Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Donald Findlay

Donald Russell Findlay KC (born 17 March 1951) is a Scottish advocate renowned for his extensive practice as a criminal defence lawyer, handling high-profile cases over more than four decades. Educated at Harris Academy in Dundee, the University of Dundee, and the University of Glasgow, he was admitted to the Faculty of Advocates in 1975 and has been recognized as one of Scotland's preeminent defence counsel. Findlay has served in prominent roles beyond the courtroom, including as vice-chairman of Rangers F.C. until his resignation in 1999, chairman of Cowdenbeath F.C., and Rector of the University of St Andrews from 1993 to 1999. His public profile includes controversies stemming from expressions of Protestant loyalist sentiments, such as being filmed in 1999 singing songs like The Sash—an Orange Order anthem—and Follow Follow at a Rangers celebration, which prompted backlash, a fine from the Law Society of Scotland, and his departure from the Rangers board despite defenses of cultural tradition over bigotry.

Early Life and Education

Family Background and Upbringing

Donald Findlay was born on 17 March 1951 in , , , to a working-class family in a former mining community. His father served as a church beadle, a role indicative of the family's Protestant heritage and involvement in local Presbyterian traditions amid 's sectarian cultural landscape. The family resided initially at 171 Perth Road in , adjacent to a jelly factory, before relocating when Findlay was around six or seven years old. This early environment, characterized by industrial grit and community solidarity, instilled values of resilience, as Findlay later reflected on his father's sharp intellect thwarted by socioeconomic constraints in post-war . Findlay's formative exposure to legal concepts came through popular media and notable events; as a young child, he was drawn to the courtroom drama of the 1950s television series Boyd Q.C., viewed on the family's bulky set with its small screen. Concurrently, the sensational 1958 trial of in heightened his fascination with , mirroring the era's public engrossment in high-stakes advocacy.

Academic and Professional Training

Findlay studied law at the , obtaining his (LLB) degree in the early 1970s. Following his university education, he undertook the standard training pathway for aspiring Scottish lawyers, which at the time involved an with a firm of solicitors to gain practical experience in legal practice before pursuing . This preparatory phase equipped him with foundational skills in areas such as , litigation preparation, and client advisory work, as was typical for those transitioning from solicitor training to the bar. In 1975, Findlay was admitted as an to the Scottish Bar through the Faculty of Advocates, a process that demanded successful completion of rigorous entrance examinations in legal subjects and a period of devilry—supervised practical training akin to —under an established advocate. The Faculty's selection criteria emphasize intellectual aptitude, ethical standards, and courtroom readiness, ensuring only a limited number of candidates advance annually to maintain the profession's exacting standards.

Legal Career

Admission to the Bar and Early Cases

Findlay was admitted to the Faculty of Advocates in Scotland in 1975, marking the start of his professional career as an advocate specializing in criminal defense. Following admission, he concentrated on criminal law matters, developing proficiency in common law offenses such as murder, assault, and theft, which form the core of Scotland's indictable crime framework under its mixed legal system. Over the subsequent decade, Findlay handled a substantial volume of criminal cases in the and sheriff courts, gaining recognition among peers for meticulous case preparation, including detailed scrutiny of evidence and witness testimonies. This early workload established his courtroom reputation for commanding presence and persuasive advocacy, attributes noted by contemporaries as instrumental to his rapid professional ascent. In 1988, Findlay was appointed Queen's Counsel (QC), a distinction awarded by the Lord Justice General on recommendation from the Faculty of Advocates, reflecting acknowledgment of his expertise and standing after approximately 13 years of practice. The silk appointment enabled him to lead more complex defenses and underscored his foundational command of procedural and substantive principles.

