Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Cold dark matter

Cold dark matter (CDM) is a form of dark matter consisting of slow-moving, non-relativistic particles that do not interact with electromagnetic radiation, making them invisible to telescopes but detectable through their gravitational influence.^[1] In cosmology, CDM plays a crucial role by providing the gravitational scaffolding for the formation of cosmic structures, allowing particles to clump efficiently on small scales during the early universe when the expansion was rapid.^[2] This bottom-up hierarchical structure formation contrasts with faster-moving "hot" dark matter, which would suppress small-scale clustering, and aligns with observations of the universe's large-scale architecture.^[3] Within the standard ΛCDM model—the prevailing framework for understanding the universe's evolution—CDM accounts for about 27% of the total mass-energy density, with ordinary baryonic matter comprising roughly 5% and dark energy the remaining 68%.^[4] However, recent baryon acoustic oscillation measurements from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) as of 2025 hint at evolving dark energy, potentially requiring refinements to the model. The model's parameters, including the CDM density (Ω_c h² ≈ 0.12), are precisely constrained by measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) from missions like Planck and WMAP, as well as large-scale structure surveys.^[4] CDM's dominance in structure formation is evident from simulations that reproduce the observed distribution of galaxies and clusters, where dark matter halos serve as seeds around which baryonic gas cools and stars form.^[5] Evidence for CDM stems from multiple independent lines of observation, including flat rotation curves of galaxies indicating unseen mass, strong gravitational lensing in clusters like the Bullet Cluster separating dark matter from visible gas, and CMB power spectrum peaks that require non-baryonic matter to match the data.^[1] While CDM excels at explaining phenomena on large scales spanning billions of light-years, it faces challenges on smaller scales, such as the predicted abundance of dwarf satellite galaxies around the Milky Way and the density profiles of galactic cores, potentially resolvable through baryonic feedback processes or modifications to dark matter physics.^[2] Proposed CDM particles include weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs), with masses around 10-1000 GeV, and axions, ultralight pseudoscalars, both predicted by extensions to the Standard Model of particle physics but yet to be detected in experiments like those at the Large Hadron Collider or direct-detection facilities.^[1]

Fundamentals

Definition and Properties

Cold dark matter (CDM) refers to a component of dark matter composed of non-baryonic particles that are non-relativistic at the epoch of cosmic structure formation, possessing negligible thermal velocities such that their speeds are much less than the speed of light (v ≪ c).^[6] This "cold" designation distinguishes CDM from hotter variants, as the particles' low velocity dispersion allows for the efficient growth of density perturbations on small scales without significant damping.^[7] In the standard ΛCDM cosmological framework, CDM constitutes approximately 26% of the universe's total energy density, serving as the dominant form of matter that drives gravitational clustering.^[7] CDM exhibits several key physical properties that make it essential for modeling cosmic evolution. It is collisionless, interacting with ordinary matter and itself primarily through gravity, with negligible self-interaction cross-sections (σ_DM-DM/m_DM < 0.47 cm²/g at 95% confidence).^[7] Additionally, CDM is pressureless, behaving like dust with an equation of state parameter w = 0 in the Friedmann equations, which permits unbounded growth of gravitational instabilities during the matter-dominated era.^[6] The cold nature further implies a suppressed free-streaming length, defined approximately as λ_fs ≈ v_th t, where v_th is the thermal velocity and t is the age of the universe at decoupling; for CDM, this scale is much smaller than for hot dark matter, enabling the formation of compact structures like galaxies through hierarchical clustering.^[7] Mathematically, the dynamics of CDM are governed by the collisionless Boltzmann equation, which reduces to the Vlasov equation for the phase-space distribution function f(x, v, t):

\frac{\partial f}{\partial t} + \mathbf{v} \cdot \nabla_x f - \nabla_x \Phi \cdot \nabla_v f = 0,

where Φ is the gravitational potential.^[7] For linear density perturbations in a matter-dominated universe, this leads to the growth of overdensities δ = δρ/ρ ∝ a, where a is the scale factor, contrasting with radiation-dominated suppression.^[6] These properties collectively ensure that CDM perturbations evolve into the observed large-scale structure of the universe.^[7]

Comparison to Other Dark Matter Models

Cold dark matter (CDM) differs from other dark matter models in the thermal motion of its particles, which determines the scale at which density perturbations can grow into structures. Hot dark matter (HDM) consists of relativistic particles, such as neutrinos with masses around 1 eV, that have a free-streaming length of order 100 Mpc. This large free-streaming erases small-scale density fluctuations below this scale through collisionless damping, leading to a top-down structure formation process where massive superclusters collapse first and fragment into galaxies. Observations of the cosmic large-scale structure, such as those from the Center for Astrophysics (CfA) redshift survey, rule out pure HDM models because they predict insufficient small-scale power and excessive smoothing compared to the observed filamentary web.^[8] Warm dark matter (WDM) occupies an intermediate regime, with semi-relativistic particles like sterile neutrinos having masses around a few keV and free-streaming lengths of approximately 100 kpc. These models partially suppress structure formation on dwarf galaxy scales, reducing the abundance of low-mass halos compared to CDM and aiming to resolve discrepancies in satellite galaxy counts. However, WDM predicts too few substructures overall—such as only about 3% of halo mass in subhalos versus 8% in CDM simulations—and fails to fully reproduce large-scale structure observations, including constraints from the Lyman-α forest that set a lower mass limit greater than 3 keV.^[8]^[9]^[10] CDM particles, with masses much greater than 1 keV and typical velocities of v \sim 10^{-3} c, exhibit negligible free-streaming, preserving power on all scales and enabling bottom-up hierarchical clustering where small-mass halos form first and merge into larger galaxies. This results in a richer hierarchy of substructure than HDM's smoothing or WDM's partial cutoff, aligning better with the observed abundance of dwarf galaxies and satellite systems. The distinction is particularly clear in the matter power spectrum P(k), where CDM maintains P(k) \propto k^{-3} at high k (small scales, corresponding to sub-galactic structures), while HDM imposes an exponential suppression for k \gtrsim 0.01 \, h \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} due to free-streaming, and WDM introduces a milder cutoff at intermediate k.^[8]

