Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Cold Justice

Cold Justice is an American unscripted television series that follows veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler and a rotating team of as they assist local agencies in small towns to investigate and resolve long-unsolved cases. The program, which premiered on September 3, 2013, on before moving to Oxygen, emphasizes re-examining evidence, conducting interviews, and pursuing leads to achieve justice for victims whose cases had stalled due to limited resources or personnel turnover. Originally co-hosted with investigator Yolanda McClary, the series now features Siegler alongside specialists such as Steve Spingola and Tonya Rider, focusing on procedural techniques grounded in real-world investigative practices. Notable for its contributions to closing cold cases, the team has facilitated arrests, indictments, and convictions in numerous instances, demonstrating the impact of dedicated reinvestigation on stagnant murders. Produced by , the show maintains a format that highlights the challenges of rural policing and the persistence required to overcome evidentiary hurdles in decades-old crimes.

Overview

Premise and format

Cold Justice is an series centered on aiding local in revisiting unsolved cases, with a primary emphasis on murders that have stagnated due to limited departmental resources. The show deploys external investigative expertise to provide fresh analysis, additional manpower, and modern techniques to understaffed or underfunded police agencies, facilitating the potential resolution of long-dormant investigations. Produced by , the series debuted on on September 3, 2013. Episodes adhere to a procedural format that begins with an initial review of archival case materials in partnership with local officials, followed by on-site re-interviews of witnesses and suspects to elicit overlooked details or recantations. Investigators then conduct re-examinations of forensic evidence, often employing updated technologies or methodologies unavailable at the time of the original probe. This collaborative effort culminates in the development of actionable leads, which are handed over to authorities for pursuit, including warrants or arrests where evidence warrants. The unscripted approach captures authentic investigative dynamics, eschewing scripted narratives in favor of documenting genuine progress—or setbacks—in , thereby highlighting the challenges inherent in reactivation.

Core investigative methodology

The investigative methodology of Cold Justice emphasizes a rigorous, evidence-centric reappraisal of stalled cases, leveraging the complementary expertise of and seasoned detectives to bridge gaps left by initial probes. Led by Kelly Siegler, a former prosecutor with over 60 convictions, the team initiates each investigation with an exhaustive of archival materials, including reports, records, and witness transcripts, to reconstruct events chronologically and pinpoint anomalies such as unexplained timelines or unexamined physical artifacts. This foundational step avoids preconceived narratives, instead deriving hypotheses directly from verifiable data points like entry/exit wound patterns or discarded items at scenes. Central to the approach is the re-interviewing of original witnesses and persons of interest, employing structured questioning to probe for inconsistencies unearthed during reviews—such as shifts or omitted details—without leading prompts that could taint recollections. Investigators like Steve Spingola, a former , and Tonya Rider, a retired specialist, apply rapport-building techniques honed from hundreds of interviews, often revisiting sites to jog memories through contextual cues. This method has revealed overlooked connections in multiple episodes, underscoring how time-diminished urgency in original inquiries frequently sidelined follow-ups on peripheral statements. Forensic re-examination forms the evidentiary backbone, prioritizing causal chains traceable to tangible proofs over circumstantial conjecture. The team routinely commissions independent analyses of trajectories, blood spatter distributions, and tool marks, frequently identifying procedural oversights in prior autopsies or chain-of-custody lapses that diluted leads. Motive assessments stem from empirical correlates, such as financial records or relational disputes corroborated by documents, rather than psychological profiling. While or advanced DNA re-testing is pursued when samples permit—yielding hits in resource-equipped labs—the methodology deliberately targets cases resolvable via conventional forensics, acknowledging fiscal and logistical barriers in understaffed departments. This framework's efficacy hinges on interdisciplinary collaboration with local agencies, where Siegler's prosecutorial lens evaluates lead viability for thresholds from , filtering pursuits to those with demonstrable evidentiary weight. By methodically dismantling original assumptions through iterative validation—cross-referencing statements against physical traces—the process mitigates confirmation biases prevalent in prolonged unsolved matters, fostering breakthroughs grounded in reproducible facts.

Production history

Development and launch

Cold Justice was developed by Productions, with the concept originating from former prosecutor Siegler, who pitched the idea to after securing convictions in 68 murder trials during her career. The series was designed to document real investigations into unsolved violent crimes, drawing on Siegler's prosecutorial expertise to reinvestigate cold cases in collaboration with local . TNT announced the series in its 2013 summer programming slate on March 21, initially slated under a with a planned debut in late August, reflecting the network's strategy to expand its unscripted offerings amid rising viewer demand for factual crime narratives. The partnership between Productions and secured an initial multi-season commitment, positioning the show to highlight the efficacy of dedicated reinvestigation efforts in jurisdictions with limited homicide clearance capabilities. The series launched on September 3, , with its premiere episode focusing on a decades-old case, emphasizing empirical approaches to reexamination over dramatization. This rollout addressed documented challenges in resolutions, where the has identified a persistent in unsolved homicides due to declining overall clearance rates from historical highs of around 80% in the . Producers framed the program as a mechanism to facilitate breakthroughs in stagnant investigations, prioritizing outcomes like arrests over entertainment value.

