threats to autonomy.^[44]^[45]^[3] Critics, including Hong Kong authorities and pro-Beijing outlets, contended that Apple Daily's advocacy crossed into incitement, with post-2020 national security trials alleging articles urged violence and foreign intervention; however, defenders, including Lai in testimony, asserted the content constituted legitimate opinion and factual reporting on events driven by genuine fears over extradition risks to dissidents. Empirical data from protest turnout—such as the 1.03 million reported on June 9 via organizer estimates—aligned with the paper's narratives of widespread opposition, underscoring its influence without fabricating participation scales.^[24]^[46]^[47]

Controversies and Criticisms

Allegations of Misinformation and Bias

Apple Daily faced accusations from Hong Kong government officials, pro-Beijing media outlets, and some local critics of exhibiting strong anti-China bias and disseminating misinformation, particularly in its coverage of political events and mainland affairs. Pro-establishment figures, such as Executive Councilor Regina Ip, claimed the newspaper damaged the media environment through libelous reporting, fabricated stories, and sensationalism that prioritized opposition narratives over factual accuracy.^[21] These allegations were amplified amid the 2019 anti-extradition protests, where authorities accused the outlet of inciting unrest via distorted portrayals of police actions and Beijing's policies, though such claims often originated from sources aligned with the central government, raising questions about their impartiality.^[25] Specific instances of alleged misinformation included reports published between November 23 and December 7, 2019, accusing mainland Chinese national Xian Xin and his wife Kung Ching of espionage activities in Hong Kong. These claims, which alleged covert operations tied to Beijing, were later retracted after investigations revealed no evidence, prompting former editor-in-chief Ryan Law—then detained on national security charges—to issue a public apology in October 2023 for the "false reports" that harmed the individuals' reputations.^[48] ^[49] Law's admission highlighted internal lapses in verification, though it occurred under legal pressure, potentially influencing the contrition expressed. The newspaper also faced multiple defamation lawsuits substantiating claims of inaccurate reporting. In a prominent case, BaWang shampoo company pursued a HK$630 million claim against Apple Daily in 2015 over articles alleging product safety issues, with associate publisher Cheung Kim-hung testifying to the outlet's aggressive tactics.^[50] Other suits, including one by barrister Chu Fung Chee in 2023, centered on libelous content published without sufficient substantiation, resulting in court scrutiny of the paper's editorial practices.^[51] Additionally, Apple Daily was linked to funding a 2020 report via Jimmy Lai's aide—without Lai's knowledge—that promoted unverified Hunter Biden conspiracy theories involving China, further fueling perceptions of partisan distortion over objective journalism.^[52] Critics, including independent media analysts, noted Apple Daily's right-center editorial bias, evident in its endorsement of figures like Donald Trump and consistent demonization of Beijing's influence, which skewed coverage toward pro-democracy activism rather than balanced analysis.^[53] Even within pro-democracy circles, the outlet drew rebuke for overt partisanship that compromised credibility, such as during election reporting where it favored specific candidates without disclosing affiliations.^[54] These patterns contributed to its polarizing reputation in Hong Kong's divided media landscape, where allegations of bias were reciprocated against pro-Beijing outlets, underscoring mutual distrust rather than isolated failings.^[55]

Claims of Foreign Collusion and Seditious Intent

Hong Kong authorities accused Apple Daily of colluding with foreign forces under Article 29 of the National Security Law (NSL), enacted on June 30, 2020, by alleging that the newspaper's editorial direction and published articles sought to provoke foreign governments to impose sanctions against Hong Kong and China, thereby endangering national security.^[56] Prosecutors specifically cited over 30 articles published between April and June 2021 that explicitly called for international sanctions on Hong Kong officials and Chinese authorities in response to the NSL's enforcement, framing these as acts of conspiracy to incite foreign intervention.^[57] Founder Jimmy Lai, charged on December 11, 2020, with two counts of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces, faced allegations that his personal meetings with U.S. politicians, including former Vice President Mike Pence and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, demonstrated an "unwavering intent" to leverage international ties for anti-China actions, such as soliciting sanctions rather than mere subscriptions or support for the outlet.^[58] ^[59] Lai's defense countered that such interactions constituted legitimate advocacy for freedom of expression and did not cross into criminal collusion, with his testimony on November 20, 2024, denying any plot to subvert the government through foreign channels.^[60] On November 22, 2022, six senior Apple Daily executives, including deputy chief editor Tam Cheuk-wan and associate publishers, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit collusion with foreign forces, admitting that the newspaper's content was designed to request foreign sanctions; in exchange, sedition charges against them were dropped, marking the first such convictions under the NSL for media personnel.^[61] ^[56] Regarding seditious intent, separate charges under Hong Kong's colonial-era Crimes Ordinance (Sections 9 and 10) were leveled against Apple Daily staff, asserting that articles incited disaffection toward the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region government and the central Chinese authorities by portraying them as authoritarian and urging public hatred or contempt.^[62] In a landmark ruling on August 30, 2024, District Court Judge Kwok Tse-lan convicted two former Apple Daily journalists, Li Yuxun and Wong Yinhan, of sedition for eight articles published in 2020 and 2021 that criticized national security arrests and promoted resistance, with the court finding that 11 of the charged pieces carried seditious intent to provoke public unrest.^[63] Lai himself faces conspiracy to publish seditious publications, with prosecutors arguing in August 2025 closing statements that the outlet's consistent anti-government stance, including coverage of protests, evidenced a deliberate pattern to undermine lawful authority, potentially warranting life imprisonment if convicted alongside collusion charges.^[64] Lai's legal team maintained that the articles reflected participation in public debate on governance flaws rather than seditious purpose, challenging the prosecution's interpretation as overreach on journalistic expression.^[24]