Historical Development

Origins of the CDM Hypothesis

The concept of dark matter emerged in the early 20th century through observations of galaxy clusters, where Swiss astronomer Fritz Zwicky analyzed the Coma Cluster in 1933 and found that the velocities of galaxies implied a total mass far exceeding the luminous matter, suggesting the presence of unseen, non-luminous material to maintain gravitational binding. This "missing mass" was later corroborated in the 1970s by studies of individual galaxies; Vera Rubin and Kent Ford's spectroscopic observations of emission regions in the Andromeda galaxy (M31) revealed flat rotation curves extending to large radii, indicating that orbital velocities did not decline as expected under Keplerian dynamics dominated by visible stars and gas, thus requiring substantial additional mass in a non-baryonic, invisible form.^[11] Early attempts to identify this dark matter as baryonic—such as dim stars, gas clouds, or black holes—faced significant constraints from big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) theory, which predicts the abundances of light elements formed in the early universe and limits the cosmic baryon density to Ω_b h^2 < 0.1, far below the dynamical estimates of total matter density around Ω_m ≈ 1 needed to explain the observations. These BBN bounds, derived from the observed deuterium and helium-4 abundances, ruled out baryons as the dominant dark matter component, prompting searches for non-baryonic alternatives. In 1982, physicist P. J. E. Peebles proposed the cold dark matter (CDM) hypothesis, suggesting that the dark matter consists of non-relativistic (cold) particles with weak interactions, which could seed large-scale density fluctuations while resolving cosmological puzzles like the horizon and flatness problems prior to the development of inflation theory.^[12] Peebles argued that such particles, unlike hot relativistic species like neutrinos, would not suppress small-scale structure formation due to free-streaming effects and could naturally produce the observed scale-invariant spectrum of primordial perturbations. This idea was formalized in 1984 by George Blumenthal, Sandra Faber, Joel Primack, and Martin Rees, who outlined the CDM model as a universe with total matter density Ω_m ≈ 1 dominated by cold, collisionless particles, predicting hierarchical structure formation where small density perturbations collapse first into galaxies and later merge into clusters, as demonstrated through early N-body simulations.^[13] Their framework integrated CDM with emerging ideas like cosmic inflation, providing a cohesive paradigm for understanding the universe's matter distribution.

Evolution into the Lambda-CDM Model

In the 1990s, the cold dark matter (CDM) hypothesis transitioned from theoretical speculation to empirical support through key astronomical observations and refined simulations. The Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) satellite's detection of cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies in 1992 provided the first direct evidence of primordial density fluctuations, with the observed power spectrum aligning closely with predictions from CDM models of structure formation. This breakthrough was bolstered by advancements in N-body simulations, such as those by Davis et al. in 1985, which were iteratively refined to better model gravitational clustering in a CDM-dominated universe, demonstrating how initial Gaussian fluctuations could evolve into the observed large-scale structure.^[14] Wright et al. further interpreted the COBE data in 1992 as consistent with CDM cosmologies, normalizing the fluctuation amplitude and validating the model's inflationary origins.^[15] A pivotal development occurred in 1998 with observations of Type Ia supernovae, which revealed the universe's accelerating expansion and necessitated the inclusion of a cosmological constant (Λ) in CDM frameworks. Independent teams led by Riess et al. and Perlmutter et al. analyzed distant supernovae, finding that the expansion rate implied a flat universe with dark energy density Ω_Λ ≈ 0.7 and matter density Ω_m ≈ 0.3, the latter predominantly composed of CDM. These results transformed CDM into the ΛCDM model, resolving tensions between matter-dominated predictions and the observed dimming of high-redshift supernovae, while maintaining CDM's central role in accounting for ≈85% of the matter budget.^[16] The 2000s brought precision measurements that solidified ΛCDM parameters through CMB experiments. The Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), operational from 2003 to 2010, mapped CMB fluctuations with unprecedented resolution, constraining CDM contributions to σ_8 ≈ 0.8 (the rms density fluctuation on 8 h⁻¹ Mpc scales) and other parameters like the Hubble constant.^[17] Subsequent data releases refined these values, confirming a CDM density parameter Ω_c h² ≈ 0.11 and supporting the model's hierarchical structure formation. The Planck satellite's observations from 2013 to 2018 further validated these findings, yielding h ≈ 0.67 and σ_8 ≈ 0.81, with tight consistency across the CMB power spectrum and lensing effects.^[18] By 2010, ΛCDM had emerged as the concordance model of cosmology, integrating CDM with dark energy and ordinary matter to explain a wide array of observations. This paradigm resolved longstanding Big Bang issues, such as the horizon and flatness problems, by leveraging CDM's influence on early density perturbations that imprint baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) as a standard ruler in the galaxy distribution.^[19] BAO detections, first reported in 2005, provided geometric probes of cosmic expansion that aligned with ΛCDM predictions, affirming CDM's necessity for the observed acoustic peaks in the matter power spectrum and cementing the model's status as the benchmark for precision cosmology.^[19]

