Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bahira

Bahira, also known as Baḥīrā or Sargis-Bahira in various traditions, was a Nestorian Christian monk purportedly active in the region of Bosra, Syria, during the early 7th century.^[1] In Islamic biographical literature, such as the Sīra of Muḥammad ibn Isḥāq (d. ca. 768 CE), he is depicted as recognizing the future Prophet Muḥammad—then a boy accompanying a Meccan trade caravan—as bearing the signs of prophethood foretold in Christian scriptures, including a distinctive seal between his shoulder blades.^[2] Bahira reportedly advised Muḥammad's uncle and guardian, Abū Ṭālib, to safeguard him from potential Jewish adversaries who might seek to harm him based on these prophetic indicators.^[3] The narrative's origins trace to early Muslim hagiographic accounts aimed at underscoring divine election, yet parallel Christian polemical legends portray Bahira negatively—as a heretical monk who either deceived Muḥammad with corrupted teachings or sought to exploit him for sectarian ends, such as promoting Arian or Nestorian doctrines.^[4] These Christian variants, circulating in Syriac, Armenian, and other Eastern traditions from the 8th century onward, reflect interfaith apologetics under Islamic rule rather than independent historical attestation.^[5] Scholarly consensus holds the encounter as ahistorical, classifying it as a legendary construct without corroboration from contemporary non-Islamic sources or archaeological evidence, likely embellished to bridge Abrahamic prophetic lineages or counter accusations of Muḥammad's doctrinal borrowings.^[1]^[3] Even some traditional Muslim evaluators, including medieval critics, have questioned its chains of transmission (isnād), deeming it deficient for biographical reliability.^[6] The motif's persistence across confessional boundaries underscores its role in medieval religious polemics over prophetic legitimacy and scriptural interpretation, rather than verifiable biography.^[4]

Name and Etymology

Linguistic Origins

The name Bahira (Arabic: بَحِيرَىٰ; Syriac: ܒܚܝܪܐ bḥīrā) originates from Classical Syriac, where it serves not as a personal proper name but as a title denoting a monk who has been "tested and approved" or "proven" through ascetic discipline and divine selection.^[7]^[8] This term derives from the Syriac root bḥar, meaning "to choose," "to test," or "to elect," implying qualities of virtue, election, or enlightenment in a monastic context.^[8] In Syriac Christian usage, bḥīrā reflects a status of spiritual refinement, akin to "the elect" or "the chosen" among ascetics.^[7] In Arabic linguistic adaptation within early Islamic texts, Bahira retained connotations tied to ascetic traditions, sometimes interpreted as "the virtuous" or "the tested," aligning with the Syriac sense of moral or divine approval rather than deriving independently from Arabic roots like bahir ("brilliant" or "dazzling"), which apply more to feminine nomenclature.^[9] No attestations of Bahira as a monastic title or name appear in non-Islamic Syriac, Aramaic, or other Near Eastern sources prior to the 7th century CE, with its earliest documented usage confined to Islamic narratives emerging in the following centuries.^[8] This absence suggests the name's prominence is contextually linked to post-Islamic literary traditions rather than broader pre-Islamic onomastic records.^[7]

Interpretations in Religious Contexts

The name Bahira, rooted in the Syriac bḥīrā signifying "chosen one" or "tested and approved by God," symbolizes divine selection and discernment in Syriac Christian nomenclature, reflecting empirical linguistic patterns in early Eastern monastic traditions where such terms denoted figures vetted through ascetic trial or scriptural insight.^[10]^[1] Within Islamic interpretive frameworks, Bahira embodies a archetype of scriptural prescience, where the name underscores a monk's purported alignment with Abrahamic prophecies—such as those in Deuteronomy 18:18 or Isaiah 42—anticipating a prophet like Moses from Ishmaelite lineage, thereby representing an early, non-polemical affirmation of prophetic continuity across faiths without reliance on post-event rationalization.^[11] This linkage privileges the monk's etymological "approval" as emblematic of empirical recognition from pre-Islamic texts, though Islamic sources like those in Kamal al-Din attribute such knowledge to preserved oral and written traditions among Syrian ascetics, cautioning against overattribution given the tradition's later compilation.^[9] Christian symbolic renderings contrastingly frame Bahira as emblematic of doctrinal deviation, often portraying bearers of the name as Nestorian or Ebionite heterodoxes whose "chosen" status veils erroneous exegesis, as seen in medieval polemics like the Apocalypse of Bahira, which casts the figure as a catalyst for aberrant revelations through selective scriptural manipulation.^[1]^[12] This interpretation, prevalent in Syriac and Latin apologia from the 8th century onward, leverages the name's connotation of divine testing to critique perceived theological lapses, prioritizing causal chains of heresy over neutral erudition and highlighting institutional biases in patristic historiography that vilify peripheral monastic views.^[1]