High-Profile Criminal Defenses

Findlay has defended clients in numerous high-profile murder and culpable homicide trials, earning recognition for his rigorous examination of prosecution evidence and exploitation of Scottish legal verdicts such as "." One of his most notable successes occurred in the 1992 trial of Paul Ferris, accused of the gangland murder of Arthur Thompson Jr. in 1991, along with six other charges including ; after a 54-day trial in —the longest and most expensive in Scottish history at £4 million—Ferris was acquitted on all counts, with Findlay's of over 300 witnesses credited for undermining the Crown's case reliant on informant . In another significant case, Findlay represented Alan Morrison in 2002 for the alleged murder of his infant son Alan on October 7, 1998, by shaking; the jury returned a not guilty verdict after Findlay challenged the forensic and medical evidence linking the father's actions to the child's death, highlighting inconsistencies in expert testimony on . More recently, in the 2020 High Court trial of Callum Owens for the of 13-year-old Grace Handling, Findlay secured a "not proven" verdict by rigorously probing witness reliability and evidential gaps, later defending the verdict's utility in cases of doubt despite public criticism. These outcomes underscore Findlay's mastery of Scotland's three-verdict system, where "not proven" allows juries to express insufficient proof without full . Findlay's approach in such trials emphasizes adaptive without notes, starting with measured questioning to build before intensifying to expose contradictions, as seen in his handling of hostile witnesses in prosecutions. He prioritizes empirical scrutiny of , forensic reports, and alibis, often dismantling prosecution narratives through logical inconsistencies rather than attacks, a method he attributes to ensuring procedural fairness even in overwhelming cases. This tactical precision has positioned him as having defended more accused than any other Scottish advocate.

Professional Milestones and Recognition

Donald Findlay was admitted to the Faculty of Advocates in 1975, commencing a distinguished career in Scottish that reached 50 years by July 2025. He attained the rank of Queen's Counsel in 1988, a designation reflecting his standing among senior advocates specializing in complex . In 1993, Findlay was elected Rector of the University of St Andrews, serving until 1999 and engaging in the institution's governance and student advocacy during that period. He later assumed leadership roles within the profession, including election as Chairman of the Faculty of Advocates Criminal Bar Association in June 2010, where he represented interests of criminal practitioners amid evolving legal aid and procedural challenges. Findlay holds the distinction of Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts (F.R.S.A.), underscoring broader recognition of his contributions to professional discourse. Throughout his tenure, he has been acknowledged by legal peers and media as possessing unrivalled expertise in forensic applications to criminal trials, honed over thousands of cases.

Controversies

1999 Sectarian Songs Incident

In late May 1999, shortly after Rangers Football Club's victory in the Scottish Cup final, Donald Findlay, then the club's vice-chairman, attended a private end-of-season celebration at a Glasgow hotel. During the event, he was secretly filmed leading players and supporters in singing "The Sash," a traditional Protestant anthem, along with a medley of other songs containing lyrics widely interpreted as anti-Catholic, such as references to the Famine Song. The amateur video, captured without Findlay's knowledge, was subsequently passed to the Daily Record newspaper. The Daily Record published the story on 31 May 1999, igniting immediate public outrage across , where longstanding Protestant-Catholic divides, particularly between Rangers and supporters, remain sensitive. Media outlets, including the and , covered the incident extensively, framing it as emblematic of persistent in Scottish and , with critics decrying Findlay's behavior as unbecoming of a prominent Queen's Counsel and public figure. Calls emerged for his from the , citing potential damage to the Faculty of Advocates' reputation. Findlay resigned as Rangers vice-chairman later that day, 31 May 1999, stating that his actions had embarrassed the club. No criminal charges were filed, and while the Faculty of Advocates launched an investigation into professional misconduct, initial responses focused on reputational fallout rather than immediate formal sanctions, allowing Findlay to continue his legal practice pending review.

Orange Order Involvement and Public Criticism

In May 1999, following Rangers Football Club's victory in the and , Donald Findlay, then vice-chairman of the club, attended a private celebratory party organized by a Rangers supporters' group in . During the event, he was secretly filmed singing "The Sash," a traditional Protestant anthem closely associated with the , which commemorates the 1690 and symbolizes Ulster Protestant heritage. He also performed "," a Rangers supporters' song containing lyrics interpreted by critics as anti-Catholic, such as references to "Fenian blood." This footage, leaked to the media, symbolized Findlay's affinity for cultural expressions, prompting immediate condemnation for allegedly endorsing sectarian division in a modern, multicultural . The incident drew sharp rebukes from institutional elites, including Rangers' owner David Murray, who demanded Findlay's resignation from the vice-chairmanship on May 30, 1999, citing damage to the club's image amid efforts to distance itself from religious bigotry. The Faculty of Advocates, Scotland's professional body for barristers, investigated Findlay for professional misconduct, resulting in a £3,500 fine in November 1999 for breaching standards of conduct expected of a Queen's Counsel. Media outlets, including outlets with established progressive leanings, framed the episode as evidence of entrenched Protestant supremacism, amplifying calls for Findlay to step back from public roles despite his prominence as a Tory supporter and defender in high-profile cases. Critics argued that such displays by a figure of Findlay's stature normalized hatred toward Catholics and Irish nationalists, exacerbating Scotland's historic tribal divides rather than fostering integration. Findlay's defenders, including some within Rangers supporter circles, contended that the response represented an overreach by bodies intolerant of private expressions of cultural loyalty to Protestant traditions, which they viewed as benign rather than active . He issued an unreserved through his lawyers, acknowledging a "serious error of judgment" in a personal context, but emphasized that his actions did not reflect professional bias or impair his ability to represent clients impartially. The controversy highlighted tensions between preserving historic symbols of Unionist —often marginalized in —and accusations of fostering exclusion, with Findlay's case illustrating disproportionate applied to Protestant-affiliated expressions compared to analogous Irish republican anthems. No formal membership has been publicly confirmed for Findlay, though the anthem's performance underscored his alignment with its cultural ethos amid broader criticism of the organization's influence in Scottish .

