Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Betti's theorem

Betti's theorem, also known as Betti's reciprocal theorem, is a fundamental principle in the linear theory of elasticity that establishes a reciprocity relation between two arbitrary systems of forces applied to an elastic body. It states that the work done by the forces of the first system acting through the displacements produced by the second system equals the work done by the forces of the second system acting through the displacements produced by the first system.^[1] Mathematically, for two force systems leading to stress fields \{\sigma^{(1)}\} and \{\sigma^{(2)}\} and corresponding strain fields \{\varepsilon^{(1)}\} and \{\varepsilon^{(2)}\}, the theorem is expressed as \int_V \{\sigma^{(1)}\}^T \{\varepsilon^{(2)}\} \, dV = \int_V \{\sigma^{(2)}\}^T \{\varepsilon^{(1)}\} \, dV, where the integration is over the volume V of the body, assuming linear elastic behavior with a symmetric constitutive tensor.^[1] Formulated by Italian mathematician Enrico Betti in 1872, the theorem appeared in his work Teoria dell'Elasticità and provided a general framework for elasticity in continuous media, building on earlier discrete reciprocity ideas by James Clerk Maxwell from 1864.^[2] Betti's contribution emphasized the theorem's validity for any linearly elastic body under quasi-static loading, without restrictions to specific geometries or boundary conditions, marking a key advancement in continuum mechanics.^[3] The theorem underpins numerous applications in structural engineering and solid mechanics, including the analysis of statically indeterminate structures via the force method, where it ensures the symmetry of the flexibility matrix—such that the displacement at point A due to a unit load at B equals the displacement at B due to a unit load at A (\delta_{AB} = \delta_{BA}).^[4] It also forms the basis for energy theorems like Castigliano's and virtual work principles, enabling efficient computation of deflections, stresses, and influence lines in beams, frames, and plates.^[1] Beyond statics, extensions of the theorem apply to dynamic elasticity and hyperelastic materials under small perturbations, confirming the existence of a stored-energy function.^[3]

Introduction

Definition and Statement

Betti's theorem, formulated by Enrico Betti in 1872, is a fundamental principle in the theory of elasticity that establishes a reciprocity relation between forces and displacements in linear elastic structures.^[5] The theorem states that for a linear elastic body subjected to two independent systems of forces, the work done by the forces of the first system acting through the displacements produced by the second system is equal to the work done by the forces of the second system acting through the displacements produced by the first system. In continuum form, this is expressed as

\int_V \mathbf{P}_1 \cdot \mathbf{u}_2 \, dV + \int_S \mathbf{T}_1 \cdot \mathbf{u}_2 \, dS = \int_V \mathbf{P}_2 \cdot \mathbf{u}_1 \, dV + \int_S \mathbf{T}_2 \cdot \mathbf{u}_1 \, dS,

where \mathbf{P}_1 and \mathbf{P}_2 are body force densities, \mathbf{T}_1 and \mathbf{T}_2 are surface tractions, and \mathbf{u}_1 and \mathbf{u}_2 are the corresponding displacement fields, with integrals over the volume V and surface S.^[6] For discrete structures, such as trusses or frames, the relation simplifies to \sum_i F_{1i} \Delta_{2i} = \sum_i F_{2i} \Delta_{1i}, where F_{1i} and F_{2i} are the forces from each system at point i, and \Delta_{1i} and \Delta_{2i} are the displacements at that point due to the respective systems.^[1] Physically, Betti's theorem illustrates the mutual reciprocity in the response of elastic bodies to multiple load sets, underscoring the inherent symmetry in how structures deform under conservative forces. This reciprocity highlights that the influence of one load on a particular displacement mirrors the influence of the reverse scenario, providing a symmetric characterization of structural behavior.^[1] The theorem relies on key concepts including the linearity of the elastic material, where stresses are proportional to strains via a symmetric stiffness tensor; the conservative nature of the forces, ensuring path-independent work; and the equilibrium of the structure under each load system, maintaining balance without inertial effects.^[6]^[3]

