Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Chelev

Chelev (Hebrew: חֵלֶב, ḥēleḇ), often translated as "suet," denotes the specific portions of animal fat that are forbidden for consumption under Jewish law as outlined in the Torah (Leviticus 7:23-25).^[1] These fats are primarily the visible, internal fats surrounding the organs of domestic kosher animals such as cattle, sheep, and goats, including those around the kidneys, stomach, and loins, which were designated for sacrificial offering on the altar in ancient Temple rituals.^[2] The prohibition against eating chelev is one of the 613 commandments (mitzvot) in Judaism, classified as a negative precept that applies even to non-sacrificial animals, distinguishing it from permissible fats known as shuman. This dietary restriction underscores broader themes in kashrut (Jewish dietary laws) emphasizing ritual purity and separation from blood, with chelev removed through the nikkur process following kosher slaughter (shechita).^[3] In contemporary observance, identifying and excising chelev requires expertise, often handled by trained kosher supervisors (mashgichim), ensuring compliance across Jewish communities worldwide.^[3]

Definition and Terminology

Biblical Definition

In the Hebrew Bible, chelev (חֵלֶב) is defined as a specific category of animal fat prohibited for consumption by the Israelites, referring to the fat derived from the internal organs of cattle, sheep, and goats. This prohibition is explicitly stated in Leviticus 7:23–25, where God commands Moses: "Speak to the children of Israel, saying: You shall not eat any fat of ox, or of sheep, or of goat... And if any person eats of the fat of beast, of which men offer an offering made by fire unto the LORD, even the soul that eateth it shall be cut off from his people." The term chelev here denotes not all animal fat but particularly the "fat of the offering" (chelev hazevach), which was reserved for burning on the altar as part of sacrificial rites. The precise scope of chelev is detailed in the descriptions of peace offerings in Leviticus 3, encompassing the fat that covers the entrails, all the fat surrounding the entrails, the fat upon the kidneys at the loins, and the lobe of the liver that is to be removed with the kidneys. These fats were to be offered by fire to the Lord from animals suitable for sacrifice in the Tabernacle or Temple, underscoring their sacred role in the cultic system. The restriction applies exclusively to the fats of these domesticated herd animals—ox (cattle), sheep, and goats—used in offerings, and does not extend to fats from wild animals or birds. This biblical injunction against consuming chelev constitutes one of the 613 mitzvot (commandments) outlined in the Torah, emphasizing ritual purity and separation in Israelite worship.^[4] The penalty for violation—being cut off from the people—highlights its gravity within the covenantal framework, linking dietary laws to the broader sacrificial context of atonement and communion with God.

Hebrew Etymology and Distinction from Shuman

The Hebrew term chelev (חֵלֶב), denoting a specific type of animal fat, derives from the Proto-Semitic root ḥalīb-, which broadly signifies fat or grease, potentially originating from an ancient connotation of the "fat of the midriff" or vital essence in Semitic languages such as Phoenician and Syriac.^[5] This root implies richness or abundance, extending to metaphorical uses for the "choicest" or "best" portion, reflecting an underlying sense of purity and essential vitality in biblical Hebrew.^[6] The word's form suggests an unused verbal root meaning "to be fat," emphasizing its association with premium or life-sustaining fats rather than ordinary substances.^[6] In contrast, chelev is linguistically and halakhically distinguished from shuman (שׁוּמַן), the latter term referring to permissible, everyday animal fats that are typically rendered or integrated with meat for general consumption.^[2] While chelev designates the sacred, prohibited suet—often the distinct, membranous fat surrounding vital organs, reserved exclusively for divine offerings—shuman encompasses softer, edible fats not subject to such restrictions, as implied in scriptural commands like Leviticus 3:17.^[7] This differentiation is rooted in biblical Hebrew's precise terminology, where chelev carries a connotation of holiness and separation, whereas shuman, emerging more prominently in post-biblical Aramaic-influenced contexts and related to shemen (שֶׁמֶן, oil), denotes utilitarian fat suitable for human use.^[5] The Hebrew language maintains this non-interchangeable usage, preventing conflation between the two in sacrificial and dietary laws.^[8] Beyond sacrificial contexts, chelev appears in biblical Hebrew with historical linguistic flexibility, often employed metaphorically to evoke prosperity, fertility, or the finest quality of non-animal elements, such as the "fat" or richest yield of crops and offerings.^[7] For instance, it symbolizes abundance in descriptions of land or produce, underscoring its broader semantic range for essence and excellence in ancient texts, independent of ritual fat prohibitions.^[6] This figurative application highlights chelev's evolution from a concrete term for vital animal tissue to a symbol of divine favor and material wealth in prophetic and poetic literature.^[7]