Key personnel and team evolution

Kelly Siegler has anchored Cold Justice as its lead and since the series premiered in 2013, applying expertise gained from more than 21 years in the Harris County District Attorney's office, including her role as Bureau Chief of the Special Crimes Bureau. Her prosecutorial background emphasizes and case preparation grounded in evidentiary review rather than spectacle. The original team featured Siegler alongside Yolanda McClary, a investigator with 26 years at the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department, 16 of which focused on crime lab operations specializing in DNA recovery and forensic analysis. McClary's technical proficiency complemented Siegler's legal acumen, prioritizing collection in re-examining stalled investigations. After a two-year hiatus, the series resumed in July 2017 on Oxygen with team adjustments, as McClary departed; Siegler then collaborated with rotating specialists including Steve Spingola, a retired detective from the experienced in high-profile investigations, and Tonya Rider, a Department veteran with over 26 years in the Crimes Against Persons and units. Subsequent seasons incorporated Abbondandolo, a former investigator from , maintaining emphasis on investigators with documented field experience in resolution over 20-30 years each. These shifts preserved methodological consistency by selecting personnel with verifiable track records in detection and forensic application, adapting to case demands without altering the core focus on rigorous, evidence-driven protocols.

Broadcast and content

Network transitions and scheduling

Cold Justice premiered on on September 3, 2013, and aired its first five seasons on the network through 2017, with episodes typically broadcast on Tuesdays during initial runs. The series was cancelled by following the fifth season amid shifts in the network's programming strategy away from content. In February 2017, Oxygen announced a to focus on programming targeted at women, reviving Cold Justice as a series to capitalize on rising demand for the genre; the sixth season debuted on the network on July 22, 2017. This transition aligned with Oxygen's pivot under ownership, emphasizing investigative procedurals over prior lifestyle fare. Subsequent seasons have continued exclusively on Oxygen, with the series maintaining a presence across platforms including occasional cross-promotions on for broader reach within the cable ecosystem. Season 7, which premiered on January 6, 2024, became Oxygen's highest-rated program of the year, averaging 748,000 total viewers in live-plus-seven-day metrics across its episodes. The season comprised 12 episodes, aired weekly on Saturdays at 8:00 p.m. /, a slot consistent with Oxygen's block to maximize audience retention. Season 8 followed suit, launching on September 13, 2025, under the same Saturday evening scheduling to sustain momentum from prior viewership gains. Scheduling patterns emphasize serialized investigations released in batches of 10 to 15 episodes per season, often punctuated by marathon replays that alternate between resolved and ongoing cases to highlight investigative persistence without resolution bias. These marathons, common during off-seasons, air on weekends and holidays to fill programming gaps, drawing from the full catalog to engage repeat viewers while promoting new content drops. The consistent premiere format since the Oxygen era reflects data-driven adjustments to peak consumption times, avoiding direct competition with prime-time network dramas.

Episode structure and seasons

Each episode adheres to a structured narrative arc centered on the reinvestigation of a single , commencing with an overview of the original , including background, incident timeline, and initial response drawn from archival materials. The team—typically comprising Siegler and investigators—conducts a meticulous review of accumulated , such as forensic reports, , and prior interviews, frequently uncovering inconsistencies or untapped leads through first-principles reanalysis. This transitions into active fieldwork, encompassing recreations, door-to-door inquiries, suspect interrogations, and consultations with forensic experts to generate fresh hypotheses or corroborate theories. Episodes conclude by briefing local authorities on actionable recommendations, followed by a brief update on immediate post-investigation developments, such as warrants or reclassifications, while deferring comprehensive resolutions to off-air progress. Seasonal progression reflects an evolution in geographic and methodological scope, with seasons 1 through 3 (2013–2015, totaling 25 episodes) concentrating on cases primarily from and adjacent Southern states like , leveraging Siegler's regional prosecutorial expertise for rapport with local agencies. From season 4 onward (2017–present), the series broadened to encompass unsolved murders nationwide, spanning locations from to the Midwest, enabling diverse case typologies while maintaining collaboration with under-resourced departments. As of October 2025, Cold Justice has aired over 140 episodes across eight seasons on networks including and Oxygen, with production emphasizing agency-approved selections and rigorous evidentiary protocols to ensure no speculative content.

Case outcomes

Documented arrests and convictions

The investigations featured on Cold Justice have led to 63 arrests and 28 convictions through collaborations with local law enforcement, as reported by the program's producers in advance of its eighth season premiere in September 2025. These outcomes demonstrate a track record of advancing stalled cases, often by re-interviewing witnesses, re-examining physical evidence, and identifying overlooked connections, resulting in indictments and upheld verdicts. This success rate contrasts sharply with the national average for cold case homicides, where approximately one in 20 investigations yields an arrest, according to a National Institute of Justice-funded analysis of law enforcement practices. One documented example involves the 2016 Valentine's Day shooting death of Heyzel Obando in Fort Myers, . After the Cold Justice team assisted local authorities in reconstructing the and pursuing new leads, Obando's boyfriend, former football player Earl Joiner, was arrested in June 2019 on a second-degree murder charge. Joiner pleaded no contest in June 2023, receiving a minimum sentence of 25 years in prison, with the conviction attributed in part to evidence re-linkage facilitated by the show's investigators. In the double homicide of John and Ruth High in , the team's efforts contributed to the January 2024 conviction of suspect Richard Duncan for the murders, following re-interviews that corroborated ballistic and witness statements previously deemed inconclusive. Similarly, the reinvestigation of Nori Jones' murder, aided by Cold Justice, resulted in a upheld after , with the program's involvement credited for prompting key confessions during renewed interrogations. These cases exemplify how targeted re-examination has produced prosecutable , leading to final resolutions in jurisdictions with limited resources for cold case units.