Accounts in Islamic Sources

The Core Narrative of the Encounter

According to Islamic tradition, Muhammad, at approximately twelve years of age, accompanied his uncle Abu Talib on a trading caravan from Mecca to Syria, reaching as far as Busra.^[13] The caravan halted near a monastery where a Christian monk named Bahira resided, who was knowledgeable in scriptural interpretations.^[13] Bahira observed a distinctive cloud providing shade exclusively over Muhammad as the group rested, interpreting it as a prophetic sign.^[10] Upon closer examination, he identified the seal of prophethood—a physical mark—between Muhammad's shoulders, confirming his recognition of the boy as the awaited prophet described in ancient texts.^[13] Bahira then questioned Muhammad privately, adjuring him by local deities to affirm his prophetic status, after which he advised Abu Talib to safeguard the youth from potential harm by Jews aware of the prophecies.^[11]

Primary Sources and Chain of Transmission

The account of the encounter with Bahira originates in Muhammad ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah, compiled around 767 CE, marking the earliest extant Islamic textual reference to the narrative.^[14] Ibn Ishaq structured his biography around oral reports with specified chains of transmission (isnad), drawing from informants such as successors to the companions (tabi'un), though his methodology included traditions without full isnads in some cases.^[15] The relevant section traces the story through Ibn Ishaq's transmission, preserved primarily via his student Abd al-Malik ibn Hisham's recension, completed around 833 CE, which omits some of Ibn Ishaq's extraneous material but retains the core Bahira episode.^[16] No mention of Bahira or the associated events appears in the Quran, revealed between approximately 610 and 632 CE, nor in pre-Ibn Ishaq sources such as early Meccan-Medinan compilations of prophetic traditions or companions' reports documented in the first half of the 8th century.^[17] Subsequent hadith collections reference variants of the monk encounter, such as Jami' al-Tirmidhi (compiled c. 884 CE), which includes a report without naming Bahira and via an isnad involving multiple transmitters, and al-Hakim al-Nishapuri's Mustadrak ala al-Sahihayn (c. 1014 CE), deemed supplementary rather than canonical.^[14] These accounts lack inclusion in the Sahih collections of al-Bukhari (d. 870 CE) or Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj (d. 875 CE), the most rigorously vetted repositories of prophetic traditions.^[17] Hadith scholars, including Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. 855 CE), critiqued Ibn Ishaq's transmissions broadly for incorporating unreliable narrators and unverified reports, contributing to evaluations of weakness in sira-derived narratives like Bahira's.^[18]

Variations Across Early Texts

Early Islamic biographical accounts of the Bahira encounter exhibit variations in Muhammad's age at the time of the meeting. Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah, the earliest comprehensive biography, places the event when Muhammad was twelve years old, during a caravan journey with his uncle Abu Talib.^[19] Other traditions, however, report him as nine or ten years old, reflecting differences in transmitted reports from Medinan and Meccan informants.^[20] The location of the encounter also differs across sources. Most accounts, including Ibn Ishaq's, situate it in Bosra (Busra), a city in southern Syria known for its Christian monastic presence.^[19] A variant preserved in later compilations shifts the meeting to Tayma, an oasis north of Medina en route to Syria, altering the geographical context without changing the core recognition motif.^[21] Signs of prophethood recognized by Bahira vary in description. In Ibn Ishaq's narrative, Bahira notices a cloud shading Muhammad and inspects the seal of prophethood—a fleshy protuberance between his shoulders—confirming scriptural prophecies.^[19] Some reports add a tree bowing or providing shade to Muhammad, emphasizing miraculous natural phenomena alongside the physical mark.^[21] Others highlight Bahira quoting directly from the Torah or Gospel to identify Muhammad, integrating textual exegesis with visual signs.^[22] Later historiographical works introduce additional elaborations. Al-Tabari's Tarikh al-Rusul wa al-Muluk amplifies Bahira's foretelling, portraying him as declaring Muhammad the "apostle of the Lord" based on unadulterated Gospel texts, and in some chains, Bahira entrusts scrolls or protective advice to safeguard the future prophet. These expansions, drawn from extended isnads, build on earlier sira motifs but incorporate more emphatic doctrinal affirmations.^[10]