Biblical Context

References in the Torah

The term chelev appears extensively in the Torah, primarily in the Book of Leviticus, where it denotes specific portions of animal fat designated for sacrificial use, often burned on the altar as an offering to God. These references occur within the framework of ritual instructions for various types of offerings, emphasizing chelev as a sacred component reserved exclusively for divine consumption rather than human eating. In the context of peace offerings (shelamim), chelev is consistently described as the fat covering the entrails, all fat adhering to the entrails, the two kidneys with their fat, and the fat on the loins, which the priest must remove and burn upon the altar.^[9] For instance, Leviticus 3:3–4 outlines this requirement for a general peace offering from cattle, stating that the offerer shall present "the fat that covers the entrails and all the fat that is on the entrails" as a fire offering to the Lord.^[9] Similarly, Leviticus 3:9–10 specifies adaptations for sheep, including "the whole broad tail" alongside the entrails fat, while Leviticus 3:14–15 applies the same to goats, reinforcing the uniformity across species in these communal or votive sacrifices.^[10]^[11] In sin offerings (chatat), chelev plays a parallel role, symbolizing atonement through its combustion. Leviticus 4:8–9 details the removal of "the fat that covers the entrails, and all the fat that is on the entrails, and the two kidneys with the fat that is on them, which is by the loins" from the bull of the sin offering, to be burned on the altar. Leviticus 7:3–4 extends this to peace offerings that include sin elements, commanding the priest to offer "all the fat of the entrails" along with the kidneys and loin fat as a pleasing aroma.^[12] These instructions underscore chelev's integral part in purifying the sanctuary and the offerer from inadvertent transgressions. Narrative accounts in Leviticus illustrate chelev's application during priestly inaugurations and ongoing rituals. In Leviticus 8:16, during the consecration of Aaron and his sons, Moses takes "all the fat that was on the entrails" of the sin offering bull and burns it on the altar as commanded. Leviticus 8:25–26 further describes handling the ram of ordination, where the fat of the tail, all fat on the innards, the fat above the liver, and the two kidneys with their fat are placed atop the breasts and waved before the Lord as part of the priests' installation. On the eighth day of service, Leviticus 9:10 records Aaron burning "the fat and the kidneys and the lobe above the liver" from the sin offering on the altar, while Leviticus 9:19–20 notes his sons presenting the fat portions—including the tail, layer of fat, kidneys, and liver lobe—from the ox and ram of the peace offering, which Aaron then burns atop the altar.^[13] These episodes highlight chelev's role in formalizing the priesthood's duties. Beyond Leviticus, chelev appears in Numbers in relation to firstborn animals. Numbers 18:17 instructs that the firstborn of an ox, sheep, or goat, being holy, shall have their blood sprinkled on the altar and "their fat" burned as a fire offering for a pleasing aroma to the Lord, without redemption.^[14] Leviticus 7:23–25 provides the sole direct dietary reference in the Torah, commanding the Israelites not to eat the chelev of ox, sheep, or goat, as it belongs to the Lord's offerings, though the focus remains on its sacrificial exclusivity.^[15] Across these verses, chelev consistently signifies the premium, internal fats elevated in worship, distinguishing sacrificial practice from everyday consumption.

Prohibitions and Punishments

The Torah prohibits the consumption of chelev from oxen, sheep, or goats, as stated in Leviticus 7:23: "Speak to the children of Israel, saying: You shall eat no fat, of ox, or of sheep, or of goat." This dietary law carries severe consequences, with Leviticus 7:25 specifying that "whoever eats the fat of the beast, of which an offering made by fire is offered to the Lord, even the soul that eats it shall be cut off from his people," imposing the punishment of kareth, a divine spiritual excision from the community and potentially premature death.^[16]^[17] For unintentional violations of this prohibition, the Torah requires the offender to offer a sin offering (korban hatat) as atonement.^[16] The prohibition is designated as an eternal decree in Leviticus 3:17: "It shall be a perpetual statute throughout your generations in all your dwellings, that you shall eat neither fat nor blood." Following the destruction of the Second Temple, when sacrificial offerings ceased, rabbinic authorities upheld the ban on chelev by extending its application to the specific chelev portions from all kosher land animals, while preserving the distinction from permissible shuman fats, ensuring its ongoing observance in Jewish law.^[16]