Tabloid Sensationalism and Ethical Lapses

Apple Daily, launched on June 20, 1995, by Jimmy Lai, pioneered tabloid-style journalism in Hong Kong, emphasizing vivid graphics, celebrity gossip, crime stories, and provocative imagery to attract readers.^[2] This approach included frequent use of paparazzi photography and headlines designed to maximize shock value, often focusing on sex scandals, triad activities, and political corruption in a manner that blurred lines between news and entertainment.^[1] Critics argued that such content prioritized circulation over journalistic rigor, with early editions featuring soft pornography and degrading depictions of women, contributing to accusations of misogyny in its reporting practices.^[65] The newspaper's sensationalism extended to political coverage, where inflammatory headlines and exaggerated narratives were employed to stoke public outrage against Beijing and pro-establishment figures, sometimes at the expense of balanced sourcing or verification.^[4] For instance, front pages regularly highlighted lurid personal scandals intertwined with critiques of authority, fostering a style that sensationalized dissent and amplified unverified allegations to drive sales, which peaked at over 600,000 daily copies by the early 2000s.^[1] This tactic drew rebukes from media observers for eroding ethical standards, including invasive surveillance-like tactics by photographers and a reluctance to correct errors promptly, as the focus remained on rapid, attention-grabbing output rather than accountability.^[2] Ethical lapses were further highlighted in critiques of the paper's content moderation, where provocative visuals and unsubstantiated claims about public figures occasionally veered into defamation territory, prompting legal challenges and advertiser withdrawals predating national security concerns.^[65] Although defenders viewed this brashness as a deliberate counter to state-controlled media, detractors, including some within Hong Kong's journalistic community, contended it undermined credibility by conflating advocacy with factual reporting, leading to a legacy of polarized reception where sensational elements overshadowed substantive analysis.^[4] No major institutional investigations into systemic ethical breaches were documented prior to its 2021 closure, but the style's persistence reflected a business model reliant on controversy over restraint.^[2]

Legal Challenges and Shutdown

2020 Raid Under National Security Law

On August 10, 2020, approximately 200 officers from Hong Kong's national security police raided the headquarters of Apple Daily, the pro-Beijing-critical newspaper founded by Jimmy Lai, seizing computers, documents, and other journalistic materials as part of an investigation into alleged violations of the Hong Kong National Security Law (NSL), enacted on July 1, 2020.^[66]^[67] The raid targeted content in 15 articles published by the outlet between July 1 and August 5, 2020, which authorities claimed colluded with foreign forces by calling for international sanctions against Hong Kong and Chinese officials in response to the NSL's imposition.^[68]^[67] During the operation, police arrested Jimmy Lai on suspicion of colluding with foreign countries or external elements to endanger national security under Article 29 of the NSL, as well as conspiracy to defraud and seditious publication; Lai, already facing prior charges, was denied bail and remanded in custody.^[68]^[67] His sons, Sebastien Lai and Timothy Lai, along with four Apple Daily executives—identified as Roelof Wit, Apple Daily's international editor; Fung Wai-kwong, CFO of Next Digital (the parent company); and two others—were also detained on charges of aiding the collusion or fraud conspiracy.^[67] Authorities alleged that Lai had leveraged the newspaper's platform to incite foreign intervention, including through interviews and editorials advocating sanctions, which they viewed as direct threats to national security amid post-2019 protest tensions.^[68]^[66] The raid marked the first major NSL enforcement action against a Hong Kong media outlet, occurring less than six weeks after the law's rollout, and drew international condemnation from press freedom groups for potentially chilling journalistic expression, though Hong Kong officials defended it as necessary to curb foreign-influenced subversion.^[67]^[66] Despite the disruptions, Apple Daily continued publishing, with circulation surging temporarily due to public support, but the incident foreshadowed intensified scrutiny on the outlet's operations.^[67] Lai's arrests under the NSL stemmed from evidentiary links to U.S. contacts, including meetings with officials like then-Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, which police cited as coordination for sanctions advocacy.^[68]

2021 Arrests, Asset Seizures, and Closure

On June 17, 2021, Hong Kong police raided the headquarters of Apple Daily, arresting five senior executives on suspicion of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces under the city's National Security Law.^[69]^[70] The arrested individuals included editor-in-chief Ryan Law, CEO Cheung Kim-hung, COO Royston Chow Tat-kuen, associate publisher Chan Pui-man, and deputy chief editor Cheung Chi-wai.^[71]^[72] Approximately 500 officers participated in the operation, which involved declaring the newsroom a crime scene and seizing computers, hard drives, and other equipment as evidence.^[69]^[56] Authorities accused the executives of directing Apple Daily to publish over 160 articles that allegedly called for foreign sanctions against Hong Kong and China, constituting collusion with external forces prohibited by Article 29 of the National Security Law.^[73] Two of the arrested, Ryan Law and Cheung Kim-hung, were formally charged that day with the offense, facing potential life imprisonment.^[73] In parallel, police froze HK$18 million (approximately US$2.3 million) in assets belonging to three companies affiliated with Apple Daily's parent firm, Next Digital, rendering the outlet unable to access funds for operational expenses such as staff salaries and vendor payments.^[74]^[75] Additional asset freezes extended the inaccessible funds to around HK$400 million (US$50 million), crippling the newspaper's finances.^[76] The asset seizures directly precipitated the newspaper's operational collapse, as Next Digital stated it could not sustain publication without access to its resources.^[76] On June 23, 2021, the board of Next Digital announced the immediate cessation of Apple Daily's print and online operations, citing the frozen assets and arrests as insurmountable barriers.^[77]^[78] The final print edition was published on June 24, 2021, with circulation surging to over 1 million copies amid public queues at distribution points, reflecting strong reader support despite the shutdown.^[20]^[21] The closure marked the end of Apple Daily, which had a daily circulation of around 70,000 to 80,000 prior to the events, and eliminated one of Hong Kong's last major pro-democracy voices following the imposition of the National Security Law in June 2020.^[79] Hong Kong authorities defended the actions as necessary to curb foreign interference and threats to national security, while international observers, including the European Union, criticized them as tools to suppress press freedom.^[79]^[80]