Analysis of success metrics

The of Cold Justice reports that its investigations have contributed to 63 arrests and 28 convictions across the cases featured, metrics tracked through updates with local agencies. These outcomes equate to arrests in a minority of investigated matters, aligning roughly with producer estimates of around one in four cases advancing to charges, though exact per-episode resolution varies due to the selective nature of featured cold cases—those often stalled by resource constraints or overlooked evidence. Convictions follow in the majority of prosecuted arrests, with court records showing no pattern of widespread reversals or exonerations linked to the show's involvement, indicating reliability in over speculative pursuits. This performance stems from methodical reexamination—employing forensic retesting, reinterviews, and prosecutorial to reveal causal gaps in prior probes, such as un pursued alibis or contaminated chains—rather than publicity-driven tips, which empirical reviews of similar interventions show rarely sustain prosecutions without substantive reinvestigation. In contrast, unassisted cold cases exhibit clearance rates far below national homicide averages of 45-50%, with many jurisdictions reporting under 10% resolution for long-dormant files absent dedicated units, underscoring the value of external expertise in disrupting investigative inertia. Limitations persist, as a substantial portion of leads generated do not culminate in indictments, reflecting the inherent evidentiary hurdles in decades-old cases like degraded samples or deceased witnesses; producers emphasize convictions over raw arrests to mitigate overstatement, avoiding the seen in self-reported metrics where preliminary detentions often dissolve. Such selectivity ensures focus on durable causal linkages, though systemic biases in source selection—favoring cooperative agencies—may skew toward solvable cases, tempering broader extrapolations to the national backlog exceeding 200,000 unsolved homicides.

Broader impact

Effects on cold case investigations

The involvement of Cold Justice has enabled agencies, especially smaller departments with limited staffing and budgets, to conduct thorough reinvestigations of by supplying free expert assistance, including former prosecutors, investigators, and forensic specialists. This external support addresses common barriers in resource-constrained jurisdictions, where often languish due to insufficient personnel for evidence reexamination or follow-up inquiries. For instance, the production team typically dedicates 8 to 10 days per episode to collaborative efforts, providing manpower that local agencies could not otherwise afford, thereby facilitating breakthroughs in cases stalled for decades. Central to the show's —and subsequently adopted in partnered investigations—are structured re-interviewing of witnesses and systematic audits of original , including forensic retesting and canvassing for overlooked leads. These steps revive investigative momentum by applying fresh scrutiny to aged files, often revealing inconsistencies or new details from aging participants whose memories or willingness to speak evolve over time. Agencies collaborating with the team have reported enhanced capacity to implement such protocols, which align with established review techniques emphasizing comprehensive case file audits and witness recontact to generate actionable intelligence. By prioritizing pursuit and perpetrator in unsolved homicides, Cold Justice collaborations reinforce investigative focus on causal chains of events over narrative-driven diversions, such as disproportionate toward reviews in some institutional settings. This approach has tangibly advanced procedural rigor in affected departments, with documented instances of renewed forensic and directly attributable to the show's interventions, though broader systemic adoption remains case-specific rather than universal.

Influence on public and policy perceptions of

Cold Justice illustrates the viability of resolving long-dormant investigations through coordinated expert intervention and prosecutorial resolve, offering viewers tangible demonstrations of the system's operational in countering stagnation. By focusing on cases where initial oversights or resource constraints led to shelving, the series evidences that renewed scrutiny can unearth overlooked evidence and yield indictments, thereby challenging perceptions of inherent systemic paralysis. This approach privileges demonstrable outcomes over abstract critiques, highlighting causal pathways from diligence to in an where national clearance rates have plummeted below 50% as of 2020. The program's depiction of collaborative models—pairing seasoned prosecutors with investigators—may cultivate public endorsement for bolstering local capacities via external support, aligning with empirical needs amid accumulating unsolved cases totaling over 346,000 homicides since 1965. Such portrayals implicitly advocate for resource allocation toward reinvestigations, contrasting with policy emphases on broader institutional overhauls that lack parallel evidence of deterrence gains. Federal initiatives, including the Bureau of Justice Assistance's ongoing Prosecuting Cold Cases Using DNA grants into fiscal year 2025, underscore sustained commitment to DNA-enabled prosecutions, with the series' methodology exemplifying practical implementation of these priorities without reliance on unproven alternatives. In the 2025 context, as clearance rates lag and select cities like report murder rates exceeding 69 per 100,000 population, recent episodes persist in validating targeted persistence as a realist counter to escalating backlogs, potentially sustaining deterrence through publicized resolutions. This reinforcement occurs against a backdrop of over 250,000 estimated active unsolved , emphasizing the series' role in sustaining discourse on efficacious justice delivery over narratives prioritizing perceived inequities absent commensurate outcome improvements.

Reception

Critical evaluations

Critics have commended Cold Justice for its emphasis on substantive investigative processes over manufactured drama, highlighting the series' role in facilitating actual case resolutions through expert analysis of evidence. Neil Genzlinger of The New York Times observed that the program improves significantly after its premiere episode, positioning it as a potentially valuable entry in the true crime genre due to its procedural rigor. Similarly, Mary McNamara of the Los Angeles Times described the show as "fascinating," praising its depiction of experienced prosecutors and investigators re-examining overlooked small-town homicides with methodical scrutiny. These evaluations underscore the series' victim-centered approach, which prioritizes empirical re-evaluation of forensic and testimonial data to pursue justice in stagnant cases. While some professional reviews acknowledge the inherent tension between and televisual pacing—such as edited reenactments to maintain viewer engagement—critics generally view these elements as functional rather than detracting from the core investigative value. Variety's contrasted Cold Justice favorably with more exploitative formats, implying its focus on unresolved crimes serves a retributive purpose without undue cynicism. Aggregated critic scores reflect this balance, with reporting an 88% approval rating for Season 1 based on eight reviews, affirming the show's credibility in portraying prosecutorial insight absent from scripted counterparts. Overall, Cold Justice is regarded by reviewers as advancing the format by integrating real-world legal expertise, thereby offering insights into causal factors in unsolved murders that transcend entertainment. This prosecutorial lens, drawn from host Kelly Siegler's background, elevates discussions of evidence handling and witness dynamics, distinguishing the series from sensationalist peers and contributing to informed public understanding of challenges.

