Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Catch and Kill

Catch and Kill: Lies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to Protect Predators is a 2019 nonfiction book by American investigative journalist , chronicling his reporting on decades of and allegations against , as well as the tactics of intimidation, surveillance, and story suppression deployed by Weinstein and allied media entities to evade accountability. Published on October 15, 2019, by , the book draws from Farrow's experiences at , where executives declined to air his Weinstein story despite internal awareness of similar issues, leading him to publish it in in 2017, an exposé that helped precipitate Weinstein's downfall and amplified the . Farrow details the "" practice—a method where tabloid outlets like the , owned by American Media, Inc. (AMI), purchased exclusive rights to damaging stories only to bury them—including instances allegedly benefiting —and alleges involvement of private intelligence firms in efforts to discredit accusers and reporters. The work earned praise for its meticulous sourcing and revelations of institutional complicity but sparked disputes, including rebuttals from leadership over depictions of their decision-making and a lawsuit from AMI editor claiming falsehoods about his role. Farrow's underlying New Yorker reporting received the for , shared with and of .

The Catch and Kill Practice

Definition and Operational Mechanics

refers to a tactic whereby a or outlet purchases the exclusive to a story—often one containing potentially damaging information about a prominent or —not to report it, but to suppress its entirely. This practice, originating in , relies on contractual exclusivity to block the source from selling or sharing the material with competitors, thereby "killing" the narrative before it can gain wider exposure. The term encapsulates both the acquisition ("catch") and the deliberate non-publication ("kill") phases, distinguishing it from standard story-buying for journalistic purposes. Operationally, the process begins when a tip or story emerges, typically from a with firsthand or documentation. The interested media entity negotiates a deal, often involving a lump-sum to the source in exchange for lifelong rights to the material and a (NDA) prohibiting the source from disclosing the information to others. Once secured, the outlet archives the story without verification, editing, or release, ensuring its perpetual burial; this exclusivity clause legally binds the source, as breaches can trigger lawsuits for damages. Payments can range from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars, calibrated to the story's perceived threat level, and may involve intermediaries like lawyers to maintain deniability. The tactic's effectiveness hinges on the enforceability of private contracts under U.S. law, which courts generally uphold absent or violations, allowing suppression without First Amendment constraints since no government action is involved. However, when tied to political campaigns, such arrangements have faced scrutiny under regulations, as seen in reviews of deals exceeding $30,000 in value. Proponents within tabloid circles have framed it as a tool for inventory control, but critics argue it perverts journalistic norms by prioritizing protection of allies over .

Historical Precedents and Notable Examples

The practice of traces its roots to early 20th-century , particularly in publications like William Randolph Hearst's New York American, which suppressed damaging stories to protect political or business allies; one documented instance occurred in 1927 when a report on a politician's extramarital was acquired and buried rather than published. By the mid-20th century, the technique had become a staple of supermarket tabloids. In the 1960s, under the ownership of Generoso Pope Jr., the National Enquirer purchased exclusive rights to a story detailing Judy Garland's drug use but refrained from publishing it, exemplifying the tactic's use to curry favor or secure access. Pope's regime, which lasted until his death in 1988, routinely involved trading story suppression for exclusive interviews, such as with comedian Bob Hope, establishing catch and kill as a quid pro quo mechanism in tabloid operations. In the 2000s, American Media Inc. (AMI), publisher of the National Enquirer, applied the practice to shield high-profile figures from scandal. During Arnold Schwarzenegger's 2003 California gubernatorial campaign, AMI paid Gigi Goyette $20,000 for the rights to her account of a sexual relationship with Schwarzenegger two decades earlier, ensuring the story remained unpublished. That same year, the Enquirer tempered a report on actor Matt LeBlanc's alleged infidelity with a stripper, softening details after securing an exclusive interview with him. In 2005, AMI agreed to pay accuser Beth Ferrier $7,500 for her allegations of sexual assault by Bill Cosby, intending to suppress the story in exchange for an interview with Cosby, though the payment was ultimately withheld after Ferrier went public elsewhere. A prominent 2007 case involved , where the acquired but withheld photos and details of one of his extramarital affairs to facilitate a cover feature on Woods for its sister publication , prioritizing promotional access over disclosure. The practice gained renewed attention in political contexts during Donald 's 2016 presidential campaign, when AMI chief , in an August 2015 meeting with and attorney , committed to monitoring and suppressing negative stories about . This included a $30,000 payment in November 2015 to a doorman for unsubstantiated claims that had fathered an illegitimate child, and a $150,000 deal in August 2016 with former model to bury her account of a months-long affair with from 2006 to 2007. Pecker later detailed these arrangements in testimony during 's 2024 New York hush money trial, confirming the intent to influence the election by preventing publication. The practice of contravenes fundamental journalistic ethics by prioritizing suppression of information over the public's , particularly when stories involve allegations of by influential figures. It transforms outlets from watchdogs into enablers of concealment, often for or strategic alliances, which undermines principles enshrined in codes like those of the that mandate seeking truth and reporting it independently. Critics, including media ethicists, contend that such tactics erode institutional credibility and foster a culture where powerful entities evade scrutiny, as evidenced by tabloid deals shielding celebrities from exposure of personal scandals. Legally, catch and kill operates within the bounds of contract law and First Amendment protections, as outlets acquire exclusive rights without any affirmative duty to publish, akin to editorial discretion in choosing non-publication. However, it invites scrutiny when integrated into broader schemes, such as election interference; in 2018, American Media Inc. (AMI), publisher of the , entered a non-prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, admitting to $150,000 and $200,000 payments to suppress stories about in coordination with his 2016 campaign, constituting potential violations under federal election law. Similar AMI arrangements to bury allegations against , including a 2017 deal for exclusive rights to a model's claims of , faced no independent criminal charges but amplified regulatory pressure on the company, leading to a 2019 corporate restructuring and sale considerations amid federal probes. While not inherently unlawful, the tactic's deployment has prompted calls for antitrust examination in cases of repeated coordination among outlets, though courts have upheld it absent provable illegality like or . In Weinstein's 2020 New York criminal trial, evidence indirectly bolstered prosecution narratives of systematic cover-ups, but the practice itself evaded direct legal , highlighting tensions between contractual freedom and safeguards.