Historical and Scholarly Analyses

Evidence for Historicity

The encounter between Muhammad and the monk Bahira is rendered plausible by the established pattern of Meccan caravan trade to Syria during the late 6th century CE, which facilitated direct contacts between Quraysh merchants and Christian communities along the routes. Archaeological and textual evidence confirms the operation of overland trade networks linking the Hijaz to Syrian markets, with Meccan traders regularly transporting goods such as leather, spices, and textiles northward via paths like the Darb al-Hijra or routes passing near Bosra.^[23]^[24] These expeditions, often involving young apprentices, align with reports of Muhammad joining his uncle Abu Talib on a journey around 594-595 CE, when he was approximately 12 years old, stopping at monastic sites en route. Syria in this period hosted dense networks of Syriac Christian monasteries, particularly Nestorian and Monophysite establishments near trade hubs like Bosra, where monks interacted with passing Arab caravans for provisions, intelligence, or commerce. Pre-Islamic Arabs, including Meccans, maintained familiarity with Syriac-speaking Christians through these exchanges, as evidenced by tribal alliances with Ghassanid clients of Byzantium and the presence of Christian traders and clerics in Hijazi markets.^[25] Such interactions provided a realistic context for a monk like Bahira, possibly from a Syriac tradition, to observe and engage with a Quraysh youth exhibiting distinctive traits.^[26] The narrative's core elements echo verifiable oral traditions of prophetic foretellings in Near Eastern lore, where ascetic figures discern divine signs in travelers, a motif attested in Syriac hagiographies predating Islam and suggesting cultural transmission via trade rather than later fabrication. Early Syriac versions of the Bahira story, preserving linguistic and thematic details absent in later Arabic retellings, indicate an origin in authentic cross-cultural encounters rather than purely polemical invention. This circumstantial alignment of trade logistics, regional demographics, and narrative typology supports the possibility of a historical kernel to the event, independent of its theological embellishments.

Criticisms of the Legend's Reliability

The primary source for the Bahira encounter is Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah (d. 767 CE), which transmits the narrative through chains of narration (isnad) involving transmitters such as Yunus ibn Ishaq, deemed weak and unreliable by hadith scholars due to inconsistencies and lack of corroboration from more rigorous collectors like al-Bukhari or Muslim.^[6] Medieval critics, including al-Dhahabi (d. 1348 CE), classified related traditions as da'if (weak) or potentially fabricated, citing interrupted links and narrators prone to error or invention, a common issue in early biographical materials predating systematic hadith verification around the 9th century.^[6] No contemporary non-Muslim records from 6th-century Syria—such as Byzantine chronicles, Syriac monastic texts, or Jewish sources—mention an encounter between a Meccan youth and a monk named Bahira, despite the region's literate Christian communities and active trade routes that would likely have documented prophetic omens if they occurred.^[27] This evidentiary gap persists even as later Islamic expansions into Syria post-634 CE produced abundant documentation, suggesting the story lacks independent verification beyond Muslim traditions compiled over a century after the alleged event circa 595 CE. The legend's structure, featuring a foreign sage recognizing innate prophethood through signs like a cloud or seal, parallels apocryphal hagiographies in Judeo-Christian lore (e.g., infant Jesus miracles in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas), indicating possible retroactive embellishment to bolster Muhammad's pre-revelatory exceptionalism amid 8th-century interfaith polemics.^[2] Such motifs served theological legitimation rather than historical reporting, as evidenced by variations across texts where details shift to emphasize orthodoxy over chronology.^[6]