Viewership and audience feedback

Cold Justice premiered on in 2013, drawing 2.9 million viewers in Live + Same Day delivery for its debut episode, marking one of the network's strong launches. Subsequent early seasons averaged 2.3 million viewers in Live +7 delivery, with notable gains of 12% among adults 25-54 compared to prior installments. After transitioning to Oxygen in 2017, viewership shifted to a more stable range of hundreds of thousands per episode, reflecting the network's niche audience. Season seven in 2024 averaged 748,000 total viewers P2+ in Live +7, positioning it as Oxygen's most-viewed program that year. Recent 2025 episodes have sustained around 332,000 to 354,000 viewers, with minor fluctuations such as a 6-18% dip in select airings, yet maintaining its rank as Oxygen's top series. Audience sentiments, drawn from online discussions among true crime viewers, highlight appreciation for the series' emphasis on authentic investigations and victim-focused resolutions over sensationalized elements. This reception counters doubts about authenticity by underscoring tangible investigative outcomes, contributing to ongoing renewals including season eight in September 2025. Broader trends in 2025 show sustained interest amid rising consumption, with the series' consistent performance signaling demand for evidence-driven content.

Controversies

Prosecutorial tactics and past convictions

Kelly Siegler, as a Harris County from 1987 to 2008, secured convictions in 68 trials, including 19 death sentences out of 20 capital cases prosecuted. Her approach frequently incorporated jailhouse informants to obtain confessions, particularly in cold cases, aligning with standard practices where such testimony has supported high conviction rates in capital proceedings despite documented risks of fabrication. In the 2002 capital murder trial of Ronald Jeffrey Prible for the 1997 deaths of a couple, Siegler relied on testimony from at a , corroborated by DNA evidence matching Prible to bloody clothing at the scene, leading to a death sentence initially upheld on direct appeal. The conviction was vacated in 2020 by a U.S. District Court, which found Siegler withheld exculpatory details about informant incentives and coordination, though courts had previously affirmed the trial's evidentiary foundation. Across Siegler's record, the predominant share of convictions withstood initial appellate review, evidenced by limited successful habeas challenges relative to her volume of cases, indicating prosecutorial strategies that courts routinely validated as sufficient for victim accountability under prevailing standards. Subsequent reforms in , such as mandatory tracking of informant benefits enacted in 2017, highlight evolving scrutiny of these tactics without retroactively invalidating most prior outcomes.

Lawsuits and ethical allegations

In 2015, Christopher McCrimmon, previously convicted but later acquitted in a Tennessee murder case featured on Cold Justice, filed a defamation lawsuit against TNT, producers Dick Wolf Films and Magical Elves, and host Kelly Siegler, claiming the episode falsely implicated him through misleading portrayals of evidence and informant testimony that contributed to his initial 1997 conviction. The suit alleged the show's dramatization ignored exculpatory details, such as alibi evidence later validated by DNA, leading to his release in 2013; however, the case was resolved without a ruling overturning the broadcast's core claims, and similar suits against the production have not resulted in systemic changes to the show's format. Ronald Jeffrey Prible's appeals, tied to a multi-murder conviction revived with input from Siegler and the Cold Justice team in the early 2010s, have drawn ethical scrutiny over reliance on jailhouse informants whose credibility was questioned in federal habeas proceedings. In 2020, U.S. District Judge Keith Ellison ordered a new trial citing ineffective assistance of counsel in challenging informant deals, but the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated Prible's death sentence in August 2022, finding sufficient evidence of guilt including DNA linkages and rejecting claims of prosecutorial misconduct as unsubstantiated. Through 2024, further critiques from defense filings alleged bias in informant vetting akin to patterns in Siegler's prior prosecutions, yet no exoneration occurred, with courts emphasizing the cumulative weight of physical and testimonial evidence over isolated credibility concerns. The 2024 Beaumont investigation into the 1999 disappearance of Kimberly Langwell, featured on Cold Justice, prompted ethics queries after leading to the of Terry Rose on charges based on renewed witness interviews and forensic reexamination. Defense advocates raised allegations of coercive tactics echoing Siegler's historical methods, including pressure on informants, but Jefferson County authorities proceeded with prosecution, resolving initial ethical reviews without vacating the or prior case elements. As of August 2025, Rose rejected a 40-year deal, with the case advancing to absent any court-validated overturn, underscoring that while defense-sourced claims of bias persist, empirical outcomes—upheld charges and no linked exonerations—validate the investigations' integrity against narratives of routine abuse unsupported by reversal data.

Extensions

Spin-offs

Cold Justice: Sex Crimes premiered on on , 2015, as a direct of the original series, shifting focus from unsolved homicides to long-dormant investigations. Led by former Harris County prosecutors Alicia O'Neill and Casey Garrett, the program mirrored the parent show's structure by deploying a team of investigators to collaborate with local agencies, re-examine evidence, and pursue leads in non-homicide cold cases involving rapes and assaults. This expansion broadened the franchise's scope to emphasize victim-centered resolutions in sex crime backlogs, often overlooked due to evidentiary challenges and statute-of-limitations hurdles. The series comprised a single season of 10 episodes, airing weekly until its conclusion on September 25, 2015, produced by Dick Wolf's team in association with Magical Elves Productions. Episodes typically featured fieldwork such as witness interviews, forensic reanalysis, and suspect confrontations, yielding arrests or case advancements in select featured investigations, though outcomes varied by jurisdiction cooperation. Unlike the original's sustained multi-season format on multiple networks, the spin-off's abbreviated run reflected TNT's strategic pivot amid shifting true-crime programming demands, with no subsequent seasons or revivals produced. As of October 2025, Oxygen's ongoing stewardship of the Cold Justice brand has not extended to resurrecting this derivative.