Historical Background

Enrico Betti, an Italian mathematician born in 1823, formulated the reciprocity theorem that bears his name in 1872 as part of his foundational contributions to the theory of elasticity. Betti's work extended principles of mutual influence between forces and displacements in elastic bodies, building directly on earlier discrete-structure analyses while addressing continuous media.^[7] Betti's theorem emerged from a lineage of 19th-century developments in mechanics, notably James Clerk Maxwell's 1864 reciprocity relation for forces in framed structures like trusses, which established that deflections due to loads at different points are equal in magnitude and direction when interchanged.^[8] This discrete reciprocity complemented Lord Kelvin's (William Thomson's) contemporaneous energy-based approaches to deformation in continuous elastic solids, which emphasized conservation principles and potential energy minimization in isotropic media during the 1840s and 1850s.^[9] Betti's generalization unified these ideas for arbitrary linear elastic systems, appearing first in his memoir Teoria della elasticità, published in Il Nuovo Cimento. The theorem gained broader applicability through subsequent refinements, including Lord Rayleigh's 1873 generalization that incorporated dynamic effects and vibrations, transforming Betti's static reciprocity into a more versatile tool for wave propagation and oscillatory systems in elastic continua.^[10] By the mid-20th century, Betti's reciprocity had become integral to numerical techniques in structural mechanics, underpinning the variational formulations and Galerkin methods central to the finite element method's development in the 1950s and 1960s.^[11] This integration facilitated computational analysis of complex elastic deformations, marking the theorem's transition from theoretical mechanics to engineering practice.

Mathematical Formulation

Assumptions and Conditions

Betti's theorem, also known as the Maxwell-Betti reciprocity theorem, applies to linear elastic bodies under specific conditions that ensure the reciprocity of work between two loading systems. The material must be linear elastic, obeying a generalized form of Hooke's law with a symmetric constitutive tensor, ensuring the existence of a strain energy density function.^[1]^[3] Additionally, the structure is assumed to be in static equilibrium, with small deformations that neglect geometric nonlinearities, allowing the principle of superposition to hold.^[4]^[12] Boundary conditions play a crucial role, typically involving fixed supports, prescribed displacements, or specified tractions on disjoint portions of the boundary, without initial stresses or temperature effects unless explicitly accounted for in the formulation.^[12] Loads are applied gradually to avoid dynamic effects, ensuring that displacements and rotations remain linear with respect to the applied forces or moments.^[13]^[4] The theorem's limitations are significant: it does not hold for nonlinear materials, viscoelastic behaviors, or structures under dynamic loading where inertia or damping introduces energy dissipation and breaks reciprocity.^[12]^[13] In cases involving damping or time-dependent problems, the reciprocal relations fail due to non-conservative forces.^[12] However, the theorem can be extended to anisotropic materials through tensor formulations of the elasticity equations, preserving the reciprocity principle in more general linear elastic frameworks.^[14]

Reciprocity Relations

Betti's reciprocity theorem establishes equality between the work done by one set of loads through the displacements caused by another set and vice versa, under the assumption of linear elasticity.^[12] In its continuous form for an elastic body occupying domain \Omega, the theorem states that for two independent systems of loads producing stress tensors \sigma_{ij}^{(1)} and \sigma_{ij}^{(2)}, and corresponding strain tensors \varepsilon_{ij}^{(1)} and \varepsilon_{ij}^{(2)}, the following holds:

\int_{\Omega} \sigma_{ij}^{(1)} \varepsilon_{ij}^{(2)} \, d\Omega = \int_{\Omega} \sigma_{ij}^{(2)} \varepsilon_{ij}^{(1)} \, d\Omega

This relation equates the mutual strain energy between the two load systems.^[12] A generalized version extends this to include body forces \mathbf{f}^{(k)} and surface tractions \mathbf{t}^{(k)} over the volume \Omega and boundary \partial \Omega, for load systems k = 1, 2, with corresponding displacement fields \mathbf{u}^{(k)}:

\int_{\Omega} \mathbf{f}^{(1)} \cdot \mathbf{u}^{(2)} \, d\Omega + \int_{\partial \Omega} \mathbf{t}^{(1)} \cdot \mathbf{u}^{(2)} \, dS = \int_{\Omega} \mathbf{f}^{(2)} \cdot \mathbf{u}^{(1)} \, d\Omega + \int_{\partial \Omega} \mathbf{t}^{(2)} \cdot \mathbf{u}^{(1)} \, dS

This form captures the equality of virtual work across distributed and boundary loads.^[12] In the discrete form applicable to structures with n degrees of freedom, Betti's theorem manifests as the symmetry of the flexibility matrix \Delta, where the flexibility coefficients \Delta_{ij} are defined as the displacement at degree of freedom i due to a unit load applied at degree of freedom j. Thus, \Delta_{ij} = \Delta_{ji}, implying \mathbf{u} = \Delta \mathbf{F} with \Delta symmetric. Equivalently, the stiffness matrix \mathbf{K} in the relation \mathbf{F} = \mathbf{K} \mathbf{u} is symmetric, \mathbf{K} = \mathbf{K}^T. These symmetries hold for multiple load sets, ensuring mutual work equality in discretized linear elastic systems.^[15]

Proofs

Principle of Virtual Work Approach

The proof of Betti's reciprocity theorem via the principle of virtual work relies on considering a linear elastic body in equilibrium under two distinct loading systems. Let the body occupy domain \Omega with boundary \Gamma. The first loading system consists of body forces \mathbf{f}_1 and surface tractions \mathbf{t}_1, producing displacements \mathbf{u}_1 and corresponding strains \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_1 and stresses \boldsymbol{\sigma}_1. The second system has body forces \mathbf{f}_2 and tractions \mathbf{t}_2, yielding displacements \mathbf{u}_2, strains \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_2, and stresses \boldsymbol{\sigma}_2. Both states satisfy the equilibrium equations \nabla \cdot \boldsymbol{\sigma}_i + \mathbf{f}_i = \mathbf{0} in \Omega for i=1,2, with \mathbf{t}_i = \boldsymbol{\sigma}_i \cdot \mathbf{n} on \Gamma, where \mathbf{n} is the outward normal. The material is assumed hyperelastic with symmetric stress-strain relation \boldsymbol{\sigma}_i = \mathbf{C} : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_i, where \mathbf{C} is the fourth-order elasticity tensor with major and minor symmetries.^[12]^[6] To apply the principle of virtual work, treat the displacements \mathbf{u}_2 from the second state as virtual displacements \delta \mathbf{u} = \mathbf{u}_2 compatible with the kinematics, inducing virtual strains \delta \boldsymbol{\varepsilon} = \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_2 = \frac{1}{2} (\nabla \mathbf{u}_2 + (\nabla \mathbf{u}_2)^T). For the first equilibrium state, the principle states that the virtual work of external forces equals the internal virtual work of stresses:

\int_\Omega \mathbf{f}_1 \cdot \mathbf{u}_2 \, dV + \int_\Gamma \mathbf{t}_1 \cdot \mathbf{u}_2 \, dA = \int_\Omega \boldsymbol{\sigma}_1 : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_2 \, dV.

This equality follows from integrating the equilibrium equation by parts (via the divergence theorem or Green's identities) and substituting the traction boundary condition, ensuring no residual terms from body forces or boundaries. Similarly, interchanging the roles of the states yields

\int_\Omega \mathbf{f}_2 \cdot \mathbf{u}_1 \, dV + \int_\Gamma \mathbf{t}_2 \cdot \mathbf{u}_1 \, dA = \int_\Omega \boldsymbol{\sigma}_2 : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_1 \, dV.