Potential Cultural and Theological Influences

The presence of Syriac Christian monasteries along ancient trade routes from Arabia to Syria and the Persian Gulf in the sixth century provided opportunities for Arab caravaneers to engage with Christian scriptural traditions and monotheistic teachings. These monastic sites, often linked to Nestorian or other Eastern Christian communities, acted as hubs for disseminating biblical narratives and theological debates, including unitarian perspectives that emphasized God's absolute oneness over Trinitarian formulations.^[28]^[29] The Bahira legend potentially incorporates elements from such real-world contacts, portraying the monk as an erudite figure versed in prophetic signs, which may composite historical monks encountered by Meccan traders like those accompanying young Muhammad on journeys to Bosra around 594 CE. Syriac variants of the story, circulating orally from the eighth century, suggest reciprocal influences between Arab and Christian traditions, adapting motifs of divine foreknowledge to affirm emerging prophetic claims.^[1]^[22] Theological resonances between the legend and non-orthodox Christian doctrines, particularly Arianism's denial of Christ's co-eternality with God the Father, offer another layer of potential inspiration, as Arian critiques of the Trinity—viewing the Son as created and subordinate—echo aspects of later Islamic unitarianism without implying direct derivation.^[30] Early polemicists such as John of Damascus (c. 675–749 CE) explicitly linked Muhammad's teachings to an Arian monk's influence, citing the Ishmaelite heresy as reviving subordinationist errors suppressed by Nicene orthodoxy.^[31] Contemporary analyses, however, emphasize the legend's role in retrojecting cultural familiarity to legitimize the narrative, rather than evidencing causal doctrinal transmission from specific sects like Arianism or Nestorianism, which had waned but persisted in peripheral regions.^[32]

Christian Perspectives and Polemics

Early Christian Interpretations

One of the earliest documented Christian allusions to a monastic influence on Muhammad dates to the mid-8th century in the writings of John of Damascus (c. 675–749 CE), a prominent theologian in the Umayyad Caliphate. In his treatise On Heresies, John describes Muhammad as having encountered an Arian monk who imparted scriptural knowledge, which Muhammad then adapted into a new doctrine that explicitly rejected the Christian Trinity and the divinity of Christ.^[30] This account posits the monk's teachings as the origin of Islam's unitarian theology, diverging sharply from orthodox Christian positions on the nature of God and Jesus.^[33] John does not explicitly name the monk as Bahira, but subsequent scholarly interpretations have linked this figure to the Bahira of Islamic tradition, viewing the encounter as a conduit for heretical ideas rather than divine recognition.^[34] The emphasis in John's narrative falls on doctrinal incompatibility, with the monk's Arianism—denying the full divinity of Christ—mirroring aspects of Islamic Christology, such as portraying Jesus as a prophet but not co-eternal with the Father.^[30] Contemporary Syriac Christian texts from the 8th century, reflecting oral traditions in monastic communities under Muslim rule, similarly depict analogous encounters between monks and Arab figures as cautionary tales against prophetic pretensions. These accounts highlight the monks' attempts to instruct in Christian orthodoxy, only to see divergences emerge in monotheistic practices that omit Trinitarian elements, serving as early warnings of theological schism rather than endorsements of emerging revelations.^[35] No sources from this period portray the interaction positively as prophetic affirmation; instead, they underscore irreconcilable differences in core beliefs about Christ's identity and divine unity.^[36]

Portrayals as a Heretical Figure

In Christian polemical traditions, Bahira is characterized as a heterodox monk whose unorthodox doctrines allegedly shaped the theological foundations of Islam, particularly its rejection of core Christian tenets like the Trinity. These depictions frame him as a Nestorian or Arian figure evading persecution from orthodox authorities, thereby positioning Islam as an extension of ancient Christian heresies rather than a distinct revelation.^[8]^[5] The Legend of Sergius Bahira, preserved in Syriac and Arabic manuscripts from the medieval period, exemplifies this portrayal by narrating how the monk Sergius (identified with Bahira) imparts to Muhammad a corrupted version of Christian scripture emphasizing monotheism at the expense of Trinitarian orthodoxy. In these accounts, Sergius/Bahira, driven by resentment toward Byzantine ecclesiastical dominance, instructs the young trader in anti-Trinitarian arguments and selective scriptural interpretations that later underpin Quranic critiques of Christianity.^[37]^[38] Similarly, the Apocalypse of Bahira, a Syriac apocalyptic text likely composed between the 7th and 13th centuries, presents the monk as a prophetic heretic who foresees and facilitates the emergence of a deceptive faith among the Arabs, blending Nestorian Christology with eschatological warnings against the "error of the Ishmaelites." This work accuses Bahira of devising teachings that deny the divinity of Christ and promote a unitarian theology, influencing Muhammad to propagate what polemicists deemed scriptural distortions.^[1] In the 9th-century Risala attributed to 'Abd al-Masih al-Kindi, Bahira is explicitly labeled a heterodox monk who abandons monastic discipline to mentor Muhammad in errant beliefs, including the alteration of biblical prophecies to suit Arab audiences and the rejection of incarnational doctrine. These polemics collectively attribute to Bahira the transmission of Arian-like subordinationism and Nestorian dyophysitism extremes, framing his encounter as the causal origin of Islam's doctrinal divergences from Nicene Christianity.^[1]^[22]