Ronan Farrow's Journalistic Background

Early Career and Reporting on Sexual Misconduct

Ronan Farrow began his professional career after earning a in from at age 15 in 2003 and a from in 2011. He initially worked in international , serving as a starting in 2001 and later as a special adviser to at the U.S. State Department, focusing on youth issues and conflict zones in and from 2009 to 2011. These roles involved fieldwork on , including advocacy against child soldiers and exploitation, which laid groundwork for his later investigative focus on power imbalances and abuse. Transitioning to media, Farrow joined in 2011 as a contributor, hosting the short-lived program Ronan Farrow Daily from 2014 to 2015, which covered policy and topics. He then contributed to , producing investigative segments for the Today show under the banner "Undercovered With Ronan Farrow," examining overlooked stories such as labor abuses and corporate . This period marked his shift toward emphasizing systemic failures, often drawing on his diplomatic experience to highlight institutional cover-ups. Farrow's early reporting on sexual misconduct centered on allegations against his adoptive father, , stemming from claims by his sister Dylan Farrow of molestation in 1992. In a May 11, 2016, Hollywood Reporter essay titled "My Father, Woody Allen, and the Danger of Questions Unasked," Farrow argued that media and industry reluctance to scrutinize Allen's relationships—particularly with his stepdaughter , whom Allen married in 1997—exemplified a broader failure to probe powerful figures' conduct. He cited Dylan's contemporaneous accounts, a 1992 custody investigation by the that referred the case for prosecution (though no charges followed after review by a special prosecutor), and a Yale-New Haven Hospital evaluation concluding the abuse allegation was unreliable, while questioning the evaluation's methodology for potential bias toward Allen. Farrow framed this as a cautionary pattern of deferred questions enabling potential misconduct, predating his Weinstein probe but foreshadowing themes of elite impunity. This piece, amid renewed public interest in Dylan's 2014 Vanity Fair interview reiterating her claims, positioned Farrow as an advocate for victims' narratives against institutional skepticism, though critics noted the familial conflict of interest and lack of new evidence overturning prior investigations clearing Allen. No formal charges were ever filed against Allen, who has consistently denied the allegations, attributing them to a contentious custody battle with Mia Farrow. Farrow's essay contributed to sporadic boycotts of Allen's films but did not result in widespread industry repercussions at the time, reflecting pre-#MeToo dynamics where such claims against established figures often faced evidentiary hurdles and public doubt.

Pre-Weinstein Investigations into High-Profile Figures

Prior to the exposé, Ronan Farrow's journalistic efforts touching on sexual misconduct centered primarily on longstanding allegations against his father, the filmmaker . In a May 11, 2016, for , Farrow criticized media coverage and biographical works for systematically avoiding direct questions to Allen about claims by Farrow's adoptive sister, Dylan Farrow, that Allen had sexually molested her in August 1992 at age seven. Farrow highlighted instances where interviewers and authors accepted Allen's denials without probing inconsistencies in his accounts or the context of the 1993 custody trial between Allen and , arguing that this reflected a deference to celebrity power that undermined accountability. The 1992 incident prompted investigations by , the Connecticut Department of Children and Families, and a clinical team from Yale-New Haven Hospital, which evaluated Dylan and concluded she had not been abused, citing potential coaching or fabrication influenced by the acrimonious parental custody dispute. Allen, who has consistently denied the allegations, prevailed in the subsequent custody proceedings, with the judge ruling the claims unsubstantiated and granting him visitation rights with and of another child. Farrow's piece, however, contended that unresolved questions—such as discrepancies in witness statements and Allen's behavior toward —warranted renewed scrutiny, framing the media's reticence as part of a pattern enabling high-profile figures to evade examination of claims. This work, while opinion-oriented rather than a new empirical probe with anonymous sources or recordings, aligned with Farrow's emerging focus at on underreported stories of power imbalances, including his "Undercovered" series for the Today show. It predated his shift to more structured investigations and underscored personal motivations from familial allegations, which Farrow later described as informing his persistence in confronting institutional resistance to such reporting. No other documented investigations by Farrow into named high-profile figures for appear prior to 2017, though his earlier State Department role (2011–2013) involved advocacy on global prevention, such as through the Preventing Sexual Violence in Conflict Initiative.

The Harvey Weinstein Exposé

Origins of the Investigation at

Ronan Farrow, serving as a special correspondent for since 2015, initiated his investigation into 's alleged sexual misconduct in early 2017. The probe began with Farrow pursuing leads on women who had reportedly faced or by the film , driven by prior whispers in circles and Farrow's own prior reporting on related issues of power abuse. A pivotal early step involved securing, through legal channels, a 2015 audio recording from Italian model Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, captured during a Department on March 28, 2015, in which Weinstein explicitly admitted to groping her breast the previous day while discouraging her from disclosing it. Farrow's NBC team, including producer Rich McHugh, conducted an initial on-camera interview with actress Rose McGowan in January 2017, where she detailed an alleged 1997 assault by Weinstein at the Sundance Film Festival, marking one of the first on-the-record accounts obtained during the network's involvement. This interview, along with the Gutierrez tape, formed the evidentiary foundation, as Farrow methodically corroborated patterns of behavior through additional victim testimonies over subsequent months. The effort aligned with NBC's broader interest in investigative segments for programs like Today, though Farrow had independently nurtured contacts from earlier informal inquiries predating his formal NBC assignment on the story. Throughout the initial phase, Farrow emphasized verifiable evidence, including the tape's authentication via Gutierrez's cooperation and police records, while navigating Weinstein's representatives who denied wrongdoing and invoked nondisclosure agreements tied to prior settlements. By spring 2017, the investigation had expanded to include accounts from over a dozen women, spanning incidents from the 1990s to 2015, though executives later cited concerns over sourcing and legal risks in declining to air the piece.