These expressions represent the external virtual work equated to the internal one for each configuration.^[12]^[6] The symmetry of the elasticity tensor \mathbf{C} (i.e., C_{ijkl} = C_{klij}) implies that the strain energy density \frac{1}{2} \boldsymbol{\sigma}_i : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_i is a symmetric quadratic form, leading to \boldsymbol{\sigma}_1 : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_2 = \boldsymbol{\sigma}_2 : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_1 pointwise. Integrating over the domain gives \int_\Omega \boldsymbol{\sigma}_1 : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_2 \, dV = \int_\Omega \boldsymbol{\sigma}_2 : \boldsymbol{\varepsilon}_1 \, dV. Therefore, the external virtual works must be equal:

\int_\Omega \mathbf{f}_1 \cdot \mathbf{u}_2 \, dV + \int_\Gamma \mathbf{t}_1 \cdot \mathbf{u}_2 \, dA = \int_\Omega \mathbf{f}_2 \cdot \mathbf{u}_1 \, dV + \int_\Gamma \mathbf{t}_2 \cdot \mathbf{u}_1 \, dA.

This establishes Betti's reciprocity relation, showing that the work done by the forces of one system through the displacements of the other equals the reverse. The proof assumes small deformations, linear elasticity, and static equilibrium, with no body couples or initial stresses.^[12]^[6] This virtual work approach aligns with Enrico Betti's original 1872 reasoning, which generalized earlier work by Maxwell using energy conservation principles in elastic systems, emphasizing the symmetry of the strain energy functional.^[12]

Stiffness Matrix Method

In the stiffness matrix method, a linear elastic structure is discretized into finite elements, leading to the global equilibrium equation \{F\} = [K] \{u\}, where \{F\} is the vector of applied nodal forces, \{u\} is the vector of nodal displacements, and [K] is the assembled global stiffness matrix.^[16] The global stiffness matrix [K] is formed by assembling element stiffness matrices ^e = \int_{V^e} [B]^T [D] [B] \, dV, where [B] is the strain-displacement matrix for the element, [D] is the symmetric material elasticity matrix, and the integration is over the element volume V^e.^[16] The symmetry of [K] arises because ([B]^T [D] [B])^T = [B]^T [D]^T [B] = [B]^T [D] [B], given the symmetry of [D]; this property directly follows from Betti's reciprocity theorem as a consequence of energy conservation in elastic systems.^[16] Specifically, the entry [K]_{ij} represents the force required at degree of freedom i to impose a unit displacement at degree of freedom j (with all other displacements zero), and symmetry implies [K]_{ij} = [K]_{ji}.^[16] To demonstrate Betti's theorem in this discrete framework, consider two independent loading cases: forces \{F^{(1)}\} producing displacements \{u^{(1)}\}, and forces \{F^{(2)}\} producing displacements \{u^{(2)}\}. The work done by \{F^{(1)}\} through \{u^{(2)}\} equals \{F^{(1)}\}^T \{u^{(2)}\}. Substituting the constitutive relation \{F^{(1)}\} = [K] \{u^{(1)}\} yields \{u^{(1)}\}^T [K] \{u^{(2)}\}. Due to the symmetry of [K], this equals \{u^{(2)}\}^T [K] \{u^{(1)}\} = \{F^{(2)}\}^T \{u^{(1)}\}, which is the work done by \{F^{(2)}\} through \{u^{(1)}\}.^[1] This matrix-based approach highlights the theorem's role in computational structural analysis, such as the finite element method (FEM), where the inherent symmetry of [K] reduces storage and computational effort by approximately half (storing only the upper or lower triangle) and ensures that influence (flexibility) matrices, as the inverse of [K], are also symmetric.^[16]

Applications

Structural Analysis

Betti's theorem plays a central role in structural analysis by enabling engineers to compute displacements at a specific point in a structure using the known responses to loads applied at another point, thereby reducing the need for redundant calculations in linear elastic systems. This reciprocity relation, which equates the work done by one set of forces through the displacements caused by another set to the reverse, simplifies the evaluation of deflections in frameworks such as trusses and frames without requiring full reanalysis for each load case.^[4] In practical applications, the theorem underpins the dummy load method, where a unit virtual load is applied at the point of interest to determine deflections elsewhere in the structure, particularly useful for statically indeterminate beams, trusses, and frames. This approach leverages the reciprocity to calculate flexibility coefficients and ensure compatibility conditions in the force method of analysis, avoiding the computation of internal force distributions for every scenario. Additionally, it serves as a verification tool for the symmetry of analysis results in indeterminate structures, confirming that mutual displacements align as predicted by the theorem to detect modeling errors early.^[6]^[17] Within structural design, Betti's theorem ensures the reciprocity inherent in influence lines for critical responses like reactions and moments in bridges and buildings, allowing designers to assess load effects efficiently across moving or distributed loads. It also aids in error checking of finite element analysis (FEA) models by validating that simulated displacements satisfy reciprocal relations, enhancing reliability in complex designs.^[18]^[19]