Links to Islamic Doctrinal Origins

Early Christian polemics, such as those by John of Damascus in the eighth century, assert that Muhammad encountered the monk Bahira during his youth and absorbed heretical Christian doctrines that later shaped key Quranic teachings.^[39] These accounts portray Bahira as an Arian or Nestorian figure whose Christological views—emphasizing Jesus' prophetic role over divinity—mirrored the Quran's depiction of Jesus as a human messenger without divine sonship or Trinitarian equality (Quran 4:171, 5:75).^[40]^[41] Arianism's subordination of the Son to the Father and Nestorianism's separation of Christ's natures provided conceptual parallels to the Quran's rejection of incarnation and crucifixion as salvific events, framing Jesus instead as a miracle-working prophet akin to earlier biblical figures.^[42] Critics from this perspective further link Bahira's purported Syrian monastic background to Muhammad's adoption of strict monotheism and vehement anti-idolatry, elements resonant with ascetic Christian critiques of polytheism prevalent in pre-Islamic Arabia.^[43] Trade caravan routes facilitated exposure to such ideas, where Syrian hermits emphasized tawhid-like unity of God over pagan shrines, influencing Muhammad's Meccan surahs condemning idol worship (Quran 53:19-23).^[44] However, no verbatim textual borrowings from Christian liturgies or scriptures appear in the Quran, suggesting indirect cultural osmosis rather than deliberate plagiarism—diffusion through oral interactions and regional debates rather than scripted transmission.^[45] These arguments, while highlighting doctrinal affinities, rely on legendary accounts of the Bahira encounter whose historicity remains contested, with empirical evidence limited to later medieval narratives rather than contemporary records.^[1] Christian interpreters thus view such parallels as evidence of syncretic formation, where heretical strands filtered through a monastic intermediary contributed to Islam's theological framework without originating from independent revelation.^[10]

Broader Implications and Debates

Role in Prophetic Legitimation

In the biographical tradition of sira literature, exemplified by Muhammad ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah (composed circa 767 CE), the Bahira episode illustrates an early external validation of Muhammad's prophetic qualities. During a Meccan trading caravan to Syria around 594 CE, when Muhammad was approximately 12 years old, the monk Bahira purportedly discerns divine signs such as a shading cloud and the physical "seal of prophethood" between his shoulders. Drawing from Christian scriptures in his possession, Bahira identifies these as markers of the anticipated prophet and urges Abu Talib, Muhammad's uncle and caravan guardian, to protect the boy from Jewish adversaries who might seek to eliminate him.^[2]^[46] This narrative serves a legitimating function by embedding Muhammad's destiny within a framework of pre-Islamic divine foreknowledge, accessible even to a secluded Christian ascetic, thus portraying his prophethood as evident through universal signs predating the first Quranic revelation in 610 CE. Within Islamic apologetics, the story bolsters arguments for continuity across Abrahamic traditions, positing that discerning interpreters of biblical texts could foresee and affirm Muhammad's role, thereby addressing potential critiques of Islam's abrupt emergence.^[2] Critical scholarship, however, interprets the account as a hagiographic construct akin to legendary affirmations in Christian vitae, where saints exhibit prodigious traits recognized by contemporaries to retroactively sanctify their lives amid community-building needs. The tale's reliance on miraculous prescience and lack of independent contemporaneous attestation suggest its development as a rhetorical device to fortify prophetic credentials against skepticism, mirroring etiological motifs in other religious foundings rather than historical reportage.^[2]