Theoretical Framework

Role in Cosmic Structure Formation

Cold dark matter (CDM) is essential for the hierarchical formation of cosmic structures via gravitational instability, where its collisionless nature and low thermal velocities enable a bottom-up process. In this paradigm, small dark matter halos form first, with typical masses around $10^6 M_\odot at redshifts z \approx 30, subsequently merging to assemble larger structures such as galaxies and clusters.^[14] This contrasts with hot dark matter models, where high velocities suppress small-scale structure, leading to top-down fragmentation of large-scale perturbations into galaxies.^[20] During the early phases of structure growth, in the linear regime of the matter-dominated era, density perturbations \delta evolve proportionally to the scale factor a, such that \delta \propto a.^[20] As these perturbations reach amplitudes where nonlinear effects become significant, the Zel'dovich approximation provides a framework to describe particle displacements, modeling the motion along straight-line trajectories determined by the initial gravitational potential gradient until shell-crossing occurs.^[21] The power spectrum of density fluctuations, P(k), governs the initial conditions and evolution of these structures in CDM. Primordial perturbations from cosmic inflation yield P(k) \propto k^{n_s} with scalar spectral index n_s \approx 0.96, as constrained by cosmic microwave background observations.^[18] The CDM transfer function T(k) then modulates this spectrum, preserving significant power on small scales (corresponding to large wavenumbers k) due to the negligible free-streaming length of cold particles, while suppressing power only at very small scales k > 1 \, h \, \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1} primarily from Silk damping affecting baryons.^[22] To quantify the abundance of collapsed structures, the Press-Schechter formalism derives the halo mass function from the statistics of Gaussian initial conditions, given by

\frac{dn}{dm} \propto m^{-2} \exp\left( -\frac{\delta_c^2}{\sigma^2(m)} \right),

where \delta_c \approx 1.686 is the critical overdensity for collapse, and \sigma(m) is the variance of the density field smoothed on mass scale m. This predicts a rich hierarchy of subhalos within larger halos, characteristic of CDM's enhanced small-scale power.^[23]

Candidate Compositions and Particles

Weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs) represent one of the primary candidates for cold dark matter, characterized by masses in the range of approximately 10 to 1000 GeV and interactions mediated by the weak force with Standard Model particles. These particles are motivated by extensions of the Standard Model, such as supersymmetry, where they arise naturally as the lightest stable supersymmetric partner, addressing the hierarchy problem while providing a thermal relic that matches the observed dark matter abundance.^[24] WIMPs are produced in the early universe through thermal freeze-out, where their annihilation cross-section into Standard Model particles determines the relic density via the approximate relation \Omega_c h^2 \approx \frac{3 \times 10^{-9} \, \mathrm{GeV}^{-2}}{\langle \sigma v \rangle} \approx 0.12, with \langle \sigma v \rangle the velocity-averaged annihilation cross-section.^[24] However, by 2025, direct detection experiments have increasingly disfavored simple WIMP models, with XENONnT setting the most stringent spin-independent cross-section limits below $1.7 \times 10^{-47} \, \mathrm{cm}^2 for a 30 GeV WIMP at 90% confidence level, excluding much of the parameter space predicted by minimal supersymmetric extensions.^[25] Axions, ultralight pseudoscalar particles with masses ranging from approximately $10^{-5} eV to \mueV, offer another compelling cold dark matter candidate, primarily motivated by the Peccei-Quinn mechanism to resolve the strong CP problem in quantum chromodynamics. Unlike WIMPs, axions interact feebly with ordinary matter through derivative couplings, such as the axion-photon interaction with strength g_{a\gamma\gamma} \sim \alpha / (2\pi f_a), where f_a is the axion decay constant.^[24] Their production occurs non-thermally via the misalignment mechanism, in which the axion field oscillates coherently about the minimum of its potential after the Peccei-Quinn symmetry breaking scale, leading to a relic density \Omega_a h^2 \approx 0.12 \left( f_a / 10^{12} \, \mathrm{GeV} \right)^{7/6} \theta^2, with \theta the initial misalignment angle. Axions have gained prominence as viable cold dark matter since the 2010s, particularly as experimental null results have shifted focus from heavier candidates, though their coherence on de Broglie wavelength scales imposes mild constraints on structure formation for the lowest masses. Other candidates bridge or extend the cold dark matter paradigm, though not all qualify as purely cold. Sterile neutrinos, with masses around the keV scale, interact only through small mixings with active neutrinos and can contribute to dark matter via non-thermal production mechanisms like resonant oscillations in the early universe, but their velocities typically render them warm rather than cold, blurring the boundary with warm dark matter models.^[26] Primordial black holes (PBHs), formed from the collapse of dense regions in the early universe due to inflationary fluctuations or phase transitions, interact solely via gravity and span a broad mass range from $10^{-16} to $10^3 solar masses, potentially constituting all or part of cold dark matter without requiring new particles, though microlensing and accretion constraints limit full coverage to specific windows.^[27] Superheavy dark matter particles, with masses exceeding $10^9 GeV, arise in grand unified theories or string-inspired models and are produced non-thermally, often as Planck-suppressed relics or from modulus decays, maintaining cold kinematics due to their extreme mass while evading standard detection channels through diluted interactions.