Obstacles Including Corporate Resistance and Espionage

During Ronan Farrow's investigation into Harvey Weinstein's alleged sexual misconduct while employed at starting in 2016, he encountered substantial internal resistance from network executives. Farrow's producer, Rich McHugh, later described how president and chairman Andrew Lack repeatedly delayed the story's progress, demanding additional corroboration despite securing on-the-record accounts from multiple women, including audio recordings of Weinstein admitting to . McHugh characterized this as a "massive breach of journalistic integrity," asserting that executives bowed to external pressures rather than pursuing the reporting aggressively. maintained that it supported Farrow's work and never attempted to suppress the story, claiming he departed with his reporting materials intact in early 2017 to publish elsewhere. Farrow alleged that Weinstein exploited personal connections to influence NBC leadership, including leveraging compromising information about former Today show host Matt Lauer, whose 2017 dismissal for sexual misconduct occurred amid these tensions. This resistance culminated in Farrow's inability to air the segment on , prompting him to take the story to , where it was published on October 10, 2017, detailing assaults by Weinstein dating back to the 1990s. Critics of 's handling, including McHugh, pointed to a pattern of prioritizing access to power brokers over investigative rigor, though the network attributed delays to standard editorial standards for sensitive allegations. Concurrently, Weinstein engaged in aggressive countermeasures through hired intelligence firms, enlisting the Israeli in November 2016 to surveil potential accusers and journalists, including Farrow. operatives, many former agents, conducted operations targeting over 100 individuals, posing as supporters or researchers to extract information; for instance, they approached actress under false pretenses to undermine her credibility. Specific efforts against Farrow involved monitoring his movements and contacts in and , with operatives compiling dossiers on his reporting progress and personal life by early 2017. Weinstein paid approximately $900,000 for these services between 2016 and 2017, as revealed in subsequent lawsuits and investigations. These tactics extended to creating false narratives, such as planting stories suggesting Farrow's motives were tied to personal grievances, and even attempting to infiltrate his professional network. A whistleblower provided Farrow with internal documents confirming the firm's role in tracking his Weinstein probe, highlighting the operation's sophistication and international scope. Weinstein's team also coordinated with American Media Inc., publisher of the , to "" potentially damaging stories, though this intersected less directly with Farrow's NBC work. Such actions, while not illegal under U.S. law for private entities, raised ethical concerns about in , contributing to the story's suppression until its external publication.

Breakthrough Publication and Immediate Aftermath

On October 10, 2017, published Ronan Farrow's investigative article titled "From Aggressive Overtures to Sexual Assault: Harvey Weinstein's Accusers Tell Their Stories," which detailed allegations from thirteen women spanning the 1990s to 2015, including claims of , assault, and by three women, such as actress who alleged forcible in 1997. The piece marked a significant escalation following ' October 5 report on Weinstein's history of settlements with accusers, as Farrow's reporting secured on-the-record accounts from high-profile figures like and , who described unwanted advances and intimidation tactics. Weinstein issued a denial through a spokesperson, calling the allegations "categorically untrue" and framing his behavior as part of a " mentality" involving flirtatious but consensual interactions, while acknowledging past "mistakes" in professional relationships. The publication intensified scrutiny on Weinstein, who had already been placed on indefinite leave from on October 6 and formally fired by its board on October 8 amid the unfolding scandal. Within days, additional women, including luminaries such as and , publicly shared experiences of harassment, accelerating a cascade of accusations that dismantled Weinstein's career and prompted the resignation or distancing by board members and executives at his firm. The article's release catalyzed broader media coverage and public discourse on sexual misconduct in Hollywood, contributing to the rapid expansion of the #MeToo movement, with over 60 women eventually accusing Weinstein of abuse by late 2017. Farrow's follow-up piece on November 6 detailed Weinstein's use of private investigators to surveil accusers and journalists, further exposing suppression efforts and bolstering the exposé's credibility amid claims of industry complicity. Legal repercussions began swiftly, with investigations launched by authorities in New York and London, setting the stage for Weinstein's 2020 criminal conviction on sexual assault and rape charges in New York.

Publication and Content of the Book

Composition and Core Narrative Structure

Catch and Kill is a 464-page work authored by , published on October 15, 2019, by . The book draws directly from Farrow's contemporaneous notes, recordings, emails, and interviews conducted during his reporting, forming a firsthand investigative that expands on his October 2017 New Yorker article exposing Harvey Weinstein's pattern of . It consists of 59 short chapters grouped into five thematic parts, plus a and , employing a thriller-esque style with rapid scene shifts to heighten tension and mimic the elements uncovered in the story. The core narrative unfolds chronologically, tracing Farrow's investigation from its inception amid rumors of Weinstein's behavior in 2015 through to the story's publication and immediate fallout in 2017. The prologue introduces private investigators Igor Ostrovsky and Roman Khaykin, hired to surveil Farrow, setting a tone of conspiracy and foreshadowing the "" suppression tactics—where tabloids like the purchase exclusive stories to bury them via non-disclosure agreements. Part I, "Poison Valley" (chapters 1–13), details the early stages at , including Farrow's initial interviews with model Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, who recorded Weinstein admitting to groping her in 2015, and the first signs of corporate hesitation from executives like . Subsequent parts escalate the drama: Part II, "White Whale" (chapters 14–28), covers persistent victim sourcing, such as former Miramax assistant Zelda Perkins's account of nondisclosure agreements silencing complaints, amid growing internal NBC resistance. Part III, "Army of Spies" (chapters 29–41), pivots to overt obstruction, including the involvement of Israeli firm in discrediting sources and Farrow's decision to leave for The New Yorker after the network declined to air the piece. Part IV, "Sleeper," culminates in the October 10, 2017, publication, revealing 13 women's allegations against Weinstein. Part V, "Severance," addresses the aftermath, including Weinstein's arrest on May 25, 2018, and extensions to 's own scandals, such as anchor Matt Lauer's firing following similar misconduct claims. The epilogue reflects on Ostrovsky's post-investigation career shift, underscoring the persistence of such networks. This structure interweaves Farrow's reporting timeline with parallel threads on institutional complicity—such as American Media Inc.'s role in quashing stories for Weinstein—and personal context, including Farrow's strained relationship with , without derailing the investigative thrust. The concise chapters, often 2–5 pages, build suspense akin to a spy , prioritizing evidentiary detail over , though critics noted occasional dramatic flourishes in pacing. The result is a layered account emphasizing causal chains of suppression, from individual NDAs to media-wide incentives, supported by over 100 endnotes referencing legal documents, audio tapes, and witness statements.