Elasticity and Deformation

In elasticity theory, Betti's reciprocal theorem provides a fundamental relation between the stresses and strains induced by two different load cases in a linear elastic continuum, enabling the interchange of loading configurations without altering the work equivalence. This reciprocity allows engineers to compute deformations or stresses in complex geometries by leveraging solutions from simpler auxiliary problems, ensuring symmetry in the material response under infinitesimal deformations.^[3] The theorem assumes linear elasticity, where stresses are proportional to strains via a symmetric stiffness tensor, valid for small deformations in isotropic or anisotropic solids. In deformation analysis, Betti's reciprocity extends to thermal or body force problems, where temperature gradients or distributed forces induce coupled thermoelastic effects. By integrating the reciprocal work over the volume, the theorem simplifies the solution of integral equations for displacement fields, reducing the need for direct inversion of Navier's equations in heterogeneous media. For thermal loading, the extended Betti-Rayleigh form accounts for temperature-dependent material properties, such as varying Young's modulus, allowing superposition of thermal expansion solutions to compute overall deformations in bodies with cavities or irregular boundaries. This approach is particularly useful in body force-driven problems, like gravitational loading in elastic foundations, where reciprocity minimizes computational overhead by relating primary and adjoint states.^[20]^[21] In solving boundary value problems governed by Navier's equations, Betti's theorem supports the superposition of reciprocal solutions to satisfy mixed boundary conditions on displacements and tractions, converting volume integrals into boundary-only formulations via the divergence theorem. This integral representation is key in deriving Somigliana's identity, which expresses interior displacements in terms of boundary data, streamlining numerical solutions for irregular domains in continuum mechanics. Modern extensions apply the theorem in fracture mechanics, particularly for mixed-mode loading where cracks experience combined opening (mode I) and shearing (mode II) under reciprocal states. In strain gradient elasticity, an extended Betti reciprocity derives two-state interaction integrals to evaluate stress intensity factors and energy release rates at interface cracks, capturing size effects near crack tips in bimaterials. This framework enhances predictions of crack propagation angles and toughness in composites, bridging classical and gradient theories.^[22]^[23]^[24]

Examples

Beam Deflection Case

Consider a cantilever beam of length L with constant flexural rigidity EI, fixed at one end (x = 0) and free at the other (x = L). To illustrate Betti's theorem, apply two point loads: P_1 downward at a distance a from the fixed end and P_2 downward at a distance b from the fixed end, with $0 < a < b < L. The theorem states that the work done by P_1 acting through the deflection at b due to P_2 equals the work done by P_2 acting through the deflection at a due to P_1, implying the reciprocity \delta_{ba} = \delta_{ab}, where \delta_{ba} is the deflection at b due to a unit load at a, and similarly for \delta_{ab}.^[25] To compute the deflections, use the moment-curvature relation EI \frac{d^2 y}{dx^2} = M(x), solved via double integration with boundary conditions y(0) = 0 and \frac{dy}{dx}(0) = 0 at the fixed end. For a single point load P at distance a from the fixed end, the bending moment (with positive M producing positive curvature for downward deflection) is M(x) = P(a - x) for $0 \leq x \leq a and M(x) = 0 for a < x \leq L.^[26] For the region $0 \leq x \leq a:

EI y'' = P(a - x)

Integrate once:

EI y' = P \left( a x - \frac{x^2}{2} \right) + C_1

Apply y'(0) = 0: C_1 = 0, so

y' = \frac{P}{EI} \left( a x - \frac{x^2}{2} \right)

Integrate again:

EI y = P \left( \frac{a x^2}{2} - \frac{x^3}{6} \right) + C_2

Apply y(0) = 0: C_2 = 0, so

y(x) = \frac{P}{EI} \left( \frac{a x^2}{2} - \frac{x^3}{6} \right), \quad 0 \leq x \leq a.