Observational Evidence

Large-Scale Structure Observations

Large-scale structure observations provide some of the strongest empirical support for the cold dark matter (CDM) paradigm by demonstrating that the distribution of galaxies and matter on scales exceeding 1 Mpc aligns closely with theoretical predictions from CDM-based simulations. These observations, primarily from redshift surveys and gravitational lensing, measure clustering statistics such as the two-point correlation function ξ(r) and the power spectrum P(k), revealing a hierarchical structure formation process driven by gravitational instability in a CDM-dominated universe. The consistency between observed clustering and CDM models, particularly in the amplitude and shape of P(k), constrains key cosmological parameters and validates the model's ability to reproduce the cosmic web on large scales. Redshift surveys have been instrumental in mapping galaxy distributions and quantifying clustering. The Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), operational since 2000, has cataloged millions of galaxies and measured the correlation function ξ(r), which matches CDM predictions for the matter power spectrum P(k) with normalization σ_8 ≈ 0.81 and matter density Ω_m ≈ 0.3. More recent efforts, such as the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) survey in the 2020s, have extended these measurements to higher redshifts and larger volumes, confirming the same CDM-consistent clustering patterns and providing tighter constraints on structure growth. The 2025 DESI Data Release 2 (DR2) baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) measurements from over 14 million galaxies and quasars up to z ≈ 3.1 further affirm large-scale consistency with CDM while offering percent-level precision on expansion history.^[28] These surveys highlight how CDM's cold particle nature enables efficient clustering on large scales, as evidenced by the observed bias parameter b ≈ 1-2 for luminous red galaxies. Baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) offer a standard ruler for distance measurements, imprinted as a preferred scale in the galaxy distribution from early-universe sound waves. This feature, with a comoving scale of approximately 150 Mpc tied to the sound horizon r_s ≈ 147 Mpc, was first detected in the 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey data from 2001 and robustly confirmed in combined analyses. Subsequent observations by the BOSS survey refined these detections, measuring the BAO peak position to percent-level precision and aligning it with CDM expectations for a flat universe with Ω_m ≈ 0.3. By fixing the sound horizon scale, BAO observations anchor the expansion history and support CDM's role in preserving this relic feature through late-time evolution. Weak gravitational lensing surveys probe the underlying matter distribution independently of galaxy bias. The Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope Lensing Survey (CFHTLenS), completed in 2012, used cosmic shear measurements to map matter overdensities, revealing shear fields γ ≈ 0.01 consistent with CDM halo profiles and large-scale power. Building on this, the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS) Legacy analysis in 2025, using the complete survey across 1347 square degrees, has delivered tomographic shear analyses showing matter clustering that matches CDM simulations with S_8 = σ_8 (Ω_m / 0.3)^{0.5} = 0.815^{+0.016}_{-0.021}, in strong agreement with Planck CMB constraints (0.73σ tension).^[29] These results affirm CDM's prediction of a web-like matter distribution, where lensing shear correlates with projected overdensities on scales >10 arcminutes. The cosmic web's filaments and voids further corroborate CDM on large scales. CDM models predict a filament-dominated structure with interconnected walls and underdense voids, as quantified by topological statistics. Observations from the VIPERS survey detect this web-like morphology at z ≈ 0.7-1.0, with void statistics aligning with CDM expectations, showing underdensities spanning tens of Mpc that evolve as predicted by N-body simulations.^[30] These features underscore CDM's success in reproducing the observed anisotropy and connectivity of large-scale structure.

Cosmic Microwave Background Constraints

The cosmic microwave background (CMB) provides some of the tightest constraints on cold dark matter (CDM) through its temperature and polarization anisotropies, which encode information about the early universe's matter composition and dynamics. In the standard CDM paradigm, CDM and baryons dominate the gravitational potential wells that drive acoustic oscillations in the pre-recombination plasma. These oscillations manifest as peaks in the CMB angular power spectrum C_\ell^{TT}, with the first acoustic peak at multipole \ell \approx 220 corresponding to an angular scale of \theta \approx 0.6^\circ, determined by the sound horizon at recombination. Higher-order peaks reveal the interplay between CDM and baryons: CDM suppresses the odd-even peak alternation by enhancing even peaks through its gravitational influence, while the damping tail at \ell \gtrsim 1000 arises from Silk damping, where photon diffusion erases small-scale fluctuations. These features robustly confirm the presence of non-relativistic matter, with CDM comprising the majority, as deviations would shift peak positions and amplitudes inconsistent with observations.^[18] High-precision measurements from the Planck satellite, combining temperature-temperature (TT), temperature-polarization (TE), and polarization-polarization (EE) power spectra along with low-\ell polarization data, yield stringent parameter estimates that anchor the CDM density. Specifically, the CDM density parameter is constrained to \Omega_c h^2 = 0.120 \pm 0.001 at 68% confidence level, while the scalar spectral index is n_s = 0.965 \pm 0.004, supporting nearly scale-invariant adiabatic primordial perturbations as predicted in CDM models. These values are derived from Markov chain Monte Carlo fits to the \LambdaCDM model, where the CDM component ensures the observed peak structure and overall normalization without invoking significant isocurvature modes. The precision of these constraints, at the percent level, underscores CDM's role as the primary non-baryonic matter driving the universe's expansion history and structure seeds visible in the CMB.^[18] CMB polarization further refines CDM constraints, particularly through E-mode patterns that trace the same acoustic physics as temperature anisotropies but with higher sensitivity to early-universe conditions. The EE power spectrum peaks prominently at \ell \approx 1000, reflecting compressed baryon oscillations influenced by CDM's gravitational pull, and aligns closely with \LambdaCDM predictions from Planck data. Tensor modes, probed via B-mode polarization, remain undetected, with BICEP/Keck observations through the 2018 season imposing an upper limit of r < 0.036 at 95% confidence level on the tensor-to-scalar ratio, consistent with CDM's expectation of low primordial gravitational wave amplitude. This limit, combined with Planck, reinforces the simplicity of the CDM framework without needing substantial tensor contributions.^[18]^[31] Despite these successes, the CMB-derived Hubble constant H_0 = 67.4 \pm 0.5 km/s/Mpc from Planck exhibits a ~5\sigma tension with local measurements like SH0ES, which report H_0 = 73.04 \pm 1.04 km/s/Mpc. Extensions to CDM, such as early dark energy or varying dark energy equations of state, can partially alleviate this discrepancy by altering the sound horizon and recombination dynamics, raising inferred H_0 values toward local estimates while preserving core CMB features like acoustic peaks. However, these modifications do not resolve the tension fully, and the standard CDM model continues to provide an excellent fit to CMB data overall.^[18]^[32]^[33]