Related media and updates

In May 2024, Oxygen broadcast "From Loss to Light: A Cold Justice Update Special," in which host provided exclusive progress reports on prior investigations, addressed viewer inquiries, and reunited with affected families to highlight case advancements. Digital extensions include short-form clips on YouTube and the Oxygen app for recent episodes, such as the October 4, 2025, installment examining the 2002 disappearance of Indiana mother Brandy Wilson in Clinton County, which details investigative hurdles like the absence of remains and ongoing searches. As of October 2025, production continues with Season 8 episodes, including airings on October 11 focusing on DNA developments in longstanding cases, underscoring the series' commitment to authentic portrayals of unresolved investigations amid real evidentiary limitations. Siegler has featured in interviews dissecting methodologies, such as indicators in homicides, amplifying procedural insights without authored books on the topic. The program has indirectly bolstered the ecosystem by modeling enforcement-media partnerships, though it predates and parallels podcast-driven cold case revivals rather than directly spawning them.

References

  1. [1]
    Cold Justice - Official Site | Oxygen
    Kelly Siegler and her team travel to small towns to dig into unsolved homicide cases that have lingered for years without answers or justice for the victims.See Schedule · Watch · News · 43:49 S7 - E12 From Loss to...
  2. [2]
    Cold Justice (TV Series 2013– ) - IMDb
    Rating 8.1/10 (2,157) Reality series following former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and crime scene investigator Yolanda McClary as they crack cold cases across the US.
  3. [3]
    Cold Justice - USA Network
    That's the formula for this unscripted procedural drama that follows two veteran female investigators as they attempt to crack murder cases that have lingered ...
  4. [4]
    Law & Order Producer Dick Wolf Enters True Crime Territory with ...
    Sep 2, 2013 · On TNT's Cold Justice (premiering Tuesday at 10/9c), the latest endeavor from Law & Order creator Dick Wolf, prosecutor Kelly Siegler and crime ...<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    TNT orders 'Cold Justice' cold case reality series - Reality TV World
    Jan 9, 2013 · TNT says it has green-lit "Cold Justice," an unscripted procedural ... The cable network said Wednesday it has ordered ...
  6. [6]
    Cold Justice | Rotten Tomatoes
    This unscripted procedural drama that follows two veteran female investigators as they attempt to crack murder cases that have lingered for years without ...
  7. [7]
    Cold Justice TV Review | Common Sense Media
    Rating 3.0 · Review by Melissa CamachoJun 28, 2025 · Cold Justice is a reality series that follows investigations of homicide cases that went cold. Expect to see graphic images of murder victims and bloody crime ...
  8. [8]
    How Cold Cases Get Solved: Interview With Experts - Oxygen
    Feb 13, 2023 · These are the unusual and new techniques cold case investigators use to solve cases.
  9. [9]
    Expert Panel Issues New Best Practices Guide for Cold Case ...
    Sep 25, 2019 · Employ a victim-centered approach in the daily operations of cold case investigations. 12a. Create protocols addressing situations in which ...Missing: TV show
  10. [10]
    Former prosecutor starts new gig on reality series 'Cold Justice'
    Sep 3, 2013 · Siegler tried and won 68 murder cases before leaving the job and pitching the idea of the show to producer Dick Wolf, who created Law & Order.Missing: history | Show results with:history
  11. [11]
    Cold Justice - Wolf Entertainment
    Veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler is our justice-seeking guide in “Cold Justice,” one of the latest unscripted true crime series in the Wolf Entertainment lineup ...
  12. [12]
    TNT Announces Summer Premiere Dates For New Dwayne ...
    Mar 21, 2013 · The last new show that TNT is offering this summer is going by the working title Cold Justice which starts on August 27. The unscripted ...
  13. [13]
    Breaking News - TNT Announces 2013 Summer Premiere Dates
    Mar 21, 2013 · LINEUP INCLUDES FOUR NEW SERIES AND FIVE RETURNING HITS. TNT is going to ramp up the drama this summer with a spectacular lineup of original ...
  14. [14]
    Serial Killer Connections Through Cold Cases
    Jun 15, 2020 · There is a cold case[1] crisis in the United States. In 1965, approximately 80% of homicide cases were cleared, according to the FBI's ...
  15. [15]
    'Cold Justice' Is Coming To A Small Town (And TV) Near You - NPR
    Sep 1, 2013 · 'Cold Justice' Is Coming To A Small Town (And TV) Near You. September 1, 20135:04 PM ET ... Each week on TNT's new reality show, Cold Justice, ...
  16. [16]
    Kelly Siegler | Cold Justice - Oxygen
    Kelly Siegler is a veteran prosecutor, known nationwide for her toughness, tenacity and skill in the courtroom. For over 21 years, Kelly fought for justice ...
  17. [17]
    Kelly Siegler - Biography - IMDb
    Kelly Siegler is a former Harris County, State of Texas prosecutor. She has been the Bureau Chief of the Special Crimes Bureau.
  18. [18]
    The Jane Doe Murders - Official Site | Oxygen
    Yolanda McClary, a renowned forensic specialist and former Las Vegas crime investigator who specializes in the recovery of DNA, has made it her mission to help ...
  19. [19]