Specific Allegations of Media Suppression and Collusion

In Catch and Kill, alleges that executives actively suppressed his multi-month investigation into Harvey Weinstein's , despite securing on-the-record interviews with multiple women, including actresses and , and audio recordings of Weinstein admitting to groping model Ambra Battilana Gutiérrez in 2015. Farrow claims that president dismissed the story's newsworthiness, reportedly stating, "For the Today show, a movie producer grabbing a lady is not news," while executives Andrew Lack and David Corvo cited unsubstantiated concerns over legal risks and corroboration, even as Farrow maintained the reporting met broadcast standards. These decisions, Farrow argues, reflected a broader institutional reluctance tied to 's own history of cover-ups, including Lack and Corvo facing prior misconduct allegations and settlements exceeding $1 million in one case. Farrow further contends that Weinstein exploited ties to NBC talent and leadership to derail the story, including ongoing communications with Lack, , and MSNBC president , as well as pitches for business deals to NBCUniversal vice chairman . Central to this, Farrow alleges Weinstein leveraged knowledge of misconduct by former Today show host —specifically, a 2014 incident where Lauer allegedly raped NBC staffer Brooke Nevils in his dressing room—to pressure the network, with Weinstein reportedly making it "known to the network that he was aware of Lauer’s behavior and capable of revealing it" via dirt sourced from American Media Inc. (AMI). Lauer, who was fired in November 2017 amid multiple complaints, had reportedly signed seven NDAs with payouts to accusers, a pattern Farrow links to NBC's hesitance on Weinstein to avoid reciprocal scrutiny. The book details AMI's role in a "" scheme with Weinstein, mirroring tactics used by AMI CEO for other high-profile figures, where the company acquired exclusive rights to damaging stories—such as those from potential accusers—and buried them without publication. Farrow alleges AMI , a close Weinstein associate, collaborated by secretly recording conversations with accusers like to discredit them and labeling Farrow himself as " fodder" in efforts to undermine his credibility. This included Howard's team maintaining a "kill file" of suppressed material and assisting Weinstein in pressuring through shared intelligence on internal vulnerabilities. Complementing these media entanglements, Farrow describes Weinstein's deployment of private intelligence firms, including , hired through his attorneys to surveil him, hack communications, and intimidate sources, with operatives posing as allies to extract information and sow doubt at . These efforts, Farrow claims, created a web of intimidation that extended to other outlets, though ultimately declined to air the piece in October 2017, prompting Farrow to publish in days before . has disputed these characterizations, asserting the story lacked sufficient evidence for broadcast and denying any external pressure influenced their editorial process.

Reception, Criticisms, and Controversies

Critical Acclaim and Awards

Catch and Kill received widespread critical praise upon its October 15, 2019, release, with reviewers highlighting its investigative depth, narrative tension, and revelations about media suppression tactics. The Los Angeles Times described it as a "spy story and media thriller" that exposed the "machinery of suppression" behind high-profile abuse allegations, commending Farrow's meticulous reporting on private intelligence operations targeting victims and journalists. Similarly, The Guardian called it an "extraordinary" account, praising Farrow's ability to weave personal peril with broader conspiracies involving figures like Harvey Weinstein and NBC executives. The book was selected as one of the best nonfiction works of 2019 by several outlets, including , , Time (as a must-read), and (as a favorite). These accolades emphasized its role in documenting the "" practices used by powerful entities to bury damaging stories, drawing on Farrow's original reporting that had previously earned a shared for Public Service—though the book itself built on rather than replicated that journalism. In literary awards, was a finalist for the 2019 in the category, announced on January 12, 2020, recognizing its blend of and exposé. The version, narrated by Farrow, earned a nomination for Best Spoken Word Album at the in 2021, underscoring its accessibility and dramatic delivery. No major literary prizes were won outright, but the recognition affirmed its impact on discussions of journalistic integrity amid institutional pressures.