Challenges and Tensions

Small-Scale Structure Discrepancies

One of the key challenges to the cold dark matter (CDM) paradigm arises on small scales, where N-body simulations predict structures that exceed observational counts and differ in density profiles from those inferred in dwarf galaxies. These discrepancies, known as the core-cusp and missing satellites problems, highlight tensions between theoretical expectations and empirical data, particularly in low-mass dark matter halos around galaxies like the Milky Way.^[34] The core-cusp problem stems from CDM simulations, which consistently produce dark matter halos with central density profiles following the Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW) form, where the density ρ(r) scales as r^{-1} in the inner regions.^[35] In contrast, rotation curve observations of dwarf galaxies reveal much shallower profiles, often consistent with constant-density cores. For instance, data from the THINGS survey of nearby dwarf galaxies, including NGC 6822, indicate inner density slopes of approximately ρ(r) ∝ r^{-0.2}, derived from high-resolution HI mapping that corrects for noncircular motions.^[36] This mismatch persists even after accounting for baryonic effects in some models, suggesting that standard CDM overpredicts the central concentrations of low-mass halos, though recent simulations incorporating feedback partially alleviate it.^[37] The missing satellites problem further underscores the excess small-scale structure in CDM. Simulations forecast approximately 100–1000 subhalos with masses exceeding 10^7 M_⊙ orbiting a Milky Way-like galaxy, based on hierarchical merging scenarios.^[38] However, observations as of 2025 have identified approximately 60 satellite galaxies around the Milky Way, including ultra-faint dwarfs from surveys like DES and Gaia. Explanations invoking dynamical processes, such as tidal stripping during orbital decay, have been proposed to disrupt or render subhalos undetectable, but these mechanisms alone prove insufficient to reconcile the predicted abundance with the observed scarcity, as many subhalos remain bound and luminous enough to detect; baryonic effects may suppress star formation in some.^[39] Related to this is the overabundance of faint dwarf galaxies in CDM predictions compared to the observed luminosity function. High-resolution simulations like the Aquarius Project reveal a subhalo mass function dn/dm ∝ m^{-1.9}, implying a steep increase in the number of low-mass systems below 10^9 M_⊙ that should host faint dwarfs.^[40] Observations of Milky Way satellites, however, show a luminosity function φ(L) ∝ L^{-1.9} that flattens with a sharp cutoff for absolute magnitudes fainter than M_V ≈ -8, indicating far fewer ultra-faint systems than expected.^[34] This discrepancy persists despite improved surveys, pointing to potential suppression mechanisms in galaxy formation not fully captured by pure CDM dynamics.

Galactic Dynamics and Morphology Issues

One notable tension in the cold dark matter (CDM) paradigm arises from the distribution of satellite galaxies around host galaxies like the Milky Way. CDM simulations predict that subhalo orbits should be roughly isotropic, reflecting the spherical collapse of dark matter halos during structure formation. However, observations reveal a striking planar alignment among the classical satellite galaxies of the Milky Way, known as the Disc of Satellites (DoS), which exhibits a thickness of approximately 10° and includes structures like the Magellanic Plane. This configuration is statistically rare in CDM models, occurring in less than 3% of simulated Milky Way-like systems as of recent assessments, suggesting a potential mismatch between predicted and observed satellite dynamics.^[41]^[42] Another dynamical issue concerns the prevalence of high-velocity dwarf galaxies in the Local Group. CDM simulations typically underpredict the number of fast-moving dwarf satellites, which require rare merger events or specific accretion histories to explain their kinematics. Observations indicate an excess of such high-velocity systems compared to expectations from standard CDM hydrodynamical simulations, challenging the model's ability to reproduce the full velocity distribution of Local Group members without invoking fine-tuned conditions.^[43]^[44] CDM also faces challenges in explaining the rotation speeds of galactic bars in spiral galaxies. In CDM halos, dynamical friction from the dark matter component is expected to slow bar pattern speeds to values below 0.2 times the circular speed at the solar radius (Ω_b < 0.2 Ω_0), leading to slow-rotating bars in simulations. Yet, kinematic measurements of observed bars, such as in NGC 1300, yield pattern speeds of Ω_b ≈ 0.3–0.5 Ω_0, indicating faster rotation that implies lower central dark matter densities than predicted by CDM. This discrepancy persists across multiple cosmological hydrodynamical simulations, highlighting a tension in bar evolution within CDM frameworks.^[45]^[46] Finally, the morphology of disk galaxies presents a morphological challenge for CDM. Hierarchical merging in CDM favors the formation of bulge-dominated systems through frequent minor mergers that drive gas inflows and violent starbursts, predicting that most massive galaxies should host prominent classical bulges. However, observations show that a significant fraction (around 10-20% pure bulgeless, higher including those with pseudo-bulges) of late-type disk galaxies (Sb-Sc) are bulgeless or nearly so, with pure exponential disks dominating their light profiles. This abundance of bulgeless giants, confirmed through deep imaging of nearby spirals, underscores a difficulty in CDM's merger-driven picture of galaxy assembly without additional regulatory mechanisms like strong feedback.^[47]^[43]