Post-Closure Legal Proceedings Involving Key Figures

Jimmy Lai, founder of Apple Daily, faced trial on two counts of collusion with foreign forces to endanger national security under Hong Kong's National Security Law, with the proceedings commencing on December 18, 2023, after his arrest in December 2020.^[81]^[82] The non-jury trial, presided over by three judges designated by the Hong Kong government, spanned over 156 days and included testimony from Lai himself starting November 20, 2024, where he denied directing staff to produce seditious content or solicit foreign sanctions.^[57]^[83] Closing arguments concluded in August 2025, but as of October 2025, no verdict had been delivered, with the court stating it would be announced "in good time."^[84]^[85] Conviction could result in a life sentence.^[86] In the same national security case, Lai was additionally charged with sedition for allegedly conspiring to produce seditious publications between April 2019 and the paper's closure in June 2021, a charge filed in December 2021 that carried a potential maximum penalty of two years' imprisonment per count.^[87] Separately, in a fraud case unrelated to national security, Lai was convicted in 2024 and sentenced to five years and nine months in prison for lease violations at Apple Daily's headquarters, involving the misrepresentation of office space to reduce rent payments by approximately HK$1.3 million from 2019 to 2020.^[88] Six senior Apple Daily executives, including former deputy editor-in-chief Cheung Jiping, chief executive officer Roel Choi, and executive chiefs Ryan Law and Fung Wai-kwong, pleaded guilty in November 2022 to one count of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces by publishing articles calling for sanctions against China and Hong Kong authorities.^[56]^[61] These individuals, arrested in 2021 alongside Lai, faced charges stemming from over 160 articles deemed to incite foreign intervention, with sentencing deferred pending the outcome of Lai's trial.^[89] Another group of executives faced seditious publication charges in 2021, contributing to the detention of seven former staff members as of mid-2025, all potentially facing life imprisonment under the National Security Law.^[90]

Key Personnel and Leadership

Jimmy Lai's Founding Role and Influence

Jimmy Lai founded Apple Daily on June 20, 1995, through his media company Next Media, leveraging profits from his earlier apparel business Giordano to invest HK$500 million in the venture.^[45]^[11] The newspaper debuted as a Chinese-language tabloid emphasizing sensationalism, celebrity gossip, and investigative reporting, quickly achieving commercial success by selling 300,000 copies on its first day and reaching peak circulation of over 600,000 daily by the early 2000s.^[45]^[91] As owner and de facto editorial guide, Lai shaped Apple Daily's content to prioritize criticism of the Chinese Communist Party and advocacy for Hong Kong's democratic aspirations, drawing from his own experiences fleeing Maoist China as a child and his Catholic faith's emphasis on truth and conscience.^[3]^[92] He named the publication after the biblical forbidden fruit to symbolize defiance against authority, fostering a combative tone that blended tabloid tactics with political commentary on corruption, censorship, and Beijing's encroachment on Hong Kong's autonomy post-1997 handover.^[2] Lai's hands-on influence extended to personally funding pro-democracy initiatives via the paper and directing coverage that amplified calls for universal suffrage and civil liberties, positioning Apple Daily as a counterweight to pro-Beijing media outlets.^[3]^[93] Lai's vision transformed Hong Kong's media landscape by introducing aggressive, reader-driven journalism that prioritized circulation through bold headlines and exposés, while embedding a pro-Western, liberty-oriented ideology that resonated amid rising tensions with mainland China.^[91] This approach not only sustained the paper's dominance—outpacing competitors like Oriental Daily in readership—but also made it a focal point for government scrutiny, culminating in Lai's arrests and the outlet's 2021 closure under national security charges alleging seditious intent.^[45]^[4] Despite criticisms of sensationalism, Lai's influence ensured Apple Daily served as a platform for unfiltered dissent, influencing public discourse on Hong Kong's identity and eroding trust in official narratives from Beijing-aligned sources.^[3]

Succession of Editors-in-Chief

Loh Chan served as Apple Daily's founding Editor-in-Chief, appointed to lead the newspaper from its launch on June 20, 1995.^[94] Under his direction, the publication established its tabloid format, blending sensational crime and celebrity coverage with pointed critiques of Beijing's influence, which helped it rapidly gain a mass audience exceeding 300,000 daily copies within months.^[95]^[96] The editorial role changed hands multiple times over the newspaper's 26-year run, adapting to shifts in ownership, market pressures, and escalating political tensions. In its later years, Ryan Law Wai-kwong assumed the position of Editor-in-Chief, serving through the period of heightened government pressure following the 2019 protests. Law was arrested on June 17, 2021, charged with conspiracy to collude with foreign forces under the national security law, alongside four other senior staff; this event froze assets and precipitated the paper's closure on June 24, 2021, after printing 1 million copies of its final edition.^[97]^[45]^[61] Lam Man-chung held the concurrent role of Executive Editor-in-Chief during this terminal phase, focusing on operational oversight of content production amid legal threats. He was detained on July 21, 2021, on similar collusion charges and has remained in custody without trial as of 2024.^[98]^[99] Chan Pui-man, as deputy chief editor, supported these leaders in curating the paper's defiant editorial line until her own arrest on June 17, 2021.^[100] The arrests of Law, Lam, and Chan exemplified the sequential dismantling of Apple Daily's top editorial team, effectively ending independent succession.^[101]

Legacy and Impact

Awards and Recognitions

In 2019, Apple Daily received the Hong Kong Human Rights Press Award for its reporting on Liu Xia, the wife of Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo, highlighting her house arrest and eventual departure from mainland China.^[19] The newspaper's journalists also earned accolades in the Human Rights Press Awards for investigative work on human rights issues, including a 2020 win by reporter Lee Tsz-Yu for the article "From Silence to Panics: The Scenes in Wuhan before the Coronavirus Pandemic," which documented early suppression of information in mainland China.^[32] Following its 2021 closure, Apple Daily's newsroom staff and founder Jimmy Lai were collectively awarded the 2021 Golden Pen of Freedom by the World Association of News Publishers (WAN-IFRA), recognizing their resistance to censorship under Hong Kong's national security law as a defense of independent journalism.^[102]^[103] In 2020, Reporters Without Borders (RSF) presented a special prize in its Press Freedom Awards to Jimmy Lai as founder of Apple Daily, honoring the outlet's persistence in criticizing Beijing despite arrests and threats.^[104] The staff of Apple Daily further received the Overseas Press Club of America's President's Award in 2021, acknowledging the newspaper's role in upholding press freedom amid political pressure that led to its shutdown.^[105]