Accusations of Factual Inaccuracies and Bias

executives, including president , disputed Farrow's portrayal of the network as suppressing his Weinstein investigation, asserting in an internal memo that the story was not broadcast-ready due to insufficient corroboration of victim accounts and that Farrow departed voluntarily after editorial disagreements. characterized the book's narrative as relying on "distortions, confused timelines, and outright inaccuracies," noting that aired multiple Weinstein-related reports shortly after Farrow's exit, contradicting claims of systemic obstruction. Critics highlighted specific discrepancies in Farrow's account of an alleged 2014 assault by on producer Brooke Nevils during the Olympics, where the book described non-consensual anal in a hotel room, followed by Nevils confiding in witnesses about the trauma. Lauer denied , describing the encounter as consensual "rough sex" initiated by Nevils, and claimed she never reported it as to NBC leadership, with two female bosses confirming to him that she referenced only an affair. A key witness cited by Farrow—Nevils' then-boyfriend, portrayed as receiving her in distress—denied recollection of , while Lauer accused Farrow of failing to contact him for verification despite promises of rigor. New York Times media columnist Ben Smith questioned Farrow's overall journalistic process, suggesting that his celebrity status as a #MeToo pioneer may have insulated the from scrutiny, particularly on the Lauer , where uncorroborated details proliferated amid power imbalances at . Lauer further alleged anti- bias in Farrow's reporting, claiming the author anticipated minimal given his reputation and personal grievances over the Weinstein story's handling. Analyses from outlets like Quillette described Farrow's narrative as constructing expansive conspiracies from sparse, unverified elements, including uncontacted witnesses and overstated connections between Weinstein's tactics and NBC's decisions, potentially amplifying bias toward portraying media institutions as complicit en masse. Farrow rebutted these as erroneous, insisting the book underwent exhaustive fact-checking, including with Lauer, though critics maintained that reliance on anonymous sources and selective emphasis undermined credibility on disputed events. Following the October 15, 2019, publication of , American Media Inc. executive , associated with the National Enquirer's "" practices, issued legal threats to block its distribution in , alleging related to his role in suppressing stories about . Despite these efforts, the book proceeded to sale there without court intervention halting it. Howard had previously sought an in U.S. courts to prevent the book's release entirely, claiming inaccuracies in Farrow's depiction of his involvement in Weinstein's suppression tactics, though no broad injunction was granted. NBCUniversal executives mounted a series of public and internal rebuttals denying Farrow's central allegation that the network obstructed his Weinstein investigation due to concerns over protecting anchor Matt Lauer from reciprocal scrutiny. NBC News president Noah Oppenheim distributed a six-page internal memo on October 14, 2019, labeling the book "a smear" and fact-checking claims point-by-point, asserting that Farrow's reporting lacked sufficient on-the-record corroboration from victims at the time NBC declined to air it. Oppenheim emphasized that NBC encouraged Farrow to complete the story but found it incomplete, with only one anonymous source willing to go on record, contrasting Farrow's narrative of active interference by executives like Andrew Lack. Former NBC anchor Matt Lauer issued an open letter on October 9, 2019, vehemently denying a specific rape allegation detailed in the book, attributed to NBC staffer Brooke Nevils, whom Lauer described as a consensual encounter distorted by post-termination motives; he accused Farrow of relying on unverified claims amid NBC's prior $7 million-plus settlement with Nevils under nondisclosure terms. NBC corroborated Lauer's denial of prior formal complaints against him before his 2017 firing, while acknowledging the network's handling of Lauer drew internal criticism but rejecting Farrow's portrayal of a broader cover-up culture. No major lawsuits against Farrow or the publisher succeeded in the years following publication, though Weinstein's legal team continued aggressive countersuits in his ongoing criminal proceedings, indirectly challenging aspects of Farrow's reporting by disputing victim credibility without targeting the book directly. Institutional responses from media outlets like focused on defending editorial decisions amid accusations of bias, with critics noting the network's rebuttals aligned with self-preservation rather than independent verification, as Farrow's subsequent New Yorker piece on October 10, 2017, secured multiple on-record accounts shortly after leaving .

Adaptations and Lasting Impact

Podcast Adaptation and Multimedia Extensions

The book was adapted into a nine-episode podcast series titled The Catch and Kill Podcast with Ronan Farrow, which premiered on , 2019, shortly after the book's publication. Produced by Pineapple Street Studios in collaboration with Farrow, the series features audio from interviews conducted during his investigation into Weinstein's allegations, including accounts from , sources, and figures involved in suppression efforts. It expands on the book's themes of media interference and , presenting unedited conversations to illustrate the challenges faced by journalists pursuing such stories. In July 2021, HBO released Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes, a six-part docuseries directed by Randy Barbato and Fenton Bailey, which repurposes the 's core episodes into visual format with added archival footage, reenactments, and never-before-seen materials from Farrow's reporting process. Each half-hour episode follows the progression of Farrow's Weinstein probe, highlighting tactics like private intelligence operations and corporate pressure, while maintaining the 's emphasis on firsthand testimonies. The series received an 88% approval rating from critics on , praised for its raw depiction of investigative hurdles but critiqued by some for limited new revelations beyond the audio origins. An audiobook version of , narrated by Farrow himself, was released concurrently with the print edition on October 15, 2019, via Audible, providing an audio extension that incorporates dramatic readings of key excerpts and investigative details. This format, spanning approximately 13 hours, has been noted for its immersive quality, allowing listeners to hear Farrow's delivery of complex narratives involving over 100 interviews referenced in the book. These adaptations collectively broadened the book's reach, with the garnering millions of downloads and the series streaming on platforms like Max, though they faced scrutiny from outlets like for portrayals of internal editorial decisions during Farrow's original reporting.

Effects on Journalism Practices and Public Accountability

The revelations in illuminated the "" strategy—wherein media outlets purchase exclusive rights to damaging stories solely to prevent their publication—prompting widespread condemnation within journalistic circles as a violation of core ethical standards that prioritize over private suppression. This tactic, previously a shadowy among tabloids like the , was detailed through American Media Inc.'s (AMI) admitted use of it to shield figures like , leading to AMI's 2018 non-prosecution agreement with federal prosecutors, which required cooperation in related investigations but highlighted how such deals enabled ongoing ethical lapses until public exposure forced . The book's documentation of these methods contributed to heightened legal scrutiny, as evidenced by their central role in the 2024 New York hush-money , where AMI executive testified about employing catch-and-kill to influence the 2016 election, thereby elevating the practice from industry anecdote to a prosecutable scheme undermining democratic discourse. Farrow's account of ' refusal to air his Weinstein investigation despite internal corroboration—citing concerns over legal risks and executive ties—intensified debates on editorial gatekeeping and institutional conflicts of interest, eroding public confidence in broadcast journalism's impartiality. Post-publication, this spurred internal NBC reviews and executive departures, including those of and Andy Lack by 2020, amid accusations that fear of litigation and access journalism stifled reporting on powerful abusers. Such disclosures fostered calls for structural reforms, including stricter internal guidelines on story suppression and greater transparency in decision-making processes, as articulated in ethics discussions by organizations like the , which emphasize that newsrooms must not subordinate truth-seeking to commercial or relational pressures. On public accountability, the book underscored how intertwined media-power dynamics enable narrative control, prompting a reevaluation of reliance on anonymous sources in abuse reporting while highlighting the need for robust protections against private intelligence operations targeting journalists, as Farrow experienced via operatives hired by Weinstein. This has led to practical shifts, such as increased adoption of tools among investigative reporters and advocacy for legal safeguards against SLAPP suits, though empirical data on widespread policy adoption remains limited. Ultimately, Catch and Kill reinforced the #MeToo era's demand for outlets to prioritize victim testimonies over elite access, contributing to a cultural pivot where suppression tactics face preemptive journalistic skepticism, albeit with persistent challenges from resource-strapped newsrooms wary of retaliation.