High-Redshift Galaxy Formation Problems

Recent observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) have revealed unexpectedly massive and structured galaxies at redshifts greater than 10, posing significant challenges to the standard cold dark matter (CDM) paradigm for early cosmic structure formation.^[48] In particular, the galaxy JADES-GS-z14-0, spectroscopically confirmed at z ≈ 14.18 (refined from initial 14.32), exhibits a stellar mass of approximately 10^9 M_⊙ and prominent [O III] emission, indicating substantial star formation activity that likely began by z ≈ 15, or less than 300 million years after the Big Bang.^[49]^[50]^[51] This detection of oxygen emission, with a line luminosity of (2.1 ± 0.5) × 10^8 L_⊙, suggests rapid metal enrichment and efficient star formation in a young system, far exceeding expectations for such an early epoch.^[50] Another example is the galaxy CEERS-93316 at z ≈ 8.7, which displays a bursty star formation history (SFH) characterized by intense, episodic bursts rather than steady growth, contributing to its high luminosity and mass assembly.^[52] These bursty SFHs, common in low-mass, high-redshift systems as seen in JADES survey data, imply variable feedback processes that accelerate stellar buildup beyond smooth accretion models.^[53] Such observations highlight a tension, as the hierarchical merging in CDM predicts slower structure growth at these redshifts, though refined models with bursty feedback are being explored.^[54] In the CDM framework, the hierarchical model anticipates that dark matter halos at z = 10–15 would support stellar masses M_* ≲ 10^8 M_⊙ due to limited halo growth rates and feedback suppression.^[48] Accretion onto these early halos is capped by the Eddington limit at approximately 100 M_⊙/yr, restricting rapid mass assembly and favoring gradual buildup through minor mergers.^[48] However, the observed galaxies like JADES-GS-z14-0 surpass these limits, requiring star formation efficiencies or merger rates that strain standard CDM merger trees. The ultraviolet (UV) luminosity function (LF) at z ≈ 10 further underscores this discrepancy, with observed number densities φ(M_UV) for bright galaxies (M_UV < -20) exceeding CDM-based predictions by a factor of approximately 10.^[55] Pre-JWST simulations aligned with CDM underpredicted the abundance of such luminous sources, suggesting that early star formation was more efficient than anticipated.^[55] These findings imply potential adjustments to the initial power spectrum or enhanced bursty feedback mechanisms to reconcile observations with CDM, though the core hierarchical assembly process struggles to account for the observed rapid galaxy maturation at high redshifts.^[48]^[52] While astrophysical effects like variable stellar initial mass functions may alleviate some tension, the prevalence of massive systems at z > 10 remains a key challenge for the model.^[55]

Modifications and Alternatives

Self-Interacting and Fuzzy Dark Matter

Self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) proposes that dark matter particles experience elastic scattering with a cross-section per unit mass \sigma/m in the range of approximately 0.1 to 10 cm^2/g, which is strong enough on small scales to thermalize particles within halos but negligible on large scales. This interaction leads to energy transfer that flattens central density profiles, transforming the cuspy \rho \propto r^{-1} profiles predicted by standard cold dark matter into cored structures with nearly flat (constant density) central profiles, \rho \approx constant for small r. Originally motivated as a way to address discrepancies like the core-cusp problem in galactic centers, SIDM can arise in weakly interacting massive particle models through light mediators that enhance interactions via mechanisms such as Sommerfeld enhancement. Fuzzy dark matter (FDM), also known as wave dark matter, consists of ultralight bosonic particles, such as axions, with masses around m \sim 10^{-22} eV, resulting in a de Broglie wavelength \lambda_\mathrm{dB} \sim 1 kpc at typical halo velocities. This quantum nature introduces an effective pressure that resists gravitational collapse on scales below \lambda_\mathrm{dB}, suppressing the formation of cusps and instead producing solitonic cores in halo centers, while wave interference interferes with small-scale structure formation to smooth out subhalos. FDM models thus provide a quantum mechanical alternative to classical particle interactions for resolving small-scale issues in cold dark matter paradigms. Numerical simulations of SIDM demonstrate that cross-sections \sigma/m \approx 1-2 cm^2/g produce cores matching observations from the THINGS survey of nearby dwarf galaxies at radii r < 1 kpc, where rotation curves indicate flat density profiles. For FDM, simulations predict a suppression of halo formation below masses of approximately $10^7 M_\odot, creating a gap that reduces the abundance of small subhalos and helps alleviate the missing satellites problem without overproducing them. Observational constraints from the Bullet Cluster merger limit central \sigma/m < 1 cm^2/g based on the separation between dark matter and baryonic components, though velocity-dependent cross-sections or offsets in dwarf systems allow higher values consistent with local observations. As of 2025, updated analyses from cluster lensing continue to refine these models, with ongoing debates on their ability to fully resolve small-scale tensions.^[56]

Other Extensions to CDM

Modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) proposes an alternative to dark matter by modifying Newton's laws of gravity at low accelerations, specifically below a characteristic scale of a_0 \approx 1.2 \times 10^{-10} m/s², where the effective gravitational force transitions from Newtonian to a square-root dependence on acceleration. This modification successfully reproduces galactic rotation curves without invoking unseen mass, but it encounters significant challenges on larger scales, such as failing to account for the dynamics of galaxy clusters, which require additional unseen components, and inconsistencies with cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies predicted by general relativity.^[57] To address these shortcomings while retaining MOND's galactic successes, hybrid models incorporate massive neutrinos as a hot dark matter component within a νΛCDM framework, where neutrinos contribute to cluster-scale gravity and large-scale structure formation without fully replacing cold dark matter. Primordial black holes (PBHs) emerge as another extension, potentially comprising all or part of cold dark matter if formed from high-density fluctuations during the inflationary epoch in the early universe. PBHs with masses below approximately $10^{15} g would evaporate rapidly via Hawking radiation, disrupting the cosmic microwave background if they constitute a significant fraction of dark matter, thus constraining their abundance in that regime. Recent microlensing surveys, such as those conducted by the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE) in the 2020s, have placed stringent limits on PBH fractions in the asteroid-mass window (around $10^{14}–$10^{17} g), with f_{\rm PBH} < 0.1 for masses near $10^{-10} M_\odot, indicating that PBHs alone cannot fully explain dark matter but may contribute as a hybrid component.^[58] Warm-inflaton dark matter models extend the cold dark matter paradigm by leveraging the inflaton field from warm inflation scenarios, where dissipative effects produce radiation during inflation, allowing the inflaton to transition into a cold dark matter candidate post-reheating with an effective particle mass in the keV range. Hybrid warm dark matter–cold dark matter (WDM-CDM) frameworks incorporate this to introduce a cutoff in the matter power spectrum at small scales, suppressing excessive structure formation; though JWST observations of unexpectedly massive galaxies at high redshifts (z > 10) challenge standard CDM predictions of slower early growth. Models with effective masses around a few keV face additional constraints from these data, as they further suppress small-scale structure formation without conflicting with large-scale cosmic microwave background data.^[59] Baryonic feedback processes offer a non-particle extension by modifying dark matter distributions through astrophysical effects rather than altering the underlying cosmology. In hydrodynamic simulations like the Feedback In Realistic Environments (FIRE-2) suite, enhanced supernova and active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback drive outflows that heat and redistribute dark matter particles in dwarf galaxy halos, transforming central cusps into shallower cores consistent with observations, without requiring changes to the cold dark matter particle properties. However, these baryonic effects prove insufficient to fully resolve discrepancies in the satellite galaxy populations around Milky Way-like systems, as they do not suppress the formation of low-mass halos on larger scales effectively enough to match the observed scarcity of satellites. As of 2025, updated analyses from JWST and cluster lensing continue to refine these models, with ongoing debates on their ability to fully resolve small-scale tensions.