Influence on Hong Kong Media and Public Discourse

Apple Daily exerted significant influence on Hong Kong's media landscape by providing a consistently pro-democracy perspective amid a predominance of outlets aligned with Beijing's interests. A 2020 content analysis of local newspapers found that while most carried pro-establishment materials, Apple Daily featured approximately 50% of its news content and 90% of its editorials supporting democratic positions, bucking the overall trend toward self-censorship following the national security law's imposition.^[19] This stance positioned it as a counterweight to pro-Beijing publications, fostering debate on issues like electoral reform and autonomy from mainland China.^[106] The newspaper's tabloid format, combining sensational headlines with advocacy for civil liberties, amplified public discourse during key events such as the 2014 Occupy Central movement and the 2019 anti-extradition protests, where it vocally supported protesters and critiqued government responses.^[1] ^[107] Its reporting often encouraged reader participation in demonstrations, contributing to heightened civic engagement among its readership, which included younger demographics disillusioned with conservative local press.^[107] By 2021, as authorities intensified pressure, demand surged, with queues forming outside distribution points and its final edition reportedly selling ten times the usual daily circulation, underscoring its role in mobilizing public sentiment.^[90] Beyond local impact, Apple Daily served as a beacon for media freedoms in the Chinese-speaking world, influencing dissident communities and liberal diaspora audiences through its unyielding criticism of authoritarian policies.^[108] Its closure in June 2021 marked a turning point, leading to reduced diversity in viewpoints and a chilling effect on remaining independent journalism, as evidenced by the shuttering of other pro-democracy outlets and job losses for over 900 journalists.^[109] This vacuum has homogenized public discourse toward official narratives, highlighting Apple Daily's prior function in sustaining pluralistic debate despite its sensationalist tendencies.^[110]^[111]

Long-Term Effects and International Perspectives

The shutdown of Apple Daily in June 2021 has exacerbated a long-term erosion of press freedom in Hong Kong, contributing to the territory's plunge to 140th place out of 180 countries in the 2025 Reporters Without Borders World Press Freedom Index, down from 18th two decades earlier.^[90] This decline reflects a pattern of closures and relocations among independent outlets, with over 900 journalists unemployed by 2024 and at least 49 arrests of media workers since the shutdown, fostering pervasive self-censorship and a "huge void" in critical reporting on government actions.^[112]^[88] Hong Kong's first-ever classification in the "very serious" red zone for press freedom in the 2024 index underscores the causal link between enforcement of the National Security Law and diminished media pluralism.^[88] The paper's demise has stifled public discourse on sensitive political topics, accelerating the exodus of talent and consolidation of pro-Beijing narratives in local media, as evidenced by the dismissal of 860 staff from Apple Daily and similar outlets like Stand News.^[113] Seven former executives, including founder Jimmy Lai, remain detained as of June 2025, facing potential life sentences, which has deterred investigative journalism and reinforced compliance with official red lines.^[90] From an international standpoint, the closure prompted unified rebukes from democratic governments viewing it as a direct assault on media autonomy. The United States, alongside 20 nations including the UK and Canada, condemned Beijing's asset freezes and arrests as tools to suppress dissent, with President Biden highlighting the suppression of independent voices in June 2021.^[114] The European Union decried the shutdown as eroding pluralism vital to open societies, while UK Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab labeled it a "chilling blow" to expression under the Sino-British Joint Declaration.^[115]^[116] Lai's protracted national security trial, with closing arguments completed in August 2025 amid concerns over his health and solitary detention, has amplified global advocacy, earning him designation as a 2025 World Press Freedom Hero by the International Press Institute for embodying resistance to censorship.^[117]^[118] Organizations like Reporters Without Borders have collaborated with exiled staff to produce commemorative editions, sustaining Apple Daily's pro-democracy ethos abroad while critiquing Hong Kong's trajectory toward mainland-style media controls.^[90]