Modern Scholarly Views

Modern scholars predominantly regard the Bahira narrative as a legendary construct rather than a verifiable historical event, citing the absence of any contemporaneous 6th-century documentation and its earliest attestation in the 8th-century Sīra of Ibn Isḥāq.^[2] This foundational version, compiled over a century after the purported encounter around 595 CE, relies on oral chains of transmission (isnād) that lack independent corroboration, leading revisionist historians to argue it emerged as a theological motif to legitimize Muhammad's prophethood through external validation.^[1] Analyses post-2000 emphasize how such stories may reflect later interfaith polemics, with Christian variants portraying Bahira (or Sergius) as a heretical influencer of Muhammad, potentially inverting Islamic claims for apologetic purposes.^[3] While some researchers acknowledge the plausibility of youthful caravan travels along Syrian trade routes—evidenced by archaeological traces of pre-Islamic commerce between Mecca and Bosra— they stress that no material remains, such as inscriptions or artifacts, link these to a specific monk-disciple interaction.^[47] Pro-historicity arguments, often from traditionalist perspectives, invoke ruins near Bosra as Bahira's monastery, but these attributions stem from medieval Islamic lore without 6th-century stratigraphic confirmation, highlighting evidential voids amid broader regional Christian-Monophysite networks.^[48] Recent studies (e.g., 2021 onward) differentiate oral precursors—possibly circulating prophetic signs in Hijazi folklore—from deliberate 8th-century fabrications, urging caution against conflating socio-economic realities with hagiographic embellishments.^[49] This skepticism aligns with broader critiques of early sīra reliability, prioritizing empirical gaps over narrative coherence.