References

  1. [1]
    Catch and Kill by Ronan Farrow | Hachette Book Group
    In stock Free delivery over $35"Catch and Kill is exhaustively reported...and compulsively readable, with nearly every page revealing a provocative detail about a household name in media or ...
  2. [2]
    Review: Ronan Farrow's 'Catch and Kill' reveals a spy story and ...
    Oct 16, 2019 · Catch and Kill,” released Tuesday, is equal parts memoir, spy story and portrait of perseverance under terrible circumstances.
  3. [3]
    Catch and Kill: Lies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to Protect Predators
    Publication date. October 15, 2019. Dimensions. 6.38 x 1.38 x 9.5 inches ... "Catch and Killis an important, frightening book...it's also a propulsive ...
  4. [4]
    In 'Catch And Kill,' Ronan Farrow Offers A Damning Portrait Of ... - NPR
    Oct 11, 2019 · The book ties the killing of his story on Harvey Weinstein's alleged sexual misconduct to a pattern of harassment and abuse within NBC ...Missing: awards | Show results with:awards
  5. [5]
    Ronan Farrow: 'Catch And Kill' Tactics Protected Both Weinstein And ...
    Oct 15, 2019 · Ronan Farrow's 2017 exposé of the sexual misconduct allegations against film producer Harvey Weinstein in The New Yorker earned him a Pulitzer ...
  6. [6]
    What We Know About Ronan Farrow's New Book 'Catch and Kill'
    Oct 3, 2019 · The title of Ronan Farrow's upcoming #MeToo exposé, Catch and Kill: Lies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to Protect Predators, is a reference to ...
  7. [7]
    Ronan Farrow under fire: What to know about his media war
    May 20, 2020 · Ronan Farrow's 'Catch and Kill' book is attacked by NBC News. NBC denies Farrow allegations that it paid off employees who said they were ...
  8. [8]
    Catch and Kill Journalism: Definition, Examples and More
    “Catch and kill journalism” describes the general act of obtaining information not for the purpose of reporting it publicly but to do the opposite.
  9. [9]
    How Tabloids Used 'Catch-and-Kill' to Trade on Secrets of Celebrities
    Apr 25, 2024 · “Catch-and-kill” is a term coined by old-time tabloid editors for buying the exclusive rights to stories, or “catching” them.
  10. [10]
    'Catch and kill' explained: Inside the practice of burying negative ...
    Aug 24, 2018 · This practice is typically done as a favor to prominent people who wants to bury negative news and it's frequently used in tabloid publications.
  11. [11]
    Catch and Kill: Does the First Amendment Protect Buying Speech To ...
    This practice, commonly called “catch and kill,” has recently come under close scrutiny and raises a host of questions.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  12. [12]
    National Enquirer owner admits to 'catch and kill' payment to ex ...
    Dec 12, 2018 · AMI told prosecutors it worked with Trump's campaign to pay for and suppress story of a sexual affair to 'prevent it from influencing' US ...Missing: tactic explained
  13. [13]
    A Brief History of Catch and Kill - Rolling Stone
    Feb 8, 2019 · More simplistically, “catch and kill” often involves procuring the exclusive rights to damaging stories that would harm their allies' interests, ...Missing: precedents notable journalism
  14. [14]
    History of Enquirer's 'catch and kill': Tiger, LeBlanc, more
    Apr 7, 2023 · But the practice of buying and burying a story as a favor has long been a tabloid technique, former National Enquirer employees told The Post.
  15. [15]
  16. [16]
  17. [17]
  18. [18]
    Trump trial highlights: David Pecker testifies on 'catch-and-kill' scheme
    Apr 23, 2024 · Pecker testified that he met Trump in the 1980s at Mar-a-Lago while there as a guest of a client. Prosecutors then asked Pecker to point to ...
  19. [19]
    'Catch and kill,' Trump's trial, journalism ethics and the First ...
    May 14, 2024 · The 2024 trial of former president Donald J. Trump for filing false statements about hush-money payments that were made on his behalf.
  20. [20]
    How Ronan Farrow's reporting on Weinstein led to the criminal case ...
    Jun 6, 2024 · Farrow was also one of several reporters who unearthed details of the so called catch and kill program in which owners of the National Inquirer ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  21. [21]
    National Enquirer: parent company considers selling US tabloid
    Apr 11, 2019 · ... media reports that the tabloid engaged in a practice called “catch and kill” to protect Donald Trump, in which it would pay for potentially ...
  22. [22]
    Ronan Farrow - | Knight First Amendment Institute
    Prior to his career in journalism, he served as a State Department official in Afghanistan and Pakistan. He lives in New York. Ronan Farrow. Sign up for news ...Missing: early | Show results with:early
  23. [23]
    Ronan Farrow, the Hollywood Prince Who Torched the Castle
    Jan 10, 2018 · His older sister, Dylan Farrow, now 32, accused their father, Woody Allen, of molesting her when she was 7. “You see early in life with that ...
  24. [24]
    My Father, Woody Allen, and the Danger of Questions Unasked ...
    May 11, 2016 · Farrow's investigative reporting series, “Undercovered With Ronan Farrow,” airs on NBC's 'Today.' A version of this story first appeared in the ...
  25. [25]
    Farrow Family Stands by Denunciation of Woody Allen Following ...
    Mar 25, 2020 · A representative for Mia Farrow and Ronan Farrow says the family has no comment on Apropos of Nothing, Woody Allen's new autobiography, but that ...
  26. [26]
    Woody Allen, Mia Farrow, Soon-Yi Previn, Dylan Farrow: A Timeline
    Feb 22, 2021 · Allen abused her that day, touching her genitalia. She was 7 at the time. She detailed her accusation in January 2018 on “CBS This Morning”:.
  27. [27]
    Ronan Farrow and NBC's Clash Over Weinstein Investigation
    Oct 9, 2019 · In 2017, Farrow was investigating sexual abuse allegations against Weinstein for NBC News, but the network ultimately declined to publish his ...
  28. [28]
    From Aggressive Overtures to Sexual Assault: Harvey Weinstein's ...