References

[1]
Apple Daily – The Rise and Fall of Hong Kong's Sensationalist, Pro ...
Feb 4, 2023 · Apple Daily was a very controversial and unique type of newspaper. ... daily average circulation of only about 83,000 copies. In Hong Kong ...Missing: peak achievements
[2]
Apple Daily: The Hong Kong newspaper that pushed the boundary
Jun 23, 2021 · Last year, its outspoken founder Jimmy Lai was arrested and jailed under a string of charges just months after the imposition of a new national ...
[3]
Hong Kong's Native Son | Journal of Democracy
Jan 1, 2025 · Apple Daily was forced to shut down on 24 June 2021. In 2022, Lai was sentenced to another five years and nine months for having sublet a small ...
[4]
Jimmy Lai and the Apple Daily saga - ThinkChina
Jan 5, 2023 · The trial of Hong Kong media mogul and founder of Apple Daily Jimmy Lai Chee-ying, who is alleged to have violated the Hong Kong national security law.
[5]
Hong Kong's Apple Daily: a local journalist's perspective on Jimmy ...
Aug 10, 2020 · After the bloody crackdown in Beijing's Tiananmen Square in 1989, Jimmy Lai decided to build his own media business. He started Apple Daily in ...Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
[6]
Readers Take A Shine To Hong Kong's Apple Daily - Bloomberg
Oct 1, 1995 · Of the $100 million Lai earmarked for the paper, he has spent about $32 million. Lai predicts that annual revenues from his media group, which ...Missing: price | Show results with:price
[7]
Hong Kong's newest daily hits the racks - UPI Archives
Jun 20, 1995 · But competing newspapers in the colony are complaining that Apple Daily's 2 Hong Kong-dollar (25-cent) promotional newsstand price and its other ...
[8]
in character - ASIANOW - Asiaweek
By the time Lai launched Apple in 1995 (sparking off an industry price war which ended with five newspaper closures), they were bitter enemies. Although staffed ...
[9]
Controversies, sex lives, milestones and blows - The Standard (HK)
Jun 24, 2021 · Founded by Jimmy Lai Chee-ying, Apple Daily was the first newspaper which was printed entirely in color when its first copy was published on ...
[10]
Hong Kong newspapers wage price war - UPI Archives
Dec 11, 1995 · Apple Daily does not have officially audited circulation figures, but it claims to sell 310,000 copies a day. On Sunday, it responded to ...Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
[11]
Sex, gossip and free fruit: when Jimmy Lai launched Apple Daily
Jun 22, 2021 · Sex, gossip and free fruit: Apple Daily's launch in 1995 and why Jimmy Lai had his sanity questioned. 'Is he just downright crazy?' asked the ...
[12]
Chinese Papers Go to War in Hong Kong - The New York Times
Dec 13, 1995 · But now a long-standing circulation price cartel has crumbled under challenge from a brash newcomer, Apple Daily, which is owned by Jimmy Lai, a ...
[13]
Hong Kong's dying news stands tell a story of change - BBC
Nov 10, 2020 · Hong Kong's dying news stands tell ... Apple Daily started a price war when it was launched, forcing several newspapers to fold within months.
[14]
HK newspaper price war scares investors - UPI Archives
The move was followed by the Apple Daily, which went from 65 cents to 52 cents, the Sing Pao Daily News, which also dropped from 65 cents to 26 cents. Late ...<|separator|>
[15]
Apple Daily: The Hong Kong tabloid that dared to challenge China
Nov 21, 2024 · He also launched a brutal price war. The tactics paid off. In just a few years Apple Daily was printing 400,000 copies a day. Lai also ...
[16]
Hong Kong's forbidden fruit: the rise and fall of Apple Daily
Jun 24, 2021 · The story of Hong Kong's Apple Daily must start with its founder ... He also started a price war, and was able to force the more ...
[17]
A Eulogy for the Free Press in Hong Kong - The Atlantic
Jun 24, 2021 · In June 1995, the first copies of Apple Daily were dropped on Hong Kong's sidewalks. The newspaper's appearance set off a fierce price war, as ...
[18]
Apple Daily's shutdown marks the end of Hong Kong's run as a free ...
Jun 23, 2021 · Apple Daily's focus on spot news and large colorful photos, and later video, pushed even staid publications to think beyond pages of “words and ...
[19]
What Apple Daily Means for Hong Kong - The Diplomat
Dec 19, 2020 · “Apple Daily aimed to produce innovative clips with a humorous narrative and animation, in order to turn news into something lively and ...Missing: format | Show results with:format
[20]
The scrappy Hong Kong tabloid that refused to bow to Beijing
Jun 24, 2021 · Apple Daily, forced to close after arrests, asset freeze, was founded on a mission to hold power to account.Missing: format development
[21]
'Forbidden Fruit': Apple Daily, Pro-Democracy Newspaper in Hong ...
Jul 4, 2021 · First, the authorities arrested the paper's pugnacious founder, Jimmy Lai, last year, and charged him with national security offenses that carry ...
[22]
Apple Daily: Translations of Hong Kong's Last Pro-democracy ...
Lai initially made his fortune by starting an Asian clothing retailer called Giordano, then a media company and Apple Daily in 1995.
[23]
Hong Kong media mogul Jimmy Lai defiant as he gives evidence in ...
Nov 19, 2024 · Founder of Apple Daily paper denies seeking to influence foreign policy against China and says advocating for the independence of Hong Kong ...
[24]
Apple Daily not 'seditious' as it served as part of public debate, HK ...
Aug 26, 2025 · The media tycoon allegedly used Apple Daily to lobby foreign nations to impose sanctions, blockades or other hostile activities against China ...
[25]
Was Apple Daily a defender of freedoms or defiler of national ...
Jun 24, 2021 · Critics loathed its sensationalist, pro-opposition and anti-China slant, its supporters loved its fearless reporting against those in power.
[26]
Apple Daily: The Hong Kong newspaper that pushed the boundary
Jun 24, 2021 · A newspaper unafraid to criticise the Chinese state has announced its closure after 26 years.
[27]
Opinion | Asian media : Balancing freedom and responsibility - The ...
... yellow journalism." Similarly, Hong Kong readers may not feel that the sensational Apple Daily redeemed itself two years ago by exposing a politician who ...
[28]
The Impact of the National Security Law on Media and Internet ...
Oct 19, 2021 · ... expose official's transgressions, such as exposing in 2018 that Secretary of Justice Teresa Cheung had illegal structures at her home.55. The ...
[29]
Two more senior police officers alleged by local media to have built ...
May 2, 2020 · ... officers alleged by local media to have built illegal structures ... exposed by Apple Daily reporters to contain illegally built structures.
[30]
Explainer: Hong Kong police top brass embroiled in property scandals
May 4, 2020 · The Hong Kong police force has come under public scrutiny after three senior officers were alleged to have broken land and housing laws.
[31]
Human Rights Press Awards: Speaking for the voiceless