References

[1]
[PDF] Christian Legend of Monk Bakira
The text of Monk Bahîrâ is an evidence of how historical traditions may have been perverted for polemical purposes. The story of the Christian monk Bahîrâ and ...
[2]
View of Muḥammad, the Monk, and the Jews - Entangled Religions
This study analyzes the foundational version of the Baḥīrā legend that appears in the Sīra of Muḥammad ibn Isḥāq (d. ca. 768 CE)
[3]
Muhammad and the Monk: The Making of the Christian Baḥīrā Legend
Jun 29, 2021 · This study examines the encounter between Bahira, a Syrian Christian monk, and the young Prophet Muhammad within the socio-religious ...
[4]
Muhammad and the Monk: The Making of the Christian Bahira Legend
The popularity of the legend among Christians living under Islamic rule is demonstrated by the relatively large number of known manuscripts, and by its impact ...
[5]
[PDF] The Legend of Sergius Bahira - Eastern Christian Apologetics and ...
found in both Christian and Muslim sources, of Muhammad, in his early years, meeting a. Christian monk, variously called Sergius or Bahira, who taught him about ...
[6]
The Story of Bahira the Monk: Fact or Fiction? (2) | Aataai Gazi ...
The story is suitable as a Hollywood movie or as best-selling fiction. But the story should not be claimed as authenticated history in the life of Muhammad ﷺ.
[7]
Sargis Bḥira - Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage
Sargis Bḥira is the name of a Syriac monk who allegedly met the Prophet Muḥammad and inspired him to begin preaching to the Arabs.Missing: origin | Show results with:origin
[8]
https://brill.com/display/book/9789004537897/BP000026.xml
[9]
Bahira - Al-Islam.org
His name derives from the Syriac bḥīrā, meaning “tested (by God) and approved”. Read More... 1 Question. How did the monks, such as Bahira, at the time of ...
[10]
Bahira: The Christian Monk who recognized the prophecy in ...
Mar 27, 2019 · The monk revealed his visions of Muhammad's future to the boy's uncle (Abu Talib), warning him to preserve the child from the Jews (in Ibn Sa' ...
[11]
Chapter 14: Report of Bahira the Monk - Al-Islam.org
Bahira then turned to Muhammad and said: I ask you three things, and adjure you by Laat and Uzza to answer. At the mention of these idols the Prophet was ...
[12]
Bahira Apocalypse - LinkedIn
Jan 26, 2020 · His appellation could have been derived from (Syriac: bḥīrā), meaning “tested (by God) and approved” or by the sheer nature of his dwelling next ...Missing: etymology bayra
[13]
Ibn Kathir: The Story of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) - Islam Awareness
When Muhammad was twelve years old, he accompanied his uncle Abu Talib on a mercantile journey to Syria, and they proceeded as far as Busra. The journey lasted ...
[14]
Story of Bahira the Monk - Prophet Muhammad Visit to Syria
Is the story of Bahira the monk authentic? After the analysis of the sources, we can say that the story of Baḥîra the monk lacks evidence.
[15]
IBN ISfclAQ'S USE OF THE ISNAD l - Manchester Hive
1 It is used, for example, about 'Abd al-Muftalib's vow when he dug the well Zamzam,2 about Muhammad's father 'Abdallah being. 'Abd al-Muttalib's favourite son, ...Missing: Bahira | Show results with:Bahira
[16]
The Reliability of Muslim Chronicler Ibn Ishaq - Answering Islam Blog
Apr 28, 2020 · As to the tradition from Fatima, al-Khatib gave us an isnad running back through I.I. and Fatima to Asma' d. Abu Bakr: 'I heard a woman ...Missing: Bahira | Show results with:Bahira
[17]
The Early Youth of the Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) - veins of truth
Jul 8, 2025 · Authenticity Note: While the Bahira story appears in early seerah books, it is not found in Sahih Bukhari or Muslim, and the chain of narration ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[18]
The Tale of Bahira the Monk | EN.tohed.com
Dec 6, 2024 · The story of Bahira, a monk who allegedly encountered the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) during his childhood, is one of the widely circulated religious ...
[19]
[PDF] Sirat Rasoul Allah by Ibn Ishaq - EMAANLIBRARY
A hundred of his followers emigrated to Abyssinia, and finally Muhammad himself decided to leave Mecca and went to Medina in AD 622. From this year the. Muslim ...<|separator|>
[20]
Early Life of Muhammad | World Civilization - Lumen Learning
Islamic tradition states that when Muhammad was either nine or twelve, while accompanying a caravan to Syria he met a Christian monk or hermit named Bahira, who ...
[21]
[PDF] Comparative Religion in Versions of the Baḥīrā Legend
The arrival of the Jewish assassins provides still more support: they too, independent of Baḥīrā, recognize in Muḥammad the scriptural signs of prophethood.
[22]
[PDF] The Story of Monk Sargis-Baḫīrā - Almuslih
It contains how Bahira first encountered Muhammand, recognizing him among the rest of the nomads, predicting that “he is the one in whom his prophecy will be ...
[23]
Trans-arabian routes of the pre-islamic period - Persée
Shahid has, in part, attributed the rise of Mecca in the 6th century to the successful diversion of caravans to it from Oman and al-Bahrayn, formerly intended ...Texte Intégral · The Neo-Assyrian Period · The Sasanian Period
[24]
http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/1184/1/1184.pdf
[25]
The identity and witness of Arab pre-Islamic Arab Christianity