For the region a < x \leq L:

EI y'' = 0

Integrate once:

EI y' = C_3

Integrate again:

EI y = C_3 x + C_4.

Apply continuity at x = a: y'(a^-) = y'(a^+) gives C_3 = P a^2 / 2; y(a^-) = y(a^+) gives C_4 = -P a^3 / 6. Thus,

y(x) = \frac{P a^2}{2 EI} x - \frac{P a^3}{6 EI} = \frac{P a^2 (3x - a)}{6 EI}, \quad a < x \leq L.

^[26] The deflection at b > a due to P_1 at a is \delta_{b1} = \frac{P_1 a^2 (3b - a)}{6 [EI](/page/EI)}. Similarly, for P_2 at b, the deflection at a < b is found using the formula for x \leq load position: \delta_{a2} = \frac{P_2 a^2 (3b - a)}{6 [EI](/page/EI)}. The expressions are identical in form, confirming \delta_{b1}/P_1 = \delta_{a2}/P_2, or reciprocity for unit loads.^[26]^[27] To demonstrate numerically, assume L = 3 m, a = 1 m, b = 2 m, EI = 1 kN·m², P_1 = P_2 = 1 kN. Then \delta_{b1} = \frac{1 \cdot 1^2 (3 \cdot 2 - 1)}{6 \cdot 1} = \frac{5}{6} m and \delta_{a2} = \frac{5}{6} m, showing exact equality without recomputing the full integration for the second load case. This reciprocity allows deflection at one point to be inferred directly from analysis at another, avoiding redundant computations.^[26] The influence diagram for deflection at a point is the elastic curve due to a unit load at that point, symmetric under reciprocity: the ordinate at b for unit load at a matches the ordinate at a for unit load at b. For the example parameters, the influence values are both \frac{a^2 (3b - a)}{6 EI} = \frac{5}{6} m/kN, highlighting the theorem's utility in efficient structural design.^[27]

Truss Structure Illustration

To illustrate the application of Betti's theorem in a discrete structural system, consider a simple plane two-bar truss consisting of nodes A, B, and C, with bar AB of length L_1 = 3 m connected to bar BC of length L_2 = 4 m. Node A is fixed against translation in both directions, and node C is also fixed (pinned support), while node B is a free joint. Loads are applied: a horizontal load F_1 at B in the positive x-direction and a vertical load F_2 at C in the positive y-direction. The cross-sectional area for both bars is A = 0.01 m², and the modulus of elasticity is E = 200 GPa. The geometry is arranged such that the span from A to C is 5 m along the x-axis, with B positioned at coordinates (1.8 m, 2.4 m), forming a 3-4-5 triangular configuration, ensuring the bars are inclined and the structure is statically determinate.^[28] The analysis begins by applying the method of joints to determine the axial forces in the members for each loading case separately. For the load F_1 at B (horizontal), equilibrium at joint B yields the axial forces N_{AB}^{(1)} and N_{BC}^{(1)} in bars AB and BC, respectively, considering the angles of inclination: \theta_1 = \cos^{-1}(1.8/3) \approx 53.13^\circ for AB and \theta_2 = \cos^{-1}(3.2/4) \approx 36.87^\circ for BC. For F_1 = 1 kN, the member forces are N_{AB}^{(1)} = 0.6 kN (tension) and N_{BC}^{(1)} = -0.8 kN (compression), depending on sign convention. For the load F_2 at C (vertical), since C is a fixed support, the support reaction at C balances F_2 directly, resulting in zero axial forces: N_{AB}^{(2)} = 0 and N_{BC}^{(2)} = 0. These forces are then used in the flexibility method (or principle of virtual work) to compute the joint displacements. The horizontal displacement at B due to F_2, denoted \Delta_{Bx}^{(2)}, is given by