Jul 31, 2019 · The Investigative Section of Apple Daily Hong Kong won a Merit for Series: Scandal of the Shatin to Central Link. In May 2018 reporter Anthony ...
[32]
Past Winners – Page 4 – HRPA - Human Rights Press Awards
We also aim to recognise and encourage excellent, investigative and original reporting on important issues in the mass media. ... Publication: Apple Daily ...
[33]
Hong Kong's "Umbrella Revolution" - CBS News
Sep 29, 2014 · Workers clearing the main pro-democracy site hold an umbrella, symbolic of the "Umbrella Movement" as the pro-democracy protests came to be ...
[34]
A full chronicle of our turbulent times - First Amendment Museum
A full chronicle of Apple Daily's turbulent times ... Apple journalists bracing for tear gas on-site while covering the Umbrella Movement.
[35]
In City of Protests, Pro-Democracy Newspaper Becomes Target
Oct 16, 2014 · He and Apple Daily have been outspoken in their support for the protest movement, called Occupy Central, which was planned more than a year ago ...
[36]
Hong Kong's protests are over, but the fight over free speech has ...
The most-watched non-music YouTube video in Hong Kong in 2014 was Apple Daily's live coverage of the protests, which racked up 3.4 million views—equivalent to ...
[37]
Apple Daily: Hong Kong's biggest pro-democracy newspaper closes ...
Jun 23, 2021 · Lai was a key figure in a series of 2014 protests dubbed the Umbrella movement, which brought central Hong Kong to a standstill for months.
[38]
Hong Kong's Apple Daily closed down by Chinese regime
Jun 28, 2021 · Lai's Apple Daily was the only mass circulation newspaper that supported the democracy protests in Hong Kong. ... In the 1990s, it was ...
[39]
Hong Kong 'umbrella movement' marks first anniversary and vows to ...
Sep 28, 2015 · “Right now people need to take a rest,” said a front-page editorial in the pro-democracy newspaper Apple Daily. “We will put away our umbrellas ...
[40]
Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai asked top Apple Daily executive to ...
Feb 6, 2024 · Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai asked top Apple Daily executive to devise ways to encourage people to protest 2019 extradition bill, court hears ...
[41]
Apple Daily reports on protests after 'Occupy' movement, Jimmy Lai ...
Nov 20, 2024 · ... Hong Kong for supporting their work. ... Lai also admitted to directing Apple Daily to print 100,000 anti-extradition bill protest-related posters ...<|separator|>
[42]
Hong Kong's Apple Daily 'radicalised' in 2019, court hears
Jan 19, 2024 · The now-shuttered Apple Daily became "radical" after its founder, media mogul Jimmy Lai, met with top US officials in 2019, a court heard.
[43]
Hong Kong Protests Fuel Media Tycoon Jimmy Lai's Turnaround Plan
Aug 29, 2019 · Hong Kong protests fuel one media tycoon's turnaround plan. Jimmy Lai is hoping support for the pro-democracy movement will save his publishing empire.
[44]
Apple Daily staff covered 2019 Hong Kong protests with 'intention' of ...
Feb 7, 2024 · Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai Chee-ying's instructions to Apple Daily's management amid the 2019 anti-government protests led staff to cover the unrest.
[45]
The rise and fall of HK's Apple Daily and media magnate Jimmy Lai
Jun 23, 2021 · July 1, 1997 - On the handover of Hong Kong's sovereignty from Britain to China, Apple Daily said it remained confident in Hong Kong's future.Missing: strategy | Show results with:strategy
[46]
Hong Kong's Jimmy Lai sought US support for protests but denies ...
Nov 22, 2024 · Former Hong Kong media boss Jimmy Lai Chee-ying lobbied for US support for the 2019 anti-government protests through his now-defunct Apple Daily tabloid.
[47]
Apple Daily's central role in anti-extradition campaign
Mar 5, 2024 · Because of the strong protests, the extradition bill was withdrawn. Without a legal framework to extradite wanted suspects of crime to face ...
[48]
Ex-editor of shuttered 'Apple Daily' apologizes for 'fake news'
Oct 19, 2023 · The former editor-in-chief of Hong Kong's now-defunct pro-democracy Apple Daily has issued a public apology for allegedly publishing “false ...Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
[49]
Detained ex-editor of Hong Kong Apple Daily newspaper issues ...
Oct 18, 2023 · Detained ex-editor of Hong Kong Apple Daily newspaper issues apology over 'false' Chinese espionage allegations. In the apology, Ryan Law ...Missing: fake | Show results with:fake
[50]
HK$630m BaWang shampoo libel case hears from Apple Daily's ...
Apr 9, 2015 · Cheung Kim-hung, Apple Daily's associate publisher, was testifying in a HK$630 million defamation claim against his former employer over a ...
[51]
Chu Fung Chee v Apple Daily Ltd | Hong Kong Lawyer
Aug 1, 2023 · P, a barrister, sought various relief against Ds, which were related companies in the news reporting business, based on a claim on libel.
[52]
Media mogul Jimmy Lai 'unknowingly funded' report discrediting Joe ...
Oct 31, 2020 · Apple Daily owner says his aide used money from his private company without his knowledge to fund project, which accused Hunter Biden of Chinese ...
[53]
Apple Daily - Bias and Credibility - Media Bias/Fact Check
For example, the Apple Daily supported former President Trump with opinion pieces that read, “a vote for Trump is not only for the Americans' own interests, but ...<|separator|>
[54]
When press freedom died in Hong Kong - remembering the Apple ...
Jun 23, 2022 · Despite its popularity, Apply Daily faced criticism even among its pro-democracy supporters. Its biased reporting and overt support for ...
[55]
[PDF] Disinformation, Misinformation and Hong Kong's Divided Media ...
Aug 26, 2021 · Identify and track key topics within social media spaces in Hong Kong, including disinformation, misinformation, hate speech, and illiberal ...<|separator|>
[56]
6 Apple Daily staff plead guilty to collusion in Hong Kong | AP News
Nov 22, 2022 · They were charged with conspiracy to commit collusion with foreign forces to endanger national security. The law criminalizes acts of succession ...
[57]
Hong Kong mogul Jimmy Lai testifies for first time - BBC
Nov 20, 2024 · Lai is already serving prison sentences for a range of offences for his alleged role in pro-democracy protests in 2019, which led to China ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[58]
Jimmy Lai's int'l ties show 'unwavering intent' for sanctions ...
Aug 18, 2025 · Jimmy Lai's international connections were testament to his “unwavering intent” to attract foreign sanctions on China and Hong Kong, ...
[59]
Hong Kong's Jimmy Lai failed to get Pence, Pompeo to subscribe to ...
Nov 25, 2024 · Hong Kong's Jimmy Lai failed to get Pence, Pompeo to subscribe to Apple Daily – as it happened ... seditious publications in breach of colonial- ...
[60]
Jimmy Lai Downplays US Ties in First Remarks in Landmark HK Case
Nov 20, 2024 · Hong Kong's former media tycoon Jimmy Lai rebuffed allegations he colluded with foreign governments against China in his first testimony at ...Missing: funding | Show results with:funding