Broader Accusations of Sectarianism

In 2005, Findlay faced criticism for telling a joke about the recently deceased during a speech at a Rangers supporters' club dinner in . The remark, described by witnesses as involving anti-Catholic elements, prompted calls for his from the position of treasurer at the Scottish Council of Law Reporting, though he ultimately retained the role amid debates over free speech. Findlay defended the incident by stating that he had repeated similar jokes at the same event for several years without prior complaint, framing it as longstanding banter within a specific cultural context rather than targeted malice. Further allegations surfaced in 2007 when Findlay was reported to the Faculty of Advocates for telling two jokes deemed sectarian at another Rangers supporters' club function, one involving simulated pipe smoke and coughing in reference to a , and another referencing the . He denied the jokes were offensive, arguing they did not meet the threshold for professional misconduct and invoking protections for expression. A ultimately cleared him, finding insufficient evidence of unacceptable behavior, despite portrayals highlighting Scotland's entrenched Protestant-Catholic divides as a backdrop for such scrutiny. These episodes drew attention to a pattern of reported sectarian humor in Findlay's social engagements with Rangers-affiliated groups, yet no formal complaints emerged from his clients—many of whom included individuals from diverse religious backgrounds in high-stakes criminal defenses—indicating that professional relationships remained unaffected by the public controversies. Critics attributed this absence to selective media focus on Protestant expressions amid broader Scottish sectarian tensions, where similar Catholic-oriented rhetoric often evaded equivalent outrage, while Findlay and supporters contended that such jokes reflected historical cultural friction rather than . No disciplinary fines or suspensions resulted from the 2005 or 2007 incidents, contrasting with the penalty and underscoring inconsistencies in enforcement against private utterances in a society still grappling with legacy divisions from Ulster-linked migrations.

Personal Life and Reflections

Family and Private Life

Findlay has maintained a low public profile regarding his family and personal relationships, with limited verifiable details emerging despite his prominence in Scottish legal circles. He was married to Jenny until the mid-1990s, when their separation attracted media attention as he began a relationship with Paddy Christie, a BBC Scotland reporter. The relationship with Christie, which lasted approximately five years from around 1994 to 1999, also drew publicity but ended without further reported personal entanglements. No confirmed or reports indicate whether Findlay has children, reflecting his evident preference for discretion in private matters amid a career marked by intense scrutiny. This approach aligns with a broader pattern of shielding non-professional aspects of his life from media intrusion, with no subsequent personal scandals documented in reputable sources.

Toll of Legal Work on Well-Being

In a 2019 , Donald Findlay described the emotional strain of his defence work as occasionally distressing, particularly when reviewing involving extreme violence such as cases with dead children. He noted that after more than 40 years handling such material, the cumulative exposure required deliberate emotional hardening to maintain objectivity. Findlay reported experiencing persistent worry during trials, often carrying the burden home and second-guessing his performance following convictions, which underscored the psychological demands of high-stakes criminal . This self-reported anxiety highlighted the challenge of compartmentalizing professional responsibilities amid intense scrutiny. Reflecting on the broader human cost, he characterized "man’s inhumanity to man" as seemingly endless, necessitating a detached view of horrific details as mere to endure the role without . Despite these pressures, Findlay emphasized through professional discipline, viewing such fortitude as essential for sustained effectiveness in defence practice.