    Oct 10, 2017 · Ronan Farrow reports the stories of thirteen women who say that, between the nineteen-nineties and 2015, Harvey Weinstein sexually harassed ...
  29. [29]
    Ronan Farrow's Ex-Producer Says NBC Impeded Weinstein Reporting
    Aug 30, 2018 · Farrow gained access to a recording of a New York Police Department sting operation in which Mr. Weinstein admitted to groping the model Ambra ...<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    Harvey Weinstein Caught on Tape Admitting to Groping
    Oct 10, 2017 · The bombshell New Yorker report, written by Ronan Farrow, details how Gutierrez, once a Miss Italy finalist, met Weinstein in March of 2015 at a ...
  31. [31]
    NBC passed on a bombshell Harvey Weinstein sexual harassment ...
    What we know for sure now, is that in January when Ronan started to report on the Weinstein matter, he had a sit down interview with the actress Rose McGowan ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  32. [32]
  33. [33]
    Ronan Farrow on investigating Harvey Weinstein - The Guardian
    Oct 12, 2019 · He is due to stand trial on multiple charges of predatory sexual assault and rape in January. You don't, Farrow says, have to believe in vast ...
  34. [34]
    NBC News says Ronan Farrow's draft story on Harvey Weinstein for ...
    Sep 4, 2018 · NBC News says Ronan Farrow's draft story on Harvey Weinstein for the network contained misstatements. A 10-page internal report says Farrow's ...
  35. [35]
    Ronan Farrow Weinstein Story Was Killed By "Very Highest Levels ...
    Aug 30, 2018 · “The assertion that NBC News tried to kill the Weinstein story while Ronan Farrow was at NBC News, or even more ludicrously, after he left NBC ...Missing: obstacles | Show results with:obstacles
  36. [36]
    Ronan Farrow talks surveillance, countersurveillance and the stories ...
    Oct 23, 2019 · In “Catch and Kill,” Farrow alleges Weinstein pressured NBC executives to quash reporting by leveraging dirt on former “Today” show co-host Matt ...Missing: resistance | Show results with:resistance
  37. [37]
    NBC News vs. Ronan Farrow on the Harvey Weinstein story ... - Vox
    Sep 4, 2018 · He said NBC had been “resistant” throughout Farrow's months-long reporting process and had, in effect, been responsible for “killing the Harvey ...
  38. [38]
    Harvey Weinstein's Army of Spies | The New Yorker
    Nov 6, 2017 · Ronan Farrow reports on how Harvey Weinstein, facing allegations of sexual assault and harassment, hired private investigators to track ...
  39. [39]
    The Black Cube Chronicles, Part I: The Private Investigators
    Oct 7, 2019 · Ronan Farrow discusses the process of investigating sexual-assault allegations. The Prime Minister Who Tried to Have a Life Outside the ...
  40. [40]
    Ronan Farrow Details How Black Cube Spies Tracked His Weinstein
    Oct 7, 2019 · The journalist details how Black Cube spies closely monitored him as he was working on his bombshell reports about sexual misconduct allegations against Harvey ...Missing: espionage | Show results with:espionage
  41. [41]
    Ronan Farrow Details How Spies Tracked His Weinstein ... - Variety
    Oct 7, 2019 · Ronan Farrow Details How Spies Tracked His Weinstein Investigation in 'Catch and Kill' Excerpt · Variety Confidential.
  42. [42]
    Ronan Farrow on His Black Cube Whistleblower
    Oct 9, 2019 · Writes Farrow: “I had obtained a list of marks suggesting that the spy agency's operatives had approached the actress Rose McGowan, the writer ...Missing: espionage | Show results with:espionage
  43. [43]
    Ronan Farrow on how the Harvey Weinstein scandal broke open
    Nov 29, 2017 · He's the reporter who's helped bring to light some of the charges of sexual harassment and abuse we seem to be hearing about in ever-increasing numbers.
  44. [44]
    Harvey Weinstein's Last Campaign | The New Yorker
    May 30, 2022 · Five days later, Ronan Farrow published the first in a series of reported pieces about Weinstein in this magazine. Thirteen women, including ...
  45. [45]
    The Impact of the Me Too Movement's Journalism
    May 15, 2021 · ... Ronan Farrow was critical in exposing Harvey Weinstein's sexual violence. Their October 2017 articles in The New York Times and The New Yorker ...
  46. [46]
    The Reporting That Led to Harvey Weinstein's Trial and Conviction
    Feb 24, 2020 · Multiple women share harrowing accounts of sexual assault and harassment by the film executive. “The Weinstein Trial and the Myth of the Perfect ...
  47. [47]
    Catch and Kill: Key Ideas & Summary - The Bibliofile
    The Key Ideas and Section-by-Section Summary for Catch and Kill by Ronan Farrow are below. Table of Contents Key Ideas & Takeaways Section-by-Section Summary ...
  48. [48]
    Catch and Kill by Ronan Farrow review – how the great white ...
    Oct 20, 2019 · Ronan Farrow's masterful account of a conspiracy of abusers reaching from Harvey Weinstein to the top of the US media.
  49. [49]
    Ronan Farrow Book: How Harvey Weinstein May Have Leveraged ...
    Oct 9, 2019 · Catch and Kill shows just how deep Weinstein's connections ran within NBC and reveals his aggressive effort to court additional executives. As ...
  50. [50]
    A wave of new books reveals the obstacles #MeToo had to overcome
    Oct 21, 2019 · Ronan Farrow has spent the past couple weeks battling with NBC over claims in his new book, “Catch and Kill,” that executives at the network ...
  51. [51]
  52. [52]
    Ronan Farrow nominated for National Book Critics Circle award
    Jan 13, 2020 · Ronan Farrow is a finalist for the National Book Critic Circle's annual awards for his “Catch and Kill: Lies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to ...
  53. [53]
    Ronan Farrow earns Grammy nomination for "Catch and Kill ...
    Nov 24, 2020 · Ronan Farrow's “Catch and Kill” audiobook, in which details how he broke the Harvey Weinstein story, earned a Grammy nomination for best spoken ...
  54. [54]
    NBC News President Hits Back at Ronan Farrow's Book in Staff Memo
    Oct 14, 2019 · NBC News president Noah Oppenheim pushed back against the explosive claims made in Ronan Farrow's book 'Catch and Kill' in a lengthy fact- ...
  55. [55]
    NBC News president sharply rejects Ronan Farrow's claims that ...