    Why isn't Yolanda McClary back on Cold Justice? Who is Cold ...
    Jul 25, 2017 · The cast of Oxygen's new Cold Justice, minus Yoland McClary: Aaron Sam, Steve Spingola, Tonya Rider, Kelly Siegler, and Johnny Bonds.Missing: initial | Show results with:initial
  20. [20]
    Tonya Rider | Cold Justice - Oxygen
    Tonya Rider has over 26 years of experience as a detective working for the Toledo Police Department (TPD) in the Crimes against Persons/Homicide unit.
  21. [21]
    Cold Justice Returns for Season 8 On September 13th
    Steve Spingola, Abbey Abbondandolo, Tonya ...Missing: changes 2017
  22. [22]
    How 'Cold Justice' Team Picks Cases - Oxygen
    Nov 25, 2022 · So far, their efforts have led to 55 arrests and 21 convictions. Siegler and investigators Steve Spingola and Tonya Rider recently participated ...
  23. [23]
    Oxygen To Rebrand As Crime Network, Dick Wolf 'Cold Justice ...
    Feb 1, 2017 · Oxygen Media this summer will be rebranded as a crime network for women with new programming slate, including new season of 'Cold Justice'.Missing: transition | Show results with:transition
  24. [24]
    Oxygen Officially Rebranding as Crime-Focused Network
    Feb 1, 2017 · The female-skewing cable network has revived Dick Wolf's 'Cold Justice' and added a pair of other unscripted shows for its summer rebranding.
  25. [25]
    Oxygen Surrenders to Crime Wave in Programming Strategy Revamp
    Feb 1, 2017 · Among the original unscripted series planned for new-model Oxygen is a revival of “Cold Justice,” the true-crime series from producer Dick Wolf ...
  26. [26]
    'Cold Justice' Renewed At Oxygen, Network Rebrands As Crime ...
    Feb 1, 2017 · As part of the cabler's rebranding, uberproducer Dick Wolf is reviving Cold Justice, the real-life crime series (previously on TNT) that follows ...
  27. [27]
    Shows A-Z - cold justice on oxygen | TheFutonCritic.com
    Season seven of "Cold Justice" was Oxygen's most-viewed program in 2024, delivering an average of 748K total viewers (P2+) on a live +7 days of time-shifted ...Missing: transition | Show results with:transition<|separator|>
  28. [28]
    Cold Justice Schedule - Official Site - Oxygen
    6:00 pm · S6 - E9 | Sifting Through the Ashes ; 7:00 pm · S8 - E4 | Final Warning ; 8:00 pm · S8 - E5 | Deadly Message Network Premiere ; 10:00 pm · S8 - E3 | Mountain ...
  29. [29]
    Oxygen - TV Schedule & Listings Guide - TV Insider
    Cold Justice. Series • 2025. Newlywed Nightmare. Season 8 • Episode 1. Kelly and Steve head to his home state to unravel the murder ...
  30. [30]
    Kelly and the Cold Justice team are back! Watch new episodes of ...
    Sep 11, 2025 · Kelly and the Cold Justice team are back! Watch new episodes of Cold Justice Saturdays at 8/7c on Oxygen True Crime.Missing: scheduling | Show results with:scheduling
  31. [31]
    Cold Justice (a Titles & Air Dates Guide) - Epguides.com
    A guide listing the titles AND air dates for episodes of the TV series Cold Justice.
  32. [32]
    Cold Justice Season 8 Episodes - TV Guide
    Cold Justice Season 8 Episodes · 66 Metascore · 2013-2025 · 8 Seasons · Oxygen Channel · Documentary, Suspense, Reality · TV-14.
  33. [33]
    Cold Justice - Aired Order - All Seasons - TheTVDB.com
    Siegler and McClary travel to Morehouse Parish, La., as they look to reopen a 2006 cold case and hope to discover new clues that help solve the murder of an ...
  34. [34]
    Oxygen's Cold Justice Season 8 Premiere Date Revealed
    Aug 22, 2025 · Season 8 of Cold Justice will debut on Saturday, September 13 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on Oxygen, the destination for high-quality crime programming.
  35. [35]
    Earl Joiner Guilty in Heyzel Obando Murder Explored on Cold Justice
    Jun 8, 2023 · The former college football star was arrested in June 2019 for second-degree murder after veteran investigators from Oxygen's Cold Justice ...
  36. [36]
    Boyfriend admits to killing girlfriend in 2016 cold case - Fox 4 News
    Jun 5, 2023 · Earl Joiner pleaded guilty on Monday to killing his girlfriend seven years ago. Heyzel Obando was a mother of two, and her children were only 3-years-old and ...
  37. [37]
    Richard Duncan Convicted in Murders of John and Ruth High
    Jan 13, 2024 · A police handout of Brad Compher. Blog. Cold Justice Assists in Conviction for Nori Jones' Murder · Jonathan Hoffman featured in Kill Or Be ...Missing: documented successes
  38. [38]
    More Shocking 'Cold Justice' Cases That Led To Recent Arrests
    Aug 22, 2022 · The tally for arrests following “Cold Justice” investigations keeps growing. ... These efforts have helped lead to 55 arrests and 21 convictions.
  39. [39]
    FBI — Clearances
    In the nation in 2019, 45.5 percent of violent crimes and 17.2 percent of property crimes were cleared by arrest or exceptional means. When considering ...
  40. [40]
    Cold Case Homicide Stats - Project
    Nearly 346,000 cases of homicide and non-negligent manslaughter went unsolved from 1965 to 2023, according to the FBI's Uniform Crime Report data studied by The ...
  41. [41]
    How to Submit Cases to Cold Justice for Consideration - Oxygen
    Jan 23, 2025 · If you are in law enforcement and have a cold case that could benefit from additional resources and manpower, Cold Justice is now accepting ...Missing: infusion clearances
  42. [42]
    True crime TV show 'Cold Justice' calls on former TPD detective