\Delta_{Bx}^{(2)} = \sum \frac{N^{(2)} n_{Bx} L}{A E},

where the sum is over all members, N^{(2)} are the member forces due to F_2 (zero), and n_{Bx} are the member forces due to a unit horizontal load at B in the x-direction. Thus, \Delta_{Bx}^{(2)} = 0. Likewise, the vertical displacement at C due to F_1, \Delta_{Cy}^{(1)}, is

\Delta_{Cy}^{(1)} = \sum \frac{N^{(1)} n_{Cy} L}{A E},

with N^{(1)} from F_1 and n_{Cy} from a unit vertical load at C in the y-direction (which also yields zero member forces n_{Cy} = 0). Thus, \Delta_{Cy}^{(1)} = 0. Betti's theorem guarantees that \Delta_{Bx}^{(2)} / F_2 = \Delta_{Cy}^{(1)} / F_1, or equivalently \Delta_{12} = \Delta_{21} for unit loads, as both are zero. This reciprocity arises from the symmetry of the flexibility matrix in truss analysis, holding even in this trivial case due to the fixed support at C.^[17] This example, though trivial (as cross-displacements are zero), confirms the theorem under the given boundary conditions. For non-trivial illustrations, consider structures where both points of interest allow displacement.^[29] Free-body diagrams: The overall free-body diagram of the truss shows fixed support reactions at A (A_x, A_y) and C (C_x, C_y), with F_1 acting rightward at B and F_2 upward at C. For the isolated joint B under F_1, the diagram depicts tension/compression in AB and BC balancing the horizontal force. Similarly, for joint C under F_2, the vertical force is balanced directly by the support C_y, with no force in BC. Displacement at C is zero by support condition, and displacement at B due to F_2 is zero as no member deformation occurs. The stiffness matrix for the system also exhibits symmetry in its off-diagonal terms, underscoring the theorem's foundation in linear elasticity.^[28]