Rabbinical Exegesis

Identification and Types of Chelev

In rabbinical exegesis, chelev is classified as specific visceral fats that are prohibited for consumption, distinct from shuman, which encompasses ordinary or subcutaneous fats integrated with the meat. The Talmud in tractate Chullin addresses biblical ambiguities by delineating chelev through anatomical precision, drawing on descriptions in Leviticus to identify fats offered in sacrifices as inherently forbidden even in non-sacrificial animals. These discussions emphasize that chelev consists of exposed or distinct fat layers surrounding vital organs, resolving interpretive challenges by excluding fats covered by flesh or those not explicitly sacrificial.^[18] The primary type is the kidney fats, termed chelev hakloyot, which encompass the fats surrounding the loins and kidneys as outlined in Leviticus 3:4. These include the upper fats enveloping the kidneys and extending along the loins, explicitly prohibited and punishable by karet if consumed, while lower kidney fats covered by flesh are permitted. Rabbinical analysis in Chullin specifies that only the exposed portions qualify as chelev, ensuring precise identification during preparation.^[18] Abdominal fats constitute another category, comprising the sheet of fat that covers the intestines and adjacent abdominal structures. This type, referenced in Leviticus 3:3, is forbidden as it forms a distinct layer over the innards, separate from intramuscular fats. The Talmud clarifies that such fats must be removed entirely, as their exposed nature aligns them with sacrificial prohibitions.^[18] Mesenteric fats, also known as omental fats, surround the stomach and digestive organs, including the omasum, reticulum, and small intestine. In Chullin, Shmuel rules that fats on the omasum and reticulum are strictly prohibited, requiring scraping on the top cubit of the small intestine to remove chelev remnants. These are distinguished from permitted fats by their position adhering to digestive membranes, directly tying to Leviticus 3:3–4's emphasis on fats upon the entrails.^[18] Tail fat in fat-tailed sheep, such as those common in the ancient Near East, is not classified as chelev and remains permitted, as indicated in Leviticus 3:9 where it is included in offerings but not grouped with forbidden visceral types. The Talmud upholds this distinction, treating tail fat as shuman rather than sacrificial chelev.^[18]

Nikkur Process

The nikkur process refers to the meticulous surgical deboning and removal of forbidden fats, known as chelev, from slaughtered land animals in accordance with rabbinic law, ensuring the meat can be considered kosher. Performed exclusively by a highly trained specialist called a menaker—an expert butcher with years of apprenticeship—this procedure demands profound anatomical knowledge to distinguish prohibited tissues from permissible ones without compromising the integrity of the carcass. The expertise of the menaker is essential, as even minor errors could render large portions of meat unfit for consumption.^[19]^[20] The process begins after the ritual slaughter (shechita) and initial inspection, with the menaker making precise incisions to isolate and excise the chelev, alongside certain blood vessels, from the surrounding muscles and organs. Guided by Talmudic directives, such as those in Hullin 48b, which outline the specific locations and characteristics of removable fats, the menaker employs specialized knives to separate layers of tissue layer by layer—often starting from the exterior and progressing inward to avoid contamination. This step-by-step separation ensures that all prohibited elements are fully detached and discarded, with the remaining meat then prepared for further koshering steps like salting. The complexity varies by cut, with forequarters generally requiring less intensive work than hindquarters, though both demand unwavering precision to comply with halachic standards.^[21]^[19]^[22] Nikkur applies specifically to kosher land mammals, including cattle, sheep, and goats, where chelev prohibitions are relevant, but it is not required for birds or fish, whose fats fall under different halachic categories. Emerging from practices tied to ancient sacrificial rites, the procedure evolved post-Temple destruction into a standard element of everyday kosher meat preparation, adapting rabbinic interpretations to modern slaughterhouses while preserving its core requirements. In contemporary settings, nikkur is often conducted at the point of slaughter under rabbinic supervision to maintain efficiency and accuracy.^[23]^[24]