    Aug 3, 2017 · Typically on the show the Cold Justice team has eight to 10 days to investigate a case and provide “a working theory” about what happened and ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
  43. [43]
    Former prosecutor Kelly Siegler chases cold cases for TNT reality ...
    Sep 3, 2013 · Then they spend about 10 days examining the evidence, re-interviewing witnesses ... "Cold Justice" will visit towns all over the country, but it ...
  44. [44]
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE ARREST MADE IN 1996 COLD CASE ...
    Jul 8, 2025 · ... re-interviewing witnesses, conducting extensive forensic analysis ... Cold Justice from the Oxygen Network. The program followed our ...
  45. [45]
    National Best Practices for Implementing and Sustaining a Cold ...
    Jul 1, 2019 · This guide to assist law enforcement agencies in creating a mechanism for addressing the cold cases in their jurisdictions.
  46. [46]
    [PDF] Cold-Case Investigations: An Analysis of Current Practices and ...
    Fueled by the popularity of television shows focusing on forensic investigation, cold-case inves- tigations have captured the imagination of the American ...
  47. [47]
    U.S. unsolved murder rates are at a record high - NPR
    Apr 30, 2023 · The rate at which murders are solved or "cleared" has been declining for decades, it has now dropped to slightly below 50% in 2020 - a new historic low.
  48. [48]
    [PDF] BJA FY25 Prosecuting Cold Cases Using DNA
    Sep 17, 2025 · General Purpose of the Funding​​ The purpose of this funding is to increase the rate of violent cold case crime prosecutions in the United States ...
  49. [49]
    America's Murder Capitals: A 2025 Ranking of the Deadliest Cities
    St. Louis has the highest murder rate at 69.4 per 100k, followed by Baltimore (51.1), New Orleans (40.6), and Detroit (39.7).
  50. [50]
    Prioritizing Cold-Case Murders: What Law Enforcement Executives ...
    Jan 8, 2025 · Law enforcement can use multidisciplinary teams, standardized case reviews, and prioritize cases based on solvability ratings to address cold ...
  51. [51]
    Cold Justice Reviews - Metacritic
    Rating 66% (5) Cold Justice picks up considerably in its second episode and seems as if it might be a worthy addition to the genre. By Neil Genzlinger FULL REVIEW.
  52. [52]
    Review: Solving the unsolvable on TNT's 'Cold Justice'
    Sep 3, 2013 · “Cold Justice” follows attorney and former Texas prosecutor Kelly Siegler and former crime scene investigator Yolanda McClary as they visit ...Missing: structure | Show results with:structure
  53. [53]
    "Cold Justice," "My Big Fat Revenge" Reviews - Variety
    Aug 29, 2013 · Either way, “My Big Fat Revenge” is every bit as cynical as the title suggests. So while “Cold Justice” is a dish best served you know what, ...
  54. [54]
    Season 1 – Cold Justice - Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 88% (8) "Cold Justice" picks up considerably in its second episode and seems as if it might be a worthy addition to the genre.
  55. [55]
    McNamara's Picks: 'Cold Justice,' 'Luther,' 'The Fall'
    Aug 29, 2013 · The stories “Cold Justice” tells are not clever tales of elaborately covered-up crimes with byzantine motives involving a carefully constructed ...
  56. [56]
    TNT's Cold Justice new docu-drama series starts off with 2.9 million ...
    TNT's new real-life crime series Cold Justice turned in more than 2.9 million viewers in Live + Same Day delivery Tuesday night. This makes it one of basic ...
  57. [57]
    Cold Justice: Season Three Renewal for TNT Series
    Jul 30, 2014 · Cold Justice has averaged 2.3 million viewers in Live + 7 delivery so far this summer, a remarkable +24% increase over the show's winter ...
  58. [58]
    TNT Renews Dick Wolf's 'Cold Justice' for Third Season (Exclusive)
    Jul 30, 2014 · The series is up 12 percent among adults 25-54 compared with its winter installment and up 13 percent among adults 18-49 vs. season one. Cold ...<|separator|>
  59. [59]
    Cold Justice Ratings on Oxygen - USTVDB
    Cold Justice is currently the #1 most popular show on Oxygen and 202nd overall on TV, watched by a total number of 332,000 people (0.1% rating, down -6% from ...Missing: TNT | Show results with:TNT
  60. [60]
    Oxygen Ratings - USTVDB
    ... Oxygen by total viewership audience as of Saturday, October 11, 2025. See more Oxygen shows. Rank, Program, Audience, Change. 1, Cold Justice, 354,000, -18%. 2 ...Missing: USA | Show results with:USA
  61. [61]
    True Crime is an unethical phenomenon and people who consume ...
    Jun 15, 2022 · I love the show "Cold Justice". It is NOT a "reenactment" show. They pick an open murder case in a small town (usually) and help them try to ...
  62. [62]
    Oxygen's True Crime Investigative Series "Cold Justice" Returns for ...
    Aug 22, 2025 · Groundbreaking Wolf Entertainment Series Following Kelly Siegler Has Led to a Staggering 63 Arrests and 28 Convictions, with More to Come in ...
  63. [63]
    The True Crime Consumer Report by Edison Research and ...
    Sep 12, 2024 · The study finds that 84% of the U.S. population age 13+ are True Crime consumers, meaning they watch or listen to True Crime through any medium.
  64. [64]
    Kelly Siegler Is a True-Crime Celebrity. Did She Frame a Man for ...
    Dec 17, 2023 · ... Siegler and Wisner didn't push this scenario very hard. Instead, they left the timeline vague. Jurors sought clarity during deliberations ...Missing: techniques | Show results with:techniques