Views on Justice and Society

Critiques of Political Interference

In July 2023, Donald Findlay publicly accused the (SNP) government of pursuing system reforms primarily for "simple vote-gathering," thereby eroding established legal standards without substantive justification. He specifically criticized proposals to abolish the "not proven" verdict—one of Scotland's three possible outcomes alongside guilty and not guilty—asserting that the change lacked empirical grounding and risked undermining protections against miscarriages of . Findlay contended that these reforms, including broader alterations to court procedures, reflected a politicization of the judiciary where ideological priorities supplanted evidence-based , potentially leading to the "dismantling" of Scotland's historic legal framework. He argued for maintaining systems proven effective through historical application, warning that hasty changes driven by electoral motives could compromise and sentencing integrity by introducing inconsistencies not supported by data on conviction rates or error reductions. Drawing on precedents like the 1908 murder case—where political and media pressures contributed to a wrongful conviction later quashed after nearly two decades—Findlay has highlighted the perils of allowing external influences to override rigorous evidentiary scrutiny in verdicts. In discussions of such historical injustices, he advocates prioritizing causal analysis of facts over reformist agendas, cautioning that similar dynamics in modern policy could revive vulnerabilities in .

Defense of Traditional Legal Principles

Findlay has consistently advocated for the retention of Scotland's unique "" verdict, describing it as a "great asset" that serves as an essential safeguard against wrongful convictions by allowing juries to acquit without requiring proof of innocence when falls short of the criminal standard. In practical application, this third has enabled acquittals in cases where prosecution , though suggestive, lacked the robustness for a "proven" finding, thereby preventing miscarriages of justice that could arise from binary guilty-or-not-guilty systems forcing convictions on marginal proofs; for instance, its use in high-profile trials has preserved the high threshold for guilt, aligning with empirical outcomes where verdicts correlate with unresolved evidential doubts rather than mere acquittals. He has warned that abolishing it risks eroding this protective mechanism, potentially leading to increased convictions based on insufficient , as juries might default to guilty under pressure from simplified options. Central to Findlay's defense of traditional principles is the advocate's ethical obligation to represent clients zealously, even those accused of heinous acts, grounded in the as a foundational bulwark against state overreach. This duty, akin to the cab-rank principle in Scottish advocacy practice, compels defense counsel to accept instructions without precondition on the client's guilt, ensuring that no one is deprived of rigorous representation solely due to the nature of charges, which upholds the adversarial system's integrity by testing prosecution cases to their limits. Findlay has emphasized that this role demands independence from public sentiment, prioritizing verifiable evidence over moral judgments, as exemplified in his approach to not requiring clients to confess guilt before mounting a defense, thereby preserving the accused's and the state's burden of proof. He rejects proposals to dilute evidentiary standards or verdicts under the guise of addressing specific social concerns, arguing that such alterations prioritize outcomes over the unyielding requirement for proof beyond , which has historically minimized erroneous convictions in Scotland's jurisdiction. By insisting on unaltered norms like corroboration and the option, Findlay privileges causal chains of factual evidence—direct witness testimony, forensic linkages, and absence of contradiction—over reforms that could lower thresholds to accommodate perceived imbalances, such as in certain crime categories, thereby maintaining the system's commitment to acquitting the factually unproven rather than convicting on probabilistic inclinations. This stance underscores his view that legal integrity demands resistance to expedient modifications, ensuring decisions rest on empirical substantiation rather than external pressures.

Recent Activities and Legacy

Ongoing High-Profile Trials

In 2024, Donald Findlay KC represented Finlay MacDonald in the trial concerning a shooting spree on the Isle of Skye on August 10, 2022, where MacDonald was charged with ing his brother-in-law John MacKinnon by discharging a at him multiple times in Teangue, and attempting to MacDonald's wife Fiona, her mother Eileen MacDonald, and osteopath Ross MacKinnon by shooting and stabbing. Findlay advanced a defense centered on MacDonald's post-arrest diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and , arguing that these conditions, combined with perceived humiliation and provocation from MacKinnon's mocking behavior during a prior family gathering, precipitated a "catastrophic" breakdown in an otherwise law-abiding individual with no prior convictions. Findlay contended that expert psychological evidence demonstrated MacDonald's actions stemmed from an acute crisis rather than premeditated intent, emphasizing how undiagnosed amplified his vulnerability to emotional triggers and impaired impulse control at the time of the incident. He highlighted the absence of prior violence in MacDonald's history, framing the events as a "genuine " explicable through neurodevelopmental factors rather than the prosecution's narrative of deliberate targeting, and urged the to consider these elements in assessing culpability. Despite these submissions, the convicted MacDonald of murder and the three attempted murders on November 29, 2024. Findlay's involvement in this case exemplified his ongoing engagement with complex defenses invoking mental health mitigations to contest Crown narratives in high-stakes proceedings, consistent with his post-2020 practice amid Scotland's .