    Oct 14, 2019 · The allegations against NBC News' leadership are detailed in Farrow's upcoming book "Catch and Kill," in which he reveals the depths of his ...
  56. [56]
    Ronan Farrow's Botched Journalism is Troubling. The Response to ...
    May 25, 2020 · Catch and Kill related a stunning tale, in which then-news anchor Matt Lauer was said to have assaulted a junior employee named Brooke Nevils, ...
  57. [57]
    Matt Lauer responds to rape allegations in Ronan Farrow's book
    May 20, 2020 · Lauer attempts to discredit Farrow's book, "Catch and Kill," which made public a former colleague's rape allegation against Lauer.
  58. [58]
    Matt Lauer slams Ronan Farrow, calls reporting inaccurate
    “All I'll say on this is that Matt Lauer is just wrong,” Farrow wrote. “Catch and Kill was thoroughly reported and fact-checked, including with Matt Lauer ...
  59. [59]
    Ronan Farrow book on sale in Australia despite legal threat from ...
    Oct 15, 2019 · Ronan Farrow book on sale in Australia despite legal threat from journalist Dylan Howard ... The book, Catch and Kill, was released in Australia ...
  60. [60]
    Farrow books sells across Australia despite legal threat - KATV
    Oct 17, 2019 · "Catch and Kill" covers events leading to Farrow's New Yorker magazine expose of Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein's alleged sexual misconduct ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
  61. [61]
    NBC News chief calls Ronan Farrow's book 'a smear' in lengthy new ...
    whom Farrow paints as obstructionist and dishonest in “Catch and Kill” — called the book “a smear.” In response, Farrow's ...
  62. [62]
    NBC Releases Six-Page Response to Ronan Farrow's Reporting ...
    Oct 14, 2019 · Oppenheim listed out point-by-point responses to many of Farrow's claims in Catch and Kill. One of those rebuttals is Oppenheim denying Farrow's ...
  63. [63]
    Matt Lauer Pens Open Letter Over Ronan Farrow 'Catch and Kill' Book
    Oct 9, 2019 · The former NBC personality's letter, in particular, responds at length to a rape claim made by former NBC News employee Brooke Nevils, who told ...<|separator|>
  64. [64]
    Ronan Farrow's book says NBC reached nondisclosure agreements ...
    Oct 11, 2019 · The claims appear to contradict statements by the network, but NBC says no "hush money" was paid and no prior complaints about Matt Lauer ...Missing: rebuttal | Show results with:rebuttal
  65. [65]
    NBC News Executives Under Siege After Release Of 'Catch And Kill'
    Oct 16, 2019 · The president of NBC News sent a rebuttal to Ronan Farrow over the network's handling of Matt Lauer and the failure to broadcast reporting on Harvey Weinstein.
  66. [66]
    Ronan Farrow, NBC News Fight Over Accusations in 'Catch and Kill'
    Oct 9, 2019 · NBC has been bracing for the Oct. 15 publication of Farrow's book and has mounted a vigorous rebuttal to some of his assertions. Oppenheim ...
  67. [67]
  68. [68]
    The Catch and Kill Podcast with Ronan Farrow - iHeart
    Coming Tuesday, November 26th, The Catch and Kill Podcast with Ronan Farrow. A look at the years-long investigation into Harvey Weinstein and the systems that ...
  69. [69]
    Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes review – the harrowing fight to ...
    Nov 4, 2021 · Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes review – the harrowing fight to bring down Harvey Weinstein. This article is more than 3 years old. Ronan ...
  70. [70]
    The Catch and Kill Podcast with Ronan Farrow - Spotify
    A look at the years-long investigation into Harvey Weinstein and the systems that protect powerful men in Hollywood, Washington, and beyond.
  71. [71]
    'Catch And Kill: The Podcast Tapes' HBO Review: Stream It Or Skip It?
    Jul 12, 2021 · Catch And Kill: The Podcast Tapes takes the episodes of Ronan Farrow's 2019-20 podcast Catch And Kill, about how he broke the sexual assault ...
  72. [72]
    'Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes' Filmmakers Show Never-Before ...
    Jul 12, 2021 · In “Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes,” six half-hour episodes follow Farrow as he works to report on Harvey Weinstein's predatory behavior.
  73. [73]
    Watch Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes | HBO Max
    Watch Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes on HBO Max. Plans start at $10.99/month. A six-part docuseries based on Ronan Farrow's book.
  74. [74]
    Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes | Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 88% (17) Discover reviews, ratings, and trailers for Catch and Kill: The Podcast Tapes on Rotten Tomatoes. Stay updated with critic and audience scores today!
  75. [75]
    Catch and Kill: Lies, Spies, and a Conspiracy to Protect Predators ...
    30-day returnsRonan Farrow exposes serial abusers and a cabal of powerful interests hell-bent on covering up the truth, at any cost—from Hollywood to Washington and beyond ...
  76. [76]
    Ronan Farrow to Launch Podcast As Part of Audible Multi-Project Deal
    Jan 8, 2025 · Farrow was previously the host of The Catch and Kill podcast, based on his book which followed the sexual assault claims against notable ...
  77. [77]
    The Catch and Kill Podcast with Ronan Farrow - Podnews
    Rating 4.8 (13,078) Sep 1, 2025 · Listen to the society & culture audio show The Catch and Kill Podcast with Ronan Farrow from Pineapple Street Studios and Audacy in Apple ...
  78. [78]
    Ronan Farrow's Catch and Kill Reveals System of Intimidation | TIME
    Oct 18, 2019 · Ronan Farrow's new book reveals the larger network of weapons used to silence, intimidate and shame victims of sexual misconduct.
  79. [79]
    'Catch and kill' scheme takes centre stage at Trump hush-money trial
    Apr 23, 2024 · A day after opening statements, prosecutors questions tabloid publisher over alleged effort to stifle bad press.<|control11|><|separator|>
  80. [80]
    Is Ronan Farrow Too Good to Be True? - The New York Times
    May 20, 2020 · In his 2019 book, “Catch and Kill,” Mr. Farrow dismisses the incident as an issue with a “peripheral witness” and attacks Mr. Weinstein's lawyer ...