This article will explore the identity and witness of the Christian presence in Arabia and claims that the development of an Arabic Bible provides a unique ...
[26]
Islam, Syriac interactions with
Interactions between Syriac Christians and Muslims were a regular feature of political, intellectual, and cultural life in the caliphate.
[27]
We know the monk Sergius/Bahira, who is believed to foretell ...
May 31, 2016 · We know the monk Sergius/Bahira, who is believed to foretell Muhammad's future as a prophet, is a Christian. But which Christianity? Was he a ...Missing: Symbolic | Show results with:Symbolic<|control11|><|separator|>
[28]
Monastic Movement as a Driving Force in Syriac Christian Mission ...
Nov 10, 2022 · ... Syriac monasticism spread from Mesopotamia to China. Most of. the monasteries were built along the trade routes, close to oasis cities or ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
[29]
[PDF] The Historical Evidence for Christians in the Arabian Gulf - Almuslih
An Anonymous monk translated from Persian into Syriac the legal book of ... Christianity and maritime trade in pre-Islamic Arabia. As mentioned above the ...
[30]
St. John of Damascus: Critique of Islam
Mar 26, 2006 · This man, after having chanced upon the Old and New Testaments and likewise, it seems, having conversed with an Arian monk, [101] devised his ...
[31]
[PDF] John Damascene in Context: An Examination of "The Heresy of the ...
May 9, 2009 · John—an earlier source than Ishaq—calls Bahira an Arian. Arian influence on Islam would be more believable than Nestorian influence, and ...<|separator|>
[32]
https://brill.com/display/book/9789004526860/BP000007.xml
[33]
Islam, Bahira the Monk, and Arianism - Orthodox - Medium
Mar 11, 2023 · The saint, St. John of Damascus believed that Islam was a continuation of Arianism in which Muhammad was inspired by an Arian monk.
[34]
Saint John of Damascus: His Encounter with Islam - Catholic 365
Jun 20, 2023 · ... influence of an Arian Assyrian Christian Monk, Bahira, who he (Muhammad) was friends with. He sums up Muhammad's teachings as: One God who ...
[35]
The Monk Encounters the Prophet—The Story of the ... - ResearchGate
Aug 7, 2025 · The Monk Encounters the Prophet—The Story of the Encounter between Monk Bahīra and Muhammad as It Is Recorded in the Syriac Manuscript of Mardin ...
[36]
[PDF] The Monk Encounters the Prophet—The Story of the ... - Almuslih
Muhammad poses leading questions, which Bahīra answers in a way which allows the reader to see both a statement of Christian doctrine and, by implication, the ...Missing: core | Show results with:core
[37]
https://brill.com/display/title/11657
[38]
Barbara Roggema, The Legend of Sergius Baḥīrā: Eastern ...
The story, found in both Christian and Muslim sources, of Muhammad, in his early years, meeting a Christian monk, variously called Sergius or Bahira.Missing: reliability criticism
[39]
[PDF] A critical analysis of Christian responses to Islamic claims about the ...
Further,. i t i s John's claim that Muhammad was influenced by the heretical Christian monk Bahira. From the Muslim perspective, however, the possibility of ...
[40]
Comparative Revelation: The Qu'ran and the Christ (HTML)
There is much similarity between this view and the Arian view of Jesus. There was also a belief taught that the Qur'an was not pre-existent and was created ...
[41]
Is Arius the Father of Islam? - Center For Baptist Renewal
Jan 10, 2022 · Arius was deemed a heretic seventeen hundred years ago, but missionaries continue to have to articulate the nature of Jesus in contrast with conflicting claims ...
[42]
https://brill.com/display/book/9789004526860/BP000007.xml?language=en
[43]
[PDF] muhammad learned monotheism from christians - onthewing.org
The truth is that Muhammad got tired of the Christians constantly preaching monotheism to his fellow Arabs, knowing in his heart, that they were correct in ...Missing: anti- | Show results with:anti-<|control11|><|separator|>
[44]
[PDF] The Prophet Muhammad: A Model of Monotheistic Reform for ... - HAL
Jan 19, 2021 · Nothing is more natural than to suppose that Mahomet, always occupied with his ideas of reform (for he at first thought of destroying idolatry ...
[45]
What is Islam's Relationship to Christianity? - Lausanne Movement
I concluded that the sheer volume of biblical reflexes in the Quran is not actually evidence of a deeper 'family-tree' affinity between Islam and Christianity.
[46]
Falsifying the Prophet: Muhammad at the Hands of His Earliest ...
... Bahira recognized the young Muhammad as the one who would fulfil his prophecy. An extended dialogue ensued, during which Sergius Bahira agreed to mentor the ...
[47]
[PDF] Islamization and Trade in the Arabian Gulf in the Age of Mohammad ...
The archaeological evidence also points to the persistence of long-distance trade in the Gulf, although the volume of the goods involved is still a matter of ...Missing: Bahira | Show results with:Bahira
[48]
Monastery of Bahira the monk - IslamicLandmarks.com
Bahira advised that Muhammad should be taken back to Makkah at once, if the Jews found out about Muhammad they would try to kill him. Abu Talib took the advice ...
[49]
<div> Interfaith Dynamics in the 6th Century Arabian Peninsula
Nov 4, 2024 · This study explores the interfaith dynamics of the encounter between Bahira, a Christian monk, and Muhammad in the socio-religious setting of 6th century ...Missing: trade routes Syria