Public Engagements and Commentary

In September 2025, Findlay participated in the Franco-British Lawyers Society's annual colloquium in , themed around historical miscarriages of justice such as the and the Oscar Slater case. He concluded the event with a dramatic re-enactment of Slater's 1909 trial in the original High Court courtroom, underscoring procedural flaws and evidential weaknesses that led to Slater's wrongful conviction for the Marion Gilchrist murder. This engagement highlighted Findlay's expertise in critiquing systemic failures in , drawing parallels to modern safeguards against similar errors. Findlay maintains an active online presence through his personal website, launched in , which offers subscribers a delivering insights into Scottish drawn from his extensive practice. Complementing this, he contributes exclusive video commentary to the Scottish Criminal Law Channel, operated by Hey Legal, addressing topics such as the retention of the "not proven" verdict, excessive remand periods, and the challenges of remote jury trials. These materials emphasize the importance of evidentiary rigor and traditional adversarial principles in preserving justice system integrity amid proposed reforms. In interviews, Findlay has positioned himself as an advocate for unflinching legal representation, arguing that lawyers must remain "fearless" to challenge state power effectively, regardless of or political pressures. He critiques contemporary dilutions of prosecutorial standards and processes, drawing on decades of high-stakes defenses to warn against eroding the or over-reliance on untested innovations like trials. These commentaries reinforce his role as a senior voice defending resilient, evidence-based against expedient modifications.