Alternative Interpretations

Ethical and Philosophical Views

In Jewish philosophical thought, the prohibition on chelev is often interpreted as symbolizing the sanctity of life's vital essence, akin to the nefesh or life force, which must be reserved exclusively for divine service rather than human consumption. The chelev, as the protective fat enveloping essential organs like the kidneys, underscores vulnerability and the preciousness of life, paralleling the biblical association of blood with the soul (Leviticus 17:11). By designating this fat for God in sacrificial rites, the Torah elevates it above mundane use, fostering a sense of reverence for animal life and its core vitality.^[25] Medieval commentator Maimonides connects the chelev prohibition to both health considerations and spiritual discipline, arguing that forbidden foods, including these fats, are unwholesome and serve to train self-mastery over appetites, thereby promoting moral and spiritual purity. In his Guide for the Perplexed (3:48), he posits that such dietary laws accustom individuals to restraint, countering base desires and aligning human conduct with higher ethical ideals. This rationalist perspective frames the prohibition not merely as ritual but as a tool for cultivating inner purity and intellectual perfection. Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook, a 20th-century thinker, extends this to ethical treatment of animals, viewing the chelev ban as a deliberate Torah mechanism to limit slaughter of domesticated animals to essential needs, rather than indulgence in their fats, thereby heightening awareness of animal welfare. He emphasizes that this distinction for animals providing milk, wool, and labor reflects refined moral sensitivity, reminding humanity of the gravity in taking their lives: "We should only take their lives out of genuine necessity." Kook's interpretation reserves chelev for divine purposes to prevent exploitation, promoting compassion in human-animal relations.^[26]

Karaite Perspectives

Karaite Judaism adheres to a literal interpretation of the Torah's prohibitions on chelev, rejecting the Rabbanite Oral Law and its distinctions between forbidden fats and permissible ones. Based on Leviticus 3:17—"It shall be a perpetual statute for your generations throughout all your settlements: you shall eat neither fat nor blood"—Karaites apply the ban on chelev, originally defined in sacrificial contexts (Leviticus 3:3–4, 9–10; 7:3–4), to all oxen, sheep, and goats slaughtered outside the Temple, viewing it as a comprehensive dietary restriction without exemptions for non-sacrificial animals.^[27] A key aspect of this stance includes the prohibition of the fat tail (alyah) of sheep and rams, explicitly designated as chelev in Leviticus 3:9 and 9:19, which Karaites forbid entirely rather than classifying as the permitted shuman. This contrasts with rabbinic permissions for tail fat, as Karaites maintain that the Torah's textual specificity leaves no room for such allowances, extending the rule to everyday consumption.^[27]^[28] The Karaite movement emerged in the 9th century amid broader sectarian debates, fostering Jewish pluralism by challenging Rabbanite interpretations through strict biblical literalism and contributing to diverse halakhic practices within Judaism. Rabbinic scholars, such as Abraham Ibn Ezra, critiqued this approach for overextending prohibitions, arguing it accused mainstream Jews of Torah violation, yet acknowledged its basis in the plain text.^[29]