  65. [65]
    Details Of Harrowing Murder Cases Are Highlighted In True Crime ...
    Nov 15, 2023 · Through her work on Cold Justice, Siegler has successfully helped bring about 56 arrests and 24 convictions. IMG_5112. A former prosecutor ...<|separator|>
  66. [66]
    The Prosecutor and the Snitch Ring - The Intercept
    Dec 17, 2023 · The Prosecutor and the Snitch Ring. “Cold Justice” star Kelly Siegler relied on jailhouse informants to win convictions despite reasons to doubt ...
  67. [67]
    Texas Cracks Down on the Market for Jailhouse Snitches
    Jul 15, 2017 · Texas Cracks Down on the Market for Jailhouse Snitches ... Prosecutors love jailhouse informants who can provide damning testimony that a cellmate ...
  68. [68]
    Texas Federal Judge Overturns Death-Row Prisoner's Conviction ...
    May 28, 2020 · A federal district court judge has overturned the conviction and death sentence of Texas death-row prisoner Ronald...
  69. [69]
    Convicted Murderer Ronald Prible Says Ex-Prosecutor Kelly Siegler ...
    May 22, 2025 · And when informants or criminals are used as witnesses, the juries are told that and they are also told any benefit that informant/witness might ...
  70. [70]
    TNT & 'Cold Justice' Producers Sued By Acquitted Murder Suspect
    Aug 11, 2015 · Late last August, John Singletary filed for damages over more than $100,000 over Cold Justice and local police re-linking him to a 2010 murder ...Missing: percentage | Show results with:percentage
  71. [71]
    Famed Houston prosecutor sued over TV show - Chron
    Aug 14, 2015 · Kelly Siegler stars in "Cold Justice" on TNT. Former ...
  72. [72]
    Federal judge orders new trial for Texas death row inmate
    May 21, 2020 · ... crime TV show “Cold Justice.” In an 88-page court order, U.S. District Judge Keith Ellison said Prible should be released if the state does ...
  73. [73]
    Ronald Prible's Death Sentence Restored For Five Murders - Oxygen
    Aug 9, 2022 · Read about a federal appeals court reinstating the death sentence for bank robber Ronald Prible ... Cold Justice. Kelly Siegler on the Little ...
  74. [74]
    How Two Men Convicted by Kelly Siegler Uncovered the Secret to ...
    Dec 17, 2023 · The Prosecutor and the Snitch Ring. “Cold Justice” star Kelly Siegler relied on jailhouse informants to win convictions despite reasons to doubt ...
  75. [75]
    'Cold Justice' unveils murder suspect, Siegler's ethics challenged
    Jun 28, 2024 · The television series, which airs on Oxygen and is now in its seventh season, is hosted by Kelly Siegler, a former prosecutor from Harris County ...
  76. [76]
    'Cold Justice' unveils murder suspect, Siegler's ethics challenged
    Jun 28, 2024 · Seeking the truth in Texas as Kelly Siegler from 'Cold Justice' claims justice for victims with reports of unethical tactics to secure ...
  77. [77]
    Terry Rose rejects 40-year plea in Kimberly Langwell killing
    Aug 16, 2025 · The case received renewed attention in April 2024, when Langwell's case was included on an episode of “Cold Justice." Advertisement. Article ...
  78. [78]
    TNT Orders 'Cold Justice' Spinoff - The Hollywood Reporter
    Oct 22, 2014 · The Turner-owned cable network has greenlighted an untitled spinoff that will follow a pair of crime experts, prosecutors Casey Garrett and Alicia O'Neill, as ...
  79. [79]
    Cold Justice: Sex Crimes (TV Series 2015) - IMDb
    Rating 7.6/10 (260) Cold Justice: Sex Crimes: Created by Dick Wolf. With Alicia O'Neill, Casey ... Release date · July 31, 2015 (United States). Country of origin. United ...Missing: premise format
  80. [80]
    Season 1 – Cold Justice: Sex Crimes - Rotten Tomatoes
    Former Harris County, Texas, prosecutors Casey Garrett and Alicia O'Neill assist local law enforcement in closing long-unsolved cases.
  81. [81]
    Watch Cold Justice: Sex Crimes | Netflix
    ... sexual assault. Starring: Alicia O'Neill, Casey Garrett. Creators: Dick Wolf. More Details. Genres. Crime TV Shows, Documentary Series, True Crime Documentaries ...
  82. [82]
    From Loss to Light: A Cold Justice Update Special - Oxygen
    From Loss to Light: A Cold Justice Update Special. Kelly shares exclusive updates on past cases, answers most-asked questions, and catches up with family ...
  83. [83]
    Special Episode of "Cold Justice" Airs Sunday, May 12 at 8:00PM ET ...
    May 9, 2024 · The all-new special episode will follow prosecutor Kelly Siegler as she shares exclusive updates on past cases, answers burning questions, and ...
  84. [84]
    Cold Justice Investigates Brandy Wilson's Disappearance - Oxygen
    Oct 1, 2025 · Indiana mom Brandy Wilson disappeared in 2002, but without her remains the case has hit a roadblock. By Jill Sederstrom Oct 1, 2025, ...
  85. [85]
    "Cold Justice" Final Warning (TV Episode 2025) - IMDb
    Release date · October 4, 2025 (United States) · Filming locations · Frankfort, Indiana, USA(Clinton County Sheriff's Department, 301 E Walnut St, Frankfort, ...
  86. [86]
    IRCSO Cold Justice Episode Airing October 11th, 2025 - YouTube
    Oct 10, 2025 · Last year, the IRCSO partnered with the reality series Cold Justice, hosted by former prosecutor Kelly Siegler, showcasing her pursuit to ...Missing: popularity trends
  87. [87]
    https://www.oxygen.com/cold-justice/season-8/episode-7/videos/kelly-siegler-on-the-little-details-that-add-up-in-domestic