References

  1. [1]
    Donald R. Findlay KC - Optimum Advocates
    Donald R Findlay KC is widely recognised throughout the UK for his unrivalled experience in the criminal courts. In more than 40 years of practice he has ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  2. [2]
    Donald Russell Findlay - Faculty of Advocates
    Donald Findlay has 40 years of experience in dealing with every aspect of the criminal law including common law crime and statutory and regulatory offences.
  3. [3]
    Donald Findlay QC - Scottish Referendums - BBC
    Mr Findlay was born in Cowdenbeath in 1951 and was educated at the Harris Academy, Dundee, Dundee University and Glasgow University. The NO/NO campaign targets ...
  4. [4]
    Donald Findlay QC | Peter Ross
    At 56, Findlay is an old hand at this. An advocate since 1975, he is widely regarded as Scotland's best defence lawyer. Today he is doing his best for Tobin, ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  5. [5]
    Donald Findlay KC - SpeakOut
    Donald Findlay KC is the UK's leading Criminal Defence Advocate. He is a former Vice Chairman of Rangers FC and a Scottish Unionist.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  6. [6]
    Rectors of the University of St Andrews, 1993 to present
    Apr 13, 2018 · Donald Findlay QC (1993-99) filled the gap left by the resignation of his predecessor. He arrived in a vintage Bentley dressed as an explorer.
  7. [7]
    The man who failed to take his own advice | UK news | The Guardian
    May 31, 1999 · The damning video tape of Mr Findlay singing The Sash, an Orange anthem, and Follow, Follow - a song that contains the line "We are up to ...Missing: controversy | Show results with:controversy
  8. [8]
    Ex-Rangers vice chairman fined £3500 over sectarian songs
    Nov 4, 1999 · Mr Findlay was secretly filmed singing the Sash, an Orange anthem, and Follow, Follow - which contains the line "We're up to our knees in ...Missing: Order controversy
  9. [9]
    Cowdenbeath: Donald Findlay at 70, his life in his own words
    Apr 17, 2021 · Cowdenbeath chairman Donald Findlay has just passed 70 and in an interview with the club programme, The Blue Brazilian, he stressed his pride at the work ...
  10. [10]
    Has it all gone up in smoke? DONALD FINDLAY He&apos
    Jun 17, 2005 · DONALD FINDLAY He's perceived by many as Scotland's top criminal lawyer but his latest lack of judgment has seen him lose another post ...
  11. [11]
    Donald Findlay QC tells 'I Was Gonnae' podcast 'I Give it 100% or I ...
    Oct 25, 2020 · Donald Findlay is Scotland's best-known advocate and Queens Counsel, he is Chairman of Cowdenbeath FC, former vice-chairman of Rangers FC and two times Rector ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  12. [12]
    The two faces of Donald Findlay, QC - The Scotsman
    May 31, 2005 · Mr Findlay was forced to resign from the board of Rangers Football Club and stand down as rector of St Andrews University. ... Dundee and Tayside ...
  13. [13]
    Donald Findlay on why serial killer Peter Manuel remains an ...
    Dec 4, 2016 · AS a seven-year-old boy, Donald Findlay was influenced ... Around the same time a relatively new TV show called Boyd QC captured his imagination.
  14. [14]
    Top 5 Scottish Law Colleges | LTSCOTLAND.ORG.UK
    ... Donald Findlay QC. This university offers a wide range of LLB courses including those specifically in Scots Law, courses which focus on English and Northern ...
  15. [15]
    Optimum Advocates, Author at Optimum Advocates
    He specialises in criminal law, children's referrals, family law and regulatory matters, with particular expertise in sexual offences involving vulnerable ...
  16. [16]
    Donald Findlay QC launches website | Scottish Legal News
    Sep 10, 2021 · Mr Findlay, Scotland's top criminal lawyer, became an advocate at the Scottish bar in 1975 and a Queen's Counsel in 1988.Missing: admission | Show results with:admission
  17. [17]
    Lawyer Donald Findlay hails not proven verdict 'great asset' but he's ...
    Sep 25, 2021 · Findlay's remarks have been criticised by Grace Handling's dad who watched the man who supplied his daughter with deadly ecstasy walk free after being defended.Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
  18. [18]
    Donald Findlay QC reflects on his most memorable case
    Jun 18, 2020 · He was acquitted of killing Mr Thompson's son, who was shot dead in 1991 outside the family home. The trial cost £4 million and lasted 54 days. ...Missing: 1998 | Show results with:1998
  19. [19]
    Paul Ferris trial for murder of Arthur Thompson junior was career ...
    Jun 18, 2020 · Paul Ferris trial for murder of Arthur Thompson junior was career highlight says Donald Findlay. Ferris was accused of the gangland killing and ...
  20. [20]
    Donald Findlay QC talks of the "distressing" toll of his work
    Jul 14, 2019 · HE is Scotland's leading criminal defence lawyer who has devoted his life to his job. But Donald Findlay QC has, for the first time, ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  21. [21]
    s murder Mother of dead child is 'disgusted with verdict&apos
    May 21, 2002 · Morrison, of Broom Crescent, East Kilbride, who was defended by Donald Findlay, QC, had denied murdering his son, Alan, on October 7, 1998 by ...
  22. [22]