References

[1]
[PDF] THE THEOREMS OF BETTI, MAXWELL, AND CASTIGLIANO CEE ...
Betti's Theorem1 (1872). For a linear elastic structure, equations (6) and (4) are equivalent. Proof: In linear elastic structures stress is proportional to ...
[2]
[PDF] An application of Betti's reciprocal theorem for the analysis of an ...
The objective of this paper is to demonstrate the effec- tiveness of Betti's reciprocal theorem in providing the solu- tion to a problem related to a rigid ...
[3]
[PDF] The meaning of Betti's reciprocal theorem
The true significance of Betti's theorem, how- ever, lies in its being a criterion jor the existence oj a stored-energy junction. Indeed, the differential ...
[4]
10.2: Maxwell-Betti Law of Reciprocal Deflections
Apr 21, 2021 · The Maxwell-Betti law of reciprocal deflections establishes the fact that the displacements at two points in an elastic structure subjected ...
[5]
A Historical Note on the Reciprocal Theorem and Theory of ... - Nature
Thus, in his book “Mathematical Theory of Elasticity” (4th edit. 1927), A. E. H. Love attributed the theorem to E. Betti (Il nuovo Cimento, ser. 2, 1872), but ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[6]
[PDF] Clapeyron's, Betti's, and Maxwell's Theorems - TAMU Mechanics
Mar 11, 2017 · Theorem: The strain energy stored in a linear elastic body is equal to one-half of the work done by external forces on the body: 1. 2. E. U. V.
[7]
[PDF] arXiv:2308.15715v4 [math.NA] 27 Jan 2024
Jan 27, 2024 · Later, in 1872, Enrico Betti—an Italian mathematician and the eponym of Betti's theorem, also referred to as Betti's relations—established ...
[8]
[PDF] I.—On Reciprocal Figures, Frames, and Diagrams of Forces
Two figures are reciprocal when the properties of the first relative to the second are the same as those of the second relative to the first.
[9]
[PDF] A treatise on the mathematical theory of elasticity - HAL
Apr 28, 2016 · Betti's general method, and some of the most important particular cases are worked out synthetically by M. Boussinesq's method of potentials ...<|separator|>
[10]
The reciprocal theorem in fluid dynamics and transport phenomena
Sep 30, 2019 · Betti's work was later generalized by the British physicist and Nobel Prize winner Lord Rayleigh ( 1873, 1876, 1877) and extended to the field ...
[11]
1.0 An Historical Perspective 1.1 Boundary Integral Equation ...
In the view of this author, the finite element and boundary element methods have a common root in the pioneer ing work of E. Betti (1872).
[12]
[PDF] linearized elasticity
Jul 7, 2023 · The proof of Betti's reciprocity theorem is straightforward. Let W12 denote the work done by forces (f(1),t(1)) acting through the ...
[13]
Reciprocal Theorem - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
That means that on a linearly elastic structure, the works done by two forces on the displacements caused by the other load are identical (Eq. 6.84). This is ...Missing: assumptions | Show results with:assumptions
[14]
Elastostatic fields in an anisotropic substrate due to a buried ...
Our approach is based on Green's function solution in anisotropic and linearly elastic half-space combined with the Betti's reciprocal theorem. ... materials ...
[15]
[PDF] FEM/BEM NOTES
Feb 21, 2001 · Notice that the element stiffness matrix is symmetric. Notice ... Applying the DR-BEM to this equation gives a matrix system of the form.
[16]
None
Below is a merged response summarizing the Betti or Reciprocity Theorem in the context of stiffness matrix symmetry, consolidating all the information from the provided segments. To retain maximum detail in a dense and organized format, I will use a table in CSV format, followed by a narrative summary that ties everything together. The table captures key details such as location, text, explanation, and URLs, while the narrative provides an overarching synthesis.
[17]
[PDF] Force Method for Analysis of Indeterminate Structures
Maxwell's Theorem of Reciprocal displacements; Betti's law. Betti's Theorem. For structures with multiple degree of indeterminacy. Example: The displacement ...Missing: statement | Show results with:statement
[18]
Maxwell Betti Law of Reciprocal Deflections - Civil Engineering (CE ...
Rating 4.7 (479) The Maxwell-Betti law also has applications in the construction of influence lines diagrams for statically indeterminate structures. The Maxwell-Betti law, ...
[19]
(PDF) Direct determination of influence lines and surfaces by F.E.M.
Aug 9, 2025 · According to this approach, the element loading matrices used to determine the influence surfaces of plates are obtained using the Betti's law ...
[20]
A Betti-Rayleigh theorem for elastic bodies exhibiting temperature ...
The reciprocal theorem of Betti and Rayleigh is extended to thermoelastic problems concerning temperature dependent properties of the bodies.
[21]
[PDF] BOUNDARY-INTEG AL METHODS IN ELASTICITY AND PLASTICITY
Derivation of Equations (50) and (51). Betti's reciprocal theorem states: Given two states of stress and displacement due to two different sets of loads, then.
[22]
[PDF] An integral equation approach to boundary value problems of ...
The Navier-Cauchy equations of elasticity in the absence of body ... The vectorial form of Betti's reciprocal work theorem can be written. L (UiTu ...
[23]
Asymptotic solution for interface crack between two materials ...
The concept of the Betti theorem extended to dipolar gradient elasticity is used to generalize the two state integral methods in fracture mechanics of materials ...
[24]
Application of Betti's reciprocal work theorem to the construction of ...
Application of Betti's reciprocal work theorem to the construction of the hypersingular integral equation of a plane crack in three-dimensional elasticity.
[25]
https://eng.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Mechanical_Engineering/Introduction_to_Aerospace_Structures_and_Materials_(Alderliesten)/03:_Analysis_of_Statically_Indeterminate_Structures/10:_Force_Method_of_Analysis_of_Indeterminate_Structures/10.02:_Maxwell-Betti_Law_of_Reciprocal_Deflections
[26]
None
### Summary of Deflection Formulas for Cantilever Beam with Concentrated Load P at Any Point
[27]
https://mechanics.tamu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/11-12-_Clayperon-Maxwell.pdf
[28]
[PDF] Analysis of Statically Determinate Trusses
Maxwell's Theorem of Reciprocal. Displacements: Betti's Law. □ The theorem also applies for reciprocal rotations. □ The rotation at point B on a structure ...