References

[1]
Dark Matter - NASA Science
cold dark matter made up of slow-moving particles and warm or hot dark matter made of faster- ...Building Blocks · NASA’s Roman to Peer Into... · NASA’s Roman Mission...
[2]
[1306.0913] Cold dark matter: controversies on small scales - arXiv
Jun 4, 2013 · The cold dark matter (CDM) cosmological model has been remarkably successful in explaining cosmic structure over an enormous span of redshift.
[3]
Hubble Sees Early Building Blocks of Today's Galaxies
Sep 4, 1996 · If the dark matter is "cold," meaning that its random motions are much slower than the speed of light, it tends to form structure from the ...
[4]
CDM Density - Nasa Lambda
In ΛCDM, most of the Large Scale Structure in the universe is associated with cold dark matter. Dark matter is not easily detected, but its presence is inferred ...
[5]
[0906.4340] The structure and evolution of cold dark matter halos
Jun 23, 2009 · Abstract: In the standard cosmological model a mysterious cold dark matter (CDM) component dominates the formation of structures.
[6]
https://doi.org/10.1038/311517a0
[7]
[PDF] 27. Dark Matter - Particle Data Group
Dec 1, 2023 · Modern cosmological models invariably include an electromagnetically close-to-neutral, non- baryonic matter species with negligible velocity ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[8]
[PDF] Dark matter and cosmic structure - arXiv
Oct 1, 2012 · Dark matter, a weakly interacting particle, amplifies gravitational forces, forming halos that stabilize galaxy disks and are a key part of the ...
[9]
[hep-ph/9303287] Sterile Neutrinos as Dark Matter - arXiv
Mar 22, 1993 · We reexamine this model and find that the sterile neutrinos can be either hot, warm, or cold dark matter. Since their only direct coupling is to ...
[10]
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9303287
[11]
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1970ApJ...159..379R/abstract
[12]
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1982ApJ...263L...1P/abstract
[13]
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1984Natur.311..517B/abstract
[14]
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1985ApJ...292..371D/abstract
[15]
[astro-ph/9805201] Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an ...
May 15, 1998 · Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant. Authors:Adam G. Riess, Alexei V. Filippenko, ...Missing: primary | Show results with:primary
[16]
[astro-ph/0302209] First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy ...
Feb 11, 2003 · ... sigma_8=0.84+-0.04. WMAP's best determination of tau=0.17+-0.04 ... The WMAP detection of early reionization rules out warm dark matter.Missing: cold | Show results with:cold
[17]
[1807.06209] Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters - arXiv
Jul 17, 2018 · Abstract:We present cosmological parameter results from the final full-mission Planck measurements of the CMB anisotropies.
[18]
[astro-ph/0501171] Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in ... - arXiv
Jan 10, 2005 · Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale Correlation Function of SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies. Authors:D. J. Eisenstein, I. Zehavi ...
[19]
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0501171
[20]
[PDF] An Approximate Theory for Large Density Perturbations
An approximate solution is given for the problem of the growth of perturbations during the expansion of matter without pressure.
[21]
https://www.giss.nasa.gov/staff/mway/cluster/zeldovich.pdf
[22]
[PDF] 1974ApJ. . .187. .425P The Astrophysical Journal, 187:425-438 ...
FORMATION OF GALAXIES AND CLUSTERS OF GALAXIES BY. SELF-SIMILAR GRAVITATIONAL CONDENSATION*. William H. Press and Paul Schechter.
[23]
[PDF] 27. Dark Matter - Particle Data Group
May 31, 2024 · “weakly-interacting massive particles”, or WIMPs have gained exceptional popularity. ... WIMP candidates. For more details see the the ...
[24]
XENONnT WIMP search: Signal and background modeling and ...
The XENONnT experiment aims to detect a signal from weakly interacting massive particles (WIMPs) elastically scattering off xenon nuclei with a detector ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[25]
[1807.07938] Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter - arXiv
Jul 20, 2018 · We review sterile neutrinos as possible Dark Matter candidates. After a short summary on the role of neutrinos in cosmology and particle physics.
[26]
Primordial black holes as a dark matter candidate - a brief overview
Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) fulfil all of the necessary requirements to be a good dark matter (DM) candidate. They are cold, non-baryonic and stable, ...
[27]
KiDS-1000 Cosmology: Multi-probe weak gravitational lensing and ...
We present a joint cosmological analysis of weak gravitational lensing observations from the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS-1000), with redshift-space galaxy ...
[28]
VIMOS Public Extragalactic Redshift Survey (VIPERS): galaxy ...
We use simulations to show the capability of VIPERS to recover robust topological features in the galaxy distribution, in particular the filamentary network. We ...
[29]
Improved limits on the tensor-to-scalar ratio using BICEP and Planck
Dec 15, 2021 · We present constraints on the tensor-to-scalar ratio r using a combination of BICEP/Keck 2018 and Planck PR4 data allowing us to fit for r consistently.Missing: upper | Show results with:upper
[30]
[2112.04510] A Comprehensive Measurement of the Local ... - arXiv
Dec 8, 2021 · A Comprehensive Measurement of the Local Value of the Hubble Constant with 1 km/s/Mpc Uncertainty from the Hubble Space Telescope and the SH0ES ...Missing: 2023 | Show results with:2023
[31]
In the realm of the Hubble tension—a review of solutions - IOPscience