    Findlay set to pen defence of not proven verdict Victims&apos
    Jan 15, 2005 · Findlay has made his name by securing acquittals in some of the most controversial cases. In 1998, in the most expensive trial held in a ...Missing: defense | Show results with:defense
  23. [23]
    Optimum Advocates' Post - LinkedIn
    Jul 11, 2025 · most formidable criminal defence advocates, Mr Findlay KC has ... He has almost certainly defended more murder trials than any lawyer ...
  24. [24]
    Interview: Donald Findlay, QC - The Scotsman
    Jun 27, 2010 · The new chairman of the Faculty of Advocates Criminal Bar Association, Donald Findlay, QC. But his FACBA election gives Findlay an opportunity for reflection.
  25. [25]
    sectarian violence Singing a history of hatred | The Herald
    Jun 3, 1999 · During the course of the celebrations Findlay sang a medley of Protestant anthems which featured anti-Catholic lyrics.
  26. [26]
    The bitter divide - BBC News | UK
    Jun 2, 1999 · But there has been more to the rivalry than just songs such as The Sash and Follow Follow, which Mr Findlay reportedly sang at the after-match ...Missing: controversy | Show results with:controversy
  27. [27]
    Scotland's top defence lawyer exposed as a Protestant bigot - WSWS
    Jul 1, 1999 · The Findlay affair exposes the pretensions of Rangers owner, millionaire David Murray, to have eliminated religious bigotry from the club.
  28. [28]
    Findlay considered suicide as row exploded over singing of Sash at ...
    Oct 15, 1999 · He resigned from his position with Rangers in May after a video of him singing The Sash - a song seen in Glasgow as sectarian and anti-Catholic ...Missing: wearing | Show results with:wearing
  29. [29]
    (PDF) Let the people sing? Irish rebel songs, sectarianism, and ...
    PDF | Irish rebel songs afford Scotland's Irish diaspora a means to assert, experience and perform their alterity free from the complexities of the.<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    Scotland | Pope joke backlash for top lawyer - BBC NEWS | UK
    Jun 5, 2005 · Leading QC Donald Findlay faces fresh controversy after making a joke about the late Pope at a Rangers social club.
  31. [31]
    UK | Scotland | Glasgow and West | Leading QC told 'sectarian joke'
    Jun 18, 2007 · A leading defence QC is accused of "unacceptable" behaviour after he was reported to have made sectarian comments ... Donald Findlay QC is one of ...
  32. [32]
    Donald Findlay cleared of offensive joke charge - The Herald
    Jul 2, 2007 · The row dates back to a Rangers supporters' event in Larne, Northern Ireland in May, 2005. Mr Findlay's after-dinner speech made headlines in a ...
  33. [33]
    Top QC cleared over 'sectarian' jokes - The Scotsman
    Jul 3, 2007 · In the same year, he was fined 3,500 and had to quit as vice-chairman of Rangers FC after singing sectarian songs to celebrate a cup final ...<|separator|>
  34. [34]
    Top lawyer cleared of offending Catholics | UK - Daily Express
    Jul 3, 2007 · One of Scotland's top criminal lawyers was yesterday cleared of offending Catholics by telling jokes at a Rangers' supporters club.<|separator|>
  35. [35]
    Findlay could face investigation after telling joke about Pope
    May 29, 2005 · After the controversial incident in June 1999 when Mr Findlay was captured on an amateur video singing sectarian songs at a private party at the ...<|separator|>
  36. [36]
    BBC NEWS | UK | Glasgow and West | Findlay faces disciplinary action
    Jan 15, 2007 · Eight years ago, he resigned as vice-chairman of Rangers Football Club after he was filmed singing a sectarian song. E-mail this to a friend ...Missing: 1999 | Show results with:1999
  37. [37]
    Woman who worked with Donald Findlay escapes fine Advocate ...
    Apr 30, 2002 · ... Paddy Christie, the television journalist, who had then been in a relationship with Mr Findlay for around five years. The distressing calls ...
  38. [38]
    FINDLAY DUMPED BY TV LOVER Findlay dumped by his TV lover ...
    At the time, he had begun spending more time in Glasgow, leaving wife Jenny at their Edinburgh home. Findlay first met Chrstie, who comes from Stonehaven, when ...
  39. [39]
    Donald Findlay accuses SNP of undermining Scottish legal system
    Jul 17, 2023 · Donald Findlay KC has accused the Scottish government of undermining the justice system for mere “vote-gathering”.Missing: criticism interference
  40. [40]
    Donald Findlay slams SNP's legal reform plans and scrapping of not ...
    Jul 16, 2023 · Donald Findlay believes the changes will result in the SNP “dismantling” Scotland's justice system - and said they're only doing it to gain votes.Missing: interference | Show results with:interference
  41. [41]
    Donald Findlay derides court reforms as 'SNP vote-gathering'
    Jul 16, 2023 · One of Scotland's most prominent advocates has accused the SNP of dismantling the country's justice system for “simple vote-gathering”.Missing: criticism interference
  42. [42]
    SNP will 'dismantle' Scotland's proud legal system just to gain votes
    Jul 16, 2023 · Mr Findlay told the Sunday Mail: "I am completely opposed to the change to the three-verdict system. There is no good reason to change a system ...Missing: interference | Show results with:interference
  43. [43]
    Supporting Justice at The Merchants House of Glasgow, Oscar ...