References

[1]
Butter Fat « Ask The Rabbi « - Ohr Somayach
Actually, your question is based on a misunderstanding of the word "chelev." The Torah forbids eating "chelev." Chelev refers only to specific fats found ...
[2]
Blood and Fat | Yeshivat Har Etzion - תורת הר עציון
There are two terms in Hebrew for fat - "cheilev" and "shuman." The terms are more halakhic than physiological - "cheilev" refers to those fats that are ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[3]
Chelev - Orthodox Union
[m.; pl. “chalavot”]; forbidden animal fats; as in “Asur le'echol chelev,” “One is not allowed to eat (forbidden) animal fats” ...
[4]
147. Fat Contentions: The prohibition against eating certain fats
Cheilev is the fat that in the case of sacrifices was burned on the altar. It is prohibited to eat these fats even from non-sacrificial animals.
[5]
A List of the 613 Mitzvot (Commandments) - Judaism 101 (JewFAQ)
Not to eat chelev (tallow-fat) (Lev. 7:23) (CCN88). See ... 21:11) It has been learnt by tradition that a kohein, who does so, violates the prohibition ...
[6]
Hebrew Language Detective: chalav and chelev - Balashon
Jun 23, 2019 · chalav חָלָב - "milk" and chelev חֵלֶב - "fat" (particularly suet, the fat forbidden to eat according to Jewish law).
[7]
Strong's Hebrew: 2459. חֵ֫לֶב (cheleb) -- fat, best, portions of ...
Or cheleb {khay'-leb}; from an unused root meaning to be fat; fat, whether literally or figuratively; hence, the richest or choice part -- X best, fat(-ness), X ...
[8]
Tzav: Good Fat, Bad Fat « What's in a Word? « - Ohr Somayach
The Biblical Hebrew word cheilev is used in reference to either animal or human “fat” or, in a borrowed sense, to something especially “fatty” or “choice.”Missing: chelev | Show results with:chelev
[9]
CHELEV - SUET: WHAT IS IT, AND WHY WAS IT FORBIDDEN?
The first sacrifice ever brought contains the chelev. Literally: "The firstborns of the flock and of their chelev - their fat parts/suet." God "pays heed" ( ...
[10]
https://www.sefaria.org/Leviticus.3.9
[11]
https://www.sefaria.org/Leviticus.3.14
[12]
https://www.sefaria.org/Leviticus.7.3
[13]
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Leviticus%209%3A19&version=NIV
[14]
https://www.sefaria.org/Numbers.18.17
[15]
Numbers 18:17 - Sefaria
אַ֣ךְ בְּֽכוֹר־שׁ֡וֹר אֽוֹ־בְכ֨וֹר כֶּ֜שֶׂב אֽוֹ־בְכ֥וֹר עֵ֛ז לֹ֥א תִפְדֶּ֖ה קֹ֣דֶשׁ הֵ֑ם אֶת־דָּמָ֞ם תִּזְרֹ֤ק עַל־הַמִּזְבֵּ֙חַ֙ וְאֶת־חֶלְבָּ֣ם תַּקְטִ֔יר אִשֶּׁ֛ה לְרֵ֥יחַ נִיחֹ֖חַ לַֽיהֹוָֽה׃ But the firstlings of cattle, sheep, ...Missing: chelev | Show results with:chelev
[16]
https://www.torahmusings.com/2022/03/the-prohibition-against-eating-helev/
[17]
The Prohibition Against Eating Helev - Torah Musings
Mar 15, 2022 · 7;23 articulates the prohibition of eating such fats from oxen, sheep, or goats. ... Officially, three kinds of fat are full helev, with the karet ...Missing: Leviticus kareth
[18]
Karet: A Biblical Punishment - My Jewish Learning
Karet (pronounced KAH-rate), also known as excision, is a biblical punishment imposed for a number of offenses, including sexual immorality, eating leavened ...
[19]
Chullin: 93a - The Talmud - Chabad.org
Rav Yehuda said that Shmuel said: The fat on the top cubit of the small intestine requires scraping, i.e., it is forbidden and must be removed. And this is the ...Missing: chelev | Show results with:chelev
[20]
Getting the Knack of Nikkur: OU Kashrut Seminar on Removing ...
Feb 7, 2007 · OU Kosher presented a Nikkur Seminar on nikkur - the deveining of meat, also known as treibering a process by which the forbidden fat is ...
[21]
Making the Cut: Assuring that Glatt Really Means Kosher - STAR-K
The removal process is referred to as “traiboring” in Yiddish, or “nikkur” in Hebrew. The skilled craftsman is known as a “menaker.” The art of traiboring is ...
[22]
https://consumer.crckosher.org/publications/nikkur/
[23]
Nikkur - cRc Consumer Kosher
Jul 5, 2024 · Nowadays, most nikkur is performed at the slaughterhouse by their staff as per the direction and oversight of the Rav HaMachshir and menaker.Missing: law Hullin 48b
[24]
Inspection & Nikur - Chabad.org
Nikur ("deveining") involves removing certain forbidden veins and fats from cattle. They are extremely prevalent in the hindquarters, and due to the complexity ...
[25]
What's The Truth About...Nikkur Achoraim and Gid HaNasheh?
Sep 13, 2006 · In 1876 the Yerushalayim Ashkenazim initiated kosher slaughter of cattle; they now introduced nikkur achoraim in Yerushalayim, based on the ...Missing: Hullin 48b
[26]
Sacred Fat, Vulnerability, and God's Choice | Hebrew College
Mar 13, 2018 · Moreover, the helev is not only forbidden for human consumption, but it is the choicest part of the animal, the part that God Godself takes as ...Missing: chelev | Show results with:chelev
[27]
Tzav: The Prohibition of Cheilev - Rav Kook Torah
The prohibition of cheilev emphasizes that we should only take their lives out of genuine necessity. Why does the Torah not prohibit eating the fats of birds ...
[28]
[PDF] Mikdash Me'at Section 15: Shechita - The Karaite Jews of America
As a Torah term, chelev refers to the “choice parts” of a slaughtered animal that were never consumed. Scripture precisely defines 6 parts of slaughtered.<|control11|><|separator|>
[29]
Fat, Tails and Intellectual Limits - Torah Musings
Mar 31, 2015 · Karaites believe that the Torah forbids eating an animal's tail. Their source is Lev. 3:9, in which the tail (alyah) is called fat.Missing: critique chelev
[30]
Biblical Exegesis as a Source of Jewish Pluralism - TheTorah.com
Jun 6, 2017 · Karaite tradition is different from the Rabbanite Oral Torah, since the Karaites do not consider their interpretations to be Sinaitic. Rather, ...Missing: Sefer Chinuch chelev