A thorough review of the problem including a discussion of recent Hubble constant estimates and a summary of the proposed theoretical solutions is presented ...
[32]
THE OBSERVED PROPERTIES OF DWARF GALAXIES IN AND ...
ABSTRACT. Positional, structural, and dynamical parameters for all dwarf galaxies in and around the Local Group are presented, and various aspects of our ...
[33]
A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering - IOPscience
A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering. Julio F. Navarro, Carlos S. Frenk, and Simon D. M. White.Missing: NFW | Show results with:NFW
[34]
THE CENTRAL SLOPE OF DARK MATTER CORES IN DWARF ...
Jun 9, 2011 · The error bars for NGC 6822 and NGC 3109 come from the different mass models that Valenzuela et al. (2007) considered for these galaxies to ...
[35]
The Core‐Cusp Problem - de Blok - 2010 - Advances in Astronomy
Nov 25, 2009 · This paper gives an overview of the attempts to determine the distribution of dark matter in low surface brightness disk and gas-rich dwarf galaxies.
[36]
[astro-ph/9901240] Where are the missing galactic satellites? - arXiv
We conclude, therefore, that unless a large fraction of the Local Group satellites has been missed in observations, there is a dramatic discrepancy.Missing: CDM | Show results with:CDM
[37]
Predictably missing satellites: subhalo abundances in Milky Way ...
Apr 17, 2019 · The 'missing satellites problem' infamously describes the overabundance of subhaloes from CDM simulations compared to the number of satellites ...
[38]
Aquarius Project: the subhaloes of galactic haloes - Oxford Academic
Simulations of the same object differing in mass resolution by factors of up to 1800 accurately reproduce the largest subhaloes with the same mass, maximum ...
[39]
[1802.02579] The Planes of Satellite Galaxies Problem, Suggested ...
Feb 7, 2018 · The Planes of Satellite Galaxies Problem, Suggested Solutions, and Open Questions. Authors:Marcel S. Pawlowski.Missing: disc | Show results with:disc
[40]
A New Rarity Assessment of the “Disk of Satellites”: The Milky Way ...
Nov 27, 2024 · The majority of satellite galaxies around the Milky Way (MW) show disk-like distributions (the disk of satellites; DoS), which is a small-scale problem of the ...
[41]
[1707.04256] Small-Scale Challenges to the $Λ$CDM Paradigm
Jul 13, 2017 · The dark energy plus cold dark matter (\LambdaCDM) cosmological model has been a demonstrably successful framework for predicting and explaining ...
[42]
Dynamical history of the Local Group in ΛCDM - Oxford Academic
Abstract. The positions and velocities of galaxies in the Local Group (LG) measure the gravitational field within it. This is mostly due to the Milky Way (Missing: CDM | Show results with:CDM
[43]
[PDF] Fast galaxy bars continue to challenge standard cosmology
Apr 29, 2023 · The actual pattern speeds p of galactic bars can thus in principle provide an important test of the CDM picture. Since galaxies come in a range ...
[44]
Revisiting the tension between fast bars and the $Λ$CDM paradigm
Nov 27, 2020 · The pattern speed with which galactic bars rotate is intimately linked to the amount of dark matter in the inner regions of their host galaxies.Missing: problem | Show results with:problem
[45]
BULGELESS GIANT GALAXIES CHALLENGE OUR PICTURE OF ...
Recognition of pseudobulges makes the biggest problem with cold dark matter galaxy formation more acute: How can hierarchical clustering make so many giant ...
[46]
Stress testing ΛCDM with high-redshift galaxy candidates - Nature
Apr 13, 2023 · Here I show that the most massive galaxy candidates in JWST observations at z ≈ 7–10 lie at the very edge of these limits, indicating an important unresolved ...
[47]
Spectroscopic confirmation of two luminous galaxies at a redshift of 14
Jul 29, 2024 · This discovery proves that luminous galaxies were already in place 300 million years after the Big Bang and are more common than what was expected before JWST.
[48]
Detection of [O iii]88 μm in JADES-GS-z14-0 at z = 14.1793
No dust continuum from GS-z14 is detected, suggesting an upper limit on the dust-to-stellar mass ratio of <2 × 10−3, consistent with dust production from ...
[49]
bursty star formation and its implications for observations of high ...
We examine the implications of bursty star formation histories for observations of high-redshift galaxies with JWST.
[50]
JADES: Differing assembly histories of galaxies
We found that high-redshift and low-mass galaxies have particularly bursty SFHs, while more massive and lower-redshift systems evolve more steadily.
[51]
A comparison of pre-existing ΛCDM predictions with the abundance ...
Here, we compare the rest-frame ultraviolet luminosity functions derived from JWST observations with those predicted by the Cowley et al. model up to z = 14.
[52]
[2207.10638] Astrophysical Tests of Dark Matter Self-Interactions
Jul 21, 2022 · This review provides a comprehensive explanation of the physical effects of dark matter self-interactions in objects ranging from galactic satellites (dark and ...Missing: seminal | Show results with:seminal
[53]
Modified Newtonian Dynamics: Observational Successes and Failures
May 27, 2025 · Abstract page for arXiv paper 2505.21638: Modified Newtonian Dynamics: Observational Successes and Failures.
[54]
Limits on Planetary-mass Primordial Black Holes from the OGLE ...
However, in recent years, some authors suggested that planetary-mass primordial black holes (PBHs) comprising a substantial fraction (1%–10%) of the dark matter ...Missing: asteroid window <0.1 2020s
[55]
[2303.14239] Warm dark matter constraints from the JWST - arXiv
Mar 24, 2023 · Warm Dark Matter (WDM) particles with masses (\sim kilo electronvolt) offer an attractive solution to the small-scale issues faced by the Cold Dark Matter (CDM ...Missing: inflaton hybrid effective few