    The speaker is the incomparable Donald Findlay KC, who is going to speak about the notorious case of Oscar Slater (1872 – 1948), the victim of a notorious ...Missing: interference | Show results with:interference
  44. [44]
    Donald Findlay talking on the case of Oscar Slater | FollowFollow.com
    Mar 26, 2024 · Findlay says it was this book that made him take up criminal law, and if you haven't read it, you should.Missing: political interference
  45. [45]
    Insight: The jury's still out on '˜not proven' verdict - The Scotsman
    Feb 13, 2016 · An original courtroom sketch of the trial of Madeline Smith (sitting upright in court) in 1857. A Glasgow socialite accused of murdering her ...Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
  46. [46]
    The great defender | The Herald
    Aug 10, 2007 · At 56, Findlay is an old hand at this. An advocate since 1975, he is widely regarded as Scotland's best defence lawyer. Today he is doing his ...
  47. [47]
    Criminal Appeals | Random Thoughts Re Scots Law by Paul ...
    ... cab rank” principle, and therefore, if instructed, and available, Mr Findlay would have had no choice but to accept instructions. Bearing in mind his almost ...
  48. [48]
    QC urges that rights of individual be defended | The Herald
    ... presumption of innocence if you are innocent, but have to end up pleading guilty because you cannot afford to hire a lawyer to make your defence properly?''
  49. [49]
    Not Proven - Scottish Legal News
    Donald Findlay accuses SNP of undermining Scottish legal system ... Law Society: Removal of 'not proven' verdict risks increase in miscarriages of justice.<|separator|>
  50. [50]
    Skye murder accused 'arrived at sister's home with gun' - BBC
    Nov 14, 2024 · Mr MacKinnon is smiling. He is wearing a shirt and tie and suit jacket. Facebook John MacKinnon was allegedly shot and murdered at his home in Skye.
  51. [51]
    Finlay MacDonald: Man who went on shooting and stabbing spree ...
    Nov 29, 2024 · Warning: This article contains details readers may find distressing ... Defence lawyer Donald Findlay KC claimed his client's autism ...<|separator|>
  52. [52]
    Something catastrophic affected killer, says lawyer - BBC
    Nov 28, 2024 · A senior counsel says Finlay MacDonald's autism must be taken into account by the jury in his murder trial.
  53. [53]
    Lawyer for Skye murder accused says autism 'counts'
    Nov 28, 2024 · Lawyer for Skye murder accused says autism 'counts' in explaining 'genuine tragedy'. Closing speeches are underway at the murder trial of Finlay ...
  54. [54]
    Murder accused Finlay MacDonald was 'focused' on attacking targets
    Nov 27, 2024 · The psychologist told the High Court in Edinburgh that, at the time of the alleged murder, Mr MacDonald was affected by autism and post ...
  55. [55]
    Finlay MacDonald: Skye murder accused felt 'humiliated' by brother ...
    Nov 19, 2024 · Finlay MacDonald, 41, has been accused of a shooting spree in the Scottish Highlands in August 2022.
  56. [56]
    2025 Annual Colloquium - Franco-British Lawyers Society
    The conference will conclude with a dramatic re-enactment of the Oscar Slater trial by Donald Findlay KC, in the same courtroom as the original trial. There ...
  57. [57]
    Franco-British Lawyers Society Conference: Art, Dreyfus, Oscar ...
    Sep 2, 2025 · Miscarriages of Justice will be highlighted at a Franco-British Lawyers Society conference to be held in Edinburgh on 18-20 September.
  58. [58]
    Dreyfus, Oscar Slater and Modern Miscarriages of Justice
    Aug 14, 2025 · The conference will draw to a close with a dramatic re-enactment of the Slater trial by none other than Donald Findlay KC, and will take place ...Missing: profile post- 2020
  59. [59]
    Donald R Findlay QC Launches New Website - Hey Legal News
    Sep 8, 2021 · A new, and first ever, website for Donald Findlay QC has just gone live. We were delighted to work with Donald to create this platform ...
  60. [60]
    Donald Findlay QC Joins Hey Legal's Scottish Criminal Law Channel
    Hey Legal · Hey Creates · Submit news · Crime · Donald Findlay QC Joins Hey Legal's Scottish Criminal Law Channel. ByEmma Flood, Hey Legal Team. Jun 22, 2021.Missing: contributions | Show results with:contributions
  61. [61]
    Donald Findlay QC: His support of the Not Proven verdict ... - YouTube
    Sep 21, 2021 · Recent press coverage has suggested Donald Findlay supports removal of the Not Proven verdict - this is not the case. In this video he ...Missing: notable | Show results with:notable
  62. [62]
    Donald Findlay QC on "Why Lawyers Need to be Fearless" - YouTube
    Jun 13, 2022 · ... Law Society of Scotland https://www.lawscot.org.uk/members/cpd-training/shaping-your-success-with-hey-legal/month-four/ Lawyers can register ...
  63. [63]
    Donald Findlay QC on Remote Jury Trials in Scotland - DRF Updates
    Jul 6, 2021 · Donald Findlay QC provides exclusive content for members of The Scottish Criminal Law Channel: ...Missing: contributions | Show results with:contributions
  64. [64]
    Episode 13 | Why lawyers need to be fearless - YouTube
    Jan 2, 2023 · As one of the country's most experienced criminal defence lawyers, Donald Findlay has more than his fair share of stories, anecdotes and ...Missing: advocacy 2024