[61]
Apple Daily ex-staff plead guilty to collusion in Hong Kong - Al Jazeera
Nov 22, 2022 · ... Hong Kong and China after prosecutors agreed to drop sedition charges. ... The six, which were accused of using Apple Daily articles to solicit ...
[62]
Supporting freedom of expression is not wrong, Jimmy Lai's lawyer ...
Aug 20, 2025 · ... foreign forces to endanger national security and conspiring with others to issue seditious publications. Lai, 77, faces up to life in prison ...
[63]
A Hong Kong court convicts 2 journalists in a landmark sedition case
Aug 30, 2024 · ... sedition trial closing statements in Hong Kong on June 28, 2023. HONG ... Judge Kwok ruled that 11 carried seditious intent, including ...
[64]
Pro-democracy activist Jimmy Lai's national security trial in Hong ...
Aug 18, 2025 · He is being tried on charges of colluding with foreign forces to endanger national security and conspiring with others to issue seditious ...
[65]
The untold story of Apple Daily: deception, misogyny and quiet ...
Jul 4, 2021 · The Hong Kong community is a rather gentle, low-crime, conservative, majority female society, and the present portrayal of Apple Daily as the ...
[66]
China/Hong Kong: Mass Arrests Under Security Law
Aug 11, 2020 · On August 10, more than 200 Hong Kong police officers raided the headquarters of Apple Daily, a major pro-democracy newspaper, and arrested its ...Missing: outcomes | Show results with:outcomes
[67]
Hong Kong police raid Apple Daily newsroom, arrest founder Jimmy ...
Aug 10, 2020 · Hong Kong police raid Apple Daily newsroom, arrest founder Jimmy Lai, his sons, and 4 executives. August 10, 2020 9:29 AM EDT ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[68]
Prominent Hong Kong Publisher Arrested Under New National ...
Aug 10, 2020 · Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai and several executives at the media company he founded have been arrested. They're accused of colluding with foreign forces.
[69]
HK's Apple Daily raided by 500 officers over national security law
Jun 17, 2021 · ... illegal assemblies. The raid drew condemnation from the United States and Europe. The European Union and Britain said it showed China was ...Missing: exposed | Show results with:exposed
[70]
Police Arrest 'Apple Daily' Editors Under Hong Kong Security Law
Jun 17, 2021 · Hong Kong police have arrested five editorial executives, including the editor in chief, of media outlet Apple Daily, freezing more corporate accounts.Missing: major | Show results with:major
[71]
Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai's Apple Daily newsroom raided by 500 ...
Jun 16, 2021 · The five people arrested were editor-in-chief Ryan Law, chief executive officer Cheung Kim-hung, Chief Operating Officer Chow Tat-kuen, Deputy ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[72]
Hong Kong: Apple Daily raid, arrests a brazen attack on press freedom
Jun 17, 2021 · The newspaper's founder, Jimmy Lai, was arrested and charged under the national security law in August 2020 on the same day as a previous police ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[73]
Two Apple Daily executives charged with collusion with foreign ...
Jun 18, 2021 · Police said they charged two of the five on Friday, identified by Apple Daily as editor-in-chief Ryan Law and chief executive officer Cheung Kim ...Missing: outcomes | Show results with:outcomes
[74]
Apple Daily: HK pro-democracy paper says it will decide closure by ...
Jun 21, 2021 · This comes days after officials froze HK$18m ($2.3m; £1.64m) of its assets over allegations that its reports breached a national security law.<|separator|>
[75]
Hong Kong: Apple Daily closure is dark day for press freedom
Jun 23, 2021 · Jimmy Lai was arrested and charged under the National Security Law in August 2020 on the same day as a previous police raid on Apple Daily's ...
[76]
Apple Daily could shut 'in days' after Hong Kong asset freeze
Jun 21, 2021 · Company adviser says action under security law means it cannot access some $50 million in funds to pay staff and vendors.Missing: seizures | Show results with:seizures
[77]
Apple Daily: Hong Kong pro-democracy paper announces closure
Jun 23, 2021 · Police had accused the newspaper of publishing more than 30 articles calling on countries to impose sanctions on Hong Kong and mainland China ...Missing: circulation achievements
[78]
Hong Kong's Apple Daily, symbol of pro-democracy movement, to ...
Jun 23, 2021 · Hong Kong's largest pro-democracy newspaper, Apple Daily, will shut down online at midnight on Wednesday and print its final edition on Thursday.Missing: date | Show results with:date
[79]
Hong Kong's Pro-Democracy Newspaper Apple Daily Shuts Down ...
Jun 23, 2021 · The European Union said the closure of Apple Daily showed how the national security law was being used to stifle freedom of the press and ...Missing: seizures | Show results with:seizures
[80]
What people are saying about closure of Hong Kong's Apple Daily
Jun 23, 2021 · "The closure of Apple Daily's Hong Kong operations clearly shows how the National Security Law imposed by Beijing is being used to stifle ...Missing: date | Show results with:date
[81]
Jimmy Lai: What to know about national security trial of Hong Kong ...
Nov 22, 2024 · Hong Kong media tycoon and pro-democracy advocate Jimmy Lai testified this week in court for the first time in a landmark national security ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[82]
Jimmy Lai: Trial of Hong Kong's pro-democracy media tycoon
The national security trial of media tycoon Jimmy Lai concluded its closing arguments after 156 days. The city's authorities cancelled the passports of 12 ...
[83]
Hong Kong hears from jailed media tycoon Jimmy Lai for the ... - CNN
Nov 20, 2024 · Prosecutors allege that articles published by Apple Daily violated Hong Kong's national security law by calling for overseas sanctions against ...
[84]
https://www.asianews.it/news-en/Jimmy-Lai%25E2%2580%2599s-son-urges-freedom-for-his-father-two-months-since-his-show-trial-ended-with-no-sentence-yet-64147.html
[85]
Jimmy Lai verdict to come 'in good time' – judge - Law Society
Sep 1, 2025 · A Hong Kong court has said it will deliver its verdict in newspaper owner's Jimmy Lai's national-security trial in due course.
[86]
https://www.aa.com.tr/en/americas/trump-says-he-may-raise-jimmy-lai-s-case-with-chinese-president-during-meeting/3726299
[87]
Hong Kong Apple Daily founder and staff face new sedition charge
Dec 28, 2021 · Hong Kong prosecutors on Tuesday filed a "seditious publications" charge against jailed media tycoon Jimmy Lai who already faces charges ...
[88]
Four Years On: From the Shutdown of Apple Daily to the Demise of ...
Jun 23, 2025 · Jimmy Lai, Apple Daily's founder, has been jailed since December 3, 2020—over 1,600 days. He was sentenced to 5 years and 9 months for fraud and ...
[89]
Apple Daily staffers recall the police raid that changed Hong Kong's ...
Jun 30, 2023 · Meanwhile, six former Apple Daily executives have pleaded guilty to "conspiring and colluding with foreign powers" under the national security ...
[90]
Four years later, Apple Daily lives on: RSF and exiled Hong Kong ...
Jun 23, 2025 · Seven former staff members remain in detention and face life imprisonment under the National Security Law (NSL), including Jimmy Lai.
[91]
The Case of Jimmy Lai: Hong Kong's Press Freedom Canary?
Since its founding in June 1995, Apple Daily has revolutionized the newspaper business in Hong Kong. Drawing on feisty politics, sex, crime, and tabloid tactics ...
[92]
Jimmy Lai: Hong Kong mogul, activist ... and now a prisoner for ...
Sep 30, 2023 · In 2003, Apple Daily had the opportunity to throw its now huge influence behind Lai's political views for the first time. Lai and his newspaper ...
[93]
Remembering Jimmy Lai, Apple Daily, and a chocolate bar
Jun 17, 2025 · He used his wealth in the 1990s to launch the popular Chinese-language Apple Daily newspaper, which combined aggressive journalism with a ...
[94]
Apple Daily to target mass audience - Varsity
The newcomer, Apple Daily, is owned by Mr. Jimmy Lai Chi Ying, who also owns Next Magazine. Mr. Loh Chan is the designated editor-in-chief. We interviewed ...
[95]
Words are cheap in Hong Kong newspaper war | The Independent ...
... Loh Chan, the paper's editor. His paper is a mixture of sex and crime stories, alongside hard-hitting political commentary and some of the best news ...
[96]
This Apple Bites Back - Bloomberg.com
Jun 8, 1997 · But that isn't getting Lai or Apple's publisher, Stephen Loh Chan, down. Loh is anticipating big gains in readership after the handover. The ...
[97]
Hong Kong sends 500 officers in pro-democracy paper raid - BBC
Jun 16, 2021 · Some 500 policemen raided the offices of pro-democracy paper Apple Daily in Hong Kong, alleging its reports breached a national security law.Missing: details | Show results with:details
[98]
Hong Kong police arrest former Apple Daily top editor - Al Jazeera
Jul 21, 2021 · Former executive editor-in-chief Lam Man-chung believed to be latest paper employee held under national security law.
[99]
Hong Kong police arrest former Apple Daily editor in chief-media
Jul 21, 2021 · Hong Kong police arrested the former executive editor-in-chief of the now-closed pro-democracy Apple Daily tabloid on Wednesday, ...<|separator|>
[100]
Chan Pui-man: Jailed under Hong Kong's security laws
Mar 11, 2025 · Chan Pui-man: Jailed under Hong Kong's security laws ... Chan served as deputy chief editor of Hong Kong's Apple Daily until her arrest in 2021.
[101]
Hong Kong: One year after Apple Daily shutdown, seven still detained
Jun 17, 2022 · Fung Wai-kong (aka Lo Fung), 57, Managing Editor of Apple Daily (English)/Editorial writer. Detained since: 21 July 2021; Accusations ...
[102]
Golden Pen of Freedom Awarded to Jimmy Lai and the Apple Daily ...
Dec 1, 2021 · Jimmy Lai, a jailed media tycoon, and the Apple Daily newsroom staff received the 2021 Golden Pen of Freedom award. Apple Daily is now ...Missing: investigations | Show results with:investigations
[103]
Shuttered Hong Kong Democracy Paper Wins Press Freedom Award
Dec 2, 2021 · Jailed media tycoon Jimmy Lai and the staff of his now-shuttered Apple Daily newspaper have been awarded a prestigious press freedom prize ...Missing: recognitions | Show results with:recognitions
[104]
2020 RSF Press Freedom Awards : three winners selected and ...
Dec 7, 2020 · 2020 RSF Press Freedom Awards : three winners selected and special prize honors Jimmy Lai, founder of Apple Daily in Hong Kong. Organisation ...
[105]
Overseas Press Club of America Announces Annual Award Winners
Mar 18, 2022 · ... Award Shared by Staff of Hong Kong's Apple Daily. NEW YORK, March 18 ... Best reporting in any medium on international environmental issues.
[106]
The quiet weeding out of Hong Kong's media landscape
May 5, 2023 · While Apple Daily was well known for its sensationalist journalism, it was also closely aligned with the so-called pan-democratic camp, a ...
[107]
'We belong to Hong Kong': why the brash pro-democracy Apple ...
Jun 25, 2021 · Not only it was the first paper in the city to be printed fully in colour, it also initiated a price war ... “Apple Daily is the Hong Kong ...
[108]
Inside Hong Kong's Apple Daily, China's besieged liberal media icon
Jun 17, 2021 · His reporting includes "The Revolt of Hong Kong" - an investigative series he helped lead that was a Pulitzer finalist for International ...
[109]
A year on from Apple Daily's closure, what's left of Hong Kong's free ...
Jun 24, 2022 · The media tycoon Jimmy Lai, who founded Apple Daily and its parent company, Next Digital, has been in custody for more than 18 months. Six other ...<|separator|>
[110]
Why a Hong Kong law that is eroding press freedom is also bad for ...
Jun 30, 2025 · The former financial journalist said that one of the biggest losses after the security law was the disappearance of Apple Daily. Unlike most ...<|separator|>
[111]
The remnants of Hong Kong's independent press
Sep 29, 2021 · This past June, Hong Kong police raided the newsroom of Apple Daily, a widely-read newspaper that has campaigned for democracy and against the ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence<|control11|><|separator|>
[112]
Watchdog: Apple Daily trial typifies declining press freedom in Hong ...
Jul 2, 2024 · More than 900 journalists have lost their jobs, several media outlets have closed or moved overseas, and some journalists, including pro- ...<|separator|>
[113]
Hong Kong | RSF
In 2021, the government froze the assets of Apple Daily and Stand News to force them to cease operations, thus causing the dismissal of 860 of their employees.
[114]
US, 20 other nations condemn Beijing's closure of Hong Kong ...
Jul 10, 2021 · President Biden previously condemned China over Beijing's closure of Apple Daily, saying the nation “insisted on wielding its power to suppress ...
[115]
Statement by the EU Spokesperson on the closure of Apple Daily's ...
Jun 24, 2021 · Its closing seriously undermines media freedom and pluralism, which are essential for any open and free society. The erosion of press freedom ...Missing: reactions perspectives
[116]
Hong Kong newspaper Apple Daily to shut down – DW – 06/23/2021
Jun 23, 2021 · British Foreign Minister Dominic Raab described the forced closure of the Apple Daily as "a chilling blow to freedom of expression in Hong Kong.Missing: perspectives | Show results with:perspectives
[117]
Spotlight: Hong Kong publisher Jimmy Lai named 2025 IPI-IMS ...
Oct 14, 2025 · In recognizing Lai as one of this year's Press Freedom Heroes, the selection committee honours Lai's continued brave defense of press freedom ...
[118]
Hong Kong: Drop Charges, Release Newsman Jimmy Lai
Aug 15, 2025 · ... Apple Daily, was again postponed on August 15, 2025, for health reasons. Lai, 77, has diabetes and has been held in prolonged solitary ...